Latest / The Vegan Report / The Cage-Free Gaslight | Ep. 120
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, I'm Ryan. What if
- 0:03I told you that cage -free campaigns are not
- 0:07only ineffective at helping hands but may actually
- 0:12cause more suffering and even set back the animal
- 0:16rights movement? That claim might surprise you
- 0:21or even shock you considering how many major
- 0:25animal rights organizations have embraced this
- 0:29strategy, and how many millions of dollars have
- 0:32been invested in cage -free advocacy over the
- 0:37years. Yet this has become the view of a growing
- 0:41number of activists, organizations, researchers,
- 0:45and veterinarians who believe it is time to rethink
- 0:49the cage -free approach. Today, You'll hear from
- 0:53three of them, first Ember Canavan, Associate
- 0:57Director of Vegan Campaigns at PETA, who co -authored
- 1:02the white paper on the failure of cage -free
- 1:05housing systems to reduce overall hand suffering.
- 1:10You'll also hear from Professor Vasilis Tenescu,
- 1:13of Mercer University, who led 50 scholars in
- 1:17signing the open letter, reconsidering cage -free
- 1:20eggs, an open letter from concerned scholars.
- 1:25Vasily also writes a sub -stack and, together
- 1:27with Tev Stenescu, co -hosts the excellent How
- 1:31We Win podcast. And finally, Dr. Crystal Heath,
- 1:36a veterinarian and founder of Our Honor. She
- 1:40has been a leading voice on this issue and her
- 1:43organization launched the veterinarians for an
- 1:46egg -free future campaign. You'll find links
- 1:49to all of these resources and more in the episode
- 1:53notes. If you find this conversation valuable,
- 1:57please share it with the vegans and animal advocates
- 2:00in your life. Let's encourage more people to
- 2:03think critically about cage -free activism. And
- 2:08if you enjoyed the show, please follow or subscribe
- 2:12for more thoughtful and challenging conversations.
- 2:16I also want to apologize for not releasing episodes
- 2:20as consistently lately. I've been spending much
- 2:24of my time working on my other project, Map Your
- 2:28Health. If you're interested in learning about
- 2:30the toxic pollutants in your surroundings, visit
- 2:34mapyourhealth .info. It's mapyourhealth .info.
- 2:40As always, thank you so much for listening and
- 2:43thank you for supporting the show. Let's get
- 2:47started with this question. There is this tension
- 2:51in the animal rights movement. between people
- 2:55who identify as abolitionists and others who
- 2:59call themselves welfarists. To help listeners
- 3:06know more about you, could you please tell us
- 3:10where you find yourself in that debate? Do you
- 3:14identify yourself as an abolitionist, a welfarist,
- 3:18or do you reject the very idea of that debate
- 3:23and division. Who wants to start? I guess I'll
- 3:27go first. So I am I consider myself an abolitionist,
- 3:34but I do support welfare campaigns. I'm a veterinarian,
- 3:38so I have colleagues who work in the industry.
- 3:42So I have supported like Prop 12 to get pigs
- 3:47out of gestation crates, and I support the ongoing
- 3:51campaigns. about the farm bill to get the pork
- 3:57industry to not overturn Prop 12. But in this
- 4:03case, I do not necessarily support cage -free
- 4:06campaigns because I believe that they've done
- 4:09a lot more harm than good. So I definitely pick
- 4:12and choose whether I am a welfarist or an abolitionist
- 4:16based on the individual campaign and the merits
- 4:19of that campaign. Thank you, Crystal. Amber,
- 4:24do you want to go? Sure. Yeah. Yeah. And that
- 4:27is very similar to PETA stance. PETA is an animal
- 4:31rights organization. We believe that animals
- 4:34are not ours to use for food, clothing, entertainment,
- 4:38experimentation or other purposes. However, on
- 4:44the way toward that goal, PETA has been in support
- 4:48of specific, particular welfare campaigns that
- 4:53still serve toward that ultimate goal. Unfortunately,
- 4:57what we have seen, especially in the last decade
- 4:59or so, but even going back even longer if you
- 5:02look, is this rise of co -option and the rise
- 5:09of humane washing, mainly to do with these labels
- 5:12such as cage -free, these buzzwords like regenerative
- 5:16agriculture. all these words that these industries
- 5:19have used and invented, and they create more
- 5:24comfort for the customers than they do for the
- 5:27animals that they are saying that they're benefiting.
- 5:32Thank you, Amber. ceiling. Yes, I don't identify
- 5:35as either a welfareist or an abolitionist. The
- 5:39term I used is what I believe in as animal liberation.
- 5:42I'm an animal liberationist. So if you think
- 5:45of the famous short story of those that walked
- 5:47away from Omelas, there is a child who's being
- 5:50tortured all the time. And so a welfarist would
- 5:53try to make the child's cage a little better.
- 5:55And an abolitionist perhaps presumably would
- 5:58leave. But what I want to do is free the child.
- 6:01And so my goal is animal liberation. I'm an animal
- 6:04liberationist and more fundamentally, I'm a pragmatist.
- 6:07I believe in fighting for what makes sense. And
- 6:10I want to echo Crystal's excellent point that
- 6:13even if all you believe in is utilitarianism,
- 6:18you should still be opposed to cage -free eggs
- 6:21because there's every possibility that it's actually
- 6:24increasing suffering instead of decreasing it.
- 6:28Thank you, Vasily. So in asking that question,
- 6:32I said, you know, the animal rights movement.
- 6:36Now, is that accurate, still accurate when we
- 6:40look at every organization that labels itself
- 6:43as, you know, animal rights? Is it true? You
- 6:49know, if we look at their mission and their work,
- 6:52or should we talk about the animal welfare movement,
- 6:56maybe? So I guess my question is, how do you
- 7:01see the animal rights movement in that debate.
- 7:05Are we more on the side of abolitionism or welfarism?
- 7:12Well, I mean, so PETA, for example, did support
- 7:16the idea of getting hens out of cages back in
- 7:20the 90s. However, that was before these cage
- 7:26-free standards, which are abysmally low, as
- 7:29low as one square foot of floor space per bird,
- 7:33which is sure enough room for them to turn around.
- 7:38It's not enough room for them to turn around
- 7:39without bumping into the body of another bird
- 7:42in most cases. You know, back then it was great.
- 7:47Cages are bad and we should get rid of them.
- 7:51And the vision was something more akin to what
- 7:54would be, you know, a sanctuary type setting,
- 7:58you know, that they have actual space and living
- 8:01conditions that make their lives worth living.
- 8:04What the industry responded to the changing public
- 8:10outcry about and just changing public attitudes
- 8:14about animals. I mean, I remember protesting
- 8:16outside of KFC when I was 19 and arguing with
- 8:21people about how chickens actually feel pain,
- 8:24just like dogs and cats do. And I so rarely encounter
- 8:30that when talking to the public now. And that's
- 8:34a testament to how much the public attitudes
- 8:36have changed. But what happened was the industry's
- 8:41response, which was this absolutely massive humane
- 8:45washing campaign to try to divert the public
- 8:50from going vegan, from making those societal
- 8:53changes that we need to see to reduce the number
- 8:55of animals who are used for food and other purposes,
- 8:59and keep them comfortable, keep them buying those
- 9:01products, even though behind the scenes, nothing
- 9:04has meaningfully changed for the animals. I would
- 9:09just echo that argument to say, so I've had a
- 9:12series of conversations now with people who are
- 9:15in favor of cage -free eggs. And the problem
- 9:17I run into is exactly this framing. They always
- 9:20want to put me in a predetermined box. That box
- 9:23is their understanding of what abolition is.
- 9:25And literally I have to keep repeating myself
- 9:27because they just don't hear the arguments. I
- 9:30was talking to one of the original co -founders
- 9:33of the Humane League, making these points, and
- 9:35she kept repeating, well, at least we should
- 9:37decrease their suffering as we work towards animal
- 9:39liberation. And I explained to her multiple times
- 9:42that there is every possibility that cave free
- 9:45eggs themselves may be increasing animal suffering.
- 9:47But it didn't seem to matter how many times I
- 9:49repeated that point. She actually couldn't hear
- 9:51it because she had a set box in which she was
- 9:54put in. all of the arguments in and she already
- 9:57knew those answers. Amber's point is really interesting
- 10:06about like what cage -free used to mean and how
- 10:09that's changed because of the industry watching
- 10:13of it I know I talked to so many people who are
- 10:14like well I have I buy the best eggs cage -free
- 10:18eggs all of the chickens are treated well and
- 10:21that reassures them and they feel more secure
- 10:24in the purchases of their eggs and Vasili's point
- 10:28about like the there's every possibility that
- 10:33these birds are actually suffering more. And
- 10:36now I'm not saying we should take cage -free
- 10:39chickens and put them back in cages. I'm not
- 10:43entirely sure that that would work either. And
- 10:45I don't think that was his point either. But
- 10:48we are neglecting all of the harms that cage
- 10:51-free eggs do cause these chickens. And we're
- 10:55not using these opportunities to point that out
- 10:58because Pointing that out and elevating the harms
- 11:02of cage -free eggs would potentially harm cage
- 11:05-free campaigns, right? But between 85 and 97
- 11:09% of hens in non -cage system suffer keel bone
- 11:13fractures. That's an injury caused by collisions
- 11:16and faults and chronic pressure on the bodies.
- 11:20Feather pecking is... In 80 to 94 percent of
- 11:24cage -free flocks, this leads to open wounds
- 11:27and infections and cannibalism. Ammonia emissions
- 11:30are much higher, 19 percent higher. Dust levels
- 11:33are 5 to 15 percent higher. They might have more
- 11:37barn fires. There might be an increased risk
- 11:39of avian influenza, all of these things. And
- 11:42when I went and investigated a cage -free facility
- 11:45that had an avian influenza outbreak, I noticed
- 11:48there's a lot of activists not sharing my work
- 11:51because I talked about this cage -free facility,
- 11:54the largest cage -free producer in the country.
- 11:58And activists don't want to be accused of infighting,
- 12:00so they don't want to share my work. And that
- 12:02harms the movement. And you talk about, are we
- 12:07an animal welfare movement? Are we an animal
- 12:08rights movement? I don't use that word because
- 12:13those phrases cause people to react in a certain
- 12:17way. Veterinarians have been very much indoctrinated
- 12:20into the belief that animal rights harms animal
- 12:22welfare. call us animal protection advocates.
- 12:26I think that's what we all aim for, whether we
- 12:28consider ourselves rights or welfare. That's
- 12:32the word I use. But I am very disturbed by how
- 12:38these cage freak campaigns lead us into our own
- 12:43little bubbles. And we then won't share the work
- 12:45of our fellow activists because they don't identify
- 12:49with that certain label. I do want to clarify,
- 12:56I do absolutely believe in and support animal
- 12:58rights. That is what I believe in 100%. But I
- 13:01do think that economy is a little false because
- 13:03for humans, we have no problem saying one of
- 13:04the rights you have as a human is not to be tortured.
- 13:08And so saying one of the rights you have is not
- 13:10to be tortured is not an animal welfarist argument.
- 13:13It is itself an animal rights argument. One of
- 13:16the many rights that animals have is the right
- 13:18not to be tortured, not to experience unnecessary
- 13:22pain and suffering, not to experience unnecessary
- 13:25confinement, etc. These are all animal rights
- 13:27arguments. So I think from an animal rights perspective,
- 13:30which I absolutely hold, you can also still point
- 13:33out that even from a wholly utilitarian perspective,
- 13:37there is every reason to believe that cage -free
- 13:39eggs may well increase suffering instead of decreasing,
- 13:42and still say I absolutely believe in animal
- 13:44rights. I do not think that those are actually
- 13:46in conflict, and I believe both. Before we zoom
- 13:51in into this issue of K3, how do you explain
- 13:56that so many animal rights organizations adopt
- 14:01those welfarist approaches? Where's the pressure
- 14:06coming from? Why is there this tendency of going
- 14:11more welfare than abolitionist? I think there's
- 14:16a lot of claims that are made to activists to
- 14:22appeal, to make them feel like cage -free is
- 14:25the way to go. One of the claims is that vegan
- 14:28advocacy has failed because animal exploitation
- 14:32has increased. There's more meat eating now.
- 14:35And so we at least have to make the lives of
- 14:38these animals better. But that's not an argument.
- 14:41for like now we have to like encourage the industry
- 14:45to do what they should be doing all along and
- 14:47treat the animals better. Like the idea of using
- 14:51vegan activists to go to crumble cookies and
- 14:55say crumble cookies use cage free eggs. I mean,
- 14:58we should be telling crumble cookies to like
- 15:00remove eggs from your products altogether. That
- 15:03is it's just ridiculous that now we're basically
- 15:07selling companies cage free eggs. We're saying
- 15:10You can increase your profits, which they have,
- 15:17by purchasing cage -free eggs, by getting other
- 15:21companies to purchase cage -free eggs. We're
- 15:23doing the industry's marketing for them. We're
- 15:28getting them more money. And the other argument
- 15:30they make is that we have cost the egg industry
- 15:34$10 billion because they have had to convert
- 15:39facilities to cage -free facilities. No, now
- 15:42they're selling their eggs for a lot more money,
- 15:45up to $1 .66, a dozen more. And they're making
- 15:50billions of dollars a year off of their investment.
- 15:53And now they've invested in all these cage -free
- 15:56facilities. It's more entrenched now. And now
- 15:59there's cage -free laws. further entrenching
- 16:01the cage -free industry. We're not fighting for
- 16:05egg -freeness. We're fighting for cage -freeness.
- 16:08And that has led to a deeper entrenchment of
- 16:12this method of protein production that relies
- 16:15on female hens laying eggs as an ingredient used
- 16:20in cookies, which shouldn't even be an ingredient
- 16:22in cookies anyway. Which would be an excellent
- 16:27campaign to get all those secret you know, accidentally
- 16:31vegan things that could exist that don't, which
- 16:34would spare the lives of so many animals and
- 16:37also make vegan food so much more accessible.
- 16:40Just by taking the eggs or dairy powder or whatever
- 16:44is in there out of the production line on the
- 16:47back end, that would be an excellent campaign
- 16:49for animal welfare and animal rights groups to
- 16:53work and invest more in. But yeah, one of the
- 16:59other aspects of this, aside from, I think, die
- 17:03-hard true believers in welfare campaigns as
- 17:07being the only thing that works, is the funding
- 17:12landscape. And a lot of money is coming in from
- 17:16certain funding organizations that I think if
- 17:23an organization organizations had a choice on
- 17:27what campaigns they would work on. Maybe they
- 17:29would be choosing to work on something other
- 17:32than cage -free. But that is, in many cases,
- 17:35where the grant money is. And we are working
- 17:39on that end of the equation as well. Yes, I agree
- 17:43with both of those points. And I watched it happen
- 17:46in real time. So basically, there was A misunderstanding
- 17:50of the rate of the number of people who are going
- 17:52vegetarian or vegan. They just got their numbers
- 17:55wrong. It was done on a single blog post by an
- 17:58intern. And then you could watch in the comment
- 17:59sections people being like, well, hey, look,
- 18:01if there's no one is going vegetarian or vegan,
- 18:04that's never going to work. We need to focus
- 18:05on other things. And that's when you start seeing
- 18:08this like move towards humane meat and cage free
- 18:10eggs is like the only possible solution. In reality,
- 18:14those numbers are far more favorable. And in
- 18:17a larger sense, they they responded to actual
- 18:20real problems. So for example, the recidivism
- 18:22rate, the number of people who go vegan and don't
- 18:25stay vegan as somehow a fixed problem that could
- 18:28never be addressed as opposed to an actual problem
- 18:32where there's plenty of peer reviewed data that
- 18:34gives us good ideas that we could actually solve
- 18:37that. And so there's this myth now that you hear
- 18:39repeated that eating meat is somehow human nature.
- 18:43even by very famous vegans, and if me eating
- 18:46meat is somehow human nature, then all we can
- 18:48do is try to make the suffering a little bit
- 18:50less. And so I think that's part of the problem.
- 18:54The other problem is the desire for smaller easy
- 18:58victories. There's an old joke about someone
- 19:01saying, hey, why are you looking for your keys
- 19:04here? Under the light and they say did you lose
- 19:07your keys there and they say no, but the light
- 19:09is better And so precisely because it doesn't
- 19:12challenge species precisely because it can help
- 19:15companies grow precisely because it can help
- 19:17companies make more money precisely because we
- 19:19have their own internal documents that say cage
- 19:22-free allows them a reset with consumers Then
- 19:26they're able to get these victories where companies
- 19:28will pledge even if they don't follow through
- 19:30to cage -free eggs But these are easy foe victories
- 19:34not real ones. And I'll add to that too. I hear
- 19:39also the argument, well, we're not going to sell
- 19:42factory farming tomorrow. We should help the
- 19:44animals now. And that's also not true because
- 19:49these many cases, the policies that were these
- 19:54promises that these companies made a decade ago,
- 19:5610 years ago, that they were supposed to be finally
- 20:00implementing now in the last year or two have
- 20:02not come to fruition. So it's actually not helping
- 20:06the animals now. It's supposed to help them now
- 20:08from something from a decade ago. And we're not
- 20:13seeing that. So I don't buy the argument that
- 20:15it's helping animals now. The proof's not in
- 20:18the pudding here. There has been a conversion,
- 20:22yes, of the industry. when you're asking a company
- 20:29that's going to have maybe three different changeovers
- 20:31of CEOs until they actually have to implement
- 20:34that, that's pretty tough to sell me on there.
- 20:41Yeah, like one of the things that Ajo del Haze's
- 20:46victory is claimed to be one of the largest victories
- 20:48in the history of the animal welfare movement.
- 20:52And Ajo del Haze Ajo del Haze failed to meet
- 20:56their 2025 commitment. And then activists engaged
- 21:01in 50 plus grassroots campaigns, hundreds of
- 21:04activists, over 13 months of campaigning. And
- 21:07then they claimed victory because Ajo del Haze,
- 21:10again, agreed to a timeline to go cage free.
- 21:15And it was all based on them failing to meet
- 21:19their 2025 commitment. They said that they're
- 21:26going to meet these benchmarks subject to WIC
- 21:33compliance in relevant states, which is a huge
- 21:37loophole. And the company is still framing it
- 21:41as progress. And it's going to be based on consumer
- 21:45demand and affordability and supply chain availability.
- 21:49and legislation and all of these things. And
- 21:53it's based on cage -free sales and SKU penetration,
- 21:59not total egg reduction. So we could see an increase
- 22:04in them selling eggs, but as long as the percentage
- 22:09of cage -free meets benchmarks, then it's fine.
- 22:14And are we again, as activists going to waste
- 22:17our time when they fail to meet those benchmarks.
- 22:21Let's talk about the corporations in in this,
- 22:25you know, formula in this equation. How do they
- 22:30receive that push, you know, to go cage free?
- 22:36Some of them accept that and do the reforms like
- 22:41the one you mentioned, Crystal, and I look at
- 22:43that with bit of suspicion. Um, others do push
- 22:47back, but is there a loss of profit associated
- 22:51with going cage free? Um, you're saying there
- 22:55isn't one. In fact, there is an increase, uh,
- 22:59in, in one, but how does the corporate world,
- 23:03you know, make sense of what's happening, uh,
- 23:06with this push with this campaign for going cage
- 23:09free? Well, I think, um, you know the activists
- 23:14say like since the the industry's fighting back
- 23:17so hard against cage -free this is proof that
- 23:19what we're doing is worthwhile but the truth
- 23:23is like there's a premium for cage -free eggs
- 23:2666 to a dollar 81 cents or more per dozen But
- 23:31the cost of producing cage free eggs is only
- 23:33like 19 cents more per dozen. So they are making
- 23:38billions of dollars a year. And the demand for
- 23:41eggs has also increased over the years. So people
- 23:45are feeling more comfortable. Of course, the
- 23:46argument's always like, as people get richer,
- 23:50as nations get richer, they consume more animal
- 23:52protein. No, they're better customers that are
- 23:55better to market to. And you're marketing a premium
- 23:59product. and activists are now doing that free
- 24:02marketing for them, promoting the idea of cage
- 24:05-free eggs. We're doing free marketing for the
- 24:08animal exploitation industry. And that is so
- 24:12disturbing to me. I can just second Crystal's
- 24:16points because she's been making exactly the
- 24:18points that I believe in. The earlier report
- 24:21that I mentioned, which is also featured in the
- 24:24white paper that Peter released that Amber co
- 24:26-authored, In the United Egg Producers Report,
- 24:30the transition to cage -free eggs consumer and
- 24:32producer perspectives list cage -free eggs as
- 24:35a way to reset with animal activists and consumers
- 24:39and one of the key benefits is that would demonstrate
- 24:41a commitment to animal welfare. They also interviewed
- 24:44producers in their own company report and one
- 24:47of the producers said that the benefit of cage
- 24:49-free eggs was the ability to have a reset with
- 24:51how consumers see us and how the animal welfare
- 24:53community perceives the industry. So is there
- 24:56some initial upfront cost? Sure. Can that upfront
- 25:00cost later be recouped by higher prices? Absolutely.
- 25:04But the more fundamental problem is exactly the
- 25:06one that was made, which that is great marketing.
- 25:08And what is left out of all the conversations
- 25:11when we're told over and over again that 40 %
- 25:13of all eggs are now cage -free is the simple
- 25:16and undeniable truth that there are more than
- 25:1840 % of eggs now than when the very first cage
- 25:21-free egg campaign began expressed in different
- 25:24terms. There are more chickens in battery cages
- 25:27today than when the very first cage -free campaign
- 25:30ever began. So if the people who first started
- 25:33the cage -free campaign goal was to get chickens
- 25:36out of battery cages, they have failed. They
- 25:38haven't decreased the number of chickens against
- 25:39the actual baseline by 40%. It's increased because
- 25:43the market has grown. And one of the reasons
- 25:46the market has grown by the industry's own report
- 25:49is that cage -free makes consumers feel more
- 25:51comfortable about eggs, they buy more eggs, they
- 25:54don't consume more vegan and other options, and
- 25:56the industry just keeps getting bigger. Amber,
- 26:00did you want to add something? How can I follow
- 26:03up with that? I think part of the conversation
- 26:10with both what are our asks of these companies,
- 26:13whether they resist, how much they resist or
- 26:16not, and what our asks are, as animal advocates
- 26:21is, is yes, we need to do the hard thing. I mean,
- 26:26I thought that I was going to be protesting Ringling.
- 26:29When I became an activist and I started protesting
- 26:32as a teenager, I was like, I'm going to be protesting
- 26:35Ringling for the rest of my life. I just took
- 26:37it kind of as a given. And lo and behold, what
- 26:42a decade now, almost. I was at the last protest
- 26:46of the last Ringling show that used animals.
- 26:49And I think the perspective is maybe lost that
- 26:55when we push for things, for what we really want,
- 26:59what the animals really need, at the right time
- 27:02and the right place for what we really want.
- 27:06You know, we can get those wins. We can ban the
- 27:10sale of fur in California. We're banning the
- 27:13sale of foie gras here in Portland, where I'm
- 27:15based. We just banned the sale of foie gras.
- 27:17We're banning parrot sales for the pet trade
- 27:20industry. We're just outright stopping. an entire
- 27:24sector of a bad thing that is done for animals.
- 27:28And there are so many more opportunities that
- 27:31we are missing because we've become so obsessed
- 27:35with this symbol of the cage being so bad. When
- 27:39there are so many other problems and also as
- 27:43we've touched on trade -offs, when you're just
- 27:46trying to take one thing out of the factory farm
- 27:51system, you're cranking one dial, but you're
- 27:54having unintentional negative consequences of,
- 27:59well, you took the cage away, but now this poor
- 28:01bird has to fight every day of her life to get
- 28:05over there to the water. She has to go through
- 28:07a crowd of stressed out, unfortunately, usually
- 28:11aggressive hens. They can never form friendships
- 28:15with other hens. That's very important for a
- 28:19flock animal. When they're put in these flocks
- 28:21of tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands.
- 28:25I was reading an industry article last night
- 28:28about they're figuring out ways to engineer the
- 28:32most efficient large cage free facility. And
- 28:36they're like, this one company accomplished building
- 28:40a cage free facility that could have over a half
- 28:43million birds in one shed. As if that is progress.
- 28:50And you start to wonder, what are we doing here?
- 28:57You mentioned a few good reasons for why animal
- 29:03rights activists and organizations are backing
- 29:05up this push. But when I hear that corporations
- 29:10are getting great marketing, positive marketing
- 29:14from this campaign, I can't help myself but think,
- 29:21well, have we been captured by the business world?
- 29:26I don't know if you came across any evidence
- 29:29of that, but is there some darker agenda at play
- 29:35here? Honestly, I think one of the toughest things
- 29:42and this is Any activist, any advocate for anything
- 29:47is not falling into despair and self -defeatism.
- 29:54And you become more willing to take smaller and
- 30:01less meaningful wins just to have a win instead
- 30:05of sticking it out and doing the tough things.
- 30:10not necessarily being able to see those results
- 30:15with your own eyes. I've rescued many animals
- 30:20and who I never met again. But I had to be comfortable
- 30:25with the fact that their lives were better, even
- 30:28though I maybe will never see them again. And
- 30:33I think also we need to stop repeating meat industry
- 30:36talking points. I think that's another unintended
- 30:40consequence. Why are we repeating meat industry
- 30:44talking points that, you know, vegan campaigns
- 30:48aren't working, that certain interventions to
- 30:50increase access to vegan foods isn't working?
- 30:54Sure, there are there are pain points everywhere.
- 30:58But we shouldn't be repeating that that serves
- 31:01the industry and not the animals. Vasily Kristol,
- 31:06do you also think that It's more of a you know,
- 31:11it's innocent, you know, it's Because of us not
- 31:15because of the industry You know, I think even
- 31:19the industry is I think people get seduced by
- 31:24good narratives and we have a bunch of low information
- 31:29producers low information activists who don't
- 31:32do their own critical thinking and research and
- 31:35they get I think even producers get sucked in
- 31:39to this. I see now it's happening in Africa.
- 31:42Good people are like being told the story of
- 31:45how they'll be wealthy if they start producing
- 31:48eggs and this is how they'll feed their communities
- 31:52and it's a compelling narrative and they bought
- 31:54into it. This is how veterinarians buy into being
- 31:59told a story about how Animals in laboratories
- 32:03are treated better than people's pets and so
- 32:05they should go if they're struggling working
- 32:07in general practice They should go work for the
- 32:10research industry because the animals are treated
- 32:11better and they'll be able to care for them It's
- 32:14where we're always told a story and it's very
- 32:18hard for us to realize that the people who we
- 32:21trust who told us that story Maybe had been manipulated
- 32:25themselves or were fooling themselves and I think
- 32:27we have to to do the work to help break people
- 32:31out of these false narratives that they're being
- 32:34told and get people to recognize that. I hear
- 32:38a lot of activists who dismiss our claim saying,
- 32:41oh, those people who are against cage -free campaigns,
- 32:45they're just jealous and resentful that they're
- 32:46not getting the funding, that their campaigns
- 32:48have failed, that they're not getting the attention.
- 32:51So they're trying to get attention by criticizing
- 32:54our successful campaigns. If the people who are
- 32:59supporting your narrative are resorting to character
- 33:01assassination and assuming bad faith and the
- 33:05people who are criticizing your campaigns, maybe
- 33:07you should give that a second thought and actually
- 33:11look at their arguments and see if you can come
- 33:15up. for yourself why their arguments are wrong.
- 33:20And let's have that discussion instead of just
- 33:23assuming bad faith in the people who are voicing
- 33:26concerns about a campaign. I think it's absolutely
- 33:30intentional from the industry. I spend most of
- 33:34my time not going to vegans and animal rights
- 33:36talks, but trying to attend actual industry talks,
- 33:39looking at their papers, reading their white
- 33:42papers, and they're not subtle. They use dismissive
- 33:45phrases like beef with adjectives, which is a
- 33:48stand -in for any of these terms, free range,
- 33:51humanely slaughtered, what have you. And so they
- 33:55think this is what consumers want. This is a
- 33:57great way to have niche marketing. This is a
- 34:00way to prevent regulatory changes, actual laws,
- 34:03cutting funding, some of the things that Amber
- 34:05were talking about. And this is a way to grow
- 34:07the industry. So their plan is a both and one.
- 34:10That's not my terminology. That's the terminology
- 34:12from the CEO of Titan. of both and strategy.
- 34:15They keep doubling down with the factory farm
- 34:17system and then they create the separate niche
- 34:20of higher priced, minimally better welfare products
- 34:23that they can sell for more money and expand
- 34:25the industry. That's what they say they're going
- 34:27to do. That's what we see happening. I believe
- 34:30that's the plan because that's the plan that
- 34:31they say they're trying to do. That touches on
- 34:35the whole halo effect of these animal derived
- 34:38products being on the same shelf. you know, with
- 34:42each other with the nice label. And we do see
- 34:47this consumers will see the nice label. Maybe
- 34:51they're at Whole Foods. They aren't choosing
- 34:54the most expensive $18 a pound or whatever thing
- 35:00on the shelf necessarily. But there's still all
- 35:02the other products on the shelf, even though
- 35:05all of them are factory farmed. But they can
- 35:09still pick the lowest level of welfare labeling
- 35:14on that whole offering and still get some of
- 35:18that dopamine, some of that assuaging of their,
- 35:23you know, confliction that they might be having.
- 35:26And again, these are, you know, generally consumers
- 35:29who are going to a new seasons or a Whole Foods
- 35:31or an Arowan, who could very easily be just reaching
- 35:36over a little further down the shelf and picking
- 35:38up that vegan item. But these labels are are
- 35:42keeping them, keeping them right there. I just
- 35:46want to briefly underscore that point. So in
- 35:48the white paper that Amber helped co -authored,
- 35:50there's a reference of five peer -reviewed studies
- 35:53that all came to the same conclusion. And that
- 35:56conclusion is that what consumers believe when
- 35:58they see cage -free is that it is the same as
- 36:01pasture -raised, that it is the same as free
- 36:03-range, that it is better for the environment
- 36:05when in fact it is worse, and that fundamentally
- 36:08their term, not mine, that cage -free equals
- 36:11cruelty -free. So that is what consumers believe.
- 36:14We don't have to imagine if there is humane washing.
- 36:17As far as I can tell, all the peer -reviewed
- 36:19data has proven that there is humane washing.
- 36:21So if you are trying to convince consumers that
- 36:24there is a problem with consuming eggs, cage
- 36:26-free is a lousy strategy. If you're trying to
- 36:29convince consumers that all the problems with
- 36:31cages can be solved if they just pay a little
- 36:33more and buy cage -free eggs, then we are doing
- 36:36great marketing. That's such a good point. And
- 36:39also how the industry has also done such a great
- 36:42job at dismantling consumer trust in things like
- 36:46seed oils and other ingredients, synthetic ingredients.
- 36:51So that makes that animal -free product with
- 36:54seed oils in it or other ingredients look like
- 36:57an unhealthy thing that they shouldn't trust.
- 37:02So if we only did what the industry did to seed
- 37:06oils, to eggs, we would You know, we could be
- 37:10where seed oils are right now with eggs, but
- 37:13we didn't do that. We instead just allowed them
- 37:17to continue to make animal free products look
- 37:20like they were synthetic and harmful and all
- 37:23of these things. Yeah, we did not do that. You
- 37:28mentioned, you know, I think, Amber, you mentioned
- 37:31funding. If I look at. who is part of the open
- 37:37wing Alliance. So those are organizations in
- 37:40the animal rights movement who are leading that
- 37:43campaign for going cage free. Many of them receive,
- 37:47you know, funding from the effective altruist
- 37:51movement. You know, I went through that list
- 37:54and recognized many past guests of this show,
- 37:56actually. So Effective altruism many other funders
- 38:03are convinced by this campaign by this argument
- 38:07that we should Go and push, you know this idea
- 38:11of going cage -free You mentioned individual
- 38:16activist crystal that are also convinced by that
- 38:19narrative now my question for you is what is
- 38:23the most convincing argument you've heard from
- 38:27people who push the cage -free agenda, the strongest
- 38:31one. And why did that argument not convince you?
- 38:37Are you asking me first? I just think the argument
- 38:46that like, oh, we've cost the industry so much
- 38:49money from these cage free campaigns and we've
- 38:52had legislative wins. These things are winning.
- 38:56We've successfully convinced corporations to
- 38:59change their practices. That whole story is really
- 39:02compelling and it's gotten a lot of people on
- 39:05our side. But as we've discussed, it hasn't necessarily
- 39:09cost them money. They've made more money. It's
- 39:13entrenched. this method of protein production
- 39:16using female hens to produce protein and it just
- 39:22increased the exploitation of animals. I'd say
- 39:27that the narrative out there that cage free reduces
- 39:33a massive amount of suffering for a hen and as
- 39:38I think the white paper compellingly lays out,
- 39:41and also my own experiences being inside cage
- 39:46-free and pasture -raised facilities, which gives
- 39:49even more space, more space to the hens, is that
- 39:56it is marginal at best and in some ways, very
- 40:03important ways worse. And a lot of that has to
- 40:06do with this visible versus invisible suffering.
- 40:11So you can so easily see that a cage causes suffering,
- 40:17confinement causes suffering. You can see the
- 40:20marks on their bodies, the feathers rubbing off,
- 40:23the pecking, the red raw skin, the paleness of
- 40:27their combs, the despair in their eyes. But cage
- 40:31-free facilities have their own set of problems.
- 40:35Crystal mentioned up to 97 % of hens in cage
- 40:39free facilities will have a broken bone, especially
- 40:43the keel bone, which is that front bone, basically
- 40:46their chest bone on the front of a bird's body
- 40:50can be broken. And if you look at that bird,
- 40:54You're not going to see that, but that is so
- 40:57much invisible pain and suffering that oftentimes
- 41:00is not making it into the metrics or the consideration.
- 41:06When the animal welfare studies and these reports
- 41:13get put out from especially the effective altruist
- 41:17crowd who believes so heavily in these campaigns,
- 41:20they're not weighing these things. appropriately,
- 41:25in my opinion. Yes, I exactly agree. So the effect
- 41:30of Altruist had these sort of original studies
- 41:32that they came out with that were done by academics.
- 41:34By and large, they weren't peer reviewed. They
- 41:36were sort of self -published, but they were done
- 41:38by academics. And they tried to argue that it
- 41:41decreased its suffering in a host of different
- 41:43factors. And the problem is they left out some
- 41:46factors. And so one of the factors that they
- 41:50didn't pay enough attention to, as Crystal mentioned,
- 41:52is the air quality issue. That the fact, as Amber
- 41:56has already mentioned, they are not actually
- 41:58cage -free. There's just one big cage instead
- 42:00of a lot of small cages. So they're still combined
- 42:02with the same air all the time. So there was
- 42:05a European study that found that daily average
- 42:08ammonium concentrations of 3 to 12 parts per
- 42:11million in furnished cages, 21 to 42 parts per
- 42:15million in multi -level cages. and 66 to 120
- 42:19parts per million in floor housing. David Atall,
- 42:23a later study found that cage systems have lower
- 42:26concentrations of ammonium than floor systems
- 42:28and avaries on and on. The point is, is it less
- 42:32suffering if their lungs are burning and hurting
- 42:35them all the time? Or is it actually more suffering
- 42:38even if they can slightly extend their wings?
- 42:41That's exactly the point that Amber was saying
- 42:42about visible or invisible suffering. As far
- 42:46as I can tell, no one's really done that data.
- 42:48Crystal mentioned their earlier point about the
- 42:50increase of avian flu. We just had that experience.
- 42:53All the data suggests that caged birds are less
- 42:56likely to get avian flu, cage -free are more
- 42:58likely to get avian flu, and then they go through
- 43:00a mass kill, all of them, even if they're not
- 43:03sick. Is that more suffering or less? We don't
- 43:05know. It's not part of any of the original effective
- 43:07altruist data. The biggest issue for me, though,
- 43:11is the one that I've been trying to emphasize,
- 43:13which is that even if... Hypothetically per a
- 43:17chicken the suffering went slightly down since
- 43:19the system increases the total number of chickens
- 43:22Total animal suffering is increasing instead
- 43:25of decreasing and there are two main reasons
- 43:28for this The first is cage -free just makes less
- 43:31eggs. So the chickens produce fewer eggs The
- 43:35eggs are smaller. The shells are easier to break.
- 43:39They're weaker. They also break the eggs. Think
- 43:41about it. They're all walking in these super
- 43:43crowded conditions where all the eggs are breaking.
- 43:46They're getting contaminated with fecal matter
- 43:48that either has to be expensively cleaned or
- 43:50most jurisdictions is just destroyed. So they
- 43:53have to have more chickens to make the same number
- 43:56of eggs. And then in addition, its marketing,
- 44:00re -ashamed consumers, we're going to keep eating
- 44:02more eggs, growing the industry, which is exactly
- 44:05what we've seen. So what stands out to me, here
- 44:09is the main takeaway. Effective altruists themselves
- 44:12frequently point to what they call the small
- 44:15body problem. How emphasis about caring for animals
- 44:18has meant fewer cows and more chickens, which
- 44:21decreases total suffering. Or how shrimp aren't
- 44:23focused on, even though each of them causes more
- 44:26suffering, people becoming pescatarian. But what
- 44:28they fail to understand is their own way in which
- 44:32what they're fighting for. The cage free system
- 44:35causes the exact same problem of increasing the
- 44:38size of the industry. So even if individual suffering
- 44:41goes down, total suffering just keeps going up.
- 44:47Is there like a cultural bias to all of this?
- 44:49Because when I hear, you know, cage, you know,
- 44:53I hear about, I feel, you know, the It's there's
- 44:58a whole literature of, you know, people in prison
- 45:01suffering and all of that. And that's what you
- 45:05think about and what your feelings orbit around.
- 45:10And then, you know, cage free. That is also very
- 45:14appealing. The idea of freedom. That's those
- 45:18are all that's just amazing marketing. That's
- 45:21just those amazing words and. It's difficult
- 45:26then to come with the truth like you're trying
- 45:31to do and go against that wording. Have you come
- 45:37up with any, you know, alternative, maybe powerful
- 45:42words to counteract this cultural effect? Well,
- 45:47I can go. I personally, I think egg free eggs
- 45:51need to be viewed as something that is. Bad and
- 45:55we need to emphasize that things are egg free
- 45:57and celebrate that as a good thing. Animal free
- 46:00needs to be celebrated. You know, it's unfortunate.
- 46:03Vegan has gotten such a bad stigma to it. So
- 46:08I've personally moved away from using the V word.
- 46:11I don't know if I'm just playing into the industry's
- 46:14hands by doing that. maybe but I think emphasizing
- 46:18animal free like it's free of animals we don't
- 46:22have to torture animals it's slaughter free those
- 46:25sorts of things to really center the animals
- 46:27instead of the people I think plant -based is
- 46:31such a horrifying word. I think we need to center
- 46:34the animals, not the plants. And plant -based
- 46:37has just led to people being like, plants feel
- 46:39pain. It's like, yes, I'm a plants rights activist
- 46:42too. And the best way to not exploit plants is
- 46:45to not feed them to animals who we then eat.
- 46:49So that's sort of my strategy. I love that we're
- 46:53here. We're recycling the work. Well, so I am
- 46:58a proud vegan, vegan AF. You know, I use the
- 47:02term vegan 100%. I think the way to undo the
- 47:05bias is to reclaim vegan, not to give it up for
- 47:08me personally. And but I think you make a great
- 47:11point. Why was the strategy to label some eggs
- 47:15cage free when they are in fact not cage free
- 47:17when the animals are still in the cages, instead
- 47:19of a strategy to label the other eggs from battery
- 47:22cages? Why aren't the effective altruists doing
- 47:25that? Why are we labeling something positive
- 47:29instead of labeling something else negative?
- 47:32I mean think about the average consumer and remember
- 47:34we can see this in five peer -reviewed studies
- 47:36They go to the store and they see eggs which
- 47:38are good and cage -free eggs, which are better
- 47:41Why as animal activists aren't we fighting for
- 47:44a system of labeling? Harm that they see wait
- 47:47battery cages a picture of what that looks like
- 47:50Think of what we accomplished with warning labels
- 47:52on tobacco How is that somehow utopian or impossible?
- 47:58How is that something even if someone says I'm
- 48:00an animal welfare organization 100 % I don't
- 48:02care about animal rights. Okay, but be effective
- 48:04Why aren't you labeling and fighting and forcing
- 48:09the industry to label their battery cages as
- 48:12battery caged eggs? Instead of giving them something
- 48:14that their own industry documents They can help
- 48:16grow the industry by labeling some of the eggs
- 48:19as good and then vegans repeat the marketing
- 48:21points That is what I don't understand. Amber,
- 48:26sorry. Oh, no. You both said it so well already.
- 48:37Yeah. There are so many horrible things that
- 48:43the egg industry does to hens, aside from the
- 48:49cages. It's the breeding practices that force
- 48:53them to their bodies to produce 320 to 350 eggs
- 48:59per year. Their ancestors, the red jungle fowl,
- 49:04which they do still exist in the wild in some
- 49:09pockets of the world, but they produce what most
- 49:12species produce, which is 12 to 15 eggs per year.
- 49:18Breeding is a whole other side of things where
- 49:21even when these birds are rescued from cage -free
- 49:25facilities, they have lifelong medical problems
- 49:30due to the massive amounts of egg laying. It
- 49:34saps their bodies of nutrients, especially calcium
- 49:37from their bones, makes them prone to broken
- 49:41bones for the rest of their lives. causes high
- 49:46rates of reproductive disease since their bodies
- 49:48are just overworking. All the resources of their
- 49:53body, large parts of their day even to have to
- 49:57go find a nest and lay an egg and then recover
- 50:00from that. Rates of reproductive cancers and
- 50:06eggs being stuck up inside of them, infections
- 50:08are all horrifically high for them. removal of
- 50:15their beaks, either through a hot blade or an
- 50:19infrared laser, which basically burns it off
- 50:22and causes it to die and fall off their faces.
- 50:26The male chick shredding and gassing that is
- 50:29common, no matter whether those hens are destined
- 50:32for cage -free or pastured, their brothers are
- 50:38all killed at the hatchery. And then the end
- 50:41of life. Most hens used for eggs, whether they
- 50:45are cage -free or pastured, or even backyard
- 50:48hens that are purchased from a farm store, they're
- 50:54coming from those same hatcheries. At the end
- 50:58of their lives, whether they are cage -free or
- 51:01pastured, they are killed at a fraction of what
- 51:06their lifespan could have been, usually about
- 51:0917 months. usually no longer than making it past
- 51:14their second birthday. And they are either gassed
- 51:17or sent to slaughterhouses and made into like
- 51:20low grade products, dog or cat food, or like
- 51:26chicken soup, low grade products because their
- 51:29bodies are just so thin and worn out. And that's
- 51:33a whole narrative that is horrifying to people
- 51:37when they learn about it. That just isn't out
- 51:41there enough and it is completely absent in most
- 51:45cases when the focus of campaigns is just cage
- 51:49-free Well, let's talk about the consumer and
- 51:55you talked about that perception they have of
- 51:58the label and how this is, you know influencing
- 52:02their choices of products I want to touch on
- 52:10a topic that is dear to my heart, and I've been
- 52:14very vocal about it on this podcast, which is
- 52:16backyard chickens. It is a growing trend for
- 52:25people to adopt backyard chickens. There are
- 52:29more and more cities across the world that are
- 52:32allowing this to happen. There is to be zoning
- 52:35laws forbidding this. And now we have, you know,
- 52:39I think 85 million backyard chickens just in
- 52:43the U .S. People are turning into poultry farmers,
- 52:48basically. And I wonder if that plays into the
- 52:53perception of eggs and chicken exploitation.
- 52:59And why hasn't this movement reacted to the rise
- 53:05of the backyard chicken practice? No one no organization
- 53:10has almost no organization has protested this
- 53:16and and try to Stop it from happening Thankfully,
- 53:23there are a few success stories for instance
- 53:27the Animal Protection Party of Canada I know
- 53:30about that that was able to stop the city of
- 53:36Toronto from allowing back your chickens for
- 53:39its residents. What do you make of that trend?
- 53:46It's a tough one because like I like and I'd
- 53:50like your help with navigating this because.
- 53:54Part of me is like, well, when people have their
- 53:56own chickens, they'll see them as individuals,
- 53:59unless they get so many that they don't or they
- 54:01just are callous about them. But I grew up with
- 54:04chickens and their eggs. So I think that's part
- 54:07of the reason why I am the way I am today. I
- 54:10grew up with dairy goats and chickens. And so
- 54:13we got our milk and eggs from our own animals.
- 54:17And so I recognize them as individuals. But it
- 54:21also, part of me, it led me to believe like oh
- 54:23all animals are treated this way and so it's
- 54:27fine that we consume their products and it very
- 54:29normalizes the exploitation of animals for our
- 54:33own purposes on one hand. But on the other hand
- 54:39like There is also an increased risk of avian
- 54:43influenza in backyard hens. Like they're usually
- 54:46the first ones to get sick. There have been cases
- 54:50where humans have gotten sick from them. I think
- 54:54I'm a little conflicted about legislation banning
- 54:59backyard chickens because then that prevents.
- 55:02maybe spent hens from being adopted by people
- 55:07in these areas and that's what I'd hope more
- 55:09people instead of going to tractor supply and
- 55:13buying baby chicks who've been shipped in the
- 55:15mail and many of them die being shipped in the
- 55:19mail that they would maybe develop a relationship
- 55:23with one of the many people like second hand
- 55:26who gets their chickens from spent hens and the
- 55:32priority isn't placed on like, oh, this is how
- 55:34I'll get my eggs. It's I chickens are great and
- 55:38we should take care of them and their purpose
- 55:41isn't to just produce eggs for us. Their purpose
- 55:44is, you know, we are here to provide care for
- 55:46them just like we do other animals that we come
- 55:51across cats, you know, that that we all love
- 55:54and take care of because we come across them
- 55:57and they need our help. They're not there to
- 56:00provide us with something that's not their purpose.
- 56:04So yeah, I'd love everybody else's thoughts on
- 56:06this problem too, because it is sort of difficult
- 56:09to navigate. And like, how do you develop a campaign
- 56:11around this? I think we definitely need to do
- 56:13more to address tractor supplies and these feed
- 56:16stores that are getting these chicks from hatcheries
- 56:18and they're being sent in the mail and they're
- 56:20often dying on the way. Yeah, I want to highlight
- 56:25something you just said crystal which is Not
- 56:28only we're not, you know opposing backyard chickens,
- 56:30but yeah many vegans among us, you know feel
- 56:34like You know, they're doing good by keeping
- 56:38chickens in their backyard Rescue chickens, which
- 56:42is not what their neighbors are doing. But yeah
- 56:46PETA does have a resource on our website. We
- 56:50have a web feature that does dive into some of
- 56:54the very serious concerns with the backyard egg
- 57:00trend. Some of the things I already touched on,
- 57:05the fact that these hens are overwhelmingly coming
- 57:08from hatcheries. Where are the roosters? Where
- 57:11are their brothers? They're most likely dead.
- 57:15and the attitude that can come along with directly
- 57:21using these animals for their eggs. And if we're
- 57:25not changing that attitude, that that hen is
- 57:28still there for their use and that those eggs
- 57:34are not ours to take. People say, oh, the animal
- 57:37gives us milk. The animal gives us eggs. We took
- 57:41those things from them. So there's definitely
- 57:48a lot to unpack there. I mean, I will say the
- 57:52fact that I'm in a city that does allow people
- 57:56to have hens. Again, roosters are not allowed.
- 57:59So that's part of a problem. But I have been
- 58:08able to do a limited amount of outreach to my
- 58:11neighbors who have their own chickens trying
- 58:12to show that there's a non -exploitative way
- 58:16to care for these birds that I adopt and don't
- 58:21shop, right? They're rescued and that I try to
- 58:27give the narrative that these hens were horrifically
- 58:31harmed by the egg industry and being exploited
- 58:36for their eggs. And now that they are rescued,
- 58:40that they will never be exploited for their eggs.
- 58:43again and explaining why we don't consume their
- 58:48eggs even if they are still laying them. And
- 58:52that kind of gets back to that core of why we
- 58:55need to change society's perceptions of animals
- 58:58and that they're not here for us. And it's definitely
- 59:03a very sensitive topic because people are so
- 59:07entrenched in this idea of how innocent a hen
- 59:12laying an egg is when in fact it is in many ways
- 59:15so taxing on their bodies and so harmful just
- 59:22seeing the health impacts that these hens have
- 59:25to deal with as they recover and as they are
- 59:27rehabilitated after they are rescued. So as Crystal
- 59:32mentioned like when There are mass rescues of
- 59:37organizations who adopt out hens who were diverted
- 59:41from being mass slaughtered at the end of their
- 59:45profitability and production. A lot of times
- 59:50those programs don't require the people to be
- 59:52vegan, to be adopters. But I do have some hope
- 59:58that people change their perspectives after just
- 1:00:03seeing how wonderful these birds are, and again,
- 1:00:06how much they do suffer from having been bred
- 1:00:10to lay so many eggs. Yes, I very much agree.
- 1:00:15I'm completely opposed to backyard chickens full
- 1:00:19stop. I would gently push back. There are organizations
- 1:00:23that are fighting against backyard Chickens and
- 1:00:26always have united poultry concerns one of my
- 1:00:29mentors before she passed away Karen Davis Was
- 1:00:32fiercely opposed to backyard chickens chicken
- 1:00:35run rescue. There's others And so why why am
- 1:00:39I absolutely opposed to backyard chickens many
- 1:00:41of the reasons? That are raised and what amber
- 1:00:45mentioned earlier this sort of difference between
- 1:00:47visible and invisible suffering Their bodies
- 1:00:50are bred to hurt them all the time So if they
- 1:00:52live a little bit longer, is that more or less
- 1:00:54suffering? Arguably, it's more suffering, not
- 1:00:57less. A lot of these people have no idea what
- 1:01:00they're doing. They get these trick -ins without
- 1:01:02any insight. Think about how, as Peter well knows,
- 1:01:06most people treat... their own companion animals
- 1:01:09the way they treat their dogs and these horrible
- 1:01:11conditions now imagine random people having chickens
- 1:01:14think about those conditions those are in there's
- 1:01:17plenty of sanctuaries overwhelmed with people
- 1:01:19who decided they were going to do backyard chickens
- 1:01:21and couldn't and then like try to donate them
- 1:01:24the sanctuaries can't take them and the chickens
- 1:01:26are in horrible shape they've been neglected
- 1:01:28mistreated what have you so it's not a rise in
- 1:01:31rooster dumping as well the shelters are Yeah,
- 1:01:35go ahead. Absolutely flooded. Yeah, absolutely
- 1:01:37flooded. So, it's not the case that these people
- 1:01:40are realizing that they're individual animals
- 1:01:43and caring for them, by and large. Often it is
- 1:01:46abuse and neglect is what is occurring. And even
- 1:01:49if they did try to eat them well, they're having
- 1:01:52industrial birds that are shipped, as Crystal
- 1:01:54said, from the exact same industrial hatcheries
- 1:01:58whose bodies are hurting them all the time, even
- 1:02:02as they produce more eggs that causes them as
- 1:02:05well as all the male chickens being killed. fundamental
- 1:02:08level and it's kind of like why the meat industry
- 1:02:11so supports 4H. I mean the truth is all of this
- 1:02:14is a rounding error on the number of animals
- 1:02:17that are raised. In reality 99 .9 % of all the
- 1:02:20animals in the United States are raised in factory
- 1:02:23farm conditions. But the point is to get as many
- 1:02:26people as possible in the system. How can you
- 1:02:31really ever fight against the factory farm when
- 1:02:36you are raising chickens yourself. And we think
- 1:02:39that that will lead to that, but the industry
- 1:02:41is betting the other way. If you have blood on
- 1:02:44your own hands, if you're owning animals, if
- 1:02:48you're eating their products, right? So like
- 1:02:51with 4 -H, you get kids, they have an animal,
- 1:02:53they raise that animal, they love the animal,
- 1:02:56they kill the animal. That moment of disavowal
- 1:02:59is what prevents any real change. So they are
- 1:03:02perfectly happy to support backyard chickens.
- 1:03:04They're perfectly happy to support 4 -H. They're
- 1:03:07perfectly happy to create this new niche marketing
- 1:03:10of humane washing of a both and strategy because
- 1:03:13their goal is just to keep people eating meat.
- 1:03:17And the more people they can do it, the more
- 1:03:18they can democratize the raising of animals,
- 1:03:22the safer they feel. That's what I'm inclined
- 1:03:28to believe too. I mean, before starting this
- 1:03:32conversation, before I pressed the recording
- 1:03:34button, we were talking about veterinary care
- 1:03:38for chickens and how, you know, chickens were
- 1:03:42considered as exotic animals and the crazy vegan
- 1:03:45I am did tested, you know, tried to call to find
- 1:03:51a veterinarian somewhere, you know, around me
- 1:03:54that could accept treating chickens and It was
- 1:04:00incredibly hard to find one and I'm thinking,
- 1:04:05you know, here are all of my Neighbors with their
- 1:04:08backyard chickens and so many thousands more
- 1:04:11out there. How are they? providing Sufficient
- 1:04:16veterinary care for their chickens. They're not
- 1:04:19they're not even thinking about it they're reduced
- 1:04:24to doing, you know home remedy stuff and Yeah,
- 1:04:29it's not it's not like a cat or a dog, you know,
- 1:04:33it's it's really they're there to feed them Eggs
- 1:04:39that's what they that's why they got them and
- 1:04:42They have no plan of keeping them. I think After
- 1:04:47they stop playing eggs Yeah Anything more to
- 1:04:54add about backyard chickens Yeah, I think you
- 1:04:59all make really good points. I'll just say that
- 1:05:02and yeah I already think not enough people provide
- 1:05:05good veterinary care for their dogs and cats
- 1:05:07and it's so hard to find somebody who knows chickens
- 1:05:10So yeah, and of course a chicken exam is gonna
- 1:05:14cost you $100 and you're gonna most people say
- 1:05:18well I could just go to tractor supply and get
- 1:05:20another chicken for a lot less than that and
- 1:05:24so they they don't and they resort to making
- 1:05:28some economic decision instead of a moral decision
- 1:05:31about the care of their animals. Placing even
- 1:05:35unconsciously a monetary value on animals, especially
- 1:05:39smaller animals. This is coming from my background.
- 1:05:44My mother owned a pet store when I was growing
- 1:05:46up. And, you know, it did not make sense to bring
- 1:05:52the hamster who we could sell for maybe back
- 1:05:55at that time, $3 .99, I think, to a vet. It made
- 1:06:01absolutely no sense. And for a hen who is in
- 1:06:06a backyard situation, first of all, people have
- 1:06:10already paid for her coop. Fencing is expensive.
- 1:06:16Feed is expensive. Other over -the -counter medications
- 1:06:20are expensive. that hen is already in debt. She
- 1:06:23can never lay enough eggs to cover this unconscious
- 1:06:29debt that that person who views these animals
- 1:06:32as an economic equation of what am I getting
- 1:06:36out of them, she is forever in debt. So taking
- 1:06:40her to the vet, even for horrific injuries or
- 1:06:45illness or end of life care, is preposterous
- 1:06:50to many of the people in these backyard egg communities.
- 1:06:55Just yesterday on Instagram, I saw a video. And
- 1:07:01it was a morning video. It was set to sweet music
- 1:07:05and a woman crying. And she said she came home
- 1:07:07and her hen was thrashing on the floor and couldn't
- 1:07:11walk. And I was like, oh, this is going to be
- 1:07:14a a euthanasia video, a tribute to the life this
- 1:07:19had had. And then it cuts to her walking to the
- 1:07:22barn with a knife. And I thought it was satire,
- 1:07:25and it was not. And the amount of defenses from
- 1:07:32the comment section was so telling. Of course,
- 1:07:36you're not going to spend money on her. It was
- 1:07:41heartbreaking. and they could not understand
- 1:07:45what the difference was if someone had done the
- 1:07:48same thing. I came home from vacation and my
- 1:07:52cat couldn't walk. Out came the knife. People
- 1:07:56would view that very differently, but because
- 1:08:00it is so normalized for chickens, it's... I don't
- 1:08:06have words. I want to spend a few minutes just
- 1:08:15talking about the risk of zoonotic diseases.
- 1:08:19You all touched on that. And I feel like we don't
- 1:08:24talk enough about it. As a society, as a civilization,
- 1:08:31we went through a pandemic relatively recently.
- 1:08:35And I feel like we learned nothing from that
- 1:08:37experience. And we're still playing with fire.
- 1:08:42And we think nothing will happen to us. Like
- 1:08:47the Black Plague, the Spanish Flu, those belong
- 1:08:51to history. Our modern society will never confront
- 1:08:57a health crisis of that scale. And at the same
- 1:09:03time, we're just fueling the fire of factory
- 1:09:08farming and just increasing the risks of... That
- 1:09:12same health crisis happening again Are you afraid
- 1:09:19of what the future holds in terms of global pandemics
- 1:09:24Yes, I mean I I don't want to frame it as fear
- 1:09:29because the industry loves to Pretend like we're
- 1:09:34a bunch of scared people and we're like raising
- 1:09:38false alarms. Anytime you talk about avian influenza,
- 1:09:42they say it's fake, COVID is fake. I just watched
- 1:09:46this morning a congressional hearing where, again,
- 1:09:48it was like, COVID isn't real. So it's frustrating,
- 1:09:56but as we increase the number of animals and
- 1:09:59can find them, we are seeing an increase. in
- 1:10:02infectious disease outbreaks, viruses, but also
- 1:10:06a rise of antibiotic resistance. And now, of
- 1:10:09course, the cattle industry is normalizing metaphylaxis,
- 1:10:13which is the use of antibiotics on feedlots just
- 1:10:16because the cows were transported there. And
- 1:10:19now we're confining the calves because of the
- 1:10:23beef on dairy industry. We're confining calves
- 1:10:25to these. crates and all of these calves are
- 1:10:29getting an injection of antibiotics. So that
- 1:10:32increases our microbial resistance. And it's
- 1:10:37a huge problem. We're going to see more viruses
- 1:10:40of pandemic potential and less trust in vaccinations
- 1:10:47and vaccinations are treated as this cure for
- 1:10:50everything. And we're injecting our children
- 1:10:53with more and more vaccinations. And I don't
- 1:10:55want to be an anti -vaxxer, but the increasing
- 1:10:59number of vaccines that we have to give children
- 1:11:02because of this. likely does have some detrimental
- 1:11:05effects of some kind. Of course, I'm a shelter
- 1:11:08vet. I vaccinate all of the animals on intake,
- 1:11:11and I think that that's vital because I keep
- 1:11:14all of these animals in close confinement, but
- 1:11:18because we have to deal with the large number
- 1:11:22of animals who go unwanted. And so yeah, I think
- 1:11:27this is a huge problem. Just the increasing number
- 1:11:29of domestic animals that humanity is creating
- 1:11:33creates this huge crisis. And we're put in this
- 1:11:37morally vulnerable position of having to deal
- 1:11:40with this. And then to solve the problem, we
- 1:11:43confine animals to laboratories to develop cures
- 1:11:47for these treatments. And then we have lab leaks,
- 1:11:51which often go unreported. And so, yeah, we are
- 1:11:56creating a huge crisis. And it all leads back
- 1:12:00to the use of animals for corporate profits.
- 1:12:07Yes, I would agree. And so we discussed earlier
- 1:12:10the H5N1 bird flu that just recently happened.
- 1:12:14And it killed over 170 million chickens, turkeys,
- 1:12:18and other birds. We don't really know. They didn't
- 1:12:19really count. Those are estimated numbers. And
- 1:12:23most of those birds were not even sick. They
- 1:12:24were just cold. They were just killed in horrible
- 1:12:27conditions, just as mass killing. And there was
- 1:12:33a study that was done for the coalition from
- 1:12:35sustainable egg supply. And the study found that
- 1:12:38cage -free avaries have the greatest HEN mortality,
- 1:12:42the worst indoor air quality, the greatest dust
- 1:12:45emissions, the greatest feed usage and carbon
- 1:12:47footprint, the greatest nutrient loss, and the
- 1:12:50greatest potential for microbicrobial contamination
- 1:12:53disease transmission. So everything that we've
- 1:12:55been talking about. So one of the key ways in
- 1:12:58which this narrative of less suffering ignores
- 1:13:01is the way that it increases greater disease.
- 1:13:03In fact, when the outbreak happened, many places
- 1:13:06places that were earlier pasture raised or free
- 1:13:09range actually shifted back to caging to try
- 1:13:12to protect the birds. If you just think about
- 1:13:14a common sense, if animals are on top of each
- 1:13:18other all the time, in these super crowded cages
- 1:13:21and pooping on top of one another, there's going
- 1:13:23to be more disease transmission than if they're
- 1:13:25isolated as horrible and as opposed to the isolation
- 1:13:27is that I am. But likewise, if they're outside
- 1:13:30and birds are flying by and pooping, there's
- 1:13:33a greater risk of disease transmission. So the
- 1:13:35real truth is most flus like just flu is actually
- 1:13:39even that we label some the bird flu or swine
- 1:13:43flu, but most flu is just from zoonotic disease.
- 1:13:46It's from animals and humans and the diseases
- 1:13:49being transmitted. And the truth is cage free
- 1:13:54or pasture raised or free range and backyard
- 1:13:56chickens actually increase the risk of all of
- 1:13:59those. Doesn't decrease it. Just touching also
- 1:14:03on the labeling and the misleading side of things
- 1:14:07as well. The industry was actually given a pass
- 1:14:12because of the avian pandemic. these outbreaks
- 1:14:17for pasture raised and, for instance, maybe if
- 1:14:21a farm was cage -free but also organic, maybe
- 1:14:25they had a label that was also requiring outdoor
- 1:14:29access, that these birds were actually, in fact,
- 1:14:34not let out their entire lives due to avian flu
- 1:14:38concerns, but they were still able to sell their
- 1:14:42eggs with those labels claiming that they were.
- 1:14:47Wow. And that is just the tip of the iceberg
- 1:14:50on how misleading these labels are to consumers
- 1:14:55who, you know, are willing to pay a premium and
- 1:14:58do care about these issues and are being misled.
- 1:15:06Well, on that happy note. Did you want to add
- 1:15:14something before we stop this conversation? I
- 1:15:20Feel like you you made a truly convincing case
- 1:15:23that The animal rights movement right now is
- 1:15:27like doing alchemy. We're trying to turn silver
- 1:15:30into gold instead of being scientists and being
- 1:15:34rational and having a long -term vision and Yeah,
- 1:15:42there's Julie, I applaud your bravery to speak
- 1:15:47up. I mean, I just think egg -free corporate
- 1:15:52campaigns, animal -free corporate campaigns are
- 1:15:55the future. We agree corporate campaigns work,
- 1:15:58we agree legislation works, but let's do it in
- 1:16:01the right direction. effective altruists say
- 1:16:06we need to bring in more donor money. And one
- 1:16:09way to do it is to tell people that you can decrease
- 1:16:13the suffering of a hen by one third by taking
- 1:16:18her out of a cage. So, you know, for every hen
- 1:16:23that we free from it, for every three hens we
- 1:16:26free from cage, it's like saving one whole hen.
- 1:16:29That was farm kinds campaign. And so if you we
- 1:16:33can get meat eaters to give money. Well, I think,
- 1:16:36you know, we can get meat eaters to give money
- 1:16:39to animal protection organizations, whether we
- 1:16:43tell them that story or not. I think everybody
- 1:16:45wants a future where animals are free and where
- 1:16:49people get access to nutritious food that meets
- 1:16:53their needs. And so we don't have to. lie to
- 1:16:57people to get them to give us money. And I would
- 1:17:01just encourage people to consider that. Let's
- 1:17:05align our messaging with our real values and
- 1:17:09not tell ourselves a fake story in order to appease
- 1:17:13people. Let's start speaking the truth. I would
- 1:17:18agree. And just going back to my point was when
- 1:17:23we push for what the animals need and what we
- 1:17:27really want at the right time and place, we can
- 1:17:32get those wins. It is possible. So people need
- 1:17:37to stay strong and stay on course. Do what you
- 1:17:40need to do to build up that grit, build up your
- 1:17:44tolerance for some uncertainties that can happen
- 1:17:46when you're advocating for something. All the
- 1:17:50twists and turns that come with trying to change
- 1:17:53society. It's a big task. We need to stick with
- 1:17:57it and not give in to self -defeatism. And PETA
- 1:18:03is absolutely there to help people and we all
- 1:18:06are, I think. We're all here to keep each other
- 1:18:11going and provide resources and information and
- 1:18:16those important conversations that really need
- 1:18:18to happen within our movement. I just want to
- 1:18:22echo your first point, which is there is a pressure
- 1:18:25in the movement when you come out against cage
- 1:18:28-free eggs, and these two people are remarkable.
- 1:18:33And it is an honor to get to be in solidarity
- 1:18:36with them, fighting for this, and their bravery
- 1:18:39in willing to pay this price to fight simply
- 1:18:42because it's what they believe to be true is
- 1:18:44inspiring. And I would say also, that if you
- 1:18:49are listening to this right now and you used
- 1:18:52to support cage -free eggs, welcome. I put together
- 1:18:57a letter of 50 scholars from all over the world,
- 1:19:02from graduates through emeritus, and many of
- 1:19:05them I individually emailed and many of them
- 1:19:07said I used to support cage -free eggs. We've
- 1:19:11heard today that PETA used to support cage -free
- 1:19:14eggs. In my own life, I remember when I first
- 1:19:18heard I thought well, that's never something
- 1:19:19I want to work on but if it decreased suffering,
- 1:19:22maybe it's okay. So we are all in this together.
- 1:19:26Welcome. You don't need to apologize for anything.
- 1:19:29We love to have you and let's work together to
- 1:19:33make a real difference. Every single vegan out
- 1:19:36there is working on the single most important
- 1:19:39issue there is and I am so deeply grateful to
- 1:19:44each of you. So let's work on something that
- 1:19:47will actually work, is truly pragmatic, and will
- 1:19:51actually help the animals. Not cage -free eggs,
- 1:19:56but just not eating eggs. Amazing. Thank you
- 1:20:03so much for this beautiful message, Vasily, Crystal,
- 1:20:08Amber. Thank you so much for all of the wisdom
- 1:20:12you've shared. and for speaking up. Thank you.
- 1:20:17This has been an amazing conversation. Thank
- 1:20:22you everyone for listening. I kindly invite you
- 1:20:25to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:20:27Let's encourage more people to take action. Again,
- 1:20:32thank you so much for caring and I will see you
- 1:20:34next Tuesday for a new episode.