Latest / MD Longevity Lab: Playing the Long Game with Drs. Vikas and Nisha Patel / 28. Can You Out-Run Your Cocktail? Exercise, Alcohol, and the Science of Damage Control
Transcript
- 0:00Longevity isn't just about living longer, it's about living
- 0:03better and being able to do the things that you like to do and
- 0:06partake in the things that you enjoy.
- 0:08If someone you know marketed a pill that cut your R.E.M. sleep
- 0:12by 30%, raised your resting heart rate, and was also a
- 0:17carcinogen, nobody would take it.
- 0:19But if you wrap that in a bottle labeled Bordeaux, right, all of
- 0:24a sudden it's like self-care. So many of our patients that
- 0:27come to see us, I think that's their fear is that they have to
- 0:32give up everything that they enjoy and that's just not the
- 0:35case. Running from death?
- 0:37Can fitness outpace alcohols harm?
- 0:40This is $1,000,000 question that you guys have all been waiting
- 0:44for. Can exercise protect you from
- 0:47alcohol intake? The answer is welcome to MD
- 0:55Launch MD Lab, where we're playing the long game.
- 0:57This is a podcast where science meets real life with expert
- 1:01insights, practical tips and real world tools to not only
- 1:05live longer, but live better. Our aim is to radically change
- 1:09the way medicine is practiced and enable individuals to age
- 1:12gracefully, maintaining health, span and vitality well into
- 1:16their later years. We're your hosts, Dr. Nisha and
- 1:19Dr. Vikas Patel, physicians, partners in life and parents
- 1:23balancing work, Wellness and everything in between.
- 1:26Let's dive in. Welcome back to the MD Launch
- 1:34Every Lab podcast. Thanks for listening, guys.
- 1:37Nish, how are you doing? I am great.
- 1:40How are you doing? I'm not bad.
- 1:44You ready to get this show on the road?
- 1:45I am ready. Today we are diving head first
- 1:49into one of the most debated topics in the health and
- 1:53Wellness space right now. And one of our listeners
- 1:56favorite topics. Yeah, and that's alcohol.
- 1:59We get asked about alcohol consumption all of the time.
- 2:03How much we drink? Yeah.
- 2:04Do we drink? Yeah.
- 2:06Everyone accuses us of not because we're healthy people.
- 2:11So specifically we're going to talk about can exercise protect
- 2:15you from the negative health effects of drinking alcohol?
- 2:20Because let's be honest, if you're listening to a longevity
- 2:24podcast, there's a decent chance you may also occasionally enjoy
- 2:29a glass of wine or two or. Maybe 3 sometimes, but it's a
- 2:35great topic because we're just coming off our spring break
- 2:39trip. We went to Whistler to ski, so
- 2:41that was pretty fun. And we skied hard and we opera
- 2:46skied. I opera skied harder than I
- 2:49skied. I don't think I opera skied that
- 2:53hard. You skied.
- 2:54Really. Hard.
- 2:54I skied hard, which made drinking not that easy because I
- 2:59was like too exhausted. Yeah, and I, I think I opera
- 3:03skied as long as I skied. That might be true.
- 3:08But no, we would definitely go back to Wizard.
- 3:09It was pretty awesome. That was our first time there
- 3:11with the kids. Yeah, they had a great time.
- 3:14Kids were literally, you know, there's these apps now that you
- 3:17can track how fast you're skiing and also how much you skied, how
- 3:23much vertical feet you cleared. And the kids were all trying to
- 3:27get better times. And the boys were over 50 miles
- 3:31an hour, right? You were like 65 miles an hour
- 3:35Max was like 60, Luke was 55, Aria was 46, and I was pulling
- 3:43up the rear with 30 miles an hour peak speed it's.
- 3:46Fast. Yeah, I'm still waiting for the
- 3:49call from Red Bull, but. Lindsey Vonn's out of a job now,
- 3:53so I know. Any day now.
- 3:54Yep. That's how I feel when I'm going
- 3:56down a green. I I had no comments.
- 4:02No, but we get asked about this a lot.
- 4:05I'm really glad we're covering this topic of alcohol because
- 4:09not only is it, it's in the conversation now, but in the
- 4:12longevity space, there's a ton of absolutionist that don't
- 4:17drink, they don't eat out. And for us, I think that's more
- 4:22of the deprivationist approach to things.
- 4:24And we do want to talk about balance because longevity isn't
- 4:28just about living longer. It's about living better and
- 4:31being able to do the things that you like to do and partake in
- 4:35the things that you enjoy, which sometimes that's good food,
- 4:38sometimes that's cocktails with friends.
- 4:40And these longevity self appointed experts, it's like
- 4:44they are so obsessed with their sleep trackers, bio trackers,
- 4:49they honestly just get caught up in the noise.
- 4:52And to me that's not living. To each their own, I guess, but
- 4:56for us, I think. I'm OK with the people tracking,
- 4:59but I don't think it's like it's not necessary, right?
- 5:03Like you get most of the benefit of healthy habits without
- 5:08tracking every metric. Like some people I think are
- 5:11just wired that it settles them mentally to track things.
- 5:15I think for other people it causes them anxiety.
- 5:17We're kind of in the middle of that stuff.
- 5:20We track some stuff, but we don't get anxious about any of
- 5:23it. And really like our goal is to
- 5:26enhance the quality of our life and enjoy the things that we
- 5:30enjoy. And then more to the topic of
- 5:33this podcast, right? Like is it possible to offset
- 5:38some of our bad habits with good habits?
- 5:41And I think that's really this game that the majority of the
- 5:46population I think plays to some degree, right?
- 5:49Like if you're going to stay up late to catch a game or binge
- 5:54Netflix, right, you're compromising your sleep for that
- 5:56night. Can you make up for that in some
- 5:59way by catching up on sleep or exercising a little bit more?
- 6:03And, and so I kind of got interested in this topic a
- 6:06little bit on like, well, if you're pretty good and
- 6:10consistent about exercising, does that offset some of this
- 6:14risk from something like alcohol?
- 6:16And I think it's a great question because so many of our
- 6:18patients, I think that's a burning question for them.
- 6:21Well, I want to live longer, but what if I don't want to
- 6:24completely be abstinent? What if I still want to have my
- 6:27glass of wine or my cocktail when I go out with friends?
- 6:30So it's definitely an important topic and I'm so excited to
- 6:34cover it. Yeah.
- 6:35And I mean, we should cover just like the public health
- 6:38messaging, you know, both the World Health Organization, the
- 6:43US surgeon general have come out with very firm stances that
- 6:48there's really no amount of alcohol that is truly risk free.
- 6:51It does not have health benefits.
- 6:54So that disclaimer should be out there.
- 6:56Yeah, and as you can imagine, that went over.
- 6:59We're real well at dinner parties everywhere.
- 7:02Of course. He went to a party and some guy
- 7:06sniffed your drink to see if you were drinking alcohol.
- 7:10Cuz you're in the you're in the quote UN quote longevity space.
- 7:13It was. Pretty awkward.
- 7:14It did happen a month ago, yeah. That was uncomfortable.
- 7:20It is what it is. And he's like, he was surprised.
- 7:22He's like, oh, you drink? It's like.
- 7:25Yeah, yeah, moderation. Yeah, right.
- 7:27So we're going to take a look at the actual science here, not
- 7:30just kind of the click bait headlines and not your
- 7:34neighbor's anecdote about his grandpa.
- 7:37Who drank bourbon everyday and lived to 97?
- 7:41The real peer reviewed data. We're going to go over what
- 7:47alcohol does to your body, what exercise does to possibly offset
- 7:51some of that damage, and whether there's a sweet spot where you
- 7:56can have your Cabernet or your whiskey and perhaps still be OK.
- 8:05Like have your Cabernet and drink it too.
- 8:08Like have your cake and eat it too.
- 8:09That's right, yeah. That's right.
- 8:11It was a good one. It was a good one.
- 8:12Is that where where you were going with that one?
- 8:15No. Oh.
- 8:17That's where I was. Going just riffing.
- 8:18No OK, so let's kind of dive into this the I'll go through
- 8:28some of the fundamentals. I think, you know, lot of people
- 8:34know that alcohol is bad in the same way that they, you know,
- 8:38know the sun is hot. Technically that's correct, but
- 8:41what does that actually mean for your biology?
- 8:43Ethanol, which is the ingredient of alcohol, is metabolized by
- 8:49your liver through a 2 step process.
- 8:52There is an enzyme called alcohol dehydrogenase.
- 8:55It converts alcohol into acetaldehyde, which is a known
- 9:02carcinogen, and then aldehyde dehydrogenase converts that to
- 9:07acetate, which the body excretes or burns its energy.
- 9:12The problem is, is that acetaldehyde is toxic.
- 9:16It damages our DNA, drives oxidative stress and forces your
- 9:21liver to run at like 150% capacity.
- 9:26Eventually, if it has enough exposure, things breakdown.
- 9:29Yeah. And I think it's important to
- 9:31mention that alcohol has zero nutritional value, right?
- 9:36It's not good for us. It literally is just 7 calories
- 9:39per gram that it adds to our intake.
- 9:44It's just empty calories, right? So no protein, no fat, no
- 9:48carbohydrate, no nutritional value.
- 9:51Just so people know, 1g of carbs has four calories in it, 1g of
- 9:57protein has four calories in it, and 1g of fat has 9 calories in
- 10:02it. So at least all of those things
- 10:05our body needs on some level, like we can't live without all
- 10:09three of those substrates. We can 100% live without
- 10:12alcohol. The seven calories we get per
- 10:14gram of alcohol has no nutritional value at whatsoever
- 10:19for us. Yeah, and it doesn't mean you
- 10:21have to stop drinking. It just means you're aware of
- 10:24this knowledge so you can make an informed decision.
- 10:27You want to talk a little bit about some of the cancer risk?
- 10:30Yeah. So we're going to go through
- 10:32each organ system just to highlight because I think it's
- 10:35pretty enlightening for patients.
- 10:38Like we have fairly educated patients and a lot of them don't
- 10:42know that there's a ton of other risks associated with alcohol.
- 10:45We know about liver disease, but I think it's important that we
- 10:48just kind of briefly go over all the organ systems.
- 10:51So cancer risk, this one rarely gets talked about at cocktail
- 10:54hour, but alcohol is a Group 1 carcinogen and that's in the
- 10:59same category as asbestos and tobacco.
- 11:02There is a dose response relationship that exists for
- 11:05cancers and those are cancers of the mouth, the throat,
- 11:08esophagus, liver, colon and even breast cancer.
- 11:12Even 1 drink a day carries A measurable increase in breast
- 11:17cancer risk and that again, this doesn't mean you have to
- 11:20eliminate it, but it is a risk that you should all be aware of.
- 11:25In 20 plus years in the ER, the number of patients who literally
- 11:30had no idea that their drinking was a cancer risk factor is kind
- 11:36of staggering. People connect smoking to lung
- 11:39cancer. Almost nobody is connecting that
- 11:43their nightly wine drinks are linked to both breast cancer and
- 11:50colon cancer. And that's not necessarily their
- 11:52fault, right? For decades, the messaging was
- 11:56moderate drinking is actually good for your heart, and we'll
- 12:01debunk that in a minute. All right, let's move on to
- 12:03sleep disruption. I think you guys are all
- 12:05familiar with this. We've covered this in previous
- 12:07podcast episodes. Alcohol is the oldest sleep aid
- 12:11in human history, and it's terrible at that job.
- 12:15We used to use alcohol as a sedative sometimes, and yes, it
- 12:19definitely does help you fall asleep faster, but sedation
- 12:23itself isn't sleep. Just like when we give patients
- 12:26anesthesia, they're not actually sleeping, they're just being
- 12:29sedated. So alcohol suppresses of that
- 12:32rapid eye movement sleep, that restorative phase of sleep where
- 12:36your brain is consolidating memory and it's clearing that
- 12:40neurological waste from your system.
- 12:42So even 2 drinks can reduce that quality REM sleep by 20 to 40%.
- 12:48Yeah, there's this rebound effect.
- 12:50So as your liver starts metabolizing the alcohol in the
- 12:55second-half of your night, your sympathetic system starts to
- 12:59activate. And that's the system that
- 13:02actually causes more awareness rather than the rest and digest
- 13:06system, which is our parasympathetic.
- 13:09So that really leads to fragmented sleep, elevated heart
- 13:13rate and early waking. There's a double whammy and poor
- 13:18sleep is linked to every one of the six horsemen that that we've
- 13:23talked about previously. Cardiovascular disease, insulin
- 13:26resistance, neurocognitive decline.
- 13:30So if your heart rate variability, your HRV is in the
- 13:35tank and your fasting glucose is starting to creep upwards, look
- 13:40at what's happening really between 10:00 PM and 6:00 AM.
- 13:43If someone, you know, marketed a pill that cut your R.E.M. sleep
- 13:47by 30%, raise your resting heart rate and was also a carcinogen,
- 13:53nobody would take it. But if you wrap that in a bottle
- 13:57labeled Bordeaux, right, all of a sudden it's like self-care.
- 14:01So I'm putting that on AT Shirt. There we go.
- 14:04So when I was opera skiing and at 2:00 AM, I'd be like, I just
- 14:12had to get up to pee and then my heart rate would be up and I'd
- 14:15be a little sweaty. I thought it was from really
- 14:18skiing hard. It's actually like a technically
- 14:21it's actually kind of like a mini alcohol withdrawal, right?
- 14:24Like we all know about people who are heavy drinkers who
- 14:27actually get true alcohol withdrawal, which can actually
- 14:30be life threatening, cause seizures.
- 14:32But just having two or three glasses of name your drink, our
- 14:38body goes through this mini withdrawal as the alcohol leaves
- 14:41our system, just drinking two or three drinks as our metabolism
- 14:48digests that alcohol and the alcohol is leaving our system,
- 14:52our body goes through this mini withdrawal.
- 14:55And that's what that that sympathetic Dr. is initially
- 14:59alcohol is is actually a little bit of a sedative, but as it
- 15:02leaves our system and our bodies like, wait, what happened?
- 15:06It over stimulates and activates that sympathetic drive.
- 15:10So that's what that awakening is and that kind of mini rays of
- 15:14your heart rate becomes. Yeah, it's just harder as we get
- 15:17older. You could have a few cocktails
- 15:19in your 20s and sleep just fine. And I feel like as we get older,
- 15:23you really feel it. Absolutely.
- 15:26Let's talk a little bit about how alcohol really affects the
- 15:30liver. So alcohol associated liver
- 15:33disease is the most common cause of advanced liver disease
- 15:38literally worldwide and a leading indication for liver
- 15:42transplants. More than 90% of heavy drinkers
- 15:46develop fatty liver, which is literally like deposits of fat
- 15:50within the liver that we can see on ultrasounds, MRICT scans and
- 15:55this is called steatohepatitis fibrosis.
- 16:00And then ultimately it progresses to liver cirrhosis.
- 16:04And then the final destination on that train is hepatocellular
- 16:08carcinoma, which is unregulated growth of cells, which is what
- 16:12cancer is. So post COVID, we've been seeing
- 16:16younger and younger patients in their 20s, thirties and 40s
- 16:20presenting with that advanced disease.
- 16:23And that's a shift and it has to do with two things.
- 16:26There was quite a bit of more drinking that occurred during
- 16:29COVID and then our obsession with excess calories in this
- 16:34country, it's like a double whammy.
- 16:36If we're eating too much, we deposit extra fat in our liver.
- 16:40Combine that with drinking too much on your liver is basically
- 16:43at its limit. Getting these two different
- 16:45insults at the same time. It's.
- 16:47Like Pate, but human Pate? Isn't that what Pate is?
- 16:52Like fatty duck liver. Yes, but they don't drink
- 16:55alcohol. But they just feed them fat like
- 16:59fatty foods. Are there duck farms?
- 17:02I don't know when we, when I see pernuvial Mris, that full body
- 17:05MRI that we do on our patients and they had a fatty liver, I
- 17:08just think of Pete so gross and I can't like can't Unsee it now.
- 17:13Yeah. I hear you.
- 17:16So, and I think it's important to note that women are more
- 17:20susceptible at equivalent intake levels.
- 17:23So you drinking 2 drinks is very, very different than me
- 17:27drinking 2 drinks. It hits me way harder, roughly
- 17:30twice the relative risk compared to men.
- 17:33And that's due to the difference in body composition, liver
- 17:37enzyme activity and hormonal factors as well.
- 17:40And it's especially important as women drinkers, our rates of
- 17:44drinking have increased over the years.
- 17:46So I think that's something to definitely be aware of.
- 17:48Yeah, I think there's definitely a difference.
- 17:50Like men carry more muscle mass, we actually have in general a
- 17:54little bit more of that alcohol dehydrogenase in our in our
- 17:57liver, which confers a little bit more protection than what
- 18:00women get. Let's kind of go through some of
- 18:04the cardiovascular myths and kind of make that pretty clear
- 18:11for patients on what the effect of alcohol is as far as our
- 18:15cardiovascular health. Yeah, that was like the
- 18:17prevailing thought process, right?
- 18:20For years. That red wine is good for our
- 18:23heart, right? We're trying to protect our
- 18:25heart and prevent stroke, and it thins out the blood.
- 18:28So the idea that moderate drinking protects your heart is
- 18:32that textbook case of what we call observational data that's
- 18:37misleading us, the abstainer group.
- 18:39So those are the patients that abstain from alcohol in those
- 18:42early studies included any former drinkers who quit because
- 18:47they were already sick and that we call that the sick quitter
- 18:51effect. They're so sick that they can no
- 18:53longer drink. When you control for that and
- 18:55for the fact that moderate drinkers also tend to be
- 18:58wealthier, more active, have better healthcare access, have
- 19:03time to exercise, that protective effect largely
- 19:07disappears. So when you eliminate all those
- 19:10other factors, I mean, it's just crazy.
- 19:13We've basically misled society for two or three decades.
- 19:18Yeah, I, I think, you know, these, these studies were
- 19:21looking at people who were drinking red wine, and that's
- 19:26not necessarily the drink of choice for the majority of
- 19:29alcohol drinkers, right? Like in France, it might be the
- 19:33drink of choice, but Europeans have a far different lifestyle
- 19:38than what Americans do. That's kind of the bottom line
- 19:41is, you know, we're not telling you that you can drink red wine
- 19:46for your heart like that era basically is over.
- 19:50It's been proven multiple times through numerous studies now
- 19:53that there is just no beneficial cardiovascular effect.
- 19:56So if you're drinking, you're drinking because you want to
- 20:00drink. You are not drinking for your
- 20:02health. Yes, there are social benefits
- 20:06to drinking. There is an ansiolytic effect of
- 20:10alcohol. So there are other benefits that
- 20:13are not necessarily the the health metrics that we would
- 20:19want to promote as far as longevity in general health go.
- 20:22Why don't you touch quickly on some of the other facts like
- 20:25brain, gut, immune system? Yes.
- 20:27So we'll wrap up real quick with the organ system.
- 20:31We know that alcohol disrupts the gut microbiome.
- 20:34It increases intestinal permeability and it drives
- 20:38systemic inflammation. It also impairs immune function,
- 20:41which is your ability to heal and recover from infection.
- 20:45And there's growing evidence of neurotoxic effects at even
- 20:48moderate levels, and this is measured by brain volume and
- 20:52that is reduced on imaging studies.
- 20:54I remember in college, like having a sore throat and one of
- 20:57my buddies would be like, oh, just like do a couple shots
- 21:01because like the alcohol will literally kill the, the virus or
- 21:05the bacteria in your throat and like actually trying that.
- 21:08And obviously it didn't work. I think they did that back in
- 21:11the olden days. Like give kids like a spoon of
- 21:14bourbon or something. Like the 1900s?
- 21:17Maybe that's the olden days. Well, our kids think that's our
- 21:20kids think. No, our kids think we were.
- 21:22They literally said we were born in the olden days because we
- 21:25were born in the 1900s. Yeah, that's crazy.
- 21:28Kind of sad. Yeah.
- 21:29So when we say negative health effects, we're not talking about
- 21:33just like one thing. We're talking about a systemic
- 21:37insult to virtually, you know, every major organ system in our
- 21:41body. Which really brings us now to
- 21:43the big question. Yes.
- 21:45This is $1,000,000 question that you guys have all been waiting
- 21:49for. Can exercise protect you from
- 21:52alcohol intake? The answer is maybe this is
- 21:57where the research gets really interesting and where I think we
- 22:01can give people really a evidence based and nuanced
- 22:05answer rather than just like the finger wagging.
- 22:08The study that made the biggest splash recently was published in
- 22:12Sports Medicine in December of just this last year, and it's by
- 22:17this doctor Naumann and out of a Norwegian University of Science
- 22:24and Technology. And it's got a fantastic title,
- 22:27Running from death. Can fitness outpace alcohols
- 22:30harm? Literally with a title like
- 22:32that, I think it's begging to be a podcast episode.
- 22:36That was intriguing. It was like we have to find out
- 22:39the answer to this. Inquiring minds want to know.
- 22:43Yeah, but here's the study design.
- 22:44They analyzed data from nearly 25,000 healthy Norwegian adults
- 22:50who participated in two large health surveys about a decade
- 22:55apart, the Hunt 2 survey in the mid 90s and the Hunt 3 in the
- 23:01mid 2000s. They were then followed for
- 23:04about 17 years. Alcohol intake was self reported
- 23:07and classified into three groups.
- 23:10So there's the abstainers, and then there's the within
- 23:13recommended limits group and then the above recommended
- 23:17alcohol limits group. Here's the interesting part
- 23:20about the fitness piece of this. They didn't actually do like
- 23:25dedicated VO2 Max testing on 25,000 people.
- 23:29They used a validated non exercise prediction equation
- 23:32based on age, waist circumference, resting heart
- 23:36rate, and self reported physical activity to classify people as
- 23:41either fit or unfit. The unfit group was the bottom
- 23:4520% for estimated fitness for their Asian sex.
- 23:48And really, the results were pretty remarkable.
- 23:53Why don't you break those down? So let's cover the bad news
- 23:56first. Increasing your alcohol intake
- 23:59over the decade of your life was associated with a higher
- 24:03mortality rate period. And that held regardless of
- 24:07fitness level. So irrespective of whether you
- 24:10were in that fit or unfit group, it didn't matter.
- 24:13So anyone out there that is listening, that was hoping that,
- 24:17you know, drink as much as you want as long as you run a
- 24:20marathon, right? Sorry, that's not true.
- 24:24Even the lead author, Doctor Naumann, said he wished the data
- 24:27had shown fitness could completely cancel out alcohols
- 24:31harms, but it didn't. Here's kind of where I think it
- 24:35gets a little bit more nuanced. Among people who remain fit
- 24:39throughout the study, changes in alcohol intake generally did not
- 24:43significantly increase their mortality risk.
- 24:45The one exception was people who went from abstaining to now
- 24:50drinking. That transition did actually
- 24:53carry an elevated risk. And here's the finding that
- 24:56raised a lot of eyebrows. Fit drinkers had better survival
- 25:00outcomes than unfit abstainers. Let's say that again.
- 25:04Being fit and drinking moderately was associated with a
- 25:08longer life than being sedentary and not drinking at all.
- 25:13That's a pretty powerful finding, right?
- 25:16And I want to be careful on how we frame that because it doesn't
- 25:20mean just like, go ahead and have at it and drink as much as
- 25:23you want. It means that fitness is such a
- 25:27powerful determinant of longevity that it can, to some
- 25:31degree, buffer the harms of moderate alcohol use.
- 25:36Yeah. And on the flip side, those
- 25:38remaining in the bottom 20% of fitness, the unfit category,
- 25:42carried a 46 to 68% higher mortality risk, even among
- 25:48people who drank within the recommended guidelines.
- 25:51So the biggest risk factor in the study wasn't how much people
- 25:54drank, it was how unfit they were.
- 25:57Declining from fit to unfit over the decade predicted mortality
- 26:03more strongly than many patterns of changing alcohol intake.
- 26:08And that's really important take away for our listeners.
- 26:12If you're going to pick one battle, the data suggests pick
- 26:16fitness. So basically, you know.
- 26:19I'm nipping at the heels of elite level VO2 Max so I can
- 26:24still opera ski all day is what you're saying?
- 26:28There you go, that is basically what I'm saying.
- 26:31In conclusion. This fits nicely into kind of,
- 26:36you know, the premise of our clinic and this the premise of
- 26:40the podcast, right? That like there's such a
- 26:44downside to being sedentary and not challenging your body in
- 26:49some ways that that you're actually even protected from
- 26:56some of the things that we know are poison to our body.
- 27:00If you manage to stay in different in decent shape.
- 27:03And that protection is literally better than if you abstain from
- 27:09that poison alcohol and you just sit on the couch all day.
- 27:13Yeah, that is so impressive and I think it's awesome because so
- 27:18many of our patients that come to see us, I think that's their
- 27:21fear is that they have to give up everything that they enjoy
- 27:26and that's just not the case. So we, you know, while we know
- 27:30there are no, there's the social benefits like you talked about
- 27:34connection when it comes to alcohol, but there's no
- 27:37nutritional benefit, there's no health benefit to alcohol.
- 27:41But patients ask us, is it something I have to give up if I
- 27:44care about my health? And I think our question is not
- 27:48necessarily, but you can't sit on your butt, be sedentary, have
- 27:53a low VO2 Max, drink all day and expect good health and
- 27:58longevity. I think you hit hit the nail on
- 28:00the head. So there are some caveats here
- 28:03and I think we need to cover that because this is a science
- 28:05podcast, not TikTok. So let's talk about some of the
- 28:08limitations to to a study like this.
- 28:11Yeah. So first, as we mentioned,
- 28:14fitness was estimated. It wasn't directly measured.
- 28:17They didn't do formal VO2 Max testing.
- 28:20The model that they use is well validated for population level
- 28:24studies, but it's still a proxy for fitness, not a direct
- 28:27measurement like VO2 Max. Second, fitness is what we'd
- 28:31call a marker of health writ large.
- 28:36One of the alcohol epidemiologist who commented on
- 28:40the study, Doctor Timothy Namie from the University of Victoria,
- 28:46made this really excellent point.
- 28:48It's hard to fully separate the benefits of exercise from the
- 28:52benefits of simply being healthier overall.
- 28:56People who are fit tend to eat better, they tend to sleep
- 29:00better, they tend to have fewer chronic conditions, and they
- 29:03generally have better healthcare access.
- 29:06Yeah, and 3rd, the heaviest drinkers were likely
- 29:09underrepresented. Anyone drinking above the
- 29:13recommended limits was grouped into one category, so someone
- 29:17having 11 drinks a week was analyzed the same as someone
- 29:20having 30. The protective benefits of
- 29:22fitness may not extend to patterns of true alcohol abuse
- 29:27or super heavy binge drinking. And the fourth thing is that
- 29:30this is an observational study, an observational cohort study,
- 29:34not a randomized controlled trial.
- 29:37So we can't say fitness causes lower mortality and drinkers we
- 29:43can say it's associated with. There's likely some bi
- 29:47directional causation and some confounding that we can't fully
- 29:51account for in a model like this.
- 29:54Yeah, these are all important caveats.
- 29:56But even with those limitations, this is a large well designed
- 30:01perspective study with 17 years of follow up.
- 30:04So that signal is pretty strong. I, I think, I think so and you
- 30:09know, this is not like an isolated finding. 2017 pooled
- 30:15analysis published in the British Journal of Sports
- 30:17Medicine. It had looked at over 36,000
- 30:21participants from 8 British population based cohorts.
- 30:25They found that meeting current physical activity
- 30:28recommendations, which is the same in this country as in this
- 30:32population in Britain, about 150 minutes of moderate or 75
- 30:37minutes of vigorous exercise per week, significantly attenuated
- 30:42the association between alcohol intake and all 'cause mortality.
- 30:46Yeah. And in that same study, the
- 30:48association between alcohol and cancer mortality was nearly
- 30:52nullified among individuals who met the PA recommendations.
- 30:57So that's particularly striking given what we just discussed
- 31:00about alcohol being a Group 1 carcinogen, right?
- 31:04There's a direct correlation to cancer.
- 31:07Yeah, and which is being attenuated by their activity
- 31:10level. So attenuated and nearly
- 31:13nullified are not the same thing as eliminated, and the benefits
- 31:18were most pronounced for moderate drinkers.
- 31:21They didn't fully protect the heaviest drinkers in that
- 31:25harmful category. But for the large number of
- 31:28people who drink within or, you know, modestly above the
- 31:32guidelines, exercise appeared to meaningfully reduce risk.
- 31:36All right, let's move on to another study.
- 31:39There was some supporting data that came from the UK Biobank in
- 31:432020 and that analyzed nearly 300,000 adults and they found
- 31:48that low physical activity individuals who consumed alcohol
- 31:52at double the guidelines had a 55% higher mortality risk
- 31:57compared to about 20% higher risk for moderate to high
- 32:01activity individuals who are consuming the same amount.
- 32:05So that's kind of crazy. Yeah, double, almost triple the
- 32:08risk in the sedentary population.
- 32:11So these patients drink the same amount and then they analyze the
- 32:15group who is exercising and the group who wasn't.
- 32:18Correct, so physically active heavy drinkers still have an
- 32:22elevated risk. Exercise didn't make the excess
- 32:27alcohol completely safe, but the gap between active and inactive
- 32:32heavy drinkers was quite substantial.
- 32:35There's also some pretty fascinating information about
- 32:39liver specific protection. So I know a lot of people end up
- 32:44getting worried about like, am I doing damage to my liver?
- 32:47A major new study that was published in the Journal of
- 32:50Hepatology in late 2025 by Vilar Gomez and colleagues at Indiana
- 32:58University analyzed over 60,060 thousand adults from the N Hanes
- 33:04and followed them out for about 12 years.
- 33:07And the key finding, physical physically active participants
- 33:12had significantly lower liver specific mortality across all
- 33:17drinking categories. Among non heavy drinkers,
- 33:20exercise was associated with a 48% lower liver death risk.
- 33:26Among heavy drinkers, 36% lower death risk.
- 33:31Among binge drinkers, a remarkable 69% lower liver
- 33:35mortality rate. Those are staggering numbers.
- 33:38And it wasn't just exercise. Diet quality was even more
- 33:43protective. People in the top quartile of
- 33:45the Healthy Eating Index had 86% and 84% lower liver mortality
- 33:52risk among heavy and binge drinkers, respectively.
- 33:55And a really important finding here, the survival benefits were
- 33:59substantially greater in women than in men.
- 34:02So for women who we know are more susceptible to alcohol
- 34:07related liver disease, the protective effect of a healthy
- 34:11lifestyle was even more pronounced.
- 34:13Finally, some good news for us. There you go.
- 34:15Like with perimenopause, I feel like everything's downhill.
- 34:18Finally, we get a win. Exercise and drink, yeah.
- 34:22I out of out of everything I've learned, I feel like that's been
- 34:26my take home. This is huge because earlier we
- 34:30talked about women having a much higher relative risk for
- 34:33alcoholic liver disease and the fact that they also derive
- 34:36greater benefit from exercise and healthy eating.
- 34:40That's actionable information, right?
- 34:43We all can use that in our everyday lives.
- 34:45Totally. And kind of rounding out some of
- 34:48this liver data, there's a 2024 study published in Alcohol and
- 34:53Alcoholism Journal from the Mass General Brigham Biobank, which
- 34:59looks specifically at patients who are diagnosed with alcohol
- 35:03use disorder. About 2000 of them followed them
- 35:07over roughly A10 year period. Those who exercise at least 2
- 35:121/2 hours per week had significantly lower rates of
- 35:15alcohol associated liver disease.
- 35:17And the dose response relationship was also
- 35:20encouraging. Each additional hour of exercise
- 35:23per week provided additional protection.
- 35:27Even people exercising less than 2 1/2 hours per week saw some
- 35:32benefit, suggesting that any amount of physical activity is
- 35:35better than none. And I think that's a really
- 35:37important message for patients who are struggling with alcohol
- 35:40use. You don't have to run marathons,
- 35:43but some movement is actually protective.
- 35:45So like, I'm a math person. Well, I'm Indian, so of course
- 35:50I'm a math person. And we were forced to decrement
- 35:53and we forced that upon our children too.
- 35:55But like in my head if I do one really solid hour or physical
- 36:01activity it kind of translates to 1 alcohol serving.
- 36:07Is that the take home that you want to give patients?
- 36:09No, that's like personalized recommendations for myself.
- 36:14That's personalized medicine. If you see Nisha at the gym,
- 36:17she's drinking that day. Got it.
- 36:20Not always, but like especially on vacation.
- 36:23We don't drink every day, but on vacation we definitely like to
- 36:27drink or when we go out to eat. So I don't think deprivation is
- 36:32the answer. And I think a lot of patients
- 36:34get scared away in the longevity space because they think they
- 36:37have to give up everything that they enjoy.
- 36:39That's my point. Yeah.
- 36:40Not the one to one ratio. I don't do that.
- 36:43One more study worth mentioning. There's a 2025 paper in
- 36:46Frontiers and Nutrition by Zhang and colleagues which looked at
- 36:51this relationship specifically in patients with established
- 36:55cardiovascular disease. So again, using ENHANES database
- 37:00data from over 4000 cardiovascular disease patients,
- 37:03they found that a sedentary lifestyle combined with even
- 37:07minimal alcohol use was associated with elevated
- 37:11mortality risk. So for cardiac patients, the
- 37:14exercise alcohol interaction is even more clinically relevant.
- 37:19All right. And since you're writing your
- 37:21book, why don't you put things into an evolutionary context for
- 37:26us? That's right.
- 37:27I can't do an episode without connecting it back to
- 37:29evolutionary mismatch theory. I I think it kind of really
- 37:33illuminates what's happening here.
- 37:35Nope, here it comes. That's right.
- 37:36So if you think about this from the ancestral environment, our
- 37:40Paleolithic ancestors were extraordinarily physically
- 37:44active. Estimates range really between,
- 37:48you know, 8010 thousand to 15,000 steps per day of movement
- 37:54combined with regular high intensity efforts from hunting,
- 37:58climbing, building, carrying and you know, what was their ethanol
- 38:03exposure essentially 0 Perhaps minimal from some naturally
- 38:09fermented fruits on rare occasion, but nothing resembling
- 38:14the consistent concentrated alcohol exposure of our modern
- 38:18life. So our bodies involved in a
- 38:21context of high physical activity and very low alcohol
- 38:25exposure, and now we've flipped the narrative, right?
- 38:30We have a ton of alcohol in society and not very much
- 38:33physical movement. Exactly.
- 38:35The modern default is kind of low physical activity and
- 38:41readily available alcohol. That combination sedentary plus
- 38:45alcohol is the quintessential mismatch.
- 38:49And what these studies that we just talked about are
- 38:51essentially showing us is that when you restore one side of
- 38:56that ancestral equation by being more physically active, you
- 39:00recover some of the metabolic resilience that our bodies have
- 39:04actually evolved for. So in a sense, exercise isn't
- 39:08doing something extra or magical when you drink, but it is
- 39:12restoring A baseline that evolution assumed would always
- 39:16be there. You're right.
- 39:18So the Hunt study found that declining into the lowest 20% of
- 39:24fitness was a more powerful mortality predictor than
- 39:28moderate changes in in alcohol intake.
- 39:32From an evolutionary standpoint, that truly makes sense, right?
- 39:35Our Physiology was designed around this constant movement.
- 39:39When you remove that every system from liver, metabolism,
- 39:43immune function, cardiovascular health, even our sleep
- 39:46architecture, it all becomes more fragile and less able to
- 39:50handle insults from alcohol. Our system generates
- 39:55anti-inflammatory cytokines from exercise and that is why
- 40:01movement is protected. It's part of the process and
- 40:05our. The body, it's counterintuitive
- 40:08that exercise, which we think of is causing small amounts of
- 40:12damage, that it's actually the thing that helps to promote a
- 40:17reduction in inflammation in the body.
- 40:19And I think this really connects to one of the core themes of the
- 40:25book and this podcast, The Horsemen of Chronic Disease.
- 40:29They don't really operate in isolation.
- 40:33Alcohol impacts sleep, which impacts metabolic health, which
- 40:36impacts cardiovascular health, which impacts brain health.
- 40:40But exercise actually touches all of those systems too, in the
- 40:46opposite direction. Yeah, it's the closest thing,
- 40:49right? Exercise is the closest thing we
- 40:51have to a universal antidote, not a perfect one.
- 40:55As the data clearly shows, exercise cannot fully neutralize
- 41:00alcohol's harms. But the most broadly protective
- 41:03intervention that we know of is exercise and physical activity.
- 41:07What do we actually do with all this information?
- 41:10Yeah. So let's go over some practical
- 41:11takeaways. The big picture is great, but
- 41:14let's talk about what our listeners should actually do
- 41:17with all of this information because I know people are going
- 41:20to ask, OK, so can I drink or not?
- 41:24And let's face it, the honest answer is it depends on what
- 41:26your goals are, what your current risk factors are, and
- 41:31how willing you are to being honest with yourself.
- 41:35But here I think our we'll go over some of the key principles
- 41:39that we'd like to offer. Yeah #1 if you don't drink,
- 41:43don't start. You're good.
- 41:46There's no reason to begin drinking for health benefits.
- 41:50That ship has sailed as we get older and the data just doesn't
- 41:54support drinking for any kind of health benefit. #2 If you do
- 41:59drink, the single most important thing you can do for your long
- 42:02term health is maintain your cardiovascular fitness.
- 42:06The data consistently shows that being fit and drinking
- 42:10moderately is associated with much better outcomes than being
- 42:14sedentary and abstaining completely from alcohol.
- 42:18That's not a pass to drink recklessly, it's an argument for
- 42:21making fitness non negotiable. #3 aim for at least 150 minutes
- 42:27of moderate intensity exercise per week or 75 minutes of
- 42:32vigorous exercise, or better yet, both.
- 42:35That's the threshold that showed up consistently across the
- 42:38British Journal of Sports Medicine study, the UK Biobank
- 42:42data and that liver specific research.
- 42:45So Zone 2 cardio, which we've covered in previous episodes.
- 42:48This is your best friend and an occasional hit workout.
- 42:51You're good to go. Yeah, Zone 2 would put you into
- 42:54that modern intensity and then the HIT workout is contributing
- 42:58to that vigorous exercise #4 pay attention to your diet along
- 43:03with your exercise. The Journal of Hepatology data
- 43:06showed that a high quality diet was actually even more
- 43:10protective for the liver than what exercise was.
- 43:13A diet high in vegetables, fruits, whole grains, seafood,
- 43:18plant based proteins and healthy fats while low in added sugars
- 43:24and solid fats provided a remarkable protection even
- 43:29amongst heavy drinkers. #5 be honest about your drinking
- 43:33patterns. A glass of wine with dinner
- 43:37three times a week is very different exposure than 4 drinks
- 43:41on a Saturday night. So we know that binge drinking
- 43:44and is particularly damaging to the liver and exercises
- 43:48Protective capacity has real limits at that level.
- 43:52As that hepatologist Dr. Elliott Tapper put in his commentary on
- 43:56this research, binge drinking will chew through a liver in a
- 44:00few years, especially as we get older.
- 44:02That's right. Number six, if you are drinking
- 44:06and not sleeping well, connect the dots here.
- 44:10Track what your heart rate variability is.
- 44:14Track your sleep quality. Most people are shocked when
- 44:17they see the objective data on what even 2 drinks does to their
- 44:23sleep architecture. We've had patients who cut
- 44:26alcohol and saw immediate dramatic improvements in their
- 44:29HRV, their resting heart rate, and their subjective energy
- 44:34levels. This is where I think we've
- 44:36talked about this before. Drinking earlier in the day is
- 44:40profitable to drinking before right before bed.
- 44:43If you drink at 3:00 PM, two drinks, it's all out of your
- 44:47system well before going to bed at 9:00 or 10:00 PM.
- 44:51And then you don't see that same hit to your negative hit to your
- 44:55sleep architecture. And #7 especially for our female
- 44:59listeners. The data shows women face higher
- 45:02risk from alcohol across multiple organ systems.
- 45:05Liver, Grass, our cardiovascular system, our brain health, but it
- 45:11also derives greater benefits when we exercise and we are
- 45:15eating in a healthy manner. So if there's one population for
- 45:19whom the stay active, eat well advice, moderate your drinking
- 45:25message is most critical, it's US women.
- 45:28And look, we talked about this. We're not prohibitionists.
- 45:31We're not saying alcohol is pure evil and you're a bad person if
- 45:36you enjoy it. What we're saying is the science
- 45:39has gotten pretty clear about this, and really the stakes are
- 45:43real and the protective strategies are actually within
- 45:48your control. You don't need a prescription.
- 45:51You don't. You really just need a pair of
- 45:54shoes to go for that run or really spend a little bit of
- 45:59time doing some resistance training so that you're getting
- 46:02the stimulus that your body needs to offset some of these
- 46:06insults that we may partake in. Yeah, and maybe some
- 46:10self-awareness about that third Margarita.
- 46:13Or 4th or 5th. Yeah, I don't.
- 46:15Nowadays I can't. I mean even three.
- 46:18I'm toast. Yeah, it's.
- 46:21Rare, it's. Not like when we were 25.
- 46:22Nope. All right, so let's do our 32nd
- 46:26elevator pitch. If someone asks you what this
- 46:29episode was about, here's what you should tell them.
- 46:31Yep, if you only remember the few things out of this whole
- 46:34episode. Alcohol is not risk free at any
- 46:38dose. It's a carcinogen.
- 46:40It disrupts sleep. It damages your liver and the
- 46:44old glass of wine is good for your heart.
- 46:47Advice was based on completely flawed data, so we've debunked
- 46:51that. But, and this is a big but,
- 46:53maintaining cardiorespiratory fitness through regular exercise
- 46:57provides significant measurable protection against many of
- 47:01alcohol's harms. Multiple large studies show that
- 47:05fit moderate drinkers consistently outlive sedentary
- 47:09non drinkers. Exercise reduces all 'cause
- 47:13mortality risk, cancer mortality risk and liver specific
- 47:17mortality risk in patients who drink.
- 47:19Exercise doesn't erase alcohols damage, it reduces risk, it
- 47:25doesn't remove it. So the protection has its
- 47:27limitations, especially at heavy and binge drinking levels.
- 47:32But for the majority of people who drink socially or moderately
- 47:35when on vacation, fitness is a single most powerful modifier of
- 47:40that risk. So bottom line, get your 150
- 47:43minutes of exercise in, eat your vegetables, and if you're going
- 47:48to drink, make sure you've earned it with a good zone two
- 47:51session. Or at least a walk to the
- 47:54restaurant and back and back. Baby steps.
- 47:58Thanks for listening to another episode of the MD Longevity Lab
- 48:02Podcast where we are playing the long game.
- 48:05If you found this episode useful, please share it with
- 48:07someone that needs to hear it. Please leave us a review.
- 48:11And if you want personalized guidance on optimizing your
- 48:14biomarkers, your fitness, your health span, check us out at
- 48:18mdlongevitylab.com. Don't forget to follow us on
- 48:21social. We're on Instagram, TikTok.
- 48:24We're too old for TikTok but we're on it.
- 48:27Check out our sub stack. Vikas does longer form articles
- 48:31which have kind of been a hit. And if you're currently enjoying
- 48:34a glass of wine while listening to this?
- 48:36No judgement. Right.
- 48:37Just make sure you also got in your workout for today.
- 48:42All right guys, we will see you next time.
- 48:43Stay fit, play the long game. Thank you for playing the long
- 48:51game with MD Longevity Lab. You can visit us at
- 48:54www.mdlongevitylab.com to learn more about how we can support
- 48:59you on your journey. Stay connected with us on social
- 49:02media at MD Longevity Lab for tips, updates, and behind the
- 49:06scenes insights. If you enjoyed today's episode,
- 49:09we'd love it if you subscribe, left us a rating, or shared it
- 49:12with someone you know who's also playing the long game.
- 49:15Thanks for listening, We'll see you next time.