Latest / No Way Out / PsyWar Primer: Liminal Warfare, Flow, 5GW, Sun Tzu and More
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No Way Out listeners, thank you for tuning in.
- 0:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're thrilled that you're here with us and I want to give you some background on this upcoming episode.
- 0:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a mashup of sorts.
- 0:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It is intended to be a fifth generation or psychological warfare primer for the upcoming no Way Out episode featuring Dr Robert Malone.
- 0:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, that's right.
- 0:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Dr Robert Malone and I have a conversation anchored around his and his wife's new book, psywar Enforcing the New World Order.
- 0:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, when will that episode be released?
- 0:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, how about we do this?
- 0:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If we can get 10 five-star ratings on Spotify, apple or wherever you listen to no Way Out, we'll release that Dr Malone episode immediately out.
- 1:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll release that Dr Malone episode immediately.
- 1:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So please leave a review, provide a rating and we like five stars and we will release the no Way Out episode featuring Dr Robert Malone immediately.
- 1:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now for this mashup in preparation for the episode featuring Dr Robert Malone, we're pulling together some key segments from previous no Way Out guests and we also have a short segment from the recording with Dr Robert Malone.
- 1:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In this mashup you'll hear from David Kilcullen, professor Adrian Bajon, james Giordano, michael Ashley, buzz Renfer, james Gimien and, of course, dr Robert Malone.
- 1:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, in this first segment, steve McCrone and David Kilcullen discuss liminal warfare and unrestricted warfare.
- 1:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, can we?
- 1:50Steve McCrone: shift tack a little bit to the idea of liminality and for the listeners who are familiar with the Kenevan framework, liminality features there in the space between the complex domain and the complicated and in the space between the complex domain and the chaotic, and that's where you're not in one or the other, but rather you're making that sort of transitory change between the two and the system is fundamentally changing.
- 2:20Steve McCrone: Can you talk about liminality in respect to your work and how you apply that concept in your consultancy?
- 2:29David Kilcullen: Yeah, so liminality is a broad-based concept, as you mentioned.
- 2:33David Kilcullen: It's a very common concept in anthropological work, which is my academic background, but it just means a threshold or a transitional zone or a transitional territory or transitional population right between established.
- 2:49David Kilcullen: You know, when things go plastic temporarily before they reset in a new form, that's a liminal moment.
- 2:55David Kilcullen: But it also means riding the threshold of detectability right, and that's how I use it in my context.
- 3:02David Kilcullen: And that's how I use it in my context.
- 3:03David Kilcullen: We've had the emergence of what military people call UTS ubiquitous technical surveillance in the last 15 years, where it's basically impossible to be covert or clandestine.
- 3:16David Kilcullen: Covert means the existence of an operation is detected but the identity of the sponsor is unknown.
- 3:21David Kilcullen: Clandestine means that the entire existence of the operation remains undetected at all.
- 3:26David Kilcullen: It used to be feasible in the special operations and intelligence world to be fully clandestine on a more or less permanent basis.
- 3:36David Kilcullen: That's not true anymore.
- 3:37David Kilcullen: What we're talking about now is more like delayed attribution, where the adversary will eventually figure out what's going on.
- 3:43David Kilcullen: It's just a question of how long.
- 3:44David Kilcullen: And there are different adaptations to respond to that new ubiquitous surveillance situation.
- 3:53David Kilcullen: One of them is one that the Russians have made a speciality in which is riding the edge between detectability and ambiguity, so conducting operations where they're not trying to be covert, they're not trying to be clandestine, they're not clear enough that we can mount a response, and they play a political warfare and information warfare game in that space to delay and obfuscate and limit a response, and that gives them a play space within which to manoeuvre.
- 4:30David Kilcullen: The Russian takeover of Crimea is a good example of that, where they had the so-called little green men.
- 4:36David Kilcullen: Nobody had any doubt really that that was Russian military, but the Russians were just denying it in a completely bald-faced manner on international media and elsewhere and saying, no, no, nothing to see here.
- 4:49David Kilcullen: That's not our guys and we have no intention of ever annexing or taking over Crimea, let alone the rest of Ukraine.
- 4:57David Kilcullen: It's just a temporary humanitarian intervention.
- 5:00David Kilcullen: And that delayed and obfuscated the response from NATO for a few weeks, which was all they needed to consolidate control.
- 5:07David Kilcullen: And then suddenly, on the 18th of March 2014, they announced okay, we're having a referendum on annexing Crimea.
- 5:15David Kilcullen: Next day, they annexed Crimea Following day.
- 5:17David Kilcullen: You know it's part of Russia.
- 5:19David Kilcullen: So that's an example of what I describe in the book as liminal warfare, right riding the edge of detectability.
- 5:27David Kilcullen: There are other ways to deal with it.
- 5:29David Kilcullen: A classic Chinese model, which is sometimes called unrestricted warfare, is to go outside of the boundaries of what we define as warfare, so that even if we can detect what's going on, we don't necessarily recognise it as a form of conflict.
- 5:44David Kilcullen: Think about what's happening with technical standards, with access to semiconductors, critical commodities like pharmaceutical precursors, those kinds of things.
- 5:55David Kilcullen: They all fit within a Chinese warfare strategy called unrestricted warfare, but Western countries typically regard those as just parts of normal commercial interaction.
- 6:05David Kilcullen: So you're moving outside the bounds of what is traditionally considered to be war fighting.
- 6:11David Kilcullen: So there are different ways to handle that approach.
- 6:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now it's time to hear from the scariest person I know on the internet, and that is James Giordano, phd.
- 6:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's the author of over 300 publications, seven books and 20 government white papers on neurotechnology, biosecurity and ethics, and in this segment I asked Dr Giordano to talk about the difference between information warfare and cognitive warfare.
- 6:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We also make some connections and references to John Boyd's OODA loop.
- 6:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So listen up.
- 6:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What about the mind here, the battlefield, the brain at the battlefield as a 21st century that you write about quite often.
- 6:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In fact, in one of your papers you bring up right away, the key to victory or defeat in war is people.
- 6:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The key to people lies in the brain.
- 6:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We also know that I believe China's doctrine right now is about mind superiority, and then Russia has something known as reflexive control doctrine.
- 7:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And, of course, john Boyd famously said machines don't fight wars, people do, and they use their mind, people, ideas and things in that order.
- 7:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Some of the things you just talked about were really about how do we fold our adversaries back inside themselves, right?
- 7:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Morally, mentally and physically, without suffering the same fate ourselves, right?
- 7:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's something that we get from John Boyd.
- 7:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So at the end of the day, here we're talking about maybe information warfare and cognitive warfare, or overall cognitive dominance.
- 7:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do we understand what's going on in the minds of others, and so forth.
- 7:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Dr G, can you help us understand the difference between information warfare and cognitive warfare if there is a difference, and perhaps take a look at it through the lens of the OODA loop?
- 7:43James Giordano, PhD: No, I think it's important to consider those as existing along a constellation or spectrum of capabilities and also context, right.
- 7:49James Giordano, PhD: So I mean, if we're talking about information, information is important to cognition.
- 7:53James Giordano, PhD: I mean, what we do cognitively is we take in sense data.
- 7:57James Giordano, PhD: We then assimilate those sense data with regard to some prior disposition or orientation to what those things are based upon, how we're sensing.
- 8:05James Giordano, PhD: That gives us a perception.
- 8:06James Giordano, PhD: That perception very often is linked to some cognitive domain that we like to call emotionality, and there's nothing that is neutral.
- 8:13James Giordano, PhD: Anything is either positively valent or negatively valent.
- 8:16James Giordano, PhD: It's just a question of where, on that sliding scale, we list them.
- 8:19James Giordano, PhD: I mean, if you really think about it, ask the listeners to think about it, think about your idea of neutrality.
- 8:26James Giordano, PhD: You're not really neutral about anything, you know.
- 8:29James Giordano, PhD: You could say well, I'm kind of neutral about Brussels sprouts, yeah, but wait a minute.
- 8:33James Giordano, PhD: If it was a question of Brussels sprouts and ice cream, well, okay, somebody would go for the ice cream, somebody would go for the Brussels sprouts, brussels sprouts versus pizza, somebody's going to go for the pizza.
- 8:50James Giordano, PhD: So what tends to happen is that neutrality is really a relative neutrality and what we're really doing is we're hierarchizing things all the time based upon the way they relatively feel to us in terms of gain or loss, pain or pleasure, understanding that information plays into the cognitive domain, because information, both in terms of current information, as it may have some speculative and predictive value this will lead to X, y or Z or, as it has, referential value, this then reflects Alpha Bravo, charlie is important because it's evocative for not only those cognitive domains but those emotional domains that drive decision-makings and actions.
- 9:22James Giordano, PhD: So the informational space and the cognitive space really represent an interdigitation, a true interdigitation of one hand sort of washing the other.
- 9:31James Giordano, PhD: The way we cognitively make sense of information is based not only on the information itself and the relative radicality of the information, what in the philosophical language is sometimes referred to as the ding on zich, the thing unto itself, but realistically, our perception, based upon our sensation of that that is then ground to some recollection of its relative meaning.
- 9:55James Giordano, PhD: Contextually, for us, dynamic, as an important cog in the cognitive wheel, can become exceedingly important in controlling and influencing narratives, symbols, expressions, dynamic interactions that are all operable within the human terrain.
- 10:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In this segment, professor Bijan addresses the suppression of ideas on social media and its relation to the loss of freedom.
- 10:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He draws parallels to the early 20th century's popularity of Marxism and fascism.
- 10:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He also comments on the belief that certain elites know better than the common people.
- 10:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So here's a question about freedom.
- 10:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the suppression of ideas on social media or anywhere through fear or concern that you're going to be canceled is that directly related to the loss of freedom in this concept?
- 11:00Adrian Bejan, PhD: of the so-called popularity of Marxism at the turn of the previous century.
- 11:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's what's going on with what you bring up and, just like more than 100 years ago, smart people, well you know, with advancement, with ready money, with food that's easy to access, and all this comes the arrogance and, of course, with degrees from Harvard and other places, the arrogance that you know better than the common man.
- 11:41Adrian Bejan, PhD: That is what happened more than 100 years ago.
- 11:44Adrian Bejan, PhD: In fact, one of my daughters published a book about fascism in the interwar period.
- 11:51Adrian Bejan, PhD: Fascism in the interwar period is associated with the brown shirts, meaning with vulgar fascists and anti-Semites, and all this meaning with the workers.
- 12:13Adrian Bejan, PhD: No, fascism in the interwar period was the baby of the intellectual elite of the world.
- 12:15Adrian Bejan, PhD: The leading thinkers, artists, writers were gaga about it.
- 12:22Adrian Bejan, PhD: I mean, just as they were with, by the way, fascism and Marxism are the same thing if you look at the history of it.
- 12:33Adrian Bejan, PhD: So, and they were gaga about you know communism as well, and so arrogance breeds this attitude of well.
- 12:45Adrian Bejan, PhD: That's why I call it a replay, or a feeling or pretense that you know better than the common man.
- 12:54Adrian Bejan, PhD: It is destructive and it's dangerous, and this is why it's important.
- 13:03Adrian Bejan, PhD: It's important especially for those who have access to education pupils, and then students and eventually professors to go through life with eyes open and questioning what they hear.
- 13:20Adrian Bejan, PhD: Question.
- 13:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In 2023,.
- 13:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Robert Ever Grant and Michael Ashley co-authored Neuromind In this segment.
- 13:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Michael Ashley takes us through the concept of surveillance capitalism.
- 13:36Michael Ashley: I think this is going on in different ways.
- 13:37Michael Ashley: I mean, you have the purely governmental version, which, of course, the Patriot Act allowed to happen, so they're able to spy on people in mass right, listen to all their conversations, and I think that one's pretty people are pretty aware of that.
- 13:50Michael Ashley: But I think the other one that people are not as aware of is what's called surveillance capitalism, and that comes from a book by Shoshana Zabuff, and, speaking of terms and the power of language, this book, I think, came out in 2018.
- 14:04Michael Ashley: I became aware of it in 2019.
- 14:06Michael Ashley: In fact, that's how Robert and I bonded.
- 14:08Michael Ashley: That's my co-author with Neuromind.
- 14:11Michael Ashley: We were both very much influenced by this book, and so the idea was, shoshana Zabuff was creating a word, a term, if you will, to explain the business practices of big tech companies like Google or Facebook, and basically they data, mine us.
- 14:26Michael Ashley: They make their money based on our information.
- 14:29Michael Ashley: There's a reason why data has replaced oil as the world's most valuable, powerful commodity, right, and so you could begin to use this data for all kinds of purposes, but I'll just give you a few.
- 14:39Michael Ashley: I'm sure you've had the wonderful situation where you're mentioning a car that you like or, let's say, a piece of furniture that you're interested in, and then the next day you get an ad for that car or that furniture in your inbox, right?
- 14:54Michael Ashley: Most people have had that.
- 14:55Michael Ashley: So that's the obvious example in which they're using it as a way to market as products.
- 15:00Michael Ashley: But there are more insidious versions of this, where surveillance capitalism is nudging us into making certain behavioral decisions.
- 15:09Michael Ashley: Right, and so Shoshana Zaboff was very influenced by BF Skinner, and so her book talks about this idea of conditioning people to do different things, and that's also what's going on with surveillance capitalism.
- 15:23Michael Ashley: So, in addition to the government surveilling us, in addition to big tech making money off of our information, they're also nudging us in different directions.
- 15:33Michael Ashley: So there's a lot that's going on with the whole surveillance situation.
- 15:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, if this is a primer for the Dr Robert Malone episode, then we have to talk about COVID vaccines, and to do this here is retired US Air Force Colonel Thomas Buzz Renfro.
- 15:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now Buzz read a book called Unyielding Marathons Against Illegal Mandates.
- 15:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In this segment.
- 15:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Buzz recounts his initial trust in the system during the COVID-19 pandemic, believing that vaccines would be handled properly and lawfully.
- 16:03Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: I didn't want to spend just like I had spent the previous 20 years tilting windmills over anthrax vaccine.
- 16:10Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: I did not want to get into another one of these whifferdales.
- 16:13Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: So my initial approach was, you know, I tried to trust in the system that they were going to put out a vaccine for a legitimate public health threat, that they were going to do it right this time and they were going to follow the law.
- 16:28Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: And I was actually very impressed initially that the military, when it was fully acknowledged that the vaccines were emergency use, authorized that they were actually having a voluntary program.
- 16:39Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: So I was, you know, I was applauding the military.
- 16:43Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: Early on, I did some research for Children's Health Defense, assisted Robert F Kennedy Jr and Dr Merrill Nass, who was one of the doctors that actually helped us during the anthrax vaccine era, and they did a citizen petition in order to try to halt any kind of mandates.
- 17:00Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: We were working on this in the spring of 2021, before there were mandates, and I was very naive, very idealistic.
- 17:07Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: When you read my book, I mean I think that's basically the picture in the memoir that is painted for you that, you know, the only reason I fought this stuff is because I'm idealistic and so, going into the COVID era, the pandemic, and prior to the mandates, I was very idealistic.
- 17:25Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: I was thinking there's no way they're going to mandate this stuff.
- 17:28Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: This is not FDA approved, so sure enough.
- 17:31Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: The Department of Defense immensely disappointed me because they ended up doing mandates when only emergency use authorized product was available and that's why it was a patently illegal order.
- 17:43Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: And the government did the same thing for civilians with mandates, even though the law specifically says that they're supposed to have the option to accept or refuse and that any consequences are strictly medical.
- 17:56Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: If you look at the context of consequences in the law, they're strictly medical.
- 18:00Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: You can't be taking away people's jobs, keeping people from going to school.
- 18:04Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: That is the law.
- 18:06Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: The military law was a subset of the earlier law I cited.
- 18:09Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: The military law is 10 USC 1107A for emergency use authorized products.
- 18:14Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: Soldiers have to have their prior consent right.
- 18:17Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: You cannot punish them, and the precedent I mentioned in the Federal Register, which is on my website, unyieldingorg, says the same thing you cannot punish them.
- 18:24Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: And the precedent I mentioned in the Federal Register, which is on my website, unyieldingorg, says the same thing you cannot penalize the troops for exercising their prior consent rights.
- 18:30Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: So when COVID came around, initially I was idealistically trusting, but ultimately the government fundamentally violated the same laws.
- 18:40Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: It disappointed me and that's why I finally put the book together.
- 18:44Thomas "Buzz" Rempfer: I said, hey, people need to understand the patterns of the bad behavior that have reemerged.
- 18:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now James Gimion has been studying and teaching the art of war, the Sun Tzu, bing Fa, since 1980.
- 18:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now he served as a general editor of the bestselling translation the Art of War, the Denma translation.
- 19:03James Gimian: In this segment, james discusses the relevance of the Sun Tzu I believe it's actually called Sun Tzu, the art of war in dealing with today's uncertainties, constant changes and interconnectedness, much like the turbulent times of the warring states period in China times of the warring states period in China, when people identify so immediately that it is the reality we're facing now, the uncertainty, the constant change, the interconnectedness which for some time we've forgotten was the ground of the world we deal with and we attempt to lead.
- 19:36James Gimian: So it does help create, you know, a lot of people will say to us what does this ancient Chinese text have to do with me?
- 19:45James Gimian: You know, the art of war seems like it's hard to understand.
- 19:49James Gimian: I'm going to spend a lot of time, I'm never going to get there.
- 19:53James Gimian: Why?
- 19:53James Gimian: From it to apply to a leadership, a broad leadership training conversation.
- 20:06James Gimian: It creates the ground of talking about what's important to people, what they experience and, like you say, everybody's experience is things are uncertain, increasingly uncertain, they're changing constantly.
- 20:17James Gimian: It's hard to make a plan and fulfill it.
- 20:19James Gimian: You don't know about your supply chain.
- 20:21James Gimian: You don't know if you're going to be able to get the labor that you need to do your job.
- 20:26James Gimian: I mean on every front.
- 20:27James Gimian: Hundred years all of the rules and regulations and laws and cultural norms were being reshaped and reformed, and so the art of war was a manual for a leader dealing with that reality, and that's why it is so helpful and relevant to our times.
- 20:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So on that, manipulation or deception, leadership and manipulation are the opposite side of the same coin.
- 21:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, to be a good leader, you actually have to manipulate people, but that's not what we say.
- 21:07James Gimian: right, we're not trying to deceive people, but please build on what Mark pointed out there and help our listeners understand what's in the book we wrote in the particular way we did about reception, about deception, just because it's the first task is to get somebody extracted from that reaction of negativity and a a negative value that's automatically put onto that word.
- 21:40James Gimian: And we're not saying that those, those negative things don't exist.
- 21:43James Gimian: But it's a limited understanding.
- 21:45James Gimian: As many books have pointed out in scientific work, we use deception in nature in our lives in multiple ways.
- 22:03James Gimian: I think the attempt we made was to set aside those most seemingly egregious expressions of it outright lying, to manipulate for personal gain, you know, is certainly not what we were talking about.
- 22:27James Gimian: But the I mean the starting point from our point of view is the multiple realities that coexist, that we choose to sort out in our individual ways.
- 22:49James Gimian: So, right from the beginning, to think that we're all talking about the same external reality, that we experience the same, is a misconception.
- 23:00James Gimian: So therefore the notion of deception changes completely if it's not about there is some right thing out there that I'm going to distort your understanding of what's being talked about in the Bingfa the art of war.
- 23:17James Gimian: The art of war is that knowing, for me and for others, is a central element to success.
- 23:29James Gimian: Clear seeing leads to effective action.
- 23:49James Gimian: So if I'm trying to prevail by having my goal succeed.
- 23:50James Gimian: It may mean that part of that is to shape others' understanding of the elements so that they can't mount resistance in ways that in fact might be counterproductive for them.
- 23:58James Gimian: And when you talk about leadership as manipulation mean leading, what does that mean?
- 24:02James Gimian: That means others are following.
- 24:05James Gimian: So you know, we don't, we don't blanch at the word leadership that it's evil because we're hoping other people will follow us, because the presumption is we're doing that for the success of the whole, for their success, for the enterprise's success, that people will benefit from that leadership.
- 24:23James Gimian: So that, therefore, shaping the world, which is making choices about what's real and what's not real, what's important and what's not important, you could call that deception, but it's inherent in bringing about something that could benefit all.
- 24:40James Gimian: So that is the presumption in the way we're applying this work, the leaders we're talking to.
- 24:45James Gimian: Their goal is in fact to surmount the obstacles to bring about a success that will benefit the company, the customers, the society, the people that they lead, the staff and workers in that enterprise.
- 25:04James Gimian: So I think just normalizing that common human capacity is a very helpful thing and it doesn't necessarily mean we're now endorsing that you can go and lie about your taxes or lie about your, you know, whatever it is.
- 25:26James Gimian: That's purely about fulfilling your sole limited benefit as opposed to the interconnected reality, the interconnected entity that you're a part of.
- 25:38James Gimian: So that changes the view of deception right there If you're acting on behalf of the whole.
- 25:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here's a short segment from the upcoming episode featuring Dr Robert Malone.
- 25:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In this segment, dr Malone discusses how the Sun Tzu, or the Sun Tzu, remains relevant in the context of fifth generation warfare.
- 25:56Dr. Robert Malone: I agree.
- 25:57Dr. Robert Malone: Okay, Sun Tzu is full of fifth generation warfare tips and tricks, except for the difference is the technology, the information management technological base that now exists, compared to what has existed historically.
- 26:17Dr. Robert Malone: Humans don't change A lot of the core strategy remains the same, but the tools and technologies now available to 5G not cell towers is so powerful.
- 26:38Dr. Robert Malone: I say again and again, and again the objective here is to control everything that you encounter in terms of information, everything that you think, everything that you feel, everything that you believe is actively being manipulated.
- 26:49Dr. Robert Malone: And when I lecture on this, I talk about a surrealistic landscape that, once you step into this, you know the famous quote the only way to win at fifth generation warfare is not to play as soon as you step into this battlefield and and you are stepping into a Cywar battlefield as soon as you engage in social media, whether or not, you acknowledge it.
- 27:09Dr. Robert Malone: So it is a full-on battleground and it's only getting more so.
- 27:14Dr. Robert Malone: Right now, and as soon as you step into that, you are subject to a huge array of technologies and manipulation.
- 27:24Dr. Robert Malone: That makes it so that if you really think it through and process what's going on here, it's hard not to conclude that it becomes increasingly difficult to separate what is you and what is your soul, what are your thoughts, from what has been injected into you, manipulated into you.
- 27:52Dr. Robert Malone: And if you're honest about it, you have to recognize that a lot of the things, the biases that you carry, the things that you believe of the things, the biases that you carry, the things that you believe, the things that you feel, are a product of the manipulations that you've been subjected to.
- 28:07Dr. Robert Malone: Right and