Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Year End Industry Data and Credit Union Trends: A Deep Dive with Todd Miller and Steve Farrar
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Kel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm back here today with Steve Farr and Todd Miller, former, also formerly
- 0:08event COA, and also members of my team here at Credit Union Exam Solutions.
- 0:12How you guys doing today?
- 0:13Farrar: Doing good.
- 0:13Happy Spring.
- 0:14Treichel: Happy Spring.
- 0:15We made it.
- 0:17For those listeners who may be new Steve and Todd have been on many podcasts, and
- 0:23I'm gonna have them do a little bit of an introduction of themselves, what they've
- 0:26been doing what they did at NCUA, and then we'll jump into an exciting topic today.
- 0:31Steve, why don't you go first?
- 0:33Farrar: Yeah, I was just gonna go through, decided to kinda update
- 0:36my career with the three parts.
- 0:37The first part was, like 15 years as a problem case officer at NCOA,
- 0:41working with the problems mainly on the west coast, involving consumer
- 0:45conservatorships assisted mergers and a lot of successful turnarounds.
- 0:51We turned credit unions around with zero capital back in those days.
- 0:55Then I went to the central office about the time Mark was in the
- 0:58central office and worked for the.
- 1:00Officer risk management.
- 1:02And that was a fun career.
- 1:03'cause I got involved in just a multitude of things that kept it interesting
- 1:06involving the, the corporate turnaround.
- 1:09I would train examiners on problem resolution and the wrote the
- 1:14enforcement manual and, ended up with a, the risk-based capital
- 1:19and the vice president of the CLF.
- 1:22And then since when Mark started his firm up, we've gotten to.
- 1:26Be active back with credit unions again.
- 1:29Looking at the problems, I did a stint as a CEO for a large
- 1:33conservator conservatorship in Manhattan, New York, which was fun.
- 1:37But but that's been, it's been a fun after 30 some years, NCUA to be able
- 1:43to take that experience and continue to apply it and keep sharpening.
- 1:47Our saw has been really nice.
- 1:49That's
- 1:49Treichel: right.
- 1:50Sharpening the saw, the old Stephen Covey thing you taught me way back in the day.
- 1:54Very good.
- 1:55And Todd, how about yourself?
- 1:57Miller: I was with NCA for 34 years.
- 1:59It's interesting about the first six, eight years of that.
- 2:02I was actually in the, under the same supervisors as Steve kind
- 2:06working on the same kinds of things.
- 2:07And then my path diverged a little bit.
- 2:10He stayed a problem case officer a lot longer than I did.
- 2:13So I spent about 10 years or so as an examiner and a problem case officer.
- 2:18Then I spent a decade as a regional capital market
- 2:21specialist from 2000 to 2010.
- 2:24And from 2010 to my retirement in 2011, I was a director of special
- 2:30actions in the western region supervising those problem case stoppers.
- 2:33There's and capital market specialists and regional lending specialists.
- 2:38And then I had the lost year in there where you drug me
- 2:40into Westcorp for all of 2000.
- 2:42Nine and when you were the agent for the conservator for Westcore and you
- 2:46let me retire for about two months before you called me and convinced
- 2:50me to come help you and help credit unions from the other side of it.
- 2:53And it's been enjoyable to actually take that 34 years of experience and
- 2:59help credit unions along the way.
- 3:00Treichel: Yeah, it has been fun.
- 3:01That was 2021 when we came through in our then Class B through Montana.
- 3:06Spent some time with Steve and then recruited Todd and
- 3:09and here we are in 20, 20, 25.
- 3:11Time flies guys.
- 3:13So this podcast is I think gonna be some fun because we're gonna talk
- 3:19about the 2024 trends that came out the data that came out from
- 3:23NCUA, which is a lot of raw data.
- 3:26But before we jump into that, number one, we're gonna talk about some
- 3:29general multi-year trends that kind of have got us here, right?
- 3:32Because if you lose track of history.
- 3:34You're condemned to repeat yourself.
- 3:36And then after we walk through the multi-year trends and the 2024 trends,
- 3:41we're gonna talk about some of the things that we've been seeing in our clients,
- 3:46in our general conversations with credit unions, et cetera, excuse me, et cetera.
- 3:50So with that let's tee off the let's start talking a little bit
- 3:54about the general multi-year trends as a primer for this discussion.
- 3:59Miller: Steve's got his head down.
- 3:59I guess he wants me to chat.
- 4:01Yeah, go ahead.
- 4:01Ahead.
- 4:01So you know, it's interesting.
- 4:03After that last recession, we had a long decade really of 2012 up until
- 4:08about 2020 of really flat rates.
- 4:11Not a lot was going on in the crediting industry.
- 4:13And then Covid disrupted the whole world, and that is still having a
- 4:18huge impact on credit unions today.
- 4:21During Covid, that savings rate jumped up to the 20%.
- 4:25Range credit unions had these massive surges of deposits and that
- 4:30was causing pressure on capital and interest rates were low.
- 4:34So what did a lot of credit unions do?
- 4:35They went a long-term with a lot of that covid money.
- 4:39They went, bought long-term investments.
- 4:42They made.
- 4:43Real estate mortgages at three or 4%.
- 4:47Of course then we hit inflation right after that.
- 4:49All of a sudden, people have less disposable income.
- 4:52Those deposits flow out the door.
- 4:55The fed raises rates to fight the inflation.
- 4:59All of a sudden that interest margins are shrinking.
- 5:02In earnings, in credit union industry have been declining
- 5:05since Covid just about every year.
- 5:07And so a lot of decisions that credit unions made back in the years of covid
- 5:11are still impacting their earnings today.
- 5:14And, the agency's been beating them up about interest rate
- 5:17risk and about credit risk.
- 5:19Because the decisions they made, following Covid.
- 5:22And we're still seeing that now during inflation savings rate wins down.
- 5:27Credit unions had to compete for funds.
- 5:29So it's just somewhere interesting than with the inflation years.
- 5:33You had this surge in loan demand.
- 5:36So bones went way up.
- 5:38A lot of that is 'cause people seeing their disposable income relative
- 5:42to inflation fall and it hits a lower income people really hard.
- 5:46So you had the surge in credit card borrowing, you had surges
- 5:49in just about every kind of borrowing, to be honest with you.
- 5:53With no share growth.
- 5:54And now as we get into 2023 and 2024, you're starting to see unemployment creep
- 6:01up and it's affecting credit quality.
- 6:03So now the agency's kind of focused on credit quality and.
- 6:09It's not anything that credits have done to change how they've made loans.
- 6:13It's just the general trends in the economy that, once again, inflation
- 6:17is still faster than wage growth.
- 6:19And we got unemployment growing up in, I think 47 of the 50 states
- 6:24unemployment went up last year.
- 6:26So that's putting pressure on asset quality.
- 6:31So everything that's going on today is a result of decisions credit unions
- 6:35made in the last two, three years.
- 6:37Treichel: Well said.
- 6:38Steve, any thoughts you wanna
- 6:39Farrar: add to that summary?
- 6:41No, that's a good summary and then, it's really most reflected and we'll cover
- 6:45it a little bit more in that creeping of the provision for loan losses.
- 6:49You went through 2001, 2002 as almost no loan losses, and now
- 6:54we're back above what would be the.
- 6:57Long term normal that we've had for the industry, which used to be about 0.4,
- 7:01and now it, it's creeped up to 0.6
- 7:03and that's been a real hindrance for the credit union.
- 7:06So
- 7:07Treichel: yeah, you add the extra PLL and the inflation, which impacts
- 7:10our operating expense, that kind of figure out why that, that net income
- 7:14is down, and one of the things, Todd, as you're walking through that, I've
- 7:17had some conversations, I've said it on some presentations I've made with.
- 7:22Some league groups is the, it's kind of like that triple black swan event.
- 7:26You had Covid and then you had the Fred rate.
- 7:28You people went long, started to go long because they thought, hey, this
- 7:33is the new normal rates are low.
- 7:34And then the second black swan event was fed rates going up 550 basis points.
- 7:39I think it was five 50 and then inflation from all the money we
- 7:43were printing and other reasons.
- 7:44Those three black swan events have really led us to today, which get us to the
- 7:49stats that we're gonna talk about next.
- 7:51So
- 7:51Farrar: yeah, and you had new accounting standard in there for the loan losses.
- 7:55Treichel: Okay.
- 7:55Farrar: Yeah.
- 7:55Treichel: Let's just
- 7:55Farrar: keep piling it on.
- 7:57Treichel: Yes.
- 7:58Yeah, actually I just got an email from a vendor that that was trying
- 8:01to touch base with me when I was at c Kuna, our America's credit union's,
- 8:05GIC, about some Cecil issues that that have popped up for one of his clients.
- 8:10Anyway, I digress.
- 8:11All right.
- 8:12They lay out this data in, in one direction, but we thought
- 8:15we would walk through it in the state of affairs of camel.
- 8:19'cause we talk about camel a lot.
- 8:21Any thoughts on what the report is showing as it relates to capital?
- 8:27Farrar: I just notice that when you mean we did have an increase
- 8:29in the net worth ratio for 2024 and that's really, that's good.
- 8:34Much of it is because we did have, of course, the growth rate in net
- 8:39worth did exceed the growth rate and for shares not by a lot, but
- 8:43by enough to make a difference.
- 8:44And it was kinda interesting.
- 8:46I've been tracking, a lot of growth is from share growth.
- 8:50And so I tracked, we had, you had more in dividends that were going into the shares.
- 8:54So what was the share growth rate?
- 8:57Discounting dividends and it was, it was about half of what
- 9:00is reported as the growth rate if you take out dividends from there.
- 9:05Around 2.16%.
- 9:07And that compares to, how big 2021 was from that normal, which
- 9:11was 12% excluding dividends.
- 9:14But, dividends are, going in and contributing to share growth.
- 9:18The other thing though that I, we really, we've looked at a
- 9:21lot is the gap equity ratio.
- 9:24'cause there's some always items that are non gap in the net worth
- 9:27ratio, but that showed improvement.
- 9:31Quite remarkably from 9.11
- 9:32to 9.66,
- 9:34and that is the result of the unrealized loss in the investments
- 9:41has come down pretty substantially.
- 9:44So that is my nutshell on capital.
- 9:47Todd,
- 9:48Miller: I would just point out the gap net worth that Steve mentioned.
- 9:512024 is the first time that ratio has improved since 2020.
- 9:57And part of that is, as Steve mentioned, the sugar, the growth has slowed way down.
- 10:01So credits have been able to actually accrete a little bit.
- 10:05Capital.
- 10:05I do think credit unions, NCUA puts it on the FPR.
- 10:09It's not on their key ratios with their exams, but credit unions should probably
- 10:13pay attention to their own gap net worth, because creditors look at that
- 10:18net worth when they're underwriting loans and things of that nature.
- 10:21So it is an important number, even though NCUA deemphasizes it for the most part.
- 10:27Treichel: And I'll just add, go ahead, Steve.
- 10:30Farrar: As a measuring stick.
- 10:31I'm I compare credit union performance a lot to what I can see
- 10:35in the community bank environment.
- 10:37And, their leverage ratio is 10.82
- 10:40and our net worth ratio is 11.21.
- 10:42So real comparable.
- 10:44Treichel: Yeah, that's good.
- 10:45That's good data.
- 10:46I recently listened to treasury Secretary Scott Cent on the Odd Lots podcast,
- 10:52which is a Bloomberg podcast, which is, really educational, but the Trump
- 10:56administration, the treasury department head is, one of their goals is to
- 11:00get 30 tenure treasury rates lower.
- 11:04Easier said than done.
- 11:05And then of course there's the Fed that makes the decisions
- 11:08on rates, et cetera, et cetera.
- 11:09But if that goal is achieved longer term I think that gap equity will recover more.
- 11:15Any thoughts on that?
- 11:17Miller: It depends on the shape of the yield curve a little bit.
- 11:20If the 10 years come down, it will definitely help the investment portfolios.
- 11:25There's still a lot of investment.
- 11:27You can see that the maturity of investment portfolios are still
- 11:31lengthening, even though they're shrinking and as the investment
- 11:35portfolio investment growth is negative.
- 11:37Credit unions are putting that into their loan portfolio, but
- 11:40they still have this overhang of.
- 11:45Long term investments that they bought in 2022 and 2021.
- 11:50And it's still gonna be with us for a while.
- 11:53Yet still a lot of investments are over three years on their balance sheets.
- 11:59And a lot of those are mortgage backed securities that are
- 12:02paying two, 3% coupons.
- 12:04Those people are not refinancing.
- 12:06Treichel: Yeah.
- 12:06Yeah.
- 12:06I was just chatting with my daughter about the good fortune of having a, 20,
- 12:1026 years left on her fixed rate mortgage.
- 12:13So Great point.
- 12:14Great point.
- 12:15Alright, let's pivot to asset quality.
- 12:17The I know one of you or both of you in a lot of our conversations talks about
- 12:21how it's when asset quality fails, it's what kills credit unions oftentimes.
- 12:26So I hope I didn't steal your thunder there, but let's
- 12:28fire away on asset quality.
- 12:30Todd, go ahead.
- 12:31I think you have lots of
- 12:32Farrar: data on this one.
- 12:33Miller: I do have lots of stuff printed out on this one.
- 12:36It's nice in CS call report now it breaks, delinquency and charge offs down
- 12:41by those individual loan categories.
- 12:43So it takes you a while to sort through it to find it all, but it is all there.
- 12:48This one kind of follows really much the covid pattern too.
- 12:51During the covid years, loan growth was pretty small down at 4%, 7% in 2021.
- 12:58Then as we came out of covid and inflation hit loan growth hit 20%, but it fell to
- 13:05six last year and 2024, it was only 2%.
- 13:10So it slowed way down, but you just look at delinquency.
- 13:14And delinquency has been creeping up in virtually every loan category
- 13:20on the credit union's balance sheet.
- 13:22Credit cards and been hit really hard, unsecured hit really hard.
- 13:26You're seeing it in the new car loans too.
- 13:29I mentioned people, especially the lower income, they started borrowing
- 13:32more during that high inflation period.
- 13:35You really see that in credit card charge offs, which, you know,
- 13:39over the last years, if, when.
- 13:40From 2% to 3.8%
- 13:43to in 2024, 5%.
- 13:46And we see some of our large, ones type clients, the credit card charge
- 13:50offs whack some of their capital plans pretty hard because of that experience.
- 13:55But even new car loans, just in the last two years have
- 14:01tripled their delinquency level.
- 14:03Used.
- 14:03Car loans have tripled and charge off levels.
- 14:06All the car loans are up to about 0.84
- 14:09charge offs.
- 14:10That's a pretty big charge off number.
- 14:12It was only 58 basis points in 2023, so it's a pretty substantial
- 14:17jump in that consumer loan.
- 14:19We do see a lot of credit unions making first mortgages and going
- 14:22back to home equity loans, charge offs with real estate loans.
- 14:25That actually held up pretty well.
- 14:27We're staying fairly small down at less than a couple basis points is all.
- 14:31So no one's charging off real estate loans at the moment.
- 14:34Residential real estate loans and commercial loans, which they
- 14:38haven't had the yo-yo growth.
- 14:39They've been growing pretty steadily at a moderate pace through all of this.
- 14:45And their delinquencies have creeped up a little bit, especially with
- 14:48some of the commercial industrial that actually improved in 2024.
- 14:54Now mid time of peaked in 2023, but commercial loan charge offs have
- 14:58been at 20 basis points is all.
- 15:00So that's almost one of the best performing pieces of the loan
- 15:05portfolios and credit unions out there.
- 15:07Residential real estate loans are doing the best credit quality wise.
- 15:11Commercial loans are doing the second best.
- 15:13Consumer loans are getting hit pretty hard in the last year.
- 15:15And so Todd, if you had to
- 15:17Farrar: A reason why the.
- 15:19Consumer portfolio has experienced this higher delinquency and losses
- 15:24Miller: because unemployment has went up in 47 states for two years in a row.
- 15:30Credit unions can't really control, the job market and they fall victim
- 15:35to those trends, and it's somewhat why some of that multi portfolio and.
- 15:39Multi-dimensional analysis is important to pay attention to what's
- 15:42going on with their portfolio.
- 15:44And it probably explains why your commercial loan losses are less is
- 15:48because you know you're doing annual reviews and talking to them and you can
- 15:52deal with problems and head them off early with your commercial borrowers.
- 15:56With the consumer loans, a lot of it's indirect lending.
- 15:59You maybe never talk to the member until it's delinquent and if the
- 16:03person's lost their job and they're delinquent, there's not a lot they
- 16:06can really do to help that member out.
- 16:08So that's kinda why you make sure you price things appropriately so
- 16:13you have some sufficient spread to cover those provision for loan losses.
- 16:17And like I said, with the per when charge offs are going up every year,
- 16:21that provision is going up every year.
- 16:24And Steve mentioned that earlier in our podcast, that whole growth in provision
- 16:29for loan loss expenses, spread here.
- 16:32It's,
- 16:33Farrar: Turning out to be a pretty big competitive disadvantage compared to the
- 16:36community banks 'cause they're not exper, they're experiencing higher delinquency,
- 16:41certainly consistent with our numbers.
- 16:43But they're PLL expenses is 0.15
- 16:48and ours is 0.60.
- 16:49So that is the difference between.
- 16:53Actual med income realized by credit union industry and the community banks.
- 16:58It's just that increased losses and certainly Todd, what as if inflation
- 17:02stays lower, that should be really helpful as I think that hurt a lot of
- 17:08people in the last, primarily year or so.
- 17:12Miller: Especially people at the lower income.
- 17:14I don't remember what the article was last year in the Wall Street Journal.
- 17:18It was a huge percentage of people can't cover a $400 expense outta cash.
- 17:23And when you get that inflation level like that, it hits those
- 17:27low income people pretty hard.
- 17:29And we have quite a few of low income and minority development
- 17:33institutions out there.
- 17:35The credit union industry does have a certain segment of credit unions
- 17:38that serve that low income audience.
- 17:40And I would suspect almost every credit union out there has a percentage
- 17:44of their members sit in that lower income stratosphere and you know
- 17:48that inflation hits them hard.
- 17:50When they get to unemployment, it takes 'em a couple weeks to get checks.
- 17:54They only get unemployment for 26 weeks.
- 17:56That job market is tough so that people in that, I don't know, bottom
- 18:0020%, bottom 30% of the, economic pile.
- 18:06It's really tough on them when they're facing inflation and unemployment is
- 18:10going up in, like I said, 47 states.
- 18:13Treichel: One of the, one of the things I heard that put that in good context
- 18:17for me was, in, if you have assets and there's inflation and you're in the
- 18:23stock market and the stock market's going up, you're not hit by the
- 18:28inflation as much, and you also have little bit less pressure on your income.
- 18:32So your stock funds are going up.
- 18:35You own real estate that's going up.
- 18:38If you're on the other end where you're struggling paycheck to paycheck and can't
- 18:42pay a $400 bill, and then that $400 bill 18 months later isn't a $400 bill, it's a
- 18:48$600 bill and you happen to lose your job.
- 18:51The barbells of the haves and the have nots have gotten more pronounced
- 18:55over these last several years, and it's, it's not a, it's not a good
- 18:58thing and it's gonna have continual issues that trickle into society.
- 19:03And we can, as we're talking about it, we're seeing that it's
- 19:05trickled onto the balance sheets.
- 19:07Miller: I think this gets distorted a little bit too by Covid.
- 19:10There was so much government assistance piled out to people
- 19:14at the lower income levels.
- 19:15It improved their credit score.
- 19:17So it actually made them more able to borrow money when the inflation started.
- 19:22So you had a temporary.
- 19:23You're almost hiding some of your higher risk people with all the government
- 19:27assistance that came out during Covid.
- 19:29So that's impacting this a little bit as well, and leading to some
- 19:33of these higher charge offs.
- 19:35I'm sure that's especially the case with the credit card portfolios that improved
- 19:39credit scores, that got these people a lot of new credit cards and they used
- 19:43them and now you got charge off that, 2.1%
- 19:48on credit cards in 2024.
- 19:50That's a pretty big charge off number for credit
- 19:54Treichel: unions.
- 19:55Said.
- 19:56Any final thoughts on asset quality guys?
- 19:59Miller: No other than you're gonna continue to see it's on NCUA.
- 20:02Supervisory priorities.
- 20:04And this is the reason, the delinquency and charge offs have been creeping
- 20:07up in just about every loan category.
- 20:10And credit unions, it's to your advantage to understand
- 20:14what's causing your charge offs.
- 20:16Is it unemployment?
- 20:17Is it's something else in your underwriting.
- 20:20So larger credit unions, make sure you're doing that analysis of
- 20:23your charge offs and figuring out, okay, what is the cause of this?
- 20:27And the second piece of it, it just comes back to you need
- 20:30to price for some of this.
- 20:31'cause it's likely to remain elevated for a while.
- 20:35Treichel: Good point.
- 20:35Good point.
- 20:37So the stats don't talk about the m and camels, so we'll jump
- 20:40over that over to earnings.
- 20:42Let's, yeah,
- 20:42Farrar: we talked to earnings.
- 20:43I'd like to get Todd's opinion because he's so well versed in
- 20:47the a LM thing and talk to the issues affecting the net margin.
- 20:52Miller: It's somewhat interesting, Steve, that if you look at NCUA.
- 20:57When they put out quarterly data, they put out a chart pack that's got 42 tables in
- 21:02there and about half of them are boring, but half of 'em are actually very useful.
- 21:06One of 'em I have in there is ROA components and they
- 21:09track it from 2015 to now.
- 21:12And we talk about, the net interest margin and it was fairly up to 3.2.
- 21:19In 2019, it fell to 2.6
- 21:21during covid.
- 21:22So it got really small, but it's actually improving back to 3.1.
- 21:26So it's back to where it historically was.
- 21:29It took credit unions 2023 and 2024 to adjust.
- 21:33A lot of 'em got beat up by their examiners, but that net
- 21:36interest margin has adjusted.
- 21:38What's really impacted credit unions is pretty much you've seen a
- 21:42decline in fee income that started in 2018 and continues to today.
- 21:48And I think part of that is the rising rates you're making.
- 21:50Yes.
- 21:50Less real estate loans.
- 21:52And I think some credit union are very sensitive to, Biden's whole era of
- 21:56junk fees and things of that nature.
- 21:58But fee income has come down, and then you talked about it right at
- 22:02the beginning of the podcast, that provision for loan loss expense.
- 22:07It was 30 basis points back, pre covid or back in 2015.
- 22:12It hit during the middle of Covid in 2021.
- 22:17You had 10 basis points of provision for loan loss expense,
- 22:21and in 2024 it's 62 basis points.
- 22:25So you've had, 50 basis points increase in PLL expense just in three years.
- 22:32So Freddy seemed to have recovered on that interest margin a little bit.
- 22:37They had made adjustments but they're still fighting that PLL expense and that
- 22:43fee income seems to have stabilized the last two years, but it certainly is down
- 22:48from what it was four or five years ago.
- 22:51And.
- 22:52And until rates fall and you start seeing real estate origination fees go up, I
- 22:56don't think you're gonna see much increase in fee income across the industry.
- 23:01There's just a lot of political pressures against it.
- 23:04Maybe with a new president that will subside for a bit, but the consumer groups
- 23:09complaining about, the, all those fees attached to overdrafts and things like
- 23:14that, I don't think that's gonna go away.
- 23:17It might.
- 23:18Simmer in the background for a while, but it's gonna come back to
- 23:21the forefront at some point in time.
- 23:23It's not gonna go away entirely.
- 23:24I don't think
- 23:26Treichel: that pendulum will swing any, anything that the data shows you
- 23:29on other, on operating expenses other than the PLL that jumps out at you.
- 23:35Farrar: Yeah, I, I, when I was an examiner I was always focused on,
- 23:39that was an area that we could make a difference and see it in the short
- 23:42run was adjustments and what we could do in the operating expense level.
- 23:47And, for the year op net non-interest expense was up 6.2%.
- 23:53The category is up the most, of course, employee compensation, which is about 7%.
- 23:59Operate office operations at six and a half and.
- 24:03Professional on the outside was up 7% mark.
- 24:06So you must be getting a lot of clients in there that are bringing
- 24:09that ratio up and hurting the cause.
- 24:12But and compared to what happened with community banks, their
- 24:15expenses same ratio went up 5.4%.
- 24:18So a little bit of difference there.
- 24:19But the other thing is when I pulled the income statement for the industry
- 24:24was all of the activity and the gains on derivatives, dis disposition of assets.
- 24:29Sale of loans and sale of other real estate owned gain from bargain,
- 24:34purchase, murder and other interesting.
- 24:36All those show a lot more activity and the other income figure of 14
- 24:42billion or is equal to basically equal to the net income for the industry.
- 24:47And that's the same for the last two years.
- 24:50Little interesting.
- 24:51Kinda change in the numbers from.
- 24:53What we've seen more historically
- 24:55Treichel: and that other, of those other, that reminds me of some things we've
- 24:58heard in credit union conversations is what's your core earnings?
- 25:02So if it that old, suzanne Vega line.
- 25:06It's a one-time thing.
- 25:07It just happens a lot.
- 25:09This year you sell your Visa stock.
- 25:11The next year you have some other oddball item that helps you show a profit, and
- 25:17then NCA comes in and focuses on core.
- 25:20Todd, any thoughts on what Steve had to say there?
- 25:23Miller: I was gonna mention the number of credit unions that had
- 25:26negative earnings last year, but I don't have that spreadsheet open and
- 25:29I didn't write it down in my notes.
- 25:31I didn't have time to actually go back and compare it from other years.
- 25:34But there are a not insignificant number of credit unions that are experiencing
- 25:40negative earnings at this point in time.
- 25:43Treichel: Yeah, that's always an interesting way to look at it too, is
- 25:46there's the winners and the losers on the net income in particular, and it's
- 25:49always a number when you look at it.
- 25:52It's bigger than you'd think.
- 25:53Every time you look at it, it's a good reminder that there's a
- 25:55lot of credit unions that are struggling and then that has them,
- 26:00what does that do to their capital?
- 26:01What does it do to their camel code?
- 26:03What does it do to how frequently NCA shows up and ask
- 26:05them about all those things.
- 26:07And I think, in my opinion, I think the pressure on merger will still be
- 26:11there, but not even having that number in front of us knowing it's probably
- 26:15knowing it's not a small number.
- 26:17I think there'll be pressures on mergers and such.
- 26:19Any thoughts on that?
- 26:21Farrar: I do have the numbers on merger though, that, that's in the
- 26:24the 10 year trends that's in the back of the recently released annual
- 26:28report and that we had 138 mergers.
- 26:32To assisted, and that's down from other recent years, slightly down.
- 26:38But and then when yeah.
- 26:40And then you get down to the, number.
- 26:41We can talk a little bit about the number of troubled institution
- 26:45and from that same report, 135 that are troubled credit unions.
- 26:4916 six, the its shares in millions is 16,000 in million.
- 26:56So the billion there, and that's a substantial increase in that we have much
- 27:01lar many larger, more or increase in the larger institutions that are trouble.
- 27:07Treichel: And for the listener definition of troubled
- 27:11Miller: camel four and five.
- 27:12Treichel: Yep.
- 27:13Miller: End.
- 27:14We'll talk about camel threes.
- 27:15I just want to point out another thing.
- 27:17During Covid, we were losing about 30 credit unions a quarter.
- 27:22I have Steve's data quarterly.
- 27:24Here in 2024, the quarters went 44, 34, 39, 32, so it's up a little bit.
- 27:32Actually in 2022.
- 27:37A couple years after Covid, that's when the mergers were really high.
- 27:40They were running about 50 a quarter.
- 27:44Treichel: Yeah.
- 27:44Was some, there was some pen up man there.
- 27:47Yeah, of course.
- 27:47The number, they're only charter one or two a year.
- 27:49The growth the percentage is a touch higher.
- 27:52Then when you just look at the gross numbers, well,
- 27:53Miller: surprisingly I have the percentage change in opinions.
- 27:57It's been 1% every year downward.
- 28:01There you go.
- 28:02We have less credit unions.
- 28:0360 a quarter is turned into 40 a quarter, but we went from 6,000 to 4,000.
- 28:08So we're basically losing 1% of our credit unions every year.
- 28:13NCOs chart pack that they put out, it goes back to 2015 by quarters.
- 28:17It's been 1% every quarter.
- 28:20I remember, it was like 10,800 or something when I started in 87, but
- 28:26that number that we lose every year just seems to be fairly constant.
- 28:30That's, yeah.
- 28:31Good point.
- 28:32Same with the community banks.
- 28:33If you look at the number of them, they disappear at about the same rate.
- 28:37Treichel: Yeah, unless two things that could impact that speed that
- 28:40up would be mergers of the agencies or loss of the tax exemption, which
- 28:44I've talked about on other podcasts.
- 28:46Most notably, one with former NCOA PACA director and former cuna guru John Ney.
- 28:52If you're interested in that, those topics.
- 28:54Check out that podcast.
- 28:56Alright, so let's see.
- 28:57We we, I think we're at LII got a feeling that, that we wanna hear
- 29:02from Todd Onel 'cause that all that capital markets knowledge.
- 29:06Miller: I would just say overall what you're seeing in 2024
- 29:09cash positions are improving.
- 29:12Credit unions are relying a lot less on borrowed money and non-member deposits.
- 29:17So I.
- 29:18Part of this is loan demand is way down, so they're actually able to
- 29:21improve their liquidity position.
- 29:23Short-term investments are still pretty low at 4.4
- 29:26of assets, long-term investments over three years, they're still 10% of assets.
- 29:30That's that hangover from 2022 still.
- 29:34But overall, in general liquidity levels are improving throughout the industry.
- 29:41Treichel: Good news.
- 29:42Good news and anything on, when I was back and still a regional director,
- 29:47it was camel instead of camel's.
- 29:48I still call it camel.
- 29:49'cause old habits die hard.
- 29:51Anything on sensitivity that you'd like to add to the mix?
- 29:55Yeah.
- 29:55Miller: Just a couple things.
- 29:56That long term assets are shrinking.
- 29:58That's an indication that interest rate risk is improving.
- 30:01The NCOA has beat people up over shares, migrating from non
- 30:05maturity shares into CDs and money markets and things of that nature.
- 30:09I will just say that there's gonna be a little bit of that at continuing.
- 30:14I have a chart.
- 30:14The share structure now is still less hot money than it was before
- 30:18the last recession in 2007.
- 30:21So we're reverting back to a main.
- 30:23People are rate sensitive, people are moving to rate sensitive accounts.
- 30:26That's gonna continue a little bit, although we're nearing the end of it.
- 30:30We talked about it already in net interest margins.
- 30:32They're back to 9, 20 19 levels, so hopefully there will be.
- 30:38Less pressure on credit unions to de-risk in terms of interest rate risk.
- 30:43'cause it's improving slowly too,
- 30:46Treichel: which is good news.
- 30:47As we wrap up those, we're gonna talk a little bit about what we've
- 30:50been seeing with our clients.
- 30:52Looking, looking at the watch.
- 30:54I know that, go ahead.
- 30:56Miller: I wanna say one sentence on camels.
- 30:59Okay.
- 30:59They have a.
- 31:01Chart and NCOs chart back for that too.
- 31:03In general, camel are improving with one exception.
- 31:07Code threes and those 500 million to 1 billion and 1 billion to 10 billion
- 31:12and over 10 billion are really been increasing the last three years.
- 31:17Under 500 million Camel codes are getting better.
- 31:20That.
- 31:21Over 500 million.
- 31:22The number of code threes has been growing for basically three years in a row here.
- 31:27I think it's just interesting 'cause usually those larger ones tend to perform
- 31:31better and that's not the case recently.
- 31:34Treichel: If I was a cynic, I would say in good times the bigger ones
- 31:38get treated a little kinder on camel, maybe appropriately and when when the
- 31:43economy gets a little bit more rocky and there are real or more material
- 31:50issues to raise with the big ones, NCA gets a little bit more aggressive.
- 31:53And that's what we're seeing.
- 31:55A little bit more maybe truth in colding in the big ones when there's really
- 31:58actually something to talk about.
- 32:00And the smaller ones tend to get beat up about operational type issues just
- 32:05because of their resources sometimes.
- 32:07So their camel codes, in my opinion are a little bit more reflective of that.
- 32:11And I don't, I know that we're gonna, we're gonna wrap this call
- 32:15up in about eight minutes because we, some of us on this call have to
- 32:19talk about some of the issues we just talked about with the client that's
- 32:22dealing with NCUA coming up very soon.
- 32:25With that let's talk a little bit about the things that we had.
- 32:29We had one podcast where.
- 32:31Which was one of our very popular ones.
- 32:33They're all relatively popular, but that one was particularly popular in the
- 32:38respect of talking about the things we've been seeing in our discussions with credit
- 32:43union's, clients, and other conversations.
- 32:45Let's hit those and use the rest of our time here on that.
- 32:48Miller: I think you know, the biggest concerns that we talked about here, the
- 32:52negative trends, are all having to do with asset quality that we spent a couple years
- 32:57where our clients were getting beat up about liquidity and interest rate risks.
- 33:01There's still a little bit of that going on, but their supervisory
- 33:04priority is on asset quality, and we are seeing a lot of that in our
- 33:09clients commercial lending programs.
- 33:12Even if there's zero losses, they're still getting criticized, especially on
- 33:16their risk rating and the annual reviews.
- 33:18There's a higher expectation of board reporting with commercial lending.
- 33:23And we haven't seen this for a few years, but in just the last six months, this has
- 33:27come up in two or three credit unions.
- 33:30NCOA is focusing on charge out policies.
- 33:32They want loans charged off.
- 33:34If they're not performing.
- 33:36And so there's always been an emphasis on concentration limits and NCOs
- 33:41asking credit unions to justify them.
- 33:44But what we've seen in the last six months, they seem to be
- 33:46getting increasingly granular.
- 33:49About the concentration limits, they're getting doors.
- 33:52It's like we don't want a concentration on indirect lending.
- 33:55We want one on, indirect lending.
- 33:57We want a concentration limit on high LTVs.
- 33:59We want a concentration on credit scores, less than six 40, things of that nature.
- 34:05And along with, we mentioned this with the losses appropriate pricing.
- 34:11We're seeing our clients get doors and findings on proving that your
- 34:15loan programs are profitable.
- 34:17And that one's at a very granular level too over time.
- 34:20They want it broken down into more finite and discrete
- 34:24portions of the loan portfolio.
- 34:25So that's a big one.
- 34:27That's new in the last, what, six to nine months that we're seeing.
- 34:33Good point.
- 34:34Treichel: Good point.
- 34:35Steve, any thoughts on those items that, that Todd?
- 34:40Farrar: No, I covered those.
- 34:40Anything that, one item that we were seeing as a really big focus was
- 34:44coming out, of course, FD seen all that was the corporate governance issue.
- 34:49And while the a kind of a proposed rule that was put out
- 34:52on there is very good guidance.
- 34:53It that was withdrawn with the change in the administration.
- 34:57And so I think, the examiner comments on corporate governance won't be as strong,
- 35:02but me personally, I still feel that area is one, when you strengthen that you
- 35:08really strengthen your institution and.
- 35:12Treichel: And you said it on the front end, but I'll repeat it.
- 35:14That was FDIC guidance.
- 35:15We've talked a lot about it here.
- 35:17We did podcast on the FDIC, guidance on corporate governance in 2024 and
- 35:212023 conversations with credit unions.
- 35:24We were seeing NCUA getting hit hard on that, and any topic that
- 35:29was brought up, they seemed to link it back to corporate governance.
- 35:32They seem to, on some of these issues we're seeing, they've seemed
- 35:35to maybe that's just not on their checklist of pushing it this year.
- 35:38'cause they seem to have backed off a little bit on that.
- 35:41I'll also say on the commercial loan topics, we have a lot
- 35:45of good podcasts on that.
- 35:47If you have commercial loans and you're getting beat up on that,
- 35:49feel free to reach out to us and or check out those podcasts.
- 35:54Which are with Vin Viton of our team, who helped write and was the major author
- 36:00of the current Commercial Loan Rule.
- 36:03Farrar: Yeah.
- 36:03One, one last thing, one thing that I've noticed that we were hearing a lot
- 36:06about is that our, a lot of our clients are saying that they're getting a lot
- 36:09of different examiners in, even they're experts, so they're having to be kind
- 36:14to work with the examiners and getting them familiar with their institutions.
- 36:17And I, that's something I think that might.
- 36:20Be an ongoing issue as we look into this year and that it's probably just something
- 36:24that it's gonna have to deal with.
- 36:26You got it.
- 36:26Good points.
- 36:28Todd, and there are
- 36:28Miller: some continuing things in the last three minutes.
- 36:31Yes.
- 36:31While liquidity has been beat up on a lot over the last couple years, it's
- 36:35less but we're still seeing a lot of credit unions get criticism on their
- 36:40liquidity contingency funding plans.
- 36:42Not in so much general liquidity, but the contingency funding plan.
- 36:47The early warning triggers.
- 36:49Seem to be a big thing that they're focusing on and having
- 36:52sufficient sources of liquidity for contingency funding purposes.
- 36:57Those still are recurring items.
- 36:59It's more defined in liquidity in general, but the contingency funding
- 37:03plans are still getting high degree of emphasis from the examiners,
- 37:07especially the early morning indicators.
- 37:10Treichel: Very good.
- 37:11And then enterprise risk management's been getting hit in the larger
- 37:14credit unions in particular, and eventually that will bleed.
- 37:18And I think also you were, one of the things we've been seeing is
- 37:22the profitability issues that we've been, that we've discussed here in
- 37:26the trends is something that we're starting to see brought up as well.
- 37:29Any final thoughts on recent exam issues, guys?
- 37:33Have issues
- 37:33Miller: with your examiners.
- 37:34Give Mark a call.
- 37:35We'll help you out.
- 37:36That's right.
- 37:36Treichel: Yeah.
- 37:37Call Ghostbusters or call us one of the two.
- 37:40Very good guys.
- 37:41As always this is a lot of fun and I will say one more time, the recent
- 37:45exam issues that I mentioned most of those we have separate podcasts on.
- 37:50So whether it's commercial concentration, loans, interest rate risk, liquidity,
- 37:54contingency funding, enterprise risk management we hit all of those in separate
- 37:58podcasts that you can find just by Googling or sending me an email and I'll
- 38:03send you a list of the ones that you want.
- 38:04Want me to track down for you?
- 38:06Alright, guys.
- 38:07Always enjoy this.
- 38:08Thanks so much for your time.
- 38:10Bye listeners, I want to thank you for listening as always.
- 38:13Hope you will listen again soon.
- 38:15This is Mark TriCal, signing off with flying colors