Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Partition of Real Property Act
Transcript
- 0:03My name is Howard Gould. I'm co -chair of the
- 0:06real estate section for the Beverly Hills Bar.
- 0:08And it's my pleasure to welcome everyone to our
- 0:11presentation on the new Partition Act today.
- 0:15Before we begin the program, I want to let everybody
- 0:19know about our upcoming programs. January 15th
- 0:23tomorrow. We are going to do a program with the
- 0:26former president of the state bar as our speaker,
- 0:29Heather Rosing. Heather's topic is cutting edge
- 0:32ethics and risk management for real estate lawyers,
- 0:35not necessarily your typical ethics program.
- 0:38She's going to talk about ethical management
- 0:41of artificial intelligence tools, lateral hiring
- 0:45risks and rewards, developments in conflict of
- 0:48interest standards, and recent developments in
- 0:51trust accounting, and also new legislation on
- 0:54lawyer advertising among other subjects. February
- 0:5726, we're going to do our annual real property
- 1:00tax program. Chris O 'Neill from Greenberg Torrig
- 1:03and one of his partners will be presenting that
- 1:05program. April, excuse me, March 19th is our
- 1:09annual California Association of Realtors. Form
- 1:12update. Jana Gardner is joining us yet again
- 1:16to go over their new forms and updated forms
- 1:19and tell you what's new at the California Association
- 1:22of Realtors. Always a very good program to hear
- 1:26the latest from CAR. April 16th, Howard Fisher
- 1:30is going to do a program on 1031 exchanges. April
- 1:3523rd, Larry Jacobson is going to do his annual
- 1:38review of the prior year's real estate cases.
- 1:41And May 21, we're doing a new topic. Steve Raucher
- 1:46is going to talk about landlord insurance coverage
- 1:49for habitability claims in landlord tenant cases,
- 1:53which has become, I think, a significant issue
- 1:55for landlords, given the number of habitability
- 1:58claims that are raised in those matters. So that'll
- 2:03take us all the way through May. Two comments
- 2:06before we begin. The program material link is
- 2:09in the chat, so you can find the link in the
- 2:12chat. And secondly, we use the Q &A for questions,
- 2:16not the chat. So put your questions in the Q
- 2:19&A, please. And the speaker is going to monitor
- 2:23those for you as we go along. My pleasure to
- 2:27welcome Elijah Underwood as our speaker today.
- 2:32Elijah operates a law firm with a heavy specialty
- 2:35in partition law. It's today's subject. In addition
- 2:39to partnership disputes and more general real
- 2:41estate law, they have extensive experience handling
- 2:44partition trials and complex partition actions,
- 2:48including multiple property, multi -family, industrial,
- 2:51commercial, and multi -million dollar property
- 2:54partition actions. His firm is handled in the
- 2:57neighborhood of 425 partition actions throughout
- 3:00the state of California. He lectures on partition
- 3:03actions for the California Association of Realtors
- 3:06and is a member of the executive committee for
- 3:09real property for the California Lawyers Association.
- 3:13He's a graduate of UC Hastings Law School and
- 3:16UC Santa Barbara and we thank you for coming
- 3:19and the floor is yours. Great. Thank you so much
- 3:22for that warm introduction, Howard. So good afternoon,
- 3:27everybody. I'll start with my PowerPoint. We'll
- 3:30get it. going here. So as Howard mentioned, I
- 3:35have a law firm. And all basically all that we
- 3:40do is partitions, you know, obviously, if there's
- 3:42related matters. So sometimes somebody will claim
- 3:45there's a life estate or, you know, there'll
- 3:48be an issue with divisibility of property or
- 3:51certain things like that. We'll handle them as
- 3:53part of the partition. But basically, the firm's
- 3:56sole focus is partitions. I think our Our running
- 4:00total is close to 500 partition matters handled
- 4:04to date. And so I'm very excited to present to
- 4:09the Beverly Hills Bar Association on the most
- 4:12recent Partitioner Real Property Act. As mentioned,
- 4:17I've been an attorney since 2009. The firm is
- 4:20actually up to about closer to 20 members. And
- 4:25we have offices throughout California. I'm in
- 4:28LA, but we also have people in Sacramento and
- 4:31San Francisco and San Diego and Orange County.
- 4:33And we have offices there. And we're handling
- 4:36partitions throughout the state. So today I'm
- 4:39going to go through Ten key provisions of the
- 4:42partition law some background on the act partitions
- 4:45and probate statutory provisions title issues
- 4:48some of the procedural stuff Basically give you
- 4:53guys a very nice overview of the act before we
- 4:58began I was Mentioning to Howard that I've given
- 5:02this presentation in a half an hour format. I've
- 5:05given it in a two hour format So today I'm going
- 5:08to give it in an hour format and happy to answer
- 5:11as many questions as possible. I'll try to break
- 5:15right at about the 50 minute mark to answer some
- 5:17of those questions. But all this to say there's
- 5:20a lot more information that's out there that
- 5:23we could cover. But I'm going to try to keep
- 5:25it pretty tight this afternoon. So as a little
- 5:29bit of background, the act is a uniform act.
- 5:36There's a conference that deals with uniform
- 5:39acts to try to implement uniformity across the
- 5:43states. And the background in the act was there
- 5:45were some issues, particularly in the American
- 5:48South, places like Mississippi, Kentucky, South
- 5:54Carolina, places like that. And there was these
- 5:57studies done by this gentleman named Thomas Mitchell,
- 6:01who's a law professor. He was the University
- 6:03of Texas. Now he's at Boston University. And
- 6:07in his law review articles, beginning in about
- 6:112003, he surmised that there could have been,
- 6:15it's possible that there was this loss of property,
- 6:20particularly in African -American communities
- 6:22in the American South. due to a lack of access
- 6:27to legal services was his hypothesis. He wrote
- 6:30this article, a series of articles. These articles
- 6:33are what led to the promulgation of this Partition
- 6:38of Real Property Act, this Uniform Act that California
- 6:41adopted in 2022. Later, however, Mitchell kind
- 6:47of recognized and actually he got a study from
- 6:50the Carnegie Foundation to do a study in North
- 6:52Carolina to see if his hypothesis could play
- 6:55out, if there was any records for it. And ultimately
- 6:58what he concluded was that there was really no
- 7:02evidence for this hypothesis. either about a
- 7:09relative lack of access to legal services or
- 7:12a loss of land due to partitions. And so basically
- 7:15he had this mistaken hypothesis, but nevertheless
- 7:19we got this act out of it. And so that will kind
- 7:25of play out as we go along. It is kind of an
- 7:27important historical point that Mitchell himself
- 7:31kind of recognized that he couldn't couldn't
- 7:33evidence his his theory. And so how this plays
- 7:37out is we have this claim about this concern
- 7:42from, again, places like Mississippi and, you
- 7:46know, maybe Kentucky or Tennessee. And the act
- 7:50gets imported into California. And what we have
- 7:52in California is the 19 basically, for those
- 7:56of us who are veterans of the field, we have
- 7:59the Act that was last reformulated in 1976. The
- 8:051976 revisions to the Partition of Real Property
- 8:07Act, which has basically, it's 106 different
- 8:11unique and separate statutes that make up what
- 8:13we know as the partition law. And then in 2022,
- 8:17there's this drive to add uniformity. And so
- 8:21then the Partition of Real Property Act is added.
- 8:24basically right on top of the pre -existing law
- 8:29from 1976. And that's relevant for those of you
- 8:34who have practiced in other states or even just,
- 8:38here's a rare thing, gone down to a law library.
- 8:42And if you go to a law library and you take a
- 8:44look at the statutes of California, You'll see
- 8:48the Civil Code and the Code of Civil Procedure
- 8:50and the Welfare and Institutions Code and the
- 8:53Health and Safety Code and the Probate Code and
- 8:56the Water Code and on and on and on. Whereas
- 8:58if you were to peruse, let's say the statutes
- 9:02of Oregon or Nevada, you basically just find
- 9:06like the Oregon uniform laws and it might be,
- 9:10I don't know. you know twenty volumes or thirty
- 9:13volumes something like that whereas california
- 9:16you know it's it's almost like you know several
- 9:18walls of books and this is relevant because you
- 9:23know in places like georgia maybe they're more
- 9:26like you know for example nevada where they have
- 9:29you know a set of laws but they're just not as
- 9:31extensive as the set of laws we have here in
- 9:34california which probably says Something but
- 9:38what it you know for our purposes i think what's
- 9:41relevant is that this partition real property
- 9:44act maybe is the only law that you know tennessee
- 9:48has on partitions or south carolina has on partitions.
- 9:52Any kind of stands on its own cuz there wasn't
- 9:55maybe a set of laws addressing it but now in
- 9:58california. It kind of exists among all these
- 10:01other laws, and it doesn't necessarily relate
- 10:06to them and interweave itself as well as it may
- 10:10in a place like North Carolina. That's kind of
- 10:18an important frame of reference here. And so
- 10:21for those of you who are just kind of attending,
- 10:24trying to get those CLE hours before the February
- 10:27compliance deadline, the March compliance deadline,
- 10:31partition is, it's just the procedure for segregating
- 10:33and terminating common interests in the same
- 10:35partial property. It's a remedy that's much favored
- 10:39in the law. And I think, but. how most of us
- 10:44see this play out is, you know, you're in your
- 10:48office and you have a client walk in and he says,
- 10:52you know, I've got a brother, but my brother's,
- 10:55you know, we're twins, but he's very different
- 10:57than me. You know, I have one way of looking
- 10:59at the world, he has another way, but they've
- 11:02inherited mom and dad's house. And so when they
- 11:05inherited mom and dad's house, they have, because
- 11:07they're Maybe they're twins, but they're very
- 11:09different people. They have very different ideas
- 11:11about what to do with that real estate. One of
- 11:13them wants to keep it. One of them wants to sell
- 11:15it. One thing's for sure is it's a bad idea for
- 11:18both of them to live there together. And so a
- 11:22fight breaks out and they start disagreeing.
- 11:26Usually these fights go on for a number of years.
- 11:28And then one of the brothers or family members
- 11:32ends up in your office. And so what we have here
- 11:35is this tool, the Partition of Real Property
- 11:38Act, as a tool to deal with this dispute about
- 11:42this piece of real estate, and it's an act in
- 11:45three parts. There's an appraisal provision,
- 11:48there's a bio provision, and there's a sale provision.
- 11:51And so, you know, as what we're going to do today
- 11:54is we're going to go through the main provisions
- 11:57of the Partition of Real Property Act and look
- 12:00at some of the terms and see if we can't make
- 12:04sure that we have a really good understanding
- 12:07of each of the terms. So the act begins by saying
- 12:10that it applies to real property held in tenancy
- 12:13in common. where there is no agreement in the
- 12:15record binding all the co -tenants, which governs
- 12:18the partition of the property. And it applies
- 12:21to actions for partition filed on or after January
- 12:251st, 2023. So I think that to a lot of us, that
- 12:31probably seems pretty straightforward and pedantic.
- 12:34Probably not a lot to question there. Except
- 12:40what happens when there's multiple parties? and
- 12:43only some of the property is held in tenancy
- 12:45in common, but others are held in joint tenancy.
- 12:47So, for example, you can have a situation where,
- 12:52let's say instead of two brothers, you have,
- 12:57let's say it's two brothers and their wives,
- 13:02and the deed to the children says, okay, to son
- 13:06and wife as joint tenants, and then to, you know,
- 13:11son number two, and his wife as joint tenants,
- 13:15right? And so maybe between the parties, between
- 13:18the couples, they hold it in tenants in common.
- 13:21But between them, they're joint tenants, or maybe
- 13:25they're not, you know, husband and wife, maybe
- 13:27they're boyfriend and girlfriend. You can imagine,
- 13:30you know, a number of different permutations,
- 13:33and I've I've seen a few. But the question is,
- 13:36If the property is held in joint tenancy by some
- 13:39of them, does the Partition of Real Property
- 13:41Act apply? It says it applies to property held
- 13:45in tenancy in common, but we don't exactly have
- 13:48that. We have joint tenancy and tenancy in common.
- 13:51So because it's not an absolute, is the term
- 13:53satisfied? Is the provision satisfied such that
- 13:56the act would apply? It's not totally clear.
- 14:00What happens if you have three children, let's
- 14:03say a son and a son and a daughter? and they
- 14:06don't have spouses, but it's just given to them
- 14:09all as joint tenants. But then one of them decides
- 14:12for estate planning purposes that they're going
- 14:14to take their property and put it into their
- 14:16trust. And so they were all joint tenants, but
- 14:19now one of them has severed and they're a tenant
- 14:22in common versus the other two are still joint
- 14:24tenants. Does the Partition of Real Property
- 14:27Act apply? Does it apply if one of the joint
- 14:29tenants wants to partition vis -a -vis the other
- 14:33tenant in the common? If the tenant in common
- 14:35wants to bring it against the other joint tenants,
- 14:38does the partition of our property act apply?
- 14:40It's not really clear how that situation should
- 14:44be addressed. But let's move on. Okay, so it
- 14:48says it applies in cases in 2023. As we get into
- 14:522026, this is less of an issue. But in 2024,
- 14:56what happened if you had a suit for partition
- 15:00and then the complaint gets amended? It gets
- 15:03amended and it was filed in 2022 and it gets
- 15:06amended in 2024. Does that an action filed after
- 15:10January 1st, 2023? Does it pertain to the amendment?
- 15:14How do you address that? What happens if the
- 15:17suit started out as quiet title, basically one,
- 15:20you know, brother seeking, let's say an adverse
- 15:24possession claim against the other? and then
- 15:26later, they add a partition claim. Well, the
- 15:30suit was filed before 2023, but the partition
- 15:33claim is new. How do you deal with that? That's
- 15:37not totally clear. So again, it says it applies
- 15:41to property held in tenancy in common. What's
- 15:43a life estate? If somebody asserts that they
- 15:46had a life estate, let's even say they can evidence
- 15:48it. Are they a tenant and common owner, such
- 15:51that they have rights under the Partition Over
- 15:53Property Act? If the tenant, you know, or is
- 15:56the reverse true? If somebody says that, you
- 16:00know, that this partition is broad and somebody
- 16:02says, well, I have a life estate in addition
- 16:05to a tenancy in common claim, does that subject
- 16:08to the partition of real property act? Right?
- 16:11What if they claim to be a constructive trustee,
- 16:14something else entirely, right? So there, you
- 16:16know, there was no specific agreement about tenancy
- 16:19in common. Are they a joint tenant? How does
- 16:22the court determine that? right? And having litigated
- 16:27these questions, the answer is just yes. The
- 16:30answer is courts come down differently on them.
- 16:34But so even even moving on, how is this right
- 16:36raised? Is it something that a party needs to
- 16:40bring in? You know, the law of pleadings is that
- 16:44the pleadings define the outer materiality of
- 16:47relevance of the issues. So if somebody doesn't
- 16:51raise the Partition of a Property Act as an answer,
- 16:55is it material? Do they have the right to resort
- 16:58to the laws? Do you raise it by a cross -complaint?
- 17:03Does the complaint itself, is it an indispensable
- 17:06element of a complaint for partition filed after
- 17:082023 in a tenancy and common relationship? That's,
- 17:12you know, is that requirement? Does it say that?
- 17:16um is you know generally the law is if it's not
- 17:19pleaded it's waived nobody can resort to it um
- 17:22for example you could even waive a you know let's
- 17:25say that somebody brings something as vanilla
- 17:28as a breach of contract claim they say we had
- 17:30a contract it was breached in 2015 if the defense
- 17:33if the if the answer does not raise a defense
- 17:36of statute limitations the law is that it's waived
- 17:38even for something as obvious as that if it's
- 17:40not pleaded um and so do you have to raise it
- 17:45in order to maintain that right? Or is it the
- 17:50judge's obligation to raise it to a sponte? Is
- 17:54the judge supposed to stop everybody and tell
- 17:57the lawyers you're doing it wrong and there's
- 17:58this other law and I'm gonna apply that? It's
- 18:01not really a question. It just says it applies.
- 18:05So something that maybe started out very clear
- 18:08is maybe not as clear as we would like. But let's
- 18:11move on. Let's see if anyone thinks this section
- 18:16is any clearer. The next part about the applicability.
- 18:22It says, in an action to partition real property,
- 18:25the property shall be partitioned under this
- 18:26chapter unless all the co -tenants otherwise
- 18:29agree in record. And it says this chapter supplements
- 18:32the other provisions of this title. And if an
- 18:34action is governed by this chapter, the chapter
- 18:35shall control over any provisions of this title
- 18:38that are inconsistent. Well. Let's ask, does
- 18:42anybody think that number one is ambiguous? Can
- 18:47anyone find anything, I don't know, challenging
- 18:52or unclear about, let's just call it sentence
- 18:57number one here? Anybody? Seeing no objections?
- 19:04Everyone agrees it's clear. It's an action of
- 19:06partition real properties. Everyone knows what
- 19:08that is. Two brothers, one of them wants to partition,
- 19:12the other one doesn't. What's so hard about that?
- 19:14Where's the dispute? Well, let's go through it.
- 19:20If there's not a D, not a will or a trust, but
- 19:24just, you know, let's say mother dies in test
- 19:27state and there's a probate proceeding to determine
- 19:31the ownership interest in the property and she
- 19:33only has two sons. We'll make it simple. is a
- 19:37proceeding in the state administration under
- 19:39probate code section 11950, an action of partition.
- 19:43The probate code specifically uses the word partition.
- 19:47Is that a partition action? Let's make it a little
- 19:51bit different. It is a family law proceeding.
- 19:54Again, it's not two brothers, it's a husband
- 19:56and wife. Husband and wife get divorced, they
- 19:58own this house, and one of them wants partition.
- 20:01It's a family law proceeding dissolution under
- 20:03family code section 2650. The family code uses
- 20:07the word partition. Does the partition of real
- 20:10property act apply in family law? Okay, let's
- 20:14get something totally outside the realm of brother,
- 20:16sister, husband, wife. Let's say two business
- 20:19partners. They have this idea for this company
- 20:23and they're going to make widgets and they're
- 20:25going to make them in downtown LA and they buy
- 20:27a warehouse for this widget factory. But then
- 20:31they have a breakup. Is a dissolution of, and
- 20:35they hold their warehouse in an LLC, is a dissolution
- 20:38of a limited liability company under corporations
- 20:40code section 17707 .03, B1, an action of partition.
- 20:46The corporations code says that when an LLC is
- 20:48dissolved, the remedy for the assets is partitioned.
- 20:51That's what the law says. Is that a partition
- 20:54subject to the Partition of Real Property Act,
- 20:56even though it's not pleaded as a partition?
- 20:59The question is, what is an action to partition?
- 21:02Everyone thought it was so simple. Nobody here
- 21:05said, Eli, I don't know what you're talking about.
- 21:07We all thought it was so straightforward. Maybe
- 21:10not. How does this provision integrate with the
- 21:14remainder of the partition law that was left
- 21:16unchanged? Again, this is kind of why this background
- 21:19is helpful. Yeah, maybe, you know, in Kentucky,
- 21:22they don't they don't get into these issues and
- 21:24their family code and their corporations code
- 21:26and their probate code. California is a little
- 21:29different. We have much more extensive laws and
- 21:32not just statutory laws, but decision laws. Nevertheless,
- 21:35both the probate code, the family code specifically
- 21:38use the word partition. The corporations code,
- 21:40the case law uses the word partition. So when
- 21:45does this act apply? It's kind of a nice question.
- 21:49let's let's move on uh so again let's say let's
- 21:54say you're able to resolve these these very thorny
- 21:57issues of what is a partition and who gets a
- 22:00partition it's let's just say it's your you know
- 22:03your two brothers they inherit mom and dad's
- 22:05house and you know one wants to buy and or one
- 22:09wants to sell and the other doesn't and a partition
- 22:11lawsuit gets filed okay now we're cooking we're
- 22:15off to the races it's all very simple So let's
- 22:18look at it. There's an appraisal provision. Code
- 22:21of Civil Procedure Section 874 .316. It says,
- 22:25except as provided, court shall determine the
- 22:27fair market value of the property by ordering
- 22:28an appraisal. If all Connaught tenants have agreed
- 22:32to the value of the property or another method
- 22:35evaluation, the court shall adopt that value
- 22:38or the value produced by the agreed method evaluation.
- 22:41Seems pretty straightforward. If the court determines
- 22:44that the evidentiary value of an appraisal is
- 22:46outweighed by the cost of the appraisal, the
- 22:48court, after an evidentiary hearing, shall determine
- 22:51the fair market value of the property and send
- 22:52notice to the parties of that value. If an appraisal
- 22:55is filed, the court, pursuant to sub D, the court
- 22:57shall conduct a hearing to determine the fair
- 22:59market value of the property. Not sooner than
- 23:0130 days after copying the notice, the appraisal
- 23:03is sent to each party, whether or not objection
- 23:05to the appraisal is filed. In addition to the
- 23:08court or appraisal, the court may consider any
- 23:10other evidence of value offered by a party. Okay.
- 23:14Who thinks that's confusing? There's an appraisal.
- 23:17One wants to sell, the other one doesn't. He
- 23:19files for partition. It's an appraisal. How complicated
- 23:25could it be? I don't know. Let's see if I can
- 23:28do a good job of making a mess of it. Let's ask
- 23:30some questions. Anybody think this is unclear?
- 23:34See none. Let's go through it. What does it what
- 23:38does it mean to say the evidentiary value of
- 23:40an appraisal is outweighed by the cost and The
- 23:44court after an evidentiary hearing shall determine
- 23:46the market by the property and send notice the
- 23:48part of the value so Is the cost of the appraisal
- 23:52is that does that include attorneys time to appear
- 23:55at the hearing and the objection? What is the
- 23:59vat what is the evidentiary value of an appraisal
- 24:02under the evidence code and owner? can testify
- 24:06as to value well if an order can testify as to
- 24:08value then what is the evidentiary value of an
- 24:11appraisal how do you measure the cost the court
- 24:14time obviously is costly to the court how many
- 24:18hearings are there going to be on this how do
- 24:19you weigh that okay that that seems like it's
- 24:24it's messy but okay so there's an appraisal enough
- 24:27let's just go on who bears the cost of the appraisal
- 24:31statute doesn't say So if if if you just want
- 24:36to sell if one party wants to sell the other
- 24:38one doesn't they want the appraisal Do they have
- 24:41to pay for the full appraisal? If they what happens
- 24:44if they don't pay for the appraisal What happens
- 24:47if they don't want it? What happens if they say
- 24:50well, there's an appraisal, but I don't want
- 24:52it is the court still required to order it and
- 24:56If they if they ask for an appraisal, but they
- 24:58don't pay for it does that prevent the partition
- 25:01from going forward? Is the party who doesn't
- 25:03want it the plaintiff? Are they required to bear
- 25:07the cost of the appraisal? What happens if they
- 25:09don't pay? What happens if the appraisal doesn't
- 25:12occur? What do you do then? Man, this statute,
- 25:17I thought it was so simple. It's maybe a little
- 25:19bit harder than we thought. But let's let's move
- 25:22on. Let's let's move on to another part of the
- 25:26procedure. So it says if an appraisal is filed,
- 25:30we went over F above, right? So here's the very
- 25:33next section, right? So it says, after hearing
- 25:37on subdivision F, but before considering the
- 25:40merits of the partition action, the court shall
- 25:42determine the fair market value of the property
- 25:44and so notice the parties of the value. Does
- 25:46anyone think that's tricky? Does anyone think
- 25:49they don't understand what that means? I don't
- 25:55see anybody piping up, okay. What are the merits
- 25:59of a partition action? It states that the act
- 26:02applies when property is held in tenancy in common.
- 26:05What about if somebody disputes that the other
- 26:07person's an owner? What if they say, well, I'm
- 26:10on title with them, but they told me that I was
- 26:12the sole owner. How do you determine, you know,
- 26:17I'm a constructive trustee. And okay, so how
- 26:22do you... determine what to do with this appraisal
- 26:26if one asserts that the other is not an owner,
- 26:29if there's a buyout, but one asserts, well, the
- 26:33other person's a 0 % owner, I'm 100%, so therefore,
- 26:36the price that I pay them is nothing based on
- 26:38my assertion. Well, how does that make sense?
- 26:43And that's what the court orders, that you pay
- 26:45them nothing based on this assertion. How do
- 26:48you determine the value of an appraisal in a
- 26:51buyout amount if you don't know the ownership
- 26:53interests of the parties. Let's actually say
- 26:56it's the other way. Let's say it's a clear case
- 27:00of fraud. There's a constructive trustee. There's
- 27:03an email that one says that says, I agree that
- 27:06I won't be an owner and you're going to be the
- 27:08owner. You'll be the sole owner. I'm going to
- 27:09be on title as a favor to you to help with the
- 27:12financing. OK. Very clear case of fraud. Does
- 27:17the court get to consider that? It says before
- 27:20considering the merits. Basically, this says
- 27:23even in a clear case of fraud, there's an email.
- 27:26No one disputes it. Does the court have to say,
- 27:29well, I can't consider that. That's the merits
- 27:30of the constructive fraud claim. So I'm going
- 27:33to order an appraisal and a buyout to occur.
- 27:35And if you don't do the buyout, then you're going
- 27:38to lose your buyout opportunity and the property
- 27:41is going to be sold even in a clear case of fraud.
- 27:43It says before the merits. That's what the law
- 27:46says. But don't you need to decide who's an owner
- 27:49before you can determine the buyout? Especially,
- 27:52skipping ahead a little bit to the next section,
- 27:54874 .317, it says the buyout price is the appraisal
- 27:59multiplied by the ownership interest. But how
- 28:01do you know what the ownership interest even
- 28:03is? Especially if we're not considering the merits.
- 28:08Seems a little tricky. But let's move on. Let's
- 28:12say you can figure out these thorny questions
- 28:14of, what is a partition action? Does the act
- 28:18apply? Who's an owner? Let's say it's very simple.
- 28:23Two brothers, 50 -50, very clear. You know, okay.
- 28:29Next section, the buyout provision. Okay. It
- 28:32says, there's an appraisal done. Court determines
- 28:34a value. We're off to the races. It says, 874
- 28:39.317 says that any other co -tenant, and this
- 28:42is paraphrased a little just because the section
- 28:44is a little wordy, but you'll have to trust me
- 28:47that I've fairly represented it here. And it
- 28:50says any other co -tenant has a right of first
- 28:52refusal and shall receive notice of that right.
- 28:54And within 45 days of receiving notice, the co
- 28:56-tenant may exercise that right of first refusal.
- 28:59The purchase price is the value of the entire
- 29:00parcel determined under section 874 .316. multiplied
- 29:06by the co -tenant's fractional ownership interest
- 29:09of the entire parcel. Okay. Again, very simple.
- 29:14After expiration of the period. If one co -tenant
- 29:17makes the election, basically the actual election
- 29:19to purchase, then the ownership shares are reallocated.
- 29:23If multiple co -tenants, again, think about our
- 29:25two brothers and a sister, maybe one wants to
- 29:28sell, the others are fine maintaining ownership.
- 29:31Then if multiple co -tenants make an election,
- 29:33the ownership shares are reallocated. If no co
- 29:36-tenants make an election, then the partition
- 29:38action shall be resolved under section 874 .318.
- 29:41The court sends notice the court shall set a
- 29:43date within 60 days to pay the amounts in a court
- 29:45if we know co -attended pays Partition action
- 29:48shall be resolved under section eight seventy
- 29:50four point three one eight Okay This seems straightforward
- 29:56everybody now you're all now you're all probably
- 29:58gun -shy by this stage But seems pretty straightforward
- 30:04there's an appraisal there's an a buyout one
- 30:07wants to buy the other has to sell What a couple
- 30:09people want to buy? One has to sell if nobody
- 30:13buys All right, then it's you know, it's resolved
- 30:16under this other section eight seventy four point
- 30:19three one eight Okay, let's take a look How does
- 30:25this section deal with a mortgage or a deed of
- 30:28trust on the property so I you know, I've never
- 30:31Really lived anywhere else. I've only kind of
- 30:33been a California kid as you can as you heard
- 30:36Howard share for my You know introduction, went
- 30:42to school, grew up here, went to school here.
- 30:45So I don't really know a lot about real estate
- 30:48in Alabama. Honestly, I don't. I don't know a
- 30:51lot about real estate in Mississippi or South
- 30:54Carolina or Kentucky for that matter. What I
- 30:58hear over and over again, what everyone tells
- 31:00me is real estate in California is so much more
- 31:03expensive than it is elsewhere. I think nobody
- 31:06would disagree with that. And so what comes along
- 31:08with that is this idea that you have to get a
- 31:12big mortgage to buy the real estate. Maybe you
- 31:15don't have to do that in Tennessee. Maybe you
- 31:16can pay cash. Or even in our example of two brothers
- 31:20inheriting property, I have lots of clients who
- 31:24inherit property and there's still a mortgage
- 31:26on it. Maybe mom and dad died in their late 60s
- 31:30and there's still money left on the mortgage.
- 31:33Well, if the buyout price is the ownership shares
- 31:37multiplied by the appraisal, What do you do about
- 31:41the mortgage? How does that how does that accounted
- 31:44for as part of this process? Especially if we're
- 31:46not considering the merits again, we don't get
- 31:49to think about it. That's what it says So let's
- 31:52imagine There's a house. It's in Let's call it
- 31:57Pasadena or La Jolla or I don't know, you know,
- 32:01San Francisco and it's inherited And let's call
- 32:05it this house in Pasadena. Let's say the house
- 32:07is worth a million dollars just to use a nice
- 32:10round figure. But there's still a quarter million
- 32:13dollars owed on the mortgage when mom and dad
- 32:16pass. But the buyout price for the sister who
- 32:22wants to buy is the ownership shares times the
- 32:26appraisal. So the appraisal is a million bucks.
- 32:29Brother, sister agree. Sister is a 50 % owner.
- 32:32So that would mean that her buyout price is half
- 32:35a million dollars But so then brother gets half
- 32:39a million dollars, but there's no accounting
- 32:40for the mortgage the house the buyout price arguably
- 32:44should not be You know a million times point
- 32:50five times half it should be 750 times half so
- 32:54the sister under this law could theoretically
- 32:57pay substantially more than She's supposed to
- 33:02Just because there's a mortgage, just because
- 33:04people in North Carolina didn't think about how
- 33:08real estate is more expensive in California.
- 33:10For those of us who've been practicing, you know,
- 33:13veterans of the partition law for a while, we
- 33:17all know claims for contribution. In other words,
- 33:20you know, brother, you know, two brothers inherit
- 33:23a house, one of them, you know, maybe mom and
- 33:26dad didn't take care of it so well at the end.
- 33:28It needs a new roof. Brother number one pays
- 33:31for it. It needs new plumbing, brother number
- 33:33one pays for it. It's still got a mortgage, brother
- 33:35number one pays for it. Brother number one has
- 33:37spent $100 ,000 on the house, even though as
- 33:41a 50 % owner, he should spend $50 ,000. So in
- 33:45partition law, he has a claim for $50 ,000 in
- 33:50reimbursement from brother number two. And if
- 33:53the house is sold, he gets credit for that. But
- 33:56again, this doesn't really address that. It says
- 33:59appraisal times ownership interest period. That's
- 34:04what it says. So did this eliminate the laws
- 34:07of contribution? What do you do about that? You
- 34:13know, procedurally, you know, let's ask some
- 34:16easier questions. What happens if they miss the
- 34:18deadline? What happens if instead of. 50 days
- 34:21after the appraisal is filed, they object or
- 34:24they say, I want to, I'll pay the money. They
- 34:27miss it. Let's say they miss it by a day. Do
- 34:31they still have that right? Is it a jurisdictional
- 34:33deadline? Is it subject to a 473 motion? Arguably,
- 34:39473 says that the court can set aside any order.
- 34:42Doesn't say set aside any time line. So is the
- 34:45court, if the court hears a 473 motion, is that
- 34:48setting aside? The entire appraisal and you have
- 34:51to go back to zero because somebody says they
- 34:54missed the deadline by a day. What are you supposed
- 34:57to do there? Is it a hard deadline or a soft
- 35:00deadline? Well. 874 .317 doesn't tell us. So,
- 35:07you know, there's there's some practical concerns
- 35:10here. Is that is that fair? Is that just? It's
- 35:13kind of interesting. Let's see if we can ask
- 35:16if we can get some clarity from the other sections.
- 35:19Okay, so let's say, you know, nobody got tripped
- 35:23up from here to there. There's two brothers.
- 35:27They're both owners. It's a tenancy in common.
- 35:30They're 50%. There's an appraisal. Nobody makes
- 35:35the election to buy. Nobody disputes the appraisal.
- 35:39You know, brother number two says, I would love
- 35:41to have bought mom and dad's house in Pasadena.
- 35:44I just don't have the cash. I can't qualify for
- 35:46the mortgage. You know, no one's disputing the
- 35:49mortgage amount. Let's say it's own frame clear.
- 35:51Okay. It goes to a sale. We've done. We've done
- 35:55our appraisal process. We've done our buyout
- 35:57process. It says if it's not resolved, it goes
- 36:00to a sale. It says if the court orders a sale,
- 36:03the sale shall be an open market sale. Unless
- 36:05an auction or seal bids would be more economically
- 36:07advantageous. Honestly, I've never seen in almost
- 36:11500 partitions, never seen an auction or seal
- 36:14bids. Almost always open market sale. That's
- 36:16what everybody wants. That's what. makes judges
- 36:18happy the court orders an open market sale not
- 36:21later than 10 days after the entry of the order
- 36:23the court shall quote appoint a real estate broker
- 36:25and establish a commission for the sale if the
- 36:29broker appointed under sub b obtains within a
- 36:31reasonable time and offer to purchase the property
- 36:33for at least the determination of value the following
- 36:35requirements apply one the broker shall comply
- 36:38with the reporting requirements the sale shall
- 36:40be completed in accordance with state law And
- 36:45the broker, under sub B, doesn't obtain an offer
- 36:47to purchase the property. For at least the determination
- 36:50of value within a reasonable time, the court,
- 36:52after hearing, may do any of the following. Approve
- 36:55the highest outstanding offer, redetermine the
- 36:57value of the property, in order that the property
- 36:58continue to be offered for an additional time,
- 37:01or the property be sold by sealed bids or at
- 37:03an auction. So, okay, seems pretty simple. You
- 37:08know, no one does a buyout, 50 % owners, they
- 37:12do a sale. Right? Pretty simple. Well, and by
- 37:17the way, Section 8, you know, I'll just represent
- 37:19to you Section 874 .312 .321 relates to notice
- 37:24provisions that are kind of similar to what happens
- 37:28in a probate sale. Basically just providing notice
- 37:31to all interested parties, making sure it's,
- 37:33you know, it's publicly noticed. Okay. For those
- 37:37of us who have been doing this a while. We all
- 37:40got used to attorney referees, right? You know,
- 37:42you appoint some lawyer they hire a realtor and
- 37:46They kind of shepherd the process, you know,
- 37:49if they're if necessary, there's an eviction.
- 37:51They'll do an eviction You know that sort of
- 37:53thing You know, it's pretty simple this section
- 37:58says you appoint a real estate broker and While
- 38:03there are some attorneys who are brokers Generally,
- 38:06the two are mutually exclusive. Real estate brokers,
- 38:09they're into real estate. Lawyers, funny enough,
- 38:11they're into law. And so what happens is the
- 38:16court must appoint a broker, but then the broker
- 38:20must comply with the law. How does a real estate
- 38:24broker, whose business is just buying and selling,
- 38:26let's say single -family homes in Pasadena, how
- 38:29does he know what to file with the court? How
- 38:32does he know how to comply with the notice provisions
- 38:35in Section 874 .321? How practically is he going
- 38:42to do, you know, the sale while complying with
- 38:47the law on his own? Is that realistic? I don't
- 38:53know. I don't know. It's kind of an interesting
- 38:55question. Relatedly, if a party failed to make
- 39:02the election under earlier provisions, do they
- 39:04still have the right to make the election now?
- 39:06Well, it's going to open market sell. Why couldn't
- 39:09they be a buyer? Did they lose their shot? The
- 39:14earlier section says that that's their election.
- 39:17Is that waived? And again, all of this is assuming
- 39:22it's this waterfall. Okay, it's a partition of
- 39:25real property. It's a tenancy in common. There's
- 39:28an appraisal process. There's a buyout process.
- 39:30And it says, but if there's not a buyout, it's
- 39:32resolved as a sale. So wait a minute. Again,
- 39:35you could have a whole defense, a righteous defense
- 39:38to a partition. And the property is just going
- 39:44to get sold and you can then do your trial on
- 39:47your defenses to the partition. The law says,
- 39:51seemingly. It's kind of an interesting issue.
- 39:56When should you try those defenses? When should
- 39:59you try all those issues, the merits, as it were?
- 40:05It's a really good question. Once the property's
- 40:09sold, especially if somebody says, well, I have
- 40:10a life estate, I have a constructive trustee,
- 40:12I wanna stay here for the rest of my life, once
- 40:15that property's sold, I mean, the horse is kinda
- 40:17out of the barn. What do you do then? What kind
- 40:21of relief do you have for your client? You're
- 40:22gonna unwind that sale? Don't know if that's
- 40:25realistic. That's that's some cold comfort Your
- 40:29file something it's kind of interesting so You
- 40:33know some issues Here's some some related issues,
- 40:37and this is kind of this kind of comes up from
- 40:39time to time What happens if somebody dies in
- 40:43the middle of the partition? Technically any
- 40:47cause of action that is he didn't possessed at
- 40:49that survives their state and maybe maintained
- 40:51or continued by the personal representative Where
- 40:54the decedent left the undivided interest in any
- 40:56property the partition action may be bought brought
- 40:59by the personal representative Against the other
- 41:01co -tenants or by the other co -tenants against
- 41:03the personal representative But the probate code
- 41:05says again. There's that word partition in the
- 41:08probate code right Under section 98 23 the personal
- 41:15representative may commence partition action
- 41:17may defend a partition action by their co -tenants
- 41:19without prior approval of the probate court Technically,
- 41:22you don't need it. You just can request the superior
- 41:25court to sub in according to the terms of the
- 41:28probate code. And again, the personal representative
- 41:32has explicit authority to commence and maintains
- 41:33actions and proceedings for the benefit of the
- 41:36state and defend actions, proceedings brought
- 41:38against the decedent personal representative
- 41:40of the state. So, I mean, you know, how do you
- 41:45you can sub somebody in? How does that work?
- 41:48Is that a Is it a is a proper substitution, even
- 41:54if the probate court doesn't determine that their
- 41:57personal representative? Kind of interesting,
- 41:59right? How do you handle if you got two brothers?
- 42:03Turns out litigation is stressful. Some people
- 42:05don't handle it that well and they depart. How
- 42:10do you do that? What happens, you know, in that
- 42:13situation? What happens if you can't find a personal
- 42:16representative or an heir? What happens to their
- 42:18interest? Do you have to do a whole probate and
- 42:21put the partition on hold in the interim? That's
- 42:24a whole thing, right? So kind of a tricky issue.
- 42:30That said, if you have a probate, you can partition.
- 42:34So this is kind of what we alluded to earlier.
- 42:35So there's three different types of partition
- 42:38and probate. Whether a student's interest includes
- 42:41an undivided interest. The surviving co -owners'
- 42:45interests are obviously not part of the decedent's
- 42:47probate estate. So basically, let's say instead
- 42:51of two brothers, you have... Well, actually,
- 42:55no. Let's say instead of mom and dad, you have
- 42:57two brothers, but they're grown. You know, each
- 43:00has their own family and they die. Well, you
- 43:03know, can you partition it just between the two
- 43:06brothers? No, you need the one brother who died.
- 43:10you know, any partition action against his estate
- 43:13must be brought in Superior Court, can't be done
- 43:15in the appropriate proceeding. There's some case
- 43:19law for you there. And there's part two. Well,
- 43:22but if it's just a mom and dad and they leave
- 43:25it to their heirs, a proceeding in the estate
- 43:29administration may be commenced to partition
- 43:31each undivided interest before distribution.
- 43:33Again, there's that reference to partition. that
- 43:37I alluded to earlier in the introduction. There's
- 43:40a case on that, you know, interpreting, giving
- 43:44some treatment of that statute. So, you know,
- 43:49there you go. One of the options available in
- 43:55a probate proceeding is to partition by appraisal.
- 43:59That's kind of like our example that we just
- 44:02gave about the appraisal and the buyout and the
- 44:05sale. Um, you can do that and probate, although
- 44:08it's voluntary. Um, you know, so some estate
- 44:13planning tips, um, you know, to take away for
- 44:16your clients, you know, advise about the risks
- 44:18of partition. Um, so again, it applies to tenancy
- 44:22in common, doesn't apply to joint tenancy. Uh,
- 44:25so if you were to leave your property to, you
- 44:27know, two sons as joint tenants, uh, the partition
- 44:32law wouldn't apply. Uh, the partition of a property
- 44:34act wouldn't apply. specifically. If there's
- 44:37multiple properties, maybe give one property
- 44:39to each party. If property is given to multiple
- 44:42heirs, make a careful choice about a tenant in
- 44:44common versus a joint tenant. If there's a single
- 44:47property that must be given to multiple heirs,
- 44:50consider structuring something in the trust about
- 44:53a bio -provision to avoid having them having
- 44:57to hire somebody like me because nobody wants
- 45:00that. So, you know, just some, you know, be,
- 45:05for those of you in the estate planning world,
- 45:06some good tips. Otherwise, this is me and the
- 45:11team of lawyers working on this. We also have
- 45:17a whatever reason that slide didn't transfer.
- 45:21So we have a blog. I think we've got hundreds
- 45:23of articles at this point about partition topics
- 45:26and related topics. So really good information
- 45:29for practitioners. And again, my office in LA
- 45:33is in Culver City. So at this point, I'd be happy
- 45:40to answer any questions that you may have. I
- 45:43see there's some in the Q &A. And I'll just kind
- 45:47of go through them. It looks like we've got about
- 45:5010 or maybe 12, maybe 15 minutes left. So I'll
- 45:54go through them. And if anybody has any other
- 45:57questions, feel free to include them. So David
- 45:59Azar. asks, can you consider including an election
- 46:04by a non moving party to get partition kind instead
- 46:07of sale and to buy out the moving parties? So
- 46:15I'm not totally sure what you mean. What you
- 46:19can do Is you know if the property is susceptible
- 46:24to partition by division you can seek that so
- 46:27for example i have a number of clients in the
- 46:29central valley and they have not you know single
- 46:32family home in pasadena they've got. Ranch land
- 46:35or farmland or you know i've had some clients
- 46:38in nappa vineyard land. Um, I have some clients
- 46:41with, um, you know, commercial acreage, like
- 46:44in downtown Sacramento and, you know, they want
- 46:48to divide it. They want to keep some of it. There's,
- 46:50you know, physical partition. So that's an issue.
- 46:53Um, so in that case, it's the partition of real
- 46:57property act. Um, you know, generally says that
- 47:02there's a preference for physical division. So
- 47:04again, because this act originated in the American
- 47:08South, you know, having to deal with a lot of
- 47:11farmland that's inherited, you know, there's
- 47:14a preference for physical division over partition
- 47:18by sale. So it's definitely something that arises,
- 47:21although it's, you know, obviously less common
- 47:24in, you know, very urban areas such as Los Angeles
- 47:27or San Francisco or San Diego. But so interesting.
- 47:31Oh, David, I'm not sure I totally answered your
- 47:33question. If I if I didn't, please add something
- 47:36to the Q &A and I'll try to do a better job.
- 47:38Um, but so moving on, uh, Jeffrey Miriam, uh,
- 47:43Raywald asks, can you discuss application of
- 47:46the partition rules procedures to partnership
- 47:48resolutions? Absolutely. So, you know, one of
- 47:54the things that we do, one of our firm's specialties
- 47:57versus some of the other firms that practice
- 47:59partition is, you know, we're very versed in
- 48:01partnership disputes and partnership dissolutions.
- 48:05And so we have a number of those going right
- 48:07now involving partitioning the property as part
- 48:10of the partnership dissolution. You know, obviously
- 48:14there may be related claims, fiduciary duty,
- 48:17conversion, constructive fraud. um you know things
- 48:21things like that um you can also have a whole
- 48:25process um where you'll have a there's a statutory
- 48:30buyout under the um Rupa, which is the revised
- 48:37Uniform Partnership Act. The Uniform LLC law
- 48:41also has something, a related provision about
- 48:43a buyout. So we've interacted with both of those.
- 48:47There's a statutory buyout provision relating
- 48:49to expert appraisals and how those are done.
- 48:55I think it's probably a little bit beyond the
- 48:57scope of this. presentation, needless to say,
- 49:00like, there are parallel provisions, and we've
- 49:03worked with them. You know, but, but basically,
- 49:08the idea is once it goes to a sale, you know,
- 49:11especially if it's an LLC with a single entity
- 49:13asset, which is like such as a warehouse or real
- 49:16estate, you know, the partition law, you know,
- 49:20would apply. So that's been kind of my experience
- 49:23with that. I mean, I could probably, you know,
- 49:26talk another hour just about that issue. So I'll
- 49:30kind of shortcut it here. I sometimes act as
- 49:35like a provisional director, provisional partner.
- 49:38Is there any interplay between those roles where
- 49:41you would think you then would need a partition
- 49:43because you have a deciding vote in the entity?
- 49:50Sorry, what's your question? Well, what would
- 49:53be the interaction if instead of somebody somebody
- 49:56says I want to do partition somebody says no
- 49:58let's just have a provisional director provisional
- 50:00partner and they will make the decision for the
- 50:02group for the entity sure they could I mean I
- 50:05guess I guess it's about the stage of the dissolution
- 50:07right so like if I think What you may be referring
- 50:10to is at an earlier stage upstream about should
- 50:13the entity be dissolved can a buyout be done?
- 50:16You know under reasonable terms even the provisional
- 50:19director can help to make that decision in the
- 50:21instance of a deadlock if however the court ultimately
- 50:24makes a decision that judicial dissolution is
- 50:26in the best interest of the party or the the
- 50:29entity then you know, one of the remedies is
- 50:32partition or just sale the asset so that the
- 50:35assets the entity can be fairly divided between
- 50:38the parties instead of two people sharing our
- 50:41warehouse, two people share $10 million or whatever
- 50:45it ends up being. But there are definitely some
- 50:49opportunities for a provisional director to foreclose
- 50:51a partition. It just depends at what stage of
- 50:55the proceedings we're finding ourselves. In the
- 50:58corporate setting, you have a Corporation Code
- 51:002000 election to avoid dissolution as well. Sure.
- 51:04And there's all these issues about, well, what's
- 51:06the election? What's the valuation that's put
- 51:09on the cost of the election, right? And that
- 51:13determination. And sometimes people say, well,
- 51:15I don't agree with that determination, so I'm
- 51:17not going to make that election. Or I can't afford
- 51:20it, right? And in which case, the alternative
- 51:22remedy, I think, only is partition. At least
- 51:27that's my kind of understanding. Yeah. OK. Cool.
- 51:32Good questions. Alice Graham asked, isn't there
- 51:35a case law that partition applies to life estate?
- 51:37Actually, Alice, it's even better than that.
- 51:39There's a partition statute that says the partition
- 51:42applies to life estates. So yes, but yes, there
- 51:45is case law that partition applies to life estates.
- 51:48I've actually partitioned a life estate. So not
- 51:53only can you do it, I've done it. So something,
- 51:57and there's a whole formula for determining the
- 51:58value of that life estate in that instance. So,
- 52:03okay, but good question. David Aser asks, regarding
- 52:08your comment of the statutory ambiguity, the
- 52:09evaluation partition comes before consideration
- 52:12of the merits of who is an owner. Has there simply
- 52:15been no reported appellate decisions yet since
- 52:17this act is new? And are you aware of any trial
- 52:19court decisions? So David, I'm not aware of any
- 52:23treatment in California. I have reviewed the
- 52:27case law, the treatment in other states again,
- 52:29because one of the beauties of being a uniform
- 52:31act is you have the same law in Nevada or Ohio.
- 52:38Or you know minnesota or whatever the case may
- 52:40be and you can read appellate opinions from them
- 52:43and we have a collection of them on our website.
- 52:47You kind of treating the act and kind of what
- 52:50it says but nothing california. Published company
- 52:53in california. I'm not aware of any truck or
- 52:57decisions on that topic frankly it is a little
- 53:00harder to track down. um but um and but there's
- 53:04no also no appellate opinion on this specific
- 53:06question from any other state of which of which
- 53:09i'm aware i haven't i haven't checked in maybe
- 53:1218 months so i could have missed something but
- 53:14that's basically you know my my knowledge of
- 53:17that topic um so okay so alice asks Since partition
- 53:24is equitable, can a judge deny it if the judge
- 53:26thinks partition would be unfair to the defendant?
- 53:28So it's a nice question. So partition initially
- 53:31was an equitable proceeding. I guess it's still
- 53:35considered to be equitable. But for there's actually
- 53:39a very, you know, I see this term thrown around
- 53:41a lot. Well, it's equitable. It's unfair. So
- 53:43we can stop it. There's actually a very specific
- 53:46meaning to the term equity. You know, the distinction
- 53:49between law and equity. And basically, it has
- 53:50to do with whether there was a right to a jury
- 53:54trial at the time that California became a state
- 53:57at the institution of the state constitution
- 53:59in 1850, because in 1850, the first act of the
- 54:03California legislature upon entry into statehood
- 54:05was to adopt the common law of England as existed
- 54:08at 1776, which basically at that time was based
- 54:12in large part on Blackstone's commentaries and
- 54:14the laws of England. So, and that was the definition
- 54:18of equity. Did you get a jury trial or not? in
- 54:21a nutshell. Since that time, however, the partition
- 54:25law, as we just discussed, has been codified.
- 54:31And so, yes, it is an equitable proceeding, but
- 54:33equity cannot necessarily override statute. And
- 54:37the partition law that stands now, I think it's
- 54:38A72 .720, says that partition is a matter of
- 54:42right and less barred by a valid waiver. So,
- 54:46you know, basically, Since that's and basically
- 54:49since 1976, since the since this partition law
- 54:54was codified and revised at that time, there's
- 54:57been no published decision that is allowed that
- 55:00is allowed for the denial of partition based
- 55:03on unfairness under the codified laws is a very
- 55:08long winding answer to that question, but a very
- 55:10good one. So I I don't think that that fairness
- 55:14is a defense in that sense. Lark Gortney asks,
- 55:20listing a property in the open market, knowing
- 55:22it as a first right of fusel is against most
- 55:24MLS rules and can result in disciplinary action
- 55:27against the broker. True. Best practice, buyout
- 55:30value, feasibility and execution, or waiver should
- 55:33be resolved before listing with a broker unless.
- 55:35I can't. I can't fight with you, Lark. That's
- 55:38probably true. I think what's noticeable or what's
- 55:41notable about this procedure is that it says
- 55:43that the sale for the broker happens only after
- 55:47the appraisal and the buyout. So under the law,
- 55:50I think it perfectly comports with what you're
- 55:53sharing. So I don't really see a conflict there.
- 55:56So I think we agree. But nice note. Chantelle
- 56:01Malmed asks, and I apologize if I'm butchering
- 56:04some of these names, I'm sorry about that. The
- 56:06statute is unclear as to how partition referees
- 56:09can or should be used to care at the process
- 56:10of determining fair market value and conducting
- 56:12partition sales under the new regime. How would
- 56:15you interpret it? Well, I'd say that partition
- 56:17referees are not determining fair market value,
- 56:21right? The appraisal process is determining fair
- 56:23market value. That said, what I've seen is basically
- 56:29brokers Listing these properties said it whatever
- 56:32they think can sell and whatever it gets the
- 56:34court approves regardless of what the appraisal
- 56:36says from a practical perspective. That's what
- 56:38I've seen Sally Williams asked can court issue
- 56:43interlocutory order to destroy joint tenancy
- 56:45so partition can proceed actually a joint tenancy
- 56:48an interlocutory judgment Wouldn't sever the
- 56:51joint tenancy. It would just affirm it so I don't
- 56:54As Sally Williams, it's an interesting question.
- 56:55I have seen that argument. They are it is so
- 56:58what I would say is it does sever the joint tenancy,
- 57:01but then that doesn't revert to apply the Partition
- 57:04of Real Property Act. It says it's a joint tenancy.
- 57:07And so the Partition of Real Property Act doesn't
- 57:09apply. So that's that's the answer I have there.
- 57:14Oh, Sally Williams adds without considering merits
- 57:16where joint tenancy was obtained by fraud. Yeah,
- 57:20I just I haven't seen that. I would be a little
- 57:22surprised if the court use the statute in that
- 57:25way. Brian Lamb asks, does the California partition
- 57:29law apply to the vision of common interest in
- 57:30a California residential mobile home? I would
- 57:35say that The Partition of a Property Act applies
- 57:40to real property in a mobile home, I think, is
- 57:44personal to you because it's registered with
- 57:46the Department of Motor Vehicles. So I don't
- 57:48believe it may it's arguably doesn't fall within
- 57:52the Partition of a Property Act. I've actually
- 57:55partitioned a couple mobile homes. I've never
- 57:58seen a court apply the partition of a property
- 58:00act to the mobile homes. I know that you have
- 58:03that on the real estate brokers test, they will
- 58:06inquire about mobile homes. But I think that's,
- 58:12you know, the last time I looked at it, that's
- 58:14my memory of it. I could be wrong, but having
- 58:19partitioned a few mobile homes, I've never seen
- 58:21a court apply the act to those mobile homes.
- 58:24So that's a nice question. William McPike asks,
- 58:29how do you perfect some recordable document like
- 58:32a deed or claim without litigation that what
- 58:34would be recorded? I'm not totally sure by your
- 58:38question, William. It's interesting. I feel like
- 58:40there's a piece I'm missing to really give you
- 58:43the best answer. Yeah, I feel like I'm missing
- 58:48a piece. I'm sorry. Matt Goodwin asks, join tenants
- 58:52with right of survivorship. Assume if this is
- 58:57How it is held in the joint tenancy severs unilaterally
- 59:00and then seeks partition. Yeah, you can sever
- 59:02the joint tenancy and then seek partition Nothing
- 59:05that prevents you from doing that. So and then
- 59:08the partition real property actor to apply so
- 59:10that's correct Terry Cohn asks what if the prop
- 59:14what if part of the property is improved in part
- 59:17not Who gets the part with the improvement is
- 59:19the divisional split by acreage by value per
- 59:22square foot? It's a great question, Terry. Basically,
- 59:25it's a court determination as to whether partition
- 59:31by sale is more equitable than partition by division.
- 59:35In that case, one party would have to say, yeah,
- 59:37I get the house and they get the backyard, but
- 59:40that's fair. There is this concept of ulti, which
- 59:44basically means that if there's a physical division
- 59:46done, then an offsetting payment should happen
- 59:49between them to equalize the value between the
- 59:51parties. That said, I've never really, it's theoretically
- 59:56possible. It's much harder in acreage cases involving
- 1:00:01farmland. In a case involving a single family
- 1:00:04home, I've never seen it. It's a very interesting
- 1:00:08issue. It's something that I think about a lot.
- 1:00:10I've seen some attorneys raise it That's that
- 1:00:13I've never really seen a court embrace that perspective
- 1:00:16just from my from my experience So but it's not
- 1:00:20I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm just saying
- 1:00:22I haven't Seen it with a lot of legs if that's
- 1:00:27if that's helpful Okay, William McPike asks,
- 1:00:34how do you prove an easement boundary line where
- 1:00:36the barbed wire fence has been in place for 120
- 1:00:38years and witnesses are dead? It's a great question.
- 1:00:42I'd probably start with a surveyor, an expert
- 1:00:43witness of some kind, especially if you're doing
- 1:00:46a physical partition. And the court can also,
- 1:00:48I've also had courts appoint referees to make
- 1:00:52that determination of a boundary line based on
- 1:00:54a written report. So I think that would be the
- 1:00:58best. This relates to a lecture I give on neighbor
- 1:01:01disputes. And he's talking about the theory of
- 1:01:04agreed boundaries. And the problem you have here
- 1:01:07is, how do you show the agreement? So you're
- 1:01:09going to think of anything evidentiary you might
- 1:01:11be able to go back to to evidence some agreement,
- 1:01:15maybe by the original people who put it in. You
- 1:01:17may look at subsequent owners and see if they
- 1:01:20conducted themselves in such a way that you can
- 1:01:23use that to evidence agreement. But the proof
- 1:01:27of agreement is probably crucial to that legal
- 1:01:29theory. Well, and it sounds like you're all over
- 1:01:32it, Howard. But I do apologize. I do have to
- 1:01:35run to my next thing. It is 1 31. But thank you
- 1:01:39all for attending. And if anybody has any questions,
- 1:01:42feel free to reach out to our office and we'll
- 1:01:46help as best we can. Thank you very much, Ellie.
- 1:01:50I really appreciate you putting on this program
- 1:01:52for us. And other than the fact that I think
- 1:01:55we are leaving with more questions than answers
- 1:01:57as to what's going on with this. I think that's
- 1:02:00a compliment. I think that means it was well
- 1:02:01done. Yeah. It means there's a lot of room for
- 1:02:05lawyering to go on. And I'm sure you guys are
- 1:02:07going to remain very busy. But thank you for
- 1:02:10bringing your expertise to us today. Thank you.
- 1:02:12All right. Bye.