Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Food Insecurity in Kentucky
Transcript
- 0:14Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:15Shaw. We thank you so much for
- 0:17joining us this evening. Our
- 0:20topic tonight food insecurity.
- 0:21It appears there is a deal in
- 0:23place to end the now 41 day
- 0:25federal government shutdown,
- 0:26but the Trump administration
- 0:28still wants the U.S. Supreme
- 0:30Court to allow it to keep SNAP
- 0:32or food stamp payments on hold.
- 0:34About 42 million Americans and
- 0:36about 600,000 Kentuckians
- 0:39receive SNAP to help put food
- 0:41on the table. And uncertainty
- 0:43about the program is prompting
- 0:44state action and new food
- 0:46drives to keep Kentuckians fed.
- 0:48And this isn't a new problem.
- 0:50Even before the shutdown, the
- 0:52organization Feeding Kentucky
- 0:53reported 700,000 Kentuckians
- 0:56faced food insecurity,
- 0:57including 200,000 children. Now
- 1:00to discuss all this, we have
- 1:02six guests with us in our
- 1:03Lexington studio, beginning
- 1:04with Michael Halligan,
- 1:06president and chief executive
- 1:08officer of God's Pantry Food
- 1:10Bank. Melissa McDonald,
- 1:11executive director of Feeding
- 1:13Kentucky. Dana Feldman,
- 1:15executive director of the
- 1:17Kentucky Department of
- 1:18Agriculture's Office of
- 1:19Consumer and Environmental
- 1:21Protection. Alison Gustafson,
- 1:23executive director, food as
- 1:25Health at the University of
- 1:26Kentucky Martin Gatton College
- 1:28of Agriculture, Food and
- 1:30Environment. State Senator
- 1:32Jason Howell, a Republican from
- 1:34Murray and chair of the Senate
- 1:36Agriculture Committee, and
- 1:37State Representative Chad Hall,
- 1:39a Democrat from Lexington and
- 1:41member of the House Agriculture
- 1:43Committee. We certainly want to
- 1:44hear from you tonight. You can
- 1:46send us your questions and
- 1:47comments by X, formerly known
- 1:48as Twitter at Pub Affairs KET
- 1:51or send an email to KY Tonight
- 1:53at ket.org or use the web form
- 1:57at ket.org KY Tonight. Or you
- 2:00can simply give us a call at
- 2:02one 800 494 7605. Welcome to
- 2:05our full house of guests. We
- 2:07appreciate you being here on
- 2:08this kind of blustery, cold,
- 2:10and somewhat snowy evening. We
- 2:12cannot believe it. It's just
- 2:14November the 10th and we're
- 2:15already talking about snow. So
- 2:16we hope that you all are safe
- 2:18at home. And if you have to get
- 2:20out, please use caution. So
- 2:21let's kind of bring our
- 2:22audience up to speed. There's a
- 2:24lot of developments today. Chad
- 2:25Aull when it comes to what
- 2:27there seems to be a
- 2:28breakthrough on the budget
- 2:29impasse. But when it comes to
- 2:31SNAP, are we there yet? And
- 2:33restoring those payments and
- 2:35what's happening on the state
- 2:36level to help folks who are
- 2:38food insecure?
- 2:39>> Well, I think we'll talk
- 2:40about the state level first,
- 2:42because I think that's a little
- 2:43bit more simple. So the
- 2:45governor last week declared a
- 2:46state of emergency and released
- 2:48$5 million out of the rainy day
- 2:49fund to go to feeding Kentucky.
- 2:51That's going to be distributed
- 2:52throughout the rest of the
- 2:54state to help some of the food
- 2:55banks mitigate some of the
- 2:57immediate emergency we are
- 2:59seeing across the across the
- 3:00state with hunger on on the
- 3:02federal level, I think the
- 3:04picture is better, but not 100%
- 3:07clear. There is a deal
- 3:10apparently in place in the
- 3:11Senate. It still has to work
- 3:12its way through Washington, get
- 3:14over to the House and get out.
- 3:15And then above and beyond that,
- 3:17it's how long does that deal
- 3:18stay in place? Is it going to
- 3:20get passed? And what happens in
- 3:22the meantime? Because people
- 3:23are hungry right now. Today, as
- 3:25we sit here in the studio and
- 3:27have this conversation and
- 3:28unfortunately, this
- 3:29administration, to your point
- 3:30in the opening, has made the
- 3:32proactive choice not to feed
- 3:34our people. There's been plenty
- 3:36of administrations in the past,
- 3:37both Democrat and Republican,
- 3:39during the times of shutdown,
- 3:41who have decided to go ahead
- 3:42with those SNAP payments. So
- 3:44this is a decision that the
- 3:46administration has made to
- 3:47punish people who are on Snap.
- 3:49And that's just not acceptable,
- 3:51because when you're hungry,
- 3:52it's not a Democrat issue. It's
- 3:53not a Republican issue, it's a
- 3:55person. It's a people issue.
- 3:57And we are punishing those who
- 3:58need our help the most right
- 4:00now, today.
- 4:01>> Senator, how how do you see
- 4:03it? Do you feel that the Trump
- 4:04administration is deliberately
- 4:05punishing people who are food
- 4:06insecure? And do you agree with
- 4:08the governor's move to take $5
- 4:10million from the Budget Reserve
- 4:11Trust Fund, sometimes called
- 4:12the Rainy Day Fund, to help get
- 4:15those payments to feeding
- 4:16Kentucky distribute to those in
- 4:18need?
- 4:18>> I think it's important to
- 4:20think about a couple of things
- 4:21in perspective. One, the budget
- 4:23the Congress shut. Being shut
- 4:26down isn't part of the
- 4:27administration. That's Congress.
- 4:28That's their prerogatives. On
- 4:30whether they pass something or
- 4:31not. And it's not about the
- 4:36decision to feed people or not
- 4:37through SNAP. That is one of
- 4:39the many things that are caught
- 4:40up in this disagreement in
- 4:42Washington with the gridlock
- 4:43that they've been that they've
- 4:44been experiencing, working
- 4:45through a bunch of different
- 4:47issues. Well, I think it's good
- 4:49that the governor did go and
- 4:51finally release some money to
- 4:52to address some of this issue
- 4:54from a short term,
- 4:56unfortunately. And I think it's
- 4:57something we need to be
- 4:59conscious of all along, is the
- 5:01food insecurity issue existed
- 5:03long before this government
- 5:05shutdown. And it will. It will
- 5:07exist long after everything is
- 5:09worked out in the Snap.
- 5:10Benefits get restored. And
- 5:12that's some of the things that
- 5:13I think that that we need to
- 5:15continue to focus on. Maybe we
- 5:17can use this situation in the
- 5:19short term to focus more
- 5:20positive attention on
- 5:22addressing the long term issues
- 5:23of food insecurity.
- 5:24>> There was some question that
- 5:26many had about, can the
- 5:27governor just take $5 million
- 5:29from the rainy day fund to do
- 5:30this? And I guess there's not
- 5:32an issue, because I haven't
- 5:34heard there being much
- 5:34dissension about that decision.
- 5:35Can you clarify that for us,
- 5:37representative?
- 5:37>> I think there's been
- 5:39language added into the budget
- 5:39that in a time of emergency,
- 5:41the General Assembly has given
- 5:42a small leeway on what the
- 5:45governor can do in those times
- 5:46when he does declare.
- 5:48>> And not to exceed a certain
- 5:49amount.
- 5:50>> Not to exceed a certain
- 5:51amount. And so I think that's
- 5:53why he chose that $5 million
- 5:54amount, because it was under
- 5:55that threshold that gave him
- 5:57the authority to provide that
- 5:58executive action.
- 5:58>> And I think sometimes when
- 6:00we think of states of emergency,
- 6:01we think of natural disasters.
- 6:03And so perhaps this expanded
- 6:04that definition of what could
- 6:06be declared a state of
- 6:07emergency because it is about
- 6:09food relief and not about
- 6:10disaster relief.
- 6:11>> And I'm thankful to the
- 6:13governor for thinking outside
- 6:14the box, using this as an
- 6:16opportunity to stand in that
- 6:18gap where families are hungry
- 6:19right now, today, he's done
- 6:21that action and hopefully it
- 6:23provides some relief for some
- 6:24time until the federal
- 6:26government can either decide to
- 6:27release the SNAP funding that
- 6:29they've been ordered by the
- 6:30courts to do so, or we can get
- 6:33a deal through the Congress to
- 6:34go back to the way it was.
- 6:36>> Yes. Just finally on this
- 6:37point, Senator Howell, so there
- 6:40is no uncomfortableness with
- 6:42the Republicans or members in
- 6:44your caucus in the Senate about
- 6:45what the governor has done,
- 6:46that you feel this was an
- 6:48appropriate action to take,
- 6:49given the circumstances?
- 6:50>> I don't think there's any
- 6:51level of uncomfortableness in
- 6:53either caucus in either chamber
- 6:54on doing what we need to do to
- 6:56keep people that that are on
- 6:58this edge of food insecurity
- 7:00fed wherever we can.
- 7:01>> Yeah. So now I want to go to
- 7:03Melissa McDonnell because you
- 7:04are overfeeding Kentucky. So
- 7:05this money was directed to your
- 7:07agency. The state health
- 7:08cabinet directs that to you. Is
- 7:10that money gone to the people
- 7:11who need it? How fast can they
- 7:13get that help?
- 7:14>> So the money went out early
- 7:16last week directly to the seven
- 7:17partner food banks that we work
- 7:19with. And so then the food
- 7:21banks were able to distribute
- 7:22that those dollars, either to
- 7:24their agency partners or to be
- 7:26able to purchase more dollars,
- 7:27I mean, more food for their
- 7:29distribution centers to then
- 7:30send the food out. So, yes, the
- 7:33food is the the dollars have
- 7:34turned into food and that has
- 7:36been distributed across 120
- 7:38counties.
- 7:38>> For those who were expecting
- 7:39perhaps to see money on their
- 7:41EBT card, they might have been
- 7:43confused by what the governor
- 7:44did and you've just stated it.
- 7:46But perhaps it's worth
- 7:47reiterating.
- 7:48>> Completely and completely
- 7:49understanding that there was
- 7:51the confusion of how the
- 7:52dollars were to be allocated.
- 7:53The dollars were directly given
- 7:56to us to be 100% direct through
- 7:59to the seven partner food banks
- 8:00that we work with, and then
- 8:02they were to turn around and
- 8:04purchase only food, to be able
- 8:06to distribute out to the agency
- 8:08partners that they work with,
- 8:09that are all in their service
- 8:11areas that cover the 120
- 8:13counties.
- 8:13>> And to make sure that those
- 8:15who are in food insecure and
- 8:16who do rely on SNAP knew about
- 8:18this happening, right? Was that
- 8:20a big barrier or not?
- 8:22>> To a certain degree, it was.
- 8:23I think there was a lot of
- 8:25there had to be some last
- 8:27minute social media, the last
- 8:28minute communications that went
- 8:30out to either just through our
- 8:33individual channels. The food
- 8:34banks were already starting to
- 8:36see an increase in their
- 8:39visitors, the neighbors that
- 8:40were coming for food all the
- 8:42way back to the beginning of
- 8:43the shutdown. Because we have
- 8:45to remember this. This is a
- 8:46disaster. To be honest. We saw
- 8:49this. And so the rainy day
- 8:51funds we saw going directly to
- 8:53a disaster is what it went to.
- 8:54And to be able to understand
- 8:56that there were also not just
- 8:59the Snap recipients that had
- 9:01the pause and their benefits,
- 9:02but we also are talking about
- 9:04federal employees that were
- 9:05going, you know, one, two
- 9:07paychecks not being received.
- 9:09And so they were also starting
- 9:11to show up to our food banks,
- 9:13and they were showing up
- 9:14looking for assistance, because
- 9:15they may never have had this
- 9:17happen to them before. So it
- 9:19was those additional dollars
- 9:20have been able to be very
- 9:22beneficial to these food banks
- 9:24and their agency partners to be
- 9:26able to ensure that they have
- 9:28extra food for anyone that's
- 9:29showing up.
- 9:30>> Was 5 million enough?
- 9:32>> I think that's yet to be
- 9:34determined. I think we have to
- 9:36see how long the federal
- 9:37government may potentially stay
- 9:39closed. Also, we know that
- 9:42there's going to still be a
- 9:43little bit of a gap in terms of
- 9:46if the federal government were
- 9:47to be open this week, those
- 9:49benefits are not going to be
- 9:52immediately turned over,
- 9:53because they're still going to
- 9:54be some nuances of
- 9:55technicalities that have to be
- 9:56taken into consideration. And
- 9:58then the other thing that you
- 10:00have to I always want to
- 10:02reiterate is that the food
- 10:03banks are not to become the
- 10:05replacement for SNAP. So Snap
- 10:08benefits those dollars. They're
- 10:10able to actually go further
- 10:12than what the food banks are.
- 10:13So we always say that a food
- 10:15bank can provide that one meal
- 10:17versus Snap benefits can
- 10:19provide up to nine meals for so
- 10:21many different reasons. One, a
- 10:23food bank is there to be able
- 10:25to come into that crunch time
- 10:27when it's ultimately needed,
- 10:28whereas a Snap benefits you're
- 10:30able to shop at in Kentucky.
- 10:32Close to 5000 retailers in the
- 10:34state of Kentucky, except snap,
- 10:36those retailers are open more
- 10:38often than a food bank or a
- 10:40pantry is so yet to be
- 10:42determined. If 5 million will
- 10:43be enough.
- 10:44>> Yeah. Mr. Halligan of God's
- 10:45Pantry, you've said and we've
- 10:47talked before in the last
- 10:48couple of weeks, that food
- 10:50insecurity in central and
- 10:51eastern Kentucky is at an all
- 10:52time high. How has it been
- 10:54exacerbated because of the
- 10:55federal government shut down?
- 10:56And did you have enough supply
- 10:57to meet the increasing demand?
- 10:59>> So I would say that the on
- 11:01the supply question, it's an
- 11:02important stopgap to provide
- 11:04immediate relief to the extent
- 11:07that we can. One way to think
- 11:08about Snap and central and
- 11:10eastern Kentucky, the monthly
- 11:11benefit is $40 million a month.
- 11:15The annual impact of God's
- 11:16Pantry food bank in terms of
- 11:18our services and the food, is
- 11:20$80 million a year. So Snap is
- 11:23six times what the food bank
- 11:26can do 40 million a month
- 11:28versus 80 million a year. So
- 11:31important stopgap. What we've
- 11:35seen, if you can, there's about
- 11:37500 food pantries, meal
- 11:38programs that are part of the
- 11:40network that we serve first
- 11:42week in October compared to the
- 11:43first week in November, a 40%
- 11:46increase in demand. You
- 11:48mentioned a minute ago food
- 11:50insecurity. It's at an all time
- 11:52high. Before the shutdown of
- 11:54about 280,000 people. That's
- 11:5718.2%. If you take that 40%
- 11:59increase in demand and you
- 12:02annualize it, that's another
- 12:04110,000 people. That puts it at
- 12:06almost 400,000 people on an
- 12:08annualized basis. So the impact
- 12:11right now is dramatic. There's
- 12:14a second thing I think it's
- 12:15important to to bring up. So
- 12:17not only do we have the funding
- 12:19authorized by the governor, but
- 12:21the impact of community
- 12:22engagement has been amazing.
- 12:24There are food drives happening
- 12:26everywhere here in Lexington,
- 12:28all across central and eastern
- 12:30Kentucky, all across the
- 12:32commonwealth of Kentucky. That
- 12:34engagement of people is making
- 12:36an immediate difference this
- 12:38week, while that funding is
- 12:40spent and that product that we
- 12:42are purchasing gets to the food
- 12:44bank so that we can then get it
- 12:46out to all of those pantries.
- 12:47>> And not that you wish for a
- 12:49prolonged endorsement of this
- 12:50whole debacle. With the
- 12:51government shutdown and
- 12:52delaying of Snap benefits. But
- 12:53how do you keep that level of
- 12:55community engagement going,
- 12:57where people still are
- 12:59motivated to donate and to help
- 13:01out food pantries like yourself?
- 13:02>> You know, so we all often
- 13:04talk about Kentuckians being
- 13:05resilient, and we all talk
- 13:07about how much we care for one
- 13:09another. And right now, we are
- 13:11seeing that more than any time
- 13:13in our history, there are
- 13:15probably two times, right? One
- 13:19was the pandemic and one was
- 13:21the Great Depression in the 30s,
- 13:23where people really leaned in
- 13:25and helped one another get
- 13:28through, get through the
- 13:28circumstances. I don't know how
- 13:30long people can sustain that
- 13:33energy because it's draining.
- 13:36The energy level right now is
- 13:39incredibly high. It's
- 13:40incredibly helpful. How long
- 13:42will it last?
- 13:43>> Yeah, as long as the news
- 13:45cycles may aid and abet. Right.
- 13:48Dana Feldman, in response to
- 13:50the federal government shutdown,
- 13:51the State Department has been
- 13:53very active in helping to
- 13:54coalesce organizations to
- 13:55provide contributions to help
- 13:57tell us about what's going on
- 13:59with the Department of
- 14:00Agriculture.
- 14:01>> Yes. Thank you. The
- 14:03Commissioner of Agriculture,
- 14:03Jonathan Schell, was able to
- 14:05coordinate different groups and
- 14:07different partners to put
- 14:09together food boxes, primarily
- 14:11vegetables, to assist in
- 14:13getting those boxes out to the
- 14:15food banks across the state.
- 14:17And we worked with our partner,
- 14:19Melissa at Feeding Kentucky to
- 14:21make that happen. But there was
- 14:23a need, and the calls were
- 14:25received to say, how can I help?
- 14:26Just what Mr. Halligan talked
- 14:28about, how can I help my fellow
- 14:30Kentuckians? And so the
- 14:31commissioner helped coordinate
- 14:32that effort to get about
- 14:34$150,000 in very quickly, and
- 14:36then also some donations of of
- 14:38beef, of chicken from Tyson as
- 14:40well, to just to say, what can
- 14:42we do quickly to help.
- 14:43>> Yeah. So I'm going to go
- 14:45over here to Doctor Gustafson.
- 14:47And in the meantime, we're
- 14:48going to have someone help Mr.
- 14:49Halligan get his mic back on.
- 14:51So this is live television, so
- 14:53we're going to have someone
- 14:54come around and kind of help
- 14:56him assist in that. So I want
- 14:58to come to you, doctor. Thank
- 15:00you so very much for being with
- 15:01us in your work. Food
- 15:02insecurity is what you do,
- 15:03right? So talk about how this
- 15:05issue in many ways has given
- 15:07rise to the conversation about
- 15:08food insecurity in a way that
- 15:10is both good and bad.
- 15:12>> Yes. So I've been
- 15:13researching and working in the
- 15:15food insecurity space for most
- 15:16of my career, and I think this
- 15:18highlights two different unique
- 15:21aspects. One is hunger, and a
- 15:23lot of the people in this room
- 15:25are addressing hunger. And so
- 15:26when someone is hungry, they
- 15:27can turn to a food pantry. They
- 15:29can. And then that food bank
- 15:31helps that pantry. But what we
- 15:32also see is sometimes there's a
- 15:34prolonged food insecurity issue.
- 15:36And that's where SNAP comes
- 15:38into play. And so it's this
- 15:40layering that we've seen, and
- 15:41we really find that SNAP helps
- 15:44people address food insecurity,
- 15:46and that it may or may not help
- 15:49improve those health outcomes.
- 15:50And so people are now noticing,
- 15:52oh, I have type two diabetes. I
- 15:55need access to healthy food.
- 15:57Because now that I've gone a
- 15:59month without eating
- 16:00appropriate food for my
- 16:01diabetes, I can't handle my
- 16:03medication appropriately. Oh, I
- 16:05have hypertension. I can't
- 16:09handle my medication for my
- 16:11hypertension because now I
- 16:12can't access food. And so our
- 16:14program and our lens is to
- 16:16address food insecurity helps
- 16:18the health of Kentuckians. And
- 16:20that's what we want. We want
- 16:22healthy Kentuckians.
- 16:23>> Yeah. And you look at the
- 16:25bigger system of health care,
- 16:26right. So talk to us about that
- 16:28from a clinical perspective too.
- 16:29>> Right. Exactly. And so
- 16:31typically what we find is those
- 16:32who are food insecure, have
- 16:33type two diabetes, have high
- 16:35risk pregnancy, have high rates
- 16:36of cardiovascular disease,
- 16:37those who have type two
- 16:38diabetes and cardiovascular
- 16:40disease, the opposite have
- 16:41higher rates of food insecurity.
- 16:43So if we can address that food
- 16:45insecurity, we can save health
- 16:46care dollars, right?
- 16:48>> And food insecurity doesn't
- 16:49always mean a scarcity of food.
- 16:51It's scarcity of nutritious
- 16:53food.
- 16:54>> Food. Yeah, exactly. Renee.
- 16:55>> Which is more expensive? By
- 16:56and large.
- 16:57>> By and large, it can be more
- 16:59expensive, but we can help
- 17:00elevate and educate people to
- 17:03understand how to use food in a
- 17:05healthy way while stretching
- 17:06their food dollar. So through
- 17:07food coping strategies,
- 17:09stretching your dollar in a
- 17:10healthy way, you can utilize
- 17:12your Snap benefit in a healthy
- 17:15way. And also you kind of learn
- 17:18those skills of how to use it.
- 17:20How do you prepare for it? How
- 17:22do you cook? And then maybe you
- 17:23garden on the side. Maybe you
- 17:25do some of these. You visit a
- 17:27farmer's market for the double
- 17:28dollar program. It isn't to say
- 17:29snap is the only thing, right?
- 17:31It's one of many resources. And
- 17:33I think there's sometimes an
- 17:35overreliance that snap is going
- 17:36to be the cure all. It's not
- 17:38the cure all. It's one
- 17:40attribute in the whole entire
- 17:42food system. And so our
- 17:44partners in the Kentucky
- 17:45Medicaid space, all of our
- 17:47health insurance partners,
- 17:48they're at the table. They are
- 17:50committed to addressing food
- 17:51insecurity for their members.
- 17:53>> Right. It's an economic
- 17:54issue for them. Right? It's a
- 17:56financial decision.
- 17:56>> And they want to see the
- 17:58return on investment. And so
- 17:59here's an example for a food as
- 18:01medicine program for $1 you
- 18:02spend you get $3 in return. Who
- 18:04wouldn't like that deal.
- 18:05>> Right.
- 18:06>> Right. So every $1 you put
- 18:08in you get three back. And so
- 18:09we are finding in our state
- 18:11insurance is at the table.
- 18:12Health care providers are at
- 18:14the table. Obviously our ag and
- 18:15food partners are at the table
- 18:17as well. But we want to use
- 18:19this food insecurity to address
- 18:20health outcomes at the same
- 18:21time.
- 18:22>> And we rank pretty low. I
- 18:23mean, we remember doctor Lee
- 18:25Todd, who used to be the
- 18:26president of University of
- 18:27Kentucky, and he used the
- 18:28phrase and maybe he even coined
- 18:30it The Kentucky Uglies. And we
- 18:31know that sometimes we still
- 18:33are battling those Kentucky
- 18:34ranks fifth in poverty, second
- 18:35highest in the percentage of
- 18:36adults reporting fair or poor
- 18:38health and the fifth lowest in
- 18:39life expectancy. So how do we
- 18:41know that what you're doing is
- 18:43going to reverse those numbers
- 18:44where we're not at the bottom
- 18:45of the good list, at the top of
- 18:47the bad?
- 18:48>> Yeah, exactly. So we've
- 18:49already we also know we'll add
- 18:51high risk pregnancy to our list
- 18:53as well. So I think one one
- 18:55solution, one avenue is really
- 18:57to say how do we in the state
- 18:59utilize a food as medicine
- 19:00framework. So so we have SNAP
- 19:03in a healthy way. We also
- 19:06provide through insurance an
- 19:08added benefit through a healthy
- 19:10way to say we're going to
- 19:11reduce those rates of diabetes,
- 19:13reduce rates of cardiovascular
- 19:15disease, and we have to track
- 19:17those numbers. Our state is
- 19:18committed to that. Our current
- 19:20cabinet has lots of funding and
- 19:23support for us to evaluate
- 19:24those programs over time, so
- 19:26that we can turn back to our
- 19:27legislators and say, this was a
- 19:29good return on investment, and
- 19:31we have to show that. We have
- 19:32to show it's a good return on
- 19:34investment.
- 19:34>> Yeah. So I want to go to
- 19:36Miss Feldman because food is
- 19:38medicine is what you all are
- 19:39doing, right? I mean, you all
- 19:41have adopted this principle. So
- 19:42explain what it looks like
- 19:43underneath your agency.
- 19:44>> Absolutely. So about May of
- 19:462024, Commissioner Shell and
- 19:47the Kentucky Hospital
- 19:48Association launched a Food as
- 19:50medicine initiative. And its
- 19:52purpose is twofold. A lot of it
- 19:54is what was already discussed.
- 19:56Healthy food in can lead to
- 19:57healthy outcomes. It can drive
- 19:59down rates of chronic disease
- 20:00in our state, which we know
- 20:02that we need. But the other
- 20:03layer two is use local products
- 20:06in the food as medicine work,
- 20:07so it also increases farmer
- 20:10gate farm gate impact. It also
- 20:12increases rural economy and
- 20:14rural development. But why not
- 20:16use local products in the food
- 20:19is medicine work? And we have
- 20:21seen that happen at your your
- 20:23institute as well. So it is
- 20:26working. We're also using food
- 20:27as medicine platform to get
- 20:29more local, healthy, fresh,
- 20:31nutritious products into the
- 20:33cafeterias. So it's also
- 20:35employee health at our
- 20:37hospitals. It's patient health.
- 20:38It's the visitors who come in
- 20:40maybe are choosing healthier
- 20:41options at the cafeteria. A lot
- 20:44of our partners, we have more
- 20:45than 50 hospitals now who have
- 20:47actually called and said, I
- 20:48want to be part of food as
- 20:50medicine in some way. It
- 20:51doesn't look the same way for
- 20:53every hospital. Every hospital
- 20:54is different. Their size is
- 20:55different, their community is
- 20:56different. But one of our first
- 20:58partners was Appalachian
- 20:59Regional Health, and they are
- 21:01doing a lot of work with
- 21:03employee health care
- 21:04initiatives. They do a pop up
- 21:06farmer's market in their
- 21:07parking lot in Hazzard, I
- 21:08believe, and they're finding
- 21:10that patients are making more
- 21:11of their doctor's visits. On
- 21:13the day that the farmer's
- 21:14market is in place, you can
- 21:16come and do your do your
- 21:17doctor's visit, maybe see some
- 21:19friends shop at the market, and
- 21:20they're also doing a voucher
- 21:22for employees to go and use at
- 21:24the market on that day as well.
- 21:26So food is medicine is is just
- 21:28as multi-layered as some of the
- 21:29other programs that we've
- 21:30talked about. But there's a lot
- 21:32of layers to it, and we think
- 21:34that it will start to change
- 21:35the landscape of what people
- 21:37expect from their food and from
- 21:38their outcomes, and then also
- 21:40help with a rural economy in
- 21:41the state.
- 21:42>> So you help introduce folks
- 21:44to that new behavioral choice,
- 21:46right. But then it's also
- 21:47making sure that they follow
- 21:49through with it. Right. And so
- 21:50by having their doctor's
- 21:52appointments sync with when the
- 21:53food markets are available,
- 21:55that probably helps. But then
- 21:56what do they do the rest of the
- 21:58time. Right. What kind of
- 21:59choices are they making when
- 22:01there's not that local
- 22:02availability of food there?
- 22:03>> Well, I think it's what was
- 22:05just discussed that it's just
- 22:06one piece and it has to come
- 22:08with education. It has to come
- 22:10with a conversation with
- 22:11physicians. Physicians also
- 22:13need to be able to sit down
- 22:14with patients and say, how is
- 22:16how is your diet? And I know
- 22:18that happens a lot with some of
- 22:20the chronic outcomes and
- 22:21chronic diagnoses that we have,
- 22:22but it also has to be a
- 22:24relationship between the
- 22:25patient and the physician as
- 22:27well, to say, here's here's
- 22:28some resources for you.
- 22:30Extension has wonderful
- 22:31resources to UK extension, but
- 22:33trying to just get the
- 22:35resources to folks so they know
- 22:36we talk a lot about the
- 22:38butternut squash. If you give
- 22:39someone a butternut squash, do
- 22:41they know how to cook it? Do
- 22:42they know how to prepare it? Do
- 22:44they know all the great things
- 22:46that they can do with that?
- 22:47They may not? And that's just
- 22:49education and just trying to
- 22:50get some outreach there for for
- 22:51healthier eating.
- 22:52>> So having classes that help
- 22:53you on how to cook those things,
- 22:55those items. Right. So what are
- 22:57the food pantries kind of come
- 22:58into this conversation about
- 22:59food as medicine?
- 23:00>> It's a really good question.
- 23:01I think it's still yet kind of
- 23:03figure out some of them are
- 23:05more advanced. And so some of
- 23:06them are actually working with
- 23:08the hospitals. And in fact, I
- 23:10have to point over to to God's
- 23:12Pantry. They actually have some
- 23:14food as medicine projects that
- 23:16are connected with hospital
- 23:17systems. So kind of more of a
- 23:20food pharmacy perspective to be
- 23:22able to make sure that when
- 23:24they're working with the
- 23:25physicians, when the physicians
- 23:26are screening them for food
- 23:29insecurity and they get flagged
- 23:30for that, they're able to
- 23:32immediately say, perfect, we
- 23:34have an opportunity for you to
- 23:35pick up a produce box or a food
- 23:38box downstairs at the pharmacy,
- 23:40or connect them to a pantry
- 23:42that may be connected with that
- 23:43hospital in that area.
- 23:44>> Yeah. Mr. Halligan yeah.
- 23:46>> So that program started a
- 23:48few years ago with the VA here
- 23:50in Lexington. We were one of a
- 23:52handful of food banks around
- 23:53the country that was partnering
- 23:54with the Veterans
- 23:55Administration to test the
- 23:58hypothesis of immediate
- 23:59intervention of healthy,
- 24:01nutritious food for efficacy of
- 24:04treatment. Today, there are 53
- 24:06health care based pantries in
- 24:08central and eastern Kentucky.
- 24:10Partnering with many of the
- 24:11hospitals. RH is one. There are
- 24:13several others, and what
- 24:14happens is the community health
- 24:16care worker in the in the
- 24:17hospital, the medical center,
- 24:19they will screen someone for
- 24:20food insecurity. And if they
- 24:22screen positive, right. There's
- 24:24an immediate intervention of
- 24:25food that day. And there's a
- 24:27referral to the nearest food
- 24:29pantry meal program to where
- 24:31someone lives so they can
- 24:34maintain that nutrition. And
- 24:35working with the doctors know
- 24:38what foods are the most
- 24:39appropriate to improve the
- 24:41health outcome. There's a
- 24:42second piece to this that I
- 24:44think is really important. So
- 24:45we talk a lot about health
- 24:47outcome. There's actually two
- 24:48more really important outcomes.
- 24:49One is educational outcome for
- 24:51kids. So imagine a child who's
- 24:53got a health condition. But
- 24:55there are also struggling in
- 24:56school. So now you get the
- 24:58benefit of a health outcome.
- 24:59Plus you get the benefit of an
- 25:01educational outcome because
- 25:02you've got better nutrition.
- 25:04And there's also a jobs an
- 25:07economic impact for someone who
- 25:10has a health outcome. They're
- 25:12more productive in the
- 25:15workplace. They're safer in the
- 25:16workplace. If they're not
- 25:17working, they've got an
- 25:19opportunity to do better in an
- 25:20interview. So we often talk
- 25:22about the food, but the
- 25:23outcomes are really all about
- 25:25health, work and education.
- 25:27>> Yeah. So do you see that
- 25:29that connection representative?
- 25:31>> Yes, I do, but I think it's
- 25:33important to point out we're
- 25:35talking about education and
- 25:37teaching people who are
- 25:38receiving these benefits. We
- 25:40had an entire program and
- 25:43department that this was their
- 25:44sole responsibility. SNAP Ed
- 25:47was to educate people who
- 25:49received Snap benefits to know
- 25:50about the double dollars
- 25:52program, to know how to use
- 25:54their benefit to cook healthy
- 25:55and nutritious meals. They had
- 25:58recipes. They had, you know,
- 26:00hundreds of people at
- 26:01University of Kentucky. This
- 26:03was their sole job or
- 26:04responsibility. And they did
- 26:06this and that entire department
- 26:07here in Kentucky and across the
- 26:09country was eliminated by the
- 26:12big whatever you want to call
- 26:13it, bill that passed Congress.
- 26:15So we're duplicating new
- 26:17programs that try to do new
- 26:19things to teach people. When we
- 26:21had the infrastructure already
- 26:23in place to do that exact same
- 26:25thing. Now it's great. I think
- 26:27food and medicine is a
- 26:28wonderful program. It's going
- 26:29to do a lot of good in the
- 26:31Commonwealth, but we're
- 26:32shooting ourselves in the foot
- 26:33on the left side, and then
- 26:35we're trying to reduplicate and
- 26:36do the other thing on the right
- 26:38side. If we left the program in
- 26:39place, we would have been a lot
- 26:41better shape right now. Today.
- 26:42>> Yeah. Chairman, how how do
- 26:44you see it?
- 26:45>> I think that what doesn't
- 26:46need to get lost in all of this
- 26:48is how incredibly complex this
- 26:50is. And there's no one silver
- 26:51bullet that's going to fix
- 26:52everything. Representative. All
- 26:54goes down a political route on
- 26:55this. And I think we've seen a
- 26:57lot of times have been a lot of
- 26:59big government programs. And
- 27:01these great educational
- 27:01programs that go in and they're
- 27:03going to change the way people
- 27:04operate and the way they live.
- 27:06And that all sounds great, but
- 27:08it typically doesn't produce
- 27:09the greatest of results. But
- 27:10here's what one thing that will
- 27:12change the results of how kids
- 27:14learn to eat is what they see
- 27:16their mother and father or
- 27:18grandparents cooking at home.
- 27:19And if we can introduce those
- 27:21practices into our homes, then
- 27:24that's going to leave a more
- 27:26lasting imprint. That's going
- 27:27to be in the mapping of our
- 27:29kids, to be able to be able to
- 27:32change some of the systemic
- 27:33ways that we approach nutrition
- 27:35in a lot of our communities.
- 27:36>> It's not political. That's
- 27:38exactly what Snap-ed did. They
- 27:39did it in the community, in
- 27:41their house. They taught people
- 27:42how to use their benefits. It
- 27:44was not a political. It's
- 27:46exactly what that program.
- 27:47>> So what was the rationale
- 27:48for eliminating it?
- 27:49>> You'd have to talk to the
- 27:51president and the Congress that
- 27:52voted for it, the people who
- 27:53voted for it and against it.
- 27:55>> Yeah. Anyone else care to
- 27:56comment on that? I would okay.
- 27:58>> I think more important than
- 27:59this is to focus on the things
- 28:01that we can control here in
- 28:03Kentucky. That's what we're
- 28:04here about tonight. That's what
- 28:05we're focusing on. And being
- 28:06able to introduce the the more
- 28:08healthier approaches to food.
- 28:10And the food is medicine arena.
- 28:12And being able to adjust these
- 28:14aren't revolutionary new
- 28:16concepts. When I started to
- 28:18school 50 years ago, we learned
- 28:19about nutrition, trees and how
- 28:21many fruits and vegetables that
- 28:22we were supposed to consume on
- 28:24a daily basis. But applying
- 28:26this in some of the things
- 28:28we're talking about is
- 28:30incredibly complex. I had a
- 28:32meeting in Commissioner
- 28:33Schill's office to address how
- 28:34we were going to view some of
- 28:36this stuff a week or so ago,
- 28:38and we're talking about working
- 28:39through Medicaid waivers to
- 28:41changing the way that we do
- 28:43government contracting for for
- 28:47suppliers in our in our systems,
- 28:49for schools and hospitals.
- 28:52These there are all these
- 28:54tentacles of these issues that
- 28:55run so deep. And as legislators,
- 28:58legislators, those are some of
- 28:59the responsibilities that we're
- 29:01going to have if we're going to
- 29:02have to to make some real
- 29:04systemic changes, we're going
- 29:05to have to change the way we
- 29:07approach and really commit to
- 29:08to the food as medicine
- 29:09approach if we're going to see
- 29:11any real benefits.
- 29:12>> So, Miss Feldman, what are
- 29:13what case are you making to
- 29:15Senator Howell on what they
- 29:16should be considering when they
- 29:17meet in January for the 2020
- 29:19legislative.
- 29:20>> Session for two hours?
- 29:22>> Can you give us the Nut Graf
- 29:24version of top three, maybe?
- 29:26>> Well, I didn't have the
- 29:28pleasure of being in that
- 29:29meeting the other day, but some
- 29:31some of the things that the
- 29:33senator mentioned, it's it's
- 29:35trying to find the
- 29:35reimbursement for the food, for
- 29:37food, whether it's food boxes,
- 29:40whether it's a food
- 29:41prescription. We talk a lot
- 29:43about medically tailored meals
- 29:44to address acute, chronic needs.
- 29:46We talk about maybe it's a
- 29:48grocery prescription or a
- 29:49voucher to go to the grocery
- 29:51store to use on healthy food,
- 29:53that that is one piece that is
- 29:55going to be very challenging to,
- 29:56to get through because we
- 29:58talked that no one's done it
- 29:59yet. So it is hard. I call it a
- 30:02project that we're just going
- 30:03to have to chip away at here
- 30:05and there to make it happen. It
- 30:07is going to happen. I do
- 30:08believe that. But we need to
- 30:10have reimbursement. Model is
- 30:12probably where it's going to be
- 30:13most sustainable.
- 30:14>> And when you say
- 30:15reimbursement model for the
- 30:16layperson at home, it's like
- 30:18reimburse who and what and how
- 30:19much.
- 30:20>> Well, well, those are some
- 30:22of the things that are going to
- 30:23have to be determined in terms
- 30:25of of the how much, but some,
- 30:27some programs in the country, I
- 30:28went to a food as medicine
- 30:30conference in DC about a year
- 30:32and a half ago, and it's coming
- 30:34through Medicaid and it's
- 30:35coming through those programs.
- 30:36The reimbursements are those
- 30:37those programs already
- 30:38reimbursed for health care
- 30:40intervention intervention
- 30:41programs already. It's and we
- 30:44do have to, unfortunately,
- 30:46prove time and time again that
- 30:48food is a health intervention,
- 30:49just like medicine would be.
- 30:51But but that's that's one of
- 30:53the arms of, of one of the
- 30:56tentacles that we're, we're
- 30:57trying to tackle. And of course,
- 30:59the Agriculture Department
- 30:59alone can't do that. It's too
- 31:01multifaceted across many
- 31:02different divisions and
- 31:04departments within the state.
- 31:05But that's one thing to look at.
- 31:07Another thing that we are
- 31:08looking at, when I talked about
- 31:10having more local products into
- 31:13cafeterias and the health, the
- 31:16dietitians and what the
- 31:17dietitians choose and the
- 31:18cafeteria managers choose at
- 31:19the hospitals, it's probably
- 31:20looking at their distribution
- 31:21contracts. And so we're talking
- 31:23maybe doing some intervention
- 31:24on some of the contracts with
- 31:26the large nationwide food
- 31:29distributors. That's going to
- 31:30be challenging, too, because a
- 31:32lot of that food right now, the
- 31:34produce is coming from
- 31:35California. It's not coming
- 31:36from Kentucky. And it's how do
- 31:37we how do we make some changes
- 31:39to kind of turn that ship to
- 31:41say, you can get the
- 31:42strawberries year round in
- 31:43Kentucky right now, why are you
- 31:45always going to another state
- 31:46for those things? So there are
- 31:48a lot of layers to the food as
- 31:50medicine puzzle, but they're
- 31:51going to come together. It's
- 31:52just going to take some time
- 31:54and some elbow grease and some
- 31:55ingenuity to get there.
- 31:56>> Well, I'd like to yeah.
- 31:58>> I really think that our
- 32:00insurance partners there at the
- 32:01table. So for 2026 we have
- 32:04partnerships with four of our
- 32:05Medicaid providers and they are
- 32:07open to testing. What does it
- 32:09look like. But it's a you know,
- 32:11it is a business. And so we
- 32:13need to show them what are the
- 32:14health benefits and what's that
- 32:16return on investment. And the
- 32:17one thing I'd love to see our
- 32:19legislators think about if this
- 32:20is the dollar price, what can
- 32:22we reimburse farmers for the
- 32:24incremental price on top of
- 32:26that basic cost? So if a basic
- 32:28cost of a meal is $4.50, can we
- 32:30reimburse for an additional
- 32:33$1.50 for that farmer? That
- 32:35means it's local food. It comes
- 32:36back to the farmer, but it's
- 32:38health that goes back to that
- 32:39patient that's enrolled in the
- 32:41Food as medicine program. So I
- 32:42think our commissioner shell,
- 32:44our secretary, cabinet, Health
- 32:46and Family Services doctor
- 32:48stack there, and our
- 32:50commissioner of Medicaid, that
- 32:51everyone wants these solutions.
- 32:53I think it just takes a lot of
- 32:55time and layering to figure out
- 32:57what is that right rate and how
- 32:59do we help our farmers at the
- 33:01same time?
- 33:01>> Sure. Yeah. Senator, go
- 33:03ahead.
- 33:03>> For both of those comments.
- 33:04Just a simple example. The
- 33:06major distributors that Miss
- 33:07Feldman mentioned, they all
- 33:10work with suppliers to forward
- 33:12contract for, for food products.
- 33:15But in Kentucky, we do not have
- 33:17a we're not set up to where
- 33:19under our model procurement
- 33:20code to where producers can
- 33:22forward contract with schools,
- 33:23with hospitals, with VA, that
- 33:25sort of thing. On a micro level,
- 33:27to be able to do this and be
- 33:29able to to service our food
- 33:30locally. So we have to go back
- 33:32in and change the way we do our
- 33:34procurement code to allow our
- 33:35local producers in the state to
- 33:37be able to forward contract so
- 33:38they can take advantage of the
- 33:40market and the way the market
- 33:42works in everything else. All
- 33:43of our grain farmers, they live
- 33:45and die on forward contracting,
- 33:47but our squash farmers in
- 33:49Kentucky, that is a more
- 33:50emerging and more micro
- 33:51industry. They haven't gotten
- 33:53there yet. So we have a gap in
- 33:55here that we've got to address
- 33:57and be able to bridge.
- 33:58>> And people would say, just
- 33:59change the procurement code.
- 34:00What's the holdup.
- 34:01>> On that?
- 34:02>> So just change the
- 34:03procurement code. That's one
- 34:04question with about 27.
- 34:06>> Parts as we can tell.
- 34:07>> And that's something that
- 34:08we're working through. And
- 34:09quite candidly, I think that
- 34:11it's been on the forefront of a
- 34:13lot of people's mind for a long
- 34:14time. But I think we have more
- 34:16of a perfect storm of people
- 34:18focused on this. And quite
- 34:19honestly, being led by
- 34:20Commissioner Schill, who he and
- 34:21his staff are willing to sit
- 34:23down and grind through the
- 34:24minutia of going through some
- 34:25of this stuff and working with
- 34:27people in the legislature, such
- 34:28as myself, that are willing to
- 34:29sit and grind through some of
- 34:31this stuff and find out how to
- 34:33change the procurement code.
- 34:34There's nothing sexy about
- 34:35going in and redoing.
- 34:36>> Procurement codes, and how.
- 34:37>> All of this goes into
- 34:38different things in the state,
- 34:40but it's the things that we're
- 34:41going to have to do if we're
- 34:43going to move forward in this
- 34:44issue with locally produced
- 34:45foods that come from Kentucky
- 34:47that are healthy.
- 34:47>> Right. Miss McDonald.
- 34:48>> And I go to the education
- 34:50piece that's so crucial here
- 34:51because, you know, if we can
- 34:53start early and we can get
- 34:54these local foods, fresh fruits
- 34:56and vegetables, protein sources
- 34:58that we have grown here in our
- 35:00state into our school system.
- 35:01You know, the farm to school
- 35:03model has been around for
- 35:05decades. Amazing model. But
- 35:06it's the procurement that's
- 35:07always been the hindrance or
- 35:09it's been the processing,
- 35:11because you have a lot of
- 35:13cafeteria staff that are
- 35:14smaller now than they were
- 35:16possibly back in the 80s and
- 35:1790s. They're not doing the
- 35:19scratch cooking. They need more
- 35:21of those prepared opportunities.
- 35:22For example, you have a farmer
- 35:24that has an amazing amount of
- 35:25corn and that wants to get that
- 35:27corn, local corn into the
- 35:28school. Well, that means that
- 35:30there has to be somebody that
- 35:31can shuck the corn, can take
- 35:33the corn off the cob, and then
- 35:35to be able to help either flash
- 35:36freeze it so that it can be
- 35:38reheated. So there's a lot of
- 35:40nuances.
- 35:40>> For hundreds of kids.
- 35:41>> Yes, for hundreds of kids.
- 35:43So I have to give a big shout
- 35:45out to the Kentucky School
- 35:46Nutrition Association, who has
- 35:47done such an amazing job of
- 35:48making sure that try and find
- 35:50little kind of like those
- 35:51tentacles to make it work.
- 35:53Representative all did a great
- 35:55job of trying to really push
- 35:57through a local food bill. A
- 35:59couple of years ago. Our
- 36:00Commissioner shell has been
- 36:01doing an amazing job. All of
- 36:03this goes to because if we can
- 36:05make sure that our children
- 36:06with with school breakfast and
- 36:07school lunch being a critical
- 36:09piece to that child's day and
- 36:12making sure that they're
- 36:13getting the opportunities to
- 36:14have those fresh, local,
- 36:15healthy foods, then their
- 36:18longevity and their ability to
- 36:19thrive will be a much further
- 36:22trajectory than what it would
- 36:23be if it's not.
- 36:24>> Right. Even if those little
- 36:26square pizzas are good, they're
- 36:27not good for you, right?
- 36:29>> Right. You know, to be able
- 36:30to find an opportunity to be
- 36:32able to serve some additional
- 36:33product with that.
- 36:34>> That's right. Yeah. So
- 36:35representative, all I want to
- 36:36go back to what Melissa was
- 36:38talking about. What was the
- 36:39bill that you tried to put
- 36:41through and will you offer it
- 36:42up again next session.
- 36:43>> Sorry about that.
- 36:44>> No, I appreciate the
- 36:46opportunity. It was so
- 36:46representative Senator Cassie
- 36:47Chambers Armstrong and I, we
- 36:48worked together with the
- 36:49Kentucky School Nutrition
- 36:51Association and the the
- 36:52Kentucky Superintendents
- 36:54Association, the Principals
- 36:55Association, teachers, just
- 36:57about everybody and put
- 36:59together a round table and came
- 37:01up with this idea that many of
- 37:02our schools are on the
- 37:04community eligibility program.
- 37:06So if they have a number of
- 37:08children in their school that
- 37:09are eligible for free and
- 37:11reduced lunch, the school go
- 37:12ahead and they cover the
- 37:14additional cost to give free
- 37:16breakfast and lunch to all the
- 37:18children who are eating in that
- 37:20school that day. And there were
- 37:22some other states, like
- 37:23Michigan and others who had
- 37:25bridged that divide and covered
- 37:27the that cost at the state
- 37:29level for those schools. And so
- 37:31we came up with a different
- 37:33program where we were going to
- 37:34provide a reimbursement to that
- 37:36local school district who was
- 37:37already incurring that cost if
- 37:39they would go and purchase
- 37:40locally produced ag products.
- 37:42It was a win for local farmers,
- 37:45win for the kids because
- 37:46they're going to have better,
- 37:47more nutritious food. And it
- 37:49was going to help the schools
- 37:50reimburse them for an expense
- 37:52they already had.
- 37:54>> What was the fiscal note on
- 37:55that?
- 37:56>> The fiscal note was,
- 37:57depending on the the multiplier
- 37:58at the federal level, which is
- 38:00always kind of in play. And
- 38:02then how many schools at that
- 38:03exact.
- 38:04>> Sounds worse than
- 38:05procurement.
- 38:05>> Yeah.
- 38:06>> That exact year.
- 38:07>> Where taking part in the
- 38:09community eligibility program,
- 38:10because that number varies a
- 38:11little bit every year. But it
- 38:13was about an 8 to $12 million
- 38:16fiscal note. And lots of
- 38:18conversations. Lots of sponsors
- 38:20just could not get it quite
- 38:21across the finish line. I've
- 38:23been talking to some of my
- 38:25majority party colleagues
- 38:26across the aisle to see if they
- 38:27want to take that ball and run
- 38:29with it. I've talked to several
- 38:31of them on the ag committee
- 38:32about that bill, and I, and
- 38:34I've talked to Commissioner
- 38:35Shell, and I know he's trying
- 38:36to see how he can, in an
- 38:38innovative way, kind of roll
- 38:40that into the Food is Medicine
- 38:41program. We actually had a
- 38:43hearing in Frankfort last week
- 38:44in agriculture where we talked
- 38:46about this, this very subject,
- 38:48because our kids, at the end of
- 38:50the day, if we can get local
- 38:52Kentucky produced ag products
- 38:55and the school district on
- 38:56their plate, it's a win for
- 38:58everybody involved. And so
- 38:59that's what we're focused on.
- 39:01>> And is there enough of that
- 39:02supply to do that for every kid
- 39:04in Kentucky?
- 39:05>> Well, I think there's enough
- 39:07to do the start. It may not be
- 39:09enough to be a 100% replacement,
- 39:11but if we're talking about five,
- 39:14ten, 15%, yes, for certain
- 39:16things, you know, we produce
- 39:18honey, you know, we to your
- 39:19point, strawberries and a lot
- 39:21of the butternut squash. I was
- 39:23down at a. West six the on
- 39:27Saturday and we were doing a
- 39:29food drive. And they had
- 39:30hundreds of thousands of
- 39:32butternut squash that we were
- 39:33washing and peeling and getting
- 39:34ready. And so there are certain
- 39:36produce that we can provide
- 39:37here locally. We're not going
- 39:38to have it all, but we're not
- 39:40talking about it all because we
- 39:42can't probably afford the
- 39:43entire fiscal impact of doing a
- 39:44100% replacement. But on the
- 39:45margin, yeah, we can do that.
- 39:47>> Right. And to to Melissa's
- 39:49point about having the staff in
- 39:50the school who can do all of
- 39:52these things, whether it's
- 39:53shucking corn and all of that.
- 39:55I mean, that takes some
- 39:56manpower in the schools. So the
- 39:59delivery and the delivery,
- 40:00right? Yeah. You want to pick
- 40:02up on that?
- 40:02>> Well, I would say that in
- 40:04the food is medicine space. And
- 40:06the school procurement
- 40:06Department of Agriculture is
- 40:08also working on a large school
- 40:10procurement project as well. It
- 40:11is to to get a start, just as
- 40:14the representative explained.
- 40:15But choose Kentucky first. How
- 40:18do we make it? So you choose
- 40:19Kentucky first and then fill in
- 40:21with whatever else that you
- 40:22need. We are not going to be
- 40:24able to supply hospitals and
- 40:26schools tomorrow. There are two
- 40:28of the largest institutions in
- 40:30the state that buy food in
- 40:32almost every county, every city.
- 40:33But how do we start to turn the
- 40:36tide to say, I'm going to
- 40:37choose Kentucky first, and then
- 40:39go and find out what else I
- 40:40need? And to also talk about
- 40:43Senator's Point on the forward
- 40:44contracting. I was invited to
- 40:47go to Needmore Acres Farm last
- 40:49week for a summit that Michelle
- 40:51and Nathan Hale had, and their
- 40:53farmers. They farm about seven
- 40:54acres, I think. And Nathan Hale
- 40:56said, if I know that it's
- 40:58coming, I'll plant it, but I
- 41:00can't plant it and not know
- 41:02where it's going. I have to
- 41:04know. So changing that model to
- 41:05do more of that forward
- 41:07contracting is one of those
- 41:08keys. Getting more on farm
- 41:10processing and more processors
- 41:11in the state is key, because if
- 41:13you can send the corn to the
- 41:14school and it's already ready,
- 41:16you have taken out a lot of the
- 41:18the problem of trying to make
- 41:19sure you're using that product.
- 41:20>> Yeah, yeah.
- 41:21>> Go ahead. Yeah.
- 41:22>> A couple of things.
- 41:24>> First of all, with butternut
- 41:25squash dice tossed with a
- 41:27little pepper and brown sugar
- 41:28and roasted for about 30
- 41:30minutes. That's the better way
- 41:31of doing this. We don't need
- 41:33the recipe for that. But in all
- 41:34seriousness, to represent
- 41:36Duvall's point and what Miss
- 41:37Feldman was talking about, we
- 41:39don't have to get to 100%.
- 41:41We're not. We may not get to
- 41:43100% of production in schools
- 41:46and hospitals with Kentucky
- 41:48proud products in my lifetime.
- 41:50Right now, we're where we are
- 41:52right now. We can't service
- 41:54that. We can't purchase some of
- 41:56the some of the products that
- 41:58we have now year long in a
- 42:00school year. The way we're set
- 42:01up and structured, this is
- 42:02going to be a really long
- 42:04process with a long runway, and
- 42:06I think it's important for us
- 42:08to do to take whatever steps we
- 42:10can to make sure the minimum in
- 42:12the kind of the critical mass
- 42:13that we seem to have on this
- 42:15issue right now, to be able to
- 42:17sustain that until we can get
- 42:18to 10 or 15%, 15% was a number
- 42:20that represented of all used.
- 42:22And I think that would make a
- 42:23huge difference in what we're
- 42:25talking about. And there's a
- 42:26line in there somewhere where
- 42:28the market consolidates from
- 42:29both supply and demand, and
- 42:30then you can move forward with
- 42:32big gaps and big jumps into
- 42:33production.
- 42:34>> Mr. Halligan yeah.
- 42:35>> So just the whole notion of
- 42:38contracting for acreage, right.
- 42:40So we talked earlier about
- 42:42reinforcement value, whatever
- 42:43the number is, if we know what
- 42:45a reimbursement value is for a
- 42:48type of food produce, and we're
- 42:51working with some 200 farmers
- 42:54today through feeding Kentucky.
- 42:56Now, not only can we access
- 42:59seconds that might not sell,
- 43:01but we can work with every
- 43:03single one of those farmers to
- 43:04say, let's carve out an acre
- 43:06for this and or an acre for
- 43:08that. We know the demand is
- 43:10there from a food insecurity
- 43:12standpoint. Right? We talked
- 43:13earlier about food insecurity
- 43:15and the awareness of food
- 43:17insecurity probably being
- 43:18higher than it's ever been. And
- 43:20in the 45 minutes that we've
- 43:22been sitting here talking, just
- 43:23think about all the amazing
- 43:24ideas that we've bantered back
- 43:26and forth around. We set aside
- 43:29some funding with one of the
- 43:31managed care organizations, or
- 43:32through some kind of
- 43:34reimbursement, and we pilot
- 43:36contracting for acreage to
- 43:37plant crop. We have an outlet
- 43:39where it can go. It's called a
- 43:41hungry, you know, someone who's
- 43:43experiencing hunger. And I
- 43:44think we've got an opportunity
- 43:46to test some things right now.
- 43:49So my encouragement would be,
- 43:51let's find some funding. Let's
- 43:54test it. Let's prove the
- 43:56concept and let's go.
- 43:57>> Well.
- 43:58>> Because we know there are
- 44:00750,000 people across the
- 44:01Commonwealth of Kentucky who
- 44:03were experiencing hunger before
- 44:04the shutdown. That number is
- 44:06probably higher today. And we
- 44:08know that nutrition is going to
- 44:10make a difference.
- 44:10>> It seems like maybe some
- 44:12logical partners start with who
- 44:13you're already working with,
- 44:14miss Feldman. Right. Kentucky
- 44:15Association of Health Plans,
- 44:17Kentucky Farm Bureau Federation
- 44:18and insurance. I mean, these
- 44:20are the stakeholders.
- 44:21>> Yes. These are the
- 44:23stakeholders. We talked about
- 44:24Kentucky Hospital Association
- 44:25as well, and it's not going to
- 44:28be done by just one agency and
- 44:30just one department. It's not
- 44:31going to be done in a vacuum.
- 44:33We are as the Department of
- 44:35Agriculture, we are ready to
- 44:36work with anybody who wants to
- 44:38push this forward. It's going
- 44:39to take all of us to come
- 44:41together. Some of us in this
- 44:43room have been working together
- 44:44for a number of years on some
- 44:46of these challenges. Yes. And I
- 44:47think, I think we I think you
- 44:49have it solved on, on what the
- 44:51pilot needs to be. Yeah, but
- 44:52but it's going to take everyone
- 44:54to come together. And like you
- 44:55mentioned, the critical mass is
- 44:57here. We need to take advantage
- 44:58of that.
- 44:59>> Yeah. Are you a Bill drafter
- 45:00too, Mr. Halligan? Because you
- 45:02can work with.
- 45:02>> The legislators.
- 45:03>> I'm a farm boy from Iowa and
- 45:05I'm a supply chain guy. So it's
- 45:07like it's in the ground. It
- 45:08needs to be to somebody's fork.
- 45:10Let's figure out how to go from
- 45:12farm to fork as fast as we can.
- 45:14>> Yeah, yeah.
- 45:14>> And like yesterday. Right.
- 45:16Because the demand is going to
- 45:17be ever increasing. Right. What
- 45:18do you think about all this? I
- 45:20mean, you're hearing all these
- 45:21ideas and you've been you all
- 45:23talk about this stuff all the
- 45:24time.
- 45:25>> You do talk about it all the
- 45:27time. I think all these ideas
- 45:28are fantastic. I think in the
- 45:30long term, having a variety of
- 45:31sources that fund food
- 45:32insecurity, work and health
- 45:33care is vital. So when we have
- 45:35insurance covering a certain
- 45:36part of that, when we have
- 45:37federal government SNAP
- 45:38covering another part of that,
- 45:40we need a I call it a suite of
- 45:43options in order to address
- 45:45food insecurity in those health
- 45:46outcomes. So I think that's one
- 45:48model that our state is really
- 45:50good at, right? We're really
- 45:52good at bringing in together
- 45:53because we're small and we all
- 45:55know each other. We play in the
- 45:57sandbox pretty nicely. And so
- 45:58we have those different
- 46:00partners coming, you know,
- 46:01coming together to address that.
- 46:02I think what's important to
- 46:04remember is that when we do
- 46:05address food insecurity, we see
- 46:06a change in health outcomes. We
- 46:08see a reduction in blood
- 46:09pressure. We see a reduction in
- 46:11hemoglobin A1-c blood glucose.
- 46:13We see way better health
- 46:15outcomes for high risk pregnant
- 46:16moms and then for babies.
- 46:18>> But are those who are food
- 46:20insecure? Do they consistently
- 46:22have a medical home and visit a
- 46:25medical doctor on a regular
- 46:26basis to get all of those stats?
- 46:28>> Yes. You know what is
- 46:30surprising to me, Renee? When
- 46:32we offer high patient touch. So
- 46:34we have referral coordinators
- 46:35that we do biweekly check ins.
- 46:37And so we have a program right
- 46:39now with U of L. And so it's a
- 46:41caregiver and up to two
- 46:42children. And we call every
- 46:44week. And we say how is the
- 46:46food program going. Do you like
- 46:47it. Do you have questions about
- 46:49how to cook. Do you have
- 46:50questions about what you're
- 46:51allowed to buy. So one mom
- 46:53wanted to buy fried chicken.
- 46:54You're not allowed to. Nope,
- 46:55nope. Because this is food is
- 46:57medicine. This isn't just food
- 46:58for the sake of food. This is
- 47:00food as medicine. You are not
- 47:01buying fried chicken, right?
- 47:02And so once she got through
- 47:04that, she then sent us her
- 47:05grocery receipt and said, my
- 47:07kids picked all this out and it
- 47:09was all fruits, vegetables,
- 47:10lean protein, low fat dairy,
- 47:11exactly what we want.
- 47:12>> And did they eat it?
- 47:14>> Yes. And then on top of it,
- 47:16they came back to their doctor
- 47:18because it's high patient touch.
- 47:19We need to meet people where
- 47:21they are and engage with them
- 47:23and they respond. They want
- 47:24good things for themselves and
- 47:26their kids.
- 47:26>> Yeah.
- 47:27>> They want good things for
- 47:29themselves and their kids. Yeah,
- 47:30they want it.
- 47:31>> Maybe the the default
- 47:32thinking is that they'll just
- 47:34take whatever they can get, and
- 47:36it doesn't matter if it's good
- 47:37or bad. And that's.
- 47:38>> And I disagree. Yeah, it
- 47:40does matter. And we don't want
- 47:41to throw junk in people's faces.
- 47:43We want good healthy local food
- 47:44in at their homes. And we see
- 47:46amazing health outcomes when we
- 47:47do that.
- 47:48>> Well. The Make America
- 47:49Healthy Again Task Force
- 47:50Kentucky Task force has talked
- 47:51about some of this, right about,
- 47:53you know, when we talk about
- 47:54some of the changes in
- 47:56assistance and being able to,
- 47:58you know, use your dollars for
- 48:00more healthy options, right.
- 48:02This is part of some of that
- 48:03conversation.
- 48:04>> Yeah. It is. I'm not on that
- 48:06task force. But we've had
- 48:07people come testify and read
- 48:09some of their press releases.
- 48:11You know, this is this is
- 48:12something we were doing
- 48:13beforehand. It's something
- 48:14we're doing afterwards. I don't
- 48:16think it matters where it's
- 48:17coming from. As long as the
- 48:19message is being delivered to
- 48:20the end user on how to use
- 48:22their funding for better health
- 48:24outcomes. And I think at the
- 48:26end of the day, we, you know,
- 48:28hunger is not a it's not a
- 48:29political issue. It's it's a
- 48:31people issue. And how are we
- 48:32going to work together to make
- 48:34things better?
- 48:34>> Yeah. Doctor Gustafson, I
- 48:37remember many years ago in
- 48:39Louisville, they were
- 48:40addressing food deserts and not
- 48:42having a local grocery store.
- 48:44So they partnered with
- 48:45convenience stores to actually
- 48:47have produce. And you know what
- 48:49happened there? The produce
- 48:50rotted. Yes. Right. So help us,
- 48:54like help us help. Why
- 48:55understand why that happened?
- 48:57>> Yeah. No problem. So it's
- 48:59because you are not engaging
- 49:01and they're not part of the
- 49:02decision making. So if I come
- 49:04into your house and I say I've
- 49:06made you this kale soup and you
- 49:08didn't ask for kale soup, are
- 49:10you going to eat my kale soup?
- 49:12You are not going to eat my
- 49:13kale soup. And so we have seen
- 49:15over time and again, when you
- 49:17are not engaging the patient,
- 49:18the member, the customer, that
- 49:20end user in the decision making
- 49:22process, and we just throw
- 49:24random food at them, you are
- 49:25not eating it, you are not
- 49:27cooking it. You are. You are
- 49:29not giving it to your children.
- 49:30And so this our program offers
- 49:32that suite of options.
- 49:33Sometimes people do better with
- 49:34a meal kit, you know, from a
- 49:36locally grown farmer. Some
- 49:38people just do better going to
- 49:39the grocery store and the
- 49:41farmer's market. And so we need
- 49:42to have options. And so I think
- 49:44that food is medicine platform.
- 49:46We can allow those options. So
- 49:48we have amazing medically
- 49:49tailored meal providers in our
- 49:51state who are using local food.
- 49:53FoodChain Kings kitchen they're
- 49:54sourcing from local farmers. Is
- 49:56the whole meal local? No,
- 49:58because it can't be, but is a
- 50:00good percentage of it? Yes it
- 50:01is. So again, we do not want to
- 50:04come in as we're going to tell
- 50:06people what to do. We want to
- 50:07invite them to the table, offer
- 50:09a suite of options, but within
- 50:10that, no, it isn't going to be
- 50:12back to my fried chicken. It is
- 50:15not going to be French fries.
- 50:16Your suite of options is still
- 50:18around the healthy palette,
- 50:19right?
- 50:19>> Right. Let's talk real
- 50:22quickly as we as we go out.
- 50:25Melissa, about if you could
- 50:27suggest policy to lawmakers
- 50:30about food insecurity, what's
- 50:32one idea that you hope that
- 50:34these two gentlemen on the ends
- 50:35would help push along.
- 50:38>> I coming from a background
- 50:40of working in schools and
- 50:42specifically working with child
- 50:43nutrition, I think if we can
- 50:45really focus on our schools and
- 50:48ensuring that healthy foods
- 50:50that we have security of
- 50:52breakfast and lunch and making
- 50:54sure that we take care and have
- 50:56the community eligibility
- 50:57provision programing, because
- 50:58we know that food insecurity is,
- 51:01you know, across the board. And
- 51:03if families are being hit hard
- 51:04now, they've been hit hard for
- 51:06years. And I always say that
- 51:09any time you have a food
- 51:11insecure mother, there are
- 51:12children right behind her and
- 51:15making sure that if they can at
- 51:17least get breakfast and lunch,
- 51:19even a dinner program through
- 51:20the Cakephp program or the kids
- 51:23cafe funding that. Cakephp
- 51:25child adult feeding program.
- 51:27Thank you that even that our
- 51:29food banks are able to provide
- 51:31or our summer feeding
- 51:33opportunities that.
- 51:33>> Many of.
- 51:34>> You mentioned about school.
- 51:35But when they're not in school,
- 51:37what's the option?
- 51:37>> The other great thing. So if
- 51:39we can make sure that we have
- 51:41policies that keep the summer
- 51:42feeding program alive, that
- 51:43ensure that food banks can be
- 51:45able to do food pantries, can
- 51:47do feeding sites, along with
- 51:48schools, libraries. Stepped in
- 51:51to this this summer. We had the
- 51:53most feeding programs than most
- 51:56of the states of the country.
- 51:57It was amazing how many feeding
- 51:59programs we've had across our
- 52:01state to be able to ensure that
- 52:03kids have an opportunity to eat
- 52:06365 days a year, because if we
- 52:08can start out early and we can
- 52:10make sure that we're getting
- 52:11them fed, then it can really
- 52:13lead to some wonderful outcomes.
- 52:16Yeah, that would be probably
- 52:17where I would start. And then
- 52:19ensuring that we have federally
- 52:21ensuring that we have support
- 52:22for our emergency, the Tefap
- 52:24funding, the Emergency Food
- 52:26Assistance Program, which is
- 52:28crucial for our our food banks
- 52:29to be able to keep their their
- 52:32shelves stocked.
- 52:32>> Yeah. Mr. Halligan, you've
- 52:34already given us some ideas to
- 52:35chew on. You got another?
- 52:37>> So the. We do not solve
- 52:39hunger without a robust public
- 52:43private partnership. And
- 52:46whatever we can do to stretch
- 52:49donated dollars, government
- 52:51dollars, purchase product
- 52:54dollars so that we are
- 52:56accessing more food and
- 52:58distributing that food for the
- 53:00same dollar. It just makes us
- 53:03all more efficient. Right? So
- 53:04my encouragement is for all of
- 53:06us to think creatively about
- 53:09how to make $1, two and two
- 53:12four, because that turns into
- 53:14more nutritious food. So a lot
- 53:17of the things that Melissa just
- 53:19talked about are a big part of
- 53:21it. The notion of doing some
- 53:22kind of a pilot with a
- 53:24reimbursement program, it's all
- 53:28about the efficiencies of scale
- 53:30and those donated dollars and
- 53:32those governmental dollars and
- 53:34those private dollars being
- 53:36cost effective.
- 53:38>> Yeah.
- 53:38>> Dana, would you like to give
- 53:40us some parting words about
- 53:41what you would recommend?
- 53:42You're already working on a lot,
- 53:43but.
- 53:44>> We are working on a lot.
- 53:45Thank you. I think you will see
- 53:47that we'll have some
- 53:49resolutions and maybe some
- 53:49legislation around school
- 53:51procurement and around food as
- 53:52medicine, just kind of start to
- 53:54lay the groundwork and make
- 53:55making it easier to choose
- 53:57Kentucky first. Yeah. And it
- 53:58might be changing the
- 53:59procurement code as well.
- 54:00>> So I think that's going to
- 54:02be job number one. Right. Which
- 54:04is you get that done on day one.
- 54:06You, Senator, Mr. Chairman, you
- 54:07can take care of that. Get that
- 54:09through the first five days of
- 54:10words. Last words from you.
- 54:12>> Yeah. I think it's something
- 54:13that we need to keep in mind is
- 54:16that we have a lot of good
- 54:17ideas. But in government, in
- 54:19the federal level and state
- 54:20level, both has have made a
- 54:22history out of throwing money
- 54:24at good ideas and not getting
- 54:26good results. And we have to
- 54:28dig down into the
- 54:30infrastructure and all of the
- 54:32supply chains. I think Doctor
- 54:33Gustafson brought up a good
- 54:35point about getting people to
- 54:36buy in to making part of their
- 54:39decision and involving the
- 54:40people that are consuming the
- 54:42food into the decisions. In
- 54:43order to change outlook, we
- 54:45have to be able to do that up
- 54:47and down our supply chain and
- 54:48the local level too. We're
- 54:49starting to go down that road
- 54:51better. In the last couple of
- 54:52years in the legislature, we've
- 54:54allocated some funding for
- 54:55rural agricultural economic
- 54:56development. I sponsored a bill
- 54:58to to put some framework around
- 54:59that in this past session, so
- 55:01we can go in and build out our
- 55:03processing group, the great
- 55:05sweet corn that you referenced
- 55:07earlier is not going to be
- 55:10shucked and cooked in a in a
- 55:13school cafeteria. It's going to
- 55:14be done in a processing place
- 55:16somewhere, and it's going to
- 55:17arrive on pallets, refrigerated
- 55:18pallets in the schools. And we
- 55:20have to build out that part of
- 55:22our infrastructure if we're
- 55:23going to take this down the
- 55:24road.
- 55:25>> Yeah.
- 55:25>> You got 10s worth of thought
- 55:27there.
- 55:27>> Hunger is not red. Hunger is
- 55:29not blue. It affects everybody
- 55:31equally. And we need to put
- 55:32down our party labels and do
- 55:34what we can collectively,
- 55:35together as a commonwealth, to
- 55:37feed every one of our neighbors.
- 55:38>> All right. We'll have to
- 55:40leave it there. We thank you
- 55:41all. This has been a very good
- 55:43discussion, animated and
- 55:44informative, and I appreciate
- 55:45it. And if we've been a part of
- 55:47the conversation that happens
- 55:48in Frankfort, well, that's all
- 55:49the better to well, we're off
- 55:50next Monday for Ken Burns
- 55:52American Revolution documentary
- 55:53series. You do not want to be
- 55:54want to miss that at all. And
- 55:56be sure to join us each
- 55:58weeknight at 630 eastern, 530
- 55:59central for Kentucky edition,
- 56:00because we're going to break
- 56:01down a lot of these issues that
- 56:03we talked about tonight. And
- 56:04then join Bill Bryant and a
- 56:06team of working journalists to
- 56:07discuss the news of the week on
- 56:09Comment on Kentucky Friday at
- 56:10eight eastern, seven central,
- 56:11right here on KET. Thanks so
- 56:13much for being with us. When we
- 56:15come back in two weeks, we'll
- 56:16talk about Eastern Kentucky
- 56:17tourism. So that will be a
- 56:19discussion that you don't want
- 56:20to miss. Then. That's in two
- 56:22weeks on November 24th. I'm
- 56:23Renee Shaw until I see you
- 56:25again. Take really good care
- 56:26and be safe out there tonight
- 56:27if you're going to be out so
- 56:30long.