Latest / MUBI Podcast / PASSAGES — Ira Sachs's "endless circle of desire"
Transcript
- 0:00Heads up, this episode includes spoilers.
- 0:06So your main character is a guy who can't settle down.
- 0:09Yes.
- 0:10He's got two lovers and he can't decide between the two of them.
- 0:12I know you are now in a monogamous relationship, but is this something you struggled with?
- 0:16Why did you want to explore that?
- 0:18No, that's...
- 0:18I'm much more obsessive.
- 0:20I'm more single-focused, I would say.
- 0:23But I have thought about the fact, this film is a love triangle, so it's a triangulation.
- 0:28And there's something about any kind of triangulation which creates really interesting dynamics, even in the most simple fashion.
- 0:35Once there's three people, there tends to be like conflict, in some ways, there seems to be tension, and there also often leads to a kind of obsession because something is unattained in a triangle.
- 0:48So on that level, I relate to kind of the endless circle of desire that is between these three characters.
- 0:55But but I wouldn't say I'm a two-timer.
- 1:00That is indie hero filmmaker Ira Sachs.
- 1:03And his new feature, Passages is about a fascinating kind of two-timer.
- 1:09The character's name is Tomas, the brooding artist who's married to another man, Martin.
- 1:14Until that is, Tomas falls for a woman named Agathe.
- 1:18And then ping pongs between the two lovers, never satisfied.
- 1:22At one point, even trying to have them both.
- 1:24We can do this together.
- 1:26- We can do what together?
- 1:26- We can be family.
- 1:29I thought that you were in love?
- 1:32I'm confused...
- 1:33Until it dawns on everyone, except maybe Tomas, that even the both of them won't be enough for him.
- 1:38That maybe nothing will ever be enough.
- 1:43I'm Rico Gagliano.
- 1:44Welcome back to the MUBI Podcast.
- 1:47MUBI's the streaming service that champions great cinema.
- 1:49On this show we tell you the stories behind great cinema.
- 1:52Season five is coming soon.
- 1:54Meanwhile, here is one of our special episodes to tide you over.
- 1:57It's my interview with Ira Sachs aboutPassages, which hits theaters in L.A.
- 2:01and New York this week, August 4th, and then rolls out around the world.
- 2:04It is a seriously sexy, brutally funny, and finally kind of mesmerizing portrait of a self-centered man and the people who just can't quit him.
- 2:12It was a huge hit with critics at Sundance, and it's the kind of movie that begs to be read as autobiographical.
- 2:19After all, the character of Tomas is, guess what, an art house filmmaker.
- 2:22And he also wants to raise a kid with both his gay partner and a woman.
- 2:26Something Sachs admitted right off the bat is indeed a situation pulled straight from his own life.
- 2:34In truth, that is what my family is like.
- 2:37I have a husband and we raise our kids with two women who live next door to us.
- 2:42So we are a kind of happier version of what is attempted in Passages.
- 2:47I mean, I was aware of this, by the way, about your life, so I'm glad that you brought it up.
- 2:51But I will, let me put it this way, I saw a thing that you did where you were talking about Fassbinder's movie, Fox and Friends, there's a video of you talking about that.
- 3:01And you said that it was almost like he was, this is a quote that you said,"Apologizing for things in his own life that he was conflicted about." And that came to mind while watching this movie 'cause this echoes your life.
- 3:12It's clearly not exactly like your life'cause you're the happy version of this.
- 3:15- But...
- 3:15- Well, you don't know that.
- 3:17But I will vouch for it.
- 3:19I'm happier than I used to be. Let's put it that way.
- 3:21Sure, based on what you've just told me, I'll just take you at your word.
- 3:24Ok.
- 3:25But are you then maybe working out conflicted feelings, even though you're having a happy version of this story, where conflicted feelings are working out with us?
- 3:31Yeah, I mean, I also want to be very clear that my filmmaking in general, is not a form of therapy, like, it's a form of storytelling.
- 3:39It's eventually it's like, it's a good story and the story has suspense, and the characters have complexity and complication.
- 3:47And I feel like that's what really what drives me.
- 3:50Once I have an idea.
- 3:50And then I mine what I know.
- 3:53So this character, I don't even, it's... people have asked me, you know,"Why a filmmaker?" There wasn't even a second he was anything but a filmmaker.
- 4:00I always knew he was some version of me.
- 4:04But that's also because it's the thing that I know the most about.
- 4:07You know, you and I can talk.
- 4:08I can talk for a long time about filmmaking.
- 4:11But if you asked me about, like, the state of the Middle East, I would have a much harder time to be articulate and thoughtful and knowledgeable and have more information than some other people might.
- 4:21Around filmmaking I'm very, it's 35 years of work and life, so I'm very versed in that, which gives me a kind of leg up when I'm creating a character.
- 4:30Well, let's talk about that character a little bit.
- 4:31I mean, it's interesting that what you're painting here, if you ask me, is a portrait of a narcissist.
- 4:37And not long ago, I talked to the director, Todd Field, about his portrait of an artist who's a narcissist, the movie Tár.
- 4:44And I'm seeing this also in TV and streaming shows.
- 4:47There's the series Fosse/Verdon, which is really about a toxic relationship between two narcissistic artists.
- 4:53Why do you think this is a time that we're exploring this so much?
- 4:57I don't actually consider Tomas the character played by Franz Rogowski, a narcissist.
- 5:03Possibly a sociopath.
- 5:03Because in every scene in the movie, both the character and the actor playing the character is incredibly interested in the other people in the room.
- 5:13Like all he's doing, except for some brief moments, he's always trying to seduce.
- 5:19And the seduction is a process of making people feel good.
- 5:22In a way, he's a pleasure giver.
- 5:24That being said, he clearly believes that the rules that are made for other people are not made for him.
- 5:29And I think that's the liberty which allows him to be an artist, but it's also the liberty which allows him to be...
- 5:37irresponsible to the effects of his actions.
- 5:40So that being said, I was writing this film under the cloud of Trump, and part of my feeling was what it was like to live under that cloud.
- 5:51But also then to see myself in that, and particularly during the pandemic, where I felt like I was a man who had a lot.
- 5:58Who didn't have as much as I wanted, and what that felt like.
- 6:02And that felt like something that was almost unlivable.
- 6:05And I think in this character, Tomas, there's an infinite gap between what he has and what he wants.
- 6:11Yeah, right. So in a way, you are both Martin and him.
- 6:16Yes...
- 6:17I think that Madame Bovary, c'est moi, which is my badly pronounced version of the fact that in some ways for me to understand characters, I need to see myself in them.
- 6:29And also, I loved all three of these actors so much when I was making this film.
- 6:34And I think that's part of the, for me that seems to be part of the texture of what the audience experiences, which is a sense that it's a film with a lot of pain and there's a lot of bad behavior, but there's also a lot of joy and pleasure.
- 6:49And I think those things come through partially because I, as the camera, felt a lot of joy and pleasure watching these three actors.
- 6:58Let's talk about pleasure while we're at it, then.
- 7:00I think this is, maybe you could say part of another trend, if you want to call it a trend, it's something that I'm seeing out there in the world of movies and TV series, that at last aren't afraid to explore sexual relationships.
- 7:13You've got just this year on the festival circuit. There's your movie, there's Joanna Arnow's The Feeling That the Time for Doing Something Has Passed, Molly Manning Walker'sHow to Have Sex, and I'm not the first person to know that art in general, like popular in any way, really hasn't seemed as interested in portraying sexual relationships for a long time in any serious kind of intimate way.
- 7:35There's not, yeah...
- 7:36And first of all, I want to wonder if you have an idea why you think that is, and then what's happening that's changing that.
- 7:42Well, I think the problem, I mean, I'm out in L.A.
- 7:45right now, I'm recording this here and I'm thinking about the fact for the last seven years, I haven't really been here professionally.
- 7:51Maybe ten years, I haven't come out here for work.
- 7:54And I was sort of like,"Oh what's changed in my life or my career that I don't come out for work?" And a friend of mine who's a film director said, "It's not you, it's...
- 8:02"what's happening out here"is changed so fundamentally that there's not a place for the people like...
- 8:08"There's not a place for people who are trying to tell personal stories.
- 8:11"There's not a place in which the detail of everyday life,"the specificity, the kind of like, literally the plot of land that I stand on"as a director is not that interesting to people in Hollywood.
- 8:25"And instead, there's this kind of broad, nonspecific"world of global marketability." So, of course, where's the room for sex in that?
- 8:37It's not necessary.
- 8:38Everybody's going for four quadrant, as they say in the business.
- 8:42Movies that appeal to like every possible demographic and age group.
- 8:45And what's really happened is they've turned, I mean, I remember when I would look at like cartoon movies and I would say those are for kids.
- 8:51They're not for adults.
- 8:51Now that we've just flipped that around.
- 8:54Now all movies are cartoons, and adults have just decided that it's okay to think cartoons are high art.
- 9:01Or, who needs high art?
- 9:02I mean, that's why theaters are going down around the country.
- 9:05That's why, you know, a lot of things are happening.
- 9:08The value of art in this culture in general is diminished.
- 9:14So that means what happens intimately between people in their houses, in their homes, their bedrooms is just not valuable.
- 9:21That feels right to me. But I'll also say that even the indie world for a long time felt fairly sexless, like it wasn't necessarily that it wasn't intimate.
- 9:28There were stories about relationships, as you're speaking of, but this feeling that I got that, like, we're not really talking about sex right now.
- 9:35Do you think that's true.
- 9:35Or am I just not seeing those movies?
- 9:37No, I mean, I think we all exist.
- 9:39We make things that we believe will be accepted within the culture at the time that we live.
- 9:44And so that's why to make this movie, I had to go back and look at movies from the seventies.
- 9:49I had to go back to like '72 and look at Chantal Akerman Je tu il Elle.
- 9:54And I had to go... that wasn't '72, but it was early seventies.
- 9:57I had to go back to early eighties and look at Taxi zum Klo a very explicit, honest film out of Berlin about a gay man, and his sexual life and experience.
- 10:07I had to go back to Passolini, like you think Salò would be made now?
- 10:11Like there's a way in which we have to say like, "Oh, we can create those images.
- 10:16"I didn't know that that was allowed." And on the reverse of that, we have like this film being, the MPAA saying this is an NC-17 and no one under 17 years old should be able to see this movie.
- 10:27So we're going back to the Code.
- 10:30Like, I want to make Pre-Code movies.
- 10:32And, you know, Hays and the whole Code that came out in the thirties, which repressed cinema in America, was founded by the Catholic Church.
- 10:39Like the Catholic Church are the people who created those codes.
- 10:43So I think that...
- 10:45I mean, I don't want to... I'm going to get off my, what's it called, soapbox.
- 10:49- I'm going to get off it...
- 10:49- Soapbox.
- 10:51I think it's called the soapbox.
- 10:52Let's just say I wanted to make a film that was as...
- 10:54I wanted to make a liberated film.
- 10:56I felt like, am I allowed to say "Fuck it?"- Sure.
- 10:58- Like, fuck it. Like...
- 10:59I just didn't want to.
- 11:01I wanted to make what I wanted to make.
- 11:02And I felt like I, for a moment, had the ability to do that, which is rare, and particularly rare for gay people in our culture in terms of money and possibility.
- 11:13And so I tried to make as free a film as possible.
- 11:17Do you think that's what's happening?
- 11:18Because the flip side of my original question was that I do see a bunch of indie movies now that are tackling these subjects.
- 11:24Do you think it's just a pent up, you know what, fuck it.
- 11:26Like everything's going to hell anyway. I'm just going all the way.
- 11:29I think that in some ways I wish that I felt, if I saw a trend I would, like, where I felt really challenged recently was from and so maybe this is what you're saying, like, I saw films coming out of Brazil under Bolsonaro.
- 11:42By filmmakers like Gustavo Vinagre and Fábio Leal, who are like making these incredibly free or if I see Sebastián Silva's film Rotting in the Sun, you know, that's a free film.
- 11:54You can maybe even say Bacurau, maybe.
- 11:56Bacurau, you know, I mean, then we could start to say,"Why don't you say Bacurau?" just, I think,"Oh, I'm just talking about good films." That's really what I'm talking about.
- 12:05They don't even need to be free, they just need to be good.
- 12:07And then I'll feel inspired and challenged and try to...
- 12:11and I think that what I do, and I'm sure there's there's a lot of good films being made now, but for me, if I can, I continue to watch Chantal Akerman, and continue to watch Maurice Pialat and continue...
- 12:23I just saw Love & Basketball the other day and I had never seen that film.
- 12:27It's so inspiring.
- 12:29Gina Prince-By the wood, her film, it's like, that is such a, like, detailed, human-specific, sexual film.
- 12:39So in some ways, I guess I just need to see more movies because that's where you get inspiration about what's possible.
- 12:47I should say by the way, since we're on the subject of sex just in general, that actually what stood out for me in this movie, maybe this is part of the liberation that you're talking about is less than the way that sex is shot in the movie is how the characters deal with their sex lives.
- 13:01They are incredibly open and enlightened, I would say about the the hero's shifting sexual desires.
- 13:08They're all pretty willing at least, to consider the nontraditional family roles that you mentioned earlier.
- 13:14Breakups aren't easy, but they're not portrayed as like explosive end of the world, things are all dealt kind of with an attempt at least at honest conversation.
- 13:21But it doesn't seem to matter...
- 13:23Like, they're still miserable.
- 13:26What are you saying with that?
- 13:28Well, I... there's no...
- 13:28there's no answer.
- 13:31It's just people, I mean, the history of literature and art is just basically it's hard to be alive, and it's hard to be close, to other people, and it's hard to be an individual within a couple.
- 13:44And I, you know, what's interesting to me about the making of this film is I think as a nearly 60 year old man, I had one idea of what the film would be about.
- 13:52And then when it was played by people who were a generation younger than me, it was a different film because I think the actors have a different idea of identity than I do.
- 14:01- Given their age.
- 14:01- How did it change?
- 14:03I just think the question of like labels and sexual identity don't exist with these three people and these three characters.
- 14:10It's not part of their dialog, It's not part of their...
- 14:13what they know, either as characters or as actors, which doesn't mean, like, I mean, I'm not anti-label.
- 14:20I think there's reasons people choose to identify themselves, but I think something about these three actors and the world that they live in comes through the film and is different than if it was 3 sixty year olds, let's put it that way.
- 14:33Was dialog or story changed according to, you know, their input?
- 14:37Or is it just kind of the texture that feels different than you thought it would, because of them?
- 14:42I'm talking about texture.
- 14:43I think I'm talking about texture.
- 14:45I'm specifically talking about like a man in a in a marriage to another man who then chooses to be with a woman.
- 14:52And I think, like, maybe the change would be there's no sense if it's the first time or the last time or if it happened before, if it didn't.
- 14:59There's no... and if it was me, it would be the first time.
- 15:03- So it'd be a bigger deal.
- 15:03- That's exactly what I'm talking about.
- 15:05Like in a previous era, there would be scene after scene where the initial couple, the gay couple, would be like, "Wait, what?
- 15:14"You went outside the relationship to a woman? What?
- 15:16"What's going on?
- 15:16Who are you?" And in this film, it's just accepted.
- 15:21It's like, "Yeah, that happened." Well, as you're talking, I realized this film is like an inverse of Making Love.
- 15:26Do you remember that movie?
- 15:27It was with... there was a movie that came out in probably the late seventies.
- 15:32It was with Michael Ontkean and the third Charlie's Angel, Kate I forgot who...
- 15:39So it's a woman in a relationship...
- 15:41Jackson! Jackson.
- 15:42Kate Jackson.
- 15:43Michael, I think, Ontkean.
- 15:46Someone's going to say "You got that wrong!" And they were in a couple.
- 15:50And then he falls in love with another guy.
- 15:52Harry Hamlin was the third guy.
- 15:55Yeah, yeah...
- 15:56And I remember the poster.
- 15:57And so it was, you know, in a way, this is like Making Love 2023.
- 16:02I want to get a little bit into the weeds on your technique.
- 16:06There's a moment in this movie that I really admired where there's a scene where it's sort of suggested that maybe Tomas and Martin could kind of raise a child with Agathe.
- 16:17And in almost the very next scene, we see the three of them are hanging out together and you get the sense that they're going to try this very unorthodox kind of relationship.
- 16:26But you don't include the scene where they talk about it and decide that.
- 16:30So tell me when and why you made that decision.
- 16:33It's funny, again, it's like certain...
- 16:35certain things are so instinctual that it didn't even occur to me.
- 16:39Because this...
- 16:39I think I'm interested in creating scenes that you always feel like you're somehow dropped in the middle.
- 16:46And I think the challenge is to give the audience enough that they don't feel that they've kind of being knocked around.
- 16:53They have to have enough information to be able to follow the plot and the emotional shifts.
- 16:59But I find the gap between chapters and specifically I would say the gap between chapters in novels, so incredible.
- 17:08Like what happens between two pages that we don't read.
- 17:12And I think that's one of the most powerful things that narrative can do, which is to jump...
- 17:18to something where you put the pieces together as you're entering.
- 17:22And that's true.
- 17:23It definitely involves you more as a viewer, because you're like, "Oh wait, I guess they already"had that conversation and now we've moved on." So you are kind of involved a little more, but it does seem like you're almost on purpose denying yourself a moment of high drama.
- 17:36I mean, like that would be the most dramatic thing.
- 17:38Now you're going to go and ask your female lover"Hey, you want to raise a kid with my ex?" Why deny yourself that?
- 17:46I mean, to me, that doesn't seem...
- 17:46there's enough high drama to come.
- 17:50- You can't hit it all.
- 17:50- That's true.
- 17:53And I guess I'm...
- 17:54you know, I'm figuring out which moments I think are most interesting.
- 17:58And that one... 'cause it wasn't.
- 18:00Last question. In the end, Tomas, is...
- 18:03he's rejected by both of his lovers and we see him biking through Paris.
- 18:07And you leave us with him and not his victims.
- 18:11And why is that?
- 18:12Well, I don't call them victims because.
- 18:15Well, you know, that's a terrible word, you're right.
- 18:16Well, ah, no, I'm just saying, actually, everyone has a choice in this movie and everybody's acting on their own impulses equally in a certain way.
- 18:23I mean, Agathe enters this relationship with Tomas knowing that he's a married man who has another home and another life.
- 18:30And... but she decides what she wants is him.
- 18:34And I think, you know, to me, this scene when you talk about Fox and His Friends the scene in the country house where Tomas and Martin invite this woman into their house as if to kind of start some new family life.
- 18:47That scene is like a horror movie to me.
- 18:50It's like there's so little care by the two men for the woman in their midst.
- 18:56And I think that to me is a very Fox and His Friends kind of moment.
- 19:00What do men do? What does the culture of gay men, what do they do?
- 19:04How aware are they of this woman, and what her feelings might be?
- 19:08And how respectful?
- 19:09So everybody... everybody acts.
- 19:12But to me, it was very clear that this was a film that began with a man on a pedestal and ended with him on the floor.
- 19:19It's a portrait film.
- 19:20I was thinking of him like, I'm always thinking of Henry James.
- 19:23It's like, this is a portrait of a man.
- 19:25And there's other major characters in the film.
- 19:29But I always knew that the protagonist is Tomas.
- 19:31Do you think he is going to learn?
- 19:33You said earlier that he was a sociopath, which almost by definition means it's very hard for you to ever learn.
- 19:38You know, I don't think a movie is very interesting unless there's change.
- 19:42I mean, I actually... years ago, I wrote a movie called Forty Shades of Blue, and Julianne Moore was going to star in the movie and in the last scene, it was like the two characters were stuck, like nothing was going to change, like these two characters.
- 19:56And she said, "I don't want to do this movie if that's how it ends." And so I was like, "Okay, I want Julianne Moore to do this movie." And so one of the characters got out of a car, like, that's all she did, like shoot that...
- 20:06She got outta the car and she started walking and she was walking who knows where.
- 20:11But it was different than when she was staying in that car.
- 20:14And then Julianne didn't do the movie, and I kept that ending.
- 20:18Because I thought dramatically, it's more interesting to see change.
- 20:22That is fascinating.
- 20:23And this movie ends with him on a bike.
- 20:25He's not walking, but he's riding somewhere.
- 20:28I know. I mean, I have... there was a retrospective in Paris of a few of my films, and it's...
- 20:32I suddenly did notice that all of them end with people walking, or on a road, or on a bike, or on a motorcycle.
- 20:42But I'm thinking of the movie that I'm writing, and I don't think it's going to end that way. So that's... change.
- 20:50Ira Sachs. Walk, run or bike to see his movie Passages when it opens in New York and L.A., August 4th.
- 20:55By the way, the sex scenes in this movie, they are smoking hot for sure, but also artful, necessary and hardly all that explicit.
- 21:01Despite what the MPAA says.
- 21:03It'll hit cinemas around the world over the next month.
- 21:05Check the show notes of this episode to learn where and when it is coming to your hometown.
- 21:10And speaking of hometowns, if yours happens to be Los Angeles, put this in your calendar on Wednesday night, August 30th.
- 21:17I will be live at the Arrow Theater in Santa Monica to present a screening of Wong Kar Wai, a stone cold Nineties classic, Chungking Express.
- 21:25You might have heard our episode earlier this year diving into the movie's great soundtrack, especially Faye Wong's Canto-pop cover of The Cranberries' Dreams.
- 21:32Now is your chance to hear that song through the Arrow's Most excellent sound system.
- 21:36We're doing this in partnership with the good folks at the American Cinematheque.
- 21:40As part of their Friends of the Fest Festival, programmed by podcasters just like myself.
- 21:44Get your tickets at AmericanCinematheque.com, that is AmericanCinematheque.com Hope to see you there. Till then, this episode was hosted, written and edited by me Rico Gagliano.
- 21:54Our producer is Ciara McEniff, booking was courtesy of Jo Dumitrescu, mastering by Stephen Colon.
- 22:00Our theme music was composed by Yuri Suzuki.
- 22:03Thanks this week to May Tsehay, Michael Lieberman, and Helen Wigger at WESA Pittsburgh.
- 22:08The show is executive produced by me, along with Jon Barrenechea, Efe Çakarel, Daniel Kasman and Michael Tacca.
- 22:14And of course, to stream the best in cinema, just head to MUBI.com to start watching.
- 22:19Thanks for listening and may all your cinemas this summer be air conditioned.