Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Crown Costs for Notes in Ether , Gold Coin Marriange, and Coffee Shop Slip and Fall
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirlnig: It's time for Legally Speaking, joined as always by barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defene Lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirlnig: Morning Michael Mulligan.
- 0:06Adam Stirlnig: How are you?
- 0:07Michael Mulligan: Hey, good morning.
- 0:08Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great, I should say, other than battling a summer cold.
- 0:12Michael Mulligan: I'm doing well, and it's always good to be here.
- 0:15Adam Stirlnig: All right, so let's take a look at some of the legal affairs that are happening in even, indeed, these summer months.
- 0:20Adam Stirlnig: It says costs rather than a stay of proceedings ordered for a crown failing to provide disclosure.
- 0:27Adam Stirlnig: Now we've talked about disclosure in the past.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: That's right.
- 0:30Michael Mulligan: So in in a criminal case, the starting point and this is sort of fundamental to how the criminal justice system works in canada crown has an obligation to provide crown, and police have an obligation to provide disclosure to the defense of evidence and other material that they have in their possession which could either show that an accused person was guilty or might show that they're not guilty.
- 0:54Michael Mulligan: Right, you wouldn't want to have a system where stuff's being hidden, and so we have a rule that that needs to be provided.
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: It's a constitutional impediment and a constitutional requirement, and a good one.
- 1:05Michael Mulligan: And so this particular case, the case of the BC, it's a case involving an allegation of impaired driving, and at issue was the defense trying to get police notes, which aren't exactly esoteric or unusual thing.
- 1:21Michael Mulligan: Police are trained as they go about their duties to make contemporaneous notes, and they are important because, of course, human memory is not a video recorder and often the notes the police officer writes are the very best evidence about what they saw or did.
- 1:37Michael Mulligan: And so this case started out with a usual request from defense counsel saying please send me the disclosure material.
- 1:44Michael Mulligan: Material came, but it was missing police notes, which are a pretty obvious thing.
- 1:48Michael Mulligan: So the lawyer wrote back to Crown saying may I have the notes please?
- 1:52Michael Mulligan: The notes didn't show up.
- 1:54Michael Mulligan: The lawyer wrote back to Crown the next month I'm still waiting for the notes, can I have the notes?
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: No notes again.
- 1:59Michael Mulligan: Lawyer again writes to Crown I'm still waiting for the notes.
- 2:03Michael Mulligan: Still no notes.
- 2:04Michael Mulligan: A different Crown counsel gets assigned to the case and that happens sometimes when trial dates are scheduled.
- 2:11Michael Mulligan: Still no notes.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: The lawyer then files a charter application seeking a stay of proceedings for failing to disclose the notes.
- 2:19Michael Mulligan: This is about the fifth time they've been requested, this time in that format.
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: Now I should pause here to say that where the Crown, if there is a failure to disclose material like that, the Crown has that's relevant and important the most common remedy where there is a remedy would be either in order to produce the thing or ultimately a stay of proceedings, like hey.
- 2:47Michael Mulligan: Crown you can't continue if you don't turn that over.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: But here the judge found that no, it wasn't appropriate to grant the stay of proceedings, but instead what the judge decided to do was to order costs against the Crown Eventually and I say this as sort of part of the unsatisfactory background here eventually, the five pages of notes which the judge concluded were significant because they weren't consistent, completely consistent at least with what the officer eventually wrote up in their report.
- 3:16Michael Mulligan: They were contemporaneous, important, repeatedly requested, and ultimately the Crown's explanation for not providing them was that notes had quote gone into the ether, close quote, perhaps due to an electronic system.
- 3:30Michael Mulligan: So there's just no reason why these things weren't produced.
- 3:33Michael Mulligan: And it meant that the trial had to get adjourned.
- 3:35Michael Mulligan: And so this lawyer who traveled in from out of town, having requested these things five times, they spent the day arguing about it and the judge ultimately ordered, rather than staying the proceedings, ordered the Crown to pay the actual costs incurred by the accused for the wasted court time and having to have the lawyer show up and argue this thing, you know, the explanation of into the ether is not really a satisfactory one.
- 4:02Michael Mulligan: And so the judge ordered the Crown to pay $9,421.06, that being the amount she determined was actually the cost produced by the Crown not turning over the notes in a timely way.
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: Well, that caused the Crown Office, I guess, to go into a bit of a spasm.
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: And that happens, I think, from time to time in a bureaucratic system where there's just no mechanism, for you know there's no kitty sitting there with $9,421.06 in it, and you know the usual remedy would be, hey, you can't proceed with this, or hey, disclose those things, what are you doing?
- 4:37Michael Mulligan: And so this produced the Crown going into a bit of a conniption and they appealed the decision to the BC Supreme Court.
- 4:47Michael Mulligan: And so we have this appeal decision that just came out, the Crown appealing and saying, hey, we shouldn't have been required to pay the $9,000.
- 4:53Michael Mulligan: And so it's a useful review of sir.
- 4:56Michael Mulligan: Well, when can that happen?
- 4:57Michael Mulligan: And the court pointed out, as the trial judge originally pointed out, that it's not every failure to provide disclosure in a timely way that's going to produce a costs award.
- 5:08Michael Mulligan: And so, at a minimum, there has to be circumstances that are a marked and unacceptable departure from the reasonable standards expected of the prosecution.
- 5:18Michael Mulligan: And everyone accepts that human affairs are not perfect, and sometimes reminders are required and sometimes things are a bit late Not every time something's late is going to produce a costs award.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: But here the judge found that the Crown had breached its duty, that this was a very basic thing, that the accused counsel had repeatedly written and asked for them, and there was just no adequate explanation for why they weren't provided.
- 5:42Michael Mulligan: And so the judge on the appeal found that the cost award was completely appropriate.
- 5:50Michael Mulligan: Now the next issue then became what about the cost of the appeal?
- 5:53Michael Mulligan: I smiled when I got to this part of it, because the defense position was okay.
- 5:58Michael Mulligan: Well, now you've produced these costs and you've appealed it unsuccessfully.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: We want costs for the appeal too.
- 6:05Michael Mulligan: And so then the judge on the appeal had to determine is it a case where there should be additional costs for the appeal?
- 6:12Michael Mulligan: And indeed it's not common in criminal cases that costs be awarded against the Crown.
- 6:17Michael Mulligan: But there are some circumstances where, on an appeal, there could be costs awarded, and there's a case from the BC Court of Appeal from a few years ago setting out what those might be, and they would include where a prosecution by the Crown has been frivolous or where the prosecution's occurred for an oblique motive, like I didn't like your politics or I didn't like what you were doing, whatever you know some oblique purpose.
- 6:43Adam Stirlnig: Yes.
- 6:45Michael Mulligan: Or where the Crown has taken some random case as a test case and taken some poor person off to the Court of Appeal or something to settle some, you know, novel point of law that really had nothing to do with them.
- 6:57Michael Mulligan: But here the Supreme Court judge, hearing the summary conviction appeal from this decision, concluded that none of those things were made out, and so the result of all this is that the case wasn't stayed crowded to pay the cost that they caused by not turning these things over, despite five requests for them.
- 7:16Michael Mulligan: But the defense doesn't get the costs of the appeal on the basis of it wasn't really a test case.
- 7:23Michael Mulligan: It was just examining whether the judge should have done what they did, and ultimately the conclusion was yes, indeed, the judge had done the proper thing.
- 7:31Michael Mulligan: So no doubt this will be a good reminder for everyone in the system to you know, make sure you're doing what you were required, and the explanation that something has gone into the ether probably isn't going to cut it.
- 7:44Michael Mulligan: And so a reminder to everyone to stay sharp and do what's required and pay attention to repeated requests for basic things, because otherwise you might have somebody looking into the petty cash box figuring out how they're going to pay the $9,000 bill that's been run up for not doing it.
- 8:02Michael Mulligan: Bill that's been run up for not doing it.
- 8:07Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest appeal decision on costs and why they're important and what can happen when things like that aren't provided.
- 8:10Adam Stirlnig: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, we'll take our first break and we'll be back in just a moment with more.
- 8:17Adam Stirlnig: All right, we're back on the air here at CFAX 1070.
- 8:20Adam Stirlnig: As we continue, legally speaking, michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers our last story talking about ways that perhaps various bodies could pay certain sums that are expected Does our next story involve am I reading this correctly a contract in gold coins?
- 8:35Adam Stirlnig: Indeed?
- 8:37Michael Mulligan: it does.
- 8:37Michael Mulligan: Okay.
- 8:38Michael Mulligan: So the background of this is it's a divorce case, a family law case, and the many elements of it aren't too surprising.
- 8:47Michael Mulligan: You know often these things.
- 8:50Michael Mulligan: I'll sort out.
- 8:51Michael Mulligan: Things like division of family property or the presumption is there of an equal division of family property not surprising to most people and there can be provision for spousal support where you've got one spouse who earns more than the other, and things like child support where is the child going to live?
- 9:06Michael Mulligan: That kind of thing, and so all of those.
- 9:08Michael Mulligan: In this case there's nothing particularly surprising.
- 9:11Michael Mulligan: But the interesting wrinkle is that this, the marriage which had lasted for some nine years or so and the parties had lived in British Columbia for most of that time.
- 9:22Michael Mulligan: The original marriage was a traditional marriage which took place in Iran, and it was a traditional marriage in the sense that the marriage was arranged by the families of the parties.
- 9:34Michael Mulligan: They didn't know each other or spend any time together before getting married.
- 9:38Michael Mulligan: And then there was a part of the marriage process there is entering into this marriage agreement or contract, I guess you'd call it, which was in Persian, it was translated here and there's this provision in it for a thing called a marriage portion or maher, and it provides this there's obligation for the husband to pay to provide to the wife one volume of the Holy Quran, a pane of mirror, a pair of candlesticks all received by the wife and 850 gold coins, full bar azadi, plus the cost of one hajj tomato, travel, travel and the husband's liability to pay to the wife upon her demand.
- 10:25Michael Mulligan: So the judge dealt with all the ordinary things like dividing up the property and child support, the spells and support all these things, debts.
- 10:34Michael Mulligan: And then the wife said well, but one more thing, what about this?
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: I want my gold coins, which would be worth several hundred thousand dollars.
- 10:43Michael Mulligan: Now the interesting thing is that the husband gave evidence about how he wound up signing this thing.
- 10:50Michael Mulligan: He noted, he signed it and he said that he showed up at the marriage commissioner for this marriage and when he read this agreement, he was shocked by it and he tried to leave the marriage commissioner's office.
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: He he was shocked by it and he tried to leave the marriage commissioner's office.
- 11:05Michael Mulligan: He said he was pursued by the claimant and the marriage commissioner, who stopped him and told him don't worry, this is just symbolic, it's to make her father happy, and so on that basis, he signed the agreement.
- 11:16Michael Mulligan: Now the judge.
- 11:19Michael Mulligan: Interestingly there's a previous case in BC a couple of them dealing with very similar clauses, and the history of these things is interesting and sometimes I think it's sort of you know everything old is new again where you had a woman who was staying at home and raising children and not working, the idea there would be if there was a breakup in the marriage, the husband could be required to pay the wife the gold coins, sort of as a dowry or it would be like the equivalent of what you might have as spousal and child support in a marriage agreement.
- 11:56Michael Mulligan: People can enter into this.
- 11:57Michael Mulligan: People might call it a prenuptial agreement here, but there's this concept in the Family Relations Act called a marriage agreement, where people can come to an agreement before they get married about what will happen if the marriage doesn't work out, and so this thing was sort of a traditional version of that.
- 12:14Michael Mulligan: Now, on the face of it, then you might say well, you've got this agreement you've entered into for these gold coins.
- 12:21Michael Mulligan: That seems like a marriage agreement.
- 12:23Michael Mulligan: Off we go.
- 12:24Michael Mulligan: But there is authority for judges to not enforce those kinds of agreements if the result of it would be an unfair outcome.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: And the judge found here because in the Canadian legal system those other things were already taken account of, things like spousal support.
- 12:42Michael Mulligan: Because he was a truck driver, made more money, she was a medical assistant, so he was already required to pay her spousal support for a period of time, child support, division of family assets, several hundred thousand dollars, her share of property and so on.
- 12:55Michael Mulligan: But it wouldn't be fair to also get the gold coins, property and so on, that it wouldn't be fair to also get the gold coins, and so on that basis the gold coin claim was dismissed.
- 13:09Michael Mulligan: But I thought it was an interesting case because it sort of touches on that idea of support and how that can be dealt with in other cultures and contexts.
- 13:14Michael Mulligan: And it's really, at the end of the day, not too far off from what we would have in BC and in Canada with the idea of a marriage agreement, you know, a couple coming to an agreement about what will happen if it doesn't work out.
- 13:25Michael Mulligan: It just happens to be expressed in a bit of a different way and so that's possible in Iran.
- 13:38Michael Mulligan: You would have a predetermined number of gold coins that the husband would be required to pay if the marriage ends.
- 13:48Michael Mulligan: So that's the outcome of the gold coins and the traditional Iranian marriage and divorce in the BC context.
- 13:57Adam Stirlnig: All right Up.
- 13:57Adam Stirlnig: Next, a civil case involving documents and document disclosure at a well-known coffee chain.
- 14:04Michael Mulligan: Yes, so indeed it's a well-known coffee chain originating from Seattle.
- 14:08Michael Mulligan: It could be anyone, and so it was a case actually out of the well-known coffee chain, one of their many locations in Vancouver.
- 14:15Michael Mulligan: Yes, and it was a sad state of affairs where it would appear clear that a man tripped and fell in one of those well-known coffee chains and was very badly injured.
- 14:26Michael Mulligan: That much seems clear.
- 14:28Michael Mulligan: Fire department personnel attended to him.
- 14:32Michael Mulligan: He allegedly suffered a skull fracture and brain hemorrhage.
- 14:36Michael Mulligan: The fire personnel described him or maybe I should describe them as first responders described him as babbling, yelling and unable to answer questions.
- 14:45Michael Mulligan: He was taken to the hospital.
- 14:47Michael Mulligan: He needed decompressive craniotomy surgery.
- 14:50Michael Mulligan: I guess that's to relieve pressure on the brain.
- 14:52Michael Mulligan: That's not good and was left permanently disabled, unable to continue his career as an accountant, and so he was suing the coffee chain and the owner of the property.
- 15:03Michael Mulligan: I guess they're leasing the coffee chain, leasing the property under the Occupiers Liability Act, alleging that there was some negligence there of some kind that led to the fall right.
- 15:12Michael Mulligan: I guess you'd have to look into things.
- 15:14Michael Mulligan: Like you know, was there water on the floor?
- 15:15Michael Mulligan: Did he trip downstairs, or what was going on here?
- 15:18Michael Mulligan: Water on the floor, did he trip downstairs?
- 15:21Michael Mulligan: What was going on here?
- 15:22Michael Mulligan: Now, the problem for this man was that, as a result of this head trauma, he had no memory of what happened.
- 15:26Michael Mulligan: So he didn't know what went on, and the case started out actually with his wife writing to the coffee chain asking for things.
- 15:34Michael Mulligan: Like you know, do you have any video of this?
- 15:35Michael Mulligan: We're trying to figure out what happened to my husband.
- 15:38Michael Mulligan: He has no memory of it.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, the coffee chain responded.
- 15:43Michael Mulligan: A legal assistant responded to the wife when there was eventually this request for the video, saying that the video is stored in Washington State.
- 15:52Michael Mulligan: I don't know how they got that set up and they required a Washington State subpoena to get it.
- 15:58Michael Mulligan: So no video was forthcoming, and eventually it turned out the video gets overwritten after 90 days.
- 16:05Michael Mulligan: So there wasn't just some video recording of it, and, moreover, the video cameras didn't focus on the customer area but on things like the safe or the back room area.
- 16:14Michael Mulligan: You know good spots to have your cameras.
- 16:15Michael Mulligan: A safe would be a good choice.
- 16:16Michael Mulligan: So there wasn't a video.
- 16:19Michael Mulligan: That we just sorted out.
- 16:20Michael Mulligan: And so then the issue became this, and it goes to how civil cases work as a contrast to criminal cases.
- 16:26Michael Mulligan: In a criminal case, if you're the person charged with something, you're the equivalent of the coffee chain getting sued.
- 16:33Michael Mulligan: You don't, in a criminal case, have an obligation to provide disclosure to the prosecutor right, it's a one way street.
- 16:41Michael Mulligan: Like the police and Crown have to provide disclosure to you, you don't have to provide exculpatory evidence.
- 16:46Michael Mulligan: You might have in the other direction if you don't wish to.
- 16:48Michael Mulligan: Now, in a civil case, the starting point is that both sides are required to provide disclosure to each other about evidence that they've got, with the idea being we want to get these sort of claims for money sorted out, and so you know, if you've got some document or you know evidence is relevant, you've got to tell the other side about it and give it to them, and both sides have to exchange that.
- 17:13Michael Mulligan: And so both sides in a civil case have to make up a list showing what all do you have right, and then, on request, you're going to turn over a copy of it to the other side.
- 17:23Michael Mulligan: Both parties can do that, and then you can figure out things like you know, was somebody negligent or was there a contract or what happened here?
- 17:30Michael Mulligan: Now there's an exception to that.
- 17:32Michael Mulligan: One of the exceptions, the key exceptions to that general rule that both sides have to turn, you know, list it and turn over to each other what they've got so we can figure out what's going on.
- 17:41Michael Mulligan: Was there a wet spot or whatever, is that things that are produced during the course of the litigation are not ordinarily subject to that right Like.
- 17:52Michael Mulligan: So, for example, if somebody writes to a coffee chain and says I'm going to sue you and the coffee chain says, oh my goodness, and they, you know, start interviewing employees and writing a letter to their lawyer and calling their insurance company and doing all the things you might do if you were a large Seattle-based coffee chain.
- 18:10Michael Mulligan: You don't have to provide the things that you've generated once it becomes clear that you're responding to the claim.
- 18:18Michael Mulligan: Yeah, litigation privilege yeah, that's exactly right.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: And so it doesn't require that the claim actually be started, like there doesn't have to be a notice of civil claim.
- 18:28Michael Mulligan: The threshold would be was litigation a reasonable prospect at the time the thing was produced?
- 18:35Michael Mulligan: And so in this case, the judge was looking at the various things that the plaintiff wanted.
- 18:42Michael Mulligan: He wanted things like email correspondence, internal email correspondence with the coffee chain and the store manager.
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: That occurred after there was sort of notice of this thing brought to their attention.
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: Things like interviews of employees you know interviews of a claims adjuster and you know a picture that was taken after various things were occurred.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: And so the judge concluded that all of the things that were being asked for were in that category that you know, once it was made clear that there's, you know, likely to be some claim from this right somebody tripped and fell in your coffee chain and you're getting written to about potential liability for that that those things were captured by that concept of litigation privilege, that idea that these things were produced in that context.
- 19:34Michael Mulligan: Now, there is a sort of a safety valve there, even if things are privileged.
- 19:41Michael Mulligan: There is a sort of a safety valve there.
- 19:42Michael Mulligan: Even if things are privileged, you know, there can be rare circumstances where things that might meet that general criteria could still be ordered, produced.
- 19:48Michael Mulligan: And the man made the argument that well, gee, I have no memory of this thing.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: This is unfair.
- 19:53Michael Mulligan: Shouldn't I be able to get these things that didn't fly here, even though there are rare cases where that can occur.
- 20:01Michael Mulligan: But the judge pointed out that this wasn't the only way in which the person would be able to the plaintiff would be able to get information about what was going on, and so there is a separate authority to apply prior to a trial to do things like require employees of a corporate defendant to show up and answer questions.
- 20:25Michael Mulligan: And so the judge pointed out that the plaintiff here wasn't completely out of luck and unable to try to figure out you know, whether somebody mopped the floor or whether there was you know some point where everyone fell down when they came out of the bathroom or something.
- 20:40Michael Mulligan: And so it pointed out that there is a separate application, which was possible pursuant to a different Supreme Court rule, which allows the plaintiff to make an application to require Starbucks employees to attend for the purpose of an examination, and so what the man will have to do that has no memory after having suffered this terrible head injury, is make that application.
- 21:06Michael Mulligan: He would then, even though he can't get the transcript that the coffee shop got when they interviewed their employees, it would be possible to require the employees to show up for their own interview.
- 21:20Michael Mulligan: And so, while it's not going to get at everything, there's still an avenue the man's not going to be left completely in the dark.
- 21:28Michael Mulligan: But the case, I think, is an important one, because it makes clear the sort of distinction between how a criminal case works where you've got an accused person who has a right to remain silent, you don't have to prove your innocence.
- 21:40Michael Mulligan: Who has a right to remain silent?
- 21:41Michael Mulligan: You don't have to prove your innocence.
- 21:43Michael Mulligan: We don't have a circumstance where we hook you up to thumb screws and try to get you to confess to the bank robbery or something.
- 21:47Michael Mulligan: That's just fundamental to how our criminal justice system works and how.
- 21:51Michael Mulligan: That's a completely different model from our civil justice system, where the starting point is everyone, turn over everything to the other side.
- 21:59Michael Mulligan: They can have a good look at that.
- 22:01Michael Mulligan: And where the overarching starting point is everyone, turn over everything to the other side, they can have a good look at that and where the you know, the overarching starting point is let's get to the bottom of whether there was some carelessness that caused you to trip.
- 22:08Michael Mulligan: After all, we're just here fighting over money, we're not trying to put you in prison, and so that's how this case, I thought, was a good contrast with the first one we talked about, just in terms of how disclosure works and how that's different in a civil versus a criminal case.
- 22:23Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the large Seattle-based coffee company.
- 22:28Adam Stirlnig: Whoever they might, be, that wasn't deliberate me saying that, it just sort of came out that way.
- 22:32Adam Stirlnig: So, maybe we'll find out someday.
- 22:34Adam Stirlnig: Michael Balgan from Balgan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, always a pleasure on CFAX 1070.
- 22:40Adam Stirlnig: Thank you so much.
- 22:41Adam Stirlnig: Always great to be here.