Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️99 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 22nd Sep Landscape Designation Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. There's a sadness and heaviness in my soul this evening, as we have come to the conclusion of our landscape designation topic, and will not be returning to it within the lifetime of this public inquiry. Four short days to neatly package up and reframe The Sperrins. Should this mine go
- 1:17ahead, at once that generational connection to landscape, and therefore the history of the people is for ever lost. The Heist Sperrins contains within it the whole rich vibrancy of life, the headwaters of the rivers, the home for the butterfly, badger, hare, and salmon. It cradles the song of
- 1:41the wind, its very being risen from its own peat bogs, its quiet rounded symmetry insulted by jarring industrialisation, harshly lit by night, endless roar and thump of heavy machinery murdering its very earth by day. Humanity needs soothing right now. The race for the accumulation of resources
- 2:08has never been quite so ugly, so devastating, or so urgent. Here we are on the brink of our lives being taken over by AI, as we rush headlong to fill the maw of that beast. Why should we believe the story and spin of what we are being told? Where have we lost our collective ability to question and analyse
- 2:33the daily narrative, and why are we not doing this? Sitting through the public inquiry since April 2026, there is a growing and profound understanding of what we are witness to is really the outline plan for the industrialization of The Sperrin mountains, creating a new, different baseline for future
- 2:56generations to become accustomed to. To pause and step back is a profound and rebellious thought that interrupts the default of establishment thinking. Left brain machine logic world only works for half our brain, or you might say half of our lives. Our creativity and sense of ease has been attacked and eroded in all
- 3:23sides, from the cancelling of university art degrees to the downgrading of the importance of nature. Combining these with the pervasive and insidious impact of social media and the instant dopamine hit, serve to collectively undermine that other half of us that is urgently in need of nourishment,
- 3:45that deep life impulse that flowers from within us is wholly sustained by the places in nature such as these Sperrin Mountains, whose very soul is the earthiness and dance of life. The profound loss of our last wild places furthers the disconnect from that intangible awareness connected to our
- 4:06consciousness, on which the right side of our brains are wholly dependent. We do not quite understand the outworking of this yet, and how it will impact the future of humanity. So, after that rather broader reflection. Let me bring us back into the room, and what actually happened on this final day of
- 4:28landscape evidence. Much of the morning came down to something very simple: what will the place like look in the dark? Because the nighttime visualisations came under fairly sustained questioning. Fermanagh and Oma District Council challenged whether the photographs actually represented conditions they were
- 4:49said to represent, and whether they showed anything like the amount of lighting that would be visible across the valley. We heard again about the light. Around the portal, the conveyor, the dry stack facility, the water treatment works, and the security areas. Miss Oxley, speaking for the applicant, says
- 5:11that with properly controlled lighting, you shouldn't actually see the light fittings themselves, or significant glare or spill. What you may see is the ground being illuminated, which led to the question: If the ground is illuminated, then from the other side of the dark valley, you are still going to
- 5:32see light. Then we got into the timing of the photographs.
- 5:39Pat Hawley pointed out that one of the images presented as a nighttime visualisation had apparently been taken during the summer, when, according to the meteorological information he referred to, there should have been daylight or twilight, and yet the photographs looked dark. That produced quite a debate
- 5:58over sunset, civil twilight, nautical twilight. Who knew there were such things, and even whether the camera might have been recording Greenwich Mean Time rather than British Summer Time? Miss Oxley explained that night photography has to be taken at dusk, otherwise, essentially, you end up
- 6:19photographing a black landscape. Her position was that these were dusk images and that they represented a precautionary or worst-case assessment. But the wider question remained: Do these images really allow you to understand what a large industrial site operating in what is presently a very dark
- 6:41rural landscape will actually look like at night, and there's another reoccurring theme from yesterday. Not everything is in the visualisations. Moving vehicles aren't necessarily shown. Some security lighting isn't shown. Fencing has changed. Operation activities come and go, and the water
- 7:03treatment works will have lighting of its own. Individually, each of those things might be described as relatively small, or transitory. That has been the word for this week. It's appeared almost every day, transitory. But the argument from the third parties, was you don't experience a
- 7:22landscape one item at a time; you experience it all together. Taking us neatly to cumulative impact, the overhead power line, the existing exploratory mine, the proposed mine itself, and the other development across The Sperrins have largely been assessed through different pieces of work. The applicant's
- 7:45case was that the necessary cumulative assessment had been carried out, and that significant cumulative effects from the power line were not predicted. But mr. Ingham reckoned that an assessment combining all of the applications together had not been undertaken. You need to
- 8:03take into account the sequential effect, because this isn't about standing at one carefully selected viewpoint. Travel along the Sperrin scenic route, and you can pass the proposed mine site, then encounter the overhead power lines, and later travel through the Uncleoo Valley, where the existing
- 8:26exploratory mine sits. So the question becomes: What happens to your experience of this landscape as you move through it? After lunch, we moved on to conditions, and conditions can sound desperately dull until you realise that this is where promises made during an inquiry potentially become enforceable
- 8:49requirements. There were discussions about the colours of buildings, local provenance for planting, soil depths, restoration periods, monitoring, and how long aftercare should continue? And then, Dr. Stephen Emerman returned to an issue to the issue of perpetuity. Savers Sperrins has proposed
- 9:12monitoring, inspection, and maintaining of the main waste of the mine waste facility in perpetuity. The applicant argued that sufficient controls already exist, and later referred to a proposed 15-year period. Doctor Emmerman's response was that perpetual monitoring and maintenance wasn't something
- 9:32Saver Sperrins had simply invented. He referred to mining industry guidance and argued there is no known way of constructing such a facility and simply guaranteeing that it will last forever without ongoing inspection, repair, and maintenance, and that left us with a bit of a contrast: 15
- 9:53years versus forever. One thing we didn't finish today was lighting conditions. That discussion has now been pushed forward to the 15th of October, and with that, four days of landscape evidence came to an end. So I guess that left us really with one question today: When you introduce a mine,
- 10:16roads, power infrastructure, lighting, security, machinery, and waste facilities into this rural landscape. Are you assessing each component separately, or are you properly considering what happens to The Sperrins when all of those things become part of the same place? And that seems like the
- 10:42right point to hand over to Dr. Amy Streicher, who has been sitting through all four days of this landscape session and has kindly agreed to give us her reflection on what we heard.
- 10:55Hi, Marella. So, just a few observations on the landscape topic after the last day today, so first of all, I think we never really got into an in-depth discussion on on designations. There were three subtopics planned for discussion under landscape, and they were designations, restoration, and
- 11:20methodology, and we spent most of the time discussing restoration and methodology, and not really going into the designations, the landscape designations, and whether this project and this development proposal would be compatible with those designations, which is what I thought we would be
- 11:44discussing under designations. So we did discuss special countryside area, but we didn't really discuss the AONB, the area of outstanding outstanding natural beauty, which is an important national designation, and of course the application site sits fully within the AOMB, and it's very rare, very rare
- 12:07that a mineral extraction project of this scale would be approved within. But aside from the AOMB, I mean there are other designations as well, and the commissioner said we'd return to these on other days, and that's fine. But I think it's worth mentioning that, you know, we do have several landscape
- 12:27designations in this area, and if we're considering, you know, cumulative impact, we have to consider the impact in all of these designations, which all interact with and will be seriously affected by the project and its various applications, and you know we only have to look at national
- 12:48planning policy. So the SPPS, which is the Strategic Planning Policy Statement for Northern Ireland 2025. I mean, there's several provisions in there that restrict, or that, or more or less say that development proposals that negatively impact on the integrity of protected sites, be it international and
- 13:13national, that they will be restricted. So that you know, there are statutory obligations. There's also the precautionary principle. So, paragraph 6.174 says planning authorities should apply the precautionary principle when considering the impacts of a proposed development on national or
- 13:38international significant landscape Or natural heritage resources, and I mean we've heard over the past few days, but also in previous sessions that there will be significant adverse effects on the landscape. I suppose there's a dispute between what the applicant Considers the so the
- 14:03applicant is trying to argue that yes, there will be localised adverse effects, but that this won't affect the overall integrity of the AONB. But that's really not the question, and it's the wrong question. It's not the it's not the policy test anyway. But anyway, aside from designations,
- 14:24I mean, there are other serious issues here. We have the fact that the landscape management plan for The Sperrins, which was entered into evidence, I mean, all of the objectives, all of the values of the landscape identified in the landscape management plan, which is the outcome of an 18-month extensive
- 14:45consultation with multiple stakeholders across The Sperrins, and is a much more robust assessment of how the landscape is valued by people in The Sperrins. You know the landscape management plan. Basically, provides a more accurate overview of landscape values, landscape
- 15:07susceptibility, and landscape objectives for planning, management, and protection of The Sperrins landscape. And I think what what's interesting about the plan is that it prevents it presents a very different view of the landscape than the applicant does. The applicant is kind of saying,
- 15:25well, apart from construing landscape really narrowly, one of the things that the applicant is saying that is is that the mine will somehow save the area. You know, as if this is you know the area needs a mine. It doesn't need the mine at all because if you look at the landscape management plan, you
- 15:45can see that actually an industry that is growing in and around this part of The Sperrins is tourism, and that's directly connected to the landscape. I mean, and that's a kind of an alternative form of development for The Sperrins, one that's already underway, and one that's just not compatible with, you
- 16:07know, with a a project of this scale and magnitude. Let me see. Yeah, I think there's another point to make, and that's the, you know, throughout the applicants' documents, and just even in some of its argumentation is is this idea that the human settlement in this is part of The Sperrins is
- 16:32somehow a reason or a justification for further development.
- 16:37I would say it's actually even more of a reason for rejection and a refusal of this project because it's actually the human settlement which is a major characteristic here, and it's precisely the human dimension that renders the proposal to to greater risk, and that's even if we consider the minimum
- 16:59distances in other countries between mine tailings and homes, you know. So People's Republic of China, it's 10 kilometres between a tailings or a mine waste facility and nearest homes or dwellings, and the same in Brazil. You know, so to think that you have homes within a kilometre of this mine waste
- 17:22facility, you know, and a primary school and all the rest, I mean, it doesn't really bear thinking about, you know. So it's not just that it's incompatible with the designations, but it's it's unfathomable when you think about the risk, and especially given the critiques of Dr.
- 17:38Emmerman in relation to the design of the mine tailings facility. So, yeah. So there are a lot of problems here. And then I suppose just the last point. I mean, there's so many points to make, but the last point is that with all of the proposed mitigation and betterment plans, and all of the conditions
- 18:00proposed so far, and no doubt there will be more. We're supposed to take this gargantuan leap of faith, you know, and rely on essentially the the promises of the applicant. The risk is not worth taking. Anyway, so I will leave it there, Marella.
- 18:23You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in
- 18:41the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our
- 19:00voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.