Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Are Bitcoin Treasuries the Next Big Thing or the Next Blowup? with Richard Byworth
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974. 1980790297, 2000
- 0:17and whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same
- 0:20thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell, hey. OK, I say when we sell.
- 0:33Just recorded with Rich Byworth and Brahm Khanstein.
- 0:36Great conversation. It was one that I was looking
- 0:38forward to because there's just been so much happening in the
- 0:41Bitcoin treasury space. And for me, it's a little bit
- 0:45challenging to be honest, to keep up with everything.
- 0:48And Twitter in particular doesn't allow for such nuanced
- 0:51conversations around the topic. So did want to get Rich and
- 0:55Brahm on the show just to discuss in more detail what's
- 0:59happened in the past six months or so with the rise of the
- 1:02pureplay Bitcoin treasury strategy, both in public and
- 1:05private markets. You know, where there's
- 1:07differentiation and opportunity, where there's risk as well
- 1:10around execution and then also just laggards in the space.
- 1:14And we also talked a lot about policy.
- 1:16Brian was down at the Bitcoin Policy Summit in DC this week.
- 1:19So discussed some of the more topical things there as relates
- 1:23to multi institution custody and policy makers, regulators coming
- 1:26around to that and kind of wrapped up with just thoughts
- 1:30around where Bitcoin ends up through the rest of the year.
- 1:33And so that ultimately leads us to on ramp.
- 1:36If you're thinking seriously about your Bitcoin allocation,
- 1:39your wealth for your family, for your business, that's exactly
- 1:43what we built on ramp for for securing 6 figure Bitcoin need
- 1:46to have a game plan as Bitcoin marches higher from 100K to on
- 1:5025 to 200, whatever it may be at the end of this year.
- 1:52Who knows certainly won't make any price predictions, but if
- 1:56you land on our website, you can schedule a consultation with
- 1:59myself or someone from the team. Happy to just better understand
- 2:02where you're coming from and if on ramp is something we can help
- 2:05out with as it relates to custody, you know, protecting
- 2:08against physical threats, digital threats, inheritance,
- 2:11insurance, etcetera. So check out our website WWW dot
- 2:16on rampbitcoin.com and hope to speak with you soon.
- 2:19Enjoy the episode. Straight down the middle of the
- 2:21fairway. Yeah, Michael's pretty burnt out
- 2:24at this point, but we are recording for the last trade and
- 2:28excited for this one because we have two returning guests.
- 2:32We have Rich Byworth from Seas Capital and Brahm Konstein,
- 2:35Bitcoin for millennials. Brahm, you've been on the show
- 2:38more recently, but Rich, you have not been on the last trade
- 2:41since September or October. We were trading in the 60s.
- 2:45It was before the presidential election here in the United
- 2:48States, which has had significant impact on the
- 2:51industry, as we all know and we'll talk about, as Brian here
- 2:54was at the Bitcoin Policy Summit this week in DC.
- 2:57And then to round it out, we have Michael Tanguma as well
- 3:00from on ramp. So Rich and Brahm, great to see
- 3:03you both. How are the two of you doing?
- 3:05Good. Thanks, Jackson.
- 3:06I actually I was on stage with your buddy Mason Carter from
- 3:10Early Riders. That's right.
- 3:12And I, I actually said on stage, I said you have to the audience
- 3:18has to understand that the choice he, he, you as a group
- 3:22have made to denominate that fund in Bitcoin and therefore be
- 3:28owe owing your investors the hurdle rate in Bitcoin as
- 3:31opposed to the hurdle rate in dollars and and Bitcoin
- 3:34performance to get your fees is significant and I think very
- 3:39notable and commendable actually.
- 3:43Well, I'll, I'll, I'll share something I love.
- 3:45Richard is mentioning the word the, the term hurdle rate again,
- 3:48right? And I think there were some
- 3:49people on Bitcoin Twitter who were like, oh, saying Bitcoin is
- 3:53a hurdle rate. It's like a trans fi grift
- 3:55something, something. But I, I think many people don't
- 3:58understand the term hurdle rate. So maybe you know, because we're
- 4:03also going to talk about Bitcoin treasuries and stuff.
- 4:06Maybe it's good to also now or later touch upon that because I
- 4:09think it's actually a very Bitcoin thing to think about
- 4:13Bitcoin as the hurdle rate for any any other thing that you can
- 4:17do right in your in your life when when you actually store
- 4:20your wealth in Bitcoin. So I just want to touch upon
- 4:22that and happy to give you guys. Yeah, glad to have you.
- 4:26I think there's two parts. When I think of Bitcoin as a
- 4:28hurdle rate, I think of it as a like a meta thing where I've
- 4:32always thought life boils down is to is the juice worth the
- 4:34squeeze? It's super crude, but it's like
- 4:36comes down to is it worth squeezing the orange juice?
- 4:39Like is it worth doing the endeavor on a personal?
- 4:41And that's personal for everyone.
- 4:43And so the idea of Bitcoin as the hurdle rate is rich is
- 4:45referring to is when we're building on ramps like, well, do
- 4:48I spend my Bitcoin or do I raise money?
- 4:51Well, I can raise money, but then if you're going to give
- 4:53away equity, that's effectively, in our view, Bitcoin in the
- 4:56future. So we spend our own Bitcoin.
- 4:58So the idea is we have to outperform Bitcoin and that
- 5:02doesn't mean, you know, from a cager perspective, it just means
- 5:05you either have to be able to sell the company for more
- 5:07Bitcoin or you just have to increase your dividends, the
- 5:09amount of value produced in the world and then create it.
- 5:13And so that's how early writers were born.
- 5:14So I think that's ultimately when a lot of people have loved
- 5:17this. You've seen Vivek, Matt Cole,
- 5:20there's a new podcast referencing it now, Pomps, you
- 5:22know, showing it. There's a lot of people out
- 5:24there saying Bitcoin is a hurdle rate.
- 5:25So I think the suits have picked up on it and that's where it
- 5:28gets a bad rap in the Bitcoin space.
- 5:30But it's just a, it's just a, a term.
- 5:32It's it's indifferent. It's just money.
- 5:34And how do you decide to spend it?
- 5:35That's your ultimate hurdle rate, which is subjective for
- 5:38everyone. It's not objective.
- 5:40I think it's just much more honest as well.
- 5:42If you're running a venture fund, you're denominating in
- 5:45Bitcoin, you're investing in Bitcoin companies.
- 5:48You know, if Bitcoin goes up, you're denominated in dollars,
- 5:51you're going to make performance fees, but you're just being much
- 5:54more honest with your investors when you're denominating in
- 5:57Bitcoin because you've got to beat Bitcoin to even get a
- 6:00performance fee, right? I think that's the key thing.
- 6:03Yeah, there's, there's some new nuance to it.
- 6:05I think you know how, how we've thought about it from the
- 6:08beginning was really internalizing it like Michael
- 6:12said, either from an individual perspective or as AGP or as a
- 6:16business founder and entrepreneur.
- 6:18Like you're internalizing that opportunity cost.
- 6:21I think brought to your point where some detractors have come
- 6:25in is, is more related to like their disdain of the treasury
- 6:29company fad or, you know, proliferation of treasury
- 6:32companies. And that being like, you know,
- 6:34part of the marketing around by my public company is Bitcoin's
- 6:39are all right. So you have to have to
- 6:40outperform it. So I think that's kind of where
- 6:42the distinction is. But there's nuance there because
- 6:46like Michael said, it is just like something you need to
- 6:48internalize whatever you're doing.
- 6:50Rich, I have a quick thing to share with you that I think
- 6:52you'll appreciate and it's going to be a little bit polarizing.
- 6:55Haven't shared it publicly, but I had this unlocked this weekend
- 6:57because we have a lot of venture capitalist buddies and they like
- 7:00what we're doing and and we're like living, you know, that term
- 7:02vicariously through them. They want to get Bitcoin in
- 7:04their, you know, via their LP's or a portion of their fund to de
- 7:07risk it and they can't get it done.
- 7:10And I was texting them because we're listening to Bill Gurley
- 7:12and all these main venture capitalists and they all like
- 7:15are so smart, but they're missing the piece that the
- 7:17money's broken. So they can't figure out why the
- 7:19alpha is being like decayed from private investments.
- 7:22And it hit me, unless we're completely dumb, it's possible.
- 7:25So it's this is a still chance. We're completely dumb where we
- 7:28blow up the fund, we can't lose. And the reason why is because,
- 7:32and I promise you and I promise you, but it wasn't even like our
- 7:34goal is to out compete and return more Bitcoin because
- 7:37that's the only way we get paid. But even if we hit Bitcoin or a
- 7:41little bit above that, we will be the best performing fund in
- 7:44venture capital. And every VC that is Fiat
- 7:47allocating is going to wake up to this is how companies will be
- 7:50built because ultimately it's just increasing the cost of
- 7:52capital. It used to be 2%, it's 6%.
- 7:54Now it's, you know, whatever bitcoins K here, we will just be
- 7:57ahead of that time and then all the money will flow in either
- 8:00way. So again, a caveat we can't blow
- 8:02up, but that's just a there was an unlock I had this past week
- 8:06and I was like, holy crap. So.
- 8:09What you're saying is when you have the comparison tables, you
- 8:13would look at your fund. It would be denominated in
- 8:16Bitcoin of course. Then it gets translated back
- 8:19into dollars for the dollar performance.
- 8:21And so as a result, you're going to just kill everybody.
- 8:25You're also going to probably kill the majority of other
- 8:29Bitcoin venture funds because they're all denominated in
- 8:32dollars. And so they're not just so
- 8:34strictly focused on businesses that can outperform Bitcoin as a
- 8:38hurdle, right, Right. And I think that's the other
- 8:41aspect of you guys, yeah. It's exactly right and it's all
- 8:44a philosophical thing because we talk to folks all the time that
- 8:47are maybe getting higher valuations or whatever.
- 8:49And a lot of these individuals are wealthy, so they don't
- 8:51necessarily need the money. And it's like, look, if you want
- 8:53more money, go do it. We won't be those people, but if
- 8:55you actually want to build a great company, we're building 1
- 8:57right now. We can like get in the knife
- 8:59fights with you. We could talk about how we can
- 9:01actually do it in real time and it's just a fundamentally
- 9:03different experience. It's actually really a had one
- 9:06yesterday with a pretty interesting firm on the Bitcoin
- 9:09equity side or a mortgage equity side, which is I think is going
- 9:12to be a big space, letting people take a small sliver of
- 9:15equity out of their space and they don't really need the
- 9:17money. But point being is you just get
- 9:20to be transparent just like we're being here.
- 9:22It's like this is our goal. Our goal is to outperform
- 9:24Bitcoin. But even if we barely miss that,
- 9:28you know, even that I would make the case a lot of Bitcoin
- 9:30individuals will benefit simply because the man in the coma idea
- 9:34you always heard about certain people have gone to prison that
- 9:36end up with more Bitcoin than most people because it's just a
- 9:39forest huddle. So anyway, we don't got to talk
- 9:42about early writers. It was just an interesting
- 9:43dynamic that's this stuff's always just like kind of as, you
- 9:47know, like percolate in your head because the marketing we're
- 9:50learning in real time about it all.
- 9:52Yeah. And that that's a perfect, it's
- 9:54a perfect segue as well because we're talking about the private
- 9:58markets and how to allocate capital with Bitcoin as the
- 10:01hurdle rate and how that informs the capital allocation process
- 10:05and how management teams think about it.
- 10:07And I would love to talk about what's happening in the public
- 10:09markets as relates to Bitcoin treasury companies because Rich,
- 10:13last time we had you on was in the fall and strategy was the
- 10:17dominant player, still is the dominant player, but there was
- 10:20not this rapidly growing ecosystem of pureplay Bitcoin
- 10:26treasury companies. And so now to Michael's earlier
- 10:29point, you know, we have strive stepping in.
- 10:32Anthony Pompliano just announced a SPAC or a merger for a Bitcoin
- 10:37treasury company. You have Metaplanet, which has
- 10:39really ramped up their efforts, similar web.
- 10:42There's all these different companies.
- 10:43There's so many that I, you know, I don't even have the time
- 10:45to follow them, to be quite honest.
- 10:48And I really want to get your thoughts on this because you
- 10:50have such a polarizing view in the Bitcoin space, where on one
- 10:53side of the barbell you have individuals who are vehemently
- 10:57against the idea of Bitcoin treasury companies because they
- 11:00feel like to them, they're a grift.
- 11:02They're scamming people out of their Bitcoin.
- 11:05But then on the other side, you have people who are so
- 11:07incredibly excited about the financial engineering, the idea
- 11:11of increasing Bitcoin per share, Bitcoin yield, and you have
- 11:15people that are even selling all their Bitcoin to allocate it
- 11:18into Bitcoin treasury companies. And so I was particularly
- 11:21excited to have Rich on the podcast because I think Rich,
- 11:24you're one of the most informed and well spoken on this topic in
- 11:27particular. And while you're bullish on it,
- 11:29you still have a very balanced view.
- 11:31So we'll love to just kind of get an overarching update, you
- 11:34know, over the past six months or so, what are the most
- 11:37important things that have happened in this space?
- 11:38You know, what's exciting to you, where the risks lie?
- 11:41We'll have a dynamic conversation, but really want to
- 11:43just let you set the stage in terms of what's going on in the
- 11:45Bitcoin treasury space. Sure, happy to.
- 11:50So I think the obviously the key moment was October last year
- 11:56when strategy announced the 2121 plan.
- 12:00I think it might have been around the time that we last did
- 12:04our chat. But obviously looking at that as
- 12:09a traditional finance guy, you're looking at a 40% dilution
- 12:13in the equity with an additional 40% potential dilution in the
- 12:18convertible bonds. And when you have a dilution of
- 12:23that level, I mean the ATM was live as of the next day.
- 12:27When you have a dilution of that level, you would expect the
- 12:31stock to fall. The stock went up and Bitcoin
- 12:36was down. And at the end of the day, the
- 12:40stock ended slightly down, but it was up as much as 2 1/2%
- 12:43intraday with Bitcoin soft on the day.
- 12:47And I looked at it and I just, I just could not understand what
- 12:51was happening. And it sort of really broke my
- 12:53brain as a traditional finance guy.
- 12:56And so I've obviously spent a lot of time thinking about it
- 13:00and had had a few discussions with, with people like Bram on
- 13:05this subject and other podcasts where we've sort of dealt delved
- 13:10into what exactly is happening. And it really just, it's really
- 13:15interesting that you bring up the point that a lot of
- 13:17Bitcoiners are seeing this as some level of grift and a scam
- 13:19and the rest of it, because I was really hit by that in Prague
- 13:26last week when we we were all there.
- 13:28There's a lot of Bitcoins. I actually shared the stage with
- 13:31someone that he didn't want to say it so directly because he
- 13:34was sat next to me, but and he knew that I obviously have
- 13:38strong views about these Bitcoin treasury companies.
- 13:41And to your point, I'm generally quite bullish, but the point
- 13:45that I made to everybody who sort of brought it up at any
- 13:49point was what you got to understand is the entire
- 13:53financial system has been pushed to a point of breaking with the
- 13:59money printing. The money printing has all
- 14:01flowed into the financial markets, right?
- 14:04So when you look at the equity markets, you look at Apple, I
- 14:08don't know what they are today, maybe 35 times PE, 35 * P that
- 14:12is ridiculous pricing for a company that just is
- 14:16demonstrating very little growth at this point in its life.
- 14:20So when you look at that, you look at the valuations all
- 14:23across the S&P. The problem you've got as an
- 14:26active manager in equities is that you need to actually be
- 14:29allocating to companies that are fundamentally completely
- 14:33mispriced. And if you don't do it, you run
- 14:36the risk of massively outperforming, underperforming
- 14:38the index. So what do you need?
- 14:41Well, you need the best performing asset on the planet.
- 14:43You need Bitcoin, right? You need the 65% CAGR that we
- 14:47talked about for the last five to 10 years.
- 14:50So companies like MicroStrategy are actually providing a bit of
- 14:54a release valve with these ridiculous valuations.
- 14:57As they attract more capital in the equity markets, they're
- 15:01relieving that pressure on the apples and all the rest of the
- 15:05MAG sevens that are arguably completely mispriced, plus
- 15:09likely the rest of the S and Pi. Don't even bother looking at it
- 15:12these days myself. But the other thing that is also
- 15:15true of the bond markets, right? No one's being paid for the risk
- 15:20that they're taking to hold dollars to continue to lend
- 15:24money to either the US government or the corporates,
- 15:27right? I don't want to hold U.S.
- 15:30dollars and then get paid 4 1/2 percent.
- 15:32I know the rate of debasement is at least 10, right?
- 15:36So the real rate needs to be at least 10.
- 15:39Well, welcome micro strategy and his preference shares, right,
- 15:4310% coupons, happy to pay it. You know, if he's get if he's
- 15:47borrowing money and paying 10%, he's essentially, you know,
- 15:52paying out and buying his Bitcoin at a 65% CAGR.
- 15:56So he's more than happy with that performance, right.
- 15:59And obviously the bond market love it because they finally got
- 16:03something that is a stable credit actually paying the real
- 16:06rate in the US dollar curve. And then you come to volatility,
- 16:10right? If you look at the convertible
- 16:12bond market, convertible bond managers desperately need
- 16:16volatility, but volatility has been destroyed by money printing
- 16:21because every time the market dips, you just get the central
- 16:25bank print more money, stabilize the price and and volatility is
- 16:30just sort of drifting to nothing, right?
- 16:32So convertible bond managers are crying out for more volatile
- 16:36product Sailor. He doesn't have any control over
- 16:40the volatility of his stock. It's completely defined by
- 16:43Bitcoin, which is this $2 trillion dinosaur tail, I call
- 16:47it waving his stock around all over the place.
- 16:50So for him, he's happy to sell his convertible bonds at A50 Vol
- 16:55when they're trading at when the volatility is really 70 or 80
- 16:58back when we were last talking and he was issuing converts.
- 17:03So if you look at all of this, all of the managers in those
- 17:07various capital pools desperately need Bitcoin or
- 17:12Bitcoin's, you know, implied dollar rate or Bitcoin's
- 17:15volatility. They don't always understand
- 17:18that that's what they need, but they're starting to.
- 17:21And this is where the Bitcoin treasuries, treasury companies
- 17:25come in because they're like the release valved release valve of
- 17:29those overpriced markets basically being slightly
- 17:34deflated by the option to move into Bitcoin.
- 17:37And so this is the peaceful transition of the financial
- 17:40markets into Bitcoin. That's what's happening.
- 17:43And so, yeah, of course you're going to continue to see these
- 17:47these companies pop up. And then you've got the whole
- 17:49debate about, well, you know, Coincilium today, they're
- 17:53trading at, I think at 10 * M NAV.
- 17:55That's the number two company in the, in the UK at 10 * M NAV at
- 18:00a market cap of 100 million. I like that because then they
- 18:03could do 100 million rays and take themselves to a 2 * m nerve
- 18:06immediately. So you've got this sort of,
- 18:10well, we can get into that, but the, the metrics are very
- 18:13difficult to sort of understand. And so you have to, it's almost
- 18:17like a multifaceted diamond. You have to look at them from
- 18:20various different angles to understand the real value.
- 18:24Otherwise you might miss something and then you might
- 18:26say, Oh well, it's a, it's an A * M now I don't want to be
- 18:29buying that. But then you miss the quality of
- 18:32the financial engineering or the the level of aggression for
- 18:35example that metaplanet are are providing.
- 18:40Yeah, that that makes total sense.
- 18:41Very salient points. I think I totally agree with you
- 18:45from sort of the money manager perspective.
- 18:48These pools of capital, that's your point, are looking at a
- 18:52historically extremely overvalued market, whether
- 18:55that's, you know, equities or debt with, you know, low
- 18:58volatility. And, and it makes no sense that
- 19:01they would want these types of investments in their portfolio.
- 19:05I think where part of the rub is at least sort of in the Bitcoin
- 19:09community or on or on Twitter. And, and obviously that's a bit
- 19:12of an echo chamber. So take all this with a grain of
- 19:14salt, but I think there is some notion and this is sort of
- 19:17anecdotal, so I don't know really the data behind it, but
- 19:20it feels to me like a lot of these things are are retail
- 19:23driven and not necessarily like professional money managers
- 19:26stepping into some of these smaller examples.
- 19:29I think particularly on the MSTR side, it certainly has been for
- 19:32years more of a institutional money manager type play.
- 19:37But I think that's part of where the rub is, is like, well, this
- 19:39is more of a retail phenomenon. And by definition, these are
- 19:42trades where people are saying, I'm going to sell some Bitcoin,
- 19:47make this trade and hopefully end up with more Bitcoin on the
- 19:50back end. And so I think that's kind of
- 19:54where some of the more negative sentiment has come from in the
- 19:57sense that it is somewhat antithetical to like Bitcoin as
- 20:00savings technology, you know, buy and hold, you're not
- 20:04trading. And in addition to that, like
- 20:07you're adding risks that are not inherent to Bitcoin, right from
- 20:10execution risk to management risk to counterparty risk in
- 20:15addition to other. So I think that's part of it.
- 20:16But I mean, is that your sense or or do you think this is
- 20:19really more of a trapped capital money manager type?
- 20:25Play. I don't know the actual
- 20:26breakdown of of who who's buying these things.
- 20:29Well, it's definitely the former because it's, it's objectively
- 20:33true that you don't create communities unless you're going
- 20:36for retail. Like of these companies are you
- 20:39get a Bitcoin influencer to join.
- 20:40That's where the like backlash is coming is because of course
- 20:44there's pooled capital and there's a lot of things and
- 20:46there's I could reference some angles on where that doesn't
- 20:48play long term because anybody sophisticated will ultimately
- 20:51want spot, not want the executioner is.
- 20:53But these are definitely like retail.
- 20:55I don't want to say retail focus, but there's a big focus
- 20:57on getting retail investors in these products.
- 21:02Yeah, I think people obviously have the right to trade and try
- 21:07and increase their Bitcoin stack.
- 21:09You've got options all over Bitcoin that, you know, very
- 21:12developed options market for people to try and trade and
- 21:16increase their Bitcoin stack using Bitcoin.
- 21:19And I think that, you know, if retail can again be the front
- 21:24runners and the beneficiary of the massive growth that will be
- 21:28driven by the institutional adoption of Bitcoin as an asset
- 21:32to improve their portfolios, be it in their equity portfolios,
- 21:35bond portfolios or convertible bond portfolios, then is there a
- 21:40problem with that? I don't have an issue with
- 21:42retail participating. I mean, I think you're
- 21:45referencing Dylan Leclair and Metaplanet when you talk about a
- 21:49specific person that was brought on with a profile in Bitcoin.
- 21:53Obviously Sailor built his profile in Bitcoin from the
- 21:57moment where he adopted. I think this, you know, from
- 22:02Metaplanet's position. I had Simon Jarovic come on my
- 22:07podcast. You know, I've known Simon for a
- 22:11few years and so he agreed to come on, but he said to me, he
- 22:15said I hate doing this. I don't want to do this.
- 22:17I don't want to do any of that. I hate being the front man for
- 22:20this sort of things, which is the reason why I hired Dylan
- 22:23because Dylan's obviously, you know, very comfortable with it.
- 22:26He can speak and it's obvious that you need to be out there.
- 22:30You need to be talking about these companies because frankly,
- 22:32people need to know about it, right?
- 22:35You know, I miss the IPO completely of Smarter Web, even
- 22:39though I'm from the UK, I completely missed it.
- 22:42I didn't hear about it. I don't know what I was doing,
- 22:44but didn't pay attention. And so, you know, I would have
- 22:50liked that they had been out there and been more active with
- 22:54marketing because at a £4 million market cap, you know,
- 22:58that's, that's the potential for significant growth.
- 23:03But I'm not saying, you know, what should people should do,
- 23:07how they should allocate. You know, for me, the benefit of
- 23:10these companies is that they are allowing, I don't know if you
- 23:13guys have seen that huge triangle of traditional finance
- 23:17capital. I think Samsung, Mao put it out
- 23:20from from the the Jan 3 channel with that tiny triangle of $2
- 23:25trillion of Bitcoin. And all that capital basically
- 23:29has to funnel in there. And of course, it's going to be
- 23:32explosive, right? And that's where we're at.
- 23:34We're at the very beginning stage of this.
- 23:36I think it's very bullish actually the amount of people
- 23:38that hate Bitcoin treasury companies because it means that
- 23:42very few people are participating in the trade, you
- 23:46know, so the purists are staying away from it.
- 23:49A lot of traditional managers don't understand the trade yet.
- 23:53But then you have the the very sharp allocators and obviously
- 23:57capital are now the second largest shareholder in
- 24:00Metaplanet. They're also a very large
- 24:02shareholder in, in micro strategy.
- 24:06They're extremely good equity allocators.
- 24:10So the fact that they are allocating into this space and
- 24:13people will pay attention, right?
- 24:15I mean, Capital Group is one of the biggest equity firms in the
- 24:19world. So I think this is all very,
- 24:22very positive. But yeah, we're, it seems like
- 24:26we're in the very early phases of all of this stuff.
- 24:29Yeah, I think just a few few things.
- 24:31I don't know how much Jackson you want to stay on this.
- 24:34We every time we talk about it, I was caveat like everything's
- 24:36good for Bitcoin including this because any awareness or price
- 24:40appreciation independent of if somebody gets rubbed or loses is
- 24:43a positive catalyst. When I reference influencers, it
- 24:48was more of just like a playbook we've seen play out with Sembler
- 24:51and I didn't even know Brunel was on his board.
- 24:53And like you know, other folks and like I think every treasury
- 24:55company has, you know, I think that was something that Bailey
- 24:58saw very early on when they were gonna launch the metaplanet
- 25:01strategy. So it just has a retail
- 25:03component. I think where a lot of this
- 25:05diverges is, and this makes sense cuz your background being
- 25:10in tratifies the relationship with money and the markets in a
- 25:14Fiat world versus a non Fiat world, our non Fiat world,
- 25:17meaning like that a lot of like there's a great article by
- 25:21friend Parker Lewis had is called Bitcoin is a great D
- 25:24financialization. It's like these markets won't be
- 25:26as big. So I do think there's a valve
- 25:29component here, but again, it's a valve component from over
- 25:33price to still overpriced Bitcoin.
- 25:35And so sure, it'll help, but the real angle is you referenced
- 25:40individuals getting exposure for the portfolio.
- 25:44Is this notion that Bitcoin is just money and it's going to
- 25:46make up the majority of somebody's portfolio and asset
- 25:48class in the future. And there's a delta between here
- 25:51and there. And so to your point, it's very
- 25:53bullish for Bitcoin and the treasury companies because if so
- 25:56many people aren't in it today, that means there's a lot of
- 25:58rugging that's going to happen in the future because they can't
- 26:00actually underwrite these different these different
- 26:03things. They all just look like tickers.
- 26:05There's only one Bitcoin, there's everything else.
- 26:07And then there's counterparty risk from A-Z on how you know
- 26:10whether it's just an ETF and who custodies it or executes the
- 26:14trades all the way to the the treasury company.
- 26:17And so we're going to get further out on the risk curve
- 26:19and it's going to get further out or harder for individuals to
- 26:22discern. And then it's ultimately a
- 26:24trade, which is the big thing like Brahm and I chat about is
- 26:27when you hold money, gold or Bitcoin, you just sleep because
- 26:31I mean, Bitcoin's a little volatile, but it's you have no
- 26:33counterparty risk. I mean, you already have very
- 26:35little depending on where you store it.
- 26:37Everything else is a proxy derivative of that.
- 26:39And ultimately is a trade, unless these companies go up
- 26:42forever and, and they're become money, which we all, I don't
- 26:45think would agree. So then you're effectively
- 26:47taking the individual's time through their day and what they
- 26:50should be doing on Earth and just like focusing on having to
- 26:53get out of this trade. The last thing I'll say is
- 26:55Parker had a really good tweet this morning, which was when
- 26:58Bitcoin treasury, what Bitcoin treasury companies are showing
- 27:00is that it's easier to arbitrage Fiat than it is to create
- 27:03productive things. This isn't an indictment.
- 27:05It's just a fact about Fiat that is laid bare by the current
- 27:08trend. Is the goal to get more money
- 27:10and accumulate capital. And I think ultimately where
- 27:12this all comes down to is what people, and I'm not saying me,
- 27:15but just in general thought they were hit their heroes in the
- 27:17Bitcoin space just went and took the money grab instead of
- 27:20producing more value. That's accretive to like the
- 27:22longevity of how most people would discern this.
- 27:25They found values like how do I get people to self custody or
- 27:27whatever. I'm again not for that or
- 27:29against it, just stating I think that's the sentiment that is
- 27:32like embodied in some of the culture.
- 27:37I don't know what you mean when you're talking about rug pulls
- 27:41in that particular situation, I think that this isn't a rug
- 27:45pull. This is the risk here obviously
- 27:48is a deflation of the M NAV without accretion through
- 27:51Bitcoin acquisition. So there's a beautiful chart
- 27:55that 80 IQ Chris or whatever his name is, he's a bit, he's a
- 28:01metaplanet focus guy. He put a really good chart out
- 28:05and I need to ask him for it because I was at lunch with
- 28:07someone. I wanted to show it to them.
- 28:09Basically it's a chart of the metaplanet price and right at
- 28:15the bottom left hand corner, when you're looking at the
- 28:18price, like down in the doldrums, there's a bar which
- 28:22he's highlighted. It's like this was a 20 times
- 28:25MF. Was this the wrong time to buy
- 28:28this stock? And obviously it's just
- 28:30absolutely exploded. And then at the top of the
- 28:33chart, you know, there was a moment where it was a 3 * M now,
- 28:37right? So because the Metaplanet team
- 28:40are recruiting so aggressively and to Parker's point,
- 28:44leveraging the Fiat markets, the financial markets to just flow
- 28:49more money aggressively into Bitcoin and doing it in such a
- 28:53way that it's super accretive to their shareholders.
- 28:56They've been very successful. And I don't, I don't see where
- 29:01the rug pull comes. I mean, the way that people lose
- 29:04money is if that, you know, three times and today a 6 * M
- 29:08NAV goes to a 1 * m NAV, which eventually, by the way, all of
- 29:13this will probably end up at a 1.2 to 1.5 * M NAV.
- 29:19What? Because obviously there's only
- 29:2021 million bitcoins. So you need to be the way that
- 29:24this is all going to go is it's going to go down the route of
- 29:27financial engineering around Bitcoin, right?
- 29:30You know, MicroStrategy is unlikely to sit with 600,000
- 29:34Bitcoin on his balance sheet doing nothing, right?
- 29:36So you're going to start to see the future of capital evolve
- 29:40into, you know, what we're seeing out of the US this week,
- 29:44people being able to borrow money or sorry, fake money, Fiat
- 29:48money against their Bitcoin so that they can then use that in
- 29:53the real world. And I think that slowly as we
- 29:56transition, these companies are going to step in to provide
- 30:00collateral into the market, the Fiat markets to to see what can
- 30:05potentially happen around borrowing, lending, yield
- 30:08products, et cetera. Now, again, lots of this stuff
- 30:11are swear words to Bitcoin Maxis who say, you know, everything
- 30:16should be self custody, custody and you should never trust any
- 30:19other organization. Sure, there will always be a
- 30:22cohort of Bitcoiners that will think that way, But you know,
- 30:26the adoption of this there was always there was always going to
- 30:29be Wall Street involvement. There's always going to be this
- 30:31sort of element to it because there's such a huge amount of
- 30:35capital sitting in Wall Street in these traditional financial
- 30:39markets. So as I keep saying, this
- 30:42release valve or this vessel, which today is the Bitcoin
- 30:46treasury companies are allowing for that transition of capital
- 30:49into Bitcoin. And you know, like it or not,
- 30:53there's a lot of money in Wall Street, and it wants to
- 30:55transition over to the real money.
- 30:58Yeah, One question I have on all that maybe to try to like fill
- 31:01in some of the gaps here is the way I I interpret it is
- 31:05Michael's not calling all is not explicitly calling them rug
- 31:08poles. But maybe we're my knowledge gap
- 31:13is or what I'm trying to parse out Rich and maybe you could
- 31:15help is like how much opportunity is there actually
- 31:18here for pureplay Bitcoin treasury companies?
- 31:21Because like any market, there's winners and losers, right.
- 31:24So there's going to be really dominant players in different
- 31:27jurisdictions. And when we had Mark use go on
- 31:30maybe about a month ago, he was talking about the arbitrage that
- 31:33exists for people purchasing Metaplanet stock because the
- 31:36capital gains on purchasing Bitcoin direct was so
- 31:39prohibitively expensive. So there is way more incentive
- 31:42to purchase equities that own Bitcoin in Japan, for example.
- 31:46So what I'm trying to figure out is there's going to be winners.
- 31:50I certainly see that there's an aspect of this.
- 31:52These companies will need to exist, right?
- 31:54Because Wall Street needs a release valve, as you pointed
- 31:57out. And some players need to access
- 32:00debt markets, others will access equity markets.
- 32:02Others may purchase Bitcoin spot directly.
- 32:05But where I struggle to understand is like, who are the
- 32:09how do you think about winners and losers in this space?
- 32:11Like is there going to be dozens of pureplay companies in each
- 32:14jurisdiction that are all going to be successful or they're
- 32:17going to be very dominant players?
- 32:18Like strategy in the US, metaplan in Japan?
- 32:21Like, how do you think this all plays out over the course of the
- 32:23next five years or so? Yeah, I think you hit the nail
- 32:27on the head. It has to have a specific edge,
- 32:31right? So why is the UK so successful
- 32:34with these companies? Why have we seen a, what is it
- 32:37100 X already in Smarter Web company in four months that
- 32:41they've been listed? Well, the reason is that there's
- 32:44a £1.25 trillion pension pool that is self directable in the
- 32:49UK that can't touch Bitcoin ETFs, right?
- 32:53So there is just huge demand from retail investors to get
- 32:58some exposure to Bitcoin, right? A lot of them.
- 33:01This is why MicroStrategy did so well was because actually
- 33:05MicroStrategy was one of the few stocks that you could buy in the
- 33:09UK in the pension system under, you know, SIP rules.
- 33:15You know, I have a friend who he has a self-directed pension in
- 33:19Guernsey and he's like, oh rich, what should I buy?
- 33:23I said, well, this was a few months ago.
- 33:25I said you should buy Metaplanet and they refused to let him
- 33:28because they'd already realized that Metaplanet was a Bitcoin
- 33:31treasury company. But the UK based companies, it's
- 33:35almost impossible for the trustees to say no.
- 33:38So that's the edge that they have and why Smarter Web have
- 33:43managed to explode to the degree that they have.
- 33:47And I think that you're going to see more and more UK companies
- 33:50come out of the woodwork as well because there's just so much
- 33:54demand in the UK for Bitcoin exposure.
- 33:58And also, you know, smarter web, they've grown very, very fast.
- 34:03A lot of people have felt that they've missed it.
- 34:06So I think the opportunity for a smaller, a smaller company to
- 34:10hit the hit the markets like a coin psyllium has done, you can
- 34:14see that I mean super successful already.
- 34:19Yeah, I think that'll make sense.
- 34:20I think that's a big component of we saw a lot of individuals
- 34:24in the US that had spot exposure and get their I remember the
- 34:27past few years that they would have access to their wife's four
- 34:30O 1 KS. They were retired and like stay
- 34:31at home mom and they just aped them into MSTR without them
- 34:34knowing. So I can see how that that makes
- 34:36sense. I think just to be clear on the
- 34:37rug pulls, when I reference that, I just mainly mean where
- 34:42somebody gets shaken out and it could be via like I was writing
- 34:45down like volatility. It could be the structure of
- 34:47products that they do underneath to accrete value.
- 34:49It could be the custody, which nobody's talking about.
- 34:52I think there's a, it's a, it's a super interesting dynamic,
- 34:58Rich, you're referencing about like the hardcore bit corners
- 35:00and then and then Wall Street. It's like we have no home and
- 35:04that's how I know we're either all know something or again,
- 35:06we're very dumb. And I told this to Cam before
- 35:08because the bitcoiners hate us because we tell you multi
- 35:10institution custody, you don't have to hold your keys and then
- 35:14try hates us. They want to hold the underline
- 35:15and do a bunch of crazy stuff. So we're either insanely wrong
- 35:18or we're really, really right. And that's the angle about
- 35:24around the past 15 years. Everyone's had a news story
- 35:26every cycle and it's really about the inorganic
- 35:28centralization of the underline. I always think about block 1 is
- 35:32this big conglomerate that had like 200,000 and 10 Bitcoin and
- 35:35they took a lot of people's and not even took a lot of people's.
- 35:38It was during the ICO craze. But we've seen the FTXS and
- 35:41we've seen the block fives. And it's not that Bitcoin back
- 35:43lending is inherently bad in the same way that every business is
- 35:46going to hold Bitcoin. It's really the notion of how is
- 35:50it sold? How is it portrayed?
- 35:52And then where does it actually go wrong?
- 35:55And then the kicker is I don't even think a lot of people will
- 35:57actually do anything. It's that somebody's going to
- 36:00mess up custody or something else.
- 36:01And then everyone's going to wake up and realize, wait, what
- 36:03the hell is this thing that they're holding and what's the
- 36:06best in class way I should do it without this counterparty risk.
- 36:09And that's kind of like, I think my big thing is it kind of
- 36:12praise in the naivete and the individual doesn't even know
- 36:14about Bitcoin. They're buying something that's
- 36:16tied close to Bitcoin because once in the beauty is it doesn't
- 36:20even matter what I or anyone thinks.
- 36:22Because generally as somebody goes down the rabbit hole,
- 36:23they're just going to be like, well, what am I doing here?
- 36:25And they're going to sell the position and then buy the
- 36:27Bitcoin. Which is why I think this is
- 36:28just a short term thing in general, especially for
- 36:31institutional allocators because it's a, it seems very crazy to
- 36:34me that the most sophisticated people today may not be able to
- 36:37get exposure. So they have to go through all
- 36:39these products. But in the future, they're not
- 36:41going to say, well, if I want 10 to 50% of My Portfolio, I'm not
- 36:44going to do an investing class way.
- 36:45I'm going to have to do what there's some proxy that doesn't
- 36:47like track for me from A, just like how this will play out.
- 36:53Yeah, I think. Which means the shareholder
- 36:54value. Which means the shareholder
- 36:55value would would reduce, right? Yeah.
- 36:59And that's what I said. I think longer term Mnavs
- 37:02gravitate towards sort of 1.21.5.
- 37:07I can see that happening as as you get more and more of these
- 37:11companies. Can you guys hear me OK?
- 37:14Yeah, OK. Yeah, I think that that will
- 37:19happen. I think this is a short term
- 37:22period where that, you know, it's, it's like just just always
- 37:26want to picture that triangle, the huge triangle, the the
- 37:29amount of pressure. It's like right now it sounds
- 37:32like a bicycle tire hiss right. But it's basically Niagara Falls
- 37:39building up behind that wall and it needs to smash through the
- 37:42dam and everybody needs to get exposure to Bitcoin.
- 37:46So you are likely to see a continuation of this in my
- 37:51opinion, because there's just so much capital built up that needs
- 37:57to get all the various things that I explained earlier, be it
- 38:01our performance in equities, you know, the rate of debasement at
- 38:05least in the bond markets or the volatility, right.
- 38:08So all of those things are key to those different capital
- 38:11pools. So I think we've probably got
- 38:15another period of of of a decent a decent period.
- 38:18I think there will be moments like we've seen in the last 48
- 38:21hours where the M Navs massively reduce and everybody has a panic
- 38:26up and you know, that's just organic, you know, ups and downs
- 38:32that we see in the market. And Metaplanet has been through
- 38:35all of this in the same way that the smaller companies are now
- 38:38going through it. But I think to your point about
- 38:43the centralization, I think you might raise a very, very good
- 38:46point about the fact that these companies, everybody's just
- 38:50assuming that they've got, you know, best in class governance
- 38:54around the way that they're dealing with their custody, all
- 38:57of these types of things. I'm not seeing a lot of
- 38:59questions being asked about that.
- 39:02So for me, I always put the sort of checklist out there.
- 39:07Do you trust the management team to make sure that they're doing
- 39:11everything properly? Because the other thing to think
- 39:13about as well is the exchanges that are listing these don't
- 39:19have the same level of governance as the higher end
- 39:22exchanges. So for example, in the UK,
- 39:26you've got the LSE, you've got then a sub market called AIM and
- 39:29then the sub sub market called Aquis, which is very, very
- 39:34flexible, very low governance. And you talk about block fire,
- 39:38you talk about Celsius, you know, what were the problems
- 39:41there? Lack of governance, lack of
- 39:45proper security solutions, right?
- 39:49And then, you know, doing high risk strategies without any kind
- 39:53of risk management. So you know, we, we have seen
- 39:57these disaster shows before. And to your point, if they're
- 39:59not managing their custody solutions?
- 40:02Properly or their governance solutions properly, you could
- 40:06end up with a theft or a loss. So these are really important
- 40:10considerations. Hope you're enjoying the episode
- 40:12real quick. Would really appreciate a like a
- 40:15comment if you're watching on YouTube.
- 40:17If you're listening on Apple or Spotify, a five star review
- 40:21really helps. A lot of time goes into booking
- 40:23guests, preparing for the show to make it a good use of your
- 40:26time, and then everything as relates to post production
- 40:29editing. So if you could just take a
- 40:31second to leave a review, a like or a comment and comments could
- 40:35provide feedback as well if you think there's things we could do
- 40:37better. So just want to hear from you.
- 40:39Really appreciate any engagement.
- 40:40It helps quite a bit in terms of continuing to get our message
- 40:44out and hopefully add more value to others that haven't found us
- 40:48yet. So if you do that, really
- 40:49appreciate it. And then the other thing would
- 40:51be if you're not subscribed to our research already, you could
- 40:54do so at on rampbitcoin.com/leaveitsresearch.
- 40:59And you can get our weekly round up there with white papers,
- 41:02weekly analysis, product updates, etcetera.
- 41:06So enjoy the rest of the episode and really appreciate you being
- 41:08here. Yeah, well said.
- 41:10Some people are concerned about the leverage in these markets,
- 41:13which we had Alex Thorne on a couple weeks ago.
- 41:16And what worked into more detail about the leverage that exists
- 41:19in Bitcoin treasury companies And the assessment there is that
- 41:22it's really not that blown out yet in terms of debt financing
- 41:26to acquire more Bitcoin. But maybe Rich and Michael, both
- 41:30to your .1 of the bigger risks that investors need to consider
- 41:33with this is kind of the underlying structure of how
- 41:35Bitcoin is secured, how the management team thinks about
- 41:40risk management, custody, counterparty risk, etcetera.
- 41:43As we know, that is critically important in Bitcoin more so
- 41:46than in traditional finance because you're dealing with a
- 41:48digital bear instrument. But maybe to move on and know we
- 41:52want to cover some other things and we have a tight timeline
- 41:55today. One thing I wanted to get the
- 41:56group's thoughts on was Bill Pulte, who kind of like a name
- 42:02that I wasn't too familiar with before this week.
- 42:05It kind of reminds me of Bo Hines six months ago.
- 42:07All of a sudden, everyone talks about Bo Hines, but Bill's.
- 42:11He's a director of Federal Housing Finance Agency, and he's
- 42:13a chair. He's the chairman of Fannie Mae
- 42:16and Freddie Mac and he issued A directive, it was either
- 42:19yesterday, Wednesday or it might have been Tuesday about allowing
- 42:23Bitcoin and crypto to be considered as part of not not
- 42:28collateral, but it's part of almost like a credit check or an
- 42:31asset check for people qualifying for single family
- 42:34residence in the United States. And we'd love to just get
- 42:37general thoughts like some people had reactions that, oh,
- 42:40this is incredibly bullish for Bitcoin because now people do
- 42:42not have to sell their Bitcoin. I kind of think it might not be
- 42:45as big of a deal because people in general are always looking
- 42:49for ways not to sell their Bitcoin.
- 42:51I deal with clients quite frequently who are looking to
- 42:54purchase a primary residence or even a secondary residence and
- 42:57they're taking out a Bitcoin back loan to do so.
- 43:00And so they weren't going to sell their Bitcoin to begin
- 43:01with. So I'm not sure how
- 43:03consequential this actually is. It's of course a great thing
- 43:06right, because people that have a serious or material allocation
- 43:10to Bitcoin and they want to be able to buy a home.
- 43:12Well, now that they'll be looked at a little bit more seriously
- 43:14from from lenders, but I'm curious like general thoughts
- 43:17there, because I think it's just like not as big of a deal as
- 43:21people are making out to be. And then we could also talk
- 43:23about the the clause in there as well.
- 43:26Brahm, I think you called it out where you know, for this for the
- 43:28Bitcoin or crypto to be considered, it does need to be
- 43:30held on a centralized exchange, which I think makes a lot of
- 43:33sense. But it also again, talking about
- 43:35counterparty risk and custody risk, then you have to consider
- 43:38that as well. So open question for anyone.
- 43:41Just welcome thoughts on this topic.
- 43:46Yeah. I think also to tie, you know,
- 43:48the previous discussion, I think this is just the path, right?
- 43:52Like we know what Bitcoin is. I think we all agree that once
- 43:59it is used more in, I don't want to say traditional finance
- 44:04sense, but in a finance sense, you know, and the more it gets
- 44:08established, the higher the probability of it still
- 44:11surviving, right? And becoming the thing that that
- 44:15that we think it is. But slowly but surely, you know,
- 44:18one by one, people are figuring this out.
- 44:20And so I think that's also interesting about these
- 44:23discussions that we have here are doing podcasts, right?
- 44:26Like we are in such a bubble. We really did the work and we
- 44:31are just watching the rest of the world slowly waking up.
- 44:34So, and maybe also to the point of, of Michael about, you know,
- 44:38the treasury companies or the, the rock pool part.
- 44:40It's like it's, I see it as growing pains.
- 44:43So people are going to try stuff.
- 44:45Stuff is going to go well, stuff is going to go horribly wrong,
- 44:49right? Because we are, we are talking
- 44:50about money and wealth and also inexperienced people that are
- 44:55seeing opportunities, right? So I think this is in general a
- 45:01maturing market, a very slowly maturing market and, and stuff
- 45:05will go right and stuff will go wrong.
- 45:07And I think, you know, for, for this topic about using Bitcoin
- 45:13as I think it's more like proof of wealth or proof of funds in
- 45:17order to actually get a mortgage, right.
- 45:19So you don't have to sell the Bitcoin.
- 45:20But there was like a byline in this request, or I'll call it a
- 45:26request that it has to be in a centralized place, which on one
- 45:30sense, on one side makes makes sense, right?
- 45:33Because you want the collateral at least for the, for the, the
- 45:38financing side, they want the collateral to be in, in between
- 45:41the person that borrows and, and, and the, and the lender.
- 45:44But I think there are this is actually an opportunity where
- 45:47new products and services will pop up, right?
- 45:50Like maybe we can have zero knowledge proof of Bitcoin
- 45:53wealth, right, or the escrow services or, you know, whatever
- 45:57on ramp could build on top of of what they provide.
- 46:00So I think this is actually the start of something new and I, I
- 46:06think that would be the best way to to look at it and and that
- 46:09there will be growing pains along the way.
- 46:11I think it's probably 100% assured.
- 46:15Yeah, I think it's. I think it's.
- 46:18I was just going to say from it's more like extremely
- 46:21positive and constructive from a narrative perspective.
- 46:24I think the just the legitimate, the continued legitimization of
- 46:29the asset. I mean, where my mind does go is
- 46:31like, I'm, I'm curious around, you know, what this ends up
- 46:35looking like in terms of because it's, it says all crypto assets,
- 46:39right? So like I would much prefer that
- 46:41it was Bitcoin specific because I think similar to like with the
- 46:44SBR stuff, right? Like there was a clear line in
- 46:47the sand of like Bitcoin is the reserve asset.
- 46:50The rest of these things are more speculative and and
- 46:53therefore we're not going to buy any more.
- 46:55We're only going to potentially sell them.
- 46:58I would hope that there was some distinction for this type of
- 47:01thing because, you know, using your fart coin as proof of
- 47:06wealth is very different than using your Bitcoin holdings as
- 47:09proof of wealth. So like, is there going to be,
- 47:11you know, analysts behind the scenes who like have knowledge
- 47:15of crypto assets, who are then assessing the different profiles
- 47:18of someone who's, you know, proving their wealth with crypto
- 47:21assets? Like those are some outstanding
- 47:23questions in my mind. And and so I think it's
- 47:25generally good, but we'll see how the implementation actually
- 47:30goes. Yeah, maybe one one thing to
- 47:33add, sorry M1 thing to add because I just saw a tweet of
- 47:37Simon Dixon. So these are his words, but he's
- 47:39talking about the IMF. So whatever you think about the
- 47:41IMF, but he says the economic hitman at the IMF now classified
- 47:46Bitcoin as a capital asset, categorized as a non produced,
- 47:50non financial asset like land or gold, recognizing bitcoins
- 47:54decentralized nature and lack of issuer.
- 47:56So this makes it distinct from stable coins, which are treated
- 47:59as financial instruments. So that's just to add Brian to
- 48:03what you said. Yeah, it's just slowly being
- 48:06legitimized more, more and more. That's basically the point I.
- 48:11Think these credit risk departments who you know, I
- 48:14mean, the way that they work is they'll look at an asset,
- 48:16they'll look at the liquidity of the asset and they'll look at
- 48:19the, you know, the viability of being able to get out of the
- 48:22asset in the event of a margin call.
- 48:24So something like FARC coin as you talk about is, is not really
- 48:29going to be categorized with the same strength as Bitcoin, right?
- 48:34There will be a haircut on FARC coin to probably 99%.
- 48:39They have to take it by the sounds of the way that this has
- 48:42been constructed. So they'll just put a 99.9%
- 48:45haircut on it and that will be the end of the conversation.
- 48:49So I think when you look at what this is really saying, this is
- 48:56this is Bitcoin really being institutionalized at at every
- 49:01level within the financial markets.
- 49:04And I think that is a very, very big positive.
- 49:07I think lots of people have made the comment that, you know, if
- 49:10you've had your Bitcoin in cold storage for multiple years and
- 49:14then you want to go and move it to a centralized organization
- 49:18and for some reason that centralized organization decides
- 49:20that, oh, this touched the Silk Road actually.
- 49:23So now we've frozen your assets. You know, these are things that
- 49:28probably need to be considerations.
- 49:31I don't know how we think about all of that from, you know,
- 49:35obviously we run a fund that's denominated in Bitcoin and you
- 49:39know, we run it, We run Bitcoin through a risk metric.
- 49:44But if someone comes to us and says, look, I'm not sure where,
- 49:48you know, my Bitcoin has been, you know, I did a real estate
- 49:53transaction in Asia like 10 years ago and someone paid me
- 49:58like 5% of it in Bitcoin. Like, you know, we'll say, well,
- 50:03look, just check the wallets yourself before you try and come
- 50:07to us, you know, and put it through a situation.
- 50:11So I think that people just obviously need to understand
- 50:16that this technology comes with a track record and if you have
- 50:21any concern about it, then you know, you need to you need to
- 50:24understand how to look at it, right.
- 50:28Yeah, I think agree with all those points.
- 50:30I think that to the point of institutionalizing, I don't know
- 50:34if there's probably any other asset even half of crypto which
- 50:37is like roughly 5 to 6 trillion that doesn't get recognized by
- 50:41the traditional markets for a home loan, right.
- 50:43So this notion of we're going to start to recognize this, it's
- 50:47this realization that it's here. And then to Brahms point, we're
- 50:50like in the installation phase with all of this.
- 50:52So there's naturally going to be some volatility or you know,
- 50:56things that don't go perfect. So to the point for coin or be
- 50:59able to manage that or the custody.
- 51:02But you know, I think this also ties back to what Richard was
- 51:06saying about the way I think about Bitcoin is just
- 51:09recapitalizing debt, unproductive and productive.
- 51:14The people that do the productive debt are going to
- 51:16make their money back. The people that do unproductive
- 51:17debt, they're probably going to get left holding a bag of less
- 51:20Bitcoin because you hear about bit bonds and all these ideas.
- 51:23I think that things people forget is you have to
- 51:24recapitalize productive debt because if it's unproductive,
- 51:26you're probably still, you know, can't repay back the debt if
- 51:29you're not recurring revenue from it, but from housing.
- 51:33A majority of people's wealth is stored in and especially in the
- 51:37United States and middle America's is in their house.
- 51:41And so whether it's going to be the notion of products that let
- 51:44you get access to liquidity to buy Bitcoin and then that
- 51:48naturally keeps the price of the underlying asset growing versus
- 51:51just completely like crashing and wiping out a lot of people's
- 51:54stores of value. And then also to Jackson's
- 51:57point, there's a lot of people that sell their Bitcoin.
- 51:58For every person you hear that took a loan out for their
- 52:00Bitcoin, there's a probably like 5 to 10 that sold it because
- 52:03most people don't want to deal with the volatility like they
- 52:06don't want to deal with like they have.
- 52:07That's a reoccurring expense that they have to pay on the
- 52:09juice for the interest. So I think this has also
- 52:12implications for the upside for people that aren't going to have
- 52:15that downside pressure. And then for Richard's point on
- 52:18the like debt markets that's going to allow other people, you
- 52:20can imagine they probably charge an extra point, an extra 2
- 52:23points to be able to take a loan and recognize your FAR coin.
- 52:25Maybe they make some money. Like there's a lot of, I think,
- 52:28really positive implications. So yeah, it's exciting.
- 52:34Yeah, makes sense. And the the clause about custody
- 52:38makes sense as well because with self custody, right, you could
- 52:42in theory provide your address as part of a wealth check.
- 52:47But then you know, a year later you lose your keys or something
- 52:51happens and then you no longer have access to your Bitcoin.
- 52:53So it makes sense it needs to be on a centralized exchange, but
- 52:55then you know, to to the all of our points made on this podcast
- 52:59already does bear risks. So it'll be interesting to see
- 53:01how this plays out. But no doubt a positive
- 53:03development. And maybe I'm just bearish.
- 53:05Maybe, Michael, I'm living in a bubble where nobody does sell
- 53:08their Bitcoin, but there are a lot of people I suppose, out
- 53:10there that that will. Well, I'd just say, Jackson,
- 53:14the, the amount of buying that you're seeing in the market and
- 53:17the fact that we're not 250,000 tells you that a lot of people
- 53:21are very happy to sell their Bitcoin, right?
- 53:24Yeah, somebody saw. Yeah, I did want to talk about
- 53:27that as well because this has been a bit of an abnormal cycle.
- 53:31Not to say I'm ungrateful that, you know, we've cleared 6
- 53:34figures and Bitcoin is consolidating at 100K and you
- 53:38know, through a lot of uncertainty in the Middle East
- 53:41and tensions rising there, Bitcoin has remained extremely
- 53:44resilient. The flip side of that though, is
- 53:46you have all these Bitcoin treasury companies that are
- 53:49aggressively tapping capital markets to purchase Bitcoin.
- 53:53Just for example, Anthony Pompliano, they raised I think
- 53:58750 million in initial funding. They've already purchased 5000
- 54:01Bitcoin average price of 105106, I believe.
- 54:05But we're still pretty suppressed in terms of
- 54:09historical cycles. And I think there's there are a
- 54:12few reasons that come to mind immediate immediately.
- 54:14If you just look at the, you know, post halving performance,
- 54:17the price was pretty elevated historically at the halving
- 54:21already because it juiced up quite a bit from all that pent
- 54:24up demand in the ETF products. So we started at a pretty high
- 54:27base. We hit hit all time highs prior
- 54:30to last year's halving, but now we're just consolidating at 100K
- 54:34or so. We still have six months in the
- 54:38rest of the year. So I'm just kind of curious to
- 54:39hear anyone's thoughts in terms of how this will continue to
- 54:44play out through 2025. You have so much demand and as
- 54:48we know a fixed supply, but there clearly are there is some
- 54:52selling pressure from perhaps larger whales.
- 54:55But what are you guys thoughts on that?
- 54:57I mean, I'm, you know, maybe I'm being a little impatient, but I
- 55:01thought we'd be higher by now. Bram and I always talk about
- 55:05this. We talk about the fact that you
- 55:07should be grateful that you can still keep buying Bitcoin at
- 55:10these levels and that we haven't adjusted to where arguably the
- 55:14price should be, right. You know, I mean, I, I made a
- 55:18presentation to the, to the board of seize group, so the
- 55:22bank board primarily. And I said, I made the point
- 55:30like once I ran through essentially what Bitcoin was
- 55:33and, and sort of told a few stories around it, like everyone
- 55:37in the room, you understand now that this is a much better
- 55:41product than gold ever was as a store of value.
- 55:45So even if you just say it's as good as gold and the value being
- 55:49of gold, 23 trillion today, then Bitcoin needs to be trading at
- 55:53about $1.1 million to equate to that market cap to just be as
- 55:59good as gold. So the fact that you can buy
- 56:01Bitcoin today at 107,000, that's a really nice discount.
- 56:06So yeah, I I'm grateful. Yeah.
- 56:10I mean, I mean that's, that's absolutely right.
- 56:12I think that if you're just looking like who is selling like
- 56:17there is on chain evidence that long term holders with extremely
- 56:20low cost basis is have been selling into this level for for
- 56:23months. So that's that is certainly
- 56:26happening. I think the other thing that
- 56:28comes to my mind is like, it's easy for us being so deep in the
- 56:34space to think like all these people are buying.
- 56:37It's so obvious you have all these treasury companies, but
- 56:41then at the same time you look at, you know, very sharp pools
- 56:47of capital that are still just just beginning to come up the
- 56:50curve. Like Philippe Lafont, who has
- 56:53run CO2 for a long time, just this past week was on multiple
- 56:58podcasts, interviews saying that he has completely re evaluated
- 57:02his stance on Bitcoin. And like, that's just a signal
- 57:07that we're still extremely early.
- 57:08Like the vast majority of huge pools of capital, smart money
- 57:13are still just beginning to come up the curve.
- 57:15And so it's easy to lose sight of that in a moment like this
- 57:18where when you have our level of knowledge and sort of just like,
- 57:21you know, looking at it every day, like, yeah, we should
- 57:23obviously be be way higher. But you put those two things in
- 57:27tandem, long term holder selling and just the reality of if you
- 57:30escape this bubble for a moment, people are still just beginning
- 57:33to learn what's going on here. It kind of makes sense.
- 57:37But totally agree with you, Richard.
- 57:38It is somewhat of a blessing. I'll keep saying it.
- 57:45A Bitcoin is an asymmetric opportunity based on publicly
- 57:48available information. I love that we're touching upon
- 57:52this, right, because there's, there are people and I think you
- 57:54use the word the correct Jackson, it's impatience, it's
- 57:58impatient. So if you are impatient, if you
- 58:01think like, oh, it should be this or should be that, then you
- 58:04don't really trust your own judgement.
- 58:06Because I actually have a podcast coming up with Steven
- 58:09paranoid. He's an astrophysicist who's
- 58:11like deep down, you know, the power law rabbit hole and stuff
- 58:15like that. You know, once you really see
- 58:17the, the, the bigger picture, which starts with, you know,
- 58:21Fiat monetary debasement is a is mathematically assured and and
- 58:25will never stop. You know what if you really do
- 58:28your due diligence on Bitcoin and you create your conviction
- 58:32based upon your own proof of work, then the only test you
- 58:37have is can you actually huddle? Right?
- 58:40If if you become impatient and you know, you find other
- 58:44impatient people online and you're like, Oh my God, you
- 58:47know, what is the price doing? Why aren't these people paying
- 58:49attention what a say or they're doing blah, blah, blah.
- 58:52You know, then you're still captured with the field mind.
- 58:55You know, the whole point is if you have better money than all
- 58:58the other money, you can actually chill, you know, So I,
- 59:02I like that personal challenge. I just want to add that as well.
- 59:05No, it's it's a really it's profound in what you're saying
- 59:10because this is what embeds all the Luddite Bitcoiners and what
- 59:13they say about Nick Quinn, always the matter if it's today
- 59:17or before it takes the path of most resistance or most time.
- 59:20It always shakes the people out. It always shakes people that are
- 59:22impatient. It almost operates like a
- 59:24fractal in the sense that it doesn't matter if it was 12 or
- 59:2625, the capital polls increase, but it still has the same human
- 59:31behavior because humans still run these things, which is
- 59:33what's embedded the beginning part of the conversation.
- 59:36I had this thought, Richard, you'll love us.
- 59:38It's like I was like, man, I need to get into meta planner.
- 59:41I need to get into whatever. Like I just, I got to do it.
- 59:44And I had thoughts about Solana being in this space too.
- 59:46They were very similar. Like you just early, you get to
- 59:49see all the things happening. You know, Dylan, Dylan was an
- 59:51advisor as before joining Mediplan.
- 59:52Like you can see all these things.
- 59:53You're like, I should get in. But then it's like there's
- 59:56there's principal, but forget about the principles.
- 59:58Just like the mindshare of like, there's so much shit going on
- 1:00:00here to have to think about. When do I exit that trade?
- 1:00:02I just don't want that sauce on me.
- 1:00:04But the real point was it started to remind me of IC OS.
- 1:00:07And I'm not saying they are IC OS, but I had that same feeling
- 1:00:10because back in the day during IC OS.
- 1:00:12It was like, shit, am I the idiot?
- 1:00:14Are we the idiots? And like we should go and like
- 1:00:16go invest there and then. And that was like the moment I
- 1:00:19was like, oh shit, now I need to stay away from this and actually
- 1:00:21talk more about it. If we're wrong, we're wrong.
- 1:00:24But that's the idea is it's very easy to buy Bitcoin.
- 1:00:27It's insanely hard to hold it just incredibly hard.
- 1:00:31And so that's the notion of like, I think where a lot of
- 1:00:34this just kind of level of, I don't know, it's almost like a,
- 1:00:40a mechanism to help like, I don't know, but that's the kind
- 1:00:43of idea I think that embodies a lot of this stuff, especially
- 1:00:46the price action. And so that's where I think we'd
- 1:00:49probably go a lot higher. I hate making price predictions,
- 1:00:51but I think we go higher than anybody's expecting because of
- 1:00:54all the stuff we're talking about Bitcoin, treasuries, the
- 1:00:56amount of time we've been consolidating this period.
- 1:00:58But then I do think if we're just barely talking about
- 1:01:01treasuries today, the amount of craziness that we'll all look
- 1:01:05back a year from now, two years that happens at the treasury
- 1:01:07level is going to cause that like, you know, deleveraging
- 1:01:10event. And then that's kind of like
- 1:01:12the, I think the rug pull for a lot of people are going to get
- 1:01:14burned. And that's just the nature of
- 1:01:16installation phase in a new technological wave.
- 1:01:20Yeah, I'll, I'll say it again. I mean, I think these Bitcoin
- 1:01:23treasury companies are Bitcoin adoption.
- 1:01:26They're Bitcoin adoption by the financial markets, by the play,
- 1:01:30the big players in Wall Street. It's not the same as looking at
- 1:01:33Solana and going, oh, I want to punt around in this nonsense,
- 1:01:36right? Like I try my very utmost best
- 1:01:42to help people understand that it's Bitcoin only.
- 1:01:46It's really hard. Sometimes people just get
- 1:01:48tempted by the other tokens. And obviously, as you say,
- 1:01:51there's a lot of very clever marketing that happens with all
- 1:01:53this stuff, but the Bitcoin treasuries are Bitcoin adoption
- 1:01:58and I think it's different. And I think it's really
- 1:02:01important to just make that distinction.
- 1:02:03Sure, to your point, there will be a point that it's painful,
- 1:02:09there are tears. You know, Mesoplanet, when it
- 1:02:12was down in that tiny stock price phase, when it went to all
- 1:02:16the way to 21 M NAV, well, it, it crashed back down.
- 1:02:19But now look at it. And if you'd border that 21 * M
- 1:02:22NAV, you'd still be way in the money because they're accreting.
- 1:02:26And so long as they're accreting and they're using the financial
- 1:02:28markets effectively to do so, they would just keep going
- 1:02:31higher and higher. So I think there's a scale
- 1:02:35problem, which is why I think pumps made a bit of a mistake
- 1:02:38and I think 21 Capital have made a bit of a mistake.
- 1:02:41They've started way too big, right?
- 1:02:43They can't scale, they can't yield to the same degree.
- 1:02:46So they don't have the same level of torque, as we call it,
- 1:02:50as these smaller companies. And when you're doing that talk
- 1:02:55and you're making the multiples, that's when you build the
- 1:02:58community. That's when people become
- 1:02:59diehard fans. MicroStrategy obviously built a
- 1:03:04whole load of diehard fans over five years with pretty much no
- 1:03:07competition right there. There are people and myself
- 1:03:11included that will never sell a core allocation in
- 1:03:15MicroStrategy, just one, right, that for me, I like, I love the
- 1:03:21way sailors continue to innovate.
- 1:03:23He's continued to tap different pools of capital in the market.
- 1:03:26And I think as we move into phase two of this thing, as I
- 1:03:29alluded earlier, when you start looking at the banks, sorry,
- 1:03:32banking type services provided by these very large holders of
- 1:03:36Bitcoin, that's where again micro strategy is going to be
- 1:03:39leading the way. Richard, can you put a finer
- 1:03:42point on, on what you just described around basically
- 1:03:47starting at a lower base? Because I think that it to some
- 1:03:49that might be a little counterintuitive.
- 1:03:51If like the goal of all these things is to acquire a ton of
- 1:03:53Bitcoin, why is it a bad thing to start with a huge slug of
- 1:03:56Bitcoin? Like can you just elaborate on
- 1:03:58that a little bit? Well, take 21, I mean 21
- 1:04:03Capital's a good example. So they started with 42,000
- 1:04:06Bitcoin. No one was allowed to
- 1:04:07participate. It's basically Tether bit Fenix,
- 1:04:10SoftBank, right? So they will put their Bitcoin
- 1:04:15in right the way that you measure the validity of the M
- 1:04:20nerve on these Bitcoin treasury companies as you look at their
- 1:04:23Bitcoin yield right metaplanet, I think their yield so far this
- 1:04:27year is something like 300% right.
- 1:04:32You look at the smaller companies, it's into the
- 1:04:34thousands of percent, right? So that's accretion of value to
- 1:04:38the shareholders, right? And remember, even as, so let's
- 1:04:43say Smarter Web, they did a capital raise I think 10, two
- 1:04:47weeks ago where they cut their M NAV in half essentially.
- 1:04:51So they went from a 25, sorry, 12 * M NAV to a 6 1/2 * M NAV,
- 1:04:58right? And then the M NAV slowly
- 1:05:00drifted up again, which gave them that torque to be able to
- 1:05:02do it again. So they just did a capital raise
- 1:05:05last night where they do it again, right?
- 1:05:08So they cut the M NAV in half again.
- 1:05:10So, so long as they keep doing that and they keep sustaining
- 1:05:12the amount of Bitcoin and the value base either collateral,
- 1:05:16either Bitcoin keeps just growing at a a much faster rate.
- 1:05:21And so when you look at a company like Metaplanet last
- 1:05:25year and you go, Jesus Christ, they went up 2500% in a single
- 1:05:30year. And by the way, that was only
- 1:05:313/4 of the year because they only started in April.
- 1:05:34That's unsustainable and that's your natural reaction if you're
- 1:05:38Jim Chanos, right? And, and these sorts of people.
- 1:05:41But actually the stock's gone up another I think 500% so far this
- 1:05:47year. I mean, we've started the year
- 1:05:48we were sort of 2 1/2 dollars. So you know, I think it's about
- 1:05:54$11.00 today. I see that's nearly five times
- 1:05:58right, that it's gone up. So when you when you look at
- 1:06:02that and you say, OK, that's what what's propelling that it's
- 1:06:06the talk, it's the Bitcoin yield, right?
- 1:06:09And for 21 capital to have Bitcoin yield to replicate
- 1:06:16Mesaplanet, they need to add 108 a 160,000 Bitcoin in the next
- 1:06:23few months to just replicate Mesaplanet so far this year.
- 1:06:29So it's impossible for them to do so, right?
- 1:06:31Like even with tether behind them, it's going to be very
- 1:06:34hard. I think tethers entire Bitcoin
- 1:06:36holding is 100,000. So it's it's just a question of
- 1:06:42growth and when they get to maturity and you could argue
- 1:06:46that MicroStrategy is mature. He needs to have had a track
- 1:06:50record of trust in the market where people know that he is
- 1:06:54going to do everything to just accrete more Bitcoin and he's
- 1:06:57going to keep tapping different capital pools, which is exactly
- 1:07:01what he's doing. He is absolutely relentless and
- 1:07:04singularly focused and he's shown the market that
- 1:07:07consistently for five years. How's Jack Malice and and 21
- 1:07:14Capital going to show that same level of track record without
- 1:07:18the talk, right, that these other companies have to compete
- 1:07:22with him? They're building a fan base and
- 1:07:24whether you like it or not, because you can then compare it
- 1:07:27to Icos, these communities become die hard fans.
- 1:07:32I'm a die hard fan of MicroStrategy and Metaplanet,
- 1:07:35right? And so, you know, I think as the
- 1:07:39next ones emerge, if we, you know, put a little bit of
- 1:07:42capital into those and they show us they are trustworthy, they
- 1:07:46show us they're capable of execution, they show us that
- 1:07:49they're capable of financial engineering and innovation, then
- 1:07:55they will create die hard fans. Do we do an honor ramp?
- 1:08:00Corporate treasury? Will you help us?
- 1:08:03Will you help us? You're pretty.
- 1:08:04You're pretty tight. You're pretty tight in this
- 1:08:06game. Look, I think you guys have
- 1:08:10great reputation. I think you're definitely smart
- 1:08:14innovators in this space and I think the temptation in the US
- 1:08:17always is, you know, this is the way we look at the US as
- 1:08:21Europeans. And Bram, I'm bulk, I'm putting
- 1:08:24you in with me as well. It's like you always just want
- 1:08:26to go bigger and better. It's about being bigger, right
- 1:08:29Big. Let's go big.
- 1:08:30You know, let's do the huge, big treasury.
- 1:08:32I'm going to buy more Bitcoin than you, right?
- 1:08:34Like it's just like, no, guys like you, you, you're missing
- 1:08:38the point of this stage because you're not going to be able to
- 1:08:40get the same level of growth if you don't do it in a more
- 1:08:43organic way. It's organic, right?
- 1:08:46And that's what I'm trying to express with all of this.
- 1:08:50To be fair, you know, a lot of these companies have other, you
- 1:08:53know, I think maybe the kicker what you just described with 21
- 1:08:56is some of that additional fan chair.
- 1:08:59If you can funnel in Bitcoin offshore from tethering dollars
- 1:09:02into the system, there's a lot of other angles that people will
- 1:09:05do or VCs getting their their companies to go public so they
- 1:09:09can get out of their liquidity. I think there's a lot of angles,
- 1:09:12but to your point, to create value you got to start at that
- 1:09:15base. Dave.
- 1:09:18I don't, I don't know how much time we have guys, but I have
- 1:09:21maybe some thoughts also to, to, to tie it in with the beginning
- 1:09:24actually when when we were talking about Bitcoin as the
- 1:09:27hurdle rate and also these treasury companies, the the ICO
- 1:09:31comparison. I mean, I, I did a lot of Icos
- 1:09:33in my crypto day, right? I think I funded more than 10
- 1:09:38neo banks that never saw the light of day, right.
- 1:09:41So I mean, I, I, I totally get the comparison.
- 1:09:46I think it's good also to chat about it.
- 1:09:48How, how we are not talking about it.
- 1:09:51There's just opportunity, right? So Bitcoin is being legitimized.
- 1:09:55People see this upper, this opportunity.
- 1:09:57I think Richard's comments are something that I fully aligned
- 1:10:03with, right? Like it's just OK, I see an
- 1:10:05opportunity, I'm going to go big, but how sustainable is it,
- 1:10:09right? Because if you don't have that
- 1:10:11community, and I think it's actually a dirty word right from
- 1:10:15the crypto days, but I do agree, if you don't have that, then
- 1:10:21you're interchangeable with whatever other stock is trying,
- 1:10:26whatever other companies trying to build a Bitcoin treasury.
- 1:10:29So eventually we're going to fall into that same game, which
- 1:10:33is fine because that's a psychology, that's the Fiat
- 1:10:36money psychology eventually. And that's, that's what I also
- 1:10:40meant at the beginning, like this is a learning curve.
- 1:10:42So, so some people will blow up or they will lose their
- 1:10:45community, right? The BLOB of money in one company
- 1:10:48is going to move to another company and then another company
- 1:10:51and there's going to be trouble from that because not everyone
- 1:10:53is going to be as diligent as as the next person, right?
- 1:10:56But you know, this is inevitable, I would say on, on
- 1:11:00bitcoins path to becoming a legitimized asset.
- 1:11:05And when you think about, you know, should I just hold Bitcoin
- 1:11:07or should I invest in these companies?
- 1:11:09This is, in my opinion, actually the difference between Bitcoin
- 1:11:13as a superior savings technology, which if you do your
- 1:11:17due diligence has very low risk, right?
- 1:11:20If you want to take a bit more risk, you invest and you and you
- 1:11:23do different things. But because Bitcoin is your
- 1:11:25hurdle rate, you are forced to do it in a more diligent way
- 1:11:30than we touched upon. You know, the whole VC game,
- 1:11:32then the whole VC game, right? If you're AVC, you have an LP of
- 1:11:35an LP of an LP, right? It's just a trickle down shotgun
- 1:11:40type approach to see if if they can find ways to have their Fiat
- 1:11:46money actually mitigated, mitigated debasement, right.
- 1:11:49So there's not a lot of diligence in there.
- 1:11:54There's more diligence when you hold Bitcoin and it is your
- 1:11:58hurdle rate and you're going to be actually way more conscious
- 1:12:01in the way you invest or take more risk, right?
- 1:12:04And so I think Richard also touched upon the fact that these
- 1:12:07are not like the Icos, these are, these are Bitcoin
- 1:12:10companies. So Bitcoin is the underlying
- 1:12:12play here. So for example, I'm also in
- 1:12:14Metaplanet and MicroStrategy and Blockchain Group, only those
- 1:12:18three. But that's with money I, I can
- 1:12:21afford to lose. And everything that's in Bitcoin
- 1:12:24is money that I cannot afford to lose, right?
- 1:12:26And I think there's a big distinction in that and just
- 1:12:31looking at it like that, but also that if you use Bitcoin as
- 1:12:35your hurdle rate, you will be more diligent in which stocks
- 1:12:38you you pick. And over time, because people
- 1:12:41get burned, they will they will learn this.
- 1:12:44But but getting burned or funding a dozens of neo banks
- 1:12:47without seeing anything in return is part of the whole
- 1:12:52learning curve, personal learning curve.
- 1:12:54I'd say to figure out that Bitcoin is the hardest money to
- 1:12:58ever exist and the thing you should save in, right.
- 1:13:00So those are kind of my closing thoughts here to, to to tie that
- 1:13:05together. Yeah, I think I'm glad you said
- 1:13:07that because I think that is that is the right mental
- 1:13:11framework to think about these things is that it is necessarily
- 1:13:15moving out the risk curve from owning spot Bitcoin.
- 1:13:18And that's perfectly fine. Like if if you want to make more
- 1:13:22Bitcoin, you want to look take a little bit more risk that that
- 1:13:25is perfectly fine. And I think if we just zoom out
- 1:13:29like that is progress, right? Like I'd much rather people are
- 1:13:32going out the risk curve with things that are Bitcoin focused
- 1:13:36than the vaporware Icos. So I think if you're, if you're
- 1:13:39zooming out and looking at where we are relative to years ago,
- 1:13:42prior cycles, like it's certainly progress in that
- 1:13:46regard. The concern obviously is people
- 1:13:49selling all their Bitcoin for these things.
- 1:13:51That's where I get like a little concerned.
- 1:13:54Conscious of time, I know we need a wrap before Brian you
- 1:13:57wanted to share really quick anything on BPI or notable and
- 1:14:01then was in. DC yesterday for the Bitcoin
- 1:14:04Policy Summit. It's the third time they've done
- 1:14:07this and just a fantastic event. Shout out to the to the guys
- 1:14:12there is that Zach Shapiro, Matt Pines, Zach Cohen, Steven
- 1:14:16Pollock, everyone who was involved in putting it on super
- 1:14:19high signal event. Really just an amazing
- 1:14:23confluence of both people in the Bitcoin industry as well as
- 1:14:26lawmakers and policymakers. Pretty much every other panel
- 1:14:29had, you know, some combination of people from DC who are
- 1:14:33thinking critically about the space and overall just very,
- 1:14:36very constructive conversations. I think there's a ton of
- 1:14:39momentum, you know, that they had a similar summit back in, I
- 1:14:45want to say February of this year.
- 1:14:47And so, you know, that was pre the genius act going through.
- 1:14:51So it's, you know, these things continue to build on each other.
- 1:14:53And so there was a lot of positive momentum.
- 1:14:56Now that stablecoin act act has gone through.
- 1:14:59Now they're looking at market structure, lots of thinking
- 1:15:02around, you know, budget neutral ways to acquire more Bitcoin for
- 1:15:05the SBR. And there was 11 funny moment.
- 1:15:09Sorry, Brian, did they give, sorry, I didn't want to cut you
- 1:15:12off, but did they give any examples of budget neutral ways
- 1:15:15that they're looking to acquire Bitcoin?
- 1:15:18Well, you know, Andrew Hones who I know you're familiar with, has
- 1:15:21this idea about around bit bonds, which isn't isn't exactly
- 1:15:26down that line of thinking. There's obviously, you know, the
- 1:15:32revaliant gold, which I think is unlikely, but there there are a
- 1:15:37number of things in the toolkit. The the one thing I was going to
- 1:15:40say that that so the deputy deputy director of the CIA was
- 1:15:45supposed to do a fireside with Matt Pines and given everything
- 1:15:50that's going on in the world, sort of geopolitical turmoil, he
- 1:15:53was unable to make it. So he cancelled last minute.
- 1:15:55And so David Zell sat in and did the fireside with Matt instead.
- 1:16:00And kind of reference like, you know, it is a signal of this is
- 1:16:04a very meaningful policy summit if one of your presenters can't
- 1:16:08come because there's a war going on.
- 1:16:10Like that is a a signpost of how far BPI has come, how far
- 1:16:14Bitcoin and the industry has come in that, you know, there
- 1:16:17are people now involved in the conversation at the highest
- 1:16:21levels of our government. And so, yeah, overall great
- 1:16:24event. And you know, looking forward
- 1:16:27to, to future content and research from BPI as well.
- 1:16:34Yeah, it was positive. I I tweeted this morning, Brian
- 1:16:37had shared a, a fireside chat between I think it was Shapiro
- 1:16:42and crypto mom. I think that's, that was her old
- 1:16:45name, Hester Pierce and was just discussing SPR custody,
- 1:16:50qualified custody and just kind of like the antiquated model
- 1:16:52around SEC or securities and stocks and gold or specifically
- 1:16:57stocks and bonds. And then actually brought up
- 1:16:59multi institution custody, which we helped.
- 1:17:02There's a report coming out that is going to pretty go pretty
- 1:17:05deep on the toolkit for BPI and SPR, the strategic Bitcoin
- 1:17:09Reserve. It's still early, but it
- 1:17:11reminded me very similar to years ago when we brought up and
- 1:17:13you had different presidential candidates like start showing up
- 1:17:16to these Bitcoin conferences that that's the notion.
- 1:17:18I think this was our first time even being introduced to multi
- 1:17:21institution custody. But again, we're only at
- 1:17:23100K250K500K. You're holding hundreds of
- 1:17:26billions, if not trillions of dollars.
- 1:17:28We feel we're going to wake up to like, holy crap, maybe this,
- 1:17:30we have to treat this in a different way.
- 1:17:33So I thought that was positive for kind of the landscape.
- 1:17:37Well, I know we have to wrap Brom.
- 1:17:39Rich, really appreciate your time.
- 1:17:41You've been very generous for the audience.
- 1:17:45If you don't like the video, leave a comment.
- 1:17:47Rich will be less inclined to join the podcast in the future.
- 1:17:51Brom almost certainly won't show up if you don't like the video.
- 1:17:54So gentlemen, thank you both. If anyone does want to get in
- 1:17:57touch and not familiar with the work that you're both doing,
- 1:18:00what's the best place to reach out?
- 1:18:04I'm pretty responsive on X. If someone wants to DM me my my
- 1:18:09DMS are open. I'm always trying to help people
- 1:18:11understand this trade. So it's at Richard Byrath and
- 1:18:15then of course at These Capital. But I also have podcasts these
- 1:18:19The Future which is on all the normal channels.
- 1:18:25Yeah, same for me. I'm also very active on X and
- 1:18:27DMS are open. I'm Bramk and my podcast is
- 1:18:32Bitcoin for Millennials that you can find on YouTube and Spotify
- 1:18:35and all these places. Thank you, gentlemen.
- 1:18:38Thanks guys. Nice to see you both.
- 1:18:40Appreciate the time. Thanks guys.
- 1:18:41Likewise. Thanks for having us on.
- 1:18:43Cheers. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:18:45week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:18:47valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:18:50rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:18:52All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:18:54notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:18:57reminder that On Ramp Media is for informational and
- 1:18:59entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:19:02investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:19:05your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:19:08Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:19:12one of our private Client advisors.