Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Carl Fung
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by Grand Gamers Guilds. If you like innovative
- 0:03games with fascinating themes in premium production, then you'll love the games from Grand
- 0:08Gamers guild. Find out more at grand Gamers Guilds dot com. Out of
- 0:17the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:20waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:24at you. The sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:29of the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:32that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:36still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 0:39shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 0:49Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities are thrust
- 0:53into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only
- 0:57take five of their games with them. Which will they choose? My guest
- 1:03this week is a war game designer and historical researcher. A lover of cuisine
- 1:07and photography, he's known in the gaming world for working with deanesig on many
- 1:10games for Multiman Publishing. These titles include Panza's Last Stand, Battles for Budapest
- 1:15and Iron Kurt in Central Europe nineteen forty five to nineteen eighty nine. My
- 1:19guest this week is Carl fun Carl, Welcome to the Cabin. Thank you,
- 1:23Ben. I'm looking forward to this. So my first question is is
- 1:26how difficult was it for you to pick the five games to take to the
- 1:29cabin. Initially, it was pretty easy except the fifth game. But then
- 1:36I started looking back and I started listening to your older interviews, I'm like,
- 1:38oh, yeah, I kind of really only picked war games, And
- 1:42of course I started overthinking. I was like, maybe shouted to the firstified
- 1:45if I'm really trying to bring games to the Cabin and want to have a
- 1:48little more diversity in my games. But I'm sticking with the list. But
- 1:53the fifth one I picked, which which is I think the first one in
- 1:56your topic for XS and Allies, was actually the hardest one to round out
- 2:01the list. And why was that hard? Because I was debating whether I
- 2:08wanted a more like juicier game, because if I'm thinking if I'm gonna be
- 2:12stuck in a cabin during you know, zombie times or whatnot. Do I
- 2:17want something that I can Yeah, something mediing and juicy. Then I realized,
- 2:22or do I something lighter fairer? Am I bringing my family or not?
- 2:25So I kind of sided with well, I kind of want to play
- 2:29something with my family, or at least my son. So I opted for
- 2:32Access and Allies and something nostalgic too. And so your list of games are
- 2:38all very very war gaming. And I noticed doing my research on this that
- 2:46every war game title has been used about fifteen times, so it's difficult to
- 2:50find the actual you're looking for. But are you that kind of game?
- 2:53Are you solely focused on those kind of deep heavy wargames or do you branch
- 3:00out into other areas occasionally? For Yeah, for my quote unquote professional gaming,
- 3:07it is. It is wargaming. You know, I'll play. I
- 3:12mean, yesterday I was playing some princess variety of Monopoly with my daughter,
- 3:16So I'll play. I definitely play a lot of games. You know,
- 3:19I'll play the cards against Humanity at times in other games like that. But
- 3:25you know that, you know that's from a family perspective. But from when
- 3:30I think about gaming, I am more drawn to, if you want to
- 3:35call it, like more of the hardcore hex encounter war games. So that's
- 3:38why my list drove me in that direction. So I've noticed over the last
- 3:43few years that people like me who generally gravitate towards eurogames have been putting their
- 3:50toe into war gaming. So I and my entry way is I think very
- 3:54much the way a lot of eurogamers are. It's through the coin series because
- 3:59they're a right recognize there are cubes. Essentially, have you seen that a
- 4:03sort of widening in the audience for war games? And do you think that's
- 4:09a good thing by and large? Oh? Absolutely, it branches that gap,
- 4:14right, and I think it's got a lot of perhaps like a negative
- 4:18association with that because they you know, you have little cubes, you have
- 4:21the meat balls, and it's like, oh, it's almost like a eurotrash
- 4:25war game. But the thinking evolved, especially when you have designers like Bulco
- 4:30Okay doing it. There is a they're backing in a lot of the history
- 4:33and a lot of the strategic analysis into that game. So it doesn't matter
- 4:38whether it's a cube or a little hardbok counter, they're the most part the
- 4:45same. They just represent different things and different levels of complexity of what you're
- 4:48where, you're looking to represent. And so how do you feel about the
- 4:55lighter raft of war games that are coming through. I'm thinking of games like
- 5:00Undaunted. I'm thinking of games like Fault Circle, companies like that that are
- 5:06doing games that, you know, wargames are famous for having a thousand page
- 5:11rulebook and playing over twenty seven hours. What's your feeling towards this, this
- 5:15this lighter war game that seems to appeal to a broader audience. I have
- 5:21no concerns over it. I personally don't have a pre election to play them
- 5:26necessarily, and I want to avoid using the word other entry war games,
- 5:32because I mean, if people stick them and they enjoy the topics, that's
- 5:36fantastic. If anybody who are playing games like Undaunted or any of those other
- 5:45let's call them CUSP war games, if they want to explore anything different,
- 5:49then there's always the opportunity to delve into games. And I endure more,
- 5:55you know, the ones with a thousand bag of rulebooks and that take twenty
- 5:58seven plus hours to play, And there's always this sense, and I think
- 6:02this is evaporating, but there's this sense that wargaming is a little elitist and
- 6:10a little difficult. It's difficult to engage with wargamers if you're new to entering
- 6:15wargames. Is this true or is this just a negative stereotype that I've been
- 6:20bombarded with. Well, I mean there's a reason why the old school wargamers
- 6:26call themselves groan yards. I mean that's from the French Imperial Army from Napoleonic
- 6:30of you know, the old grumblers, And I think it's a bit reflective,
- 6:35right, there's a you know, we are proud of playing these you
- 6:39know, hardcore war games that are hex encounters with the big rule books and
- 6:42whatnot. And perhaps for some of them they might feel that to have coin
- 6:49games and area movement with with blocks isn't wargames. And they're trying to define
- 6:56hard lines. And you know, honestly, if you look at board game
- 6:59game, there's a hard definition of what is a war game. And I
- 7:03don't want to step into there because there's no answer. It is a big
- 7:06gray area twenty different answers from wargamers, and it's always different. Twilight Struggle,
- 7:12right, and whether or not that's a war game or not. I
- 7:14mean, I tried playing Twilight. I think it's a great design. I
- 7:17can't beat it, I can't win. But but a lot of these decisions
- 7:21regardless, you know, again, regardless of whether it's like car driven,
- 7:26area movement, hexacounter, they're all to some theme of some martial thing,
- 7:34right, a war battle and other related items like that. So I guess,
- 7:41back to to your original question, I don't think a lot of gamers
- 7:46are in two categories like, oh, I'm a war gamer and has the
- 7:53you know, difficult rules and whatnot or complicated, and then there's the other
- 7:57lighter side, which I'm going to disregard that there's some branch over because I
- 8:01think also as as some gamers are getting older, they may not want the
- 8:07hard rules because our memories start to fade. And I think I'll throw myself
- 8:11in their bucket, even though I'm probably in the younger side. For you
- 8:15who's got the bloody time you know, oh that too, right, And
- 8:18there's always complaints of well, you know, my table space is only this,
- 8:20I'm using the dining table to play, and my wife is kicking me
- 8:24off the dining table because we you know, trying to serve dinner, So
- 8:28there's always that unless you have the big dedicated gaming space, which some do.
- 8:33I this is very rare for some people to have the twenty map games
- 8:37out for months on end, so it has to be so basically, there
- 8:43has to be a diversity in it to keep the hobby and your interest going
- 8:48right. So let's go back to the beginning then, So you grew up
- 8:52as a lonely child. Can you tell us about that? Yeah, a
- 8:56lonely child. Yeah. I grew up in the suburbs of New York City
- 8:58on Long Island. I was the youngest of three. My oldest sister was
- 9:03six years older at sir, another sister who was two years older than me,
- 9:09and my parents worked all day. They worked in the restaurant industry,
- 9:13so they'd be gone from the morning time and then they would come home like
- 9:16super late at I like ten ten at night. So I was pretty much
- 9:20a latch key kid, which means that I had keys when I was pretty
- 9:24much an elementary school I would let myself into the house, do my homework,
- 9:28my dinner ready, basically tacker myself. My sisters would have good social
- 9:33lives and whatnot, and would go out so I'd pretty much be in the
- 9:37house for the most part, by myself for a lot of the period.
- 9:41I mean, mind you. In some ways, that's probably why I got
- 9:43into war gaming and liked it because I can focus on long, boring games
- 9:46and whatnot. But yeah, that's pretty much the environment I grew up in.
- 9:50So I had a similar upbringing. I was a latch key kids growing
- 9:54up, and it led me into discipline habits. Were you a conscientious kid?
- 10:03I was a rules follower. Yeah. My sister's lost though, because
- 10:07they would like escape out of the house hang out with their friends. I
- 10:09would just be like, no, I'm not gonna I'm gonna get caught.
- 10:13I'm going to stay in the house. I'm going to follow the rules.
- 10:13I'm not going to break anything. Yeah. So maybe that's why I like
- 10:18reading rules to games or something. Yeah. So you discovered an early interest
- 10:22in military history. Was it games that inspired that or was it the military
- 10:26history that inspired the interesting games? The evolution was I was into the military,
- 10:31uh, because you know, I'd play with you know, there'd be
- 10:37the fascination of playing with the plastic army soldiers and then evolved to playing with
- 10:39g I. Joe even shows like F Troop, you know, the reruns
- 10:43of showing F Troop and like having the cavalry with Silly. It was you
- 10:48know, there was something that kind of drew me to that, and then
- 10:52I think that led me to getting into military history. There was a book
- 10:56we had at home called The Pictoral History of the of World War Two,
- 11:03because it was all you know, mostly black, whiter or some color photos
- 11:07in there, with a lot of captions, and so I read it obsessively
- 11:11over and over Again'm just kind of reading the captions and looking at it.
- 11:13And I think that got my interest into World War Two in elementary school,
- 11:18and then I go to the library, I take off books, and you
- 11:22know, it's just everything that evolved from there. I finally got into war
- 11:26gaming when in high school, I joined the Social Studies club and one day
- 11:33they had you know, they set up a big room and they had access
- 11:37and allies there and you just joined a bunch of other kids and you've learned,
- 11:41and I was like, oh, you can play World War two.
- 11:45This is awesome. And I kind of just spiled down there. So and
- 11:48then I went you know, I remember like the next weekend, I went
- 11:50down to the library and I found Jim Dunigan's Complete War Games Handbook and I
- 11:56was reading, like, oh my god, there's so many other of these
- 11:58games out there. Yeah, I gotta find him, and I got I
- 12:01want to play these things because you know, then it's correlating only military history
- 12:03that I liked to whoa I can actually recreate and play it myself. And
- 12:09so you you sent me an extensive bio, and one thing popped out is
- 12:15that we have a mutual hero in Anne Boordain. May he rest in peace.
- 12:18So what was it about him that was so engaging? And how was
- 12:22it to meet him? Because you met him a couple of times? Yeah,
- 12:26I mean he just oozed coolness. Yeah, just laid back, cool
- 12:35chef. You know, the lifestyle that I didn't live, and you know,
- 12:39you want to live vicariously through him. I read his book Kitchen Confidential,
- 12:43and I fell in love with it, right, Yeah, you know,
- 12:48no was it no fish on Mondays and reading all the inside you know,
- 12:54all the inside scoop on things. His writing style was fantastic. And
- 12:58then came his his subsequent Boo a Cooks tour and then the TV shows that
- 13:01followed, So him melding you know, cuisine and cultures and travel just clicked
- 13:09with me. So when you know, when I was able to travel,
- 13:16I would try to match his itineraries. You know, I'd watched the shows.
- 13:20I'd say like, oh, where do you go? What cities?
- 13:24Did you go to? Particular restaurants? And I would literally just follow his
- 13:28itinerary and go to the same place as he did, so just kind of
- 13:31like rattle off a couple of places. Spain. Spain was a big influence,
- 13:37right, did you manage to go to El Buis? No I ate
- 13:41at? No? I wish I did? I ate at another one of
- 13:46his restaurants. It was called like thirty seven Degrees or something like that,
- 13:52and it was almost like thirty seven courses and it was amazing. You're eating
- 13:56there for basically like three four hours. It was a great experience. But
- 14:03otherwise, in Spain, one of the big influential things, and one thing
- 14:05that Tony Bridaine really loved the love was the Basque area San Sabastian. There
- 14:11was one particular restaurant that he ate at which drew me in. It was
- 14:15called asidor Extravary, and it was in the middle of Basque country outside of
- 14:20San Sebastian and they only had like six reservation blocks during the entire week,
- 14:28and we got like a lunch reservation and went there. It was fantastic.
- 14:33It was one of the best meals ever had in my life. And it
- 14:37was also around the time that I was going to propose to my wife,
- 14:39so I thought it was a perfect day to cap off. I didn't propose
- 14:43that at the end of the meal, but later that night, as we're
- 14:48digesting her food and just walking around to San Serbastian, I proposed to her.
- 14:52So there's there's a big connection with me. And it was all because
- 14:56you know, Tony Bendeen kind of had these you know, the itinerary for
- 15:00us, and you couldn't go wrong doing what he did. Did you don't
- 15:05you get on your knee in the middle of the street. I did.
- 15:11I did. It was right along the coastline. My wife was so excited.
- 15:13She started like I just got proposed, and she's going up to everyone
- 15:18who only speaks Spanish. You take a picture and the like. They figured
- 15:22it out and took a picture and so, yeah, how was he in
- 15:26person? I assume you didn't go out for a night on the time with
- 15:30him, but did he come did he come across in person the way he
- 15:33came across in his writing. So the first time I saw him, he
- 15:37was literally outside of his restaurant, Laisal, which is like a prossery in
- 15:43the like twenty third Street in New York, and you know, he just
- 15:48hanging out there talking with a friend. And I see him on the street
- 15:52and I'm like, I gotta talk to him. So I got up to
- 15:54them and I wait patiently. I didn't want to just like bargin Wally's having
- 15:56conversation. I finally, you know, got Tom. I got to shake
- 16:00your hand. I'm a huge fan. He was gracious, but you could
- 16:04also tell like he's he wasn't like a super celebrity. You know. He
- 16:10was like, oh, you know, he's very gracious, very nice.
- 16:12But I also didn't want to be starstruck with him. But it was n
- 16:17We had a little banter. I was like, you know, I'm definitely
- 16:18going to a restaurant. He's like, oh yeah, and I'll see you
- 16:21there. The other time I met him was at a book signing, so
- 16:25it was a little more of a formal setting. Unfortunately, I was at
- 16:27the end of the signing list. So by the time I got to him,
- 16:32you could tell he was exhausted, and he was he was very charitable
- 16:34because he had just had his baby, so he was getting a lot of
- 16:37baby gifts and everything. So by the time I got to him, I
- 16:41was asking him like very chiffolated question, like, oh, we did Scott
- 16:44Bryant leave this restaurant? He's like, I'm not sure, why do you
- 16:47go to DC? And this and that? But you can tell he's kind
- 16:48of exhausted. But at least in terms of his personality on the show versus
- 16:52reality, it wasn't there. But again, I know he's a human being.
- 16:57I know he wasn't like a super lebrity or whatnot. So I kind
- 17:00of respected that, but it was still amazing to have him, you know,
- 17:04sign my copy of Kitchen Confidential, just meet him in person, and
- 17:08very sad, right I think. I think if I had a list of
- 17:12people who I thought were going to take their own lives, I wouldn't have
- 17:15put out some evil Dane on it, right, No, completely, I
- 17:18mean it was it was unknown and which which says a lot about people's inner
- 17:25demons and the things you don't know because you know, because especially with the
- 17:30way media is built as that people will put a lot of things in the
- 17:33pedestal and they think they have a great life and you don't know what's behind
- 17:37it. Right, So your first game then is you've already mentioned it,
- 17:41which is Access and Allies. So firstly you kind of mentioned why you're taking
- 17:45this one to the cabin. But do you think it still holds up as
- 17:48And you don't seem to like the term, but I'm going to use it
- 17:52for want of a better one as an entry level wargame. Does it all
- 17:56up now? But it's fun to play because because I'm playing with my son
- 18:04right now. He crushed me the first time around. But like the enjoyment
- 18:08he's getting from it, like I like it. Does it hold up from
- 18:11a historic perspective? No, because when you set up the game and I'm
- 18:15playing with him and I'm the axis and I get to Japan's turn and I
- 18:22realized, wait, I can just hop over to Hawaii and destroy his carrier
- 18:30in a submarine that's there, and I get it's supposed to be after Pearl
- 18:33Harper, so there's no battleship there to help protect him. Like, wait,
- 18:36this isn't right, But I'm gonna do it anyway. Fortunately, I
- 18:41rolled bad because I don't want to crush my son's spirit on his first Worga
- 18:44experience. I rolled bad, and he came back roaring and he crushed me.
- 18:48But yeah, so from the historical perspective, it doesn't hold up because
- 18:52I'm looking at it and I know so much of the history, and I'm
- 18:55like, you can't do that. You shouldn't be able to do that.
- 18:56You can't do this, why would you do this? But of course my
- 19:00son's like, I want to do this. I'm like, yeah, So
- 19:03from from the enjoyment perspective, it's great for him, and I can.
- 19:07I have to remind myself to set aside all the historical nerdiness and grumbleness of
- 19:15what I have just is like, let's let's just enjoy the experience in war.
- 19:18Well, actually your son when he's enjoying himself, I guess exactly.
- 19:22And I can't talk at right away. I want to play guys, go
- 19:26there for a longer period of time. So are you the kind of parent
- 19:30that is charitable to your children when you play with them? Or do you
- 19:33do you want to teach them a stern lesson about the injustice of life.
- 19:40I I'm charitable because I'll kind of let them win, but I'll sometimes i'll
- 19:47hit them back a little hard, but ultimately I kind of let them win.
- 19:51And that's only because so my daughter's five, my son is seven,
- 19:55so they're kind of at the age that they don't take defeats well or you
- 20:00want to encourage them because you know, any small matter, and you know,
- 20:03we see it at the dinner table, like you're Roger and they throw
- 20:07off attention and like storm off to their room. So you gotta have to,
- 20:10like you kind of work it in to kind of help build up their
- 20:12confidence. And I've reminded my son, you know, as we're playing Access
- 20:18to that, I was like, you know, you won the first time
- 20:19and I did a really bad job, and he made some good decisions,
- 20:22and I just said, next time we play, just understand that this possibly
- 20:26that I might win. And you know, if you lose a battle,
- 20:30you can't be upset about it. He gets it. I think he's getting
- 20:33there. So again, yeah, I'm charitable enough, but I want to
- 20:36work in so that they can understand that I mean, I'm maybe losing in
- 20:41the game can correlate to you losing out something in life too. I mean
- 20:45I haven't still got there, but anyway, So I've interviewed a lot of
- 20:49people on this show, and often people have a sort of point of origin
- 20:55for their life. In games, is access and Allies your point of origin?
- 21:00Yeah? Absolutely, absolutely, yeah, the first Warrior Man. Yeah.
- 21:04Again, when I went to the library and I got Jim Dunigan's you
- 21:07know, handbook, complete handbook on war games, it was a revelation to
- 21:14me and I wanted to get all these games and it got me interested in
- 21:17more more military history periods and besides World War Two. So I want to
- 21:23move on there to talk about your design. So how did you start?
- 21:27How did you start designing games? And do you think it's the fact that
- 21:32every gamer kind of has a design rattling around in the back of the head
- 21:36and you just need the courage to do something with it. That's pretty much
- 21:40it. And I mean, yeah, when I was kind of thinking about
- 21:41that question, that's how it started. A lot of players have it in
- 21:45their head like well I would have done something different, or I have an
- 21:48idea about something, and whether or not you commit to ultimately doing it and
- 21:55doing a formal design is another matter my ny beginning about twenty years ago,
- 22:03when it was originally like, hey, it be really cool to come up
- 22:07with a game on this. So two designs that recently came out, but
- 22:12it had initial design efforts twenty years ago was the Battle of Goose Green in
- 22:18the Falklands for the Tactical Comment series and Valleeteers, which is on the Yamkapor
- 22:25War. Yeah, so the initial efforts for that, it was like twenty
- 22:29years ago and just because like, hey, it'd be really cool if I
- 22:30design a game on that. The the interestcting point was I got I started
- 22:37to get looped in with Danesig. Initially I was doing module work, so
- 22:45there was a software before Vassal called aid de Camp but similar things that were,
- 22:52you know, you create a game module for a computer and you can
- 22:55move pieces. You're you're basically replicating the physical game into on a computer form
- 23:00where you can move pieces around it and I'll keep track of, you know,
- 23:03different aspects. It's very clunky and now you know it's been replaced by
- 23:07Passels. So I was doing these camp modules for for Dean for his you
- 23:12know, play testing games and the Solider for surely I kind of get into
- 23:17his inner circle and then we'd bounce ideas around and then you know, he
- 23:22he realized that was a good historical researcher, and I had designs out there
- 23:29and things just one thing led to another. You know. One thing great
- 23:34about Dean was that he would create series rules, right, so every single
- 23:40individual game out there has a certain set of rules, right, how to
- 23:45how to move, what's his zone and control and what are the victory conditions
- 23:48want to and they're all typically there one rule per game. Here he created
- 23:53series rules, so there's an underlying core rules for defining the basic thing the
- 24:00zones and controls, how you move, and you know, combat and whatnot.
- 24:03So all you really have to do in terms of doing a design was
- 24:04kind of qut your historical situation and all the research, create the specific pieces
- 24:10in the map for it, and then lay them on top of these core
- 24:12rules, and then put any unique rules specific for that situation to that game.
- 24:18So that's where everything kind of melded in. I think other designers when
- 24:22they're designing games have to think about all these other asss, you know,
- 24:27basically the shoot the nuts. I was able to kind of layer it in
- 24:30there it coins a lot it coins a lot like that too, right,
- 24:33because how the core coin rules are and you've seen how it's propagated into a
- 24:42lot of different themes and a lot of different topics. And I think that's
- 24:47the way gaming is going. And it's good because again, you gamer is
- 24:52trying to remember a lot of rules, and a lot of rules for different
- 24:53games is difficult. So a lot of what I'm realizing is a lot of
- 24:57gamers are sticking to certain series. They like certain series because they know the
- 25:03core rules and they can adapt and play multiple games on that without having to
- 25:07remember ten different games, ten different rules. So what are the challenges of
- 25:12designing historical games? And you've already mentioned you know you're being pulled at access
- 25:19and Allex, I mean with that, how important his historical fidelity. It's
- 25:27very important for my purposes, but it shouldn't handcuff the entire design. I
- 25:36I would say, like selfishly, but I mean I pride myself on doing
- 25:41a lot of historical research. I dig beyond like the Wikipedia pages or even
- 25:48just the general history reading book of you know what you find in bookstores.
- 25:56I'll go to original sources. I'll look up after action reports, war diaries,
- 26:02you know, the original things that are being output from from the originating
- 26:07sources of the combatants and all kind of dig there, finding correct original topography
- 26:17maps so that you know what the representation of the terrain and the cities and
- 26:22little locations because that those do evolve over time besides mega cities whatnot. You
- 26:27know, just having everything correct is important to me. So putting all that
- 26:32historical analysis into a game is very important to me because I want to demonstrate
- 26:37as closely as possible the way it was when the battles were fought. One
- 26:44thing that I'm kind of known for is order of battle research. What that
- 26:48is is building up the historical composition of the way the forces were laid out.
- 26:56Typically you can find that on Wikipedia or as I kind of joke like,
- 27:00usually in the appendix of the book right the back of the book,
- 27:03the little boxes of the hierarchy of units and this and that. I know
- 27:08oftentimes author's role take shortcuts to that or they may not have a full understanding
- 27:15of that. So that's where I'll look into a lot of these alternate sources,
- 27:19more so the original sources to kind of validate it and scrutinize it and
- 27:23kind of rebuild it or see if there's accuracies or inaccuracies, because I think
- 27:27that's one of the core foundational things of designs is when you have an accurate
- 27:33representation of the way the forces were built, then you kind of know who
- 27:37and why they did so and so movement. You know, this is on
- 27:41top of having accurate maps and the related rules to represent specific historical events to
- 27:49that situation. And So what are the periods of history that really grab you
- 27:56when it comes to sort of thinking about designing a game. Yeah, primarily
- 28:03World War two, American Civil War, and post World War two modern I
- 28:08have debbled in World War One. I'm interested in it, but I haven't
- 28:12dealt as much likewise with Napoleon and nic Era and just generally American history.
- 28:19And for someone who seems to be quite focused upon the historical fidelity, are
- 28:30the classical times, the ancient Greeks, the ancient Romans? Is it just
- 28:33too vague and wooly to be able to really pique your interest? Yeah,
- 28:41a bit. I do get interested in it, you know, watching movies
- 28:47like Gladiator, and I was recently just watching a clip on Alexander the Really
- 28:53Scott movie, and they had their recreation of the Battle of Gagamela. I
- 28:57was like, oh, that's actually pretty historically accurate. Because I started looking
- 29:00up other videos and reading a little bit, I'm like, oh, they
- 29:03actually did a pretty good job on that. But it's a bit broad based
- 29:07for me, Like the room in area interests me, but not so much
- 29:14that I can devote a lot of my time to understanding it. So history
- 29:18in general just really interests me, but the level that I can get of
- 29:23knowledge that I can get to for other periods, I don't know how much
- 29:27time do we have and how long am I going to live? So your
- 29:30next game then is Last Blitz Creek. So why are we still so obsessed
- 29:37with the Second World War? I think for all the same stereotypical reasons that
- 29:42we know of World War Two is, you know, the biggest war in
- 29:48history. It's a global war. It's probably the last quote unquote good versus
- 29:56evil war out there. I mean, it's got to really defined villain and
- 30:00a really defined hero. I guess right, absolutely, even though you know
- 30:03we're seeing the ramifications from it and maybe a little less so. But yeah,
- 30:08at least in the time frame for World War Two itself, there where
- 30:11there was a good guy and there was a bad guy, and so how
- 30:15well does loves bliss Krieg put us in the Second World War? That's a
- 30:25bit of difficult answer to reply, because I'm you know, if I if
- 30:29I am just saying well, it's got the so and so armored units and
- 30:34panzers and Germans, and you know that that kind of answers the question,
- 30:40but at least from the frame of mind of as a player, and again,
- 30:44you know, it's taking a step back of you know, me who
- 30:47knows a lot about the Battle of Bulls, by someone who who's generally playing
- 30:49it. You do, you do get that sense because a lot of the
- 30:53decision making that you are taking in there as the Allied player or as the
- 31:00German player does actually represent the same kind of decision making that the historical commander's
- 31:08done. And the rules, the rules set for the Battalion combat series rule
- 31:14set kind of puts you in this frame of mind. Basically, at a
- 31:18two level, one is the overall commander, whether not your eyes an hour
- 31:22or you know, Hodges or patting down to the individual formation which is or
- 31:30individual divisions like the first infantry division under Cliff Andrus and so you know,
- 31:34you can you're you're kind of representing different commanders when you're playing a game in
- 31:41different different roles, So it does put you in the spot and it kind
- 31:45of goes back to what I was saying about having the accurate representation of you
- 31:48and is having the accurate map, because you can see why the Germans were
- 31:52funneled to go in certain ways and not just you know, running through the
- 31:56forest off road. Granted, a lot of bullet games will obviously do that
- 32:01because they will have their accurate depictions of the map and everything. This last
- 32:07blis Becuez was just Dean and my take on it, based on a lot
- 32:14of the new findings that we're doing. Dean wanted to have the map represented
- 32:22for the entire battle at a one kilometer per hex scale, even the other
- 32:29games at that same unit level are typically one mile per hext. So basically
- 32:35what that means is that there's a little bit more fidelity in the terrain,
- 32:40so there's a little bit more maneuver because the individual hexagon that you're moving in
- 32:46there's more of it because you're representing more I guess less space in this respect
- 32:52of what you could do, so units aren't cluttered around. There's a little
- 32:58bit more maover so you can kind of see little holes opening up and move
- 33:00through there. And it is important, especially in the Battle of the Balls,
- 33:05where there are you ares surrounded by more mountainous terrain and woods that you
- 33:09have to find a little seam to kind of punch you. And that happened
- 33:13more times than not in the battle. So you've mentioned this, but this
- 33:16is a game in the Battalion Combat series. Now, my knowledge of anything
- 33:22is pretty terrible, but especially in the three history, can you explain to
- 33:27us what battalion combat means? Sure? So the hierarchy of units in a
- 33:35military formation, you know, you have armies, you have quars, you
- 33:39have divisions and down there regiments, battalions and so and so forth. From
- 33:44a heart perspective, there's different aspects and more familiar in terms of you know,
- 33:51strategic and tactical and it kind of in between. You have operational.
- 33:54Strategic is decisions that are being made that impact basically the war as a whole.
- 34:00You're fighting over countries, the fall of fall of Germany and fall of
- 34:04France. Operational are individual movements like the Battle of Bulge was the Ardennes campaign.
- 34:09That is an operation, so that's a grander scale battles or campaigns that
- 34:17are being fought to achieve a strategic victory. Below that is a tactical level,
- 34:23where it's how individual smaller units are doing, moving and fighting in order
- 34:32to achieve to win that battle at that operational scale, in order to achieve
- 34:37the strategic value, so to come back around, So battalions are kind of
- 34:42at the cusp of that tactical and operational level. So each individual unit is
- 34:51a battalion and that typically represents five hundred and two, one thousand men in
- 34:55machines and one on. So you have these individual units are representing these battalions
- 35:02and they're kind of individually maneuvering and above them controlling them is a regiment or
- 35:09a division, and the game system works and that you're activating or you're moving
- 35:15these group of units within that hierarchy, and the opposing player has their activations
- 35:22for that formation, and you're basically recreating the battle at that battalion scale.
- 35:30So each time you move, you're moving you know, each to them,
- 35:32you're moving a unit, you're moving five hundred and two thousand men around at
- 35:37a time. I hope that helps answer the question. Yeah, lovely.
- 35:40So I want to move on now and talk about someone you've mentioned quite extensively
- 35:45already, and this is Deanesseg. So there are many people listening to this
- 35:50who don't know who he was? Can you give us a tell us who
- 35:53he was? And give us a portrait of a man. Dean Sseg was
- 36:00a prolific game designer who started up a company called The Gamers. I think
- 36:07he actually started in nineteen eighty six, but he didn't have he did.
- 36:09He produced his first game in nineteen eighty eight, so he's been designing games
- 36:15for, you know, thirty five years. He through his company, he
- 36:22through his company, and later on when he started working with Multimi Publishing.
- 36:30He released one hundred and three games. He personally designed thirty seven games,
- 36:35but he also developed seventy two of them. And the difference between designing and
- 36:40developing is that designing is you're putting everything soup to nuts. You're designing from
- 36:45scratch. Developing is basically like an editor where you're helping assist and clean up
- 36:52and straightening out a game design for another designer. So he produced a lot
- 37:00of game series which include Operational Combat series, Battalion Combat Series, Tactical Combat
- 37:06series, Standard Combat Series, Line of Battle, Civil War Brigade series,
- 37:10and there was a subset of regimental sub series and a Napoleonic Brigade series.
- 37:17So yeah, he had a long background. His background. He was a
- 37:23US ranger and he told me a story and I don't think this is mentioned,
- 37:29so maybe this is a reveal to the public. He told me that
- 37:34he was a ranger around the time when Operational Ego Claw was occurring, and
- 37:37this was the botched Iran hostage rescue, that he was an alternate, that
- 37:44he was almost slated to potentially go into Iran. I think it was like
- 37:47a stadium to get staged as a backup for the main force that was going
- 37:52to try to rescue the hostages. And so how was so you worked with
- 38:00him quite extensively, How was he to work with? How was he as
- 38:04a how was he as a man? If if I could say he was
- 38:10stubborn and flexible at the same time, it was he was very he was
- 38:19very committed. He was he was focused, He knew kind of what he
- 38:22did and when you see him do his design work. It was. It
- 38:23was pretty amazing. But he would also never kind of arrest on his own
- 38:29laurels, because he would if he wasn't comfortable with his own series, roles
- 38:35or game, he didn't mind revising it. And you know, some people
- 38:39grumble about that, like, you know, you have a perfectly fine thing
- 38:42while you're revising it, because he just went he just wouldn't sit back and
- 38:45he's like, well, you know, he feels uncomfortable with it. He
- 38:47would make revisions, come up with new, a completely new, you know,
- 38:52version of his serious roles, with the hindsight of making sure that it
- 38:58was backwards compatible for all the previous games that he had out there. Flexible
- 39:04also in the sense that you know, when we collaborated a lot, so
- 39:07I would design games or I would help on research games that he designed.
- 39:12You know, he'd come up with idea and then I would let's say,
- 39:15come back and say, well, I don't think that's going to work because
- 39:16it's historically YadA, YadA, YadA, and he would step back and like
- 39:21okay, he would either scrap it or change it. So he would listen
- 39:25to input, you know, not just from my celf, from a lot
- 39:28of playtesters as well. He was big into playtesting because he would make sure
- 39:32that the design worked, not just you know, having it on historical rails,
- 39:38but there's enough flexibility there. You know, playtesting is always big and
- 39:44important because you want to make sure that the game's not you know, the
- 39:46big thing that working is the game is broken. To make sure that the
- 39:51game works, that there's no holes in the rules, So he take a
- 39:54lot of input from the playtarf So sometimes he would not take all of the
- 40:00input because that's he saw in a certain way and he would go that way.
- 40:05Ultimately, I you know, it is all about compromise. That no
- 40:10one can just stand stuff and they say no, this is the right way.
- 40:14I'm gonna not budge from that. Any good working relationship is all about
- 40:17compromise. But ultimately, as long as the end product works and is to
- 40:22the satisfaction of those involved, then that's right. So everything I've personally in
- 40:28design that Dean has helped me develop, I've been extremely satisfied with the product.
- 40:35So yeah, he strikes that balance between knowing his direction which is the
- 40:39suborn part, but also flexible enough to kind of take input from folks and
- 40:44adjust from there. And so the reason I heard Dean's name was because unfortunately
- 40:50he died very recently. How difficult was it to lose someone that you'd worked
- 40:54so closely with. It's a terrible loss. He wasn't just someone I worked
- 41:00with. He's my friend. His memorial service was this Best Saturday, and
- 41:07a group of gamers went to his memorial service. It was nice to,
- 41:13you know, kind of meet them and talk and share our experiences. It
- 41:19was tough because we would almost communicate every day through email. Mostly I don't
- 41:28have that sounding board anymore. It's yeah, I can't believe he's gone.
- 41:32It's really sad. No, yeah, and no, and yeah. I
- 41:44did want to say that too. That one proud thing for me and I
- 41:47feel honored is that multimand Publishing definitely needed to take over, say takeover to
- 41:54help see additional games for the gamers continue. So I can at least kind
- 42:01of take that and then honor Dean. But I continue to see his legacy
- 42:07and his games go forward and not just kind of and with his passing and
- 42:12online, what do you think is Dean's legacy to the war gaming world.
- 42:19He was innovative, and I struggle to say that because it's a it's a
- 42:28subjective word, you know what is innovative. But particular examples when you look
- 42:34at his Civil War Brigade series, you have to write out your orders if
- 42:39you want your own units to do things. You are writing the orders as
- 42:45if you were Robert E. Lee or George Mead or George McLelland, and
- 42:51you're saying, I want so and so units to do this, and you're
- 42:55writing it, and there's a whole built in system that your subordinates who is
- 43:01still you can accept it, or they look at it, they misinterpret it,
- 43:07maybe the messenger gets lost. So it creates a built in friction and
- 43:13fog of war that the quote unquote normal war games don't because in a quot
- 43:20unquote normal war game, whatever you do when you move that piece over it
- 43:25just like chess. And when you move that piece and you let go of
- 43:29that piece, that's your decision and you have exact, finite control from the
- 43:35top all the way down to the individual thing you're moving. He was trying
- 43:39to represent that fog of war that nothing works like you expect it to.
- 43:47Right, It's it's either Murth Freeze law or the Clausewitz in thing of you
- 43:53know, once again into battle, the all plans fall apart. You can't
- 43:58handle it. So sometimes some players will roll together because like no, no,
- 44:02no, I want to do this because I know my exact plan.
- 44:05But you know what, if you're thinking about a game represents different aspects of
- 44:08different rounds and thousands upon thousands of men with different opinions about something, right,
- 44:13no one's going to fall over the commander and say I'm going to do
- 44:15exactly what you want. And there's a lot of demonstratable situations where that with
- 44:22that occurred, where or make commander wanted to do something but it's supported and
- 44:27it's Nope, not going to do it, or they hesitated in doing it,
- 44:30and the resulting metal was because of that, not because of the general
- 44:37with the perfect with perfect plan was always going to be able to execute it
- 44:40his way. So that's one of his legacies. And again just the breadth
- 44:45of the games and the type of topics that he released was was his legacy
- 44:52to WORKA world Origins is coming up and you can pre order tons of games
- 44:59from the Grand Game Guild website. Simply go to Grand Gamesguild dot com and
- 45:02use the code origins to let the bods at GG know that you want to
- 45:06pick them up. There you could pre order tea in a nog from famed
- 45:09board game designer Isaac Shalev. The American read Wolf scenario for Endangered Words of
- 45:15a Feather, and many more just got a Grand Games Guild dot com.
- 45:17I'd like to thank them for sponsoring this podcast. So I want to move
- 45:29on now to your next game, which is the last chance for victory.
- 45:31So what makes this a unique Gettysburg game? This was This was one of
- 45:38Dean's self proclaimed best games that had done. So, you know, there's
- 45:44there's obviously a lot of Gettysburg games out there. This was his take on
- 45:49it. If you ever get a chance, and I actually do recommend you,
- 45:53you know, read his designer notes on it. He's adding a lot
- 45:59of shows that he knows a lot about the battle and not just the typical
- 46:05things about what you can read in any general history book about Gettysburg. He
- 46:09talks about the different relationships between the generalism, you know, why different personalities
- 46:15did this and did this, and a little aspect of that. So you
- 46:20could tell he poured his heart and soul into it. When the game initially
- 46:23was put out for order. He put it on July first, right,
- 46:28it was just the anniversary of the first of the first day of the battle,
- 46:31and it just oozed his confidence and it just oozed his basically representing this
- 46:39is my Gettysburg game. Uh. And when you look at it and you
- 46:43play it, you're like, yeah, this is this is very unique.
- 46:45This is his take on it. It's not his take on it. But
- 46:50you know, you're not going to deviate from the way the battle squad.
- 46:53You know, you're not finding a completely different corner of the battlefield. But
- 46:58these little nuances in the all things that he did to the game just really
- 47:01shines. America seems to me now to be as divided as it's ever been
- 47:10in my lifetime, which which unfortunately is getting getting longer and longer. But
- 47:15how important is the Civil War to fostering these kind of vision divisions and also
- 47:22the sign of view that America has of itself. Yeah, it's very important.
- 47:29But yeah, you have to look at it from an academic point of
- 47:37view and not just fall on tropes of statues and arguments like that, or
- 47:45debates over the flag or whatnot. And again, I look at it from
- 47:49an academic perspective, and from a research perspective, I can respect Robert as
- 48:00a commander. I know he's you know, he fought for the Confederacy,
- 48:07he left the United States, so all his personal feelings, but his commandability
- 48:10was great. I think, you know, as a man he was.
- 48:15He's fallible, like every single person. So there there can I see it
- 48:20as there can be a bit of a duality there. I can understand and
- 48:24appreciate why men fought. I can understand and respect why the Confederacy fought well
- 48:31and why they fought. I don't think they did it for the right reasons.
- 48:40But yeah, I'm struggling with it because, yeah, I'm almost taking
- 48:47a neutral stance on it. But you know, it's especially when I'm researching
- 48:52these games, I am actually judging individuals because on the individual counter form there
- 49:00are ratings for their commandability and reason to inspire it. And you know,
- 49:05more often than not, Confederate leaders will have higher ratings than the Union leaders.
- 49:09And that's just there was a matter of their abilities. And this isn't
- 49:15to say that I'm pro Confederacy or anything like that. It's just my academic
- 49:19background and their research involved indicates that, and especially when it kind of correlates
- 49:24back to showing or validating the results of the game and the results to show
- 49:36the historical outcome. I think that's where it's important to take that academic point
- 49:44of view or the research kind of point of view and so on. That
- 49:47then, how is the Civil War interesting in a military sense, specifically taking
- 49:55away the political level? Militarily is it interesting unique? The Civil War is
- 50:05such a big event in the United States history. It's where the most Americans
- 50:16fought and died, so it is important from the historical aspect and from the
- 50:22military aspect. You talk about the type of tactics involved, and there is
- 50:28this stereotype that men were just lining up in front front of each other and
- 50:31just firing away, and why were they doing that with rifled muskets. But
- 50:37when you play games like Last Chance for a Victory, you are seeing a
- 50:42bit of the nuances that there was a little bit of nuances in terms of
- 50:45strategy and tiny bits of maneuver here and there. So when you delve past
- 50:53the stereotypes, you can see where where the kind of history comes alive.
- 51:00Then you can kind of see where it kind of deviates from these stereotypical things,
- 51:04and in Getty's work, is obviously the biggest or most popular battle in
- 51:09the Civil War because it was pretty much the turning point of the war.
- 51:15The South had invaded the North and it was Lee's last invasion of the North.
- 51:22He was defeated, and if the Union did not when there would have
- 51:28been a lot of negative consequences. So I want to move on now and
- 51:32talk more broadly about historical games and their connection to history. So what role
- 51:39do you think can gaming have in the teaching and learning of history? It
- 51:46helps immersion. You know. One thing I'll do is I want to read
- 51:52a book on history or misery history, even history in general. Sometimes I'll
- 51:59miss the relation between well, okay, I can understand I'm reading it,
- 52:02but I may not understand the context, especially if let's say I'm reading a
- 52:07battle and it says so and so did this and they moved to so and
- 52:13so location. You know, one thing that a lot of war games complain
- 52:16about when they read their history books is that there's always poor maps, right,
- 52:21and you're trying to pull them out and they're like, I don't.
- 52:22They're not able to follow along when you're playing a game or war game in
- 52:27this sense, you have that direct correlation, so you can tie what you're
- 52:32reading in the books and the like, oh so and so uniit because there's
- 52:36the actual explicit unit for that is moving from this place to this place.
- 52:38Oh, I see that, you're going to see that road, maybe you'll
- 52:42see the force around. It's like, oh, that's why they couldn't go
- 52:44around. So it helps with that immersion, and then they kind of perpetuate
- 52:49because when you start playing the games, you might not like, huh,
- 52:53that's interesting. I'm interested in that, so I want to read more about
- 52:57it, so you'll, you know, want to buy more books or read
- 53:00more about it. One thing I make sure I do in my games and
- 53:05even the game that I helped Alfredan is that I'm always including a recommended reading
- 53:08list and a bibliography for all the sources that I use, so that anybody
- 53:12who is gonna pick the interest of that they can go out and read more
- 53:16about it. So it helped gaming and history kind of ties things together very
- 53:24well. And so when I first got into gaming, I found myself put
- 53:31off wargames, and I've developed that stance over the years, but I think
- 53:37the reason I was put off was that it seemed to me that wargames fetishized
- 53:45tactics strategies and never really tried to portray the reality that these are real people
- 53:54being killed in battle. Can wargames teach about the tragedy of war? That's
- 54:02a really good question and difficult to answer because of exactly the way you said
- 54:08it. That there's a misassociation or lack of understanding that when you are pushing
- 54:20a unit forward, like I want to get that objective, you are,
- 54:27in a historical sense, you're setting men to die. You know, typically
- 54:30there's no rules against you throwing one hundred units in to win that objective,
- 54:37because you know, the game says, hey, that's your objective to win
- 54:40the game, and like, heck, these are just things of cardboard that
- 54:45are going to die, not real men. So tying it back to the
- 54:50historical sense of tragedy and the carnage of war, there is that kind of
- 54:55lack. Yeah, it's difficult to answer because it's it is also you know,
- 55:04when you talk about games, there's also the fun factor. Are you
- 55:10having fun playing this game? And that even applies to war games too,
- 55:15right, because you want to make sure that a situation is dynamic, and
- 55:19fun for both sides. But I also want to make sure that what you're
- 55:29also getting at a game is an understanding of the battle itself, from that
- 55:34maneuver perspective, from like why they took it over, but tying it to
- 55:39the loss of men, the carnage destruction and everything like that. It is,
- 55:44It is difficult, and if games do try to broach that, I
- 55:49think it does at times get controversial. So it is kind of difficult to
- 55:53answer because I don't think there's a good melding melding point for that. And
- 56:00so I've found myself as I get older, getting more and more into history
- 56:06and reading more historical books, listening to more historical podcasts, and I've sort
- 56:10of interrogated recently my interest in history. And what I realize is, I
- 56:16think that maybe my interest in history is that it takes me out of these
- 56:22things have already happened, so it takes me out of the mess that is
- 56:25the present day. Do you think, by and large, and interest in
- 56:32history is a form of escapism, and the games play into that. I
- 56:39think it depends. History is fascinating to me because I want to know about
- 56:45the past. I'll oftentimes put myself in those situations, like what would I
- 56:51do. I was just listening to a podcast about the Battle of Lady Gulf
- 56:57and they're talking about, you know, Japanese aircraft carrier sinking and how many
- 57:02unfortunately sailors drowned and died in that, and I'm thinking myself, like,
- 57:07God, that's awful. But you know, when I play a game,
- 57:13Let's say, if I'm ever playing a game on Lady Golf, all just
- 57:15like I just wrote a Japanese character. Yeah, so we did a bit
- 57:22of escapism. And it kind of goes back to the earlier question about how
- 57:25you're kind of tying and relating things together. But I'm still fascinated because I
- 57:30still even though they're you're reading about tragedy, I think it's important to read
- 57:35about tragic events, right because you don't sometimes want history to repeat yourself and
- 57:39you kind of want to know what a crip before. History is not easy
- 57:51and we should know about it. And I think it just helps us grow
- 57:54individually intellectually and probably even so Idle too. And I guess I remember the
- 58:04controversial controversy over the Scramble for Africa game a few years ago, and that
- 58:09struck me as essentially without wanting to be too derogatory, bourgeois squeamishness, and
- 58:16and and not a desire to and and also this this notion that somehow games
- 58:22can't deal with I can't deal with weighty topics. And I guess that we
- 58:30have to get over the fact that history is unpleasant, right or can Yeah,
- 58:36it's a correlation between. I think it's more of the association that games
- 58:40are fun or games are meant to be fun, and I see it as
- 58:45games don't necessarily games, And I'll say war games don't necessarily always have to
- 58:52be fun. They can be analytical. And you look at some of the
- 58:57professional war game is being produced by designers like Sebastian Bay, you know,
- 59:01who are designing games for the US military, because they are studying the consequences
- 59:07and the actions of things like the invasion of Taiwan, potential invasion of Taiwan,
- 59:13and other events like that, so they can be a form of analysis.
- 59:17And I can see that aspect and analyssistant fun needn't be mutually exclusive,
- 59:23right, correct? You talk about from that professional aspect of ones being designed
- 59:30by by Sebastian Bay, you know, for those US military but you also
- 59:37talk about the commercial side, which I am on, and that because we're
- 59:42kind of selling them for profit, that they kind of that they do have
- 59:45to be fun because if you do a more straight up analytical game that maybe
- 59:52doesn't have consequences or doesn't have well defined objectives and to to you know,
- 59:57I I win, you know, whether you're playing the game sorry, or
- 1:00:00whether or you're playing a last chance for a victory, you want to win
- 1:00:04the game. Yeah, So I'm kind of see myself there, but it
- 1:00:13ultimately comes down to you. For these commercial games, whether the war games
- 1:00:17or or any game like that, it is a bit of escapism. But
- 1:00:21games can be other things as well, and they're not necessarily it's going to
- 1:00:25boil down to fun and I kind of try to straddle both of them right
- 1:00:30now. So your next game is the ACA And I'm being incredibly pretentious by
- 1:00:36pronouncing it in the German way, but it's taken me forever to learn bloody
- 1:00:38German, so I'm going to use it if I can. So this is
- 1:00:45this is about the Deutsche Africa Cores. And this seems like a very involved
- 1:00:50game. Is it really difficult to play? It? Is? It is
- 1:00:58not too difficult. Once you get when you get used to the core rules,
- 1:01:01it's pretty I'll say, it's pretty straightforward. This was Dean's take on
- 1:01:10the infamous game of Campaigns for North Africa. So for anyone, the one
- 1:01:15that takes twenty five years to play or something correct and made it infamously by
- 1:01:20by being on the Big Bang theory, because you know, Shelton came up.
- 1:01:22I was like, this is the hardest game in the world, and
- 1:01:23you know, it kind of got a spotlight there. Dean related the story
- 1:01:29that he got campaigned from North Africa. He goes, oh my god,
- 1:01:31it's a huge game. You can fight the whole battle of the Italians,
- 1:01:37Germans and North Africa against the British. And Dean said, hey, this
- 1:01:40doesn't work. It's too complicated or they added so many weird compilated rules.
- 1:01:45So his own take based on that experience was to design Dak Deak for the
- 1:01:54Operational Combat series. So at least from comparing it to Campaigns for North Africa,
- 1:02:00it's easier. Is it a super easy game? Perhaps not, But
- 1:02:06when you get familiar with the rules for operational commentaries, it's it's not terribly
- 1:02:10difficult. It's just a big long game because you're basically playing from you know,
- 1:02:15nineteen forty one or nineteen forty three across the whole North African desert.
- 1:02:20It's a it's a great game. I played it many years ago and just
- 1:02:25you know, just zipping across and playing all these battles in the desert was
- 1:02:30was well, I'm going to say the word fun even though, back to
- 1:02:34our previous conversation. Game and so I'm British, so when I think of
- 1:02:39the Second World War, I think of D Day, I think of the
- 1:02:42Battle of Britain. You're American, so I assume you think about the Pacific
- 1:02:45and things like this. This is North Africa. It's the Deutsche African Core.
- 1:02:51How does doesert combat differ from combat that we we central European combat?
- 1:02:58For want of water? Yeah, it's I remember, I don't know where
- 1:03:04the quote is from, but basically it's desert fighting is like ships under ocean
- 1:03:09fighting, right, because there's no restrictive terrain. You're have an open desert
- 1:03:15and it is very tank focus because you need the mechanization of forces to kind
- 1:03:22of move around. You're not going to have guys trump or on or foot
- 1:03:24out there. Although I think the Italian said, so the style of fighting
- 1:03:30is very different. It wasn't meedable to tanks fighting in the desert because it's
- 1:03:35a perfect environment from the environment for them because they can sweep across on their
- 1:03:39tracks through sand, so there's a lot of back and forth action. There's
- 1:03:45not a lot of natural terrain like forest or rivers to kind of stop there.
- 1:03:51So natural stopping points in the desert is if you actually make it.
- 1:03:57It's actually a man made So at least two battles that were flowed in North
- 1:04:00Africa and World War Two where there was almost a static position for one side
- 1:04:06was a Gazala and La La made because the British had built fortifications and minefields
- 1:04:14all around in the middle of the desert, just because they say, like
- 1:04:16we have to have a place to defend. But of course being the desert,
- 1:04:20you know, the access force has just kind of swept around or kind
- 1:04:24of filtered through it. So it's completely different from a style of fighting from
- 1:04:30Central Europe or even the Pacific. And so why have you chosen this one?
- 1:04:36What makes it special? Similar level to a last chance for victory that
- 1:04:45you know, this was one of Dean's big games, and I kind of
- 1:04:48so. A couple of years ago, Dean listed like, these are my
- 1:04:53best five games that I ever designed, so to list them off, one
- 1:04:57was DAK. This game and actually a lot of them follow on my list
- 1:05:00too. I'm not slucking up to them because I think they're a great game.
- 1:05:03To Dak last blit's great last chance for victory, and the other one's
- 1:05:08case which is not on the list but is a big East Front game for
- 1:05:14for operational comment series. Dak is just fun because it's a big game.
- 1:05:18The counterdentity, which is basically means the number of playing units on the map
- 1:05:24isn't huge, so you're not slogging it with hundreds or thousands of little cardboard
- 1:05:29counter units all over and you're keeping track of little widgets and hunched over the
- 1:05:32table. There's a lot of maneuverability, but also gives us a good sense
- 1:05:36of the kind of fighting that was being done being done in North Africa and
- 1:05:42World War Two. Yeah, and I was saying earlier the experience I hadn't
- 1:05:46playing it years ago was was really enjoyable. You know, just a lot
- 1:05:54of times. You know, your great greatest gaming experiences is from nosology when
- 1:05:58you look back upon it when even if you lose, I get trashed on
- 1:06:02if you had a great time, you have a good camaraderie, which they
- 1:06:05did. When I was playing this game, buildings your head and I was
- 1:06:12like, you know what, I'm going to take this game to the cabinet
- 1:06:14with me. So I want to talk now about the future. So what
- 1:06:16do you have coming out in the future. I have a lot of games
- 1:06:21now that I am helping oversee the gamers out our products. There's a whole
- 1:06:27slate of games that are in the works, some that Dean had actually worked
- 1:06:31on, and of course I never wasn't finished the So I'm going to take
- 1:06:34the helmet and see them through. So if you permit me, I'll kind
- 1:06:39of run through them. Oh you go for your life. The first one
- 1:06:43he has is for his Line of Battle series. It's called No Turning Back.
- 1:06:46It is on the Battle of Wilderness. This was fought in Virginia in
- 1:06:51the spring of eighteen sixty four. It was the first battle between ulyss As
- 1:06:57a Scrant and Robert E. Lee. Really was kind of the start of
- 1:07:01the end for the Civil War. Dean had worked on this for a number
- 1:07:06of years. He was looking to finish up some revisions to it, and
- 1:07:12unfortunate with his passing out, I'm kind of taking over and kind of seeing
- 1:07:14his vision and hopefully getting that too soon. Another game he worked on which
- 1:07:20didn't finish is called Inflection Point. This is for the Battalion Combat series.
- 1:07:26This is going to represent two battles on the Eastern Front, both revolved around
- 1:07:31Stalingrad without actually being about Stalingrad itself. The first battle is the Battle of
- 1:07:36Klock, which was a number of kilometers west of Stalingrad. This is fought
- 1:07:43in the summer of nineteen forty two, where the Germans had wanted to encircle
- 1:07:47and basically crushing capture of the Soviets so they would have an easy walk into
- 1:07:55Stalingrad itself. Obviously that didn't turn out spoiler alert, so you get to
- 1:08:01refight that battle. The second battle in that game is the Battle along the
- 1:08:05Cheer River. So there's a kind of a famous battle that's been mentioned a
- 1:08:10number of times because of one of the German general's biographies and also has been
- 1:08:15studied a lot by the US Army about like a maneuver battle along this river.
- 1:08:19Chier that it was a single pans a division that basically did everything,
- 1:08:25and that's why it's studied by the US Army of like how can you use
- 1:08:30armored warfare in a defensive manner? So we're going to represent both games in
- 1:08:34this and the reason why it's called Inflection Point is because there is a defining
- 1:08:40point, a turning point in and around Stalingrad where the Soviet Union was still
- 1:08:45of coming out of the ashes from our boriation Barbarosa from the year before,
- 1:08:49and then finally after everything got bogged down in Stalingrad, the Soviets were able
- 1:08:56to kind of rebuild themselves, built up the confidence, build up the men,
- 1:09:00prove the morale and launch a big, massive counter attack. So you
- 1:09:02start seeing the turning point in the war in this game. Additional games that
- 1:09:09we are coming up with is going to be the next one after in Flection
- 1:09:12Point is going to be the Battle of Gala, which is in July nineteen
- 1:09:15forty three in Sicily. Also for the Battalion Combat series. I'm also designing
- 1:09:20games on the Fall of France for a Battalion Combat series. A market Garden.
- 1:09:26I'm a big nut and nerd when it comes to market garden. I've
- 1:09:32been trying to study that for the past twenty years, so I'm going to
- 1:09:35put my take on it. Other games that are out there being done by
- 1:09:42other designers and other folks who I'm coordinating with is for Operation Comment series is
- 1:09:48The Forgotten Battles, which is an Eastern Front taking place from September nineteen forty
- 1:09:54three to May nineteen forty four. For the Tactic Combat series, there's a
- 1:09:58Vietnam War game as going to be five smaller battles that are gonna be packaged
- 1:10:01into this, the Five Battles or the I Drang Value basically the Wheaversholdiers movie
- 1:10:09Battle Operation Starlight with the Marines in nineteen sixty five, Operation Pegasus which is
- 1:10:14the relief of Kason in nineteen sixty eight, doc to and Hembriger Hill so
- 1:10:19basically the movie from nineteen sixty nine, or Battle Think About It in nineteen
- 1:10:24sixty nine, and last one is a Battle of Third Karkov for Standard Combats
- 1:10:30series. So yeah, a lot. So I want to I want to
- 1:10:35ask you as a as an expert in wargames for those people listening to this.
- 1:10:41Most of the people listening to this aren't wargamers, but for those who
- 1:10:45are walking curious and want to go over to the dark side. What kind
- 1:10:49of game? What kind of games would you recommend for them as a starting
- 1:10:53point. So we have been talking about Access and Allies. That was my
- 1:10:58start and I have nothing along with that. And again, whether or it's
- 1:11:00an entry level game or not, or you're doing it purely out of,
- 1:11:04you know, for enjoyment, there's nothing wrong with Access and Allies. Another
- 1:11:09game that I have on my shelf, which I kind of started my son
- 1:11:12off with kind of initially, is a game called w eighteen fifteen. It's
- 1:11:17a recreation of the Battle of Waterloo. It's by Ump Games from I believe
- 1:11:21it's Finland. It's a very easique thing because it's basically just a little hard
- 1:11:27work setup and you have blocks that you're positioning where all the historical start lines
- 1:11:31for the you know, the French, Prussians and British and British Allies were,
- 1:11:36and you're kind of pick a card and all the card where certain actions,
- 1:11:42and you kind of roll the dice and see what happens. And each
- 1:11:44time you cause a casual theory you get inflicted on on yourself. You're kind
- 1:11:47of picking up these blocks as a casualty and it determines your overall morale.
- 1:11:54I think it's a great starting game. So basically you could play the Battle
- 1:11:58of Waterloo and in about like fifteen minutes. That's a good entry point,
- 1:12:01and it's serious enough that you're making conscious decisions of what you're looking to do.
- 1:12:10I know, oftentimes other suggestions will be put out there for and you
- 1:12:15mentioned earlier games like Undaunted. Undaunted practically didn't strike me as a good game
- 1:12:20because I see that more as like a deck building game than actually more of
- 1:12:25a direct correlation to what's representing of like you know, man to man or
- 1:12:30you know, squad combat. So again, for my personal take, Undaunted,
- 1:12:35you know, sure you can go ahead and play it, but it's
- 1:12:38not necessarily my cup of tea at least in terms of, you know,
- 1:12:42getting into war games. Let's say, possibly step up from there. The
- 1:12:46series under the gamers line of the Standard Combat series is kind of the straightforward
- 1:12:54games if you if anyone's looking to get into hex En counter war games.
- 1:12:59The core rules is only eight pages, so it's very It's meant to kind
- 1:13:04of harken back to the days of the SPI or the Avalon Hill games from
- 1:13:09the sixties and seventies, whereas straightforward and you're not looking for that fine fidelity
- 1:13:14of complex rules and you know, super detailed the research and everything in there.
- 1:13:19It's movement for that, let's play have quote unquote fun with it.
- 1:13:28So yeah, if anyone's interested, and then usually my recommendation is if you
- 1:13:33enjoy a particular topic, a particular era, look for something in that.
- 1:13:40Usually there's a blankets I hey, I want to get too work. I
- 1:13:42mean, recommend me something and you'll get bombarded with one hundred different things and
- 1:13:46wide rated from agents to super modern, depending on your interest. If you
- 1:13:51are intert in a particular era, there's going to be something out there for
- 1:13:55you. These are the ones that I'm and I'm personally familiar with. So
- 1:14:00your final game then is Valley of Tias, which is one of yours.
- 1:14:03So this deals with the Young Kipper War. What's interesting about this period of
- 1:14:08history It shaped modern Middle East and this particular war was fought by the Arab
- 1:14:20armies where they were finally able to be capable enough to take on the Israeli
- 1:14:27military. When you look at the prior wars that were fought since the Israeli
- 1:14:31independence in nineteen forty eight. They were pretty much one sided. The Arab
- 1:14:36nations weren't able to coordinate it because they usually had their juntas or their brothers
- 1:14:45leading their armies, and then the men wouldn't be well trained or whatnot.
- 1:14:49Finally, by nineteen seventy three, both or both the Syrian and Egyptian armies
- 1:14:56were capable enough of taking on the Israeli military. Right, so it shaped
- 1:15:00a lot of the way the Middle East looks right now and was a direct
- 1:15:05contributor to the oil crisis that occurred right afterwards. And so what inspired you
- 1:15:14to make a game about this period? Yeah, so during during college,
- 1:15:18I read a book called Elusive Victory by Trevor Dupoy, which is all about
- 1:15:24all the war, all the you know, modern Arab was really worse since
- 1:15:28nineteen forty eight, and it kind of fascinated me just kind of reading about
- 1:15:30it, you know, to kind of talk to kind of relate it back
- 1:15:33to Daka. You're talking about battles in the desert and the big sweeping motions
- 1:15:38and tank battles and whatnot. It was fascinating. But you also talk about
- 1:15:42like a lot of the personalities have involved like gold in my ear and Ara
- 1:15:45Sharon and Mono can make them, and a lot of other folks like Saddad
- 1:15:51and Nasa that interested me. It caught on for some reason, and I've
- 1:15:59been fascinated with with the Arab Israeli wars, so at least in thinking,
- 1:16:04hey, if I wanted the design and game on it, I want it.
- 1:16:09Originally I wanted the design a game about all those wars, the Sixth
- 1:16:14Day War, the Sinai Crisis, and the Yamkaor War, but because they
- 1:16:16were a bit one sided for the other ones, the only game that I
- 1:16:19could think of that would be kind of viable from a playability level was a
- 1:16:25Yamka Bor War. And I was mentioning earlier on the design originated back in
- 1:16:31like twenty years ago, dripped some jobs of information. It was it was
- 1:16:36very difficult to find information because even twenty years ago, and honestly only up
- 1:16:44until about ten years ago, there was not a lot of information coming out
- 1:16:49from the Israeli side or the Arab side, And I think that difficulty in
- 1:16:56finding information kind of drove me motivated me to find more, and only in
- 1:17:00the past ten years or so there's been a big opening up of archives and
- 1:17:05information. I've been able to find a ton of information, original information in
- 1:17:12Hebrew, in Arabic on the Yamkapor War, and I've been able to utilize
- 1:17:16and put this into the game. So selfishly, I'll say that Valideers is
- 1:17:23the best representation of the Yamkapor War out there. And I'm not trying to
- 1:17:27be selfish. It's only because I've been able to utilize all these resources and
- 1:17:32marshal it together into this game. So even I'm big into putting designer notes
- 1:17:40and historical notes into my rule books because I want to give the history to
- 1:17:44the players. Whether they read it or not is up to them, but
- 1:17:48I want to provide the historical aspect that my historical findings into those notes.
- 1:17:55So it was a big data dump out of my mind into that, and
- 1:17:59I want to make sure that I kind of portrayed. And I got so
- 1:18:02fascinated with it that I traveled to Israel in July of twenty fourteen. And
- 1:18:11this interesting story about that. Because I traveled, I wanted to travel today
- 1:18:15Israel. Always wanted to to to explore the historical sites like Jerusalem and whatnot,
- 1:18:20and Petra, which I got to visit, which is beautiful, but
- 1:18:24I also wanted to see the goal on heights. So in July twenty fourteen,
- 1:18:30my wife and I landed and there was an incident right before we landed
- 1:18:33where they were Israeli teenagers who were kidnapped. So we landed and we're coming
- 1:18:41back from dinner and basically shared out of a movie, we're seeing people just
- 1:18:45kind of outside looking at TVs like you know, again like shared out of
- 1:18:48a movie where they're kind of looking at it that and the news came out
- 1:18:51that they've unfortunately found the Israeli teenagers murdered in the West Bank. So we're
- 1:18:59like, what do we do, Like, we'll be fine, you know,
- 1:19:02Israel is kind of known for its internal security. Then the next day
- 1:19:06we go out and yeah, sure enough, you know, there's a lot
- 1:19:10of security around the West Wall and Old Jerusalem and whatnot. And so we're
- 1:19:14traveling around the country and we eventually go to to Petro and the only way
- 1:19:17crossing point for tourists to Petras is through a lot in the south by the
- 1:19:25by Alcabo. We go there. Everything turned out fine, but sure enough,
- 1:19:30you know, you've seen reports and news that that's when Hamas started firing
- 1:19:34the rockets into Israel. So my wife is like, what's going on.
- 1:19:39She's freaking out. She's like, you know, like, what do we
- 1:19:42do. We're in the middle of a war zone. I'm like, it's
- 1:19:45fine, and of course, you know my military head, I'm like,
- 1:19:48yeah, the Hamas doesn't have rockets that will that could hit anything, not
- 1:19:53where we are. You know, we were going up to Golden Heights and
- 1:19:56they can't reach out of far Tel Aviv. It's not going to reach that
- 1:19:58far. The only hitting place like Ashkalon and Ashdod, which only a couple
- 1:20:00of miles away from from the border of the Gaza Strip. So I'm trying
- 1:20:03to reassure my wife. You know, go to Petro and gorgeous. We
- 1:20:06come back. I go up through the goal on Heights. Of course I
- 1:20:09didn't tell her. Hey, you know, two days before we flew out,
- 1:20:11there was a shooting with the border. Of course, Syria is right
- 1:20:14next door. It is part of the middle of civil war. I didn't
- 1:20:15tell her that. They said we we got to enjoy this. There's fantastic
- 1:20:18wineries out there. So we were like liquid our bo cells up to give
- 1:20:21us, give us some liquid courage. I didn't meet. Uh. I
- 1:20:26got through that travel. I got to meet an ex pat wargamer who was
- 1:20:30a tour guide. So he drove us around, which is fantastic. Uh,
- 1:20:33Cliff Triggan, if you're hearing this, I'm forever indebted to you.
- 1:20:36So we traveled around the goal on Heights and just to experience, and it's
- 1:20:42pretty much pristine the goal on heights from from the way it originally was.
- 1:20:47Mind you, there's a ski resort up in up in the Mount hermone No
- 1:20:51and there's wineries like I was saying, but scattered throughout the Goal on Heights
- 1:20:57you'll still see recks of centurions and T fifties, you know, T sixties
- 1:21:02and T fifty fives. There's a lot of memorials out there. You know.
- 1:21:08We went to one of the abandoned bases, Israeli bases, and you're
- 1:21:12you're literally looking out into middle of Syria. It is so you know,
- 1:21:17ultimately all of that combined together, it just made me love the game.
- 1:21:21Oh and by the way, so when we finally flew home, in the
- 1:21:28airport's you know, basically in between Tel Aviv and and Jerusalem. Two days
- 1:21:31after we flew out, Hamas was hitting the summers of Tel Aviv. So
- 1:21:34I told my wife that would see what you got out just in time.
- 1:21:39And so you know, you've studied this a lot, and it's one of
- 1:21:45the it's one of the major news stories around the world at the moment.
- 1:21:47I mean, do you see the situation in the Middle East to be intractable?
- 1:21:53Yeah, easily. I mean as much as there's talks, as much
- 1:21:57as there's negotiations about you know, some moments and to say solution and whatnot.
- 1:22:03You can't have a solution when it's been culturally baked in for this long.
- 1:22:13I mean you think how maybe a lot of this started because the Balfour
- 1:22:16Declaration and at the end of World War Two and how everything was sliced up
- 1:22:23and done there and you know, artificial boundaries put up. Yeah, nothing
- 1:22:30is easy. Uh, it's just kind of unfortunately culturally baked in. You
- 1:22:34know. The hope is that people's mindsets change over time, but but all
- 1:22:40for the good, that people were trying to work toward a mutual solution.
- 1:22:45I don't know if that's possible, but I mean call my optimistic side that
- 1:22:50I am hopeful, but I know it's going to take a long time,
- 1:22:53if if possible. So one last question, man, So yeah, you're
- 1:22:59hitting the cabin down the road and you go around a corner and the back
- 1:23:01door of the car flies open. Four of the games flying down into river,
- 1:23:05and I swept away to posterity. Which games your hope is sitting on
- 1:23:09the backseat of the car? Valieteers? Because I that is my opus,
- 1:23:16and it's mostly because of all that input, research and everything that I poured
- 1:23:23my hearts us all. I put my hearts all into all the designs I
- 1:23:25do. But Valeteers is definitely my proudest game because I'm able to meld a
- 1:23:35lot of original newfound source material into that game. I work with Middle East
- 1:23:43experts on it and authors, so it was a bit contributing the contribution from
- 1:23:50a lot of folks into that game. So I'm extremely proud of it,
- 1:23:55and I really hope anybody who does pick up the game understands it. It
- 1:23:58might be complicated for them, you know, it might be not easy for
- 1:24:01them to play. It's it's a pretty big game. It is a big
- 1:24:04game. But just to understand the devotion, I had to kind of making
- 1:24:10a proper game and understanding the history and putting that and demonstrating that in the
- 1:24:16game. I hope people appreciate that. So if people want to get hold
- 1:24:23of you and they want to know when your stuff's coming out, how can
- 1:24:26they go about doing that. I run a blog on board game Game.
- 1:24:30It's called Hans and Carl take Over the Nakatomi Plaza. They're one of my
- 1:24:36gave me buddies is Hans Kishel. He and I were originally had ideas about
- 1:24:41starting up a blog. He's he's gone in and out. You know,
- 1:24:45he's has some you know, life and health concerns, so he's less involved
- 1:24:51with the blog. I've kind of pretty much taken over and I run a
- 1:24:55blog where I kind of give updates about the games. I'll also do you
- 1:24:59know, historical interesting tippits, any findings like that. It's my outlet.
- 1:25:03I can't do podcasts. I can't do you know, video content kind of
- 1:25:09thing, because I think I'm better in the written form than I am in
- 1:25:11the visual form. Plus, you'll also don't have to look at my ugly
- 1:25:14mug all the time, and I can edit myself at least before I you
- 1:25:17know, click to send and put up the blog posts, but folks can't
- 1:25:21find me there. And now that I am helping support the gamers, and
- 1:25:27if anybody does reach out to the multimand publishing, they will reach out to
- 1:25:30me if anyone has any questions. I'm also pretty active on social media,
- 1:25:34which I don't do it well. No, I mean blame Zuckerberg, I
- 1:25:39guess for having that bug they put in you for, you know, just
- 1:25:42wanting to always scroll through Facebook. But yeah, I'm fairly active on like
- 1:25:47Facebook and Twitter. Even in other platforms. I can mess it on and
- 1:25:53discord through various channels, so I'm around. Folks can definitely find me if
- 1:25:57they're interested. Excellent, well, Carl Funk, thank you very much.
- 1:26:01Thank you Ben. You can support the show in many ways. You can
- 1:26:04tell your friends, you can talk about it on social media. You can
- 1:26:08talk about it in your own blog, podcast, or video. You can
- 1:26:10support it directly by going to patreon dot com, forward slash five g D
- 1:26:13for a rolling donation or for a one off donation hitting the PayPal link at
- 1:26:15the bottom of the website five Games for Doomsday dot com. It's these donations
- 1:26:19that keep the show going. Also, if you want to say something nice
- 1:26:23about the show, or if you want to say something horrible about the show,
- 1:26:25you can contact me on Twitter at five Games for Doomsday or send me
- 1:26:29an email at five Games for Doomsday at gmail dot com. And if I've
- 1:26:31managed to leg it from the Dancing Piglets and this feeling that I'll never get
- 1:26:35it back, I'll see you in two weeks for another five Games for Doomsday.