Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Chairman Todd Harper's Recent Testimony: House Financial Services Committee
Transcript
- 0:35Ethan: I continue to experiment with Artificial
- 0:37Intellegence as we wrap up 2023.
- 0:39This is With Flying Colors and this is NOT Mark Treichel.
- 0:42Rather is is an artificial intellegence voice I have chosen
- 0:45for this episode -known as Ethan.
- 0:47This podcast is essentially an audio book like version of a recent
- 0:50speech by NCUA Chairman Todd Harper.
- 0:53The Chairman leads NCUA.
- 0:54While they only have one of 3 votes their power is vastly more
- 0:57than the other board members.
- 0:59The Chairman sets the agenda.
- 1:00The Chairman - as outlined in the Federal Credit Union Act is the
- 1:03official spokesperson of the NCUA.
- 1:06With a new democratic board member coming on board soon, the Chairman's
- 1:09power will go up This is why this recent speech is worthy of covering
- 1:12as a stand alone podcast - as it tells you what Chairman Harper wants to
- 1:16do - which can have a major impact on credit unions, CUSOs, other entities,
- 1:21members, and of course NCUA staff.
- 1:23NCUA Chairman Todd M.
- 1:24Harper's Written Testimony Before the House Financial Services Committee
- 1:28Chairman McHenry, Ranking Member Waters, and members of the committee,
- 1:32thank you for inviting me to discuss the work of the National
- 1:35Credit Union Administration (NCUA).
- 1:36The NCUA insures deposits at federally insured credit unions, protects
- 1:41credit union members, and charters and regulates federal credit unions.
- 1:45The NCUA also protects the safety and soundness of the credit union system by
- 1:49identifying, monitoring, and managing risks to the National Credit Union Share
- 1:53Insurance Fund (Share Insurance Fund).
- 1:54In my testimony today, I will discuss the state of the credit union system, recent
- 1:59efforts by the agency to strengthen the system, and several legislative requests.
- 2:03State of the Credit Union System
- 2:05The credit union system over the last year has remained largely stable
- 2:08in its performance and relatively resilient against economic disruptions.
- 2:12However, during the last few quarters, the NCUA has seen growing signs of
- 2:16financial strain on credit union balance sheets and in household budgets.
- 2:20Economists are also forecasting an economic slowdown as the lagged effects
- 2:24of elevated interest rates take hold.
- 2:26Each of these developments could affect credit union performance
- 2:29in the coming quarters.
- 2:31Over the same period, the NCUA has also seen growing stress within
- 2:35the system because of a rise in interest rate and liquidity risks.
- 2:38In fact, this financial stress is reflected in the increasing number of
- 2:42composite CAMELS code 3, 4, and 5 credit unions.1 Assets in composite CAMELS
- 2:47code 3 institutions increased sizably in the second quarter, especially
- 2:51among those complex credit unions with more than $500 million in assets.
- 2:55Such increases may well continue in future quarters.
- 2:58We have additionally seen more credit unions fall into the composite CAMELS code
- 3:024 and 5 ratings during the second quarter.
- 3:05Credit Union System Performance
- 3:07As of June 30, 2023, the system’s net worth ratio stood at 10.63 percent.
- 3:12There was continued year-over-year growth in assets and lending, with system assets
- 3:17surpassing $2.2 trillion and outstanding loans at more than $1.5 trillion.
- 3:22Although insured shares and deposits decreased slightly compared to the
- 3:25previous quarter, they stood almost 2 percent higher than one year earlier.
- 3:29Second quarter data also demonstrate some indications of
- 3:32growing consumer financial stress.
- 3:34The delinquency rate for loans rose slightly to 63 basis points, although
- 3:39it remains below historic averages.
- 3:41Credit cards and automobile loans, however, show increased delinquency levels
- 3:45at 154 and 67 basis points, respectively.
- 3:49Additionally, net charge-off levels have risen over the last year,
- 3:52returning to pre-pandemic averages.
- 3:54Additionally, funding costs for credit unions have increased significantly in
- 3:58the rising interest rate environment.
- 4:00Credit unions have increased their issuances of time deposits, leading
- 4:04to total interest expenses growing substantially over the year.
- 4:07However, the industry’s return on average assets remains sound at 79 basis points.
- 4:12Together, these numbers show the credit union system continues
- 4:15to rest on a solid footing.
- 4:17External Factors Affecting the System
- 4:19The NCUA is closely monitoring the financial markets and the economy as the
- 4:23current environment has created challenges for some consumers and credit unions.
- 4:27Inflation and interest rates are affecting household budgets,
- 4:31which could lead to an increase in credit risk in future quarters.
- 4:34In addition, the prevalence of hybrid work environments has placed pressure
- 4:37on commercial real estate lending.
- 4:39While the credit union system overall has modest exposure to this type of
- 4:43lending, the NCUA is closely monitoring individual credit unions with material
- 4:48exposure to commercial real estate.
- 4:49The rise in interest rates has also increased liquidity and interest
- 4:53rate risks in the credit union system, including at several of the
- 4:56421 federally insured credit unions with more than $1 billion in assets.
- 5:01Accordingly, the NCUA has emphasized the importance of liquidity risk
- 5:05management and contingency planning in its industry communications and
- 5:08will continue to ensure credit unions conduct liquidity and asset-liability
- 5:12management planning to address current challenges and future uncertainties.
- 5:16With respect to all these risks and to protect the Share Insurance Fund
- 5:19against potential losses, the NCUA will continue to vigilantly monitor
- 5:24credit union performance through the examination process, offsite
- 5:27monitoring, and tailored supervision.
- 5:29The NCUA will also, when appropriate, take action to protect credit
- 5:33union members and their deposits.
- 5:35Share Insurance Fund Performance
- 5:37Backed by the full faith and credit of the United States, the Share Insurance
- 5:40Fund provides insurance coverage for individual accounts at federally insured
- 5:44credit unions up to $250,000.2 As of June 30, 2023, the Share Insurance Fund insured
- 5:51$1.7 trillion in deposits and shares.
- 5:55Notably, the Share Insurance Fund protects nearly 92 percent of total share
- 5:59deposits in the credit union system.
- 6:01In comparison, uninsured shares and deposits equaled approximately $160
- 6:06billion in the second quarter or 8 percent of total share deposits.
- 6:10The Share Insurance Fund continues to perform well, with
- 6:12no premiums currently expected.
- 6:14As of June 30, 2023, the Share Insurance Fund reported a year-to-date net
- 6:19income of $79 million, a net position of $20.3 billion, and an equity ratio
- 6:25of 1.27 percent.3 The NCUA projects that the equity ratio of the Share
- 6:30Insurance Fund will end the year at 1.27 percent, which is sufficient but
- 6:34below the 1.33 percent normal operating level target set by the NCUA Board.
- 6:39Given the liquidity events in 2023, economic conditions, and the growing
- 6:43stress in the credit union system from liquidity and interest rate risks,
- 6:47the NCUA Board decided to build up the liquidity position of the Share Insurance
- 6:51Fund to a targeted amount of $4 billion.
- 6:53The Share Insurance Fund reached that target in September.
- 6:56The NCUA Board continues to monitor liquidity in the Share Insurance Fund.
- 7:00State of the Central Liquidity Facility
- 7:02The COVID-19 pandemic, inflationary pressures, interest rate volatility, and
- 7:07liquidity risk have all underscored the importance of the NCUA’s Central Liquidity
- 7:11Facility (CLF).4 The CLF is an important tool and acts as a shock absorber when
- 7:16unexpected liquidity events occur.
- 7:18Under the NCUA’s regulations, credit unions with assets more than $250
- 7:22million must have access to a federal emergency liquidity source as part
- 7:26of their contingency funding plans.
- 7:28This federal emergency liquidity backstop can be the CLF, the Federal
- 7:32Reserve’s Discount Window, or both.
- 7:34Credit unions with less than $250 million in assets are not required
- 7:39to have membership with a contingent federal liquidity source; however,
- 7:42they must identify external sources as part of their liquidity policy.5
- 7:47As of September 30, 2023, the CLF had 399 consumer credit union members, providing
- 7:53$19.8 billion in lending capacity.
- 7:56These credit unions range in asset size from less than $50
- 7:59million to more than $10 billion.
- 8:02Their access to the CLF helps protect approximately $360 billion
- 8:06in credit union members’ assets.
- 8:08The more members the CLF has, the more effective it is as a liquidity facility.
- 8:12As of December 2022, the CLF had a much greater total membership of 3,673
- 8:18consumer credit unions with a combined $537 billion in member assets and a
- 8:23lending capacity of $27.5 billion.
- 8:27This rapid decline in membership assets followed the expiration of the
- 8:30temporary statutory enhancements that:
- 8:32Increased the CLF’s maximum legal borrowing authority;
- 8:35Permitted access for corporate credit unions, as agent members,
- 8:39to borrow for their own needs;
- 8:40Provided greater flexibility and affordability to agent members to
- 8:44join the CLF to serve smaller groups of their covered institutions; and
- 8:48Gave the NCUA Board the clarity and flexibility about the loans it can
- 8:51approve by removing the phrase, “the Board shall not approve an application
- 8:55for credit the intent of which is to expand credit union portfolios.”
- 8:59Among other benefits, these statutory provisions facilitated agent
- 9:02membership of corporate credit unions.
- 9:05These enhancements, however, ended on January 1, 2023, resulting in 3,322
- 9:11credit unions with less than $250 million in assets losing access to the CLF.
- 9:16Consequently, the CLF’s borrowing capacity has decreased by almost $10 billion.
- 9:21To address this expiration and growing liquidity risks, the NCUA Board has
- 9:25unanimously requested that Congress allow corporate credit unions to purchase
- 9:29capital stock in the CLF to help smaller credit unions access to the facility.
- 9:34This change would make the CLF more affordable for corporate credit unions
- 9:37subscribing for a subset of their members.
- 9:40The Congressional Budget Office has scored the CLF reforms at no cost to taxpayers.6
- 9:45NCUA’s Efforts to Protect and Strengthen the Credit Union System
- 9:48In recent months, the NCUA has undertaken several actions to respond
- 9:52to cybersecurity risk; support minority depository institutions; enhance the
- 9:57credit union system’s and the NCUA’s diversity, equity, and inclusion
- 10:01efforts; and consider and adopt new rules to strengthen the system.
- 10:05Enhancing Cybersecurity
- 10:06Cybersecurity threats within the financial services industry are high and expected
- 10:11to remain so for the foreseeable future.
- 10:13To maintain vigilance against these threats, the NCUA is
- 10:16committed to ensuring consistency, transparency, and accountability
- 10:19in its cybersecurity examination program and related activities.
- 10:23Earlier this year, the NCUA deployed its updated, scalable, and
- 10:27risk-focused Information Security Examination (ISE) procedures.
- 10:31The ISE examination initiative offers flexibility for credit unions while
- 10:35providing examiners with standardized review steps to facilitate advanced
- 10:38data collection and analysis.
- 10:40Together with the agency’s voluntary Automated Cybersecurity Evaluation
- 10:44Toolbox maturity assessment, the new ISE procedures will assist
- 10:48the NCUA in protecting the credit union system from cyberattacks.
- 10:52In addition, the NCUA’s recently implemented cyber incident reporting
- 10:56rule has proven to be helpful to the agency and credit union industry.7 The
- 11:00final rule requires a federally insured credit union to report a substantial
- 11:04cyber incident to the NCUA as soon as possible but no later than 72 hours after
- 11:09the credit union reasonably believes a reportable cyber incident has occurred.
- 11:13In the first 30 days after the rule became effective, the NCUA received
- 11:17146 incident reports, more than it had received in total in the previous year.
- 11:22More than 60 percent of these incident reports involve third-party
- 11:25service providers and credit union service organizations (CUSOs).
- 11:29The NCUA also actively communicates with credit unions about the increased
- 11:33likelihood of cyberattacks resulting from geopolitical and other cyber events.
- 11:37Credit unions of all sizes are a part of the U.S.
- 11:40critical infrastructure and should implement appropriate
- 11:42controls in the technology they use to deliver member services.
- 11:46Maintaining Consumer Financial Protection
- 11:48An important part of the NCUA’s mission is to examine credit unions with less
- 11:52than $10 billion in assets for compliance with consumer financial protection laws.
- 11:57The agency’s consumer compliance efforts are integral to maintaining
- 12:00a safe-and-sound credit union system.
- 12:02In 2023, the agency’s consumer financial protection supervisory priorities have
- 12:07included overdraft protection, fair lending, residential real estate appraisal
- 12:12bias, and Truth in Lending Act and Fair Credit Reporting Act compliance.
- 12:16The NCUA also prioritized examining credit union compliance with the
- 12:20Flood Disaster Protection Act, including disclosure requirements.
- 12:24In addition, the agency increased its review of overdraft programs and
- 12:27non-sufficient funds fee practices at credit unions to assess whether providing
- 12:31those services and charging the fees are potentially unfair practices.
- 12:35The NCUA’s supervision of the services aims to create a more equitable system
- 12:39that supports financial stability for credit union members, improves
- 12:43transparency, and advances the statutory mission of credit unions to meet the
- 12:47credit and savings needs of their members, especially those of modest means.8
- 12:51Furthermore, the NCUA conducts targeted fair lending examinations and
- 12:55supervision at federal credit unions to assess compliance with federal
- 12:59fair lending laws and regulations.
- 13:01These reviews are critical to identifying discrimination and
- 13:04fostering financial inclusion.
- 13:06In August 2023, the NCUA encouraged the industry to review and comply with
- 13:10previously issued guidance addressing prohibited discriminatory practices
- 13:14in automated underwriting systems.
- 13:16Specifically, the agency encouraged credit unions to review system
- 13:20parameters to ensure compliance with the Equal Credit Opportunity Act
- 13:23and its implementing regulation.
- 13:25In addition to appraisal bias oversight examinations, the NCUA joined with the
- 13:30other Federal Financial Institution Examination Council agencies in
- 13:33June to issue proposed guidance for reconsideration of value for
- 13:36residential real estate valuations.
- 13:39The proposed guidance advises on policies that financial institutions may implement
- 13:43to allow consumers to provide information that may not have been considered during
- 13:47an appraisal or if deficiencies are identified in the original appraisal.
- 13:50As part of its consumer financial protection efforts, the NCUA’s Consumer
- 13:55Assistance Center also resolves consumer complaints against federal credit unions
- 13:59with total assets up to $10 billion and, in certain instances, federally
- 14:03insured, state-chartered credit unions.
- 14:06In 2022, the Consumer Assistance Center responded to 10,589 written
- 14:11complaints, 1,842 inquiries, and 30,232 telephone calls from consumers
- 14:18and credit unions concerning consumer financial protection regulations.
- 14:22Finally, the NCUA regularly presents webinars promoting financial
- 14:26literacy and financial inclusion.
- 14:29Over the past year, the agency has hosted webinars on appraisal
- 14:32bias, elder financial abuse, and minority depository institutions.
- 14:36In addition, the agency participates in national financial literacy initiatives,
- 14:41including the interagency Financial Literacy and Education Commission.
- 14:45Supporting Minority Depository Institutions
- 14:48Supporting minority depository institution (MDI) credit unions is a
- 14:51longstanding priority for the NCUA.
- 14:54MDI credit unions represent approximately 10 percent of federally
- 14:58insured credit unions, and there are presently 498 such credit unions.
- 15:02These MDIs have more than five million members and exceed $66 billion in assets.
- 15:07In 2015, the NCUA established its MDI Preservation Program and has
- 15:12since sought new ways to assist MDI credit unions, their members,
- 15:16and the communities they serve.
- 15:17In 2022, the NCUA launched the Small Credit Union and MDI Support
- 15:22Program, allocating resources to assist MDIs in addressing operational
- 15:26challenges such as staff training, examinations, and improving earnings.
- 15:30In 2023, the NCUA allocated 10,000 staff hours across its three
- 15:34regional offices for the program.
- 15:36This year, the agency also issued customized guidance to examiners to
- 15:40provide insights into MDIs’ unique business models and members’ needs.
- 15:44The guidance assists examiners in understanding MDIs’ distinct business
- 15:48model compared to other mainstream financial institutions by providing
- 15:52instruction on how to use MDI peer metrics instead of traditional peer metrics.
- 15:56Notably, while MDIs tend to be smaller institutions, they have relatively
- 16:00strong financial performance.
- 16:02As of the end of the second quarter of this year, MDIs averaged about $133
- 16:06million in total assets, yet their return on average assets and net worth
- 16:10ratios were higher than federally insured credit unions overall and equal to credit
- 16:14unions with assets exceeding $1 billion.
- 16:17Meanwhile, their charge-off levels were consistent with the levels
- 16:21reported for both larger credit unions and credit unions overall.
- 16:24Congress recently authorized all MDIs to be eligible for Community Development
- 16:29Revolving Loan Fund grants and loans.
- 16:31Previously, MDIs required the low-income credit union designation to qualify.
- 16:36In the 2023 grant round, 42 MDIs received more than $1.4 million
- 16:41in technical assistance grants.
- 16:43The amount of funding MDIs received was a five-fold increase from the
- 16:46level of funding provided in 2022.
- 16:49Finally, the NCUA in October hosted an MDI Symposium that discussed how the agency
- 16:54can better serve these institutions.
- 16:56The MDI Symposium brought together MDI credit unions and industry stakeholders to
- 17:00learn about the challenges faced by MDIs.
- 17:03Sessions included case studies of successful MDI business
- 17:06models for replication.
- 17:07The NCUA plans to leverage this information to further support
- 17:11its MDI Preservation Program.
- 17:13And, as part of the NCUA’s Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Summit for
- 17:17credit unions in early November, the NCUA held a session that discussed MDI
- 17:22challenges and strategies for success.
- 17:24Advancing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
- 17:27The NCUA is fully committed to fostering diversity, equity, and
- 17:31inclusion (DEI) within the agency and the credit union system.
- 17:34The agency uses data from the Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey,
- 17:37including the Office of Personnel Management’s Diversity, Equity,
- 17:41Inclusion, and Accessibility index, to inform its data-driven
- 17:45DEI strategies and activities.9 The agency’s internal practices to
- 17:48promote DEI are also wide-ranging.
- 17:50For example, the NCUA’s employee resource groups serve more than 30 percent of
- 17:55agency staff, surpassing the industry standard membership goal of 10 percent.
- 18:00Further, the NCUA’s special emphasis program educates staff
- 18:04on cultural diversity and provides dedicated support for employees
- 18:07and managers with disabilities.
- 18:09In addition, the NCUA routinely recruits employees with diverse
- 18:12backgrounds and seeks to ensure broad applicant pools for vacancies.
- 18:16These diversity recruitment efforts are aimed at attracting
- 18:19and retaining highly qualified individuals from underrepresented
- 18:22groups, including Hispanics and candidates with disabilities.
- 18:26In 2023, the NCUA conducted a targeted barrier analysis to identify
- 18:30hiring and retention challenges for women and Hispanic employees.
- 18:34In addition, the agency has consistently exceeded the federal employment rate
- 18:38goals for employees with disabilities and targeted disabilities since
- 18:412017.10 Slightly more than 59 percent of the NCUA’s managers are women.
- 18:47The NCUA has additionally built a diverse supplier network to obtain innovative
- 18:51solutions and the best value, particularly in technology and IT solutions.
- 18:56During 2022, the agency awarded $32.8 million of reportable contract dollars
- 19:01to minority and women-owned businesses.
- 19:03That figure represents 45 percent of the agency’s contracting
- 19:07dollars, an increase of 8 percentage points from the prior year.
- 19:11Credit unions may also assess their DEI policies and programs through a voluntary
- 19:15credit union diversity self-assessment offered annually.11 Credit union
- 19:19submissions of their self-assessment have no bearing on their CAMELS rating,
- 19:22and examiners cannot access the data.
- 19:25The NCUA reports credit union diversity data only in the aggregate.
- 19:29The agency encourages credit unions to use this tool to support their DEI efforts.
- 19:33In 2022, 481, or 10 percent of all credit unions, submitted a self-assessment.
- 19:39The figure represents an all-time high for submissions to the NCUA.
- 19:43Of those submissions, 302 were federally chartered credit unions, 178 were
- 19:48federally insured and state-chartered, and one was a non-federally insured,
- 19:52state-chartered credit union.
- 19:54The number of CUDSA responses in 2022 is twice as much as the 240
- 19:58self-assessments submitted in 2021.
- 20:01Finally, to support credit union accomplishments in DEI and
- 20:04provide further guidance, the NCUA hosted its fourth DEI Summit in
- 20:08Washington, D.C., in early November.
- 20:11This now annual event provided a forum for hundreds of credit union
- 20:15stakeholders to network, share best practices, and meet with thought leaders
- 20:19on ways to expand their DEI efforts.
- 20:21The event also highlighted the importance of allyship in helping to achieve the
- 20:25NCUA’s and credit unions’ DEI goals and improve the financial prospects and
- 20:29futures of families across the country.
- 20:31Rulemaking Activities
- 20:33Since May, the NCUA Board has engaged in several rulemakings on
- 20:36topics like MDI preservation, member expulsion, financial innovation, fair
- 20:41hiring, and charitable donations.
- 20:43These rulemakings have aimed to implement laws required by Congress
- 20:46and strengthen the credit union system.
- 20:49In May, the NCUA Board approved a proposed rule that would add “war
- 20:52veterans’ organizations” to the definition of a “qualified charity” that
- 20:55a federal credit union may contribute to using a charitable donation account.
- 20:59The NCUA Board approved the proposed rule noting the attributes of “veterans’
- 21:03organizations” as defined by section 501(c)(19) of the Internal Revenue Code
- 21:07are aligned with the purposes of the current charitable donation account rule.
- 21:11A “qualified charity” is a section 501(c)(3) entity defined by the Internal
- 21:15Revenue Code and must be both a non-profit and be organized for a charitable purpose.
- 21:19The final rule will be considered on November 16.
- 21:22In June, the NCUA Board approved proposed changes to the interpretive
- 21:26ruling and policy statement on the agency’s Minority Depository
- 21:29Institution Preservation Program.
- 21:32The proposal would amend an existing interpretive ruling and policy statement
- 21:35to update the program’s features, clarify the requirements for a credit union to
- 21:40receive and maintain an MDI designation, and reflect the transfer of the MDI
- 21:44Preservation Program administration from the agency’s Office of Minority
- 21:48and Women Inclusion to its Office of Credit Union Resources and Expansion.
- 21:52Proposed amendments to the interpretive ruling and policy statement also include
- 21:56incorporating recent program initiatives, providing examples of technical assistance
- 22:01an MDI may receive, establishing a new standard for MDIs to assess their
- 22:05designation periodically, and updating how the NCUA will review an MDI’s
- 22:09designation status, among other changes.
- 22:12This rule is pending.
- 22:13Additionally, the Board finalized a rule in July to implement requirements of the
- 22:17Credit Union Governance Modernization Act of 2022.12 This regulation streamlines
- 22:23procedures for credit unions to expel a member in cases of serious misconduct.
- 22:27In September, the NCUA Board approved a financial innovation final rule that
- 22:32provides flexibility for federally insured credit unions to utilize advanced
- 22:36technologies and opportunities offered by the financial technology sector.
- 22:40The final rule specifically provides credit unions with options to participate
- 22:44in loans acquired through indirect lending arrangements and financial technology.
- 22:48With the adoption of this final rule, the limits previously found in
- 22:51the NCUA’s regulations are replaced with policy, due diligence, and
- 22:55risk-management requirements that can be tailored to match each credit
- 22:59union’s risk levels and activities.
- 23:01Lastly, the NCUA Board in October approved a proposed rule that would
- 23:04incorporate the NCUA’s Second Chance Interpretive Ruling and Policy Statement,
- 23:09and statutory prohibitions imposed by Section 205(d) of the Federal Credit
- 23:13Union Act into the agency’s regulations.
- 23:16This proposed rule would allow people convicted of certain minor offenses to
- 23:19work in the credit union industry without applying for the NCUA Board’s approval.
- 23:24It would also amend requirements governing the conditions under which
- 23:27newly chartered or troubled federally insured credit unions must notify
- 23:30the NCUA of proposed changes to their board of directors, committee
- 23:34members, or senior executive staff.
- 23:36The comment period closes on January 8, 2024.
- 23:40Legislative Requests
- 23:41While the credit union system continues to perform well overall, several amendments
- 23:45to the Federal Credit Union Act would provide the NCUA with greater flexibility
- 23:49to effectively regulate the credit union system and protect the Share Insurance
- 23:53Fund in light of an evolving economic environment, a changing marketplace,
- 23:57and technological advancements.
- 23:59Central Liquidity Facility Reforms
- 24:01As noted previously, the NCUA Board unanimously supports a statutory change
- 24:06to restore the ability of corporate credit unions to serve as CLF agents on behalf
- 24:10of a subset of their member credit unions.
- 24:12Such legislation would better allow the CLF to serve as a shock
- 24:16absorber for liquidity events within the credit union system.
- 24:19On February 28, 2023, lawmakers introduced bipartisan legislation that
- 24:24would allow corporate credit unions to purchase CLF capital stock on behalf
- 24:28of a subset of their members.13 This legislation would permit corporate
- 24:31credit unions to contribute capital to provide coverage for smaller members
- 24:35with less than $250 million in assets.
- 24:38Liquidity risks within the credit union system are rising, and timely
- 24:42consideration of this bill would better protect the credit union
- 24:45system from future liquidity events.
- 24:47Restoration of Third-Party Vendor Authority
- 24:49The risks resulting from the NCUA’s lack of vendor authority are real,
- 24:53expanding, and potentially dangerous for the nation’s financial infrastructure.
- 24:57Other independent entities, including the Government Accountability Office, the
- 25:01Financial Stability Oversight Council, and the NCUA’s Office of Inspector
- 25:06General, have identified this deficiency as inhibiting the NCUA from fulfilling
- 25:10its mission to safeguard credit union members and the financial system.
- 25:14And, it is the NCUA Board’s continuing policy to seek third-party
- 25:17vendor authority from Congress.14
- 25:20The agency is working within its current authority to address this growing
- 25:23regulatory blind spot, but it is evident that additional authority is needed.
- 25:28There has also been a shift in credit union leaders’ understanding of the
- 25:31value of the NCUA having the same vendor authority as the federal banking agencies.
- 25:36The benefits include credit union access to NCUA examination information
- 25:40when conducting due diligence of vendors, fewer requests from the NCUA
- 25:44to credit unions to intervene with vendors experiencing problems, and fewer
- 25:48losses to the Share Insurance Fund.
- 25:50The potential for such resulting losses to the Share Insurance Fund is real.
- 25:54The NCUA’s Office of Inspector General stated that between 2008 and 2015,
- 26:00nine CUSOs contributed to material losses to the Share Insurance Fund.
- 26:04The report noted one of the CUSOs caused losses in 24 credit
- 26:08unions, some of which failed.
- 26:10According to NCUA staff calculations, at least 73 credit unions incurred
- 26:14losses between 2007 and 2020 as losses at CUSOs roll onto credit union
- 26:20ledgers and lead to liquidations.15
- 26:22The absence of third-party vendor examination authority limits the NCUA’s
- 26:26ability to assess and mitigate potential risks associated with these vendors.
- 26:30Vendors typically decline these requests or refuse to
- 26:34implement recommended actions.
- 26:35This limitation exacerbates any exposure credit unions have to the operational,
- 26:40cybersecurity, and compliance risks that can arise from these relationships.
- 26:44Without the authority to enforce recommended corrective actions, the
- 26:48NCUA is unable to effectively protect credit unions and their members.
- 26:52Furthermore, the growing reliance on third-party services in the credit
- 26:55union industry poses a systemic risk to the credit union system.
- 26:59Five core banking processors, for example, handle more than 90 percent
- 27:03of the credit union system’s assets.
- 27:05A failure of one of these critical third parties could cause hundreds
- 27:08of credit unions and potentially tens of millions of their members to lose
- 27:12access to their funds simultaneously.
- 27:14Such a vendor failure, in turn, may result in a loss of
- 27:17confidence in the financial sector.
- 27:19Ensuring proper oversight is imperative, as CUSOs and third-party
- 27:23vendors are poised to capitalize on financial institutions’ growing
- 27:26appetite for artificial intelligence and real-time payment services.
- 27:30If granted third-party vendor authority, the NCUA would implement a risk-based
- 27:34examination program focusing on services that relate to safety and soundness,
- 27:39cybersecurity, Bank Secrecy Act and Anti-Money Laundering Act compliance,
- 27:43consumer financial protection, and areas posing significant financial
- 27:47risk for the Share Insurance Fund.
- 27:49Additional Flexibility for Administering the Share Insurance Fund
- 27:53The recent turmoil in the banking sector, growing liquidity risks within the credit
- 27:57union system, and rising interest rate risk all highlight the need for the
- 28:00NCUA to have additional flexibility for administering the Share Insurance Fund.
- 28:05Specifically, the NCUA requests amending the Federal Credit Union Act to remove
- 28:09the 1.50 percent ceiling for the Share Insurance Fund’s equity ratio
- 28:14from the current statutory definition of “normal operating level,” which
- 28:17limits the ability of the Board to establish a higher normal operating
- 28:21level for the Share Insurance Fund.
- 28:22A statutory change should also remove the limitations on assessing Share Insurance
- 28:27Fund premiums when the equity ratio of the Share Insurance Fund is greater than
- 28:311.30 percent and if the premium charged exceeds the amount necessary to restore
- 28:35the equity ratio to 1.30 percent.16
- 28:39Together, these amendments would bring the NCUA’s statutory authority over the
- 28:43Share Insurance Fund more in line with the FDIC’s authority as it relates to
- 28:47administering the Deposit Insurance Fund.
- 28:49These amendments would also better enable the NCUA Board to proactively
- 28:53manage the Share Insurance Fund by building reserves during economic
- 28:56upturns so that sufficient money is available during economic downturns.
- 29:00This more counter-cyclical approach to managing the Share Insurance Fund
- 29:04would better ensure that credit unions will not need to impair their one
- 29:07percent contributed capital deposit or pay premiums during times of economic
- 29:11stress, when they can least afford it.
- 29:13Conclusion
- 29:13The NCUA stands ready to address the impact of the evolving
- 29:17economic and business cycles within the credit union system.
- 29:20The NCUA will continue to monitor credit union performance and coordinate with
- 29:24other federal financial institution regulators, as appropriate, to
- 29:28ensure the overall resiliency and stability of our nation’s financial
- 29:31services system and economy.
- 29:33Thank you again for the invitation to testify about the
- 29:36NCUA’s programs and operations.
- 29:38That Concludes the words of NCUA Chairman Todd Harper.
- 29:42If you enjoyed this type of podcast - and made it all the way to the end - check
- 29:45out our related podcast on credit unions called Credit Unions this Week.
- 29:49This is Mark Treichel typing and Robot Ethan talking, thanks for listening,
- 29:53Happy Holiday's and Merry Christmas.