Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Unitary Business Theory and New Limits on Taxing Nonresident Sole Proprietors
Transcript
- 0:07Okay, Philipp, and you can start. Good morning,
- 0:16or good afternoon. I'm Philipp Berendt, chair
- 0:18of the BHBA tax law section. The tax section
- 0:21is sponsored by Hochmann Zock and Toscha Perez.
- 0:24The Hochmann -Socken -Tosch -Opera SPC advantage
- 0:26is experience, an eye for innovation, and a genuine
- 0:29dedication to clients, the families, and the
- 0:31business. In addition to their national practice
- 0:35in civil and criminal tax controversies and related
- 0:38litigation in federal and state courts, the firm
- 0:41is also active and successful in handling other
- 0:43non -tax, white collar investigations and prosecutions.
- 0:47I'm delighted to introduce our speaker today,
- 0:49Robert Horowitz. Robert is an attorney at Hoffman's
- 0:52Hawk and Toscia Press with over 35 years of experience
- 0:55representing clients in civil and criminal tax
- 0:57matters, including audits, appeals, collection
- 1:00issues, criminal investigations, and trials in
- 1:02both federal and state courts. He has served
- 1:07on the Executive Committee of the Taxation Section
- 1:10of the State Bar of California, including as
- 1:13Chair of the Taxation Section for 2015 to 2016
- 1:17and as former Chair of the Tax procedure and
- 1:20litigation committee. Robert, take it from here.
- 1:24Okay. Thank you, Philip. Next slide. We're going
- 1:27to be discussing the unitary business theory
- 1:31and its limits focusing on a recent California
- 1:35court of appeals case, Garcia Rojas versus Franchise
- 1:40Tax Board. Next slide, please. Okay. The Uniform
- 1:47Division of Income for Tax Purposes Act or UDIPTA
- 1:52was established to have a standardized method
- 1:55for apportioning income among the states in which
- 1:58a multi -state business operates to ensure that
- 2:01the business is not taxed by two states on the
- 2:05same income. And in California, it sets code
- 2:09section revenue tax code sections 25 120 to 25
- 2:15139. And the first step that's done in UDIPTA
- 2:19is to allocate income between business income
- 2:23and non -business income. Non -business income
- 2:27is allocated to specific states based on the
- 2:32type of income. One type of non -business income
- 2:36for a sales or manufacturing company would be
- 2:41rental income. office building where its headquarters
- 2:48is and it operates in California, but the headquarters
- 2:52is in Kentucky. Part of the space it rents out
- 2:57that would be non business income. Business income
- 3:00is apportioned among the states in which the
- 3:03company does business based on an apportioned
- 3:07formula. Originally there were was a three factor
- 3:11apportionment formula based on. apportioning
- 3:15income based on sales, property within the state,
- 3:21and payroll within the state. But now many states,
- 3:25including California, focus just on sales within
- 3:29the state for purposes of apportionment. Next
- 3:32slide. Business Theory is a method of apportioning
- 3:41the income of a multi -state business among the
- 3:44states in which it does business by determining
- 3:47what portions of the business are going to be
- 3:51included in the tax base for the state. And the
- 4:00Unitary Business Theory had its genesis approximately
- 4:04140 years ago. in a property tax case involving
- 4:10Union Pacific Railroad where Union Pacific was
- 4:19Cheyenne, Wyoming, taxed Union Pacific on its
- 4:23rail lines that went through Cheyenne. And to
- 4:27determine the value of those rail lines, it valued
- 4:30the entire Union Pacific rail line from Chicago
- 4:35to San Francisco and determine the value of the
- 4:39entire rail line and then determine what percentage
- 4:43of the rail line was in Cheyenne to determine
- 4:47the. Amount of the value of the rail line in
- 4:54Cheyenne and the Union Pacific. attacked that
- 4:59on the basis that it should only be taxed on
- 5:02the value of the rail lines that were physically
- 5:06in Cheyenne and the Supreme Court rejected it
- 5:09and held that the entire rail line was a single
- 5:13unit and it therefore was sensible to tax it
- 5:18as a whole unit and base valuations on just the
- 5:24percentage that went through Cheyenne, Wyoming.
- 5:27business unitary business theory evolved and
- 5:32by 1941 the free unities test was formulated
- 5:40by the California Supreme Court in Butler Brothers
- 5:43versus McCogan which was affirmed by the US Supreme
- 5:48Court. Butler Brothers was a wholesale company
- 5:53based in Chicago that had seven wholesale distribution
- 6:00facilities, one of which was in California. And
- 6:04each distribution facility kept a separate accounting
- 6:09records of income and expenses. And California
- 6:15determined that the entire business of Butler
- 6:21Brothers should be taken into consideration and
- 6:25the net income apportioned apportioned to California
- 6:34of the entire business and shouldn't treat the
- 6:38separate facility in California as a separate
- 6:42business and the California Supreme Court developed
- 6:47what was known as the three unity test which
- 6:50to be a unitary business. There must be unity
- 6:54of ownership, unity of operation, and unity of
- 6:57use. Next slide. And unitary of ownership requires
- 7:05some bond of ownership or control. And under
- 7:08UDIPTA, unity of ownership exists if one corporation
- 7:13owns or controls more than 50 percent of the
- 7:15voting stock of another corporation. Unity of
- 7:19operation exists if two or more related corporations
- 7:22have common operations, including centralized
- 7:26purchasing, centralized advertising, centralized
- 7:30accounting, and centralized management. And unity
- 7:33of use exists if the corporations share an executive
- 7:39force or one corporation controls the executive
- 7:43function of the other, and the three unities
- 7:46were found to exist in the Butler Brothers case.
- 7:51Next slide. The second test is the contribution
- 7:57or dependency which involved derived from Edison
- 8:01California stores versus McLaughlin, which is
- 8:06at 30 cal second at 472 and that in that case
- 8:16the court. Enunciated a. Contribution or dependency
- 8:23test, which was quote if the operation of the
- 8:28of the portion of the business done within the
- 8:31state is dependent on or contributes to the operation
- 8:36of the business. Without the state. that contribution
- 8:43or there was contribution or dependency and the
- 8:47business operation is unitary and the that case
- 8:53involved a Company based in Atlanta that had
- 8:58stokes that sewed women's shoes handbags and
- 9:02accessories and they had stores in a number of
- 9:06states including in California and they set up
- 9:09a separate corporation for each state to that
- 9:15would own the stores in that state and they argued
- 9:20that they were different than Butler Brothers
- 9:23because each Butler Brothers dealt with one company
- 9:27that Corporation that did business multi -state
- 9:33and here each corporation was separate and the
- 9:37California Supreme Court held that there was
- 9:40a Contribution or dependency and that also the
- 9:45case was substantially similar to Butler Brothers
- 9:49So even if the three unities test didn't apply
- 9:54The company corporations contributed to each
- 9:58other and were dependent on each other. And therefore,
- 10:02Edison California stores income nationwide had
- 10:07to be apportioned, including to California. Then
- 10:11the next significant case was AM Casso Company,
- 10:16which was a meadow. processing company, which
- 10:22purchased a subsidiary from whom it bought tubes
- 10:29and metal bars, which it then processed and sewed
- 10:35to its customers. And the California Court of
- 10:38Appeals applied the contribution or dependency
- 10:43test to determine that the companies were Unitary
- 10:49and the court in AM CASO noted that the two tests
- 10:53are basically alternate tests and that they overlap
- 10:58in many areas and factors used in one test often
- 11:02are used in the other test. Next slide, please.
- 11:08And so the FTB has applied the unitary business
- 11:11theory to situations where not only Our two commonly
- 11:17controlled corporations are commonly controlled
- 11:20entities, but I've also applied it to tax the
- 11:25business income of a non resident using Udipta
- 11:28apportionment rules. And the lead case on that
- 11:32was the Office of Tax Appeals, Binley case, where
- 11:35a non -resident screenwriter contracted with
- 11:39two California LLCs. He wrote screenplays for
- 11:43them, never came to California, did all of his
- 11:46work out of his home in Arizona. And the OTA
- 11:52held that he was conducting business both within
- 11:58and outside of California and that his business
- 12:03was unitary business and thus his business had
- 12:07to be apportioned to California under UDIPTA
- 12:10and there have been several OTA cases which applied
- 12:17Binley to other cases involving non -resident
- 12:21sole proprietors. Next slide. This brings us
- 12:25to Dr. Garcia Rojas. And Dr. Garcia Rojas is
- 12:33a radiologist who resides in Texas. He became
- 12:40an independent contractor for a California -based
- 12:44company called Stat Radiology Medical Corporation.
- 12:48And Stat Radiology does teleradiology. They retain
- 12:55um and contract with radiologists throughout
- 12:58the companies and Radiological and other images
- 13:03are sent to the radiologists who then provide
- 13:06reports um to the medical facility in California
- 13:14and other states that conduct the radiology and
- 13:19then statrad paid for Dr. Rojas to be credentialed
- 13:25in California and 28 states. They provided hospital
- 13:30privileges for him in California and the other
- 13:33states paid for medical malpractice insurance
- 13:36for him in California and the other states and
- 13:39the only state for which they did not. pay for
- 13:43his credentials or provide hospital privileges
- 13:47or malpractice insurance was his home state of
- 13:51Texas. Stat Red also gave him the hardware necessary
- 13:56to read the images. It sent him along with a
- 14:00phone number, a California mailing address, an
- 14:03email, and trained him how to use their software.
- 14:07and Dr. Garcia Rojas never performed any services
- 14:12under the contract in California and never came
- 14:17to California for training or any other purpose
- 14:21for his contract with StatRest. Next slide. Now,
- 14:27unlike the taxpayers in Binley and the other
- 14:36cases, where there was a notice of proposed assessment
- 14:41issued, and the taxpayers protested the notice
- 14:45of proposed assessment. And when that proved
- 14:48fruitless, went to the Office of Tax Appeals,
- 14:53Dr. Garcia Rojas did not file income tax returns
- 14:57in California for 2018, 2019, or 2020. and Dr.
- 15:04Rojas reported his income from StatRAD on his
- 15:08federal schedule Cs. So the FTB contacted Dr.
- 15:14Garcia Rojas and requested that he file returns
- 15:17and report the income from StatRAD. Rather than
- 15:22ignoring the FTB and waiting for a notice of
- 15:25proposed assessment to be issued, Dr. Garcia
- 15:28Rojas' filed returns for the three years reporting
- 15:35the income from STAT RAT that was Alicaba to
- 15:38California, paid the tax due and filed a refund
- 15:42claim. And when more than six months passed without
- 15:46the FTB acting on their refund claim, they brought
- 15:50a refund suit in the Superior Court for San Francisco
- 15:56County. And in California, you can only bring
- 16:01a refund suit and accounting in which the Attorney
- 16:04General has an office. So that would be San Francisco
- 16:08County, Alameda County, Sacramento County, Fresno
- 16:12County, San Francisco, San Diego County, and
- 16:16Los Angeles County. And The FTB moved for summary
- 16:21judgment, which was granted by the Superior Court,
- 16:25holding that as a sole proprietor. Ms. Dr. Garcia
- 16:29Rojas was conducting a unitary business, and
- 16:33he had to apportion his income to California.
- 16:36Next slide. Okay. And so, The California Court
- 16:52of Appeals initially began its analysis by discussing
- 16:56the taxation of non -residents, and non -residents
- 16:59are taxed on income derived from sources within
- 17:04California, and to compute taxable income of
- 17:08non -resident who has sources of income within
- 17:11and outside of California, the income is allocated
- 17:15in proportion under regulations prescribed by
- 17:19the FTB. And if the non -resident's business
- 17:23is so proprietor that carries on a unitary business
- 17:27inside and outside of California, the net income
- 17:30derived from within the state is determined under
- 17:34UDIPTA rules. Next slide. And this is where the
- 17:41court starts to part ways from the Superior Court
- 17:45and the OTA. First, the Court of Appeals held
- 17:53that the Superior Court aired in determining
- 17:57that Dr. Garcia Rojas operated a unitary business.
- 18:01There was no authority to support the FDB's claim
- 18:05that a sole proprietor engaged in a single business
- 18:09activity and receiving compensation from one
- 18:13corporation as a unitary business, and no court
- 18:17has ever applied the unitary business theory
- 18:20to a single person or a sole proprietor engaged.
- 18:24in one business activity and that in all of the
- 18:30California cases, unitary business has long been
- 18:35recognized as being two or more business entities
- 18:40commonly owned and integrated in a way that transfers
- 18:44value within the affiliated entities. And since
- 18:48Dr. Garcia Rojas at most operated so proprietorship
- 18:54engaged in one business activity, the unitary
- 19:00business theory did not apply to the facts in
- 19:03his case. Next slide. And the court noted that
- 19:13the OTA's decision in Binley is not binding on
- 19:18either the Court of Appeals or any California
- 19:21court and it found the court's OTA's reasoning
- 19:25unconvincing and according to the Court of Appeals,
- 19:31Binley focused on tests to determine whether
- 19:34two different businesses are unitary and it ignored
- 19:38that there must be separate business activity
- 19:41to unite and also the regulation the FTB relied
- 19:46on only applies if two or more businesses of
- 19:50a single taxpayer. And here Dr. Rojas, only Garcia
- 19:54Rojas only had one business and that it was therefore
- 20:00not a unitary business. And so the court reversed
- 20:04and remanded the case to the superior court.
- 20:07Next slide. Now then the California. The FTB
- 20:14has petitioned the California Supreme Court for
- 20:18review, and the case has been officially reported
- 20:22in the California appellate courts. So, unless
- 20:28and until the Supreme Court grants the FTB's
- 20:32petition for review, Garcia Rojas can be cited
- 20:36as precedent. If review is granted, it may be
- 20:41cited for persuasive value only, but any citation
- 20:45to it must note that review has been granted
- 20:49by the Supreme Court of California. Next slide.
- 20:54And if the California Supreme Court denies the
- 20:59petition review, or grants the petition and affirms
- 21:02the Court of Appeals, the FTA will no longer
- 21:06be able to use the unitary business theory to
- 21:09tax non -resident sole proprietors who conduct
- 21:14a single business just because they perform services
- 21:18for California clients, and Binley's decision
- 21:22will effectively be overruled. And any sole proprietor
- 21:28who paid tax and income from services performed
- 21:31outside of California for California clients
- 21:35should consider filing a protective claim for
- 21:39refund. And that would include Binley and the
- 21:43cases that followed Binley if the statute of
- 21:47limitations on filing a refund claim is still
- 21:51open in California. It the statute limitations
- 21:56on filing a refund claim is the later of four
- 22:00years after the return is filed or one year after
- 22:05the tax is paid and. Now then I personally feel
- 22:11that the decision in Garcia Rojas was correct,
- 22:17but I am not quite sure I agree with the courts
- 22:21rationale that. Dr. Garcia Rojas did not have
- 22:28a unitary business. I feel my position would
- 22:34be that Dr. Garcia Rojas, since he performed
- 22:38services only in Texas, never came to California
- 22:42to conduct business, didn't conduct business
- 22:45in California. He was not conducting business.
- 22:50conducting a trader business within California,
- 22:53and therefore he shouldn't be taxable in California.
- 22:58And if Dr. Garcia Rojas, rather than entering
- 23:03into a independent contractor relationship with
- 23:07StatRat, had been engaged as a W -2 employee
- 23:13who performed all his services in Texas, he would
- 23:17not have been taxable. in California on the income
- 23:21he received from stat rent. Next slide. Now then,
- 23:28the FTB has used the unitary business theory
- 23:30to tax non -residents who, through a non -resident
- 23:35partnership, had a gain from the sale by the
- 23:39non -resident partnership. of an interest in
- 23:42a pass -through operating company that did business
- 23:45in California. And the lead case on that is appeal
- 23:49of Smith. And there have been several other cases,
- 23:53including appeal of El Varco, which involved
- 23:59a contact lens company that was the business
- 24:08largest independent contact lens company in California
- 24:12and if and the issue is and in many of the cases
- 24:18where the FTB has used the independent unitary
- 24:22business theory involving partnerships they have
- 24:28the FTB has looked not to whether the partnership
- 24:33was You know, they basically look at well the
- 24:42partnership is Has a unitary business with its
- 24:46partnership interest so someone who was who owns
- 24:50only 10 or 15 percent of a partnership interest
- 24:54could be taxed on Is or her income from sale
- 25:06of the partnership. And normally the unitary
- 25:11business theory has looked to corporate businesses
- 25:14that owner control more than a majority of the
- 25:20voting stock of an entity. And therefore I think
- 25:24there may be a grounds based on Garcia Rojas
- 25:28if it's affirmed by the California Supreme Court
- 25:32to attack the FTB's position regarding taxpayers
- 25:38who own indirectly a minority interest in a partnership
- 25:44that does business in California. The court in
- 25:52first question from Jack Russo, can any of these
- 25:58points or authorities be used to establish alter
- 26:01ego and or successor liability? The court in
- 26:07Garcia Rojas noted that it was not determining
- 26:11whether or not there could be another theory
- 26:19by which the FTB could have taxed Dr. Garcia
- 26:23Rojas since they relied solely on the unitary
- 26:27business theory. But an alter ego could apply
- 26:37in a unitary business theory where a one corporation
- 26:45controls another or an individual controls a
- 26:49business entity and the business entity and the
- 26:55individual are so closely intertwined that the
- 27:00business entity can be treated as the individual's
- 27:03alter ego and obviously if their successor liability
- 27:09would normally be for sales tax or EDD taxes
- 27:16and you know but some of the same factors that
- 27:22would apply to a unitary business could be applied
- 27:31to the parent of a subsidiary that goes out of
- 27:36business owing sales tax or employment taxes.
- 27:42And no briefs have yet been filed in the California
- 27:46Supreme Court in the Garcia Rojas case because
- 27:51the petition for review is still pending. And
- 28:00then The 45 -day rule, I believe you are referring
- 28:07to the Revenue and Taxation Code provision regarding
- 28:15an individual who resides in California, who's
- 28:21a California resident who contracts with an employer
- 28:25to work outside of California for more than 18
- 28:30months. and they will not be considered California
- 28:37employees if they do not come back to California
- 28:41for more than 45 days. And so Dr. Garcia Rojas
- 28:49was the Texas resident and never performed services
- 28:56within California. So that wouldn't be applicable
- 28:59to his case. And I believe those are all the
- 29:04questions. And I believe, so that basically wraps
- 29:21up the case. We'll have to wait to see whether
- 29:24California Supreme Court will grant review. in
- 29:28the Garcia Rojas case. If it grants the FTP's
- 29:32petition for review, you will not be able to
- 29:34cite Garcia Rojas as precedent that is binding.
- 29:41If it does not grant review, it will be binding
- 29:45and it will be a big blow to the FTP's efforts
- 29:49to tax out -of -state sole proprietors who do
- 29:53not conduct business in California. Thank you.