Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / Inside Costa Rica
Transcript
- 0:02It is 08:47AM
- 0:04Pacific Daylight Time. It's the August
- 0:072025,
- 0:08and this is episode eleven fifty five
- 0:10of Bitcoin and Yesterday,
- 0:13while cutting yesterday's episode of Bitcoin and it became apparent to everybody but me that Google
- 0:21has pulled a little rabbit out of their hat and it's not a good rabbit this is not the rabbit this is not the fluffy rabbit that you want
- 0:29This is the bad kind of rabbit that nobody nobody wants and I'm gonna talk about it and then we're gonna talk about a possible solution
- 0:38but then I'm gonna do a long read
- 0:41from Bitcoin Magazine about the circular economy
- 0:44in Costa Rica.
- 0:47And, honestly, right now, unless something changes
- 0:51during the show while I'm recording,
- 0:54there's just not a whole I mean, unless you want me to go over
- 0:58again how many companies are starting to get into shit coinery for their corporate treasuries, and I've got that in quotes. You can't see me, but I'm air quoting their their corporate treasuries.
- 1:09Because I've I discussed it yesterday
- 1:12sort of at length
- 1:14that we're seeing an alt season that's being driven
- 1:17by
- 1:18CEOs
- 1:19and CFOs
- 1:21because they're doing the they're making the exact same mistakes
- 1:25that went on
- 1:272017,
- 1:282018,
- 1:302019,
- 1:312020,
- 1:32'21, '22, you name it. They're doing the same they're making the same mistake.
- 1:38Except this time instead of it being retail
- 1:40and people being duped
- 1:42into buying some kind of shit coin on Twitter,
- 1:45this time it's
- 1:47people that should know better.
- 1:49People that have a a much better world view
- 1:53in terms of economics and how they work and what these technologies actually mean when they're free and running around in the wild. And yet, here we are.
- 2:03It's 2018,
- 2:052019,
- 2:07all over again, except this time it's wearing a suit. Because, honestly, that is
- 2:12all
- 2:13that I am picking up
- 2:14as I did my morning curation for today's episode. And I'm just I'm not going to do it. It's a waste of everybody's time to talk about how Tom Lee has bought yet more Ethereum.
- 2:25I I feel bad for Tom Lee.
- 2:28Unless, of course, he's doing this on purpose so that he can sell his bags later and dump it on retail as these people usually do and then
- 2:35buy actual real Bitcoin with it, but it's just not worth our time.
- 2:40But the circular economy
- 2:43and what's going on in Costa Rica,
- 2:45I think that is worth our time because I've always kind of thought that after El Salvador,
- 2:51just down south, you know, I think you skip over Nicaragua and then you go down south a little further, you've got Costa Rica, which is
- 2:58damn near a first world country and has been for quite a while. It's been a destination for American tourism for decades and decades and decades. It's clean. It's nice.
- 3:08It's fairly wealthy as far as Latin American countries go, and they were have been dipping their toes into the Bitcoin scene for a while, and I keep thinking that they're pretty much next on the list. So I really wanna get into this
- 3:21big read from
- 3:24Bitcoin magazine
- 3:25about what's going on in Costa Rica. And I I actually think it ties in nicely
- 3:32with what's going on here with Google and this this
- 3:36Linux phone that I wanna tell you about
- 3:39because we either start taking things into our own hands
- 3:44and start building the things that that have been provided to us now
- 3:50or we're just gonna end up in a gulag.
- 3:52I
- 3:53the whole point
- 3:55of being able to side load APKs into your Google phone
- 4:00was so that you could try out stuff that that the Google people didn't really want in their Play Store. They didn't want to take
- 4:07responsibility for something bricking your phone. And, hell, from a liability standpoint, I don't blame them on that.
- 4:14But they honestly just just should have put a waiver up
- 4:18on
- 4:19the Play Store or
- 4:21or or something. When you buy your phone, when you buy your Pixel or whatever, the a waiver that you have to sign that says, if I side load for, like, APK
- 4:30and it breaks my phone, I will not hold Google responsible.
- 4:33But no, they didn't go that route, and you have to ask yourself why.
- 4:38So let's let's begin today's episode by reading
- 4:42this one from TechCrunch.
- 4:44Google will require developer verification
- 4:47for Android apps
- 4:49outside
- 4:51the Play Store.
- 4:53This is Sarah Perez writing by the way.
- 4:56Google is tightening security measures around Android app distribution, the company announced on Monday.
- 5:02Starting next year,
- 5:04Google will begin to verify the identities
- 5:07of developers
- 5:08distributing their apps
- 5:10on Android devices,
- 5:12not just those who distribute
- 5:14via the Play Store.
- 5:16The changes will affect all certified Android devices once live,
- 5:21though the global rollout will be more gradual.
- 5:24The tech giant stress that this does not mean developers can't distribute outside of the Play Store through other app stores
- 5:31or via sideloading,
- 5:33Android will remain open in that regard. However, developers
- 5:37who appreciated the
- 5:39anonymity of alternative
- 5:41distribution methods will no longer have that option.
- 5:45Google says this will help cut down on bad actors who hide their identity
- 5:50to distribute malware,
- 5:52commit financial fraud, or steal users' personal data. I'm pausing right there to say this is nothing but a it's for the children argument
- 6:01because they could very easily draft a waiver
- 6:05that you have to sign when you purchase a Pixel phone or a Google phone or something like that.
- 6:11They could very well
- 6:13have put something in their operating system
- 6:16that senses that, hey. You're about to side load an APK. You've gotta sign this waiver that says you will take full responsibility for any damages that this app or apps that you're about to sideload.
- 6:29You take full responsibility for it bricking your phone or or losing your personal data or whatever.
- 6:36But, no,
- 6:38Google chose not to go that route.
- 6:41They could have, and it would be legally binding, and it would completely shield them from any legal action if that particular
- 6:50document was created
- 6:52right,
- 6:53but no.
- 6:54And you have to ask yourself
- 6:56why.
- 6:58Let's continue. According to its very own survey, Google says that more than 50 times more malware came through the Internet side loaded sources compared with Google Play, where it has required developer verification since 2023.
- 7:12Initially,
- 7:13Google will allow interested developers to sign up for early access starting in October 2025 to test the system and provide feedback.
- 7:22In March 2026, verification will go live for all developers. And by September
- 7:272026,
- 7:29any app
- 7:30installed on an Android device in Brazil, Indonesia, Singapore, and Thailand will have to meet the new requirements.
- 7:37Starting in 2027,
- 7:38the requirements will be rolled out globally.
- 7:42Developers will have to provide their legal name,
- 7:46address,
- 7:47email, and phone number, which could push independent developers to register as a business for their own privacy's
- 7:54sake.
- 7:55Apple implemented a similar change for the EU App Store earlier this year to comply with the Digital Services Act, a regulation that now requires app developers to provide their trader status, and that's in quotes,
- 8:07to submit new apps or app updates for distribution.
- 8:12Google notes that student and hobbyist developers will be able to use a separate
- 8:17type of Android developer console account when this system rolls out as their needs differ from commercial developers.
- 8:25The changes could have
- 8:26significant
- 8:28impact on the Android app ecosystem
- 8:30and app distribution
- 8:32as Google works to cut down on the security issues and malware
- 8:36that have typically plagued its platform.
- 8:39So that that's the TechCrunch article that was being blasted out far and wide yesterday.
- 8:45And honestly, all it says is it does not matter.
- 8:49You are going to have to dox yourself
- 8:52if if
- 8:53if you are developing for Google,
- 8:56which
- 8:57begs the question.
- 9:00If Google's not in control of me getting something from GitHub, an APK
- 9:07from GitHub,
- 9:08and sideloading it into their phone
- 9:11now,
- 9:12with I mean, because
- 9:14these guys are are are anonymous.
- 9:16Cali is a good example. BitChat. He he he took he took the code for BitChat from
- 9:22iOS and essentially
- 9:24ported it, for lack of a better term, to Android.
- 9:29We don't know who Cali is. He hasn't I I guarantee you he hasn't given his phone number to somebody, his physical address to somebody, and his legal name to somebody.
- 9:39Not not for for Bitcoin and and and development stuff. I I can almost guarantee it.
- 9:45Cali's not that kind of person. I haven't met him personally, but you get a sense of some of these people when you've been in the space for a while. Cali's not not not the kind of guy that says, hey. Here's my address and phone number. I I'm sure that you'll that that you having
- 10:07BitChat app
- 10:08side loaded into a Google device, like a phone.
- 10:13Or how
- 10:15how
- 10:16are they going to get Cali to dox himself?
- 10:20And I think what this all leads to is that there is going to be some kind of change to the Google operating system for their phones and whatever else you you put this this mobile,
- 10:31operating system on, that there will be a change to it. And it will sense that you're about to sideload an APK
- 10:39and that it will look for some kind of certificate
- 10:43from that APK
- 10:45that Google
- 10:46issues
- 10:48to a developer
- 10:49if they want their app to actually be able to be side loaded into the Google phone.
- 10:57So I sense that a Google operating system for mobile devices is on the horizon.
- 11:03It will be rolled out. It will probably be certificate based. And to get that certificate,
- 11:10if you want to distribute you you're more than welcome to develop anything for
- 11:15Google OS
- 11:17for their
- 11:18phones and distribute it via GitHub. But if you want it to actually be side loaded and work inside the Google environment, it's going to have to have a certificate.
- 11:27And the only way you're getting that certificate
- 11:31is by doxxing yourself to Google.
- 11:36This is
- 11:38not good.
- 11:40And Google was the last, sort of like the last bastion. And I was I had always been wondering when this day would come.
- 11:47I I I honestly thought it would be a lot sooner than
- 11:51than what we're seeing.
- 11:53That said,
- 11:55there has to be a different way.
- 11:58We've only we we essentially only have a couple of phone makers.
- 12:02You know, we we've got we've got Apple,
- 12:05and we've got Google,
- 12:07and we got well, I mean okay. We've got a few phone makers. Right? But they are they only really ever use the operating system iOS
- 12:16or Android.
- 12:18Yes. There's graphene. Yeah. I get that.
- 12:23When will they be compromised?
- 12:26And I'm not saying that they will. I'm just saying
- 12:31I I can't go around feeling good about myself saying, well, there's GrapheneOS and everything will be fine,
- 12:37which is why I want to tell you about this Linux phone. And, again, this is this was a note on Nostr.
- 12:44So so but I'm over here at the at the the note provided a website,
- 12:48and it's called
- 12:50Liberux.
- 12:51Liberux?
- 12:52Liberux?
- 12:53Liberux?
- 12:54I l I b e r u x. And you can go find it at liberux.net.
- 13:01That's liberux.net.
- 13:05And it's a it's a handheld mobile phone,
- 13:08looks to be a smartphone.
- 13:10It's called the Linux phone.
- 13:12That's what LibriX is is saying.
- 13:16According to this, it's not out. They're, I guess, in the middle of crowdfunding.
- 13:21It's, quote, coming soon, t m.
- 13:24But if it does come out,
- 13:27you can look forward to an eight core processor,
- 13:31up to 2.4
- 13:32gigahertz. So it seems to be fairly powerful.
- 13:36It looks like a smartphone. It's got a it it looks like any other smartphone that you might have. It's got a nice screen. It's nice and big. It's got a black background. It seems to display graphics very, very well.
- 13:49It has 32 gigabytes of RAM dual channel
- 13:53and a two terabyte storage capacity, which is wow. Well, honestly, that's kind of impressive right there.
- 14:00So if I go if I dive a little bit further into the specs where where was it? Oh, for god's sake. Where was it?
- 14:08I think it's on Debian. I think that the distribution that it's using is Debian. Yeah. Here it is.
- 14:15LibreX OS is based on Debian
- 14:1813 Linux,
- 14:20and it's touted as being an ethical and mostly open source operating system. I I guess they're talking about the Debian the Debian development itself,
- 14:31but
- 14:33it's apparently designed to have modular
- 14:36architecture.
- 14:38So what they're saying is that you can replace the RAM,
- 14:41you can remove the LTE five g modem and replace it. It has interchangeable storage,
- 14:47error correcting
- 14:49memory.
- 14:50It's just it's it's about they're they're saying that it's about
- 14:54reuse and not obsolescence.
- 14:57So that could be just pure marketing.
- 15:00Who knows?
- 15:02But
- 15:03I would love a Linux based phone.
- 15:06So
- 15:08I'm sure that there are other devices out there that that run on Linux, but this particular ecosystem
- 15:15is
- 15:18it's ripe
- 15:20for massive development
- 15:22in the with with the same ethos and the same fervor
- 15:26that we're seeing development on Noster,
- 15:29with BitChat,
- 15:30with Bitcoin, with Lightning, with eCash,
- 15:34You name it, man. That that that whole thing,
- 15:37this goes right along with it.
- 15:40So if you know more about LibriX,
- 15:43get in touch with me on Noster,
- 15:45and
- 15:47let me know what you think. And also
- 15:51let me know what else is out there.
- 15:54Okay. So let's just break it down right here. We've got iOS as an operating system.
- 15:58We've got Android OS as an operating system.
- 16:02We've got Graphene OS, which seems to be breaking the tide of
- 16:08the the stranglehold
- 16:09that that iOS and Android OS has.
- 16:13But
- 16:14what
- 16:16Linux based solutions
- 16:18do we have
- 16:20for mobile
- 16:21smartphones
- 16:22with five gs connectivity
- 16:25or LTE or four gs or you know wireless and Wi Fi the the the Bluetooth
- 16:31the whole what else
- 16:33out there exists that developers can start developing for
- 16:37because we've got to leave
- 16:40the Play Store and the Apple App Store behind.
- 16:44We've
- 16:45we've really got to start looking back at Zapstore, which is something that you can use with Graphene OS,
- 16:51at least as far as I as far as I know.
- 16:55We need more. We need we need a lot more than just this. But if you wanna go look at on if you wanna go look at the phone, again, it's libereux.net,
- 17:05liberux,.net.
- 17:08It's a good looking phone. I I have to admit, man. I mean, honestly, I I kinda want one of these, you know, if if if at all possible.
- 17:16But, again, it's, you know, it's just in development as far as I can tell.
- 17:21So
- 17:22that was sort of the the the spiel about the fact that we've gotta get out of this.
- 17:27We don't have any choice.
- 17:29We are ethically bound at this point
- 17:32to be like water, just like Bitcoin is water to the economic system, just like Nasr is water to the modern communication systems.
- 17:40We need
- 17:42water for the App Store ecosystem.
- 17:45We've got to be able to route around it because they're putting dams up,
- 17:49and all that water is looking for
- 17:52is the lowest point of energy entry
- 17:56to go downhill. That that it water wants to move.
- 18:00It will flow,
- 18:01and it will eventually flow over the top of the dam.
- 18:05We just need to figure out a way to route around this shit right now.
- 18:09Now
- 18:10now. Not later.
- 18:12Not a it'll be fine for, like, a couple of years. No. It's not fine.
- 18:17This is not fine.
- 18:19It needs to be fixed, and we need to fix it right now.
- 18:23Otherwise,
- 18:24freedom is
- 18:29freedom is in danger.
- 18:33Okay. I'm gonna take a breath. I'm gonna take a little pause,
- 18:35and we're gonna go in and read this big read
- 18:39from Bitcoin magazine, and it's written by
- 18:42Gabriel Kerman.
- 18:46Freedom of mind and freedom of money
- 18:49inside
- 18:50Costa Rica's growing Bitcoin
- 18:52circular economy.
- 18:54And this is an excerpt
- 18:57from a book entitled
- 18:59Bitcoin Circular Economies.
- 19:01And this is the chapter in that book
- 19:04about Costa Rica.
- 19:08The embryo of each Bitcoin circular economy is unique.
- 19:12The purposes of Bitcoin circular economies are diverse,
- 19:15and as they grow, the projects develop their own identity,
- 19:19education,
- 19:20p two p,
- 19:22payments, wallets, etcetera.
- 19:24The quests
- 19:25of their protagonists
- 19:27often shape the origin of each with characteristics
- 19:30and needs that define them. The founders,
- 19:33who decided to pursue
- 19:35this social,
- 19:37technological,
- 19:37and economic adventure, defined the spirit of the project.
- 19:41The Bitcoin Jungle project was born in the heart of the Costa Rican jungle, where a vibrant community of expats
- 19:49and digital nomads from all over the world is trying to develop a more conscious way of living in harmony with nature.
- 19:57Two men
- 19:58lit the spark
- 19:59that gave birth to Bitcoin jungle.
- 20:02Over
- 20:03time, others joined the fire.
- 20:05But two were the energies that aligned to start this project, one, a developer and serial entrepreneur,
- 20:12the other, a journalist,
- 20:15retired teacher, and democracy
- 20:17activist.
- 20:19Both share two deeply rooted beliefs in their hearts. First, Costa Rica is the best place in the world to live.
- 20:26Second,
- 20:27Bitcoin is an enlightening technology that can lead humanity to a more peaceful and evolved lifestyle.
- 20:35Richard Scottford lived in Hong Kong for more than twenty years.
- 20:39He worked as a teacher and a freelance reporter for various media outlets, always as a political analyst.
- 20:46Richard witnessed firsthand the peaceful protest
- 20:49that began
- 20:50there
- 20:51in 2014 with the Umbrella Movement, which later became a symbol of resistance.
- 20:56Without mincing words, Richard supported Hong Kong's democratic struggle against the Chinese Communist Party,
- 21:02which imposed an election system where the people could only choose
- 21:06among candidates
- 21:08selected by the Communist Party.
- 21:11Through his articles, Richard became part of Hong Kong's political scene, and when his friends and colleagues began to be imprisoned,
- 21:18he decided it was time to take a new direction in life.
- 21:22At the time, Richard knew nothing about Bitcoin
- 21:25and admits that he crossed off the list
- 21:28of all the mistakes that cryptocurrency
- 21:31users usually make before coming into Bitcoin.
- 21:34Quote, we were scammed. We lost money until mid twenty eighteen when we started to understand the differences
- 21:42between Bitcoin and the other cryptocurrencies,
- 21:46end quote.
- 21:48The realization about Bitcoin and the profound impact it could have on the world came at a very special time in the lives of Richard and his wife.
- 21:58Quote,
- 21:59we were in the middle class trap
- 22:02where we had everything we needed.
- 22:04All we could do was have more or better stuff, a better car, a fancier boat, a bigger house, or join a better club. I call it a trap because there was nothing extra to own.
- 22:17It was clear that our happiness was not going to change by having more or better things.
- 22:23We wanted to do something radically different, and that's how we ended up in Costa Rica, end quote.
- 22:30At first,
- 22:31the couple explored the diverse climates and landscapes of the country.
- 22:35They found many similarities with the jungles of Hong Kong, enjoyed the volcanic beaches of the Pacific Ocean as well as those of the Caribbean.
- 22:43It was not easy to impress the new visitors who knew the Asian beaches by heart, and it wasn't until Christmas of twenty nineteen
- 22:51when Richard would find a new meaning to his purpose in Costa Rica.
- 22:56Quote, we participated in an Ayahuasca
- 22:59ceremony in the jungle.
- 23:01Suddenly,
- 23:02three different ideas connected in my mind.
- 23:05On the one hand, I felt a call to deep dive
- 23:08into jungle medicine,
- 23:10which is central to Costa Rican culture. On the other hand, all the ideas I had about Bitcoin connected.
- 23:16At the time, I was precisely
- 23:18falling down the rabbit hole studying and learning as much as possible.
- 23:23It all connected with conversations
- 23:26about the best way to school our daughter.
- 23:29It all came together. I was a teacher in Hong Kong, so naturally, it came up for me to get involved with the local elementary school.
- 23:37Then the idea of building our own secondary school in 2020 would come up. End quote.
- 23:42Before long,
- 23:44the dream of opening his own school came to life. Quote, I told my wife, we are going to create the first school in Costa Rica that accepts Bitcoin,
- 23:52and we're going to teach their kids and our kids about Bitcoin.
- 23:57The only thing I could think of was to send out a tweet to the Bitcoin community that said, quote,
- 24:03we are a school in Costa Rica. We want to accept Bitcoin.
- 24:07How can we
- 24:09do
- 24:10it? Many people responded
- 24:11to Richard's request for help, including
- 24:14Nicholas Berti, cofounder of Galloy and the Bitcoin Beach wallet currently called Blank.
- 24:20Nicholas suggested that the best way to start accepting small payments was through a Bitcoin Lightning wallet and offered to help.
- 24:27He encouraged them to create a fork of their own wallet based on the open source repository of the Bitcoin Beach wallet.
- 24:35That was the first moment
- 24:37Richard realized he wasn't alone. Quote,
- 24:40that's where things started to take shape. We wanted to develop our own wallet to simplify payments at school and at the same time also facilitate Bitcoin adoption in Evita,
- 24:51the town we chose to live in.
- 24:53The problem was that we didn't have the technical skills needed to fork the Goloj repository
- 24:58and build it, end quote.
- 25:01The universe manages to cross the paths of people who need each other. Just when Richard was stymied by his lack of technical skills to launch a local version of the wallet tailored to Uvita's needs,
- 25:12he met Lee Salminen,
- 25:15a software engineer and serial entrepreneur from Boulder, Colorado.
- 25:19Lee is a cheerful, positive person who sees opportunity in every challenge.
- 25:24The combination of his technical skills, his passion for Bitcoin, and his purpose in life
- 25:29made him the perfect candidate
- 25:31to start a Bitcoin circular economy.
- 25:34Richard and Lee fit together like pieces of a puzzle.
- 25:38Lee is another
- 25:39core founder of Bitcoin Jungle. He was able to bring the project to life. He copied Galloy's wallet over a weekend without any support.
- 25:48Even the guys at
- 25:49Galloy couldn't believe we had done it so fast.
- 25:52Quote, Bitcoin is a tool to change the world,
- 25:56to raise the awareness of humanity, end quote.
- 26:01Just at that time,
- 26:03the first edition of the Adopting Bitcoin conference was taking place in El Salvador.
- 26:08Richard traveled to the neighboring country while Lee stayed in Costa Rica working on the wallet.
- 26:13Going on that trip to El Salvador
- 26:16was eye opening.
- 26:17No one knew who I was. Just a simple English guy walking down the halls trying to make friends saying, hi. We want to do something like Bitcoin Beach in Costa Rica. Can you help us? End quote.
- 26:31Seen from the outside,
- 26:33Bitcoin Jungle's approach seemed impossible.
- 26:35Copying the source code of a wallet over a weekend without technical support from the original developers was a huge challenge.
- 26:42Then
- 26:44launching an adoption campaign without a significant amount of SATs to donate and start the process.
- 26:50However,
- 26:51Richard knew that a Bitcoin circular economy in Costa Rica had potential for one simple reason. Quote,
- 26:58the SATs were already there.
- 27:00I knew Costa Rica was different. There were a lot of people around me who owned Bitcoin. It was full of expats.
- 27:07All we needed was to create the payment rails to get them moving.
- 27:11The money was already here. We just needed places to spend it, end quote.
- 27:16Richard doesn't beat around the bush and get straight to the point because he feels he has a message to share.
- 27:22Quote,
- 27:23you have to know your community,
- 27:26understand, and provide the services they need. It's important to learn from other circular economies, but many times the keys to success
- 27:34are in the differences, end quote.
- 27:37When Richard returned from El Salvador, Lee already had his wallet working.
- 27:41The excitement within the volcanoes of the Costa Rican jungle
- 27:44was beginning to stir the first tremors.
- 27:48From the beginning,
- 27:49the founders of Bitcoin Jungle decided to keep the efforts concentrated
- 27:53in a relatively small area called the Golden Triangle,
- 27:57demarcated by the towns of Domenical,
- 28:00Uvita,
- 28:01and Tinamaste.
- 28:03Instead of spreading the efforts throughout the country, they decided to focus on this particular region
- 28:09characterized by spiritual seekers,
- 28:12surfers, and people with a deep connection to nature. Quote, although Bitcoin jungle is spilling all over Costa Rica, in the beginning, we had no plans to go out massively and try to adopt the whole country.
- 28:25It has always been about keeping it small, local,
- 28:28within our personal connections.
- 28:30The area between Dominical,
- 28:32Uvita, and Tinamaste
- 28:34has a lot of healers,
- 28:36natural medicine practitioners, and alternative people.
- 28:39It has this unique energy that is hard to explain but easy to feel.
- 28:44It is a very large area full of foreigners who receive income from their countries
- 28:49and need to spend it in Costa
- 28:52Rica. Govinda
- 28:54wears yoga attire and whispers in a calm voice, which conveys
- 28:58the vibe of much of this community
- 29:01of foreigners
- 29:02who chose Costa Rica as their new home.
- 29:04Govinda is another key member of Bitcoin Jungle.
- 29:08He runs the holistic center Awake,
- 29:10a sustainable hotel,
- 29:13with activities related to yoga and meditation.
- 29:16Awake is also the place where many Bitcoin meetings are held, as well as training sessions on the Bitcoin Jungle Wallet.
- 29:23This center is also the location where the Nostrika
- 29:27conference was held in 2023.
- 29:30This unique community has adopted Bitcoin as another tool
- 29:33to seek the elevation of human consciousness
- 29:37and harmony with nature.
- 29:39In pursuit of contributing to this balance,
- 29:42gaining trust within the community
- 29:43was key to integrating this innovative technology
- 29:47into their daily lives.
- 29:49Quote, it was the key to success of the project to have founders like Lee and Richard, Govinda explains.
- 29:56When the project started,
- 29:58there were several cryptocurrency
- 29:59scams going around and they were able to explain in Spanish to the store owners the differences with Bitcoin
- 30:06as well as the technical aspects of the wallet in very simple terms.
- 30:11They were key to developing confidence in the project and the team of people behind it.
- 30:18Being scarce, digital, and transparent,
- 30:21Bitcoin begins to demonstrate its advantages,
- 30:24solving problems for multiple types of people.
- 30:28It was worth looking into at the profile of the main users of Bitcoin Jungle. They face a different problem than the exiled families in El Salvador
- 30:38who send remittances back home.
- 30:40It is true that both projects coincide in the way they define their target influence area, seeking to concentrate the amount of Bitcoin payments per store,
- 30:50nurture their user experience, and economic revenues with the aim
- 30:54of maintaining a stable relationship between the number of visitors and the length of the stored network.
- 31:00However,
- 31:01the Golden Triangle population has something in common that other Bitcoin circular economies did not.
- 31:07As Richard likes to say, quote, most of the people in the Bitcoin jungle community
- 31:12have already done the work, end quote.
- 31:15He refers to the fact that many of the people in Uvita and Domenical
- 31:20already understood
- 31:22how to hold virtual currencies,
- 31:23and many even used Bitcoin as a store of value.
- 31:26The team just needed to give them a direct payment system to ignite the virtuous circle
- 31:32cycle.
- 31:33Instead of paying with high fee credit cards and constantly needing to transfer money into the country from abroad,
- 31:39users could simply load their Bitcoin lightning wallet and buy whatever they needed. Quote, our main goal was pretty simple.
- 31:46We were focused on reducing the friction of using Bitcoin for people visiting and living in Costa Rica.
- 31:52Richard expounds
- 31:54the conclusion
- 31:55he came to
- 31:56sometime after processing the purpose that had distilled
- 32:00his spiritual journey.
- 32:02All that remained
- 32:03was to design an adoption strategy and encourage Bitcoiner tourism.
- 32:09Costa Rica is known worldwide for its paradiasicle
- 32:13beaches, misty jungles, exotic animals, volcanoes, and surfing.
- 32:18It tends to be a very attractive spot for tourism in the Central American Corridor.
- 32:24Add its political stability, its high security standards, its motto, pura vida, which means pure life, as a declaration of respect for nature and the abolition of its army.
- 32:35The result not only caught the attention of tourism within the ecosystem,
- 32:40but also of the community of digital nomads who began to take it as one of their permanent residences.
- 32:47The community continues to expand with a growing percentage of visitors and families
- 32:51who decide to settle.
- 32:53Most are foreigners from The United States, Canada, and Europe, some seeking to escape excessive surveillance
- 32:58and increasing
- 33:00government oppression. Quote, many came here looking for a new social contract,
- 33:05one that works for everyone and is not imposed from a top down approach. Govinda stresses before pausing,
- 33:11taking a breath, and clarifying the unwritten but community adopted manifesto.
- 33:17Quote,
- 33:18we believe in freedom, peace, and prosperity,
- 33:21which are values that are deeply aligned with Bitcoin.
- 33:24We don't want to be told what to do.
- 33:26This is why I have high hopes for the rapid growth of the Bitcoin jungle community.
- 33:33However,
- 33:34the first years of these projects, which grow into a Bitcoin circular economy, are not easy.
- 33:40Founders often delimit the boundaries.
- 33:44There are multiple ways to get involved in the Bitcoin ecosystem, and given the characteristics of the Costa Rican community,
- 33:51different models were discussed in the early days.
- 33:54Having a large community of tech savvy expats with Bitcoin available to spend represents either a temptation or an opportunity, depending on your point of view, to develop a profitable business.
- 34:06One of the early contributors to the project was interested in pursuing this line,
- 34:10while the other founders wanted to build a nonprofit community endeavor. Quote, there was an interesting situation at the beginning because one of the early founders
- 34:20tried to turn it into a commercial project and make money from it.
- 34:24All the other founding members were more interested in it remaining a community driven thing.
- 34:30This led to a very healthy split around 2021
- 34:34and what is now known globally as Bitcoin Jungle is the non profit project that we decided to continue Govinda clarifies,
- 34:42inviting reflection with raised eyebrows.
- 34:45There are multiple Bitcoin businesses around the world
- 34:49that follow conscious efforts of social responsibility.
- 34:53However, there is a reason why Bitcoin circular economies are deeply rooted as nonprofit community projects.
- 35:00Govinda converses while touching the air with his hands.
- 35:04The more he shares his thoughts, the closer he comes to the image of a shaman who can observe the inner self of people who cross his path.
- 35:14People can sense it.
- 35:16The energy is completely different if there is someone behind it who wants to make a profit
- 35:21or if it comes from a sincere and genuine interest in the good of people and humanity.
- 35:26These subtle energies create projects with a very different spirit.
- 35:31We were not doing this for the money.
- 35:35Govinda
- 35:36speaks confidently of ideals.
- 35:39When the goal is to provide that a new social contract is possible,
- 35:44The words do not waver, quote, we believe in Bitcoin and we believe in Costa Rica.
- 35:49We want it to be a union between technology and nature
- 35:53to raise the level of consciousness.
- 35:55We are ready to dedicate some of our time and energy to make this happen as a gift to our community
- 36:01and to the world.
- 36:03Bitcoin aims to change power dynamics of money,
- 36:07to break free from abusive forces that enslave us and to reclaim our sovereignty to choose freely.
- 36:15Bitcoin Jungle was able to build its own identity.
- 36:19Another unique feature of this Bitcoin circular economy is to link with Nostr,
- 36:25the open source communications protocol that's ideal for developing decentralized
- 36:29social networks.
- 36:31These platforms can easily integrate with the Bitcoin Lightning Network and implement micro donations called Zaps for content creators.
- 36:39Given its unrestricted
- 36:41access, design, and
- 36:43resistance to censorship, Nostra is ideal
- 36:46for promoting freedom of expression in the face of social control and government censorship.
- 36:51Jack Dorsey, the original founder of Twitter, has been living in Costa Rica for a long time and has been closely following and supporting the growth of Bitcoin jungle.
- 37:00He is one of the big promoters of Nostr, has funded several projects in that ecosystem,
- 37:05and was instrumental
- 37:07in creating the first
- 37:08international conference on this technology.
- 37:11Quote,
- 37:12Jack was one of the first people to follow our Twitter account,
- 37:15but he had no personal contact.
- 37:18One day, he tweeted that a Nostra conference should be organized in Costa Rica and that he was willing to fund it
- 37:26if the community
- 37:27organized it, end quote.
- 37:30Pride covers Richard's face as he describes the backstage of Costa Rica,
- 37:35the event they organized together.
- 37:38After all, Richard had experienced firsthand the social control during his years in Hong Kong. Quote, we all love the idea because decentralized social networks are very much needed today.
- 37:50So we reached out to him and offered our entire infrastructure and business ecosystem to simplify payments for attendees.
- 37:57The combination of the world's first Nostra conference with the possibility of powering the Bitcoin jungle circular economy
- 38:04seemed like a perfect match.
- 38:06Jack Dorsey
- 38:08gave the green light.
- 38:09The Nostra Protocol has multiple philosophical
- 38:12similarities
- 38:13with Bitcoin,
- 38:15and, consequently, there is significant overlap between their communities.
- 38:20Govinda,
- 38:21as expected,
- 38:22holds space for individual freedoms alongside its inner peace.
- 38:26This new communications protocol has the potential to enable social networking
- 38:32with complete freedom of expression.
- 38:34We could build a decentralized Twitter on Facebook.
- 38:38We can talk
- 38:39and share ideas or images without surveillance. It's cryptographic
- 38:44and decentralized,
- 38:45like Bitcoin.
- 38:48Since its creation by anonymous user Fiat Joffe in 2020, the Nostra Protocol
- 38:53has seen a rapid increase in usage driven primarily by the Bitcoin community.
- 38:59The team insisted to Jack that the event be held in Uvita to leverage
- 39:04and stimulate the Bitcoin circular economy.
- 39:07As it happened, the Nostra Rica conference was a success.
- 39:11With over 50 speakers and 300 participants,
- 39:14it significantly increased international awareness of Bitcoin jungle.
- 39:18Quote,
- 39:19it really put us on a map as a destination for many Bitcoiners Richard recalls.
- 39:25We already had one of the best user experiences for spending sats and enjoying Bitcoin, but
- 39:30many of them still hadn't heard of us before this event.
- 39:34The circular economy that Nasr has its strongest relationship with today is Bitcoin jungle,
- 39:41and that has had many good consequences. Not only did it increase the endogenous tourism of the ecosystem,
- 39:48the unexpected success of the conference
- 39:50also generated the first economic gain for Bitcoin Jungle.
- 39:55Up until this event, everything had been self funded.
- 39:58The devices we delivered to the stores, the cost to support the users,
- 40:03the training,
- 40:04the node on which the wallet runs, and so on.
- 40:07We don't charge anyone, not on transactions within the node. Everything is completely free,
- 40:13Richard humbly shares.
- 40:16Going forward,
- 40:17we plan to continue doing festivals every year to further advance our community mission so everyone is invited
- 40:23to the Freedom Festival in February
- 40:262025,
- 40:27end quote.
- 40:30Costa Rica is a very special place.
- 40:33Many people who dream of making a positive contribution to the world, for some reason, are attracted to this country.
- 40:40The connection between these international
- 40:43spiritual seekers and Costa Rica has created a unique community in the world,
- 40:47combining
- 40:48innovation,
- 40:49yoga, nature,
- 40:51Ayahuasca,
- 40:52and technology.
- 40:54In retrospect,
- 40:55it is understandable
- 40:56why this environment became fertile ground for the birth for perhaps the most important Bitcoin circular economy in the world.
- 41:05This transcendental
- 41:07aspect
- 41:08is present in the minds and hearts of those who make Bitcoin jungle.
- 41:11Richard,
- 41:12who used to be a reporter clinging to the truth and transparency of democracy,
- 41:17continues to go through a personal transformation,
- 41:20though without losing his essence. Quote,
- 41:23I would say my main goal is the spiritual elevation of consciousness about Bitcoin.
- 41:29I think Bitcoin is a fundamental part of this new world that we are trying to build. That's why we created Bitcoin Jungle.
- 41:36It's our contribution to a more conscious and free future for humanity.
- 41:43Those who are deeply connected to Gaia
- 41:46tend to perceive the cyclical nature of all processes
- 41:49in our universe.
- 41:51Human evolution has also been shown to follow recurring patterns.
- 41:55Many Bitcoiners
- 41:57have been pointing out for over a decade
- 41:59that we may be on the verge of a major paradigm shift.
- 42:04This sense of hope is palpable throughout the Bitcoin Jungle community.
- 42:07There is a deep shared belief
- 42:10that after the inevitable collapse of fiat currencies under the weight of their own debt,
- 42:15there will be a new beginning.
- 42:18There is a large community of international seekers here.
- 42:22They believe in freedom, peace, and prosperity,
- 42:24values that are deeply aligned with Bitcoin's culture. They understand how money printing and inflation create poverty and inequality.
- 42:32They understand
- 42:33how traditional institutions and governments extract value from working people.
- 42:38All of us believe in the sovereignty of individuals
- 42:41and the power of decentralized communities.
- 42:44This is why Bitcoin and Costa Rica are made for each other.
- 42:50Govinda no longer sounds like a shaman. He now speaks like the leader of a movement.
- 42:55He probably has a little bit of each. Either way, both he and Richard are very clear in their motivations.
- 43:02Quote, we're not just doing this because we love Bitcoin.
- 43:05We're doing this because we want to change the world. But to do that,
- 43:10it's important that we also change inwardly.
- 43:13It's a fusion between our spiritual quest,
- 43:16a new philosophy of life, and a technology that facilitates it.
- 43:21There is no way we can sustainably raise human consciousness
- 43:25unless we liberate the way we store and transfer value between us, Richard concludes.
- 43:32When people cannot control the soundness and ownership
- 43:35of their own money,
- 43:36their vital energy can be abused and manipulated.
- 43:40This also applies to sovereign countries when they see their foreign currency reserves being diluted by the issuers
- 43:47of those fiat currencies.
- 43:50With Bitcoin, individuals and nation states become truly sovereign entities
- 43:55with the ability to protect their wealth from potential confiscation.
- 43:59Quote,
- 44:00Bitcoin protects your energy in a way that no one can mess with, Govinda enthuses.
- 44:06Quote, before Bitcoin, we were truly free only in our souls.
- 44:10We have energy sovereignty as spiritual beings, but on a physical level.
- 44:15We were completely controlled by the elites,
- 44:18their politicians,
- 44:20and their armies.
- 44:21Now Bitcoin has extended our freedom to the physical world. That changes everything.
- 44:27It also enables sovereignty,
- 44:29celebration of life,
- 44:31and healing on a global scale.
- 44:34Bitcoin is the liberation of humanity from ancestral
- 44:38abuse,
- 44:39end quote.
- 44:41In the case of Bitcoin jungle, as in all other Bitcoin circular economies,
- 44:46their first contact at the beginning of the project was with the friends of Bitcoin Beach.
- 44:52In addition to that first inspiring trip to El Salvador
- 44:56and the opportunity
- 44:57to use their wallet code, both teams have a permanent communications channel to collaborate and share ideas.
- 45:04On the educational side, Bitcoin Jungle has also received support from My First Bitcoin. Quote, we have a very good relationship with Mike and the Bitcoin Beach team.
- 45:15We are also very grateful to Napoleon from My First Bitcoin, Richard punctuates his mental list of collaborations.
- 45:22Quote, I myself
- 45:24dictate his materials to the kids here at school.
- 45:27Whenever we meet at any conference, we try to organize a dinner between the circular economies.
- 45:33Thankfully, that table is getting bigger and bigger every time.
- 45:37Bitcoin is very powerful,
- 45:38end quote.
- 45:40The Bitcoin circular economies play a unique role in the ecosystem
- 45:45because
- 45:46they demonstrate on a smaller scale how global Bitcoin adoption
- 45:50can benefit people and communities with different needs. Quote, I'm a big fan of the Bitcoin Ecosi team, Richard sums up in a demonstration of the strength that traces the invisible thread. Quote,
- 46:03how a poor village in South Africa has been able to create a Bitcoin circular economy that is becoming known around the world.
- 46:10Richard even dreams of the day
- 46:13when we have conferences totally dedicated
- 46:15to studying these early
- 46:17adopter case studies.
- 46:19Quote, I would love to see a conference totally dedicated to Bitcoin circular economies with projects from all over the world coming together to share their experiences, their stories, and their lessons learned, end quote.
- 46:33What role
- 46:34will a Bitcoin circular economy play in the future?
- 46:37Will these early communities be the birth of a new way of organizing society?
- 46:42Will we see an exponential growth of Paris Passau BCEs
- 46:47with the mass adoption of Bitcoin?
- 46:51If today's overcrowded cities continue their decline along with fiat governments drowning in debt, it is possible
- 46:57that a decentralized
- 46:59way of living could offer a better quality of life,
- 47:02greater community livelihood, and deeper connection with nature.
- 47:06For years,
- 47:07the Bitcoin community has predicted the emergence of luxurious Bitcoin citadels in the future.
- 47:13Can a Bitcoin circular economy be a more heterogeneous
- 47:16and inclusive alternative to those citadels?
- 47:20Quote, to me,
- 47:22a circular economy is the lifeblood of Bitcoin even if many Bitcoiners haven't realized it.
- 47:28Bitcoin strongholds will be elitist places,
- 47:31designed from the top down and only for a lucky few.
- 47:34The great thing about a Bitcoin circular economy is that we have not been designed
- 47:39out of luxury, Richard expounds. Quote, we have simply emerged from social,
- 47:44not for profit efforts with the goal of improving the lives of everyone in our communities.
- 47:50And that's the end of the article. Now here's some some notes at the bottom end of this article.
- 47:56Gabriel Kerman
- 47:58is a blockchain entrepreneur with more than a decade of corporate finance experience. He's a cofounder of several projects such as Rootstock,
- 48:05lie law, Bitcoinetta,
- 48:07and Blockchain for Humanity. He dedicates his life to Bitcoin innovation and education.
- 48:13His first book, Bitcoin Circular Economies, is out this month by Bitcoin Magazine Books.
- 48:19Bitcoin Jungle can be found on Instagram and
- 48:22a few other places. You can read the article for yourself.
- 48:26So that's that's the article. I really wanted to to get into this one because I believe that he's right.
- 48:33Bitcoin circular economies
- 48:35are more important now than they have been in a long time. And I don't mean that in a way that means that at one point or another Bitcoin circular economies weren't ever important.
- 48:48In fact, Bitcoin circular economy has is
- 48:51is just as important now as it ever was. What I'm talking about is the in the minds of humans,
- 48:57our perception
- 48:58of the importance
- 49:00of Bitcoin
- 49:01circular economies.
- 49:03There was a time when we really weren't thinking about it. You know, back in the day was huddle, huddle, huddle. And now we're getting into a lot more people saying, you know, we should probably
- 49:13be spending our our Bitcoin.
- 49:15Well, let me tell you first and foremost, nobody can tell you what to do with your Bitcoin.
- 49:20They can make a suggestion, and you are more than, you know, welcome to tell them to go pound sand.
- 49:24There's there's nothing in on my side of this microphone that is trying to suggest that you need to go spend your Bitcoin. That's that's for other people to say. You do whatever the hell with your Bitcoin that you wanna do with your Bitcoin. It's your Bitcoin.
- 49:37You're 100%
- 49:38sovereign, and that's
- 49:41the core
- 49:43of a Bitcoin circular economy.
- 49:46No one can tell you what to do with your money, and nobody can tell you what the value of your money
- 49:52is.
- 49:53That's just between you and a vendor, or you and a friend, or you and your remittance partner, however it is that you wanna look at it.
- 50:02Nobody gets to define
- 50:04the value of that but you and the other person.
- 50:08For instance,
- 50:10you can say, yeah, but
- 50:12the value of Bitcoin today is basically in dollars, and that's kind of like, you know, the markets decide. No, no, no,
- 50:18no. I don't I don't actually have to look at that if I didn't want to. If I'm in a Bitcoin circular economy and it's 100%
- 50:26Bitcoin being passed between people that are selling, I don't know, empanadas
- 50:29and, people that are selling houses and motorbikes and boat rides out on the Pacific Ocean,
- 50:35that's between me that value of how much Bitcoin I give them is between me and that person.
- 50:41It doesn't have to be
- 50:43centered on what the value is
- 50:46of the market.
- 50:48Now most people will do that.
- 50:50I'm not saying that they won't, and I'm not even saying that they should or they shouldn't look at it that way. I'm just saying that nobody's nobody's telling me that I have to look at 1 Bitcoin
- 51:01as a $110,000
- 51:03US.
- 51:04I could simply say I I have 1 Bitcoin.
- 51:08I think that that yacht that you own there, mister Yacht owner, is is worth 1 Bitcoin, and I would like to buy that yacht. If the yacht owner agrees that 1 Bitcoin buys that yacht, then that yacht owner is going to sell me that yacht, and I'm going to give him 1 Bitcoin.
- 51:23Maybe that yacht's worth $250,000.
- 51:27Who knows?
- 51:29That
- 51:30because the value of bitcoin is what we make of the value bitcoin because it's sovereign money for the first time.
- 51:37It's sovereign money And now it becomes
- 51:40a conversation
- 51:42between two people in a true Bitcoin circular economy.
- 51:46And I shouldn't I honestly, I shouldn't have picked on yacht because
- 51:50honestly, I'm
- 51:52have owning a yacht
- 51:54is like
- 51:55if you've ever talked to an RV owner,
- 51:58most of them, they think that they like an RV,
- 52:01find out that they don't really like having a recreational vehicle at all, and then they wish that they had never bought it. And the same is true for even a small boat.
- 52:11Could you imagine a yacht?
- 52:13A $250,000
- 52:14yacht with twin diesel 12
- 52:17cylinder engines
- 52:18and cooling systems and electrical systems. I mean, there's a lot of people that own a boat that wish they'd never got it. Not a never got a boat in the first damn place. There's a lot of boats that I've seen in
- 52:30in the
- 52:32in Colorado where I I go to a house up there all the time, which is by a lake. I see a lot of people whose boats haven't moved in ten years,
- 52:39and they're by a lake.
- 52:42It's clear that they're not all that interested in owning their boat.
- 52:45It sounds to me like a yacht would be a management nightmare, so let's talk about something more
- 52:51more along my lines of what I find valuable.
- 52:5510 acres of of arable land in Costa Rica.
- 52:59How much Bitcoin is that worth?
- 53:01I'm not required
- 53:03to go check
- 53:04Coinbase
- 53:05and find the price of the United States dollar against Bitcoin.
- 53:09And neither is the person who has 10 acres of arable land in Costa Rica and wants to sell it to me. Me and him can have a conversation of what we think the value is. I'm not saying that that happens.
- 53:22I'm saying that for the first time in the history of humanity,
- 53:25or at least the first time in the history history of humanity
- 53:29since,
- 53:33money was taken over and turned into essentially fiat by governments and people that have a lot of people in their pay on their payroll with guns.
- 53:43Before that time when money was private, we could have that conversation about what we thought something was truly worth.
- 53:50But when the when money was taken out of our hands and for whatever reason, we said, yeah, may the government should be in control of the money.
- 53:57Where
- 53:58a, where did we get that notion from in the first place?
- 54:01I think it was marketing by by people
- 54:05who just wanted to steal everything, and they, over hundreds and hundreds and hundreds and thousands of years,
- 54:11figured out that most humans are just rubes waiting to be told what to do, what to believe,
- 54:17what color they think they're seeing is actually some other color. It is amazing
- 54:22what you can do to the human mind. I've seen it in marketing.
- 54:27It's amazing that you can sell somebody the ugliest jeans
- 54:31if you pay a supermodel
- 54:33a whole shit ton of money to get in front of a camera while she's wearing it.
- 54:39And all of a sudden, those jeans, even though they're
- 54:42fugly as
- 54:43a f,
- 54:46become something everybody wants.
- 54:49I mean, back in the eighties, there was Mon Chichi.
- 54:52It was a stupid toy monkey,
- 54:54but the marketing campaign behind it made it one of those things where you it was sold out by Christmas.
- 55:00You couldn't get it for your kid.
- 55:03Many such cases.
- 55:05Why do you think that money is not a product?
- 55:09Because that's what fiat money is now. I can tell because it's been marketed.
- 55:15We got marketed out of the sovereignty of our money.
- 55:18And because of that, we constantly have to ask a third party what the value of that money is.
- 55:27You see how that works? It's non sovereign
- 55:30money.
- 55:32The only place that I can tell where sovereign money truly exists is in two places.
- 55:38One, a Bitcoin circular economy,
- 55:41and two,
- 55:42people that are willing to trade bricks of gold between each other physically,
- 55:46not paper gold,
- 55:48actual standing in front of the other person saying,
- 55:51here's my bar of gold. Where are the keys to the house that you're selling me? Because we're standing on the on my new front lawn. Where are the keys?
- 55:59Alright. That that's the that's the only time that you're gonna find
- 56:04actual sovereign money.
- 56:09So a Bitcoin circular economy
- 56:12is increasingly important.
- 56:14It's increasingly important
- 56:16as our as to how we perceive
- 56:19its importance. It's always been important. It will always continue to be important.
- 56:26How do we perceive that?
- 56:28That that's sort of what is the make or break of all of this.
- 56:32And the way that I'm beginning to perceive it is that I don't have to
- 56:37look at the price of Bitcoin in US dollars to find its value.
- 56:42I can have a conversation with somebody else who is like minded and doesn't need to necessarily look at the value. Doesn't mean they won't,
- 56:51and it doesn't mean I won't. It just means that we could.
- 56:55Whereas, if we're holding fiat,
- 56:58we don't have a choice.
- 57:00We don't have a choice.
- 57:04So
- 57:06that's
- 57:07the episode for today,
- 57:09and I do hope you got something out of it. I think it's a really good chapter
- 57:14for this book. I'm becoming a little bit more increasingly interested in
- 57:18possibly getting this book for myself and reading about the other Bitcoin circular economies because there's
- 57:24there's not just the Costa Rican one.
- 57:26These things are popping up in a lot of places.
- 57:29And what else does it mean? And what other ways can we live? Do we have to live the way that we're living? And I contend that the answer to that question is
- 57:39no.
- 57:41I'll see you on the other side.
- 57:43This has been Bitcoin and and I am your host, David Bennett. I hope you enjoyed today's episode and hope to see you again real soon.
- 57:51Have a great day.