Latest / Journey to the Fringe / A history of violent strikes - Pinkertons
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:12Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, where we too partake in New Year's resolutions
- 0:18and our New Year's resolution to you is more assholes all the time, but not just UFO assholes
- 0:24now.
- 0:25We have diversified and we will be looking at all kinds.
- 0:27Except there, you know, there'll be people, the personification of the idea of an asshole.
- 0:32So yeah, if you're looking for porn, it's not here.
- 0:34Sorry guys.
- 0:35We are continuing our January tradition of historically looking at strikes that have
- 0:40brought us to the world that we have for workers' rights.
- 0:43Chelsea, today we're going to be looking at both a man and a company that have really
- 0:48shaped our labor market as we see it today.
- 0:52This episode is on the Pinkertons.
- 0:54Now, Chelsea, have you ever heard this name?
- 0:56Aside from our ongoing list of things to cover on the podcast, I have not.
- 1:02Okay.
- 1:03I just kept scrolling past it because I didn't know what it was.
- 1:06Yeah, fair enough.
- 1:07And you've actually mentioned them in the past before.
- 1:09A few of our previous episodes are going to come up in this one, but I think this is
- 1:13a good way to come into this episode because there's a lot to learn and there will be
- 1:18some surprises along the way.
- 1:19Oh, I love surprises.
- 1:21Sometimes.
- 1:22Sometimes.
- 1:23I hope they're good surprises.
- 1:24This one, I'm just going to spoil it a little bit right now.
- 1:27There's no murder death cults in here.
- 1:29So we're good.
- 1:30We go so far as to say that is foreshadowing.
- 1:33There may be some foreshadowing.
- 1:35There will be death.
- 1:36It will not be mass starvation.
- 1:37Okay.
- 1:38Well, that's good.
- 1:39That surprises out of the way though.
- 1:41Anyhow, let's get into our story and it starts with the birth of a man by the name of Alan
- 1:45Pinkerton.
- 1:46Surprisingly enough.
- 1:50Now Mr. Pinkerton born baby Pinkerton in Glasgow in July of 1819.
- 1:55He only went to school until he was 10 and then his father died.
- 2:00And I should say a lot of this comes from Wikipedia and the Pinkerton's website itself.
- 2:04There's some of it that's probably embellished.
- 2:06I'll talk about them when I'm not sure if it actually happened or not.
- 2:09Okay.
- 2:10Okay.
- 2:11So despite the fact that he left school at 10 years old, Pinkerton was still a voracious
- 2:15reader and really liked to self educate.
- 2:17Turn out that's true, no idea because it doesn't really have anything to do with the story.
- 2:21Just says he was a cooper by trade and he was active in the Scottish chartist movement
- 2:26as a young man.
- 2:27The chartists were basically the first people to say we need workers rights in the UK.
- 2:32And actually it was super interesting.
- 2:33I didn't know this, but before the chartists came along, it was actually illegal for anybody
- 2:37who didn't own land to act as a member of parliament.
- 2:41You had to own land, which basically means no workers could participate in parliament.
- 2:45I think we've talked about that before, right?
- 2:47I think I knew that.
- 2:48Well, back in the day, there used to be you had to own land to vote and that was basically
- 2:53the old style.
- 2:54Also, there was no wage for working in parliament either.
- 2:56So really, if you weren't rich outside of it, you couldn't be in parliament.
- 3:01So like the chartist movement was a big push.
- 3:04They got a few things changed.
- 3:05Those are two of the things.
- 3:06There was five things in total they did, but this is not a chartist episode.
- 3:09So we're going to keep going.
- 3:10Okay.
- 3:11But weirdly paints him as kind of like a pro worker guy.
- 3:13We'll talk about that later.
- 3:14He also says that he was raised as a lifelong atheist.
- 3:17Now, Pinkerton moves to the U.S. in 1842.
- 3:21And in 1843, he settles down in Dundee Township, Illinois, which is 50 miles northwest of Chicago
- 3:27on the Fox River.
- 3:28He built a cabin there and he starts his own Coopridge, who we don't know anything about
- 3:32because they don't mention her outside of this.
- 3:35Is sent to move with him.
- 3:37She was living in Chicago.
- 3:38He's like, Hey, I built this cabin.
- 3:39Come live with me.
- 3:40She says, okay.
- 3:41Remember, these are all thick, thick Scottish accents.
- 3:44I was going to attempt it, but I want this to be listenable.
- 3:47I was just gonna say, should we be doing that or is that a bad idea?
- 3:54Well we don't actually have that much of a Scottish listening population.
- 3:57So maybe, but didn't prep it.
- 4:00So we'll do it a different time.
- 4:01And they add this here as early as 1844.
- 4:04Pinkerton was part of the Chicago abolitionist movement as one of its leaders and his Dundee
- 4:09home was a stop on the Underground Railroad.
- 4:12So helping freed slaves get to Canada.
- 4:14Oh, that's good.
- 4:15Yeah.
- 4:16Nothing to substantiate it.
- 4:17Okay.
- 4:18Either of those.
- 4:19That's neutral then.
- 4:20Pinkerton, you know, he's got his Coopridge.
- 4:21He's making barrels, but he starts to get into a bit of criminal detective work in a
- 4:25very strange way.
- 4:26He was out in the forest looking for wood to make barrel staves and he came across what
- 4:32he considered a band of counterfeiters.
- 4:35After observing their movement for some time, he informed the local sheriff who arrested
- 4:39this counterfeiter group.
- 4:40This led to Pinkerton being appointed in 1849 as the first police detective in Chicago.
- 4:45And in 1850, he partnered with Chicago attorney Edward Rucker in forming the Northwestern
- 4:50police agency, which later became Pinkerton and company.
- 4:53And finally it ends up with the name Pinkerton National Detective Agency.
- 4:57Those were his only prerequisites with stumbling upon a group of counter.
- 5:02Were they actually even counterfeiting?
- 5:05See, I don't actually know for sure because you know, police records from that day are
- 5:09spotty at best.
- 5:10Like there's no criminal database at the time.
- 5:12Wow.
- 5:13I am just flabbergasted at this.
- 5:15Back in the days when you just had to stumble upon a crime to...
- 5:18Some crazy Scottish man yelling things.
- 5:21I better follow him.
- 5:22Seems like an excellent detective.
- 5:24Okay.
- 5:25Okay.
- 5:26He's a shaker and a mover.
- 5:27Got it.
- 5:28So the Pinkerton's National Detective Agency starts off and kind of the bread and butter
- 5:31of the detective work.
- 5:33First off working for the postal service because you know, postal detective work is lucrative
- 5:38at the time.
- 5:39And then they move on to the railway because you know, natural segue because those are
- 5:43the two groups that pay well.
- 5:44For how he got into this, like then he just gets postal and railway, like national things.
- 5:51You just wait to see where this goes.
- 5:53First off, he realized that this company was going to be very evil right from the start.
- 5:59Chelsea, I need you to look up Pinkerton logo just so that you can see what I'm talking
- 6:04about.
- 6:05Oh no.
- 6:06Pinkerton's insignia is a wide open eye with the caption, we never sleep underneath it.
- 6:10Oh no.
- 6:11This is troublesome.
- 6:12This is very straight up.
- 6:14He's like, how can I make this seem evil?
- 6:16I don't think you can come up with an evil or logo.
- 6:19Nope.
- 6:20And this is how he got the counterfeiters for sure is by never sleeping and always watching
- 6:26them.
- 6:27Yeah.
- 6:28Okay.
- 6:29So he gets out doing postal detective work and then moves on into the railway because
- 6:34there's lots of train robberies happening at the time.
- 6:36It apparently solves a couple of them during the 1850s.
- 6:39And this brings Pinkerton into contact with a man by the name of George B. McClellan,
- 6:43who was the chief engineer and vice president of the Illinois Central Railroad.
- 6:46And then another man you may have heard this name before, Abraham Lincoln, who was a lawyer
- 6:51for the company as well.
- 6:52Can we just go over his details quick because he's a very tall man, well known for his wrestling
- 6:57acumen.
- 6:58And he turns up, I believe, also becoming president of the United States and assassinated.
- 7:02Right.
- 7:03That Abraham Lincoln.
- 7:04Okay.
- 7:05Yes.
- 7:06As a act.
- 7:07Yes.
- 7:08Wood teeth, I believe as well.
- 7:09No, that was the other one.
- 7:10It was Washington.
- 7:11Wood teeth.
- 7:12Yeah.
- 7:13Yeah.
- 7:14Anyhow, that he has a relationship now with Abe Lincoln.
- 7:16And then the civil war begins.
- 7:18Pinkertons ends up serving as the head of Union intelligence services during the first two
- 7:23years of the war.
- 7:25And apparently he heads off an alleged assassination plot in Baltimore to assassinate Abe Lincoln
- 7:31on his way to Washington, DC.
- 7:33Weren't they friends or lovers?
- 7:35Friends as far as I can tell.
- 7:36He was also tasked with providing estimates of Confederate troop numbers to General George
- 7:41B. McClellan.
- 7:42Again, that other guy was part of the railroad.
- 7:44This guy just seems to stumble into like the best people to get him stuff.
- 7:48You can't even do something like this these days.
- 7:51You could never have no credentials and just be head of security for the United States.
- 7:57Literally, in 1844 is around the time that he stopped the counterfeiters.
- 8:02And then five years later, he's protecting the president.
- 8:05This is five years later?
- 8:07Wow.
- 8:08No, this is like a different day and age.
- 8:10You could never.
- 8:11We can't even own houses now because they're too expensive.
- 8:16Oh, man.
- 8:19So he was tasked with providing general estimates of Confederate troop numbers for General George
- 8:24B. McClellan when he commanded the Army of the Potomac.
- 8:27His agents often worked undercover as Confederate soldiers and sympathizers to gather military
- 8:32intelligence.
- 8:33Pinkerton himself served on several undercover missions as a Confederate soldier using the
- 8:37alias Major E.G. Allen.
- 8:40And I really love when people are so lazy with their aliases that they literally just
- 8:43use their first name as their last name.
- 8:46It's pretty great.
- 8:47I'm just getting to thinking now.
- 8:49Where would he come up with his like process for how to do things as like intelligence?
- 8:55Like he has no experience other than stumbling upon people in the woods.
- 9:00And now he's like in charge of very big things.
- 9:02Oh, yeah.
- 9:03He's just making it up.
- 9:04He's like, maybe we got to do this today.
- 9:08And allegedly stops an assassination attempt against Ample Lincoln, which is just like
- 9:12so bizarre.
- 9:13But at the same time, zero proof, zero proof this ever happened.
- 9:17Like nobody was arrested for it.
- 9:18Okay, so maybe that's how he's doing things.
- 9:21My opinion is he's an absolute bullshitter.
- 9:24Yeah.
- 9:25And people can't understand him.
- 9:26And you can only ask somebody three times to repeat themselves before it's too awkward
- 9:30to just accept what they said.
- 9:34I'm flabbergasted at this point.
- 9:36Like, okay, okay, let's continue.
- 9:38He's working as Major E.G. Allen in the Confederacy to go undercover and figure this shit out.
- 9:43What's going on?
- 9:44He was crossing the deep south in the summer of 1861, focusing on fortifications and Confederate
- 9:49plans.
- 9:50He was found out in Memphis and barely escaped with his life.
- 9:53This counterintelligence work done by Pinkerton and his agents is comparable to the work done
- 9:57by today's US Army counterintelligence special agents in which Pinkerton's agency is considered
- 10:02an early predecessor.
- 10:05He was succeeded as intelligence service chief by Lefayette Baker.
- 10:08The intelligence service was then the predecessor of the US Secret Service.
- 10:12So basically the Pinkertons invented the Secret Service too.
- 10:15This is insane.
- 10:16Out of nowhere.
- 10:17This guy just meat-up.
- 10:19Just one of those in meat-callets.
- 10:20I have to add this at this point because we just talked about how instrumental he was
- 10:24during the Civil War in the US.
- 10:27Military historians have been strongly critical of the intelligence Pinkerton provided for
- 10:31the Union Army, which for the most part was undigested raw data.
- 10:34In the view of T. Harry Williams, Pinkerton was the poorest intelligence service any general
- 10:40ever had.
- 10:41Pinkerton's estimates of rebel troop numbers derived from his credulous interrogations of
- 10:45Confederate prisoners, deserters, refugees, and escaped slaves, and civilians, unused
- 10:49to counting large bodies of men, badly exaggerated the size of those formations, sometimes almost
- 10:54doubling their actual strength.
- 10:56So the general would ask him to go figure out how many Confederate troops are in this
- 10:59area and he would be like, oh yeah, there's like 10,000 troops and there'd be maybe a
- 11:04few hundred.
- 11:05I mean, that's on point for this guy.
- 11:08I would expect something more like this.
- 11:10So yeah, that's a lot of this is really curated to make Pinkerton's look like they're really
- 11:15good, but there's definitely information out there that they weren't that great.
- 11:19I mean, that would track for me as far as what I know so far.
- 11:23Once the Civil War is done, Pinkerton finishes the service with the Union Army.
- 11:26This is done before a Blinkins assassinated, so you really can't blame him for not stopping
- 11:31that assassination.
- 11:32That one did exist and it did happen.
- 11:34However, he continued pursuits outside of that work, working for the train companies
- 11:38again.
- 11:39Pinkerton started running down train robbers, including the Reno gang, which I didn't end
- 11:42up looking into, who is also hired by the Railroad Express companies to track Jesse
- 11:46James.
- 11:47This is a super messed up story.
- 11:49Jesse James and Pinkerton's have like a big fight for a long time, I guess a feud.
- 11:53So Pinkerton's fails to capture him for a while.
- 11:56Railroad withdraws their financial support for Pinkerton's, but Pinkerton's continues
- 12:00to track James at their own expense.
- 12:02And after James allegedly captured and killed one of Pinkerton's undercover agents, they
- 12:07decide in 1875 they're going to go to Jesse James' mom's house and they do a raid, like
- 12:13one of the first police raids, even though they're a private company.
- 12:16It's in Clay County, Missouri.
- 12:17Frank and Jesse, Frank is, I believe, Jesse's partner.
- 12:20They were nowhere around.
- 12:21It was just like Jesse James' mom and his half brother who's eight years old.
- 12:25Pinkerton's they go in, they get in a huge argument with the mom, and then somehow during
- 12:29this entire time, one of the detectives throws something inside the house and it explodes.
- 12:36Jesse James' mother's arm is blown off and his half brother ends up dying.
- 12:41So there's a botched raid.
- 12:43Pinkerton's the company loses a lot of PR over this time.
- 12:46And after seeing his detectives denounced as murderers in the papers, Alan Pinkerton decides
- 12:51to call off his war against Jesse James.
- 12:52Never catches Jesse James.
- 12:53Then in 1871, Congress appropriates $50,000 to the new Department of Justice to form a
- 12:59sub-organization devoted to quote, the detection and prosecution of those guilty of violating
- 13:05federal law, end quote.
- 13:06The amount was insufficient to actually start an internal investigation unit.
- 13:10So they just end up contracting out to Pinkerton's.
- 13:12So Pinkerton's gets $50,000 in 1871 for detective work for the government.
- 13:17That's about $1.2 million today.
- 13:19Holy crap.
- 13:20And in 1872, they are contracted by the Spanish government to help suppress a revolution in
- 13:25Cuba which intended to end slavery and give citizens the right to vote.
- 13:29So they are now being contracted as a militia, like internationally.
- 13:33This is so wild right?
- 13:35Yeah.
- 13:36And this is super weird too, because Pinkerton, remember, he was part of the abolitionist movement
- 13:41in Chicago allegedly.
- 13:42So why the hell would you take money from this to suppress a slave uprising in Cuba?
- 13:48If you're abolitionist.
- 13:50Sounds like he either wasn't a part of it in the first place or he's just doing whatever
- 13:54to make money.
- 13:55I think part of it is just trying to give a good reflection on the history of saying,
- 13:59oh yeah, he's an abolitionist when really he would just take any money he could get.
- 14:03And like right from the start again, evil logo, evil as logo you could get.
- 14:07It's true.
- 14:08It doesn't get much evil than that logo.
- 14:09In the 1870s, Franklin B. Gowan, then president of the Philadelphia and Reading Railroad,
- 14:14hired the agency to quote, investigate and quote, the labor unions in the company's minds.
- 14:19Pinkerton agent James McParland using the alias James McKenna infiltrated what is called
- 14:24the Molly McGuire's, which was a 19th century.
- 14:26It's called a secret society, which apparently they infiltrated of mainly Irish American coal
- 14:32miners.
- 14:33They ended up being the cause of the Molly McGuire's being no more.
- 14:36Now I need to tell you, Molly McGuire's their secret society of Irish immigrant coal miners
- 14:41basically just advocate for workers rights.
- 14:43Now they are a little more extreme and that they would terrorize or even kill foremen and
- 14:49supervisors.
- 14:51They also are anti-war.
- 14:53Part of their charter is they won't fight a rich man's war and they rebelled against
- 14:56drafts during the civil war.
- 14:57So not considered great, but they were literally just workers have no rights.
- 15:01There's no way to enforce them.
- 15:02We need to be violent.
- 15:03I mean, I can't argue with their logic.
- 15:06I agree with everything that they're for.
- 15:08The undercover work done by Pinkerton's during this time led to many of them being executed
- 15:14by the state in 1877.
- 15:16And this inspired Arthur Conan Doyle, the writer of Sherlock Holmes to write the novel
- 15:21The Valley of Fear, a Pinkerton agent also appears in a small role in the adventure of
- 15:25Red Circle, which is a Sherlock Holmes story.
- 15:28So Arthur Conan Doyle was very aware of them and writing about them as well.
- 15:32Well, they seem to be shaking things up during this time.
- 15:35But alas, our friend Alan Pinkerton comes to an end on July 1st, 1884.
- 15:41Get this.
- 15:42Okay.
- 15:43Pinkerton living a big life.
- 15:44How do you think he came to an end?
- 15:45He choked on a ham sandwich.
- 15:47You know what?
- 15:48Not that far off.
- 15:49Okay.
- 15:50How was it?
- 15:51The general consensus at the time was that he was walking, slipped on some pavement,
- 15:56bit his tongue, died of gangrene.
- 15:58What?
- 15:59You know, it's not hard to die, really.
- 16:02Especially before penicillin.
- 16:03It's a scary thing.
- 16:04Yeah.
- 16:05There's things out there that are very mundane that'll get you.
- 16:08And it's the world's escape replace.
- 16:10I should say a lot of people also believe it could have been a stroke, but the consensus
- 16:14of the time was gangrene of the tongue.
- 16:16Wow.
- 16:17That okay.
- 16:18So, he dies in 1884, control of Pinkerton's detective agency goes to Pinkerton's sons,
- 16:23Robert and William Pinkerton, and the company continues to grow.
- 16:27So by the 1890s, 1884, within five years, Pinkerton's has 2,000 detectives and 30,000
- 16:34reserve, which is basically anybody that can get in to come do stuff.
- 16:37This is more men than the standing army of the US.
- 16:40Where are these people coming from?
- 16:42It's just people need work.
- 16:43Okay.
- 16:44And then like, these are the only detectives.
- 16:46And some states see this and they're like, holy shit.
- 16:48This is a mercenary army that you guys have.
- 16:50So some states outright ban Pinkerton's or outlaw Pinkerton's from working in their
- 16:54state.
- 16:55It's really just Ohio, but they at least said like, we don't want Pinkerton's in here,
- 16:58so they banned them.
- 16:59It's not a bad move, I would say.
- 17:02During Alan Pinkerton's life, the Pinkerton's detective agency is credited with creating
- 17:06the first crime database.
- 17:07They're credited with creating the idea of a mugshot.
- 17:10They hired the first female private investigator in US history, and they in fact coined the
- 17:14term private investigator or PI.
- 17:16I was just going to say, not only did they hire the first female when they had the first
- 17:21male one.
- 17:22Yes.
- 17:23But that's actually, that's crazy.
- 17:26It just seems weird to me, like a woman working in the 1800s as a PI.
- 17:31Like that seems pretty progressive.
- 17:33It is actually.
- 17:34Okay.
- 17:35Kids take it over.
- 17:36We're going to get into some of the shadier shit that goes on now.
- 17:38First and foremost is the Haymarket riots.
- 17:40In 1886, there was a protest against the killings and woundings of several workers during a
- 17:45strike at the McCormick Reaper works.
- 17:47This is in Illinois.
- 17:48The Haymarket riots take place in Chicago.
- 17:50Everybody goes to the Haymarket.
- 17:52All these workers go there.
- 17:53They start having a protest, turns into a riot.
- 17:56Situation escalates into a violent riot when an unidentified person throws a bomb at the
- 18:00police, which results in the death of eight people.
- 18:03Policemen and Pinkerton's were surrounding this protest at the time that the bomb went
- 18:07off.
- 18:08And then seven anarchists are arrested despite zero evidence linking them to the specific
- 18:11crimes.
- 18:12Pinkerton's detective testifies at the trial that they saw these people do this.
- 18:16Four of the men go to the gallows.
- 18:17They were hanged.
- 18:18Oh, no.
- 18:19During the trial, a defense team actually suggests there's evidence linking the Pinkerton's
- 18:24to the bomb being thrown, which reflects a widespread belief among the strikers.
- 18:28However, they could not substantiate this and again put to the gallows.
- 18:32Four of them.
- 18:33Well, the Pinkerton's?
- 18:34No, the anarchists.
- 18:35Well, how come the anarchists have to substantiate this and not the freaking Pinkerton?
- 18:40Because Pinkerton's are detectives, so they know this shit.
- 18:43That's at least what people believe at the time.
- 18:44Oh my God.
- 18:46Okay.
- 18:47This is a wild time to be alive.
- 18:50Seven years after this, the Illinois governor ends up pardoning the last three living haymarket
- 18:55anarchists after identifying the police and Pinkerton's as unreliable narrators.
- 19:00So yeah, they said that it turns out it's not true at all.
- 19:03Oh my God.
- 19:04Then in 1892, there's what's known as the Homestead Strike.
- 19:07This is Andrew Carnegie, who's a steel robber baron.
- 19:11You would know Andrew Carnegie not necessarily by name, but you've heard of Carnegie Hall
- 19:15before, right?
- 19:16Yes.
- 19:17No, I'm thinking of Dale Carnegie.
- 19:18Yeah, I know.
- 19:19Dale Carnegie's a different guy.
- 19:20Carnegie ends up donating pretty much all of his wealth before he dies and they build
- 19:23like culture around the big cities in the US.
- 19:26He ends up fairly poor when he dies, but he's an absolute asshole while he's alive.
- 19:31To give you a short idea of what the Homestead Strike is, in 1892, there's a city in Pennsylvania
- 19:37called Homestead.
- 19:38It's a company town, so it's built around a steel mill.
- 19:41Andrew Carnegie has a guy to run the plant and his last name is Frick.
- 19:44Can't remember his first name, but Frick is good enough for this.
- 19:47That's a good last name.
- 19:48Oh, especially if you're going to be somebody who's doing the biddings of a robber baron.
- 19:53Anyhow.
- 19:54Do they have those anymore?
- 19:56We just have nicer names for them.
- 19:57We just call them philanthropists.
- 19:59Okay.
- 20:00Carnegie tells Frick he wants to get rid of the union in town.
- 20:03So when the contract's up for ratification, they lock the workers out of the plant.
- 20:07They put up barbwire fences around the actual plant itself.
- 20:10They put up water cannons, which can actually spray boiling hot water at anybody outside.
- 20:15Basically, they say, no, can't go in there, can't work.
- 20:17We're going to bring people into town to do the job instead of you scabs.
- 20:21And the workers are saying, well, screw you.
- 20:23We're just going to not let anybody in.
- 20:24It's a company town.
- 20:25They live there with their families.
- 20:27The only way in and out of town is by barge because it's on a river.
- 20:30They just block anybody if they don't know in town.
- 20:32They say, get the hell out of here.
- 20:33The only people actually from outside of town they allow is the media.
- 20:36And if they think you're going to write a bad thing about the workers, they say, get
- 20:39lost.
- 20:41They were really set up quite nicely with that barge in and out.
- 20:45Carnegie ends up hiring 300 Pinkerton detectives to come shut down the strike.
- 20:50They come in by barge.
- 20:52They end up getting into a 12 hour gunfight between 3,800 workers and 300 Pinkerton's
- 20:58that are on the barge.
- 20:59Three Pinkerton's die and seven workers die and then Pinkerton's end up surrendering.
- 21:03So doesn't go well for them.
- 21:05That's a really weird way how this strike ends just to give you the Coles notes.
- 21:09An anarchist from New York hears what's going on and the workers had huge public support.
- 21:15This anarchist hears about this Frick guy and he's like, oh, this guy is horrible.
- 21:18He ends up going to Homestead and attempting to assassinate Frick.
- 21:21He stabs him, but Frick survives and then public attention of this changes and they're
- 21:26against the workers now.
- 21:27So whether or not that's actually what happens, that's how the story ends up changing and
- 21:31the strike breaks.
- 21:32Everybody ends up going back to work working longer hours for less pay.
- 21:36Oh no.
- 21:37Yeah.
- 21:38Pinkerton's tried to have a hand in that.
- 21:39They did horribly in it.
- 21:40So Homestead happens and the Pinkerton's group starts moving out of the corporate thug
- 21:44business like where we'll go just shut down a strike.
- 21:47They felt that the damage to the company's reputation was not worth the business.
- 21:51After all, the company's technical main business was catching criminals and not serving as shock
- 21:57forces for capitalists, but they still remain involved in Union Bustin by setting in agents
- 22:02to spy.
- 22:03The next strike that they get involved in is the Cortalane Strike in Idaho.
- 22:06In order to invest in machinery, a coal mine in Idaho decides that what we're going to
- 22:11do is change your hours.
- 22:13All the workers, they work working nine hour days, six days a week.
- 22:15They want to change it to 10 hour days, seven days a week and give them a pay cut.
- 22:19Oh my God.
- 22:20They form a labor union.
- 22:21They start planning a strike and the labor union is then infiltrated by Pinkerton's agents.
- 22:26They basically go in and say like, oh yeah, I want to work in the coal.
- 22:29Oh yeah, I want to be part of the union.
- 22:30They go to all the union meetings as Pinkerton agents and pass that information all on to
- 22:34the owners of the mines.
- 22:36So they routinely provide union information to the mine owners and there ends up being
- 22:39violence in this.
- 22:41On July 11th, 1892, the striking coal miners in Cortalane blow up the Frisco Mill, a mine
- 22:47building filled with guards after getting into a firefight with Pinkerton's later on.
- 22:51Killing two mine employees and taking about 60 mine guards prisoner.
- 22:54This led to the governor of Idaho declaring martial law over the mining district and crushing
- 22:58the mine strike.
- 22:59During this time, like it's a field day for union busting company.
- 23:02So another one pops up kind of the big competitor of Pinkerton's of the day is called the Baldwin
- 23:07felts agency.
- 23:08They really have a foothold in West Virginia.
- 23:10So a lot of the strikes that go on in West Virginia end up having Baldwin felts agents
- 23:14attached to it.
- 23:15So like the battle of Blair Mountain had Baldwin felts as opposed to Pinkerton's.
- 23:19Okay.
- 23:20Do you remember the battle of Blair Mountain where it's all those coal miners on strike
- 23:22that end up getting attacked by air raids?
- 23:24Yeah, I always get that one confused with the big foot one.
- 23:29That one's also a battle of some mountain.
- 23:31Right.
- 23:32Right.
- 23:34Next up is the Pullman strike of 1894, which we did in our first episode of a history of
- 23:39violent strikes.
- 23:40Just to give you a bit of an idea, Pullman is a company that builds box cars just outside
- 23:45of Chicago.
- 23:46They have the American Railway Union and out of union solidarity, they started blocking
- 23:51anything that was pulling a Pullman car.
- 23:53They just said, Nope, Nope, we're not going to work on it.
- 23:55During this strike, 20,000 troops were called out to ensure that the trains carried us mail
- 24:00could travel freely.
- 24:0130 people end up being killed during riots in Chicago for this, which may have gone up
- 24:06to 40 of nobody really knows.
- 24:07And there was property damage in the excess of 80 million.
- 24:10This is specifically listed under the Pinkerton's Wikipedia page as something they're involved
- 24:14with, but I couldn't find the particulars as to how they were involved with it.
- 24:18So they were just involved with the Pullman strike as far as I can tell.
- 24:20Okay.
- 24:21Somehow, maybe.
- 24:22Yeah.
- 24:23They were involved in one called the Miner Strike in Bradwood, Illinois.
- 24:26Pinkerton's was used by the industrialists against the miners during these strikes.
- 24:30The strikes were triggered by wage cuts and resulted in violent confrontations between
- 24:34Pinkerton's and striking miners.
- 24:35They were also involved.
- 24:36Chelsea, you did this one, the Great Railroad Strike of 1877, which was one of the most
- 24:41significant labor disputes in the 19th century.
- 24:43Strike was triggered by wage cuts and was marked by violent confrontations again between
- 24:47Pinkerton's and strikers.
- 24:49In 1905, Harry Orchard ends up being arrested by the Idaho police and confessing to Pinkerton
- 24:55agents, particularly James McFarland, that he assassinated former governor Frank Struenberg
- 25:00of Idaho.
- 25:01He's a prominent person in the workers' rights worlds and for unions.
- 25:05And he just so happens to confess to a Pinkerton's person detective that he murdered the former
- 25:11governor.
- 25:12I mean, they seem like standup guys that would always tell the truth, though.
- 25:16Oh, yeah, for sure.
- 25:17Yeah.
- 25:18And so, they acquitted for it in a nationally publicized trial.
- 25:21However, there were several people that were implicated in this and there was a trial.
- 25:24Harry Orchard ends up receiving a death sentence but ends up getting it commuted, so he's not
- 25:28actually put to death.
- 25:30What actually happened there, I'm not sure, though.
- 25:31This one I find super interesting.
- 25:33In 1907, Morris Friedman reported that Pinkerton agents had infiltrated the Western Federation
- 25:39of Miners and managed to gain control of the strike relief fund.
- 25:43So you know that money that they have for a rainy day if they need to go on strike?
- 25:46He ends up exhausting the treasury by awarding lavish benefits to strikers.
- 25:50However, many attacks against unions have used force for one sort or another.
- 25:54They found new and different ways to actually stop strikers.
- 25:57This guy joined the union as a Pinkerton's detective.
- 26:00He's like, oh yeah, yeah, I'm good with money.
- 26:02I'll handle the money.
- 26:03And just gave it all out so that they had no money to support themselves while striking.
- 26:07Their timeline of events is bizarre.
- 26:10It's just been a wild ride from like stumbling upon people potentially counterfeiting in
- 26:15the woods to now they're working against unions and like.
- 26:19And that's like exclusively what they do during this time.
- 26:22Like they're still working for the railways.
- 26:23This is so weird.
- 26:24But yeah.
- 26:25And then according to the New Republic, a newspaper, the Pinkerton's were also brought
- 26:28in alongside the Colorado National Guard during the 1914 Ludlow massacre.
- 26:32So I have to give you a little more background on this one because this is just insane.
- 26:35So the Ludlow massacre is basically soldiers from Colorado's National Guard and private
- 26:39guards employed by the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company who were brought in to stop a strike
- 26:44that was going on at a coal mine, basically a tank colony of roughly 1200 workers and
- 26:50also their families living in Ludlow, Colorado.
- 26:52So Pinkerton's and the Colorado National Guard are brought in to suppress it.
- 26:57John Rockefeller Jr. was also a part owner in this company.
- 27:00And that's just a little bit of information for the robber baron side of it all.
- 27:03Anyhow, what happens is they end up burning down the tent city and 69 to 199 people were
- 27:10killed during the suppression.
- 27:12And it's considered quote the deadliest strike in the history of the United States.
- 27:16I don't know what to say about that.
- 27:18And the 69 to 199 people who died were mostly women and children.
- 27:22They were not the people that were on strike because the families would be in the tent.
- 27:26I was just going to say were like they doing any fighting or did they just go light up
- 27:31the houses, so to say.
- 27:32I think they were trying to disperse them away from the mine so that if you don't have
- 27:36a place to live, why would you stick around the mine?
- 27:38Great idea Pinkerton's, but that's been the theme for the whole podcast.
- 27:43The Ludlow massacre was a watershed moment in American labor relations.
- 27:47Socialist historian Howard Zinn describes it as quote the culminating act of perhaps the
- 27:51most violent struggle between corporate power and laboring men in American history and quote.
- 27:55And this is really a changing point for how Pinkerton's can relate to things.
- 27:59So Congress responds to public outrage by directing the House Committee on Mines and
- 28:03Mining to investigate the events.
- 28:05It publishes a report in 1915 which is super influential and child labor laws being introduced
- 28:11to the US and an eight hour work day.
- 28:14The Ludlow Town site and the adjacent location of the tent colony is now a ghost town that
- 28:18you can go visit.
- 28:19So super weird.
- 28:21The massacre site is owned by the United Mine Workers of America which erected a granite
- 28:25monument in memory of those who died that day.
- 28:27I should also say it's not just Pinkerton's that's implicated in that one, Baldwin Felt
- 28:32is also implicated.
- 28:33In the 1930s the Pinkerton agency employed 1200 labor spies and nearly one third of them
- 28:38held high level positions in targeted unions.
- 28:40The International Association of Machinists was damaged when Sam Brady, a veteran Pinkerton
- 28:45operative held a high enough position in the union that he was able to precipitate a premature
- 28:49strike.
- 28:50So he pushed them to go on strike when they weren't ready for it.
- 28:53So it was a failure.
- 28:54And all but five officers in the United Auto Workers Local in Lansing, Michigan were driven
- 28:59out by Pinkerton's agents.
- 29:00The five who remained were Pinkerton's at the end of the day.
- 29:03At the Underwood Elliott Fisher Company plant the union local was so badly injured by undercover
- 29:07operatives that membership dropped from more than 2500 to fewer than 75.
- 29:12So they moved from being like just the bullies to a very different style.
- 29:17This is so stupid.
- 29:19But this is where the big change happens for Pinkerton's.
- 29:21Bosses once hired the firm because agents would do just about anything to break a strike.
- 29:26Pinkerton's agents would lie and kill if necessary and they could do things and go places
- 29:29law enforcement could not.
- 29:31Companies hire Pinkerton's now because the firm's very name still implies a threat.
- 29:35As the 20th century progressed, Pinkerton's changed their concentration and more of their
- 29:39resources into surveillance and corporate espionage.
- 29:42When the U.S. Senate convened the Lafayette Civil Liberties Committee in 1936, senators
- 29:48found that the Pinkerton's had not only infiltrated general workers whose workers were then attempting
- 29:53to organize with the United Auto Workers.
- 29:55Their agents had also destroyed evidence before the governor could complete an investigation
- 30:00of their activities.
- 30:01They're not only infiltrating these guys, they're specifically destroying evidence
- 30:05that could implicate them in anything that the government is finding.
- 30:09Because of this, they passed the Wagner Act through Congress in the 1930s, which made
- 30:13the investigation of labor activities illegal.
- 30:16Pinkerton's then shifted its focus towards the investigation of gambling, particularly
- 30:20the horse racing circuit.
- 30:21Weirdly enough.
- 30:23During World War II, in the 1940s, the agency provided guarding services for war supply plans.
- 30:28This marked a significant shift in the agency's service, with property guarding becoming their
- 30:32primary focus.
- 30:33It's all been significant shifts, I would say.
- 30:37They're just all over the map.
- 30:38In the 1960s, the word detective disappeared from the agency's letterhead, reflecting
- 30:42its shift from the detective work towards protection services.
- 30:46During this period, the agency also established offices in Hong Kong, opening doors to operations
- 30:50in Asia.
- 30:51I don't know much about that side of it.
- 30:53In the late 20th century, the company became increasingly involved in risk management
- 30:57and executive protection, and it was bought by a Swedish security company known as Securitas
- 31:02AB in 1999, which led to further expansion and diversification in its services.
- 31:07The company now operating as Pinkerton Consulting and Investigations Incorporated focuses on
- 31:13threat intelligence, risk management, executive protection, and active shooter responses.
- 31:18Within recent years, Pinkerton has transformed into a global provider of corporate risk management
- 31:23and has pioneered the holistic approach called ESRM, Enterprise Security Risk Management,
- 31:27and has also developed a comprehensive risk management platform to unlock a specialized
- 31:32solution framework.
- 31:33A lot of that comes from PR bullshit from them.
- 31:35They are still around today.
- 31:36They're very real still.
- 31:37The Pinkerton survived and entered the 21st century intact, largely on the strength of
- 31:42their ability to intimidate, surveil, and gather intelligence about workers.
- 31:46On its website, the company advertises global protective intelligence, and produced in
- 31:51large part by agents who are embedded or on call.
- 31:55Corporate clients can access the Pinkerton Vigilance Network, which consists of the
- 31:58firm's agents, government agencies, and 1,000 plus private sources.
- 32:03The goal is to help corporations manage risk on all fronts, from natural disasters to political
- 32:09events.
- 32:10Pinkerton's hardly the only firm to advertise such services, but its history sets it apart
- 32:14and the company embraces its legacy.
- 32:17Quote, with one call to Pinkerton, you gain access to our global network of resources,
- 32:21providing boots on the ground when and where you need them.
- 32:24End quote, it promises.
- 32:26And Securetoss add for the firm lists, quote, labor demonstrations, and quote, among the
- 32:30risks it can monitor.
- 32:32So they're still in anti-union bullshit.
- 32:35Trouble can happen anywhere, anytime.
- 32:37That's their tagline.
- 32:38Is that legal anymore?
- 32:39Anti-union?
- 32:40Let's look at what they've been doing the last few years.
- 32:42This came right from Chelsea of all places that's writing anti-Pinkerton stuff.
- 32:48What magazine do you think it is?
- 32:49Is it the cult one?
- 32:50You're never going to guess it.
- 32:51This is Teen Vogue.
- 32:52I'm never going to...
- 32:53Teen Vogue?
- 32:54Yeah.
- 32:55Okay.
- 32:56Weirdly, a bunch of bullshit about teenage celebrity shit and then pro-labor rights stuff.
- 33:01Okay.
- 33:02Don't understand it at all.
- 33:04The Pinkerton promise is attractive to some Silicon Valley firms.
- 33:08The Guardian reported on March 16th that Google and Facebook have both retained Pinkerton's
- 33:13to monitor staff for leaks, quote, among other services Pinkerton offers to send investigators
- 33:18to coffee shops or restaurants near a company's campus to eavesdrop on employees' conversations,
- 33:23end quote.
- 33:24Olivia Salon reported, oh my God.
- 33:26The Pinkerton representatives told Salon that its agents typically focus on IP theft
- 33:32and insider trading, but the firm's reach may not end with those concerns.
- 33:36And sorry, I said this is Teen Vogue.
- 33:38This one's not Teen Vogue.
- 33:39This one's Salon.
- 33:40Quote, through LinkedIn searches, the Guardian found several former Pinkerton investigators
- 33:44to have subsequently been hired by Facebook, Google, and Apple.
- 33:48Salon roped.
- 33:49Oh.
- 33:50Facebook and Google fittingly are now in the process of building their own physical communities.
- 33:54Apartments in Willow Village and Alphabet City will theoretically be available to all,
- 33:57but the parallels of company towns of mold are obvious.
- 34:01That's crazy.
- 34:02So they're working for Facebook and Google doing God knows what and Apple.
- 34:06Next up, dozens of leaked documents from Amazon's Global Security Operations Center
- 34:10reveal the company's reliance on Pinkerton operatives to spy on warehouse workers and
- 34:14the extensive monitoring of labor unions, environmental activists, and other social
- 34:19movements.
- 34:20Is that legal?
- 34:21Is it?
- 34:22Or no?
- 34:23Yes.
- 34:24It must be.
- 34:25Quasie.
- 34:26Gray area.
- 34:27Next up, there have been reports of Starbucks using Pinkerton agents to monitor labor board
- 34:29rulings.
- 34:30This suggests that Starbucks may have been using Pinkerton agents to gather information about
- 34:33potential union activities and to prepare for potential strikes or other labor disputes.
- 34:38All these big companies.
- 34:39And then this one is super weird.
- 34:42This has to do with Magic the Gathering.
- 34:43Chelsea, do you know what that is?
- 34:45Yeah, that card game.
- 34:47Major nerd card game.
- 34:48They're owned by Wizards of the Coast, who is an ardent defender of its IP.
- 34:52Basically, they make a ton of money off Magic the Gathering and a few other things.
- 34:55So they tightly hold things close at hand without letting it out.
- 34:59A YouTuber by the name of Dan Cannon, who goes by old school MTG on YouTube, he uploaded
- 35:04a video of himself opening a box of Magic the Gathering cards that he'd just got in
- 35:08the mail.
- 35:09And it turns out the cards weren't supposed to be released yet.
- 35:12They accidentally got sent to him.
- 35:14They were from the next set that was supposed to come out, not the current set that was
- 35:17coming out.
- 35:18So he posts these videos of him opening what's called the March of the Machines aftermath.
- 35:22Whereas the card set that had come out was March of the Machines.
- 35:25You can see how it's fucking confusing.
- 35:28This set was not due to be released until later in the year, but Cannon had purchased
- 35:32the box from an acquaintance who was unaware they were selling an unreleased set.
- 35:35In response to these videos, Wizards of the Coast, the publisher of Magic the Gathering,
- 35:39hires Pinkerton to recover the leaked cards.
- 35:42The agents arrive at Cannon's house, demand he hand over the stolen products, and tell
- 35:47him that he will face jail time.
- 35:49If he does not, they're in his house, berating him and his family, and saying, you're going
- 35:53to go to jail if you don't hand these cards over because you stole them.
- 35:56He ends up giving all of the cards and tokens and everything that had to do with these cards,
- 36:00even the packaging, to the Pinkerton's detectives.
- 36:03Because they intimidated him so much.
- 36:05Why is that the way they do it though?
- 36:07Why wouldn't they be like, I'll give you these ones instead, just give me those?
- 36:11I don't want to do dicks.
- 36:12Yeah, Cannon, the guy who posted the videos, maintains that the cards were just mistakenly
- 36:16sent to him from a person whom he purchased them from.
- 36:19And after the incident, Cannon was given a number to call at Wizards of the Coast.
- 36:22The representative he spoke to was apologetic and assured him they did not believe any
- 36:26one had stolen the cards instead.
- 36:27They wanted to investigate how the unreleased set had ended up in his hands and plug that
- 36:32hole.
- 36:33They might just be making that shit up, but Pinkerton's might have also been way more
- 36:36aggressive than they intended them to be.
- 36:39Well just looking at their track history.
- 36:41Because of this entire thing happening, Cannon ends up removing his unboxing videos from
- 36:45YouTube and he asks anybody who is using videos or screenshots from his YouTube channel to
- 36:50please delete them.
- 36:51Like he just wants nothing to do with this anymore.
- 36:53This last one is not really detective activity, but I had to include it just because it shows
- 36:58you what they are.
- 36:59I'm still unsure of what they are.
- 37:02Chelsea, you've heard of Rockstar before, right?
- 37:05Not the energy drink, the video game company.
- 37:07They make Grand Theft Auto and Red Dead Redemption.
- 37:09Okay, yeah, I know those games, I guess.
- 37:12Red Dead Redemption takes place in the late 1800s, early 1900s.
- 37:16And because of this, and then being outlaws, guess who shows up in the game?
- 37:19Yes, D. Jane.
- 37:20The Pinkertons.
- 37:21Oh, okay.
- 37:22So this ends up filing a lawsuit against Rockstar and its parent company, Take Two Interactive,
- 37:27alleging that Rockstar had no right to use their agency's name in the game.
- 37:31Red Dead Redemption 2.
- 37:32The game features Pinkertons agents as the antagonists who are constantly pursuing the
- 37:36Vanderlind game, the game's protagonist.
- 37:39In response, Rockstar and Take Two filed a counter lawsuit in January claiming that the
- 37:43use of Pinkertons name was protected under the First Amendment as it was part of the
- 37:47game's historical setting.
- 37:49They argued that Pinkertons could not use trademark law to own the past and prevent
- 37:53creators from including historical references to Pinkerton agents and depictions of the
- 37:57American West.
- 37:58Yeah, I'm on their side.
- 37:59Do they win?
- 38:00Pinkertons' original lawsuit accused Rockstar and Take Two of violating its trademark of
- 38:04the Pinkerton name.
- 38:05However, the legal disputes and quietly Take Two voluntarily dismisses the lawsuit that
- 38:10they filed against Pinkertons and it appears that Pinkertons also just dropped their case.
- 38:14Because, you know, that's a huge company.
- 38:16And yeah, they're still alive and kicking like all over the place today.
- 38:20I did not expect it to end like that.
- 38:22You'll see a lot of this.
- 38:24Anything that's set in the late 1800s, early 1900s likely has some sort of reference to
- 38:28Pinkerton for that day because it is a household name at the time.
- 38:31The Red Dead Redemption games, it shows up a lot.
- 38:34There was actually a Canadian show called Pinkertons for a while.
- 38:36I've never seen it.
- 38:37Apparently it exists.
- 38:39And Bioshock Infinite has references to Pinkertons as well.
- 38:42So it shows up a lot in relevant media.
- 38:44If you're looking at the 1800s, it's huge.
- 38:47They...
- 38:48Well, it sounds like it.
- 38:49Put that on the logo and never look back.
- 38:51Just decided, yep, we're evil.
- 38:53What's the evilest stuff we could do?
- 38:55Okay, this one, we can't do this one anymore.
- 38:58What's the next evilest thing we could do?
- 39:00Let's go beat up a nerd with some magic cards.
- 39:03Yeah, I wasn't prepared for this.
- 39:06I mean, every time I thought I got a hold on what was going on with the Pinkertons,
- 39:09they completely changed the course.
- 39:14But history, everybody should know.
- 39:16This company is still around.
- 39:19And people doing shady shit.
- 39:21All the biggest companies still use them.
- 39:23And was shocked about that as well, to find out they're still around.
- 39:26I was expecting them to shut down or something.
- 39:29But I guess that wouldn't track.
- 39:30I guess they would still be around.
- 39:32Well, I learned a lot of new things today.
- 39:35Chelsea, anything you want to add before we end the episode?
- 39:38No.
- 39:39Okay.
- 39:39I have been Taylor, here with Chelsea.
- 39:41We are Journey to the Fringe.
- 39:42Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 39:45Bye.
- 39:46Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 39:49If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe, or follow,
- 39:55depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 39:58Also please, if possible, leave a five star review, as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 40:04Should you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 40:09I bet you we are there.
- 40:11And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 40:15us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe.com.
- 40:22For now, I'll see you in the next episode.