Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep11: GRD011: Should I Borrow From My 401K?
Transcript
- 0:00INTRO: Hi, I'm Ed Slott, and I'm Jeff Levine, and we are two guys who just
- 0:03love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the savers, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic with the.
- 0:23Helping you keep more of your hard-earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip
- 0:29a coin winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want
- 0:33to argue, and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respect positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner you, a more
- 0:45informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate to your
- 0:49own personal situation to decide what's.
- 0:51For you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate!
- 1:02Jeffrey Levine: Hey, welcome back to the Great Retirement Debate, ed.
- 1:05Good to be back with you for our latest episode.
- 1:08Ed Slott: That's right.
- 1:09Great retirement debate.
- 1:10The winner.
- 1:11Is everybody listening.
- 1:13Jeffrey Levine: Well, what are we debating today, ed?
- 1:16Ed Slott: Uh, whether somebody should borrow from their 401k or not,
- 1:19especially in these economic times.
- 1:21People see a big account there and they say, you know, I need money.
- 1:25Maybe I should tap into that.
- 1:27Jeffrey Levine: Well, maybe they should, maybe they shouldn't.
- 1:29We'll find out.
- 1:30So your topic, I get to pick the coin.
- 1:32Flip, uh, I'm gonna go tails today.
- 1:35Ed, I gotta say tails.
- 1:36And let's flip that coin.
- 1:37Ed Slott: Alright, uh, here we go.
- 1:38Real coin.
- 1:42Heads.
- 1:42Jeffrey Levine: Heads.
- 1:43All right, well you get to, you get to make the choice, ed.
- 1:47Ed Slott: Uh, I'd like, or I'm gonna go with the easy one.
- 1:50At least in my, I'm, I'm going say, don't borrow from a 401k.
- 1:54Jeffrey Levine: All right.
- 1:54That means I am arguing for taking a loan from your four Ed, you could lead us off.
- 2:00Why shouldn't you?
- 2:01You seem pretty passionate about this.
- 2:03Why wouldn't you take money from your 401k?
- 2:05Ed Slott: Well first again, we say, you know, if you are listening
- 2:09to this, there are two sides.
- 2:10Like we flip, flip the coin of every argument and people
- 2:14might be thinking about this.
- 2:15I never liked the idea borrowing from a retirement account, uh, only because.
- 2:20Unless it's your absolute last resort, I mean, it takes years to build a good
- 2:25retirement savings plan, a little at a time, a week at a time, month at a
- 2:29time, and then you just take it out.
- 2:31It's the hardest money to replace, and if you use it before retirement,
- 2:36what's going to be left in retirement.
- 2:39So those are the main things I worry about.
- 2:41Now, I'll turn it over to you.
- 2:42Why for the other side of the.
- 2:45Jeffrey Levine: Well, I mean, I, I would say at the starters, if you're
- 2:48looking to take a loan from your 401k, you probably need the money.
- 2:52And so it's not so much a matter of, do I take it?
- 2:55It's where do I get it from?
- 2:57And the question is, where else could you get it?
- 2:59Are you gonna borrow from family?
- 3:01Well, that we know can be very messy.
- 3:03And one of the great things about a 401k loan is that, you're
- 3:08getting money tax free, right?
- 3:10In a lot of places, if you were going to get, if you were gonna need dollars,
- 3:13right, you could take a distribution from your 401k or distribution from your ira.
- 3:18But if you're under 59 and a half, not only would you have income tax, but you
- 3:22could have a 10% penalty on top of that.
- 3:24Whereas if you take a loan from your 401k, you're actually able to access
- 3:29that money without paying an income tax.
- 3:31Just like any other loan you would take.
- 3:34Ed Slott: You know, I've heard that argument, but in real life I've
- 3:37had clients that did that in the past and it didn't work out well.
- 3:41Uh, it's true.
- 3:41They were in the same situation you are talking about.
- 3:44Uh, they had no other money.
- 3:46Now, this was a bad case because they, it was a second marriage for
- 3:50both of them, and they wanted to use the money for their wedding.
- 3:53I mean, you know, second marriage, I don't call that essential.
- 3:57You know, I gave him the advice and they didn't listen to me.
- 4:01So they took money.
- 4:02The husband, it was the one that had the 401k, took money out of
- 4:05his, he borrowed from his 401k cause he had a balance there.
- 4:09And then he, he couldn't pay it back.
- 4:11Uh, and then all of a sudden it becomes a taxable distribution.
- 4:14And the very penalty you're talking about being worried about, uh, he got hit with.
- 4:19Plus when they had to pay the tax, they didn't have money cuz they
- 4:23spent all the money on the wedding.
- 4:25Uh, so there was almost no intention.
- 4:27Maybe there was an intention, but there wasn't an ability to pay it back.
- 4:31That's why I said, you know, if you're gonna use it for food or
- 4:34shelter, something like that.
- 4:35But, uh, and I'm not saying the, the big wedding, and it wasn't even a big
- 4:40wedding, but they wanted to do something and there was no other money available.
- 4:43I advised against it.
- 4:45But the, uh, if you can't pay it back, it's a real problem.
- 4:48And I find a lot of people, although there are schedules and some people
- 4:52may be able to pay it back, I find most people, at least in my experience that
- 4:56did this, were not able to pay it back and had to suffer the consequences.
- 5:00Jeffrey Levine: Well, let's talk about that schedule for a moment,
- 5:02because a lot of times when people borrow money for emergencies, they're
- 5:06typically short-term loans, right?
- 5:08They might borrow some money from a family member's like, wait,
- 5:10I'll hit you back next month.
- 5:12Or I'll catch up with you over the next year.
- 5:14Well, that's a short period of time.
- 5:16And while not 30 years, like let's say a mortgage, with the exception of some,
- 5:22uh, some loans that are used to purchase a home, there's a five year timeframe in
- 5:27which you can pay back those 401k loans.
- 5:29So even though it's not.
- 5:30You know, 10, 20, or even 30 years, like many mortgages might be, uh,
- 5:34you are looking at a period of time that's dramatically longer than a
- 5:37lot of short-term loans would be.
- 5:39Plus, uh, when you go to take out a loan, let's say you were looking
- 5:43at someplace else to get the money and you had a, a house already.
- 5:46Maybe you needed to make repairs or maybe you just need to pay for.
- 5:50You know, again, whatever it is, if you were to go for a loan
- 5:53from your house, you're probably paying loan origination fees.
- 5:56You're probably paying, you know, some sort of fees to the bank.
- 5:59Whereas if you take that money from your 401k, you are able to access that money
- 6:04without all those upfront costs that you would from other loan providers.
- 6:09Ed Slott: Yeah, I get that it's, uh, easier to obtain credit, but, uh,
- 6:13another problem with this, is it easier to take - even if you can pay it back?
- 6:18Okay.
- 6:18Let's say somebody's diligent and they'll be
- 6:20Jeffrey Levine: OK, someone's diligent.
- 6:22Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 6:23and, and it, you know, there's always good intentions, but you know
- 6:26what they say, the road, whatever.
- 6:28Is paved with good intentions.
- 6:29The intention is always to pay it back because if you don't pay it back, uh,
- 6:34your retirement account will forever be lower and won't provide you what
- 6:37you'll actually need in retirement.
- 6:41But, if you do, even if you do pay it back, I find the people that have paid
- 6:45it back, something else has suffered.
- 6:48They only have so much money.
- 6:50Remember, these are people that had financial issues, uh, emergencies,
- 6:54whatever it was, because otherwise they wouldn't be tapping a 401k.
- 6:59Hopefully they would look for other areas of credit if available, but now
- 7:04they have a limited amount to pay back.
- 7:06So they pay back because they wanna stay on the schedule, which means they
- 7:10probably don't have the disposable cash to continue making 401K contributions.
- 7:16So in that respect, you're replenishing, but you're not replenishing the
- 7:21contributions going forward.
- 7:22Jeffrey Levine: Ed, let me ask you a question.
- 7:24If I take out a loan from the bank, are they gonna give me that loan for free?
- 7:29I mean, besides origination cost, is there any other cost associated with that loan?
- 7:34Ed Slott: There's lots of costs associated with a bank loan, and sometimes you
- 7:37might not even be credit worthy.
- 7:39Jeffrey Levine: Okay.
- 7:40But let's just say I am.
- 7:41Okay.
- 7:41Is the bank gonna give it to me for free?
- 7:44Or am I gonna have to pay some sort of interest to, to have
- 7:47the privilege of borrowing?
- 7:47Ed Slott: No, of course you're gonna pay interest.
- 7:49Jeffrey Levine: Okay.
- 7:49If I borrow money from someplace else, am I gonna have to pay interest?
- 7:52Ed Slott: Is a trick question.
- 7:52Yeah.
- 7:53Loans have interest.
- 7:54There's no free, give me the name of that bank that hey, gives out the free money.
- 7:58Jeffrey Levine: Well, that's my point, because if I'm taking a
- 8:00401k loan, I am paying interest.
- 8:03But Ed, who do I pay that interest to?
- 8:07Ed Slott: All right.
- 8:07Here's the argument you pay.
- 8:08Jeffrey Levine: I pay it to me!
- 8:09Yes, that's right.
- 8:10Ed Slott: Back to your own 401k and that's an argument,
- 8:13but I can argue the other way.
- 8:15You all, you'll pay tax twice on that money.
- 8:17You have to pay tax, uh, on the money you made to, uh, get the money in.
- 8:23Well, you get a deduction for it.
- 8:25But when you want to make, uh, you'll need new money to, uh, make new contributions.
- 8:31Jeffrey Levine: Effectively you're saying to pay back the loan, I've gotta
- 8:34use after tax money that that goes into a 401k, that later on in retirement,
- 8:38when I take a real distribution, I've gotta pay tax on it again.
- 8:40Ed Slott: Right, right.
- 8:41So you pay tax.
- 8:41I don't, not twice on the same money, but you pay tax twice.
- 8:44That's the way I look at it.
- 8:45When people say, uh, give the same argument, that's
- 8:48probably number one argument.
- 8:50I've seen it in articles.
- 8:51Oh, pay yourself back interest now, instead of going to
- 8:54the bank, it goes to you.
- 8:55It goes to your 401k.
- 8:56The interest and it has-
- 8:57Jeffrey Levine: That's right.
- 8:58Ed Slott: Cause those are the rules.
- 9:00But you're still out that money and, uh, where are you gonna get the money to pay
- 9:05it back and to make future contributions?
- 9:08I don't like it as a planning tool that that's all unless
- 9:11it's an absolute last resort?
- 9:14Jeffrey Levine: Well, let's, let's go down that road.
- 9:15Let's just say I'm, I'm sitting there and I'm looking at my IRA or my 401k
- 9:19and where I'm gonna tap that money from and I have to get money from somewhere.
- 9:23I think the 401k is a much better option because there I can actually
- 9:27borrow that money, but what happens if I borrow money from my IRA, Ed?
- 9:31Ed Slott: Uh, you can't borrow from your IRA, that's a prohibited transaction.
- 9:34And uh, just cause you went down that road, I'll have to open that road up.
- 9:39Uh, you mentioned borrowing from your IRA.
- 9:41People think you can, you really can't, but there are articles
- 9:45about a so-called 60 day loan where you could take money from an IRA
- 9:49and roll it back within 60 days.
- 9:51Jeffrey Levine: It's just a fancy name for a 60 day reollover.
- 9:53Ed Slott: Right.
- 9:54But with IRAs, you can only do that once a year, every 12 months.
- 9:59If you, once you do a second one, you can't roll that back over, so
- 10:02that becomes a taxable distributions, it seems to me, with any kind of,
- 10:07so you can't borrow from your IRA.
- 10:09Yes.
- 10:09If you had to borrow 401k, at least it's available.
- 10:13It's not available from an IRA, but in any case, down the road.
- 10:17If you're looking long term.
- 10:18And I can understand if people say, well, I can't look long term.
- 10:21I need money now, I feel like that commercial, uh, I need cash now...
- 10:27Jeffrey Levine: Yes, yes, yes.
- 10:27Uh, JG Wentworth, I believe.
- 10:29Ed Slott: Yeah right.
- 10:29Yeah.
- 10:29Other than the JG Wentworth thing where I need cash now, uh, you
- 10:34know, that would be the case.
- 10:36But, uh, if there's nothing else available, it's, it
- 10:38should be a last resort.
- 10:40You're, you're hitting the, the account you're counting on in retirement.
- 10:44That's why they call it a retirement account.
- 10:46And you should do everything you possibly can to keep, not only, uh, keep that
- 10:51intact and not borrow from it, but keep contributing to it as much as possible.
- 10:56Jeffrey Levine: Well, all good points, but I would once again say that if I'm
- 11:00forced to take money from somewhere, it may be better to go into my 401k, then
- 11:04certainly better than my IRA may be better than having to go into my home to get
- 11:09money where I am going to pay origination fees, and I'm gonna be paying someone else
- 11:14interest, and I'm still gonna have to pay that back too, and it may be better than
- 11:19going to a family member where if I don't pay that back, you know, if I don't pay
- 11:23my 401K back, my penalty is financial.
- 11:27If I don't pay a family member back, my penalty is, well..
- 11:31Ed Slott: Forever.
- 11:32Jeffrey Levine: Yes.
- 11:32It's, it is forever.
- 11:33Yeah.
- 11:34, uh, and, and, and so that may be worse, uh, ultimately, but look, I,
- 11:38I, I think one thing we, we certainly both agree on here is that retirement
- 11:42accounts as, uh, as a general rule of thumb, should be considered for
- 11:47retirement could be used for retirement.
- 11:50Um, and, you know, I'll, I'll throw one other item out here, ed, that is
- 11:53really, uh, in favor of the 401k loan.
- 11:56In lieu of that, someone might be tempted to put a, uh, a large purchase
- 12:02on a credit card or some other form of revolving line of credit and the
- 12:06interest rates there, it's amazing how they don't border on usery sometimes,
- 12:11you know, with 18, 19, 20% rates.
- 12:14So even if you are in a situation where you.
- 12:18You know, you're not even sure that you're gonna be able to pay back the 401k loan.
- 12:22It's not great.
- 12:23Not advocating for, not saying, Hey, let's try not to pay back that loan.
- 12:27But if my choice is take a 401k loan out and potentially default on it, or
- 12:32put money onto a credit card where I'm gonna have, you know, a 20% annual fee or
- 12:37annual interest plus penalties each month.
- 12:40If I can't make my minimum payments or whatnot, I might just wanna bite the
- 12:43bullet, you know, suck it up for the time being, see my retirement account
- 12:47reduced, and then go about trying to improve my life, improve my financial
- 12:52situation, and build back that 401k later, because even though that 401K
- 12:56maybe less now, I might have a better ability to build it up in the future if
- 13:01I'm not paying those astronomically high interest rates that credit cards and other
- 13:05revolving lines of credit often charge.
- 13:07Ed Slott: That's true, but also I said it before, uh, if you default, you will not.
- 13:13You will have to pay, you'll have a taxable event.
- 13:17So let's say you withdrew, you'll borrowed a few thousand dollars, that becomes
- 13:22a taxable distribution, that can't be rolled over, by the way, with other
- 13:27money to an IRA, plus a 10% penalty if no other, uh, if you're under 59 and a half.
- 13:33So it can be very costly.
- 13:35That's 10 per, you're talking about interest rates.
- 13:38It's a 10% penalty if you're under 59 and a half plus the tax.
- 13:42Jeffrey Levine: Yeah.
- 13:42Well, at least it's only a 10% one time penalty.
- 13:45And if I have to pay it, you know what I could do, Ed?.
- 13:47I could just borrow more from my 401k.
- 13:50Ed Slott: Aye, aye aye..
- 13:51Well, you know, you can make the decision for yourself.
- 13:54Everybody listening, that's why we're here for, but, uh, I'm not a
- 13:58big fan and I think, uh, Jeff just said it before, one thing we agree
- 14:01on retirement accounts should be for retirement, but life happens.
- 14:04Jeffrey Levine: That's right.
- 14:05That's right.
- 14:05That's fair.
- 14:06Yes, life happens.
- 14:07Um, well, ed, I think we've covered both sides of this pretty well,
- 14:11and so we can wrap it up here.
- 14:12And as we always say, there are two sides to every coin, but your life
- 14:16and your retirement decisions are too important to leave up to a coin flip.
- 14:20And that's why one thing that Ed and I always agree on, is making sure that
- 14:24you're talking through any big decision like this, like whether you should
- 14:27take a loan from your 401k or from someplace else with a knowledgeable
- 14:31financial advisor or tax professional, so that you can weigh the pros and
- 14:35the cons of different options against your specific goals and objectives.
- 14:39If you'd like to continue the discussion with Ed and I, we'd love to hear from you.
- 14:43You can reach Ed on Twitter using the handle @TheSlottReport.
- 14:47Again, that's the Slott Report with two Ts and you can reach out to
- 14:50me using the handle @CPAPlanner.
- 14:53Once again, that's @CPAPlanner.
- 14:56We'd love to hear from you.
- 14:57We'd love some of your thoughts on a future topic for discussion for us to
- 15:01debate, and we thank you for listening.
- 15:04Ed?
- 15:05Ed Slott: Yep.
- 15:05I will see you next time on the Great Retirement Debate!
- 15:08Outro: Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 15:12This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 15:15not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 15:18Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 15:21which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 15:24Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 15:27completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 15:29The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 15:32and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.