Latest / Film And Whiskey / Memento / Rabbit Hole Cavehill Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 2000, director Christopher Nolan and star Guy Pierce gave
- 0:04the world a frenetic flick that toyed with the ideas of memory,
- 0:08time and reality. In 2023, we returned to Kentucky
- 0:12to try a four grain bourbon. The film is Memento.
- 0:16The whiskey is rabbit hole. Cave Hill and we'll review them
- 0:20both. This is the film.
- 0:23And whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:44Podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:47glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:50I'm Brad Gee. And this week, Brad.
- 0:53The mind effing begins on film and whiskey.
- 0:56Bob, I I got a tattoo in memoriam of this episode.
- 1:02It's just as Brad explains. Fact #1, Brad always explains.
- 1:09This week we are starting a miniseries of films by
- 1:12everyone's favorite time traveling director, Christopher
- 1:15Nolan. We've done a few Nolan films on
- 1:18the show before Brad, I know we've done Interstellar.
- 1:21Let's see, Inception and The Dark Knight, right?
- 1:24So this is, yeah, 4-5 and six from Chris Nolan.
- 1:28Which will put him up there as one of our higher, you know,
- 1:31amount of films reviewed. Yeah, I mean, it really was kind
- 1:35of fortuitous, Brad, because we're doing this miniseries of
- 1:38directors, and if you look at, say, the IMDb Top 250, you see a
- 1:42lot of Nolan movies in there, and it's because A, Nolan makes
- 1:46really good movies. And B.
- 1:48He has amassed a following as a director that is kind of
- 1:51unparalleled I would say, since the early Tarantino days in
- 1:55terms of having fanboys. So I kind of figured it would be
- 1:58necessary for us to talk about these three movies at some point
- 2:03and what better time to do them then leading up to the release
- 2:06of his movie Oppenheimer, which I believe comes out on the 21st
- 2:10of July. So yeah, it's, it's, it's great
- 2:13time for engagement and downloads, Brad.
- 2:15That's daggone, right? It is.
- 2:17I was going to say if there's any time where we wanted to
- 2:19ingratiate ourselves to the Nolan fanboys, this is it.
- 2:23This is the time. Get ready for the butt kissing
- 2:26of all butt kissing. Oh, and Speaking of which, not
- 2:30the butt kissing part, but the fortuitous timing part.
- 2:34We don't always line up our whiskeys in thematic ways, but I
- 2:38figured we had a whiskey sitting on the shelf called Rabbit Hole
- 2:41and I was like, oh man, if we're going to talk about going down
- 2:44the rabbit hole with any director, Chris Nolan.
- 2:47Yeah. Am I right?
- 2:49I mean, am I right? Because I matched him up so?
- 2:52It would have been better with the matrix.
- 2:54I think it would have been even better with the Prestige, just
- 2:57because of pulling rabbits out of hats and stuff like that.
- 2:59And you're going down the rabbit hole that.
- 3:02Would have been better. That's all right.
- 3:03We did pretty. Good So.
- 3:05Well, by you take your own blame for the failure of the show,
- 3:09Bob. I mean, this could have been the
- 3:10week we did, like Basil Hayden's or something, Brad.
- 3:12So just count your lucky stars, man.
- 3:15Oh God, that whiskey sucks. All right, well, let's steer
- 3:18away from Basil Hayden. Let's steer back into Chris
- 3:21Nolan. So it's been a while since we've
- 3:23done a Nolan film on the podcast.
- 3:24Brad, you know, just, I'm sure that you've watched a Nolan
- 3:28film, probably in the interim, just because they're so popular.
- 3:30When you think about Christopher Nolan.
- 3:33What kind of directorial or writing or acting hallmarks come
- 3:38up in your mind? Like who is he as a director?
- 3:41First off, I love that you assume that I just watch movies
- 3:46like we've been friends for long enough, Bob.
- 3:48That, you know, I don't watch movies other than for the
- 3:51podcast. I feel like it makes me feel
- 3:53like such a huge jerk, though, to assume the other way to be
- 3:57like, well, Brad, I assume you don't watch any movies, so let's
- 4:01just say that you haven't watched a Chris Nolan movie in
- 4:03two years. I I will clear the record for
- 4:06everyone listening here, Bob. I have not watched a Christopher
- 4:10Nolan movie in the last. Two years?
- 4:12Well, then, let me rephrase in the two years it's been.
- 4:15What kind of things about Nolan stick out to you when you think
- 4:18about him as a director, even through two years of hazy, foggy
- 4:22memory? I think that he always has
- 4:26really dynamic relationships with the characters in his
- 4:30films. I'll I'll spoil a tiny bit of
- 4:33momento here. The moments where he has
- 4:36memories of his wife feel like the most.
- 4:40Null in the version of himself in this, you know, his earliest
- 4:44film. Is this his first film?
- 4:48It's not technically his first film, so he made a movie called
- 4:50Following a few years before this, which was I think it's
- 4:53only about 65 or 70 minutes long.
- 4:56Like it's just long enough to count as a feature film.
- 4:58It played in a few film festivals and kind of got him
- 5:01the recognition he needed to make Memento.
- 5:03But Memento is the movie that introduced him to the world.
- 5:06So yeah, it's his second movie, but for all intensive burdens,
- 5:10it it's kind of his first movie. Yeah, so there there's pieces of
- 5:14Memento that feel like, oh, you can see where he will go as a
- 5:19blockbuster director. But for now, what?
- 5:22What I think of when I think about Nolan is convoluted plots.
- 5:27That have just wild endings. And I think, I mean the only one
- 5:34I can think of that's not necessarily that wild is like
- 5:37Batman Begins. And even that one has a plot
- 5:40twist. He is just a fascinating
- 5:44director who uses the camera really well in memory sequences.
- 5:49I think that's what I I think about and and I'll go back to
- 5:52what we said about Interstellar. He just swings for the fences
- 5:57constantly and it doesn't mean he always gets there, but I
- 6:00think the reason he has a fanboy following is because he's always
- 6:05trying to like, hit a Grand Slam.
- 6:09Yeah, I mean, totally agree. I think that as a filmmaker,
- 6:12what he's most known for is playing with time.
- 6:15He's obsessed with the concept of time.
- 6:18Whether it's moving forward in time or backward in time or
- 6:20across time in Interstellar, it's always a theme throughout
- 6:24his movies. And time and memory, I think,
- 6:27are the two things that you could really call his hallmarks
- 6:29as a director. Brad, you know, we, we just came
- 6:31off of a Chaplin series, and I told you that I got 12 books out
- 6:34of the library about Chaplin. I went to the library and I
- 6:37ordered some books about Chris Nolan, and there's only three of
- 6:40them on my shelf now. And I think it says a lot about,
- 6:44I don't know, the state of film criticism that one of the most
- 6:47significant filmmakers of the last 20 years has only had a few
- 6:51films written about him or a few books written about him.
- 6:54And I can't decide if it's because it it just doesn't seem
- 6:58like it's been long enough to offer a career evaluation.
- 7:01Or if it's just that his themes are so on the surface or, you
- 7:06know, so proudly displayed that there's really not much of A
- 7:09need to do a book length dive into them.
- 7:12Because I think everyone recognizes this is what this guy
- 7:15deals with. Like, even to your point,
- 7:17something like the Batman series that he did, The Dark Knight
- 7:20series. Those are all about time.
- 7:22There's always a ticking clock at the end of those movies,
- 7:24whether it's the bomb at the end of the third one or racing
- 7:27against time in the Joker in the second one, then even in the
- 7:30first one. When you're establishing the
- 7:32story of Bruce Wayne, like the memory of his parents getting
- 7:36murdered is what drives the character of Batman.
- 7:39And so it he's always been the perfect filmmaker for that
- 7:42character because it's right in line with what he likes to talk
- 7:45about. I haven't seen Batman Begins in
- 7:48a really long time. I think that one ends with a
- 7:50bomb racing for Wayne Tower at the at the center of the city,
- 7:54right? Yeah.
- 7:55It's him and Liam Neeson on The Monorail, yeah.
- 7:58Yeah, so even that one, it's it's a bomb race.
- 8:01Kind of like the third one. Yeah, man.
- 8:05I'm excited to dive into Nolan, and I don't mean to make it
- 8:08sound like he's a simplistic filmmaker.
- 8:10Like you said, he's always playing with the chronology of
- 8:13his movies. And sometimes it seems like it's
- 8:16necessary for the movies to be told.
- 8:19And sometimes it feels like it's just Chris Nolan wanting to take
- 8:22a pretty straightforward story and just make it convoluted for
- 8:25the sake of making it convoluted.
- 8:27These three films we're going to look at, I have wildly different
- 8:30opinions across the three of them.
- 8:32And to get us back to Memento, I will say this.
- 8:34I have not seen Memento in probably 15 years.
- 8:37I watched it one time. I wasn't a huge fan.
- 8:39I always felt like it was a little forced.
- 8:41It was a little contrived. A little too cute for its own
- 8:44good, you and I, Brad sat down and watched this movie together.
- 8:50A first for the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 8:53An absolute first. I I mean, we have never once sat
- 8:56down together and watched a movie for the purpose of
- 8:59recording an episode for you all.
- 9:02You are welcome. That's crazy, man.
- 9:04Yeah, you're welcome. I mean this is this is episode
- 9:06what like 209 or something for us?
- 9:09And it's never ever happened before.
- 9:11And not to spoil too much of my thoughts on the movie, but I
- 9:14have changed my tune on Memento. I I mean, I'm excited to talk
- 9:20about it then. All right, man, I think that
- 9:23I've been delaying something, the inevitable here for a couple
- 9:27minutes, and that's because I do not envy your task today.
- 9:31In our first segment, which we call, Brad explains.
- 9:34Brad's gonna give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 9:38ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with
- 9:41this little segment that we call Brad explains.
- 9:44Would you say that doing a Brad explains for Gone with the Wind
- 9:49or Memento would be harder? I mean, God, the wind is just
- 9:52like this happens, and then this happens, and then this happens.
- 9:55And, you know, like it's just a long.
- 9:56Movie. But God with the Wind is like
- 9:58this happens then this happens. And then 397 other things
- 10:03happen. That was more just like a list
- 10:05that you were reading. This is going to be a real
- 10:08challenge. So Brad explains is the part of
- 10:10the podcast where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that
- 10:13he has just seen often for the first time Brad was this your
- 10:17first time watching Memento? It sure was, Bob.
- 10:20Well then, I really don't envy you.
- 10:22You have 60 seconds on the clock to break down the plot of this
- 10:25movie. Folks, we are going to get into
- 10:27spoilers on this review. If you've not seen the 22 year
- 10:30old movie Memento, I need you to just stop here, go listen to it
- 10:34and then come back because this movie and the discussion of it
- 10:38is going to hinge on its spoilers.
- 10:41So Brad, just a no holds bar. Don't hold anything back.
- 10:45You've got one minute on the clock to break down this movie
- 10:48and go. Guy Pierce is an insurance agent
- 10:51whose big break came when he proved that a man named Sammy
- 10:54Jankes. Did not actually have shortterm
- 10:57memory loss, and he was faking it, which led to the death of
- 11:02that man's wife and then he himself.
- 11:07Guy Pierce's character receives shortterm memory loss after his
- 11:10wife is brutally attacked and murdered in their home.
- 11:15The rest of the film is about him trying to put together the
- 11:19pieces of his wife's murder and figure out who the killer is.
- 11:24By the end of the film he has interacted with Trinity from the
- 11:28Matrix and she is helping him to try and figure out the problem.
- 11:33Joe Pantoliani, Leoni Leoni. Joe plays a guy named Teddy who
- 11:39is a police officer who's trying to help him find the killer.
- 11:43But at the end of the film, it turns out that they already
- 11:45found and killed the killer, but the shortterm memory loss never
- 11:48allowed him to remember that. And so Teddy has been using him
- 11:52to kill a bunch of different people who are bad guys, and Guy
- 11:57Pearce turns the formula around and uses his shortterm memory
- 12:01loss to seek out and kill Teddy. OK, I'll let you go for a minute
- 12:07and 20 seconds because that's, it's hard, man, you know?
- 12:10Thanks man. It is what?
- 12:11It is. I'm really interested, Brad, in
- 12:13the fact that you explained this movie in the chronological order
- 12:19that the events happen in the movie.
- 12:21That's the only way to do it, man.
- 12:24And I'm wondering how important it is that we say upfront that
- 12:27the central conceit of this movie is that it is not told in
- 12:31chronological order. It is told in a disorienting
- 12:34fashion. And it really does take you
- 12:36until just about the last minute of the movie to piece everything
- 12:39together, not only because information is withheld from
- 12:42you, but just because you are watching two different timelines
- 12:46being intercut. Yeah, and and that's, that's
- 12:49kind of the whole, the whole gimmick, Bob.
- 12:53It's it's, I hate to say it, but this movie is a big gimmick.
- 12:57It is a big. It mostly works.
- 13:01The thing that makes it not work is what Nolan is constantly.
- 13:06Undermined for which is way too much dialogue.
- 13:11And I I just don't know if he's a great director of actors
- 13:15because there's a lot of bad acting in this movie.
- 13:17Oh yeah, I disagree with that. I think that he's a really good
- 13:20director of actors. I will say that you and I were
- 13:22sitting next to each other on the couch watching this movie
- 13:25and at multiple points, you know, at, you know, in the
- 13:27middle of the movie, we were stopping it and just laughing at
- 13:30some of the dialogue in this movie.
- 13:32But. And I think it's also really
- 13:34important to note that if you're going to kind of categorize this
- 13:37movie into a genre, this is a noir.
- 13:40This is 100% of film noir. It has all of the elements of a
- 13:44noir. It's an unreliable narrator who
- 13:47may or may not be doing sketchy things.
- 13:49It's got corrupt cops. It's got a femme fatale.
- 13:52It's got a mystery that needs to be unraveled.
- 13:54People keep dying. It has a really bleak outlook on
- 13:57the world, like it is 100% of film noir.
- 14:01And I do wonder if. Because of having that in mind,
- 14:05if Nolan makes these characters speak in sort of almost 1940s
- 14:12hard boiled detective language, I'm not saying it works, but I'm
- 14:16wondering now, Brad if the the reason the dialogue feels so
- 14:19forced sometimes is because he's trying to make the dialogue
- 14:22sound more like a noir. Yeah, and and there's places
- 14:27where it works. I mean, honestly, I think that
- 14:29some of the black and white scenes.
- 14:31Work because they're black and white and you're like yeah, this
- 14:34is this is a noir that is totally makes sense.
- 14:37I think that the the big issue I have is that not only is the
- 14:42dialogue rough, but it the actors just often feel stilted
- 14:48throughout the movie. I think that guy Pierce does a
- 14:51phenomenal job when he's not talking like when he is silent.
- 14:56I I think that he has a talent for looking blank.
- 15:01On the surface, while like completely confused underneath
- 15:05and trying to figure out what's going on, and he has a real
- 15:08talent for that. But then he opens his mouth and
- 15:11it's not great, Bob. I can feel you trying to jump
- 15:17into performances here, and I want to.
- 15:19I just want to real quick, I want to reestablish this whole
- 15:22thing about the timeline of the movie, because I feel like we're
- 15:25going to be talking about the different timelines of this
- 15:27movie and we need to at least offer a little bit of an
- 15:29explanation, so. The movie starts with the
- 15:33chronological ending of the events, and you kind of get a
- 15:39hint very early on that everything that you see in color
- 15:42is moving in reverse chronological order.
- 15:45At the same time, these color scenes are being intercut with
- 15:48black and white scenes and those are moving forward in time the
- 15:51way time normally works. And what you come to find out is
- 15:54basically like you have two timelines being intercut 1.
- 15:59Going from the end towards a middle point backwards in time
- 16:03and one going from the beginning towards that same middle point,
- 16:06and they both arrive at the same middle point at the end of the
- 16:08movie. And you get this really cool
- 16:10transition from black and white fading into color.
- 16:13And you can tell all right, this is where these two timelines
- 16:15intersect. But you're entirely right, Brad,
- 16:18in that the the stylizing of those different timelines is
- 16:23almost completely different. I mean, not just the fact that
- 16:25it's black and white, but. The kind of dialogue that or I
- 16:29guess monologue that Guy Pierce is giving in those black and
- 16:32white scenes where he's just talking over the phone to an
- 16:35unseen person that feels very much like your standard, you
- 16:39know, Double Indemnity or Sunset Blvd. kind of narration where
- 16:43he's he's just talking about okay.
- 16:45This is what happened with Sammy Jenkas.
- 16:47And you could see that if this was a movie from the 50s, they
- 16:49would have this. Really nice.
- 16:51Like dissolve into the first time I met Sandy Jenkins and you
- 16:55have this voice over, except it's not played as voice over.
- 16:58It's played as like this paranoid conversation that he's
- 17:02having inside a motel room. I don't know, man.
- 17:05I I I can't say that the dialogue or the way that it's
- 17:08written works for me as believable dialogue.
- 17:13But I think for me it's more that this is the early 2000s
- 17:16where it was really cool to mumble everything.
- 17:20Like, it reminded me so much of, like Jim Carrey in Eternal
- 17:24Sunshine how you can never he's like, he's so morose that you
- 17:28can't really understand what he's saying at any point.
- 17:31That's Guy Pearce in this movie. And I know it's intentional, but
- 17:34we watched this movie with subtitles on because it was the
- 17:37dialogue comes at you really fast, but it's never enunciated
- 17:41well enough to understand. And and that's that's like a
- 17:45problem, Bob, like if I'm sitting here on this podcast.
- 17:49And I'm just talking like this. And I think that it's really
- 17:51silly that I just, you know, things like, like you would
- 17:54drive down to Delaware and slap me across the face.
- 17:57Right with a microphone. With a microphone, tell me to
- 18:01enunciate, sit closer. And I I just don't understand
- 18:06how a Hollywood film director can struggle to have his actors
- 18:12be understood. And I know that he has a whole
- 18:14thing about how he wants his sound design done.
- 18:17You don't need to understand every word.
- 18:19And like, for the most part, I'm fine with that.
- 18:22Like, I actually have come to a point where I don't like
- 18:24subtitles because I want to watch the movie as the director
- 18:28wants me to watch it. But I'll just tell you this if I
- 18:31can't understand. Even like 30% of what an actor
- 18:36says throughout the movie, you know, especially if it's the
- 18:38main actor, I'm not going to enjoy the movie.
- 18:41I want to know what's going on. And and Momento was a struggle
- 18:45with that. Especially in a movie like this,
- 18:47where so much of the information is withheld from you until the
- 18:50very end that you need to be able to rely on what you're
- 18:54seeing and hearing just to make heads or tails of what's going
- 18:57on. Even if it's supposed to be
- 18:59disorienting, Even if you're not supposed to understand exactly
- 19:02who put those. Cuts on his face or what's her
- 19:04motivation right now? You at least need to be able to
- 19:07understand what they're saying and what they're pretending is
- 19:10their alibi. And when you can't understand
- 19:12that, it really does cause some huge problems for this movie.
- 19:16And I think that it's kind of a minor miracle, Brad, because
- 19:19like I said, at multiple points in this movie, I was like, this
- 19:22is not working at all, Brad. And you were like, no, I don't
- 19:24like this at all. And I was about to come in here
- 19:26with the hottest hot takes ever and say, oh man, it's even worse
- 19:30than I remembered. And to its credit.
- 19:33The last 20 minutes of this movie are pitch perfect to a
- 19:38point where I can't believe how much it improved my final score.
- 19:43Yeah, no, I I mean the the last 20 minutes of this film,
- 19:47everything comes together. The editing is nice and tight.
- 19:50The acting takes a jump up as the action becomes more tense.
- 19:55Like everything about the last 15 to 25 minutes was great.
- 19:59Like impressive. But the rest of it was a very,
- 20:03very average film that I wish had been directed by, like, I
- 20:08don't know, Alfonso Cuaron. Like, I feel like there's just
- 20:12other people who would have done a much better job with like 80%
- 20:16of this movie. I think that this movie relies
- 20:18on its editing, and we usually don't talk about editing on this
- 20:22podcast in depth, but the way it's edited together, it reminds
- 20:26me a lot of, like some of the. Like like Oliver Stone movies
- 20:29from the early 90s, like JFK, which Brad, I can't wait till we
- 20:32watch that on the show someday. It is probably the best edited
- 20:35movie I've ever seen. And there's this whole sequence
- 20:37towards the end of the movie where Kevin Costner's character
- 20:40is giving his argument in court for why Lee Harvey Oswald was
- 20:44not actually the killer. And it's just this dizzying
- 20:48montage of, you know, the Zapruder film with reenactment
- 20:52with courtroom footage and the sound and the John Williams
- 20:55score is like. It to me it's like the pinnacle
- 20:57of film editing and I think this movie relies on that a lot.
- 21:00You see this all through the 90s with the twist ending kind of
- 21:04movies like The Usual Suspects and and I think this movie
- 21:08really, really does rely on that editing.
- 21:10I don't know if a Cuaron necessarily would have made this
- 21:14movie that much better because it's about the way that the
- 21:17movie is cut. And if you don't have what I
- 21:20think is some really great editing, I don't think the movie
- 21:22works at all, no matter who's behind the camera.
- 21:25I have a question for you about the JFK assassination.
- 21:28Yes, this is exactly what I wanted to talk about on our
- 21:30Momento episode. Hey man, you brought it up, so
- 21:33it's all your fault. So a conspiracy theory, by
- 21:37definition, is something that, like, a small part of the
- 21:41population believes, right? Like that's kind of like a basic
- 21:44thing is like, yeah, this little group of people believe in
- 21:47Sasquatch. Sure.
- 21:50Would you say it's more of a conspiracy theory?
- 21:53To believe that, like Oswald was the shooter, that like, he was
- 21:58the only one. Like to believe the story that
- 22:01was told to us. Or to, like believe the the
- 22:04gunman on the hill, the two shooters, the whole thing.
- 22:07Like, do you think it's more of a conspiracy theory now in 2023
- 22:12to be like, yeah, no, I just think it happened the way the
- 22:14government said it did. I feel like everybody believes
- 22:18in the conspiracy theory. I think it's a good question.
- 22:20I think that you can't necessarily equate the terms
- 22:23conspiracy theory and like fringe belief, right?
- 22:27Like conspiracy theory is just like the theory that someone was
- 22:30conspiring in a way that the record doesn't reflect and at
- 22:34that could be something that is believed by a small or a large
- 22:37part of the population. I think you're right though in
- 22:39that it is a more. Fringe belief.
- 22:43A more radical notion nowadays to believe that it happened the
- 22:47way they said. I think more of the population
- 22:49thinks JFK had some shady business going on and the
- 22:53government and or someone else took care of him.
- 22:56Some some bad actors, if you will.
- 22:59Speaking of bad actors, let's get back into talking about
- 23:02Memento. I'm really excited together,
- 23:05baby. I'm really excited to talk about
- 23:07Carrie Ann Moss in this movie because she plays.
- 23:10One of the most villainous and devious femme fatales I've ever
- 23:13seen in a noir. And yet, the more I thought
- 23:16about this movie, Brad, the more I'm not sure how devious she
- 23:20actually is. We need to talk about it.
- 23:22But before we get into the character, let's talk about the
- 23:24performance. I think she's really good in
- 23:26this movie. Like, her character's not
- 23:29fleshed out on purpose. We only know who she is through
- 23:32Leonard, and she plays exactly the role she needs to play in
- 23:36his story, and then she's out of the movie.
- 23:38So you don't get these big emotional scenes from her where
- 23:41she's talking about her motivations, but you don't need
- 23:44that in a movie like this. And I think for what she's asked
- 23:47to do, she's really, really good.
- 23:49Yeah, overall, her performance is like 7 out of 10, and then
- 23:55she has that scene where she's screaming at him and just like
- 23:59basically calling him an idiot. And like, you're not even going
- 24:03to remember this. Like, I'm going to go back out
- 24:06and come back in. You're going to forget the whole
- 24:07thing and I'm going to tell you whatever I want.
- 24:09And then she does it. And it like her performance in
- 24:13that scene where she's faking how she got attacked is
- 24:18mindblowingly good, like 10 out of 10 acting.
- 24:21And I was just like, oh man, dude, she is like terrifying
- 24:26here. All right, so here's The funny
- 24:28thing about this character and Brad.
- 24:29I was reading and reading and reading before we press record.
- 24:32I understand this movie pretty easily.
- 24:35Like, once you understand the gimmick of the movie, you go,
- 24:37OK, so I can lay these things out in my mind chronologically.
- 24:40The only thing that I couldn't wrap my mind around was her
- 24:43character. And if she is truly evil or
- 24:46like, what is the the end point of her character?
- 24:50Does she still, is she still using Leonard?
- 24:52It does she still hate Leonard? And we think about the character
- 24:55chronologically. She is a bartender who is also
- 24:59kind of helping set up drug deals for her boyfriend Jimmy.
- 25:03Jimmy is supposed to go meet this guy named Teddy, who we we
- 25:06later learned who Teddy is, and she sets up this deal and Jimmy
- 25:09never comes back. And then a guy who we know is
- 25:13Leonard shows up in Jimmy's car wearing Jimmy's clothes, and she
- 25:18figures out pretty easily that it's this guy that Jimmy's been
- 25:21calling the memory guy from seeing him around town.
- 25:24And so she starts using him to try to get information on what
- 25:27the hell happened to her drug dealer boyfriend.
- 25:29She has him go kind of kidnap and get rid of this guy named
- 25:32Dodd at some point. And once he does that, she seems
- 25:37to have like a change of heart. Because the first times we see
- 25:41her in the movie is the end of the story chronologically, and
- 25:44she's helping him find this license plate that he wrote
- 25:47down. And I kept thinking, like, oh,
- 25:49she was using Leonard to bump off Teddy the cop.
- 25:54But I think at one point in the movie, Teddy even tells Leonard,
- 25:56like, no, she doesn't know who I am.
- 25:58So I don't really think she actually is being devious beyond
- 26:02getting the information that she wanted.
- 26:04And and she was like, hell yeah, I'll use this guy, He's wearing
- 26:07my boyfriend's clothes. He clearly knows something.
- 26:10And the more I think about it, the more I'm like, the reveal is
- 26:13set up as if she's a femme fatale.
- 26:16But when you lay it out chronologically, it's actually
- 26:18kind of reasonable what she does.
- 26:21Yeah, and and I'm curious if she somehow knows that Teddy is a
- 26:25cop. Like even if he says, oh, she
- 26:28doesn't know who I am, Like, I wonder if she has figured out
- 26:32somehow that he's a cop and is responsible for her boyfriend's
- 26:35murder. And so it's like, well, you
- 26:37know, I can use this, this peers to get Leonard to get back at
- 26:42him. But even if that's not the case,
- 26:44like. I like I like her character.
- 26:47I think that she's kind of smart and witty and her ability to
- 26:53control the situation is really impressive.
- 26:56And that takes us to Joe Pantoliano as Teddy, who I
- 27:00think, I mean, he has this, the kind of scene stealing
- 27:04performance of the movie, like he's the wisecracking side
- 27:08character. He is perfect for what this
- 27:11movie needs him to be. It's the Edward Edward G
- 27:14Robinson character of this movie.
- 27:17He's really, really good. And I love that Nolan catches
- 27:20both of these people, Carrie Ann Moss and Joe Panchaliano coming
- 27:24off The Matrix. Like this is the first movie
- 27:26they make after The Matrix. I think both of them.
- 27:29And they're both so good in this movie.
- 27:32And I think that it's kind of funny because in The Matrix you
- 27:34get the big reveal that Joe Panchaliano is the bad guy.
- 27:37In this movie, you get the big reveal that he's actually been
- 27:39helping our protagonist the whole movie, and that the
- 27:43Trinity character is actually kind of a Dick to him, you know
- 27:47what I mean? Like it's a great little
- 27:49reversal of their roles from The Matrix.
- 27:52I really loved his performance. Yeah, Joe was hands down the
- 27:57best performer in the movie. I really liked Mark Boone
- 28:00Junior. I thought that he was good as
- 28:02the the receptionist. At the motel.
- 28:06But I I think that Joe Pantoliano definitely steals the
- 28:10show and I like. At the end of the day though, I
- 28:14have to ask, is it like, was what he was doing worth it?
- 28:20Like he like, he tells him like, yeah, you killed the guy like 4
- 28:24guys ago and I've just been using you to keep killing more
- 28:28guys. Like do you think he has it down
- 28:29to a science of like? All right, day one show him this
- 28:34picture this guy, and day two do this and like like does he have
- 28:39it figured out down pat? Like how to get him to kill
- 28:42people? I just feel like there's easier
- 28:44way to kill people than have a dude with short term memory
- 28:47loss. Like go through the motions
- 28:50every day and figure it out. Well, especially since you have
- 28:53to be with him for so much. Like, it's one thing to just
- 28:56hire a hitman when you don't have any other contact beyond,
- 28:59like, here's the guy, here's the money, go kill him.
- 29:02You know, like they're going to have video surveillance footage
- 29:04of him riding around in a car with Leonard, like, for weeks
- 29:08and weeks on end. Yeah, it it just feels very
- 29:13contrived. I don't know out of out of all
- 29:16the plots. That Christopher Nolan has sold
- 29:19us. I feel like this one is kind of
- 29:21the silliest where this this detectives like yeah, you know
- 29:25what I could do with this short term member lost guy you know
- 29:27turn him into a psych hospital or.
- 29:33All right, Brad, I think we're in a good place to hit pause.
- 29:36Let's try this rabbit hole. What do you say?
- 29:39Let's get to it. All right, so today we are
- 29:47checking out Rabbit Hole Cave Hill.
- 29:50This is the second Rabbit Hole product we've tried on the show.
- 29:53And the thing about Rabbit Hole Brad, is I know that at one
- 29:55point they weren't putting these fancy little names on their
- 29:58bottles. It was just like Rabbit Hole
- 30:00Black Label or Rabbit Hole Red Label.
- 30:03And so when we were first sent these samples by our friend
- 30:06Austin at the Bourbon Earring Podcast, it was just like Rabbit
- 30:09Hole Bourbon. And then Rabbit Hole Red or
- 30:12something, it's like what is the because then I go look it up
- 30:14online and now they've added these names like Cave Hill and
- 30:17High Gold and all these things. So what we're trying today, you
- 30:20may know it as just Rabbit Hill, Rabbit Hole Black Label.
- 30:25This is a four grain bourbon, 70% corn, 10% malted wheat, 10%
- 30:31honey, malted barley, 10% malted barley.
- 30:35So I mean two of the grains are barley but they're malted in
- 30:37different ways. So they count them as separate
- 30:39things. I'm pretty pumped to try this,
- 30:41Brad. It's a high barley mash bill,
- 30:44much more barley than there is wheat in this, and no rye.
- 30:48Yeah, it sounds absolutely delicious.
- 30:51I will say, without it being an age statement as a Kentucky
- 30:54straight bourbon whiskey, doesn't that doesn't that mean
- 30:56it has to be at least four years?
- 30:58At least four years old to not carry an age statement.
- 31:00So that means that the youngest whiskey in this blend is at
- 31:03least four years of age. They have a big thing on their
- 31:05website that they say this is an extreme small batch.
- 31:10Never, never more than 15 barrels in each batch, which I
- 31:14really like that, you know, that does seem small enough that it
- 31:16seems like a legitimate small batch and not whatever the hell,
- 31:20you know, wild turkeys trying to sell us or.
- 31:22We have 200 and 5300 barrel blend.
- 31:26All right, so this is coming in at 95 proof, or 47.5% A/B V
- 31:32Let's dive in, man. What are you picking up on the
- 31:33nose? The nose is really beautiful.
- 31:36It's got some nice caramel and vanilla.
- 31:38There's toasted marshmallow, some strawberry, and almost at
- 31:42the end I found myself thinking about like Cream of Wheat, but
- 31:46not bad. Like like a really nice sugary
- 31:50Cream of Wheat. I I liked it a lot, Bob.
- 31:54I gave it an 8 out of 10. I like this a lot too.
- 31:57It's very bright on the nose. I get a lot of like almond
- 32:00extract on this, almost like an almond cake.
- 32:03But it goes along with all those notes you were talking about,
- 32:06lots of vanilla on this. And then I get quite a bit of
- 32:08blueberry, which is something I don't usually get.
- 32:11And I'm not talking like blueberry syrup or something.
- 32:14It's just fresh picked. Like when you go to wash them
- 32:17before you eat them, like, it's just, man, it's really, really
- 32:19nice. And then I get just a slight,
- 32:22the slightest hint of like, brininess on this.
- 32:24There's just a little bit of a salty thing going on here too.
- 32:28I'm excited to see how that translates to the taste, but the
- 32:31the nose is off the charts man, really good.
- 32:33I'm going to give it an 8 1/2. Yeah, the pallet is matches the
- 32:38nose perfectly for me. It it turned into a little bit
- 32:42more of a floral honey agave type of direction along with
- 32:48some caramel that you got on the nose and then it almost got a
- 32:51little bit minty for me at the end like a like a sweet mint and
- 32:55I. Absolutely love this, Bob.
- 32:58I give it an 8 1/2 out of 10. This is definitely not an
- 33:02unsweet whiskey, but the the sweetness that we normally get
- 33:06on weeded bourbons is not the dominant flavor here.
- 33:10It's really nice and I I think I still am getting some of that
- 33:12blueberry. It's like almost like a dark
- 33:14fruit underlying it. You might be able to pick it up
- 33:17as black cherry. You might pick it up as like a
- 33:19Raisin. For me, it's coming across as
- 33:21blueberry right now. There's a lot of vanilla on it
- 33:25as well and then it gets really heavily like char flavor for me.
- 33:29I really like it and I think that might be the barley coming
- 33:31through a little bit. But the combo of that kind of
- 33:34really dark char with some really nice dark fruit is super
- 33:40unique. This is not a flavor profile we
- 33:42get on many bourbons. Brad.
- 33:43I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10.
- 33:46Yeah. And then as we get into the
- 33:47finish, I think that there's like everything you want on a
- 33:50finish is here. It's a little bit oaky.
- 33:53The mint keeps coming through for me and then the the Cream of
- 33:57Wheat almost kind of blends with some of the fruity notes and
- 34:01almost turns into like an orange creamsicle flavor for me on the
- 34:04finish. I really liked it.
- 34:06Again, I'll, I'll give it an 8 out of 10.
- 34:09Yeah, I think the finish is just more of the same from the
- 34:11palette, which is really nice. Like it's it's it's nice
- 34:14sometimes. When you don't have to give a
- 34:17whole new set of notes on something and it's just super
- 34:19consistent, it's the same notes of like really dark blueberry,
- 34:23almost a blueberry compote, dark cherry for me.
- 34:26And then that that barrel char mixed with a little bit of that
- 34:31kind of light effervescence that we get from weeded bourbons,
- 34:34lots of vanilla, that caramel and brown sugar finally come out
- 34:38on the end. This is really nice.
- 34:40I will say this Brad, I don't know if this is like.
- 34:44An intro to bourbon. Bourbon.
- 34:45You know what I mean? This is like A, it's more
- 34:48complex than most bourbons. I would offer someone who's just
- 34:50starting out. But B, it seems outside the norm
- 34:55of weeded bourbon enough that I wouldn't like.
- 34:58If you put this in the lineup with like Rebel and Weller and
- 35:02Maker's Mark, I think this is the one that would be like the
- 35:05outlier of the group. Flavorwise, it's really, really
- 35:08good. I just think that I'm glad we
- 35:11waited until now to try it, because.
- 35:13It. Defied my expectations so much.
- 35:16I'm going to give it an 8 on the finish and I'm also going to
- 35:20give it an 8 1/2 on the balance. See, I think balance is actually
- 35:24where this stands out. I think that there's enough
- 35:27complexity here with really nice balance of flavors that move
- 35:34through the nose to the taste to the finish really, really well.
- 35:38I give it a nine and a half on balance by.
- 35:41And then when we get to value in the state of Ohio, you can get
- 35:45this 750 milliliter bottle for $60.00.
- 35:51And honestly I think that that's a pretty good value like this
- 35:55across the board is like a B plus whiskey.
- 36:00And so I I think that $60.00 is kind of right on par for where
- 36:04it should go. As far as just the juice that's
- 36:06in the bottle, I give it an 8 out of 10.
- 36:08Yeah, I I will say that. Again, we we always come back to
- 36:11this thing of like Brad scores his value score based on like
- 36:15does the taste of the product justify the price?
- 36:18And I always come at it a little bit more from like man, it's a
- 36:21good thing this tastes good because I think this is kind of
- 36:23pricey for a four year bourbon, you know what I'm saying?
- 36:26Like Rabbit Hole always prices their stuff kind of in that
- 36:30premium pricing range and the last Rabbit hole we had we liked
- 36:34but we didn't love it and I think at $60.00 that one was a
- 36:37pretty low value. This is the same kind of
- 36:40principle. It's a four year bourbon.
- 36:42You could get Rebel for $20 or you get this for $60.00.
- 36:47I think that it's slightly overpriced, but I am swayed to
- 36:50give it a better score because the juice is really, really
- 36:53good. I think I'll still give this a 7
- 36:56out of 10 on value, but that is with the caveat that like I'm
- 37:01scoring at that high because the product is good, not because the
- 37:05production. Mandates that this needs to be
- 37:08$60.00. Does that make sense?
- 37:10Yeah, 100%. Yeah.
- 37:12So for me, at the end of the day, I am coming out to a a
- 37:15pretty high score here, Bob. I'm at a 42 out of 50.
- 37:19I am at a 40 out of 50, which takes us to a very easy to
- 37:22average 41 out of 50 or an 82 out of 100.
- 37:27This is our highest scoring whiskey in a little while, Brad.
- 37:29It's nice to have one that we can pretty heartily recommend
- 37:32here. Yeah, this is a very obvious
- 37:35whiskey that you should go try. I think it's worth getting a
- 37:38sample at the bar. I think it's worth getting a
- 37:41bottle. So also, it's a really beautiful
- 37:43bottle. So yeah, add it to add it to
- 37:46your liquor shelf. This is an easy recommend from
- 37:49both Bob and I. Now I am like the If you're the
- 37:52resident rye fan on this podcast, I feel like I can
- 37:55pretty confidently say I'm the resident weeded bourbon guy.
- 37:59Like this is just this is my favorite kind of bourbon.
- 38:01Which would you agree with me that this is probably the most
- 38:05unique tasting weeded bourbon we've ever had, just in terms of
- 38:09being outside the norm? Yeah, 100%.
- 38:12This one has some really interesting flavors for me.
- 38:16It was that mintiness that like really turned me on to this
- 38:20whiskey and I I just enjoyed it a lot.
- 38:23Me too, man. All right, so we're above the 40
- 38:25mark once again. Go buy it.
- 38:27Go try it. Brad, Let's get back into
- 38:29talking about Memento. What do you say?
- 38:31Let's get to it. All right, everybody.
- 38:38That was Rabbit Hole Cave Hill Bourbon.
- 38:41A whiskey worth going down the rabbit hole for Bob.
- 38:44I will say we have climbed back out of the rabbit hole.
- 38:47Brad and I can't wait to dive back in again.
- 38:51Nailed it. You know what rabbit hole I like
- 38:54going down every week, Bob? I think I do.
- 38:57Brad, Is it 2 facts in a falsehood?
- 38:59Canada's favorite segment 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 39:03Brad. Is gonna try to stumpy ball. 2
- 39:08are right and what is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 39:14and a Falsehood is the part of the podcast where Brad presents
- 39:17three items to me as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 39:21which is a lie, and I have to figure out which one that is.
- 39:26Brad, I don't remember what I'm sitting at on the season.
- 39:28I think I'm like. A game under 500, like I'm still
- 39:31hanging around in the Division. Yeah, but I'm.
- 39:35Like I'm like in 3rd or 4th place in the Wild Card race, you
- 39:38know? If I if I had to guess, I'm
- 39:39pretty sure you are six and seven right now.
- 39:42We'll say six and seven. That sounds good.
- 39:44Yeah, you're doing great, man. I'm proud of you.
- 39:46You're giving it the old college try.
- 39:49It's a little demeaning, but that's fine, I'll take it.
- 39:52Hey, that's about the best you'll get for me.
- 39:53Fact #1. Initially, Brad Pitt showed
- 39:57interest in playing the role of Leonard but was not able to do
- 40:01to other commitments once he passed on the role.
- 40:03Christopher Nolan did not consider any other Quote a List
- 40:06actors because he wanted to have the ability to spread his budget
- 40:09more evenly among the cast. Fact #2, Christopher and
- 40:14Jonathan Nolan were turned down by 12 different studios before
- 40:17New Market Films picked them up. Momento was their first film and
- 40:21it's critical success helped them succeed as a film
- 40:24distribution company. Fact #3.
- 40:27Christopher Nolan's screenplay was based on his brother
- 40:29Jonathan Nolan's story Memento Mori.
- 40:32However, the screenplay is still considered original rather than
- 40:35adapted because Jonathan's story was not published until after
- 40:39the film was completed. I think #2 is the falsehood, but
- 40:45I'm going to, I'm going to vamp a little bit so we get some
- 40:47quality content out of this. Brent, I read earlier that I,
- 40:51Brad Pitt had been considered for this role, that he had a
- 40:54really busy schedule. And I found that very funny and
- 40:56I was going to bring it up at some point on this episode
- 40:58because you and I had said at multiple points this would have
- 41:01been a great Brad Pitt role. And the stylings of of Guy
- 41:05Pierce look very similar to Brad Pitt in Fight Club, from the
- 41:08bleached spiked hair to the the kind of wiry frame.
- 41:13I think it's really funny that the suit that Guy Pierce wears
- 41:17in this movie is really similar to the suit that Brad Pitt then
- 41:20wears the next year in Ocean's 11.
- 41:22So I could very easily see Brad Pitt in this.
- 41:25I think one's true. I also think 3 is true because I
- 41:29know that this was based on on Jonathan's short story.
- 41:32I know this movie was nominated for a screenplay Oscar, but I
- 41:35don't remember if it was original or adapted.
- 41:38So you might be able to get me there, but that sounds very
- 41:41true, so I'm going to go ahead and say two is the falsehood.
- 41:46Bob, you are now seven and seven on the season.
- 41:50Congratulations. Look at you coming back up to
- 41:52500. Thank you, Brad Pitt.
- 41:56I'd like to thank Brad Pitt for not being in this movie so that
- 41:59I could learn the trivia about him.
- 42:01Dude, the other person I was thinking about was Edward
- 42:03Norton, which, you know, obviously like the Fight Club
- 42:06duo, but I I feel like Edward Norton could have pulled this
- 42:11role off better than Guy Pearce. I've thought about this because
- 42:14he told me this the other night, and I don't think I agree
- 42:17anymore. I think Ever Norton would have
- 42:18brought too much kind of nervous energy to this movie, whereas
- 42:22the kind of like detached, cool, calm, collected version of Guy
- 42:27Pearce. You know, I was reading
- 42:29something Nolan said about him and why he loved Guy Pearce so
- 42:32much in this movie. And he talked about Leonard's
- 42:34optimism and how if this movie was laid out chronologically, it
- 42:38would suck because it's just not told that way, but also because.
- 42:42You have to keep buying into the fact that this guy wakes up
- 42:44every day with this blank expression on his face and and
- 42:49motivated by optimism like a puppy dog.
- 42:52And I think you really do get that in a lot of these scenes.
- 42:54I kind of commented that to you as we were watching it that
- 42:57there is a sort of earnestness to him as a character even
- 43:01before you find out some of the shady stuff he did at the end of
- 43:03the movie that the version who doesn't remember that, you know.
- 43:08He goes into the world very naive, not too differently than
- 43:11the tramp that we've been watching for the last four
- 43:13weeks, Brad. Look at you.
- 43:15Bob I just. I think the guy Pierce pulls
- 43:18that part of the role off better than most people could,
- 43:21especially in the early 2000s. Yeah, I I mean, I I think that
- 43:26there is an element of that's of that that is true.
- 43:29I think my struggle is the idea of him as a optimistic puppy dog
- 43:33who has tattoo a tattoo on his body.
- 43:37That says John G raped and killed my wife.
- 43:41OK, well I will say I I ad libbed the puppy dog part of it.
- 43:45But I am with Chris Nolan on his optimism comment.
- 43:48Yes I am. I agree that most dogs would not
- 43:51tattoo that on themselves. It's a very grim optimism at the
- 43:55very least, like I might not have been able to save my wife.
- 44:00But I'll get the bastard who did it.
- 44:02But I think the naivete and the like, the trusting of people
- 44:06that he probably shouldn't be trusting of and that as an
- 44:09audience member, we have a sort of natural wariness towards.
- 44:14I think that Pierce pulls that off really well.
- 44:16He puts himself in harm's way a lot.
- 44:18And you as an audience member, even though you're trying to
- 44:21figure out this mystery alongside him, you don't want to
- 44:23see him get hurt. And so it really does.
- 44:25It does a great job of making him the protagonist of the
- 44:28movie. And not simply the plot engine
- 44:33of the movie. Yeah, I I think the other thing
- 44:37is that Nolan leans into kind of the horror movie trope of like,
- 44:41why are they going into the basement rather than the the
- 44:44running car outside in the sense that like as an audience member,
- 44:48you just keep asking yourself, why is he trusting her?
- 44:51Why is he trusting him? Like what?
- 44:52Like why are you doing the things that you're doing and
- 44:55yet? It like works for the movie
- 44:57because it keeps you engaged as a viewer where you keep asking
- 45:00yourself, like, why is he doing the things that he's doing and
- 45:04and and you you're trying to learn about him as a character
- 45:07and and you get to the point where you realize he has this
- 45:10grim optimism of like, I'm going to do whatever it takes to to
- 45:14solve the murder of my wife. All right.
- 45:18Brad, is there anything else about the movie itself you want
- 45:21to talk about? I have like a fun closing
- 45:24segment for us, but. Is there anything within the
- 45:27movie itself, the direction, the cinematography, anything that
- 45:30you want to make sure we talk about first?
- 45:33I really like Stephen Tobolowsky and Harriet Harris as Mr. and
- 45:39Mrs. Jancus. Yeah, they were excellent.
- 45:41Like the those were probably some of my favorite parts of the
- 45:44film when he's like explaining the story of of Sammy Jancus.
- 45:49Yeah, cool. Good.
- 45:52Good observation, man. Nailed it.
- 45:54Thanks for the great, great, you know, little kick back there.
- 45:58I love the way we have dialogue, Bob.
- 46:00It's a lot of fun. Yeah, well, you've been
- 46:02criticizing dialogue this whole episode, so I'm trying to
- 46:04eliminate any between us here. I mean, if I wanted to do
- 46:08dialogue the way Guy Pierce talks on the phone, I would go,
- 46:12well, First off, I would wait like 3 seconds after you talk
- 46:15and then I would go, wow, yeah, Bob.
- 46:19That's what I think about it too.
- 46:21Shut up, dude. It's not that bad.
- 46:24It's pretty rough, man. OK, here's my question for you,
- 46:27Brad. I don't know if this is a fun
- 46:28segment, but the more I think about this movie, the more that
- 46:31it really puts an incriminating light on another movie that I
- 46:36really, really love. And that movie is Martin
- 46:39Scorsese's Shutter Island, because they are the same movie,
- 46:43like, like every single thing about the plot of both movies.
- 46:48Is the same, and I think that's why Shutter Island received such
- 46:52kind of lukewarm reviews when it was first released.
- 46:54I think critics are coming around to it now more because of
- 46:57what Scorsese did than anything in the script.
- 47:00But that was a book written by Dennis Lehane, the guy that also
- 47:03wrote Gone Baby Gone and Mystic River, and I love all of those
- 47:09movies. But I got to say, the guy really
- 47:12just ripped off Memento. I don't think that Shutter
- 47:15Island was written prior to Memento coming out.
- 47:17I'll have to look at the release date, but in any case, it is a
- 47:21huge coincidence that those movies both end up being about a
- 47:24guy with a dead wife who is trying to find her killer, who
- 47:29goes into these shady environments and is then told
- 47:32that you know, he was the cause of the whole thing.
- 47:36You find out at the end of both movies.
- 47:38Spoiler alert, I guess. That they are both the one that
- 47:42killed their own wife and they could not live with the grief.
- 47:45And so they invented kind of alter egos for themselves.
- 47:49And in this movie it's this, you know, this John G character in
- 47:54Shutter Island. It was what's the guy's name
- 47:56that they're searching for latest?
- 48:00He's looking for a guy named latest in that movie.
- 48:01And then he finds out that his name is actually Edward latest,
- 48:04right? His name's Teddy in the movie.
- 48:06There's a Teddy in this movie. I don't know.
- 48:09If I should have less respect for Shutter Island, and I'm
- 48:13wondering what your thoughts are because I know that we both
- 48:16mentioned Shutter Island at one point while we were watching
- 48:19Memento. Yeah, I I don't know if I would
- 48:22say Shutter Island and Memento are like as much of A Onetoone
- 48:25comparison for me. Shutter Island feels much, much
- 48:30more like A Beautiful Mind in in like the detective nature of it,
- 48:35like this one. Doesn't really feel like a
- 48:38detective movie to me, which I I know sounds weird, but it's so
- 48:45strange, the chronology of it, that you quickly realize this
- 48:49isn't about him. Like, figuring it out.
- 48:52It's about Nolan being cool as a director and like, doing the
- 48:56movie backwards. OK, so take wait.
- 48:58Take the genre out of it though, and even to some extent the
- 49:01structure. Like if you were doing a Brad
- 49:03explains. On the plot of Shutter Island
- 49:07and a Brad explains on this movie, which you just did.
- 49:09And you laid this movie out chronologically when you did
- 49:11your Brad explains like you got to at least admit that almost
- 49:16beat for beat. These movies follow the exact
- 49:19same story. I don't know if they do that.
- 49:24Like for me, I I don't know. I don't think that Shutter
- 49:28Island and this film remind me of them a lot at all.
- 49:34Yeah, I I don't feel like you're not.
- 49:36To some extent. I don't know that you're
- 49:37answering my question. Like if you took the plot of
- 49:40Forrest Gump and made it a horror movie, like they still
- 49:43have the same plot. You know what I'm saying?
- 49:44Like it's. It's memento if you turn Forrest
- 49:48Gump into a horror film. Is that what you're saying?
- 49:49No, I'm saying that you can take any movie and replicate the plot
- 49:55and make it a different genre, but that doesn't negate the fact
- 49:58that they still follow the same beats like.
- 50:01These movies follow the exact same story beats, and there are,
- 50:04I think, too many similarities between them to not at least
- 50:07confront that head on. And I was going to, you know, I
- 50:10thought that you'd be more cooperative with this segment.
- 50:12This has been a huge flop for me, but.
- 50:14I'm going to. I'm going to give you one last
- 50:16push back, Bob. Any detective movie has the same
- 50:19beats. He did it.
- 50:21Oh, wait, no, he didn't. Oh, wait, it was her.
- 50:24Oh, wait, it wasn't. Oh, wait.
- 50:25Now there's the twist. This is who actually did it.
- 50:28You pissed me off so much, dude. Like, literally, you're not even
- 50:31engaging with what I'm saying I was going to be.
- 50:33With what you're saying, I literally just, I'm like, yeah,
- 50:37almost all detective movies have the same beats.
- 50:39OK, but it. Doesn't make me.
- 50:40Like most detective movies, that they're, most detective movies
- 50:43don't have anything to do with the hero getting convenient
- 50:46amnesia after murdering his own wife and the big reveal being
- 50:50that he murdered. His own wife and then
- 50:51constructed an identity for himself to not deal with the
- 50:55grief. Like there are very few movies
- 50:57where that is the big reveal. Maybe.
- 51:01Sure. All right.
- 51:03God bless it. I was going to come in at the
- 51:05end and be like, well, actually I you know what I don't have?
- 51:08I haven't lost respect for Shutter Island because at the
- 51:11end of the day, I think that if you're going to blame anybody
- 51:15for Shutter Island being similar to this movie, it would be
- 51:17Dennis Lehane for writing the story.
- 51:20But Scorsese directs the hell out of Shutter Island, and I
- 51:24think that Shutter Island is a much better directed movie than
- 51:27Memento is. And that was going to be my big
- 51:29segue into us doing let's make it a double in our final scores.
- 51:33But I guess to try to redeem this segment, I will say, Brad,
- 51:36do you agree with me that Scorsese directing Shutter
- 51:40Island does a better job than Nolan directing Memento?
- 51:45A million times yet. OK, well there, that's the
- 51:48that's the easiest take in the world.
- 51:50Shutter Island is way better directed film, and just a better
- 51:55movie altogether than than Memento is.
- 51:59Well then, let's get into. Let's make it a double.
- 52:01We're near the end of the episode, so thanks for listening
- 52:04to the film and whiskey show. Let's ever know the film with
- 52:07this one, even if it's struggling.
- 52:09It's a final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 52:12Let's make it a double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 52:14movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 52:17feature. Brad, I'll let you go first
- 52:20since Shutter Island apparently is nothing like this movie.
- 52:22So I'll scramble to think of something else while you give us
- 52:27your perfect pick. I'll give you this, man.
- 52:29I I like Shutter Island way better than Memento.
- 52:32They just don't remind me of each other.
- 52:35I'm going to pick The Truman Show 1998.
- 52:39Jim Carrey. I think that that film has
- 52:42enough in common of a man whose life isn't anything like what he
- 52:48thought it was. And I I think that there's some
- 52:50good similarities there that make it the same movie, and we
- 52:54should probably put down Memento because of it.
- 52:56So The Truman Show. I'm going to go noir with this
- 53:00one. I'll go way back to like the
- 53:011940s. I'm going to pick a movie called
- 53:03DOA, which is a movie about a guy.
- 53:06It's a really cool movie, Brad. It's about a guy who gets
- 53:09poisoned somehow with some sort of radioactive something, and he
- 53:12finds out that he has like 24 hours before he dies and he has
- 53:16to figure out who poisoned him before he croaks.
- 53:19It's a really good movie. You can't trust anybody.
- 53:23Motives are always called into question.
- 53:25I just we don't do a lot of noir on this podcast.
- 53:28And any chance that I get to plug, like, Really Hard Boiled,
- 53:32Mean Spirited Noir movies, I will do so.
- 53:35I'm going to pair it up with DOA.
- 53:37Brad's going to pair it up with The Truman Show.
- 53:40Now Bob, you have to be clear here because DOA could be
- 53:44referring to 1980 Eight's Dennis Quaid Meg Ryan starring film.
- 53:48That is the remake. Of the 1949 verse, is it 49 the
- 53:53original? 49 Yes, Or you could be talking
- 53:56about 2006, dead or alive. No, I'm referring to DOA, which
- 54:02in most parlance refers to dead on arrival.
- 54:05So that's the one I want 49, not the Dennis Quaid, not the 2649.
- 54:12Just just making sure we're clear here.
- 54:14I know we've had some miscommunication with.
- 54:15My gosh, you are just full of sass today Sir.
- 54:19Let's get to final scores. I'll let you go first so that I
- 54:22can I can calm my nerves over here.
- 54:25I think that the idea of Memento is way cooler than the actual
- 54:31film Memento. Like the the idea of it is
- 54:35really fascinating and really, really like draws you in.
- 54:41And the final 20 minutes of the film are like far and away the
- 54:45peak that this film has to offer.
- 54:48The rest of it's just okay. Like and like on the lower end
- 54:53of just okay. I'm going to give it a 7 out of
- 54:5510 Bob. But it was entertaining.
- 54:57Like it was fine. But it I don't think it's a
- 54:59movie I would ever want to come back to.
- 55:02I'm way higher on this movie than I thought that I would be.
- 55:05I was thinking about giving it an 8.5.
- 55:07I don't think I'm going to go that high because like I said,
- 55:10for a good chunk of the movie I was like, this is a four, what
- 55:13the heck, man? And it got to the ending, and
- 55:15the ending was so good that I have been left with this
- 55:18existential question of like, does a perfect ending cover a
- 55:21multitude of sins, right? Like how much does a perfect
- 55:26ending improve? A four out of 10 movie and I
- 55:30think by the time the ending came around, I was at least at
- 55:32like a six out of 10. But this movie has really
- 55:35serious flaws with it. But it is so brilliantly
- 55:38constructed and the ending is so good that I think people are
- 55:41willing to forgive a lot with this movie.
- 55:44I'm willing to forgive most of it, but I think you do have to
- 55:46keep in mind that this is not a perfect film.
- 55:49And so I'm going to come out to an 8 out of 10 way higher than I
- 55:52thought that I would be. And I will say to the film's
- 55:55credit. I've been thinking about it
- 55:57almost nonstop since we watched it.
- 55:59The problem is that sometimes I thought about it from the point
- 56:02of view of, like, does that even make sense?
- 56:04Like, did they only do that one thing because it's cool to not
- 56:09tell the audience that? Not every thought that I had
- 56:12about this movie has been positive, I guess is what I'll
- 56:14say. But at the end of the day, I've
- 56:16been thinking about it, and that is a largely positive thing to
- 56:19say. So I'm at an 8.
- 56:21Brad's at A7. We are coming out to once again
- 56:23a very easy to average 7.5 out of 10.
- 56:28Bob, do you want to know what movie I've been thinking about
- 56:30that I watched like two or three days after Memento?
- 56:33What's that? Bicycle Thieves?
- 56:37Brad, look at you. Do you like it?
- 56:40Big fan, like 9 out of 10? Absolutely love that movie.
- 56:45I don't know if there's ever been a better film.
- 56:48That captures the, like, hopelessness of being in
- 56:51poverty. So just beautiful.
- 56:55Also, we've talked about Haley Joel Osman in The Sixth Sense is
- 57:00the best child performance ever. Whoever the little kid is who
- 57:04plays Bruno might be the cutest child ever caught on film.
- 57:09Brad, I you know, once again, I don't mean to disparage or
- 57:12demean you, but like, what led to you watching The Bicycle
- 57:14Thieves? Because that seems like a movie
- 57:16that I would have had to pull teeth to get you to watch.
- 57:19Like what? What made you stumble upon that
- 57:21one? I was.
- 57:24I had a week off. I was up in the Akron area with
- 57:27my wife and kiddos and I was like just looking through HBO
- 57:31Max. And they have a Turner Classic
- 57:34movie section. And I was looking for something
- 57:36to watch. And I saw Bicycle Thieves and I
- 57:38was like, you know, that like I I looked back.
- 57:41I think it's like #38 on the most recent sight and sound
- 57:44pole. And a lot of people have it like
- 57:47in their top ten. And I was like, you know, I'm
- 57:50going to give it a try. It it is.
- 57:52But, you know, it really tips me into watching it, Bob.
- 57:54What's that it's like? 83 minutes and I was like less
- 58:00than less than 90 a man. All right man.
- 58:03So we are coming out to a 7.5 on Memento.
- 58:07I would really like to talk about the bicycle teams with you
- 58:09someday, but you got to save it for the pod, man.
- 58:11Can't give it all the way here. I'm so sorry.
- 58:14Let us know what you think about Memento Brad.
- 58:16We are definitely lower than most people on this movie.
- 58:19I think this has around an 8, either an 8.3 or an 8.4 on IMDb.
- 58:23It's definitely in their top 250.
- 58:25It's dude. I think it's in their top like
- 58:2720-5 or third. That's crazy.
- 58:31It has an 8.4 on IMDb and is. It's not that good guys.
- 58:38I will say that in that group of movies that are like they hit
- 58:42late Gen. X, early millennials at the
- 58:44right time and they were like cool guy movies, I think this
- 58:47might be the best of the bunch. Like, I think this is a better
- 58:49movie than Fight Club, or at least that it works better for
- 58:52me than Fight Club did, but. I still lump it in with those
- 58:56movies the like Boondock, Saints, Fight Club, Memento,
- 59:01even The Matrix to some extent. But The Matrix is just a way
- 59:03better movie than any of these. I I just, I've never understood
- 59:07why we inflate that group of movies in the cultural like
- 59:12consciousness. Because regardless of the fact
- 59:14that I like it better than you Brad.
- 59:16This is not one of the 25 best films ever made.
- 59:19What are you people talking about?
- 59:20So I will say I will. I was wrong.
- 59:22I just looked it up. But I'm going to make you angry
- 59:24Bob. This movie is number 55 on IMDb
- 59:28at with an 8.4 is at #55 right in front of In Order Django
- 59:34Unchained, Indiana Jones and Raiders of the Lost, Art and and
- 59:38Wally all. All three all better than this.
- 59:43Way better films than Memento. Well, film and Whiskey Nation, I
- 59:47think we've given you some fuel. Do you agree or disagree with us
- 59:50about Memento? You can find us on our social
- 59:52media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, or TikTok
- 59:56at. Filmwhiskey or you can jump onto
- 59:59a Discord. We are on there every single day
- 1:00:01talking to you guys, the fans of the Film and Whiskey Podcast.
- 1:00:05So if you want to join the conversation on Discord, you can
- 1:00:07find a link to it at the end of every single one of our show
- 1:00:10notes. Next week we will be back with a
- 1:00:12very special guest talking about a movie that I have a
- 1:00:15contentious relationship with and that is one of Nolan's
- 1:00:19highest regarded films, The Prestige.
- 1:00:22Join us next week for that, but until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:00:25I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.