Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 93: On French digital culture, productivity, and work with Rahaf Harfoush
Transcript
- 0:07Hoobastank to the New Paris, I'm your host.
- 0:10Was it Remuda? One of my goals with my last
- 0:13book, the new by his vision was to highlight the richness of
- 0:16talent coming from women in and around the capital.
- 0:20There's tremendous creativity knowledge, Innovation and
- 0:23inspiration. And it's these women and so many
- 0:26others like them, who fuel my own work and thinking, We're
- 0:30Half her foolish, one of the women in the book and a longtime
- 0:33friend, is one of the women, I admire most and whose research
- 0:38writing and thinking on technology.
- 0:40And the culture of work has been endlessly Illuminating.
- 0:44She joins me today to talk about the research.
- 0:46She's been doing her work with a French Commission on the digital
- 0:49space and how we can all exert control over Technology's impact
- 0:53on our daily lives. However, half Island Z.
- 0:58You were previous guest on the show.
- 1:01In fact, I think you were like our second guest and I say our
- 1:04because this is when I had a co-host of, so this is like, you
- 1:07know, a long long time ago, but you're someone who, who I think
- 1:11is so important for so many different reasons.
- 1:14And one of the reasons I wanted you to be one of the early guest
- 1:18this season, is because I feel like with your work and your
- 1:21vision for keeping focused, in New Year, especially during
- 1:25Times. I thought it could be very
- 1:27inspirational and helpful for listeners.
- 1:30So how has the start of the year been for you?
- 1:33Like how did you get prepared? And given that, we're now into
- 1:36February, and we're experiencing another period of conflict.
- 1:40Like, how do you, how do you approach your work?
- 1:44Well, one thank you for having me back.
- 1:46It was said, it's always such a pleasure to chat with you about
- 1:49these topics. Okay.
- 1:52So the Ed, the answer is a two part one to this.
- 1:55The first thing I will say is that the last two years have
- 1:58taught me that I needed to completely reframe my
- 2:03relationship with uncertainty because based on what we've all
- 2:08lived through. It seems to me that this next
- 2:11period of time things popping up and disrupting.
- 2:15Our lives are going to become more and more frequent.
- 2:18So it's not just the pandemic. We not to start off on a super
- 2:21depressing note, but they're calling this this next sort of
- 2:2550 years. The era of pandemics.
- 2:27I think we're going to see more of this.
- 2:30Hopefully now that we've put the infrastructure in place and
- 2:33won't be so globally. Destabilizing but you know, so
- 2:36things like pandemics things like climate change, things like
- 2:39political upheavals even technological of people's.
- 2:43So it's very clear to me that we're We're living in an era
- 2:45where disruption is the norm, which means that in order for us
- 2:49to survive. We can't keep getting completely
- 2:53overthrown and completely destabilized by every single
- 2:56time things change. And one of the foundational
- 3:00ideas that I have been thinking about for years.
- 3:03Now is this concept called antifragility and anti
- 3:08fragility? Is this concept that was written
- 3:11by an economist. Taleb Nassim.
- 3:15I think his name is, he wrote a book about it.
- 3:18And what was really interesting about it, the premises and I'll
- 3:20save you the trouble of reading the book.
- 3:22I'll give you like, the, the two second summary is that when
- 3:26people talk about resilience people who are resilient just
- 3:29survive periods of change and he says, people who are or
- 3:34institutions that are anti fragile, actually Thrive and
- 3:39grow and get better in periods of doing order.
- 3:44So for so long, I was thinking, how do I weather this?
- 3:47Year? How do I survive this year?
- 3:49How do I get through this year, but then, when you think about
- 3:52entering fragility, you realize, it's not the right question that
- 3:54the question should be. How do I use this year and the
- 4:00chaos of this year to get better, to grow my business, to
- 4:05better design my life. And so, it's like thriving in
- 4:072022 because of 2022. Not in spite of 2022.
- 4:13And so that was a really Fundamental shift for me because
- 4:16it requires you to look at these disruptions as periods of
- 4:21opportunity and every time, they're these big upheavals.
- 4:25Instead of just panicking which I used to do instead of
- 4:27stressing, which I used to do instead of being anxious, which
- 4:30I used to do, is to say, okay, this type of change is now a
- 4:34normal part of our life. So I need to be very open and I
- 4:38need to be looking at the opportunities that are coming up
- 4:40in the space and there are very concrete ways to do that.
- 4:43So for example, Looking at your own business and saying, do I
- 4:47have a lot of options, a lot of flexibility, say in the revenue
- 4:51streams. So for me in 2019, I'm a keynote
- 4:55speaker. So, I used to spend a lot of my
- 4:57time traveling and speaking at conferences, that part of my
- 5:01business, completely died in 2020.
- 5:04And so my lesson there was don't have one Revenue stream that
- 5:09you're super depended on, right? So like these are the thinking
- 5:12words like when I'm structuring my life to how I'd be as
- 5:15flexible as possible. So that no matter what happens.
- 5:18I have options and I never have all my eggs in one basket.
- 5:22They focus is specific, go to people who work for themselves,
- 5:25you know, in the, you know, creative Fields.
- 5:28I mean, honestly, I know this is maybe not advise that is often
- 5:32given, but I think anybody working whether you're working
- 5:36for a full-time company, whether you're working for yourself need
- 5:40to be thinking of antifragility. Like if you are working for Or
- 5:44somebody else that means one hundred percent of your income
- 5:48is coming from that source. So if you get laid off, as many
- 5:51people did during the pandemic, or if you get let go or
- 5:55whatever, then that means you're losing a hundred percent of your
- 5:57income. So, is there a way for you to
- 5:59maybe do something else? Maybe there's like a side hustle
- 6:04or maybe there's something yummy.
- 6:05And I'm not saying burn an entire salary, but is there a
- 6:09way that you're not 100 dependent 100% dependent on like
- 6:13one source of income. And so that was a big part of my
- 6:17thinking and so this year. I've sort of been putting those
- 6:20practices in place by just continuing to look at and
- 6:23saying, okay, like how can I structure my life?
- 6:26And I have a very specific planning approach because I'm
- 6:29working on this concept called human productivity.
- 6:31And so what I do is I have like a weekly planning session of
- 6:34quarterly planning session a monthly planning session with
- 6:37yourself with myself. Yes, right.
- 6:39Very with myself only with myself me myself and I wear once
- 6:44a year. A year, I sit down.
- 6:45I set goals. I then break those goals down
- 6:48into, you know, 90 days friends and then I break that down into
- 6:51monthly. I basically go from Big to small
- 6:53small, small. And so every week, I sit down
- 6:55and I look at what I want to get done this week.
- 6:59And so now is, we're at the end of February.
- 7:01I'm in the process of looking at.
- 7:03What I, what do I hope to accomplish in the next month?
- 7:05In a way, where I can be laser focused on my goals, but also
- 7:10not be overwhelmed, not be burned out, not be signing up.
- 7:14Unrealistic expectations of myself.
- 7:16So how do I design a life that is aligned with the way I want
- 7:21to live. I will say that one of the
- 7:23things you told me many years ago, that has always stayed with
- 7:26me is and I'm sure this is like, you know, the most basic of
- 7:30things that are, you know, have been part of your routine for so
- 7:33long, but for so many people, they go about it in the wrong
- 7:36way, which is to set these realistic.
- 7:38To-do lists. I remember you said something
- 7:42like, you know, if you have more than three things on your to-do
- 7:44list, List for a day, you're set up for your setting yourself up
- 7:47for failure, just because it's like, it's not possible.
- 7:51We can't do it all. And then we get disappointed
- 7:53with ourselves and we can't get across those things off a list.
- 7:56Well, yeah. And so the idea, I mean, I am a
- 7:59planner. So if you're not a planner on,
- 8:01this doesn't work for you, you're probably not going to
- 8:03like a lot. What I have to say, but if you
- 8:04are planner, you are going to love this conversation because I
- 8:08believe that flexible planning is really the key to live your
- 8:13best possible life. And planning doesn't mean that.
- 8:16I I account for every single minute of the day or it's like,
- 8:19you know, I'm doing my tasks from 11:15 to 11:21 planning.
- 8:23Just means that I understand where my time is going in
- 8:26general buckets. In a way, that makes sure that I
- 8:30am getting the big things that I want to accomplish finish.
- 8:33Because if people who are listening, if you have a big
- 8:36project like you want to write a book or you want to plan a trip
- 8:40or, you know, something that you can't do in 1 sitting, it can
- 8:42sometimes feel really overwhelming.
- 8:44And the problem with two Duelists is that if they're
- 8:47completely disconnected from your calendar, their tasks that
- 8:50are just like floating in The Ether.
- 8:52So sure, put a hundred things on your to-do list, but if you're
- 8:55not actually blocking out the time in your calendar to do
- 8:58them, then you're going to put this unnecessary pressure on
- 9:01yourself and it's like, well, if you have, you know, 15 hours
- 9:06worth of tasks on your to-do list, and you only have an eight
- 9:09hour day. Most people beat themselves up
- 9:12about the fact that they didn't get it.
- 9:14Stuff done instead of saying, wait a minute.
- 9:17Am I being realistic with what? I'm promising myself that I will
- 9:21do, right? And so part of my system is
- 9:23also, you know, my weekly system.
- 9:25It's look at the tasks that I have and to take them off of my
- 9:29to-do list. And to say, when in the week, am
- 9:31I going to do this? Because if you don't allocate
- 9:34the time for them, then somehow we expect that.
- 9:37We're going to find the time in between them all of our other
- 9:40responsibilities. And then we didn't just give
- 9:42carried over or just keep pushing it.
- 9:44And I fallen into that trap many times.
- 9:47But, you know, as I think it's helpful for people to hear it in
- 9:51that way also and then it sticks in their mind.
- 9:53Like, you know, what, why do I keep struggling with this same
- 9:56issue? Maybe my system needs some, you
- 9:58know, revisiting, but I do want to talk about the Paris and
- 10:03France, sort of tech scene and the things you've been doing but
- 10:07before that because, you know, you just talked about trying to
- 10:10prevent yourself from burnout and protect yourself.
- 10:14That really is tied to your most recent published book, which was
- 10:19called hustle, and float. And that looked at the origins
- 10:22of the work devotion epidemic and the cult of productivity,
- 10:26and you've basically been Consulting Business Leaders on
- 10:29how to overhaul work culture to create a better environment for
- 10:32workers. And when I think of work
- 10:34devotion, I think of, I mean, instantly, I think of Americans.
- 10:37And I think of the Japanese who I mean, seem to have this sort
- 10:41of cultural trait, almost now built into their DNA.
- 10:44Yeah, but as you and I have seen, this is made its way to
- 10:47France to. So, can you talk about what got
- 10:49you into this work? And then how you see it playing
- 10:52out locally in France? Sure.
- 10:54So what interested me in this is again, I'm a researcher.
- 10:58I'm a business person and so I was starting to in my own life
- 11:02and my own professional work. Start to recognize that the
- 11:04systems that I was expected to adhere to of being always busy
- 11:09long days. Hustle culture was negatively
- 11:13impacting my ability to You my job that I wasn't actually able
- 11:16to consult or to speak or to write if I was constantly
- 11:20exhausted. And the idea that the system's
- 11:23themselves were designed to in a way that was hurting my ability
- 11:28to perform had never really occurred to me until I started
- 11:31to take a deeper look because we assume that all of the advice
- 11:35that we get is in service of our performance.
- 11:37We get told wake up early, stay late, you know, you know, we get
- 11:41told all of these things about how to be successful and we just
- 11:43do them. But now, we are in an era of
- 11:46knowledge work, which means most of us are doing jobs that
- 11:50require us to use our creativity in order to get paid and this
- 11:54doesn't mean singing, or dancing or writing, this means running
- 11:59teams and collaborating, and doing research and working with
- 12:02clients and spotting Market opportunities, and fixing
- 12:05problems. All of that is deeply dependent
- 12:08on your ability to be creative. So we have this entire business
- 12:12world that is obsessed with innovation.
- 12:14That needs people to be resilient adaptive quick
- 12:17thinking but that demands this of them in a system where they
- 12:21are constantly burned out where they're being working too much
- 12:24and working too much as literally preventing them from
- 12:26being able to do their jobs. And so businesses now are just
- 12:30starting to realize that if they want to have a Workforce that
- 12:33can help them be strategic and on an agile and Innovative, they
- 12:38can't work these people until they're empty husks and folder
- 12:43just like empty. T shells of human beings.
- 12:46Like you need to give them the opportunity to recharge and this
- 12:50really hit home in 2019. When the World Health
- 12:52Organization declared burnout was a workplace, a workplace
- 12:57Hazard. And in the last two years, we've
- 12:59seen companies around the world start to really reconsider their
- 13:02meeting policy. Their vacation policy.
- 13:05And so I'm really interested in the idea of how do we build
- 13:09systems that were designed for people like us because the That
- 13:14we are currently shoving ourselves into was never meant
- 13:18for the type of work that we all do.
- 13:20And so instead of just like, trying to contort ourselves to
- 13:26keep up with this hustle culture.
- 13:28It's like, well, what does the system look like in pursuit of
- 13:31Optimal Performance? And pursue what you talked about
- 13:34in your book is also that this, this is something that goes back
- 13:37to the Industrial Revolution, which is not how we work today,
- 13:41but we're would you say that also.
- 13:44Applies to like. That seems very American to me,
- 13:48you know, the the way that structure was was established.
- 13:53How do you explain then? How those, I mean, I guess it's
- 13:56just globalization, but how those pressures, how those
- 13:59systems have been made, its way over to Europe and in other
- 14:03cultures, which maybe didn't have the same, you know, source
- 14:07of the problem, but but clearly there's, there's the same
- 14:10imbalance. So what's interesting and this
- 14:12bridge is the link between the technology seen in the work
- 14:15seen, is that the idea of the American dream or, you know, the
- 14:19American Centric version of success, which is dependent on
- 14:23working. Really, really hard.
- 14:25That was a night. That is an idea that has been
- 14:27exported around the world mainly through the examples of some of
- 14:32the most popular and well-known technology companies in the
- 14:34world today, right? You have Amazon, you have
- 14:36Facebook. You have Microsoft, you have an
- 14:38apple, you have Netflix, these All American companies that are
- 14:43seen as globally dominant. That are seen as a state to
- 14:48Aspire to to other countries, right?
- 14:50Every other countries like, how can I get my own Google?
- 14:53How can I get my own Amazon? And this is a big part of the
- 14:57technology strategy for Nations that are trying to remain
- 14:59competitive and relevant in this globally.
- 15:01Connected ecosystem. However, those companies and
- 15:05their CEOs who are very well known.
- 15:07Now, also, just through their behavior have Have sold or have
- 15:12presented a very specific vision of success.
- 15:15So we know that Jeff Bezos is a workaholic.
- 15:18We know that Elon Musk sleeps on the floor of his factories.
- 15:21We know that, Mark Zuckerberg regularly works over 80 hours a
- 15:25week. These are things that are
- 15:26constantly spoken about. So what we absorb from that
- 15:30unintentionally is, if we want to be successful, we have to do.
- 15:34We have to act in this way to and you see this, for example,
- 15:38in Francis startup scene, the the The technology startup scene
- 15:42where you'll hear Founders saying, I'm going to be like
- 15:45these people in order to emulate their success.
- 15:49You hear it how we talk about success in the tech startup
- 15:52sphere. Anyway, and then the second
- 15:54aspect of that is international company.
- 15:56So you have a lot of global companies that operate in France
- 16:00and they have a very specific work ethic that all of their
- 16:03staff is expected to adhere to. And so suddenly, the idea of
- 16:08taking a August off becomes. You know, a luxury and France
- 16:12has not been immune to this, by the way, like in France, you
- 16:15have somebody that when you want to leave, they say, oh, you
- 16:18know, lose that a pond of a club comedy, right?
- 16:21If you leave at 6:00, they get told.
- 16:23Oh, you're gonna take your afternoon off there, there.
- 16:25It's kind of Permitting everywhere.
- 16:27And the interesting reason, why, is because it because we have
- 16:31this, like Global narrative, about success now, and we have
- 16:35Associated our personal success with how hard we work.
- 16:38Now, the interesting thing and I'll just diverged, just super
- 16:41Lee, but just for a second, is in Asian countries, so unlike
- 16:44Japan and South Korea and China, they have the same workaholic
- 16:49Tendencies, but unlike the US and Western Europe, it's not
- 16:54about the individual, it's about supporting the collective.
- 16:58So in Japan, if you take a day off, you're letting your team
- 17:02down, you're bringing in younger, you're leaving them,
- 17:05you're betraying them by leaving them to pick up the slack versus
- 17:09in North America and in Western Europe, it's less about the
- 17:13collective, and it's more about your personal, your
- 17:15individualized need for success. And what interests me is that in
- 17:19both these cases over working, whether it's on an individual
- 17:23level or in support of the collective is seen as the the
- 17:28moral way. Like you do it to be deserving
- 17:31of your success, you do it to show your loyalty to your team.
- 17:35But either way, the behavior itself, which is quite toxic and
- 17:38quite negative is presented in a way that Says this is
- 17:41aspirational, right? It's virtuous.
- 17:44It's a virtuous way. It means that this is who you
- 17:46are. Also, I mean constantly connects
- 17:48to work and productivity to who you are as a person which is
- 17:51certainly what you're trying to move away from France in the
- 17:55last few years, came out with this right to disconnect law,
- 17:58but in my circle and in my husband Circle, you know, and I
- 18:02mentioned him only because he works in a super traditional
- 18:06corporate environment. It's not really a thing like
- 18:09it's not really. Just what do you make of that
- 18:12development? Like was it just a PR stunt?
- 18:16So the right to disconnect and I mean, this is where you get into
- 18:19the, the Deep cultural effects of hustle culture.
- 18:23Because it's not just something that an organization has to do.
- 18:27There are actually a lot of things that the individuals have
- 18:30to do. So, for example, Netflix, try to
- 18:34give its employees unlimited paid vacation days, so unlimited
- 18:38paid time off and people were not taking it.
- 18:41So why this problem is so complex is that because there
- 18:44are things that an individual has to do, there are things that
- 18:47a team or company has to do. And then there are things that
- 18:50we as a society have to do and French society.
- 18:53I think on a societal level, we're actually pretty good.
- 18:55We have a lot of vacations. We have a an attitude around
- 18:59disconnecting which I think is fascinating and wonderful.
- 19:03And one of the main reasons I moved to France was because it
- 19:05seemed like much more Humane idea.
- 19:08You are expected to take your entire.
- 19:11ER, T of your vacation time. You're expected to go and live
- 19:14your life in that way. And I think that's incredible.
- 19:17However, you have organizations that don't have those.
- 19:20Sometimes that I've read and I've spoken an interview to
- 19:23people with people who work in Paris and even though they're on
- 19:26vacation. They're still answering emails
- 19:28because there's an Unwritten agreement that they're supposed
- 19:31to be quote unquote available, right?
- 19:33Then the last piece of the puzzles, the individual.
- 19:35So if you yourself have internalized productivity
- 19:39cult-like thinking, where you Really believed in your heart
- 19:42that the only way for you to guarantee success in your life
- 19:45is to be constantly connected and to constantly demonstrate
- 19:48work devotion. Then you're not going to
- 19:50disconnect your boss can give you time off, you're not going
- 19:53to disconnect. So I think in order for the law
- 19:57to disconnect, which is fantastic, by the way, in order
- 19:59for the law to disconnect to really be applicable.
- 20:03We need to look at, not just the policies of the company, but the
- 20:06culture around which we are communicating our standards of
- 20:10success. And what's interesting.
- 20:12We can talk about this as Belgium recently just approved.
- 20:14Some new measures around a 40. Yeah. 40 work week like this is
- 20:18the really next big Trend that we're starting to see which are
- 20:21so good with all these pilot programs and the biggest points
- 20:24of resistance are people's feelings and beliefs because the
- 20:30data is there, there now, been experiments in Portugal and New
- 20:34Zealand in Iceland in the UK and every single one of these pilot
- 20:39programs from a Out of perspective have said, giving
- 20:43people a four-day Work Week doesn't doesn't decrease their
- 20:47productivity. In fact, it increases their
- 20:49well-being and improves. Their performance is what the
- 20:52data says. And yet, why are we not rolling
- 20:55this out everywhere? Because we have this resistance.
- 20:58Like, what do you mean? We're going to give people an
- 21:01extra day off because we're so obsessed by the act of working.
- 21:05But it's also what we saw during the pandemic when you know,
- 21:09despite governmental measures. He's insisting really that
- 21:13people work remotely wherever possible, including with big
- 21:17corporations that, you know, represent France, not to name
- 21:21names, but there's some big conglomerates that were so, you
- 21:23know, supposed to adhere to this Rule and yet hearing directly
- 21:27from people who work for them. You know, I was, I was reading
- 21:30and hearing that they were still actually encouraged to go in
- 21:34four days a week when it was supposed to be one day a week
- 21:36during, you know, a Health crisis.
- 21:38And so you have these big companies or traditional
- 21:40companies. That may not have the same.
- 21:44I don't know. Progressive openness in the ways
- 21:48of operating that some of the newer companies have where they
- 21:51still. Not only do they not think that
- 21:54people are working properly from home, but surely, they think.
- 21:57Oh, well four-day work week. They're just, they're not going
- 21:59to get anything done. Yes.
- 22:01So it's like you have to combat it on so many fronts.
- 22:05Well, yeah, I'd like the I mean so culturally and France with
- 22:08love being inside offices, but that Also, going back to
- 22:12outdated models of management. That also means that for most
- 22:17managers. If you really need people to be
- 22:19in the office, that means you're using a measure of control that
- 22:23you need to see, people being productive, which is linked to
- 22:25the same idea. It's actually indicates, a lack
- 22:27of trust with your employees, or it indicates a lack of systems,
- 22:32like, the right systems to measure performance it.
- 22:35Considering we're all doing like knowledge work.
- 22:37There's really very little reason for somebody to be
- 22:39standing over our shoulders. Right?
- 22:41And if your manager needs to stand over your shoulders to see
- 22:45what you're doing, then to me, that's sends a big signal, like
- 22:48well, we're not measuring the right thing.
- 22:50We don't have the right goal to don't have the right updates or
- 22:53team, you know, project updates or whatever.
- 22:56So, that's the first part. The second thing that I also
- 22:58want to highlight is in France during the pandemic, many people
- 23:03who are working from their Apartments did not have the
- 23:06space or the privilege of having a dedicated working environment.
- 23:10So, we Have people that were looking from their living rooms
- 23:13from their bedrooms, like, I think in North America, where in
- 23:16some cases. And again, I really underline
- 23:18privilege here, but in some cases, you had an extra bedroom
- 23:21that you could turn into an office, you had a backyard, you
- 23:24had a place where you could have a good remote experience, many
- 23:28people in Paris. And I saw this in my students.
- 23:30I heard this from my clients. We live in an urban city because
- 23:34the city is supposed to be an extension of our living space,
- 23:37right? I'm supposed to be able to go to
- 23:38a cafe, to go to a park to Walk around and suddenly you have
- 23:42people who didn't have that and it was quite disruptive to their
- 23:45working environment. Not to mention kids at home
- 23:48Elder Care. All of these other things.
- 23:49So I can also understand why many people would want to go
- 23:53back to the office because if you weren't lucky enough to have
- 23:56that environment, it could your productivity probably did go
- 23:59down. If you had your partner right
- 24:02across the table from you. I had a friend who was trying to
- 24:06do her job, her husband, they both were consultants and they
- 24:09were both on call. Calls all day.
- 24:11And they did not have the space to be able news spread out and
- 24:15they, this is during the confinement, so they couldn't
- 24:17leave. So imagine your ability to get
- 24:20your job done. If you have that at that
- 24:23constraint and you have kids and you have you, no pets and all of
- 24:26these other things. So, I also want to recognize
- 24:28that like going into the office is often seen as necessary in
- 24:32some of these cases, if you don't have the luxury of working
- 24:34in a cafe, but now that things are opening up.
- 24:37Again, the idea around hybrid work is supposed to That, you
- 24:41know, nobody's saying, we never go back into the office.
- 24:44We're just saying, we want the flexibility, to be able to,
- 24:46again, back to my first point around, human productivity
- 24:49design, a way of working, that allows us to live our lives.
- 24:53So in addition to all of this research and you're already on
- 24:56to your next, I mean what you're talking about here, Humane
- 24:58productivity is sort of your next, big research, Focus, but
- 25:02continues, you know the work you started with Hustle & Flow but
- 25:06aside from that you've been involved in other things.
- 25:09So a commissioner established by the French President to report
- 25:12on Technology's impact both good and bad on society, as well as
- 25:17offering Solutions on to disinformation on the internet.
- 25:21And so you've been part of this commission that features, you
- 25:24know, I'm assuming French sociologists and other types of
- 25:28workers. What was that?
- 25:30Like, why? You know, why was this put
- 25:33together and what were some of your findings?
- 25:36So the commission, which was a thing called the commission on
- 25:40bond? But the official name was The
- 25:42Luminaries in the age of digital, and the digital age was
- 25:47put together by President macaron because we have an
- 25:50election coming up, and we have seen over the last couple of
- 25:53years that technology has been used in a very deliberate way to
- 25:57undermine the Democratic process in countries around the world.
- 26:01We've seen this in the US, we've seen this in Canada.
- 26:03We've seen this all over the place.
- 26:05And so the president macaron was really interested in what we
- 26:09need to do on a A national level to safeguard elections and to
- 26:13make sure that we don't have one misinformation floating around
- 26:17everywhere and to that we don't have interference from other
- 26:21interested parties. Be it like foreign interference
- 26:25from other governments or you know, just businesses or people
- 26:29that want to profit from the divisiveness of social media.
- 26:32And so at two data points, for example, is that a couple of
- 26:36months ago, France was the was the target of what?
- 26:40Allegedly assumed to be a Russian Cyber attack.
- 26:45That was promoting a lot of fake information around the Pfizer,
- 26:48vaccine. For example, all of a sudden we
- 26:51have all these articles and telegram groups and new things
- 26:53that were telling people, fake information, like like
- 26:57completely untrue information about the vaccine to sow,
- 27:00unrest, just so distrust and systems, Etc.
- 27:03So this was not something that citizens were doing.
- 27:05This is a foreign government that was coming to meddle.
- 27:08And if you, if they can do that, for the vaccine will.
- 27:10Of course, they can do that for our election.
- 27:13And so, some of the things that we looked at was really is that
- 27:16us as a country. What do we have to do in order
- 27:19to set proper policies in place so that we can limit the harm
- 27:25that these platforms can do. So, for example, one of the
- 27:28people that the commission spoke to was France's Hagen who was
- 27:31the Facebook whistleblower and she was giving really specific
- 27:34recommendations. Like for example, countries
- 27:37should insist that companies like meta like Look, give their
- 27:43users, the opportunity to opt out of the algorithm.
- 27:46So a feature where we can just turn off the algorithm that
- 27:49chooses what you say and that just sort of sorry that chooses
- 27:53what you see so that we can have maybe less influence from the
- 27:57algorithm other recommendations were that there's no more of
- 28:01this black box around the algorithm that companies like
- 28:04Facebook and Google and Twitter should explain very clearly how
- 28:09their system is. Commending things to you.
- 28:12And this is so important because what The Whistleblower documents
- 28:15showed is that people are finding increasingly radicalized
- 28:20groups to join whether it's human or whether it's
- 28:23antibiotics or whatever because the algorithm is suggesting it
- 28:27to them. They're not finding them on
- 28:29their own. These groups are being suggested
- 28:32to them by Facebook's own algorithm.
- 28:34So, we need to end. This is all happening behind
- 28:37this like, in this like black box, if we don't fully know.
- 28:41Now, we know because the documents are out, but nobody
- 28:43really knows like how this algorithm was why it was
- 28:46suggesting what it was suggesting when we didn't know
- 28:48that. So there are certain
- 28:50recommendations that we need to really start thinking about
- 28:53because these platforms that operate internationally.
- 28:57Like Facebook has almost 3 billion users now is deeply
- 29:01impacting the processes of our offline World democracy,
- 29:05vaccinations public policy campaigns, like, all of this
- 29:08stuff. So, these are the types of
- 29:10recommendations. Nations that we suggested to the
- 29:12president including setting policies about what how like
- 29:16what disclosure should happen setting policies around
- 29:20limiting. The spread of disinformation, be
- 29:22sure that we're investing in citizen education.
- 29:25Be sure. And I was just going to say,
- 29:26yeah, all of those things but it, that it has to be a, it has
- 29:31to be a multi-layered approach. Like it's not, just the
- 29:35government. There's an education piece.
- 29:36There's an economic piece. There's a foreign policy
- 29:39geopolitical piece. Is a, you know, a citizen and
- 29:43Civic piece, but all of that needs to be put together and
- 29:46what's fascinating? Is that now we're living in the
- 29:49eighth in the age where as a global citizen or as a French
- 29:53citizen. You have you're dealing with
- 29:55interference from like Global superpowers and from Global
- 30:00multinational. So what how do you protect your
- 30:03citizens? If a company whether it's Google
- 30:06or Facebook or Twitter, or Amazon or whatever has just as
- 30:09much power. As another government.
- 30:12And that it was really, what's really interesting, and then we
- 30:15talk about things like, will we need to look at influencers?
- 30:18We need to look at, you know, the Joe Rogan issue what
- 30:21responsibility does somebody who has so much reach have in terms
- 30:26of what they share. How do you navigate that with
- 30:29with the with the freedom of speech?
- 30:30So it's really really complex. But at the very least we started
- 30:34off with some very concrete recommendations around.
- 30:37Insisting on more clearer moderation practices.
- 30:40Assisting on clear algorithmic disclosures insisting on money,
- 30:45for Education, insisting on better, understanding of digital
- 30:48culture. Because if we don't take control
- 30:51of these systems, these systems are, this isn't like whale or if
- 30:56or, maybe these systems are being used by very specific
- 30:59agenda holders to so descent to so distrust and to destabilize
- 31:05political societies Democratic societies.
- 31:08So, how does it make you feel being?
- 31:10Being, you know, someone who's not natively French being asked
- 31:15to be part of this commission. I mean, it's a huge honor for
- 31:19me. I mean I have lived in France
- 31:21for 10 years this year and I think it is, you know, I'm an
- 31:27immigrant right, my parents immigrated from Syria to Canada.
- 31:30I have immigrated now to France and so my viewpoint has always
- 31:33been one of incredible gratitude and one of Civic.
- 31:40Obligation, like I believe that France has let me stay here and
- 31:44work here and live here. And I think that we all have a
- 31:47civic responsibility to do what we can to contribute to the
- 31:50better to the collective good and so I was incredibly honored
- 31:54to be the only Canadian asked on this commission and was just
- 31:59delighted to be able to use my work to try to have a, you know,
- 32:03some type of small positive impact because I am very
- 32:06protective, not just of Canada but of France, I'm very
- 32:09protective of Democracy, I think we can't take it for granted.
- 32:14I'm very protective of the type of world that we're leaving
- 32:17behind for the next generation. And I think that people forget,
- 32:21it's very easy to feel overwhelmed, and it's very easy
- 32:24to feel like, oh, we can't do anything.
- 32:26People forget that on an individual level.
- 32:28We have a tremendous ability to have an impact.
- 32:32And so, I was hoping that my work and the work of the
- 32:34commission and the research that we're doing reminds people that
- 32:37they themselves. Can also volunteer.
- 32:40Expertise in their time and their energy to making our world
- 32:44a little bit less scary. Well, and not that I want to end
- 32:51with a sort of non hopeful note. But, you know, before we started
- 32:57recording, we were talking about the period we're living in right
- 32:59now. And, you know, we Russia has
- 33:02invaded Ukraine. We have how many different, you
- 33:06know, conflicts conflict zones in the world and and Never in,
- 33:11you know, certainly in our when our parents were our age,
- 33:14perhaps did they have the access to up-to-date information about
- 33:19every single move during these sorts of events.
- 33:22So I mean if you could leave people with one sort of digital
- 33:28word of advice. You know, how do you continue to
- 33:31do, you know, do your work and do the things you need to do to
- 33:34feel like you're still moving forward, but also be engaged
- 33:38citizens, you know, not everyone will have a chance to be part.
- 33:40If you know a commission like you have how can people sort of
- 33:46reconcile, the the the digital space as it is today and not be
- 33:51completely submerged by it. So I think that these tools have
- 33:58been created by companies that are trying to make money.
- 34:01So their end goal is for you to spend as much time on these
- 34:06platforms as possible. So they will make them as
- 34:08addictive as possible, that will try to suck you in as much as As
- 34:10possible. And despite this fact.
- 34:13I still think that they can still do a lot of good.
- 34:16So my solution, my advice would be to really focus on the
- 34:20intentionality of what you want to get from these tools.
- 34:24So for example, when I go on Instagram, I have set a very
- 34:28clear guideline for myself. That I want to be educated.
- 34:32I want to be connected. I want to be delighted.
- 34:34I want to be informed. I don't want to be made to feel
- 34:37bad. I don't want to follow stuff.
- 34:39That makes me not. I feel good about my life.
- 34:41I don't want to follow fake people and so to get really,
- 34:44really clear about the intention of where you're spending your
- 34:48time because we all have such a limited amount of time and
- 34:51attention and energy and anytime something drains our attention
- 34:56or energy. It ends up impacting the rest of
- 34:58our lives, right? So as we're navigating, this
- 35:01really devastating situation in Ukraine, I think you need to
- 35:04remember that. There are a circle of control
- 35:08with which we all stand in, where there are things.
- 35:10Is that we can do. So use social media, for
- 35:13example, to find causes to support, and then support.
- 35:16Those causes use social media to be informed but like don't read
- 35:21breaking news for six hours, read once a day and update
- 35:24really the breaking news. Unless you know, unless it's
- 35:27something that's specifically going to impact you, you don't
- 35:30need to know everything as it happens and then to limit the
- 35:34time you do that. So once your informed and once
- 35:37you've suggested and sort of suggested once your informed and
- 35:40once you Corded causes once you figured out the best way to
- 35:43maybe amplify Ukrainian, voices, support Ukrainian businesses,
- 35:47sign up, or talk to your elected representative to make sure that
- 35:50we're welcoming Ukrainian refugees, etc.
- 35:53Etc. Once you have done everything
- 35:55within your zone of control, you need to log out and you need to
- 36:00stop. Letting these constant new
- 36:03stories, impact your mood and your attention one.
- 36:07We see research now around digital contagion saying it has
- 36:10a Very deep impact on your mental, well-being.
- 36:13The human nervous system and the human heart was not meant to be
- 36:16exposed to so much grief and so much tragedy non-stop on a
- 36:20global scale. It just we are not meant to
- 36:23experience this way. And this doesn't mean that we
- 36:27don't sympathize with the people of Ukraine that we don't do
- 36:29everything in our power, to help them.
- 36:31It just means that I cannot carry so much tragedy.
- 36:34Not just from the Ukraine, by the way, everywhere, Highlands
- 36:38and the United States, starvation and Yemen.
- 36:40Climate issues all over the world.
- 36:42Like there is no shortage of tragedy here.
- 36:44And all we're doing, is, we are just exposing our nervous
- 36:47systems our bodies to this, and it's having a physical tangible
- 36:50effect on us. So what I do personally is I
- 36:53have a limited amount of time where I'm updated on facts, of
- 36:57what's happening. I really try to limit the human
- 37:01interest pieces only because when when I went through this
- 37:04with d Syrian Civil War, I quickly realized that, I know
- 37:09what happens to people. Of War.
- 37:11I know the tragedies that are faced.
- 37:12I don't need more stories. I'm very well aware of what
- 37:15happens to people in zones of conflict because I've educated
- 37:18myself on this. So I try to limit that and I
- 37:21really, really focus on what I can do to help.
- 37:24So if I read a story about animal cruelty, can I donate 5
- 37:29dollars to a shelter that is taking you know, and some people
- 37:33might say but it's only five dollars.
- 37:34Yeah, but you know what? $5 is better than 0.
- 37:38A ten dollar donation to the Red Cross.
- 37:40Better than 0. So, my whole philosophy is what
- 37:43can I do? That's more than 0 and then
- 37:45everything else. I have to be present in the
- 37:47moment and I have to live my life, because what good does it
- 37:51do for? Spend six hours of my day,
- 37:54reading, sad, stories, feeling, horrible, feeling stressed out,
- 37:58feeling, anxious feeling depressed.
- 38:00Okay, like and and then what, what do we do with that?
- 38:03That doesn't actually do any good for anyone.
- 38:06So zone of control, figure out what you can do to help there
- 38:09are so Many civilian initiatives that are taking place right now.
- 38:13There are so many ways that you can help.
- 38:16Whether it's just amplifying Ukrainian voices, or supporting
- 38:19Ukrainian causes or donating to Charities.
- 38:22Whatever it is. There are people who are in
- 38:24Europe that are going down to the borders, to help with, you
- 38:27know, blankets and food and all of that stuff.
- 38:29There are people donating or opening up their homes, their
- 38:32shelters taking in people's pets, like there is something.
- 38:35So, I always think to myself, you know, nobody can do
- 38:38everything but everyone can do. So did one thing contribute and
- 38:44then you have to disconnect you have to be able to live your
- 38:47life because it's not, you know, you might feel like it's doing
- 38:51something but you being in this constant state of stress,
- 38:53doesn't actually add any value to anybody.
- 38:56And so, that would be, my recommendation is to set a
- 38:59process for yourself. I'm going to read ten minutes of
- 39:04friends, 24. I'm just going to get the facts
- 39:06of what's happening. So I'm informed going to
- 39:08identify two causes. I'm going to get 8 x amount
- 39:11however, small every bit helps. And then I'm going to
- 39:14deliberately and intentionally disconnect.
- 39:17I'm going to replenish going to take care of myself.
- 39:20Like let's also not forget that we're still living through a
- 39:23global pandemic or so living through a lot of economic
- 39:26uncertainty. There's a lot going on.
- 39:28So let's take care of ourselves because as creatives, our
- 39:33creativity is fueled by our energy and our happiness and
- 39:38our, you know, our capacity to be able To live in the world and
- 39:41we can't do that. If we are being hijacked by
- 39:44chatter that is designed to make us feel awful about the world.
- 39:48So do that and then do an audit of all of your social media
- 39:52feeds and anybody who is not adding emotional experience that
- 39:58you want to have online. You need to mute them or block
- 40:00them or follow them or delete them because life is too short
- 40:03to give so much of yourself to like internet strangers.
- 40:07And the last last thing I would say is even if If it's just a
- 40:11couple of hours, like, on Sundays, I really try to be off
- 40:14of social media. I've never realized how much
- 40:19chatter and noise we take into our lives.
- 40:21Like Twitter's people yelling Instagrams people.
- 40:24Everyone has an opinion everyone screaming and one has content.
- 40:27And so when in your day can you carve out just a little bit of
- 40:31time even if it's 15 minutes or 30 minutes for you to just let
- 40:36your own thoughts, take Center Stage let your owned mind.
- 40:40You let your own heart speak to you.
- 40:42We spend so much time listening to other people.
- 40:44We're not creating space to touch to get in touch with what
- 40:47we want. So it's very important from a
- 40:49deist immunization perspective to give ourselves some time to
- 40:52just relax replenish recharge, get in tune with ourselves, do
- 40:57our planning figure out our goals for the year.
- 41:00Go out in nature. Move.
- 41:01Our bodies, eat something healthy and nutritious, and then
- 41:04come back in. Because if left to our own
- 41:07devices, we could spend 24 hours a day plugged into the The net,
- 41:10but it's not actually adding anything of value, but you are.
- 41:14So thank you for everything that you're doing and researching and
- 41:19sharing because it is not only extremely valuable.
- 41:22But I think exactly the kind of information we need to make sure
- 41:24that we are not going into that pool of Despair on the on the
- 41:29internet with our technology. So Rahab, thank you so much, and
- 41:33I can't wait to see what you produce with this Humane
- 41:36productivity work. Thank you so much.
- 41:38I'll keep you posted. That's the show for today.
- 41:43As always. Thank you for listening
- 41:45subscribing and sharing with Friends.
- 41:48You can find all previous episodes of The New Parish
- 41:50podcast, wherever you stream your podcasts and on world radio
- 41:53Paris. If you're enjoying these
- 41:55conversations, please consider picking up a copy of the New
- 41:58Paris book or my recent release the new packaging from your
- 42:01local book sellers. Until next time, I didn't poop.