Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / A Suspicious "Sound of Freedom"
Transcript
- 0:00We got to stand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a
- 0:08symbol, an idea. The population of atheist this country is going through the
- 0:13rule, rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell
- 0:19the truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my
- 0:23hand on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational
- 0:28world. Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth,
- 0:32beauty, and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing,
- 0:37question everything, and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by
- 0:46Said Andrews. All Right, I know this is not a standard Tuesday release,
- 1:00but I'm doing an extra show this week. I have been repeatedly asked
- 1:03if I'm going to talk about this new film, The Sound of Freedom.
- 1:08It is starring Jim Caviezel, best known as Jesus in the Mel Gibson movie
- 1:15The Passion of the Christ, a guy who's just gone off the rails with
- 1:18a number of wacky conspiracy theories, and I'm going to get into that.
- 1:22He's playing the character of a guy named Tim Ballard who goes out and rescue
- 1:27is the victims of child sex trafficking, and I guess as a work of
- 1:32fiction or played as a movie thriller. It is well done, it's well
- 1:37reviewed, and it's making crazy box office eighteen million dollars its first weekend,
- 1:42a debut just behind Indiana Jones and Insidious. I mean for this indie movie
- 1:48produced by Angel Studios, right seem to come out of nowhere. I've seen
- 1:53billboards everywhere for it, and it is doing massive business, over forty million
- 2:00dollar gross in the first five days. And it is the darling of American
- 2:06conservatives. The on screen story of Tim Ballard, this is kind of a
- 2:10fictionalized version of what is supposed to be a true story or real life story.
- 2:15A former government agent is rescuing child victims all around the world. Jim
- 2:21Caviezel plays the lead Tim Ballard. The character is a real life guy.
- 2:27He is a former Homeland Security agent and back in twenty thirteen he founded Operation
- 2:34Underground Railroad or ou R Hour, and this organization apparently conducts sting operations around
- 2:43the world to rescue kids from sex traffickers. And Tim Ballard has been featured
- 2:47on media everywhere you know, from ESPN to Fox News and Prince and He
- 2:53was actually appointed to an anti trafficking advisory position by Donald Trump during the Trump
- 2:59administer But already, if we look into Tim Ballard, things start to get
- 3:02really sticky. Investigators have looked in to Operation Underground Railroad O you are,
- 3:12and they are worried that most of the organization's claims have been pretty much impossible
- 3:17to fact check. So they come forward with all of these heroic tales of
- 3:23running in and grabbing the kids and whisking them out to safety and helping them
- 3:28to rehabilitate. They might be true, but unfortunately there's no way to verify
- 3:35if they are true. The practices are not known, the success stories cannot
- 3:39be vetted or verified. Many people are suspicious that Oure is actually building an
- 3:46image, right, Tim Ballard, hero legend, is sort of building his
- 3:51legacy on an organization, and so they go in makeup stories, exaggerate stories.
- 3:57What's going on there, We certainly don't know, but there's reason to
- 4:00be genuinely suspicious. And of course, the second you begin to ask questions,
- 4:08critics who are emotionally charged, and it's understandable over this legitimate, horrifying
- 4:14human rights nightmare, child sex trafficking yes, it happens. Yes it's rampant.
- 4:20Yes, we must be made aware in that context. I actually think
- 4:25a movie like Sound of Freedom is a good idea. But here's the thing.
- 4:30If you start to ask questions about this specific film, who is behind
- 4:34the scenes. Is there a subtext that is linked to a bunch of different
- 4:40conspiracies and stories that aren't rooted in the data. Is this problematic? Right?
- 4:46Is this something that is not sound wearing the veneer of a legitimate problem
- 4:54in this world, child sex trafficking. If you stop, for many people,
- 4:58if you stop and start to ask these types of questions, they will
- 5:00turn on you. Who could ever criticize a film that is ringing the alarm
- 5:06bell against child sex traffickers? Are you yourself a pedophile? I've seen this
- 5:13already on Twitter, Hey pedo, Why in the world would you ever criticize
- 5:16this wonderful, noble message. And this is really sticky because I think it's
- 5:23important to understand what's going on under the hood. Who are these people?
- 5:28Investigators have looked in to Operation Underground Railroad. They are hearing stories that aren't
- 5:34really true. Here's an example. There was the story of a victim she
- 5:40goes by the name Liliana. And when she was fourteen years old in Mexico,
- 5:45she was wooed and taken in by this man, this older man,
- 5:48and he introduced her to his family, and he said he loved her,
- 5:53and she was totally smitten. Right. He seduced this child as her boyfriend.
- 5:59And then they got into the United States from Mexico, and as soon
- 6:03as they crossed the border and got a house, the man turned on her.
- 6:08The house had bars on the windows. He locked her inside and sold
- 6:11her as a sex slave for three years until Liliana finally escaped. But she
- 6:18got out on her own. She actually escaped the house and sped away in
- 6:24a cab. She did this all on her own, and yet Oh you
- 6:29Are has claimed that it was heavily involved in her rescue. Tim Ballard was
- 6:33on Fox News. He did an op ed in twenty nineteen where he said
- 6:38this quote. The private anti trafficking organization I founded over five years ago,
- 6:44Operation Underground Railroad, eventually helped Liliana escape her hell. Tim Ballard told the
- 6:51same story three days later at a big Trump White House event, and he
- 6:57actually changed the details. He lowered her age from fourteen to eleven. He
- 7:02embellished the story that she had been groomed by her seducer for two full years.
- 7:08The court documents say nothing about anything like that. There were no details
- 7:13like that. Apparently he just added those in. He used her story to
- 7:17campaign for the Trump border wall. The idea was, you know, if
- 7:23Trump's wall had been there, Liliana's abductor would have had to get her through
- 7:28legitimate entry points at the border, and she could have been saved. There's
- 7:32another story about a noure operative. This woman was said to have wrestled away
- 7:38a golden padlock from an abductor. So the abductor had grabbed a child and
- 7:45was whisking it off to be locked in a prison or a room with bars
- 7:50and locks on the doors, and this brave woman went in and battled the
- 7:56attacker and wrestled away the padlock and rescued the children. This story was told
- 8:01by Tim Ballard in front of a live audience. The audience went crazy,
- 8:07the media lapped it up. The story has never been verified. At the
- 8:11event, he actually pulled the golden padlock out of his pocket and he held
- 8:16it up in front of the audience and he said this is the actual padlock
- 8:20that was going to imprison the children, and our brave operative wrestled it away.
- 8:26No evidence for any of this right, but the Golden padlock man.
- 8:31It's a great story, and people lap that stuff up, and then some
- 8:35people are protesting that Oure is misleading donors. And there were some tax filings
- 8:43from twenty eighteen that were closely examined. Two million, seven hundred thousand plus
- 8:48dollars were said to have been used to assist law enforcement in freeing sex slaves
- 8:56and providing aftercare for victims North Africa and the Middle East. The descriptions were
- 9:03vague and broad, and many of the law enforcement organizations in questions say they
- 9:09don't really work much at all with Oure. Instead of being side by side
- 9:15and shouldered his shoulder. It looks like many of these organizations may have just
- 9:18grazed by them along the way. Other reputable child advocacy and aftercare organizations say
- 9:24they don't even know who ou are is. Public records request to New York
- 9:31State's Office of Victims Services returned zero documents mentioning Tim Ballard's organization. The United
- 9:39States Department of Criminal Justice Services could not confirm any elements of his claims,
- 9:45and they said that the office had no relationship with OURE. The state funded
- 9:50Response to Human Trafficking Program said they didn't even know who this organization was.
- 9:56And finally, if there is a child trafficking rescue case in the United States,
- 10:01the Office of Refugee Resettlement is almost always involved in the safe keeping and
- 10:07the relocation of survivors. The US Committee for Refugees and Immigrants would also likely
- 10:13be involved. The Department of Health and Human Services Administration for Children and Families
- 10:18would probably be involved. These organizations say they have no relationship with ou ARE.
- 10:26It's not connected at all to a leading anti trafficking coalition called the Freedom
- 10:33Network USA. Again, this is a coalition. This is an organization of
- 10:37gathering a connecting of child advocacy groups nationwide. Freedom Network USA said, we
- 10:45don't work with these people. Tim Ballard's organization is multimillion dollar organization is apparently
- 10:52operating largely on its own, with big claims and hidden checkbooks. There is
- 10:58reason to be vicious beyond that Tim Ballard is a conspiracy theorist. And oh
- 11:07look, he is played on screen in the Sound of Freedom by another conspiracy
- 11:13theorist, the actor Jim Caviezel. And we know Jim Caviezel because he played
- 11:18Jesus in a lucrative movie called The Passion of the Christ, which was directed
- 11:24by another conspiracy theorist, Mel Gibson. Now I'm talking about the players,
- 11:31the producers, the gears in the machine. I was going to try to
- 11:35describe everything in more detail, but since I haven't actually seen the film,
- 11:41right, I'm gonna wait. I'm not gonna buy a ticket, I'm gonna
- 11:43wait and stream it. I wanted to read for you an article by someone
- 11:48who has seen the film. Miles Klee wrote a July seventh article for Rolling
- 11:56Stone. I'm just going to read the whole thing for you. Here a
- 12:00negatory spoiler alert in case you want to be surprised when you see the film,
- 12:05and here we go. The article is titled Sound of Freedom is a
- 12:09superhero movie for Dad's with brainworms. The article says this based on a true
- 12:20story I heard from somewhere across the theater. The familiar words had appeared on
- 12:26screen, and an elderly man had taken it upon himself to read them aloud
- 12:31to the rest of a sizable audience seated for a matinee showing of the anti
- 12:35child trafficking thriller Sound of Freedom starring Jim Cavizel. For the seasoned movie goer,
- 12:41this phrase is a joke. We know that cinema will stretch almost any
- 12:46truth to the breaking point, and the rank insincebrity of such a pronouncement is
- 12:52the foundation of the prankish opening titles of Fargo. But this crowd, I
- 12:58could tell, would view the events depicted over the next two plus hours as
- 13:03entirely literal. Cavezel, best known for being Tortured to Death and Mel Gibson's
- 13:09The Passion of the Christ, has become a prominent figure on the conspiracist right,
- 13:16giving speeches and interviews in which he hints at an underground holy war between
- 13:20patriots and a sinister legion of evildoers who are harvesting the blood of children.
- 13:28It's straight up qan On stuff, right down to his use of catchphrases like
- 13:33the storm is upon us. Here he gets to act out some of that
- 13:39drama by playing a fictionalized version of Tim Ballard, head of the anti sex
- 13:43trafficking nonprofit operation Underground Railroad, in a feature film that cast the operator as
- 13:50a Batman style savior for kids sold into the sex trade. Ballard himself has
- 13:58dabbled in q adjacent conspiracy theories, such as the Wayfair trafficking hoax. By
- 14:05the Way I got to stop here. Wayfair is a furniture retailer, and
- 14:09Tim Ballard once said that he suspected that Wayfair was involved in the trafficking of
- 14:15children when they weren't selling furniture. Okay, While his organization has far right
- 14:20affinities and a long record of distorting its botched quote unquote raids which rely on
- 14:28bizarre tactics like asking psychics where to find victims for rescue, Ballard, Caviesel,
- 14:35and others of their ilk had primed the public to accept Sound of Freedom
- 14:39as a documentary rather than delusion by fomenting moral panic for years over this grossly
- 14:46exaggerated epidemic of child sex trafficking, much of it funneling people into conspiracist rabbit
- 14:54holes and QAnon communities. In short, I was at the movies with people
- 15:01who were there to see their worst fears confirmed. Sound of Freedom lives up
- 15:05to that anticipation. It's a stomach turning experience. Fetishizing the torture of its
- 15:13child victims and lingering over lush preludes to their sexual abuse. At times,
- 15:18I had the uncomfortable sense that I might be arrested myself just for sitting through
- 15:22it. Nonetheless, the mostly white haired audience around me could be relied on
- 15:28to gasp, moan in pity, muttered condemnations, applaud and bellow amen at
- 15:35moments of righteous fury, as when Ballard declares that quote God's children are not
- 15:41for sale. They were entranced by what they clearly took for a searing expose.
- 15:48Not even the occasional nasty coughing fit, and we had no shortage of
- 15:52those could break the spell. At the outset, we were introduced to cavezel
- 15:58Is Ballard, working for the Department of Homeland Security as part of the Internet
- 16:03Crimes against Children task Force. He takes down purveyors of child pornography, but
- 16:10is haunted by the knowledge that the actual victims are beyond his grasp. Meanwhile,
- 16:15a father in Honduras entrusts his young daughter and son to a woman who
- 16:21claims she can set them up with modeling careers, only to abduct them for
- 16:26transport to a child sex trafficking ring in Columbia. When Ballard takes the initiative
- 16:32of arranging his first sting to nab a pedophile who has a stolen child in
- 16:37tow, he conveniently ends up rescuing that little boy and commits to finding the
- 16:42sister as well. Eventually he'll abandon the DHS altogether, a rogue crusader fed
- 16:49up with bureaucratic limitations to infiltrate and bring down the Columbian operation. Apart from
- 16:56its relentless messaging, the move is hobbled by a near total absence of procedural
- 17:03logic. That original rescue is only possible because Ballard is standing at the exact
- 17:10right spot of a US Mexico border station at the very moment his target tries
- 17:17to cross. Lucky Earlier, Ballard convinces an imprisoned child porn peddler facing a
- 17:23sentence of thirty years to help him contact traffickers in exchange for an immunity deal,
- 17:30needlessly posing as a pedophile himself to game trust. When the guy fulfills
- 17:37his end of the bargain, Ballard has a dozen police officers swarm the diner
- 17:41therein to arrest him again. Wait, how is he sprung from custody in
- 17:48the first place? Doesn't matter as long as the drooling creep with requisite glasses
- 17:53and pervert mustache gets his head slammed against a table once more. The same
- 18:00udled approach is taken to Ballard's later, more sensational busts, which is certainly
- 18:04in keeping with the way O You Are embellishes and misrepresents their internal missions.
- 18:11According to a Vice News investigation of the group, then you have Caviezel bleached
- 18:18blonde to match Ballard's buff, clean cut Mormon profile. Performance Wise, he
- 18:25stuck on a note of world historical grief, either crying or staring with bloodshot
- 18:30eyes as he attempts to convey the scale and weight of the tragedy before him.
- 18:36The unambiguous hero of the piece, Ballard invokes parmenthood as his motivation or
- 18:41an argument to get the cooperation he once quote, what if it was your
- 18:45daughter is practically his catchphrase, Yet, aside from a dialogue free breakfast scene,
- 18:52he never interacts with his offspring, and if Mira Sorvino, who plays
- 18:57his wife Katherine, meant more a day on set, you'd never know it.
- 19:02She's there for all of two minutes, offering brief words of encouragement,
- 19:07while Ballard spends weeks undercover as a lush sex tourist in Central America. She
- 19:14too, evidently had a personal stake in joining this film, telling The Washington
- 19:18Examiner this week that she has quote met so many child survivors and my heart
- 19:23burns for them. As implausible as the movie is, it invents a finale
- 19:30where Ballard journeys deep into a jungle alone to pluck a girl from the clutches
- 19:34of guerrilla militants, which he accomplishes by posing as a doctor distributing cholera vaccines.
- 19:42One wonders if it was extreme enough for cavezls liking. The actor is
- 19:48taken to repeating the most grotesque falsehoods of the sprawling Queanon ideology, among them
- 19:55that traffickers are harvesting children's organs and extract the chemical compound adrenochrome from their brains
- 20:03before murdering them. Compared to this nonsense, Sound of Freedom is relatively grounded
- 20:11in our universe, but that mainstream accessibility makes it valuable as a recruitment tool,
- 20:18much as generic Save the Children campaigns proved gateways to far rite conspiracy theories
- 20:26about a secret cabal of evil elites conducting blood rituals. On the qan on
- 20:32message board Great Awakening this week ad here and celebrated the movie's box office success
- 20:38while crowing that demons, including movie theater employees annoyed by the demographic had pulled
- 20:45in, were miserable at their victory. Do you see how more powerful we
- 20:52are than the legacy news, wrote one board user, we are the news
- 20:56now. On a different thread, one attempted to prove that Donald Trump's endorsement
- 21:03of the film on truth social was connected to a random que post from twenty
- 21:07eighteen, Some discussed efforts to get normies who are in need of awakening to
- 21:15see Sound of Freedom, including with the assistance of a promotional program that allows
- 21:21customers to buy tickets for strangers. Quote crimes against children will unite us.
- 21:26All eyes are opening, read one optimistic post, while another was more emphatic.
- 21:33Still, we are witnessing true divine intervention. It matters too that Sound
- 21:40of Freedom almost never saw the light of day. Completed in twenty eighteen,
- 21:45no studio would take it for fear of losing money. According to the producer
- 21:51with Netflix, and Amazon among those who passed. It finally found distribution thanks
- 21:56to Angel Studios, a Utah based meeting, a company that crowdfunds original films
- 22:03and TV series that quote amplify Light. Although founded by Mormon brothers who originally
- 22:10created a content filtering service to prevent children from seeing violence, nudity, and
- 22:15profanity, it claims no formal church affiliation. Therefore, to its boosters,
- 22:22the movie checks many satisfying boxes at once. Cavezel, a devout Catholic allegedly
- 22:29blacklisted by the entertainment industry, back for a mythology, burnishing biopic of Ballard,
- 22:36a call to action in an imagined global war against sexual predators, a
- 22:41blow struck at the heart of woke Hollywood, the dan of iniquity that snubbed
- 22:47it, and lest we forget is thought to produce the wealthy devians who serve
- 22:52as villains in this story, meaning it will surely do no good to point
- 22:57out sound to freedom Hackney white savior narrative, or it's wildly immature assumption that
- 23:03abused and traumatized children go right back to normal once the bad guys are in
- 23:10handcuffs, or that it enforces stereotypes about trafficking that Angel Studios itself says are
- 23:17less than accurate to the film's intended viewers. These cannot be flaws, they're
- 23:22the whole appeal. There is visible suffering all around us in America. There
- 23:29are poor and unhoused, and people brutalized or killed by police. There are
- 23:34mass shootings, lack of healthcare, climate disasters, and yet over and over
- 23:41the far right turns to those sordid fantasies about godless monsters hurting children. Now,
- 23:48as in the nineteen eighties satanic panic, they won't even face the fact
- 23:53that most kids who suffer sexual abuse are harmed not by a shadowy cabal strangers,
- 24:00but at the hands of a family member. To know, thousands of
- 24:04adults will absorb sound of freedom, this vigilante fever dream and come away thinking
- 24:11themselves better informed on a hidden civilizational crisis. Well, it's profoundly depressing.
- 24:19Worse still, they'll want to spread the word. Rolling Stone is absolutely right
- 24:29about Jim Caviezel being cast off. He was whining about it on the Charlie
- 24:33Kirk broadcast, and Charlie Kirk is another right wing Christian nationalist crackpot bigot and
- 24:40so he's on Charlie Kirk's program. Let me just play you the audio.
- 24:42This is the actor Jim Caviezel just a few days ago. A drina chrome.
- 24:47That's not true, it's nine nine h three. This is a chemical
- 24:53compound that is absolutely list has been around in modern sciences in the nineteen thirties.
- 25:00You can actually there's a synthetic form and there's a regular natural form which
- 25:07is caused by torturing little kids to get their adrenaline up, essentially and then
- 25:15extracting it from them when you sit and and so I brought this up a
- 25:22few years ago, and all of a sudden I was attacked by every media.
- 25:26Look it up, it's there. I absolutely went after me and the
- 25:32next day I never heard from my agents, my agency. Fourteen months,
- 25:38my lawyers let me go. My agency never called me after that, and
- 25:44essentially it was done. Now. I don't know about you, but I
- 25:47see a pattern here. Because one somebody kind of goes off the rails,
- 25:52right, or they become marginalized, or maybe they're just no longer bankable by
- 25:56Hollywood, they seem to go find a niche in this sort of right wing
- 26:02hardcore conspiratorial evangelical thing. I mean, look at Kevin Sorbo, look at
- 26:07the films by Pure Flicks as they bring in a lot of actors that may
- 26:11have been prominent years ago. Maybe they're sort of languishing and all of a
- 26:17sudden they find a new home. They claim this religious nobility and they are
- 26:22out there fighting. Perhaps they're sincere, Maybe they are just marketing. Maybe
- 26:26they're just like the musicians who can't make it in pop culture and so they
- 26:32go find a career in the religious music industry. Christian music is always looking
- 26:37for opportunities to find marketable stuff that sounds like what's happening in secular radio.
- 26:44So the BCMD players and the fringe gentleman's can go there and find a home.
- 26:48I think this may be what happened with Jim Kvezel. He when off
- 26:52the rails, everybody said we don't want anything to do with you, and
- 26:56now he has landed in a very friendly net. Now again, you and
- 27:00I are in this very difficult position. Or we have to take a hard
- 27:06forensic look at a film and the agenda behind the film, one that brandishes
- 27:11up front a legitimate problem, a legitimate human horror and the game is rigged
- 27:18so that if you and I say there may be some problems with this story,
- 27:22their response can be, you don't care about our children. We see
- 27:26this all the time. Is bad people weaponize legitimate issues, distort them,
- 27:33and then hide behind them. Trade Crowder, the comedian, the liberal Redneck.
- 27:37He released them commentary. I think this runs three or four minutes about
- 27:41Sound of Freedom, and he had this to say about it. Libs are
- 27:45getting owned all across the multiplex this summer as conservatives come out and drove to
- 27:49support the Sound of Freedom, the child sex trafficking action thriller starring renowned nutbag
- 27:55Jim Caveazel. The film's critics say that it's qan on adjacent. Its supporters
- 27:59say that it and it's the truth that the left doesn't want you to see.
- 28:02So let's get something straight right now. Okay, child sex trafficking is
- 28:04very real issue, and it's awful. Nobody but the traffickers supports it.
- 28:08Okay, listen, people on the right, the only reason we're not with
- 28:11you one hundred percent on this issue is because you insist on salt baying everything
- 28:18with lunacy. Okay, that's why you just come out and say hey,
- 28:22we need to do something about this child sex trafficking problem. Everybody goes,
- 28:25yeah, you're right, we should go on. And then you say,
- 28:27yeah, we gotta stop this shadowy global cabal of Elidus who use ritual sacrifice
- 28:32to harvest the blood of the innocent in their undying quest for immortality. And
- 28:34it's like, wait, what what kind of peasant mob shit was that ritual
- 28:41sacrifice? Were you talking about? Pagans and the blood? Wood say it's
- 28:45twenty twenty three, dude, what I'm good. You sound like you're about
- 28:48two steps away from getting out the witch burning sticks. Okay, so good
- 28:52luck with all that, right, Like I get it as a parent,
- 28:55I'm sensitive to anything about, you know, kids being abused or whatever.
- 28:59But y'all start talking about Vampire's pizza adrenochrome and I dive out the rabbit hole,
- 29:03dude, on account of how crazy that's. Do you really not realize
- 29:06how crazy that sounds? Right? But to be fair to this movie,
- 29:10reportedly, it don't do none of that. The movie itself is just a
- 29:12standard issue action thriller with the quips to match, although I guess the quips
- 29:17and sound of Freedom is stuff like never trust a pedophiles. Thank you Sound
- 29:22of Freedom here. I was about to sign off on this chomos car long,
- 29:25but I guess I won't. Now so good lucking out Sound of Freedom
- 29:27shows. And if you produce a competently made film with an actual budget and
- 29:32real talent behind it that panders directly to the flagging Bible brigade, and you're
- 29:36off to the racist buddy, let's right to ain't no griff like a right
- 29:38wind griff because the right wind griff blows cops. That's right. This movie
- 29:41somehow makes these people feel like they are certified dog kicking, child saving patriot
- 29:48heroes just for buying a ticket and eating popcorn in the dark. It's brilliant,
- 29:52right, And if I know anything about how Hollywood works, it's success
- 29:56probably means we're about to see a whole trend of forthcoming Clint Eastwood style edom
- 30:00boner extravaganza. So buckle up, film goers, because I got a failing
- 30:03We're just getting started here again. That's Trey Crowder, t r Ae Crowder.
- 30:07If you're not subscribed to him on social media, you should be okay.
- 30:14So that's kind of what we know. If you've seen the film and
- 30:18you'd like to weigh in, sound off whatever to defend it, or warn
- 30:22against it, or explain it better than we have here. Please do so
- 30:26in the comments section. But at least now we have begun the conversation about
- 30:33the sound of Freedom film and the agents, or at least a few of
- 30:37the agents behind it. Thank you so much for listening. I'll see you
- 30:40back here next week. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a
- 30:45complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the
- 30:49Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming
- 30:55free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thin Being Atheist
- 31:00dot com.