Latest / Newcomer Pod / Vibecode Showdown
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Newcomer podcast. I'm Eric, Newcomer.
- 0:04And I'm Madeline Renbarger. Each week, Eric and I discuss
- 0:11the VC deals and the drama that went down.
- 0:14Let's do it. Here we go.
- 0:19Oh, a loyal supporter. Of the newcomer podcast, I, I
- 0:23think our first advertiser and Christina the CEO has been on
- 0:26the show anyway. Without further ado.
- 0:28You're a startup founder. Finding product market fit is
- 0:31probably your number one priority.
- 0:33But to land bigger customers, you also need security
- 0:36compliance and obtaining your SoC.
- 0:39Two or ISO. 27 OO One certification can open those big
- 0:43doors, but they take time and energy, pulling you away from
- 0:47building and shipping. That's where Vanta comes in.
- 0:51Vanta is the. All in one compliance solution,
- 0:53helping start-ups like yours get audit ready and build a strong
- 0:57security foundation quickly and painlessly.
- 0:59How Vanta? Automates the manual security
- 1:02tasks that slow you down, helping you streamline your
- 1:05audit. And the platform connects you
- 1:08with trusted experts to build your program, auditors to get
- 1:12you through audits quickly, and a marketplace for essentials
- 1:15like pen testing. So whether you're closing your
- 1:18first deal or gearing up for growth, Phantom makes compliance
- 1:21easy. Join over 9000 companies,
- 1:24including many Y Combinator and Techstar startups who trust
- 1:27Vanta. Simplify compliance and get
- 1:30$1000 off at vanta.com/newcomer. That's V anta.com/newcomer for
- 1:39$1000 off. Eric, how is your vibe coding
- 1:44going? Well, first of all, you know
- 1:46Guillermo, the CEO of Versal, having lunch with him at Human
- 1:50X, you know, it's like, oh, you could build everything in VO,
- 1:54their coders. So I started there.
- 1:57Honestly, I got stuck in VO. What was the problem?
- 2:01It was like some button, you know, it was just like, make the
- 2:03button work, you know, And it's like I was like start over.
- 2:06I, I don't know, I, I just like got stuck.
- 2:08I moved to lovable. The buzziest company of the hour
- 2:12right now. On on the wing list we just
- 2:14published and very buzzy company that did the best.
- 2:19Honestly. Spoiler alert so far I have had
- 2:21the most success with lovable, you know and, and for the
- 2:27viewer, what listener I I don't know how to code at all like I,
- 2:30I don't know anything When I went to college, I studied
- 2:33philosophy, I was into journalism.
- 2:35I had no idea that I would be covering tech ever did not even
- 2:38cross my mind yeah. I did not take CS anyway, so
- 2:42know nothing about coding, but lovable, you know, created
- 2:45uploaded our design elements like our logo and so it borrowed
- 2:50our green and made really a nice website.
- 2:54You know, it's all the front end.
- 2:55I don't want to say exactly what I'm trying to build because it
- 2:57is a real product that I would be excited about, but the front
- 3:01end sort of exists. There are still some buttons
- 3:04that don't do exactly what I want, but I was able to add sort
- 3:07of user comments and annotations and cool.
- 3:11So that was actually pretty amazing.
- 3:13So lovable was my like Oh my God, like this is magical.
- 3:18Have you played with any of the others?
- 3:19Have you touched Windsurf or any of these guys?
- 3:22I've not done Codium's windsurf, though I should, and I haven't
- 3:26done cursor, which honestly I feel like is maybe the elephant
- 3:29in the room I. Was gonna say if you're gonna do
- 3:31one it feels like you should do cursor.
- 3:33My sense of cursor was that, you know, it's used more by coders
- 3:36where lovable is used by, you know, plain text.
- 3:40I went to Claude code anthropics product, which is insane in that
- 3:47like you use the terminal of your computer.
- 3:51So you're like using like command lines on your Mac, which
- 3:56I doesn't seem good opsec, but I have like anthropic over total
- 4:02access to my computer and it's much more autonomous like you
- 4:05describe and text what you want. I was joking on Twitter that,
- 4:08you know, coding with Claude code is just like hitting one.
- 4:12Music keeps asking me like, do you want me to do this thing?
- 4:14It's like one, yes. And then going to Claude Online
- 4:19just to sort of like, well, Claude code's asking me this,
- 4:22like, what do you think you know?
- 4:23And so you're just sort of like facilitating a conversation
- 4:27between two bots. I did end up with a locally
- 4:30hosted design website. Can't remember if buttons
- 4:35worked. The design was way worse but it
- 4:39did feel insane in terms of the vibe.
- 4:42You did that all based on just plain English prompting, so you
- 4:46can build a lot with just that. That is impressive.
- 4:49Lovable was easier to like both lovable and VO.
- 4:52I think you're like ripping, you know, I take a screenshot of
- 4:56some stuff, you know, it's like do do something like this, you
- 4:59know. So there's definitely a risk
- 5:01that it's a little derivative, but you move fast from an image.
- 5:06Claude code. Yeah, I was text based, all of
- 5:09them. I have sort of lost team.
- 5:11I mean, it took a fair bit of my time.
- 5:14It sounds like the front end stuff is working really well and
- 5:16from you and other people I talk to who play with it, but I
- 5:19wonder, I mean, the skeptical journalist in me is always like,
- 5:22if you get 80% of the way there, that's great.
- 5:24But if the last point like doesn't work, is it, how amazing
- 5:27is it really? It's it seems like smoke and
- 5:29mirrors flashy demo day and the actual tech work still needs to
- 5:34be tinkered out, which you know, we support.
- 5:36Where's your read on where this actually is overall?
- 5:39I mean, it it, you know, we experienced it with self driving
- 5:42cars. You can feel super close and
- 5:46then you're actually far away. Now self driving cars seem to
- 5:48have solved that. I think we'll talk about them a
- 5:51little bit more later in the show.
- 5:52But for a long time it was like, oh, they're, they're nearly
- 5:55here. And it's like, oh, I don't know,
- 5:57getting all the little details right matters.
- 6:01And with my experience, I don't even think it wasn't like an
- 6:048020 situation. I think it's more like a 2080
- 6:07situation. It's like, yeah, I had the nice
- 6:11design and sort of I had the concept, but no back end.
- 6:16I've no idea how to like host it.
- 6:19Some of the features weren't working.
- 6:21That almost sounds like a competitor to like a Figma or
- 6:24like a design tool rather than like coding full websites.
- 6:27Yeah, well, that's why people are saying vibe coding.
- 6:29Yes, I think that you understand this, but I think that's what a
- 6:33lot of people aren't in it don't get.
- 6:35It's like, yes, it's very compelling for the design part
- 6:38of the website. So that's why it's fun with
- 6:40front end. You're like, here's a
- 6:42screenshot, here's some assets like play around with it.
- 6:45Oh, I don't like that reshuffle it this way.
- 6:46You know, that's where it's a threat to Figma because you know
- 6:50it's well, you know, we're all playing around with you know
- 6:53what ChatGPT just came out with, you know, on four O they're
- 6:58really a Studio Ghibli machine. My Twitter feed is dominated by
- 7:03Studio Ghibli images and I have to say I've been building them.
- 7:08I've sent them to my wife. Oh, did you make some of you and
- 7:11your wife? Chachi BT This is a real reveal
- 7:17here. Red pandas are my favorite
- 7:18animal. It's realized that it should
- 7:20just like put red pandas, right? Some of these images, I'll like
- 7:24them better. It's like, oh, here's a family
- 7:26portrait and a red panda is in it.
- 7:29You know which. It's learning so much about you.
- 7:33Eric Yeah, exactly. I love it.
- 7:35Which is what I want. I'm always shouting at it.
- 7:36Remember Me? We've talked many times before.
- 7:39Uses the context. All my things I've asked you and
- 7:42uploaded. This is the dream, you know?
- 7:44We just get pandered to. Have you played with it yet?
- 7:47I've played a little bit with it.
- 7:48I'm more experienced with some of the older image generators.
- 7:50I was a really big fan of when like Dolly first launched.
- 7:54I I spent like days on that just prompting it with the most
- 7:58random crap. I think I did like any of the
- 8:01memes with like trail Cam footage of someone in the woods
- 8:05and make everything look like a grainy picture when that
- 8:07actually became visible. So this I need to still play
- 8:09with. You're like, I have to file my
- 8:11draft. I don't know what I'm writing.
- 8:15I wrote a piece earlier this week.
- 8:16You know, I get to play around, make little images for work.
- 8:20The beauty of covering AI. I do since I've been kind of
- 8:25spoiler alert for little future work talking to some people in
- 8:28the legal tech world. Recently all of his image stuff
- 8:31has been making me think a lot about copyright laws.
- 8:34Are we just throwing those out at this point?
- 8:36Like the the Studio Ghibli stuff is very clearly Studio Ghibli
- 8:39style. And literally the CEO, Sam
- 8:42Altman is tweeting out like images of him in Studio Ghibli
- 8:45profile. Picture Ghibli Altman.
- 8:47Right. Do they have a deal?
- 8:49I assume not. No, I can't imagine.
- 8:51Also, yeah, yeah, I don't, I don't remember Miyazaki being
- 8:54particularly pro this kind of stuff.
- 8:57Anyway, it's very fun, but then it opens up this whole host of
- 9:00defensibility from like a business perspective.
- 9:02Do you think it is a legal loser or like you know, there's no law
- 9:06anymore and it's only power? I think it's great.
- 9:10I kind of am feeling like that's the direction we're going.
- 9:13I mean, Grok was the first to have the image generator.
- 9:15That was no regard for copyright at all.
- 9:18And for the most part, opening eyes still on paper looking to
- 9:22do that, there's workarounds and you know how to prompt it to get
- 9:24it to generate the style so it's easy to work around.
- 9:27But at least on paper, they have their lawyers saying, you know,
- 9:30you can't do this this way, but I don't know if that's going to
- 9:33hold. Imagine you're an artist and you
- 9:36have this genius style. I wouldn't want every Joe Schmo
- 9:41to be able to copy it. I mean, it's like, it's one
- 9:44thing if talented artists can sort of pay homage to it, but of
- 9:47course they've learned to paint or draw and so now they have
- 9:51some skill and so maybe they try to be creative themselves.
- 9:55You know, this is the ultimate couldn't be more derivative.
- 9:59And even though it's fun, you know, for everybody to be able
- 10:01to do their family because you're not going to be able to
- 10:03hire the artist to do it for you.
- 10:06It's just clearly is going to dilute the artistic style.
- 10:11So putting aside the law, it's just sort of, you know, it's
- 10:15happy and sad I'm doing it, but you know, I wouldn't want to
- 10:18have an iconic art style right now because it's going to get
- 10:22copied. Madeline, what's your forecast
- 10:25on copyright? They're wild now as they're
- 10:27acquiring customers and they'll get more buttoned up.
- 10:30Or you think this is the new normal?
- 10:32I think that we're still in the early days of adoption.
- 10:36Like as much as this feels ubiquitous to us being really in
- 10:39this ecosystem, not everywhere has really taken advantage of
- 10:42this. Just speaking also with my
- 10:44lawyer mother that I keep referencing on this podcast,
- 10:47it's they're very cautious about how to implement this kind of
- 10:50stuff. And so the sort of like 20%
- 10:53early adopters to 80% mass thing is really real with this.
- 10:57I can tell in a lot of industries and circling back to
- 10:59copyright, a lot of people are very nervous about this and
- 11:02don't want this to get them in trouble.
- 11:04So I don't think it's a total free for all yet.
- 11:07Long term, will it be? That's something that's I think
- 11:10certainly going to have to be renegotiated, yes.
- 11:12But for the immediate time right now, I think people are at least
- 11:15in the content space or a little bit wary of doing this as
- 11:19directly. It's bleeding over more now than
- 11:21it was before. Like I think I don't think Sam
- 11:24Watlin would have used copyright style images.
- 11:26What's funny that it's like the media channels.
- 11:29If you're like NBC, you're surely paranoid about ripping
- 11:33off somebody's art style. But open AI, which is definitely
- 11:39more valuable than NBC, it's like, oh, the old guard
- 11:42companies that are responsible but not as valuable are more
- 11:46cautious than the startup worth, you know, 300 billion.
- 11:50I don't know. It's it's classic.
- 11:52Moving on, different drama, different day. 11X this sales
- 11:56automation AI startup backed by Andreessen and Benchmarks.
- 12:00So some pretty happy hitters was accused of falsely claiming
- 12:04certain companies as its customers.
- 12:06Eric, what do you make of this? I think short term customers who
- 12:10turned off but were still advertised as customers on the
- 12:13website maybe. I think some annual ARR.
- 12:18I don't know if it was recurring revenue or runway in revenue,
- 12:20but ARR maybe inflated potentially.
- 12:25But the really charged idea at the top of the story was that
- 12:28Andreessen Horowitz was going to perhaps mulling suing the
- 12:33startup. They backed 11X dot AI.
- 12:37And just like knowing anything about Andreessen, you need to
- 12:40have that like lock solid, I think to lead off the story
- 12:44saying that Andreessen's gonna sue the start up.
- 12:46I mean, Andreessen came out defending the start up and Sarah
- 12:50Tovill and Benchmark did. And you know, they're not as
- 12:54hostile to the media. And so I feel like it was a very
- 12:58predictable as soon as it came out, like, oh, people are
- 13:00talking about whether Andreessen might sue.
- 13:04The other thing that was obvious in the story is like, clearly
- 13:07they are there are a lot of angry former employees.
- 13:11Like, you know, I think there was some picture in the story
- 13:14and it's like everybody in this picture is gone besides the
- 13:17founder. And as someone who has written
- 13:20about these types of companies, I mean, it is employees can get
- 13:23themselves incredulous that like, wow, we all left and like
- 13:28it's clearly a disaster, not going to work.
- 13:31Sometimes they're right and sometimes they're wrong, and
- 13:33clearly, you know, VC's back the founder, especially Andreess.
- 13:38Yeah, the VC's are doubling down.
- 13:40Do you think churn like that at a startup like this that's super
- 13:43fast growing is like an immediate red flag?
- 13:46I mean, based on your history of reporting, I feel like it really
- 13:49depends if there's something fraudulent going on for that's
- 13:52obviously sketchy. But with this, it just seems
- 13:54like maybe not quite to that tier.
- 13:57It's hard. It's hard to know, you know, the
- 13:59business person and me. Churn is bad.
- 14:02Obviously, it makes it very hard to keep growing if you have to
- 14:05replace all your old customers. But if you're sort of early on
- 14:09and figuring out what works, you're obviously going to churn
- 14:12out customers who weren't the right fit for you.
- 14:15So it's hard to know, just like churn on its own.
- 14:18Yeah. I mean, the issue is that it was
- 14:20easy for people to abandon. They had sort of a loose brake
- 14:23clause, but then they baked in those customers to their ARR,
- 14:29you know. But again, this is sort of the
- 14:30type of type of thing which is why we have staged venture
- 14:33capital funding. It's like if you if you sort of
- 14:36fake the AR today and those people churn, unless you're
- 14:39really pushing it, you're going to have trouble the next round.
- 14:44So I think a lot of VCs are just sort of this is the process.
- 14:48Why? Why write an expose on a Series
- 14:50B company? Well, also a lot of these even
- 14:53really these early AI startups, there's been a ton of reporting
- 14:56about how a lot of customers for these early AI startups have a
- 15:00lot of customer entrance and then a lot of churn, but then
- 15:03still rate retain a lot of customer interest.
- 15:05Like it's not like these companies are failing these,
- 15:07these are still backing them and they're growing.
- 15:08It's just like a high. It seems like a lot of these
- 15:10companies just have higher turnover than maybe traditional
- 15:13SAS companies did at this time. If you need fewer employees, you
- 15:17you can churn the ones that are annoying to you as a CEO.
- 15:20I guess I don't know a couple wild tweets that I would never
- 15:25put in a story, but in a podcast I can read to you one from, you
- 15:30know, a non account basically is like the fake revenue expose has
- 15:35begun. Theranos will be forgotten.
- 15:37Long live the AI sales agent. Next is Mercor, then scale
- 15:40perplexity, open AI mean that's bombastic.
- 15:43But I do think there's like, we don't know anything about, you
- 15:47know, the nature of this revenue.
- 15:50But Arthur Rock, who has a track record of good reporting, said
- 15:54an AI company with a similar quote revenue trajectory likes
- 15:58to include early equity raise as part of their ARR calculation.
- 16:03Raised 20 million so far and is quite literally everywhere.
- 16:06I'm pretty sure none of its investors are aware of this good
- 16:09litmus test on who is doing most basic DD due diligence.
- 16:13Clearly. I mean, money's flying and there
- 16:16are going to be some startups that do shady things and
- 16:19inflating revenue could be one of them.
- 16:21I think TechCrunch needed to be more buttoned up here about
- 16:25having this lawsuit idea at the top of their story when they had
- 16:29other interesting claims that they could have focused on.
- 16:32Regardless, this is a TechCrunch story that drums up a ton of
- 16:35media attention and hits just a week after their big sale, which
- 16:40had a lot of people scratching their heads as to what that
- 16:42means. Yeah, I'm interested to see.
- 16:45Obviously TechCrunch has been an institution.
- 16:49I think selling to private equity does not make people more
- 16:52optimistic about the fate of a beloved brand.
- 16:55But you know, Apollo owned Yahoo which owned TechCrunch.
- 16:59So one to another we'll we'll see.
- 17:02Hopefully they figure it out. I said earlier that we might
- 17:05come back to self driving cars. It is now the time to do so.
- 17:09Waymo, my my favorite dear, near and dear to my heart way MO's
- 17:13planned robo taxi launch in Washington, DC intends to
- 17:18introduce by 2026. I mean, what is, is DC going to
- 17:22be part of the Trump federal administration by then?
- 17:25I don't know what'll be a separate city.
- 17:26I don't know. But but anyway, they they want
- 17:28to go to DC. What do you think, Madeline?
- 17:31I think this is cool. Of course, the launch is
- 17:33dependent on if they can change some local laws that currently
- 17:35require human drivers in autonomous vehicles.
- 17:38So obviously they're going to be pushing for that so that it does
- 17:42go through. I think that DC as a
- 17:44neighborhood makes a lot of sense for Way MO.
- 17:46It's a bigger city, obviously it's nation's capital.
- 17:50The access of power is Silicon Valley moves closer in you know
- 17:53maybe probably good call there, but I also think it's just
- 17:57exciting to see self driving cars in growing cities one step
- 18:01closer to getting to New York City.
- 18:02Am I right I. Was reading something.
- 18:04I worry that New York is going to be a particular particularly
- 18:08big hurdle. Taxi cabs are powerful and
- 18:11highly regulated. Also the just the the culture of
- 18:15jaywalking and the chaos of New York streets I feel like is
- 18:19something to consider too not to be.
- 18:21You're buying car propaganda there.
- 18:23This is why it's self driving cars.
- 18:26They're much better. I I was looking at analysis by
- 18:29Timothy Lee. He analyzed the 38 most serious
- 18:34crashes Waymo experience between July 2024 and February 20, 2516.
- 18:42Crashes where another vehicle crashed into a stationary way
- 18:45MO. I think the only ones where way
- 18:47MO is sort of responsible are passengers getting out and like
- 18:52during like a bicyclist or something.
- 18:55OK, for sure. Again, also human error.
- 18:59In a certain way, though, a product design, I think Waymo's
- 19:02trying to warn people when people are coming.
- 19:04But anyway, by by any standard there, he's he he predicts that
- 19:08there would have been way more incidents with human drivers.
- 19:12I mean, I think it's pretty clear at this point that Waymo
- 19:15is superior. I think you'd be right in them.
- 19:18You're like, yeah, this is definitely safer.
- 19:20So if you want to protect pedestrians in the streets of
- 19:23New York, we need Waymo. That's our show.
- 19:26Thanks for listening. See you next week.