Latest / Kublai Khan and the Mongol Rule of China — Fexingo History / The Four Great Khanates and Kublai's Broken Empire
Transcript
- Lucas: So last time we talked about Kublai's grand canal and how he basically rebuilt China's infrastructure to feed his new capital. But there's a much bigger story lurking behind all that — the fact that by the time Kublai was doing all this, the Mongol Empire his grandfather had built was already falling apart. Luna: Falling apart? I thought the Mongols were this unstoppable force that ruled everything from China to Persia. Lucas: Well, they did, but only for about a generation. After Genghis Khan died in 1227, the empire was divided among his sons and grandsons, and by Kublai's time, it had splintered into four major khanates that were often at each other's throats. You've got the Yuan dynasty in China and Mongolia, the Chagatai Khanate in Central Asia, the Ilkhanate in Persia, and the Golden Horde in Russia. Lucas: And here's the thing — Kublai technically was the Great Khan, the supreme ruler of the whole Mongol world, but in practice, he only controlled his own territory. The other khans paid him lip service at best, and some of them were actively fighting against him. Luna: Wow, so the Mongol Empire was really just a bunch of rival cousins by then? Lucas: Exactly. And the rift started almost immediately after Kublai took power. You see, when Genghis's grandson Möngke Khan died in 1259, Kublai and his younger brother Ariq Böke both claimed the throne. Ariq was in Karakorum, the old Mongol capital, and had the support of the traditional Mongol elite. Kublai was in northern China, commanding the armies that had just conquered the Song dynasty's territory. Lucas: This wasn't just a simple succession dispute. It was a clash between two visions of what the Mongol Empire should be. Kublai wanted to rule from China, adopting Chinese customs and governing as a Chinese emperor. Ariq and his supporters wanted to keep the old nomadic ways, ruling from the steppe and maintaining the traditional Mongol lifestyle. Luna: So it was almost like a culture war, not just a power struggle. Lucas: Precisely. And Kublai won the military side of it. He captured Karakorum, and Ariq eventually surrendered in 1264. But the cost was huge — the other khanates, especially the Chagatai and the Golden Horde, sided with Ariq or just used the chaos to assert their independence. The Toluid Civil War, as it's called, basically shattered any hope of a unified Mongol Empire. Lucas: The Yuan Shi, the official history of the Yuan dynasty, records that Kublai summoned a kurultai, a great assembly of Mongol nobles, to legitimize his rule, but only his own supporters showed up. The other khans didn't even bother. Luna: That must have been a blow to his legitimacy, not even getting the other khans to recognize him. Lucas: It was, but he didn't let it stop him. He just went ahead and founded the Yuan dynasty in 1271, with himself as the emperor of China. He moved his capital to what is now Beijing, which he called Khanbaliq, and he set about ruling his Chinese subjects. But he never gave up the dream of reuniting the Mongol Empire. Lucas: He tried to assert his authority over the other khanates, mostly through diplomacy and military pressure. He sent envoys to the Ilkhanate, which was ruled by his brother Hulagu, and they generally had good relations. But the Golden Horde, under Berke, was a different story. Berke had converted to Islam and was furious at Hulagu for sacking Baghdad and killing the caliph in 1258. Luna: So the Ilkhanate and the Golden Horde were basically at war with each other? Lucas: Pretty much. Berke allied with the Mamluks of Egypt, who were the Ilkhanate's biggest enemies, and he even fought a war against Hulagu in the Caucasus. Kublai tried to mediate, but he didn't have the authority to force them to make peace. He was the Great Khan in name only. Lucas: And then there was the Chagatai Khanate, which controlled Central Asia. That one was a thorn in his side because it controlled the Silk Road. Kublai wanted to keep trade flowing between China and the west, but the Chagatai khans were often hostile, taxing caravans or even raiding his territories. Lucas: One of the most persistent opponents was Kaidu, a grandson of Ögedei, who was Kublai's uncle. Kaidu controlled much of Central Asia and spent decades fighting against Kublai, using the Chagatai Khanate as his base. He even allied with the Golden Horde at times, creating a real headache for Kublai. Luna: So Kublai had to deal with enemies on almost every front, even while he was conquering China. Lucas: Exactly. He had to fight the Song dynasty in the south, the Chagatai and Kaidu in the west, and keep an eye on the Golden Horde. It's a wonder he managed to do as much as he did. But it also explains why his empire was so different from his grandfather's. He wasn't just a Mongol khan — he was a Chinese emperor, and he had to prioritize his Chinese domains. Lucas: This is also where you see a real shift in how the Mongols viewed themselves. Kublai adopted the Chinese court rituals, took a Chinese title, and even moved his capital to China. He surrounded himself with Confucian scholars and Chinese officials, much to the dismay of the traditional Mongol aristocrats. They saw him as betraying the old ways. Luna: So the Mongol Empire was really a collection of independent states under different rulers, all with their own agendas. Lucas: That's right. And that's why when we talk about 'the Mongol Empire' after Kublai, it's more accurate to think of it as a commonwealth, or a sphere of influence, rather than a single political entity. Each khanate had its own government, its own army, its own foreign policy. They were connected by trade, by family ties, and by a shared Mongol heritage, but not by a central authority. Lucas: And the legacy of that fragmentation lasted for centuries. The Yuan dynasty in China, the Ilkhanate in Persia, the Golden Horde in Russia — they all eventually fell, but their histories were shaped by their Mongol origins. Even today, the influence of that Mongol world can be seen in the culture and politics of Central Asia. Luna: It's amazing how one man's ambition to rule an empire from China ended up fracturing his own family's legacy. Lucas: Yeah, it's ironic. Kublai wanted to be the Great Khan, the ruler of the entire Mongol world, but by the time he died in 1294, the empire was more divided than ever. He had succeeded in conquering China, but he had lost the other khanates. And his successors, the Yuan emperors, were even less able to assert any kind of authority over them.