Latest / Diplomacy and International Relations / Denmarks Green Push - Leading Europe Towards Sustainability

Transcript

Denmarks Green Push - Leading Europe Towards Sustainability · Diplomacy and International Relations

• 0:00
  Welcome to Diplomacy and International Relations by
• 0:02
  Bastion Freeborg, the deep dive where we cut through the noise
• 0:06
  for you. We try to extract what really
• 0:08
  matters in shaping our world. Absolutely.
• 0:10
  And today we're taking a really fascinating look at Denmark,
• 0:14
  specifically its strategic role, which seems to be growing in
• 0:18
  Europe's green transit, right. It's not just about what they're
• 0:21
  doing at home, though that's groundbreaking stuff we'll get
• 0:23
  into. Exactly.
• 0:24
  It's also how those domestic policies are making waves
• 0:28
  internationally, especially within the EU context.
• 0:31
  Yeah, that intersection is key national policy influencing the
• 0:35
  bigger European picture. So our mission for this deep
• 0:38
  dive, we want to distill these complex dynamics for you.
• 0:41
  It's this intricate dance, isn't it?
• 0:43
  Between national ambition, policy, innovation.
• 0:46
  And, you know, global influence all seen through this lens of
• 0:49
  Denmark's green agenda. And we've pulled together quite
• 0:52
  a bit of material. LinkedIn posts from places like
• 0:54
  State of Green Denmark Heuristed.
• 0:57
  The big energy player. And official announcements from
• 0:59
  the Danish EU presidency too. So a good mix.
• 1:01
  A real tapestry, as you said. The idea is you get a deeper
• 1:05
  understanding of what's going on, maybe uncover some
• 1:08
  surprising facts and really grasp the implications for
• 1:12
  Europe's energy future, its green goals.
• 1:15
  Without getting totally bogged down in the details, we're
• 1:18
  aiming for the shortcut to Insight here.
• 1:21
  Before we jump in, just a quick note.
• 1:23
  You can subscribe to Diplomacy and International Relations by
• 1:26
  Bastian Freiborg on Spotify. There's a small monthly fee.
• 1:30
  It genuinely helps us keep these deep dives going.
• 1:33
  And you get access to extra episodes to the links right
• 1:36
  there in the description. Definitely check it out if you
• 1:38
  find this valuable. OK, let's unpack this first big
• 1:41
  topic. Denmark hosting Europe's energy
• 1:43
  future sounds grand, doesn't it? It does.
• 1:46
  We're talking about their upcoming EU Council presidency
• 1:49
  in 2025. Right.
• 1:51
  And leading up to that, they recently hosted European Leaders
• 1:54
  Attaches rolled out the green carpet in Copenhagen.
• 1:57
  It felt like more than just protocol though, more like a
• 2:00
  statement of intent. What's fascinating is you
• 2:02
  pointed out earlier isn't just that they're hosting.
• 2:04
  It's how they're doing it, using that leadership role to
• 2:07
  actively, you know, shape the European green agenda.
• 2:11
  So not just chairing meetings passively.
• 2:13
  No, definitely not. It's about showing vision,
• 2:15
  demonstrating solutions, kind of setting the tone for where
• 2:18
  Europe needs to go on energy A. Strategic way for a smaller
• 2:21
  country to really amplify its voice.
• 2:23
  Exactly. The sources mentioned this key
• 2:25
  informal meeting of EU Energy Ministers September 4th and 5th,
• 2:29
  2025 in Copenhagen at Forum. Hosted by their Climate and
• 2:34
  Energy Minister Lars Zegaard. And the objectives seem pretty
• 2:38
  clear. Future energy architecture,
• 2:40
  scaling up clean tech, expanding infrastructure.
• 2:44
  But why are they so challenging right now for Europe?
• 2:46
  Well, if you connect the dots, these aren't just standard goals
• 2:49
  anymore. Europe's under immense pressure.
• 2:51
  Energy security is a huge one, obviously.
• 2:53
  Yeah, geopolitical shift. Right.
• 2:55
  Plus the urgency of climate commitments and needing to stay
• 2:58
  competitive economically. It's a tough balancing act.
• 3:00
  So the ambition goes beyond just talking.
• 3:03
  Oh, definitely. It's about fostering real
• 3:06
  dialogue, practical cooperation between Member States, getting
• 3:09
  everyone aligned on energy independence, competitiveness.
• 3:13
  And that site they included to the Avador power station.
• 3:16
  That's highly symbolic. I think it takes the
• 3:18
  conversation from abstract policy to.
• 3:21
  Something tangible working solutions.
• 3:23
  Precisely. It's like saying, look, this
• 3:25
  isn't just theory, this is how it's done.
• 3:27
  It's almost an implicit nudge to others.
• 3:29
  See what's possible and it. Wasn't just formal talks and
• 3:32
  tours, right? Denmark seems to be using a more
• 3:35
  subtle approach too, like a nudge strategy.
• 3:38
  Yeah, tell me about that. Well, they contributed to the
• 3:40
  venue branding, working with their foreign ministry.
• 3:43
  There was this interactive cube thing, a green together
• 3:46
  experience. OK, showcasing their expertise.
• 3:50
  Exactly. Highlighting solutions they
• 3:52
  already have in place. Making sure those success
• 3:54
  stories are really front and center.
• 3:55
  That makes perfect sense. It's classic soft power isn't
• 3:59
  it? And often very effective in
• 4:01
  international relations. Well, Denmark isn't just making
• 4:04
  arguments in meetings, it's using its own track record.
• 4:07
  It's proven tech and policies to influence the wider EU approach.
• 4:11
  So showing, not just telling. Exactly.
• 4:13
  By showcasing what works, the real results, the functioning
• 4:17
  infrastructure they offer for a compelling case.
• 4:20
  Almost irresistible, really. Making it easier for others to
• 4:23
  adopt similar things, right? It's more potent than lobbying
• 4:27
  alone. They're not just persuading,
• 4:28
  they're proving it works, nudging the negotiations towards
• 4:32
  those green goals. Encouraging collaboration rather
• 4:34
  than just issuing mandates. Which in a diverse union like
• 4:37
  the EU, can often work much better.
• 4:39
  It builds buy in. Leading by example essentially.
• 4:42
  But, you know, using that soft power, does it have limits,
• 4:46
  especially when you're trying to influence countries with, say,
• 4:49
  very different economies or politics within the EU?
• 4:51
  That's a really good point. Demonstrating success is
• 4:54
  powerful but you can't just copy paste solutions everywhere
• 4:57
  right? Denmark's relatively small
• 4:59
  wealthy. Strong consensus on green stuff
• 5:01
  for bigger industrial economies or places still heavily reliant
• 5:05
  on fossil fuels. The costs and changes are way
• 5:08
  bigger. Exactly.
• 5:09
  So the nudge might open the door, show what's possible, but
• 5:12
  actually doing it takes huge political will, massive
• 5:16
  investment from those individual states.
• 5:18
  So Denmark strategy helps build the argument, but doesn't solve
• 5:22
  everyone's specific problems. Precisely.
• 5:25
  But by stressing collaboration shared benefits, they hope to
• 5:29
  make those hurdles seem a bit less daunting.
• 5:31
  OK. That makes sense.
• 5:33
  So we've seen Denmark projecting outwards, trying to shape the
• 5:36
  EU's energy path. But this isn't happening in
• 5:39
  isolation. No, it's rooted in some pretty
• 5:41
  revolutionary things happening back home.
• 5:43
  Which brings us inwards, and here's where it gets really
• 5:45
  interesting. Denmark's historic green
• 5:47
  tripartite agreement. Yes, the agricultural.
• 5:50
  Announced June 24th, 2024 and Tripartite is key government,
• 5:55
  industry, agriculture and environmental groups all
• 5:57
  involved. A broad coalition.
• 5:59
  Its goal? Slash agricultural carbon
• 6:01
  emissions, restore nature and hit Denmark's 20-30 climate
• 6:05
  target. And that's huge for a sector
• 6:07
  often seen as tough to change. And this really does raise the
• 6:10
  question, why is this so historic?
• 6:12
  Why is the world watching? OK, why?
• 6:15
  Because Denmark is set to be the first country in the world to
• 6:18
  tax livestock emissions. Wow.
• 6:20
  That's pioneering. Unprecedented, really.
• 6:23
  It could totally change how countries tackle agricultural
• 6:26
  emissions, a sector that's notoriously hard to decarbonize.
• 6:29
  Holding agriculture accountable for its climate footprint like
• 6:32
  other industries. Exactly.
• 6:34
  It signals a major shift. Let's dig into the details
• 6:37
  though, because they seem quite specific, maybe pragmatic.
• 6:40
  The livestock tax starts at DKK 300 per ton of CO2 E.
• 6:45
  Carbon dioxide equivalent? Yeah, the standard measure.
• 6:47
  That's from 20-30, then it goes up to DKK 750 in 2035.
• 6:51
  But, and this seems important, there's a 60% floor deduction.
• 6:55
  What's that about? That deduction is absolutely
• 6:58
  crucial. It really shows the tripartite
• 7:00
  compromise in action, balancing the green ambition with, well,
• 7:03
  economic reality for farmers. So.
• 7:05
  It's not the full wax straight away.
• 7:07
  No, it softens the blow initially, gives farmers time to
• 7:10
  adapt, invest in greener methods, transition their
• 7:13
  businesses rather than face a sudden, crippling cost.
• 7:16
  So the effective tax is lower to start.
• 7:18
  Right. The effective tax starts at DKK
• 7:21
  120 per ton in 20-30, then rises to DKK 300 per ton by 2035.
• 7:28
  It acknowledges the need for a fair transition for the industry
• 7:31
  that. Sounds like the key to getting
• 7:32
  everyone farmers, industry, environmentalists on board.
• 7:35
  It was definitely key, a pragmatic path towards
• 7:38
  decarbonization. And the money involved isn't
• 7:40
  just the tax, there are massive financial commitments alongside
• 7:43
  it. Huge.
• 7:44
  Just over 30 billion Danish kroner.
• 7:47
  What's that? About €4 billion.
• 7:49
  Yeah, around that earmark for converting 140,000 hectares of
• 7:52
  carbon rich lowland soils and planting 250,000 hectares of New
• 7:57
  Forest. Plus another 10 billion krona,
• 7:59
  roughly €1.34 billion in subsidies for biochar production
• 8:03
  pyrolysis. OK, let's pause there. 140,000
• 8:06
  hectares of lowland soil conversion.
• 8:09
  How significant is that in Denmark and what's the hope for
• 8:11
  biodiversity? Those are big numbers for a
• 8:13
  reason. 140,000 hectares. That's around 5% of Denmark's
• 8:17
  total farmland. It's substantial.
• 8:19
  And it's not just about locking up carbon, it's about restoring
• 8:21
  vital ecosystems. These low lands were often
• 8:24
  drained for farming, releasing stored carbon, rewetting them.
• 8:28
  Turns them back into carbon sinks.
• 8:29
  Right and creates habitats huge for biodiversity and biochar
• 8:34
  that's basically charcoal made from biomass without oxygen and.
• 8:38
  You add it to soil. Yeah, it stores carbon for
• 8:41
  potentially centuries, improves the soil, reduces the need for
• 8:44
  synthetic fertilizers. It's a long term investment in
• 8:47
  both carbon reduction and better farming.
• 8:50
  So the overall target from all this 1.8 million tons of CO2 E
• 8:55
  reduction by 2030. Estimated yeah, with potential
• 8:58
  for up to 2.6 million tons. Which makes a real dent in
• 9:03
  reaching their national 70% climate target for 2030.
• 9:06
  It closes a critical gap. It shows they're using multiple
• 9:09
  tools, not just one silver bullet.
• 9:11
  A really comprehensive approach. Exactly.
• 9:13
  The vision is bigger though. Denmark wants to be an
• 9:16
  international role model for like holistic Land Management,
• 9:20
  integrating everything, nature conservation, biodiversity, city
• 9:22
  protecting drinking water with efficient modern food
• 9:25
  production. They're not seen as separate
• 9:27
  problems anymore. They're interconnected.
• 9:29
  Right. And they're setting up a new
• 9:30
  green fund to drive it, about 40 billion kroner, or €5.36 billion
• 9:36
  for things like planting forests, taking land out of
• 9:40
  intensive production. Plus, a commitment to the EU's
• 9:42
  Water Framework directive cleaning up coastal waters.
• 9:46
  It's an all-encompassing strategy Climate, nature, water
• 9:49
  all tackled together within agriculture.
• 9:51
  It sounds incredibly ambitious, integrated, but surely this tax
• 9:56
  being the first, there must be pushback.
• 9:59
  Concerns from farmers about costs, food prices, Oh.
• 10:02
  Absolutely. No question.
• 10:03
  An agreement this big always sparks debate.
• 10:06
  Initially, yeah, some farming groups were worried about
• 10:09
  competitiveness, the burden on individual farmers, maybe higher
• 10:11
  food prices. Understandable.
• 10:13
  But that tripartite structure was key.
• 10:15
  Again, having environmental groups and industry leaders at
• 10:18
  the table helped find compromises.
• 10:20
  Like the phased in tax in the subsidies?
• 10:22
  Exactly. The subsidies for lane
• 10:24
  conversion for biochar. They're designed to support the
• 10:27
  transition, not just penalize farmers.
• 10:29
  The aim is to transform the sector, not break it.
• 10:32
  A. Testament to finding consensus
• 10:34
  even on tough stuff. It really is for Denmark.
• 10:36
  So, OK, that's the domestic picture, incredibly innovative.
• 10:41
  What does it mean for the rest of Europe?
• 10:42
  Are these ideas spreading? Well, it seems so.
• 10:45
  We're seeing a direct link actually.
• 10:47
  Europe's adopting a new tripartite energy model.
• 10:50
  Inspired by Denmark's Agricultural 1.
• 10:51
  It looks very much like it. It's fascinating how that
• 10:54
  successful collaborative approach in farming is now
• 10:57
  influencing EU energy policy now.
• 11:00
  So on September 8th, 2025, the EU Energy Commissioner Dan
• 11:04
  Jorgensen. Who is Danish, of course.
• 11:06
  Right. He unveiled the first two
• 11:08
  sectoral tripartite contracts specifically for offshore wind
• 11:13
  grids and energy storage. OK.
• 11:15
  So applying that same collaborative model, government,
• 11:18
  industry, maybe communities to big energy projects.
• 11:21
  Exactly. Bringing together public
• 11:23
  authorities, the energy developers, manufacturers, maybe
• 11:26
  labor unions too. The idea is to de risk these
• 11:29
  huge long term investments. Yet everyone pulling the same
• 11:32
  direction for things like offshore wind.
• 11:34
  Right, moving beyond slower, potentially fragmented
• 11:38
  traditional agreements and the. Focus on offshore wind seems
• 11:41
  massive. I saw that quote from Erstad CEO
• 11:44
  Raz Mazerbo. Yeah, committing to lead the
• 11:46
  build out you. Projected offshore wind could be
• 11:49
  what, 1/4 of Europe's electricity by 2050, providing
• 11:53
  affordable green power. That's a huge projection.
• 11:56
  It underlines how critical offshore wind is strategically.
• 11:59
  And the goal isn't just green power, is it?
• 12:01
  No, it's multifaceted. Reduce energy import dependency,
• 12:05
  big for security. Accelerate the clean energy
• 12:08
  transition. Foster growth.
• 12:10
  Create jobs. But it needs massive
• 12:12
  collaboration, cross-border innovation.
• 12:14
  Relentless partnership as they said.
• 12:16
  And yes, there are ongoing discussions about the financials
• 12:19
  like Ersted's capital raise. That's normal for projects this
• 12:22
  huge and capital intensive part of the.
• 12:24
  Dialogue. Exactly.
• 12:26
  But the overall goal is clear. Build robust green energy
• 12:30
  infrastructure for the whole continent.
• 12:32
  These tripartite deals are meant to provide the stability needed
• 12:35
  to attract that investment. OK, so that brings us to the
• 12:38
  final point, really for you, our listener.
• 12:40
  Why does all this matter? Why is Denmark's approach
• 12:43
  significant for international relations?
• 12:45
  For European politics? Well, I think it really shows
• 12:48
  how a smaller nation, Denmark in this case, can use a really
• 12:52
  smart joined up strategy. Combining the bold domestic
• 12:55
  policies, we talked. About that effective showcase
• 12:58
  facing the nudge diplomacy. And diplomatic engagement, all
• 13:01
  driving national and international goals.
• 13:04
  It's a powerful example, isn't it, how a smaller country can
• 13:07
  genuinely impact massive global issues like climate and energy
• 13:11
  security? Leading not just with words, but
• 13:14
  with concrete actions, proven models.
• 13:16
  Yeah, and maybe it leaves us with a final thought, a question
• 13:19
  to ponder. Go on, as Denmark keeps pushing
• 13:22
  these integrated, pragmatic approaches, it makes you wonder,
• 13:26
  doesn't it? Can the success of this small
• 13:29
  but important nudge, as you called it, truly change the
• 13:32
  speed and scale of global climate action?
• 13:35
  Can it inspire other countries with maybe trickier politics or
• 13:38
  different economies to adopt similar holistic collaborative
• 13:42
  strategies? Exactly how much can One
• 13:44
  Nation's bold moves really accelerate the whole global
• 13:47
  effort? It's a crucial question, I
• 13:49
  think. It really is a powerful thought
• 13:51
  to end on. Thank you for joining us on this
• 13:54
  deep dive into Denmark's green strategy.
• 13:56
  And fascinating to discuss. If you found this insightful,
• 13:59
  please follow Diplomacy and International Relations by
• 14:02
  Bastian Freiburg for more explorations of critical global
• 14:05
  topics. And if you liked what you heard,
• 14:08
  please. Give us a five star rating.
• 14:09
  It genuinely helps us reach more people trying to make sense of
• 14:12
  our complex world. Until next time.