Latest / The Bitcoin Way Podcast / "I Predicted The Node Wars" - Start 9 CEO on Bitcoin's Potential Chain Split
Transcript
- 0:00But I predict it with shocking accuracy, by the way, if people were to go back and just read
- 0:05the statements and how it all played out so far, it has been to the T.
- 0:09What's the benefit to someone besides network decentralization?
- 0:12Could you explain like how an individual would utilize a node for their own benefit?
- 0:16Like we have now reached the point of war.
- 0:18You don't get out of that without consequences.
- 0:20Bitcoin is losing a limb, period.
- 0:22The question is which limb?
- 0:23The data suggests that real people are spending real money to buy real hardware and spin up a node.
- 0:30Mostly what we have done as a company is upheld as our core principle is user sovereignty.
- 0:36That's what we stand for above everything else.
- 0:49Today on the show, I have Matt Hill from Start9.
- 0:52And so we start off with basically why run a node? What are nodes?
- 0:55I think there's a lot of misunderstanding about the importance of running a node and being a participant in the Bitcoin network.
- 0:59But it gets spicy. We talk about BIP 110, NOTS versus CORE.
- 1:04And I think if you are new to this and all this sounds like a foreign language, you're going to come away with a lot of great takeaways from Matt.
- 1:10He's very insightful, has a firm stance, and I don't think he's shy about that.
- 1:14But you're going to really enjoy this episode.
- 1:17Hey, everyone. Like I said in the intro, I have Matt here with me.
- 1:19Matt, welcome back to the Bitcoin Way podcast.
- 1:22Hey, happy to be back. Thanks.
- 1:23Yeah, I'm excited for this chat. So we're going to jump right into, I think, one of the most important and fundamental aspects of Bitcoin. It's nodes. You know this is better than anyone else. You're building hardware to help people do that and obviously to do many other things. But we get asked all the time, why run a node? What is a node? How would you describe that to someone? I would love to hear your answer. And then we're going to talk a little bit more about the node wars and some of the other fun stuff that's been going on.
- 1:46Yeah, great. So Bitcoin is a network of nodes. I mean, Bitcoin without nodes is not Bitcoin. It is an integral and sort of inherent aspect. Bitcoin is not just a currency and it's not just a mining operation, etc.
- 2:00I mean, Bitcoin is defined by a network of nodes that interact with one another for the purpose of enforcing a set of consensus rules, as well as propagating transactions around the world such that they can eventually be mined into blocks and then also verifying and propagating blocks around the world to reach an eventually consistent state such that all nodes around the world know the same thing.
- 2:30but do not have to trust each other or anyone else in the process to know the thing that they know.
- 2:36So ultimately, the Bitcoin and the nodes that comprise the network results in a degree of truth,
- 2:44a state of information that all can agree on despite existing in an adversarial environment.
- 2:53So if you want to be a part of this network, you need to run a node. You can use the network
- 2:59without running a node, right? You can buy Bitcoin, the currency to speculate on it or
- 3:03save and hedge against inflation. You can use the network to conduct Bitcoin transactions.
- 3:09You can mine and verify and conduct proof of work to compose transactions into blocks and
- 3:18hope to earn a block reward. And none of that requires you to run a node. Mining in the true
- 3:26requires you to run a node, but to produce hash and sell that hash to a miner does not require you
- 3:32to run a node. It just requires you to run a hashing machine. So there are a variety of ways
- 3:35to participate or to use the Bitcoin network, but the only way to participate in its creation,
- 3:42to be a part of that network is to run a node. I agree with that completely. I like to say that
- 3:48if you're not running a node, you're not really a participant. And I think that's an important
- 3:51distinguishing feature of what it means to run a node. Obviously, we need nodes for the network
- 3:55to be strong, for the network to be sufficiently decentralized. I think there are a lot of people
- 4:01who probably hear that and they say, okay, yeah, but I've seen estimates. There's 20,000 reachable
- 4:05nodes online. There are many more besides that. Why do I need to run a node? So what's the benefit
- 4:11to someone besides network decentralization, which I think should be enough, but could you explain
- 4:16how an individual would utilize a node for their own benefit? Sure. Yeah. And to be fair,
- 4:22out of, I only answered your question halfway, right? I described sort of what a node is and how
- 4:26it relates to the Bitcoin network, not why you would want to run one. So I would argue that
- 4:31decentralization of the network benefit to the network is actually a secondary or even tertiary
- 4:35consideration when it comes to running a node. The primary reason that someone would want to run a
- 4:40node is to have total sovereignty over their financial transactions. When you run a node,
- 4:46you validate inbound transactions, aka when somebody sends you money, you are able to verify
- 4:54the authenticity of the funds received yourself. It's like having your own little light that you
- 5:01can shine on bills Like if someone were to hand you a large bill and you want to know if it counterfeit or not you going to take this light out of your pocket and shine it on that bill to see if it counterfeit And you trust your light because it yours right It can lie to you And so you know that that money is real
- 5:22And in a world where there's lots of counterfeit money going around and that all money has the
- 5:27potential to be counterfeited, it's really a good idea to have a verification tool in your pocket
- 5:31to make sure that when somebody pays you, you know you've actually been paid in real money.
- 5:35And if you don't run a node, you are asking somebody else to use their tool, right? So if somebody were to hand me a large bill, and then I were to turn to a bank or some other trusted party and be like, hey, Bob gave me a bill. Is this bill real? I'm now asking them to tell me if the money I received is real, which means they could lie to me, right? I am now at their mercy.
- 6:01And again, in a world where authorities are betraying trust on a daily basis and with
- 6:07increasing frequency, you really shouldn't be outsourcing things as important as verifying
- 6:13the authenticity of your money to banks and governments and other trusted third parties
- 6:18when you can so trivially do it yourself.
- 6:20So the Bitcoin node is the equivalent of that little flashlight that can tell you if the
- 6:24money is real in the Bitcoin world.
- 6:26running a node tells you with certainty that the money you've received, one, that you have
- 6:31received it, and two, that it is not counterfeit. Second reason, go ahead.
- 6:36No, I was just going to say, I think that's such an underrated aspect of what Bitcoin enables. And
- 6:41until the switch is flipped for users of the Bitcoin network, that this is the don't trust
- 6:47verify that we talk about all the time. I think a lot of people just reiterate that trope, and they
- 6:51never really internalize it. And so they sit on the sidelines and continue to buy Bitcoin,
- 6:56leave it on an exchange, maybe. Maybe they take self-custody, but not really. They're not fully
- 7:00sovereign. So I think you hit on there, I think, a very important point. I'm sorry, back to your
- 7:04second reason. Number two is censorship resistance, right? The ability to send money.
- 7:10So the whole first part was about receiving money and making sure that it is valid.
- 7:14And the second part is, say, I want to pay someone else. Well, who do I have to ask for
- 7:19permission to do that. If I want to send you Bitcoin and I want to do that without permission,
- 7:25I just want to send you Bitcoin, right? I want to open up my phone, send you some Bitcoin.
- 7:30The only way to do this is if you're running your own node. You cannot send Bitcoin to somebody
- 7:35without sending the Bitcoin to a node somewhere, right? Even if it's directly to a miner,
- 7:41that's still a node, right? A miner is running a node. So there's no way to make a transaction
- 7:46exist without handing it to a node. It's like trying to deliver mail without handing it to a
- 7:51postal worker. That's the only way your mail is going to get anywhere is if you hand it to some
- 7:54postal worker. And in the Bitcoin world, there isn't even this concept of delivering it yourself.
- 7:59I guess there is, which is if you hand them your private key. If you were to put Bitcoin on a
- 8:03private key, like a bearer asset, like an open dime, and then give someone that open dime, then
- 8:08yes, you have successfully transferred Bitcoin without conducting a transaction. But if you want
- 8:15to send somebody Bitcoin via the Bitcoin network, via a transaction, it has to go to a node. So the
- 8:21question is, who's node, right? If it's not yours, it's someone else's. And if it's someone else's,
- 8:28they can tell you no, it's their property. And if they tell you no, then you have to ask someone
- 8:32else and you have to hope that somebody is going to take your transaction. And in today's world,
- 8:38it's pretty easy to do. It's pretty easy to find somebody who will take your transaction.
- 8:41There's literally drop boxes online where you can just drop your transaction and it'll get
- 8:45sent to the Bitcoin network. That might not always be the case, right? Just like it isn't with fiat
- 8:50currencies. And so you should take measures to ensure that you will never be cut off from
- 8:56participating in the network. And the way that you do that is by running your own node, because if
- 9:00you do, nobody can cut you off. And so this is where like some of the node war stuff that comes
- 9:06into play is who's going to be willing to relay these transactions depending on the type of
- 9:11transaction it is, right? So what you're saying is that it would be trivial for if you're an
- 9:16exchange and you run a node. And so many people are relying on that node to effectively broadcast
- 9:21transactions to the network. It would be trivial for them either through government coercion or
- 9:26their own determination that, well, we don't want to send that transaction. They just can opt out
- 9:31basically and say, sorry, you're out of luck. And your node enables that. They could filter by IP
- 9:35address. They could filter by doing KYC. And there's like, hey, we are a gateway to the Bitcoin
- 9:41network, we accept transactions, but you have to fill out this KYC form. That wouldn't be effective
- 9:46in today's world because there's somebody right next door willing to take it without KYC. But again,
- 9:50the harder this clamps down, the ultimate end game of this is to run your own node. Because
- 9:55if you hand the transaction to your own node, it can now flood the network without permission. It
- 10:02can flood the network without them even knowing where it originated. This is the whole point
- 10:06of the V2 transaction relay, as well as Tor and I2P, right? So the whole game is to get the
- 10:13transaction to a node, any node, anywhere. So long as that node is connected to other nodes,
- 10:19your transaction will make it right But it getting it to that first node is where the choke point could happen It the on to the network And then lastly the last reason that someone would want to run a node aside from the broad
- 10:34benefit to the entire Bitcoin network when people do the things I just mentioned, there
- 10:38is a third reason, which is political activism, right?
- 10:42So running a node makes you part of the network.
- 10:45And as a member of the network, you have a very small degree of influence over what is and is not permissible on the network. And there are sort of two layers of political activism within the Bitcoin network.
- 11:02network. One is the policy, right? You can view this as like standards, sort of cultural standards
- 11:12and accepted best practices, right? This is like you go to a park and there's a sign that's just
- 11:19like code of conduct. This is how you behave here. It's loosely enforced, but if you abuse it,
- 11:25then maybe we'll call someone, you know, it's just an acceptable code of conduct that everyone
- 11:31kind of agrees to, and then it works. And then the second layer is actually consensus, is the law
- 11:36of the land, okay, where you're setting hard limits on what can and cannot be done,
- 11:42and not retroactively. This is like proactive law. This is like you're setting, you're changing
- 11:48the laws of physics such that skateboarding at the park just can't be done, right? Like,
- 11:54this is what they tried to do during COVID. They like ripped up the concrete and filled it with
- 11:58sand so that you couldn't skateboard at the park anymore. That's consensus. You're actually changing
- 12:03the physics and the ground to prohibit certain types of behavior, whereas the sign is more of
- 12:11the gentleman's agreement, so to speak. And nodes get to participate in both of those activities,
- 12:17both of those political processes, and in very different ways. And depending on which one,
- 12:22there are different degrees of power that different nodes have. Not all nodes are created equal
- 12:28depending on which layer you are operating on. And we can dig into either one of those
- 12:33separately if you'd like. Let's focus in on that. When you say that not all nodes have the same
- 12:38degree of power, what does that mean? Who has more power? Who has less power? What's the nature of
- 12:42that power? I think that would be interesting for folks to hear about. Yeah. Let's split the
- 12:48political powers into two categories, right? Policy and consensus. Okay. And we'll talk about
- 12:54them separately. Let's talk about policy first. So policy is simply what your node
- 13:01deems to be a standard or non-standard transaction, a standard use case of Bitcoin versus a rare and
- 13:11non-standard use of Bitcoin. And this is your decision, right? This is a personal decision.
- 13:17It's you making a local, personal, economic or political decision on what you would like to see Bitcoin used for.
- 13:26So you're going to give these certain types of transactions like first class citizenship.
- 13:31And you're like, those I love.
- 13:32That's great.
- 13:33These things, don't want to see them.
- 13:35Don't want them around.
- 13:37I don't think that they should be competing for mempool and block space with these other types of transactions that I really think are how I and others should be using Bitcoin.
- 13:47Again, a very personal decision.
- 13:50And these are highly tunable.
- 13:51So you can say like how much data in an operaturn output is permissible, right?
- 13:57Or how many transactions per second are allowed to enter your memble.
- 14:00There's lots of little knobs that you can turn in the settings of your node.
- 14:06Most people never touch these things, right?
- 14:08Because they ship with very sane, very reasonable defaults, or at least they have for a long
- 14:14time.
- 14:15And so most people could just kind of plug their node in and know that it was, you know,
- 14:18enforcing certain types of transactions or granting certain types of transactions,
- 14:23first-class additionship and de-emphasizing and rate limiting other types of transactions.
- 14:29And so you tune this. And what happens is, so you tune your node how you want,
- 14:34and then I tune my node how I want. And Bob and Nancy, they all tune their nodes how they want,
- 14:40everyone makes this decision on their own. And it just so happens that if everyone agrees,
- 14:48right? If a super majority of people agree, like if I've chosen, if I say, hey, I don't like
- 14:55operaturns that are bigger than 83 bytes, and I'm going to set that on my node. And then you say,
- 15:00you don't like operaturns that are bigger than 83 bytes. And then everyone says that, right?
- 15:04Let's say that a super majority of people around the world say that. Then what it means is that
- 15:08any transaction containing an operaturn output of greater than 83 bytes just isn't going to make it
- 15:12around the network, right? Because I'm going to get it and I'm going to be like, I don't like
- 15:15these things and I drop it.
- 15:17But maybe it gets to a node that is okay with it and it goes to forward it on,
- 15:22but nine out of the 10 nodes that it forwards it to also don't like it and drop it.
- 15:27So you can see how probabilistically,
- 15:30the more nodes that are refusing to either store or relay a certain type of transaction the less likelihood
- 15:44that that transaction has of flooding the network and eventually finding its way to a miner.
- 15:51And so, like I said, it's just a signpost. It helps limit that type of transaction. It's a rate
- 15:57limiter. A lot of people were using the word filter to describe these things. I think rate
- 16:03limiter is a much more accurate word, much more intuitive word. You are not eliminating anything.
- 16:09You're not outlawing anything. You're just putting a degree of friction in place in order to limit
- 16:16the instance rate of a certain type of transaction so that you can optimize the network and minimize
- 16:25the fees for a different type of transaction that you think is more important than that type
- 16:31of transaction. So all you're doing is skewing the instance rate higher for normal standard
- 16:37transactions and lower for non-standard abnormal transactions. And so this is your political power
- 16:45here, and it's a collective power. You personally can't do anything, but if you and everyone else
- 16:50agree on what these policies should be, what these rate limiters should be,
- 16:55then they become highly effective and have been highly effective in Bitcoin for many, many years.
- 17:01Now, not all nodes are equal in this, right? So the more connected your node is,
- 17:07the more power it has in the realm of policy. So if your node is connected outbound to three
- 17:17other nodes and inbound from one other node, you're kind of isolated, right? You're kind of
- 17:23like on the fringe of the network. You don't have a lot of connections to other nodes, which means
- 17:29you could be enforcing all sorts of policies, but not many transactions are even going to go
- 17:34through your node because it's not well connected. So the more well connected your node is,
- 17:40the more transactions it will see from other nodes, and therefore, the more it will be enforcing
- 17:48its own local rate-limiting policies, and therefore would have a larger effect on the
- 17:56network as a whole. So nodes that are connected over Tor, that are connected over I2P, that are
- 18:03connected over ClearNet, that are connected over CJDNS, if your node is using all of these and
- 18:09it's connected to hundreds of nodes all over the world using all these different network protocols,
- 18:14then your node is a first-class policy-enforcing node. Now, still not a huge power, right? You're
- 18:22still just one out of many thousands of nodes, no matter how well-connected you are. It's not
- 18:27like you are now wielding massive political power in Bitcoin. You still are absolutely meaningless
- 18:32if many, many other nodes around the network don't also agree with the policies that you have set.
- 18:38Okay, so that's policy. Any questions or comments regarding policy?
- 18:42That makes sense.
- 18:44Okay. Moving to consensus. Consensus, like I said, is a changing of the laws of physics. It is changing what is permissible on Bitcoin in the first place. It is not a rate limiter, it is an eliminator.
- 18:56Okay. And nodes also decide this. So nodes have the power of policy and they have the power of
- 19:03consensus. And the way that they enforce consensus is both proactively and retroactively on transactions
- 19:12that they see on their way to a miner and then on blocks that emerge from a miner. Okay. So a
- 19:20transaction gets handed to the network and it does not conform to your laws. Now, again, this is not
- 19:28a rate limiter. It's not like you're just dropping the transaction. You are now viewing that peer as
- 19:33malicious. They're a criminal. They're violating the law. And so if they try to hand you a transaction,
- 19:40you are going to drop it. You might even ban them as a result. And that's when the transaction is on
- 19:46its way to a miner. So as the transaction attempts to flood the network, it will get hard stopped in
- 19:52a very similar way as the rate limiting policy would have done. The bigger difference is once it
- 19:59gets mined into a block, like let's say that nodes disagree on the law. Some nodes are saying,
- 20:05yeah, A, B, and C are legal. And other nodes are like, no, C is definitely illegal.
- 20:09And so the transaction is lucky and it finds its way to a miner that agrees with the first set and
- 20:16goes, oh yeah, A, B, and C is fine. This transaction does C. It's fine. I'm going to put it into a
- 20:19block. And it sends that block out to the network. Same thing is going to happen. Nodes that agree
- 20:25with that law are going to accept this block as valid. And nodes that disagree with that law are
- 20:31going to reject that block. They're going to refuse to add that block to the blockchain and
- 20:38instead will favor a block that does not have illegal transactions in it. Not illegal in the
- 20:45jurisdictional sense.
- 20:46We're only talking about Bitcoin here.
- 20:48I want to be very, very clear about that.
- 20:50These are Bitcoin laws, not nation state laws.
- 20:53So maybe laws are even the wrong words, right?
- 20:55It's consensus rules, right?
- 20:56It's the proper technical term for these.
- 20:59And so as a node, you have this power.
- 21:02You can decide what is legal and what is illegal, but there's risk, right?
- 21:07So if you decide that a certain type of transaction is illegal
- 21:12and that transaction is flying all over the place, like there's tons of them,
- 21:17and there's blocks being handed to you with that transaction and you're refusing to put them on
- 21:22your chain, you've essentially just seceded from the network. You are no longer a part of the
- 21:28network. You just disagree with the law of the land. You've emigrated. You're out. You've moved
- 21:35to another land. There's some nuance there in terms of whether you are differing from the network in
- 21:44that you are allowing something that nobody else allows, or you're differing from the network in
- 21:50that you disallow something that everyone else allows, right? So are you being more permissive
- 21:57than other nodes, or are you being more restrictive than other nodes? And this has consequences,
- 22:04right? Which one it is matters. Now, before we get into that nuance, which we probably should,
- 22:09the degree of your political power in this realm has nothing to do. I shouldn't say nothing.
- 22:19It has almost nothing to do with how well connected your node is. Unlike policy, which is that is the
- 22:26only real lever of how powerful your node is, is how well connected it is. In the realm of consensus,
- 22:33connectivity doesn't really matter that much. What matters instead is economic power,
- 22:41economic weight. How important is your node? Economically speaking to the broader network,
- 22:49and not all nodes are created equal. So unlike policy where you have weak nodes that are only
- 22:59connected to, say, 10 peers, and you have powerful nodes that are connected to 100 peers,
- 23:04neither of them are very powerful. You could be the weakest node or the most powerful node,
- 23:10but you're still this big. You need everyone else to agree with you. But in the realm of consensus,
- 23:18this is not true. One very highly economic node, economically important node, could be worth as
- 23:28many as 10,000 uneconomic nodes, right? Like there's a huge difference between a not powerful
- 23:35node and a powerful node, massive gap. It's like the difference between a beggar on the street
- 23:41and a Senator, right? Like massive difference in political power on the Bitcoin network.
- 23:47So could you explain that? Like who are the powerful nodes,
- 23:52the economically powerful nodes and why?
- 23:55And why?
- 23:56Yeah.
- 23:56Economically powerful nodes mean nodes that other people are using to engage with the
- 24:02Bitcoin network.
- 24:03Okay.
- 24:04So if everyone was running their own node for their own transactions, the only economically
- 24:13powerful nodes would be businesses, right?
- 24:15So businesses who are buying and selling products with Bitcoin using their own node are economically
- 24:22powerful nodes.
- 24:23For example, Start9.
- 24:25Start9 is not the most economically powerful node, but we sell real world physical products
- 24:31in exchange for Bitcoin. We accept Bitcoin as payment and it goes through our node.
- 24:37We validate that transaction through our node. So other people around the world, namely our
- 24:43customers, are using our node. They may have broadcast the transaction through their own node,
- 24:50right? Probably not since they're buying a server from us. It probably means that they want to run
- 24:54of nodes. They're not yet running one, but they didn't broadcast the transaction through our node.
- 24:59It's that our node did the verification. We hold the power in that transaction, right? You're
- 25:04handing us a bill. It's up to us to verify the authenticity of that bill. If we don't think it's
- 25:09authentic, we're giving it back to you. We're not accepting your money if it's not authentic,
- 25:15right? So if we as a company that people want to buy products from is looking at a bill and saying,
- 25:22we only accept bills that have blue marks on them. This bill only has red marks. We're not taking it.
- 25:28And if other businesses were to agree with us and be like, oh, yeah, yeah, no, we only take
- 25:32bills with blue marks. If it has red marks, we don't take it. Well, then suddenly nobody wants
- 25:36bills with red marks on it. You can't spend them. Nobody's going to take your bill if it has red
- 25:42marks on it. And that was decided by the businesses, by the people who were selling
- 25:48goods and services, individuals and companies who were willing to accept Bitcoin for their goods and
- 25:55services decided what Bitcoin was in this instance Do you understand They saying I want this thing And so if they want that thing then it means other people want that thing because it the
- 26:08only thing the businesses will take in exchange for their goods and services. So those are highly
- 26:13economic nodes. As it stands, there are other very economic nodes as well. There are mining pools,
- 26:19right? So when someone is running a little bidaxe miner at their home and they're pointing it
- 26:25to a remote miner and they are not running their own node, right? They're not doing their own block
- 26:31template construction locally using something like Datum or public pool, but they are instead
- 26:36just basically selling hash to a miner, somebody who is running a node and constructing those block
- 26:44templates. Those nodes are now economic nodes. They're willing to purchase hash in exchange for
- 26:52Bitcoin in order to mine. And so they are economic nodes. You have exchanges. So things like Kraken
- 27:02and Coinbase, massive economic nodes, right? If you want to deposit Bitcoin to Coinbase,
- 27:09they are validating that transaction to make sure you're not giving them counterfeit Bitcoin.
- 27:15And so you can imagine how much money, how much Bitcoin is being deposited into Kraken and
- 27:20Coinbase on a daily basis and being validated by their nodes, that makes them extremely powerful
- 27:27economic nodes. Because if they were to stop accepting a certain type of Bitcoin, Bitcoin that
- 27:34had red marking on it, to stick with the analogy, then suddenly people would be like, well, I don't
- 27:40want Bitcoin red marking on it because Coinbase or Kraken won't take it. Please don't use Coinbase,
- 27:45by the way, but they, they won't, they won't take it. So you don't want it either because you can't
- 27:50send it to an exchange and sell it for fiat money. Not sure why you'd want to, don't do that.
- 27:55But, um, I'll, I'll throw in a few little, uh, yeah, we need to point people in the right
- 28:01direction. Don't use Coinbase. Don't sell, don't use Coinbase. Yeah. Don't, don't sell and don't
- 28:07use any exchange, but if you need one, don't use Coinbase. Um, so, so anyway, uh, there are economic
- 28:14nodes. Another one would be wallets. So a lot of people use Bitcoin from their phones, right? So
- 28:20you download some app on your phone, like Bull Wallet, which is my favorite Bitcoin lightning
- 28:25wallet on the market right now. You download that to your phone. And by default, that app,
- 28:35right, that you've downloaded to your phone is going to connect to a node that is owned and
- 28:42operated by bull Bitcoin. And this is necessary, right? Because if you don't run your own node,
- 28:49then you need one. So by default, all wallets connect to a node that is owned and operated
- 28:58by the person who built the wallet, which means de facto, they are a powerful economic node because
- 29:05most people, if we're being honest, don't switch the default to use their own node. They just stick
- 29:13with the default, which means everyone who's downloaded that app and is using it to send
- 29:17and receive Bitcoin is actually sending and receiving Bitcoin through the company node,
- 29:23not your own. However, good wallets like the bull wallet allow you to change that. You can go into
- 29:34the settings and say, oh, instead of using the node that is run by BullBitcoin, you can use
- 29:42the node in your home, then now you have that economic power and corresponding political power.
- 29:52You've disempowered the massive economic node that everyone was using and taken a piece of it
- 29:59for yourself. And so those are the economic entities in Bitcoin. You have the exchanges,
- 30:08the pools, the wallet developers, the people who ship wallet software, phone and desktop.
- 30:16You have businesses, right? Merchants, individuals and businesses selling goods and services.
- 30:23And then you have the consumers, people who are buying goods and services,
- 30:28buying and selling goods and services from each other.
- 30:31Do you view any of the inherent centralization of these economic nodes?
- 30:37It's far fewer exchanges, for example, than there are individuals.
- 30:41Is that a risk? Is it a problem?
- 30:44Or is it just an inherent aspect of the network?
- 30:48It's inherent.
- 30:49I think it's fairly well balanced.
- 30:52There's far more decentralization in node operatorship than there is in mining, for example.
- 30:57Right? Mining is much more centralized. Mining is a problem at the moment.
- 31:02Mm-hmm .
- 31:03And long I think there are some interesting trends that are helping and will continue to help decentralize mining But in terms of economic power on the Bitcoin network it fairly well distributed right So I just named quite a few different entities I mean the pools are huge and the miners are sorry the mining pools are huge The exchanges
- 31:25are huge. The merchants are huge. And so, yeah, I think it's fairly well distributed.
- 31:33Okay. So my intention when we kicked this off wasn't necessarily to do like Node 101,
- 31:38But I think that really sets the stage well for people who are sorting through this.
- 31:42And there are a lot of people asking questions about core versus knots, BIP 110, what's going to happen?
- 31:47Where do I land on this sort of spectrum of believing Bitcoin is money versus it's just a decentralized file storage or a lot of opinions?
- 31:58Start9 got itself not into a mess.
- 32:01I mean, I don't think anyone has any issue with your product.
- 32:03We personally love it.
- 32:04But the Start9 Twitter account was sharing some thoughts that were taken to be an endorsement of Bitcoin nots. And I think you told me in Vegas that really wasn't what the tweet was. Could you describe what the tweet was that caught fire and then where Start9 is a company or maybe you personally stand?
- 32:25So there definitely was not like a tweet. This has been like an ongoing saga for at least a year. So to rewind a little bit, right? We'll go back to, let's go back to the beginning. I'll tell you a little story here.
- 32:40So back to 2019, when we decided to start this company, we knew then and even used language in late 2019 around this concept of like Bitcoin citizenship, right?
- 32:54Which was not novel.
- 32:55It's just something we were orienting around.
- 32:58And we didn't want to be like hyperbolic about it.
- 33:00We didn't want to like exaggerate the importance or the political power gained by running a node.
- 33:04But we did recognize that ultimately, it is the nodes that compose the network, the connected, maintained, economically important nodes that comprise the Bitcoin network that would do and would continue to define what Bitcoin is and what its future holds.
- 33:28This was not the only, but was sort of the supreme political power in Bitcoin. There's lots of political constituencies in Bitcoin. And I talked about this at the Bitcoin 2025 conference. And I would encourage anyone here, because I'm not going to rehash that whole conversation right now, to go watch that talk where I talk about what are the five political, five slash six political constituencies of Bitcoin.
- 33:54What powers do they have and how do they exercise those powers? And how does it result in a very elegant balance of power, more so even than the three branches of government that compose, for example, the United States system? Bitcoin has five or six branches of government.
- 34:11And in my mind, the most underestimated and ultimately most powerful branch of government is the economic nodes. Ultimately, they hold the trump card. They are collectively, acting collectively, can basically strong arm the rest of the network into anything that they want.
- 34:31So if the economic power in Bitcoin collectively, meaning the mining pools, the exchanges, the wallet developers, the merchants, and the consumers all get together and decide that they want to make some new law, everyone else is eating it.
- 34:45The miners are eating it.
- 34:46The exchanges are eating it.
- 34:47And again, it doesn't have to be everyone agreeing.
- 34:48It's just that as long as the weight is in favor of a certain change, the nodes will carry that vote.
- 34:56They have that power.
- 34:58Is that specifically with respect to Relay?
- 35:00Because I assume, you know, like Coinbase can just decide,
- 35:04eh, 21 million is not enough.
- 35:05We're going to change something at the consensus layer.
- 35:08No one's playing along with that.
- 35:09Are you speaking specifically to policy?
- 35:12No, this is both.
- 35:13Potentially?
- 35:14Yeah.
- 35:14So the nodes acting collectively at the policy layer
- 35:19can absolutely effectively rate limit transactions, right?
- 35:24This is a non-debatable factual statement, right?
- 35:28Like if 95% of the nodes on the network want to rate limit, limit the instance rate of a certain type of transaction, it shall be limited, right?
- 35:37It doesn't mean that that transaction is illegal or forbidden or can't be sideloaded to a miner with added risk and added fees and added inconvenience and all the rest.
- 35:46But it just means that it will be rate limited in the peer-to-peer network period, right?
- 35:51And so that is a highly effective political power.
- 35:54It's just not a nuclear power.
- 35:57It's not violence.
- 35:58It's civil.
- 35:59It's civil powers.
- 36:01It's people agreeing to agree in a civil society, right?
- 36:06But if that fails, and this is what my speech at that conference got into, is I did not
- 36:13advocate for, but I predicted with shocking accuracy, by the way.
- 36:17If people were to go back and just read listen to some of my podcasts and read some of the tweets that came from me in the Start9 account over the last year and a half And for a second take off the blinders about what you think intent is and just read the statements
- 36:32as fact and how it all played out so far. It has been to the T. And what I predicted at that
- 36:38conference was I said, because this is back when the policy war was raging. We won't call it a war.
- 36:44The policy debate was raging, right? And Knotts was garnering adoption at a shocking rate.
- 36:51And we were selling servers left and right for people who wanted to run Bitcoin knots. What I claimed there was that, okay, this is the civil political activism in Bitcoin right now. You have a legitimate expression of discontent.
- 37:10you have willingness to expend economic, right, to purchase physical hardware in order to run
- 37:21software that expresses your opinion about what you want Bitcoin to be and that people were taking
- 37:28to the streets. This was a form of protest, right? The migration from core to knots was a very real,
- 37:34very genuine protest that we don't need to get into the gritty details of, but it was a
- 37:40political protest. And the way that that protest was dealt with by the incumbent powers, we'll call
- 37:48it, was basically the Tiananmen Square. It was like total disregard, right? So you have in the
- 37:56real meat space world, when people get upset about something in mass and they start doing something,
- 38:03they start moving economic purchasing power from one company to another, or they start marching in
- 38:08the streets, so they start breaking things, there tends to be this very seasoned response
- 38:13from the incumbent powers. They know how to deal with civil discontent. So it's listen,
- 38:19it's accommodate, eventually it is usurp and conquer. So I'm not saying it's necessarily a
- 38:28good thing how the incumbent powers in meat space deal with civil discontent, but they at least
- 38:33know how to deal with it. They have a degree of tact. They've learned from history where it's like,
- 38:38hey, if everyone is like marching through the streets and switching from one brand to another,
- 38:42demanding, you know, immigration rights because they need to get out of here,
- 38:46you probably shouldn't just go in and start shooting them all, right? Like that's only
- 38:49going to make it, it's only going to add flames to the fire. And that's basically how, for lack
- 38:54of a better word, the loose organization and affiliation known as Bitcoin Core dealt with
- 38:58this situation. It was very poorly dismissive, condescending, elitist, and ultimately forceful,
- 39:09ultimately just like a shut up and take it. And so at that conference, I predicted, I said,
- 39:13if that is the way that this goes down, if this is not dealt with in an appropriate manner,
- 39:18the response of the nodes is going to be to stop playing at the civil nice layer,
- 39:23and they're going to take it to the legal layer where they have the only nuclear button.
- 39:27No other political constituency has the nuclear button except for the nodes.
- 39:33That's BIP-110, I assume.
- 39:34Correct.
- 39:35Yeah, this ultimately manifested in what is now known as BIP-110, where the node operators, the people who were upset with decisions that were being made and in the manner in which those decisions were being made, stopped playing nice.
- 39:52Basically, they said, okay, well, we tried policy.
- 39:55We tried to rate limit these things.
- 39:58We didn't want to make them illegal.
- 39:59We just wanted to differentiate them, first class versus second class type of citizenship and transaction.
- 40:07But now, because that was denied, we're going to create a law that makes them illegal.
- 40:15And in the process, wipes out or would, if enacted, would wipe out a very significant amount of capital that has been invested in and around the protocols and new application opportunities that those changes that were originally pushed back against, like the operaturn change, enable.
- 40:38Um, and so that is where it currently is, is there is now a, um, a movement to change the
- 40:46laws of physics.
- 40:47And ultimately, as I stated earlier, that is determined by the economic nodes.
- 40:55The economic nodes decide what Bitcoin is, period.
- 40:59That is the nuclear button in Bitcoin politics.
- 41:01Uh, the question is, do the economic nodes have enough weight and consensus to, uh, push the vote forward? That is the open question.
- 41:13Okay. So I think I listened to the talk that you referenced. Um, it's been a while though. I'm going to take it at your word that the predictions have all more or less come to pass, uh, with a high degree of accuracy.
- 41:24How do you see BIP 110 the next couple of months?
- 41:29And then I guess just sort of projecting to the future
- 41:31what this might look like, what's gonna happen?
- 41:33Because I think there are a lot of people who are saying,
- 41:35just fork off, you know, like if you want something
- 41:39something different, go a different direction.
- 41:41A lot of people who I've talked to are very enthusiastic about the traction
- 41:46that BIP-110 has gained and think, yeah, it's certainly going to activate.
- 41:51Where's your head at?
- 41:53By the way, are you cheering on activation?
- 41:55And then what's your prediction about activation?
- 41:57Okay, so yeah, before we get to the future,
- 41:59and I'm happy to talk about all that,
- 42:01what I gave was background on an original question
- 42:04around our own perception and tweets and all of that.
- 42:07Or posts, I guess, now that it's X.
- 42:09So, what we have done, by and large, okay, not to say that there is no opinion, of course, and we uphold our right as individuals and as a company because Start9 is not some megacorp owned by the shareholders and a board.
- 42:28We're like a couple individuals, right?
- 42:30And it's supposed to be that way.
- 42:32Start9 has a personality. The company has a personality and it's basically a mesh of me and Aiden, right? And the other people who are part of this company and our community, like that is what gets expressed. And we think it's perfectly appropriate for companies to have opinions. I can't believe people pushed back against that. But anyway, what those opinions are has been largely misunderstood.
- 42:51it. So mostly what we have done as a company is upheld as a principle, as our core principle,
- 42:57is user sovereignty. That's what we stand for above everything else, no matter how strong our
- 43:05opinion is about something. User choice, user sovereignty. We are building computing systems
- 43:11that put people in charge of their own computers, including what software those computers run.
- 43:17And we do everything that we possibly can, which has its limitations, by the way, because
- 43:22defaults are unavoidable, right?
- 43:24Because UI design inherently has opinions in it, even if you don't want it to, it's
- 43:29like hard to keep yourself out of stuff, right?
- 43:31But we do everything that we possibly can to create a neutral technology, a technology
- 43:38that puts the user in total control by telling them what's what, by giving them all the
- 43:43information that they could need and the buttons to act on the combination of the information
- 43:49and their own desires and wills. That's what we do. And that's what we have stated repeatedly.
- 43:58When it came to the policy debate and now the consensus war, the fork, the pending fork,
- 44:06Mostly what we have done, I'd argue 90 to 95% of what we have done is observe, state what we observe, right?
- 44:17Say, hey, there's a duck, right?
- 44:19Like just observe things and say them factually and then make predictions.
- 44:25We've said, okay, we see a duck.
- 44:28We also see a coyote.
- 44:31we predict that this coyote might see that duck and chase it. That's what we have done, 95%.
- 44:38What everyone reads in there is, why do you want that coyote to eat that duck?
- 44:45That's what they hear. Because that's X. That's social media. That's human tribalism.
- 44:52Where do you stand? Do you want the duck to get eaten or no? It's like, we see a coyote,
- 44:58we see a duck. We think that coyote is going to chase that duck and that duck probably won't get
- 45:02away. So it's probably going to eat that duck. And everyone's like, you want the duck to die.
- 45:05Okay. We didn't say that. I'm not saying we don't have an opinion. I'm just saying that
- 45:10that has been our public stance from the get-go, trying to call it like we see it,
- 45:17trying to predict what comes next as best as we possibly can, because we think information
- 45:21should be free, is free, and that the more information that floods the world, the better,
- 45:26because the more information people have, the better they can make an informed decision.
- 45:30And so I have never held back in sharing information that I see. And we have a first
- 45:35class view to this. There's thousands and thousands of people out there buying servers
- 45:43to run nodes, to be politically active in Bitcoin. They're buying them from us.
- 45:49We talk to them in our support channels. We hear them in emails. We know what they're thinking.
- 45:54We know what they want. We know how they feel. So we actually have a vantage point here that you'd
- 46:00think a lot of people would be interested in hearing. But every time we've managed to state
- 46:05anything that we're seeing, like last year, I published our sales figures. I wasn't bragging.
- 46:10They weren't even braggable, right? Like I'm not proud of a couple million dollars in sales in a
- 46:15year. Like we're a pond. We're a fucking tadpole on a pond compared to other computer companies.
- 46:20I published the numbers to verify what others were observing on the network, which was a rise in Bitcoin not node count.
- 46:31And there was a lot of people out there being like, these are Sybil attacks.
- 46:33They're not real nodes.
- 46:34They're just people spinning up nodes.
- 46:36They're bots.
- 46:37And I was like, no, they're not, guys.
- 46:39Look at our sales numbers.
- 46:41I'm telling you, these are real nodes by real people who really care.
- 46:45This is not a fucking Sybil attack.
- 46:47And again sharing that information was viewed as like an endorsement of knots or an endorsement of Bitcoin 10
- 46:57Again, I'm not saying anything about my personal, my partners, anyone at the companies or Start9
- 47:03as a company's opinion right now.
- 47:05I'm just saying that that observation was just information for the world to have so
- 47:10that we could have a better debate, so that we could have a better conversation.
- 47:15but it wasn't welcomed or accepted in that way.
- 47:19And so...
- 47:20Yeah, I mean, that's the tribalism coming in.
- 47:23The whole point being the data suggests
- 47:25that real people are spending real money
- 47:28to buy real hardware and spin up a node.
- 47:32And perhaps other things, by the way,
- 47:34like sovereign computing extends beyond
- 47:36running your own Bitcoin node,
- 47:37but probably largely, I think a lot of people know you guys
- 47:40as you guys make hardware that they can easily run a node.
- 47:43By far.
- 47:44And immediately, immediately people go to this, you know, well, you're trying to prove that Knott's is, you know, picking up steam.
- 47:53And so you must be Team Knott's and you have this opinion.
- 47:57And we talked a little bit of Vegas.
- 47:59I know to some degree your opinion, which you can share in as much detail or not as you'd like.
- 48:04But, yeah, I think that's a great use case of sharing knowledge because it is helpful for people to understand whether you like it or not.
- 48:12It doesn't matter which side of the fence you're on.
- 48:14There is a real movement.
- 48:15There is real discontent at the way that core handled this particular change.
- 48:21And it is the,
- 48:22the word I use is dismissive.
- 48:25And we're seeing it too,
- 48:26by the way,
- 48:27and not just knots nodes,
- 48:28but I mean,
- 48:29we have literally spun up over the last couple of years,
- 48:31thousands of nodes.
- 48:32We've helped users spin up thousands of nodes.
- 48:35Yeah.
- 48:35I know,
- 48:36you know,
- 48:36I have a good vantage point.
- 48:37Yeah.
- 48:38You see it coming in and,
- 48:39and these are real people.
- 48:40These are real clients.
- 48:41We're working with them, we're training them, helping them configure their node.
- 48:45And to me, that's the signal is that there really is something happening here and not just a bunch of bots or something like that.
- 48:53Correct. No, this is real discontent from real people who really care about Bitcoin.
- 49:00And it's a shame that it's gotten to where it is.
- 49:04I have had ongoing conversations privately with multiple people from what would be broadly classified as the core camp for over a year now.
- 49:18Not like daily or anything like that, but there are back channels.
- 49:21And I have tried to leverage whatever clout and communicative abilities I have to help try to avoid what's coming in August.
- 49:38But unfortunately, at this point, I think that it is an irreconcilable difference of opinion about what Bitcoin is and what it should be.
- 49:47and that I no longer have any hope that a fork will be avoided
- 49:56or will be non-contentious.
- 49:59At this point, we are heading towards a contentious soft fork,
- 50:04and like any war, entering it is a dark corner.
- 50:09You don't know what's going to happen.
- 50:10And oftentimes the ones going in yawning and bragging and with total arrogance are the ones surprised when their enemy punches them in the nose.
- 50:22And when you start bleeding, you change your mind real quick.
- 50:25So obviously you don't know with certainty what's going to happen.
- 50:32If you were to pull out your crystal ball, what do you think you'd see here in August?
- 50:37And maybe explain what's been proposed, what we're talking about, the activation of BIP-110, and then how you think this plays out.
- 50:47Well, it is a fascinating experiment at the very least. Historically, this is a really interesting
- 50:58moment for Bitcoin. Regardless of how it goes, many lessons will be learned and it will be
- 51:06studied in retrospect to see how and why it went down the way that it did.
- 51:12so stay tuned
- 51:14it's going to be a really interesting couple of months
- 51:16here's kind of the
- 51:18the factors at play
- 51:21because it's not simple
- 51:22this is complex stuff
- 51:24so an attempt to oversimplify it is a mistake
- 51:27which is what a lot of people are doing
- 51:28I'm not going to do that
- 51:30and I'm also not going to pull out a crystal ball
- 51:32so to speak
- 51:33I'm going to kind of give you a little bit of the players
- 51:35and the lay of the land
- 51:36and then we'll see what happens
- 51:38because I don't know
- 51:40but BIP 110 is a restricting of the consensus rules, right? It's a tightening of the consensus
- 51:48rules. What that means is, is that things that used to be allowed are no longer allowed,
- 51:56all right It is not adding new features It not like hey that thing used to be illegal Now we making it legal That is a hard fork When you take something that used to be illegal and you make it legal it a hard fork
- 52:12And you can think of a hard fork as a cessation from the union.
- 52:18It is basically one state or one province of a larger state saying, we no longer want
- 52:24to be a part of this.
- 52:25We're leaving.
- 52:26We're forming our own nation.
- 52:28and issuing our own currency by default. And that is why it is an airdrop. So hard forks are
- 52:37inherently the creation of a new token, a new set of rules, and that's it. So this would be like
- 52:46Bitcoin Cash. It was a hard fork. And it doesn't need to result in two chains. So for example,
- 52:53if everyone goes along with it. So let's say Texas was just like, we're out. We don't want
- 53:00to be in the United States anymore. And then every other state, every other state in the union was
- 53:06like, we're going with you. It would basically just be Texas moving the United States to Texas,
- 53:12right? So it would be the same set of states, the same set of people with a new name and a new law.
- 53:19So if everyone goes along with the hard fork, then you end up with a single chain and a single currency. The chances of that happening are basically zero. I can't even imagine a scenario where that could happen. I think it happened once in Bitcoin's history.
- 53:37and it was when it was very, very, very small
- 53:40and it was like an emergency
- 53:42because it was a runaway inflation bug
- 53:45and so they were hard forked to a new network basically
- 53:50and everyone on the old network came over
- 53:52because nobody wanted to be on that network.
- 53:53So the only way a hard fork I think could work
- 53:55in modern Bitcoin is if there was a similar type
- 53:59of existential imminent threat
- 54:01that everyone and everyone agreed with
- 54:03and I just don't, that's not really possible.
- 54:05I don't see that.
- 54:06maybe the edge of science fiction possibility quantum, maybe, but probably not.
- 54:15So anyway, that is not what BIP-110 is. BIP-110 is not a cessation from the Union. BIP-110 is a
- 54:20tightening of the consensus rules. It is a group of people saying things that used to be allowed
- 54:27are no longer allowed. We are going to prevent, prohibit those things going forward.
- 54:35And the analogy here is a coup. The more proper analogy for a soft fork is a coup. It's not Texas leaving and saying we're forming our own nation. It's Texas invading Washington and trying to sit their own governor in the White House in order to change the laws of the land to be more tight, to be less permissive.
- 55:05That is a soft fork. And in a soft fork scenario, as in a coup attempt, you don't end up with two countries. What happens if you try to overthrow the government and it fails?
- 55:20you don't get eradicated yeah you don't get to go form your own country right you might be able
- 55:26to secede had that been your intent from the get-go but you don't get to like attempt to
- 55:31to take over the network and and fail and live to see the next day you're done for
- 55:38and so that's what's that's what uh is at stake here so temporarily you could end up with like
- 55:45two states, so to speak, two chains, right? So if, when BIP-110 activates,
- 55:53as soon as a block is found that has illegal transactions in it, right? These new non-compliant
- 56:02transactions, nodes and miners on the network that are part of the legacy group will accept that block.
- 56:12nodes and miners that are part of the BIP-110 chain will reject that block.
- 56:20So I shouldn't have said chain.
- 56:21There's not two chains yet.
- 56:22It's all one chain.
- 56:23Until somebody mines a block that has a newly invalid transaction, there's one chain.
- 56:32Everyone is still happy.
- 56:33It's like even once BIP-110 activates, it's all still one country.
- 56:36There's just been a declaration of coup.
- 56:39There's been a declaration of war.
- 56:40There's been no split yet.
- 56:42But as soon as a non-compliant block hits the network, the chain will split.
- 56:51And you will now have a BIP-110 chain and a core chain.
- 56:56And then it's off to the races.
- 56:59Now it's an arms race.
- 57:00Okay, it's a hashing race.
- 57:02And there will be some luck involved here as well, which adds a whole other element to history here, right?
- 57:07Like you can actually luck might play a part in Bitcoin's future.
- 57:12a small part but still And so the 2 Chainz are now going to race to the future to um accumulate the most proof of work Okay
- 57:24And whichever chain succeeds in accumulating the most proof of work in the
- 57:28ensuing, I don't know. And the number of blocks.
- 57:32We don't know yet. We don't know yet. Right. Like there's not a lot of precedent
- 57:37here, but not very long, like possibly single digit blocks.
- 57:42I mean, it could be less than 10 blocks.
- 57:45Like this could be very fast or it could drag out.
- 57:47It kind of depends, right?
- 57:49It depends on how deep people are willing to dig in, how much risk they're willing to take.
- 57:55But it's off to the races.
- 57:57And if after a few blocks, it's very clear which one is running away, right?
- 58:01Like, oh my God, all the hash is over there.
- 58:03All the hash is over there.
- 58:04The other side is done for.
- 58:07They're done.
- 58:08It's over, right?
- 58:10There's no coming back.
- 58:11you cannot catch up to a runaway chain. I like the analogy there. It's a runaway chain.
- 58:17You're not going to catch it. It's okay if it gets a little bit ahead, even a few blocks.
- 58:24But if it gets really far ahead and there's no indication that it's going to slow down,
- 58:29the other side has to capitulate. You're now on a shitcoin. You're not going to keep going.
- 58:38Nobody wants to be the shitcoin here.
- 58:40This isn't Bitcoin Cash.
- 58:41Bitcoin Cash wanted to be a shitcoin.
- 58:44It's like their stated intent.
- 58:46They're like, we don't want to be Bitcoin.
- 58:48That thing is not Bitcoin.
- 58:50We're going to start this thing over here.
- 58:53Nobody wants that here.
- 58:56The core side, the not side, the Bitcoin side,
- 58:58I don't even know what the camps are called anymore,
- 59:00but everyone wants to be Bitcoin.
- 59:02And so whatever Bitcoin is going to be,
- 59:04which is defined by the most proof of work,
- 59:06the chain with the most proof of work is Bitcoin.
- 59:07that's what everyone is going to converge on. However, everyone has dug in so deep on this,
- 59:14like socially, reputationally, there's so much all in here. Everyone has, not everyone,
- 59:22a lot of people have really staked everything on this, their reputation, that they're not going to
- 59:32be able. I mean, they might. And if there's mercy on the other side or a degree of tolerance or
- 59:37acceptance, maybe. But I don't see a real reconciliation here. Somebody's getting wiped
- 59:44out. Come activation time for Bit.10, we're either going to lose. Again, not every person
- 59:52and not lose is in their dead. Bitcoin's going to lose a limb here. You understand?
- 59:59We have now reached the point of war. You don't get out of that without consequences.
- 1:00:04Bitcoin is losing a limb, period. The question is which limb? Are we going to lose the core
- 1:00:12constituency, right? The maintainers, a lot of the contributors, both in code and finance,
- 1:00:22right? People who are contributing money to Bitcoin development, core development,
- 1:00:27contributing time, energy, and code to Bitcoin core development, maintaining that code,
- 1:00:33as the five maintainers currently do.
- 1:00:38And they're, we'll call it like influencer ecosystem, right?
- 1:00:45So some of the more prominent influencers like Adam Back,
- 1:00:48who have been very, very aggressive on this side
- 1:00:52or trolls like Shinobi and stuff like that.
- 1:00:55And I hope, sorry, he's a troll.
- 1:00:57I don't care which side of the fucking debate you're on.
- 1:00:59That guy is a douchebag coward.
- 1:01:01So anyway, but anyway, so, so that's either, either we're going to lose them because they've gone all in on this, right?
- 1:01:09They are not living in a knots world.
- 1:01:11I'll tell you that right now.
- 1:01:12If BIP 110 succeeds, they're rage quitting.
- 1:01:14They have to.
- 1:01:16They don't rage quit.
- 1:01:17Then, oh my God.
- 1:01:18Like, then everything they said, you know, I just don't see it.
- 1:01:20I don't see how they stick around.
- 1:01:22Save face.
- 1:01:23Nobody can save face here.
- 1:01:24So that's one camp.
- 1:01:25or we're going to lose the BIP110.
- 1:01:32Luke, mechanic, yeah.
- 1:01:34I would call that actually the equivalent
- 1:01:38of like the Adam Back and Shinobi.
- 1:01:40It's the, neither one is a troll by the way,
- 1:01:42but the influencer camp around it.
- 1:01:46What is the actual core of the BIP110 side, right?
- 1:01:48So on the core side, who actually represents that?
- 1:01:52Who we're losing?
- 1:01:53Who's getting carved off of Bitcoin
- 1:01:55is like the contributors, the developers, the maintainers, the financiers, the people who have
- 1:02:01funded and contributed to Bitcoin Core, the code base and project. That's who we're losing.
- 1:02:10Then there's the surrounding influencer class, the podcasters and the celebrities and the
- 1:02:16trolls that are all around that group. Yes, it's all one camp. I'm just saying there's two
- 1:02:23categories, right?
- 1:02:24Yeah.
- 1:02:25Then on the not side, you have the same thing.
- 1:02:28But who is the core of that?
- 1:02:29What is the analogy on that side of like the developers, the financiers, the contributors on the core side?
- 1:02:35What's that analogy on the not side?
- 1:02:37Can you guess?
- 1:02:38No.
- 1:02:39It's the plebs.
- 1:02:42It's the people.
- 1:02:44Who now are faced with the question of, is Bitcoin still what I intended for it to be?
- 1:02:51Is this what I opted into?
- 1:02:52You have thousands.
- 1:02:55Okay, there aren't that many nodes in the world.
- 1:02:57It's like 20,000 reachable nodes.
- 1:02:59A ton of those are people who genuinely believe that should we continue down the track that Core has led us, Bitcoin is doomed in the long run.
- 1:03:17not imminently, but that it sets us on a track to be usurped by the legacy system and, you know, perverted and usurped and overtaken.
- 1:03:33All right. Co-opted is the word I was looking for there.
- 1:03:37Yeah.
- 1:03:37And so what are they going to do? What are they going to do if BIP-110 fails?
- 1:03:42I could point to a couple thousand immediately and be like,
- 1:03:45they turn off their node.
- 1:03:47I'm not saying they sell their Bitcoin.
- 1:03:48Maybe they do.
- 1:03:49Maybe some do.
- 1:03:51I wouldn't advise it.
- 1:03:53But they turn off their node.
- 1:03:55They lose interest.
- 1:03:57Right?
- 1:03:57So we might not lose these people in the true sense of like they vanish from Bitcoin,
- 1:04:03but the energy drops to zero.
- 1:04:07Okay?
- 1:04:07The BIP-110, the essence of the BIP-110 side, the essence and beating heart of it is extreme ideological cypherpunk passion.
- 1:04:26It's like gritty-ass political activism.
- 1:04:29It is basically the people, again, not carrying all the economic weight, not politically influential in meat space. It's just the people in a sense that Bitcoin was made for. It's the people who want to save in Bitcoin and use Bitcoin and abandon the fiat system and who are libertarian politically or anarchist even and are cypherpunk and basically just who perfectly align with the essence of the world.
- 1:04:59and ethos of Bitcoin, as it has always been, are going to be completely disenfranchised
- 1:05:05and deflated if this movement fails. Along with them comes their representatives,
- 1:05:17the influencer class. So Luke, Mechanic, and others. They sort of all go down together.
- 1:05:25Now, I don't know what Chris Guida and Mechanic and Luke are going to do if BIP110 fails.
- 1:05:36Well, yeah, that's what I was going to ask.
- 1:05:37Could you see a scenario where they say, okay, the most peaceful means by which we try to get back on track failed, we're going to hard fork and see if they can bring the plubs with them?
- 1:05:49Or do they just give up?
- 1:05:51No, there's zero chance of maintaining an alternate coin in network.
- 1:05:58Yeah.
- 1:05:59Not a single person that I have ever talked to, big or small, powerful or powerless on the BIP-110 side of this,
- 1:06:09have any desire whatsoever to fork off the network.
- 1:06:13Yeah.
- 1:06:13This is a coup attempt.
- 1:06:16It almost sounds like a negative word when you say coup, right?
- 1:06:19is an attempt to take control of a network that they believe has taken a very wrong turn
- 1:06:30in order to turn it back. That's what this is. And if they fail in doing that,
- 1:06:37every person now has to decide for themselves what it means to them. Are they rage quitting?
- 1:06:43Are they holding Bitcoin and hoping it goes up even though they no longer believe that it can
- 1:06:49deliver on its promise for open, global, decentralized money,
- 1:06:58I don't know what they're going to do. I think everyone has to decide for themselves.
- 1:07:03Some might say, I was wrong. This is fine. I just didn't see it before. Others might be like,
- 1:07:10well, this sucks, but there's nothing better. I'll just go along with it anyway.
- 1:07:14Others might be like, screw this. I'm selling. I'm out. I'm burning the house. I don't know.
- 1:07:18Everyone has to decide for themselves.
- 1:07:22But somebody's getting disenfranchised here.
- 1:07:25It's so unfortunate.
- 1:07:26It's so unfortunate.
- 1:07:27I really, really didn't want this to happen.
- 1:07:28And I saw it coming from a very early stage.
- 1:07:32And I was talking to all the right people.
- 1:07:35And I not again I not special I just was in a position to try because I knew some people and I feel like I kind of have an understanding of both sides and I was trying to really align interests and I thought that we had the proposal
- 1:07:54So Aiden at Start9, our CTO, and I came up with a proposal that we, to this moment, believe is the solution.
- 1:08:03Everyone wants this.
- 1:08:04We have the ultimate compromise.
- 1:08:06It's not even a compromise because in a compromise, the perception is that you didn't get, you
- 1:08:11had to give something up to get something, right?
- 1:08:13That's kind of how people think about a compromise.
- 1:08:15This isn't a compromise.
- 1:08:16It's literally everything that you want, you get both sides.
- 1:08:20Everything that the core side has stated that they want, they get with our proposal.
- 1:08:25Everything that not side has stated that they want, they get with our proposal.
- 1:08:29It was literally spit on by the core side.
- 1:08:32when we presented it.
- 1:08:34Why?
- 1:08:34You familiar with the term
- 1:08:36distributed totalitarianism?
- 1:08:39I'm not.
- 1:08:41Sorry, distributed authoritarianism.
- 1:08:43Distributed authoritarian.
- 1:08:46It's made the rounds on X.
- 1:08:48There are literally people
- 1:08:49with it in their bios
- 1:08:51where it's like,
- 1:08:52I'm a distributed authoritarian.
- 1:08:54Just think about those two words
- 1:08:55for a second.
- 1:08:56It makes no sense together, right?
- 1:08:57Right.
- 1:08:59This is what our proposal was called.
- 1:09:01When Aiden submitted our proposal to the Bitcoin mailing list, Greg Maxwell, in a matter of minutes, responded with a historic rant.
- 1:09:15I encourage people to go look this up, that was so emotional, violent against the proposal
- 1:09:23that he had the audacity to, in that response, cite our proposal as an example of distributed
- 1:09:32authoritarianism that needs to be avoided. What he meant by that was that when all the people get
- 1:09:39together and decide that they want something, that thing happens. He called that distributed
- 1:09:43authoritarianism. Not freedom, not sovereignty. Not people agreeing. Not the right to choose.
- 1:09:48Yeah, correct. And so what we should do instead was listen to him. It was the most insanely
- 1:09:56authoritarian response to an insanely freedom-loving democratic process.
- 1:10:06Democracy has problems, don't get me wrong. Our proposal was not majority rule. Our proposal was
- 1:10:12overwhelming super majority rule. It was like, hey, in this proposal, if and only if everyone
- 1:10:20and their mom agrees on something, it happens. And he was like, oh, no, you don't. I'll tell you
- 1:10:26what we're going to do. You distributed authoritarian. And this made the rounds.
- 1:10:29It was really funny for a few days because it just made no sense. I got multiple private messages
- 1:10:35from core contributors, from people on the core side apologizing for his response.
- 1:10:42because it was so outrageous.
- 1:10:44Everyone was just like, what happened to Greg?
- 1:10:47Greg's a legend.
- 1:10:48Can't even imagine what happened.
- 1:10:52It makes no sense.
- 1:10:53But anyway, we had the proposal.
- 1:10:55So, okay, we're already past an hour,
- 1:10:59so I want to be respectful of your time
- 1:11:01and also the ability for everyone
- 1:11:04to zero in on some of these concepts.
- 1:11:06I guess maybe my last question for you is,
- 1:11:08I think you and I are generally in alignment
- 1:11:11on a lot of this stuff.
- 1:11:12Um, there's been a lot of talk about core being captured. Okay. And that could mean probably a number of things they bought and paid for. Are they, they philosophically, uh, I don't know, drifted. What's, um, like, what's your take on why? Hang on. Let me just step back for one second.
- 1:11:32The whole opera turn thing for me, what just made no sense wasn't like I actually went and read like the mailing list.
- 1:11:40And I think that there is probably technical merit on both sides.
- 1:11:46I think one side is stronger.
- 1:11:48I think that there are smart people who can make a case for either side.
- 1:11:51What I thought was completely unforgivable was the way in which the change was, in my view, just rammed through.
- 1:12:00It was, it obviously, I mean, you showed, you talked about the numbers that you showed for a number of new nodes.
- 1:12:05People are running knots.
- 1:12:06It's not just a civil attack.
- 1:12:08And they just put, they were dismissive.
- 1:12:10They pushed it through anyway.
- 1:12:12That was my biggest complaint.
- 1:12:15Was it just pushed through because of Citria or because of funding or because of some sort of political capture?
- 1:12:23What's your view on why this played out the way it did when it went to your point?
- 1:12:27It didn't seem to have to.
- 1:12:28So unfortunately I have not read the three series of investigative journalism that Hodlnott recently published It is at the top of my list I very very busy these days And I had AI throw together a quick summary just so I could sort of prime myself for it But I do intend to read the entire thing I seen enough both from the summary that I consumed as well as the chatter around it that I convinced it worth reading I convinced that he is a genuinely
- 1:13:05good actor who is performing one of the greatest feats of modern investigative journalism that
- 1:13:12we've actually seen, right? Most journalism is just opinion wrapped up in fake, you know,
- 1:13:19error or half-assed investigations. I think that he did the proof of work.
- 1:13:24And I cannot vouch for the accuracy of anything because I haven't read it or validated it myself.
- 1:13:31But I do intend to get deeper into the specifics of what happened in and around the Bitcoin core,
- 1:13:41Again, broadly speaking, it's sort of a loose organization and affiliation.
- 1:13:46But what happened in and around Bitcoin Core over the past five to 10 years, probably not
- 1:13:5210, but going back five to eight years.
- 1:13:54So I'll have a stronger opinion once I have done my own research.
- 1:14:00I, without reading those, already have done some.
- 1:14:04So I can comment to a degree on some of it.
- 1:14:06I know because they say it very bluntly and very openly that there is an intent on the core side to expand the use cases of Bitcoin to essentially anything.
- 1:14:28The goal is arbitrary use case, ultimately.
- 1:14:32Within the broader constraint of censorship resistance, privacy, to the extent that it can even be done in Bitcoin, but definitely censorship resistance and permissionless.
- 1:14:51I think that there is a genuine attempt by many people on the core side to create a censorship-resistant, open, borderless, permissionless something.
- 1:15:06And the something is, ideally for them, anything.
- 1:15:11They want to create an open, borderless, permissionless, whatever, computing machine.
- 1:15:19Yeah.
- 1:15:19Data, data machine, a computer, a global computer, right?
- 1:15:23This is basically how Ethereum advertised itself.
- 1:15:26Literally the advertisement on the website, right?
- 1:15:28Was the, like, the global computer to be used for anything and everything.
- 1:15:32Because, right, it's all just information, right?
- 1:15:36This is their stance.
- 1:15:37It's just information, guys.
- 1:15:39And what we need is a permissionless, censorship-resistant way to share information around the world.
- 1:15:45And this is their explicit stated intent for Bitcoin. And why that intent existed is unclear to me. It is unclear whether there was leadership in core that genuinely wants this and believes this and managed to sort of convince everyone else in conversations like any team has.
- 1:16:11whether this was financiers, right?
- 1:16:14The people who were paying them sort of pushing this
- 1:16:17and also seeking people.
- 1:16:19So people like Gloria Zhao, right?
- 1:16:22Who very explicitly is sort of an Ethereum head, right?
- 1:16:27Like from the crypto, DeFi kind of vein of all of this
- 1:16:33and very much wanted to see Bitcoin go in that direction.
- 1:16:38again, I'm not putting words in her mouth. This is her stated intent. Very much, they want
- 1:16:45DeFi and smart contracts and arbitrary data and all the rest. It's like Bitcoin needs to compete
- 1:16:52with Solana and Ethereum. These things are doing so much more than Bitcoin does. And Bitcoin needs
- 1:16:58to catch up and do it too. We need to be more like them. We need to be more like Ethereum,
- 1:17:03guys. That is it. That's the culture. That's what they want. That's what they've said.
- 1:17:10Now, they want it to be proof of work and bigger and more robust than Ethereum. They would argue
- 1:17:15that a lot of the reason that Ethereum and other networks haven't made it is because they didn't
- 1:17:19have the adoption. They didn't have the network effect. They didn't have the hash power to protect
- 1:17:24the networks. They didn't have the culture of strict code review and et cetera. They shipped.
- 1:17:30They were highly centralized. But from a technology standpoint, they actually admire these projects for what they've achieved in their zero-knowledge proofs and roll-ups and smart contracts and DeFi technologies.
- 1:17:42reason. However, however, and I'll say this as a side note, to date, none of that has actually
- 1:17:50been demanded by the market, right? So like, these projects from a Rube Goldberg machine
- 1:17:55standpoint are very impressive. But there's other than other than doing things, they don't
- 1:18:02really provide value Well they enable NFTs they enable JPEGs right They enable speculative markets I would argue is the one and only demonstrated use case of public blockchains and cryptocurrency
- 1:18:22cryptocurrency networks is speculative Ponzi-like endeavors where people sort of create assets,
- 1:18:35hype them, dump them, and move on. That is what it enables. I'm not saying there isn't something
- 1:18:41there in the future. I'm not saying that there couldn't be truly decentralized financial solutions
- 1:18:47such that people all over the world can have access to credit and futures and savings and
- 1:18:53interest bearing accounts that are based on Bitcoin. I'm not saying all that's not possible.
- 1:18:57Just saying that at present, that these things have never been successfully used for those
- 1:19:03purposes on any meaningful scale. The only thing that they have been used for is to perpetuate
- 1:19:08scams. And that I would argue that entire future world of truly decentralized, open,
- 1:19:14borderless finance that everyone should want is only possible if it's on the basis of a truly open,
- 1:19:21decentralized, permissionless monetary base that is truly and wholly outside the constraints of
- 1:19:27banks and governments all over the world. Cart before the horse. You have to get the money right
- 1:19:33first before you can build anything on top of it. But we're so excited about the things that
- 1:19:40might come next. Some of us, not me, right? Like I'm mostly focused on the money. I'm saying some
- 1:19:45people are so excited by the use cases, the use cases, more use cases that they can't wait to
- 1:19:50build them. And so they're building them now before they're needed, before there's any market demand
- 1:19:54for them. And ultimately, whether they intended to do it or not, ultimately end up being a scam,
- 1:20:01right? Whether that was their initial intent or not, that's where they all end. So anyway,
- 1:20:06that is an explicit intent, okay, on that side of the argument. They want to turn Bitcoin into
- 1:20:15Ethereum, BitTheorem, okay? And I don't want that, right? So at this point, it's probably clear
- 1:20:22which side of this that I'm on. I'm just always very careful because what is even more important
- 1:20:29to me than my personal opinion about Bitcoin, which is something I care about very deeply and
- 1:20:35want to see succeed for the sake of my family and my grandchildren for the whole world is open
- 1:20:43and free information, right? So on a more meta level, I actually completely agree with the core
- 1:20:52side about what I want for the world in terms of do anything with a computer that you want,
- 1:20:59right? I just don't think that that computer is Bitcoin. I think that that computer is a computer.
- 1:21:04I think it's a server.
- 1:21:05It's you run a server, I run a server,
- 1:21:07and we can share information all day long, right?
- 1:21:10And it's censorship resistant
- 1:21:11because there's no middlemen, no custodians.
- 1:21:13So it's like to achieve a global censorship resistant,
- 1:21:18redundant, available network for arbitrary data,
- 1:21:23it's called the internet.
- 1:21:25And we have that.
- 1:21:27We have a global computer and network
- 1:21:31for sharing information in an open world.
- 1:21:34And you can have your own node in that network.
- 1:21:35You can buy a start nine and you can have your own node.
- 1:21:38We have the thing that so many people are claiming we need and trying to build as an app on the thing they're claiming they need.
- 1:21:51It's like me saying, okay, we have an oven that cooks food.
- 1:22:00so I'm going to try to make food that cooks food.
- 1:22:06It's like, what are you talking about?
- 1:22:08The oven cooks food.
- 1:22:10What food do you want to cook?
- 1:22:11They each have an identity, right?
- 1:22:14You can cook a pizza or you can cook steak.
- 1:22:16But if you try to cook an oven, that's Ethereum.
- 1:22:20It's like, what are you doing?
- 1:22:21You're trying to build the internet on the internet.
- 1:22:24Stop it.
- 1:22:26It's just an app.
- 1:22:28It's an app.
- 1:22:30Bitcoin is an app. It is not the internet. It doesn't need to do arbitrary data. The internet
- 1:22:38does that. We just need to decentralize the internet by proliferating servers. That's it.
- 1:22:44That's all the internet needs to be decentralized is more servers, more people self-hosting.
- 1:22:49Bitcoin is an app. What is that app? It's money.
- 1:22:54It's the decentralized money.
- 1:22:55Yes. It's open, borderless, permissionless money. Stop trying to make it do more.
- 1:23:01It's just a grift. It's just a grift.
- 1:23:04Yeah. I think that's a good place to wrap, except I have one final question. I always ask,
- 1:23:09what is an unpopular opinion you hold bonus points if you offend some Bitcoiners with it?
- 1:23:14You've shared a few, but if you've got anything else. Um, I'm a huge advocate for
- 1:23:19arranged marriages. Ah, interesting. That's the first of its kind. Okay. Well, you want to maybe
- 1:23:26explain briefly why? To be clear, I'm not against forced marriages, just arranged, right? Meaning
- 1:23:34the kids don't have to do it. Like you're not going to be like, you will marry that person or
- 1:23:40some consequence ensues. I'm just for the practice of arranging marriages for young people.
- 1:23:50I think that they are not suited to do it for themselves. I think that knowing what is going
- 1:23:56to be best for you in your long run, you need to be a part of it for sure, a part of the conversation
- 1:24:01as arranged marriages have always been. But I think that we lose a lot in society by adults
- 1:24:07not taking the initiative to matchmake and arrange partnerships for their children and loved ones.
- 1:24:13Okay. Well, as a guy who is eagerly awaiting my third daughter, I think I can sympathize with this
- 1:24:22opinion more than probably I could have years ago.
- 1:24:24Well unfortunately I already have three daughters because otherwise you and I might have had something to talk about here if they were three boys but yeah i got one i got one i got one boy
- 1:24:35for you so okay good he's gonna be a uh a sovereign individual so maybe we can chat we'll talk yeah
- 1:24:43i got three really great girls awesome i've got i've got two two girls and a boy now and any day
- 1:24:49now we're expecting the uh the fourth so yeah well hey it's always fun talking with you matt you bring
- 1:24:54a wealth of knowledge. Really appreciate your time. Tell people where they can find Start9,
- 1:24:58anything else you want to share with them. Well, we're not hard to find. Start9.com.
- 1:25:02It's a really crappy website that we haven't updated in like four years, but we've been busy
- 1:25:06and we're getting to it. StartOS 040 is here. It's beautiful. It's amazing. It's better than
- 1:25:12we thought it was going to be. It's better than you thought it was going to be. Technically,
- 1:25:16it's in late stage beta right now, but it is absolutely production ready. We're using it for
- 1:25:20all our production servers. Many, many people around the world are using it for their production
- 1:25:24So if you haven't updated 0351 yet, go and get it done.
- 1:25:27All servers that we sell now are coming with 040 pre-installed by default.
- 1:25:31We don't even offer 0351 anymore.
- 1:25:33Consider it a deprecated abandoned operating system We not doing updates for it anymore Get on 040 It is night and day better Start Tunnel is an amazing cloud product that you can throw up on a VPS to
- 1:25:46have a virtual private router, right? It's instead of your home router, you have a router in the cloud
- 1:25:51that you can then use to create virtual networks and do clearnet hosting without exposing your home
- 1:25:56IP address. And StartWRT is our router operating system that is now complete and will be selling
- 1:26:03routers. These are home routers, physical devices that will go in your home. StartWRT is, in my
- 1:26:10opinion, my humble opinion, the best router operating system the world has ever seen.
- 1:26:15It is fully open source and the router that we are selling it on, the physical hardware,
- 1:26:19is also open source based on a RISC-V architecture, maximally open source that a hardware product can
- 1:26:25possibly be in the world. So a fully open source router from hardware to software, maximally
- 1:26:30powerful yet insanely easy to use. I think we have the best router in the world. We are currently
- 1:26:35pre-selling it on router.start9.com. Fantastic. You guys always make the best. So really appreciate
- 1:26:42it Matt grateful for your time as always Always a fun conversation with you We catch up again soon Yeah it was fun Thanks man Cheers man And that a wrap again Hope you enjoyed my conversation with Matt
- 1:26:54I know I did. I always learn a lot when I talk to him. He can go deep on so many technical topics,
- 1:26:58but just a smart guy. Great guy to chat with. Go check out Start9. We are huge fans of all that
- 1:27:04they do. And of course, if you need help taking your Bitcoin into proper 100% self-custody and
- 1:27:09running your own node, signaling whatever it is that you want to signal, go to thebitcoinway.com
- 1:27:14slash podcast. You can schedule a free 30 minute introductory call with our team. We can also help
- 1:27:19you with online cybersecurity and privacy, setting up a privacy phone. We've got a plan B residency
- 1:27:23program in Panama. Many people need to consider that today. You've got to have your plan B in
- 1:27:28place. And again, that's thebitcoinway.com slash contact and follow us on X. Do me a huge favor,
- 1:27:34go over there at the Bitcoinway underscore. I'm also there as well at the other M Jordan.
- 1:27:39Make sure you like this episode if you enjoyed it. Make sure you're subscribed to our channel as
- 1:27:43well. Really appreciate anything to help feed the algorithm. And until next time, stay safe,
- 1:27:47stay sovereign, and remember the yield on Bitcoin is freedom.