Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / How to Utilize Compliance to Fast-Track Your Business Growth
Transcript
- 0:20Welcome to this very special edition of the cage, a
- 0:23masterclass life, that show, which ensures that you profit
- 0:27from your time. Spent here with experts, either
- 0:30through the industry, insights information, or simply learning
- 0:33from them. And today, we have Tom Fox, the
- 0:37voice of compliance founder of the compliance podcast Network,
- 0:42and he is also the compliance evangelist.
- 0:45If you can call him that, that's what he wants to be caught,
- 0:48Welcome to The Showdown. Thank you very much.
- 0:51It's my privilege pleasure and honor to be with you today.
- 0:55Thank you. Tom, thank you.
- 0:56Welcome to the show. Welcome to India.
- 0:58And a lot of people across the globe would under, try to
- 1:02understand this issue better from you.
- 1:05You are the compliance evangelist you have written the
- 1:08compliance handbook, Third Edition, and so many other books
- 1:12on the subject. So my first question to you, Tom
- 1:16is to what is a compliance evangelists to Got odd.
- 1:21Casting the compliance evangelist.
- 1:25I took that name because in ancient Greek, and evangelist
- 1:29was the bringer of the good news.
- 1:32And I think, for business compliance is the good news.
- 1:36I believe that more effective compliance equates to Greater
- 1:42business efficiency, which at the end of the day, means
- 1:45greater profitability or Roi. So, I see compliance.
- 1:50As a business process which actually makes companies
- 1:54stronger, it makes them better and makes them more resilient
- 1:57but most importantly, it makes them more profitable so that's
- 2:02why I took the name compliance evangelist.
- 2:04The podcasting is a natural outgrowth of my blogging.
- 2:09I started in this field in 2010 in private practice and I
- 2:14blogged and in 2012, I added podcasting.
- 2:19It just seemed to be another way to reach my audience in 2017.
- 2:24I founded the compliance podcast Network and now we have over 65
- 2:28shows about compliance on the compliance podcast Network.
- 2:34Wonderful wonderful. Now from a business point of
- 2:38view from the businesses perspective.
- 2:41You so say that you know compliance we can make you more
- 2:44efficient and profitable but before that you know let me
- 2:49understand from a Layman's perspective.
- 2:51What exactly is compliance compliance people do understand.
- 2:56They do know about complying to certain things but want to
- 2:59understand from your perspective and especially small businesses
- 3:04A lot of individuals are there. Do they also have to come, do
- 3:09the do anything with this compliance?
- 3:12So comply, it started as a response to legal issues.
- 3:18So in the United States, there is a law which prevents us
- 3:23corporations for making bribes or corrupt payments outside the
- 3:27United States, all the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.
- 3:31So compliance began as A way to Simply that comply with that
- 3:37law, but compliance has evolved into a business process.
- 3:43Now, the original law was passed in 1977 and compliance was seen
- 3:51as a legal response initially into the first decade of this
- 3:56century. Then it evolved to a business
- 4:01process. And here's why.
- 4:03Because compliance is based upon your internal controls, and
- 4:09internal controls our financial controls.
- 4:13So any company that has ifs our accounting reporting us.
- 4:20Gaap attorney accounting reporting is subject to any us.
- 4:26UK Western Europe. Europe or deed Indian oversight.
- 4:30As a public company has some form of accounting controls.
- 4:33They have to have in place to assure that there's no fraud
- 4:38waste and abuse and now and and compliance can is built on those
- 4:44controls. So that's why I say effective
- 4:48compliance can make you more efficient because effective
- 4:51compliance is largely internal controls and that's what drives
- 4:55the business business efficiency of Of a company and that's why
- 4:59it's a business process. Two things here.
- 5:03Come first is if your compliance is such a good thing and it is,
- 5:08it can be profitable, it can lead to better efficiencies, why
- 5:12don't you why don't companies want to follow it to the extent
- 5:16that they should do? It is not doing more profitable
- 5:20or doing is more profitable, then you would not be doing a
- 5:22podcast on this. You would be doing doing much
- 5:26much better stuff and you know, helping them Elevate their
- 5:30companies. The better man well actually no
- 5:36I wouldn't because the United Nations estimates that three
- 5:41trillion dollars is lost to the world's income annually due to
- 5:46bribery and Corruption. So the problem is truly
- 5:49worldwide in scope, it's not limited to one region, it's not
- 5:53limited to what country is not limited to one set of people.
- 5:57It is a worldwide problem and so Alliance.
- 6:03Was in response to this problem and first of all so I'm a lawyer
- 6:08by professional background and as a lawyer I found compliance
- 6:13was a way for me to help fight this International scourge of
- 6:17bribery and Corruption bribery and Corruption leads to
- 6:21criminality. It leads to terrorism.
- 6:24It leads to Deaths of innocent people through faulty
- 6:28construction. It leads to corruption at the
- 6:32highest levels. Of government, it leads to
- 6:34dictatorships and it leads to a wide variety of - business and
- 6:41personal consequences. So, first of all, the as a
- 6:46lawyer, and as someone in compliance every day, I get to
- 6:50help in the fight against International bribery
- 6:54corruption, number one. And number two is the reason
- 6:58many companies, well, the, the amount of He lost bribery and
- 7:04Corruption shows to the problem, but many companies believe, if
- 7:07they take shortcuts, they'll be better off.
- 7:10Well, for any businessman, if it's a one-person business man
- 7:16or it's a 10,000 person business, if you engage in
- 7:21bribery corruption in the long run, it will hurt your business.
- 7:25Number one, you won't create as good a product or deliver as
- 7:30quality of service. But number two, once you start
- 7:34paying a bribe, it doesn't stop people don't say oh you paid me
- 7:39enough Rives, they say no you got to pay me more if you want
- 7:41to continue this relationship. So once their claws are in you,
- 7:45their claws are in you because what are you going to do?
- 7:48Go to the police and say they're demanding, more bribes for me.
- 7:52And then number three is really this, this whole notion of
- 7:59corruption at the highest levels of government.
- 8:02You live in a democracy. I live in a democracy.
- 8:05We're both privileged to live in democracies, but if you look at
- 8:09dictators across the globe and you name the country, you see
- 8:14that they are paying bribes to their friends, Russia is the
- 8:19most prominent example right now, simply because of the
- 8:22Russian invasion of Ukraine. But that's not the only example.
- 8:25So I'm a big believer in democracy as the way we all
- 8:30should be governed because it allows people.
- 8:32Like, you and me to participate in our government even if it's
- 8:35just when we vote. So, I view this is all tied
- 8:40together. Now, for the business person,
- 8:43the reason you want to do business in compliance is it
- 8:47makes you more attractive as a business partner.
- 8:50If I come to India and I look for an agent to sell my product
- 8:55into your country. I want someone who is familiar
- 8:59with compliance, who's had some compliance training has no
- 9:02background. And or history of engaging in
- 9:04bribery and Corruption, it's going to do business the right
- 9:07way. Because as an American, I'm
- 9:09responsible for that agent. And if that agent in India
- 9:13engages in bribery corruption, I'm the one that has to pay for
- 9:16that, either from criminal or civil prosecutions.
- 9:20So a business person who can demonstrate that they do
- 9:25business in compliance, it's going to make themselves more
- 9:28attractive for a business partner from a country such as
- 9:32The United States Brazil, United Kingdom, you name the country,
- 9:37and it's a business positive. Right, right on if I understand
- 9:45a lot of companies want to comply with the local laws and
- 9:50do it several times, they've been use that in a different
- 9:55country, some American company or European continent, company
- 10:00has given some sort of, you know, some favors to somebody or
- 10:06the even government officials in a particular country.
- 10:10And then later on in In investigations, it was commit,
- 10:14came to know that it has happened.
- 10:16Now, how do company, what do you advise companies when it comes
- 10:21to? Because there is so much of
- 10:22competition, especially for Global firms.
- 10:25They want business, they want to comply with the local loss, but
- 10:29at the same time, they have to look at the business interest.
- 10:32Also, they want business and several of the situations is
- 10:37that you have to do this stuff not in terms of Your money
- 10:43exchange, but in other sort of favors and it is it is everybody
- 10:48comes to know about it. How do you deal with that?
- 10:52And what is the way out? That you suggest that they
- 10:56comply and still do not lose on the business because somebody is
- 11:03asking for some assistance as they may call it in some other
- 11:08manner because several times governments, government
- 11:11officials. If we say, Say, put pressure
- 11:14obviously not in writing, but through another other means.
- 11:18So there's a couple of different ways to look at that.
- 11:21Question to give you an answer number one.
- 11:25It is the company's responsibility to make sure they
- 11:28have controls in place to prevent bribery and Corruption.
- 11:33If I could make the analogy, if I work for a company and I
- 11:38defraud that company, I am stealing money for that, come
- 11:42from that company for my own personal benefit.
- 11:44However, a might do it, if I'm Going to engage in bribery and
- 11:49Corruption. I'm still stealing money from
- 11:52the company, but I'm not keeping it for myself.
- 11:55I'm using it to pay to someone else.
- 11:57It's a long way of saying to pay a bribe.
- 12:00You have to create a pot of money, or a pool of money.
- 12:03And so, whether that however, you create, that pot of money,
- 12:07and that's where company's internal controls are so
- 12:09important. Because if I, all of a sudden,
- 12:12have a 50,000 100,000 of 500,000 dollar marketing expense, So,
- 12:18when my annual marketing spend has been 25,000 a year for the
- 12:21last five years, that should tell someone, there is a
- 12:25problem, or at least ask the question of mr.
- 12:28Fox, why have you increased your marketing spend from 25,000
- 12:31dollars to five hundred thousand dollars?
- 12:34Now you can hide bribery funds in a variety of places but the
- 12:38key is the company has to have internal controls in place.
- 12:43Under the US law. It is it prevents payment to a
- 12:49government official What if the government official says?
- 12:55You know, we really like to do business with you but we want
- 12:58you to invest in our local community.
- 13:01And we want that investment to be a hospital.
- 13:04Well, if a company, then builds a hospital for the communities
- 13:09use. That's okay.
- 13:11Or that's legal. So the key is The law prevents
- 13:17the US law, prevents payment to a specific government official.
- 13:21But if you say Tom, I'd like a soccer field and I build you a
- 13:24soccer field. And that soccer field is used by
- 13:26the community. That's not viewed.
- 13:28As in the illegal bribe under us law.
- 13:33Okay. But in terms of say, if it's not
- 13:39a democracy, how do companies meet expectations government
- 13:45expectations around client compliance in a country like say
- 13:49China, how do you do that? So, number one, and you raise an
- 13:54excellent question because you have to look at the overall
- 13:58risk. Is my risk in China.
- 14:01So great that I have to pay a bribe, to get a contract.
- 14:06If that is my risk, perhaps I shouldn't do business there,
- 14:10perhaps I should go to Taiwan perhaps, I should go to India,
- 14:13perhaps I should go somewhere else, so if you have to pay a
- 14:17bribe to get a contract, that's probably not a place.
- 14:20You can safely do business. Number one, number two is most
- 14:27companies who make clear they Not pay bribes.
- 14:32Eventually the government official will accede to that and
- 14:36honor that with number three and perhaps most importantly, what
- 14:43we've seen particularly from China with their belts and Roads
- 14:47initiative is many. These were massive
- 14:50infrastructure, construction projects, I think, well,
- 14:53intended for the countries where they did them, but what we've
- 14:56seen is because of bribery and Corruption these Projects are
- 15:02substandard and that many are not working.
- 15:06Now, or the roads are not usable now or whatever.
- 15:08The construction project was. Well, that's as a direct result
- 15:11of, instead of using the money in the project, they use the
- 15:17money. So, some of the money to pay
- 15:19bribes. So, if, if your government
- 15:22accepts bribes, you may get a substandard project and it does
- 15:26you no good. If you've built a road for
- 15:29miles, but you can't use it. Okay, know how do you define
- 15:35bribery and Corruption? Because the law might be
- 15:40different though. Everybody understands what a
- 15:42bribe is but you are an advocate you lawyer, how good you look at
- 15:48bribery as Carlson? How do you look in the United
- 15:51States? Is it as simple that you don't
- 15:54have to pay money as you said, if you are doing something for
- 15:57the community but in any other place, if they say, Listen, this
- 16:03is this project even if it's a hospital or something for the
- 16:07community, you give it give the contract to The Minister's son
- 16:13and he will do all the work and that.
- 16:16And then you do it in their ministers constituency because
- 16:20and you don't want to do it. But you got to this, do the
- 16:23work. How do you define primary in
- 16:26that sense? So there's a couple of different
- 16:30questions there are The start with the question of what how do
- 16:34I Define bribery bribery is giving someone something to
- 16:39cause them to do something that's illegal so it can be
- 16:48payment of money. It can be tickets to the World
- 16:51Cup, it can be first-class travel across the world.
- 16:55It could be a lavish party, it can be a lavish event.
- 16:59It can be a shopping trip in Dubai.
- 17:01It can be a lot of things, other than the old-fashioned way,
- 17:05backs of cash, out of the trunk of a car.
- 17:07Although we still see that occasionally, so it's getting
- 17:11someone to do something, they wouldn't otherwise do.
- 17:15Now in the situation, you raised is absolutely spot-on.
- 17:22Minister says, I'd like a hospital.
- 17:25And here's my selected list of contractors to build that
- 17:29hospital. I perform due diligence and my
- 17:32son-in-law owns one or all of the company's, well, that could
- 17:40be seen as a bribe. But if the son-in-law comes to
- 17:44me and says, here is my proposal, here's my proposed
- 17:50spending here, is my proposed profit margin, and all of those
- 17:54are in line. With a reasonable business
- 17:58proposal and a reasonable profit 510, perhaps a little higher
- 18:02percentage and not 100% profitability.
- 18:06Then that would probably be acceptable.
- 18:10Because once what I've just described as a business process
- 18:13for looking at a proposal and hopefully every company will
- 18:17look at a proposal in that same way.
- 18:19And if there's no business reason to use the contractor,
- 18:23the minister has suggested You shouldn't move forward at all.
- 18:28Okay. What about I'm Steve's in many
- 18:34cases or in any other did? There is no substandard work or
- 18:41product involved. Like, even in arms deals, many,
- 18:44a times we hear this particular deal has taken place.
- 18:49And there were middlemen, and there was commissioned and all
- 18:52that stuff, and it's a huge amount of money.
- 18:55Several times, they say a better product was left behind some
- 19:01substandard product was but many, a times you have bought
- 19:03the right thing now is buying the right thing still and paying
- 19:10to middlemen. You know, there are different
- 19:12ways to be people are very smart, we don't know about it,
- 19:15at least, I don't know about it, there are offshore accounts now
- 19:18they're Bitcoin and all that stuff.
- 19:20So how do you look at that is bribery only for standard thing.
- 19:27Is it to pass? Get your some something wrong or
- 19:30not. Not does not meet the law.
- 19:32So you pay the bribe and you get that work done or is is the law
- 19:37still applicable US law. That you are getting the things
- 19:42done and right things done but still you are you are paying
- 19:48money in the name of several times in the name of commission.
- 19:51How do you look at sure? So what Have described as
- 19:56actually happened. So we have real cases.
- 20:01Basically, with the fact scenario you have discussed,
- 20:04there is nothing wrong with using a metal man.
- 20:07There's nothing wrong with having an a commission, sales
- 20:10agent, there is nothing wrong with having a distributor which
- 20:13is a different sales model. The key is number one does that
- 20:18middleman bring real value, real business value.
- 20:22And number two, how much money? Is the middleman, keeping
- 20:29meaning, what's their cut, what's their profit?
- 20:32Because if they're if they have a million dollar sale and their
- 20:36commission is 1%, is that a lot of money?
- 20:40Certainly yes. And it may be a lot of money in
- 20:43certain countries in the world, but that's generally going to be
- 20:48seen as a reasonable Commission. And if their Commission on a
- 20:53million dollar sale, is 20% you began to immediately see that is
- 20:59not reasonable because a large part of that money could be used
- 21:04to pay a bribe. So if you think a get once again
- 21:08is a business process, you have a middleman, you have an agent,
- 21:11you've done due diligence investigation on his background
- 21:14or her background they have no history of bribery and
- 21:19Corruption either in Criminal cases or in social media.
- 21:23So to newspapers that sort of thing you have a they're
- 21:28performing a business service, they then receive a reasonable
- 21:34commission generally seen between one and five percent.
- 21:37Recognizing if it's a billion dollar contract, one percents a
- 21:40lot of money and then that you monitor that payment and you pay
- 21:47it to an account, you can see meaning.
- 21:50Not an offshore account. Now, I realize once you pay
- 21:53them, they can transfer that to somewhere else.
- 21:57What if I'm an American company and I've transfer money to the
- 22:01National Bank of India, there is visibility into that.
- 22:05And I have some comfort that it's not an offshore account, or
- 22:09an illegal account, or some other account.
- 22:12So then and then I monitor to the extent possible, the end
- 22:17user because I'm going to have a business relationship.
- 22:20Up with that end user because they're going to need parts,
- 22:24they're going to service, they may be training or instruction.
- 22:27So if I have done my business process, right?
- 22:32You can see all of the steps you would take from the business
- 22:35perspective. Well, another way to say it is,
- 22:38those are internal controls and those are internal compliance
- 22:41controls. I've the way I described it was
- 22:44the business process of a sale though.
- 22:46So that's why when we started visiting together, I said,
- 22:51Increased or more effective compliance can lead to Greater
- 22:54business efficiency because you can have greater business
- 22:58efficiency in that overall sales process.
- 23:03Right, right. No, these are big companies.
- 23:06The CEO or the country manager, outside America, who is
- 23:10representing that company? People generally think that the
- 23:16country managers life or the CEO life or the vice president's
- 23:20life, who's looking after the particular region or a country
- 23:24is very cozy. Very nice.
- 23:27What is your experience is? It is it that nice, as it looks
- 23:32like to be? The topmost man in tough or is
- 23:35it, is it a tough job, maintaining his position, as
- 23:40well as maintaining and looking at the bottom lines from that
- 23:43company? Because it drops he loses his
- 23:45job. How you sit in the central
- 23:47position? A lot of American companies and
- 23:50other companies, they are brought work across the globe.
- 23:53How would you like to like to help us understand the position
- 23:59of the man who has to look after generating?
- 24:02The Business because everything looks good when we talk, but
- 24:06when it comes to actually getting the word on the ground,
- 24:10they have to deal with people and governments everywhere,
- 24:14including China, Russia. Any other country can name it.
- 24:20That's the responsibility of the company.
- 24:23The company's responsibility is to do business ethically and in
- 24:27compliance and have a culture, which says we will do business.
- 24:32Ethically and in compliance, and we will not engage in bribery
- 24:36and Corruption. So that message is the
- 24:39responsibility of the CEO in the corporate headquarters, wherever
- 24:43that might be and that message has to be communicated.
- 24:46Throughout the organization, you can communicate that through a
- 24:50series of incentives, IE bonuses, IE promotions raises,
- 24:57And you can also punish people who violate that General
- 25:01culture. The United States Department of
- 25:04Justice, says it all starts with culture.
- 25:06So if you have a culture of compliance when that American
- 25:10arrives in your country, he or she understands.
- 25:15Yes, I have to hit numbers but I have to hit numbers doing
- 25:18business, ethically, and in compliance.
- 25:21And if I cannot do so, then I have to find a way to do so, and
- 25:26that The responsibility of the country manager, but if the
- 25:30corporation has a culture of compliance and then monitors
- 25:35through some of the strategies, we've talked about already and
- 25:37internal controls. That's, that's how a company can
- 25:41ensure that someone who becomes a country manager can hopefully
- 25:46meet their quotas, but also doing it, ethically and in
- 25:49compliance. Right?
- 25:51What about small companies, dog? They are just growing and
- 25:56startups. They want to expand and they're
- 26:00very small T. They go to a country democracy
- 26:03or even, you know, conservative countries and there they think
- 26:08they don't have that much of wherewithal like a large
- 26:11corporation. Can have how do they do with
- 26:15this part because there might be a day that today they have to
- 26:20get their work done. Run through mediators to
- 26:22middlemen through any other agency, which say that they will
- 26:27be able to get their work done and they try to get their work
- 26:30done at that point in time, they want to grow. and later on this
- 26:35thing, because, Things cannot be hidden and later on it comes to
- 26:40light. How do you look at people who
- 26:43want to grow and as well as be compliant in terms of local laws
- 26:49wherever they want to go? So we have talked about sort of
- 26:55compliance in responding to Regulators such as the United
- 27:00States Department of Justice. The United States Securities and
- 27:03Exchange Commission, other regulators, and other countries.
- 27:06But we've been talking basically about criminal law.
- 27:10But there's another reason to do business, ethically, and in
- 27:13compliance, and that's your business reputation.
- 27:16And if you go to a country as a very small start-up or small,
- 27:21Enterprise and you engage in bribery and Corruption and you
- 27:25get away with it and you grow your business?
- 27:28Well, I'm not quite sure if your professional background but I
- 27:32come out of the energy industry and I've lived overseas and
- 27:39everybody knows is doing dodgy things.
- 27:44You know, everybody know what we call it in the energy industry
- 27:48or sharp operator. Everybody knows who the sharp
- 27:51operators are. Well, what happens is, if that
- 27:55small company then becomes a larger company, their reputation
- 27:59is now tarnished and other companies are there countries
- 28:04may not want to do business with him.
- 28:06So that's really the other reason to do business ethically,
- 28:10and in compliance because it's the reputational damage that
- 28:14your company will suffer and hurt their long-term growth as
- 28:19well. Right.
- 28:22Right, not. Let's look at companies from
- 28:25outside. So, for example though, this is
- 28:28this may not be the ideal one but I will try to understand for
- 28:31a company like Tick-Tock or the owner by dance and all whatever
- 28:35it is the way they have registered.
- 28:37And it's a company from outside. Suddenly there's AA, the US
- 28:45government files that it might be, you know, doing things that
- 28:50they are not comfortable with how do companies from outside
- 28:54comply with the u.s. laws or continue to comply with us laws
- 29:01and not suddenly become become difficult for them to operate
- 29:06whatever way we want to. I say, as I said, Tik-Tok may
- 29:09not be the perfect example for that, there might be The other
- 29:12companies, certainly the business environment is not
- 29:15good. Between the political
- 29:17environment is not good between the country, and the goods that
- 29:20you are providing to the US, they start having those checks
- 29:25and it's some some some, some problem starts dropping off.
- 29:29How do you ask the company separate from India or any other
- 29:33place? Be able to comply with the u.s.
- 29:38loss and be comfortably continue to do.
- 29:41So. So let me answer that by saying
- 29:45that, if I come to your country and I'm privileged to do
- 29:48business in India, I'm only privileged to do.
- 29:51So if I comply with Indian Law, whatever those laws might be,
- 29:54they may be different than mine. They may be different than
- 29:57America's laws, but they're your laws.
- 29:59And if I'm going to do business in your country, I not only have
- 30:03to respect your laws. I have to comply with your laws
- 30:06and the same is true of a Chinese, Indian British
- 30:09Brazilian, you name the company that might come do business in
- 30:12the United. United States.
- 30:14Now The Tick-Tock example may be different, I won't say more
- 30:19difficult but certainly different because there are
- 30:22other issues about data privacy data, security ownership by a
- 30:30foreign government agents, all of those sorts of things.
- 30:33The key there is transparency. If Tick-Tock if the United
- 30:37States government says, we are concerned that the Chinese
- 30:40Communist party is the ultimate owner Tick-Tock Tick-Tock as to
- 30:44show them who the owners are in a transparent manner under, you
- 30:49know, applicable US law. So in responding if I come to
- 30:55India, and I have to respond to the Indian government's inquiry,
- 30:59the answer is transparency. If Tick-Tock comes to the United
- 31:02States and has to respond to the US, government's inquiry, the
- 31:06answer. Once again, is transparency.
- 31:08So responding is transparency, but I have no Mm, if I come to
- 31:14India and you or your government all the way to the Prime,
- 31:18Minister says Tom, you have to comply with any law.
- 31:22I think that's. It should be that way.
- 31:26Okay, let's look at the business park in the Russia, Ukraine
- 31:32conflict. Now a lot of companies across
- 31:36the world especially in the United States and the Europe.
- 31:40They were operating in Russia and out the outcome was that
- 31:44many many companies withdrew from them in whatever form.
- 31:50There will be a time, they have taken their own positions,
- 31:54whatever reason whatever it is it's up to them.
- 31:58After some time, the world will be different.
- 32:02The world thinks will be normal again, hopeful whenever
- 32:06hopefully Will this companies? How should these companies?
- 32:13When they go back to Russia, business has to keep going.
- 32:18How should they position themselves?
- 32:20Because right now they have taken a position.
- 32:23Tomorrow, they have to go back to the same country and comply
- 32:26with those laws at that point in time.
- 32:31Many companies have taken business, you know, position,
- 32:36which is related to business. But because of their own ways,
- 32:41of either political, understanding of their
- 32:43themselves because of, moral, ethical, whatever reasons that
- 32:47they what should the how do you advise such companies?
- 32:52What is the way? What is should be their stance?
- 32:55Is it the correct way of looking at it?
- 32:57What about Russian companies are there Russian companies?
- 33:00Still operating in the u.s. some subsidiary, something or the
- 33:05other. How are these things happening?
- 33:08Because India is doing business with Russia.
- 33:11We have and things have been very open because we do things,
- 33:15whatever makes good business sense for a country.
- 33:18That's the way. That's the Sovereign part of
- 33:20every country that they can decide for themselves.
- 33:23How do you look at this help us? Understand how is it between
- 33:27Russia the business between Russia and and And the u.s. in
- 33:31terms of business from Russian Russian companies in the US and
- 33:36US companies in the in Russia. So first, let me start with,
- 33:41you're absolutely right. Things will change, not
- 33:45hopefully, but eventually they will change and I would point
- 33:48you to France and Germany. In the 1950s became very big.
- 33:52Trading partners are having fought a horrible conflict in
- 33:56WWII America's biggest, trading partner, In Asia Pacific is
- 34:02Vietnam and, you know, the Vietnam War still ingrained in
- 34:07many people's minds. So, the old enemies can become,
- 34:14if not friends at least, trading partners and can at least
- 34:18coexist. So things will change.
- 34:21Now, what happens when they do change?
- 34:25What happens is, if I am American company will say, Tom,
- 34:31Fox, Energy company and I want to go into Russia after all
- 34:36sanctions have been lifted, Ike that is my right to do so, but
- 34:41they are, there will be some risk.
- 34:43I can't tell you right now what that risk will be, but I have to
- 34:46assess that risk that risk may be well, if Vladimir Putin is
- 34:52still in power, I may have to leave again.
- 34:56If I have to leave again, am I going to have to leave all my
- 34:58equipment? What's going to be the cost of
- 35:00that? If I have to leave again?
- 35:03What's going to happen to my employees?
- 35:05Are they going to be arrested and held as hostages?
- 35:10So, what I have to do is Tom, Fox, Energy company is assess
- 35:14the potential risk from a geopolitical basis.
- 35:18As you've talked about a little bit earlier and then assess,
- 35:22what potentially could be the cost.
- 35:24If I have to leave again and are there steps I can take to
- 35:28mitigate that risk. So, for instance, on the
- 35:31equipment, could I RIT equipment in Russia.
- 35:35That yes it would hurt if I lost it but I wouldn't be losing.
- 35:39Billions of dollars worth of equipment.
- 35:42Can I employ people safely? Perhaps not in US citizens,
- 35:46perhaps their citizens from other countries.
- 35:49That would have less risk of being held hostage by Russia.
- 35:53Perhaps someone from the stands or some other country that has a
- 35:58better relationships with Russia.
- 36:00So part two of that is is assess your risk and then try to risk
- 36:07or manage those risks through a risk management strategy.
- 36:12Okay. Okay, okay.
- 36:14Drum. You have explain things in such
- 36:16a nice manner to each and every question several of them very
- 36:19open in it and very difficult to find yes or you know the right
- 36:23thing but you have made me a wiser man.
- 36:26In terms of this compliance stuff, I only earned earlier to
- 36:30this, I only understood what compliance word is all about
- 36:33beyond that. I did not know.
- 36:35So this is very helpful now to understand from you, Tom.
- 36:40Is that what why? Why are you?
- 36:42So you seem to be very passionate about compliance in
- 36:46the as a lawyer, you could be doing other a lot of other
- 36:49things. Why compliance so much of
- 36:52fashion intervals. Like I said, the world loses
- 36:56three trillion dollars every year to prevent corruption.
- 37:00If you had money laundering that's two trillion more a five
- 37:03trillion dollars is lost to the world's economy annually.
- 37:08Many people think corruption was a direct precursor to the
- 37:13attacks on the United States on 9/11 we all know what happened
- 37:17then but we all know what happened after that the United
- 37:20States invaded Iraq and it was a horrible 20 year war. or if in
- 37:25the United States from the United States fought in Iraq and
- 37:28Afghanistan, countless I don't know how many people died from
- 37:33all of that. So that's sort of one thing I
- 37:36think we now see how and the Arab Spring a few years ago, was
- 37:43started, over someone who refused to pay a bribe to a
- 37:46government official. So bribery corruption is real,
- 37:50it's a huge problem. I don't know if it's been a
- 37:53problem since Adam and Eve or the founding of people, but or
- 38:01see, Which and I should say but it certainly is a problem that's
- 38:04ongoing and I am passionate that I can do something to fight
- 38:10that. And what you and I are doing
- 38:13right now, is part of that fight, because you've already
- 38:17said you've been educated. And if someone hears this, they
- 38:21may say, you know, that's something that interests me and
- 38:25you don't have to be a lawyer to be in compliance.
- 38:27You can be an engineer, you can be a scientist, you could be a
- 38:30data analytics person, you can be a behavioral psychologist.
- 38:34You can be someone who studied English and taught elementary
- 38:37students. Anyone can be in compliance
- 38:41because it's telling a story of how to do business correctly.
- 38:44So, what we are doing in my mind, and why I wanted to come
- 38:48on your show, was that passion and yes, I've written a lot of
- 38:53books and yes, I've given a lot of speeches, but every time I do
- 38:57due diligence, every time I answer a question every time I
- 39:00help someone One, a student who's in the compliance field in
- 39:05Academia University. I feel like I'm moving the ball
- 39:09forward even if it's just an inch and that's what fires me
- 39:13every day and it still does. Right, right.
- 39:18As I said this, this particular episode has been quite
- 39:21educative. What about people want to
- 39:23connect with you? They want to know about your
- 39:26podcast about the compliance handbook, Third Edition, you
- 39:29have authored, 25 Books, & business, leadership,
- 39:32compliance, and ethics and corporate governance.
- 39:35How do people get hold of in the book section?
- 39:39Both books part in the podcasting part?
- 39:41How do they connect with you? So the best way to connect with
- 39:45me is on LinkedIn I'm Thomas or Fox fo X on LinkedIn.
- 39:52My podcast network is the compliance podcast network.
- 39:55If you'd like to find that it's www compliance podcast Network
- 40:01dotnet. You can also connect with me
- 40:04through the compliance podcast Network, I have a site where you
- 40:07can send an e-mail or you can send a voicemail if you'd like
- 40:11to buy the compliance handbook. In addition, I would love for
- 40:15you to buy one, but I will tell you that the fourth edition will
- 40:19be out in May you might want to wait for that but if you want to
- 40:23buy it now or look at it, it's at www.decksdirect-dot-com as
- 40:31Fox. Fo X.
- 40:32So that's where that book is located.
- 40:35The rest of my books are also found on the compliance podcast
- 40:38Network site so you can connect with me through any of those
- 40:42means. To hear from you.
- 40:44If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer any questions
- 40:47that I can. I try to be a resource for
- 40:50anyone in the compliance space. So I'd love to hear from you.
- 40:54Wonderful, wonderful. Thank you so much.
- 40:57Tom for all the, for all the understanding, all the
- 41:00resources, all the insights into this world of compliance.
- 41:06Thank you so much indeed. Thank you.
- 41:10This is a wrap on this, very special edition of the cage, a
- 41:14master class. Thank you so much indeed for
- 41:16joining us.