Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Conversation with Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye (Ret.)
Transcript
- 0:00I am April Zanis and together with Dan Bemel, we are the chairs of the BHBA Family Law section.
- 0:12We are very excited to bring you a conversation with the former Chief Justice of the California
- 0:17Supreme Court, Ann Anthony Storm.
- 0:21Chief Justice Tani Kuntil Sakauwe joined ADR Services in 2023 after a distinguished career
- 0:28as the 28th Chief Justice of California.
- 0:32A native of Sacramento, she earned her JD from UC Davis School of Law and began her
- 0:38legal career as a deputy district attorney with 32 years of service on California's
- 0:47appellate and trial courts.
- 0:49She was appointed by three governors, starting with her role on the Sacramento Municipal
- 0:53Court in 1990.
- 0:56About her tenure, Chief Justice Kuntil Sakauwe emphasized transparency and civic learning,
- 1:02leading initiatives to inform Californians about the judiciary.
- 1:07Anthony Storm is the founding partner of Storm Pallion, specializing in electronic security
- 1:13issues related to high-profile divorces.
- 1:16He safeguards private information for public figures and minimizes harm from potential
- 1:22disclosures.
- 1:23Prior to entering family law, he clerked for the U.S. Attorney's Office, where he received
- 1:28awards for outstanding service.
- 1:31Anthony has authored articles on family law, including a notable piece on representing
- 1:36individuals with notoriety, and he regularly lectures on various family law topics.
- 1:42We hope you enjoy their conversation.
- 1:46Thank you, April, for that wonderful introduction.
- 1:49It's much appreciated.
- 1:52Quick quote from the last panel.
- 1:54I couldn't agree more with the citation that said successful appellate practice begins
- 2:00at the trial court.
- 2:02The trial court are the building materials for the appeal.
- 2:05It is a foundation of all of your legal arguments, and when you miss a beat at the trial court,
- 2:10sometimes you can't go back.
- 2:12The follow-up quote that said if it wasn't in the record, it doesn't exist, couldn't
- 2:17be more true.
- 2:18I'd also like to thank all the judges and attorneys who are participating in this program
- 2:23for their time and effort.
- 2:25It's a wonderful program.
- 2:26Special thank you as well to Dan Bemmel and April Zanis for steering the ship here.
- 2:32We're going to have a great fireside chat with Justice Teni Kantil Sakaua.
- 2:38As we just heard from April, Justice Kantil Sakaua has done it all.
- 2:45You were a DA, Chief Justice, more than three decades on the bench, appointed by three governors,
- 2:53Duke Magian, Wilson, and Schwarzenegger.
- 2:57You started at the municipal court level in around 1990, moved up to the Superior Court
- 3:02in 1997, did criminal and civil assignments, and at that time established something that
- 3:08I think is near and dear to most of the viewers here, which is a specific domestic violence
- 3:14court in Sacramento.
- 3:17In 2005, you moved to the Court of Appeal of the Third District.
- 3:21Right now, you are CEO and president of the Public Policy Institute of California, where
- 3:29you hold the Walter and Esther Hewlett Chair in Understanding California's Future, as
- 3:34well as your part of ADR Services, where amongst other things, you handle mediations, case
- 3:42evaluations, mock trials, and act as a special master.
- 3:48We've spoken once before.
- 3:49I've had the opportunity to sit and watch you preside over Supreme Court matters.
- 3:56It's always been my impression that you conduct yourself with integrity, honesty, and you're
- 4:01a person of great moral character.
- 4:03We're very thankful to have you here.
- 4:08I know you're a Sacramento native.
- 4:10We chatted briefly about that.
- 4:12I mentioned before it, it's a special place for me.
- 4:16I went to law school about a mile away from where you went to high school.
- 4:21My old eldest daughter was born in Sacramento, a couple blocks from the state capitol while
- 4:27I was clerking for the U.S. Attorney's Office.
- 4:31And it's really, really a wonderful opportunity, and we are honored to have you here at the
- 4:3650th anniversary of this program.
- 4:38So thank you very much for participating.
- 4:41Thank you, Anthony, and thank you to the BHBA for inviting me.
- 4:45When it took time for me to register with the Bar Association, I looked who had the
- 4:48best MCLE, and I registered as a member of BHBA.
- 4:53Out of all of the different Bar Associations, I could have selected, I looked at your menu.
- 4:58So thank you, and thank you to April and to Dan for making this happen.
- 5:04So we've talked about all of your great experience, and it's very rare.
- 5:11In fact, I know of nobody else who sat on all levels of the court, municipal court, you
- 5:16were a DA, so much different litigation experience sitting on both sides of the fences.
- 5:24I imagine preparing for a case at all those different levels is completely different.
- 5:30In your experience, what did you see as the biggest difference in adjudicating matters
- 5:35at each level?
- 5:36Thank you, Anthony.
- 5:37That's a really good question, because each level requires the judicial officer to bring
- 5:43a different set of skills and statutory construction.
- 5:47And so I will say at the trial court, the different skills that a judge needs to bring,
- 5:53frankly, is to clear the decks, to allow the attorneys to do the best they can in the well
- 5:59in the arena and let the attorneys try their case.
- 6:03So in other words, get all of the heavy lifting out of the way for the judge, that is, all
- 6:08the motions in liminame, all the anticipated questions, all the nuts and bolts, so that
- 6:13the attorneys aren't distracted, so that the judge isn't distracted, so there are very
- 6:17few surprises, few interruptions, and making sure that an understanding as a trial judge
- 6:26that I need to let people make their record, and I want the attorneys to make their record,
- 6:30especially in those instances where the attorneys are denied or are limited, offers of proof
- 6:35are very important, as you know, as an appellate specialist.
- 6:39And so it is really important that this record and the judge sort of stay out of the way
- 6:44and let it happen, and also allow the attorneys to speak to sidebars on the record when they
- 6:50aren't recorded, or a summary of what happens in chambers when they aren't recorded, because
- 6:55the appellate court really wants to know, and more and more appellate justices who don't
- 7:00have a trial background, they need that context.
- 7:03At the appellate level, very different.
- 7:06We're reading the book, and as you so eloquently put it earlier, if it's not in the record,
- 7:10it didn't happen, even though we know something happened, even though we know it happened,
- 7:15but we are not allowed to review that or talk to our colleagues about that.
- 7:19And at the appellate level, we keep in mind that we follow the rule of law, we follow
- 7:25all of the precedent, we follow our different colleagues' analyses if we agree with them,
- 7:30but they're not otherwise binding.
- 7:32The conflict amongst the appellate courts and the divisions they're in are what makes
- 7:37for important Supreme Court review.
- 7:40At the appellate level, the appellate justice has to be thinking, I'm writing so my Supreme
- 7:45Court colleagues can understand fully where I am on the standard of review, why I have
- 7:51phrased my analysis in this way.
- 7:54I'm speaking frankly to the court so they better understand what my work was at the court
- 7:59of appeal.
- 8:00And also, this is an opportunity for the appellate justice to be able to invite the attorneys
- 8:07to do supplemental briefing and new cases and to ensure that what's before the court
- 8:12of appeal at that time, that it's being litigated is truly the state of the art that we know
- 8:17it to make the best kind of case possible, because very likely there'll be a petition
- 8:23for review out of that particular litigation.
- 8:27And at the Supreme Court, that's a whole new ball game because now there are seven different
- 8:31law offices with very different business models, very different backgrounds, looking and very
- 8:37different geographical backgrounds, diversity backgrounds, age backgrounds, practice backgrounds.
- 8:43And so we very often at the Supreme Court start from scratch because we don't assume
- 8:47the knowledge that we have is homogeneous and it's not.
- 8:52So this is where we have to be very patient, very collaborative, take our time, allow all
- 8:57arguments to develop and to be really civil and respectful with one another because we
- 9:02are supposed to disagree and we're going to handle a lot of cases that we hope will shape
- 9:07the law.
- 9:09You talked about the importance of making a record, having offers improve, making sure
- 9:14everything is recorded.
- 9:16Right now there is a huge access to justice issues.
- 9:19There are not enough court reporters.
- 9:21In our last panel, one of the panelists said it's almost impossible in her experience to
- 9:27get a settled statement.
- 9:29So what sort of opportunities might there be for these litigants who can't afford a
- 9:34court reporter, who don't know the local rules about requesting that the hearing be recorded,
- 9:41which is a relatively new thing we have in Family Court and LA Superior Court.
- 9:48What in your mind can be done to sort of to alleviate this problem with people who don't
- 9:55know and maybe can't even afford to bring their own court reporter?
- 10:00You have really touched upon an access to justice issue that existed long before this
- 10:04chronic shortage of court reporters that we've read about in the last four years because
- 10:09family law, at least even when I was on the trial court back in the 1990s for 14 years,
- 10:16suffered from an inability to have court reporters in the family court courtrooms because they
- 10:23were used elsewhere by way of statutory priority for some criminal and otherwise civil.
- 10:31And it was very, very difficult.
- 10:33That's only exacerbated over time with family law judges having to write their own records
- 10:39and heavy case loads without a recording.
- 10:43And many, many times I have spoken to the legislature and to Governor Brown and to Governor Newsom
- 10:49that this is where this is the most critical piece of access because family law is about
- 10:55families and children and support.
- 10:58And we must have a record because on appeal, as all of you know, the judgment is presumed
- 11:04correct.
- 11:05And it is the appellants role to prove error and without a record, we will assume there
- 11:12was no error.
- 11:13Even when I was on the court of appeal, there were virtually few records out of family law
- 11:18courts.
- 11:19And so we would basically have to either dismiss or affirm.
- 11:24And that really puts people who have no control over this because court reporters at one point
- 11:29were all staffed in the courts, but they were now, they became court employees, but they
- 11:35still had a fair amount of freedom.
- 11:38And so now the system has become acute because now we have just a shortage.
- 11:42We don't have enough bodies.
- 11:44All of us are aware of the different counties and especially let's just say LA where we
- 11:48are with this bar association that put out signing bonuses that pleaded with people to
- 11:54please come and be a court reporter.
- 11:56And we know that that was to no avail.
- 11:58And I think Los Angeles boldly did the right thing as you referred to with that order and
- 12:02that rule, Anthony.
- 12:04And that is to allow people to make their own record because I think that you'll, that
- 12:09kind of argument will be sympathetic and persuasive to courts of appeal who are all aware that
- 12:15our hands are tied.
- 12:17We can't encourage any particular profession.
- 12:19We tell and ask and plead with the governor's office and the unions, but there's just no
- 12:24more bodies becoming court reporters.
- 12:26And the truth is across the country, they have turned to technology in lieu of court
- 12:30reporters, although court reporters have been re-engineered for different purposes to make
- 12:34a record, but they're not taking a verbatim.
- 12:37And we also know all court reporters have always recorded the work that they're doing
- 12:42as backup.
- 12:43So I think it's an incredible fiction to say there's any due process lost by not having
- 12:47a court reporter.
- 12:48But I do think we have to push the envelope.
- 12:50The envelope has to be pushed by innovative ways because I think those kinds of arguments
- 12:55that get to the court of appeal as to who that panelist who said, I can't get a settled
- 12:59statement, so you find some way to get a settled statement, whether you record it on your cell
- 13:03phone, but you make that argument.
- 13:05That's the argument that the courts of appeal will resonate.
- 13:09They will speak to it and it will catch the attention of the Supreme Court.
- 13:13Rules will change.
- 13:14Judges will write to it.
- 13:17It's still though, it's going to be a problem.
- 13:19We have to change the technology.
- 13:20There's no other question.
- 13:22Other states have done it.
- 13:24California just has a strong union hold.
- 13:26I could go into some terrible stories about that, but the truth is it is about jobs and
- 13:30labor and it's changing.
- 13:32It has to change.
- 13:33Well, you have such unique experience in navigating between the judicial branch and intersecting
- 13:39with the government, getting these issues accomplished and challenges overcome like
- 13:45these court reporter issues.
- 13:48Talked about technology and how that can help things.
- 13:51I guess the one positive thing that may have come from the pandemic is the pushing for the
- 13:57courts to adopt so many new technologies.
- 14:00We had remote appearances come, e-filing, document management, document sharing.
- 14:07There are obstacles balancing budget needs and adopting technology.
- 14:13Artificial intelligence, for example, is now in its infancy, but progressing at an extremely
- 14:18astounding pace.
- 14:21In terms of technology, what do you see as the future of the court?
- 14:26Thank you, Anthony.
- 14:27What people have to know as a baseline when we talk technology in the court is that prior
- 14:32to the pandemic, there were a number of legislative statutes that prohibited the court from using
- 14:37technology.
- 14:38So much so that we had to report every year to the legislature what technological devices
- 14:44we were purchasing because they didn't trust us not to use technology.
- 14:49And the reason they didn't want us to use technology, I'll just be clear and I can speak
- 14:53as a retired, is that because they were concerned it would take over jobs.
- 14:57So mark that because that's the same argument over AI.
- 15:01But let me say what happened is while we were within these constraints where we were prohibited
- 15:05by law from electronically recording felonies and all civil, we found out that during the
- 15:14pandemic when everything turned around and upside down, the governor gave me as the
- 15:19chief justice and the judicial council the power to suspend statute in an executive order.
- 15:25This power to suspend statute allowed me and the judicial council to lift all of those
- 15:31prohibitions.
- 15:32So we immediately went into remote appearances, remote arrangements, as much remote and hybrid
- 15:38that we could encourage because we didn't want to bring people into the courts.
- 15:44We didn't want to bring jail populations into the courts.
- 15:46We didn't want to have the transportation.
- 15:48We didn't know how the virus was spreading.
- 15:50We have a lot of vulnerable populations in the courts.
- 15:53We just didn't want the spread to have be a super spreader.
- 15:57So we were very innovative in COVID because I and the judicial council suspended as many
- 16:03statutes as we could to allow remote access thereafter when there was a concern whether
- 16:10or not by suspending trials and suspending hearings and blowing the three year rule and
- 16:16blowing the five year rule, whether or not there'd be litigation over all of those actions
- 16:21taken in that emergency.
- 16:23A senator came in and asked me a lawyer and she said, what do you need to legitimize everything
- 16:28you did during the pandemic?
- 16:30So she wrote a statute that legitimized all of our actions.
- 16:34It also was the proving ground as Anthony has referenced for the court to begin even greater
- 16:41more systemized, normalized technological use, which you're seeing now.
- 16:46There's still a fair amount of distrust as the legislation is the remote access legislation
- 16:52has a sunset date, has a data, has a pilot.
- 16:55I have said to the governor before I left, we've had three years of pilot.
- 16:59What more do you need?
- 17:01It's an option.
- 17:02It's not a requirement.
- 17:04It's cleared caseloads.
- 17:05It's made things more accessible.
- 17:08I don't know that you can point to a single negative.
- 17:12And so it continues to be a struggle.
- 17:14Now the new monster on the block, so to speak, is AI because AI is, as you pointed out, Anthony,
- 17:21it's growing.
- 17:22No one knows what it is.
- 17:23All we can do at this point with AI is to provide guidelines and also ethical rules around
- 17:29its use because it's changing so rapidly in my role as the president of the Public Policy
- 17:34Institute of California.
- 17:35We're a think tank.
- 17:37And so I'm putting together a group of researchers and PhDs to come up with ethical guidelines
- 17:43that researchers can and cannot use in purposes of AI.
- 17:47But all of us have used AI.
- 17:49And AI is a great starting point for our work.
- 17:52It's just not the end point for our work.
- 17:54And the people I trust the most with AI, frankly, are lawyers because lawyers are critical,
- 17:59thinkers.
- 18:00Lawyers will question the source.
- 18:01They'll run it down.
- 18:02They'll find out if it's true.
- 18:04They'll find out if it's still true.
- 18:06That critical thinking has to be, I think, really spread across all users.
- 18:12But no question, AI is confounding all disciplines.
- 18:17It's going to be, as you all know, a huge disruptor of knowledge professions, which is
- 18:21new to all of us.
- 18:23It can never supplant.
- 18:24It can never take.
- 18:25It can never be the end all because it is generative.
- 18:28It's looking off of the worldwide web.
- 18:31But we have to be in control of it.
- 18:34And we have to make sure that it's not being abused.
- 18:38And that's going to be the role of the attorneys who are boots on the ground with the use of
- 18:42AI in practice by their clients in business and in court.
- 18:47We're certainly entering a new era of technologies.
- 18:50And I'm sort of a technology guy.
- 18:54I follow everything.
- 18:55I love it.
- 18:56I adopt everything and see how it works.
- 18:58And I'm certainly looking forward to some of the efficiencies that it might create in
- 19:03both of our practices and on the bench.
- 19:07You briefly touched the floor on family law and the importance of the record.
- 19:13One really clear thing everybody in this audience knows that I think is one of the most important
- 19:18and core examples of the California Constitution and the US Constitution is the statement,
- 19:26be the people.
- 19:27It's maybe perhaps to me the most personal statement in the Constitution.
- 19:33Courts are the arm of the government that established justice for the people.
- 19:40Family law being very special and very personal.
- 19:44You talked about the importance of having a record.
- 19:47It's more than just a collection of courtrooms.
- 19:50You get to know families.
- 19:51You get to work on fixing relationships.
- 19:55You help victims of domestic violence.
- 19:57I think family law attorneys really, really do some good.
- 20:00It's something that's really close and important to me.
- 20:04I also surmise giving your involvement with domestic violence issues that you share this
- 20:09belief.
- 20:12With that in mind, we see that there's a right to counsel and criminal actions.
- 20:16But nothing that I see is perhaps more fundamental and personal to people are litigating their
- 20:24family law issues.
- 20:27So many litigants seem to be lost in the process and without the availability and the ability
- 20:33to afford counsel.
- 20:35Do you have any insight on anything that can be done to improve this issue?
- 20:42You have put your finger again on a really critical longstanding challenge in the judiciary
- 20:47and in the legal profession.
- 20:50We always point to family law when the statistic comes up that over three quarters of civil
- 20:57cases have at least one party unrepresented.
- 21:01We also know that when we train new judges who typically go into family law as a first
- 21:06assignment in many courts, that the population of pro-per can be anywhere from 70% to 80%.
- 21:14And you're absolutely right, knowing that the United States Constitution, the California
- 21:20Constitution has recognized that family and parenthood and parenting is a basic right,
- 21:28a fundamental right, entitled to greater due process than other rights.
- 21:32It's significant that we do not provide that kind of counsel.
- 21:37We do provide, the courts have provided, and we have run pilot programs like the Civil
- 21:42Gideon Project, which does in some counties, we have funding, and it's over now probably
- 21:4815 years old, where we do provide counsel or we provide an organization that provides
- 21:57assistance to support the pro-say party in court.
- 22:03We do a fair number, and I'm not saying this is in any way sufficient, and I'm not saying
- 22:08because the gold standard is a lawyer on the other side in a family law case.
- 22:14That's the gold standard.
- 22:15The gold standard is something we have never been able to meet.
- 22:18So we have a lot of piecemeal efforts.
- 22:21We have AmeriCorps.
- 22:22We have kiosks.
- 22:24We have training.
- 22:25We have bots that can walk you through the process.
- 22:29We have and train the new judges and the judges in family law to be better prepared to work
- 22:35more patiently with pro-pers to use the time wisely so these hearings don't have to be
- 22:39continued and repeated.
- 22:42We have made a number of efforts.
- 22:45None of them are sufficient.
- 22:46We've gone to the state bar on numerous times to ask for pro bono work, to ask for support,
- 22:54and they also mean well, but when it comes to getting something like this passed before
- 22:59the state bar board of trustees, which for some period of time in my administration were
- 23:04elected, now they're basically appointed, it's a difficult challenge.
- 23:10People have very strong emotions about changes in family law.
- 23:14The lawyers, the different groups that are interested.
- 23:19When I ran the judicial council, the public policy arm of the judiciary of the third branch,
- 23:25we had public comment.
- 23:26Public comment at every single meeting was family law litigants.
- 23:31There was never negligence litigants.
- 23:33There were never breach of contract litigants.
- 23:35There were always people who had been through family law and who felt that somehow, some
- 23:40way the judge had shafted them.
- 23:43It was a constant.
- 23:45We took it to the legislature and we found a legislator who had a hearing about what
- 23:49can we do in this area about representation.
- 23:52It still eludes us, but I think you're absolutely right about recognizing that court appointed
- 23:57council with the appropriate funding ought to be permitted, ought to be encouraged, ought
- 24:03to be piloted somewhere.
- 24:05We have tried a lot of little programs that still aren't doing justice to it and you've
- 24:09pointed out perennial problem.
- 24:12Thank you.
- 24:13It's really insightful answer and I appreciate all those insights.
- 24:17You also spoke about lawyer's ability to reason when discussing technology.
- 24:23How does a bench officer look at each issue to help think about and resolve those problems
- 24:27that are before it?
- 24:29Well, a bench officer under the X party rule has to be very careful because the bench officer
- 24:35can only look at the briefing and what's submitted as part of the briefing or is in evidence.
- 24:43If we were to look at the canons and the ethical rules pretty strictly, I'm not supposed to
- 24:48go on the internet to know what a hydraulic lift looks like in the litigation that I'm
- 24:53trying to figure out.
- 24:54Someone was injured.
- 24:55What does that even look like to me?
- 24:57I have no idea.
- 24:58Even when I go online to look at it, I feel a little, huh, I probably shouldn't be doing
- 25:02this because it's not in the record.
- 25:04Historically, judges at all levels of bench, like humans, there are some early adopters
- 25:11like yourself and there's others who abhor technology, never want to learn it, don't
- 25:16want to figure it out, hate it and find every reason to avoid it.
- 25:20Now, I would like to say that those dinosaurs are retiring and we have a new crop coming
- 25:25in and they're used to technology.
- 25:27So we'll see technology pick up speed with users who are used to it and demand it as
- 25:31judges.
- 25:32But I was on the, this is dating myself, but I was on the court when computers were introduced
- 25:37to individual chambers and judges were like, I'm not touching that.
- 25:41It's that Chief Justice Ron George, a man I love and respect when I walked into his office
- 25:46to take over, his computer was in a corner unplugged, facing the wall down near his bathroom.
- 25:52He never used that thing.
- 25:55So we are getting and changing the hearts and souls and minds of new judges, but they
- 26:00are constrained.
- 26:01They are not supposed to go outside the record looking for things when it comes to briefings.
- 26:08With that in mind, I mean, everything that we present the court is their role to view
- 26:12these cases with.
- 26:14What can we do as an, as attorneys to better prepare both if for litigation and mediation?
- 26:22There's obvious, of course, like exchange briefs and, but
- 26:26Sure.
- 26:27Well, let me start with a mediation because in mediation, maybe you don't have to go to
- 26:33the mat if you think there's a chance that it might resolve because you have done enough
- 26:38discovery to know that there's leverage on each side.
- 26:42So the best case for mediation prepared by the attorneys is to know the case and to know
- 26:49the weaknesses of your case and to know therefore why it is you might be open to some kind of
- 26:56agreement.
- 26:58Also in mediation, it's really important for the attorneys to prepare their client for
- 27:03that different kind of setting.
- 27:05It is a place to talk, to be heard, to, to try to resolve.
- 27:09It's not a place to stand on your binary rights and how right you are on the law and how you
- 27:16know you're going to get this ruling because you don't know that.
- 27:19But a lot of clients are not prepared and attorney needs to prepare.
- 27:23Litigation is you have to be prepared, think like your opposition.
- 27:27You need to prepare like your opposition and you need to prepare to your weak spots.
- 27:31And some of those weak spots, it depends on the nature, has to be disclosed to the court
- 27:37in full disclosure.
- 27:38But it is about preparation.
- 27:40That's why an attorney's job is so hard and so long.
- 27:44It takes a long time.
- 27:47What advice would you give to new attorneys who are just coming into the practice of law?
- 27:52I would say to new attorneys first that you develop really strong, healthy habits, not
- 27:58only about taking care of yourself and your family, but also about how you work.
- 28:03I think that you need to set boundaries.
- 28:05But just to be clear here, you're going to work on the weekends and you're going to
- 28:08work at night if you expect to be successful, whether you're in private sector or public
- 28:12sector.
- 28:13Also, to the extent that you can keep a record of your research so that you don't have to
- 28:17reinvent the rule every time something comes up in a summary judgment motion that you think
- 28:21you heard about, attend CLEs.
- 28:24Attend as much as you can, even if it's not on your subject area.
- 28:28Listen and get to know and find out what the other areas of law are.
- 28:33New attorneys, you should join things.
- 28:35You need to network.
- 28:36You need to find out how other attorneys are operating, job operations, different modes
- 28:40of appearances in different courts.
- 28:43And I think if you ever think you want to go to the bench, you need to start keeping
- 28:46a strong record of your cases, keeping it updated.
- 28:49Because if you do ever decide to try to get appointed, you're going to have to fill out
- 28:53like a 30-page single-space application that's going to ask you everything about your practice
- 28:58and you want to be able to answer that.
- 29:00So it is about keeping a record.
- 29:02It's about being prepared.
- 29:03It's about committing to working hard.
- 29:05Well, that's great advice.
- 29:08I wish I had done some of those things in my practice.
- 29:11I wish it.
- 29:12I've always created a record of everything I've done.
- 29:15I think that's really important for new attorneys to do.
- 29:19Do you have a particular vision for the future of the courts?
- 29:22Yes.
- 29:23I think that the vision of the courts is that we are going to have more options that are
- 29:30more streamlined that are in greater and plainer English, that we will reconsider, I think,
- 29:38some statewide rules that seem and just do a vetting of those rules with the different
- 29:43attorney groups to find out whether or not they're still relevant and useful.
- 29:48I think we can look to other states that have gone, for example, fully remote and fully
- 29:55automatic in courtrooms.
- 29:58There aren't court reporters, but there is a record and that record can now be accessed
- 30:02on appeal in a really exciting way.
- 30:06The trial court's record can be used on the appellate court by actually clicking in on
- 30:11the link and actually hearing the testimony.
- 30:15There's a number of things I think technology is going to bring us, but it's going to bring
- 30:18us efficiency.
- 30:19We have to be careful because we don't want to lose the human touch.
- 30:22We still, that is the nature of law, is our ability to be and work in conflict, but do
- 30:27so civilly.
- 30:28But I think technology is really going to change the court and the court needs to be
- 30:32aware of it because that's what the public will demand.
- 30:34I thank you so much, Your Honor.
- 30:36I mean, I thought this was a fascinating program.
- 30:40Discuss the intersection of the judicial branch and government, integration of technology
- 30:44in the court and what we as litigants can do better.
- 30:48I found so much value in this program.
- 30:51I very, very much appreciate you coming today.
- 30:55I wish we had so much more time because there's so many more things I could ask.
- 31:01And it truly, truly was an honor to have this opportunity.
- 31:05Thank you.
- 31:06Thank you, Anthony.
- 31:07I appreciate it.
- 31:08I also still remember your case in front of the California Supreme Court.
- 31:12Won't mention it, but I think you did win.
- 31:14So there you go.
- 31:15Thank you.
- 31:16It was a pleasure.
- 31:17Your honor.
- 31:19You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 31:22Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.