Latest / Sacred Texts Archive / 09 - The Swiss Reformer - The Great Controversy
Transcript
- 0:00Chapter nine the Swiss Reformer. In the choice of instrumentalities for the reforming of
- 0:07the Church, the same divine plan is seen as in that for the planting
- 0:11of the Church, the heavenly Teacher passed by the great men of earth,
- 0:15the titled and wealthy, who were accustomed to receive praise and homage as leaders
- 0:20of the people. They were so proud and self confident in their boasted superiority
- 0:26that they could not be molded to sympathize with their fellow men and to become
- 0:29co laborers with the humble man of Nazareth. To the unlearned, toiling fishermen
- 0:35of Galilee was the call addressed, Follow me, and I will make you
- 0:39fishers of men. These disciples were humble and teachable. The less they had
- 0:44been influenced by the false teaching of their time, the more successfully could Christ
- 0:49instruct and train them for his service. So in the days of the Great
- 0:53Reformation, the leading reformers were men from humble life, men who were most
- 0:59free of any of their time, from pride of rank, and from the
- 1:03influence of bigotry and priestcraft. It is God's plan to employ humble instruments to
- 1:07accomplish great results, then the glory will not be given to men, but
- 1:11to him who works through them, too will and to do of his own
- 1:15good pleasure. A few weeks after the birth of Luther, in a miner's
- 1:19cabin in Saxony, Ulrich Swingli was born in a herdsman's cottage among the Alps.
- 1:26Singley's surroundings in childhood and his early training were such as to prepare him
- 1:30for his future mission. Reared amid scenes of natural grandeur, beauty, and
- 1:36awful sublimity. His mind was early impressed with a sense of the greatness,
- 1:41the power, and the majesty of God. The history of the brave deeds
- 1:45achieved upon his native mountains kindled his youthful aspirations, and at the side of
- 1:51his pious grandmother, he listened to the few precious Bible stories which she had
- 1:56gleaned from amid the legends and traditions of the Church with eager interest. He
- 2:00heard of the grand deeds of patriarchs and prophets, of the shepherds who watched
- 2:05their flocks on the hills of Palestine, where angels talked with them, of
- 2:08the Babe of Bethlehem, and the men of Calvary. Like John Luther,
- 2:14Singli's father desired an education for his son, and the boy was early sent
- 2:17from his native valley. His mind rapidly developed, and it soon became a
- 2:22question where to find teachers competent to instruct him. At the age of thirteen,
- 2:28he went to Bern, which then possessed the most distinguished school in Switzerland.
- 2:32Here, however, a danger arose which threatened to blight the promise of
- 2:37his life. Determined efforts were put forth by the Friars to allure him into
- 2:40a monastery. The Dominican and Franciscan monks were in rivalry for popular favor.
- 2:47This they endeavored to secure by the showy adornments of their churches, the pomp
- 2:52of their ceremonials, and the attractions of famous relics and miracle working images.
- 2:58The Dominicans of Bair saw that if they could win this talented young scholar,
- 3:02they would secure both gain and honor. His extreme youth, his natural ability
- 3:07as a speaker and writer, and his genius for music and poetry would be
- 3:13more effective than all their pomp and display in attracting the people to their services
- 3:16and increasing the revenues of their order. By deceit and flattery, they endeavored
- 3:22to induce Singley to enter their convent. Luther, while a student at school,
- 3:27had buried himself in a convent cell, and he would have been lost
- 3:30to the world had not God's providence released him. Singley was not permitted to
- 3:34encounter the same peril. Providentially, his father received information of the designs of
- 3:40the friars. He had no intention of allowing his son to follow the idle
- 3:45and worthless life of the monks. He saw that his future usefulness was at
- 3:50stake and directed him to return home without delay. The command was obeyed,
- 3:55but the youth could not be long content in his native valley, and he
- 3:59soon resumed his studies, repairing after a time to Basil. It was here
- 4:04that Singley first heard the gospel of God's free grace. Wittenbach, a teacher
- 4:11of the ancient languages, had, while studying Greek and Hebrew, been led
- 4:15to the holy scriptures, and thus rays of divine light were shed into the
- 4:18minds of the students under his instruction. He declared that there was a truth
- 4:23more ancient and of infinitely greater worth than the theories taught by schoolmen and philosophers.
- 4:30This ancient truth was that the death of Christ is a sinner's only ransom.
- 4:34To Thingley, these words were as the first ray of light that precedes
- 4:39the dawn. Singley was soon called from Basel to enter upon his life work.
- 4:45His first field of labor was in an Alpine parish not far distant from
- 4:48his native valley. Having received ordination as a priest, he devoted himself with
- 4:55his whole soul, to the search after divine truth. For he was well
- 4:59aware, says a fellow reformer, how much he must know to whom the
- 5:02flock of Christ is entrusted. The more he searched the scriptures, the clearer
- 5:08appeared the contrast between their truths and the heresies of Rome. He submitted himself
- 5:13to the Bible as the Word of God, the only sufficient, infallible rule.
- 5:18He saw that it must be its own interpreter. He dared not attempt
- 5:23to explain scripture to sustain a preconceived theory or doctrine, but held it his
- 5:28duty to learn what is its direct and obvious teaching. He sought to avail
- 5:31himself of every help to obtain a full and correct understanding of its meaning.
- 5:36And he invoked the aid of the Holy Spirit, which would, he declared,
- 5:41reveal it to all who sought it in sincerity and with prayer. The
- 5:45scriptures, said Spingley, come from God, not from man. And even
- 5:49that God who enlightens, will give thee to understand that the speech comes from
- 5:54God. The word of God cannot fail. It is bright, It teaches
- 5:59itself, It discloses itself, It illumines the soul with all salvation and grace,
- 6:03comforts it in. God humbles it so that it loses and even forfeits
- 6:09itself and embraces God. The truth of these words Zwingli himself had proved.
- 6:15Speaking of his experience at this time, he afterward wrote, when I began
- 6:19to give myself wholly up to the Holy scriptures, philosophy and theology, Scholastic
- 6:25would always keep suggesting quarrels to me. At last I came to this that
- 6:30I thought, thou must let all that lie and learn the meaning of God
- 6:33purely out of his own simple word. Then I began to ask God for
- 6:39his light, and the scriptures began to be much easier to me. The
- 6:44doctrine preached by Zvingli was not received from Luther it was the doctrine of Christ.
- 6:48If Luther preaches Christ, said the Swiss reformer, he does what I
- 6:53am doing. Those whom he has brought to Christ are more numerous than those
- 6:57whom I have led. But this man I will bear no other name than
- 7:01that of Christ, whose soldier I am, and who alone is my chief.
- 7:05Never has one single word been written by me to Luther, nor by
- 7:10Luther to me. And why that it might be shown how much the Spirit
- 7:15of God is in unison with itself, since both of us, without any
- 7:17collusion, teach the doctrine of Christ with such uniformity. In fifteen sixteen,
- 7:24Spingley was invited to become a preacher in the convent at Einsedelm. Here he
- 7:29was to have a closer view of the corruptions of Rome, and was to
- 7:32exert an influence as a reformer that would be felt far beyond his native Alps.
- 7:38Among the chief attractions of Ainsidolm was an image of the Virgin, which
- 7:42was said to have the power of working miracles. Above the gateway of the
- 7:46convent was the inscription Here a plenary remission of sins may be obtained pilgrims at
- 7:53all seasons resorted to the Shrine of the Virgin, but at the great yearly
- 7:57festival of its consecration, multitudes came from all parts of Switzerland and even from
- 8:03France and Germany. Singly, greatly afflicted at the sight, seized the opportunity
- 8:07to proclaim liberty through the Gospel. To these bond slaves of superstition. Do
- 8:13not imagine, He said, that God is in this temple more than in
- 8:16any other part of creation. Whatever be the country in which you dwell,
- 8:20God is around you and hears you can unprofitable works, long pilgrimages, offerings,
- 8:26images, the invocation of the Virgin or of the saints secure for you
- 8:30the grace of God. What avails the multitude of words with which we embody
- 8:35our prayers? What efficacy has a glossy cowl, a smooth shorn head,
- 8:39a long and flowing robe, or gold embroidered slippers. God looks at the
- 8:43heart, and our hearts are far from him. Christ, he said,
- 8:48who was once offered upon the cross, is the sacrifice and victim that had
- 8:52made satisfaction for the sins of believers to all eternity. To many listeners,
- 8:58these teach were unwelcome It was a bitter disappointment to them to be told that
- 9:03their toilsome journey had been made in vain. The pardon freely offered them through
- 9:07Christ, they could not comprehend. They were satisfied with the old way to
- 9:11heaven which Rome had marked out for them. They shrank from the perplexity of
- 9:16searching for anything better. It was easier to trust their salvation to the priests
- 9:22and the Pope than to seek for purity of heart. But another class received
- 9:26with gladness the tidings of redemption through Christ. The observances enjoined by Rome had
- 9:31failed to bring peace of soul, and in faith they accepted the Saviour's blood
- 9:35as their propitiation. These returned to their homes to reveal to others the precious
- 9:39light which they had received. The truth was thus carried from hamlet to hamlet,
- 9:45from town to town, and the number of pilgrims to the Virgin's shrine
- 9:48greatly lessened. There was a falling off in the offerings, and consequently in
- 9:54the salary of Vingli, which was drawn from them, But this caused him
- 9:58only joy, as he saw that the power of fanaticism and superstition was being
- 10:01broken. The authorities of the church were not blind to the work which Singley
- 10:07was accomplishing, but for the present they forbore to interfere, Hoping yet to
- 10:11secure him to their cause. They endeavored to win him by flatteries, and
- 10:16meanwhile the truth was gaining a hold upon the hearts of the people. Sphingley's
- 10:20labors at Ainsidalne had prepared him for a wider field, and this he was
- 10:24soon to enter. After three years here he was called to the office of
- 10:28preacher in the cathedral at Zurich. This was then the most important town of
- 10:33the Swiss Confederacy, and the influence exerted here would be widely felt. The
- 10:39ecclesiastics by whose invitation he came to Zurich, were however, desirous of preventing
- 10:43any innovations, and they accordingly proceeded to instruct him as to his duties.
- 10:50You will make every exertion, they said, to collect the revenues of the
- 10:54chapter, without overlooking the least. You will exhort the faithful, both from
- 10:58the pulpit and in the confession, to pay all ties and dues, and
- 11:01to show by their offerings their affection to the Church. You will be diligent
- 11:07in increasing the income arising from the sick, from masses, and in general
- 11:11from every ecclesiastical ordinance. As for the administration of the sacraments, the preaching,
- 11:16and the care of the flock, added his instructors, these are also
- 11:20the duties of the chaplain. But for these you may employ a substitute.
- 11:24And particularly in preaching, you should administer the sacraments to none but persons of
- 11:30note, and only when called upon you are forbidden to do so without distinction
- 11:33of persons. Spingley listened in silence to this charge, and in reply,
- 11:39after expressing his gratitude for the honor of a call to this important station,
- 11:43he proceeded to explain the course which he proposed to adopt. The life of
- 11:48Christ, he said, has been too long hidden from the people. I
- 11:52shall preach upon the whole of the Gospel of Saint Matthew, drawing solely from
- 11:56the fountains of scripture, sounding its depths, comparing one passage with another,
- 12:01and seeking for understanding by constant and earnest prayer. It is to God's glory,
- 12:05to the praise of his only son, to the real salvation of souls,
- 12:09and to their edification in the true faith that I shall consecrate my ministry.
- 12:16Though some of the ecclesiastics disapproved his plan and endeavored to dissuade him from
- 12:20it, Singly remained steadfast. He declared that he was about to introduce no
- 12:24new method, but the old method employed by the Church in earlier and purer
- 12:28times. Already an interest had been awakened in the truths he taught, and
- 12:33the people flocked in great numbers to listen to his preaching. Many who had
- 12:39long since ceased to attend service were among his hearers. He began his ministry
- 12:45by opening the Gospels and reading and explaining to his hearers the inspired narrative of
- 12:50the life, teachings, and death of Christ. Here As at Anzadelm,
- 12:54he presented the word of God as the only infallible authority, and the death
- 12:58of Christ as the only complete sacrifice. It is to Christ. He said
- 13:03that I desire to lead you to Christ, the true source of salvation.
- 13:09Around the preacher crowded the people of all classes, from statesmen and scholars to
- 13:13the artisan and the peasant. With deep interest. They listened to his words.
- 13:18He not only proclaimed the offer of a free salvation, but fearlessly rebuked
- 13:22the evils and corruptions of the times. Many returned from the cathedral praising God.
- 13:28This man, they said, is a preacher of the truth. He
- 13:31will be our Moses to lead us forth from this Egyptian darkness. But though
- 13:37at first his labors were received with great enthusiasm, after a time opposition arose.
- 13:43The monks set themselves to hinder his work and condemn his teachings. Many
- 13:48assailed him with gibes and sneers. Others resorted to insolence and threats. But
- 13:54Singly bore all with patience, saying, if we desire to gain over the
- 13:58wicked to Jesus Christ, we must shut our eyes against many things. About
- 14:03this time a new agency came in to advance the work of reform. One
- 14:07Lucian was sent to Zurich with some of Luther's writings by a friend of the
- 14:11Reformed faith at Basel, who suggested that the sale of these books might be
- 14:16a powerful means of scattering the light. Ascertain, he wrote to Svingley,
- 14:20whether this man possesses sufficient prudence and skill? If so, let him carry
- 14:26from city to city, from town to town, from village to village,
- 14:30and even from house to house among the Swiss. The works of Luther,
- 14:33and especially his exposition of the Lord's Prayer written for the laity. The more
- 14:37they are known, the more purchasers they will find. Thus the light found
- 14:43entrance at the time when God is preparing to break the shackles of ignorance and
- 14:48superstition, then it is that Satan works with greatest power to enshroud men in
- 14:52darkness and to bind their fetters still more firmly. As men were rising up
- 14:58in different lands to present to the people forgiveness and justification through the blood of
- 15:01Christ, Rome proceeded with renewed energy to open her market throughout Christendom, offering
- 15:07pardon for money. Every sin had its price, and men were granted free
- 15:13license for crime if the treasury of the Church was kept well filled. Thus
- 15:18the two movements advanced, one offering forgiveness of sin for money, the other
- 15:22forgiveness through Christ. Rome licensing sin and making it her source of revenue,
- 15:28the reformers condemning sin and pointing to Christ as the propitiation and deliverer. In
- 15:33Germany, the sale of indulgences had been committed to the Dominican friars and was
- 15:39conducted by the infamous Tetzel. In Switzerland, the traffic was put into the
- 15:43hands of the Franciscans, under the control of Samson, an Italian monk.
- 15:48Samson had already done good service to the Church, having secured immense sums from
- 15:52Germany and Switzerland to fill the papal treasury. Now he traversed Switzerland, attracting
- 15:58great crowds, despoiling the poor peasants of their scanty earnings and exacting rich gifts
- 16:03from the wealthy classes. But the influence of the reform already made itself felt
- 16:10in curtailing, though it could not stop the traffic. Swingley was still at
- 16:15Ainsdalm when Samson, soon after entering Switzerland, arrived with his wares at a
- 16:19neighboring town. Being apprized of his mission, the reformer immediately set out to
- 16:25oppose him. The two did not meet, but such was Singley's success in
- 16:29exposing the Friar's pretensions that he was obliged to leave for other quarters. At
- 16:34Zurich, Swinglely preached zealously against the pardon mongers, and when Samson approached the
- 16:40place, he was met by a messenger from the Council with an intimation that
- 16:44he was expected to pass on. He finally secured an entrance by Stratagem,
- 16:48but was sent away without the sale of a single pardon, and he soon
- 16:52after left Switzerland. A strong impetus was given to the reform by the appearance
- 16:56of the plague or Great Death, which swept over Switzerland in the year fifteen
- 17:02nineteen. As men were thus brought face to face with the destroyer, many
- 17:06were led to feel how vain and worthless were the pardons which they had so
- 17:10lately purchased, and they longed for a surer foundation for their faith. Swingly
- 17:15at Zurich was smitten down. He was brought so low that all hope of
- 17:18his recovery was relinquished, and the report was widely circulated that he was dead.
- 17:25In that trying hour, his hope and courage were unshaken. He looked
- 17:29in faith to the cross of cavalry, trusting in the all sufficient propitiation for
- 17:33sin. When he came back from the gates of death, it was to
- 17:37preach the Gospel with greater fervor than ever before, and his words exerted an
- 17:41unwonted power. The people welcomed with joy their beloved pastor returned to them from
- 17:47the brink of the grave. They themselves had come from attending upon the sick
- 17:52and the dying, and they felt as never before the value of the Gospel.
- 17:56Swingley had arrived at a clear understanding of it, and had more fully
- 18:00experienced in himself its renewing power. The fall of man and the plan of
- 18:06redemption were the subjects upon which he dwelt in Adam. He said, we
- 18:11are all dead, sunk in corruption and condemnation. Christ has purchased for us
- 18:17a never ending redemption. His passion is an eternal sacrifice and everlastingly effectual to
- 18:22heal. It satisfies the divine justice forever in behalf of all those who rely
- 18:27upon it with firm and unshaken faith. Yet he clearly taught that men are
- 18:33not, because of the grace of Christ, free to continue in sin.
- 18:37Wherever there is faith in God, there God is, and wherever God abideth,
- 18:41there a zeal exists, urging and impelling men to good works. Such
- 18:47was the interest in Zingley's preaching that the cathedral was filled to overflowing with the
- 18:51crowds that came to listen to him. Little by little, as they could
- 18:56bear it. He opened the truth to his hearers. He was careful not
- 19:00to introduce at first points which would startle them and create prejudice. His work
- 19:04was to win their hearts to the teachings of Christ, to soften them by
- 19:07His love, and keep before them his example. And as they should receive
- 19:12the principles of the Gospel, their superstitious beliefs and practices would inevitably be overthrown.
- 19:18Step by step, the Reformation advanced in Zurich in alarm. Its enemies
- 19:23aroused to active opposition. One year before, the Monk of Wittenberg had uttered
- 19:29his no to the Pope and the Emperor at Firms, and now everything seemed
- 19:33to indicate a similar withstanding of the papal claims. At Zurich. Repeated attacks
- 19:37were made upon Zwingli in the papal cantons. From time to time, disciples
- 19:42of the Gospel were brought to the stake, but this was not enough.
- 19:45The teacher of heresy must be silenced. Accordingly, the Bishop of Constance dispatched
- 19:52three deputies to the Council of Zurich, accusing Zingli of teaching the people to
- 19:56transgress the laws of the Church, thus endangering them peace and good order of
- 20:00society. If the authority of the Church were to be set aside, he
- 20:04urged, universal anarchy would result. Sphingley replied that he had been for four
- 20:11years teaching the Gospel in Zurich, which was more quiet and peaceful than any
- 20:15other town in the Confederacy. Is not, then, he said, Christianity
- 20:19the best safeguard of general security. The deputies that admonished the councilors to continue
- 20:26in the church, out of which they declared there was no salvation. Singly
- 20:30responded, let not this accusation move you. The foundation of the Church is
- 20:34the same rock, the same Christ that gave Peter his name, because he
- 20:38confessed him faithfully. In every nation, whosoever believes with all his heart in
- 20:44the Lord Jesus is accepted of God. Here truly is the Church out of
- 20:48which no one can be saved. As a result of the conference, one
- 20:53of the bishop's deputies accepted the Reformed faith. The council declined to take action
- 20:59against Singley, and Rome prepared for a fresh attack. The reformer, when
- 21:03apprized of the plots of his enemies, exclaimed, let them come on.
- 21:07I fear them as the beetling cliff fierce the waves that thunder at its feet.
- 21:12The efforts of the ecclesiastics only furthered the cause which they sought to overthrow.
- 21:18The Truth continued to spread in Germany. Its adherents, cast down by
- 21:22Luther's disappearance, took heart again as they saw the progress of the Gospel in
- 21:26Switzerland. As the Reformation became established in Zurich, its fruits were more fully
- 21:32seen in the suppression of vice and the promotion of order and harmony. Peace
- 21:37has her habitation in our town, wrote singly, No quarrel, no hypocrisy,
- 21:41no envy, no strife. Whence can such union come but from the
- 21:45Lord and our doctrine, which fills us with the fruits of peace and piety.
- 21:51The victories gained by the Reformation stirred the Romanists distill more determined efforts for
- 21:56its overthrow. Seeing how little had been a calmons by persecution in suppressing Luther's
- 22:02work in Germany, they decided to meet the Reform with its own weapons.
- 22:07They would hold a disputation with Spingley, and, having the arrangement of matters,
- 22:11they would make sure of victory by choosing themselves, not only the place
- 22:15of the combat, but the judges that should decide between the disputants, And
- 22:19if they could once get swingly into their power, they would take care that
- 22:23he did not escape them. The leader silenced the movement could speedily be crushed.
- 22:30This purpose, however, was carefully concealed. The disputation was appointed to
- 22:34be held at Baden, but Stingley was not present. The Council of Zurich,
- 22:40suspecting the designs of the Papists, and warned by the burning piles kindled
- 22:44in the papal cantons for confessors of the Gospel, forbade their pastor to expose
- 22:48himself to this peril at Zurich. He was ready to meet all the partisans
- 22:52that Rome might send, but to go to Baden, where the blood of
- 22:56martyrs for the truth had just been shed, was to go to certain death.
- 23:00Ecolampadius and Haller were chosen to represent the reformers, while the famous doctor
- 23:06Eck, supported by a host of learned doctors and prelates, was the champion
- 23:10of Rome. Though Vingley was not present at the conference, his influence was
- 23:15felt. The secretaries were all chosen by the Papists, and others were forbidden
- 23:19to take notes on pain of death. Notwithstanding this, Swingley received daily a
- 23:25faithful account of what was said at Baden. A student in attendance at the
- 23:30disputation made a record each evening of the arguments that day. Presented these papers,
- 23:34two other students undertook to deliver with the daily letters of Ecolampadius to Svingli
- 23:40at Zurich. The reformer answered, giving counsel and suggestions. His letters were
- 23:45written by night, and the students returned with them to Baden in the morning.
- 23:49To elude the vigilance of the guard stationed at the city gates, these
- 23:53messengers brought baskets of poultry on their heads, and they were permitted to pass
- 23:57without hindrance. Thus Bingley maintained the battle with his wily antagonists. He has
- 24:04labored more, said Myconius, by his meditations, his sleepless knights, and
- 24:08the advice which he transmitted to Baden, than he would have done by discussing
- 24:12in person. In the midst of his enemies. The Romanists, flushed with
- 24:18anticipated triumph, had come to Baden, attired in their richest robes and glittering
- 24:22with jewels. They fared luxuriously, their tables spread with the most costly delicacies
- 24:27and the choicest wines. The burden of their ecclesiastical duties was lightened by gayety
- 24:33and reveling. In marked contrast appeared the reformers, who were looked upon by
- 24:38the people as little better than a company of beggars, and whose frugal fare
- 24:42kept them but short time at table. Ecolampadius's landlord, taking occasion to watch
- 24:48him in his room, found him always engaged in study or at prayer,
- 24:52and greatly wondering, reported that the heretic was at least very pious. At
- 24:56the conference, ec haughtily ascended a pulpit's bl undidly decorated, while the humble
- 25:00Ecolamparius, meanly clothed, was forced to take his seat in front of his
- 25:04opponent on a rudely carved stool. Ex Stentorian voice and unbounded assurance never failed
- 25:11him. His zeal was stimulated by the hope of gold as well as fame,
- 25:17for the defender of the faith was to be rewarded by a handsome fee.
- 25:21When better arguments failed, he had resort to insults and even to oaths.
- 25:26Ecolampadius, modest and self distressful, had shrunk from the combat, and
- 25:30he entered upon it with the solemn avowal I acknowledge no other standard of judgment
- 25:34than the Word of God. Though gentle and courteous in demeanor, he proved
- 25:40himself able and unflinching. While the Romanists, according to their wont appealed for
- 25:45authority to the customs of the Church, the Reformer adhered steadfastly to the Holy
- 25:49scriptures. Custom he said, has no force in our Switzerland unless it be
- 25:55according to the Constitution. Now, in matters of faith, the Bible is
- 25:59our constitution. The contrast between the two disputants was not without effect. The
- 26:06calm, clear reasoning of the Reformer, so gently and modestly presented, appealed
- 26:10to minds that turned in disgust from ex boastful and boisterous assumptions. The discussion
- 26:15continued eighteen days. At its close the Papists, with great confidence, claimed
- 26:22the victory. Most of the deputies sided with Rome, and the diet pronounced
- 26:26the Reformers vanquished and declared that they, together with Singley their leader, were
- 26:32cut off from the church. But the fruits of the conference revealed on which
- 26:36side the advantage lay. The contest resulted in a strong impetus to the Protestant
- 26:41cause, and it was not long afterward that the important cities of Baron and
- 26:45Basel declared for the reformation. End of Chapter nine