Latest / The Midday Report with Mandy Wiener / Land Expropriation Act challenged
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: But let's start in the courts where the Land Expropriation
- 0:03Speaker 1: Act is being challenged. The Western Cape High Court today
- 0:06Speaker 1: hearing arguments both for and against the Expropriation Act. The
- 0:11Speaker 1: applicants are the Democratic Alliance, Every Forum, the Institute for
- 0:15Speaker 1: Race Relations. They're asking the court to declare parts of
- 0:18Speaker 1: the Expropriation Act unconstitutional and invalid. And at the heart
- 0:23Speaker 1: of this is whether the Expropriation Act strikes the correct
- 0:25Speaker 1: balance between protecting private property and enabling meaningful land reform.
- 0:32Speaker 1: Bula Mabasa is the head of land reform at Worksman's
- 0:35Speaker 1: Attorneys's written an excellent book on this topic if you
- 0:38Speaker 1: want to read it. Good afternoon to you. Thank you
- 0:41Speaker 1: very much for for your time. Always lovely to have
- 0:43Speaker 1: you on the Midai Report.
- 0:44Speaker 2: Thank you very much, always wonderful. Thank you, Mandy.
- 0:48Speaker 1: So if you could unpack for us the matter before
- 0:51Speaker 1: the High Court today, it's all to do with one clause. Really,
- 0:56Speaker 1: as I understand it, What are the applicants arguing. What's
- 0:59Speaker 1: the case that they making?
- 1:02Speaker 2: So, Mandy, I think the first place to start is
- 1:05Speaker 2: that these started as two separate cases. There was a
- 1:07Speaker 2: case before the Pretoria High Court by every Forum, and
- 1:11Speaker 2: there was another case by the DA before the Western Cape,
- 1:15Speaker 2: and so the parties agreed to consolidate both these cases,
- 1:19Speaker 2: which has now culminated into today's hearing before the Western Cape.
- 1:24Speaker 2: The level of the issue Mandy is that the two
- 1:27Speaker 2: main contentious clauses is Section twelve, which deals with lifts
- 1:35Speaker 2: the circumstances under which expropriation with our compensation may occur.
- 1:42Speaker 2: The fundamental challenge against that is that the section is
- 1:45Speaker 2: widely written. It includes words such as including, but limited
- 1:50Speaker 2: to so In other words, the argument goes that that
- 1:53Speaker 2: list where expropriation if our compensation may happen might be
- 1:57Speaker 2: interpreted as not a close list, and that can that
- 2:00Speaker 2: it may potentially extend the state power to put in
- 2:05Speaker 2: more circumstances under which appropriation with our compensation could happen.
- 2:10Speaker 2: The second major section that has been challenged is the
- 2:13Speaker 2: section twelve. I mean through section nineteen, and Section nineteen
- 2:17Speaker 2: effectively enables the states to continue with an expropriation process
- 2:22Speaker 2: in circumstances where the parties are still negotiating the reasonable
- 2:29Speaker 2: amount for compensation. So, for example, whilst the parties could
- 2:34Speaker 2: be drawn out in a mediation or arbitration, the state
- 2:37Speaker 2: is enabled them to continue with the expropriation process. What
- 2:42Speaker 2: the state has done in the meantime it has almost
- 2:47Speaker 2: capitulated to the fact that the wording in the Act
- 2:51Speaker 2: is not as precise or that it doesn't give sufficient clarity.
- 2:58Speaker 1: So the President has actually at most of those in
- 3:00Speaker 1: court papers he agrees that it's irrational.
- 3:04Speaker 2: Yes, And what has happened then is that today's the
- 3:08Speaker 2: Parliament and the President have then proposed a reading in
- 3:14Speaker 2: of words, which is which is a principle that is
- 3:17Speaker 2: acceptable in constitutional law, where words can be read in
- 3:21Speaker 2: in order to cure the defect. However, the question then
- 3:25Speaker 2: will become whether the reading in process is rational, is
- 3:29Speaker 2: it not rational? Is it does it give sufficient clarity
- 3:34Speaker 2: to the act. And then there's some challenges around whether
- 3:38Speaker 2: the court has the necessary jurisdiction or mandate to make
- 3:43Speaker 2: those amendments or whether that is the job of the legislature,
- 3:46Speaker 2: in other words, whether that must go back to the legislature.
- 3:50Speaker 1: Okay, so the just explain that that reading in. Why
- 3:54Speaker 1: is the DA and the other applicants so opposed to
- 3:57Speaker 1: the reading in.
- 3:59Speaker 3: Well?
- 4:00Speaker 2: Their argument is that the firstly, that there are different
- 4:03Speaker 2: versions of the reading in and that the state's respondents
- 4:06Speaker 2: come up with different proposals. When I heard the argument
- 4:10Speaker 2: earlier on was that there's about nine different versions around
- 4:14Speaker 2: how their reading in should happen. And so the difficulty,
- 4:18Speaker 2: or rather the argument that has been fought by the
- 4:21Speaker 2: DA is that you need this well the constitutional principles
- 4:25Speaker 2: that you need laws to be clear and to have certainty,
- 4:28Speaker 2: and they don't believe that that needs that challenge. What
- 4:32Speaker 2: is important, Mandy here is that we must remember that
- 4:35Speaker 2: expropriation of the concept has always been in South African law.
- 4:38Speaker 2: We're already dealing with We already have the nineteen seventy
- 4:41Speaker 2: five Acts, which has been used since Timing Memorial. So
- 4:44Speaker 2: expropriation on its own is not a new concept or
- 4:48Speaker 2: it's not controversial. What is controversial here is that there
- 4:53Speaker 2: are now provisions to make provision for expropriation with our
- 4:56Speaker 2: compensation within a finite set of circumstances, which the other
- 5:03Speaker 2: parties are arguing it's not drafted with certain with sufficient
- 5:07Speaker 2: clarity to avoid those circumstances being extended beyond what the
- 5:14Speaker 2: legislation intended below were.
- 5:18Speaker 1: There are also suggestions that there could be a political
- 5:20Speaker 1: solution to this. Now, I know you're a lawyer, and
- 5:23Speaker 1: I won't ask you to wide into the politics of this,
- 5:26Speaker 1: but there were some suggestions that because the President had
- 5:30Speaker 1: conceded that Section nineteen rationality, they could have found an
- 5:35Speaker 1: out of court settlement on this matter. And then bearing
- 5:38Speaker 1: in mind, of course that the minister that needs to
- 5:40Speaker 1: actually defend this is Dean macpherson, as I understand it,
- 5:43Speaker 1: he's a DA minister. So what are the chances of
- 5:46Speaker 1: a political solution to this?
- 5:49Speaker 2: Look, I think, you know, if you think about how
- 5:53Speaker 2: expropriation has always attracted this amount of attention, it even
- 5:58Speaker 2: you know, attracted the attention of Trump President Trump in
- 6:02Speaker 2: the US. I do believe that these issues are capable
- 6:06Speaker 2: of being resolved, especially when you're talking about you know,
- 6:11Speaker 2: I don't want to call it legal semantics, but it
- 6:13Speaker 2: is possible to reach a place where there is enough
- 6:17Speaker 2: certainty around those circumstances. And let's of course, the issue
- 6:21Speaker 2: is that the political issue, really, Mandy, if you dig,
- 6:25Speaker 2: if you dig deeper, is that there is no agreement
- 6:29Speaker 2: on expropriation with our compensation as a concept. I think
- 6:32Speaker 2: the DN thepor Forum don't believe that we should have
- 6:36Speaker 2: a you know, expropriation with that compensation, and that's what
- 6:41Speaker 2: kind of widens that gap between the parties because on
- 6:45Speaker 2: the on the on the other hand, expropriation with our compensation.
- 6:49Speaker 2: The counter argument is that it is possible if you
- 6:52Speaker 2: look at twenty three soction twenty five three. So I
- 6:55Speaker 2: think that gap that makes it difficult for even a
- 7:00Speaker 2: political situation to become available or viable is the fact
- 7:07Speaker 2: that there is a principal issue against expropriation with that
- 7:12Speaker 2: compensation as a concept by the DA and the AFRO Forum.
- 7:19Speaker 1: Call Blawa, thank you so much. Blowa Marasa is the
- 7:22Speaker 1: head of Land Reform at Worksmen's Attorneys unpacking that matter
- 7:25Speaker 1: currently before the Western Cape High Court. Let's listen into
- 7:28Speaker 1: that argument happening right now. There's feitist courtesy of the
- 7:31Speaker 1: SABC down to the.
- 7:33Speaker 3: Issue of the uf dunity because that's what the rules
- 7:38Speaker 3: of vision is there to deal with the Mayusha SR
- 7:43Speaker 3: pursuings and of the days there were certainly master down
- 7:46Speaker 3: as soon as it's the things, it will be people
- 7:49Speaker 3: who will learn data out whatever.
- 7:52Speaker 4: It is, and.
- 7:55Speaker 5: Well it certainly wouldn't as they may well be asses
- 8:00Speaker 5: that follow on here at the moment after submissions are later,
- 8:04Speaker 5: I directed at whether it's competent.
- 8:08Speaker 2: For this court to make.
- 8:10Speaker 4: A median import in light of the different options that
- 8:15Speaker 4: are there. And that's around a statutory priesthood, it's not
- 8:20Speaker 4: around a deferral offers options to the statue.
- 8:24Speaker 3: Said that, but actually about the manusia of militias standing.
- 8:30Speaker 1: So that's argument currently underwear in the Western Kpe High Quarter.
- 8:32Speaker 1: The issue there around the reading in as Bullla Mabasa
- 8:36Speaker 1: explained to us about that the President has concedered the
- 8:40Speaker 1: section nineteen years irrational. He says can be remedied by
- 8:43Speaker 1: a reading in the DA eight disagrees. That's the argument
- 8:46Speaker 1: currently before the court.