Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / ColdCard Was An Inside Job | Bitcoin News
Transcript
- 0:02It is 08:11AM
- 0:04Pacific Daylight Time. It is the August
- 0:072026,
- 0:09and this is episode thirteen
- 0:11sixty
- 0:12five.
- 0:13Yeah. Thirteen sixty five
- 0:16of Bitcoin
- 0:17and boy howdy.
- 0:20People have been digging all over the cold card stuff.
- 0:25Is not gonna be a somber of a show as yesterday,
- 0:28you know, simply because we we
- 0:32it's over.
- 0:33Well, I mean, the attacks are still ongoing.
- 0:36If you have any kind of money on any kind of cold card, and at this point,
- 0:42just assume that everything is is jacked with cold card.
- 0:47And as far as I can still tell, this is only cold card. If you got money on cold card, I don't care what firmware edition. I don't care what,
- 0:56what, what, what, you know, if it's a mark one or a mark five,
- 1:00you know,
- 1:01consider getting your money off in somewhere else. I will continue with that warning forever, as well as this one. The phishing attacks are ramping up.
- 1:13Do not,
- 1:14do not,
- 1:15do not
- 1:16fall for an email that says, Hey man, here's your, here's your recovery button. Press this. You know, don't, don't, don't do that. Please, please, please, please, please, please. But we got, we've got all kinds of stuff going on today.
- 1:31I got bolts in the news.
- 1:33Strategy
- 1:34is in the news. I got,
- 1:37let's see who else, who else is here there? We are going to do some, some more cold card stuff. I want to read this from the rage. It's a low elites
- 1:45and she's kind of got like,
- 1:47an overview of, of what happened. And then in the second part of the show, we're going to continue with the, cold card thing
- 1:55and,
- 1:56talk about the phishing attacks,
- 1:59because there's some, some news there,
- 2:01but then
- 2:03we've got an interesting situation. Remember, right. I just a few seconds ago, I was talking about people are just crawling all over
- 2:11the whole cold card thing. And that means they're getting deep, deep, deep
- 2:17into the GitHub repository.
- 2:20And there's a couple of really old tweets that cold card made
- 2:24that it, it, this does not look good
- 2:28from the standpoint of it wasn't, maybe it wasn't just that Novak
- 2:33wasn't as paranoid as we thought.
- 2:35Maybe it wasn't just
- 2:37that he was
- 2:40turns out that maybe he was incompetent.
- 2:43It looks like maybe there was something else afoot and we'll we'll get into that. But then we're going to go down to Texas
- 2:51where
- 2:52it looks like there's a moratorium
- 2:55on a BTC miners,
- 2:58or not BTC miners on AI data centers.
- 3:02We'll we'll we'll get into that. It looks like Greg Abbott, the governor down in Texas
- 3:07has been getting enough,
- 3:09enough flack that maybe he wants to do a, an audit,
- 3:13which we should all be doing audits
- 3:15on everything we see.
- 3:18Clarity act will be the last up in the news today because it's getting down to the wire. Okay. So Boltz,
- 3:25b o l t z.
- 3:29It's a non custodial protocol. All right. But we'll, there'll
- 3:33be a further description here in a minute. But Boltz is a, kind of like a, a lightning network swapping service,
- 3:40but they've paused their service after a wave of AI
- 3:45assisted
- 3:46hacking
- 3:47attempts.
- 3:48Felix Ng from
- 3:50Cointelegraph.
- 3:52Bolts,
- 3:54a non custodial
- 3:55Bitcoin swapping service
- 3:57says that it has disabled its service until further notice
- 4:02after a rise in AI assisted hacking attempts over the last few months in opposed to X on Monday.
- 4:08Boltz said the decision came after seeing a steady increase in automated
- 4:14AI assisted probing of its infrastructure
- 4:17this year. Quote,
- 4:19over the past months,
- 4:22we have dealt with several exploits.
- 4:24Each was contained,
- 4:26but the pattern is clear.
- 4:28Attackers now iterate faster
- 4:31than a team of our size can find and patch. I'm going to pause right there. If you did not listen to the last part of yesterday's show where I get into swarm auditing,
- 4:43you might want to go back and listen to it because it's, I think I'm right.
- 4:48I think I've made the right call. I think what's going to take
- 4:52teams of people that don't even work for the companies that they love to help
- 4:56audit
- 4:57code. I know. I know. It's like, well, I don't know how to audit code. I don't even know how to code.
- 5:03Go back and listen to the last part of yesterday's show. Just, I, know, like I think I started talking about it about, you know, twenty minutes before the end of the show. And it's like almost that show is almost two hours long. It's like one hundred and thirteen minutes long. So,
- 5:20you know, you're gonna have to fast forward quite a bit to get there, but
- 5:24it's going to take, it's going to take the village to raise this idiot. I did just is I, I don't know how else to say it, but it's going to take
- 5:35several thousand people from now until the day that
- 5:40I guess we die
- 5:42to actual, like if we're using the products
- 5:45of a company, like let's say a hardware wallet manufacturer,
- 5:49then we're going to have to help them do whatever it is that we can help them do.
- 5:56And it doesn't mean working full time. It means that if I, if you got like a thousand customers of hardware wallet company,
- 6:03I don't know, X let's say, and there's a thousand people that are willing to help out,
- 6:08dude, you don't need to have a thousand people help out like 24 a day. But if a thousand people
- 6:15donate one hour of their week,
- 6:19think about that. That's a thousand hours of manpower a week. Yes, there will be noise. I get that part. There will be people that's that literally have so much no idea of what they are doing that it, you know, will inject noise into the system
- 6:36is just, I don't see any other way out of this.
- 6:40Bolts is not the only company that has kind of paused their,
- 6:44their service. There's another,
- 6:47Zeus
- 6:49Zeus lightning has a
- 6:51pause their service for the exact same reason. They are getting hit and they are getting hit
- 6:57hard by AI probing and AI attacks and exploit searching and all the rest of the stuff.
- 7:04They don't have team sizes.
- 7:06This is what I was saying about rate. This is a form of regulatory moating.
- 7:11Do you have enough money to buy enough AI tokens on the proper models that will help you actually guard
- 7:19against a 100 people coming after you when you've got a team of three,
- 7:25If you're if you use bolts as a service and you love them, you might consider donating, you know, some time if you have anything that you can offer. I mean, this we've gone from the value for value
- 7:40model
- 7:41into a, Oh my God, we're all going to die if we don't pitch in. It's it's like the bait,
- 7:49like if you're in a ship and it's taken on water
- 7:53and you've, you, you literally have to have a bucket brigade
- 7:57and maybe that's where we're at. The value for value bucket, brigade,
- 8:02bucket,
- 8:03big, great brigade.
- 8:05I can't, I can't even talk. I can't even talk. But you get what I'm going for here. Right.
- 8:11I mean, I hate using the analogy that the ship is sinking. I don't think that that's what it is. I just think that we find ourselves in a very heavy storm
- 8:20because ships can take on water during a very heavy storm and the ship itself is completely watertight.
- 8:27But when you've got 25 foot waves crashing over the bow of your ship, you're going to take on water.
- 8:33It's going to happen. You're going to need the whole fucking crew out there with a bucket
- 8:39just passing bucket after bucket after bucket to the dude at the edge of the boat.
- 8:43Who's throwing it back over, you know, literally back over the edge of the boat. That's what a bucket brigade is. It's also, you know, helps when you're putting buildings out that are on fire
- 8:54in the seventeenth century because there was no such thing as a fire engine. But let's let's continue quote
- 9:01after reviewing
- 9:02the results of our own recent security scans, we cannot responsibly re enable Bolt swaps,
- 9:09especially as we are being actively targeted by what appear to be multiple resourceful groups while we race to deploy fixes, end quote.
- 9:18Bolt's operational
- 9:20pause highlights the, difficulty that smaller development teams are facing
- 9:25as attacks discover vulnerabilities and adapt exploits faster than they can respond.
- 9:31Quote,
- 9:32in the past few days alone,
- 9:35we saw a drastic acceleration of attacks, and we do not believe this asymmetry will reverse,
- 9:41end quote, said Boltz.
- 9:44In July,
- 9:46Solana Foundation's new chief information security officer, Michael Coates,
- 9:51told Coin Telegraph there is a need to switch to automated defenses in the age of AI quote. We're at a tipping point as an industry where humans just cannot scale
- 10:02to meet these threats. Said Coats quote, the only path forward we have
- 10:06is to have autonomous defense
- 10:09that operates at the speed of machines
- 10:13in quote
- 10:15pay per Q a pay per prompt AI service that takes payment in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies said it has also been dealing with the surge in exploits possibly AI powered quote.
- 10:26We've been fighting off exploits every other week for several months, most of which we believe are AI powered.
- 10:34It's a very dangerous time out there in quote.
- 10:39Bolts
- 10:40lets users perform
- 10:42non custodial
- 10:43trustless atomic swaps,
- 10:46moving Bitcoin and Bitcoin denominated assets between the main net and different layers of Bitcoin, such as the Lightning Network and the liquid network.
- 10:55DeFi Lama
- 10:56showed total value locked on bolts
- 10:59at the time of writing was only $180,000
- 11:04Bolt said that no user funds have ever been at risk as all bolt swaps use advanced cryptography and are non custodial,
- 11:12which means users retain full control of their assets throughout the swap process.
- 11:17Bolt said its API will remain available to process refunds
- 11:22and a support team will stay reachable.
- 11:25Quote,
- 11:26what we are seeing
- 11:28is a major paradigm shift for Bitcoin services
- 11:31operating on an open source stack
- 11:34and it needs careful analysis.
- 11:37Do not expect swap services to resume
- 11:40shortly.
- 11:41End quote.
- 11:42They're
- 11:44not going to turn it back on.
- 11:47You know, when bolts first came out, people were like, oh man, this is freaking awesome.
- 11:51Bolts very well may be done.
- 11:55Zeus LN may very well be done.
- 11:59You know, what are the implications for E cash?
- 12:02What are the implications for Fed admit?
- 12:05You know, what are the, know, what are the implications for all the shit coins out there?
- 12:10The, the fact that I'm not seeing that other than defy,
- 12:15which I, which I'm pretty sure are all AI hacks.
- 12:19There's not a whole lot of hacks that I'm seeing on wallets,
- 12:23like Cardano shit. Right?
- 12:25I'm not seeing attacks def you know, against these particular chains
- 12:30or
- 12:31the things that revolve around the chains like, you know, wallet addresses and other types of security. I'm not seeing attacks on MetaMask and I'm not, I don't think that that's because
- 12:43look how much stronger their, their stuff is against, you know, compared to Bitcoin. I don't think that's it.
- 12:49I think there's no value there.
- 12:53I think there's no value in
- 12:56doing anything other than trying to attack things related to Bitcoin because that's where the real value is. This has nothing to do with.
- 13:04It's easier to hack, you know, things that are rotating
- 13:08around Bitcoin because you can't hack the chain, but you can, you can screw with wallets like we've seen and we'll, we'll get into the fact that this may have been
- 13:17something other than we thought on the second part of the show.
- 13:22But I'm right.
- 13:25I know I'm right.
- 13:27It's going to take a lot of us to somehow or another.
- 13:31I don't know how to donate like AI, you know, like open AI tokens. Not, not that that would cause open AI is kind of like not really used
- 13:40for coding. It's more of a, you know, it's more for writing and, and, and other things can code.
- 13:47I guess it could secure your, you know, personal website. But I, you know, you kind of need something like mythos or,
- 13:54or Claude code or, you know, Kimmy three or something like that to be really credible. How do you donate those tokens?
- 14:01You know, is there a credible,
- 14:04is there a credible way to pool
- 14:06these tokens? If, if you just don't, if you want to be able to give
- 14:10to some, somebody like bolts so that they can maintain automated AI defenses
- 14:16from here until the end of time at this point. I don't know how to do that. I, you know, if somebody knows something,
- 14:25please let me know so that I can announce it here on the show. But until then, we got to move on to your favorite guy, Michael Saylor.
- 14:34Strategy
- 14:35sells Bitcoin again after five weeks without buying Matthew
- 14:40DeSalvo from Bitcoin magazine. And before I even begin, let's pause.
- 14:48You couldn't pick a better time, sailor.
- 14:52You you it's not like you were living under a rock. You knew what was going on with the cold card hack,
- 14:59but yet
- 15:00now was the good, the best time for you to sell. Right? It was it was now.
- 15:05Wasn't next week. You couldn't wait a couple of days.
- 15:09You couldn't wait,
- 15:10you know,
- 15:12I don't know, maybe longer than a week.
- 15:17I find it suspect.
- 15:20I I at this point,
- 15:23Michael Saylor can go fuck himself.
- 15:26And and and we can, I guess we can apologize, you know, be apologist for him and say, well, he's just, he's just doing his business? You know, he's just,
- 15:34he's just, it's not him that's selling it's it's his company strategy.
- 15:38They're the ones that are selling, you know, and, and, and you know, maybe they're retired, you know, they're buying back their stretch to, you know, pump their, the, the S T R C,
- 15:49perpetual
- 15:50because it never, it's never gotten back to its a $100 peg. It's like 92
- 15:55or something like that, or at least it was F and they had to buy a shit ton of it to get it back up to 92
- 16:02and it's still not hitting its peg.
- 16:05You know, it's, it's time for Michael Saylor to retire
- 16:08that whole fucking thing
- 16:10That, I mean, it was a dumb idea to begin with. I mean, I've always said, you know, if somebody says, Hey, I got a yield product on Bitcoin.
- 16:18You need to ask where the yield comes from because right now it's coming from selling Bitcoin,
- 16:24Bitcoin treasury strategy
- 16:27on Monday announced that it had yet again
- 16:30sold a slice of its Bitcoin holdings. It offloaded $16.38
- 16:35Bitcoin for $104,700,000.
- 16:39I suppose it could have been worse.
- 16:43In a filing with the SCC, the company said the sale took place between July 27 and August 2 at an average price of $63.09
- 16:52$5.07 per coin.
- 16:54Proceeds were split to cover two obligations.
- 16:5752,400,000
- 16:59went toward dividend payments on strategies, preferred stock and 52,300,000
- 17:04funded buybacks of its stretch preferred shares.
- 17:07It marked the latest string of weeks where strategy has chosen to trim Bitcoin
- 17:12rather than add to it, continuing a pattern that began earlier this summer as the company leaned more heavily on stock sales and cash management to fund its obligations.
- 17:22Because
- 17:24it's apparently against the rules and strategy for anybody to develop a product or a service that is useful enough to be sold to the public and that,
- 17:35you know, product or service be so useful that a lot of people want to buy that product.
- 17:40They used to have a product.
- 17:42I don't know. I I have I have not seen strategy advertise
- 17:47anything
- 17:49but shit like stretch
- 17:51now offering 12%,
- 17:53by the way.
- 17:55It's all bullshit.
- 17:57They're not advertising
- 17:59a
- 18:00product that people can actually use their their their
- 18:04and
- 18:05you could you could say, well, I use stretch
- 18:09for yield. Okay. I mean,
- 18:11dude, I mean, you got fucking software engineers sitting behind desks. What are they engineering? If you come up with a better manifold for a car?
- 18:21Have you done anything in the space industry?
- 18:24Are you still working on software for business intelligence that actually works
- 18:29in a way that people say, I want that? I am willing to pay $10,000
- 18:35a year for a subscription
- 18:38for that.
- 18:40Yet we don't know. Like at this point,
- 18:43you don't know what strategy makes
- 18:45outside of A. I.
- 18:48Financial instrumentation.
- 18:50You and me. And I guarantee you nobody else actually knows anything
- 18:56that is produced
- 18:58by strategy.
- 19:01Nothing.
- 19:02They make
- 19:03nothing at this point or at least so it seems. I thought they had an a that they bolted AI onto their original, you know, business intelligence package, but I don't think so.
- 19:13At this point, it looks to me like strategy
- 19:16literally builds
- 19:18nothing.
- 19:20And I wonder,
- 19:22I wonder what their people do all day at the strategy headquarters.
- 19:28What exactly is it you do here, Bob?
- 19:31Well, I don't know.
- 19:33Nothing, I guess. It's fucking ridiculous.
- 19:38But people that do work
- 19:40and do build products
- 19:43are people like galaxy mind. The circle P is open for businesses where I bring plebs
- 19:48with goods and services,
- 19:50actual goods and services
- 19:53for sale in Bitcoin to other
- 19:55plebs just like you who want to buy said goods and services, but you will be buying it in Bitcoin
- 20:01because or well, you'll be
- 20:03you'll be buying in Bitcoin because if you're not selling it for Bitcoin, you're not in the circle P and galaxymind.space
- 20:11is a website
- 20:12that basically,
- 20:13well, let me, let me read, let me read to you this
- 20:17galaxymind.space
- 20:20is a free set of Bitcoin tools.
- 20:23No accounts, no KYC,
- 20:25no tracking.
- 20:26The core of it is a community submitted directory
- 20:29of over 100 merchants
- 20:32in around 19 countries who take Bitcoin
- 20:35for physical goods.
- 20:37So the focus is on spending sats, not just stacking sats.
- 20:42It also has a buying gauge that reads 10 market signals to answer whether or not now is a decent time to buy with a seven day forecast,
- 20:52a float tracker that estimates how much Bitcoin is realistically still available to buy a scoreboard comparing the Bitcoin treasury companies like strategy, Meta Planet twenty one and strive
- 21:03on the same MNAV basis and an allocation tool for Bitcoin adjacent securities.
- 21:09The data is timestamped and the methodology is public. So you can check the math for yourself.
- 21:15It's free to use and free to embed on your own site. But the biggest part of this is the amount of merchants.
- 21:23Now it's up to 128
- 21:24merchants
- 21:25in 20 countries
- 21:27that you can go to galaxymind.space
- 21:30and find, and you can buy their stuff.
- 21:34There's all, let's see. Where,
- 21:36where, hold on for a second. Let me, let me see what the hell is going on here.
- 21:40Like some got some, some funny business area. BTC
- 21:44Aloha,
- 21:47BTC Aloha
- 21:48makes Bitcoin beach wear art
- 21:51and, you know, Aloha shirts, dresses and towels and bags in linen,
- 21:57organic cotton and silk
- 22:00handmade to order in England,
- 22:02even though she's not in Hawaii. She's in, you know, in in in lovely
- 22:06Old England where she's making this stuff.
- 22:09But she's selling her apparel in Bitcoin and you're buying in a Bitcoin and you can find her at Galaxy Mind Dot Space. That's Galaxy Mind
- 22:19Dot Space. Today's vendor,
- 22:22the vendor of vendors
- 22:24in the Circle P.
- 22:26Okay.
- 22:27Lola leads
- 22:28from the rage. Well, actually the rage is is Lola leads as rag. She doesn't work for the rage. She owns it and she has sort of made a
- 22:40well, let's,
- 22:41let's just call it a rundown of everything you need to know about the cold card hack.
- 22:48Right? So I tried to do a decent job yesterday,
- 22:52but let's see what Lola has to say this morning.
- 22:57First and foremost,
- 22:59if you are an effective user,
- 23:01do not dispose of your cold card device.
- 23:05The UID that generated the seed might be used to help identify you as a rightful owner. If, if, if
- 23:12any funds are recovered,
- 23:14if you use cold cards as the majority of devices in your multi signature setup,
- 23:20only move funds via private mempool services,
- 23:22such as slipstream to avoid your transactions from being sniped.
- 23:27For more information, jump to your affected. Now what and chances of recovery sections in this article.
- 23:34And the article begins
- 23:36on July 30,
- 23:38a Reddit user posted in panic to the message board that one of their wallets left untouched since 2021
- 23:46had been drained for roughly 0.8
- 23:49BTC.
- 23:50Quote,
- 23:51I haven't done anything since creation except sending into the wallet. The user wrote
- 23:56quote, I'm hearing a potential issue with some cold card wallets being drained.
- 24:01Kevin Loic of the Bitcoin security firm wizard sardine posted on quote. I will not fund,
- 24:08but would like to get at least reports of trusted people
- 24:12in quote
- 24:14throughout the day, more and more reports of affected users started to roll in quote. There's no need to panic.
- 24:20Someone loaded a bad seed into a cold card and or leaked their seed. Rodolfo Novak
- 24:27founder of cold card manufacturer
- 24:30coin kite posted,
- 24:32on X
- 24:34The post
- 24:35has since
- 24:37been
- 24:38deleted quote.
- 24:40That post is wrong.
- 24:42Novak better known as NVK explained
- 24:45since Thursday over 1,000 Bitcoin worth more than a $100,000,000
- 24:49have been drained from cold card devices.
- 24:52Researchers that block part of Jack Dorsey Square were quick to identify the issue
- 24:57while implementing a new random number generator in 2021
- 25:01cold card engineers disabled
- 25:03the very feature that was meant to retain randomness
- 25:07from the devices hardware causing random number generation to fall back to the software library
- 25:14resulting
- 25:15in not creating enough entropy to be secure.
- 25:19Anyone
- 25:20with some compute is now able to recreate a cold card wallet seat
- 25:25in total four waves of suspected drainages have been identified
- 25:30over the past four days.
- 25:33You're affected.
- 25:34So what now?
- 25:36Well, if you're a cold card user and you were fortunate enough to not yet have been targeted for the drain, move your funds immediately to another device with high transaction fees to be included in the next possible block.
- 25:49When moving your funds to a new wallet, make sure that you are using legitimate software.
- 25:54An app being featured in an official app store such as Apple or Android gives absolutely no guarantee of the software's legitimacy.
- 26:03To be sure,
- 26:04navigate to the software's official X profile and only download software from links or sources on the project's website.
- 26:11Make sure to check follower counts and match the website
- 26:15to other officially available sources such as a project's GitHub page.
- 26:20If you're using cold cards as part of your multi signature setup
- 26:24and cold cards compose a signing
- 26:27majority
- 26:28of the multi sig wallet
- 26:31only move funds by utilizing a private mempool service such as marathon mining slipstream
- 26:37who are waiving all fees on their service for the foreseeable future.
- 26:43This keeps God,
- 26:45hold on. That actually surprises me because I don't like Mara or Marathon.
- 26:52And yet they're they're waiving all their fees on their service for the foreseeable future
- 26:58so that they can help
- 27:01this fucking catastrophe that Novak started.
- 27:04And it gets worse, by the way,
- 27:06not in this art. Well, maybe in this article, but later in the show, we'll you'll see.
- 27:11Anyway, it's the whole slipstream thing keeps attackers from learning your complete multi signature setup,
- 27:17which enables them to double spend your transactions in the mempool before confirmation,
- 27:22diverting them to their own addresses.
- 27:25If you do not have access to your cold card device,
- 27:28ask trusted persons to locate your device
- 27:32and move your funds for you.
- 27:35Alternatively, ask the person to send a picture of your seed via signal messenger so that you can move the funds yourself. Quote, don't have a spare key to your house. Have them smash open a window or kick down a door writes Bitcoin influencer,
- 27:49American huddle on X
- 27:51Quote, you are in a race against motivated and malicious people wanting to steal your wealth.
- 27:57Throw the regular rules out the window and do what you must in order to save your coins. Don't wait, end quote.
- 28:05Since the original attack reports have started to come in of cold card wallets being drained that have been protected by so called pass phrases,
- 28:13a mechanism which adds an extra layer of security
- 28:17to your original Bitcoin seed.
- 28:20All cold cards appear vulnerable depending on how much compute
- 28:24attackers are throwing at the problem.
- 28:27Should your wallet already have been drained? Do not panic
- 28:30immediately.
- 28:31Check whether the outgoing transactions have already been mined
- 28:35by filling the transaction
- 28:37ID
- 28:38into a public mempool explorer like mempool.space.
- 28:44If the transaction has not yet been mined,
- 28:48move fast
- 28:49to replace the malicious transactions
- 28:52via replace by fee, otherwise known as RBF
- 28:57to re transfer the funds into your custody.
- 29:01If the fraudulent transactions have already been mined,
- 29:05do not dispose of your cold card device that was used to generate the affected seed.
- 29:10The featured UID
- 29:12might be able to be used to determine you as
- 29:17the BTC's
- 29:18rightful owner.
- 29:20If any of your coins have been purchased via processes subjected to know your customer, or you have any other documentation over rightful ownership of coins, such as invoices featuring the payout addresses
- 29:32that can be corroborated
- 29:34by third parties. Your Bitcoin could be returned to you in case that Bitcoin is recovered.
- 29:42File a report
- 29:44with your local law enforcement cyber crime unit,
- 29:49as well as
- 29:50the FBI's
- 29:52internet crime complaint center
- 29:54to document your loss and be eligible to recover funds.
- 29:59What are the chances of recovering funds?
- 30:02Well, the chances of recovering at least some of the stolen proceeds appear slim,
- 30:06but not zero.
- 30:08Over the past few days,
- 30:11reports have surfaced of white hat hackers taking control of funds with the intention of returning them to their rightful owners.
- 30:19While it is unclear
- 30:21whether all waves of attacks have been initiated by the same person,
- 30:25at least some of the attackers
- 30:27do not appear to be very sophisticated.
- 30:31Alex Thorne of galaxy research, who has been tracing the money for the past five days following a suspicious pattern such as exorbitantly high fixed amount transaction fees
- 30:41originally identified by block researchers.
- 30:44He has stated to have identified at least one deposit
- 30:48to a cryptocurrency
- 30:50casino site,
- 30:51which he states
- 30:53to have the depositors identity
- 30:56on file.
- 30:57Researchers
- 30:58at block
- 30:59also have stated to have found that one of the attackers may have used a paid account
- 31:05at a well known blockchain services provider
- 31:08offering yet another potential avenue to identify the attackers.
- 31:14How did we even get here?
- 31:17Over the years,
- 31:19cold card has been one of the few true love brands within the Bitcoin only industry. The devices
- 31:25designed to look like calculators could function fully air gapped pictures of cold cards along raw meat and guns frequently popped up on the timeline.
- 31:35The devices even featured a designated area to shoot if the wallets were to be discarded.
- 31:42If you held anything of your conviction
- 31:45to the Bitcoin purity team,
- 31:47cold card was the device to secure your wealth and make you look extremely cool while doing so. In hindsight, many now acknowledge that the red flags
- 31:57had always been there.
- 31:59Coldcard's engineering team is alleged to have struck or stuck to a rather unconventional
- 32:04path of committing changes to the software, including a lack of commit descriptions
- 32:09as well as the direct commitment to cold cards, main repository without standard practice review
- 32:17quote
- 32:18committing direct
- 32:20to main
- 32:21without any peer review is acceptable only for a pet project. Right. Security researcher Taylor Moynihan
- 32:28on X quote, not something protecting 9 figures
- 32:32of other people's fucking money in quote.
- 32:36Novak's coin kite additionally held what appeared to be a rather subjective bounty
- 32:41program for vulnerability disclosures,
- 32:43which is another standard practice in software development.
- 32:48Anyway, the firm explicitly reserved the right to patch vulnerabilities
- 32:52without offering a bounty payout.
- 32:56So yeah, it's rather unconventional
- 32:58bounty program where somebody finds, you know,
- 33:02finds a thing and says, Hey, I found the thing. And, and, and they patch it and they don't actually pay you a bounty.
- 33:08It was basically just harvesting goodwill at that point. Just
- 33:15getting pissed. Sorry. Hold on. Take a breath.
- 33:20Complicating
- 33:22incentives
- 33:23to review cold card code further was Novak's rather adversarial
- 33:27approach to all competitors.
- 33:29After the hardware wallet developer foundation devices
- 33:33forked cold cards code
- 33:36and used for their own implementation,
- 33:38Novak decided to remove the project's free and open source license,
- 33:43placing the software instead under a viewable source license.
- 33:47You could see the source code. You just couldn't actually do anything
- 33:51with it because it was licensed.
- 33:53And if that license wasn't you anyway,
- 33:56but when no one is allowed to use your code,
- 34:00there's not very many people who have any incentive whatsoever
- 34:03to review it either.
- 34:06The commit message to change cold cards, random number generator
- 34:10changing fifteen
- 34:11thirty four lines of code then featured
- 34:14five or then features five characters and is simply the word
- 34:19runs
- 34:20notes, lightning developer, dusty Damon in a writeup of the incident,
- 34:25but the code could not have run
- 34:27had the software been correctly implemented.
- 34:30Let's read that again.
- 34:33The code
- 34:34could not have run
- 34:37had the software been correctly implemented.
- 34:41Damon points out quote, there is now
- 34:44no way for this code to compile.
- 34:48I assume in about a frustration
- 34:50he set the random number generator
- 34:52to zero,
- 34:54which would have resolved a compiler error
- 34:58setting RNG to zero completely removed the code
- 35:02that use the hardware random number generator.
- 35:05The compiler error was begging the programmer to reconsider
- 35:10his logic. Damon concluded
- 35:13quote, instead of that happening,
- 35:15the compiler error was simply silenced.
- 35:19The compiler was giving the developer one last chance
- 35:23to reconsider what he was about to do, but the alarm was ignored and then it was silenced.
- 35:30End quote.
- 35:32Developers are now questioning whether cold card has ever initiated a third party security audit on its software.
- 35:39The RNG is arguably
- 35:42the most important line of code in the firmware.
- 35:45Right? Pseudonymous
- 35:46cashew developer Cali on X quote. It would be interesting to know whether CoinKite did have external security audits and what those audits said.
- 35:58You can find CoinKite's
- 35:59disclosures here. And of course, here is actually an underlined link.
- 36:04Okay.
- 36:05There's more to this story,
- 36:08but there's two things here that I want to talk about before we run numbers.
- 36:13One is
- 36:15the code
- 36:17was
- 36:18not able to run because it wouldn't have been able to compile
- 36:23so that that's one thing.
- 36:25And there's two things that I want to say about it. The first thing that strikes me is remember coming out of 2017
- 36:32and
- 36:34there was,
- 36:35the, Sigwit or Sigwit,
- 36:38but I can't,
- 36:39segwit fork.
- 36:41Okay. Now, well we ended up getting segwit on actual Bitcoin
- 36:46on the actual Bitcoin
- 36:48blockchain.
- 36:49But there was there was a another
- 36:53the people that wanted to increase the block size during the block size wars.
- 36:57The you the user activated software basically,
- 37:01you know, killed, killed that whole thing.
- 37:04We were going to have Bitcoin the way Bitcoin was, but we were going to get segwit and that was it. And that's what we got, blah, blah, blah. And you can complain about what, whatever that caused with ordinals inscriptions
- 37:15later on, But that's what we were left with now. That's actual real Bitcoin.
- 37:20But they implemented a hard fork. There were you know, we're going to have four megabyte blocks anyway. We're going do all this shit anyway.
- 37:27And that
- 37:29fork
- 37:30never
- 37:31mind a block because there was an off by one error in the code
- 37:36and it completely failed on implementation.
- 37:39That is exactly
- 37:41what I was thinking when I read this line.
- 37:45But the code
- 37:46could not have run the software
- 37:49or had the software been correctly implemented. It wouldn't have run.
- 37:54And the, and here's the second part of what I want to say,
- 37:58and we're going to get into this. Okay. There was a change.
- 38:02We talked yesterday. I talked about the, well it fell, it fell back to this other, you know, the, this other thing it was, you know, that fell back to the software.
- 38:12What I didn't know at the time
- 38:15was this
- 38:19a developer at CoinKite
- 38:21could not get the code to compile unless
- 38:25he set the random number generator.
- 38:28The one thing the hardware wallet is supposed to be able to do is actually give you a true random number.
- 38:36He set it to zero. Essentially he turned it off
- 38:40and he turned it off so that he could get the goddamn code to compile
- 38:48and instead of fixing it later because maybe he did that or she did that, maybe they did that
- 38:55simply to get it to compile so they could fix something else. I don't, you know, or, or look at something else or whatever.
- 39:03But it's very clear now
- 39:05that people are looking, I mean, there's eyes all over this code. This code is basically probably more audited now
- 39:12than any other code in history
- 39:14except for the B the actual Bitcoin,
- 39:17code itself.
- 39:20We're finding out that they never fixed that
- 39:23in the 2021
- 39:24firmware upgrade
- 39:26random number generator.
- 39:27The code for that was set to off
- 39:32just so the software
- 39:34would compile.
- 39:39Think about that because we're going to come back to that particular
- 39:43commit
- 39:44in the GitHub stack. So if you don't know what GitHub is, lots of people use it to, you know, so other people can use their code. It's a way for many people to work on the same code. It is standard operating procedure in software development. GitHub is very well known
- 40:02and you can see who committed what,
- 40:06and we now we we're, we're now pretty sure that we know exactly
- 40:10who turned
- 40:11this off
- 40:14and exactly
- 40:15who set
- 40:17this version
- 40:18of the turned off random number generator
- 40:21to be committed
- 40:23or in other words
- 40:25enveloped into the actual code base that was going to be loaded on tens of thousands of cold card devices
- 40:32that you bought with your money so that you could think that you were actually protecting your money.
- 40:39And this is going to come back in the second part of the show. But first we got to run numbers.
- 40:53CNBC futures and commodities. And I guess we're all okay with Iran
- 40:59again
- 41:00because
- 41:01all energy is in the red. Brent Norsey is down 5.6%
- 41:05to under $80
- 41:07a barrel,
- 41:08$78.99
- 41:10West Texas intermediate getting hit just as hard,
- 41:13almost 6% to the downside.
- 41:16$75.49
- 41:17natural gas is not being a hedge today.
- 41:204.1%
- 41:22to the downside, 2.66
- 41:24per thousand and gasoline is down 4.4
- 41:27to $2.83
- 41:28a gallon and Merbon crude
- 41:31down 5% to $76.94
- 41:34metals, as you might imagine, are very much in the green today.
- 41:38Palladium is up over 7%
- 41:41gold is up, but it's only up a one and a quarter percent to $41.40
- 41:45and 6 dimes
- 41:46platinum is up 7.7%
- 41:49silver's up three and a half,
- 41:52just a hair under $60 per ounce. Copper is up 1.7%
- 41:57ag is mostly in the red, but there's a few green ones here. And the biggest winner today is coffee up almost a full point.
- 42:05Biggest loser is wheat down 2.11%
- 42:10live cattle is down 0.1%
- 42:12lean hogs down 0.2 feeder cattle up a third
- 42:16and the indices are all in the green because you know, Hey, we're all going to be fine with Iran for the fifteenth try and it's going to work this time. This time it's different.
- 42:26S and P is up one and a third NASDAQ is up 2.7%
- 42:30Dow is up one and a half and the S and P mini is up $1,464,100
- 42:38dollars is what we're getting on a Bitcoin today with a $1,290,000,000,000
- 42:42market cap. And we can get 15.7
- 42:45ounces of shiny metal rocks with our one Bitcoin of which there are 20,065,510.51
- 42:53Bitcoin
- 42:55in circulation. And the average fees per block are normal 0.02
- 43:00Bitcoin taken in fees on a per block basis.
- 43:02Again,
- 43:04about 45 blocks carrying 89,000
- 43:06unconfirmed transactions
- 43:08waiting to clear at high priority rates of two sats per V byte low priorities will get you in at 0.6,
- 43:16a nine forty
- 43:18nine extra hashes per second. I am surprised
- 43:21at just how much hash rate is still on
- 43:25after all of this,
- 43:27the bear market
- 43:29basically getting just getting kicked in the nuts with the cold card thing,
- 43:35bolt shutting down, Zeus lightning
- 43:38shutting down. I mean, maybe not permanently,
- 43:41but they ain't coming back in the foreseeable future. You got strategy selling Bitcoin and yet Bitcoin's like 64 ks, man, 64 ks. And the hash rate at 949
- 43:54is actually pretty damn high.
- 43:58And so that's all the protection that I need.
- 44:01But what I do need are donations. I need donations to the show
- 44:05because now more than ever, I really don't want to go get any kind of sponsors
- 44:12because I actually
- 44:14tried to go get coin kite as a sponsor for this show because at the time I still trusted them.
- 44:21Right? And I was completely ghosted and looked like they were actually going to do it. And then they found out that nobody likes me on X and then they said, fuck you.
- 44:30So I never had never got,
- 44:32I never got,
- 44:33you know, a sponsorship
- 44:36out of them. And I still to this day do not have a sponsorship. And a lot of that's my fault because
- 44:42I just, you know, I don't really reach out that much,
- 44:45but then again, something like the cold card incident comes along and reminds me that maybe I dodged a bullet.
- 44:52Don't know.
- 44:53But one thing that I do know is I got bills to pay and I love doing this show and I think it's an important show. I think it so that you can just listen on the train, go into work or wherever it is that you are. And you don't have to wade through the seven fricking Bitcoin news websites
- 45:10and filter out all the fricking garbage so that I can tell you what the hell is going on in Bitcoin today. And if you think that's valuable
- 45:17and you want to pay Fiat
- 45:19to help
- 45:20me out here,
- 45:22you can go to bitcoin and show.com that's bitcoinandshow.com.
- 45:26I got a couple of different paid tiers.
- 45:28You will get the exact same thing that even the free guys get, right? Because I want to make everything open.
- 45:37I don't want to hide shit. Oh, you can only see it if you pay me $50 a year.
- 45:42You can pay me $50 a year, but it's for value for value. If you think I'm bringing you value,
- 45:47then please show me some value back. Go to Bitcoin and show.com
- 45:52bitcoin and
- 45:54show.com
- 45:55that's bitcoin and show.com
- 45:58sign up for one of the two paid tiers. And if you just don't want to do that, you know, you can have the free one too. I will give you, you know, like two or three times a week. I convert a full show into a little write up. I've got a link to the show. I try to put some art in, you know, that, that represent is representative of what's going on in, you know, in that day's news
- 46:19and, and it, it, it for you, but it's also so that you can say, I listened to the show.
- 46:26I got $50.
- 46:28It's in fricking Fiat, but you know, here you go. You can go to Bitcoin and show and you can show your love there. And if you don't want to do it that way, you want to pay with Bitcoin.
- 46:38That's why I do value for value in podcasting
- 46:42and only podcasting 2.0
- 46:44allows you to send me a note
- 46:46like INPC
- 46:48who gave me a Petra boost on not cold enough yesterday's episode
- 46:53of Bitcoin. And,
- 46:56and as soon as his fricking
- 46:58thing comes up, I will let you know what he said. And I may not be able to do that. I may have to go back and get the regular one. Hold on.
- 47:07Okay. Here we go.
- 47:09I N P C with a Petra boost that is a row of seven, seven thousand seven hundred and seventy seven sat says, appreciate you Dave.
- 47:18At least you never profited from promoting
- 47:21cold card.
- 47:23Maybe getting banned from Twitter was a good thing. Value for value is super hard. I know my own little show generates pennies, but if we take the sponsorship cash,
- 47:34the risk of compromise is so much greater unless you have the time and inclination to fully scrutinize the sponsor and what sponsors want that.
- 47:44I hope Zaps improve over time.
- 47:47Big up.
- 47:49Thank you. I N P C.
- 47:52I
- 47:53appreciate that. Even after I've gotten your name wrong so many times, I, you know, I kept calling him LNPC,
- 48:01but it's not. It's INPC.
- 48:03I appreciate.
- 48:04I appreciate that, sir.
- 48:06Terron, who I've never seen before gives me 5,005
- 48:10sets. So it's a palindrome boost.
- 48:12Dave, give yourself some credit, please.
- 48:16We do listen and enjoy this podcast.
- 48:19We do think for ourselves.
- 48:21And if you are not, and if you are not,
- 48:25then that is you
- 48:27don't trust verify.
- 48:29We all just got reality checked. You damn Skippy. We did cause peeling with five twelve says, dude,
- 48:36I cannot blame you. I lost 27
- 48:39UTXOs.
- 48:41I don't blame you. Thanks for your work.
- 48:44I appreciate that, sir. Jason Highwood two fifty says the
- 48:48cold card thing is a bit distressing
- 48:51for non techie people like me.
- 48:53I didn't have a cold card. I have a different hardware wallet, but I was trusting that coder types were all checking the code on these things.
- 49:03Was cold card open source? No, it wasn't. It was known Jason. It was known as what's called source
- 49:10viewable.
- 49:12You could see and read the source code,
- 49:16but you could not use the source code and no outside
- 49:20person was able to make or suggest or basically make a pull request. As far as I know, they certainly couldn't make commits and we're going to get to that here in the commitment phase of a GitHub repository here in a minute. And, and I don't know. I'm
- 49:36going to be honest. I don't, I've never actually seen a GitHub repository that has source viewable only. I don't know what exactly that means. I can only, from what I understand from other people, it means yes, you can read the code,
- 49:50but I don't know if that means that you can. So I guess it means that you can't clone the repository,
- 49:57which means that you have a complete copy of everything
- 50:00in that repository
- 50:02on your own machine
- 50:04or
- 50:05recommit it back to your own
- 50:08GitHub account
- 50:10so that you can start pulling it apart, have your own pull requests, have your own commit, start making your own thing. I'm not exactly
- 50:17sure
- 50:18what source viewable
- 50:20actually is in the full parameter set of what source viewable is. But one thing I can tell you,
- 50:26no one was allowed to use this code
- 50:29after March 2021 before
- 50:32that
- 50:33it was fully open source.
- 50:35And remember what I read to you foundation devices
- 50:39got, you know,
- 50:40did what people on GitHub do with free and open source software.
- 50:44They clone the GitHub repository
- 50:46from cold card and they built their own device
- 50:49and Novak
- 50:52hit the ceiling
- 50:53and shit the bed at the same time, about that. And then closed up the source code and read it and put all the sort, all of the source code under a completely different kind of use license
- 51:08so that you weren't able to actually use the code.
- 51:11That's we'll get into that a little bit heavier here in a second.
- 51:16Nick dose with a two fifty two says cheers
- 51:19and Noster gang with 101
- 51:22sat says this whole thing is fucked.
- 51:25If anyone needs someone to talk to hit me up,
- 51:28I'm not technical, but willing to help in any way I can.
- 51:32I do work in data validation.
- 51:35Perhaps that could be useful in some capacity.
- 51:38Again, that is Noster gang
- 51:40on Noster.
- 51:42If you're not on Noster, you have to ask yourself the question why?
- 51:46Because there are really good people and Noster gang is one of the really good people. Nick Dose is great. Jason High is great. Cause peeling is great. INPC is great.
- 51:56Terren seems like a good guy. I mean, I've never actually entered. I don't think I've ever actually interacted with Terren, but they're all on Doster
- 52:04and,
- 52:05and
- 52:06Noster gang
- 52:08she's helping or she's offering to help you, you know, maybe just as even an emotional salve. If you just need someone to talk to Nostrad gang is offering herself up as, as you know, a sympathetic ear. So you might want to consider that
- 52:24if you got, if you got hoes,
- 52:27that's the weather report.
- 52:38Welcome to part two of the news that you can use where we will beat a dead horse
- 52:43Hardware wallet firms warned of phishing surges
- 52:47as cold card losses near
- 52:50$130,000,000
- 52:53Stephen Graves
- 52:55on the scene for decrypt.co
- 52:57hardware wallet manufacturers,
- 52:59treasure
- 53:00and foundation
- 53:01have warned of a surge in phishing attempts trading
- 53:04on the cold card firmware exploit
- 53:07with
- 53:08scammers chasing users, recovery phrases, and pushing malicious downloads.
- 53:13Trezor said it was already seeing an increase in phishing attempts following the disclosure, telling users to enter a wallet backup only on the device itself
- 53:21and reiterating that its own hardware was unaffected.
- 53:25Foundation said it
- 53:27had been made aware of emails impersonating
- 53:29that firm
- 53:31and pushed recipients towards fake websites and malicious downloads. Adding that foundation itself will never ask for a recovery phrase nor tell users to install software to secure a wallet
- 53:44security firm proof point documented a phishing campaign targeting
- 53:48cold card users on Monday.
- 53:51Email sent from a spoofed cold card address invite recipients to complete a quote coordinated
- 53:58hardware
- 53:58audit,
- 54:00a theme lifted from the security incident itself
- 54:04and linked to a clone cold card site carrying
- 54:07a quote start hardware
- 54:09audit button. And you probably can tell what the hell that button does.
- 54:15Clicking the button in fact, pulls a batch file hosted on GitHub,
- 54:20which installs screen connect a legitimate remote access tool.
- 54:26Proofpoint said that gives attackers a route to data and financial theft or to follow on
- 54:32malware
- 54:33such as ransomware.
- 54:35The fake site also runs a customer service chat window.
- 54:39Proofpoint said a real person, not a bot answers in that window
- 54:44and walks victims through the installation,
- 54:46assessing the breach as an effective social engineering lure
- 54:50because it preys on the fear and concern holders now have about their crypto security.
- 54:56The cold card exploit stems from the March 2021 firmware build
- 55:01that drew wallet seeds from a software fallback
- 55:05instead of the devices hardware,
- 55:07random number generator leaving private keys, guessable
- 55:11galaxy research has confirmed
- 55:13three waves
- 55:15of thefts since July 30 and puts high confidence in losses
- 55:19at $15.96
- 55:21Bitcoin.
- 55:22That's well above a $100,000,000
- 55:25including a fourth wave. It suspects,
- 55:28but is not confirmed
- 55:30that total could reach $130,000,000
- 55:34The firm's head of research, Alex Thorne said Tuesday that at least 15 separate attackers,
- 55:4015
- 55:41separate attackers are now exploiting the flaw noting that every wave, but the first was identified through victim reports.
- 55:49Cold card manufacturer CoinKite has issued patched firmware
- 55:53and told affected users to move funds to newly generated seeds pausing to say,
- 55:59just do never use CoinKite products again. Never use CoinKite products again.
- 56:05Never
- 56:06use
- 56:07CoinKite products again.
- 56:09I won't tell you where to go because I was telling people to get cold cards. I'm not going to, I'm not, I can't, I can't.
- 56:17I,
- 56:18right now today,
- 56:19I cannot offer you another vendor, but do not fucking use CoinKite.
- 56:26Rodolfo Novak
- 56:28and his friend, Mr. Gray can go fuck themselves.
- 56:31And if you don't know who Mr. Gray is, you will hear in a minute. But before we do that, let's finish this.
- 56:39Just so you know,
- 56:41phishing campaigns have used an array of methods to target hardware wallet owners
- 56:47in February,
- 56:48treasure and ledger users were hit by a physical mail campaign
- 56:53impersonating
- 56:54the firms complete with holograms
- 56:56and forged executive signatures
- 56:59built around the same manufacturer deadline.
- 57:02A counterfeit ledger app drained millions of dollars from holders in April
- 57:07and a March campaign used fake GitHub issues to lure developers onto a spoofed site.
- 57:15Galaxy research said the cold card exploit is on going
- 57:19and urged holders to move funds to a fresh seed
- 57:23or to a custodian
- 57:25giving the fishing lure a long potential shelf life.
- 57:29That last sentence,
- 57:31I want to reiterate why it's important.
- 57:34This fishing campaign is going to go on fucking forever.
- 57:38And here's why. Because before the days of AI,
- 57:42I would actually have to, I don't know, like one day wake up and go, you know, I haven't fished somebody for that exploit that happened
- 57:50two years ago in long time. You know, maybe I should put that back out. No, no. Now,
- 57:56now I can just harness like three or four different artificial intelligence
- 58:01agents
- 58:02utilizing
- 58:0312 different LLMs
- 58:05and
- 58:06just have it automate that for me.
- 58:09Phishing campaigns
- 58:12are not just this, but essentially everything
- 58:16are now fully automated. Now they, I
- 58:20know there's been automated fishing campaigns before,
- 58:23but now all of them are going to be automated
- 58:27because if you're competing in the, I need to steal somebody's
- 58:31money
- 58:32arena,
- 58:33you're not going to be able to survive unless you can afford the tokens to be able to do it.
- 58:38Remember what I was saying yesterday,
- 58:41small companies will not have the money available to them to be able to daily audit their code or daily, you know, basically look for, for, you know, use every new model under the sun
- 58:53every day that a new model comes out. You'll have to use that to reevaluate
- 58:58your code, to see if that model finds something different. And unless you have the money for the tokens,
- 59:03you don't survive. And that's legitimate.
- 59:06That is, that is legit
- 59:08businesses.
- 59:09They may be assholes for doing it, but it's still legitimate business. We're now in the realm of talking about fishing, which is clearly illegitimate
- 59:18and they are going to have the same problems. If you want to compete in the field of stealing people's money, you're going to have to use AI.
- 59:26Do you have enough tokens to be able to spend
- 59:29and is your spend less than what you received from the phishing attempts that are now 100% fully automated?
- 59:38I,
- 59:39again,
- 59:40I know I'm right.
- 59:42Swarm audits are the only thing that is, is going to be able to, to get not only save people in different situations,
- 59:51but to allow smaller
- 59:52teams because we used to say, well now one guy can build the next billion dollar company.
- 59:58Are we sure
- 1:00:00is, is that already over as of K three from Kimmy or from moonshot or whatever, you know, Kimmy K three from moonshot AI over in China ever since that shit dropped. It's like that's that, that Rubicon moment kind of at least, at least that's what it looks like.
- 1:00:18Is it now possible for one guy with, you know, a harness full of AI agents to be able to actually build the next a 100,000,000,000 trillion dollar company? I don't know. I don't think so. I think we're right back to where we were before all this bullshit started
- 1:00:34because you
- 1:00:35don't have enough token.
- 1:00:41All right.
- 1:00:44What is a retirement attack?
- 1:00:47Well,
- 1:00:50I got a screenshot here
- 1:00:53of BLK
- 1:00:54$0.01 4 asking that very question
- 1:00:57directly as a reply to cold card. So cold card wrote something about retirement
- 1:01:03and, or rather
- 1:01:05cold card themselves actually wrote a, a, a, a, a tweet
- 1:01:10back in 2021
- 1:01:13back in 2021
- 1:01:14when
- 1:01:16the whole RNG being set to zero was actually done
- 1:01:22with that. That commit was made in March
- 1:01:242021
- 1:01:26where they set RNG to zero so that the fucking code would compile
- 1:01:30in October
- 1:01:322021
- 1:01:33cold card made say, said something made a joke about a retirement attack.
- 1:01:38BLK zero fourteen
- 1:01:40writes back and says, what
- 1:01:42is a retirement
- 1:01:44attack?
- 1:01:46And cold card out of the kindness of their heart took time out of their fucking day
- 1:01:51to write this back.
- 1:01:53It's when the project makers
- 1:01:56could have a quote bug
- 1:01:58in the entropy
- 1:01:59generation
- 1:02:01for later retrieval.
- 1:02:04You want to sit with that for a moment or shall I tell you what Michelle Weekly
- 1:02:09did right after that comment? Cause she was, you know, she's on X and she replied directly to that, to that statement, the cold card made,
- 1:02:18you know, it's odd.
- 1:02:19I think she found it odd that that he's like, well, this particular retirement account or retirement
- 1:02:25attack, this isn't the entropy generation.
- 1:02:28That's
- 1:02:29our, when that's the random number generator.
- 1:02:32Remember
- 1:02:33RNG was set to zero. So the code could compile and it was shipped in that state to thousands of people.
- 1:02:43And he's talking about that's how you get your, that's how you go to retirement.
- 1:02:47Or you could also be said that's how you attack other people's retirement Cause that's what both
- 1:02:53happened at the exact same time. This, this attack allows somebody to retire
- 1:02:57on the back of the retirement of other people.
- 1:03:02So Michelle weekly,
- 1:03:04she writes back to cold cards, you know, cold card joking around and says, Grock,
- 1:03:10what are the mathematical
- 1:03:12odds that cold card would make this joke? And then the exact scenario they're joking about
- 1:03:18turn out to be true a few years later.
- 1:03:22I know it's Grock,
- 1:03:24take it with a grain of salt, but even Michelle Weekly is like, dude, what are the chances?
- 1:03:28Grock happens to think the odds of pure coincidence
- 1:03:32is effectively zero
- 1:03:37retirement attack,
- 1:03:40a bug in the entropy generation
- 1:03:44for later retrieval. What does later retrieval mean? It means I know,
- 1:03:49I know because nobody else could view my code. Now this is pure conjecture. Okay. I know because nobody can actually see the, you know, this deep into the code commits
- 1:04:00that we actually set RNG to zero. So this fucker would compile or maybe
- 1:04:05we just set it to zero
- 1:04:08and we ship it that way.
- 1:04:10And we keep it shipped that way all the way up until now.
- 1:04:15That's the retirement attack because Oh, at that point maybe it is the case. And I'm not again, conjecture.
- 1:04:21Maybe it was Rodolfo Novak
- 1:04:23and a gentleman named Peter Gray and maybe a couple of other people at coin kite decided
- 1:04:29that they wanted to retire
- 1:04:31and they pulled out the retirement attack,
- 1:04:34which is
- 1:04:35RNG set to zero.
- 1:04:39Now again,
- 1:04:41100%
- 1:04:42pure conjecture. I have no evidence
- 1:04:45of,
- 1:04:46know, this, this kind of, you know, malfeasance
- 1:04:50actually it's not even malfeasance. It's just straight up death.
- 1:04:53I have no proof and I'm not going to conjecture any longer because I want to get to this one.
- 1:05:02Dylan Leclaire
- 1:05:04has a screenshot
- 1:05:07and
- 1:05:08essentially the screenshot
- 1:05:09is of,
- 1:05:12hold on the
- 1:05:14screen. I'm
- 1:05:15sorry. I'm sorry. Something flickered and it caught my attention. And for some reason or another,
- 1:05:20my
- 1:05:22browser is not,
- 1:05:25well, that's weird.
- 1:05:26My browser is not,
- 1:05:28allowing me to zoom into this
- 1:05:32anyway. So Dylan Leclaire posted a screenshot
- 1:05:37and
- 1:05:38I'll tell you what the screen. I can't really describe what the screenshot is. It's basically
- 1:05:44looking at PGP keys
- 1:05:46in the GitHub repository
- 1:05:48of CoinKite.
- 1:05:49And those PGP keys would be basically generated by people that are making pull requests,
- 1:05:55but moreover
- 1:05:56people that are actually
- 1:05:58changing
- 1:05:59the coin kite code
- 1:06:02and committing that code to what goes out into production
- 1:06:07to make sure that the person that did it actually has a like that that person is who that person says they are.
- 1:06:14A lot of people will use it. Here's my PGP key. And that's what you use to sign the commit that actually gets the changes you made
- 1:06:23into the production code.
- 1:06:25Well,
- 1:06:27we thought it was this one guy that did this RNG set to zero, but it turns out
- 1:06:33that it's probably another guy.
- 1:06:36Right?
- 1:06:38Here's what I mean.
- 1:06:41The PGP
- 1:06:42key that was actually used
- 1:06:44to sign
- 1:06:45the commit
- 1:06:46and a whole bunch of other stuff around the RNG
- 1:06:49equaling zero thing where, where the entropy was basically
- 1:06:53screwed. And that's what caused this entire mess in the first place.
- 1:06:57That PGP
- 1:06:58key actually belongs to a gentleman named Peter Gray.
- 1:07:03And who may you ask is Peter Gray. He's the chief
- 1:07:07technical officer or yeah,
- 1:07:10door chief technology
- 1:07:11officer
- 1:07:12of
- 1:07:13CoinKite and
- 1:07:15the co founder
- 1:07:17of CoinKite.
- 1:07:20We all see Rodolfo Novak as the face of the cold card.
- 1:07:24Hardly anybody knows who Peter Gray is
- 1:07:27yet. It turns out
- 1:07:29that Peter Gray
- 1:07:31looks like the dude
- 1:07:32that made this commit.
- 1:07:35And it also looks like he's the guy that set RNG to zero to get the code to compile.
- 1:07:45It's
- 1:07:49it's if
- 1:07:51this ends up being true, it's reprehensible.
- 1:07:55So I ran across a tweet from a guy named James Robb or I'm sorry, James OB or Jay actually it's, it's James O'Byrne.
- 1:08:04Who's been looking at this particular situation
- 1:08:08and he's got, he's got a, a get, well, he's got an analysis on GitHub
- 1:08:14at his own GitHub repository
- 1:08:16about the very situation that that came up from Dylan Leclaire. Now that screenshot that Dylan Leclaire,
- 1:08:24sparked a lot of stuff.
- 1:08:26And I don't know if it was James O'Burney came up with the first, but it doesn't matter.
- 1:08:32The title
- 1:08:33is
- 1:08:34switch
- 1:08:35equals
- 1:08:37doc hex
- 1:08:39proven by GPG
- 1:08:40commit signatures.
- 1:08:42The question,
- 1:08:44here's the question. This is important
- 1:08:46is the GitHub alias
- 1:08:49switch, which is spelled with a K and not an H at the end, but with a K, but I'm going to call it switch. Cause I don't know how to pronounce that other word is the GitHub alias switch
- 1:08:59actually doc hex,
- 1:09:02which is Peter Gray's alias on GitHub
- 1:09:07on the basis of GPG signatures over Git commits.
- 1:09:12So who's switch?
- 1:09:15Well, switch
- 1:09:17was actually the guy that we thought was making the GitHub commit,
- 1:09:24but switch had to use a PGP to actually sign that commit to get the code into production.
- 1:09:31And everybody can see that PGP key on these commits.
- 1:09:35So we know,
- 1:09:37at least up until yesterday, we thought it was this guy named switch that did it.
- 1:09:41But upon further examination,
- 1:09:43the PGP key
- 1:09:46isn't switches key.
- 1:09:48It's matched
- 1:09:49to Peter Gray,
- 1:09:51the CTO
- 1:09:52of CoinKite.
- 1:09:55So the answer to the question reads like this. And again, this is on, on James O'Byrne's,
- 1:10:01GitHub.
- 1:10:02He asked the question is the GitHub alias switch
- 1:10:07actually doc hex, which is Peter Gray's alias
- 1:10:11on the basis of
- 1:10:13GPG
- 1:10:14signatures
- 1:10:15over Git commits
- 1:10:18answer.
- 1:10:19Yes.
- 1:10:21Cryptographically
- 1:10:22proven
- 1:10:2458 commits were authored as switch
- 1:10:28and they carry valid GPG signatures,
- 1:10:31but they were made with doc hex's personal key.
- 1:10:35That's Peter Gray,
- 1:10:36the CTO
- 1:10:37of CoinKite.
- 1:10:39The same key that signs doc hexes
- 1:10:43commits
- 1:10:44in the exact same repository
- 1:10:47interleaved
- 1:10:48in time.
- 1:10:50The switch GitHub account has no GPG
- 1:10:53key of its own.
- 1:10:56Okay. So there's a guy working or doing work for, for CoinKite.
- 1:11:00His name is switch. He makes this change in the random number generator
- 1:11:05sets it to zero so the code can compile. That's what that's
- 1:11:10the story so far. And then
- 1:11:13switch
- 1:11:15signs a commit
- 1:11:17to get that exact
- 1:11:20RNG set to zero into production code,
- 1:11:24which means it's going to be copied and put on all the devices that are made by coin kite and mailed to customers who paid them good money to try to secure their futures the right way.
- 1:11:35Switch never had his own GPG
- 1:11:39signature.
- 1:11:42Peter Gray's
- 1:11:43signature is the signature used to make that commit, but it was made in switches account,
- 1:11:50but it was signed for by Peter Gray's PGP key.
- 1:11:55We know it was Peter,
- 1:11:57the guy that introduced the bug,
- 1:12:00at least getting it into production code
- 1:12:03was Peter Gray
- 1:12:05chief technologist,
- 1:12:07technology
- 1:12:08officer of coin kite and he did so in March 2021
- 1:12:13and then you've got in October
- 1:12:15of that same year,
- 1:12:17cold card making jokes about retirement attacks
- 1:12:21and how it is basically
- 1:12:24where a
- 1:12:25bug is introduced
- 1:12:27in the entropy generator
- 1:12:30for retrieval at a later date.
- 1:12:35It was a long con.
- 1:12:39I have no proof that that was a long con,
- 1:12:42but I'm calling it
- 1:12:44for the entirety
- 1:12:46of this time since at least more, I don't know what changed in March 2021. We might want to go back and look at what events
- 1:12:54surround were, were surrounding Bitcoin
- 1:12:56March
- 1:12:572021
- 1:12:58aside from COVID.
- 1:13:00Well, actually that may have been it. Maybe it was just the fear of COVID anyway, that's when it was made. But since that time
- 1:13:06they knew they were going to rug. I think this is 100% an inside job as to whether or not Rodolfo Novak and Peter Gray are actually the ones doing it. Can't prove it. I don't know.
- 1:13:20Where's Novak
- 1:13:21and where the fuck is Peter Gray? These are the questions that we need to be asking.
- 1:13:30It is
- 1:13:31my belief at this time until something changes.
- 1:13:35This was actually a robbery
- 1:13:38committed on people
- 1:13:40that
- 1:13:41really thought
- 1:13:43coin kite was above board.
- 1:13:46If
- 1:13:47it's true, Novak and Peter Gray played on the hopes and dreams of thousands of people that just wanted to do the right thing
- 1:13:55for their families and for themselves.
- 1:13:58And they ate it like
- 1:14:01dog food.
- 1:14:04Need nobody at this point, nobody at coin kite
- 1:14:09needs to be able to escape
- 1:14:11because this, this looks like it was pure theft from the inside.
- 1:14:16It doesn't. It no longer looks like
- 1:14:20it was done from somebody who accidentally
- 1:14:22discovered
- 1:14:23this particular bug
- 1:14:25by what did I say yesterday? Looking through all of the, firmware upgrades over the years and finding if asking the question to like Kimmy three or whatever
- 1:14:37saying,
- 1:14:38look at all these, look at all these firmware upgrades and tell me which one introduces any kind of bug that I can use to exploit.
- 1:14:45That bug was there. It was done on purpose. The exploit was basically sitting there and it looks like to me that mr. Gray and mr. Novak decided to abscond with everybody's money.
- 1:14:56That's what it, that's what I believe 100%
- 1:14:59in my core at this moment of time that could change
- 1:15:04because I don't have, I I'm I, if I get new info, like new shit has come to light, man. If new shit comes to light man, then maybe I'll change my mind. But for right now I can't see past.
- 1:15:18This was a very
- 1:15:20long
- 1:15:20con
- 1:15:23and good people paid the price.
- 1:15:27Let's move to Texas.
- 1:15:29Texas electric grid moratorium
- 1:15:32won't have a big impact on Bitcoin miners according to Bernstein,
- 1:15:37Robert Locken
- 1:15:38from CoinTelegraph.
- 1:15:40Bitcoin miners with operations in Texas are not expected to be impacted by a moratorium
- 1:15:45on the approval
- 1:15:47of data center projects connected to the state's grid operator ordered by governor Greg Abbott,
- 1:15:53Bernstein analysts said on Tuesday
- 1:15:55because
- 1:15:56Abbott on Monday directed the public utility commission of Texas and the electric reliability council of Texas, otherwise known as ERCOT to audit
- 1:16:06all data centers
- 1:16:09seeking to connect to the state's power grid.
- 1:16:11The duration of the audit was not specified and comes amid increasing public backlash to the pace of data center build out across the state.
- 1:16:20Bernstein analysts told clients on Tuesday
- 1:16:23that as most of the Bitcoin miners operating in Texas are under contract for approved electric capacity.
- 1:16:29Those operations are unlikely to be impacted by any of the moratorium.
- 1:16:34However,
- 1:16:35we believe this is a quote,
- 1:16:37this audit throttles speculative data center pipeline
- 1:16:40and makes genuine sites with development history more valuable. The research team led by Gautam Chunagi
- 1:16:48said in its note quote, Bitcoin mining sites are favorable places
- 1:16:52with the longest gestation,
- 1:16:54self funding infrastructure
- 1:16:56and local community management. They said, let's pause right there. What did he just say
- 1:17:02Because of this moratorium and because of the wild ass build out,
- 1:17:07expectations
- 1:17:08across the artificial intelligence
- 1:17:11industry,
- 1:17:13the previously existing Bitcoin mining sites with previously
- 1:17:17existing power contracts
- 1:17:20have become even more valuable.
- 1:17:23We might be losing some miners here in the future because it looks like it just doubled the buy price of any of these miners that were already there.
- 1:17:32Continuing,
- 1:17:33they said that local operators,
- 1:17:36operations of cypher digital and core scientific and clean spark could be the miners most exposed to future public opposition
- 1:17:42to data center expansion,
- 1:17:44particularly
- 1:17:45during ERCOT's approval process
- 1:17:47to convert their pipeline assets into grid connected power capacity quote.
- 1:17:52We believe with increasing political opposition to new data center projects and fresh capacity being throttled by moratoriums and state directives,
- 1:18:01the approved
- 1:18:02megawatts
- 1:18:03become even more valuable. They said highlighting the Texas mining operations, iron,
- 1:18:08which is fully ERCOT grid approved and the operations of riot platforms.
- 1:18:13C I F R shares were down more than 7% on Tuesday's pre market trading. According to Yahoo finance data,
- 1:18:21the minor reported second quarter results earlier on Tuesday, posting a loss of 65¢
- 1:18:27per diluted share widening from last year's loss of 12¢ per diluted share.
- 1:18:32So no more, no more AI data center build outs in Texas, at least for the time being
- 1:18:39until I guess, I guess the audit's going to include,
- 1:18:43exactly how much power do you want and how are you going to get it here? And this is, this is sort of what I, where I think all this is going right
- 1:18:51now. The data center build out is basically the data center guys, the investors
- 1:18:57behind it and all the people that are planning it.
- 1:19:00This is low hanging fruit.
- 1:19:03I will just connect to the state's power grid. Dude, it's going to be great. We'll just pay him money. We'll pay him money for the power. But now that power is becoming more and more scarce and it's causing problems
- 1:19:14for residents because residential
- 1:19:16power bills are indeed going up. And I'm not saying this because my next sentence is going to be kill, kill everything, you know, like make sure I know, no, I don't want to whatever
- 1:19:26I what I'm getting at is that I think that this audit
- 1:19:31represents itself its own kind of crossing the Rubicon.
- 1:19:35You will not be able to functionally be an AI data center unless you produce your own power.
- 1:19:43I think that's where we're going.
- 1:19:45And I think it's going to be great for natural gas because out in West Texas where there is a fuck ton of natural gas wells that are abandoned because nobody had the money to build the pipes to it. I'll bet you start seeing a lot of pipelines being laid for natural gas in West Texas
- 1:20:01because these data centers are going to bet you my top bottom dollar
- 1:20:07that Texas is going to start saying, sure,
- 1:20:10we'd love to have you and your data center come party with us. But buddy,
- 1:20:15this is bring your own power.
- 1:20:17We're not providing an open bar.
- 1:20:19You got to generate your own power.
- 1:20:22And
- 1:20:23furthermore,
- 1:20:26in order to do that, you're going to have to agree
- 1:20:30to grid stabilization,
- 1:20:31which means that in times of stress on the power grid,
- 1:20:36you're not your power that you are required to produce yourself.
- 1:20:39We'll buy it from you, but you're going to be required to switch over to the grid and send the power that you generate for your data center out to the, to Texas grid or at least a portion of it
- 1:20:52to help out. But I think the days of power or AI and data centers just easily being able to connect to some state or regional grid,
- 1:21:02that shit is now over.
- 1:21:04They're going to have to come bearing their own gifts
- 1:21:08and that it'll be a gift of power.
- 1:21:11Last up clarity act teeters.
- 1:21:14And as it does a mystery group hammers away at crypto in Washington ads, CoinDesk,
- 1:21:20Jesse Hamilton writing
- 1:21:22the crypto industry's central policy drive is to get us laws that elevate it to a fully regulated and government approved corner of the financial system.
- 1:21:32While the legislation to do that is kind of struggling with its final Senate test,
- 1:21:38A mystery organization
- 1:21:39is flooding Washington DC with ads linking crypto to terrorists
- 1:21:45and drug cartels.
- 1:21:46Surprised they didn't use child fucking trafficking.
- 1:21:49Across television and social media, the localized campaign warns in one example, quote, the worst people
- 1:21:56operating in the darkest places use crypto
- 1:21:59because there's no guardrails
- 1:22:02in, quote, citing connections to drug cartels, terrorists, and people praying against senior citizens.
- 1:22:08They brought out the old people, but forgot to include the kids. I guess that's coming next quote. Let's bring crypto out of the shadows. Now the ad says
- 1:22:18the recently emerging group behind the campaign is crypto watchdog
- 1:22:23run by executive director Chapin Fay, a media strategist who has been involved in past Republican
- 1:22:30political campaigns,
- 1:22:32but hadn't been previously associated with crypto.
- 1:22:35Quote, our mission is fairly simple and direct. He told CoinDesk in an interview, quote, it's to bring sunlight and transparency
- 1:22:43to an over $12,000,000,000,000
- 1:22:45industry that has historically not been transparent in quote.
- 1:22:49His organization started work several weeks ago as the digital asset market clarity act
- 1:22:55has been heading toward the intense end game of its us Senate negotiations in which many Democrats and some Republicans
- 1:23:02have wavered or
- 1:23:04stridently withheld their support as some of the bills most contentious points are debated quote,
- 1:23:10as the public dialogue and debate is going on about the clarity act and other regulatory schemes. We want the decision makers and the American public to have all the information they can possibly have and understand the risks in each different category.
- 1:23:26Faye said
- 1:23:28a June survey,
- 1:23:30it commissioned of 1,000
- 1:23:32voters suggested that 65%
- 1:23:34of them viewed crypto with a high level of distrust.
- 1:23:38The group reported
- 1:23:39similar to findings in a CoinDesk
- 1:23:42survey earlier this year in which 60% of respondents saw crypto as a mostly a negative force in the economy
- 1:23:48and crypto watchdogs push for transparency doesn't extend to its own backers
- 1:23:53similar to certain dark money efforts on the other side of the crypto ledger, such as the multimillion
- 1:23:59dollar pro crypto Cedar innovation foundation that's pitted itself against democratic officials.
- 1:24:06It's not revealing the sources of its funding.
- 1:24:10Oh, you want us to, oh, you want us to shine a light on everything, but we can't even tell who's funding you.
- 1:24:15The hypocrisy
- 1:24:16is a big pile of shit here, man. When Faye was asked who was paying for that organization's activity, he says, I'm not going to speak for our funders.
- 1:24:27And when asked whether transparency
- 1:24:30should go both ways,
- 1:24:32he argued that crypto transparency
- 1:24:35and information about crypto watchdog supporters
- 1:24:38are apples and oranges.
- 1:24:41Yeah, there's an agenda here. Faye contends his group is an anti crypto,
- 1:24:46though its website highlights articles on hacks and thefts and scams
- 1:24:51delves into the most negative aspects of the sector.
- 1:24:55The group's cautionary message keeps circulating this week as the Senate faces its final hours in which lawmakers can either advance or stall the clarity act.
- 1:25:04Many of the earlier issues
- 1:25:06had been ironed out by lawmakers from both parties until the most significant gap remains a proposed ethics constraint
- 1:25:14on senior government officials.
- 1:25:16Democrats with president Donald Trump in mind has demanded the legislation include limits on government officials crypto activity.
- 1:25:25The Senate has entered its final week before its summer recess,
- 1:25:30and the lawmakers are currently scheduled to finish work on Friday.
- 1:25:34That's this Friday
- 1:25:36before leaving Washington, D. C.
- 1:25:39Crypto lobbyists see these final days as the very last chance to get at least 60 Senate supporters together to start approving the bill.
- 1:25:48Even if the work has to get finished during Congress's next brief window in September,
- 1:25:54One of the clarity acts, most vehement opposition forces is the banking lobby,
- 1:25:59which has continued to campaign
- 1:26:01or continued
- 1:26:02its campaign to convince lawmakers
- 1:26:04that the crypto sector stable coin will threaten
- 1:26:08us banking deposits. If the platforms are permitted to shower users with rewards, you know, I, if
- 1:26:17it doesn't go through and it looks like it might not, again,
- 1:26:21we're going to take a hit on Bitcoin price
- 1:26:24and then it's going to rebound because, you know, after a few days people forget that
- 1:26:29that clarity failed and blah, blah, blah. And it doesn't matter because the clarity act is a bad bill. It's just a bad bill. It doesn't have enough developer protections.
- 1:26:38I can understand
- 1:26:40the Democrats argument, right? You know, hear about like, dude,
- 1:26:44the president shouldn't be getting rich off this stuff. Fuck. I agree.
- 1:26:49Biden and his son shouldn't have been getting rich off Ukraine either,
- 1:26:53But I'm not suggest I didn't say that last thing
- 1:26:57because, you know, because they did then president Trump can. No,
- 1:27:01I want I want quite the opposite.
- 1:27:04I want these motherfuckers poorer than barn mice.
- 1:27:07I want them to get no money. Actually, I take that back.
- 1:27:12I want
- 1:27:14people in the Senate and House of Representatives,
- 1:27:17the presidency,
- 1:27:18I want them to depend
- 1:27:20on their paycheck from the American people,
- 1:27:23the paycheck that they get as a Senator,
- 1:27:26as a
- 1:27:28representative,
- 1:27:30as a president or a vice president, they need to depend on that for their fucking livelihood.
- 1:27:35And anybody who doesn't need to depend on that for their livelihood
- 1:27:39is somehow or another. I don't know how to say it other than
- 1:27:44banned from ever running
- 1:27:46because I'm tired of this shit.
- 1:27:48And you'll you'll immediately go, that's just as bad as having the poorest people tell all the rich people what to do. I don't know what to do at this point with any of this.
- 1:27:59I have I do not have the answers.
- 1:28:02I'm a capitalist at heart. I think you should be able to deploy capital
- 1:28:06and that the amount of money that you make by the, that that capital allows you make, whether you opened a restaurant or I, you know, or a software company that the money you make out of that endeavor endeavor
- 1:28:19is more than the money that you put in to cause the endeavor to occur. That's just capitalism is at its base. It's the deployment of capital in order to make a profit.
- 1:28:30Now using government, you know, regulatory moding to make sure that you're the only person that makes a massive profit in a particular industry.
- 1:28:38That's not capitalism.
- 1:28:39That's cronyism.
- 1:28:40There's a fucking difference. Please go back to school. If you think that, oh, yes, capitalism. No, it is not. No, it is not. No, it is not.
- 1:28:49A lemonade stand run by two little girls in the middle of summer.
- 1:28:54It's not gonna make any money, but it's capitalism.
- 1:28:57Pure
- 1:28:58unbridled
- 1:28:59capitalism.
- 1:29:01Why? Because it took them time to set all that shit up
- 1:29:04and their mom may be invested in it by going to the store and buying them a couple of packs of lemon Kool Aid, whatever.
- 1:29:11You know, this is the way shit's been done. But their hope is by doing this work, that they will be able to make some kind of money and be able to
- 1:29:19have fun doing it. That's why one of the reasons why I love Lubbock, Texas,
- 1:29:24they have an entire weekend
- 1:29:26that the chamber of commerce,
- 1:29:29the Lubbock economic development council, and a couple of other people, small business association, they all get together and they all sponsor
- 1:29:36lemonade stands.
- 1:29:39They want they
- 1:29:41basically will look, they are encouraging children to write up a business plan.
- 1:29:47It's like a letter to Santa. We all get it. But
- 1:29:52the kids bring in their business plan to the small business association or the chamber of commerce.
- 1:29:58And it's read by an adult that has at least some experience in business or experience dealing with people with that are experienced in business and they read it
- 1:30:08and they tell the kid,
- 1:30:10here's what you could do to make it better. Or you know, basically it's a chance to teach the kid how to do business.
- 1:30:16It's not, not going to turn them into billionaires,
- 1:30:19but fuck, it's more not God and God damn high school.
- 1:30:23And they do it for an, it's like an entire week. Right? And it culminates in that weekend where they build the actual, you know, where they build the lemonade stands and the business plans. They, and they do all that for the week. And then it's all, it all happens on this one weekend
- 1:30:39where all these kids and all their parents and all these people, got together to put fucking lemonade stands on corner streets and shit at parks,
- 1:30:49you know, and they remember
- 1:30:51during COVID were or like, or rather right before COVID when it got so bad, the cops were shutting down. You'd read store news stories about cops shutting down lemonade stands.
- 1:31:01That was actually kind of happening in Lubbock too. And then all of a sudden somebody came up with a great idea. It's like we're going, we're, we're literally going to codify this as lemonade stand week or I can't remember lemonade. I think they call it lemonade day.
- 1:31:15But it's like a whole few days
- 1:31:18where
- 1:31:19adults are helping kids get their shit together.
- 1:31:23You know, that's capitalism.
- 1:31:26And it's also honestly, you know, you're going to hate me. It's also a little bit of socialism,
- 1:31:30because a lot of people are kind of donating their time for shit that they'll never get back, but it's their choice to do so. That's why it's not really socialism,
- 1:31:39socialism
- 1:31:40and communism. You're forced to do that shit. But if you do it out of the out of goodwill because you want to help the kids,
- 1:31:47that's
- 1:31:48that's not socialism.
- 1:31:49It's social. Maybe it's socially inspired.
- 1:31:52Maybe it's for the social good,
- 1:31:54but that's your choice.
- 1:31:57I have the choice to deploy capital to make money to make a profit. I have a choice to ask for help. I have a choice to go into value for value for this podcast and, and not lean on sponsors because God only knows how they're going to fucking rip my listeners off. I have a choice.
- 1:32:13These people that are helping these kids at lemonade day in Lubbock, Texas, they have a choice
- 1:32:18to read the scribblings of a six year old.
- 1:32:22Could you imagine?
- 1:32:23But these people have a lot of fun doing that.
- 1:32:28I mean, I guess it's still going on,
- 1:32:30but I've gone on, I've gone on to, I don't even know how the hell I got onto that. But
- 1:32:36in either event,
- 1:32:39these guys in Washington, DC, it's whether, whether or not clarity act passes.
- 1:32:45If we get the bill, it's a bad bill. If we don't get the bill, it's bad for the price of Bitcoin.
- 1:32:50That's this week.
- 1:32:53By Friday,
- 1:32:54the fat lady will sing one way or another, and I'll see you on the other side. This has been Bitcoin. And and I'm your host, David Bennett. I hope you enjoyed today's episode and hope to see you again real soon.
- 1:33:07Have a great day.