Latest / Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick, powered by CBT News / Jason Swiech on How Dealers Can Improve the F&I Experience
Transcript
- 0:07Speaker: Welcome to Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:14Jim Fitzpatrick: The FI office has always been a critical part of the dealership experience, and today's customers want a faster, more transparent process.
- 0:22Jim Fitzpatrick: CDK recently released their annual FI survey, and the research highlights how central the FI experience has become in the overall dealership journey.
- 0:32Jim Fitzpatrick: Joining us now with more on this is Jason Swick, who's the FI product marketing manager at CDK.
- 0:38Jim Fitzpatrick: Thank you, Jason, for joining us on the show today.
- 0:41Jason Swiech: Thank you for having me.
- 0:42Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure.
- 0:43Jim Fitzpatrick: So talk to us about the state of the FI office overall right now in the industry.
- 0:49Jason Swiech: Yeah, it's interesting.
- 0:50Jason Swiech: Like you said, we just released our study, and this is um two years in a row now that the FI industry has been looked at as the most trusted source in the entire workflow by customers.
- 1:01Jason Swiech: Uh, they're the ones that are trusting them on their recommendations.
- 1:05Jason Swiech: Um, they look at them as a very honest uh area of the workflow, um, which, you know, I think surprises some of us that are in the industry.
- 1:13Jason Swiech: We hear so many bad things about F and I.
- 1:16Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 1:16Jason Swiech: But in the reality, you know, customers still see it, like you said, is that central uh place for them to get that advice.
- 1:23Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 1:24Jason Swiech: Um, now that being said, we still hear that, you know, wait times are long for FI.
- 1:28Jason Swiech: Um on the product side, we see the extended warranties, scheduled maintenance, gap is our huge products right now.
- 1:36Jason Swiech: But that makes sense with how long uh customers are taking these loans out for and things like that to protect those investments.
- 1:43Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, for sure.
- 1:44Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, we and it's funny, I I spent four years of my life as an FI manager at a high volume Toyota dealership.
- 1:50Jim Fitzpatrick: And um we always tried to position the office.
- 1:53Jim Fitzpatrick: In fact, we called ourselves business managers, not FI managers, and we always tried to position the office, even in its appearance, as a bank, uh like almost like a banker's office.
- 2:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Do you know what I mean?
- 2:03Jim Fitzpatrick: And you're right, people would come in, they'd feel much more comfortable.
- 2:06Jim Fitzpatrick: They'd be like, oh, okay, now we've got somebody that's you know gonna shoot us straight.
- 2:10Jim Fitzpatrick: And you know, they're not out there as a slick salesperson.
- 2:13Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, we we always wore uh pinstripe suits and button-down collars and what have you.
- 2:18Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh so yeah, consumers e today, even going into F and I offices, feel like, all right, this this guy, uh this, you know, this person in this office is gonna shoot me straight on this, right?
- 2:28Jason Swiech: Yeah, exactly.
- 2:29Jason Swiech: I mean, they're the ones that have to finish the deal, as you know.
- 2:32Jason Swiech: So they're the ones that the customer is gonna trust because they're the ones that are like you said, you know, you kind of focused on like that banking institution kind of feel.
- 2:41Jason Swiech: Um, and they're gonna be the ones that explain that whole experience.
- 2:44Jason Swiech: Even though we are trying to upsell, um, that's what customers take away from that, is is that really that big trust factor.
- 2:51Jim Fitzpatrick: It was amazing how many customers would ask me now.
- 2:53Jim Fitzpatrick: Do you work for the bank?
- 2:54Jim Fitzpatrick: And I'm thinking, wow, okay, we this is uh this is incredible that they're they actually think I work for the bank.
- 3:00Jim Fitzpatrick: But uh so talk to me about wait times because this is something that is frustrates the consumer.
- 3:06Jim Fitzpatrick: It frustrates the salesperson because they want to get on with their next sale, especially if it's Saturday at two o'clock in the afternoon and you know you're four deep in F and I.
- 3:14Jim Fitzpatrick: And but this really frustrates the customer that's got to wait so long.
- 3:18Jim Fitzpatrick: And of course, it frustrates the finance manager because it's it's difficult to sell those products to a customer that comes in that's been waiting for the last hour or maybe 90 minutes or longer just to get in to see you.
- 3:31Jim Fitzpatrick: So many times you have to deal with that, right?
- 3:34Jason Swiech: Yeah, exactly.
- 3:35Jason Swiech: Um, and you're absolutely right.
- 3:36Jason Swiech: Even though we saw 90% satisfaction rates from customers in the FI office, 46% of them still have to wait longer than 20 minutes just to get into the FI office.
- 3:46Jason Swiech: And that's way too long.
- 3:48Jason Swiech: Uh, because like you said, FI managers have to deal with walls all the time when they talk about products and bringing those walls down.
- 3:54Jason Swiech: And that just builds those walls in front of that discussion.
- 3:57Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 3:58Jason Swiech: Um, so it is a it still continues to be a huge problem.
- 4:01Jason Swiech: What we are seeing a lot of dealerships do um are trying to look at the rest of the workflow to see what they can minimize uh having to go into the FI office with a lot of uh of a lot of it around documentation.
- 4:13Jason Swiech: Are we duplicating our processes?
- 4:16Jason Swiech: I see a ton of dealers still signing two credit apps, one outside and one inside the FI office, duplication of collection of documents like driver's license.
- 4:25Jason Swiech: So these are all small things.
- 4:26Jason Swiech: They sound like they're small things, right?
- 4:28Jason Swiech: But they they really do make a big difference when it gets into F and I.
- 4:31Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, and it and it's it's frustrating for the consumer that goes, wait a minute, I already signed one of these, I already gave you my driver's license, I already did all of this.
- 4:38Jim Fitzpatrick: And it's it's kind of like that situation where a consumer does a lot of work online and then they get to the dealership and the dealer, you know, the salesperson says, Okay, I need this.
- 4:46Jim Fitzpatrick: This it's like, wait a minute, what what did I just spend all that time online for?
- 4:49Jim Fitzpatrick: You know?
- 4:49Jim Fitzpatrick: And now we're we're doing it in F and I.
- 4:52Jim Fitzpatrick: So um, so yeah, to improve the the process, especially around the document uh management and reducing fragmented workflows and and uh yeah, I mean that's it.
- 5:02Jason Swiech: And it's a continued process evaluation.
- 5:04Jason Swiech: You know, I I work with a lot of dealers and a lot of them focus on what they're doing process-wise.
- 5:09Jason Swiech: Yeah, but then it might be two years down the road that they haven't really focused on that process once they put it in place.
- 5:14Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 5:15Jason Swiech: So it's that continued evaluation, going through your process, seeing what your customers are experiencing.
- 5:19Jason Swiech: Yeah, and like I said, making those small changes.
- 5:21Jason Swiech: You don't have to revamp your entire process and blow up what you're doing.
- 5:25Jason Swiech: You can make these small enhancements, and then by you know, six months later, you you have revamped your entire process.
- 5:31Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 5:32Jim Fitzpatrick: I always say this about uh shopping a dealership for a dealer principal or a general manager.
- 5:36Jim Fitzpatrick: When was the last time you bought a car and had to wait an hour and a half to get into the finance office and and and go through that whole process?
- 5:44Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, we as managers and leaders in the industry, we have a tendency to get away from what it's actually like, you know, down in the trenches because you're not you're not going through that when you buy a car, you know?
- 5:55Jim Fitzpatrick: But if they did, they might be surprised as to what they find their consumers have to go through, right?
- 6:01Jason Swiech: Exactly.
- 6:02Jason Swiech: Yeah, yeah, it it it makes a huge difference when you can actually experience what your customers are or have somebody around you experience that so that they can kind of give you that insight.
- 6:11Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 6:12Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 6:12Jim Fitzpatrick: So, and is the goal to go paperless one day where it's just you're not dealing with all of this?
- 6:18Jason Swiech: Yeah, that's you know, that's the question that I've always gotten.
- 6:20Jason Swiech: And and the easy answer is we obviously all want to go paperless and digital is not going away, right?
- 6:26Jason Swiech: And I'm not here to say to to introduce paper back into your process by any means.
- 6:31Jason Swiech: That being said, what was interesting and has been interesting is that customers are still saying that they want that flexibility when they're buying a car and how they get documentation, how they experience it.
- 6:42Jason Swiech: Most of them are good with the signing ceremony being digital, but if I spend $20,000, $30,000, $40,000, $50,000 on a car, a lot of them still want that paper in their hand when they leave or at least that flexibility to have it.
- 6:54Jason Swiech: And this goes back to that process piece where, you know, as you evaluate your process, don't put yourself into one experience only.
- 7:03Jason Swiech: Make sure you have those exceptions built in because if you don't, that is what elongates that process.
- 7:09Jason Swiech: So if you are so focused on that digital aspect, but then you have a customer who would prefer paper or a different delivery method, having that in your process is just as important.
- 7:20Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, for sure, for sure.
- 7:21Jim Fitzpatrick: Do you see FI continuing to be a required separate office, or do you see more dealers wanting to combine that with other parts of the workflow?
- 7:31Jason Swiech: I continue to see a lot of dealers questioning whether or not the F and I office has to stay separated.
- 7:37Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 7:37Jason Swiech: And what I would say to that is, and and I've had a lot of discussions with dealers on this as well, is that whatever decision you make, again, start small.
- 7:47Jason Swiech: See if you can start bringing things out of the FI office if that's the way you want to go, and and see if you're it's detrimental or if it's helpful.
- 7:55Jason Swiech: You know, we don't want to hurt your revenue because we're bringing that forward, but we also don't want to just keep an FI office because it's what we've done year after year.
- 8:04Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 8:04Jason Swiech: So I think for each dealer, they have to kind of look at this and see if it would work for them.
- 8:09Jason Swiech: But just be very aware of what you're getting rid of in the F and I office, the compliance side, the documentation side, and obviously the per vehicle revenue side, and and start bringing that forward and seeing if you can actually adopt to that method.
- 8:21Jason Swiech: Yeah.
- 8:22Jason Swiech: I don't think there is one easy answer to that.
- 8:25Jason Swiech: I just think each dealership needs to evaluate it.
- 8:27Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 8:28Jim Fitzpatrick: I do think that from a consumer standpoint, this is just me personally, but uh that that a separate office is kind of nice when you're talking about credit rating and you're talking about monies and down payments and and accounts and account numbers and social security numbers, you know, rather than being out in the open, you know, among all of the other desks and salespeople and customers, and you never know who's listening or what have you.
- 8:53Jim Fitzpatrick: And the F and I manager might be asking you, you know, personal questions or whose account is this and whose account is that, and what are you paying for this, and how's your credit, and all of those questions that they ask.
- 9:02Jim Fitzpatrick: And um it can make consumers feel a little bit more uncomfortable out in the open, you know, rather than going, well, can we go in the office and discuss this rather than all of my information being out there, right?
- 9:15Jason Swiech: I just my personal opinion.
- 9:16Jason Swiech: I'm actually on the same boat as you.
- 9:19Jason Swiech: I I want that more private experience.
- 9:21Jason Swiech: But that's that's where they can evaluate those processes.
- 9:24Jason Swiech: Maybe it's not a um a normal conventional F and I office, but more of a car delivery room experience or something like that.
- 9:32Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, good point.
- 9:33Jason Swiech: I would talk to a dealer who kind of merged their sales manager and F and I manager together, uh, but they still have the sales manager be part of that initial, you know, greeting so that they they can meet that that next level uh with that customer.
- 9:48Jason Swiech: So in every experience, I think it's gonna be different for them the dealership and also what market they're in and their customers specifically.
- 9:57Jim Fitzpatrick: With vehicle prices and interest rates continuing to rise, affordability is is obviously at the forefront of everybody's mind right now, whether you're a dealer, OEM, or a consumer.
- 10:07Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, it's becoming a bigger concern for car buyers, I think.
- 10:10Jim Fitzpatrick: But uh, what role do you believe the FI manager plays in helping customers navigate those pressures and find solutions that work for their budgets?
- 10:20Jason Swiech: Yeah, I think uh FI managers or the FI process overall plays a huge piece to this.
- 10:26Jason Swiech: I I mean we talked about bringing things forward.
- 10:28Jason Swiech: Yeah, those discussion points being at the very beginning of the process, I think are crucial.
- 10:33Jason Swiech: Um, we've seen it be impactful with presenting products earlier in the process, but having those really deep discussions around rates and things like that in the very beginning are going to be important and not just giving more of a generic uh experience to a customer, but but kind of nailing them down on what they can actually afford and what's available to them.
- 10:55Jason Swiech: So so when dealerships look at this, I think even if they have that traditional FI office where F and I kind of gets the deal bought, I think that they could still bring some of those processes forward to make sure that you know they're running credit applications maybe earlier in their process to get an actual um payment for that customer that's not going to change in FI because we still see a lot of times that payment's changing because of what that customer can truly afford.
- 11:21Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, yeah.
- 11:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Very good, very good point.
- 11:23Jim Fitzpatrick: How can dealers present F and I product options in a way that you know builds value without overwhelming that customer who's really focused on the overall vehicle cost?
- 11:34Jason Swiech: Yeah, I think there is really two ways.
- 11:36Jason Swiech: Uh, first of all, just like the rates discussion, continuing to talk about it initially is a huge thing.
- 11:43Jason Swiech: We talked about walls earlier in the FI office.
- 11:46Jason Swiech: If you're not talking about products early on, you're building that wall up for that failure of product sales in the FI office.
- 11:52Jason Swiech: So again, continuation of discussions early in the process.
- 11:57Jason Swiech: But then I think the other way is customization of presentations.
- 12:01Jason Swiech: Now, I'm not saying not to show all products all the time.
- 12:04Jason Swiech: I still think we should.
- 12:05Jason Swiech: But when you're showing all those products all the time, also make a customized menu for each of your customers because they're gonna be focused on what's important to them.
- 12:15Jason Swiech: And if you're just starting off with a normal gold, platinum, silver, best, better, you know, uh presentation, you're you're already overwhelming them.
- 12:24Jason Swiech: So if you can give them guidance, again, we talked about the trust side that they're the trusted advisor.
- 12:30Jason Swiech: If you can start off by giving them guidance with a customized menu, I think that goes a much farther way.
- 12:36Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, I I agree.
- 12:37Jim Fitzpatrick: I agree.
- 12:37Jim Fitzpatrick: It's got to be more of a uh consultation, right?
- 12:40Jim Fitzpatrick: Than it is boom, boom, boom, which one do you want?
- 12:43Jim Fitzpatrick: Here it is, you know, wham, bam, thank you, ma'am, kind of thing.
- 12:46Jim Fitzpatrick: And it and yeah, that there's no question.
- 12:48Jim Fitzpatrick: And they're they're the I think the consumer is counting on today's FI manager to to to uh to handle themselves that way, right?
- 12:55Jason Swiech: I think so.
- 12:56Jason Swiech: I think a lot of customers go to dealerships and that's where they want that consult uh consultation.
- 13:01Jason Swiech: Um, they want to be able to sit with an FI manager and really understand what is available to them, or not even just the FI manager, but the dealership personnel overall.
- 13:11Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 13:11Jason Swiech: So yeah, I I think customers go in now, not really understanding the landscape.
- 13:16Jason Swiech: Yeah, one of the things that we thought was interesting was a lot of these buyers haven't grown up in a world where rates have been this high for this long.
- 13:24Jim Fitzpatrick: That's a good point.
- 13:24Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 13:25Jason Swiech: There's a lot of buyers that are still in that world of 0% was a normal thing for a long time.
- 13:30Jason Swiech: So I I think right now there's an education factor that a lot of these customers walk into dealerships needing.
- 13:36Jim Fitzpatrick: Yes, I agree.
- 13:37Jim Fitzpatrick: I agree.
- 13:38Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, I've spoken to a number of dealers that have said we've banned, we've just put a band on 84 month financing.
- 13:44Jim Fitzpatrick: We don't think it's good for the industry.
- 13:46Jim Fitzpatrick: We don't think it's really good for even the customer.
- 13:49Jim Fitzpatrick: And we definitely don't think it's good for the trading cycles out there, you know, to put somebody in an 84-month contract.
- 13:55Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, have you heard anything like that before that uh that that you there's some dealers are like, yeah, we don't do 84-month financing.
- 14:02Jason Swiech: Yeah, I think there are definitely dealerships kind of walking that back a little bit and and kind of evaluating that for their customer base.
- 14:09Jason Swiech: I still think that, you know, unfortunately for some situations it's a necessity, but I do agree with you.
- 14:15Jason Swiech: I think dealerships need to evaluate if that's really what where they want to put their customers.
- 14:19Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah.
- 14:19Jason Swiech: And I honestly think that it goes back to that trust factor.
- 14:22Jason Swiech: You know, if if you are offering something that long out, uh imagine what your customer's experience is going to be like that far out, you know, those years down the road.
- 14:32Jason Swiech: So I do think dealerships always need to continually look at do they need to go with where the market's going or do they need to go where their customers that they deal with uh really would benefit from?
- 14:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, totally agree.
- 14:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Totally agree.
- 14:45Jim Fitzpatrick: Jason Swick, F and I product manager, uh marketing manager, I should say, at CDK.
- 14:51Jim Fitzpatrick: Thank you so much for joining us on the show.
- 14:52Jim Fitzpatrick: Very much appreciate it.
- 14:53Jim Fitzpatrick: Look forward to our next time together.
- 14:55Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh, as an old FI manager, we need guys like you out there helping us figure all of this out, you know?
- 15:01Jim Fitzpatrick: So the Absolutely.
- 15:03Jason Swiech: Thank you for having me.
- 15:04Jim Fitzpatrick: Absolutely.
- 15:04Jim Fitzpatrick: Take care.
- 15:05Jim Fitzpatrick: Have a very nice fourth.
- 15:07Jason Swiech: You too.
- 15:07Jim Fitzpatrick: Thanks.
- 15:13Speaker: Thanks for watching Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.