Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 09/15/26 EPISODE 024: BETWEEN THE LABELS - EAGLE RARE 10 YEAR vs. EAGLE RARE 12 YEAR
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Going on here today, Ronnie. We got a little bourbon roulette going on here with this mini table. Yeah, we are gonna be doing a f I've been waiting to do this episode for a while. ⁓ we're gonna be blinding together the original Eagle Rare 10 year old with the Eagle Rare brand new release twelve year old. I think everybody's gonna find this interesting if we're blinding two bottles that I can see and touch right now, but okay. Yeah. Let's see how this goes. By the way, I'm Ronnie. With the 323 Bourbon Library. You're listening to the 323 Bourbon Library podcast. I got my buddy Barsh in the room. And why don't we get these poured up? We don't have any help this evening. ⁓ so we are gonna utilize the solo blind. The solo blind barsh is gonna pour up the two ⁓ tens, two glasses of ten. I'm gonna pull up pour up the twelves. ⁓ that was a thick pour. Yeah, you're doing big pours, aren't they? I did not mean to pour that thickly. I might spread those out just a little bit. This one needs to touch more and it come. We don't have to drink it all. And I spelled a drip. We are gonna probably drink it all. All right, so we got Eagle Rare ten year old, e r eagle rare twelve year old. We'll Marry these up. Actually we're hiding it for those that want to watch us load this thing. ⁓ still traffic. I love this thing. Either you put yours in crooked or I'll put mine and then I'll put mine across from it and then you just put yours in in the blank spots. Perfect. Kind of lock in there. We'll get it spun up here. this is interesting. Eagle Rare is ⁓ one of the first bottles that I got into when I started getting into bourbon. I think it's a nice entry drinker for a lot of folks. ⁓ so while these are just resting for a moment, let them get little bit of air and you can ⁓ a little bit of background here. One is a fresh crack. The Eagle Rare 10 is a fresh crack. Eagle Rare 12 has been open for a little bit. So I wanted to dive into ⁓ because this brand in the is so historic, right, I wanted to get a little bit of details and share one for myself, but also be able to share it with ⁓ anyone that was interesting interested in some of the background story on Eagle Rare. Go for it. So the story of Eagle Rare is one of the most fascinating his fascinating histories in the whiskey world. It wasn't actually born at Buffalo Trace. Every it's known for being a Buffalo Trace, but it was not born there. It was originally created as a direct weapon in a quote unquote bird war. ⁓ against another massive brand. Well, let me guess. Originally Eagle Rare was 101. Proof? Yeah. ⁓ I would say possibly. Yeah. It was. And so probably Wild Turkey. They were they were trying to one war. They were kind of trying to compete with Wild Turkey there. So ⁓ Turkey was a beam product or no wild turkey is wild turkey. Okay. so ⁓ there are beams. Yeah. Out people with the last name beam ⁓ that are with Heaven Hill, with Wild Turkey, that's what I'm thinking of just all over the world of whiskey. ⁓ so the the chronological timeline is kind of have has been forgotten a little bit. So in nineteen seventy the brand evolved in w into one of the most highly al allocated and sought after bourbons on the planet. ⁓ so in nineteen seventy-five, this is what is kind of known as the 101 proof era. Okay. Eagle Rare was created by master distiller Charles L. Beam at the Seagram's owned Four Roses distillery. Okay. ⁓ then what it was called Old Prentice Distillery. It was intentionally built to compete directly with Wild Turkey 101, like you said. 101. To beat the to beat the turkey, Beam released Eagle Rare as a premium ten-year-old bourbon. Bottled at at a bold 101 proof. Okay. So in 1989, Sazerac comes into the into the picture and they buy the brand. So it goes from Seagrum to Sazerac, okay. Correct. So it in the cut kind of what they call the Bourbon Glut era, ⁓ when that hit America's sales plummeted, Seagrim sold off a lot of things, including the Eagle Rare brand, to the Sazerac company. Because Sazerac didn't own a majority dis a major distillery yet, they contract sourced the bourbon. From Heaven Hill to keep the brand alive. So Eagle Rare was originally four roses distilled, then Heaven Hill distilled. ⁓ pretty crazy. Okay. So it it then in 1992, ⁓ Sazreck purchased the historic George T. Stag Distillery in Frankfurt, Kentucky, which they renamed Buffalo Trace in nineteen ninety-nine. Okay. Eagle Rare production officially moved in-house, ⁓ transitioning to the Buffalo Trace's famous Low rye mash bill number one. So in in two thousand and five, Buffalo Trace completely reimagined the brand. They dropped the proof from one ⁓ one to ninety. I kind of wish they would have kept it at the one on one. I like that little bit higher proof, but ninety is more approachable for a lot of folks. Yeah. So probably ⁓ some marketing involved in that decision. ⁓ but they introduced the iconic tall, eagle etched glass bottle and designated it a single barrel bourbon. While keeping the 10-year age statement. This can this configuration launched it it into Super Stardom. Yep. From 2012 to 2017, Eagle Rare demand exploded. Buffalo Trace transitioned from slow hand bottling to a high-speed automated line. And this is where that single barrel becomes a problem. Correct. Because of the small amount of bourbon. that remained pr potentially remained from a previous barrel and it could mix with the next barrel during the automated transitions, they no longer could legally print single barrel on the label. They quietly re removed the text and the neck wrap, transforming it into a select small batch of individual barrels. It's interesting to think about that. How many times as we've gone over this in the last couple of years have we seen select small batch? And never did I think It really is a single barrel. It's just they're legally not allowed to because the first couple of bottles could have had a little bit of cross contamination through the automated process. Exactly. So small batch to me now all of a sudden means it's single barrel or could be. Maybe, maybe not. ⁓ not a hundred percent of the time, but it's gonna make me think a lot more often that it's not a select small batch. Yeah. It's a legal requirement that they're not allowed. They've got to have a a a distinct way of stopping any mingling from one one barrel to the next. Yeah. ⁓ so let's let's let's push forward just a little bit more. In twenty twenty four to twenty twenty-six, Eagle Rare became f the face of Buffalo Trace's climate-controlled, space aged warehouse pea experiments. Pushing beyond the standard tenure and the antique collection 17 year old expressions, they broke records by releasing Eagle Rare twenty-five-year-old. ⁓ wow. In an ultra rare, high-aged bourbon with an MSRP of $12,500. Nikes. ⁓ then they launched this year, Eagle Rare 30 year old. The oldest bourbon ever released by the distillery. ⁓ my goodness. I personally saw one of these bottles for sale ⁓ at a fries event for thirteen thousand dollars. Thirteen thousand dollars at a discount supermarket. At a supermarket. I mean, not a discount, a major chain. Fries Kroger. Okay. Yeah. That's not that's I wouldn't call that high end supermarket, but okay. Yeah, yeah. But they got their hands on a thirty year old eagle. ⁓ Lord. It's crazy. ⁓ so if you're ⁓ let's see here. So the thing here that some people dive into is age statements, the hide and seek, how it's changed. ⁓ you know, some of these ⁓ eagle the current iteration says 10-year-old, 12-year-old on the front of the bottle. For a while, it left the front of the bottle, it went to the back of the bottle. Right. It it just kind of moved around in the labing, and I'm I'm kind of interested why they do that. So ⁓ when Buffalo Trace redesigned the bottle, they moved the 10 years old text from the front label. To the back of the bottle. Many casual drinkers thought the age statement had been dropped entirely because they never turned the bottle around. But it remained a true 10-year-old bourbon. Eagorare is made from the exact same mash bill as Buffalo Trace. Okay. Mash Bill number one. It's literally the exact same distillate as Buffalo Trace, E. H. Taylor, George T. Stag. Really? The only difference is it's ten years ⁓ versus roughly seven to eight years for Buffalo Trace. ⁓ and then where in the Rick House? It is aged. I think that makes a big difference then because I can't believe I I'm probably wrong, but I can't believe that just aging a couple more years turns Buffalo Trace into this Eagle Rare. Yep. Eagle Rare particularly is generally pulled from lower floors in the warehouse where it ages slower and it's a little more oak forward. Okay. In that in the finishing of that. ⁓ so while the standard Eagle Rare dropped from 90 proof back in dropped to 90 proof back in 2025 or 2020 five. ⁓ the incredibly rare Eagle Rare 17 year old, which was part of the Buffalo Trace antique collection, actually moved back up to the historic 101 proof. ⁓ wow. So ⁓ starting in 2018 to pay homage to Charles Beam's original 1975 version. So what we're drinking today or comparing today is the 2026 release of Eagle or end of 2025, I think maybe. Okay. Eagle Rare 12 year old. It's the biggest news the brand has had in in a long time. ⁓ so they're dropping this 12 year old. ⁓ the s the facts around this thing, it's obviously two years older than the standard 10-year product. It's also five proof points higher. So it's 95 proof versus 90. We'll see if we can taste that in our blind here. It's the same mash bill, MSRP on the bottles, fifty bucks if you can find it. We're gonna scoot these over so people can see this barrel here as you give it one more spin before we taste them out. Yeah, well keep keep it keep it moving. Let that air get in there a little bit. There you go. so this is a permanent addition to the lineup, which is awesome. I think ⁓ they've obviously saw the demand for bourbon coming, and I'm I'm s I love that they're letting this sit a couple years longer to get some more age on it. ⁓ so why did they ex why does this even exist? You know, they they've had e Eagle Rare, the standard 10-year-old version for decades. ⁓ yeah. ⁓ so so basically for the last 10 years, or ⁓ Buffalo Trace has been undergoing a massive $1.2 billion distillery expansion. They added 14 new Rick Houses, a massive new still house, and and they've dramatically ramped up production. ⁓ because those expansion barrels are finally hitting maturity, Buffalo Trace has has the mature stock to launch a brand new ⁓ age stated line rather than dropping more of their tenure bourbon okay onto the market. ⁓ and frankly, I got my f the bottle we're gonna drink, I got back in January of this year, never saw another one. And then all of a sudden in the l here in Arizona at least in the last month or so. They're starting to drop. All of a sudden all the stores have getting getting them. So ⁓ I got that one in in California ⁓ back at the beginning of the year. ⁓ so how it differs, ⁓ We're not going to dive into the notes because I want to taste this thing and we'll come back to as we go through, taste it a little bit for ourselves. ⁓ let's give it one more spin and then we'll pull them out. And let's talk through these things. Yeah, they've had a bunch, right? I know you guys can't see this, but they are they are spinning around. So if you take, I'll just take the two closest to me here and those. ⁓ we're not doing one and one at the same time. One across from each other. I understand that, but now how do I know which one you have that matches the one I have? Right there. All right. So pull that one off. This one. Yeah. So that'll be glass. I'll put that on my left side. Number one. And I'll put this one on my right side. Number two. Perfect. We'll lose the carousel. Let's say I want to make sure we're drinking the same one at the same time. That's what I was worried about. ⁓ that's true. That's true. When you just pulled them off, I was like, I don't know. I'm gonna be tasting the same one as you at the same time. That's the could be the lighting in here or it could be the the way that you over poured that particular bottle. ⁓ One of them's definitely darker than the other in front of me. Well it's and one of them looks dark definitely darker in front of you. Yeah, pull them out. It's a ⁓ very I mean I think it might be the blackness of the Could be the lighting where I'm sitting. No, I see it. As soon as I pick ⁓ up, I still see it. They're it's a little bit darker. It's not significantly darker. Okay. ⁓ I'm gonna taste ⁓ right to left. That's just right to left. Right to left, yeah. So my right, ⁓ I get a well, ahead. Go for it. I I got a cherry immediately. As soon as I stuck my nose in there, I got some sort of cherry. Now, you're gonna ask me what kind of cherry or smoke cherry, w wood cherry. I got a distinct that's a sweet cherry. I get a little bit of that cherry note, but I also get ⁓ like this grape big league chew bubblegum y type. I can see that. Like that powdery bubblegum note. I tell you it smells good though. Smells very smells really good. I'm going to compare it to glass two on my right, or my left, excuse me. What is that? I'm gonna go on a limb and say I smell everything exactly the same, only lighter. And this one looks lighter to me. So if you if I'm getting a mild cherry or you or or big lead chew as you described it, it's more intensified than the other glass that we smelled first. I'm really curious. I'm not getting a I'm not getting a delta yet as to I don't know how we would have done this, but did we accidentally put them on different sides from each other? Because my darker one, if I had to say it was in my left hand. And you say your dark own is in your right hand. You put your two on and I put my two on the carousel. So you put your two on correctly. I had no choice but to mine on correctly. But you took yours off incorrectly. Well, I put ⁓ back the exact same way. I took ⁓ off. So my my my first one on the right is the darker one, more intense on the aromas. I th I I'm not getting anything different. It's just lighter. It's sweeter. If if you were to say, you know, brown sugar versus white sugar, this is gonna be the lighter sugar. Your left. My left is definitely lighter. So that's hilarious. My right smells lighter to me. So we we do we may have mixed them up, who knows? They are labeled in the tags. So we can determine if we did mix them up somehow or Who knows? It just I think the glasses just look a little different. Hold them off wrong. I don't think I didn't. The carousel works fine, ladies and gentlemen. We spun the carousel just perfectly. Ronnie just glommed two glasses too quickly. Solo blind. I I pulled them off and I put them right back on. I think you mixed them up. You do? I do. We will see. We will see here. ⁓ I'm gonna try Your first one. My right. Okay. I will try my right one as well, which I believe is different than yours. Okay. Well we'll see. So you got you got cherry. I got a little bit of like grape bubblegummy note on this. ⁓ I'm still getting that cherry. ⁓ cherry soda, cherry pop, cherry pie. Mm. ⁓ that's good. Yeah. It's got some nice legs and some tannins streaking through the glass. It's it's not barking and biting. It's not drinking like a one on one if it is. None of these are one on one. It's I don't know what the proof is on either one of these right now, but this is not hitting me with a high proof at all. One is ninety and the other one is ninety five. Yeah. These are diff definitely nice and low proof. No Kentucky hug. Yeah, they're there. I'm still getting a lot of that that cherry, cherry soda. On glass. I'm I don't know how we would have messed it up, but maybe we messed it up. ⁓ I'm confident we did. I I messed it up. I'm absolutely confident we did. I mean there's some there's definitely some sugar in there. I don't know if you I'd describe it as a brown sugar or a white sugar, maybe a burnt sugar. I would say wouldn't that be a brown sugar though? Yeah. Maybe. So no brown sugar's different than just white burnt sugar. ⁓ I definitely think that glass A or whatever one, my right, has that little cherry, grapey type fruitness, a little bit of like light caramel, light vanilla, soft oak. Yes. And a nice just even sweetness. It's a good little sipper. ⁓ this is this is that a daily sipper for I mean both of these are pretty much daily separators, but glass A is really good. If I don't I haven't tasted glass B yet, let's do that now before I ma wager a guess as to what's what on either of these. ⁓ Class B. Yeah. My left. I think it's just so typical for us to say things like, you know, brown sugar and smoke sugar and smoke flavors. I'm I'm not getting a smoke off of that. No, no, no. And that's Kai went for the the the burnt sugar instead of the brown sugar as a description. And again, I'm I'm gonna get to my second glass, which is I think the opposite of you. So this is gonna be much lighter, I I'm expecting, than what I just had. Yeah, the second glass, my glass B left side, it it smells a little richer. Then glass A. I'm I'm getting everything that I was getting out of my first glass, only lighter, sweeter. I'm liking it better, believe it not. again, I think our glasses are backwards from each other, so ⁓ my second one is your first. I'm I'm liking this one better, I think. Listen, one of these times I I'm gonna go back and forth and sip ⁓ both again, but I mean we gotta have the wives in here to pour these things proper 'cause we somehow I put ⁓ in the w I fuck. You put them in fine, you pulled them off wrong. I messed that one up. When you pulled your two off and you put one back and Well, I don't know, actually. We don't know if they're messed up. The second one ⁓ I guarantee it, I can tell. You you can tell? Yeah. The second one tastes a little bit ⁓ richer to me. Yes. ⁓ it has a little more When I swap glasses so I'm with you on the second one. Yes, the second one, which was my first one, is richer. It's darker. It has a little more spiciness to it on the back in a bad way. Not in a way. ⁓ If I wouldn't have had the other one next to it, I clearly would pick this over something else all day long. The fact that we've got these two next to each other, and I'm kind of surprised 'cause I know which one's which, you know, at this point, ⁓ I like the lighter one better, the regular Eagle Rare. If you if you think that's the regular Eagle Rare. You don't know if that's the regular Eagle Eagle 10. Okay. ⁓ I'm gonna taste them one more time. Which one you doing first? You're number one or your number two? I'm gonna do my right. Okay, I squat at you. So your right. Which is now my right. Okay. Which was your left. Was my left. ⁓ yeah, I like that. I mean, you know me, ⁓ half the time I want to put an ice cube in something and you don't need ice cube on Let let open up and sip on it longer and the I the I especially when you're out to dinner or something like that, ⁓ the ice cubes, well the the the brick you put on there, it just makes that drink last a little bit longer. You you don't have six drinks way out to dinner with your wife having a steak, right? So a little bit of ice kind of helps open it up, make it last a little bit longer. yeah, no, I'm definitely I'm definitely digging this this first one here on my right. Which you think is The Eagle Rare tin. Yes. The ⁓ the other ones though, Eagle Rare what? Well, it would be the twelve. ⁓ it'd be the twelve. So the twelve here is more intense. Doesn't make it bad in any way, shape, or form. I like it a lot. And if you would have had six other bottles in the room, I might have picked this. I think it's all the six. I think it's just a little more concentrated on the flavors. A little richer, very similar flavor notes. ⁓ gosh, yeah. But it's just a little bit richer. ⁓ Without guessing at them, let's just let's figure out what there's. I'm gonna look at my right. I'm gonna say they're both freaking awesome, by the way. I really like them both. ⁓ yeah, you're not going But having the two of them side by side, I now know which one I like better. And hopefully when I pull the tag on the first one. Let's see. What is that? No, I think you wrote an E. That's a 10. Sideways. That's a 10. That's a 10. Somehow we pulled them out wrong. That's okay. So 10. And then the 12 is on the 10 is really good. 12, the 10 is great. It's a it's an absolute banger pour. There's nothing wrong with the 12. I I really, really, really am liking it. ⁓ just having the two of them at the same time. And it's it's palette preference, right? I'm going, yeah. I think I just like the lighter 10 for just sipping on. It's a great starter pour. ⁓ gosh, yeah. Great starter pour. Now here's the thing. Like some ⁓ you know, I think the 10 is like 45. MSRP, the twelves fifty bucks or so. I've seen them seventy, eighty dollars in our market. Right, but we've gone out to some steakhouses and stuff where they're the same price for a pour or similar price for a poor. They're not five dollars off on a poor. Yeah. And that's where I'm saying I would then go for the twelve. Yeah. Just and put an ice block in it and let it last a little bit longer because it's I know it's gonna be darker and stronger than the ten. Yeah. And that that brick of ice is gonna make that drink. You're blowing my mind putting putting bourbon on an ice block, but do it. You do you. You drink your bourbon however you want to drink it. I just think it's going out to dinner with the wife and a couple of friends, last thing you want to be doing is drinking six straight bourbons. Well that's well you put an ice brick in there and it lasts it does last longer. You and you get hydrated at the same time. There you go. See hydration. Important key. So I do so I think the the twelve very similar on the notes just a little bit richer. Yes. A little a little bit more yeah a little bit more elevated on the experience. So let's let's finish reading here what ⁓ what Buffalo Trace says. So let's see here. ⁓ I can't believe that's just two more years in the barrel that makes that big of a difference. That's a neat little experiment to say this is literally Buffalo Trace, aged a couple more years, in the right spot in the wreck house. And ⁓ by the way, we went with two extra years and it's completely different. So wow. We did not read these notes. Which notes? ⁓ we got them up on screen. Before we tasted it. Okay. What did you say on the nose? I said cherry. And what did I say? ⁓ grape. Grape what? ⁓ bubblegum. Bubblegum. Big league chew bubble. Big league chew, exactly what you said. So the distillery says it retains ⁓ the ⁓ on the twelve, the nose retains that distinct buffalo trace dark grape soda. ⁓ duh yeah. And big league chew does taste like grape soda. And cherry profile. Okay. Interesting that you got one, I got the other, but carries a much heavier wave of sweet oak, burnt sugar, rich caramel. I don't think either one of us said caramel, but I did talk about sugar and I think I maybe even said burnt or smoked or something. It's a plate of tape. You said it doesn't taste doesn't taste smoked. on the on the palate, the extra two years in the barrel and the five proof point, give it a thicker, more buttery mouthfeel. I let you and Giancarlo talk about that mouthfeel because I don't I don't always relate to there If it's not giving me a Kentucky Ogin burning coating. It's a buttery mouthfeel. Like nine out of ten. It leans darker, brings out a little bit more barrel char leather, orange zest, and baking spice. And now that I'm read that, I took a sip of it right as I read the palette. That orange zest, I got 100%. You said it twice now, and I'm I'm literally feeling it, tasting it, smelling it. Yeah. But you said something else. It was a ⁓ leans darker, brings more barrel char leather, orange zest, and baking spice, more butter. Baking spices. Yeah. I tend to think of rye whiskies more when you say when you say baking spices, but okay. Yeah, cinn yeah. Well I mean cinnamon cinnamon or nutmeg, those that's kinda what I think on the sweeter side of the baking spices. Finish on the finish on this thing, a little bit longer, a little bit drier than the tin. Mm-hmm. ⁓ dominated by oak tannins, Luxardo cherry, and a light peppery kick from the slier slightly higher proof point. I think I said that it had a little spice on the back side of the Yeah, I would go with that's a light pepper for sure, yeah. ⁓ listen, I is it worth it? I think if you can get either of these bottles at MSRP, absolutely do it. A lot of people are seeing and I what I was seeing for the longest time, Eagle Rare 12 for like $200, $250 a bottle. I don't think it's worth that. I don't think you should pay up s that's that much on secondary for it. Unless you're like, I just I never see it. It's my only option to get one. Then sure, you know, it's your money, do whatever you want. Well, you always make fun of me because I live across the street from the big liquor supermarket, yeah, that you know has their own store picks that's crap and stuff. But it's right there. And you know what? When you when you see Eagle on the shelf there, it's the regular price. It's not marked up and crazy. I go to some of the liquor stores that you often talk about and the they're great liquor stores, but they're always like a few dollars more. Marked up a little bit. Yeah, listen, I I I've never I I don't mind that that liquor supermarket that I go to for certain things like a bottle Eagle. I've never shied away from picking up a bottle of Eagle Rare. It's it's ⁓ Fun little story. Eagle Rare 10 is the only bourbon that I have cracked a bottle and killed the bottle in the same evening. ⁓ with a spouse. With my wife. I know the story. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We we had a place up north one night, no kids around. And the two of you function the next day if I recall. We sat around on the no zero hangover. You functioned the next day. I we were almost like, should we pop another one? And we're like, ⁓ it's like eleven PM, we should go to bed. But yeah, it was just it was one of the best nights we've ever had. Just sitting there shooting the shit, talking about life. Out on the golf course, enjoying the weather. Yep. Yep. Cool weather, sweatshirt on in the fall, leaves falling. Yeah, it was awesome. ⁓ anyway, Eagle Rare 10, Eagle Rare twelve. Pick ⁓ up. Solid pores to have in your in your lineup on your bar. ⁓ on that Eagle Rare twelve. Don't go, don't go crazy on the price. Don't go pan's go pan secondary for it. Just hold up. It'll hit your market. These are they're gonna be right. Dropping these a ton. When you find it for the right price, it's definitely worth picking it up. Yeah, I think I bought like I said, that bottle that's open there I got back in January. Never saw another one. And in the month of August, I bought three more. Four more. I actually picked you one up. So there's one over there for you. Yep. ⁓ so four more in one month. I'm like, ⁓ these are everywhere, everywhere. You can get these now. So but what's blowing my mind, as you said earlier, is this is literally Buffalo Trace products. So if if anybody out there is a Buffalo Trace fan, likes it at all, this is worth picking up these bottles. Yeah. Stepping it up a little bit. So you have them when you want to crack ⁓ open. It they're good. Yeah, they're not like shelf princesses, just they're they're drinkers. Go enjoy them with your friends, family. And ⁓ hey, listen, thank you all for for tuning in to the podcast. Listen to us somehow screw up pulling bottle ⁓ blind cups out of a spinning wheel and ⁓ and getting through this little blind tasting. We'll have a little more ⁓ quality assurance rigor on a future episode. but ⁓ if you like it, thank you for the support. Please like, subscribe, tell your friends about it, and ⁓ leave us a comment. on or a review Spotify, Apple Music, wherever you happen to be listening to us or watching us on YouTube. We appreciate it. We'll see you next time for another episode. Cheers. Cheers.