Latest / The History of Austria: Empire, Collapse, and Reinvention — Fexingo History / The Habsburgs and the Spanish Inquisition: Family Ties and Religious Terror
Transcript
- Lucas: So today we’re going to wade into some dark waters — the Spanish Inquisition and the Habsburgs. Now we’ve talked about the Habsburgs a lot on this show — their marriages, their wars, their reforms. But the Inquisition brings together two things the family really cared about: dynastic power and religious uniformity. Luna: Right, and the Inquisition existed before the Habsburgs, didn’t it? It was started by Ferdinand and Isabella. Lucas: Exactly. The Inquisition was established in 1478 by the Catholic Monarchs — Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile — with papal approval. Initially, it was aimed at conversos — Jews who had converted to Christianity, often under pressure — who were suspected of secretly practicing Judaism. But the institution really took off after the Habsburgs inherited the Spanish throne. When Philip the Handsome married Joanna of Castile, their son Charles V became the first Habsburg king of Spain in 1516. And the Inquisition became a key tool of state control under Charles and especially under his son Philip II. Luna: So the Habsburgs didn't invent it, but they definitely weaponised it. Lucas: Yes. Charles V was a devout Catholic who saw the Inquisition as a way to enforce orthodoxy across his vast empire — Spain, the Netherlands, Naples, the Americas. He expanded its reach. But it was Philip II — the quintessential Habsburg — who really made it a central pillar of his rule. Philip governed a global empire from his desk in El Escorial, and he believed that religious unity was the only way to hold it together. Dissent was treason. Heresy was a disease. Lucas: The Inquisition operated through a network of local tribunals, each led by an inquisitor. The head of the entire system was the Grand Inquisitor, a position often held by a Dominican friar. The most infamous was Tomás de Torquemada, who served under Ferdinand and Isabella, but later Grand Inquisitors were very much Habsburg appointees. For example, Cardinal Diego de Espinosa served under Philip II, and he was also president of the Council of Castile — so the overlap between church and state was complete. Luna: What was an auto-da-fé actually like? I know it means 'act of faith', but I've seen dramatizations that make it look like a big public spectacle. Lucas: That's exactly what it was — a highly choreographed public ritual. An auto-da-fé typically took place in a town square, with the condemned wearing a sanbenito — a yellow garment painted with flames and demons. The ceremony included a sermon, the reading of sentences, and then the handing over of those who refused to recant to the secular authorities for execution. The church didn't technically execute anyone — it 'relaxed' them to the civil power, which then carried out the burning. It was theater of terror, designed to intimidate the population and show the power of the Inquisition and the crown. Luna: And who were the targets? I know conversos were early on, but later it seems like it shifted. Lucas: The targets evolved. Initially, conversos were the main focus, but after the conquest of Granada in 1492, forced conversions of Muslims produced moriscos — Muslims who converted to Christianity, often superficially. Many of them were suspected of crypto-Islam. The Inquisition also went after Protestants, especially in the 16th century when Lutheran ideas began to spread. And there were also cases against bigamy, blasphemy, and even superstition. But it was never a mass terror in the way we might imagine — the numbers of executions were relatively low compared to other persecutions in Europe. Over its almost 350-year history, the Spanish Inquisition executed somewhere between 3,000 and 5,000 people. But the psychological impact was enormous. Luna: Still, that's a lot of people. And the Habsburgs used it in the Netherlands too, right? That's where the Duque de Alba comes in. Lucas: Absolutely. That's a crucial point. When the Dutch Revolt began in the 1560s, Philip II sent the Duke of Alba — Fernando Álvarez de Toledo — with an army to crush the rebellion. Alba established the Council of Troubles, which the Dutch called the 'Consejo de Sangre' — the Blood Council. It was essentially an Inquisition-style tribunal that tried thousands of suspected heretics and rebels. Alba had hundreds executed, including the counts of Egmont and Horn. That brutal repression actually fueled the revolt rather than ending it. The Inquisition became a symbol of Spanish tyranny in the Netherlands. Luna: So the Inquisition didn't just stay in Spain — it followed Habsburg power. Lucas: Exactly. The Inquisition's jurisdiction extended to all Spanish territories, including Sicily, Sardinia, and the Americas. In the New World, it was used to police the faith of colonists and indigenous converts, though it was often less harsh than in Europe because there were fewer trained inquisitors. But the point is, wherever the Habsburgs ruled, the Inquisition — or something like it — was present. It was part of the imperial toolkit. Lucas: Now, one fascinating figure who navigated this world was the Jesuit Francisco Suárez, a theologian who argued that the pope had no direct temporal authority over kings — a controversial position that could have gotten him in trouble. But he was protected by the Habsburgs because his ideas supported royal power against papal interference. So the Inquisition was selective — it could be used to silence opponents of the crown, but also to protect allies who promoted Habsburg-friendly theology. Luna: So it wasn't just about religious purity — it was a political weapon. Lucas: Precisely. And the Habsburgs understood that better than anyone. Philip II used the Inquisition to control the flow of ideas — books were censored, foreign students were monitored, and any criticism of the monarchy was treated as heresy. The Index of Prohibited Books was enforced rigorously. That's part of why Spain's intellectual life stagnated in the 17th century while other parts of Europe were experiencing the Scientific Revolution. Lucas: The Inquisition also targeted the moriscos with particular severity. In 1568, a morisco rebellion in the Alpujarras mountains was brutally suppressed, and then in 1609, under Philip III, the moriscos were expelled from Spain entirely — about 300,000 people. That decision was supported by the Inquisition, which argued that the moriscos were a fifth column for the Ottoman Empire. Luna: That expulsion must have devastated the economy in some regions. Lucas: It did huge damage, especially in Valencia and Aragon, where moriscos made up a large part of the agricultural workforce. But the Habsburgs prioritized religious purity over economic common sense. That's a recurring theme in their story. Luna: I've also read that the Inquisition had a role in suppressing the Spanish mystics — people like Saint John of the Cross and Saint Teresa of Ávila were investigated, even though they were later canonized. Lucas: Yes, that's true. Both were investigated by the Inquisition for alleged 'alumbrado' tendencies — that is, claims of direct divine illumination, which could be seen as a challenge to church authority. They were eventually cleared, but it shows how the Inquisition could target even the most devout if their practices seemed unorthodox. The line between mysticism and heresy was thin. Lucas: The Inquisition declined in the 18th century, under the Bourbon kings who replaced the Habsburgs after the War of Spanish Succession. But it wasn't formally abolished until 1834, under Isabella II. By then, it had been a shadow of its former self for decades. Luna: So the Habsburgs and the Inquisition — they really were intertwined for nearly two centuries. Lucas: They were. The Inquisition gave the Habsburgs a tool to enforce unity, and the Habsburgs gave the Inquisition the political backing to operate with terrifying effectiveness. It's a reminder that religious institutions are never just about faith — they're also about power. Luna: Speaking of power and support — and I know we're near the end here, but it occurs to me that this show is kind of our own small institution, kept going by listeners who value ad-free, in-depth history. If anyone wants to help keep these conversations coming, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way to keep the lights on. Lucas: And we really appreciate that. It means we can keep diving into these dark corners of history without any commercial interruptions. So thanks to anyone who considers it. Lucas: So to wrap up — the Spanish Inquisition wasn't just a Spanish story. It was a Habsburg story. From Charles V to Philip II, the Inquisition was central to how the dynasty ruled its far-flung empire. It shaped Spanish society, culture, and politics for centuries, and its legacy is still debated today. Next time, we'll look at another Habsburg institution — the Imperial Army — and how it held the empire together. Luna: Looking forward to it. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And thanks to all our listeners.