Latest / Ego and Other Things / The Most Important Question to Ask Yourself - The Vital Question Series
Transcript
- William: My childhood environment was Oftentimes violent and abusive. both of my parents had very different views on what it meant to be a good person And while they put their opinions to me authoritatively. Not only did they contradict one another, but they weren't always consistent. There was an abundant hypocrisy There was this gap between what we said was good. and right and true and wonderful to live out and how we actually live that kind of life. And that gap existed regardless of the content of what was asserted as good and right and true and wonderful. How can I live a meaningfully good life? This is a question. That almost everybody at some point in their life has tried to answer. This is a question which humanity throughout its history has tried to answer time and time again. It's a question which is not only exclusive to philosophy, but which finds answers in psychology and sociology, in religion, in history, in practically every kind of intellectual or creative domain that we have. An attempt Has been made to answer this question. How can I live a meaningfully good life? And it's no wonder then that this question is difficult. It's no wonder then that this question is not obvious. It doesn't have an obvious answer. In fact, some people would say that it has no single answer to it whatsoever, that it comes down to people's opinions. There are many different opinions about what it means to live. a meaningfully good life Question is full of implications and consequences for. ourselves and for the society around us. There is a difficulty in discerning between what is good versus what is bad, or what is meaningful versus what is purposeful. Are a good life and a meaningful life the same kind of thing? What does I mean? Who am I who goes out and lives the good life? What is the difference between my thoughts on a good and meaningful life and how I can actually practice what I think in the real world. What does it mean in relationship to my society, in relationship to my friends and my family is a life that is meaningfully and good for me, something which kind of I can expect for the people around me or for my society to encourage or promote? Do I have the right to demand that other people live up to my understanding of what is a good and meaningful life? Or is it all subjective? Does it all come down to personal opinion? It even reaches down into more fundamental questions of how can we know anything at all? How can we know the difference between good and bad? By what standards do we use to investigate the world around us? By what standards do we use to investigate ourselves? In fact, What part of this life that we are living is real versus unreal? How do we even determine the difference between reality and fantasy, between imagination and fact? between opinion and truth and what is our relationship to all of these different things? And how do they actually look in real life? And yet I think each and every one of us has to be confronted with this question at some point. At some point, we have to make a decision about how we are going to live, what we are actually going to do, what kinds of beliefs that we are going to ascribe to. And the the standard of thought that we're going to use to investigate these kinds of questions. Because for some people They never think too deeply about these questions at all. Whilst for others, all they do is think about them. And they never actually put their thoughts into action. But everybody at some point has to consider what they're going to do and why. And so I think this is a question which can speak to everybody. I think this is a question which kind of has importance to everybody. It's kind of question which I think that you watching this now have probably thought about at one moment or another in your life. And so part of the reason why I'm going to be talking about this question. in this upcoming series of videos is because I know that it has relevance to the people of this world. I know that it has relevance to many of the individuals out there trying to seek purpose and meaning and goodness and truth and trying to figure out and struggling to figure out what it means to live a good life. But at the same time I want to start this series on this question because this is the question, whether I've understood it explicitly or not, whether it was at the forefront of my brain or not. This is the question that has followed me throughout my philosophical journey, through my questioning of truth, of goodness, of society. through my trying to understand myself and understanding the world around me. Everything has in my life centered on this question of How can I live a meaningfully good life? And in part, what has drove me on to try to answer that question so obsessively for the past 15 years now or so, is that I was never really given a solid answer to this question that I could trust. My childhood environment was Oftentimes violent and abusive. I came from a divorced house where both of my parents had very different views on what it meant to be a good person and what it meant to live that goodness out, what it meant to live a meaningful life, what kinds of activities were meaningful and not. They had very different perspectives on Essentially what it meant to be a human being trying to live life in the world in the best way that we could. And while they put their opinions to me authoritatively. Not only did they contradict one another, but they weren't always consistent. In fact, they were rarely consistent in their actions when it came to applying these kinds of moral standards. There was an abundant hypocrisy that I found not only in my parents, but in my friend group and in myself. And later on, I would see in the wider world. There was this gap between what we said was good. and right and true and wonderful to live out and how we actually live that kind of life. And that gap existed regardless of the content of what was asserted as good and right and true and wonderful. And so from an early age, I didn't have a solid answer. I didn't have a solid answer of what it meant to live a good life, or what it meant to live a meaningful life, or how you actually went about this. I had no models for that. I had no absolute answers. And at the time that was confusing. That was discouraging because I, like everybody else who grows up, wanted to be a good person, wanted to be heroic. wanted to do something meaningful and impactful with my life, wanted to help the people around me. But without answers or assumptions as to what that was or what that looked like, I was forced to try to figure it out on my own. And forced to figure it out not just mentally, not just internally, but forced to figure it out practically, forced to go out and actually experiment and test with the thoughts and the conclusions that I came to in order to see, does this idea actually hold true in the world? Does what I think is helpful to another person actually helpful? Do I think what is meaningful to me actually bring me, does it actually bring me meaning? Do I think what is good actually produce goodness in the world? And so from air a a very early age, as as at very least since the age of 15, I've been on this rather personal journey to answer this question: how can I leave live a meaningfully good life? And that journey has led me into a variety of disciplines, a variety of questions, a variety of concepts, and a variety of experiences. which have formed that. Like I said, it hasn't though much of this thought has been dominated by philosophy and by the study of philosophy. This journey has also been informed by history and by psychology, by sociology, by literature, by religion and theology. By politics and by art. Though this has begun in philosophy, it is so often, in my experience, branched out into practically every intellectual or creative area that could lend a hand to answering this question. How can I live a meaningfully good life? And throughout all of my explorations, that is the question that I kept coming back to again and again. It was that question and the consequences of the answer to that question which has formulated and bridged my exploration of all of these different branches, of all of these different activities. regardless of how diversed or even opposed at times that they seemed. To me, this has become the most important question to answer. Because it is it defines how I live. It defines what I prioritize. It defines what I value. It defines where I put my time. For example, recording this vid this YouTube video right now is an extension of the practice of answering this kind of question. Because part of part of how I view how to live a meaningfully good life is to try to help other people to think independently and come to their own conclusions about this kind of question. Because I know how important it is to have a unifying and oriented answer to this question. I know how important it is for determining what we do with our lives and for the feeling of wholeness, of completion, and of joy and of peace. that comes about in trying to answer this question and live it out. And I'm doing this now because by this point I feel as though I've gotten enough practice with speaking that I can. Do the exploration of this question with you some justice. For a long time, this journey was something that went on internally, or it went on in my personal life, or it went on in journals that I was writing. I did very little verbal articulation, I did very little verbal even debate about this kind of journey or the conclusions that I came to. And so when I began this channel, I My first priority, besides figuring out how to actually record videos, was figuring out how do I actually articulate my thoughts here. What are the major points that I'm really driving at? I had to learn the instrument of articulation so that I could get to the point of being able to share the journey of this question with you and encourage you to come into conversation with me about this kind of question. And so I'm starting this series now, not only because I feel somewhat confident in my ability to articulate this. But because I've also put enough time and thought and effort into the answer to this question. To where though even though the answer is not necessarily final, it does feel in many many respects solid. In many respects it feels as though I know where I stand on this question. And even though I may be wrong, and even though it may be improved, or there may be aspects of it which I haven't understand or haven't seen yet. The answers that I have gotten have been solid and helpful for me in my life. And part of what I want to do is to share those answers with And so a big reason as to why I'm starting this now is because I feel as though I've arrived at a place, both in terms of articulation as well as in terms of the solidity of my opinion, that I can confidently share with you my thoughts and invite you into a conversation about this question. How can I live a meaningfully good life? Keeping all that in mind, I want to emphasize that this series is going to be just that, an attempt of an attempt at conversation. I want to try and keep as close to a conversation as possible. I know that that's sort of difficult when it comes to YouTube videos. I know that I'm the one kind in one sense lecturing about my opinions on this, but I really don't want it to reflect as a lecture. As strongly as I hold some of the conclusions that I'm going to share with you, as strongly as I hold some of the methodologies by which I've reached those conclusions. I recognize that not everybody's going to agree with me and I actually welcome and encourage disagreement and criticism in part because I'm trying to hold this balance between sharing with you what I genuinely think when it comes to the answer to this kind of question. While at the same time trying to model an open, vulnerable, and honest thinking process. It's why these videos are gonna be largely unedited, where I'm simply trying to cut out the silences. And keep the thinking as much off the top of my head and live as I can, reflecting that again, conversational style that you would have with another person. So these videos aren't scripted. These videos are completely off the top of my head in the moment. And that means that some of this content is going to be visibly uncertain or wrong. I might backtrack and have to re answer a question again. I might recognize in the middle of a sentence that that wasn't actually the way to articulate what I was trying to do. I may contradict myself without even recognizing it. And I may even at some points miss the point of what I've been trying to say entirely. part of this is a learning process for myself too. How do I actually share and express these ideas with people in a more solid and coherent way that reflects again that vulnerable, authentic, honest kind of conversation? So this is not going to be a a series of lectures. It's not going to be a series of completely thought out and solid conclusions that I'm just going to feed you and accept you and expect you to believe uncritically. In fact, what I'm going to do is encourage you to think about these questions seriously and to bring your best arguments, either in favor or against, your best criticisms, your best thoughts into this conversation, whether that's in the comments, whether that's in video responses, I want to welcome and invite as much thought, constructive thought as possible on these questions. Not only in order to to benefit myself, because Of course, I want to see the weaknesses of my own thoughts, but also to encourage you to think deeply about these kinds of questions, to think deeply about how you can live a meaningfully good life. Because I believe that the more that we try to answer that question and try to live it out, the better we're going to have of an understanding of what that question means. And and so therefore, the better we're actually going to be able to really live a good. and meaningful life. So this isn't gonna be a lecture, this isn't going to be a very polished kind of structured argument all the time, but at the same time, I'm not going to shy away from the conclusions that I've come to, some of which are controversial, some of which you guys might not agree with, or you might find maybe a little bit shocking. And again, when that when and if that happens, I encourage you to share your thoughts. I encourage you to share your criticisms. I would love to learn and I hope that you can also learn something from me. So with that in mind, you know, the map of what's to come here is relatively uncertain. There are come some key and central concepts that I believe are are central to my own answer to this kind of question. There have been some spots along the the journey in my road where I've really made a kind of turning point in my own thoughts, in my philosophies. And so as I'm going forward, I'm probably going to be Asking some further deeper questions about this main question. The main question of how can I live a meaningfully good life? I'm going to take that main question and break it down into some subsequent questions, like, what does it mean to be good? What is it, what is the difference between goodness and meaning? What is the I in this question? How do we actually know how to approach any of these kinds of things? How do we deal with ambiguity? How do we deal with our relationships with other people? What is the political implications of a question like this? I'm going to be dealing with a variety of questions, further and deeper questions that come out of that central question and trying to answer them as best I can within that video. And perhaps. following that up with further and deeper questions, trying to expand the investigation as far as is possible in as many directions as I can understand. So it may not always look like a direct Premise, premise conclusion kind of presentation. Again, it might reflect something that's closer to a conversation where a conversation tends to go wherever the curiosity leads. And that's what I'm going to be doing here. But I could also use your guys' help. If I post a video and you have some further questions about it, again, put it in the comments. I would love to explore the aspects that the aspects of the questions that people have about whatever topic that I've talked about or whatever questions they have when it comes to the question of how can I live a meaningfully good life. Everything is going to center back and radiate back towards that central question. But each video is going to be diving into a question, a deeper question that comes out of the central question. How can I live a meaningfully good life? I believe that this series as a whole can challenge the way that you think if you let it. If you actively participate with the questions here, if you actively reflect with what is spoken about here, I believe that regardless of whether you agree with me, regardless of whether you think my presentation here of the question is coherent or Or even a good answer, engaging with it critically and bouncing off your own thoughts and ideas off of what is being talked about here is going to be the best way to sharpen your own kinds of thoughts. I like to think that I have some experience with philosophical debates. I like to think that I'm At least generally coherent with my ideas. But regardless, engaging with these videos critically is going to help you. To refine your own thoughts and come to a clear understanding of what you think it means to live a meaningfully good life. And as your own thought process develops An answer to that question it's going to enable you to live a better and better kind of life. It is difficult to do that kind of thinking on our own. It is difficult to test our own conclusions without running into The beliefs and thoughts of other people who differ from our own. But what I have found so often in other kinds of thinkers is a dogmatic presentation of the truth. presentation of their views that does not allow much room for criticism and does not invite the kind of conversation and dialogue that is really necessary to build one's own more true and more good conception. of how one can live a meaningfully good life. Ask yourself before we get into this video series, what is your answer to the question, How can I live a meaningfully good life? And what is that question based on? How do you justify that question to yourself? And more crucially, how do you live that question out in your day-to-day life? My own journey to that question is exactly what I'm going be presenting to you in this series. And so I'd love to hear more of your thoughts. I'd love to hear the conclusions that you've gotten to in answering this question. And so I hope that you'll join me in this conversation and this journey to figuring out the answers to this question In the next video, we're gonna look at the first question that really came to my mind, the question that I really had to answer in order to first get my bearings Which was, what is goodness to begin with? So I hope you join me next time as we dive into that question. And as always, guys, thank you for listening, and I'll talk to you next time.