Latest / Film And Whiskey / On the Waterfront / Gentleman Jack Tennessee Whiskey
Transcript
- 0:00In 1954, director Elia Kazan and star Marlon Brando gave the
- 0:05world a poignant drama regarding the dangers of being a stoolie.
- 0:11In 2024 we try a whiskey that's meant for some higher ups.
- 0:16The film is on the waterfront. The whiskey is Gentleman Jack.
- 0:21More of you than both. This is the.
- 0:24Film and Whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:46podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:50glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:53It could have been a contender. That was perfect.
- 0:57I'm so proud of you. You've been working on that for
- 0:59weeks, haven't you? I did it on the spot without.
- 1:03Watch Really. No.
- 1:07And this week we are looking at the 1954 film On the Waterfront.
- 1:13Brad, each week I start our episodes by saying that we
- 1:15review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 1:18And that's always true in the general sense.
- 1:20Certainly true about the whiskey.
- 1:22I say it's definitely whiskey we're drinking.
- 1:25But you know, sometimes we kind of stretch the definition of a
- 1:27classic. And, you know, we've done whole
- 1:28seasons where we've just looked at modern films and it's really
- 1:32nice revisiting these Season 1 films, especially when you land
- 1:36on a movie like On the Waterfront, which is as highly
- 1:39regarded as an American movie can possibly be.
- 1:42This is in the conversation for one of the 10 most lauded
- 1:47American films ever made. It is the one that you hear
- 1:50actors, you know, jizz all over themselves about when they talk
- 1:53about Marlon Brando. Like it's just, I mean, let's
- 1:57be. Honest here dude.
- 1:58Raunchy here, my friend. If you hear any actor from 1954
- 2:03to now talk about Marlon Brando, this performance is going to
- 2:06come up and it's going to be, oh, this was the thing that got
- 2:09me into acting. It's all about on the
- 2:11waterfront. And so this movie carries a lot
- 2:15of cachet with it, is all I'm trying to say.
- 2:17Yeah, no, I this is number 19 on the AFI top 100.
- 2:22And would you say that it would be higher on the list if not for
- 2:27the Kazan reputation being attached to it?
- 2:32Good question. Yeah, it's funny because I think
- 2:34when the very first AFI list came out in 1998, it was number
- 2:388. And so when they revisited it 10
- 2:41years later, it had dropped to #19.
- 2:43Now I think part of that is just we're getting farther away from
- 2:46this movie coming on the scene in 1954.
- 2:48It's now 70 years old, and I think that as as people get
- 2:54older, like the idea of the method, acting, the Actor's
- 2:58Studio influence, it's been a little bit inflated.
- 3:01And it certainly was among the boomer generation and now
- 3:04younger generations just don't gravitate toward that as much.
- 3:08But I also think you've hit the nail on the head pretty early,
- 3:10man, because I don't know if it was just when we were all in
- 3:13lockdown in the pandemic, but people on Twitter started doing
- 3:17film history and found out some things about Elia Kazan and
- 3:21spoiler alert, they do not like him.
- 3:23No, you wouldn't say that. People on the left side of the
- 3:28political spectrum hate people who snitch on them.
- 3:34I mean, I feel like people on all sides of the political
- 3:36spectrum hate being snitched on. I think political affiliation
- 3:40has to do with, hey, man, don't rat me out.
- 3:44Maybe we should get this out of the way on the on the front,
- 3:46though, Brad, Like, I, I wanted it to be a point of conversation
- 3:48at some point today, but we've only done a couple Elia Kazan
- 3:52movies on the podcast, and I think we still haven't done one
- 3:55of his most famous ones, A Streetcar Named Desire.
- 3:58So Kazan is a very famous director at this point.
- 4:01He's already won an Academy Award for Best picture with
- 4:04gentleman's Agreement in the late 1940s.
- 4:06He makes Streetcar in 1951. This was Brando's big arrival
- 4:11onto the scene. It was the the explosiveness of
- 4:15this new style of acting that he brought to the screen.
- 4:18And this is like their big follow up to that.
- 4:21Now, Brando had obviously made movies in between, but On the
- 4:24Waterfront was their return to form in 1954.
- 4:27And so Kazan has his place in movie history kind of cemented
- 4:31already at this point. And this is a hard movie to
- 4:34grapple with because two years prior to this movie coming out,
- 4:38Kazan was called before the House on American Activities
- 4:41Committee. He whack to name names, to say
- 4:44who, who are them commies out there in Hollywood.
- 4:47And your boy Elia Kazan did did not keep his mouth shut.
- 4:52He named a whole bunch of names. To be specific, Bob, he named 8
- 4:57names and According to him they were all names that were already
- 5:03known by the Hue Act. Yes, as communist.
- 5:06Correct. Yeah, that that is important
- 5:08context because I think depending on how you want to
- 5:11look at the situation, cuz then willingly talked about this
- 5:15years later. Cuz I think he did an interview
- 5:17at one point where they were like, hey, like, you know, I'm
- 5:20sorry to bring up sensitive history.
- 5:21And he was like, it's not sensitive history.
- 5:23I'd do it again. My guy was proud of doing this.
- 5:28And so it gets a really hot topic even still in Hollywood.
- 5:32You know, if you watch, I mean, I, I say still the guy's not
- 5:35alive anymore, but you watch him collect his honorary Oscar for
- 5:39like a lifetime achievement later in life.
- 5:41There's a great video on YouTube of him coming out on the stage
- 5:44to collect this Oscar. And actors you and I know are in
- 5:48the audience and some of them stand up and clap for him.
- 5:51And some of them are sitting down on their hands and looking
- 5:53very, very angry at the man. So it's he has a very divisive
- 5:57legacy now. How does that reflect on the
- 6:01film? I think that's something we can
- 6:02get into. But Brad, coming into this
- 6:05revisit of On the Waterfront, I honestly can't remember if we
- 6:08talked about this in our first episode or not.
- 6:11Were you aware of everything that surrounded Kazan?
- 6:14I think we talked about it a little bit during last episode.
- 6:21This time through, I did a bit more of a deep dive.
- 6:24I watched the video of him receiving his lifetime
- 6:27achievement award where half the audience is seated and not
- 6:31clapping. Even, you know, the likes of
- 6:34Steven Spielberg. I believe he's clapping but
- 6:37would not stand up. Like, like you have all of these
- 6:41mixed responses from the crowd. And that led me down a rabbit
- 6:46hole where I read a lot about the Hue Act and Hollywood.
- 6:50And it seems like the general consensus is that nobody blames
- 6:55McCarthy for being McCarthy in this instance.
- 6:58Like, obviously they all hate his guts.
- 7:01But it's almost like if Donald Trump does something that
- 7:03liberals don't like, like, like they already hate him so much
- 7:08that it's like, yeah, Trump is going to do Trump thing.
- 7:11But it would be as if, I don't know a current, like, I don't
- 7:16know, like Nancy Pelosi came out and like, suddenly became a
- 7:20Trumpian. Like there's almost a deeper
- 7:23hate for her for turning on them right than for Trump.
- 7:27Well, I mean is. That is that a fair I was.
- 7:28Going to say, let's draw even more apartment comparison.
- 7:31It would be like Steven Spielberg becoming a tremor, you
- 7:34know what I mean? Sure.
- 7:35Yeah, yes. So how does this tie to the
- 7:39movie? I guess if you haven't seen this
- 7:41movie, you're very confused and you're wondering why we're
- 7:43talking about some director in Hollywood history.
- 7:45Now, the plot of the movie, Brad, will break down in just a
- 7:48minute. But in broad strokes, it is
- 7:49about a guy who rats a bunch of people out and is presented as
- 7:53the hero for doing it. And if you just watch this movie
- 7:56on face value, Brad, this is an incredible movie that we have to
- 8:00eat some pie, some humble pie about our thoughts ten seasons
- 8:04ago. But it's weird because you can
- 8:07talk about the movie and we will on its own.
- 8:11You can also look at the movie from the lens of like Elia Kazan
- 8:15was absolutely embarrassed in Hollywood because of what he did
- 8:20and then doubled down and made a movie about a guy ratting people
- 8:24out and portrayed himself as the hero in that movie.
- 8:28Which is either like either or both the most dickish and or the
- 8:33most ballsy thing anyone's ever done.
- 8:37I mean, honestly, I I think it's kind of awesome.
- 8:41Like whether whether or not he did the right thing, the dude
- 8:45stood by his actions. Oh, he had.
- 8:47Convictions for sure. Yeah, like he believed in what
- 8:50he did. It seems like in that those
- 8:54years and beyond, he very much so did not like the Communist
- 8:59Party in America. And so he just was like, hey,
- 9:03hey, by the way, I'm glad I did it.
- 9:08You and him and John Wayne would have all gotten along real well
- 9:11back in the day. Brett, I'm sure we would have,
- 9:13man. All right, let's start talking
- 9:15about the movie in earnest. And in order to do that, we need
- 9:18to get to our first segment of the day, which we call, Brad
- 9:21explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 9:23movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 9:26ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 9:30Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 9:33show where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he has
- 9:36just seen, often for the first time.
- 9:39This is at least Brad's second time seeing On the Waterfront.
- 9:42Did you have any exposure to the movie Brad in the intervening
- 9:45years? From 2019 to now, no.
- 9:48OK, not at all. So you came into this
- 9:51essentially cold off of a, you know, 5.
- 9:54Year. Gap Yeah, I really like that
- 9:57because as I've said, I have many thoughts.
- 10:00But like my chief thought is, man, we were really off in our
- 10:04initial assessment of this movie.
- 10:05And I'm, I'm very excited to give this movie The flowers that
- 10:09we did not give it the first time around.
- 10:11But that also means this is your first time explaining the movie
- 10:15because you didn't do it in season 1.
- 10:16So, Brad, you get 60 seconds to break down the plot of the film.
- 10:20Folks, if you have not seen On the Waterfront, I highly
- 10:22recommend you hit pause here. Go back and watch it and then
- 10:25return to this episode and join us, Brad.
- 10:28And I will say, Bob, an hour and 45 minutes.
- 10:31Yeah, it's a tight. It's a tight movie.
- 10:34Not quite a 90 minute film, but close enough that you can hit
- 10:38pause here and not miss too much.
- 10:39Yeah, and never boring, I will say.
- 10:42Like just just short enough to never be boring.
- 10:44Brad 60 seconds and go. On the Waterfront is a film
- 10:49about a young man named Terry Malloy, played by the famous
- 10:53Marlon Brando, who is in a difficult position Bob.
- 10:58He is used as a setup man in the death of a young man on the
- 11:04Waterfront, and the rest of the film follows him as he tries to
- 11:09follow his conscience and figure out what he ought to do in the
- 11:13face of brutal a brutal, murderous man.
- 11:22I My brain is just not working well today, Bob.
- 11:24You want to tag me in here? Yeah, tag in Bob, finish it off
- 11:28on the. Waterfront is a film about
- 11:30Marlon Brando. Marlon Brando plays a washed up
- 11:34X boxer named Terry Malloy. Terry and his brother both work
- 11:37for the local mob boss who is essentially a a a union local
- 11:42leader. This union is corrupt through
- 11:44and through. It's the longshoreman who unload
- 11:46all of the ships that come into the dock and they rule with an
- 11:49iron fist. The movie starts with a young
- 11:51man getting thrown to his death, and like Brad said, Terry was
- 11:55the setup guy for this whole thing.
- 11:57Terry gets a tinge of conscience after his actions, starts
- 12:01wondering if this is all worth it, and sees the route that he
- 12:04might go down if he keeps following this boss, Johnny
- 12:07Friendly. There is a priest in the
- 12:09neighborhood who decides that it's time to roll up his sleeves
- 12:12and do what Jesus would have done and stand up for what's
- 12:14right. At the same time, Terry meets
- 12:16the sister of the young man who was killed.
- 12:19They start to fall in love, and he is wracked with guilt about
- 12:21what to do with the rest of his life.
- 12:25He gets a subpoena from the cops, and he has to decide if
- 12:27he's going to rat everybody out or if he's going to be D&D deaf
- 12:31and dumb like everybody else on the waterfront.
- 12:34Boom, Bob explains. Nailed it.
- 12:38That felt good. I've never done that before.
- 12:41Isn't it nice when you just nail it?
- 12:43It sure is, Brad. All right, Brad, let's start
- 12:46talking about this movie. Where do you want to start?
- 12:49I mean, we could, I, I think when we reviewed it the first
- 12:53time, we complained a lot about the script.
- 12:55We said that it was kind of hokey.
- 12:56It didn't hold up very well. I, I don't know if I agree with
- 13:00that anymore, but I think we'll get around to hitting all of our
- 13:03gripes and revising them in the course of this episode.
- 13:06So where should we begin? Man, I, I think that the place
- 13:10to begin is what everybody sees most directly.
- 13:14I I think we should talk about the performances here, Bob,
- 13:18because they are incredible. Yeah, man, top to bottom.
- 13:21And I, I think one of the things that as I watched it this time,
- 13:26in the intervening years, from the time we first watch it to
- 13:28now, you went on your own little self quest of discovery with
- 13:32movies. And I remember you, you called
- 13:34me up one day and said, guess what?
- 13:36I just watched. And I was like, I don't know,
- 13:38you know, freaking Marvel something or other.
- 13:41And you were like, no, dude, I watched The Bicycle Thieves, the
- 13:45Italian neorealist masterpiece from the 1940s.
- 13:48And I was like, holy crap, The Bicycle Thieves.
- 13:51I never would have begged you for that dude.
- 13:53What a movie and if you know anything about Italian
- 13:55neorealism, and I'm sure everyone listening does, it was
- 13:58a movement that came out of the post war years in Italy when
- 14:01everything was rebuilding. It was a much grittier style of
- 14:03filmmaking and it was marked by the use of a lot of non
- 14:06professional actors and it really gave the movie a sense of
- 14:09realism. And that kind of gets carried
- 14:12over into what Kazan is doing here.
- 14:14He's using these actors from the Actors Studio in New York who
- 14:17are all method and really trying to tap into this naturalistic
- 14:21style. But then the way the movie's
- 14:22shot is really gritty and feels like a documentary sometimes.
- 14:26And you've got like your five big actors at the top of the
- 14:29movie, but then almost everybody else beneath them, You can't
- 14:33quite tell if they're just like a bit player actor or if they're
- 14:36just a guy that they grabbed off the docks in New York.
- 14:39And I think that all of that blended together, the way it's
- 14:42shot, the way it's acted, it gives this movie this sense of,
- 14:48I want to say realism. But what I really mean is like
- 14:50foreignness. It feels so different to
- 14:53everything else that's coming out of this time period.
- 14:56Like, this is the same year that Rear Window comes out, Brad.
- 14:58And the styles of acting in these two movies and the way
- 15:01these movies are shot could not be any different.
- 15:04I don't know, Bob. I think it's basically the same
- 15:06movie. This this was actually directed
- 15:09by Alfred Hitchcock, if you couldn't tell.
- 15:11Oh, man, if this movie was directed by Hitchcock, I think,
- 15:16man, that I'm really glad you brought up Rear Window because
- 15:20this has such an incredible amount of realism compared to
- 15:24that specifically. And you and I have both
- 15:29proclaimed from the rooftops we love Rear Window.
- 15:32Great, perfect name. Yeah.
- 15:35But this is so much different. And I, I, I think there are
- 15:39areas where this script struggles a little bit, but
- 15:43overall the acting performances feel so much different.
- 15:46I I'm thinking specifically of like Jimmy Stewart fumbling with
- 15:51his camera and like trying to like bulb flash the guy into
- 15:56submission and, and not necessarily Jimmy Stewart, but
- 16:00his attacker and like the way he like puts his hands up and like
- 16:04it just feels very artificial. And there is not a moment of
- 16:09acting in this movie that feels artificial.
- 16:12I mean, you have Brando and his brother who who plays his
- 16:17brother Bob. Oh, that's the actor Rod
- 16:19Steiger. Yeah, Rod Steiger.
- 16:21Jeez Louise. The scene with the two of them
- 16:24in the back of the taxi cab is. It's the most famous scene in
- 16:28the movie. Yeah, I.
- 16:29Would say it's as highly regarded as it is for a reason
- 16:32because they are freaking destroying it in that scene.
- 16:37I think this movie really thrives it.
- 16:39It has great crowd scenes and it's good when when there's
- 16:42three or four people pinging off of each other.
- 16:44But this movie really thrives in those one to one moments,
- 16:47whether it's that first kind of sheepish meeting between Brando
- 16:51and Eve Marie St. where he's playing with her glove.
- 16:53That's a very famous moment in acting circles or you know, the
- 16:57the interactions that Karl Malden has with with Eva Marie
- 17:01St. with Brando, that moment with Rod Steiger in the back of
- 17:05the car. Like there's just so many great
- 17:07one-on-one scenes in this movie. And I think it goes to show
- 17:10again, like their theatrical background.
- 17:12All these actors had a theatrical background, but their
- 17:14ability to read each other's expressions to let moments play
- 17:18out. You know, I'm thinking
- 17:19especially of the end of the film, which we'll get around to
- 17:22talking about the ending itself. But Brando has been beat to a
- 17:26pulp. And they convince him to stand
- 17:29up. And they don't even know if
- 17:31he'll be able to, like, keep his feet underneath him.
- 17:33And as you watch this movie, I finally got this.
- 17:36I like it. It finally dawned on me 30
- 17:39seconds before the movie's over that Brando isn't really even
- 17:44acting at this point. Like he's he's behaving in a
- 17:48rhythm that is not made for movies.
- 17:51They stand him up and he takes like 10 seconds to study
- 17:54himself. And then somebody asks, you
- 17:56know, are you OK? And he says, am I standing?
- 17:58And they say you're standing? And he takes another 10 seconds
- 18:01to study himself. And he goes, OK, OK.
- 18:03And it is the most believable looking thing because he is his
- 18:08internal clock that he's counting the seconds of OK, this
- 18:12is how long till I'm not woozy anymore.
- 18:14It mimics real life. It doesn't mimic movie acting.
- 18:17And I think that that's like one of the most startling things
- 18:20about this movie is how fresh and vibrant, but how true to
- 18:24life. Every moment feels still.
- 18:27And the camera work in that scene is so good, like as he's
- 18:31slowly stumbling towards the the dock area of the the warehouse
- 18:37area that they're working in, like the camera goes from
- 18:41showing him stumbling to like his first person view.
- 18:45And they do such an incredible job of matching.
- 18:48Like you see his head kind of roll back a little bit and then
- 18:52it's a first person of the camera, like slowly getting
- 18:56blurry as it looks up towards the sky and then it snaps back
- 19:00down and then it flips back to showing him his head falls
- 19:04forward and he looks. It's incredible camera work,
- 19:08Bob. Yeah, yeah.
- 19:09And this movie is such a great blend of, like I said, you know,
- 19:13it's called like cinema verite. It's this idea of, like, filming
- 19:17the truth. And it looks like gritty and
- 19:19realistic. And there's also moments,
- 19:21there's this great moment in this movie where a guy who has
- 19:25decided to kind of rat, they set him up to get killed by dropping
- 19:28like a whole pallet of cargo onto him when he's like, you
- 19:32know. Not just cargo, Bob.
- 19:33Whiskey. Irish whiskey, yes, he gets
- 19:36crushed to death by whiskey. That seems like it's something
- 19:39that is looming over us both, Brad.
- 19:42I feel like that should be the the film and whiskey drinking
- 19:45game. Any any time we're watching a
- 19:46movie and they reference whiskey like that, that's when we start
- 19:50drinking. Yeah.
- 19:52So they're showing like an on location version in some shots
- 19:56like Karl Malden rides the lift back up afterwards.
- 19:59You can tell it's like this is a real place.
- 20:01This is not recreated in the studio somewhere.
- 20:04But then they have a few shots like inside of that ship where
- 20:08Ava Marie St. is there for some reason with the priest.
- 20:11They just let her wander into this crime scene and she's
- 20:15looking at Brando and Brando's in the foreground and she's in
- 20:18the background and there's like. You know, pallets and pallets of
- 20:20whiskey behind them in the background and it's lit like the
- 20:24most perfect Hollywood thing ever.
- 20:26And so you can tell that's like on a set somewhere.
- 20:28But they do such a good job of marrying traditional Hollywood
- 20:32style filming with like shaky Cam documentary style.
- 20:35There's moments of like film noir when he's walking down that
- 20:38alleyway when the truck is chasing them.
- 20:41The lighting is this really harsh, like not realistic
- 20:44lighting at all, but it's like Moody.
- 20:46And I think that all these things taken together, it's,
- 20:49it's a very realistic movie, but it also does all the things you
- 20:52love best about what Hollywood can do in a movie. 100% I think
- 20:56the biggest thing that shifted for me this time around was the
- 21:02pacing of the movie. I I feel like before it came
- 21:06across as really slow and it allowed the script errors to
- 21:11shine through and for whatever reason this time the this movie
- 21:15just felt like it moved at such a nice pace and the slow moments
- 21:22of the movie allowed you to live and breathe with the characters.
- 21:28There's a lot of stories about Brando, especially as he got
- 21:31older. I mean, he took advantage of his
- 21:34stature in a lot of ways. Like he would never memorize his
- 21:36lines. And so by the time he got to the
- 21:38Godfather, you know, if there was somebody in the scene with
- 21:41him that was facing away from the camera, they would like tape
- 21:44cue cards to that person's chest so he could just read his lines
- 21:47off the person's chest. And he would, you know, he was
- 21:50known for kind of like, taking a very indulgent look at the
- 21:54ceiling in the middle of the scene because there'd be cue
- 21:56cards taped up at the ceiling. And he would always play it off.
- 21:59But it was a very, like, it's an indulgent style of acting.
- 22:02You know you have to make these grand gestures.
- 22:04To I don't know, man. I mean, wasn't Marilyn Monroe
- 22:06doing that in? In something like a hot The
- 22:10Line, Where's that bourbon? Yes.
- 22:12So it's a tough line. It really is, man.
- 22:15So Brando's known for doing stuff like that.
- 22:17And I, I think that what really struck me this time around is
- 22:20that the movie is paced so well that it gives all the actors
- 22:25enough room to breathe with their performances that nothing
- 22:28ever really feels rushed. But it never feels indulgent
- 22:32either. And I think that that's like
- 22:33sometimes with method acting, that's the thing that can really
- 22:36strike me as like it, it Dings it a little bit.
- 22:39Honestly. We talked about this with There
- 22:41Will Be Blood. As good as that performance by
- 22:43DDL is like there are moments where it feels like the scene is
- 22:47going on a little too long because we're just letting we're
- 22:49letting the guy cook. You know, I don't feel that way
- 22:53with Brando in this movie. I don't feel that way with
- 22:54anybody in this movie. And I think that it's a really
- 22:57like, it's a huge credit to Kazan and the editors that it
- 23:01doesn't feel shaggy and it doesn't feel like they're just
- 23:04indulging this kind of prima Donna actor at the lead.
- 23:08I think it's also because you have Karl Malden opposite of
- 23:12Brando, and he has such a calm, forceful, moving personality
- 23:21like that. He's never allowing the movie to
- 23:25slow down. And I don't say that in the
- 23:27sense that he's frenetic in any way.
- 23:30He just has this really magnetic, driving personality
- 23:35that keeps the story moving forward in a really powerful
- 23:40way. Molden was also with Brando and
- 23:43Kazan in Streetcar Named Desire, and he might have won the Oscar
- 23:46for Best supporting actor for that movie, but you know, he's
- 23:49used to working with Brando at this point.
- 23:51And that kind of dance you have to do with him when you're in a
- 23:53scene with him. And his character in this movie
- 23:55could not be any more different from his character in Streetcar.
- 23:58And because in that movie he was really kind of like, I don't
- 24:02know what's the term, a cock. He's just a a real beta in that
- 24:06movie. Man Bob, the sexual references
- 24:10are coming fast this this episode.
- 24:12Well, you know, we mentioned Hitchcock, so I feel like I have
- 24:14to represent that old pervert spirit of Hitchcock.
- 24:18Just got to force it in there. And I think when you get to this
- 24:21movie, they have that familiarity with each other.
- 24:23But if we can talk about Malden for a minute, I think his role
- 24:27and his performance among the main actors is probably the most
- 24:32classically Hollywood style of acting.
- 24:34Like it feels like he could have been playing opposite Bogart
- 24:37instead of Brando and it would have been the same performance.
- 24:40It doesn't feel as methody quote UN quote, but I feel like the
- 24:44movie needs that too because he also represents such a different
- 24:48way of living from what Terry is currently experiencing.
- 24:51And he has his literal getting up on a soapbox speech moments
- 24:55in this movie. But they all work so well
- 24:57because Carl Malden has this very trustworthy puppy dog kind
- 25:04of persona that you buy that he is a man of conviction.
- 25:07He's a man of principle. And he really reminds me of like
- 25:11his generations, John C Reilly kind of, you know what I mean?
- 25:14Like I can see that so much if they remade this movie today but
- 25:19Malden absolutely knocks it out of the park dude and I think it
- 25:22was one of the keys for me to re appreciating this movie.
- 25:27Yeah, the the scene of him giving his speech is just
- 25:31incredible. Like, the First off, the bravery
- 25:36to just, like, invoke the name of Jesus in a movie feels rare.
- 25:44Like, I don't know, we just don't see that anymore.
- 25:47Bob, you've often talked about the reality that Hollywood never
- 25:52takes religious thoughts seriously anymore.
- 25:56And so it almost feels refreshing to see a movie where
- 25:59the priest is treated like a hero of the film, like somebody
- 26:04who's actually has the best interests of these longshoremen
- 26:09at heart, that this is his parish, these are the people he
- 26:12needs to care for, and he's going to do it in such a way
- 26:15that might not be fitting for a priest who is living out in the
- 26:19countryside. Yeah, yeah, we had a
- 26:22conversation about like the Tom Joe to speech at the end of
- 26:25Grapes of Wrath. And I feel like in a lesser
- 26:28movie, this, this that the speech in this movie is just
- 26:31that it's a very like Hollywood liberals idea of what a priest
- 26:37should be. And I feel like at its worst, it
- 26:40almost tips into that. But they do such a good job of,
- 26:43I don't want to say pulling back, but making him walk the
- 26:47walk, right? It's not just about ideals.
- 26:49It's not just about like this is what I think a priest should be.
- 26:52And so I'm going to write this ideal character that way.
- 26:55You know, they let him smoke and they let him drink a beer and
- 26:58he's a flawed person. But beyond that man, when he he
- 27:03has that speech after Dugan gets killed where he's standing next
- 27:07to Dugan's body talking about like, I told him I would go with
- 27:11him to the end of the line here. So I'm going to take my stand
- 27:13now. And he has that speech about
- 27:15Christ is with you on the waterfront.
- 27:17And it's the first time in the movie that the words on the
- 27:19waterfront are actually uttered in order like that.
- 27:24And I like to think it's where the title of the movie comes
- 27:26from. I know they say it a couple more
- 27:27times as the movie progresses, but when he says Christ is with
- 27:31you on the waterfront, Christ is here kneeling beside Duguid.
- 27:34Like I got emotional, man. It was it was like this true.
- 27:40Not just a wish fulfillment of what the church could be, but
- 27:43but like a depiction of doing the nitty gritty dirty work that
- 27:49it requires to actually bring hope and also change to a
- 27:54community of people that you are serving.
- 27:56It's like it's just such a beautiful picture of what the
- 28:00church can and should be. And that's just like, that's
- 28:03completely beside how good the performance itself is.
- 28:07Yeah, I mean, there's a scholar named Eugene Peterson who wrote
- 28:11a translation of the Bible. Well, an interpretation of.
- 28:16The Bible, yeah, don't call it call translation.
- 28:19You'll get the Bible Bros coming after.
- 28:21You I know all the Bible Bros that listen to our our podcast
- 28:26Derek Derek human's going to come after me.
- 28:27I know he wrote this thing called the message and it is a
- 28:33interpretation of the Bible. And in John 1, he takes a very
- 28:37famous passage about how Jesus is the word and it came to live
- 28:42with us. And he talks about it, that it's
- 28:45Jesus with clothes on who came into the neighborhood to live
- 28:51next to us. And I, I feel like this movie
- 28:54captures that idea of a Jesus who just lives in the
- 28:58neighborhood, who's one of us. That speech captures it better
- 29:03than almost any other Hollywood film I've ever seen.
- 29:08All right, Brad, I want to talk a little bit about the other
- 29:09main performers in this movie. And I don't want to get too much
- 29:12farther without bringing up Ava Marie St. who at the time of
- 29:16recording is still alive. She is 100 years old.
- 29:19So keep keep going, sis. I want this to let's go to still
- 29:23be true when this episode actually comes out.
- 29:25But I love Ava Marie St. We've only ever talked about her
- 29:28outside of this film in her performance in North by
- 29:31Northwest Hitchcock again. And once again, those two
- 29:35performances could not be any more different from each other.
- 29:38In that movie, she plays this really sultry, sexy spy.
- 29:42In this movie, she's playing, I don't know what you would call
- 29:46her, a vulnerable, grieving, bereaved sister who is also,
- 29:50like, filled with rage and confused about why the system
- 29:55works the way it does. I just think that the way she
- 29:59and Brando play off each other, they bring out these moments of
- 30:02almost like childlike innocence in each other and and purity in
- 30:06each other. And you start to see those
- 30:08cracks in Terry's facade because of what Ava Marie Saints
- 30:13character is doing. But more than that, it's the way
- 30:15these two actors are like, there's this sense of like
- 30:18almost naked vulnerability between them.
- 30:20And if we're a movie that's 70 years old, it feels so intimate
- 30:24to watch these two in a scene together.
- 30:28I don't know man. I think.
- 30:31I think the weakest part of this film for me is still the romance
- 30:36between Terry and Edie. Like I, I just.
- 30:40Weakest in terms of how it's played or in terms of like how
- 30:44it's written? Because I I still have some
- 30:46issues with how rushed the timeline of this movie is.
- 30:50Sure. You know what I mean?
- 30:51Like from the time her brother dies, the time she's like making
- 30:54out with this boxer, like 3 days, yes.
- 30:57That is 100% a part of it. I I mean, there are moments
- 31:02where it is portrayed extraordinarily well.
- 31:04I think my favorite moment of their relationship is when
- 31:08they're having the confession where Terry is confessing to
- 31:14Edie that he was the one who set up her brother, even though he
- 31:18didn't realize he was doing it. And they they play it with the
- 31:21the scream of a ship whistle blowing in the background.
- 31:27And it it's just incredible filmmaking.
- 31:31Like we can't choose what's going on in our environments
- 31:34when we're fighting. Well, in the way they're
- 31:36underscoring that emotional turbulence with this, like,
- 31:39horrific sound. I do think it's funny that
- 31:41you're like, my favorite moment is the moment where you can't
- 31:44hear either one of them talking. Yep, and and there's just so
- 31:48many moments where I I think that both Brando and Eve Marie
- 31:54St. are are doing great jobs. I just don't know if they click
- 32:01together. Oh, interesting.
- 32:03I will say this time, the thing that really overwhelmed me about
- 32:06this movie and I got emotional at a few points of this movie,
- 32:09is this like pervading sense of sadness in this movie.
- 32:13Like it is an incredibly sad film.
- 32:16It's just, I don't call it depressing movie, but like they
- 32:19do such a good job of placing you in the hopelessness and
- 32:23almost like inevitability of these people's lives.
- 32:27And I've always had an issue with, like, OK, the first
- 32:30moments of the movie is night one Joey there that, you know,
- 32:34the brother dies. And then like, morning #2
- 32:38they're all on the waterfront, like on the docks again.
- 32:40And as if nothing happened. And like, the guy's dad is there
- 32:43and he's like, well, my son shouldn't have got himself mixed
- 32:45up. But I'm like, dude, what?
- 32:47How are you so callous about this?
- 32:48And it's, it's always struck me as like a weakness of the movie.
- 32:52I still don't think it's perfect.
- 32:54But watching their reaction to their friend Dugan get killed
- 32:57this time. And when that comes almost at
- 32:59the midpoint of the movie and they react almost exactly the
- 33:03same. And they're like watching his
- 33:04dead body laying there under these crates of whiskey.
- 33:07And he's like, you know, you don't, he doesn't need a a
- 33:11doctor. He needs a priest or whatever.
- 33:13And it's just like the callousness with which these
- 33:16people have learned to have to deal with this in their lives.
- 33:19There's this moment where they're they're trying to bait
- 33:22Terry out onto the street because they they've killed his
- 33:25brother. And they're like, we've got your
- 33:26brother down here. And he goes off and Eva Marie
- 33:29Street is chasing him like down the fire escape.
- 33:31And her neighbor says that's exactly the way they called my
- 33:35Andy before they killed him. Andy's not even the person we've
- 33:38ever heard of in this movie to this point.
- 33:40And it just like, again, it it it underlines and underscores
- 33:43this cycle of violence and just like oppression that these
- 33:47people have made a part of their lives.
- 33:50And I think watching the intimate moments of Eva Marie
- 33:53St. and Marlon Brando, you don't.
- 33:56I didn't really get the sense so much this time that they're like
- 34:00falling head over heels in like a Romeo and Juliet way.
- 34:02It's not like West Side Story where the world's falling down
- 34:05around them, but they're in love.
- 34:07It just seems like two people who feel like they've lost hope
- 34:11and they're just like finding each other in this moment of
- 34:15emotional turbulence. I don't know, I thought it was
- 34:18much more beautiful this time because it didn't strike me as
- 34:21like a standard romance. It struck me as like 2 grieving
- 34:24people kind of using each other in that moment of grief.
- 34:27And they might love each other and they might not.
- 34:29But like you're, you're watching these kind of like freight
- 34:33trains of emotion wrecking into each other.
- 34:37And it's it's most perfectly identified by Brando's
- 34:41character. When when Terry says, like,
- 34:44you're the first good thing that's ever walked into my life.
- 34:49And I think that that is a really touching moment where it
- 34:55shows the importance of beauty in the life of a human soul.
- 35:01That when we live in a world that has no beauty, no goodness,
- 35:06nothing, no nothing dignifying in the world around them, even
- 35:11just a spark of that can bring up something in that person that
- 35:17they never knew that they had. That this, this woman who has
- 35:20come into his life, who has shown him a little bit of
- 35:23goodness, is sparking the conscience that they continually
- 35:28reference throughout the movie. All right, I think we've talked
- 35:31about Brando, we've talked a little bit about Rod Steiger,
- 35:34we've talked about Karl Malden and Ava Marie St.
- 35:36And that really just leaves Lee J Cobb as Johnny Friendly, who
- 35:40is the big bad. My guy knew how to scream, you
- 35:44know, and he's one of the great all time screamers, but so
- 35:48physically imposing too. Like when he's fighting with
- 35:50Brando at the end of the movie, you can tell he's fighting dirty
- 35:53and he's out of shape, but you could tell that, like, this man
- 35:57could land some punches too. You know, he could beat the snot
- 35:59out of you if he really wanted to.
- 36:01And I think that Cobb has always been so good at kind of throwing
- 36:05around that physicality as a way of covering up for whatever's
- 36:10going on emotionally underneath. He did it so well in 12 Angry
- 36:14Men, and I think he does it equally well here in On the
- 36:17Waterfront, just without that added layer of vulnerability.
- 36:20Like he just has to be the bad guy, and he does a really good
- 36:23job at being the bad guy. And he and he sets up the world
- 36:28of gangster films for like the prototypical mob boss that you
- 36:35see played over and over and over again throughout the years.
- 36:39I think that when you look at Jack Nicholson and The Departed
- 36:43that you see like a evolution of the Lee J Cobb character.
- 36:49I I think when you look at Robert De Niro in Goodfellas,
- 36:56like you're seeing an evolution of Lee J Cobb.
- 37:00And I don't know about you, Bob, but I saw the this felt like an
- 37:04origin story for all gangster movies to come in a lot of ways.
- 37:08Yeah, it really did, man. And I think a lot of that comes
- 37:10down to, and Scorsese's talked about this too.
- 37:13Like this is one of the first times I saw people that I
- 37:16recognized on screen. And it's in the way that, you
- 37:18know, they dress the bartender in in that flannel shirt and
- 37:22just things details that you wouldn't get in a Hollywood
- 37:24movie before this. So, you know, for all the crap
- 37:27that we've talked on Elia Kazan, he, he at least got flannel
- 37:30shirts, right, You know? Couldn't keep keep his story
- 37:35straight in front of Congress, but man, those flannel shirts.
- 37:40Let's take a break here, man. Let's drink some whiskey.
- 37:42I'm excited to revisit Gentleman Jack.
- 37:44What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 37:53All right, today we are checking out Gentleman Jack Tennessee
- 37:57Whiskey. This comes from the Jack
- 37:59Daniels. Gentleman.
- 38:00This comes from the Jack Daniels distillery.
- 38:03It is like, I don't know, the second lowest on the rung of
- 38:07Jack Daniels in terms of like how fancy you can get.
- 38:10You get regular Jack, then one step up you get to become a
- 38:13gentleman and have gentleman Jack.
- 38:16That's right, Bob, have I ever told you that for a long time,
- 38:22when I was like 21 to 24, my best friend and I would would
- 38:27drink Jack Daniels all the time. You have told me this.
- 38:31We got the Frank Sinatra select and I wish I still had it
- 38:35because I'm very curious now what it tastes like.
- 38:38Yeah, I wonder after drinking like 500 whiskeys if you'd be
- 38:40like, oh, this is super mediocre, but back then because
- 38:44I. I mean back then we bought this
- 38:46in 20/13/2014 and it was $150.00 back then.
- 38:52Wow dude, you got suckered by the marketing man.
- 38:56Oh, 100%. Dude, and all along you could
- 38:59have just been drinking Gentleman Jack.
- 39:01Now let me segue back into Gentleman Jack.
- 39:03So the difference between regular Jack Daniels and this
- 39:06and the difference between all Jack Daniels and bourbon is that
- 39:09Tennessee whiskey is bourbon, folks.
- 39:12People like to say that it's not.
- 39:13It is bourbon that has been put through an extra step in this
- 39:16process called charcoal filtration at the Jack Daniels
- 39:19distillery. What that means is that they run
- 39:21their bourbon through wood that has been soaked in high proof
- 39:25Jack Jack Daniels and then lit on fire to make charcoal.
- 39:29They say that it purifies it and in the case of Gentleman Jack,
- 39:33they do that two times before entering the barrel.
- 39:35So Gentleman Jack is double charcoaled, Brad, and that's
- 39:39what I'm going to start saying when I burn the burgers on my
- 39:42grill, like it's not burnt, it's double charcoal charcoal.
- 39:48The mash bill on this is 80% corn, 12% barley and 8% rye, and
- 39:53it is 80 proof. Brad.
- 39:55Let us dive into Gentleman Jack. What are you picking up on the
- 39:58nose? This is a really pleasant nose
- 40:00Bob. The the first note that I got
- 40:03kind of overwhelmingly was like a really nice butterscotch.
- 40:07There's a lot of vanilla, there's some honey going on, and
- 40:12at the end of the day, this is Jack Daniels.
- 40:14I am getting a nice pleasant waft of banana.
- 40:18This is a 7 1/2 for me. It's not incredible, but pretty
- 40:22good. I'm also at a 7 1/2, and let me
- 40:25say that we shouldn't just assume that Jack Daniels is
- 40:29synonymous with banana the way that like Jim Beam is with
- 40:32peanuts. Because Brad, I like it is so
- 40:36obvious to me that there's banana on the nose of Jack
- 40:38Daniels products. I don't see that nosing note a
- 40:41lot amongst other people. I think it might just be me and
- 40:44you that are out here, like preaching the gospel of Banana
- 40:47Jack. But like it.
- 40:49It smells like a banana laffy taffy to me.
- 40:52Like it's just slightly an artificial banana candy kind of
- 40:55thing. And that is on top of a really
- 40:58oaky, really spicy bourbon. This smells like it's going to
- 41:02be more prickly than an 80 proof whiskey usually is.
- 41:06And I like that 'cause it smells mature in my glass and just with
- 41:09a waft of like banana candy to go with it.
- 41:12It's a 7 1/2 for me. Brad, what did you think of the
- 41:15taste? The taste came through with lots
- 41:18of banana. To me it was almost like, have
- 41:22you ever had a like a campfire fruit where you you, you like
- 41:29cut open the fruit? Usually people do with apples
- 41:32and bananas. It's like with an apple you
- 41:35would core out the middle. With a banana you you cut it
- 41:38down the middle like a banana split and you put toppings in
- 41:41it. You wrap it in tinfoil and you
- 41:42put it in the fire for like 3 or 4 minutes.
- 41:45Have you ever done that? No, I never have, but that
- 41:47sounds divine. Oh dude, you haven't been
- 41:51camping until you've done this. It kind of reminds me of like a
- 41:56slightly toasted smoked banana. There's some Maple syrup going
- 42:01on. I I think that those burnt notes
- 42:05almost turn into like a burnt toast flavor to me.
- 42:09There's a little bit of wheatiness that not wheat like a
- 42:12weeded bourbon, more like like wheat bread.
- 42:17It's it's good, but it's not great.
- 42:23I think I'm sitting at a six out of 10.
- 42:26Yeah, I think that because I was expecting that banana to be
- 42:29there, I tasted it more than I might have if I just sipped it
- 42:32blind. But it it had a ton of like
- 42:35almost banana pudding for me on the front of my palate.
- 42:37And then it got pretty quickly that sort of sour oak that we
- 42:42get on toasted barrel products that really came out strong for
- 42:46me on the back of the palate. It's not bad.
- 42:48And I will say this is like way more interesting than 99% of the
- 42:5480 proof bourbons we drink. I just don't think it's great.
- 42:57Like it. I, I applaud it for being
- 42:59something different. It's but it's not knocking my
- 43:02socks off and it's not a super cohesive tasting experience.
- 43:06I'll also give it a 6 1/2. The finish is kind of in a weird
- 43:10spot too, because I get that toasted oak.
- 43:12It's a little bit bitter, It's a little bit sour.
- 43:15I almost have that kind of like pink bubble gum powderiness a
- 43:19little bit on on my palate after I swallow.
- 43:22It's nice and I I think this is a really good sipping whiskey
- 43:26for an 80 proof bourbon. I don't think this would hold up
- 43:28super well in a cocktail. It's a little too sweet and the
- 43:32oak isn't really like spicy so much as it is bitter and sour.
- 43:36But just just on its own, I think it's like a 7 on the
- 43:39finish. Oh, I the finish for me is where
- 43:44the proof stands out that it just comes across really watery.
- 43:50There's not enough flavor, like you're just getting hints of the
- 43:55flavors you got on the palate and nothing sticks around for
- 43:58long enough to make an impression other than the
- 44:00sourness. So for me, it's a 5 1/2 on the
- 44:04fish. Wow.
- 44:05OK. And I, I think balance wise,
- 44:09this is just really all over the place of an experience.
- 44:13I'll I'll give it a six out of 10 here.
- 44:17Yeah, I think I'll give it a 6 1/2 because again, like I think
- 44:22sometimes distilleries proof things down to 80 proof as a way
- 44:26of kind of diluting out how drastic some of the flaws in
- 44:32something can be. And then it kind of like rounds
- 44:34those edges out. So I don't want to give the
- 44:35distillery too much credit here, but as an 80 proof whiskey, like
- 44:41the nose to the taste of the finish are a definite like
- 44:44downturn, but they're not drastic enough for me to merit
- 44:48like a really low balance score. So I'll give it a 6 1/2 on the
- 44:52value. This is interesting because I
- 44:53think when we first bought this back in 2019, it was running
- 44:57around $28.00 a bottle somewhere in there.
- 45:01Brad, what's it currently going for in the state of Ohio?
- 45:042999. OK.
- 45:06Inflation has not affected it too much.
- 45:09I don't think this is a $30 bottle of whiskey like 262728
- 45:14maybe, but there's something about that, that two extra
- 45:16dollars that I've just like, absolutely not.
- 45:20I think this is like a six out of 10 on the value.
- 45:24There's other things you could get for around this price point
- 45:26that are better. There are some things you can
- 45:28get for way less that are significantly better than this,
- 45:30like a Rebel 100. I do think this is a good
- 45:33example of the Jack Daniels flavor profile, and it's a
- 45:38little bit better than regular Jack.
- 45:40So not a terrible value, but definitely not a great one.
- 45:44Yeah, I'm, I'm at a 5 out of 10 on value.
- 45:47It's not horrible value at $30.00, but there there are just
- 45:52so many other things you can get like at the end of the day Bob,
- 45:57you can get a Cooper's craft bottled and bond for like 2 more
- 46:02dollars than this. And that is a far superior
- 46:08whiskey for sure to, to gentleman Jack for sure.
- 46:11So I, I, for me, this is only a 5 out of 10.
- 46:15I, I think that this had a solid start to it.
- 46:17It's a really interesting nose that just doesn't have enough
- 46:21oomph to push it over the finish line.
- 46:24I'm coming out to a 30 out of 50, Bob.
- 46:27I'm at a 33 1/2, so I'm a little bit higher than you, but not
- 46:31significantly. That takes us to a 63.5 out of
- 46:35100 or a 31.75 out of 50 on average.
- 46:40This is below where we would normally start recommending.
- 46:43I do think I will recommend like if you want to buy a bottle, you
- 46:47know, go ahead and do it with the caveat of like there's
- 46:49better stuff at this price point.
- 46:51I think if you wanted to try a pour that might be the way to go
- 46:53because I don't think this will be more than like 6-7 dollars a
- 46:56pour and it's an enjoyable pour especially if you like lower
- 47:00proof whiskeys. Yeah, I, oh, I think that if you
- 47:07want to try the Jack Daniels line and, you know, not the
- 47:11entire line, you just want to try a sample of it, I actually
- 47:14do think that Gentleman Jack is the place to go.
- 47:18You know, regular Jack Daniels. If you like whiskey and have
- 47:23have tasted around the wheelhouse a little bit, you're
- 47:26probably not going to enjoy it. Gentleman Jack gives you an
- 47:29opportunity to see what they can do.
- 47:32And if it tempts you to go further, awesome, Go for it.
- 47:37But but this is this is probably a good starting point.
- 47:40All right, man, so we're we have cooled a little bit on Gentleman
- 47:43Jack, but it sounds like we've warmed up to On the Waterfront.
- 47:46What do you say we get back into talking about the movie?
- 47:49Let's get to it. All right, everybody.
- 47:55That was Jack Daniels gentleman version of their base whiskey, a
- 48:02whiskey that I I don't know if I would share with my gentleman
- 48:08kind of friends. Luckily I'm not friends with any
- 48:11gentleman so they will gladly. Accept this.
- 48:16Well aware of that, Bob. You know what is the most
- 48:20attractive thing to a good gentleman, Bob?
- 48:23Is it 2 facts and a falsehood? It sure is.
- 48:27Brad is going to try to stump you.
- 48:29Bob to our right and what is wrong?
- 48:362 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 48:39the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 48:42the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie and I
- 48:46have to guess which one that is. I say this every week.
- 48:50It is super fun to do these on the Season 1 films because a lot
- 48:54of these are movies that are like, not just near and dear to
- 48:57my heart, but we're really formative in starting to
- 49:00understand what a classic movie could be.
- 49:02And so to get facts about a movie as important as On the
- 49:05Waterfront, I don't know, it's just really cool.
- 49:07I also had to hold myself back from looking at the trivia page
- 49:10on IMDb. So, Brad, I come into this.
- 49:13I'm proud of you. Honestly, hit me with your two
- 49:16facts and a falsehood. Fact #1 Lee J Cobb refused to
- 49:20sport a black eye for the final scene of the film, as his
- 49:23contract specifically stated that his eyes would not be
- 49:26marred in any way. This led to Kazan's choice to
- 49:29have cuts completely surrounding his left eye.
- 49:32However, it left the eye itself untouched.
- 49:36Fact #2 The leading characters were based on real people.
- 49:40Terry Malloy was based on longshoreman and whistleblower
- 49:43Anthony Dave Vincenzo, Father Barry was based on waterfront
- 49:46priest John M Cordon, and Johnny Friendly was based on mobster
- 49:51Albert Anastasia. Fact #3 after the ill feelings
- 49:57harbored by Rod Steiger toward Marlon Brando.
- 50:00After shooting their taxi scene, the two actors refused to speak
- 50:03to each other for many years after until the 1990s, when they
- 50:08got back in contact with one another and attempted to bury
- 50:11the hatchet. I will say I don't think I had
- 50:14heard that story before. It's #3 so that immediately
- 50:17throws up some suspicion for me. But I mean, who knows?
- 50:20Like all these guys had beef with each other at some point,
- 50:22so maybe they did. It's like Arby's, they've got
- 50:27the beef. #2 I'm going to assume it's true for the time being
- 50:32because this movie was based on true, a true story.
- 50:35I believe it was a series of articles that were written that
- 50:38won the Pulitzer, and so I don't know the names of the real
- 50:41people. So unless you made-up characters
- 50:44for half of that fact, I'm going to assume 2 is.
- 50:47True. Was the real story a Pulitzer
- 50:49Prize winning story written in the paper, or was it just Elia
- 50:54Kazan's? The number one was a Remind me.
- 50:59It was about Lee J Cobb Doing what now?
- 51:01Yeah. That he would not have a black
- 51:04eye. That's right.
- 51:05Because I'm kind of, you know, cut his face up around the eye.
- 51:14I'm going to say 1 is the falsehood.
- 51:16I like it. Maybe not because that sounds
- 51:18like something stupid and diva ish that a actor would have in
- 51:21their contract. But Lee J Cobb, I just want to
- 51:24believe that he was not that, not that much of A prima Donna.
- 51:27So I'm going to say #1 is false. Bob wants his villains to be a
- 51:32good guy, to be a. Good guy deep down, yeah.
- 51:36Yeah, he hopes that there's hope for him.
- 51:38And there is because Lee J Cobb was not a diva, and that was the
- 51:42false. All right, so Steiger and Brando
- 51:46really did have beef. They 100% did literally like 5
- 51:50of the facts through the IMDb fact page were like riffs on the
- 51:55exact same thing. So essentially what I gathered
- 52:00was that Marlin had a very strict clause in his contract
- 52:06that he left the set at 4:00 PM every day because his mother had
- 52:12just died and he was seeing a therapist and he would go every
- 52:16day to see this therapist. And Steiger?
- 52:20The close-ups of his of him were shot without Marlon in the taxi.
- 52:28Oh, interesting. Whereas when Marlon did his
- 52:31close-ups, Steiger stayed in the taxi to help him stay in
- 52:35character. And so, you know, Steiger just
- 52:38has some guy reading Marlon's lines and he's acting off of
- 52:41that and, and it he just kind of felt like.
- 52:45He got the shaft. Yeah, I get.
- 52:47It he got the shaft. Absolutely, yeah.
- 52:49I'm I'm Team Rod in that scenario.
- 52:52Honestly dude, the the more the more and more I hear about
- 52:55Marlin. Oh, he was a weird bird man.
- 52:59Yeah. I'm just kind of in that camp of
- 53:01like method acting beyond like, I don't know, like on a scale of
- 53:071 to 10 of method acting like if you get beyond like A5 or A6.
- 53:14Like you're just. Kind of a Dick.
- 53:16Yeah, yeah, he, he had a really messed up psychology.
- 53:22I don't think people have still ever really figured out what was
- 53:24going on in his head. Like, he just seemed like a
- 53:25really tortured guy who acted out in some very weird manners.
- 53:31But we have this body of work of his that's like, how do you,
- 53:35Yes, like how do you say you can't say anything that hasn't
- 53:39been said about this specific role and performance?
- 53:43And Brad, we've done a couple Brando movies, like we've done
- 53:46Apocalypse Now, we've done The Godfather.
- 53:48I keep mentioning that we haven't done Streetcar.
- 53:50I think that would be kind of like one of his Mount Rushmore's
- 53:52for me. I have to assume.
- 53:56I mean, the Godfather's a great role, but like this is his best
- 53:59performance that we've watched. At least that would be my vote.
- 54:04Oh, 100%. Like, and for me, it comes down
- 54:08to when his brother pulls a gun on him.
- 54:13The way he looks at his brother, it's so mournful, it's so sad.
- 54:21And the way he pushes the gun away, there's like No Fear
- 54:26there. Like, Like Terry Malloy, Brando
- 54:30knows that his brother Charlie isn't pulling the gun out of a
- 54:35fear for Brando's life. It's out of a fear for his own
- 54:38life. Yeah, that that little
- 54:40disappointment is just like, it's so crushing.
- 54:44It's it is incredibly crushing. And so it's like moments like
- 54:47that where I'm like, you don't quite get that in in Godfather.
- 54:52Brando's so good at acting with his back to the camera too.
- 54:57And just, like, watching his physique change as his, like,
- 54:59his posture changing to indicate his emotion when he stumbles
- 55:04upon his brother dead with four shots in his chest, hung by his
- 55:09hook in an alley. Like, first of all, a gruesome
- 55:13death. Yeah, absolutely.
- 55:15You know, you see it from Brando's perspective, and then
- 55:18you kind of see it from like, behind his back as he decides
- 55:21what to do. And and he first it sinks in
- 55:23what's happened and he's not facing the camera and and the
- 55:26first thing he does is just kind of like lean up against the wall
- 55:29and brace himself for a minute. And it's just, it's such a
- 55:32Brando thing to do. Like it's no one else in the
- 55:35world would have thought of. You know, someone else would
- 55:37have been a Tommy Wazzo about it.
- 55:38And you know, you're tearing me apart, Lisa.
- 55:42He doesn't do that. You know, like he he has this
- 55:44internal thing going on and you only watch it by like looking at
- 55:48the muscles in his back contort a different way.
- 55:51And it says so much. And then you finally get the
- 55:54moment where he he lays him down on the ground and he tells Edie,
- 55:57like, for God's sakes, don't let them leave him out here too
- 56:01long. And his voice finally cracks.
- 56:04And it's the moment where it like, it gets me, you know what
- 56:06I mean? Like, because you haven't seen
- 56:07this guy crack the whole movie despite all the pressure.
- 56:10And when he finally starts to kind of cry a little bit there,
- 56:13it's just, it's just such a masterful performance, man.
- 56:16Yeah, we, we've spent so much of this movie talking about
- 56:21performances in general, lots about Marlon.
- 56:24Is there anything else in this movie that you feel compelled to
- 56:28talk about before we wrap up shop here?
- 56:31I want to talk about the ending really quickly because the
- 56:34ending I think is the part of the movie that works the least
- 56:36for me. It's it's the most Hollywood
- 56:38like putting a bow on everything type ending to the point where
- 56:42like the actual mechanics of what's happening plot wise don't
- 56:47really make a lot of sense. So like Brando goes to confront
- 56:52Johnny and like all the longshoremen are hesitant about
- 56:55going to work anyway and they kind of are just sitting back
- 56:57watching. And then Brando starts getting
- 57:00his ass kicked and all the longshore men are like he's 1 of
- 57:03theirs anyway. And then somewhere in between
- 57:06him starting to get his ass kicked and having his ass fully
- 57:09kicked, they all change their tune and they're like, he's
- 57:12actually one of us now. And then they decide without
- 57:15consulting each other that if he walks in first, they'll walk in
- 57:20with him as a sign to demonstrate to the shippers who
- 57:23have just showed up that they're not taking orders from Johnny
- 57:26Friendly anymore. Now you don't see any of that
- 57:29interaction amongst themselves happening on screen.
- 57:31It's a very elaborate plan that requires Brando to be like the
- 57:34symbolic person for them. And then you have Father Barry
- 57:39Karl Malden convincing him to do it and not allowing anyone to
- 57:43touch him. And there's literally no plot
- 57:46reason for no one to be allowed to touch him other than that it
- 57:50is a direct literal parallel to him talking about Christ being
- 57:54with them on the like. He's being the Jesus figure.
- 57:56He's being marched to his own kind of crucifixion as like the
- 58:01scapegoat for all these people. He is broken and bruised.
- 58:04He's holding his side at one point.
- 58:05Like it's a very obvious Christ metaphor.
- 58:08And but it doesn't make sense why.
- 58:09Like why can't two guys just kind of come under each of his
- 58:12arms and go in with it? Like it doesn't really have any
- 58:15reason for existing other than that and so.
- 58:17Moses having his arms held up type of thing.
- 58:19Yeah, I just like when you think about it in the context of the
- 58:23world of the movie, like this doesn't make any sense.
- 58:26And so they actually, you know, Johnny Friendly this whole time
- 58:29is like, come on, you bums go to work and they won't listen to
- 58:33him. But then they go to work.
- 58:35They do exactly what Johnny Friendly told them to do.
- 58:38But they said, well, now that they saw that we weren't taking
- 58:41orders from him, but we came in on our own volition, they'll
- 58:45they'll never let Johnny Friendly give us orders again.
- 58:49That makes absolutely no sense. And like at the end of the
- 58:52movie, he's just standing there going, I'll be back.
- 58:55You just watch. But like, you still have the
- 58:58keys to the warehouse. Your office is still right
- 59:00there. Like, what do you mean it'll be
- 59:01back? No one kicked you out.
- 59:03You are clearly not from on the waterfront.
- 59:06You don't understand how these men think.
- 59:09Brad, enlighten me. I know you grew up in some rough
- 59:12and tumble parts of Seven Hills. OH.
- 59:14Yes, it was it was a very rough time in Seven Hills.
- 59:18OH, I still remember I dated a girl from the Brecksville
- 59:22Broadview Heights area, which is like a little more affluent than
- 59:27Seven Hills Parma, but that crazy.
- 59:29So and we were at a dance the one time and her friends were
- 59:33asking me like, what's it like being at Normandy in in the
- 59:36hood? And I was like, I don't know if
- 59:39you guys understand that Parma is very, very similar to
- 59:43Brecksville, Broadview Heights. And I'm just over here in
- 59:47Barbara didn't like, OK, Seven Hills.
- 59:50Exactly so. Let's talk about the ending,
- 59:52though. Like, I know I'm ranting and
- 59:55that it, I'm saying it doesn't make any sense.
- 59:57It still works emotionally. Like it's a great ending, but it
- 1:00:01did kind of pull me out, You know, it was like, oh, this
- 1:00:04movie's A-101010101010, maybe it's a nine and a half.
- 1:00:07And it it was the ending that did it for me.
- 1:00:10Yeah. I mean, I, I think that the from
- 1:00:13a story standpoint, there's an element of these longshoremen
- 1:00:21only respect brute power and strength, and that's the reason
- 1:00:26that they've stayed in line for so long.
- 1:00:28And so to watch somebody be on the receiving end of Johnny
- 1:00:35Friendly's raw power and still get up and walk in, like, to me,
- 1:00:42it felt like they were voting him in as the next Union Leader.
- 1:00:47Like that's kind of the vibe that I got.
- 1:00:49Like, we'll follow him to work. We'll never follow Johnny
- 1:00:54Friendly into work anymore. So I like it.
- 1:00:57It worked for me. But but I'm with you.
- 1:01:00I think that's one of the weakest parts of the film as
- 1:01:03from a story standpoint, but from an emotional standpoint,
- 1:01:06like, I mean, it's, it's right up there with like passion of
- 1:01:11the Christ, like, like he's, he's dragging himself up there
- 1:01:15like like Jim Caviezel. That's that's the comparison I
- 1:01:20want to make on this podcast is like Marlon Brando clearly
- 1:01:23patterning himself after Jim Caviezel.
- 1:01:26Yes, obviously. All right.
- 1:01:29One more point I want to make real quick.
- 1:01:30And it's it's the really famous scene in the taxi cab that we've
- 1:01:34mentioned a couple times and the famous line, you know, you don't
- 1:01:37understand. I could have had class.
- 1:01:39I could have been a contender. It's the number three quote of
- 1:01:43all time, according to the American Film Institute.
- 1:01:46It's taken out of context all the time, you know, when people
- 1:01:48are parodying Brando. But man, that scene is crushing
- 1:01:52in so many ways. And you talked about when
- 1:01:54Steiger pulls the gun and Brando's just disappointed more
- 1:01:58than anything. For me, it's the it's the it's
- 1:02:01hearing him confess out loud and owning the fact that he's a bum.
- 1:02:07It's like, ah, dude. Like even he accepts that he's a
- 1:02:10butt. The whole movie, people have
- 1:02:12been calling him a bum. And he's like, I'm not a bum.
- 1:02:14Don't you call me a bum. And to get to this moment where
- 1:02:18everything he's been feeling, it's like he's clearly believed
- 1:02:20this about his brother making his life miserable for years and
- 1:02:24he's never said it. And to hear him confess out
- 1:02:27loud, not only have I finally given into seeing myself as a
- 1:02:31bum the way everybody else does, but it was you that made me this
- 1:02:36way is like, it's like a double gut punch in one line.
- 1:02:41And I, you know, I keep talking about how unbelievably sad this
- 1:02:44movie is. I'm sure I'm not inspiring
- 1:02:45anyone to go watch this movie, but it really taps into this
- 1:02:49undercurrents of not just the inevitability and the
- 1:02:53oppression, but kind of like failed dreams and, and losing
- 1:02:58out on who you're supposed to be because you've allowed yourself
- 1:03:01to be taken advantage of. And it really all culminates in
- 1:03:05that one moment. Not even just that whole scene,
- 1:03:08but just that one moment for me. And I I couldn't let us get out
- 1:03:11of here today without talking about it a little bit.
- 1:03:13Yeah, I It taps into the very essence of what it means to be a
- 1:03:19human, that the moments that make us and break us until we're
- 1:03:26willing to lament what could have been and lament what
- 1:03:32happened in our lives and call out the truth of what our
- 1:03:37experience has been. Until we're willing to do that,
- 1:03:40we will live conflicted, disintegrated lives.
- 1:03:44And and you see that in the character of Terry Malloy.
- 1:03:47He he doesn't know who he is. He doesn't have a conscience.
- 1:03:51It, it, it, it is a broken, boring, sad life that even his
- 1:03:56brother says like, you know, you're like, you're coming up on
- 1:03:5930 now, man. You got to make something out of
- 1:04:01your life. And and that's what leads to
- 1:04:04this conversation where Terry finally acknowledges who he is
- 1:04:10now, and he laments the events that led to him becoming who he
- 1:04:15is. And it's that choice to lament
- 1:04:19that choice to call a spade a spade, that leads to him being
- 1:04:25redeemed as a character. And I think that's the reason
- 1:04:29why I've swung around on this movie is because that message is
- 1:04:34so important for all humans to hear.
- 1:04:38All right. On that note, it is time for us
- 1:04:39to get into our last segment of the day, which we call let's
- 1:04:42make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:04:45episodes of Things, listening to the film and Whiskey Show.
- 1:04:49Let's have another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:04:51struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 1:04:52day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:04:54Let's Make It a double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:04:57movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 1:05:00feature? Brad, do you want to go first or
- 1:05:02should I go first? Yeah, I'll go first, Bob.
- 1:05:06I am going to pair this film because I, I think it fits
- 1:05:12thematically and I, I think that there's a similar vibe
- 1:05:17throughout the film. I'm actually going to pair this
- 1:05:20with Raging Bull. Now, I, I think I do want to
- 1:05:25interrupt you just for a second to say I texted you at one point
- 1:05:28today and I told you, hey, I was going to spring this on you
- 1:05:31later, but I want to know your thoughts now.
- 1:05:33And I said, what did watching the Bicycle Thieves do for your
- 1:05:38appreciation of this movie? And your response was, damn it,
- 1:05:41Bob, I was going to make Bicycle Thieves my let's make it a
- 1:05:43double. So I want to publicly apologize
- 1:05:45for stepping on your Let's make it a double.
- 1:05:47That's OK, man. No, I, I think bicycle thieves
- 1:05:50would be a great let's make it a double.
- 1:05:52I, I think especially for the fact that they came out in, in
- 1:05:55similar, you know, chronological time, like, you know, raging
- 1:05:59Bulls 1980. The reason I went with Raging
- 1:06:03Bull is because that scene where he acknowledges who he is.
- 1:06:10I think if you juxtapose that with De Niro at the very end of
- 1:06:16Raging Bull and his inability to ever accept who he is and the
- 1:06:21actions that have brought him to where he is.
- 1:06:25Like when you juxtapose those two characters and the ends of
- 1:06:30the film, like that scene with Pesci at the end of the movie.
- 1:06:33Is. Just still one of the most
- 1:06:37crushing moments I have ever seen in a movie.
- 1:06:42And so I, I think that thematically, if you, if you
- 1:06:44just go with the theme of like the importance of accepting the
- 1:06:49things that have happened in your life and naming them and,
- 1:06:53and, and lamenting what has gone on.
- 1:06:57And then you see one side of the coin and the other between On
- 1:07:02the Waterfront and Raging Bull. I I think it's a really poignant
- 1:07:05pairing. Yeah, I think we could honestly
- 1:07:07just put together a series of movies called Big Dumb Boxers
- 1:07:10and they could do these two and then you could throw a Rocky in
- 1:07:14there because I don't know if you've ever seen the original
- 1:07:16Rocky, Brad it like it is just on the waterfront, except like
- 1:07:21he stays a boxer and you love him.
- 1:07:24You know what I mean? Like that's it.
- 1:07:26Like it's. Oh dude, I I literally couldn't
- 1:07:28stop thinking about Rocky when, when Brando breaks into the room
- 1:07:35and starts making out with her even though she's telling him
- 1:07:38not to, I'm like, Oh yeah, it's, it's Rocky all over again.
- 1:07:42Sylvester Stallone out here winning Oscars for his script
- 1:07:44that is literally just on the waterfront.
- 1:07:47Yeah, So I, I think you could do Rocky.
- 1:07:50I think I'm going to pair this movie up with Mr. Smith Goes to
- 1:07:53Washington, which is another movie about a guy that is like
- 1:07:56fighting corruption to a point where like 15 minutes before the
- 1:08:01movie's over, you're like, how the hell is this going?
- 1:08:04How is he ever going to win? This seems insurmountable.
- 1:08:07And then the ending of each movie is a little bit of like a
- 1:08:11Deus Ex machina. It's a little bit of just like
- 1:08:14really tidy, puts a bow on things.
- 1:08:16Might be the weakest part of the movie, but God, I love them both
- 1:08:20and I and and damned if I don't feel inspired at the end of each
- 1:08:23of these movies. I really do think you could do a
- 1:08:25lot worse than pairing up on the Waterfront and Mr. Smith Goes to
- 1:08:29Washington. That is an interesting pairing.
- 1:08:33I'm not going to lie that there's a lot different about
- 1:08:36those films, but I I think I see where you're coming from it.
- 1:08:39It would be a very entertaining evening to say the least.
- 1:08:42And you know, you Brad, as the anti commie crusader that you
- 1:08:47are. That's right.
- 1:08:48You you definitely want to end with Mr. Smith Goes to
- 1:08:50Washington so you can hear all that patriotic music and, you
- 1:08:54know, salute the flag, dude. America, am I right?
- 1:08:59All right, let's give this movie some final scores.
- 1:09:01I think last time I gave this an 8, and that was really by virtue
- 1:09:04of the fact that I'd seen it many, many times and loved it.
- 1:09:07But then the watch that we specifically did for the
- 1:09:10podcast, I was like, oof, doesn't hold up for me.
- 1:09:14I don't know what I was drinking the night before we recorded
- 1:09:16that. Dude, this is a fantastic.
- 1:09:18I think that it does have some some slight flaws, but it's not
- 1:09:22enough to bring it any lower than a 9 1/2 for me.
- 1:09:25I believe that I was at a 7 out of 10 and I'm going to follow
- 1:09:30your pattern. I'll bump up a point and a half.
- 1:09:33I'm going to give this an 8 1/2 Bob.
- 1:09:35I think it's an incredible film that has a few of the most
- 1:09:39important scenes in film history that everybody should watch.
- 1:09:43It just doesn't quite rise to that 9 out of 10 wildly
- 1:09:49impactful films for me. Right now, this is sitting at
- 1:09:52#199 on IMD BS top 250 at an 8.1.
- 1:09:58So Brad, would you say, I mean, obviously you gave it an 8 1/2,
- 1:10:01but thinking about the general population, does that seem about
- 1:10:04right or do you still think that's a little too low for
- 1:10:05where this movie should be? I think with the general
- 1:10:09population I'm a little bit surprised that it's 8 out of
- 1:10:138.1. I would almost guess people
- 1:10:15would be at a 7978 out of 10. So you think this is like the
- 1:10:20ceiling for where for where it could be in 2024?
- 1:10:24I would say so. I think it's an old film and I
- 1:10:27think that people will struggle to connect with certain elements
- 1:10:31of it. I mean, one of the motivating
- 1:10:35factors of the film is that after he rats on the
- 1:10:40longshoreman's union, they kill all his pigeons.
- 1:10:43Bob. Oh no.
- 1:10:45That. Made me sad, man.
- 1:10:49The little kid crying the pigeon for that pigeon, Yeah.
- 1:10:54There was a few references throughout the film that I was
- 1:10:56like, Oh yeah, this is 100 percent 1954.
- 1:10:59I have no idea why that was an insult.
- 1:11:05All right man, so that is on the waterfront, but we'd like to
- 1:11:08know what you folks think is an 8.1 on IMDb about where you
- 1:11:12would land. Are you closer to where me and
- 1:11:14Brad would be? You can find us on social media,
- 1:11:16Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok, YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:11:22Or you can jump onto the discord.
- 1:11:24We are having a conversation every single day about movies,
- 1:11:27whiskey, and a large variety of other things.
- 1:11:31So if you'd like to join the conversation, you can use the
- 1:11:33link at the end of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:11:36Next week, we will be talking about a film maker whose name we
- 1:11:39dropped earlier in this episode, Steven Spielberg looking at his
- 1:11:432002 drama comedy masterpiece. Catch Me If You Can.
- 1:11:48I cannot wait to revisit that one, Brad.
- 1:11:49That's what, a fun movie. Oh dude, the scene when Leo is
- 1:11:54is at the window during Christmas time.
- 1:11:56Not fun, but a great scene. So good.
- 1:12:00All right, so join us for that next week.
- 1:12:02But until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:12:05And we'll see you next time.