Latest / Politics with Paul / Lobbying: A Misunderstood, Necessary, and Flawed Institution | Politics with Paul #93
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08Before we begin, please like, comment, subscribe to the podcast on YouTube, Spotify,
- 0:15and Apple Podcasts, and share with all the people that you know.
- 0:19So today is going to be about lobbying, the misunderstood, necessary, and flawed
- 0:27institution of lobbying.
- 0:29Whenever you hear the term lobbyist, what do you think of?
- 0:34For many citizens, it conjures up images of nefarious and scheming individuals making
- 0:40shadowy deals with politicians that screw over the taxpayer, enrich powerful special
- 0:45interests, and ultimately pull all the strings of public policy.
- 0:51General perception of lobbyists is so considerably negative that some actual
- 0:55lobbyists have taken to calling themselves advocates instead.
- 0:59Now it's certainly true that some lobbyists are shady, corrupt, or at the very least self
- 1:05interested, and some of them downplay the seedy and disreputable side of the lobbying world.
- 1:14At the same time, however, the public misunderstands a lot about how lobbying works,
- 1:20and some have a shortsighted view of what to ultimately do about it.
- 1:25So for today's episode of the podcast, we're diving into lobbying, and that includes the
- 1:29similarities and differences between lobbying and advocacy, some of the misconceptions of
- 1:36lobbying by the public, some of the ways that lobbyists try to sanitize the profession, and
- 1:42why you probably don't hate lobbyists as much as you think you do.
- 1:46Well, let's talk about it.
- 1:49So first of all,
- 1:51is there a difference between lobbying and advocacy?
- 1:55Because some people do make a distinction, some people say that they're basically the same
- 2:00thing.
- 2:00You can ask multiple people in the professions of lobbying and advocacy whether and how
- 2:07different the two professions are, and get a different answer from each of them.
- 2:12In fact, when I was doing more research on this topic to put together notes for it, I
- 2:19encountered some of these differing takes.
- 2:21And the confusion and disagreement become even more pronounced when you include people that
- 2:26aren't lobbyists or advocates.
- 2:29And this could be for a variety of reasons, and they're not necessarily anything underhanded.
- 2:35They might be motivated to differentiate between the two because, for example, lobbying
- 2:40has a much dirtier, more negative connotation than advocacy does, which we'll explore in a
- 2:46little bit.
- 2:47They also might just genuinely be viewing it through different lenses where they're looking
- 2:53at it from legal definitions because there are legal distinctions between advocacy and
- 2:59lobbying.
- 2:59Or there might be a genuine misunderstanding about what the two are.
- 3:03So it could be motivated differences in the definition of the two, and sometimes it might
- 3:11not actually be motivated, but it can there can be all sorts of biases at play, or sometimes
- 3:17not necessarily a bias.
- 3:19It's just whatever the case may be.
- 3:21You ask multiple people if there is a difference between the two.
- 3:24Some of them will say yes.
- 3:25Some of them will say no.
- 3:27You ask if they do think there's a difference.
- 3:29You ask them what that difference is.
- 3:30Some of them will say one thing, and some people will say another, and then you have
- 3:34another group that'll say even something else.
- 3:37Now to be sure, there is a lot of overlap between lobbying and advocacy because
- 3:42you're whether you're an advocate or whether you're a lobbyist, you're ultimately trying to
- 3:47influence the passage of policy.
- 3:50It's just the way that you do it can sometimes be different.
- 3:55You might go through different avenues to do it.
- 3:57So the easiest way to think about and define advocacy and lobbying, how you differentiate
- 4:05the two, is advocacy is more just about generally arguing in favor of a cause or an
- 4:13idea, whereas lobbying is attempting to influence a politician on a specific piece of
- 4:18legislation.
- 4:19So advocacy is a lot more general.
- 4:21Lobbying is a lot more focused and targeted, and lobbying can be obviously the most common
- 4:27thing that you would think of is to directly contact legislators because they're the ones
- 4:32who are ultimately writing bills.
- 4:35But it doesn't have to be that necessarily.
- 4:37And a lot of times, you can't directly contact legislators because they have a whole bunch of
- 4:42people that are trying to get their ear.
- 4:45So you might contact that legislator staff, whether it's in congress, whether it's a state
- 4:50legislator, maybe you contact the president if we're talking about the federal government, or
- 4:55if it's state government, you might contact the governor.
- 4:58You might contact the governor's staff or the White House's staff or employees of government
- 5:04agencies that execute these policies, and you might try to influence the way
- 5:09that they interpret some laws on the books
- 5:12because there is some and depending on what whether you're talking about a state or federal
- 5:18governments or in which state you're talking about, yes, legislatures write policies, but
- 5:24the executive branch who has to execute these laws, they might have different interpretations
- 5:30than what the legislature intended.
- 5:32And that's that's a whole other discussion, but lobbying can be contacting any one of those
- 5:40people.
- 5:41And a couple of other differences that you can argue is that advocacy often focuses on general
- 5:47policy beliefs.
- 5:48Lobbying is about more the actual codifying of policies into law.
- 5:54Advocacy also is often more directed at the public while policy is less focused on the
- 6:00public, is more directly to the people in office.
- 6:04That is not always the case though.
- 6:06Sometimes lobbying actually does go more grassroots and sometimes advocating is more
- 6:11direct to people in office.
- 6:14But a lot of times, advocacy will be more public facing and lobbying is not as much about
- 6:20the public.
- 6:21But, again, not always.
- 6:23And also lobbyists, they can be
- 6:24thought of as more hired, more professionalized advocates in a way because all lobbyists
- 6:32advocate, but not all advocates lobby.
- 6:37So some more concrete examples of the differences between advocacy and lobbying.
- 6:43Advocacy might be telling a member of Congress or the or a state legislature how a policy
- 6:49affects constituents.
- 6:51Not necessarily saying specifically, you need to vote this way on a specific bill, but just
- 6:55saying, hey, here's what's going on in my district
- 6:58and with this group that I care a lot about.
- 7:03Or you use social media and publish reports to influence public opinion.
- 7:09For example, think tanks.
- 7:11A lot of
- 7:11times we'll put out published reports and use social media to try to influence public opinion
- 7:19about whatever the public policy is more in general.
- 7:22Not necessarily a specific piece of legislation, but just the public policy in
- 7:26general, whether it's for more gun control or less gun control for that's just one of many
- 7:33examples.
- 7:34Lobbying on the other hand is you're asking your member of Congress or the state
- 7:38legislature to vote specifically yes or no on a specific bill, or
- 7:44you may email if you have a
- 7:48group who has a lot of members, you might email them if they are subscribed to get email
- 7:52updates from your group to tell them to contact their legislators to vote yes or no.
- 7:58Or these lobbyists might make an online petition that's open to the public to try to
- 8:04get the public, the general public to push these legislators to vote yes or no.
- 8:11So legally, lobbying and advocacy are distinct in some ways because there are a lot
- 8:16more regulations on lobbying.
- 8:18For example, generally speaking, you can't give gifts as a lobbyist, and you certainly can't
- 8:24receive said gifts as an elected official.
- 8:29What contacts need to be reported publicly?
- 8:32Some states might be a little looser on that or some might be stricter on that.
- 8:38Like, does every single email that you send to a legislator have to be reported?
- 8:45Maybe not necessarily in some states, but in other ones, they might require that.
- 8:51As opposed to, like, if you're directly meeting one on one with that legislator, you will be
- 8:57required to report that publicly.
- 8:59What specific settings you can meet in?
- 9:02Sometimes they have, like, in down Florida, sunshine laws where you can't just have a one
- 9:07on one meeting.
- 9:08It has to be out in public.
- 9:10And if you are out in public, you have to
- 9:11have somebody else there with you, which is very it's a very oversimplified version of it.
- 9:17But if depending on what state you have, there might be more open access laws in that regard
- 9:26or how much
- 9:27of your business has to be made more public that can differ between states and what those
- 9:33regulations are.
- 9:34Whereas in general advocacy,
- 9:37a
- 9:37lot more of that is protected by First Amendment free speech rights.
- 9:41When you're advocating for something, there's you don't really have these kinds of
- 9:45regulations.
- 9:45Now, obviously, in certain contexts, advocacy will then start looking like lobbying if you do
- 9:50that.
- 9:51But advocacy for the most part, because it's just generally advocating for something, it's
- 9:57not as the rules regarding that are not necessarily as stringent, but that's the legal
- 10:04side of things.
- 10:06In practice, lobbying and advocacy can and often do look and operate the same way because
- 10:15many lobbyists also advocate for the general policy position in addition to saying you
- 10:23should vote yes or no on this specific bill.
- 10:26And then advocates often will eventually lobby as well or try to influence members of the
- 10:31public to lobby or contact their legislator regarding a bill.
- 10:39So where advocating ends and where lobbying begins can often be a murky lie, and it's part
- 10:48of why there's so much disagreement on whether advocacy and lobbying differ, and if they do
- 10:56differ, how exactly do they differ?
- 10:59And of course, a lot of lobbyists call themselves advocates as sort of a semantic way
- 11:03to avoid negative connotations of lobbyists.
- 11:06They are lobbyists even if they don't wanna actually say it openly because of public
- 11:13perception about about the profession of lobbying.
- 11:16But once again, it is still partly a divide in how people perceive how different and similar
- 11:25lobbyists and advocates are.
- 11:27Some of those lobbyists that
- 11:28call themselves advocates might genuinely see themselves as advocates even though they really
- 11:34are still lobbyists in the end.
- 11:36And then another another way I've seen them differentiated is that and this this this was
- 11:42part of a LinkedIn post I saw that sparked a lot of this idea for this episode.
- 11:47Basically, the differentiation it made was that advocates speak for those who can't while
- 11:51lobbyists speak to improve policy for everyone.
- 11:54Now, you tell that that distinction was made by a lobbyist?
- 11:58But I I do take some issue personally with that distinction because advocates absolutely can
- 12:05also speak on an issue for people that do have a voice.
- 12:08It's not just for people that don't have a voice.
- 12:12And you just arguing in general for a policy doesn't doesn't always have any regard to
- 12:20whether the people affected by that policy do whether they do actually have a voice or not.
- 12:26And even if the people that advocates speak on behalf of don't have a voice, they may be
- 12:33represented by an organization that does have a voice.
- 12:36So, again, where is that line between lobbying and advocacy?
- 12:41It can be very murky.
- 12:43And as
- 12:45much as I'm trying to make it as as obvious as possible what that distinction is, it still can
- 12:51be difficult to do for me as well.
- 12:54But basically, just generally think of advocacy as your genuine or generally, excuse me,
- 13:00arguing in favor of an idea or a cause, whereas lobbyists are attempting to influence a
- 13:07politician directly to vote specifically yes or no on a specific bill.
- 13:11That's the probably the most succinct way to differentiate the two.
- 13:17But what exactly is the role of a lobbyist?
- 13:20Because oftentimes, the public boils down a lobbyist role to overly simplistic phrases and
- 13:29terms.
- 13:29Maybe they'll just say as, oh, lobbyists, they just tell politicians to vote this way on a
- 13:34bill to receive x amount of campaign dollars, and then politician votes this way.
- 13:38Or that lobbyists write all the bills for legislators.
- 13:43In some cases, they do write the bills for legislators, but that's not the case in every
- 13:50situation.
- 13:50Or that lobbyist does x dirty thing and politician wants more of that so they vote the
- 13:56way that the lobbyist wants.
- 13:59Now in certain instances, maybe each
- 14:01of those things is a true statement.
- 14:05But like many
- 14:07things in politics and political commentary, those are overly simplistic ways to look at
- 14:12things because lobbyists have a lot of different responsibilities and duties that they
- 14:19perform.
- 14:21One of the most common ones that you hear lobbyists especially tell you is that they
- 14:26legit they they educate politicians on what is going on in that industry, and they do.
- 14:32They legitimately do educate politicians on certain policies because politicians, even
- 14:40though we often want them to have a 100% of the answers all the time, they don't have all the
- 14:45answers.
- 14:45Even about, you know, the industry that they're most involved with.
- 14:50Like, if they came from farming, for example, or from an agricultural background and they're
- 14:55in office or if they're from an engineering background or whatever the case may be.
- 15:00Even if you're an expert in your field, you can't know about everything that's going on.
- 15:04And as an elected official, you have to know at least a little bit about a whole bunch of
- 15:09different things that are going on in regards to public policy.
- 15:13Yeah.
- 15:14You can be very specialized, but there are so many things that government policy has to be
- 15:21involved in to some extent that they can't possibly know everything.
- 15:27So lobbyists do have that function of legitimately educating politicians on, hey,
- 15:35this is what's going on with this public policy.
- 15:37This is how it's affecting my client.
- 15:39This is how it's affecting my constituency that I'm from.
- 15:43Lobbyists also act as a liaison between governments and the private interest that the
- 15:48lobbyist works for.
- 15:50It's not as simple as just that specific interest talks to that elected official because
- 15:57that interest has a lot of other things that they're on their plate that they're dealing
- 16:01with.
- 16:01So they'll have somebody specifically geared towards government affairs, and they'll send a
- 16:07lobbyist to talk to that elected official.
- 16:11And then, obviously, lobbyists are, at least theoretically, supposed to have more of a way
- 16:19with words, so they might be better at convincing an elected official about the merits
- 16:25of their ideas and their causes and their bill that they support versus if somebody else from
- 16:33the industry, like if we're going to agriculture again, somebody who's a small
- 16:38business owner that deals with agriculture and farming, they might need somebody who actually
- 16:45can be capable of conversing directly with that government official to more effectively
- 16:52influence them to vote a certain way on bills.
- 16:55Lobbyists do also write some legislation, but politicians also still have to hammer the the
- 17:01final product out through legislative committees and full legislative chambers and
- 17:06the overall legislature, whether it's the state or whether it's a specific state or whether
- 17:11it's congress.
- 17:12And by that point, the legislation the lobbyist proposed can be far more modified so they don't
- 17:16necessarily get entirely what they they being the lobbyist want.
- 17:23Now that doesn't always happen.
- 17:24Sometimes the legislation barely changes, but it's not like every single case a lobbyist will
- 17:31write that legislation for that politician to put forth in their committees.
- 17:38And then those lobbyists then go back to their clients to tell them how amenable certain
- 17:44elected officials are to their clients' interests.
- 17:47Now a lot of times, those elected officials were already a little bit more amenable to that
- 17:54policy, especially as the parties have become more and more siloed in their respective you
- 18:00know, this is these are the specific kinds of clients and industries that typically align
- 18:05Republican, and these are specific clients and industries that typically align Democrat.
- 18:09Yes.
- 18:09You already have a little bit more of an idea of who's gonna be more amenable in the first
- 18:15place as the parties have become more uniform, but it still isn't always that obvious.
- 18:21There's still a lot of wheeling and dealing that you need to do.
- 18:24And then even though advocates tend to be more focused on influencing public opinion,
- 18:31lobbyists absolutely work to that end as well, especially if they can use it to push elected
- 18:38officials one way or another by saying, hey.
- 18:40You know, these constituents, we can tell them
- 18:42to vote against you or for you depending on how you vote on this bill.
- 18:47So, again, where's that line between advocacy and lobbying?
- 18:52It can get
- 18:53a little murky.
- 18:54But lobbyists, even though they operate more with directly going to that legislator, they
- 19:00can still use the public to to suit their ends as well.
- 19:05And speaking of the public, let's talk a little bit more about those public perceptions of
- 19:10lobbying.
- 19:11Because in basically every poll about public opinion that includes some question about the
- 19:18influence of lobbyists and relatedly campaign donors and money in politics in general.
- 19:24Not always the same exact thing, but all three of those things often go hand in hand.
- 19:29A large majority of Americans view those things as too influential on politics.
- 19:34And to be sure, they do often have undue influence.
- 19:38In a recent Pew Research Center poll, for example, 85% of respondents said it was a good
- 19:44description to say that, quote, special interest groups and lobbyists have too much say
- 19:50in what happens in politics, end quote.
- 19:53And then 73% of respondents in that same poll said that lobbyists and special interest groups
- 19:59are too influential on members of Congress.
- 20:01Two similar statements, but in polls, just changing around a few words, even if you think
- 20:07it wouldn't have that much of an impact, it really can have that big of an impact.
- 20:11Now, in contrast, when people hear the word advocacy, they tend to have a much more
- 20:17positive view.
- 20:18Who doesn't like an advocate?
- 20:19Oh, I like advocating for
- 20:20things that I care about.
- 20:22That's why a lot
- 20:23of lobbyists just call themselves advocates so that they don't get that derisive look from
- 20:29somebody who says, you're a lobbyist?
- 20:31That's gross.
- 20:33Who are you working for?
- 20:34And also another way that public opinion can be a little bit manipulated.
- 20:40If you specify particular political interest groups, almost all of which have somebody
- 20:47lobbying for them, opinion opinions on lobbying will differ much more than just the general,
- 20:54like, oh, I hate lobbying.
- 20:56Republicans, Democrats, and independents alike can largely say, yeah.
- 21:00Lobbying sucks.
- 21:01I hate lobbyists.
- 21:02But if you take specific groups, like if you're a conservative,
- 21:08the NRA, if you're a liberal, Planned Parenthood, even nonpartisan groups that
- 21:15independent middle of the road independents may support.
- 21:20Suddenly, if you talk about those specific groups, even though they lobby, you'll see
- 21:26certain groups on depending on what their party or ideological persuasion is, they'll suddenly
- 21:31be a lot more amenable to lobbying.
- 21:34It's a lot of it is the whole people generally hate lobbyists, but they're gonna be much more
- 21:39okay with it if it's a group that they support.
- 21:41So if it's a conservative Republican, they'll say that Planned Parenthood has way too much
- 21:48influence, but they probably won't say that about the NRA.
- 21:50And if you're a liberal democrat, you'll probably say that the NRA has way too much
- 21:55influence while Planned Parenthood is okay.
- 21:59And then if you're independent, maybe you support a talk about redistricting because
- 22:07right now that is a very salient topic.
- 22:10If you talk about a group that wants to push an independent redistricting commission, that's
- 22:15not left or right, but that is still lobbying.
- 22:20You are still lobbying for a specific policy.
- 22:22Republican, Democrat, independent, doesn't matter.
- 22:25Generally, a lot of them will say that they hate lobbyists and they hate lobbying as a
- 22:30whole.
- 22:30But if it's for an interest that they support, suddenly we and I'm not pretending that I have
- 22:38not been had this kind of opinion too.
- 22:41But then when you get to specific groups, suddenly lobbying sounds a lot more okay.
- 22:46Now it's not so much undue influence.
- 22:49Now, even though that is a critique of the public perception of lobbying, lobbyists
- 22:56themselves, of course, deserve some critiques too.
- 23:00We all do when it comes to this perception about lobbying and what it really is.
- 23:05Because lobbyists do somewhat whitewash their profession, and it's not even from a dishonest
- 23:11standpoint necessarily.
- 23:13Like, it's not just this
- 23:17scheming lobbyist is just trying to pull the wool over people's eyes so they don't see all
- 23:22the dirtiness that goes on lobbying.
- 23:25No.
- 23:25That's that's not necessarily true.
- 23:27Many lobbyists do work by the rules, and they do want to promote the not seedy side of
- 23:33lobbying.
- 23:34Many of them really do lobby for what they think is the right policy.
- 23:39And genuinely, even though, yes, they're trying to work for their client, they do often
- 23:43genuinely believe it is the best policy for people.
- 23:47But that being said, they obviously have a vested interest in downplaying the grimy parts
- 23:53of their profession.
- 23:55Yes.
- 23:56Lobbyists can and do educate elected officials about policies and their efforts on their
- 24:03clients and communities because politicians can't know everything that's going on.
- 24:10But what lobbyists see as quote unquote education can also be very biased and geared
- 24:16towards the client's goals.
- 24:18And, you know, we got
- 24:19the very well documented confirmation bias.
- 24:23All this data that supports our arguments, we're gonna bring
- 24:27it to the people we're trying to influence.
- 24:30All the data that doesn't support our argument, it's probably crap anyways.
- 24:33We're not gonna bother putting it out there because that hurts us.
- 24:36And it's not necessarily a conscious thing.
- 24:40But, yes, there's a
- 24:42lot of education that goes on, but it's not always true education.
- 24:47It's not necessarily objective.
- 24:50Yes.
- 24:50Some lobbyists truly want good policy, but their primary concern is about helping their
- 24:56client, which they are going to, of course, perceive as good policy because this is
- 25:01the client they're working for.
- 25:02If they didn't really think it
- 25:05was good policy for if they didn't truly believe it was good policy, they probably
- 25:09wouldn't be working for that client unless that client is just really paying them a whole lot
- 25:12of money, then that might be a different story.
- 25:15But of course, also good policy is subjective.
- 25:19I can look at a specific policy and say, Oh, wow, that one's great.
- 25:23And then you can go right back to me and say, Paul, you're an idiot.
- 25:26That's not good policy.
- 25:27What are you talking about?
- 25:29And then somebody else might say, Well, you both need to calm down here.
- 25:32There's some good parts of it and then there's some parts that are not good.
- 25:35What is good policy?
- 25:37It's it's not something that's easily defined because obviously people have different
- 25:43opinions about what actually is good policy.
- 25:46And yes, some lobbyists help to shape legislation in helpful ways, but many also have
- 25:52too much influence on the actual writing of bills.
- 25:55Sometimes having fully prewritten bills and often operate too much out of the public eye
- 26:01where it's very hard for the public to keep tabs on them.
- 26:05And even when news organizations, for example, bring all those private dealings to light,
- 26:13people still have to go and search for that information, have to internalize the
- 26:17information, have to understand what's going on and as if they don't have a whole bunch of
- 26:21other things that are going on in their lives because everybody's busy and especially people
- 26:26who are not involved in politics, they are gonna have limited time to be able to take in
- 26:33into account this information.
- 26:35So that can also help lobbyists operate more in the shadows compared to or because the public
- 26:43is it can be hard for them to keep tabs on what's going on.
- 26:46And yes, lobbying can strengthen democracy by acting as a legitimate conduit between
- 26:52government and private citizen private interest or the citizenry.
- 26:58But they can also weaken democracy because lobbying is slanted toward the most well
- 27:03funded, most organized, the biggest interest that there are.
- 27:08That does not mean that interests that are not any of
- 27:11those things can't operate, but they are obviously going to
- 27:15be at a disadvantage, especially if you're not organized.
- 27:19If you're unorganized, you're almost never going to win.
- 27:22And to be able to be an effective player in the realm of lobbying, you're gonna need some level
- 27:28of organization and funding.
- 27:30But that doesn't mean that just because you're not one of the big dogs doesn't mean that you
- 27:35can't compete to some extent.
- 27:38But it would be disingenuous to say that lobbying is not heavily slanted to certain
- 27:47powerful interest because it is.
- 27:49Now whether it is as much as some people think it is, it's a bit of a different discussion.
- 27:55But this brings me to one of the key points I really wanna talk about here before we end
- 28:00things.
- 28:02You may have you may remember from the very beginning, the very intro of this episode that
- 28:08I said you probably don't hate lobbying as much as you think.
- 28:12Now at risk of making a very arrogant statement by saying that, let me explain.
- 28:20Self interest does not inherently mean that you're acting in a dirty or unethical manner.
- 28:26It just means that lobbyists are primarily concerned about helping their client, which is
- 28:31what they were hired to do.
- 28:33So of course, they're going to try to do things that benefit who they're working for.
- 28:37And we also sometimes conflate self interest and selfishness with unethical and illegal.
- 28:44And I think part of it goes back to this whole when we disagree with somebody, more and more
- 28:49we tend to say that, oh, it's not just that we disagree with these people.
- 28:53These are terrible people.
- 28:54They're evil.
- 28:55They're stupid.
- 28:55These people should not be allowed to talk.
- 28:57I think you kind of that kind of attitude seeps in a little bit when it comes to lobbying where
- 29:03you see people act in a very self interested manner and assume that something untoward is
- 29:07happening.
- 29:08That's not necessarily the case.
- 29:10There's also not as much illegal activity that goes on in lobbying as some people think.
- 29:15Though, whether much of that activity should be illegal is a whole other discussion because
- 29:20some of it is still unethical.
- 29:22Not obviously, not trying to say that there isn't unethical or illegal activity that goes
- 29:26on because there most certainly is.
- 29:28But when it does happen, it tends to get overly highlighted compared to the stuff that is
- 29:34usually by the book because we like things that are we we tend to pay more attention to the
- 29:41things that are controversial, that are that we attach a negative label to, that we see as a
- 29:49more we're moral or wrong.
- 29:51When things are a lot more positive or moral or working as intended, we tend not to pay
- 29:58attention.
- 29:58It's it's a natural human bias that we have regardless of what our politics are.
- 30:03Now, is there a lots of or at least some dirtiness and problematic behavior that goes on
- 30:09in lobbying?
- 30:10Yes.
- 30:11Of course.
- 30:11Absolutely.
- 30:13Now how much there is is up for discussion, but it's generally not as bad or nefarious as much
- 30:20of the public thinks.
- 30:22There's also a fact that just about every entity that directly engages with the
- 30:27government has somebody lobbying for it, including the groups that we support.
- 30:33That political group that you agree with, that you think everything they do is great and that
- 30:36you're signed up for their newsletters and and they basically can do no wrong, but you hate
- 30:43lobbying?
- 30:44Oh, believe me, that group absolutely does lobby.
- 30:48Use the same examples that we had earlier.
- 30:51If you're conservative, the NRA, you
- 30:54might be very supportive of.
- 30:55If you're liberal, Planned Parenthood, you're probably very supportive of.
- 30:59Guess what?
- 31:00Both of them lobby.
- 31:01Even nonpartisan groups lobby.
- 31:04No matter how much you support that policy, how good you think that policy is, and no matter
- 31:09how much you hate lobbying, guess what?
- 31:12That policy has somebody lobbying for it.
- 31:14And it's not just specific political groups, that politician or candidate you support, guess
- 31:22what?
- 31:22They court lobbyists.
- 31:23No matter what they say.
- 31:24A lot of people talk a big game about how lobbyists have undue influence and I can't be
- 31:29bought and I'm I'm always gonna listen
- 31:31to the will of the people.
- 31:33That's not true.
- 31:35I'm not
- 31:35gonna say that they don't try to listen to the will of the people, but anybody who tells you
- 31:38that they they're not that they can't be bought or that they're never gonna listen to special
- 31:43interests, That's just not what's gonna happen.
- 31:46There are going to be lobbyists that have their ear.
- 31:49It might not be the usual groups you think of, but they will still listen to lobbyists.
- 31:54It's going to happen.
- 31:55So and a lot of times, it's the people who make the biggest fuss about lobbyists are the ones
- 32:01that are most beholden to them.
- 32:02Because, of course, nobody wants
- 32:04to admit that they're beholden to special interests.
- 32:06But when they really gotta go out of
- 32:10their way to tell you that they're
- 32:11not beholden to special interests, It's it's
- 32:14probably not true.
- 32:16And some of the negative perception about lobbying is not just how, oh, lobbyists suck in
- 32:22general.
- 32:22Some people straight up suggest banning lobbying.
- 32:27Now, some people that's probably partially sarcastic, but there are others who genuinely
- 32:31mean we should stop lobbying period.
- 32:35Not saying that a lot of people have suggested that, but it has been said.
- 32:40And there are some that want to at least severely curb lobbying.
- 32:44There are more than a few lobbyists that are slimy, that are unethical, they're dirty.
- 32:50Some even break the law.
- 32:52They don't just act unethically.
- 32:53They actually act illegally.
- 32:56But trust me, you don't really want lobbying gone or too heavily restricted.
- 33:01And here are some of the reasons why.
- 33:03Number one, you can't fully ban it anyway because there are too many powerful interests
- 33:07that would see to it that that does not happen.
- 33:10But more importantly, number two, the implications for First Amendment freedom of
- 33:15speech and the ability to petition governments would be highly negative because those rights
- 33:20are being infringed upon.
- 33:22You may have specific conceptions of these lobbying groups that have too much influence
- 33:28and you want to ban them, but guess what?
- 33:31If you're going to ban them, you have to ban a lot of groups, including ones that you support.
- 33:38Speaking of which, number three, interests that you do support, especially those with less
- 33:43influence, would have little to no recourse to get government to listen to them, especially
- 33:48with how much we talk about how government doesn't listen to us anyways.
- 33:52Number four, because the line is blurred between advocacy and lobbying, since there
- 33:57isn't a whole lot of agreement on where that line is and whether the two things are even
- 34:04different, Advocacy without lobbying is also going to take a hit because if you're trying to
- 34:10legislate out lobbying, a lot of legitimate advocacy is going to go by the wayside too
- 34:14because the way that you're going to codify it and say, we're going to ban lobbying, it's
- 34:19going to completely ban a lot
- 34:21of ways that advocacy happens too.
- 34:23And government is going
- 34:25to is going to respond and listen to us even less if we do that.
- 34:29And then the fifth biggest point to bring up about why you really don't want lobbying being
- 34:35banned or severely restricted.
- 34:38Not every special interest is a heavily partisan ideological or issue based one, and it
- 34:44it they're not necessarily Democrat, Republican, or independent.
- 34:47For example, your local government will lobby the state or federal for various reasons.
- 34:53Local governments a lot of times will lobby their state for more home rule or needing
- 35:00funding for local projects.
- 35:01Nonprofits that legitimately do good work will also lobby.
- 35:06So if we're trying to
- 35:07get rid of lobbying completely or heavily restricting it, guess what?
- 35:12All those groups, they're not gonna be able to do it anymore.
- 35:17And that's going to really hinder a lot of public policy.
- 35:20The ability for government to respond to whatever the issue is, it's not gonna be able
- 35:27to do that.
- 35:28It's gonna become even more bogged down and inefficient because people can't actually lobby
- 35:34the government or petition the government for things because you've severely restricted that.
- 35:39And they also aren't all private interests in industries where clients all have a ton
- 35:44of money, which is that typical conception of lobbyists.
- 35:49It's not, again, even though the biggest, most
- 35:52organized and most well funded groups are the ones that have the most power in the realm of
- 35:57lobbying, it is not always them who have that power.
- 36:00And also, even if we did ban lobbying, those groups still have a lot more recourse to
- 36:07influence
- 36:07government in ways that are not lobbying than these groups that have a lot less size and
- 36:15money
- 36:16than they would be able to do.
- 36:19So it's one of
- 36:19those cases where you think you're fixing a problem,
- 36:23but you're actually making the issues that you think that problem is causing, you're actually
- 36:29making the issues from that problem even worse because you've addressed it in completely the
- 36:33wrong way.
- 36:34So, all that to say that lobbyists are an important, albeit very flawed part of
- 36:41democracy.
- 36:43This episode is not intending to be an apologist for lobbying because I think I've
- 36:51made very clear that there is
- 36:52a lot of griminess that goes on in lobbying.
- 36:55But people
- 36:57do have a very skewed perception of what lobbying is, a very flawed perception of what
- 37:01lobbying is.
- 37:02Yes.
- 37:03Lobbyists do simultaneously pose a lot of problems for democracy and responsive
- 37:08government.
- 37:10That is true.
- 37:12But despite the profession's many flaws and considerable room for improvement, whether it's
- 37:19in terms of lobbyist conduct, the laws and regulations regarding lobbying because I can
- 37:25personally get behind making some of those rules tighter.
- 37:29Not saying that we can't make those things better.
- 37:32All that being said, lobbying is a necessary institution and to some extent has some First
- 37:39Amendment protection, especially when it comes to freedom of speech and the right to petition
- 37:46government.
- 37:48Properly evaluating, lobbying, and debating its influence, being honest about its pros and cons
- 37:53is necessary for improving public trust and political efficacy.
- 37:59Lobbyists need to be more cognizant of how the public perceives it.
- 38:04Citizens need to be more cognizant of how biased their perception about it is.
- 38:10Too many people feel that government is unresponsive, that it's beholden to a handful
- 38:16of powerful interests and not trying to give lobbying a proper appraisal of its pros and
- 38:21cons only makes those feelings worse.
- 38:25Because there's a lot of things that happen too often here.
- 38:27Lobbyists too often downplay the bad parts of their profession, and some of them try to push
- 38:33the envelope, try to push and bend the rules too much.
- 38:38Politicians and candidates too often let lobbying interests overly influence their
- 38:44policies instead of acting in a way that where they're generally trying to be genuinely good
- 38:51stewards for their constituents.
- 38:54And citizens too often misunderstand lobbying and have an overly negative opinion about how
- 39:00it all works.
- 39:02And addressing
- 39:05all of these angles is a critical necessary component to improving public trust and
- 39:12political efficacy, which is right now in the dumps.
- 39:17So it's just one of those many things in politics where we can all do better in
- 39:22perceiving what's going on and understanding where other people are coming from and trying
- 39:29to incorporate feedback from a bunch of different perspectives to try to fix the
- 39:35problem because there are plenty of things to fix about it, but there are a
- 39:39lot of good things that come from it too.
- 39:42So, yes, lobbying has a lot
- 39:45of dirtiness to it, but don't overestimate just how much negativity and problematic things that
- 39:54go on in the profession as well.
- 39:57And so that's gonna wrap things up here for today's episode of Paul Tips with Paul.
- 40:01As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 40:03Please like, comment, share, subscribe with all the people you know.
- 40:08And whether you obviously love hearing from people who enjoy this content and really like
- 40:14this content, but even if you have a critique, I wanna hear it.
- 40:18Maybe there's something I missed that I could have included here because all of us can
- 40:22improve at something.
- 40:23Right?
- 40:23We're all human beings, especially when it comes to politics.
- 40:26So if you have something else that you you you have
- 40:29a disagreement, let me hear it.
- 40:31Whether you wanna email it or put it in the comments or or reach out to me on LinkedIn,
- 40:37whatever the case may be.
- 40:38Speaking of which, my links, my Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker, LinkedIn profile, my
- 40:44medium.com profile, my five day educational email course about how we can all improve on
- 40:49how we can all do better about mitigating polarization, my email and my websites and my
- 40:57book on Amazon.
- 40:59So that's gonna end things here.
- 41:01So as always, thank you so much
- 41:02for listening, and we'll see you next time.