Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: Trump Trial Nears End & SCOTUS Sides with GOP
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: As your plans to testify.
- 0:12Speaker 2: Yeah, I would testify absolutely.
- 0:14Speaker 3: It's a scam.
- 0:15Speaker 4: It's a scam.
- 0:16Speaker 3: That's not a trial. That's not a tran that's a scam.
- 0:19Speaker 5: Donald Trump wants vowed to take the witness stand in
- 0:23Speaker 5: his hush money criminal trial, but the defense wrapped up
- 0:26Speaker 5: its case this week without jurors hearing from the former president.
- 0:30Speaker 5: Here's how Trump explained his reason for not testifying on
- 0:34Speaker 5: WABC radio on Wednesday.
- 0:37Speaker 3: Yeah, because he made rulings that makes it very difficult
- 0:42Speaker 3: to testify anything I did, anything I did in the past.
- 0:46Speaker 3: They can bring everything up, and you know what, I've
- 0:49Speaker 3: had a great pass but anything but the other thing
- 0:53Speaker 3: is and the main reason, and I don't even mind that.
- 0:55Speaker 3: In fact, I like talking about it, because we had
- 0:58Speaker 3: rigged cases.
- 1:00Speaker 5: The jury has heard a month of dramatic and sometimes
- 1:03Speaker 5: tawdry testimony from a tabloid publisher, a porn star, a
- 1:07Speaker 5: long time Trump aide, and his former fixer turned star witness.
- 1:12Speaker 5: As the prosecution tried to prove its case, charging Trump
- 1:16Speaker 5: with thirty four counts of falsifying business records. The defense
- 1:20Speaker 5: put on two witnesses, but their case mainly consisted of
- 1:24Speaker 5: cross examining the prosecution's witnesses to poke hold in the
- 1:28Speaker 5: case against Trump. Closing arguments our schedule for Tuesday, followed
- 1:32Speaker 5: by jury instructions, and then this Manhattan jury will begin
- 1:36Speaker 5: deliberating whether Trump falsified his company's records to hide a
- 1:40Speaker 5: hush money payment to porn star Stormy Daniels and influence
- 1:44Speaker 5: the twenty sixteen election. To get a conviction, the prosecution
- 1:48Speaker 5: must convince all twelve jurors beyond a reasonable doubt that
- 1:53Speaker 5: Trump falsified or caused the records to be falsified with
- 1:56Speaker 5: the intent to commit or conceal another crime. Any verdict
- 2:01Speaker 5: must be unanimous, but the defense only has to create
- 2:04Speaker 5: doubt in the mind of one juror to get a mistrial.
- 2:08Speaker 5: Joining me is criminal defense attorney Jeremy Saland he was
- 2:11Speaker 5: formerly a prosecutor in the Manhattan DA's office. Jeremy, let's
- 2:15Speaker 5: start with the cross examination of the prosecution's star witness,
- 2:19Speaker 5: Michael Cohen. The defense attorney was very aggressive. How effective
- 2:25Speaker 5: was he in undermining Cohen's credibility which sort of hangs
- 2:29Speaker 5: by a thread.
- 2:29Speaker 6: Anyway, I think that there was diminishing returns in the
- 2:34Speaker 6: times that Branche kept him on the stand, the lack
- 2:38Speaker 6: of what I thought was enough leading questions as opposed
- 2:41Speaker 6: to open ending questions from what I read. And I
- 2:43Speaker 6: also thought that there were times when he hits some
- 2:45Speaker 6: of the same points over and over, and that goes
- 2:48Speaker 6: back to the diminishing returns. And it's not just diminishing
- 2:50Speaker 6: returns in that you lose the jury they get the point,
- 2:53Speaker 6: but you also run the risk of opening certain doors.
- 2:56Speaker 6: The end of his cross examination went flat. It could
- 2:59Speaker 6: have been better, but at the same time, it exposed
- 3:02Speaker 6: Michael Cohen for who he was, which is a conniving, dishonest,
- 3:07Speaker 6: selfish person with an agenda to really hurt the former president.
- 3:11Speaker 6: Now I will say this though, and this shouldn't be
- 3:13Speaker 6: lost on anybody, when we think of John Gotti, I'm
- 3:16Speaker 6: not comparing the two of saying Donald Trump is John Gotti.
- 3:19Speaker 6: But who was the main cooperator in that case? It
- 3:22Speaker 6: was Sammy the Bull. So when we hear up beating
- 3:25Speaker 6: up Michael Cohen and we hear about the attacks on
- 3:27Speaker 6: Michael Cohen, you know he's not Sammy the Bull. And
- 3:30Speaker 6: if Sammy the Bull who was alleged to have committed
- 3:32Speaker 6: I believes nineteen some odd murders could cooperate and have credibility,
- 3:36Speaker 6: and there could be a finding of guilt against John
- 3:39Speaker 6: Gotti for that matter. How many people love the movie
- 3:41Speaker 6: Goodfellas that's based on Henry Hill. Henry Hill was a
- 3:44Speaker 6: cooperator who had a rap sheet in all sorts of
- 3:47Speaker 6: bad things, and people love Henry Hill. Well, at least
- 3:49Speaker 6: they loved Rayleiota in the movie. So let's have some
- 3:52Speaker 6: perspective here. You don't catch the main bad guy. You
- 3:54Speaker 6: don't get the kingpin. You don't get the main drug dealer,
- 3:57Speaker 6: you don't get the main mobster. Not saying it again,
- 4:00Speaker 6: that's who Donald Trump was. But you don't get him
- 4:03Speaker 6: or her unless you get the person who is next
- 4:06Speaker 6: in line, a lieutenant, a worker, the dealer, the guy
- 4:09Speaker 6: who cuts the drugs, the guy who counts the money.
- 4:11Speaker 6: You don't get that unless you have some of those
- 4:13Speaker 6: dirty hands. That's how you get the big boss.
- 4:15Speaker 5: The defense called two witnesses in their case. The last
- 4:18Speaker 5: one was lawyer Bob Costello, who I think they called
- 4:22Speaker 5: to damage Cohen's credibility even further, but he ended up
- 4:26Speaker 5: acting out on the witness stand, being disrespectful to the judge,
- 4:30Speaker 5: rolling his eyes, muttering on the stand, and at one
- 4:33Speaker 5: point it was incredible. The judge said to him, are
- 4:36Speaker 5: you staring me down right now? And the judge cleared
- 4:39Speaker 5: the courtroom.
- 4:40Speaker 6: Really disappointing if I'm Donald Trump's team in Donald Trump,
- 4:44Speaker 6: because you have a witness who objectively could have shared
- 4:47Speaker 6: some really valuable information about Michael Cohen, supposedly telling him
- 4:51Speaker 6: that Donald Trump wasn't aware that basically Donald Trump was
- 4:53Speaker 6: not in the noah on what was going on, but
- 4:55Speaker 6: it was lost in the petulance, sophomoric, amateur behavior from
- 5:00Speaker 6: a guy who served in his senior capacity at the
- 5:03Speaker 6: US Attorney's Office. This is not his first rodeo. What
- 5:06Speaker 6: he was thinking, he shot his own credibility in the foot.
- 5:10Speaker 6: You know, don't run your mouth, show respect to the court.
- 5:13Speaker 6: You may be a fed and you look down on
- 5:15Speaker 6: the state. Maybe that's a little desarrogance. I don't know,
- 5:17Speaker 6: but you're in a court of law and follow the
- 5:19Speaker 6: court's instructions. And as I tell every witness, every witness,
- 5:23Speaker 6: kill him with kindness. Looked the defense or prosecution in
- 5:26Speaker 6: the eyes, look the jury in the eyes, be respectful,
- 5:29Speaker 6: be the bigger person. That's what he did not do.
- 5:32Speaker 6: And I'm really surprised. I'm really surprised.
- 5:35Speaker 5: So the biggest news to come out of the trial
- 5:37Speaker 5: this week was no news. Actually Trump had vowed to
- 5:40Speaker 5: testify in his own defense, then started backing off. I
- 5:43Speaker 5: don't know that any defense lawyer would have encouraged him
- 5:47Speaker 5: to testify. So was that the right decision?
- 5:50Speaker 6: Unequivocally, absolutely, and any criminal defense attorney would say, especially
- 5:55Speaker 6: in a case like this where he has a chance
- 5:57Speaker 6: to have do I think he can get an acquittal
- 5:58Speaker 6: and know but going down on the limb here I
- 6:00Speaker 6: may be completely totally wrong. If I could read juries,
- 6:03Speaker 6: I would be charging a lot more. I think we
- 6:05Speaker 6: all would with it. None of us could read a
- 6:07Speaker 6: jury's mind. But every New Yorker knows the term hutz book,
- 6:10Speaker 6: and he did not have the hutzpur to get up there.
- 6:12Speaker 6: Despite his behavior and his demeanor. He would get eviscerated,
- 6:15Speaker 6: he would get hung out to dry. And if he
- 6:17Speaker 6: has a chance of beating this case, he would have
- 6:19Speaker 6: lost it if he ran his mouth, because he would
- 6:21Speaker 6: have opened up door after door. And as bad as
- 6:23Speaker 6: Costello was and as good. Frankly, as Michael Cohen was.
- 6:27Speaker 6: None of them, even on their worst day, would have
- 6:29Speaker 6: done what Donald Trump would have potentially done on that stand.
- 6:32Speaker 6: So it was a smart move, an intelligent move, common
- 6:35Speaker 6: sense move, not to get up and testify.
- 6:37Speaker 5: Looking at the prosecution's case, has the prosecution made out
- 6:42Speaker 5: its case?
- 6:42Speaker 4: Do you think I thought.
- 6:44Speaker 6: The evidence went in pretty well? There is an element
- 6:46Speaker 6: of common sense that is so critically important here. You know,
- 6:50Speaker 6: if I'm the prosecution, I'm arguing saying, you have Weifelberg's
- 6:54Speaker 6: handwriting on these notes. It's not just Michael Cohen. It's
- 6:57Speaker 6: not just Stormy Daniels. You have phone law, you have
- 7:00Speaker 6: other witnesses. You have Hope Hicks, who puts people in
- 7:03Speaker 6: certain places at certain times, who describes Michael Cohen not
- 7:06Speaker 6: as a giving, generous person that he's going to go
- 7:08Speaker 6: out on a limb here a man who I believe
- 7:10Speaker 6: made roughly a half a million dollars a year and
- 7:12Speaker 6: took a whole equity line of credit up and was
- 7:14Speaker 6: going to bear responsibility and take ownership for those dollars.
- 7:18Speaker 6: That seems pretty unlikely. So I think very much that
- 7:21Speaker 6: the evidence went well. Will the jury convict that's tough.
- 7:24Speaker 6: But all they need is want to remember. All they
- 7:25Speaker 6: need is want to hang in the defense.
- 7:27Speaker 5: Legally, the case gets complicated because the prosecution, as you know,
- 7:33Speaker 5: is out to make these misdemeanors of falsifying business records
- 7:37Speaker 5: into a felony, so it has to be done with
- 7:39Speaker 5: the intent to commit another crime. How tricky is that?
- 7:42Speaker 5: For prosecutors.
- 7:44Speaker 6: It's tricky because a couple things. When the jury gets
- 7:48Speaker 6: the case, a judge can instruct the jury on what's
- 7:50Speaker 6: called a lesser included offense, meaning the judge can tell
- 7:54Speaker 6: the jury, you can consider the felonies on the indictment,
- 7:56Speaker 6: but even if you don't find the felony, you could
- 7:59Speaker 6: find for the miss demeanor of that same falsifying business records.
- 8:02Speaker 6: That's what's called the lesser included defense, even though it's
- 8:04Speaker 6: not actually charged. Now, the question I would ask is,
- 8:07Speaker 6: if I'm the prosecution, do I ask the judge not
- 8:09Speaker 6: to submit that? If I'm the defense, do I ask
- 8:12Speaker 6: the judge to submit it or not to submit it?
- 8:14Speaker 6: Why do I ask that? Because in my view, a
- 8:17Speaker 6: conviction on the misdemeanor is a loss, and that's ed
- 8:20Speaker 6: on the face of Alvin Bragg. It's really all or nothing.
- 8:22Speaker 6: So it's either a conviction on the felony or an acquittal.
- 8:25Speaker 6: If I'm the defense, do I want to make the
- 8:27Speaker 6: jury make that decision and don't give them the sort
- 8:29Speaker 6: of compromise. It's either is or it isn't. So it's
- 8:32Speaker 6: an interesting question whether they're going to want the judge
- 8:34Speaker 6: to instruct the jury or it's all or nothing. That's
- 8:36Speaker 6: number one. The other difficulty is, you know, what is
- 8:39Speaker 6: that other crime? Now you don't have to prove that
- 8:41Speaker 6: crime beyond or reasonable doubt that you're trying to conceal
- 8:44Speaker 6: some election crime. So don't misconstrue that to prove this
- 8:48Speaker 6: secondary element to make it the felony, the intent to
- 8:51Speaker 6: commit or conceal this other crime, that you have to
- 8:53Speaker 6: actually prove beyond a reasonable doubt that other crime. But
- 8:56Speaker 6: you know, I see as much strong evidence as you
- 8:59Speaker 6: did about actual direct evidence of falsifying business records or
- 9:03Speaker 6: the circumstantial evidence, it was more difficult. So I see
- 9:06Speaker 6: the misdemeanor as an easy conviction, Frankreet, from what they've done.
- 9:10Speaker 6: The selony is going to be a little bit harder.
- 9:12Speaker 6: I think they did a good job, but I think
- 9:13Speaker 6: it's still going to be hard.
- 9:14Speaker 5: The jury instructions are always important. How much depends on
- 9:19Speaker 5: how the judge frames the instructions for that second crime.
- 9:23Speaker 6: Well, there was some argument back and forth if I
- 9:26Speaker 6: recall about whether there was two intents, and that's what
- 9:29Speaker 6: the defense was asking for. It the intent to defraud
- 9:31Speaker 6: and deceive, and you have to have the intent to
- 9:33Speaker 6: commit another crime. There's an expanded definition of intent, for example,
- 9:37Speaker 6: and that's in the actual jury instructions, where there's a
- 9:40Speaker 6: charge solely for intent as opposed to the intent you
- 9:42Speaker 6: will find in the charge for the particular crime, which
- 9:44Speaker 6: is the same across the board, which is basically it's
- 9:46Speaker 6: your objective and goal, which is an expanded version. So
- 9:49Speaker 6: this is a complicated case, but it's not. It's fairly straightforward.
- 9:54Speaker 6: And if the jury has problems, they can go back
- 9:56Speaker 6: and ask for the judge to reinstruct them. They can
- 9:58Speaker 6: go back and ask to hear the Tran script again,
- 10:00Speaker 6: and to listen to testimony again. But framing it has
- 10:03Speaker 6: to be done on the right way. I have confidence
- 10:05Speaker 6: that the court will. I have zero worry about that.
- 10:08Speaker 6: But people are people. This is an intelligent jury. These
- 10:10Speaker 6: are new Yorkers. They could find reasonable doubt, I'm sure,
- 10:13Speaker 6: and they could find proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 10:15Speaker 5: Has there been any real testimony or evidence on Trump's
- 10:20Speaker 5: intent or motivation.
- 10:22Speaker 6: The prosecution does not have to prove motive that is
- 10:26Speaker 6: not an element of the crime. As much as we
- 10:29Speaker 6: want to add that in as prosecutors and defense attorneys
- 10:32Speaker 6: may challenge or add their own motives, it's not a requirement. So,
- 10:35Speaker 6: for example, if your motive was to protect your family,
- 10:37Speaker 6: as the allegations were on the form of President's side,
- 10:40Speaker 6: as opposed to prosecution allegations, which was to fix or
- 10:43Speaker 6: protect the election, there is no requirement that that motive
- 10:47Speaker 6: be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. I will say, however,
- 10:51Speaker 6: if I'm the prosecution, I would say, even if you
- 10:53Speaker 6: believe that that was his motive that was to protect Millennia,
- 10:57Speaker 6: what I would say is they're not mutually exclusive. You
- 10:59Speaker 6: can want to protect your family and had the intention
- 11:01Speaker 6: of protecting your family, and there's the intent, not the motive.
- 11:03Speaker 6: But he also had the intent to protect himself in
- 11:05Speaker 6: the election and make sure this didn't get out to
- 11:07Speaker 6: protect the election. So it's a mixed band. And in
- 11:10Speaker 6: terms of the evidence coming in. This goes back to
- 11:12Speaker 6: that common sense. This goes back to why are they
- 11:15Speaker 6: paying for it? If you believe Trump had his hands
- 11:17Speaker 6: in it? You know, why is he paying for this
- 11:19Speaker 6: at this time, right before the election is about to hit,
- 11:22Speaker 6: as things were going sideways, and you have Hope Hicks
- 11:25Speaker 6: telling you that, you know, this could be really, really
- 11:28Speaker 6: detrimental to women voters. I think they did the job
- 11:31Speaker 6: they needed to do, even if not directly because you
- 11:33Speaker 6: don't hear from the Donald Trump, but circumstantially through all
- 11:36Speaker 6: the other evidence and testimony. This is not easy. And
- 11:40Speaker 6: you know, as much as all this want to pontificate
- 11:42Speaker 6: and say I believe ex or I believe why, I'm
- 11:44Speaker 6: not going down on a limb other than to say
- 11:47Speaker 6: that I do believe the case went in well. I
- 11:50Speaker 6: do believe that the prosecution proved their case. You know,
- 11:52Speaker 6: I don't think that Blanche and his team did the
- 11:55Speaker 6: job they needed to do. Michael Cohen kept his composure
- 11:59Speaker 6: up there. I thought they beat up Stormy Daniel a
- 12:01Speaker 6: little too much. I do think that the defense their
- 12:04Speaker 6: main way I think they'll take this down or tear
- 12:06Speaker 6: this apart is you can't believe Stormy Daniels. She's an extortionist, blackmailer,
- 12:10Speaker 6: and you can't believe you know a guy who's a thieving, malicious,
- 12:14Speaker 6: vengeful guy in Michael Cohen, who is a known liar,
- 12:17Speaker 6: and make it about the two of them, as opposed
- 12:19Speaker 6: to making about falsifying business records. And the prosecution has
- 12:23Speaker 6: to do the job and bring it solely back to
- 12:25Speaker 6: falsifying business records.
- 12:27Speaker 5: Next week is going to be very interesting and we
- 12:30Speaker 5: may even get a jury verdict before the end of
- 12:32Speaker 5: the week. Thanks so much, Jeremy. That's criminal defense attorney
- 12:35Speaker 5: Jeremy Salande. I'm June Grosso when you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 12:40Speaker 5: By a six to three vote down ideological lines, the
- 12:44Speaker 5: Supreme Court's conservatives upheld a Republican drawn congressional map in
- 12:48Speaker 5: South Carolina, rejecting a lower courts finding that lawmakers unconstitutionally
- 12:54Speaker 5: relied on race when drawing the map. In the majority opinion,
- 12:59Speaker 5: Justice Samuel Alito echoed the position he'd taken during the
- 13:03Speaker 5: oral arguments, saying the challengers had not shown that race,
- 13:06Speaker 5: rather than partis in politics, was the driving factor in
- 13:10Speaker 5: drawing the map and flood out rejecting the evidence the
- 13:13Speaker 5: three judge panel had found after trial, At.
- 13:17Speaker 1: Least as a practical matter, in a case in which
- 13:20Speaker 1: there is no direct evidence or virtually no direct evidence,
- 13:24Speaker 1: there is no way in which a plaintiff can disentangle
- 13:28Speaker 1: race and politics, except by providing an alternative map.
- 13:34Speaker 5: Just as Elena Kagan wrote a scathing descent for the
- 13:37Speaker 5: three Liberals, saying the majority's decision signals that state legislators
- 13:42Speaker 5: can now use race as a proxy to achieve partisan ends.
- 13:47Speaker 5: As she told South Carolina's attorney, you.
- 13:50Speaker 4: Think, well, the evidence showed that we were just doing politics.
- 13:53Speaker 4: The court said, no, the evidence showed that you were
- 13:56Speaker 4: doing race as a proxy for politics, and surely there
- 14:00Speaker 4: were good reasons to do race as a proxy for politics.
- 14:03Speaker 5: Here, with this decision, the court is making it much
- 14:06Speaker 5: more difficult for plaintiffs in the future to challenge maps
- 14:10Speaker 5: based on racial discrimination. Joining me is election law expert
- 14:14Speaker 5: Richard Brefald, a professor at Columbia Law School, rich explain
- 14:18Speaker 5: Alito's reasoning. In the majority opinion.
- 14:20Speaker 7: The majority concluded that the three judge court below the
- 14:23Speaker 7: district Court erred that there was clear error in finding
- 14:27Speaker 7: that the redistricting of District one in South Carolina was
- 14:30Speaker 7: done on the basis of race rather than on the
- 14:32Speaker 7: basis of party. The court recognized that racial jerry mannering
- 14:35Speaker 7: and partisan jury mannering often look alike. Said the burden
- 14:38Speaker 7: was on the plaintiffs to show that this was race
- 14:40Speaker 7: and not party. And then the court then kind of
- 14:43Speaker 7: carefully picked apart and quite to tail the findings of
- 14:46Speaker 7: the district court and concluded that the district court had
- 14:48Speaker 7: made a mistake in concluding based on the evidence that
- 14:51Speaker 7: this was racial rather than partisan.
- 14:53Speaker 5: I mean, the district had heard evidence right and made
- 14:56Speaker 5: these conclusions that the Republican lawmakers established a of seventeen
- 15:00Speaker 5: percent black voters for the first district. Alito said the
- 15:04Speaker 5: state had strong evidence that the seventeen percent figure was
- 15:07Speaker 5: simply a side effect of the legislature's partisan goal. What
- 15:12Speaker 5: evidence is he talking about.
- 15:14Speaker 7: Well, the thing is normally, when you're viewing a district
- 15:17Speaker 7: court's findings a fact, the burden is on the state
- 15:19Speaker 7: to show that the district court was completely wrong. And
- 15:22Speaker 7: here he seems to have put the burden more on
- 15:25Speaker 7: the plaintiffs, not just in the original case where they
- 15:28Speaker 7: persuaded the district court, but also in the Supreme Court
- 15:31Speaker 7: to show that the district court was right as opposed
- 15:34Speaker 7: to being reasonable. I mean, in some ways there's an
- 15:37Speaker 7: argument that he in applying with is theoretically a differential
- 15:40Speaker 7: standard to the district court. The Senative clearly erroneous. He
- 15:44Speaker 7: went much further and in some sense reviewed all the
- 15:47Speaker 7: facts himself and concluded that on his reading of the
- 15:50Speaker 7: facts and his reading of the expert testimony, the plaintiffs
- 15:53Speaker 7: had not made their case.
- 15:55Speaker 5: He also said that a party challenging a map's constitutionality
- 15:59Speaker 5: must disentangle race and politics if it wishes to prove
- 16:02Speaker 5: the legislature was motivated by race as opposed to partisanship,
- 16:06Speaker 5: and the challenges provided no direct evidence of a racial gerrymander.
- 16:10Speaker 5: Is he looking for a statement by a Republican lawmaker
- 16:13Speaker 5: or we're doing this because of race.
- 16:16Speaker 7: Mean, it basically said you could either do it by
- 16:18Speaker 7: direct evidence like a smoking gun statement, or by strong
- 16:22Speaker 7: circumstantial evidence. And hear what the plants were about the
- 16:24Speaker 7: show is, if you look at the numbers, there was
- 16:26Speaker 7: a huge movement of people in and out of this district.
- 16:30Speaker 7: The map makers dramatically move large numbers of people around.
- 16:33Speaker 7: In particular, they seem to be moving more black voters
- 16:37Speaker 7: out and more white voters in, and that in the end,
- 16:40Speaker 7: with all of the movement, that sixteen point eight percent
- 16:43Speaker 7: number was a number that the Republicans felt was low
- 16:46Speaker 7: enough so the district would continue to chill Republican His
- 16:49Speaker 7: view is that was really about partisanship. The plaintiff's view
- 16:53Speaker 7: and the district courts view was that no, that show
- 16:56Speaker 7: that they were engaged in a racial gerrymander. They moved
- 16:58Speaker 7: like one hundred and eighty thousand people around. What their
- 17:01Speaker 7: target was to keep the racial fraction the same, and
- 17:04Speaker 7: they did it by moving black voters in one direction
- 17:07Speaker 7: and white vote in a different direction.
- 17:08Speaker 5: Justice Kagan wrote a blistering dissent for the three liberals.
- 17:13Speaker 5: She said the majority was stacking the deck against the
- 17:16Speaker 5: challengers by presuming legislatures are acting in good faith. Go
- 17:20Speaker 5: right ahead, this court says to states today, it will
- 17:23Speaker 5: be easy enough to cover your tracks in the end.
- 17:26Speaker 5: Just raise a possibility of non race based decision making
- 17:30Speaker 5: and it will be dispositive. And she quotes from Alito's opinion,
- 17:35Speaker 5: taking him head on.
- 17:36Speaker 7: Yeah, I mean Alito begins with the basic premise that
- 17:39Speaker 7: whenever a law is challenged, their law has presumptively valid.
- 17:43Speaker 7: The burden is on the plaintiffs to show that it's invalid.
- 17:46Speaker 7: And that's the kind of judicial review one on one,
- 17:48Speaker 7: as you begin with the presumption of validity. But she's
- 17:51Speaker 7: saying he's taking it so far that he's using it
- 17:54Speaker 7: not at the opening stage of the case, but on
- 17:56Speaker 7: the appeal following a determination by the district court, a
- 18:00Speaker 7: lengthy trial with lots of testimony, lots of exhibits, lots
- 18:03Speaker 7: of depositions, the three judge panel that found the other way,
- 18:06Speaker 7: And so she's saying that in effect, he's putting such
- 18:08Speaker 7: a heavy thumb on the scale for the legislature that
- 18:11Speaker 7: he's making it almost impossible for plaintiffs to prevail in
- 18:13Speaker 7: a case, even after they prevail before the district court.
- 18:16Speaker 5: Is this decision raising the bar for winning a challenge
- 18:20Speaker 5: to a map based on racial gerrymandering.
- 18:23Speaker 7: I think it is. I mean, I think basically the
- 18:25Speaker 7: burden is now even heavier on the plaintiffs to disentangle
- 18:29Speaker 7: race from party and to show it was clearly race
- 18:32Speaker 7: and not party, as opposed to the intertwining that we
- 18:35Speaker 7: often see. So I do think although technically he's applying
- 18:38Speaker 7: the same standards as before, he is now playing them
- 18:41Speaker 7: in a much tougher way. He's also added a kind
- 18:43Speaker 7: of requirement that court had rejected as a requirement before,
- 18:47Speaker 7: which is that the plaintiffs produce an alternative map which
- 18:50Speaker 7: produces the same partisan results but with a different racial makeup,
- 18:54Speaker 7: to show that it really was race and not party
- 18:57Speaker 7: that was driving this. The Court in the past that
- 18:59Speaker 7: said having a map is helpful, but now he has
- 19:01Speaker 7: come very close to making it a requirement.
- 19:04Speaker 5: It is difficult to separate race from politics. But does
- 19:09Speaker 5: this give, as Elena Kagan said, state lawmakers an incentive
- 19:15Speaker 5: to use race as a proxy to achieve part as
- 19:18Speaker 5: it ends.
- 19:19Speaker 7: Yes, I think until now the Court has said that
- 19:21Speaker 7: although we won't hear parties in jerry mandering cases, we
- 19:24Speaker 7: will hear claims of racial gerrymandering. So it was one
- 19:27Speaker 7: way in which plaintiffs couldn't directly attack the partners in jerrymander,
- 19:31Speaker 7: but they could try and do that, or they could
- 19:33Speaker 7: show that it was also a racial gerrymander. Now the
- 19:36Speaker 7: Court has pretty much made that impossible, or made it
- 19:39Speaker 7: an even much much harder to be able to make
- 19:41Speaker 7: a racial gerrymanderin claim outside the context of party. I
- 19:45Speaker 7: suppose you could have a racial jerrymanderin claim in a
- 19:47Speaker 7: one party state, But in a situation where race and
- 19:49Speaker 7: party are so intertwined, it's going to be much harder
- 19:51Speaker 7: to make any kind of racial gerrymanderin claim.
- 19:54Speaker 5: So for anyone who thought that the Conservatives had changed
- 19:58Speaker 5: when the Court ruled that Alabama Republicans violated the Voting
- 20:02Speaker 5: Rights Act, is this proof that, no, it hasn't changed.
- 20:07Speaker 7: I think it shows the ongoing difficulty of dealing with
- 20:12Speaker 7: these districting disputes when race and party are so intertwined.
- 20:16Speaker 7: And yes, that case, the Alabama case was a case
- 20:19Speaker 7: where the court did different to the findings of the
- 20:21Speaker 7: lower court, and they're the point is didn't vide alternative
- 20:24Speaker 7: maps to show that the district could be done in
- 20:27Speaker 7: a different way. But I think in some ways that
- 20:29Speaker 7: it really does show the court's kind of impatience with
- 20:32Speaker 7: the effort to possibly outslank the court's unwillingness to hear
- 20:36Speaker 7: partisan jury mannering claims by hearing racial jury mannering claims
- 20:40Speaker 7: where if the plaintiffs win, the victory would be similar
- 20:43Speaker 7: to the victory to partisan jurry mentoring case. I think
- 20:45Speaker 7: they've just made that much harder. It's not impossible.
- 20:48Speaker 5: We've been talking about the constitutional challenge to South Carolina's
- 20:51Speaker 5: map based on the Equal Protection Clause, but didn't the
- 20:55Speaker 5: challengers also bring a claim based on the Voting Rights Act.
- 20:59Speaker 7: They'd bring a voting rightsack boat dilution claim, which they
- 21:03Speaker 7: won on, but the court said the lower court erred
- 21:05Speaker 7: on that as well, because the lower courts have applied
- 21:08Speaker 7: the same standard, and it's a different standard both dilution cases.
- 21:11Speaker 7: So if they were reversed and remanded, so if there's
- 21:13Speaker 7: going to be a trial on that, it would be
- 21:15Speaker 7: there different claim. I think they are somewhat different theories.
- 21:18Speaker 7: The theory of legal protection claim is that the state's
- 21:21Speaker 7: motivation was predominantly racial. Doesn't have to show that there
- 21:25Speaker 7: was an underrepresentation of black voters, but just that the
- 21:28Speaker 7: state was purposely drawing lines based on race. And whereas
- 21:32Speaker 7: both dilution you don't even have to show that race
- 21:34Speaker 7: was intentional. What you do have to show is that
- 21:38Speaker 7: as a result of the line drawing, black voters or
- 21:40Speaker 7: voters of color were underrepresented that it was more difficult
- 21:44Speaker 7: for them to win elections than otherwise.
- 21:47Speaker 5: Would you say that for the last decade or so,
- 21:51Speaker 5: the Roberts Court's decisions have made it harder for black
- 21:56Speaker 5: voters to challenge redistricting plans.
- 21:59Speaker 7: Well, the Roberts Court obviously famously got rid of Section
- 22:02Speaker 7: five of the Voting Rights Act, which required dates in
- 22:05Speaker 7: covered jurisdictions to get Justice carp and approval first, so
- 22:08Speaker 7: therefore actually putting the burden on plaintiffs to go ahead.
- 22:11Speaker 7: I think how they've handled vote dilution cases has been
- 22:14Speaker 7: a little inconsistent. As you point out, plaintiff is one
- 22:17Speaker 7: of vote dilution case from Alabama last year. This was
- 22:20Speaker 7: tecondally a constitutional case, so it's a little hard to
- 22:23Speaker 7: characterize sometimes plaintiffs in one, but certainly this one I
- 22:26Speaker 7: think is going to make it much harder for plaintiffs
- 22:29Speaker 7: to win cases like this.
- 22:31Speaker 5: As you know, the Republicans hold this razor thin majority
- 22:35Speaker 5: in the House, and the outcome of this case another
- 22:39Speaker 5: redistricting cases could help determine which party controls the House
- 22:43Speaker 5: for the next decade. As far as the cases that
- 22:46Speaker 5: have been decided so far, do the Republicans have an advantage?
- 22:50Speaker 3: Now?
- 22:51Speaker 7: My understanding is that the Republicans have gained slightly through
- 22:54Speaker 7: the registrict process because of a partisan gerrymander. They pushed
- 22:58Speaker 7: it in North Carolina the North Carolina Supreme Court change dance.
- 23:02Speaker 7: North Carolina Supreme Court had struck down a Republican gerrymander
- 23:05Speaker 7: in North Carolina, so the state was seven to six
- 23:08Speaker 7: Republican Democrat. Once the North Carolina Supreme Court changed over,
- 23:11Speaker 7: the legislature re redistricted, and it's now going to be
- 23:14Speaker 7: ten to three. So I think there was a big
- 23:16Speaker 7: Republican pick up in North Carolina. The rest of the
- 23:19Speaker 7: country I think is a little mixed. There may be
- 23:21Speaker 7: a Democratic pick up in Alabama. Maybe went in Louisiana
- 23:24Speaker 7: as a result of redistricting, But North Carolina was a
- 23:27Speaker 7: big win for the Republicans.
- 23:28Speaker 5: The Republicans were bold in North Carolina, while the Democrats
- 23:32Speaker 5: were timid in New York.
- 23:34Speaker 7: Not clear that New York is going to change right
- 23:35Speaker 7: in the end, the new Planet in New York tinkered
- 23:38Speaker 7: very slightly with the districts in a very very close election.
- 23:41Speaker 7: That might make a difference, But the New York re
- 23:43Speaker 7: redistricting did not make big changes.
- 23:45Speaker 5: Yeah, it's puzzling why the Democrats even bothered with all
- 23:49Speaker 5: the litigation. Thanks so much, rich that Professor Richard Ruffald
- 23:53Speaker 5: of Columbia Law School coming up next on the Bloomberg
- 23:56Speaker 5: Law Show. Why Google cut a check for the US
- 23:59Speaker 5: government and will it work? I'm June Grosso, and you're
- 24:02Speaker 5: listening to Bloomberg.
- 24:04Speaker 2: As alleged in our complaint, for fifteen years, Google has
- 24:08Speaker 2: pursued a course of anti competitive conduct that has allowed
- 24:12Speaker 2: it to halt the rise of rival technologies, manipulate auction
- 24:16Speaker 2: mechanics to insulate itself from competition, and force advertisers and
- 24:21Speaker 2: publishers to use its tools.
- 24:23Speaker 5: The Justice Department suit accusing Google of monopolizing the digital
- 24:27Speaker 5: advertising market is scheduled to go to trial before a
- 24:31Speaker 5: jury in September, but Google is trying to avoid trying
- 24:35Speaker 5: the case to a jury with a novel move cutting
- 24:38Speaker 5: the government a check. The search giant wants a judge,
- 24:42Speaker 5: not a jury, to decide the case and argues that
- 24:45Speaker 5: government has no right to a jury trial without a
- 24:48Speaker 5: claim for money damages. Joining me to discuss this novel
- 24:53Speaker 5: and perhaps feudal move is antitrust law expert Harry First,
- 24:57Speaker 5: a professor at NYU Law School, how has this been
- 25:00Speaker 5: done before, paying damages before a trial or a finding
- 25:05Speaker 5: of liability?
- 25:06Speaker 8: Not to my knowledge, it's a you know, you might
- 25:09Speaker 8: say a clever move, or you might say it's a
- 25:11Speaker 8: silly move, or you might say, when it's Google, who cares?
- 25:15Speaker 8: How many millions of dollars you may pay unnecessarily? So
- 25:19Speaker 8: I've never seen this before. Liligans don't usually pay out
- 25:22Speaker 8: money in advance of a trial, an advance of even losing,
- 25:27Speaker 8: So you got to have a lot of money to
- 25:28Speaker 8: do that.
- 25:29Speaker 5: The Google argument is that without a monetary damage's claim,
- 25:33Speaker 5: the government has no right to a jury trial. Is
- 25:36Speaker 5: that true?
- 25:37Speaker 8: Well, Google's argument is, let's see, should we call it silly,
- 25:42Speaker 8: ridiculous or desperate? I don't know. So if you are
- 25:46Speaker 8: not asking for money, go back to day one. You
- 25:49Speaker 8: file a complaint and all you're asking for is an injunction.
- 25:53Speaker 8: That is what's called a suit in equity and is
- 25:57Speaker 8: just handled by a judge. That's the way case have
- 26:00Speaker 8: been handled since common law period. If, on the other hand,
- 26:04Speaker 8: you go into court and you ask for money damages,
- 26:07Speaker 8: that has to be before a judge with under the
- 26:11Speaker 8: Seventh Amendment. If it's for more than twenty dollars I
- 26:15Speaker 8: think with a jury. So that's the distinction. Now, what
- 26:19Speaker 8: Google's trying to say is, oh, guess what, Now there's
- 26:21Speaker 8: no damages, so you don't get the jury trial. So
- 26:25Speaker 8: presumably the Justice Department will say to this check, thank you,
- 26:28Speaker 8: but no thank you. You know, we want to prove
- 26:30Speaker 8: our damages and will prove them anyway. So it is
- 26:33Speaker 8: still a suit for damages, and you can't get out
- 26:36Speaker 8: of it by sort of pre paying the damages and
- 26:39Speaker 8: now saying, guess what, it's not for damages. The suit
- 26:42Speaker 8: was always for damage.
- 26:44Speaker 5: The size of the payment hasn't been disclosed, but Google
- 26:48Speaker 5: said that after months of discovery, the Justice Department could
- 26:51Speaker 5: only point to estimated damages of less than a million.
- 26:54Speaker 5: Since the law allows the court to issue treble damages,
- 26:58Speaker 5: the speculation is that check is for about three million,
- 27:02Speaker 5: which is a drop in the bucket to Google.
- 27:06Speaker 8: Well, yeah, I mean originally they claimed at least one
- 27:09Speaker 8: hundred million, and what they're going to be able to
- 27:12Speaker 8: prove up a trial, it seems to me, is still
- 27:15Speaker 8: a question for trial. So I don't know what their
- 27:18Speaker 8: expert reports show or whether they have some additional evidence,
- 27:22Speaker 8: So I don't know what the amount is, and I think, frankly,
- 27:25Speaker 8: it doesn't really matter. The legal point is the case
- 27:28Speaker 8: was filed for damages. It is still a case for damages,
- 27:33Speaker 8: and paying them off doesn't and the case and doesn't
- 27:37Speaker 8: change the nature of the case. So I don't see
- 27:39Speaker 8: this as the gambit that's going to work. Their claim
- 27:42Speaker 8: is not moved, no matter how much the checks for,
- 27:45Speaker 8: and you're right, from anyone's point of view, whether it's
- 27:48Speaker 8: five million, ten million, one hundred million dollars, this is
- 27:52Speaker 8: not very much to Google, and that's really, frankly not
- 27:55Speaker 8: the point. So I think, you know, more significant are
- 27:58Speaker 8: the other arguments that Google tries to make, which is
- 28:01Speaker 8: that this shouldn't be a suit tried by a jury.
- 28:05Speaker 8: And that's a more straightforward argument. It's not yes, it's
- 28:09Speaker 8: a jury trial, but no, it's not a jury trial,
- 28:11Speaker 8: because I mean, it would sort of be like saying, well,
- 28:14Speaker 8: you asked for an injunction, so yeah, it's fine, We're
- 28:16Speaker 8: fine with an injunction. So now it's not a case
- 28:19Speaker 8: for anything. So I don't think that's going to work.
- 28:21Speaker 5: Google also argues that the government has said the case
- 28:24Speaker 5: is highly technical and outside the everyday knowledge of most
- 28:28Speaker 5: prospective jurors. Google said it's aware of no case in
- 28:32Speaker 5: American history where a civil suit brought by the United
- 28:35Speaker 5: States pressing only antitrust claims was tried to a jury.
- 28:40Speaker 8: You know, it's likely that that's correct, simply because the
- 28:44Speaker 8: Justice Department has almost never filed suit for damages and
- 28:48Speaker 8: so it's not a major claim. What would be an
- 28:53Speaker 8: interesting claim is if nobody had ever filed for a
- 28:56Speaker 8: jury trial, including private party. And that actually is true.
- 29:00Speaker 8: And in fact, this claim was made in the nineteen
- 29:04Speaker 8: eighties in litigation involving the sale of Japanese televisions in
- 29:09Speaker 8: the United States at allegedly predatory prices, and the defendant,
- 29:14Speaker 8: Japanese television manufacturers, made a strong effort to say there
- 29:18Speaker 8: is no right to a jury trial here because it's
- 29:20Speaker 8: too complex. The courts never quite got to that holding
- 29:26Speaker 8: for other reasons. They focused on other issues. But we've
- 29:29Speaker 8: seen the claim before, and courts are not all that
- 29:33Speaker 8: well disposed to it. In private cases, there are lots
- 29:36Speaker 8: of complicated cases patent infringement cases. Patents are complicated, A
- 29:41Speaker 8: lot of patent infringement cases. A large part of it
- 29:43Speaker 8: to try to juries trade secret cases, complex fraud cases.
- 29:48Speaker 8: There's a lot of complex cases. To say somehow anti
- 29:51Speaker 8: trust is beyond the realm is a little silly, particularly
- 29:56Speaker 8: after Google had a jury trial in the epic case. Now,
- 30:01Speaker 8: Google's right to say that this is unusual for the government,
- 30:04Speaker 8: but that's a knock on the government, but not on
- 30:06Speaker 8: the legal case. And there are reasons for that. But
- 30:09Speaker 8: the government clearly is the statutory right to sue for
- 30:12Speaker 8: treble damages. Congress gave that to them in nineteen ninety,
- 30:16Speaker 8: originally with single damages nineteen fifty five. I mean, it's
- 30:19Speaker 8: a specific statue. So, as I said, frivolous, bad argument, Harry.
- 30:25Speaker 5: Before we go any further, tell us about the government's
- 30:28Speaker 5: case against Google here.
- 30:30Speaker 8: Basically, it involves the advertising side of what Google does
- 30:35Speaker 8: and the auctions that it runs for those ads that
- 30:38Speaker 8: you see popping up every time you move online that
- 30:42Speaker 8: seem to say, hi, Harry, this is for you. You know,
- 30:45Speaker 8: search advertising, display advertising, and they run auctions. I forget
- 30:50Speaker 8: the number every second, but it's a huge volume of
- 30:54Speaker 8: advertising auctions, and they run the platforms and they provide
- 30:58Speaker 8: the tools for both the advertisers and the publishers of
- 31:02Speaker 8: these ads to figure out how much space there is
- 31:06Speaker 8: where these ads could go, what to charge, how to
- 31:09Speaker 8: auction them off, so that each side feels they're getting
- 31:11Speaker 8: the best deal, and you know, they sort of run
- 31:14Speaker 8: the show. And they also have the search engine that generates,
- 31:18Speaker 8: you know, a lot of the information, so they are
- 31:21Speaker 8: all over what people call the ad tech space, and
- 31:25Speaker 8: the Justice Department wants to separate out some of these
- 31:29Speaker 8: functions so that different platforms might arise that could compete
- 31:34Speaker 8: against Google without you know, having the same search engine
- 31:37Speaker 8: and having sort of the same tools that seem to
- 31:40Speaker 8: favor Google, and placement on Google websites rather than through
- 31:45Speaker 8: being so forth. So that's the real thumbnail sketch. But
- 31:49Speaker 8: you know, everything you read. The first thing you know
- 31:52Speaker 8: that people say is, well, this is a complicated market
- 31:54Speaker 8: to understand. But you know, again, this is what good
- 31:58Speaker 8: trial lawyers do. They break down complexity so that people
- 32:02Speaker 8: who have to decide the case. In this case, the
- 32:04Speaker 8: jury can follow it through. And that's going to be
- 32:06Speaker 8: their challenge.
- 32:07Speaker 5: You mentioned the Fortnite maker Epic Games case that was
- 32:11Speaker 5: one of the worst legal losses for Google. So Google's
- 32:15Speaker 5: been burned by a jury. Is that why maybe looking
- 32:18Speaker 5: for a judge to decide this case, although I would
- 32:22Speaker 5: think that it would be harder to try a case
- 32:24Speaker 5: before an experienced trial judge than before a jury.
- 32:29Speaker 8: Your question now has moved from are they making a
- 32:33Speaker 8: frivolous legal argument to are they making a smart tactical argument.
- 32:38Speaker 8: And you know, I'm not sure the answer to that.
- 32:40Speaker 8: Why do they prefer judge bring them to a jury.
- 32:44Speaker 8: And the only answer I can come up with is
- 32:47Speaker 8: just what you said. They don't want to present themselves
- 32:51Speaker 8: to a jury. They did that an epic which they
- 32:53Speaker 8: wanted to avoid desperately and were unable to and in
- 32:57Speaker 8: less than four hours the jury said, we know who
- 32:59Speaker 8: you are. You are a monopolist. You know at the
- 33:02Speaker 8: fancy junk you're a monopolis, and you've excluded competitors. They
- 33:06Speaker 8: didn't have much trouble with this. Now you could say, well,
- 33:09Speaker 8: one strategy is you make this soap complicated the jury
- 33:12Speaker 8: to just throw up their hands and say we can't
- 33:15Speaker 8: figure this out. On the other hand, a jury trials
- 33:18Speaker 8: incentive to both parties to present an understandable case. And
- 33:22Speaker 8: you know, the government chose this, and they actually chose
- 33:26Speaker 8: a difficult path. They have the burden of proof, and
- 33:29Speaker 8: they have to make this understandable to the jury, and
- 33:32Speaker 8: it's not going to be easy. I don't think it's
- 33:34Speaker 8: complicated industry. But you know, if they do it well,
- 33:38Speaker 8: the jury will understand it. And maybe that's exactly what
- 33:41Speaker 8: Google's afraid of. The jury will see. They're on both
- 33:45Speaker 8: sides of these transactions. Even Microsoft, the second largest company
- 33:51Speaker 8: in the United States by market cap but valued over
- 33:55Speaker 8: what now three trillion or two trillion, I lose a
- 33:57Speaker 8: trillion here or there, even they are having trouble in
- 34:00Speaker 8: this space. And you know, I think jurors will get it,
- 34:04Speaker 8: and I think Google's afraid that jurors will get it.
- 34:07Speaker 8: And obviously they're not so much afraid of the money
- 34:10Speaker 8: part here, since they said, hey, here, take our money please.
- 34:14Speaker 8: They're worried that the jury is going to find against
- 34:17Speaker 8: them that they've monopolized this market and then strong relief
- 34:21Speaker 8: is going to follow.
- 34:22Speaker 5: But if a jury would get it, wouldn't a judge
- 34:24Speaker 5: get it as well? And you know, get it faster
- 34:27Speaker 5: and with more background information.
- 34:30Speaker 8: I do wonder about that. Judge Brinkhama is a really
- 34:34Speaker 8: good district court judge. She's moved this case along pretty quickly.
- 34:39Speaker 8: She doesn't seem disposed to Google's efforts to get out
- 34:43Speaker 8: of her court. She hasn't dismissed the complaint, So I
- 34:46Speaker 8: wonder why they think they'd have a better chance with
- 34:49Speaker 8: her when it comes to tactics. These are judgment calls,
- 34:52Speaker 8: you know. Those lawyers may know things about their case,
- 34:55Speaker 8: may feel that she could understand better why they're on
- 35:00Speaker 8: both sides of the transaction, how these marketplaces work. I
- 35:03Speaker 8: don't know. That's a decision they have made, though they
- 35:06Speaker 8: really don't want twelve people judging their behavior.
- 35:10Speaker 5: Some of the plaintiff states that had joined the Justice
- 35:13Speaker 5: Department suit said the court to deny Google's motion for
- 35:17Speaker 5: some rejudgment allow the case to proceed to try out quote.
- 35:20Speaker 5: Google argues that it lacks monopoly power along every dimension
- 35:24Speaker 5: except the one that matters most under the law, whether
- 35:27Speaker 5: it has the power to control price or output.
- 35:30Speaker 8: And it does well, you know, just as in the
- 35:33Speaker 8: epic litigation with Fortnite. Yeah, don't look over here that
- 35:37Speaker 8: we have a monopoly. Look over there, that we compete
- 35:40Speaker 8: for lots of other advertising and so forth. And a
- 35:43Speaker 8: lot of this does turn on some sort of technical
- 35:46Speaker 8: concepts about how we define markets and what the market
- 35:49Speaker 8: share is. And the state's position is that we can
- 35:52Speaker 8: figure out whether someone is a monopoly not just by
- 35:56Speaker 8: defining a market and seeing whether they have.
- 35:58Speaker 6: Most of it.
- 35:59Speaker 8: We look see whether they can do what monopolists do.
- 36:03Speaker 8: So monopolist control price, they raise it, and they restrict output.
- 36:07Speaker 8: And that's what they want to show in their case,
- 36:09Speaker 8: that they control the output of advertising and these advertising services,
- 36:14Speaker 8: and that leads to higher prices.
- 36:16Speaker 5: There's a hearing on June first before Judge Brinkama, and
- 36:20Speaker 5: we should learn more then. Thanks so much, Harry. That's
- 36:22Speaker 5: Professor Harry First of NYU Law School. And that's it
- 36:26Speaker 5: for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you
- 36:29Speaker 5: can always get the latest legal news by subscribing and
- 36:32Speaker 5: listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 36:35Speaker 5: Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June Grosso
- 36:40Speaker 5: and this is Bloomberg