Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP199: The Genesee River Killer
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi Tanya, Hi Talia. Welcome by
- 0:35everybody to Crimes and Consequences. We're so excited to have you here with us.
- 0:40If you could do us a favor before we start getting into some crazy
- 0:43true crime, hit the like, follow, subscribe button, whatever you normally
- 0:48would do, and are you ready? I Roddy, Are you ready?
- 0:53II Roddy? All right, We're gonna get into some true crime then.
- 0:56Before we do, though, everybody should know a couple things about us.
- 1:00We're lawyers, we swear sometimes a lot, yes, and we can be
- 1:06pretty graphic with our true crime. So if you don't like that, that's
- 1:08fine, but you will. You're gonna love us. You're gonna love us
- 1:12because we are the best show out there. So can you quit talking?
- 1:15Oh? Yeah, I'm sorry, let's hear some true crime. I'm gonna
- 1:18not stop talking because it's my episode. Let's do it. Have you ever
- 1:22heard of Arthur Shawcross. Yes, okay, Well, I'm gonna tell you
- 1:26all about him today. I don't know who he is, but I have
- 1:30heard of him. Well, he's a horrible, horrible person, of course,
- 1:33horrible serial killer absolutely, and so I'll start with his background. Perfect.
- 1:38He was born premature, okay, in the early morning hours of June
- 1:42sixth, nineteen forty five, at the US Naval Base in Kittery, Maine.
- 1:48I think I said that right. He was two months early. Probably
- 1:51not. We always mispronounced everything. That's another thing about us. He was
- 1:55two months early. I was two months early, okay, But anyway,
- 1:57for sharing, you're welcome. At the time of his birth, his mom
- 2:00Elizabeth, she went by Bessie. She was just eighteen years old, and
- 2:05his father, Corporal Arthur Roy Shawcross, he was twenty one. Two weeks
- 2:12after his birth, Bessie took baby Arthur and she moved. She left.
- 2:16Well, yeah, she moved to Waterton, New York. But she only
- 2:20did that. She really didn't leave the dad. She left because he was
- 2:23being deployed, so she went to be closer to family. By nineteen forty
- 2:29eight, the family had built a small house in a rural area six miles
- 2:34northwest of Waterton, near Brownville. Arthur was only three at this time,
- 2:38and yet he already was beginning to show signs of some abnormal behavior, starting
- 2:45fires, badwater. Yes, and he talked like a baby until he was
- 2:51about six. The following year he started running away from home, which family
- 2:57members she ignored. Yeah, when he was seven, they said, you
- 3:00know, it's just a way for him to get attention, so they just
- 3:04kind of ignored it. By the time he was eight, other behavioral problems
- 3:07began to surface. He seemed to really dislike, like, kind of hate
- 3:12children younger than himself now, and he would tease them until they started to
- 3:16cry. That's not that abnormal, that is true. Sometimes he became obsessed
- 3:23with his sister, Jeanie, and he ignored his other sister and brother.
- 3:29So he had he had two siblings. Yes, he's one of three.
- 3:31Yes, he invented imaginary friends and he spoke to them using strange voices.
- 3:38And he's eight doing this. Yeah about that, Okay. His classmates constantly
- 3:43made fun of him and called him Addie because he was odd, and he
- 3:47absolutely hated this nickname. Ah No, Arthur was a loner whose weird behavior
- 3:53made it really hard for him to communicate and mix with the other kids.
- 3:59He would often seen He was often seen being alone, like in the classroom,
- 4:03he's kind of ostracized, you know, the kids would be out playing.
- 4:06Yeah, because he's weird. A school nurse remembered him as being troubled,
- 4:12and he constantly ran away from home. He often carried an iron bar
- 4:15with him. Oh, he was just a weird kid. Okay, so
- 4:18now everybody's got this picture of this weird kid. Yeah. By the time
- 4:23he entered third grade, Arthur's behavior only got worse once He's only in third
- 4:26grade. I mean, he was just a weird kid, and his grades
- 4:30plummeted. He was given a series of psychological tests which indicated that his behavior
- 4:35was due largely in part to his feelings of inadequacy rejection. He had a
- 4:42growing hostility like this hostility that he felt towards his parents, especially his mother.
- 4:47Was he being abused no surprise, surprise, mummy issues. Regardless of
- 4:54the results of the tests, he later moved on to fourth grade, where
- 4:57he stayed for two years. He did not asked fourth grade the first time
- 5:00around. During this time, he ran away yet again, and he was
- 5:05picked up at the Canadian border. I mean he's like light or nine.
- 5:09He's like nine. Wow, I know. So by the time he was
- 5:13nine, his home life was no better and a school was even worse,
- 5:17especially when Arthur's mom found out that Arthur's dad had a whole other family in
- 5:27Australia, in Australia, in Australia. How does somebody do that? Well,
- 5:32back then it was easy, really probably Okay, it was maybe like
- 5:36the fifties, right, Okay, it might have been a lot easier.
- 5:41Did you take a long time? He got deployed out there. I'm being
- 5:44deployed. Yeah, I'm being deployed Australia again. Okay, all right,
- 5:49exactly. Arthur did his best to stay out of his mom's way, which
- 5:59meant he spent a long time at his grandma's house. He said though he
- 6:04suffered some sexual abuse from home. While he was at his grandma's house.
- 6:09He said that his mom, he said he was suffered the sexual abuse from
- 6:14He said he suffered the sexual abuse at the hands of his mom. Okay,
- 6:17so maybe that was happening earlier. Maybe he would say that, you
- 6:21know, true, I don't know, because we have to rely on what
- 6:26Arthur said, okay, okay, so maybe I don't know, and we
- 6:30know serial killers don't die, right, never, never, okay, he
- 6:34said. She first began masturbating him, and then soon we started performing fallacio
- 6:41Okay, he said. His aunt joined in. Yeah, all right,
- 6:45I'm not saying it's not true. I know, but I'm just it's a
- 6:48little far fetched, but it could have happened. Maybe, you know,
- 6:51I'm not going to discount it. As the years passed, Arthur grew even
- 6:56more violent and he would often beat up the neighbor kids. He just became
- 7:00well known for his explosive temper. He also began breaking into houses he stole
- 7:05from local businesses, and this is when he started lighting fires. Called it.
- 7:11I knew it was coming. You called it, you knew it.
- 7:15On one occasion, after falling into a river at a family picnic, oops,
- 7:19he complained that his legs were sore, so he was given a brain
- 7:23scan and a battery of other tests to determine, you know, why are
- 7:27his legs sore? But the tests revealed nothing. And that's what his family
- 7:31said, Oh, he's probably doing it for attention, right, yeah,
- 7:34because he's always did stuff exactly becoming increasingly withdrawn and anti social. Arthur fell
- 7:44further and further behind with his schoolwork, and by the time he was in
- 7:46eighth grade, he was three years older than all the other eighth He should
- 7:51have been like a junior. Eighth grade isn't hard to begin with, let
- 7:56alone, you're three years older, yes, and everybody else. Yeah,
- 8:00So he was obviously an outcast and way through puberty and all that, right,
- 8:05I mean there's a big difference. Yeah, there's a big difference between
- 8:09eighth grader and an eleventh grader. By his mid teens, he was still
- 8:15wedding the bed, and he had check and he had almost completely withdrawn into
- 8:22his own little private world. He spent hours walking in the woods, where
- 8:26he would talk to himself. He was often seen yelling at inanimate objects and
- 8:31beating the undergrowth with a stick. Schizophrenia, don't spoil it. No,
- 8:35I'm gonna spoil it. No. He was never diagnosed with schizophrenica. He
- 8:39would beat the underbrush with a stick as if he was fighting someone or something
- 8:43that wasn't there. By the time he was fourteen, Arthur claimed that he
- 8:48was regularly having oral sex with his sister Jeanie, and his cousin Linda.
- 8:54Oh and like mom and an nice, he insist. He also claims that
- 9:01he had another relationship with a young girl who lived nearby, and they were
- 9:05caught by her brother and at the time he was performing oral sex on the
- 9:11girl. That is more believable. The brother supposedly threatened him, like I
- 9:16said, I'm going to tell your parents unless Arthur performed earl sex on him.
- 9:20Okay, all right, again, I'm getting really annoyed. But it's
- 9:24from Arthur's, you know, his point of view. And it was around
- 9:30this time that Arthur's craving for sex became insatiable, and he continued to have
- 9:35oral sex with anyone, like any chance he could get. That year also
- 9:41marked the period when Arthur claimed to have his first associated violence. Wait,
- 9:45I'm sorry that didn't come out wrong. That you're marked a period of time
- 9:48where Arthur claimed this is when he first associated violence with sex. Okay,
- 9:54okay. It began after he's walking home from school one day and he was
- 9:58picked up by a man in a red convertible who supposedly held him by the
- 10:01throat while performing oral sex on him. Was he kidnapped or did he willingly
- 10:07get I think he willingly got in the car and he This is what Arthur
- 10:11had to say about it. He said, quote, he held onto my
- 10:13balls and sucked me off end quote. Oh, I don't want to say
- 10:20about any of this ship. This one's pretty graphic. When Arthur failed to
- 10:26reach orgasm, the man antally raped him and dropped him close to his house.
- 10:30Oh. I hope that's not true. I hope that's not true.
- 10:31From that time on, Arthur claimed he could never reach orgasm without inflicting pain
- 10:37on himself, on himself, on himself, oh right. The following year,
- 10:43he was arrested for breaking into a serious department store. Do you remember,
- 10:46of course, I remember sears. They're not around anymore. Yeah,
- 10:50it doesn't that long ago. I remember, course. Okay, anyway,
- 10:56go ahead. But he didn't take anything, so he was just given pro
- 11:00like. All he did was break in. Why break into sears? I
- 11:03don't know. Maybe he just got a throw up breaking into places, who
- 11:07knows. For the next few years, Arthur wandered aimlessly throughout life until the
- 11:11age of nineteen, and that's when he got married for the first time.
- 11:15He got married. Yucky lady, some lucky lady out there snagged him at
- 11:20the ripe old age of nineteen. The union lasted less than three years and
- 11:26produced a son. In nineteen sixty eight, at twenty three years old,
- 11:30Arthur went into the army. And so it's nineteen sixty eight, and you
- 11:33know what's going on at that point, no more Vietnam War. So he
- 11:35began a tour of duty in Vietnam. Just prior to his leaving for Vietnam,
- 11:41Arthur married his second wife. So he got divorced, Yes, divorce,
- 11:45and he's what twenty four, Yes, he's yeah, twenty three,
- 11:50twenty four. A second wife, yep, prettame was Linda. They had
- 11:54a very brief courtship. Once he got to Vietnam, he was assigned to
- 11:58a year unit as a supply clerk. As a supply clerk, one of
- 12:03his duties was to arrange for the distribution of ammunition, which consisted of him
- 12:09traveling to other units by helicopter. And it was at that point he later
- 12:13told psychiatrists that he started going out on fire missions with various companies. Faire
- 12:20missions are when the unit was assigned a specific target and included like when you're
- 12:26supposed to fire on it and how much ammunition you're supposed to use. So
- 12:30if they said, you know, access your target in action, he yes,
- 12:33they're in action. Yes. Initially, when he was in Vietnam,
- 12:37he said, you know, he was initially shocked by all the violence,
- 12:39but soon he began to crave the danger of going into the jungle looking for
- 12:45the enemy, and he referred to himself this is when he became a predator.
- 12:52Onward. On one such mission, Arthur claimed he encountered two Vietnamese women
- 12:58hiding guns. I don't want to know. Yeah, it's pretty bad.
- 13:01They were hiding these guns in a hollow tree. He shot one of them
- 13:03initially, and he tied the other one to a tree. The woman who
- 13:09was shot, she was actually still breathing when Arthur cut her head off.
- 13:13What Yeah, this is what he said he did. He said, then
- 13:16he took her head and put it on a post. What the fuck is
- 13:20this ship for the Vietcong to find? Okay? He then he said,
- 13:24he cut off a section of her thigh and roasted it over a fire.
- 13:28He did that to the one. The other one she tied to a tree.
- 13:33Watching this, Yes, and he said he ate it, or ate
- 13:37a portion of it. So we have. We're very else here, right,
- 13:45you have to question, Yeah, exactly what's going on? He said
- 13:48the other woman. He ended up having oral sex with her, and he
- 13:52raised her before shooting her in the head. And then he said he butchered
- 13:56her body, which I'm taking to me and he dismembered her. Okay,
- 14:01he's doing all in the jungle Vietnam. Yeah, alone roasting. Okay,
- 14:05where's the guys in his company? I don't know. I don't know,
- 14:07I don't know. I'm taking a story. I don't know anything, he
- 14:09says. Right, He became an expert sniper who claimed that he fashioned a
- 14:16silencer out of a rubber nipple from a baby's bottle. Can you even want?
- 14:20I don't. I've never tried to make my own silencer. No,
- 14:22never, no, no, I swear I haven't not yet. But I'm
- 14:28maybe I have gone. I don't know what if. It seems kind of
- 14:31weak to be able to be a silencer. But this is what he said
- 14:35he did. And this guy says, he said that allowed him to pick
- 14:37off the enemy without giving his position away. Really, yeah, why wouldn't
- 14:41Why wouldn't everybody just put a nipple on? Right? I know I have
- 14:48no words. So I'm already annoyed with this guy so much. Oh,
- 14:52you're gonna hate him. Before this episodes over, Arthur admits he became an
- 14:58animal quote unquote in v Nam, and he found it difficult to control the
- 15:03violent urges that he had that drove him to rape and kill. The enemy
- 15:07weren't the only victims of his sexual rays of his sexual rages, as he
- 15:13also claims to have tacked several Asian sex workers. Salma's young as eleven years
- 15:18old. It's just sad. Yeah, sad, discussed it right over,
- 15:22asshole, Alight, that's getting really angry. Yes. When he returned home
- 15:28to Waterton in nineteen sixty nine, but he was lovely. He was a
- 15:33changed man, but not for the good. No, he was continually agitated.
- 15:39He found it hard to relax. After after visiting his mother, he
- 15:43went to see his wife, only to find that she had spent all the
- 15:46money he had sent home and she was sing another man. Well, you
- 15:52know, what, what the hell was he doing? Exactly? I can't
- 15:58get mad at Linda. Soon after, when he was transferred to Fort Sill,
- 16:03Oklahoma. That's where he was to serve out the remainder of his term
- 16:07in the army. Linda went with him, and it was at this time
- 16:11that they got they I guess, I know, even though you know she
- 16:15spent all their money in love. I guess this. At this time is
- 16:18when Arthur began to experience violent flashbacks and nightmares, and he began to physic
- 16:25his own action. By the way, right, he began to physically abuse
- 16:29Linda, which led him to consult with an army psychiatrist. Good idea.
- 16:34The doctor suggested therapy and a period in a mental hospital to try and stabilize
- 16:40him, But Linda was a Christian scientist and she was wary of doctors and
- 16:45hospitals, and she refused to sign the commitment papers. So he wasn't able
- 16:48to get that help in the Army hospital, and they didn't volunteered to know
- 16:53they were trying to involuntarily commit him. Yes, without therapy, Arthur's mental
- 16:57state began to decline and he became wine. Okay, he was already in
- 17:03the ascent, so we're just continuing descent descent. Sorry, you're right,
- 17:07descent descent, my bad up down descent ascent. Yeah, you're right,
- 17:14he spiraled. Okay, Okay, he just grew more and more irritated Linda
- 17:18and her family. In April nineteen sixty nine, Arthur took his anger out
- 17:22by setting fire to a local paper mill and later that year the cheese factory
- 17:27where he worked at the time, A cheese factory. You know, I
- 17:33do like the small burnt cheese, but it is really delicious. You're right,
- 17:36Not when people could be hurt. No, I know, I wonder
- 17:40when he did it after hours. I don't know. I don't know.
- 17:42He was later arrested and convicted on two counts of arson, and was sentenced
- 17:47to five years in prison. He served the first six months of a sentence
- 17:51at Attica Prison, where three inmates allegedly raped him. Okay, this guy
- 17:56has been sexually assaulted. H oh. Arthur claims he later got revenge by
- 18:03beating and raping each of his attackers and separate incidents. Eventually, he was
- 18:08transferred to Auburn prison to serve out his sentence. In nineteen seventy one,
- 18:14he's given early release when he saved the life of a prison guard. Loves
- 18:18nice of them and the prison guard had been clubbed during a prison riot which
- 18:22was sparked by racial tension in the prison. He returned to Waterton to start
- 18:26a new life, but it was without Linda, Linda can only do it
- 18:33was without her. They got divorced while he was in prison. He stayed.
- 18:37His stay in prison did little for his already fragilemental state, and by
- 18:41the time of fragil did I say fragile, fragile mental state? Fragel And
- 18:47by the time of his release, he was in a highly agitated fraom of
- 18:51mind, ready to do further damage to anyone or anything. But he now
- 18:59war and be in prison did not make him a better person. Unfortunately,
- 19:04it just gets worse. One of my favorite things. She says that all
- 19:08the time to me, and when she says it, she means it.
- 19:12Yes, it's gonna get really, really fucking bad. It's gonna get bad,
- 19:18and it's time to settle into a normal routine. Arthur took a job
- 19:21at the Waterton Public Works Department as a handyman, and he got married for
- 19:25the third time. This guy could he just you know, couldn't beat the
- 19:27women off of a stick. Apparently all right. His new wife, Penny
- 19:33Nichol, was a school was a school friend of his sister Jeanie and had
- 19:38two children from a former relationship. Arthur claims that up until this time,
- 19:42he was still having a sexual relationship with his sister Jane. He's going to
- 19:47ask about that really, in that she introduced him to Penny because she had
- 19:51gotten pregnant by her boyfriend and couldn't continue her relationship with her brother Arthur any
- 19:56further. Okay, why if you're having relations with your brother, what does
- 20:02it matter if you're pregnant, girl? I don't know rules to incest.
- 20:04I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know.
- 20:07I don't know. By his recollection, after five months, the relationship
- 20:12with Pennies seemed to be going great, and at one stage she got pregnant,
- 20:17but she miscarried sometime later. He claims that the marriage came under threat
- 20:22when Penny's father accused him of sexually assaulting Penny's younger sister. Arthur said,
- 20:29you know, he denied all these aim but from that time on, Penny's
- 20:33parents spent a great deal of time around the house watching him, probably trying
- 20:37to protect the sister. Does she live in with him? Okay? Arthur
- 20:41spent a lot of his spare time fishing in the creeks and rivers around Waterton.
- 20:47As a result, he came to know many of the town's children,
- 20:49and he often shared the same spot with them, because little kids liked to
- 20:53go fishing and everything, and Arthur probably liked the little kids. Well he
- 20:59didn't them, just spoiler alert. But I don't know. Maybe he did.
- 21:03I don't know, Okay. One of his regular fishing companions was ten
- 21:07year old Jack Blake, and on one occasion Arthur had gone to the boy's
- 21:11house to ask Jack's mom, Mary, if Jack could go fishing with him.
- 21:15According to Mary, when she refused because she probably thought it was weird.
- 21:19Yeah, what are you doing, your little creeper, Arthur was polite
- 21:22and agreed that she had made the right decision. Oh what's he gonna do
- 21:27to Mary? He doesn't do anything to marry Oh goad. Sorry. Four
- 21:34months later, on the morning of June fourth, nineteen seventy two, Jack
- 21:40went out to play near the Cloverdale apartment block where Arthur lived, and he
- 21:44never came home. Later that night, while out looking for her son,
- 21:48Mary Blake knocked on Arthur's door and said, you know, where's Jack?
- 21:52Have you seen Jack? Said, I haven't seen him. No, I
- 21:56haven't seen him since this morning. What the matter was that Arthur had taken
- 22:00Jack into the woods and after stripping him naked and forcing him to run through
- 22:06the woods. What yeah, what, he caught him, molested him and
- 22:11then strangled him. You just told me the kid, I didn't want you
- 22:15to do what I knew he did. That's horrible, Yeah, it is
- 22:19horrible, man. Why would he do that to Jack? Jack was his
- 22:23body like they fished together? Because Arthur's a fucking asshole. Okay. Later,
- 22:29Arthur would admit to removing the boy's heart and genitals and eating them.
- 22:34Stop. I know the story. I told you. It gets true though
- 22:40the backs to back that up, which is Arthur. I believe it just
- 22:45came from Arthur. Okay. Although Arthur was a suspect in Jack's disappearance,
- 22:52no action was taken due to a lack of evidence because he doesn't admit the
- 22:56stuff until later three months later, when the police were still searching for Jack,
- 23:03eight year old King, they hadn't found his body. Eight year old
- 23:07Karen and Hill was found dead under a bridge near Black River. She had
- 23:12been raped, mutilated, and strangled wasn't care for the boy, girl man
- 23:19woman who When a police investigation revealed that Karen and Arthur had been seen together
- 23:27earlier that same day, Arthur became a suspect in her murder. After they
- 23:33received another report that Arthur was seen eating ice cream at the bridge near where
- 23:37the body was found, the police picked him up and took him in for
- 23:41questioning. He was by the way, hey Jack, you know what a
- 23:45coincidence? You know Jack too? It was only three months after Jack had
- 23:51disappeared, So I don't know. I don't know if the police put the
- 23:53two in two together. He never was charged with anything regarding Jack's disappearance or
- 24:02murder. Arthur was interrogated at police headquarters for a full day before he surprised
- 24:07the police by asking them in front of his defense attorney, what's going to
- 24:14happen to me? If I tell you something? I have to get into
- 24:15trie so fast. Well, it's probably a wold have been arrested. I
- 24:19had somebody on retainer maybe okay, sorry, that's okay. So if he
- 24:26was my client, I've been like, shut up, shut up, she's
- 24:29got nothing to say. Would have kicked him when he said that I didn't
- 24:33pinch him. After several more hours of interviews and bargaining, Arthur ended up
- 24:41pleading guilty to the land to the manslaughter of Karen Ann Hill. He was
- 24:45later convicted and sentenced to twenty five years in prison. It's a lot for
- 24:52a manslaughter case, don't you think. Well, I mean, I mean
- 24:55it's not life. But yeah, I'm just so confused. Like he had
- 25:03an attorney and he just went and spilled his whole guts out. M I
- 25:08probably wanted to tell someone, don't you think. Yeah, probably got off
- 25:11on it, yeah, or at least bragg at least bragg a. Yeah.
- 25:17He was never charged, like I mentioned, with the murder of Jack,
- 25:21even though he did later admit to the rape and murder. And he
- 25:23showed police where he had dumped the body. And I don't know why that
- 25:27wouldn't give them enough to convict him. Here's his body, I mean,
- 25:33yeah, anyway, maybe it was a part of a police maybe the body.
- 25:37If you don't, maybe charge me. He subsequently told police psychiatrists that
- 25:44he had returned to the grave site. Oh stop, do not you got
- 25:48ready for this on several occasions to have sex with Jack's corpse. Adding in
- 25:56nephilia, necrophilia, cannibalism, child the lasting. Yeah, he's just fucking
- 26:03gross. Yea, extremely, this is a terrible growth story. Absolutely.
- 26:08Arthur began his second jail term in the New York Penitentiary in greenhn For the
- 26:14first eight years he was there, he spent much of his time protecting himself
- 26:18from the other inmates because they found out he was a child killer. Yeah.
- 26:22Absolutely, he was like the lowest of the low. His record shows
- 26:26many incidents of fighting minors, stealing offenses, lighting fires, and refusing to
- 26:32lead a cell. Eventually, though, he began to settle in to prison
- 26:37life. He's getting older now, yeah, you know, more mature.
- 26:38Maybe he started behaving himself and he seemed to be a model prisoner. Stop
- 26:47during his raping anybody, beating, anybody, setting fires. Now he's a
- 26:51model. Now he's like a sawyer boy, right. Yeah. During his
- 26:56incarceration, he claimed that he tried to tell the prison psychiatry that his problems
- 27:00were a result of the Vietnam War, but they refused to listen because psychiatrists
- 27:06apparently don't listen. Oh yeah. One of the first psychiatrists to examinee was
- 27:11doctor Albert dresser. He did not consider Arthur a psychological risk resent. What
- 27:18does that mean? Well, his report shows that he didn't perceive any evidence
- 27:22of delusions hallucinations, Okay, didn't diagnose them with any sort of mental ill
- 27:26right, there was no sensory deception in Arthur. Some months later, in
- 27:32October nineteen seventy three, another prison psychologist, doctor mc williams, also examined
- 27:38Arthur, and he carried out a series of tests including the Bender motor Gustalt
- 27:44test and the Weschler adult intelligence tests. Yeah, but found no evidence of
- 27:48any neurological impairment. What he did find was that Arthur suffered was from being
- 27:56fucked up. He suffered fits of deep depression. Well, okay, and
- 28:00in prison. Yeah, I mean right, Prison's just depressing enough. But
- 28:04he also relied heavily upon fantasy as a source of satisfaction coping skills. Yeah,
- 28:11fantasy. Yeah, you're right, you're right. His final entry in
- 28:15the case file was that he considered Arthur quote to be a normal individual,
- 28:21but who knows he's done wrong. It would like to help himself get back
- 28:26on the right track for his eventual return to society. No, no,
- 28:33not gonna happen curiously. In his file, though, an unknown person crossed
- 28:37out the reference to normal person and doctor mcwilliam's report and wrote the words a
- 28:42psychopathic killer above it, yeah and pencil thank you. You know, someone
- 28:48was like, nope, nope, nope, it's not normal. In nineteen
- 28:52seventy six, doctor Micah doctor Michael Boscha examined thirty one year old Arthur,
- 29:00and he found that he hadn't come to terms with the severity of the crimes
- 29:03that he did, and he constantly blamed other people for his problems, so
- 29:10he didn't take responsibility for anything. In his opinion, Arthur hadn't requested that
- 29:15first psychological exam. He didn't request it like to deal with his mental problems.
- 29:19He had done it merely to impress the parole board. The following year,
- 29:23this model prisoner had taken courses in locksmithing and horticulture. Locksmithing, Yeah,
- 29:30let's let him know. Let's let a criminal let locksmith think locksmith.
- 29:37I thought that was funny too, Yeah, that's interesting. And he began
- 29:41preparing for his ged with more than a touch of irony. He also began
- 29:45working with mental patients as a counselor. Oh soul right now, tell me
- 29:52about it. I know, hey, I know how you're feeling. You
- 29:56I'm like cutting someone's heart out. I'd been there. I've been there.
- 30:00This is how you cope? What? What? How did they let him
- 30:03do that? What? I don't know, I don't know and befool them
- 30:08all or something. I don't know how, But go ahead. I don't
- 30:11know, I don't know. I'm so confused by this and angry. Before
- 30:15I tell you more, we're going to take a break. In June nineteen
- 30:22seventy seven, yet another prison psychiatrist, doctor have Alwalla sounds good. I
- 30:30probably mispronounced he did, I'm sure, gave him another psychological exam and found
- 30:34that although he had adapted to prison life, you know, he had a
- 30:38prison routine, but he had his schizoid personality. I knew it, Yeah,
- 30:44I knew it. He was antisocial and he had a distinct personality disorder.
- 30:48In addition that that was his personality disorder. They didn't specify. They
- 30:52just said it was a personality disorder. Probably everything. I'm sure there's a
- 30:57lot of things he have been diagnosed well. The doctor also wrote, quote,
- 31:03this man does not show a good degree of evidence of successfully resolving or
- 31:07working out his psycho sexual conflicts end quote, which sounds like he's pretty dangerous
- 31:14to me, because when you do that shit, you can't get better.
- 31:19Some things cannot be turned around. No, no, they can't. Absolutely,
- 31:25if you find God and Jesus, you still can't stop the sexual fantasies
- 31:32and desires. I mean, I don't know personally, I'm just saying,
- 31:34I'm guessing. I'm guessing. Two more years passed and yet another report was
- 31:40tendered which described Arthur as quote a person of abnormal character traits with psycho sexual
- 31:45tendencies. It must be noted that the above mentioned complications tend to be chronic
- 31:52in duration. Like you said, you just can't used to like to have
- 31:56sex with dead children or cannibalize people over that now or you know, commit
- 32:02necrophilia. Yeah right. Basically, what most doctors were trying to say that
- 32:08under was that under normal circumstances, Arthur was a passive individual, but when
- 32:14subjected to stress, he became a slave to his inner sexual drives and he
- 32:17was unable to stop himself from giving them full rain. I get it,
- 32:23you're under stress, but don't you want to kill someone when you're under stress.
- 32:29No, no, well, okay, I mean we're recording. As
- 32:36your attorney, I would suggest you don't answer my own question. Everybody in
- 32:38life has stress, Yes, exactly, most of us cope with it.
- 32:45I mean maybe not so well, but yeah, okay, we don't murder
- 32:49people. I don't. No, I don't. I don't. It's being
- 32:54clear and regardless of these and other unfavorable logical report, you do not tell
- 33:00me he gets out or lose my mind. Oh okay, we'll be prepared
- 33:05what. Arthur continued to improve himself in prison. By nineteen eighty five,
- 33:09he had completed his high school diploma and had enrolled in college courses at Penn
- 33:15State University. A parole report during that same period further stated that Arthur exhibited
- 33:21a belligerent reaction, representing a foreboding potential for a possible re enactment of his
- 33:28tragic behavior. It's a lot of fancy words to say, he was going
- 33:30to read He's gonna do it again. Yes. The report went on to
- 33:35further criticize the prisoner for his disdain for the prison sex offender program and is
- 33:39playing his fury during a parole interview. You gotta be nice. You would
- 33:45think that you play the game honestly, right, but incredibly, despite the
- 33:52numerous psychological reports to the contrary and the board's own misgivings, don't say it.
- 33:59I'm gonna say it. Arthur qualified for early release in March nineteen eighty
- 34:04seven. Anne was deemed to be fit to re enter society. What the
- 34:08fuck is that, Tanya? I know? His pearl officer was quite upset.
- 34:14Why bit after his release. This pearl officer he worked in bingham in
- 34:19Binghamton County, his name was Robert T. Kent. He wrote to his
- 34:22superiors, get a load of this. I quit fuck you. I'm moving
- 34:29away to get away from this freak quote. At the risk of being melodramatic,
- 34:36this writer considers this man to be possibly the most dangerous individual to be
- 34:40released to this community for many years. Hello, Hello, people, somebody
- 34:47gets it with it? You know, I'm like it all worked up?
- 34:52You know, no one? No one heeded the warning. When Arthur was
- 34:59released and he was placed in the Binghamton area, the officials and residents of
- 35:04Waterton had made it plain and clear they didn't want him there. Who wants
- 35:07this freak? Right? He also had been maintaining a penpale relationship with a
- 35:13woman named Rose Wally and indicated they get married. Oh they do, but
- 35:20you're killing me here, he told, you know, he told the Pearol
- 35:23Board he's going to go live with her. He's probably gonna marry her.
- 35:27Because his pearl conditions, among other things, you know, required him to
- 35:31have somewhere to go. It restricted his movements to Broome County. He had
- 35:37a curfield, so he couldn't go out, you know, between eleven pm
- 35:39and seven am. He couldn't are taken any alcoholic beverages. He wasn't allowed
- 35:45to have contact with anyone under the age of eighteen, and he was supposed
- 35:50to stay away from schools and other places where children were. Well, that
- 35:52makes sense. This stay in Bangington proved to be a short one because nobody
- 35:58wanted him there. So he got approval to move to Delhi, New York,
- 36:02and that's when he moved in to Rose Wiley's apartment. Shortly after he
- 36:07moved in, however, the residence of that community got wind of his presence
- 36:10and they wanted him out. They wanted him out, so he appealed to
- 36:15the parole board and he was sent to live in the basement of a Baptist
- 36:17church in Delhi until suitable accommodations could be found. He and Rose later moved
- 36:23to Fleischmann's, New York. They moved into a large house, and Arthur
- 36:29obtained work with a local building contractor. So everything seems to be normal.
- 36:35Yeah, but a woman, got a big house, got a job.
- 36:37Everything seems to be going great. But within a matter of days days he
- 36:43was recognized at a local post office and later that night an angry mob hell
- 36:47yeah, thank you, led by the mayor. Oh, we're like,
- 36:52he needs to go, they assembled outside his house and they demanded that he
- 36:57leave the area. In the following weeks, Arthur and Rose were bounced around
- 37:01from one area to the next and until they were finally given an apartment in
- 37:06Rochester, New York. Because you know, he's bound by these parole conditions.
- 37:08He can't just move where ever he wants. Eventually, according to Arthur,
- 37:13he grew tired of the parole boards, interference, interference, and he
- 37:17and Rose got their own apartment and new jobs and settled into their surroundings.
- 37:21Because what would happen, is, he would say, him having trouble here
- 37:23they would find him a new place to live, so he instead he just
- 37:25said, we're going to find a place to live. Okay, I don't
- 37:29need your help. Yes. The job that Arthur got was at a company
- 37:32where he was employed to pick salads and boxes. Oh seems like a I
- 37:37don't want a different job. Yeah, I don't know. His life seemed
- 37:40stable enough until Christmas nineteen eighty seven, when he was forty two years old.
- 37:45This is when he asked his family to come to Rochester to meet Rose
- 37:50and they refused. Well, yeah, I'm surprised to him talking to him.
- 37:54But his mood darkened when his sister informed him at the only visited her
- 38:00in Virginia and told her how they had returned. And she told Arthur how
- 38:07his family had returned the Christmas presents that he had sent them. Why would
- 38:12you tell him because he can fuck off? Oh, I don't know.
- 38:16Because he's had sex with it. He murdered kids. I don't know,
- 38:20that's why. Yeah, I'm surprised anyone in his family he been talking to
- 38:23him after everything he alleged had like allegedly having exactly, so, I don't
- 38:29know. He became angry and ranted about how his family didn't want him.
- 38:32Who is right for me? Anyone? Out at his bike and rode for
- 38:37miles until he cooled down. Shortly after the Christmas incident, he started a
- 38:42relationship with another woman. What having a Rose, Well, she's still around.
- 38:45He's got two ladies now, must be. Is he good looking?
- 38:50No? I mean my standards. No, I don't know. Maybe the
- 38:54ladies found him. I mean pretty low, you bitch, Just kidding,
- 39:01but I don't know. So this new woman was Clara Neil, and she
- 39:06had a car, and he often would borrow her car. For a year,
- 39:09he maintained both relationships, and he explained to Rose that I'm just being
- 39:14nice to Clara so I can borrow her car. I'm using her. I'm
- 39:17using her. Yeah, okay, honey, okay. Great. Because he
- 39:21didn't want to ride his bike everywhere. On one particular evening, this is
- 39:27March fifteenth, nineteen eighty eight, he rode his bike to Clara's and took
- 39:31the car and he drove around until he reached Lake Avenue, which is near
- 39:36the Genesee River. It was an industrial area well known for its chief sacks
- 39:40and drug deals. As he drove slowly down the street, twenty seven year
- 39:45old Dorothy. She went by Dotsy Blackburn signaled for him to stop. When
- 39:52he pulled over, she asked him, you know, do you want a
- 39:53date? He said yes, and she directed him to park his car behind
- 39:58a warehouse. He told her he wanted to have mutual oral sex, and
- 40:02he paid her thirty dollars. She then undressed like she got his car undressed,
- 40:07and she complied with his request. Okay, now this is what Arthur
- 40:13describes. He says, at that point, dots He bit him on the
- 40:15penis, drawing blood. Why would she do that? Thank you? He
- 40:20said. He became enraged and bit her vagina out of revenge and squeezed her
- 40:24throat until she lost consciousness. He then attempted to stop the flow of blood
- 40:30from his damaged organ and tied Dotsy up with articles of her own clothing before
- 40:36driving out of town along State Route one oh four to an area in Northampton
- 40:40Park called Salmon River and it was one of his favorite fishing spots. Okay,
- 40:45so she's still alive. He told her that he was going to rape
- 40:49her, and she began taunting him and calling him names. That's what you
- 40:52do when you're tied up and you're terrified for your life. Yeah, he
- 40:58threatened to kill her, but she can tinue the name calling until he just
- 41:01couldn't stop. He lost it. Yeahs stressed out. Yeah, he took
- 41:06her. He took her neck in his hands, and he crushed the breath
- 41:08out of her. He stayed in the car with her body until nearly midnight,
- 41:14then calmly carried her through the snow to the river bridge and dropped her
- 41:19body into the icy river below, because that's what you do. Walking back
- 41:23to the car, he drove back into Rochester and drove up and down Lake
- 41:28Avenue looking for any sign that maybe indicated people were looking for Dotsy. You
- 41:32know, didn't anybody miss her? I don't know how we would find out,
- 41:36right, And you're just putting yourself back into an area where you could
- 41:40cause suspicion. That's why I called bullshit and everything he said satisfied. You
- 41:47know, okay, that nobody saw me pick her up. He went to
- 41:52a nearby coffee shop to relax. That's what you do, right, And
- 41:54after about an hour or Starbucks or whatever. Yeah, after about so he
- 42:00went back to the car. He collected Datsy's clothes and other property. They
- 42:05threw them into a dumpster bin. The following morning, after he cleaned up
- 42:09Clara's car, he returned it to her, and then he wrote his bike
- 42:13home, thanks, let me use thanks. Because of his normally erratic behavior,
- 42:20I guess he'd probably disappeared a lot. Neither of these women in his
- 42:23life realized that there was anything different in his behavior. Plus, you know,
- 42:28he suffered from these nightmares, and you know, so if he was
- 42:30acting weird, it was probably normal. And they liked it. They liked
- 42:35normal, they liked weird, they liked him. I guess you're probably right.
- 42:38Something little off about them too. I'm guessing I don't know him.
- 42:42I don't know him. They're probably lovely. I don't know. Maybe,
- 42:45I don't know. Maybe. In the following months, Arthur became a Lake
- 42:49Avenue regular, and he was well known by the local sex workers as Mitch
- 42:53Mitch Mitch. On March twenty fourth, about a week after Arthur murdered,
- 43:00Dotsy Plice found her body floating in the river some distance downstream from the area
- 43:06where she had been dumped. Her body was well preserved by the icy waters
- 43:09because it's March, but It also removed any evidence that might link her with
- 43:15her killer. The one thing that they did notice about her body was there
- 43:21was like a chunk that had been torn from her vagina. And so that's
- 43:23where he better bit or tore a chunk bit he said he better, said
- 43:30a chunk. Well, that's where there was a chunk missing. Okay,
- 43:34okay, I'm no he didn't he said he better. Oh, I believe
- 43:37he better. But that's a bite, that's more. I mean, that's
- 43:39like, never mind, let's just move on. I don't know what it
- 43:43looked like. Girls like Arthur then contained his urge to kill for several months.
- 43:51But when Arthur's boss learned why Arthur had been in prison because apparently he
- 43:54didn't know, he fired him, and that triggered off Arthur's next wave of
- 44:00violence. The second victim, while this is actually the fourth victim, but
- 44:07because you don't give to count jack and what would have helped Vietnam to yeah,
- 44:13m yes. She was a part time sex worker named Anna Stephen who
- 44:16Arthur had picked up and taken to the river near Driving Park Bridge. Arthur
- 44:22claimed that she had offered him sex for twenty dollars, but when he was
- 44:25unable to get an erection. She began making fun of him, because again,
- 44:30this is what people do. I guess I don't believe it. Everybody
- 44:34else's fault. They're all just bullying, right Arthur, making fun of him,
- 44:38calling him names, right, I mean, it goes back to childhood.
- 44:44He became angry and punched her, which made her fault to the ground
- 44:46trying to get away from him. She crawled into the water, but he
- 44:50went in after her, and he held her under the water until she drowned.
- 44:54He later told police said he couldn't be bothered trying to conceal her body,
- 44:59and he just let it float down the river. I'm surprised that he
- 45:01just drowned, like that's all he did me too, You're right, she
- 45:07became caught up in debris downstream, where because of the warmer conditions, her
- 45:12body rapidly decomposed. From that time on, he tried to resist the temptation
- 45:16to kill. He got another job working nights pecking salads for a company called
- 45:21G and G Food Service, pecking salads again. Yeah, he was pecking
- 45:23salads again and at night, So maybe this kept him off the street for
- 45:29a while. It did, because he didn't kill again until June nineteen eighty
- 45:32nine, so it was maybe like, oh, a year and three months,
- 45:37so we know, yeah, so he says. So, he says
- 45:39he was forty four at the time. This next victim was different than the
- 45:45first two, and that she wasn't a sex worker. She was a fifty
- 45:49year old. She was a fifty eight year old homeless woman named Dorothy Keller.
- 45:52And I'm gonna call her Keller because we already have Dotsy and Dorothy in
- 45:57our story. Arthur had met Keller when she worked as a waitress and a
- 46:00diner that he frequented. The two struck up a friendship, which quickly turned
- 46:05into an affair. What the hell, dude, he's a ladies man.
- 46:08This is It's crazy right. One afternoon, Arthur was on his way to
- 46:13the river to fish when he stopped to talk to Keller. When she found
- 46:16out where he was going, she asked, can I tag along? He
- 46:20said, sure, I wants to tag along fishing I don't know anyway,
- 46:23According to Arthur, they spent the morning fishing and having sex. Fishing and
- 46:30having sex, and they're out the open along this river bish and had some
- 46:35sex by the river. Daylight, right, I mean, I don't know.
- 46:39I don't know. I've never seen people do that, but okay,
- 46:44I'm sure people are doing it, all right. I don't know. They
- 46:46were there until midday when it started to rain. They huddled under a crude
- 46:52shelter that he had built, and while there they got into an argument about
- 46:55Keller stealing money and about his relationship with Clara and Rose, because apparently she
- 47:00was jealous that Clara and Rose were in his life. I don't know.
- 47:05He claims that when Keller threatened to tell the other women about the affair,
- 47:08he became angry, he got upset, he got stress, and he had
- 47:13no other choice but two. He picked up a log and beat her on
- 47:16the side of the head, killing her instantly. M Yeah. After hiding
- 47:22her body under a fallen tree, he returned home. He later told police
- 47:24that he returned to the spot. Sp don't do not say he had sex
- 47:30with her. Yeah, several months later. What he didn't have sex with
- 47:34her. He removed her skull and he dumped it in the river. I
- 47:36know that, Okay, he probably did, because it's what he fucking does
- 47:40all the time, so I wouldn't doubt it. Yeah, No, one
- 47:44said he just put her head in the river, because that's not disgusting either.
- 47:46Maybe, yeah, I probably, I don't know. Didn't want her
- 47:49identified. I don't know. I don't know. Fisherman eventually found Keller's remains,
- 47:53but Arthur was never connected with this woman, even though he had been
- 47:57seen with her regularly and often went to this fishing spot. Let's not forget
- 48:00his history. No, but nobody put two and two together. The next
- 48:06to die was another Lake Avenue sex worker named Patricia Ives, and she was
- 48:09known on the street as crazy Patty. Oh I want to be as crazy
- 48:14Tanya you are, but we just don't say it to your face. Oh
- 48:17okay. He claims that she offered him sex for twenty five dollars and when
- 48:23he approached the same wait, I'm so sorry. He claimed that she offered
- 48:29him sex for twenty five dollars. When he approached the same diner where Dorothy
- 48:32Keller had worked, he agreed that they He agreed, and they went to
- 48:37a construction site. While they were having sex, Arthur said he caught Patty
- 48:40like reaching for his wallet oh okay, and he pushed her heart against the
- 48:46ground when she began to cry. He antally raped her and began strangling her
- 48:52until she went limb These poor women, I know. He hit her body
- 48:57under some scrap of construction material. He waited until dark and then he went
- 49:00home. It's so cruel. Oh, he's awful. I told you you
- 49:05were going to hate it before. This episode's old for the women. I
- 49:08mean. Two months later, he killed another sex worker named Francis Brown in
- 49:14similar circumstances, except in this instance, he claimed to have choked Francis with
- 49:19his penis. He choked her literally, I'm calm, bullshit. Oh so
- 49:25during oral sex? Yees, during oral sex? Oh man, what are
- 49:31we to go? Hontelea? What the fuck is that? This whole?
- 49:35I hope, I just hope he's lying. I hope he's lying too.
- 49:38It's horrible. And he said he continued to have sex with her after she
- 49:42died. Okay, I do believe that. Okay, I'm not stopping.
- 49:47Do you have any good news? It's horrible. I know, it's really
- 49:52horrible. No, seriously, it is horrible. That's horrible, yes,
- 49:55okay. He then dumped her body down a nearby and ba. Following Francis's
- 50:01murder, the media began to pick up on the story of the murdered five
- 50:06Rochester, New York women. This all happened within eighteen months, and they
- 50:09called the unknown perpetrator the Rochester night Stalker, the Rochester strangler, and the
- 50:15Genesee River Killer. Some even suggested that the crimes were similar to the Green
- 50:21River killings in Seattle and speculated that the killer had merely just changed locations,
- 50:25like maybe you know, because they hadn't caught Gary Ridgeway by then. For
- 50:31the next victim, which total, how many more we get, Well,
- 50:37this is the eighth victim, and he did have a total of thirteen victims.
- 50:42Of a few more to tell you about, Arthur again chose someone close
- 50:45to home. June Stats was a friend of Arthur and Rose and regularly was
- 50:51a visitor at their home. She was also mildly mentally challenged. Arthur had
- 50:55seen June sitting near the river on a warm November day, hanging up by
- 51:00this river I know, and he said to her, you know, do
- 51:02you want to come for a ride with me? She accepted and they drove
- 51:06down to a local bench O beach. Sorry, she accepted and they drove
- 51:12down to a local beach where they played in the sand and fed the birds
- 51:15before they walked to a deserted area and lay down on the ground to have
- 51:20sex. Everybody's just dying to have sex with Arthur by a river, by
- 51:23a river. At some point during sex, Arthur claims he made an innocent
- 51:30comment about her not being a virgin, and she started screaming. He then
- 51:35held his hand over her mouth to silencer, and then he soon realized he
- 51:37had accidentally suffocated whoops. He then cut her open with his knife so that
- 51:45she would decompose quicker, and he covered her with a blanket in some nearby
- 51:49brush and then left her. You blood all over him? Think, So
- 51:52that's why I don't know. I don't know how to feel about him saying
- 51:57these things. You would think, like there's nobody else in this area.
- 52:01It's I can't I can't even look gum on the sidewalk without getting a ticket.
- 52:08Right, I don't know, not that I have. Well, guess
- 52:12what he did something horrible to her. He later claimed that he removed her
- 52:16vagina and some of her organs and he ate them. Okay, again,
- 52:22I don't know. Is he trying to shock? Where? Where do you?
- 52:24Where? How do you? I don't know what a coup bullshit?
- 52:30Yeah, I hope. So. Look it's what I know. I can
- 52:34only say what the fux so many times? I know it's bad, It's
- 52:38just bad. Why would you admit that? Like, I know, That's
- 52:43what I'm saying, Like, is he trying to shock probably like the police
- 52:46or I don't know. I don't know. Maybe he did do it,
- 52:49I don't know. That same month, Arthur picked up Maria Welch from Lake
- 52:53Avenue, that's where the sex workers were usually found, and he took her
- 52:58to a small beach near the bank of the Genesee River, where they argued
- 53:01over a suitable price before they began having sex again. Like Patty Ives,
- 53:07he claimed that Maria tried to reach for his wallet like that. Yeah,
- 53:10they're all just robbing him, I know, And so he snapped and he
- 53:13strangled her. He later changed his story, and he told investigators that he
- 53:17had become angry and killed her when he realized she was menstruating, because that's
- 53:22her fault. He drove further down the road next to the river and dumped
- 53:25her body in some bushes. Who knows what the truth is. On November
- 53:30eleventh, nineteen eighty nine, police. Police investigators from the sixty strong Serial
- 53:37Crimes Unit identified the body of Francis Brown. Incredibly, no one in the
- 53:44newly formed task force uncovered the fact that a known sex offender and child killer
- 53:50was still on parole living in their midst I don't know. It's before computers
- 53:52were really popular too. I guess I can't blame, you know. I
- 53:57mean today you'd all know. They don't know, you know, hopefully,
- 54:00hopefully. Two weeks later, on November twenty third, while police were examining
- 54:04the decomposing body of June's stats, Arthur killed again, as before the pattern
- 54:09was set. He picked Darlene Trippy up from the Lake Avenue area and drove
- 54:15to an isolated car park. After the money was paid, they had oral
- 54:19sex, but Arthur failed to get an erection. He claimed she became frustrated
- 54:25was calling him name, oh there we go again, rights and taunting.
- 54:30He said that enraged him. He choked her until she lay dead under him.
- 54:36He dumped her body in open woodland. The following month, he killed
- 54:39Elizabeth Gibson in a similar fashion when she got into his car to keep warm
- 54:45while he was getting coffee from a diner. They had oral sex in the
- 54:49car, and again he claimed she tried to take his wallet, and angry,
- 54:52he strangled her. Arthur later told police that she had struggled so hard
- 54:58that she had broken the gearshift his car. He disposed of Elizabeth's body in
- 55:02an area near Wayne County that he hadn't used before, as he feared that
- 55:07the police were getting too close. Like he went he did dump people like
- 55:13in similar areas. So I mean it was stupid. He was stupid,
- 55:17thankful, because that's how people get caught. Two more weeks passed, and
- 55:22even though the police were out in full force in the Lake Avenue area,
- 55:27Arthur picked up an attractive girl named June Cicero and took her to another another
- 55:31isolated area, and attempted sex with her before he strangled her. He dumped
- 55:36her body off a bridge near the Salmon River. Two days later, he
- 55:40returned to the dump site with a small Handsaw. Okay, and that's when
- 55:46he said he cut her vagina from her froze body. Okay, it was
- 55:52just okay, I don't understand, all right. The final victim, yes
- 55:58please, yes, was another sex worker, only she was different than the
- 56:02others because she was a black woman named Felicia Stevens didn't fit his normal profile.
- 56:08When he was interviewed later, he said he really couldn't remember too many
- 56:12details about killing her, other than the fact that she was a black woman
- 56:15and that he strangled her. He dumped her body near those of June's Cicero
- 56:20and Dorothy Blackburn. And Dorothy Blackburn was his first victim that had picked up
- 56:23like one of the first sex workers. It was this desire to keep the
- 56:28bodies where he could find them again that left he was capture. On Wednesday,
- 56:36January third, nineteen ninety, forty five year old Arthur drove to Salmon
- 56:39Creek in Northampton Park to visit June's Cicero's body. He was aroused at the
- 56:45thought of him and say he hadn't been following the progress of the Serial Task
- 56:52Force that had become prime news on TV and in the newspapers, which I'm
- 56:57really surprised because a lot of killers get off on that. Yeah, and
- 57:00I thought you said that he went to like some park, like a parking
- 57:04lot and dumped one because he thought they were getting to clothes. But he's
- 57:07not following it. Yeah, he's not following He had clippings and stuff like
- 57:09they do. He didn't follow it that close. He's just visiting the body.
- 57:14And if he had followed the case, he would have known that the
- 57:17police surveillance was in and around the Northampton Park that had increased dramatically. But
- 57:23they were out in full force. You know, they really wanted to catch
- 57:25this killer. He was happy that there were no cars parked where. He
- 57:30wanted to stop on a bridge overlooking the creek so he could view June's body
- 57:34while he ate his lunch. So I guess he could get it. He
- 57:36could get on this bridge and I guess he could see her. Well,
- 57:38he ate his lunch, lunch just casually. I'm gonna, you know,
- 57:43bring my brown bag. And I know he didn't realize that a police helicopter
- 57:49had been checking the Salmon River and had not only seen his car parked on
- 57:52the bridge, but also the outline of the body under the ice. Oh
- 57:58wow. Yeah. As a helicopter approached, Arthur noticed it. He left
- 58:02the area and drove along Highway thirty one and he turned laughed at route to
- 58:08fifty nine, heading toward the town of Spencerport, with the helicopter following him.
- 58:14You're not going to get away from the helicopter found him entire time.
- 58:19The helicopter crew then called in to patrol cars to follow Arthur and intercept him.
- 58:24They followed him to an address in Spencerport where the car was parked,
- 58:28and Arthur got out and entered the Wedgewood adult home where his wife worked.
- 58:32Oh hey, honey, honey. I The police entered the home and asked
- 58:37the attendant about the man who had just honored, and they told him he
- 58:40went down into the basement. The police followed and approached Arthur in the basement
- 58:45and they asked for his ID. Well casual about it. He took his
- 58:49ID out and said, hey, what's up? What do you guys?
- 58:52Stop sign? What what's you doing here? They then asked him to step
- 58:55outside to answer some questions. Later, he was interview in the car by
- 59:00Paul Dasillis, who was one of the Task Force investigators, and he was
- 59:05asked why he had been at Samon Creek in lunch. Yeah you know,
- 59:08but Arthur said, oh, I'd been out driving and I stopped a pea.
- 59:13But then when he saw the helicopter, he got shy and he decided
- 59:15to sit in his car and pee in a bottle because guys do do that.
- 59:20Ye so, but God forbid the you know, helicopter see him p
- 59:23outside. It's probably a crime. I don't know. Yes it is,
- 59:27Yes, it is for several hours. Can't just piss outside. I don't
- 59:30do it. I know. But you're a lawyer, You're like, it's
- 59:34probably a cript. I's gonna let you know. Thank you to Leah.
- 59:40Detective Dacillus question Arthur for hours, question him extensively about his movements that morning,
- 59:47but found that Arthur had a pretty convincing story while they were talking.
- 59:52While they were talking, Arthur told him about his earlier conviction for the chick.
- 59:55Hey, guess what kids better casually? I don't know. Detective d.
- 1:00:01Sillis continued to ask him questions about his wives, his jobs, his
- 1:00:07sexual habits, and even asked him details of the attacks on Jack Blake and
- 1:00:12Karen Hall. Those children, Karen Hill, those children. Throughout the questioning,
- 1:00:15he was completely cooperative, even though he hadn't been arrested and he was
- 1:00:21talking to the police voluntarily. Later that night, he was released and he
- 1:00:25went home, unaware that his house was now under constant surveillance. The following
- 1:00:30morning, the detectives picked him up early again because they're like, we need
- 1:00:35you to come back to the station questions. There's some inconsistencies we need your
- 1:00:42help with. Again, Arthur complied with their request and he went with them.
- 1:00:46They drove him to an area near a golf course where he had supposedly
- 1:00:50had a liaison with a sex worker who had said, you know, he
- 1:00:53often took her to this area and that's where he picked up a lot of
- 1:00:59sex workers. When Arthur agreed with that assrotation, he's like, yeah,
- 1:01:02I do. He was asked to accompany the detectives to their office, where
- 1:01:07an official interrogation was conducted. Later that same evening, Arthur positively identified photographs
- 1:01:15of the eleven victims, and he confessed to their murders. Thank god,
- 1:01:19okay. He then accompanied the police to various grave sites, and later that
- 1:01:23night, after twelve straight hours of interrogation, Arthur was officially charged with the
- 1:01:29Genesee River killings. At his arraignment, Arthur followed his court appointed attorney's advice
- 1:01:35and and pled innocent on all charges, and it was strongly rumored that he
- 1:01:39was going to raise the insanity defense for the next several months, Arthur was
- 1:01:45given a multitude of tests by numerous psychiatrists, one of which was doctor Krauss,
- 1:01:50who compiled an extensive report which suggested that Arthur was quote and emotionally unstable,
- 1:01:57learning disabled, genetically impaired, I know, biochemically disordered, neurologically damaged,
- 1:02:05individual, psychologically alienated from significant others during his entire life, venting his
- 1:02:10frustration and rage mixed with fear and defiance in a lifetime of ever more violent
- 1:02:17and destructive aggression which ultimately turned to overpowering, murderous fury aka fucked up.
- 1:02:24That's its diagnosis. Yeah, I mean, he just so tell me what
- 1:02:32happens to him? Please please? Well, he went on trial because we
- 1:02:38didn't take the stand. It was extensively covered by the media. The only
- 1:02:43defense witness was not Arthur. It was doctor Dorothy at now Lewis, who
- 1:02:49testified that Arthur had been hideously traumatized as a child. Maybe that's true,
- 1:02:53which left him with multiple people personality disorder. Oh really yeah. Yes.
- 1:03:02She also cited post traumatic stress disorder caused by his war experiences as a root
- 1:03:07cause for his behavior, which it probably contributed. Yeah, but a lot
- 1:03:13of people went through. Oh yeah, absolutely, they don't do this shit
- 1:03:17show whatever. I can't even fucking you're so angry, so angry, you
- 1:03:23can't even talk. No excuse for it. I know. I don't know
- 1:03:25why one person goes through the same thing and they don't end up killing thirteen
- 1:03:30people. But anyway, Arthur acted like a good boy, and he made
- 1:03:35sure to play the part, play the part. Sitting in court. Could
- 1:03:38you look like a goddamn good boy? We sat there. I'm sorry,
- 1:03:42I'm gonna be I only ate the vagina. No, you can't be a
- 1:03:45good boy. He tried to give the impression that he had advanced psychosis to
- 1:03:51the jury, which I don't know, what, do you have a crazy
- 1:03:53look on your face or something. But the jury was less than impressed because
- 1:03:58it only took them six and a half hours. I took them six and
- 1:04:00a half hours. Yeah, well, there's a lot of there's a lot
- 1:04:03of victims. They returned a unanimous guilty verdict and recommended a sentence of two
- 1:04:09hundred and fifty years in jail. Okay. In September of nineteen ninety nine,
- 1:04:13Arthur was found to be selling his paintings and autographs on the Internet from
- 1:04:18within prison. The New York State Department of Correctional Services temporarily suspended his art
- 1:04:24privileges after learning that his artwork and autographs were listed for sale on eBay.
- 1:04:30What people were buying this ship? People did buy the ship just really getting
- 1:04:33out of a prison. I don't know. Somebody was probably smuggling it out
- 1:04:36for him and then taking a New Blacks something like that. Yeah, right,
- 1:04:43they had the panties in origin and New Black. Yeah. He received
- 1:04:45disciplinary actions for the breach, which included being locked in a cell for extended
- 1:04:49periods. So do you want to know where Arthur is today? Yes?
- 1:04:54I do. Well, he's dead. That's what I was hoping you would
- 1:04:58say. He died on No remember ten, two thousand and eight of cardiac
- 1:05:01arrest. How old was he? He was a whopping sixty three. He
- 1:05:05died young. But it's young. It is young. But yeahs for him?
- 1:05:12Though too long? You aren't too long for him? Too long for
- 1:05:14him, exactly, asshole. Horrific excuse for life, waste of oxygen.
- 1:05:20This was a tough one. Yeah, I know, I just said through
- 1:05:24it. Yes, that's that's the end. There's no more victims. I
- 1:05:30think I feel bad saying this, but thank you for thinking you're welcome.
- 1:05:33You're welcome a lot. That's sad, right, it was very sad,
- 1:05:38But I mean I don't make I mean to make light of it. That's
- 1:05:41how we cope. Yes, And I laugh when I'm nervous or uncomfortable,
- 1:05:45so that doesn't help, you know, I'm not giggling because it's a hilarious
- 1:05:48story. No, it's just ridiculous lies. Yeah, his lives were stupid.
- 1:05:55And hate him, you know. I think God he was dumb though,
- 1:05:58t leah, because that's how he got Yeah. Well it took a
- 1:06:00long time, it did, a lot of people lost it. He moved
- 1:06:03a lot though. I mean he was killing people like left and right.
- 1:06:05Yeah. Thank you everyone for tuning in to this episode of Crimes and Consequences.
- 1:06:11Thank you, and if you haven't done so already, please hit like
- 1:06:15or subscribe both both please, and please share this episode with all of your
- 1:06:19friends. Tell everybody, Tell everybody, because we love doing this and we
- 1:06:25love you guys, and your friends are going to appreciate it. And until
- 1:06:29our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye.