Latest / The Climate Translation / When the Math Breaks

Transcript

When the Math Breaks · The Climate Translation

0:00
Most people think climate change becomes real when something dramatic happens, a wild
0:13
fire on the horizon, flood water in the street, a hurricane on the radar.
0:19
But for many families, it shows up in a much quieter way.
0:23
It arrives in the mail, a notice that your insurance premium has doubled, or that your
0:28
deductible has changed, or that your company is no longer renewing policies in your area.
0:36
No storm, no flames, just math.
0:40
Today we're looking at what happens when the math breaks.
0:44
We'll talk about why insurers are pulling back in parts of Florida and California, how
0:49
risk models differ from weather forecasts, and why a 30-year mortgage is really a 30-year
0:57
bet on future climate conditions.
1:01
And even if you live in Nebraska, far from rising seas or wildfire zones, we'll explore
1:07
why climate change risk doesn't stay local in a connected financial system.
1:14
Welcome back to the podcast, I'm Dr. Mac, and this is the Climate Translation.
1:25
Most weeks on this podcast, I translate the physical science of climate change.
1:31
We talk about ocean currents, carbon cycles, atmospheric physics, the how behind the
1:38
warming.
1:39
But climate change doesn't just show up in thermometers or satellite data.
1:44
It also shows up in systems that most of us interact with on a daily basis.
1:51
Insurance is one of those systems.
1:53
You may never calculate radiative forcing at your kitchen table, but you do notice when
1:59
you're monthly bill changes.
2:02
You notice when you're deductible increases.
2:05
You notice when you're insurer since a letter saying they're no longer writing policies
2:09
in your area.
2:11
That's why this conversation matters, because when we talk about climate risk, we often
2:17
focus on the physical side, rising seas, stronger storms, longer fire seasons.
2:24
But there's another layer, how markets respond to those risks.
2:31
Insurance is one of the earliest signals that something in the math has shifted.
2:36
Not because insurers are political, not because they're trying to make a statement, but because
2:42
their entire business model depends on calculating probability.
2:47
And when probability changes, prices change.
2:52
So this episode isn't about taking sides on a policy debate, it's about understanding
2:57
what happens when the assumptions behind decades of financial modeling begins to move.
3:03
So that brings us to a question I've heard a lot lately.
3:07
I don't live on the coast.
3:09
I don't live in a wildfire zone.
3:11
So why did my insurance bill go up 20% this year?
3:15
It's a fair question.
3:17
The answer is because insurance doesn't just price the risk on your street, it prices
3:22
the risk across the entire pool of customers.
3:27
Insurance works by spreading risk.
3:29
Thousands, sometimes millions of policyholders, pay in to the same system.
3:36
The idea is simple, not everyone experiences a disaster at the same time.
3:42
But here's where climate change enters the math.
3:46
Risk has two parts.
3:48
The physical risk is the event itself, the hurricane, the hail storm, the wildfire.
3:55
Financial risk is the probability of that event multiplied by the cost to rebuild.
4:02
For decades, insurers relied on a powerful assumption about stationarity.
4:08
The idea that the past is a reliable guide to the future.
4:13
If a region has experienced one major flood every 50 years, the model assumed roughly
4:19
the same pattern going forward.
4:22
But in many places, the frequency and severity of extreme events are shifting.
4:29
Warmer oceans can fuel stronger storms.
4:33
Warmer air holds more moisture, increasing heavy rainfall.
4:37
Longer droughts intensify wildfire risk, and rebuilding costs have surged.
4:44
So even if your town hasn't flooded, the overall pool of risk has changed.
4:50
And when the pool changes, everyone's math changes.
4:56
Imagine you and 1,000 people are pitching in to cover medical bills for whoever gets sick.
5:02
If three people get sick each year, that contribution stays manageable.
5:07
But what if 100 people get sick, and then the hospital charges double?
5:13
Everyone's share has to go up.
5:15
It doesn't matter if you personally feel healthy, the system has to adjust.
5:21
That's what's happening in parts of the insurance market, not because the temperature
5:25
graph has moved a tiny bit, but because the cost curves and the probability curves are
5:31
moving faster than they used to.
5:34
And when the assumptions behind the math change, premiums follow.
5:40
So if insurance isn't just reacting to last year's storm, how are these decisions
5:45
actually made?
5:47
This is where risk modeling comes in.
5:50
Insurance companies and banks aren't looking at a weather forecast for next Tuesday.
5:55
They're looking decades ahead.
5:57
To do that, they use something called a catastrophe model, often shortened to a CAT model.
6:04
A CAT model combines historical disaster data, engineering information about buildings,
6:11
and increasingly climate change projections.
6:15
Think of it less like a crystal ball and more like running thousands of stress tests.
6:21
Engineers build a digital representation of a region, the types of homes, the construction
6:27
materials, the elevation, the vegetation, the distance from water.
6:33
Then they simulate thousands of possible future events, not just one hurricane, thousands
6:39
of hurricanes, not just one wildfire, thousands of possible ignition and wind scenarios.
6:46
From those simulations, they create probability curves, and those curves estimate how often
6:53
losses of a certain size might occur.
6:57
Here's how I would explain this in my classroom.
7:00
Imagine you're rolling a dice, and you're asked, if I roll this dice 10,000 times, how often
7:07
will it land on the one side?
7:11
But then what happens if you load that dice, or the dice changes?
7:17
Climate change doesn't guarantee disasters every year, but in some regions, it increases
7:22
the probability of certain extremes, it loads the dice.
7:28
You can have stronger rainfall events, more intense wildfire conditions, faster hurricane
7:34
intensification, that changes the distribution of outcomes.
7:40
Now there's another layer most homeowners never see, reinsurance.
7:46
Reinsurance is insurance for insurance companies.
7:50
Local insurers spread the risk across customers, but if the disaster is large enough, they
7:57
rely on a global reinsurance firm to absorb part of the loss.
8:03
When reinsurers are seeing volatility in disaster losses, whether from climate factors, development
8:10
and risky areas, or rising rebuilding costs, they adjust the price they charge insurers.
8:17
And when the wholesale risk price rises, retail premiums follow.
8:23
In recent years, some major insurers have reduced new policies in parts of Florida and
8:29
California.
8:31
That wasn't a weather forecast decision.
8:34
It reflected modeling that suggested projected losses, combined with regulatory limits on
8:40
pricing, created unsustainable risk.
8:44
It wasn't politics.
8:46
It was the probability distributions shifting.
8:50
When the projected losses over 30 years increase, the financial math adjusts.
8:55
Even if the physical disaster hasn't happened yet.
8:58
And that's where climate science intersects with everyday economics.
9:03
Because once the insurance math tightens, it doesn't stop with premiums.
9:08
It moves into lending.
9:10
And that's where the ripple spreads far beyond coastlines.
9:16
Now for those listeners in Nebraska, Ohio, or even Northern Georgia, places that may
9:21
feel far removed from rising seas or wildfire headlines, let's talk about the 30 year
9:28
mortgage.
9:29
When a bank lends you money to buy a home, it's not approving a transaction, it's evaluating
9:35
long-term risk.
9:38
In the United States, a typical mortgage lasts 30 years.
9:42
That means the lender is making an assumption that the property will remain insurable,
9:47
habitable, and valuable for decades.
9:50
But here's something most people don't realize.
9:53
Most banks don't hold that mortgage for 30 years.
9:57
They bundle it with thousands of others and sell those loans onto a secondary market,
10:03
often to entities in the U.S. called Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac.
10:08
Those organizations keep the housing market liquid by buying and guaranteeing mortgages.
10:14
And increasingly, they, along with private investors, are asking a new question.
10:21
How exposed are we, and these properties, to long-term climate risk?
10:26
If insurance becomes significantly more expensive or harder to obtain in a region, lending
10:33
conditions tighten, not instantly and not everywhere, but gradually.
10:38
Lenders typically require insurance.
10:41
If insurance costs rise sharply, monthly payments rise.
10:46
If coverage options shrink, underwriting standards may adjust.
10:50
And when borrowing becomes more expensive or difficult, property demand can change.
10:56
It doesn't collapse the city overnight, but it can mean that appreciation slows, or certain
11:02
neighborhoods face higher financing costs than others.
11:06
In some coastal cities like Miami researchers have observed shifting demand towards higher
11:13
elevation areas.
11:15
That pattern, sometimes called climate-driven migration within cities, reflects how risk
11:22
perception can influence housing markets.
11:25
But let's look back at the American heartland, to someone who lives in Kansas, for instance.
11:31
Even if your town isn't facing sea-level rise, you're part of a national financial system.
11:38
Pension funds, retirement accounts, and mutual funds invest in mortgage-backed securities, bundles
11:45
of home loans from across the country.
11:48
If climate-related losses increase in one region, the costs don't stay isolated.
11:54
They're absorbed by insurers, reinsurers, investors, and taxpayers.
12:01
At the local level, property taxes fund schools, fire departments, and infrastructure.
12:07
If insurance costs rise and drought-prone farming regions, or hail damage becomes more
12:13
frequent in the Plains, that affects budgets, too.
12:17
A 30-year mortgage is, in part, a bet on stability.
12:22
And for much of the 20th century, climate variability has been treated as a relatively
12:27
stable background condition.
12:30
In some regions, that background risk is shifting.
12:33
It's not collapsing or exploding, but it's definitely shifting enough that financial
12:38
models are being recalibrated.
12:40
And when the math changes at scale, that ripple effect extends far beyond the original hazard.
12:49
We've seen how insurance responds to shifting probabilities.
12:52
We've seen how lending depends on insurance.
12:55
But let's talk about what happens when the adjustments start to scale.
13:00
In your house, a circuit breaker is a safety device.
13:04
If too much current flows to a system, the breaker trips to prevent damage.
13:09
In financial systems, something similar happens.
13:13
Not as a dramatic shutdown, but as a tightening.
13:16
When projected losses rise, beyond what can reasonably be covered by premiums, reserves,
13:22
or public backstops, price increase, coverage narrows, or exposure is reduced.
13:29
That adjustment is the system protecting itself.
13:33
In some states, governments have tried to cushion that adjustment.
13:37
Florida's Citizen Property Insurance corporation, for example, was created as an insurer of
13:43
last resort.
13:45
It provides coverage when private options are limited.
13:48
Over time, as private insurance reduced exposure in high-risk regions, enrollment and
13:54
Citizens grew significantly.
13:57
That doesn't mean collapse is imminent, but it does mean the risk is being concentrated
14:02
into publicly-backed pools.
14:05
And when risk is pooled publicly, losses are distributed more broadly, sometimes through
14:10
assessments and higher premiums across the system.
14:15
And here's the climate connection.
14:17
Insurance companies don't make decisions based on political debates.
14:21
They make decisions based on loss data and forward-thinking risk models.
14:27
If wildfire seasons lengthen, if rainfall events intensify, if rebuilding costs climb
14:34
after repeated disasters, their actuarial tables adjust, regardless of any rhetoric.
14:41
The physical climate signal shows up first in loss records and then in pricing.
14:49
Paradise, California, is one example of how that played out.
14:53
After the Camp Fire in 2018, rebuilding was physically possible, but insurability became
14:59
more difficult, and when insurance becomes expensive or limited, financing becomes complex.
15:07
That doesn't end the town overnight, but it does change who can rebuild, how fast,
15:13
and at what cost.
15:15
This is what I meant by an economic breaker.
15:17
It's not a sudden shutdown, but it's a recalibration.
15:21
For decades, much of our infrastructure and financial planning assumed that historical
15:26
climate patterns would be stable.
15:29
Now in some regions, the baseline is shifting.
15:33
When physical risk increases, the financial system doesn't debate it, it prices it.
15:38
And that's the quiet but powerful signal.
15:41
Even if governments minimize or dismiss climate projections.
15:46
Even if public opinion remains divided, the insurance market responds to observed losses
15:52
and model probabilities.
15:54
That response can be gradual, it can be uneven, it can be politically uncomfortable, but
16:00
it reflects a reality.
16:03
Climate change is not just measured in degrees Celsius, it's measured in loss ratios,
16:09
and when those ratios move, the math moves with them.
16:22
Climate change doesn't just show up in satellite images and temperature graphs.
16:27
It shows up in insurance premiums, in lending standards, and in budgets.
16:32
The next time someone says climate change is a future problem or a coastal problem, you
16:37
don't have to argue about sea level rise.
16:40
You can ask a simple question, has the cost of the risk changed where you live?
16:45
The financial system is often one of the first places that long term physical trends become
16:51
visible.
16:52
And it's not because it's political, it's not because it's ideological, it's because
16:57
risk has a connection to dollars and cents.
17:01
When probabilities shift, the pricing shifts.
17:06
Meaning that shift doesn't have to be frightening.
17:09
It just means recognizing that climate is no longer just a fixed background condition.
17:14
It's a variable in an equation.
17:17
And the sooner we account for that variable, the more options we have.
17:23
I'm Dr. Mac, and this has been the Climate Translation.
17:27
If you have a question about the climate that you've been too afraid to ask, or if you
17:31
have a differing opinion, please let me know.
17:34
I can use your viewpoints in future episodes.
17:37
You can reach me at theclimatetranslation at gmail.com.
17:42
I'll see you next time.