Latest / Windy City Breakdown / Cubs panic level rising after pitching injuries?
Transcript
- Tony Andracki: Everybody welcome into another episode of the Windy City Breakdown. Tony and Drakey here joined by Andy Martinez and Kyle Milanovich. And guys, it's kind of bleak times for the Cubs right now. You know, we're recording this Monday afternoon. Kate Horton obviously got hurt over the weekend on Friday in Cleveland. Forearm injury was almost immediately placed on the IL later in the weekend. Matthew Boyd also on the IL right now with a little bit of a bicep strain and bicep issue. Kyle: you Tony Andracki: So things not looking great from the starting pitching standpoint. We talked, we've talked a lot on this pod just about the depth that they've built up and how they can kind of wait things out until just the steel comes back. But we're immediately seeing that depth tested right now. Right, Andy? Kyle: . Andy: Yeah, it's so funny. We did talk about the depth and we're like, well, we talked about how your side starting the year in triple A and he's coming up and taking Matthew Boyd's spot and we're recording this on Monday. So we might be listening to a side starting on Tuesday. He might have already pitched by the time you're listening, but it's so funny when you talk about all the depth and then you're wondering like, oh, like steel in June. And now you're wondering like, man, what's the soonest you can kind of get him back the way things are looking with the Kate Horton and the Matthew Boyd injury. Cause really like if Kyle: Okay. Andy: If you had another, if you have another injury to the rotation, you're kind of thinking like Ben Brown's probably back in the rotation. mean, think about like some of the depth options that are, think about some of the depth options beyond that, right? Like Jordan Wicks is also hurt, so he's not an option. Like Jackson Wiggins has had one start in AAA, like are you going to try and go to that route? There's some veterans that are in the minor leagues, Vince Velasquez, like that. Tony Andracki: Yeah, you'd love that Andy. Andy: you really start questioning the depth about the start of pitching if another injury happens and that's kind of where it's a little bit concerning with those two guys going down. Tony Andracki: Yeah, Kyle, what do you make of this? actually, real quick, Kyle, before I throw to you on that, Matthew Boyd talked on Monday early afternoon and he reminded me of you right away, Kyle, because he said with his biceps, couldn't like the issue. couldn't point his foot at a certain thing, which feels like the way like Kyle kind of messes up saying sometimes and like goes back and forth with some stuff. like he didn't know exactly where. Kyle: One idiot. Tony Andracki: or when the issue started, but instead of saying point your finger, he said he couldn't point a foot at like a specific moment. Kyle: So he pitched, when did he pitch last? Was it Wednesday against ⁓ the Angels at Wrigley? he went, essentially six scoreless, might've, whoever came in and inherited a couple runs, but ⁓ yeah, I think it might be time. This is the meatball fan. Brown breaking out the panic button. I mean, again, Kate Horton injury, anything, I know it was forearm, but that's. Tony Andracki: Yeah, looks good too. Kyle: That's too close to the elbow for my comfort zone. And the Matthew Boyd thing, mean, he's, he, I mean, they both, have a history, they have an extensive injury history, right? Boyd didn't Boyd have Tommy John in 22. He missed a chunk of 23, obviously, or maybe it was 24, whatever. The Cade thing is, that's... Tony Andracki: Yep. ⁓ Andy: He came back in 24 and debuted against the Cubs. Sorry. Kyle: August 12th, yeah, shut up me. Yeah, it scares me. mean, I think the panic meter is higher on Cade than it is on Boyd just because of the type of injury and then obviously the potential that Cade has. either way, I mean, you guys hit the nail on the head. If you get one more injury, it's like we're fucked. Andy: I was gonna s- I was going to say the K thing. It reminded me a lot of the Justin steel injury last year and just the way the phrasing has been going about by the Cubs or like the I would say like just like how it's being treated. Like the Justin steel injury was like, oh, you know, it's just it's just a forearm. You know, he had he had missed time in 24 with a forearm injury and it was just the minimum stay. And that was kind of like what they were alluding to. then if you remember, he goes on the he has the season ending surgery shortly after. And there was a line that Craig Consul told reporters in Cleveland that I thought was interesting ⁓ when on Sunday before the before the double-header finale where he talked about like, ⁓ he's going to get through all the the evaluations and opinions. And then he like had a brief pause and then goes, as you always kind of do in these situations. And I'm like, if it's just a minimum stay or if it's just like a like a slight concern, like it was being said. I don't think you need a ton of evaluations, right? Like that's where the alarm bells started going off for me of like, this might be more ⁓ serious than they're maybe leading onto. And who knows, again, maybe we'll get more word in a couple of days and it's, it is just a minimum say, but like, at least on the early initial reaction on what's being said, Kate Horn's going back to Chicago to get, get more, more imaging done. Like that's a little concerning. Kyle: Okay. Tony Andracki: Yeah, I mean, I think it is concerning it. There's a little bit of like copium, hopium, like aspect of it started in his wrist and moved up to his forearm. Whereas like you feel like if it's a serious elbow injury, it would we've always heard it like kind of the other way around. The forearm is kind of the thing that that is hurt first, not like a wrist issue. I will say good on Cade for like coming out right away when he felt something, not trying to like push through it. Kyle: Okay. you Tony Andracki: You know, so if it does end up being a shorter stint, even if it's not the minimum 15 days, if it's only three weeks or something like that, like good on him for not pushing through and making something more severe. But like we said, the time of this recording right now, it might still end up being really severe. Like we don't know for sure exactly like how this is all going to play out. And, you know, maybe he does follow the path that Justice Steel has had where, you know, both these guys have had Tommy John surgeries before. you know, steals obviously a little further along in his career than Kate Horton. But it's just another tough injury blow for Kate. And, know, I had the bold prediction before the season that I think he could finish in the top three in Cy Young voting. mean, this seems like it seems like that's probably not going to happen right now just because of this already. Here we are in April 6th talking about this. You know, it seems like it's just it's not going to be a full season no matter what. And now best case scenario, he only misses two weeks. like. Kyle: Okay. Tony Andracki: it might be more realistic. Like you said, Andy, when you're talking about seeing specialists and getting opinions and imaging and all of that done on your forearm, you know, one of the scariest, maybe the scariest area for our picture right away, probably three, four weeks is what we're looking at in a best case scenario. So and obviously worst cases he's done for the year and he made a start and not even a half of another one. So ⁓ definitely scary. And I mean, I think to your point, Kyle, about like Kyle: you A second. Tony Andracki: panic level. mean, I don't think the boy thing is as big of a panic level that to me seems like maybe it crops up and it lingers a little bit. But like that could just be a minimum stay and you don't want to push things with a guy who does have a long injury history. You just don't want to push things at this point in the year. But anytime you see a guy like Cade walk off the mound like that in the middle of the second or third inning, can't remember now. Second inning, you know, like walking off that early is just worrisome, especially when he's Andy: site. Tony Andracki: clearly the best pitcher on the roster too. So yeah, I do think that there is a panic level around the starting rotation for sure. And I feel like about this, you know, this team in general has not played up to its capabilities. Like they haven't won on back to back days. They're four and five entering the series in Tampa Bay. Like, you know, I think it's still early and a lot can happen. And we talked about the start of depth. I think when you pencil in Colin Ray and Javier Asad, like you still have, there's a pretty good options to. Kyle: Realistic number probably six to seven, probably six and a half. My internal panic level probably nine. But yeah, probably six to seven. Tony Andracki: to fill even if it's your one or two starters in Boyd and Kate Horton. But reasonable panic level. mean, Kyle, if you were to put a number on it, what would you say one to 10 panic level for Cubs right now? Andy: you Tony Andracki: What's the difference? What's the difference between like internal and like realistic panic? Kyle: I think that makes sense. probably being optimistic or pessimistic. Like I feel like I'm, like if you have Colin Ray and Javier Asad starting making 25 to 30 starts each, that's not good. ⁓ but if it's more like 10 to 15 maybe each, if that, then it's the panic level goes down significantly. But I mean, they're obviously not bad options, but ⁓ ⁓ at the same time, I think you would rather have Matthew Boyd and Kate Horton. Tony Andracki: you Yeah, Andy, what about you? What's your panic level? Are you think right now for cubs or rotation or whatever in general? Andy: guess for the rotation, yeah, you're probably like at a seven or eight but like for the Cubs and like it's so funny because like you guys always give me crap for being like the negative one like I'm honestly like I like a four or five like ⁓ of those some of those games were like weird games right like the like the the second Cleveland game I understand like ⁓ second double header game excuse me in Cleveland that the Cubs lost like I understand like ⁓ Ben Brown situation but like I ⁓ understand correct console of like Ben Brown covering these innings to save the bullpen at the back of a double header with three games coming up in Tampa Bay. Like I understood that logic. like you're not, you're not really like pushing the levers that you would normally push later in the season because you're trying to protect the roster health like overall. like, yeah, you'd probably want them to be, you know, they're, four and five. You'd probably want them to be like six and three or seven and two for sure. But like realistically, like you've had some crummy weather days you've had. Kyle: Okay. We're good. Andy: ⁓ two injuries to your rotation now like you're figuring out your bullpen pieces Yep, you've been without say Suzuki and also they've run into some crappy luck I was like I saw the tweet and I looked up the double check to double check the stats still Going into Monday's games the Cubs are still second in hard hit percentage Among all as a team among baseball like they're hitting the ball hard. They're they're they're squaring up balls Tony Andracki: You're without space. ⁓ Andy: Alex Bregman kind of like that felt like the epitome of that first home series where he felt like he was hitting the ball hard every single time and it was finding a glove or it wasn't dropping. Like the offense is going to come around, which is what we kind of figured would be, you know, the strength of this team if all goes well. You want that to, you figure that's going to turn and that's going to start leading to some better results. I understand some panic because it's early in the season, but I think if this was June and the Cubs were amidst a four and five stretch. Kyle: ⁓ huh. Andy: the panic level might be in the four or five range compared to like the six or seven. Tony Andracki: Yeah, I agree completely. I think it's the time of the year weighs heavily on this. ⁓ I'm probably, you know, overall for this team at like a three or four. And I think all of the three or four is solely contingent upon Kate Horton's health. You know, if if if Horton just had a biceps injury the same way that Matthew Boyd did and both around the IL, I mean, I'd probably be at like a zero or one panic level. mean, I think that. It's just all it's all contingent on behind Cain Horton. But that being said, I think the panic level with this rotation is at a nine right now. mean, Edward Cabrera has not stayed healthy his whole career. Shota Minagas had issues staying healthy, obviously, just in his brief MLB tenure. Last year he had the hamstring injury that then affected him the rest of year. But, know, Jameson Tyrone has been on the aisle a couple of times like Kyle: you you Tony Andracki: You're you're an injury away from one of those guys are just limping off a mound or slipping on wet grass or something away from being like full blown panic mode. You going back to what you said earlier, Andy, of like who comes up next? I mean, you have Kyle Wright, you have Vince Velasquez in the minors, but neither guy has really pitched much in the majors over the last few years. So it's it's tough. It's it's not a great spot for them to be in right now. you know, there's still a month and a half plus before Steele comes back. Like I think it's May 24th is the first day for him to come back. but yeah, overall, I mean, the offense will warm up as the weather warms up. They will get more consistent with, with better batted ball log and say it coming back is going to help things out too. I think that'll kind of raise the floor at the very least. So panic level overall. Yeah. I don't think, you know, really that big, but, I mean, this Kate Horton stuff, I think their season Kyle: you you Tony Andracki: relies pretty heavily on him. And if he goes the justice steel route of last year and this is the only six innings or whatever that he pitches this year, think that's a really, really tough position for them to be in. And it's just something that's really tough for them to climb their way out of. But anything short of Cade Horton being done for the year, even if he misses two, three months, like I think, I think they're still in good shape ⁓ as the season moves along. Andy: Yeah, for sure. I think that's why you accumulate this kind of pitching depth for this certain situation. You hope it's tested in May, June, July, as opposed to April 6th, but that's the situation that comes around. Tony Andracki: So Andy, you talked about Ben Brown situation, the second game in the doubleheader on Sunday, Easter Sunday, doubleheader in Cleveland. Cubs win game one, one nothing, lose game two, six five. ⁓ Just take us through Andy, that whole Ben Brown situation. I know I saw Cubs fans I rate on social media about correct counsel and the decisions he made, but you... already made my argument that I was going to make in this earlier, just about like how counsel has to pull these levers needs kind of relies on Ben Brown. But like, Andy, just your thoughts on the bullpen moves that that council made, especially in game two. Kyle: Okay. Andy: Yeah, like if you pitch in game one of a double hunter, especially in April you're down for game two like you're not pitching in game two unless you go into like the 14th or 15th inning and you desperately need arms. So you're you're Tony Andracki: So that takes DL Barr, who threw 28 pitches to Milner and Palencia. Those three guys are down. Kyle: Okay. Andy: Right, so then you're looking at the highest leverage guy I think left in that bullpen was Phil Maytown, which is like 4-3 game, sure you want to bring him in. But then you put him in there, you don't have an 8th, 9th inning guy. And I understand the situation of like, well you don't get there without it. But it's also April, so you want to save him for the 9th inning, you want to save him for the 8th inning. You can afford to do that in April. And in the Ben Brown situation, if you're able to cover the three innings with Ben Brown in that situation, or multiple innings, then that leaves you with three fresh arms, if he doesn't use Jacob Webb, Hunter Harvey, and Phil Maton, that leaves you with three fresh arms to start ⁓ Monday's opener in Tampa Bay, which then maybe you can give Palencia a rest, who's already had a pretty taxing start to the season with the WBC and everything, and give some of those other guys that pitched in game one a rest. You put yourself in a position to kind of rest your bullpen where you're not taxing them in April so that... Kyle: . Andy: when you have to pitch them four times in five days or ⁓ two in a row or something like that later in the season, they can do that because they haven't been gassed. That's why it's so important to have a Ben Brown or a Colin Ray in the bullpen early on in the season because it can cover those multiple innings that you're not burning through your bullpen in April in trying to chase games like has been in the case in the past with the Cubs. Kyle: Okay. Tony Andracki: Yeah. And I think it was, it was a really difficult spot. To me, Ben Brown gets a lot of the heat, but I think like what, what his issues were, was it not just like a Ben Brown? think, I think Sunday's game too, was more of a Jacob Webb issue than Ben Brown truthfully. Like, so Brown comes in, are still up three, nothing. Then Ian Hap, know, gives the Cubs a four, three lead. Jacob Webb comes in, gives up three runs. They're suddenly losing six to four. Like. Kyle: Okay. you Tony Andracki: To me, I think it's a Webb issue and like Brown, you know, had a little bit of an up and down first couple outings. I've looked amazing outing two of the season. First outing was, you know, a little bit hit or miss, gave up a homer, right? But the third outing, not great. Still that told, like all told, he's had a pretty solid start to the season. Jacob Webb and Hunter Harvey have not been what the Cubs hoped they were going to get. Both have really struggled. know, Webb has a seven something ERA, but his, peripheral numbers are even worse than that. His expected array is like 12, you know, and Hunter Harvey is has struggled as well, too. So like where I get, ⁓ you bring in Ben Brown, like Cubs fans are like crucifying Craig Council for this. like, I don't know where you go either. I mean, that's not the case for Riley Martin's MLB debut. That's not the spot for it. Ethan Roberts, your 27th man, you're not bringing him in there. Like you said, you can bring in Phil Maton or you could bring in Jacob Webb or you could bring in Hunter Harvey. Kyle: Move. Okay. Tony Andracki: Fine. like, Meitan in the sixth inning of a game, that's I don't know if that's the best time for it. You have to get so many more out. Hunter Harvey and Jacob Webb, I would I would go to Ben Brown to over those guys like I have more trust in Ben Brown right now, even after yesterday, after Sunday's outing than than Harvey or Webb. Just the way they've looked. ⁓ You know, they've both been hit hard. It's just. It's been a difficult start for those two guys. They have some decent track records, so I think they can clearly iron out the creases here. But I feel like there's just not really a lot of great moves for Council to pull, great buttons for Council to push there. Andy: Yeah, that's like the difficulty with a double header is that like you're not managing it like a normal game because you're either having the piggyback effects of game one or you're trying to plan ahead for game two. You almost like split your bullpen in two of like, all right, these four guys I'm going to use in game one and these four guys I'm going to use in games two. ⁓ like, yeah, like you have to like, you have to throw Jacob Webb and Hunter Harvey in situations. Kyle: So. So. Andy: to and get them like they're not going to correct their mistakes or figure out their issues by sitting in the bullpen and not pitching but like you also want to protect these guys and Ben Brown has to pitch these multiple and he has to cover these multiple innings and then when he runs into trouble you have to have the hope that Webb and Harvey are going to come in and do so and obviously Jacob Webb didn't do it on Sunday afternoon Sunday night Sunday afternoon like that's where you that's where the issues stem from I agree like it isn't totally a Ben Brown decision there's question marks about him for sure like what What is he, what are his roles? Like what guy are you going to get on a given day when it comes out to pitch? like that was that Sunday's wasn't totally on Ben Brown. Tony Andracki: Kyle, what's your take on this? do you... Do you kind of armchair manage alongside console as you watch games like this? Kyle: Yeah, no, no, it's funny is like I think people online Manage like they're playing video games where every game every guy has a hundred percent stamina or it's like that's what's That's not real life. So and I mean, I'm not gonna Tony Andracki: Yeah. Kyle: Everything I would say is what Andy and you guys were both saying earlier is like, if you pitch game one, you're not going to pitch game two, especially in April. But what really got me thinking was you obviously get the extra guy, the 27th man for a double header. I'm curious what you guys think. Do you think it makes any sense, especially maybe even in April to get two extra guys, like two extra pitchers for a double header? Just because I mean, there's so much, I don't even know what the phrase would be. There's just, I mean, there's so much caution with arm injuries and not over extending guys does it make sense to have two extra arms for for double headers so i mean think the cops are now playing their third game in essentially 28 hours here like it's taxing for bullpen guys so like in this situation i'll say just the first month of the year like up until may 1st do you agree with that disagree with that that's something i've been thinking Tony Andracki: That'd be cool. just, don't know how you have a different set of rules for a certain month. That being said, obviously you have expanded rosters in September. So I think, I think there's like something of a precedent for it. And we've never seen something in the beginning of season, but I don't see why not. And honestly, along those lines, like, I don't see why you can't have 27 guys in March and April to help pitch your injuries anyway. And that last guy's a pitcher and then. Kyle: Yeah. Tony Andracki: If you have a doubleheader in March or April, you get a 28th guy. then it kind of like, you're talking about. Like, I think that would actually make more sense to me almost than this September call up where they have right now. You get two extra guys and it's just kind of a weird fit right now. Kyle: Mm-hmm. Andy: It's what they did after the COVID, or after in 2021 and the 2022. Remember the first month of season, there was 28 men on the roster because of the short and spring training and all that. And it is interesting that in September, like theoretically when you're like kind of at your peak or like built up, they added two extra roster spots and obviously it used to be 14 or 15 more extra roster spots or up to that amount. But like at the beginning of the season, when you're like kind of trying to get your feet under you, they're like, no, you're playing. Tony Andracki: ⁓ yeah. Kyle: you Andy: You're playing with the 26 guys. I mean, I think a lot of it goes down to like the CBA and like that creates more jobs and do owners want to pay more for players? Like, you know, we're already seeing the labor issues pop up now. Like I think creating an extra spot even for March and April, probably the owners probably wouldn't like that a whole lot. Tony Andracki: Yeah, I think that it would be difficult to come to pass, but I do think it makes a lot of sense. ⁓ but also it, it, it invokes this strategy too. Right. So like, I think one of the things that council does really well, one of the reasons why he's paid $8 million a year, one of the highest paid managers in the game. I don't know if he still is the highest paid. I don't know how manager salaries, but like, you know, the reason is because of how he handles his pitchers, but, but more so like how he views the big picture. Andy: I agree. Tony Andracki: throughout every game of the season. He does that, I think, better than any other manager in the game. Now, admittedly, I haven't seen every other manager, like, manage on a daily basis. But that was his one of his calling cards in Milwaukee is like, you don't use Josh Hader, Devin Williams, some of these top guys when the team is down. Like, you save those guys, you don't burn them out. You don't tax your pitching staff in April. You know, that's why that's how you get to the point where, know, it's like Craig Timber and Craig Tober, right? Like of Kyle: Okay. Tony Andracki: September and October of like the Brewers were always hitting their stride and taking off was because he did what he could. Some things out of your control. Kate Horn, Matthew Boyd injuries. But he did what he could to keep the big picture, the long view in mind. And I think that's exactly what he did yesterday on Sunday for the double header is like, OK, we're not going to tax Palencia. We're not going to tax Thiel Barr and Milner, who also has looked really good. Like these are three really important guys. We got one win. We got that one nothing win we held on. Of course, it'd be great to win game two as well, especially when you're staked to a three nothing lead. But like, is it really the end of the world if you lose that game? If it means that you lose a pitcher, if it means that you have a guy, you know, have like a shoulder injury or something like that. Like we're seeing right now when Houston, one of the best pitchers in the game is Hunter Brown, and he threw a hundred and two or something pitches on opening day. He was the most out of anybody in the league. Then the next time out, he rarely through on like the regular five day routine last year. Then he comes out, throws on that like five day routine, was kind of banged up or like, you know, I guess came out of it not feeling great. And now he's on the high with a shoulder injury and we don't know what his season, the rest of his season is going to look like. like by the Astros pushing their young ace too far, too hard, too quickly, it may impact them the rest of the year. And that's what council doesn't want to do. So it stinks. And like, and I'm with you, Kyle. I feel like people manage a lot like it's video games. But I think people also manage a lot like they don't think about the big picture and they don't think about 162. They think about like, I got to win this game right now. I want to win this game right now. And there's that's great. And I love that. I'm super competitive and I would want to do that, too. But that's why what I think makes counsel so great as a manager and why his players do love him and play well for him is because he thinks about all of that kind of stuff. And so, yeah, it really does like stink from the Cubs perspective that they blew that lead. But also, like, you know, again, you need if Jacob Webb pitches what he's supposed to and Hunter Harvey comes in after and then Meitan, we're not even really talking about the Ben Brown thing that much. It's mostly I feel like because they lost that we talk about it. But but I do feel like the Webb and Harvey additions so far have just not panned out ⁓ again. Very, very small sample size. like the Cubs need those guys. to pitch meaningful innings this year and they needed to kind of right the ship at the Kyle: Do you think it takes Craig a little bit of time to figure out where guys roles will be in the bullpen like a month or two and guys obviously getting accustomed to to Craig's setup so to say Andy: Definitely think so and I think we saw that last year where it's like I think he goes in and I think every team does this I think he goes in where it's like these are probably my three leverage guys and maybe this guy's my closer or my ninth inning guy ⁓ But I think he's very adaptable and and like and gives guys opportunities and I think this goes to kind of what Tony was saying it's like He will try things or he will put he'll push guys Maybe he'll push Ben Brown for for an extra inning or situation to see how they do because I think it's one of the most important things when you're trying to develop a bullpen. It's like early on in the season, do you punt a game and lose a game to push a guy in a leverage situation or push a guy, maybe an extra out batter or something like that? So A, for the learning experience, B, just to save the other bullpen arms. And does that help you win two more games later on in the season because now he develops? I think back to Palencia last year where first save opportunity in Miami, He blows it right he had two strikes two outs he blows it and like it would have been really easy to say all right like this guy can't do leverage situations like Let's go back to Ryan Presley and and and poor. think Porter Hodge was still healthy at the time Let's go back to those two guys and and plenty can go back to low leverage or going back and forth between Iowa but two days later he went right back to him and He picked up the save and obviously took off from there and now he's the everyday closer or the full-time closer It's do you punt that one game in Miami because it gets you 22 more saves the rest of the year or do you try and chase that one game in Miami and then you don't maybe get Maybe you don't get Palencia like that's that's the ultimate conundrum and that's what Craig Council does so well as you mentioned Tony Tony Andracki: You know, I do think that I think it takes all managers, Kyle, like time for. Time to build those, the bullpen kind of the way you want it. I think bullpens around baseball are on shaky ground all of March and April. I think like unless you have an entirely veteran lading group, but even then guys get off to slow starts or kind of banged up like. relievers are so volatile, maybe a little less volatile nowadays than we've seen in even the somewhat recent past. like there's still guys that kind of come out of nowhere and have incredible seasons. Brad Keller, example, last year, even Drew Pomerant. But like, you know, it'll take some time, I think, to for everybody to kind of get right. And you also figure like the bullpen is probably not firing in all cylinders at the beginning of a season anyways, because Kyle: Okay. So Tony Andracki: when you have eight guys down there, the chance of all eight guys pitching at the top of their game, right? To start out the season when maybe you're physically not even in your prime, like we talked about in like, you know, in August or September being a lot different than March or April. So, yeah, I do think that that's all a factor here too. But ⁓ I do want to talk about one guy specifically in the bullpen is Riley Martin. We didn't see him in the doubleheader at all, you know, but he comes up Andy and You have a tie to him just based off of the Quincy tie in Illinois. Andy, tell us a little bit about Riley Martin, what Cubbs fans can expect, and just his journey to the majors and how kind of cool this story has been. Andy: Yeah, we overlapped in college for like a year. So I was it was my last year and it was his freshman year. And the baseball program at Quincy's always been really, really good at the D2 level. They reached the college World Series, I think it was 2017 or 2018. So like there was a standard of high success at the Division 2 level. The former coach, now the athletic director, Josh Rabie played at played for the twins for a couple of years in the 2000s. And he kind of ran the program like a like a high level college program with like how they trained and the expectations and he picked up a lot of fringe D1 guys that kind of developed the program. And with Riley Martin, was a guy who was a really good D2 college pitcher, which there's a lot of really good D2, D3 college pitchers that like, that's kind of like their max, right? Like they're just gonna hit that peak. ⁓ And so his senior year was the 2020 season and he was under the impression that like, all right, I'm gonna pitch 2020 and then I'm gonna go to pharmacy school. I'm hitting 88, 89 miles an hour on a fastball. I'm not going to get drafted, but I'm going to try and reach the College of World Series and have a good season. And then obviously the pandemic happened, season gets cut short. So he gets the extra, the season. So he calls SIU Edwardsville and he's like, Hey, I'm going to defer my acceptance to pharmacy school. Like I want to pitch one more year. don't want my college or my baseball career to come to an end like this. So he worked out, he lifted a lot. He had built a gym in his, in his home. and lifted and suddenly he was throwing 94, 95 and was using a four seam as opposed to a sinker. He was striking out everyone. He set the school record for season strikeouts, wins, all of that. And that led to being a senior signed draft pick. So he signed for a thousand dollars, right? Like nothing out of the draft. And teams usually do that with senior guys because they know it's like either you sign for these a thousand bucks or you're not going pro. ⁓ So he did that and then he went through the minor league grind and was at AAA for parts of four seasons. Then finally got the call up on Saturday and was in the big leagues. So that was really, really cool to see his journey where it's like this is a guy who literally was going to pharmacy school, had his mindset on wearing a white coat and filling out prescriptions and now he's wearing white pinstripes and the Chicago Cubs uniform, which is just an awesome journey. Tony Andracki: Yeah, it is for sure. And I mean, think it's it's always kind of cool to see those guys get their shot. And I don't know how long he'll be up here. I think it's a little bit unique to write as as like, you know, another lefty when you have the bar and Hobie Milner and stuff. you know, Andy, what what can excuse me, what can Cubs fans expect from him and what role do you think he might play in this? Andy: Yeah, I mean, it's clearly going to be low leverage to start and I think it's going to be a multi inning relief role. Like that's kind what he was doing throughout his minor league career where he's kind of been pitching longer relief situations. But credit council mentioned this in Cleveland, like they have a lot of lefties Tampa Bay does and Cleveland did. So you want another lefty in the bullpen for that reason. And he can cover length, truthfully. Like we mentioned, like if you're in a situation where either you're up bigger or down big. Maybe he can come in and cover two or three innings and when he does, he does still strike out a lot of guys. I think it was 80 strikeouts over 64 innings last season at AAA or something like that. It was insane strikeouts to innings pitch ratio. But there are still questions about the walk. He had a lot of walks. He's lowered them each year in the minor leagues, but the walks are still heavy there. So that'll be one thing to watch is he might be able to strike out lot of guys, but will he be doing it with traffic from the walks? you're like also refer for like that's why you watch sports where you watched the the underdog story watch these guys that were supposed to be doing what they're doing doing it at the biggest level Tony Andracki: And one of the guys that Riley Martin was just playing with down in minors in AAA, Kevin Alcontra, he's tearing it up in AAA to start the year. ⁓ Lower average, you only 220 range, but seven hits so far this season, six of which have gone for extra bases. Four homers, eight RBI, two doubles in there, slugging 700 with a 1.02 for OPS through the first eight games. This is, again, we're recording before he plays on. at all this week after Sunday's action. Kyle, I'll throw you first. Is it time to call up Kevin Alcontra and take into account, where would he play considering Seiya is coming back later this week too? Kyle: That's why I'm looking at his baseball reference page here. It's so crazy to think he's only 23 years old. I feel like he's been with the Cubs for a decade. Tony Andracki: Yeah. Yeah. Well, I mean, yeah, you came in the Rizzo trade, which is crazy to think about, Kyle: Yeah, I so he's literally been in the organization. This will be his six different season in with the Cubs So yeah, I mean he's just so young it's it's crazy to me. No, don't bring him up I mean, I think if you're gonna bring him up you have to play him every day You're not gonna bring him up to sit on the bench, right? Like what the fuck would you do that? I mean as much as I love the power I he's still hitting 233 which isn't the best but take just take all that out if if you're bringing up you're playing him every day and not to say he shouldn't be up but I'm just saying Tony Andracki: Yeah. Kyle: they're not going to bring him up because he probably won't play every day. my definitive answer is no. Andy, what say you? Andy: ⁓ I wonder if there's like a buyer's remorse or like a second guessing themselves of like should they have been up on opening day? Right and and been playing right field every day I mean, obviously you wouldn't have known and then there's no there's no guarantee that he would have been having the success at the major league level it's a big jump from AAA to the majors, but like He was he was one of the final cuts again this year like he was last year for the opening day roster like they have been better off in right field defensively and offensively who knows right and and ⁓ right Kyle like the time to bring him up is probably past Just because ⁓ not he's not gonna be playing every day and as hot as he is if he's playing once every fifth day like ⁓ not gonna continue that success. So you just want him playing every day in case like an injury happens to ⁓ or yen happer or Or say Suzuki or by a sterile's word. Maybe the path to everyday at bats ⁓ increases Kyle: Okay. Okay. Tony Andracki: Yeah, I think he would be playing every day over Matt Shaw. And that's tough to do when you feel like Shaw's earned it. Right. And and the Cubs clearly do. I don't have an opinion one way or another, whether Shaw did or didn't earn an opportunity to play right field pretty much every day, as he has and say, his absence. But but I think the Cubs feel like Shaw has, you know, that he went out and played a bunch of different positions this spring after playing really well at third base. mean, they've they've jerked him around a little bit, right? Like they've moved him all over different positions and. Kyle: Okay. Tony Andracki: ⁓ Turned him into a super utility guy and this was their top prospect or at least in their top two or three Consensus, know just a year ago at this time so to to kind of do that with Shaw and then you know be like hey go to the outfield cuz say has heard and Okay, play there in Wrigley Field with the wind and the Sun possibly creeping in and just you know some some difficult and a difficult like environment ⁓ I think he's done a really nice job with that too like handling all of that. So And yeah, I don't think there's any guarantee that Alcantara would come up and be slugging 700 with four homers and eight RBI in his first the first eight or nine MLB games of the year. ⁓ I do think that like big picture wise, this is huge. And like I think Cubs fans should really root for Alcantara even to have the success even at the AAA level, because next year we've talked about this just on the last couple of podcasts about who the Cubs should extend. You have Seiya Suzuki, you have Ian Hab, both in their last year of their deals. Alcantara very well could be the Cubs starting left fielder or right fielder next year. He's out of options after this year, right Andy? Like this was his last option year. So the Cubs have a decision to make after this year anyways. Like they have to carry him on the 26 man or risk losing him from the organization or they have to trade him or they give him like an everyday spot. And to your point initially, Kyle, like if you're gonna include him on the 26 man roster next year in his age 24 season, Andy: Yep, yes. Tony Andracki: you're going to want to play him every day. Like this is still one of the top prospects in baseball. A top 100 guy, one of the top of the organization. So I think it's just huge to like for the Cubs organizationally to see a really big year out of Alcontra who like has not really put it all together. Like we've talked about this before and he's like tantalized his potential. But like, I don't think he's really had like that big breakout statistical season where you're like Kyle: So Tony Andracki: ⁓ yeah, this dude had a year like PCA did a couple of years ago or even like Matt Shaw is down in the minors, right? We're like, yeah, I feel really good about this guy. Look at the numbers, you imagine, you know, kind of dream on how that would be at the big league level. So I just think that like the Cubs would be in a really good spot if Alcantara goes out and has a great year, even if it doesn't come in the big leagues in any level, because it might help solidify a spot next year in one of the corner outfield spots. Andy: Yeah, and that's the thing. It's like if he plays up to his potential and then you don't worry about losing one of Hap or both or maybe both Suzuki like that's ultimately what you want and again, like I've mentioned it on this podcast. I've spoken to you guys about it. Like the other thing that's tantalizing about him besides the hot start he's having with his bad is defense is really, really good. Like if you put him with PCA and an outfield and you couple that with all the the infield success defensively that you have Kyle: Okay. Andy: Like you're talking about a really, really elite defensive team. And if you want to, if you decide you want to throw say Suzuki on left field, or if you bring back Ian Hap, ⁓ Gold Glover in left field, now you're really just talking about a really, really good defensive team where your pitching staff is gonna just gonna love playing in front of those guys. Tony Andracki: Yeah, definitely. So I mean, I agree, though, with you guys, it's not time to call him up right now. But I think really cool that he's off to such a hot start down there. Definitely will bear watching throughout the rest of this season or at least the rest of this month, depending on how injuries play out for the position player group. But they'll do it for this edition of the Windy City Breakdown. Stay tuned later in the week. We're going to have a two podcast week. We have a guest joining the show for Thursday's Cubs off day. So. Stay tuned there, check us out wherever you get podcasts on Spotify or Apple Podcasts or in video form on YouTube. Thanks as always for tuning in and checking us out.