Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / Asking for a Raise When You Were Just Rejected for One
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, you've asked for a raise, you made your case, you felt good about it, and then your manager says no. What do you do in that moment? Luna: I think a lot of us would just nod, smile, and then go back to our desk and feel awful. But there's actually a smarter way to handle it. Lucas: Right, and that's what we're digging into today. Because a 'no' isn't the end of the conversation, it's the beginning of a different one. And the way you respond in the first five minutes can set the tone for everything that follows. Luna: So, what's the first thing you should do? I imagine you shouldn't just accept it quietly. Lucas: Exactly. The most important thing is to stay composed and ask a couple of strategic questions right then and there. You want to understand the 'why' behind the decision. Is it a budget issue? Is it timing? Or is it a performance concern? You need to know which one it is. Luna: But isn't it awkward to push back in the moment? You don't want to seem difficult. Lucas: It's not about pushing back, it's about clarifying. You can say something like, 'I appreciate you being straight with me. Can you help me understand what factors went into this decision?' That's not confrontational, it's professional curiosity. And it gives you valuable information. Luna: Okay, so you've asked, and they say it's a budget thing. What do you do with that? Lucas: Then you ask about timing. 'Is there a time later this year when budgets might be more flexible?' and 'What specifically would need to change for you to revisit this?' You're trying to get a roadmap, not just a dead end. Luna: So you're turning a rejection into a negotiation about the future. That's clever. Lucas: And here's a key move: ask for it in writing. Not the rejection, but the reasons and what you'd need to achieve to get the raise in the future. You want a clear set of criteria you can work towards. If your manager is vague, push for specifics. 'What KPIs or milestones would make a difference?' Luna: That makes sense. So you leave the room with a written action plan. Then what? Lucas: Then you send a follow-up email within 24 hours. Thank them for the conversation, recap what you discussed, and outline the agreed next steps. This creates a paper trail and shows you're professional about it. It also keeps the conversation alive. Luna: And I imagine you should also keep a record of your achievements from that point forward, right? Lucas: Absolutely. Start a 'brag file' — a running list of your wins, compliments, and tangible results. By the time you follow up in six months, you'll have concrete evidence to back up your case. It's much harder to say no to a documented track record. Luna: So you're saying the rejection is actually an opportunity to build a stronger case? Lucas: That's the reframe. It's not a closed door, it's a delay. And your behavior in the months after can either strengthen or weaken your position. If you sulk, that's a mark against you. If you double down and perform, you're making your next ask almost inevitable. Luna: But what if the manager said it's a performance issue? That's a different kind of 'no'. Lucas: Then you need to get very specific about what's missing. Ask for examples and ask for a development plan. If they can't articulate what's lacking, that's a red flag. But if they can, you've got a clear roadmap to improve, and you can schedule a check-in in three months to reassess. Luna: What if you've done all this and they still say no the next time? At what point do you walk away? Lucas: That's the question, right? After a second no, especially if you've done everything they asked, it's time to reassess. Are they ever going to pay you what you're worth? It might be a sign that your growth path there is limited. And you should start looking externally. Luna: And having that external offer can be a powerful lever, too. But you have to be willing to actually leave. Lucas: Exactly. And a lot of people negotiate better from a position of an offer in hand. So even if you love the job, it's worth keeping your network warm and your resume updated. That way, if they say no again, you have options. Luna: Speaking of options, we should mention that these conversations are never easy, but having a mentor or a career coach to talk through them makes a huge difference. Lucas: A hundred percent. And if today's episode helped you think through your own situation, that's exactly what we're here for. It's why we do this every day, and why we keep the show ad-free — so that kind of advice stays accessible. Luna: If it was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep these conversations going. Lucas: And we don't say that lightly. It's just if you value the show, that's how you support it. No pressure ever. Luna: Right. And now back to your career. So you've got your action plan, you're building your case, and you're staying engaged. The last piece is to actually schedule that follow-up. Lucas: Yes, and don't leave it vague. Before you leave that first conversation, say, 'Can we put a check-in on the calendar for three months from now?' That holds you accountable and ensures the topic doesn't get forgotten. Luna: And in the meantime, keep delivering value and keep documenting it. That's really the core of it. Lucas: Exactly. Because when you come back with receipts, it's not a request, it's a business case. And that's much harder to deny. Luna: So to sum up: don't take the no personally, ask the right questions, get it in writing, and set a timeline. Lucas: And if the company continues to say no despite your efforts, remember that your worth isn't defined by their budget. There are plenty of organizations that would value what you bring. Sometimes the best raise is the one you get by moving on. Luna: That's a powerful note to end on. Thanks for joining us, and we'll talk soon.