Latest / Her Comeback: Women Who Rebuilt Their Lives / Why Saying 'I Don't Know' Is Your Most Honest Act | Her Comeback
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of exhaustion that comes from pretending you have all the answers, a heaviness in your shoulders that no amount of coffee can fix. I want to tell you about the day I finally let that weight drop. We spend so much of our lives performing competence. It starts early, doesn’t it? You’re five years old, and someone asks you where the moon goes during the day, and instead of saying you don’t know, you invent a story because you are terrified that silence will be interpreted as stupidity. As we grow older, that performance just gets more elaborate. We curate opinions on topics we’ve only skimmed headlines about. We nod confidently in meetings when we have no idea what the spreadsheet means. We offer advice to friends on breakups or career moves, drawing from a well of certainty that we haven’t actually earned. It’s exhausting, isn’t it? To constantly be the expert, the guide, the person who has it figured out. I used to think that admitting ignorance was a sign of weakness, a crack in the armor that would make people lose respect for me. But I’m learning, slowly and painfully, that it’s actually the opposite. It’s an act of profound integrity. Let’s sit with that for a second. What did it actually cost you to keep up that charade? Because there is a cost. When you pretend to know, you close yourself off to learning. You build a wall around your curiosity because you’re too busy protecting your image. I remember a time in my corporate communications days when I was leading a project that was spiraling. The client was unhappy, the timeline was impossible, and my team was burning out. Instead of saying, 'I don’t know how to fix this,' I tried to maneuver us through with vague promises and confident smiles. I thought I was being a leader. In reality, I was just delaying the inevitable crash. I was afraid that if I admitted I didn’t have the answer, I’d be replaced by someone who claimed they did. But that fear kept me isolated. It kept me from asking for help. It kept me from being honest about the chaos we were facing. And eventually, the truth always surfaces. It always does. Saying 'I don’t know' requires a different kind of courage than pretending you have the answer. It requires you to trust that you are still worthy of love, respect, and opportunity even in your uncertainty. It’s radical pragmatism, really. It’s choosing accuracy over ego. When you say 'I don’t know,' you are opening a door. You are inviting collaboration. You are signaling to the world that you value truth more than comfort. This is especially true for women, who are often socialized to be accommodating, to smooth things over, to be the ones who hold the emotional labor of keeping everyone comfortable. Admitting you don’t know disrupts that script. It can feel dangerous. Your heart might race. Your palms might sweat. But underneath that anxiety is a sense of relief. A lightness. Because you are no longer carrying the burden of having to be omniscient. You are just a human being, standing in the messy middle of not knowing. Think about the last time you truly learned something new. Did it happen because someone handed you a polished, certain answer? Or did it happen because you asked a question, stumbled into confusion, and had to do the work of figuring it out? That friction, that discomfort, is where growth lives. When we rush to provide answers, we rob ourselves—and others—of that necessary struggle. We skip the part where we actually understand. I’ve started practicing this in my own life. Recently, a listener wrote in asking for advice on navigating a complex family dynamic after her mother passed. She was grieving, and she needed direction. My first instinct was to give her a step-by-step plan, to be the wise friend with the soup and the solutions. But then I stopped. I realized I didn’t know what was right for her. No one could know. So I said, 'I don’t know. But I am here with you while you figure it out.' The shift in her voice when she replied was palpable. She didn’t need a map. She needed witness. She needed someone to acknowledge the vastness of her loss without trying to minimize it with easy words. When we admit we don’t know, we create space for others to do the same. It gives permission. If I can say I’m confused, then maybe you can too. We stop competing for the spotlight of certainty and start collaborating in the shadows of discovery. This is how community works. Not as a collection of experts, but as a network of seekers. I see this in my caregiving work every day. The nurses, the aides, the doctors—they aren’t heroes because they never make mistakes or never feel lost. They are heroes because they say, 'I don’t know, let’s find out together.' They lean on each other. They admit their limits. And in doing so, they create a safer environment for everyone involved. There is dignity in that admission. There is strength in acknowledging the boundaries of your knowledge. It’s not a surrender; it’s an invitation. An invitation to learn, to grow, to be human. So how do we practice this? How do we get comfortable with the pause? Start small. Next time someone asks you a question you’re not sure about, resist the urge to fill the silence. Let the silence breathe. Say, 'That’s a great question. I need to think about that.' Or simply, 'I don’t know.' Notice how your body reacts. Do you feel the urge to apologize? Do you feel the impulse to add a qualifier, like 'I think maybe'? Just let it be. 'I don’t know.' That’s it. No extras. No hedging. Just the raw, honest truth. Over time, you’ll find that the world doesn’t end. People don’t laugh. In fact, many people will sigh with relief. Because they’re tired of pretending too. They’re tired of the performance. By dropping your mask, you give them permission to drop theirs. You become a safe harbor in a sea of noise. You become real. And real is so much more attractive than perfect. Perfect is static. Real is alive. Real is changing. Real is growing. Thank you for sitting with me today. For trusting me with your time and your attention. Remember, you don’t have to have it all figured out to be enough. You are allowed to be a work in progress. You are allowed to be curious. You are allowed to be unsure. I’ll be here, listening, next time. Until then, take care of yourself. Be gentle with your not-knowing. It’s where the magic begins. Bye for now.