Latest / Property Investment & Wealth Creation Australia | The Michael Yardney Podcast / Property Investors: A valuer's opinion on how long this downturn could run | Scott Chapman
Transcript
- 0:00There's one thing every property investor or property owner wants to know right now,
- 0:03and that's how long is this property downturn actually going to last?
- 0:08You've heard all the opinions,
- 0:09haven't you? Some people say it's almost over,
- 0:12others are telling you we're heading for a crash that will make 2008 look like
- 0:16a picnic. Neither of those are right.
- 0:18And today's guest has the data to prove it.
- 0:21By the end of today's show, you're going to understand exactly what history tells
- 0:25us about how long property downturns run for.
- 0:27Why some markets are falling harder than others,
- 0:29and what you need to be doing right now if the July 2027 capital gains
- 0:35tax changes could affect you. You see,
- 0:37my guest today is Scott Chapman,
- 0:39Managing Director of Opteon for Australia and New Zealand.
- 0:42Opteon is the largest independent valuation firm in the country,
- 0:45which means Scott and his team aren't reading about the market from
- 0:48a spreadsheet somewhere. They're valuing thousands of properties every week right across the country.
- 0:53So they see exactly what's happening on the ground before it shows
- 0:57up in the official statistics.
- 0:58Opteon has released some fascinating analysis comparing this downturn
- 1:02to the last three property downturns.
- 1:04And what they found may surprise you,
- 1:06and it's got real implications on how you should be thinking about your property
- 1:10portfolio right now. Hi, I'm Michael Yardney,
- 1:13and welcome to this episode of the Michael Yardney Podcast.
- 1:16Look, I've been investing for over five decades now,
- 1:18and I've seen all the cycles, the booms and the busts,
- 1:21and the so-called crises. And I know how confusing all this noise is,
- 1:24and that's why twice a week I bring you
- 1:27proven strategies and insights from Australia's leading experts to help
- 1:31you make better decisions and build wealth safely.
- 1:34So let's get into today's show.
- 1:42Scott, welcome to the show. Now before we get into the numbers,
- 1:45I'd like you actually to tell us a little bit about Opteon,
- 1:48what you do and why you're in such a unique position to comment
- 1:52on what's really happening in the property markets at the moment.
- 1:55Yeah, thanks very much, Michael.
- 1:56A pleasure to be here. I've been with Opteon for seventeen years now
- 2:00and worked in the property sector for the best part of twenty-five years,
- 2:03so most of my professional life.
- 2:05And Opteon is a firm that we undertake thousands of valuations a
- 2:09day all across Australia, in multiple asset classes.
- 2:11So All of residential, we cover 98% of the postcodes in the country.
- 2:15And we're also looking at a lot of commercial and agri-rural assets as well.
- 2:18So our value, we have over 500 professionals that work for us that
- 2:22are talking to customers and real estate agents every day.
- 2:26And that provides us some really terrific insights,
- 2:28especially in times like these.
- 2:29Well, I think that's giving us a good start and I was interested in some
- 2:34of the research you've done because Opteon looked at the last three Australian
- 2:38property downturns to give us an idea of what's ahead.
- 2:42What did your analysis actually find,
- 2:44Scott? Yes, well, I mean, history can be a reasonable teacher at times.
- 2:48We know that the markets can depend on a on a number of factors that drive what
- 2:52happens in the go forward. But the last two downturns we experienced
- 2:56in the Australian property cycle for residential,
- 2:59they actually only lasted for ten to twelve months.
- 3:01That's from peak to trough. So they're relatively short,
- 3:04if you like, by some of the longer historical averages.
- 3:07The third most recent one, which occurred during the Royal Commission,
- 3:11which is the sort of 2017, the Banking Royal Commission,
- 3:142017 to 2019. Me too.
- 3:15I remember that well. We all do.
- 3:17It persisted. Yeah, we
- 3:18Yes. it was it was tough times. It persisted for around 20 months.
- 3:23And during those cycles, what was interesting around the length of those cycles,
- 3:27what was interesting for our research was typically the average peak to trough
- 3:32price falls for those downturns were in the order of eight to ten percent.
- 3:36So the falls were relatively similar,
- 3:38notwithstanding every market is different,
- 3:41every postcode is different, and of course every asset course. class is different.
- 3:45So the current downturn has become more broad based and boy,
- 3:48there's been some interesting predictions about how far things will fall.
- 3:54The typical property bears have come out again.
- 3:57The ones who only during COVID were suggesting that we were going to have
- 4:0230% falls. So yes, it is broadly based around Australia at the moment.
- 4:08But what do you think made that
- 4:102017 to 2019 one drag on longer than the others, which lasted considerably less.
- 4:17Yeah, it's a great question, Michael.
- 4:19I feel as though there's some parallels to today.
- 4:22One of the elements in that cycle was access to credit or the ability
- 4:27for people to get finance to organize their loans for property.
- 4:31And it was more difficult to get during that time.
- 4:33So that element also combining with the sentiment in the market.
- 4:38So people are worrying about where's the bottom of the cycle,
- 4:41should I purchase, led to that cycle going for longer.
- 4:44And At the moment, when I look at the current place that the Australian economy is in,
- 4:48if you like, for property and more broadly speaking,
- 4:50people are talking, commentators are saying that we may expect another increase.
- 4:54Inflation's a little bit nasty at the moment.
- 4:56And I don't think that the government is in a strong position
- 5:01to bring any stimulus into the market,
- 5:03which sometimes in other cycles has helped us turn the corner more quickly.
- 5:07I think we've got to remember that during COVID there were business assistance,
- 5:12the bank protected you if you had difficulty paying your mortgage.
- 5:16The government had
- 5:16Sure. first homeowner schemes and encouraged purchasing and building.
- 5:21But you're suggesting that the government may not be in as good a position this time
- 5:27around. Is that what I'm hearing?
- 5:28It doesn't seem so. All the commentators are pointing to those examples,
- 5:32and particularly after they've made the tax reform announcements only back in May,
- 5:36mind you, it wasn't that long ago.
- 5:37I just don't think that they're looking to make any changes and they want
- 5:41to see this play out, it would seem.
- 5:42Well, it's interesting. So the downturn started in Sydney and Melbourne earlier this
- 5:47year before the tax changes. Then we had three interest rate rises
- 5:51and then there were the tax changes.
- 5:54And that's actually created a lot of negative consumer sentiment.
- 5:57Is that the right way to say it?
- 5:59People have lost confidence. So if buyers
- 6:00Yeah. and sellers are not confident,
- 6:03they don't make big decisions like moving home or buying an investment property, do they?
- 6:08No, Consumers are often, you know,
- 6:11they see the signals in the market,
- 6:12like auction clearance rates, and they're watching the news and reading
- 6:15the newspapers or watching on social media where it might be.
- 6:18And when I reflect back, if you like,
- 6:20to early in the year to some of those examples,
- 6:22Michael. Geez, it seemed to turn quickly,
- 6:24if you like. Like auction
- 6:24Yes. clearance rates fell very fast and sentiment moved quickly.
- 6:28And I sort of have this saying,
- 6:29I've I've heard other people say,
- 6:31that when the market is turning positive or negative,
- 6:34no one waves you in and says, today's the day,
- 6:36this is the peak, this is the trough,
- 6:38you need to go now.
- 6:39No, I agree with that. Interestingly,
- 6:41the underlying fundamentals are still there.
- 6:44People are still getting married,
- 6:46getting divorced, having babies and maybe not in that
- 6:48Yeah. order. They're coming to Australia.
- 6:50They're leaving their parents home,
- 6:52maybe not as much now. So there's still the underlying demand,
- 6:56but it's being suppressed. I think it's also important to remember that most sellers
- 7:00are buyers as well. People need to move home still.
- 7:04So there are discretionary buyers who are not getting into the market as much,
- 7:09and there's also investors who clearly are not taking the leap into property
- 7:14investment as much at the moment.
- 7:16But there is this pent up demand.
- 7:18So you're right, when it eventually turns,
- 7:22there's going to be a sort of slingshot effect that it's going to pick up quickly,
- 7:26just like it changed quickly. That's the experience I've seen in the past as well.
- 7:30But having said that, based on the evidence you're seeing,
- 7:34How much further do you think this particular downturn could run?
- 7:38Hmm. So a lot of the signals at the moment in regards to some of the falls,
- 7:42particularly on the East Coast, in the Melbourne and Sydney markets,
- 7:45again, remembering every postcode is a little bit different from each other, we're course.
- 7:49already seeing reports of sort of that 8 to 10% fall.
- 7:53And some commentators are saying potentially a little bit,
- 7:55a little bit more.
- 7:56I've actually read something yesterday saying we think we've
- 7:59hit the bottom of the cycle,
- 8:01if you like, in regards to the fall-in value. and look,
- 8:03And some smaller capital cities like Perth and Brisbane and Adelaide have been
- 8:07quite resilient, as have the regional centres,
- 8:10that's been really interesting to watch.
- 8:12I really like your point, Michael,
- 8:13around the supply and demand factors in Australia.
- 8:16So like post-budget, we still have broadly the same population.
- 8:19We still have broadly the same number of dwellings in the country.
- 8:22sentiment is absolutely playing a factor.
- 8:24Sure. So I think what's going to happen is the decline is going to continue on.
- 8:30And unfortunately, if interest rates go up and there seems like now,
- 8:34gee, it's changed, hasn't it? Even recently,
- 8:36a 50-50 chance that there's going to be change in one more interest rate rise
- 8:41sometime this year, maybe Cup Day.
- 8:43That will again play on consumer sentiment.
- 8:46But what happened in previous cycles is the market slowly
- 8:51stops falling as much and then remains flat for a while and then things pick up.
- 8:56I see auction clearance rates as one of the interesting early indicators
- 9:01of how things are happening, how people are feeling,
- 9:04Scott, because it actually gives you a good in time indication of
- 9:10how buyers and sellers are feeling.
- 9:11And I guess the other leading indicator I look for is also finance approvals.
- 9:17In other words, a lot of people get their finance in advance of going
- 9:20out looking for their home. Anything else that you look out for?
- 9:23Yeah, well, a really simple one that our valuers like to do is
- 9:27our property valuers typically live in the communities where they work.
- 9:30So they often will head off on a weekend to open houses.
- 9:33And going Yep.
- 9:34to an open house now, compared to say three,
- 9:36four, five months ago, you can see there's less people.
- 9:39You can see the shift in attitudes and the discussion.
- 9:42So even just being around markets,
- 9:44and often that's our advice to whether it's investors if you like, or homeowners, that
- 9:48Getting out amongst it is where is the best place to learn.
- 9:51That's a really good point. And I know Nerida Conisbee,
- 9:54the chief economist of Ray White,
- 9:56who apparently sell one in three properties in Australia.
- 10:00And so they Mm.
- 10:01monitor all the open homes. She's done some great graphs
- 10:06showing how the number of people coming to open homes has decreased considerably.
- 10:11And it's now around two people compared to five or six people to each open home
- 10:15a year ago. But recently,
- 10:18that seems to have stabilized and there's a little bit of an increase.
- 10:22Now, again, you've mentioned a couple of times that there
- 10:25are markets within markets. So the upper end of the market works very differently
- 10:30to the middle range of properties and the more affordable properties.
- 10:34So more expensive properties in general aren't transacting as well,
- 10:38which means the median figures reported are really more related
- 10:43to lower price points.
- 10:45So just because figures in the media say the value of Sydney properties
- 10:51or Melbourne properties or Brisbane properties have gone down,
- 10:53doesn't mean your house has gone down as much.
- 10:55I guess it really doesn't matter as much because you and I have been around long
- 10:59enough to know this too shall pass.
- 11:01So the value of your property,
- 11:02I guess, matters when you buy it, when you want
- 11:05Yeah. to refinance it or when you want to sell it.
- 11:08So it doesn't matter that
- 11:10much if you've got a longer term perspective.
- 11:13As we say, there's different markets.
- 11:14Regional markets have actually performed a bit differently to
- 11:16the capital cities this time around,
- 11:18Scott. Absolutely. some of the larger regional hubs like Newcastle,
- 11:23Cairns, Geelong, clearly in those communities the affordability factor
- 11:27plays into people's minds there.
- 11:30So that's helpful. I we have seen a shift since COVID,
- 11:34if you like, which saw a higher supply of buyers,
- 11:37if you like, so people moving to those regions.
- 11:40But in some of those regions, the
- 11:42The supply of housing doesn't keep up with the new demands.
- 11:45So then of course it you know it drives prices or it drives competition.
- 11:48And from a volume perspective as well,
- 11:50so not just in regards to prices,
- 11:53but we've seen really steady volumes in those regions.
- 11:57Compared to Melbourne and Sydney,
- 11:58we've seen volumes fall in the best part of 20% since budget
- 12:01Yep. night. They've recovered a little.
- 12:03Regional is effectively flatlined if you took it as a collective market.
- 12:06Interesting. So again, as we keep saying,
- 12:09there are markets within markets.
- 12:10Now, I'd like to talk about the elephant in the room.
- 12:13There's been a bit of in the news about this,
- 12:15the capital gains tax changes,
- 12:17which are going to change from the 1st of July,
- 12:192027. Why could a property's value on that particular date become important
- 12:26for property investors, not homeowners?
- 12:28Great question, Michael. So without walking into the tax advice territory, but that
- 12:33Yeah, okay, this is general information.
- 12:35There's always a disclaimer at the end,
- 12:37but yes, let's put
- 12:37Love it. that in there right now that we're not giving tax advice.
- 12:41I'm asking your opinion as a valuer.
- 12:43Lovely. Thank you, Michael. So,
- 12:45of course, as you've suggested,
- 12:47that date is where the Australian Tax Office set out that they're moving to
- 12:50a new tax system through their tax reforms,
- 12:52the way that they're calculating capital gains tax from that date in the future.
- 12:56So anyone that owns an asset that qualifies as an investment property under
- 12:59the new under the reforms, which is a high percentage of property,
- 13:02they're going to be calculated at a higher rate when they sell
- 13:06the property or dispose of it post that date.
- 13:08So what people are trying to work out is
- 13:10Am I going to hold onto my property post that date?
- 13:12Am I going to sell it earlier? That valuation is going to form that baseline,
- 13:16if you like, of where the old tax system and the new tax system
- 13:20are going to cross paths.
- 13:21So what we should probably say is that while negative gearing
- 13:25has been grandfathered for people who own properties in the past before budget
- 13:29day this year, the capital gains tax changes,
- 13:32how you will be taxed if you sell a property,
- 13:35will affect everyone who owns an investment.
- 13:38Is that correct? Correct.
- 13:39So in the past, when you sold a property,
- 13:42you got a 50% discount on capital gains.
- 13:45In other words, if your property went up $300,000 from the purchase price,
- 13:49you paid capital gains tax on 150,000,
- 13:5250% of it at your tax rate, because there isn't a capital gains tax rate.
- 13:57You pay it at the taxpayer's
- 13:59rate, a person, a couple, or if it's a company, the company rate.
- 14:03Right. That's going to be different in the future,
- 14:06isn't it? What are the new changes going to be?
- 14:09In fact, boy, they remind me of the old days when it was indexed when
- 14:13I first started investing.
- 14:14Yeah. Yeah. So the new minimum baseline is thirty percent
- 14:18for capital gains tax. So the way the discount works
- 14:21in the future is not going to be as favorable for a lot of people depending
- 14:25on their ownership structure. So that's causing a lot of people
- 14:28to wonder about whether they maintain a residential property
- 14:32or commercial property for that matter as an asset to build wealth,
- 14:35because they're they're wondering around the disposal and what
- 14:37the tax implications are going to be.
- 14:39Well, again, our strategy at Metropole is to hold properties in the long term,
- 14:43but over time, your circumstances change and you may need to sell a property.
- 14:48But I don't think tax should be the main reason you buy an asset.
- 14:52Tax doesn't make a bad investment good or a good investment bad.
- 14:56But there is that cutoff point then,
- 14:58isn't there? On the 1st of July,
- 15:002027, you're going to want to know what the property is worth.
- 15:05And you can't just use a real estate agent's assessment.
- 15:09I think the tax department's going to want you to have a valuation.
- 15:13Is that correct? Thanks, Michael. The tax office talks about
- 15:17a credible valuation assessment, and perhaps some people have seen,
- 15:21whether it be in the media, that they've released their
- 15:25formula, their apportionment formula.
- 15:27And we would certainly suggest that the best place
- 15:30to organise which method is through their tax agent or accountant.
- 15:34And if you're running the apportionment method,
- 15:37you don't know what
- 15:38how to minimize your tax if you don't have another method to compare it
- 15:41to, such as a valuation.
- 15:42So depending on how long the person's held the asset and how
- 15:45the asset has performed, if the if the asset's had a lot of growth prior
- 15:50to capital growth prior to that baseline date,
- 15:53the apportionment method with all the examples we've seen is not going
- 15:56to favor them well, subject to how the future plays out with indexation and so on.
- 16:01So a valuation is going to give them legitimately a better tax outcome
- 16:05Sure, but what if on disposal.
- 16:06the market's weaker over the next year like we've just been speaking about?
- 16:10How would Mm.
- 16:11that affect an investor's eventual CGT position if in July next year we're still
- 16:17at the end of this downturn?
- 16:19Love that question, Michael. So this is the challenge, because
- 16:22the valuation can't be undertaken earlier than that date.
- 16:26So whilst we're seeing potential values falling,
- 16:29if you like, whatever the property is worth today may be less on that day,
- 16:33which means your baseline on that day is going to be lower,
- 16:36which effectively could cost you a little bit more tax in the future on disposal,
- 16:40which which would be, you know,
- 16:41a shame for people trying to minimize that.
- 16:43Yes. OK, so I guess what we're saying is your final result will depend upon your initial
- 16:48cost base, how long you've held it,
- 16:50what's happened to inflation and what's happened to the value
- 16:54of your property before July 2027,
- 16:56and then what it'll be when you eventually sell it.
- 16:59And then it depends on the eventual sale price and the marginal tax rate.
- 17:03Boy, there's a lot of moving parts, aren't there?
- 17:06Yeah, Michael, that's been the interesting thing for me to watch.
- 17:09The old system was relatively straightforward
- 17:14and we could all work it out in our own spreadsheets very quickly,
- 17:16what the outcome is going to be based on a couple of assumptions.
- 17:19Whereas the new system is going to be more challenging and we'll need to lean
- 17:23on our tax advisors for help.
- 17:25And I guess one of the things that I would be doing for my own portfolio
- 17:28or for other people that have them is thinking about,
- 17:31as you suggested earlier, so you know,
- 17:33why did you buy the property in the first place?
- 17:35have things shifted in that market?
- 17:36So was there a lot of investors in that market and now they've disappeared?
- 17:40So what does that mean for future demand?
- 17:41is yours a secondary property that might be on a busier road instead
- 17:45of a quieter street? These are the factors that may
- 17:48influence your tax outcome in the future because that's all leading towards
- 17:51the growth or lack thereof after that date.
- 17:54So what's your advice to our viewers and listeners?
- 17:57Should every property investor arrange a formal valuation on the 1st of July,
- 18:022027? I really think it's important that people speak to a number of their advisors.
- 18:07So whether they have financial planners or accountants,
- 18:09understand from them what they suggest people should do.
- 18:13We would suggest that getting a property valuation today,
- 18:17even, is going to give that person an understanding of where their property
- 18:21is at in the market, talking to the valuer.
- 18:24Has anything changed in that community or in that postcode?
- 18:27Any fundamentals around the market?
- 18:28And then when the 1st of July 27 comes,
- 18:31valuation firms can update that number if it's changed,
- 18:35provided the property hasn't changed materially at a fraction of the cost.
- 18:39So people don't need to wait to get the valuation if you like.
- 18:42They could get an assessment now.
- 18:44They could get their inspection done at this point,
- 18:47and we could collect all the data and photos and so on,
- 18:50because you need good records for tax purposes.
- 18:53And then that assessment can be done,
- 18:55you know, the first of July, the first of August,
- 18:57first of September. The further that the valuer or any professional has
- 19:00to go into the future to do that assessment,
- 19:03the more challenging it becomes.
- 19:04So asking someone in the year 2030
- 19:07to undertake a retrospective assessment and say,
- 19:09hey, on that baseline day, what was our property worth?
- 19:12It's harder to get information.
- 19:14Yes. You've got to put your mind back as to what the period was like.
- 19:17And usually when people undertake retrospective assessments,
- 19:20it costs you more, unfortunately,
- 19:23because of the nature of the work is more complex.
- 19:25Okay, so it doesn't actually have to be done on the 1st of July,
- 19:28but you shouldn't leave it too long.
- 19:30And I think the other thing we should remind our viewers and listeners
- 19:34is keep track of any receipts that you've had if you've been doing
- 19:38any renovations or other things.
- 19:41Records disappear, memories fade,
- 19:43conditions of your property can change.
- 19:45So preparation around July 27 could save you a lot of trouble later.
- 19:50Now, again, just to make things clear, for somebody who bought a property before
- 19:55the cutoff date, they're not grandfathered under the capital gains tax rules,
- 20:00are they? They still are going to need this information.
- 20:03That's correct. There's the negative gearing element,
- 20:06which is not what we've been talking about.
- 20:08And under Yes.
- 20:08the CGT they will need to know what that baseline number is as at that date.
- 20:14I know some people are going to be listening to you and saying,
- 20:16he's a valuer. He's telling us we've got to use their services
- 20:20and Opteon services are very valuable and we've used them for a lot of our clients.
- 20:23And I'll leave a link to Opteon in the show notes so you can find out
- 20:27a bit more about their services.
- 20:28But others are going to say, hey,
- 20:31what about those automated valuations online or an online price estimate?
- 20:35Can I maybe go to that? How valuable,
- 20:38how useful are they during these changing markets?
- 20:41Yeah, thanks, Michael. Automated valuations are a useful guide depending
- 20:47on what the market's doing and depending on how generic your property is.
- 20:50So in a market that is shifting around,
- 20:53it requires stable evidence, if you like,
- 20:56because that's how these things work,
- 20:58whether it's a human doing the assessment or the computer.
- 21:01In a market that's moving, or if there's not a lot of evidence that's like for like,
- 21:05it has to make further assumptions about the value.
- 21:08And it can be, we've seen a lot of examples where it can be quite inaccurate.
- 21:12It's certainly a useful tool because it's free.
- 21:14You can jump onto Google and type in your address and get a number.
- 21:17I'd I'd certainly encourage people to do that.
- 21:18But I wouldn't encourage people to make any big decisions based on that.
- 21:21I've seen them being very inaccurate and I know people are saying,
- 21:25they must be smarter now because of AI,
- 21:28but they don't know if you've improved the property,
- 21:32whether you put air conditioning in,
- 21:33if you put new flooring in, they don't recognise if you've
- 21:36got a northerly orientation that some people are prepared to pay more for.
- 21:41So I'd be very cautious of automated valuations,
- 21:44but don't some valuers for some bank requests
- 21:49just do an online valuation and not even go into the property.
- 21:53Terrific question, Michael. So there's effectively three products for an assessment.
- 21:58So we've talked about the AVM and we've talked about the full valuation,
- 22:01which is, you know, a full inspection.
- 22:03And then there's there's a product in the middle,
- 22:05which is referred to as a desktop.
- 22:07And it is what it sounds like.
- 22:08The valuer is still the professional behind the desktop.
- 22:11So they're drawing information from a number of sources.
- 22:14It might be government databases around planning and the like.
- 22:17It'll be online, or we might have valued the property previously, because we've
- 22:21valued millions of properties in Australia.
- 22:22So they're drawing information,
- 22:24might even be confirming information with the occupant of the house.
- 22:27Might be photos. And they're doing a what's called the desktop assessment based
- 22:31on that collective information.
- 22:33So it's still a human in the loop if you like.
- 22:35It they are quite useful.
- 22:37But at times, because of some of the nuances,
- 22:41they don't seem to be as accurate as a full inspection valuation.
- 22:45Okay, well thank you. You've given us a lot of information,
- 22:47but I know there'll still be some people watching,
- 22:50listening to this, being a bit nervous about the property market and
- 22:54the cycle and where we're at and the negative media they keep hearing.
- 22:58Knowing what you know from valuing thousands of properties every week,
- 23:02have you got some advice you'd like to leave our viewers and listeners?
- 23:05Yeah, so I think it's really important that as an owner of a property
- 23:10to remember probably two things.
- 23:11Number one, why did you buy the property in the first place?
- 23:14Was it a place to live for the next 10 years?
- 23:16And are you happy in that location?
- 23:17Because as you've said, Michael,
- 23:19good markets and bad markets come and go.
- 23:21History tells us that that's happened dozens of times in our sector.
- 23:24The second element is this.
- 23:26Please take the time to educate yourself.
- 23:28There's an abundance of information available online today.
- 23:31Heading out to some open homes,
- 23:33speaking to a couple of real estate agents at those open homes,
- 23:36getting a feel for what's happening in the sector.
- 23:38not just, you know, maybe a family relative that might have dabbled
- 23:40in property once or twice. And then of course,
- 23:42engaging professionals such as property valuers or accountants is going
- 23:46to put you in the best position to make an educated decision about your asset.
- 23:51Well, thanks, Scott. I think that's been great conversation and it's helped
- 23:54our viewers and listeners look beyond the property headlines,
- 23:57the figures in the media and understand what values are seeing on the ground.
- 24:01I guess the lesson that you've mentioned is what we keep mentioning that there isn't
- 24:05a single Australian property market.
- 24:07Melbourne, Sydney, Perth, the regional markets,
- 24:10we're all moving at different speeds.
- 24:12And individual suburbs and property types are similarly producing different outcomes.
- 24:17But I think it's really valuable that history lessons that you've shown
- 24:21us that property downturns eventually end.
- 24:24And if you've lived through a number of them,
- 24:26as you and I have, we know that this too shall pass.
- 24:30And when you look back, it isn't as bad as it seemed as you went through them.
- 24:34Now, I know the 2017-19 experience reminded us that sometimes they
- 24:39can last longer than many people expect.
- 24:41But imagine if you bought a property then,
- 24:44now seven, eight years later,
- 24:46in Melbourne, it's probably doubled in value and in some areas even more.
- 24:51So investors should have, I guess,
- 24:53sufficient buffers and the capacity to hold their quality assets through these sort
- 24:58of weaker times. And I guess the other lesson I got from you is that with
- 25:01the approaching capital gains tax changes,
- 25:04if you own an investment property,
- 25:05you really need to speak to your accountant and consider whether
- 25:09you require a professional valuation around
- 25:12that date in July next year. That's not going to tell you whether you've
- 25:15got a good or bad investment. What it is going to tell you is what it's like
- 25:19at the time for the new tax changes.
- 25:21And again, as always, tax should only be one consideration.
- 25:24It's not the strategy. Your decision should really be grounded in
- 25:28the quality of your assets, your financial capacity and your long term plan.
- 25:32Now, if you've enjoyed my chat with Scott and you know somebody else who's
- 25:36interested in property who would benefit from this,
- 25:39Please do us a favour and share this. In every podcast app
- 25:43There's a share button. Please pass this on to somebody else.
- 25:47And if you've got benefit and you actually don't subscribe or follow
- 25:50the Michael Yardney Podcast, click the follow button.
- 25:54The algorithm will then send you our best shows,
- 25:56the ones that get the most views and the most comments.
- 25:59Now, Scott, one of the comments we've been making is don't make rash decisions based
- 26:03on the tax changes. But recently,
- 26:06the government changed the treatment of distributions from trusts.
- 26:11And over the years, we know that governments change.
- 26:14It would be interesting to see if some of these tax changes happen.
- 26:18In fact, I remember way back when negative gearing changes were removed in the 80s,
- 26:24the ability to negatively gear.
- 26:26Two years later, they brought back that again, didn't they?
- 26:29Absolutely. I had to look it up,
- 26:32Michael, but it was in July nineteen eighty-five.
- 26:34We've been talking to people about this in our office.
- 26:37It was the Hawke Keating government.
- 26:39And in September nineteen eighty-seven,
- 26:41because of a number of reasons that they had to bring it back.
- 26:45They effectively abolished negative gearing and brought it back.
- 26:47So we sort of saying to people that when you're thinking about your investment,
- 26:51make sure you number one, you're having a long-term lens, but number two
- 26:54We never know what might happen in the future and that could impact
- 26:57the market very quickly.
- 26:59Well, again, have long-term perspective and don't make your investment decisions
- 27:03based on tax alone.
- 27:05Well said. Scott, thank you very much for your time.
- 27:08Some interesting times ahead for us.
- 27:10Absolutely. Thank you very much,
- 27:12Michael. More than 20 years ago, I wrote the first edition of my best selling book,
- 27:21How to Grow Multi-Million Dollar Property Portfolio in Your Spare Time.
- 27:24And since then I've updated it several times as our property markets,
- 27:28the finance systems, and the tax rules evolved.
- 27:30But this time I had no choice but to bring out a new edition because
- 27:34the 2026 federal budget changes made some fundamentals that serious property
- 27:39investors have relied on in the past not be as relevant.
- 27:42So this new edition's got
- 27:44new chapters, updated numbers, a straight assessment of what these changes mean
- 27:48if you're thinking about buying,
- 27:49holding or selling property. And to explain it all,
- 27:52I'm holding a series of seminars in Brisbane,
- 27:55Sydney, and Melbourne where I'm going to unpack the changes,
- 27:58discuss the opportunities that still exist,
- 28:00and answer your questions. So when you purchase a copy of my new book,
- 28:04your seminar admission is included for free.
- 28:07Now I haven't done anything like this for years,
- 28:09and I don't plan to again
- 28:11And we've deliberately kept the room small because I want these events to
- 28:15be like a genuine conversation.
- 28:17I want to be able to look you in the eye,
- 28:18hear your questions, and talk openly about what's really happening in property,
- 28:23what the new rules could mean for you.
- 28:24And of course, a small room means limited seats,
- 28:28but I'm going to leave a link in the show notes for you to secure your spot
- 28:32for late October or November. I look forward to discussing these changes
- 28:36in property with you.
- 28:44Each show I like leaving you a trivia question,
- 28:46which gives you a chance of winning one of three books that I give away each week,
- 28:51and everyone who answers gets a report.
- 28:53And based on my conversation today,
- 28:55my question to you, a true or false question,
- 28:58go to propertytrivia.com.au and leave your answer.
- 29:02True or false. In the last three property downturns in Australia,
- 29:05the average peak to trough fall was more than twenty percent.
- 29:09True or false? propertytrivia.com.au
- 29:12The average fall for the last three big property downturns was more than twenty
- 29:16percent. Hey, it doesn't matter if you listen to the show a bit late,
- 29:19your entry will still count to get a report or a chance to win a free book.
- 29:23And I'll leave that link in the show notes, propertytrivia.com.au.
- 29:38Today I'd like to ask you who had the greatest positive impact on your life?
- 29:42For most people, their parents were the greatest influence on their lives.
- 29:46Certainly, in his Rich Habit study,
- 29:48my good friend Tom Corley found that for millionaires in his study,
- 29:53their parents were the primary success mentors in their life.
- 29:56A whopping 94% of those millionaires said their parents taught them success habits
- 30:01that were critical to later success.
- 30:03Now you probably know Tom and I wrote Rich Habits Poor Habits.
- 30:06That's a great book to read about the mindset of success.
- 30:09Go to richhabitspoorhabits.com and get your own copy.
- 30:12But I guess what I'm saying is that these people were the lucky ones.
- 30:16The reality is that most of us weren't blessed with parents who
- 30:20are focused on raising kids to be successful in life.
- 30:22This is just the sad reality, particularly in poorer households.
- 30:26If, like me, you weren't one of the lucky ones.
- 30:29You were forced to find your own success mentors outside your home.
- 30:33The good news is success mentors are everywhere.
- 30:36They're in your neighbourhood, at work,
- 30:38running local and community based charities in books,
- 30:41and at school, they could even be your parents' friends.
- 30:45For me, my friends' parents, who happened to be my parents' friends,
- 30:49were the greatest influence as I saw how wealthy they were and how they invested
- 30:54in real estate. And also I read books.
- 30:58They had a great positive impact on my early life.
- 31:00I read many books about successful people,
- 31:03as well as self-help
- 31:04books and listened to audio programs.
- 31:06Look, in those days they were tapes.
- 31:08Now that's podcasts and YouTube videos.
- 31:10And then later in life, I paid a lot of mentors.
- 31:13I went to their seminars. I paid for courses.
- 31:16And for the last 20, 30 years,
- 31:19I've been paying for business coaches.
- 31:21They literally taught me what to do what not to do.
- 31:25My question to you is who's had the most positive influence on your life?
- 31:29Was it your parents? Was it books?
- 31:31as it was in my case, or was it somebody else?
- 31:34And I'd like you to just have a think about what lessons and habits
- 31:37did you learn from them that you can share with your siblings,
- 31:42your friends, your family, your children?