Latest / Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson / REALITY CHECK! Rutgers' New Study on Reality TV Participants' Mental Health w/ Christine Chapais
Transcript
- 0:00It's unfulfilled motivations, expectations, and promises.
- 0:05And then one of the quotes was, be careful what you wish for.
- 0:09So essentially, you know, you're taking people who have stars in their eyes, a lot of ambition and motivation to go on a TV show, whether it be because they're looking for a really fun experience, just like,
- 0:23you know, a checkmark off the bucket list, doing something unique, an adventure, or maybe even looking for fame.
- 0:29Some people are even looking for their businesses to take off and see that as a way to do that, too.
- 0:36And so you've got these people with really high hopes.
- 0:39And in some instances, people who are coming from very vulnerable backgrounds,
- 0:43Are you going through life blind?
- 0:45This is Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson.
- 0:48On this podcast, we share knowledge and stories that build human connection while elevating stigmatized societal issues such as mental health, holistic wellness, culture, free speech, and more.
- 1:00All to ensure we show up in the world with our eyes wide open.
- 1:06Hello, everyone, and welcome back to this episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 1:09Our guest today is Christine Chappé.
- 1:12Christine is a licensed social worker, certified school social worker, and an assistant professor at Rutgers School of Social Work.
- 1:21She is also the author of the newly published research paper titled Reality Check, a Qualitative Study of Mental Wellbeing.
- 1:29among participants, which examines reality TV participants' perceptions of their mental well-being during and after their involvement in reality TV shows.
- 1:39And then in full transparency, I think I'm allowed to say this, but I participated in this study, which is how I met you and know of the paper, but I don't know any of the other participants, so I just want to clear that up out of the way.
- 1:53Or maybe I do know them and I just don't know who they are, but...
- 1:56So, you know, just full transparency for the audience.
- 1:59I participated in this study and I think there were 15 total.
- 2:02Is that right?
- 2:03That's correct.
- 2:0315 total?
- 2:04Yep.
- 2:04Okay, great.
- 2:05So we're gonna talk about your study and your research and we'll talk about this paper and all the things that you learned.
- 2:13kind of what your takeaways are and some of the things that you think should be adjusted in the industry to help with participants.
- 2:20But before we get into the meat and potatoes, as they like to say, why don't you answer my favorite question?
- 2:28And that question is, what did you want to be when you were growing up?
- 2:31And then how did that lead you to the work that you do now?
- 2:34And I think that's an awesome question because I think it's twofold and it leans into why this research study interested me.
- 2:43Growing up, I loved entertainment.
- 2:45I like to sing.
- 2:46I like to act.
- 2:47I like to dance.
- 2:48All of the performing arts.
- 2:50And so that's always something that I wanted to do, paired with just always caring a whole lot about people and wanting to do something where I get to help people.
- 3:01I remember as early as eight years old, I was.
- 3:05going into AOL chat rooms and asking people if they needed a friend to talk to.
- 3:10And I swear I have a good mother.
- 3:12She did pay attention to me and made sure that I didn't make friends with strangers.
- 3:18But I guess that's a pretty young age to start wanting to help others.
- 3:23But I continued to do the performing arts and just I absolutely loved expressing myself through, you know, entertainment.
- 3:34And I've always said that the performing arts and social work or any sort of caring profession has the theme of like being really in touch with your emotions and being able to identify other people and their emotions and what they're doing.
- 3:52their needs might be.
- 3:53So I feel like they somehow do enter intertwine in a way, if that makes sense.
- 3:58No, it actually does.
- 3:58I've never thought of that before.
- 4:00But like, if you're going to be any kind of performer, you have to be in touch with maybe not all of your emotions, but in touch with emotions so that you can know how to express them in a performance.
- 4:12Right.
- 4:12Exactly.
- 4:13Yeah.
- 4:13That's it.
- 4:14I never thought of that before.
- 4:15That's really interesting.
- 4:16Maybe another research study.
- 4:18Yeah, yeah.
- 4:19And also, where were you when I was going through it at 13 years old on AOL instant messenger and in chat rooms and needing a friend and it was like, everyone was mean.
- 4:32Why are you bullying me?
- 4:33Yeah, and that's actually, that's just inhibition.
- 4:38It's like another thing that has been studied about how people interact online.
- 4:45When people have anonymity on their side, they tend to just speak differently to others, treat them differently than they might.
- 4:54when they're in person.
- 4:56I kind of think of it like fence rage.
- 4:59Like, have you ever seen a dog on one side of the fence?
- 5:01And they're usually like a friendly dog.
- 5:03And then they're met with these other dogs.
- 5:05If they were in a dog park, they would be the best of friends.
- 5:07But for some reason, that fence in between them makes them want to fight.
- 5:11And it's like the same thing online.
- 5:13Sometimes you see it in comment sections.
- 5:16It's, it's disturbing, honestly.
- 5:17I'm sure I am sure you heard a lot about it doing this research project from all of us.
- 5:24But that that's interesting, because I always assumed that right that like, you get kind of like the guise of having, you know, not to look someone in the eye when you say something harmful or hurtful.
- 5:35Exactly.
- 5:36And then you've got the people that are even a layer deeper, who don't have a profile picture, don't have any followers, just
- 5:41kind of troll online and then they're kind of like twice removed from that interaction because they're not even representing their real self.
- 5:50Maybe they are, but you know what I mean?
- 5:51Like their real, their face, right?
- 5:53They get to be someone completely different if they want to be.
- 5:56Yep.
- 5:57And what do you think?
- 5:58And I didn't expect to go down this path actually, but...
- 6:02What do you think from the research causes that?
- 6:05Is that like some sort of illness or what do you think it is?
- 6:10No, no.
- 6:10I think, well, I guess in the extreme versions, it may be something that is pathological, but it's literally called disinhibition.
- 6:20And it's something that I've studied in my other research too, because I'm a director of online research.
- 6:25programs at Rutgers School of Social Work.
- 6:27So I've also looked at it in terms of how students interact with each other within discussion threads for asynchronous classes, because it can happen there too when you're getting into like more sensitive topics or difficult discussions.
- 6:42People may not realize that what they're saying, you know, lacks nuance or the tone that you would typically hear.
- 6:51So some of it is perfectly innocent and others it's just, it might be that they want attention and they're okay with getting negative attention rather than positive attention because maybe the person isn't getting it from elsewhere.
- 7:05I think there's a lot of reasons for that.
- 7:10And it's really unfortunate.
- 7:12And some just, I think, in their head, it's like, well, I'm allowed to do this.
- 7:17This is my right.
- 7:19And, you know, you're the one that put yourself out there.
- 7:22So it's not my fault that you're on the internet.
- 7:25where I don't personally agree with that.
- 7:27I like to lead with kindness, whether I know the person or not, and whether they chose to be on the internet or not, whether they're a celebrity or not, I feel like it's just, for me, it's 10 times easier to just be nice.
- 7:39I don't personally understand why people are so mean.
- 7:43Yeah, you know, I always I always say when I'm building some sort of content around reality TV or doing an interview, I just did an interview with a Harvard law student earlier this afternoon.
- 7:54And, you know, one of the questions she was asking me was about
- 7:57like what kind of like my messages to people.
- 7:59And it's like, whether you're on TV, whether you're an actor or an actress, whether you're an influencer, whether you're just a content creator, whether you're a normal person, like the common denominator there is that we are human beings.
- 8:11We have feelings, we have emotions, they're complex, they're nuanced.
- 8:15And I personally try to look at everyone and give them grace, whether they say or do the wrong thing, especially if you're a public figure of some sort, because when you're a public figure,
- 8:27or you're on a reality show or you, or you're, um, you know, doing something online, having a meltdown, whatever that is, you're doing that in front of the whole world.
- 8:38Most people get to do that in the privacy of their own life.
- 8:41Right.
- 8:41Someone makes a giant mistake on reality TV.
- 8:44The world is coming for their head where you could make that mistake or say that same thing in real life.
- 8:50And life kind of goes on and people that love you and are surrounding you with support, even if it's,
- 8:56You know, not the best thing, but it always blows my mind how people choose to be negative or hurtful or harmful to someone over just kind.
- 9:07Or my favorite thing to say, which makes me feel like I'm the Internet's dad, is when I was in about kindergarten, I learned if you don't have something nice to say, don't say anything at all.
- 9:17And I think that can work for us adults as well.
- 9:20Agreed.
- 9:21Interestingly, and just to go back to that point, you know, about this happening so much in comment sections and everything.
- 9:29It's also the age of social media and the Internet.
- 9:32You know, humans are not meant to hear feedback about themselves every second of the day at their fingertips.
- 9:38You know what I mean?
- 9:39Yeah, from strangers.
- 9:40That's that's not something that we historically have experienced.
- 9:45had to endure to this extent.
- 9:47But there is actually an aspect of human nature as it relates to human degradation and public humiliation.
- 9:54There is research on that as well, which is very interesting.
- 9:57If you even think about, like, fictionally, Game of Thrones, right?
- 10:01Cersei Lannister and the shame, right?
- 10:04For some reason, humans have this thing in us where we feel the need to, like, publicly
- 10:11show that someone has done something wrong or that we're not happy with something that someone has done.
- 10:17So that's very interesting, too.
- 10:20That's a very good point.
- 10:22And again, that's another thing I never thought about, like getting the constant feedback all the time.
- 10:28You know where I notice, and this is a little bit off topic, but that's okay.
- 10:31That's the podcast they're for, right?
- 10:33Yeah.
- 10:33I notice lately...
- 10:36that the amount of like notifications, ding, ding, ding, it's like text message, group text message, phone calls, work messages, work emails, personal emails, DMs, TikTok DMs,
- 10:55Twitter, like it's so much.
- 10:58It's non-stop.
- 10:59Like any given, I cleared here.
- 11:01I'm looking right now.
- 11:02I cleared my notifications right as I was getting on here.
- 11:05And by the way, my Instagram notifications have been turned off for like two years at this point.
- 11:09Right.
- 11:09And so I'm looking on here.
- 11:10I've already got two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15,
- 11:15Too many to count notifications.
- 11:16Oh my gosh.
- 11:17Just since we started, what, 20 minutes ago?
- 11:19Wow.
- 11:20Yeah.
- 11:20We got on here.
- 11:21And to me, it's like that.
- 11:23And it's like, ding, ding, ding.
- 11:25And you can't concentrate on anything.
- 11:27Yep.
- 11:28And then when it's like negativity or feedback or something like that, it super heightens it.
- 11:33Yep.
- 11:34Plus, you're also kind of like...
- 11:36overstimulated all the time.
- 11:37I think, I think we're all very overstimulated all the time.
- 11:40Now.
- 11:41100%.
- 11:41Yeah.
- 11:42It's to the point where sometimes I even catch myself.
- 11:44I'm like, okay, I'm going to sit down and watch TV show.
- 11:47And then I'm also going to scroll on my phone while I'm watching the TV show.
- 11:50Like, okay, I do the same thing.
- 11:52Relax here.
- 11:54I know.
- 11:54I do the same thing.
- 11:55You know, my, um, my therapist had me track
- 11:59cause I've been like kind of dealing with feeling burnt out and she's had me like track stuff that I was doing in like, if it was, you know, uh, more than a 15 minute interval, I document it.
- 12:09And so I documented it and like she wanted me to get the multitasking.
- 12:12So like pay attention to when you're multitasking.
- 12:15And so like all of these things that I thought I was doing, like going on, um, you know, I make time to go on like 15 minute walks with my dog.
- 12:22Well, guess what I'm doing on those walks.
- 12:24I'm responding to work emails.
- 12:26I'm,
- 12:27editing like podcast clips on my phone for social media because it's like, and I'm sitting there and I'm like, wow, I think I'm walking.
- 12:35I'm taking a 15 minute break, but I'm really not.
- 12:38Yeah.
- 12:38Same with the, you know, movies at night, like sit down to watch a movie or a show.
- 12:43It's how long do I go before I pick up my phone and start scrolling?
- 12:46Or I'm like, oh, I need to go buy this on Amazon or whatever that is.
- 12:50Like, I think.
- 12:51It's just so much information all the time.
- 12:54And I think that's where mindfulness comes in.
- 12:56That's not my area of expertise.
- 12:58I actually have one of my best friends is an absolute expert in mindfulness.
- 13:05And, you know, with the walk, for example.
- 13:09to try to prevent yourself from doing that checking and looking at your phone, you can go on that walk with intentionality and say, okay, during this walk, these are the things that I'm going to make sure I do.
- 13:18This is something that I've tried to help myself with personally, where I'll say, okay, today I'm going to see how many birds I can see on my way walking.
- 13:28and I'll count the birds.
- 13:29So I'm intentionally looking through nature and maybe the next time I'll say, okay, this time I'm gonna see how many different sounds that I hear.
- 13:40So I personally like to use the five senses and have a goal set.
- 13:44So that when I am walking, I'm forcing myself to do the mindfulness.
- 13:49And when I have that goal in mind, it helps me.
- 13:51I'm not really great at just the open-ended, like, I will be one with the universe and be, you know, silent.
- 13:58I can't.
- 13:59My mind will drift off right away.
- 14:01So I find that the goal setting helps redirect my attention.
- 14:06That's a great idea.
- 14:07I'm actually going to try that, but I can't count the birds because there's so many pigeons in my neighborhood that it would become like anxiety inducing trying to count all of the pigeons flying around.
- 14:17Right.
- 14:17Right.
- 14:18And then you have to search for the baby pigeon because isn't that what they say?
- 14:22You never see any baby pigeons.
- 14:25So that'll be what you're looking for.
- 14:26That's a good point.
- 14:27I've never noticed a baby pigeon.
- 14:29But is that, is that something the people that like, don't believe the birds are real say?
- 14:34I don't think so.
- 14:35But that's a good point.
- 14:36That might be actually, maybe that's where I got that from.
- 14:39I promise I'm not a bird conspiracy theorist.
- 14:42It's so funny.
- 14:43I didn't even know what that was.
- 14:44And I kept seeing like stickers, like on little lamp poles and stuff around the city a few years ago.
- 14:48It says the birds aren't real.
- 14:49I'm like, this has to mean something else, but no, it literally means people think the birds aren't real.
- 14:55I think it did, to be fair, I think it did start off as a gag, but, um.
- 15:00Maybe some people do believe that the birds are not real.
- 15:03I happen to believe the birds are real.
- 15:05I've seen plenty of dead pigeons that are inside out and I'm pretty confident that's real.
- 15:12Got it.
- 15:13Yeah.
- 15:14I'll believe you.
- 15:16Anyway, let's talk about this research paper.
- 15:19This just dropped, what was it, last week published?
- 15:23Yes.
- 15:24So again, it is, the link's below if anyone wants to read the full research paper.
- 15:30I think you have to buy it, right?
- 15:33Isn't it?
- 15:35Yeah, I think it's like $17.95 or something.
- 15:39And then you can own the copy yourself.
- 15:43Yeah.
- 15:44And one of the things that made me excited to participate in this research with you as one of the subjects of it or participants of it was that there's not a lot of research.
- 15:58on the mental health aspects and the experiences of reality TV cast members.
- 16:05Now, as you point out in this paper, that reality TV can be traced back to, I think it was like the 1940s.
- 16:11You know, I have
- 16:16personally traced it back to like the late 80s with cops and, you know, the talk shows that would come out of there, eventually becoming like Jerry Springer and stuff, because they were telling, you know, narratives about people and kind of putting their lives out there and, you know, those dramatic ways, but it goes all the way, oh, we've got a little friend.
- 16:37Hello, this is Coda.
- 16:38Hello, Coda.
- 16:39For those of you just listening.
- 16:40You're showing them that I don't actually have a library behind me.
- 16:45Stop.
- 16:47For those of you that are listening, her cat, Koda, just jumped onto the screen.
- 16:50So we had a little visitor.
- 16:53So when you decided you were going to take on this research project, what was your inspiration?
- 17:00Or was there a tipping point or a pivotal point that you were like, this is something that I think we need to look into or that I want to start looking into?
- 17:07Yeah.
- 17:07Yeah, absolutely.
- 17:08So I would say reality TV is a guilty pleasure of mine.
- 17:12I love watching reality TV, but I started picking up on things and maybe it's because I've done, you know, scripted television work where I just started noticing that people were saying things while they were obviously intoxicated.
- 17:26And I felt like
- 17:27Would they have said that if they weren't intoxicated or, you know, just picking up on little things.
- 17:33I'm very, very passionate about ethics and autonomy and all of that.
- 17:39So when I started picking up on these things that were questionable, I...
- 17:44I wanted to look more into it.
- 17:46I think it's important that the entertainment that we consume is ethical.
- 17:50There are people on the other side of the screen.
- 17:52And I think even more so with reality TV, you are having real people that are being thrust into the spotlight that don't know what to do with that.
- 18:04they don't necessarily know what to anticipate and what is going to come on the other side.
- 18:08They might think that they do, but they don't have the support or the team that a celebrity might wear.
- 18:16There's a wraparound service to help them when the public is scrutinizing them.
- 18:22Just thinking about all of that, that this is going to impact real people, people who are going to have to go back to their busy lives at work.
- 18:30The things that are shown on TV could actually impact their livelihood.
- 18:35They could lose their job because of things happening.
- 18:39So all of that just made me really question it and want to dig deeper.
- 18:43I care a lot about people, as I've discussed.
- 18:47And I think that...
- 18:49You know, there is a difference between choosing to be an actor and being on a show where you play a character versus being on a show where you think you're playing yourself and someone else has decided on a character for you.
- 19:03Because the audience doesn't realize that.
- 19:06The audience thinks you're playing yourself and they have no idea what goes into what they're actually seeing on the other side of the screen.
- 19:14You can't.
- 19:17nailed that.
- 19:18And I think that what is so
- 19:23difficult for so many of us, whether we felt like we got, you know, portrayed properly, a good at it, bad at it, whatever that is.
- 19:31I think what's so hard is like, you have so many expectations, which is something that, you know, you identified in your, your work, but you have so many expectations of what it's going to be and how it's going to change your life.
- 19:43And, you know, or in my case, like what it was going to be like if I found love and got married and all of that stuff.
- 19:50And then, you know,
- 19:52almost the expectation that nobody who hasn't gone through it can't understand is the expectation that you're actually going to be yourself, portrayed as yourself.
- 20:02Right.
- 20:03And through the power of editing and through the power of
- 20:08you know, psychological, I would say, manipulation from the whole structure of how these shows are done and manufactured and how you're cast to be a certain way.
- 20:21And they decide all of that.
- 20:23It's impossible to feel, you know, you go in and you just expect to be mostly portrayed as yourself.
- 20:29Like for me, and I didn't get a bad edit or anything, but I was like, I'm just going to be myself.
- 20:35I'm not going to.
- 20:36I'm gonna act with integrity because that's a core value of mine.
- 20:39I'm not gonna say or do anything out of character.
- 20:41I have nothing to worry about.
- 20:43And I think most people go in with that mindset, whether they say it or not, thinking I'm just gonna be myself.
- 20:51I'm fun, I'm cool, I'm dramatic, I'm this, I'm that.
- 20:55people, America is going to love me or the world's going to love me because you know, who are we surrounded by people that love us?
- 21:02Right.
- 21:03So it's like, it's our worldview and you just have no idea or no consideration to even think, oh my gosh.
- 21:11this could go horribly wrong and not even necessarily for something I did or said.
- 21:16Right.
- 21:17Exactly.
- 21:19Now to, to also show a different side, there actually are some people who go into this knowing that they are going to maybe portray a slight character, which I also find interesting.
- 21:31There were, there was a couple of people that I spoke to that were,
- 21:35They were able to compartmentalize the person that they portrayed in this show versus who they are in real life.
- 21:42I think that is not typical.
- 21:45I think that that is a very specific person that is able to do that.
- 21:52their outcome, because they were able to do that, was more positive in the long run, because they were able to make that separation for themselves.
- 22:00And they kind of decided, like, this is just a character I'm portraying.
- 22:03And therefore, what the audience says, it doesn't really matter, because that's not even me anyway.
- 22:08Yeah.
- 22:08I totally, I love that.
- 22:10And whenever I talk to cast members, especially...
- 22:14not even just from Love is Blind, from like all the shows that people I've talked to, especially when the show is airing, they're understandably hot and ready to explode.
- 22:27But I always tell them, I'm like, you have to separate yourself from the edit.
- 22:32And I know that's hard because of the public, but like it's the hardest thing for people to do.
- 22:37That's the number one piece of advice I give people is you have to separate yourself from the edit.
- 22:44And I always tell myself, it's something that I did.
- 22:47It's not who I am.
- 22:49And I think that is another thing that's very, very hard for people to do.
- 22:53is to just accept that I did this.
- 22:55And to so many people in the world, what they saw in that hour and 20 minutes of my love story or my life, they think that that hour and 20 minutes
- 23:09like sums up my 35 at the time years, 39 years now on this earth.
- 23:17And that's just not the case.
- 23:18And so it's kind of like that job you had that didn't work out for you or that, you know, person you had in your life that wasn't right for you.
- 23:27And you had to make the cut.
- 23:29You got to kind of be able to think of it like that.
- 23:31And it seems like it's just really hard for most people and understandably so.
- 23:34Right.
- 23:35Right.
- 23:35I think that makes a lot of sense because even when we make mistakes in our real lives, we don't have a camera that has, you know, this evidence forever and ever.
- 23:47And I think part of the other issue is that the audience, not like, like I said earlier, they don't realize what goes into this.
- 23:56So they believe that everything that they're seeing.
- 23:58is 100% accurate and real, forgetting that, you know, clips can be cut together.
- 24:07One of the participants that I spoke to gave an example where, um, they said that someone asked them for the definition of a word.
- 24:15They said the definition of the word, and then the editor took what they said about, you know, that definition.
- 24:22and applied it somewhere else to make it seem like they were saying something mean about someone.
- 24:27So just completely took words that they did say, but used it in a scenario that never actually existed.
- 24:35And what makes me nervous personally is with the advent of AI, and I said this in my paper with artificial intelligence, we can do deep fakes and voiceovers that sound like the person actually said it, especially if you've
- 24:50you know, signed over your rights, they can take samples of your voice and then just create you saying something that you never did.
- 24:56They don't even have to show your face.
- 24:57They can have you doing a voiceover over a montage or B-roll, and then the audience is going to believe that you've said that.
- 25:05So that's a little scary and something to pay attention to if people are signing up for reality TV to make sure that they're really looking at their contracts so that they're not allowing people to do that.
- 25:19Well, I think we're on the precipice of those contracts and a lot of cases being deemed illegal and a shift coming, especially starting with Love is Blind, as the National Labor Relations Board declared that we should be considered employees.
- 25:38And of course, that's going to go to court because they're not going to.
- 25:40let us disrupt the business model that much without a fight.
- 25:43But those basic things in the contracts, it says we can misrepresent you, we can defame you, you have no recourse.
- 25:52And, you know, I read that and I was like, what am I going to like?
- 25:56But I, you go and you ask, what's the definition of, you know, some word and then you say and then that's used in a scene out of context.
- 26:05That's
- 26:06You can't anticipate that.
- 26:08Right.
- 26:08You can't.
- 26:09And that's actually part of the first theme of my research paper.
- 26:13It's unfulfilled.
- 26:15Let me just look up the wording.
- 26:17It's unfulfilled motivations, expectations and promises.
- 26:22And then one of the quotes was, be careful what you wish for.
- 26:26So essentially, you know, you're.
- 26:29taking people who have stars in their eyes, a lot of ambition and motivation to go on a TV show, whether it be because they're looking for a really fun experience, just like,
- 26:40you know, a checkmark off the bucket list, doing something unique, an adventure, or maybe even looking for fame.
- 26:47Some people are even looking for their businesses to take off and see that as a way to do that, too.
- 26:53And so you've got these people with really high hopes.
- 26:56And in some instances, people who are coming from very vulnerable backgrounds, like women.
- 27:01I remember back in the day watching American Idol, for example, and you always see the stories, these traumatic experiences that people have been through, which are so heartwarming, and yet it's a singing TV show, right?
- 27:16So these are all motivators for someone to want to be involved and to say, I can do this, this won't be me.
- 27:24And then on top of it, because they're so motivated,
- 27:28they don't wanna give up their spot.
- 27:29So saying, hold on one sec, let me find an entertainment lawyer or hold on one sec, let me read this.
- 27:35It feels rushed because they're afraid that their spot is going to be given up to someone else who's not going to read the contract in full or not going to hire a lawyer.
- 27:44And so it just becomes much more rushed and people are signing things that maybe they wouldn't have if they had more time.
- 27:53Yeah, I think you're right.
- 27:55And I know,
- 27:57I wasn't under as much pressure and time to sign as some of the other cast members I've talked to have, but they do kind of pressure you.
- 28:04And there is always that, um, unspoken commentary from throughout the whole process that like, you're lucky to have this, you're easily replaceable.
- 28:15And, um, to your point about why people go on these shows.
- 28:20or what their motivations are, I think too, at least from what I've learned and in my experience, like I actually did go on, because I thought it was a good way to maybe meet someone.
- 28:31And it was different and I believed in the process, but,
- 28:35that's also what they sold me because I think during the casting process, they picked up on me kind of not being concerned about fame or fortune or anything that comes with it.
- 28:46Like I genuinely thought maybe I could meet someone this way and they they'll sell you whatever's if they want you, they'll sell you whatever's gonna,
- 28:55get you to agree to do it.
- 28:57So by the time you're signing that contract, you've already been sold almost like your dream scenario for whatever your motivations are.
- 29:05So then when those aren't met, you also feel a little bit cheated and you feel like you were conned and scammed.
- 29:12And that also contributes to all of, I think all of those missed motivations.
- 29:19Yeah, absolutely.
- 29:21Yep.
- 29:22And having those high expectations and just really it's an even further fall from from grace.
- 29:27And sometimes you don't realize it right away.
- 29:29Like one of my one of my favorite quotes from this is a little bit of a lengthy one.
- 29:33I would love to.
- 29:34to read it if we have time, but you let me know.
- 29:37No, go for it, we do.
- 29:39It's just so poetic.
- 29:41So it was like being caught in a torrent that doesn't feel dangerous yet, but you have no ability to get out of it.
- 29:49It started out where you choose to jump into the river and it's a gentle current.
- 29:53You've made the decision to go down it and you can get out at any time.
- 29:57But then at some point it becomes too rapid to escape.
- 30:01You're still having fun, like a whitewater rafting trip.
- 30:04But then it gets to the point when you're crushed under the rapids and you're bashed against rocks and there's no escape.
- 30:11You realize that you're drowning, but there's nothing that you can do about it.
- 30:16I just so poetic and just really eloquent in a way to say, like, yeah, I did choose this.
- 30:23I was having a great time.
- 30:24And then all of a sudden I realized, wait a second, I feel like I'm being exploited.
- 30:28And these things, these things don't feel right.
- 30:31And now I can't get out of it because it's too late.
- 30:33And it's slow.
- 30:34That's the thing.
- 30:35It's a slow burn.
- 30:36Right.
- 30:37It's like, it's like the dog, it's the frog in the pot of water.
- 30:41Like you're slowly boiling that water.
- 30:43The frog has no idea what's going on.
- 30:45Right.
- 30:46That's what it's like.
- 30:47Yep.
- 30:48I do want to, I do want to continue in the themes, but one of the, one of the parts I found interesting was that you chose the narrative identity theory.
- 30:58Yes.
- 31:00Can you, in layman's terms,
- 31:03explain what that theory is and what that means, you know, in your work and then why you felt that was a good application.
- 31:13I think just hearing the word narrative sounds, gives people an idea, but I think hearing from you, what this theory is, why it was chosen and how it was applied would be great.
- 31:26Yeah, absolutely.
- 31:27And I'm so sorry, everyone.
- 31:28Koda, my cat, continues to want to be a star.
- 31:31He may just keep on coming up here and that's okay.
- 31:34I'm going to try to ignore him.
- 31:36It's fine with me.
- 31:37I even had the door closed.
- 31:39Like this cat literally opened the door fully to be a part of this conversation.
- 31:45Motivated.
- 31:46Exactly.
- 31:46Motivated indeed.
- 31:49So narrative identity theory, it basically helps to frame the understanding.
- 31:54It is the story that we tell about ourselves.
- 32:00What we understand about ourselves is extremely important.
- 32:04And so when a narrative is different than what the narrative we tell ourselves is, it can mess with us, basically.
- 32:10And so when a narrative is different than what the narrative we tell ourselves is, it can mess with us, basically.
- 32:15And these narratives can be past, present and future, and it emphasizes coherence, agency or autonomy and community or excuse me, and communion.
- 32:26So when any of these things is sort of different than our own understanding of ourselves, it can negatively impact our mental well-being.
- 32:37So it's the disruption between public persona versus our self-perception.
- 32:43The agency aspect is that loss of control over our own story.
- 32:47So when you're talking about, you know, an editing process where someone else gets to determine how you look or the story and change it from what actually happened.
- 32:58that is going to impact our sense of autonomy and agency.
- 33:02And then the communion aspect is the isolation from social connections.
- 33:07So as human beings, we need to have connections with others.
- 33:11Not all of the shows do this, but a lot of them, even when they're not immersive, tend to isolate people.
- 33:18And that's so that they can make sure that the story gets told on camera.
- 33:23So even when the cameras are shut off and they're going back to their hotel rooms, they are put in their own hotel rooms and they're not allowed to talk to each other.
- 33:31And so that can be really isolating and impact that communion aspect of narrative identity theory.
- 33:37And then there's something called the redemption arc, basically.
- 33:42where you regain control of your identity and your own story and you turn any challenges into opportunities for growth, which is also known as meaning making.
- 33:55And you gain self-awareness over any difficult conversations.
- 33:59You figure out what you've learned.
- 34:01from that.
- 34:03Um, and so all of those things just really spoke to me and felt like it fit really well with, with what, what happens in reality TV and the experiences.
- 34:12Yeah.
- 34:13And you don't always get your arc.
- 34:16You don't always get it.
- 34:18Exactly.
- 34:19You know, I tell myself, um, when I
- 34:26I thought the end of my reality TV story, right?
- 34:31I thought, well, initially I thought it was going to be get married and live happily ever after.
- 34:36Then I thought it was going to be surviving
- 34:42Probably when we first connected, I was probably in the, oh my God, I just got to survive today and then do it again tomorrow mode.
- 34:49Right.
- 34:50And then I thought to myself, um, as I was going through kind of like my growing, my reflecting and my like comprehension of what actually had happened and how that much has impacted me and in, in my career, my mental health, all of that stuff.
- 35:04And then.
- 35:06I thought, oh, my my end of my story is going to be when I'm feeling like myself again.
- 35:11And then I realized I'm like, oh, my God, this is chapter one.
- 35:14And I started you can.
- 35:16And I was like, OK, well, now I'm doing now I'm trying to unionize.
- 35:20And I'm just like the story just keeps on going.
- 35:22But like that's your meaning making, Nick, your creation of you can and and taking this
- 35:29this experience that you had and saying, I want to make a difference.
- 35:33I want to change this.
- 35:35That's the redemption arc.
- 35:37That's maybe you don't feel it all the way yet.
- 35:40I can't, you know, I'm not in your shoes, but that's the meaning making aspect that you're doing there.
- 35:47That makes sense.
- 35:48Yeah.
- 35:49And I will say, not everyone gets that.
- 35:51And I'm really stubborn and I'm very driven.
- 35:55And when I think something's the right thing to do, you better get out of my way because I will bulldoze people to do the right thing.
- 36:02But if I had a villain at it, and here's what I think part of the problem with all of this is I'm starting to realize.
- 36:09The people that are the most vocal usually got a bad edit or were a villain or were for some way, shape or form, felt like they were misrepresented.
- 36:20Right.
- 36:21But people don't wanna listen to those people and don't take them as seriously because they just think they're complaining.
- 36:28because of the bad edit or because they weren't represented in a good way or didn't get all of the, you know, expectations they had met.
- 36:35And so they're immediately discredited so that even telling their own story doesn't get them that final arc.
- 36:44Because people are just like, shut up, you're a psycho or shut up and die or whatever horrible thing they have to say at that moment.
- 36:51And it just totally takes away that part of it.
- 36:55And it just, it just villainizes them even further.
- 36:57I never really thought about that in that way until recently.
- 37:01Absolutely.
- 37:02So that's, yeah, that's interesting.
- 37:05Man, it just makes me feel for people that are just trying to find some sort of closure and they can't get their own story.
- 37:14And there's an aspect of what you're describing, too, of what's called disenfranchised grief, where you feel a loss of something that it's not acceptable to talk about or that people won't understand.
- 37:27So when we talk about grief and loss, we think of people who have died, but it can apply to other things as well.
- 37:33It can apply to the life we thought that we would have.
- 37:36Right.
- 37:37or how a situation would wind up one way and it didn't wind up that way.
- 37:41So there are grieving processes in a lot of different aspects of our life.
- 37:46And in this scenario, it's that people are telling them, well, I'm not gonna listen to you because obviously you just don't like your edit.
- 37:54Or, oh, come on, you should just be grateful because you were on TV.
- 37:58Not everybody gets to be on TV.
- 38:00Or people that just don't get it.
- 38:02Like maybe they're trying to listen and they just will never understand.
- 38:07So it's that that sense of disenfranchised grief that also impacts the mental well-being as well.
- 38:14That's, I had not heard of that term before.
- 38:18That's definitely how I felt right after my divorce.
- 38:21I was like, nobody gets this.
- 38:22Nobody understands.
- 38:24To everybody else, it's just, it was on TV.
- 38:27It's like watching a movie and then you forget about it.
- 38:29Right.
- 38:29And it was like, I was going through so much loss that people, even in my life, close people to me, like, I just felt like they couldn't get it.
- 38:38It is.
- 38:39So it's a, that's very interesting.
- 38:41I'd never heard of that before.
- 38:43Yeah.
- 38:44Yeah.
- 38:45So one other thing I wanted to ask you, so we talked about like the unfulfilled motivations, expectations, promises was the first theme.
- 38:53I wanna get to the other two, but I wanted to ask you another question about that.
- 38:58What do you think,
- 39:00can be done or what do you, maybe not can be done industry-wide, but if you have that too, but like, what do you think a person who's going into a reality TV show now, or is considering it or going through it, what do you think they can do to better align their expectations with the reality of reality TV?
- 39:24I think that's a great question because I think there are some people that no matter how much you tell them, there are some people that just
- 39:31They won't believe you until they experience it for themselves.
- 39:35So true.
- 39:36You know what I mean?
- 39:36They think I'm going to be the one that I am more powerful than this.
- 39:40This is something that I'm going to be able to do, even though nobody else was able to do it or most people aren't able to do it.
- 39:46That's how I feel about the people that say you signed up for this.
- 39:50It's because I think they think they could have done it better or different or wouldn't be impacted by it.
- 39:55Right.
- 39:56Yep, absolutely.
- 39:57So I think for other people who maybe don't have that perspective, just really paying attention, listening to the actual voices of people who have experienced, you know, being on a reality TV show.
- 40:11and hearing those personal perspectives.
- 40:14And that's part of why I wanted to do a qualitative study rather than a quantitative study, because I wanted to amplify actual voices of people who have been on reality TV and hear directly from their perspective.
- 40:27So, you know, the beauty of a qualitative study is,
- 40:31No, it's not exactly generalizable because there's not enough number, but you're getting to hear the deep thoughts of people who you don't know who's talking.
- 40:40So they might be a little bit more open and you get to really have an understanding of their perspective.
- 40:45So I hope people will listen to that.
- 40:49I think also...
- 40:52Once you've heard those perspectives and you get an education on these practices, then go back and rewatch some of your shows that you like and see it.
- 41:02One of the things that I know about because I've been, you know, I've, I've,
- 41:07filmed things before is the idea of continuity.
- 41:10So when you're watching a scene, if someone is eating food and then all of a sudden their food has disappeared, then you know there was a jump in that scene.
- 41:20There was a cut, right?
- 41:21That's the whole reason on Love is Blind, why they have those gold chalices is because they don't want you to see that the liquid in the glass has gone down or up and that way they can cut things easier.
- 41:33I'm assuming, allegedly, I'm not really sure.
- 41:35That's correct.
- 41:36Yeah.
- 41:39I can't say it's 100% correct, but I can say that it's correct from my perspective.
- 41:44It's maybe one of the reasons.
- 41:45Yeah.
- 41:46And now I do think it's a branding exercise.
- 41:48Those things are so popular.
- 41:49I have to hide them.
- 41:51I have some, and I hide them in my house because otherwise people would see them go crazy, and then it'd become a topic of discussion.
- 41:57But then I'm sitting here with my friends talking about the show again, and it's like...
- 42:01Yeah.
- 42:02Right.
- 42:02So just little things like that.
- 42:04Once you become educated on what to look out for, I tend to view things from the perspective of how would I feel if that were me?
- 42:14So if I said that thing on screen, would I regret that afterwards?
- 42:23Right.
- 42:23And I'm, I guess I'm thinking of, you know, when someone is very obviously intoxicated and they're saying something that,
- 42:30you know, people are making fun of afterwards or it feels embarrassing even when you're just watching it.
- 42:36Would I want someone filming me intoxicated and putting that on national television for everybody to see?
- 42:42How would that make me feel afterwards when I am coherent and I am thinking and making decisions for my logical mind?
- 42:50You know what I mean?
- 42:51I mean, just from a consent perspective, how can you get someone's consent to be on TV if you're filming them while they're intoxicated?
- 42:59Right.
- 42:59And there's many things.
- 43:02Yeah.
- 43:02It's to do things.
- 43:03I actually wanted to ask you what.
- 43:08When I went on.
- 43:11God, what?
- 43:12Oh, I went on a podcast that covers true crime and cults.
- 43:18What was it called?
- 43:19That's so effed up, I think it's called.
- 43:21I'm so sorry to Ashley for screwing that up.
- 43:22I thought you were like, that's so effed up that I can't remember.
- 43:24No, no, no, no, I think that's what it's called.
- 43:26And I'm sorry to Ashley, who's the hostess.
- 43:29But one of the things that we chatted about was like informed consent.
- 43:35And it's like, I can make informed consent
- 43:41But once I have that drink or that second drink or I haven't eaten or whatever that might be, or it's 12 hours into filming, like, am I still able to give that consent?
- 43:54I think there's real questions about that.
- 43:58I agree with you.
- 44:00I mean, we, you know, mental health professionals have to give, you know, request informed consent on a regular basis, even from the perspective of competency and to make sure that someone fully understands what they're getting into.
- 44:15You know, you have to really make sure that they understand and that maybe in different scenarios that consent will apply there as well.
- 44:25because it might change.
- 44:27You might need to check back in.
- 44:28And maybe that's a practice that needs to be adopted too, where, all right, you agreed to this now.
- 44:33Let's do a check-in and make sure you still agree to this.
- 44:35How do you feel?
- 44:36Yeah.
- 44:37Yeah.
- 44:37And you know, I want to have one of my, my pillars is that I want to have independent mental health professionals for each cast member who is part of their, their role there would be to have the ability to work with their, their person and determine if they're,
- 44:57able to give consent to be filmed.
- 44:59So like, I think back to my experience in Mexico when Danielle had a panic attack and there was no mental health professional there to help her.
- 45:07Like she should not have been filming after that.
- 45:10And I think, and I compare it often to like the NFL's concussion protocol that now has an independent neurologist conducting concussion tests on the sideline and outside of the team has the ability to say, this person cannot play, they are concussed.
- 45:25And when it was a team doctor, it would be like, ah, they're fine.
- 45:29Send, send them back in.
- 45:30So I think of it kind of like that, because if we have, um, you know, someone there who has to get consent on a regular basis, understands consent, they can make sure that the person's in a place mentally where they can give consent.
- 45:44Right.
- 45:44And so something that very interesting that happened organically with my study was that it just so happened that half of the people I spoke to.
- 45:55filmed in the US and the other half, basically around half, filmed in the UK even though they were from the US.
- 46:04And so in the UK, they have different standards of mental health evaluations and just support throughout the process.
- 46:14So I forgot to mention this earlier, but this is really what drove me to want to research this as well, is when I started doing my research, I saw that 21 people had died by suicide within the span of 10 years in the US.
- 46:32And yet there really has been no progress in mental health support.
- 46:36Whereas in the UK, two people died by suicide and almost immediately they changed the policies to protect people's mental wellbeing.
- 46:48And so in the UK, there's still a lot of work to do there in the UK too, but it's, yeah, they, they have something.
- 46:55They have something.
- 46:56Yes, it is.
- 46:56It is better than the US.
- 46:58It still has some work to do for sure.
- 47:00But they have a regulatory, a regulatory body called Ofcom.
- 47:05It's kind of like the FCC here, but not exactly.
- 47:09Ofcom also cares about the people that are on the reality TV show, whereas the FCC, they're more interested in consumers.
- 47:18So they really, they don't have any protections for the people actually on the show and,
- 47:24for viewers who may not know, if you're a professional actor or actress or whatever, you do have some protections because you have a union.
- 47:34You have- SAG-AFTRA.
- 47:36SAG-AFTRA, exactly.
- 47:38They can protect you.
- 47:39Reality TV, they don't have a union.
- 47:42So not only do they not have the protections from the FCC, but then they also don't have a labor union protecting them either.
- 47:50Whereas in the UK, they at least have some rules within Ofcom.
- 47:54Exactly.
- 47:54And I'd like to add yet.
- 47:57We don't have a union yet.
- 47:58Right.
- 47:58Yes.
- 47:58We're going to change that.
- 48:00Yeah.
- 48:02Great.
- 48:03So another trend that you found was that.
- 48:09What was it?
- 48:09People had, oh my gosh, why am I blanking out?
- 48:13Hold on, let me check.
- 48:14That's okay.
- 48:15I can say I have it up too.
- 48:17It was about authenticity.
- 48:19Yes.
- 48:20I just want to get the language right.
- 48:22There you go.
- 48:22Yeah.
- 48:23Compromised authenticity and identity.
- 48:27So that's just leaning more into the specifics of the editing process and what that might look like.
- 48:33There's even some research that names it and they call it Franken biting.
- 48:38where they create a whole storyline.
- 48:41And to compare the US and the UK, the UK does have contractual obligations to not defame people, or to change the storyline in a reality TV show.
- 48:52They do have to still stick to the storyline,
- 48:55That doesn't mean that they don't try to direct storylines so that they do happen.
- 48:59And they do try to manufacture it in a way, but they do so more in the US after it's already been filmed.
- 49:08And so many- And in the US too, at least in my experience and what I've seen, there's actually story producers.
- 49:15So there's like a producer that's kind of working behind the scenes outside of the person who's directing the scenes.
- 49:20Right.
- 49:20And that person's keeping track of the story and making sure that they hit the story points they want to hit on.
- 49:26Right.
- 49:27And it's to the point where even producers in some ways.
- 49:32people that I spoke to said that they would literally text someone within the what's being recorded to say, say this or do this.
- 49:42Um, so the person looks like they might just be looking at their phone and really they're being told by someone to do something else for the camera.
- 49:50Um, or they're being, you know,
- 49:52directed in another way where maybe they did say something, but then the producer is saying, can you say that again?
- 49:58But can you say it this way?
- 49:59So it's almost like line readings as well.
- 50:02That happens too.
- 50:04That is true.
- 50:05And even stuff about like tense.
- 50:08So it's like, oh, say it like it's present tense.
- 50:10It's like this happened six weeks ago.
- 50:11I don't even remember it.
- 50:12And it's like, well, this happened.
- 50:14Say this.
- 50:14That's exactly right.
- 50:16Right, right.
- 50:17And so then the person winds up feeling like this is a misrepresentation of who I am.
- 50:22And the stories that are typically told, they might fit into a certain theme.
- 50:27Like you said earlier, maybe someone's story is that they're the villain or that they're the princess.
- 50:33Or it could be even racially biased, like that's the angry Black woman.
- 50:39So just leaning into these stereotypes
- 50:42and putting people into boxes and pigeonholing them into characters that really don't represent themselves.
- 50:48And that's going to disrupt that narrative identity, the story that they've told themselves.
- 50:55And that makes them struggle with their own self-perception and their authenticity.
- 50:59And then if people are scrutinizing them, they feel like they need to fight back and say, that's not me.
- 51:04What are you talking about?
- 51:04So you constantly feel like you're defensive.
- 51:07What do you think are the long-term effects of that or people feeling like they don't really have control of their identity?
- 51:16I imagine, and I can't say for sure, that's actually one of the things I think should be researched after this is the long-term effects.
- 51:25But, you know, shame, I suspect, is a big theme.
- 51:29I think as human beings, shame can really take a front seat for a lot of people and can be the culprit of a lot of the things that we deal with.
- 51:40And so if people are constantly saying you're not good enough and you're a terrible person, whether you know that to be true or not, that's going to take a toll on you.
- 51:49I imagine that you're going to always have to feel like you're sticking up for yourself.
- 51:58and always have to fight for people to know who you are.
- 52:01And at some point it might even impact your own knowledge of yourself and your own understanding of yourself.
- 52:09You may not know your own identity after a while.
- 52:12There's actually, there's theories and it's not related to reality TV, but for example, there's a personality disorder called borderline personality disorder.
- 52:22And one of the,
- 52:24the main or central ideas of borderline personality disorder is that it's
- 52:31people having difficulty with a sense of self.
- 52:35And so that might impact them being able to stand strong in their convictions and knowing what they want, you know, and I'm not just talking about people with borderline personality disorder, but in general, if you don't have a confident understanding of yourself, you might become a people pleaser.
- 52:51You might become codependent where you're trying to find meaning of who you are through other people and the stories that they tell you of who you are.
- 52:59Yeah.
- 53:00I also think, and I don't know if, I don't think that this came up in the paper in your research, but maybe it did in a different way or with one person, it wasn't a trend, but did you, I've noticed some people can or have sort of become the character that they were on the TV and almost embraced it to the point where like,
- 53:29they don't really have the sense of former self.
- 53:34They only have become like the character that they were on the show or that almost like the show made them become.
- 53:42Like, did you see any of that in your interviews and research?
- 53:44Okay.
- 53:45Yes, absolutely.
- 53:46Just embracing like, okay, fine.
- 53:48If that's who you think I am, then that's who I'm gonna be.
- 53:51Or like, you know, that phrase, I'm in my villain era.
- 53:56You know, if you think I'm a villain, then I'll be a villain.
- 53:58I'm I give up at this point because if you're never going to believe me for who I am, then I'm just going to play into it.
- 54:05And, you know, some of the people that I spoke to that had that perspective was like the one that I mentioned before, where it's like, OK, well, I find I was playing a character.
- 54:16You know, this is the character I portrayed and that's not really me.
- 54:19I'll keep on playing that character just for you if it makes you happy.
- 54:22Well, and it also can become...
- 54:27and I'm speculating, there's certain people I'm thinking about that I'm speculating on across several different shows and even networks.
- 54:33But like, it almost becomes a point, and actually I've talked to Danielle Gates from 90 Day Fiance about this, where it's almost like if you become the character, you can get on more shows, you can make more money, and then it becomes the point where it's like, it becomes your way of life.
- 54:55And the only way you can make money is to go on more shows and become more of a caricature of this character.
- 55:01Right.
- 55:01Or you see you see people who maybe have been portrayed as like the party person or the one who's always drinking.
- 55:09And then before you know it, like you always got to be a little tipsy.
- 55:12And then all of a sudden you maybe develop a drinking problem.
- 55:15And, you know, this isn't anyone specific.
- 55:16I'm thinking about.
- 55:17Yeah.
- 55:17That's an example.
- 55:18And it can be very dangerous to like become the character to the point where it becomes the, it becomes your way of life and the way you make money and your career.
- 55:31And then it just consumes you.
- 55:33Right.
- 55:33And I think that speaks to narrative identity theory too, because although you've embraced this character and now you are finding success based on this other version of you, if that's incongruent to the actual person that, that you are, I imagine that that would also cause, um, some negative outcomes because that's, that's a lot to upkeep, you know, for people to constantly think that this is who you are and really you're this entirely different person.
- 56:02But I think that that would also be great as part of sort of the longer term.
- 56:06We definitely need long term studies.
- 56:08Yeah, definitely.
- 56:10Another thing that I've noticed, and then we'll get to the third and the third theme.
- 56:14Another thing I've noticed, too, is I feel like some people get stuck in in this like and maybe this is kind of the same thing as what I was just saying to become here.
- 56:22But they get like stuck at this moment in time when.
- 56:27When it was, everyone knew who they were.
- 56:30Everyone was following their story and they know they can get the dopamine hit from the clicks, from the likes, from all of that.
- 56:36If they just keep talking about it, keep reliving it over and over again.
- 56:40And I feel like that's also dangerous and I've seen that happen to people that I know and that I care about.
- 56:46And I think it happens in real life too, right?
- 56:47Like I have a friend who's stuck on a relationship that ended three years ago.
- 56:52Like it ended two months ago.
- 56:54And it's like, I think people can get stuck in these things for different reasons.
- 56:58And I would love to see like long-term studies to show...
- 57:03these long-term effects on people and how do people heal and how do people overcome and move on and what comes with that.
- 57:11One thing, I've shared this on the show before, but like I learned last winter that I actually have new public social anxiety that I've never really had.
- 57:21I went to a bar with a girl that I had just started dating and this was the first time that we had really been out in public
- 57:30together.
- 57:30And it was a very popular bar in the West, uh, West loop of Chicago, which is a very trendy place to be.
- 57:37I say it's the demo.
- 57:38It's like the 20 to 30 year, 20 and 30 year olds that are out and about at this bar.
- 57:42And I was in this bar and it was packed and there was like so many people that were like pointing and this and that.
- 57:48And then, you know, um, she's my, my girlfriend now, but like she, she went to like, kiss me in public, like on the cheek and I freaked out and I was like, I can't,
- 57:59And I never had that before.
- 58:01Right.
- 58:02And I usually don't go out there in that place because it's the demo and I don't want that kind of attention.
- 58:08But, like, doing it, I realized, oh, my God, like, I don't like being here.
- 58:11I was sweating.
- 58:12It was the middle of winter.
- 58:13I'm sweating.
- 58:14I'm anxious.
- 58:14I'm, like, taking bathroom breaks just to, like –
- 58:18regulate myself and it's it's all new stuff from stuff that happened years ago Right just now kind of realizing is they're being put in new or or different situations So I I think there's a lot of stuff and that's you know basic and it's not not too big of a deal Like I can manage it, but you know There's things like that that I think you you have to develop what are the long-term mental health concerns that come out of this?
- 58:41Yeah
- 58:43I think that makes a lot of sense too, right?
- 58:46When you've been on TV and you know that people might know who you are when you go out in public.
- 58:51Oh no, they're perceiving me.
- 58:53What do they think of me?
- 58:55What if they have a camera and they're going to video this happening and then post it online?
- 59:00People are going to make fun of me.
- 59:02Right.
- 59:02So and so I think that's very valid.
- 59:05I think that those would probably come to my mind, too, if I was on TV.
- 59:09And just to go back to what you first said, just about that, you know, it's like you keep on measuring yourself or you keep on going back to this moment in time.
- 59:18I think
- 59:20That could happen with any of us in terms of a moment in time where we may have felt the most success or the most happy.
- 59:29And we keep on comparing and going back to that.
- 59:31I identify with that myself.
- 59:33And...
- 59:35you know, to put myself in those shoes and say, there are times where I feel shame because, you know, when I was 18, I was on a Broadway national tour.
- 59:45And sometimes my mom will say, oh, this is my daughter, Chrissy.
- 59:49She was on a Broadway national tour.
- 59:50And I'm like, yeah, that was when I was 18.
- 59:52I'm not that good at, you know, I haven't been on one since then.
- 59:56And now I'm not good enough.
- 59:57That was really cool that I did that back then.
- 59:59And now, now I don't do that anymore.
- 1:00:01And so I feel,
- 1:00:03you know, that's part of the identity too.
- 1:00:06I personally, you know, my identity was doing theater and now I'm not doing that anymore.
- 1:00:11So I have to change my understanding of my identity.
- 1:00:14Now I'm a social worker.
- 1:00:15Now I'm a professor and a researcher, right?
- 1:00:18And so
- 1:00:19You change the story of yourself and realize these two things are true about me and they're both wonderful.
- 1:00:25Right.
- 1:00:25This is now just a different time.
- 1:00:27And maybe you're at a time in your life where you don't feel like you're, you know, to to that high part that you would consider yourself at that point.
- 1:00:38But that doesn't mean you're at a you're.
- 1:00:40you know, not successful.
- 1:00:41It doesn't mean that you won't be successful in a different way in the future.
- 1:00:45So it's those comparisons that we have.
- 1:00:47And the comparisons aren't just with other people.
- 1:00:49The comparisons are what we have with ourselves in another given moment in time too.
- 1:00:55So true.
- 1:00:56So true.
- 1:00:57Yeah.
- 1:00:58I know we're coming up on like our scheduled time.
- 1:01:00Do you have an extra few minutes to go through a couple more?
- 1:01:02Okay, okay, okay, cool.
- 1:01:03So the third,
- 1:01:06trend that you found was about challenging mental health and coping skills or just maybe just coping, right?
- 1:01:14Yeah, and coping.
- 1:01:15Yep, exactly.
- 1:01:15Yeah.
- 1:01:16So can you talk to us about that trend and what you learned from your interviews?
- 1:01:20Yeah, so that's pretty much when the production stops.
- 1:01:24And that's where the comparison also happens between the U.S. productions and the U.K. productions, where the mental health support in particular for the U.K. productions continued on.
- 1:01:36But a lot of the support was focused around like
- 1:01:40maybe not really mental health support, but more so public relations training and make sure you don't say this, make sure you don't violate your NDA.
- 1:01:49I got that too, by the way, it was totally useless.
- 1:01:54It's like if someone's mean to you, block them.
- 1:01:56Right, right.
- 1:01:57Or don't block them.
- 1:01:58I've also heard that too, which is very interesting.
- 1:02:00Like, if you know, just just don't say anything at all.
- 1:02:04I don't know about that.
- 1:02:05But yeah, so some of those things maybe were labeled as support, but really, it's not supportive of the person, but more supportive of the production company, it seems like from afar.
- 1:02:17Yeah.
- 1:02:20But this is also where what we mentioned earlier, the meaning making, and the disenfranchised grief comes in, the feelings of isolation.
- 1:02:31One of the things about humans is that we need to feel validated and we need to have things normalized.
- 1:02:36That's part of the reason why group therapy works so well is because you come to a group of people who have had similar experiences and you realize, oh, okay, I'm not alone.
- 1:02:46I'm not this one person on an island all by myself.
- 1:02:50There is someone else who has gone through this and look at them, they've survived or look at them, they understand me.
- 1:02:55So that's something that we need as people.
- 1:02:58And so when you have such a specific experience, like being on reality TV, you have less people to work from to be able to validate that and normalize that.
- 1:03:08And then if you're isolating people from maybe even being able to talk to each other, or it's just hard because they're spread across the continent, then that can also make people feel isolated.
- 1:03:19But the meaning making, I think, is one of the best things for someone's mental health.
- 1:03:25And it comes in the shape of, you know, like yourself, creating an organization that helps other people or just looking at things from a different lens and saying, you know, I watched myself go through this really terrible thing on television.
- 1:03:38And if anything, it held one of the quotes says,
- 1:03:40it held a mirror up to my face and made me realize that if I can survive that, I can survive anything.
- 1:03:47And so it's just really finding that inner strength and seeing, okay, I am- Did I say that?
- 1:03:51No, you didn't say that.
- 1:03:52Oh, okay.
- 1:03:53I was like, I say- Wow, that's beautiful.
- 1:03:56No, no, I was like, that's really the best.
- 1:03:58Cause I say that a lot.
- 1:03:59I'm like, what this taught me when people are like, well, what did you learn out of it?
- 1:04:02I'm like, it taught me that I can handle anything.
- 1:04:05I'm very, I'm way more resilient than I ever thought I was.
- 1:04:08And now I feel like nothing can ever take me down.
- 1:04:11Right.
- 1:04:12Cause it doesn't get any bigger than being on the biggest reality TV show in the world.
- 1:04:17And then being drug through the mud where you lose your job, you get a divorce and you have trouble.
- 1:04:23Like I was,
- 1:04:25literally three days away from not being able to pay my mortgage when I got a paycheck from, from a new job, like it didn't get much worse.
- 1:04:33So to me, it was like, wow, I can overcome anything.
- 1:04:38Like bring it on.
- 1:04:39Yeah.
- 1:04:40Yeah.
- 1:04:40So I'm sorry.
- 1:04:41Yeah.
- 1:04:42So I didn't mean to plagiarize that.
- 1:04:44No, but did it normalize for you that, hey, wow, I had this thought to somebody else felt that way.
- 1:04:48How like how cool is that?
- 1:04:49That someone like yourself can read this paper and say, oh, someone else also thought that and felt this way.
- 1:04:56And it's just it's a good way to normalize the experience and the after effects.
- 1:05:01Yeah, I will be very candid.
- 1:05:02The first time I read it, which I know you sent it to me before it was published, I was on a plane and I actually like teared up because I was like, so some of the, that might've been one of them.
- 1:05:13This was a while ago now, but like, it was so like relatable.
- 1:05:19Right.
- 1:05:21And that was so like refreshing.
- 1:05:24Yeah.
- 1:05:26And that just, I'm so glad that you were able to have that experience.
- 1:05:32And it's also, you know, some people might read this and they've been on reality TV and they might say that was nothing like my experience at all.
- 1:05:38And that's okay too.
- 1:05:40You know, it doesn't mean that their experience wasn't valid.
- 1:05:44And it's just that these happen to be the people that I spoke to and, and I'm glad that I got to share their stories in a way.
- 1:05:52Yeah.
- 1:05:53Yeah.
- 1:05:54Well, I appreciate you doing this work and getting this conversation started.
- 1:06:03What I wanna ask you, and this will be the last question.
- 1:06:05I actually think,
- 1:06:08you probably could do a whole episode answering this question, but, um, you know, after your research and, you know, you've been very open, you're a consumer of reality TV, you enjoy it, uh, which is totally fine.
- 1:06:20I want everyone, I always remind people I'm not, I want everyone to enjoy reality TV, but we can enjoy it and produce it ethically and still have fun with it, um, without ruining people's lives.
- 1:06:31But what do you think are, um, some of the most, um,
- 1:06:37urgent things that you would like to see changed and, um, kind of expanding off of that.
- 1:06:45Um, how do I want to word this?
- 1:06:49Let's start with that.
- 1:06:50What I'm gonna ask you two more questions.
- 1:06:52What do you think are some of the most urgent things that we need to change when it comes to reality TV and mental health?
- 1:06:58So I think first of all, within the contract itself, there, there should be no room for defaming someone.
- 1:07:07I think that people are interesting enough where we can tell their stories and not rework it.
- 1:07:13And it might mean that it takes a little longer to edit or it takes a little longer to have, you know, to film these people to get the things that you need.
- 1:07:25But I don't think that people should be allowed to mischaracterize other human beings.
- 1:07:34I think that there should be regulatory oversight to ensure that that happens, because who's to say that people are going to follow a contract if they're not made to, unfortunately.
- 1:07:49I agree with what you said earlier.
- 1:07:51I think that in terms of mental health support, first of all, there needs to be more mental health support.
- 1:07:57Right now, psychological screenings tend to be a little surface level.
- 1:08:01And, um, and that's not helpful.
- 1:08:05Yeah.
- 1:08:06And used nefariously.
- 1:08:07And used against you.
- 1:08:08Yeah.
- 1:08:09Yeah.
- 1:08:09So exactly.
- 1:08:12We had a bunch of cast members try to get their psych evaluations and they said, no, that we contracted the way our way our rights to get them away.
- 1:08:20Right.
- 1:08:21So how is that legal?
- 1:08:23As a social worker, like when I hear about a psychological evaluation, my immediate assumption is that it would be confidential.
- 1:08:30And I think that it should be confidential.
- 1:08:33To me, the purposes of a psychological evaluation is to see, to assess whether someone is competent enough
- 1:08:40and will be mentally healthy enough to participate in a reality show.
- 1:08:45I don't think that the actual discussion or the things explored during the evaluation need to be shared.
- 1:08:55I think those specific details can be kept confidential and it's just a yes this person's good to go or no this person is not going to be safe to be on this show.
- 1:09:04And that doesn't mean that just from the perspective of like, do no harm to self or others, it doesn't mean that they're immediately going to try to die by suicide or hurt someone else.
- 1:09:16It could just mean that this person has experienced a lot of trauma,
- 1:09:19And if they go on television and their trauma is used for their story, that's going to negatively impact them to the point where maybe they could, you know, hurt themselves at some point.
- 1:09:31So just kind of really going more in depth there and not,
- 1:09:36not letting production be privy to that information that's assessed within that evaluation.
- 1:09:42And I think that that third party provider should be the same third party provider throughout.
- 1:09:51Maybe they are on set and the person can request to speak to that person when needed.
- 1:09:57When the show is over, the person is able to talk to that person without fear that the contents of their conversation is going to go back to production.
- 1:10:04And that also helps with any NDAs as well.
- 1:10:07Maybe that psychological...
- 1:10:09you know, that clinician or the therapist can be somehow written into the NDA.
- 1:10:15I mean, it shouldn't matter because when you talk to a clinician, it's confidential.
- 1:10:19It's supposed to be, unless there's like fear of self-harm or something or harm to others, right?
- 1:10:24Yeah, but if it makes people feel like they can then be more open, then I think that's important.
- 1:10:28We all deserve to have somebody to talk to and to talk to openly.
- 1:10:34Because when you don't, that just leans into that conversation we had earlier about the feeling of isolation, not being able to share your story, that disenfranchised grief.
- 1:10:43Yeah, I agree.
- 1:10:46For real, my last question, one takeaway you'd like for reality TV viewers, maybe even industry professionals, cast members, mental health professionals, like what's one takeaway you would want people to get from your research?
- 1:11:03I think that this one should be obvious, but that you are dealing with real human beings, just like you are on the opposite end of the screen.
- 1:11:13We are all just people and the way that we treat other human beings, for you it might last for a second or for a season, but for that person it can last their entire lifetime.
- 1:11:26And so, as human beings we're fragile,
- 1:11:33We need to treat others with dignity and respect and worth, no matter where you are in the equation.
- 1:11:42If you are a producer, I understand that that is your livelihood, this is your job.
- 1:11:47If you're an editor, same thing.
- 1:11:49You know, I feel like there's a certain cognitive dissonance that has to happen that allows you to almost dehumanize others.
- 1:11:57And I think the reminder is we are all humans.
- 1:12:02You know?
- 1:12:05Yeah, I think that's really important to remember.
- 1:12:07Well, thank you for that.
- 1:12:09And thank you again for starting this research.
- 1:12:13Before we go, I always like to ask my guests if they wanna ask me anything.
- 1:12:17And I think I forgot to remind you or tell you that at the beginning of the show.
- 1:12:21So I'll give you a chance if you have anything that you wanna ask me about anything, literally ask me anything.
- 1:12:29The floor is yours for a minute here.
- 1:12:32So I guess my question is, because you were just talking about, you know, if you consume reality TV, that's okay.
- 1:12:41From your perspective, what is the best way for an audience member to assess whether the entertainment they're consuming is ethical?
- 1:12:51What are your suggestions in terms of still being a consumer of reality TV?
- 1:12:56How to be able to do that while still respecting the people on the screen?
- 1:13:00That's a great question.
- 1:13:01I think it's, it's very clear to me that reality TV is here to stay.
- 1:13:08Um, I believe that ethical reality TV is possible.
- 1:13:11And my ask of people that enjoy the content is, is maybe
- 1:13:16a couple of folds, but one, like watch it, understanding that you're watching real people and that you're watching curated content that has been edited for entertainment purposes.
- 1:13:27And so what you're seeing is not real or at the very best lacks context.
- 1:13:33So watch it for entertainment and then go about your life and don't,
- 1:13:39Um, don't give space to hate or be vengeful or, or anything.
- 1:13:44Like if you don't have anything nice, don't say anything at all.
- 1:13:47Um, and then I think, uh, advocacy work in joining this movement, this, um, reality TV reckoning, or however we want to.
- 1:13:56to brand it, um, support the people that are coming out and speaking up because there's more and more people doing it.
- 1:14:03Don't villainize them, uh, for talking about what their working conditions were like, or how their mental health has been impacted or whatever that might be.
- 1:14:14Like, let's work together and let's advocate for the rights of cast members, uh, past, current and future.
- 1:14:20Um.
- 1:14:21And then let's do what we can to share our perspective.
- 1:14:27If you do know what's going on, share it with someone who maybe doesn't and share it with empathy and grace, because I genuinely believe that the majority of people just don't that don't know.
- 1:14:39or something they just don't know, and you don't know what you don't know.
- 1:14:42So if you have someone in your life that maybe takes it a little too seriously or doesn't understand or know or understand some of the behind-the-scenes work, educate them.
- 1:14:54Send them to UCAN Foundation, the various podcasts, mine included here, and just watch these things and show people some grace.
- 1:15:05And then lastly...
- 1:15:07When there's an opportunity for you to say something mean through DM or online or write something mean or even in person say something, I always, again, dad of the Internet, tell people, stop for a second and ask myself, is this really about them or is this something going on with me?
- 1:15:26And you're going to find that it's always something going on with you.
- 1:15:30So if you can do that introspective work, I think you'll find a lot more peace.
- 1:15:35And then you'll maybe not say something that would impact and hurt somebody else.
- 1:15:40But fight with us.
- 1:15:41Join with us.
- 1:15:42Educate people.
- 1:15:43Spread the word.
- 1:15:44My favorite, favorite person that I met recently in the last couple months.
- 1:15:49Actually, it's longer now.
- 1:15:50I was walking home from the farmer's market last fall.
- 1:15:54And this woman stopped me and she said, I'm really grateful for the work you're doing with UCAN.
- 1:15:59You know, you are changing the way that I view reality TV.
- 1:16:04Like me and my girlfriend used to watch these shows and we would sit around and gossip about it.
- 1:16:09Now we watch these shows and we talk about what we think is really going on.
- 1:16:13And that's all because of the work that we've done with UCAN Foundation.
- 1:16:16So like maybe instead of gossiping about an unreal or not real fiction-esque unscripted show, maybe talk about what
- 1:16:27you could be seeing that's going on there.
- 1:16:29Maybe talk about the way that you would feel if you were edited this way, or you said this drunk thing, as you pointed out earlier on TV, and talk about how that would make you feel.
- 1:16:40And maybe then you can sort of spread the word and normalize conversations that humanize these people instead of villainize them.
- 1:16:48I love that.
- 1:16:49That's wonderful.
- 1:16:50I absolutely love that, what you just said.
- 1:16:53Use it as almost a training, an exercise, if you will.
- 1:17:00You can even make it fun.
- 1:17:01Try to figure out, oh, did you see that cut there?
- 1:17:04Yeah, exactly.
- 1:17:05Make it fun, but also make it an empathy exercise.
- 1:17:08I think that's a great idea.
- 1:17:11Just don't make it a drinking game because then you're going to be one of the drunk people saying something silly because there's going to be a lot of edits.
- 1:17:20Well, I want to thank you again for coming on my show to talk about your writing.
- 1:17:24I know that it's new and it's fresh and you're very, very busy and you're getting your doctorate degree and everything.
- 1:17:32So taking time today is greatly appreciated.
- 1:17:36And I appreciate the work you're doing.
- 1:17:38I have all of the links below, but where can people find your research and where can people find you if they want to connect with you on LinkedIn or Instagram?
- 1:17:46Yeah, thank you so much.
- 1:17:48So on Instagram, my username is Chrissy4Missy.
- 1:17:52Feel free to say hello.
- 1:17:53And then on LinkedIn, it's just my first and last name, Christine Chappé.
- 1:17:57I think it might show up as Christine C. As like a third party invitation.
- 1:18:03But feel free to say hello.
- 1:18:06And you can find my article.
- 1:18:09It's published through Psychology of Popular Media, which is an APA publication.
- 1:18:16Great.
- 1:18:16And again, those links are below.
- 1:18:18So thank you so much.
- 1:18:20And I appreciate you spending time with me.
- 1:18:22Thank you so much, Nick.
- 1:18:23It's been a pleasure.
- 1:18:28Thank you for joining us on this week's episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 1:18:31If you enjoy the show, the best way to support us is by sharing or dropping a review.
- 1:18:35For more information and content, check out engagewithnick.com or find me on Instagram at nthompson513.
- 1:18:42Don't go through life blind.
- 1:18:44Do the work so you can show up in the world with your eyes wide open.