Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 211. Small Screens, Strong Signals: Mastering Modern Communication
Transcript
- 0:05Matt Abrahams: If you think about your communication over a week or even a day or
- 0:08even an hour, think of how many different types of virtual communication you use,
- 0:14texting, slacking, emails, virtual calls.
- 0:19We need to make sure that we are as efficient and as effective as we can
- 0:23be when we are communicating virtually.
- 0:27I'm Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at Stanford
- 0:30Graduate School of Business.
- 0:32Welcome to Think Fast, talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:37Today I am excited to speak with Andrew Brodsky.
- 0:40Andrew is an expert in workplace technology,
- 0:42communication, and productivity.
- 0:44He teaches and conducts research at the McCombs School of Business
- 0:47at the University of Texas, Austin.
- 0:50His latest book is Ping: The Secrets of Successful Virtual Communication.
- 0:55Welcome, Andrew.
- 0:56Your work is so relevant and of the moment.
- 0:59I appreciate you being here.
- 1:00Andrew Brodsky: Thanks for having me on the show.
- 1:02I've been a long time fan of your work, so I'm really excited getting to talk.
- 1:05Matt Abrahams: Thank you for that.
- 1:06So shall we get started?
- 1:07Andrew Brodsky: Yes, let's go for it.
- 1:09Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 1:10So your latest book, and work, focus on virtual communication.
- 1:14I'm curious what counts as virtual communication for you?
- 1:17Is it just Zoom, Meet, or Teams, or is it something even more than that?
- 1:21Andrew Brodsky: For virtual communication, it's simply defined as anything that
- 1:25involves communicating through some kind of electronic device or computer.
- 1:29So that is, of course, Zoom, Teams, those video calls.
- 1:34But it goes all the way down to text messaging, instant messaging,
- 1:37email, and now phone calls are virtual because they all happen via
- 1:42our smartphones or voiceover IP's.
- 1:45So anything that happens electronically.
- 1:47So basically not face-to-face interactions and not snail mail,
- 1:52where you're writing letters and sending them via the post office.
- 1:55Matt Abrahams: I'm not even sure younger folks know how to
- 1:56do that latter part anymore.
- 1:59When we communicate virtually, we have choices about tools
- 2:03and channels, et cetera.
- 2:05Do you have advice and guidance for which tools are better for
- 2:07which certain communication goals?
- 2:09So do I use a text to let my boss know I'm gonna be late?
- 2:13Do I send an email?
- 2:15What's advice and guidance on these different channels?
- 2:18Andrew Brodsky: I wish I could say that there was just one best mode, although
- 2:22that would make for a very short book.
- 2:23The key general advice here is you wanna think about, what are the core
- 2:29things you're trying to do here, and what mode serves that best?
- 2:33For instance, if we're considering meetings versus email, are
- 2:36you relaying information?
- 2:38Do you want to have a back and forth?
- 2:40Once you get the basics down, you start to think more into the granularity
- 2:44of what you're trying to achieve, interaction, and then the dynamics
- 2:47that are going on in each one.
- 2:49For instance, let's talk about brainstorming.
- 2:52So brainstorming many people think is better in person.
- 2:57We can bounce ideas of each other.
- 2:58We got a nice whiteboard in front of us.
- 3:01But generally, what research shows is that the earlier stages of brainstorming are
- 3:05better done separately and electronically.
- 3:08And the reason is a few fold.
- 3:09When we're sitting in a group, only one person can talk at a time.
- 3:12That's productivity loss right there.
- 3:14If you're all trying to generate twenty ideas, it doesn't really work well in a
- 3:19meeting with ten people because we don't have time to say twenty ideas out loud.
- 3:24If you're all typing them down separately, that is much more productive.
- 3:27When we have a group of people staring at us, we're afraid
- 3:31often of saying something really non-conforming because they'll judge us.
- 3:35But when we're sitting behind our computer typing, that fear, that presence
- 3:39of the other people's less salient.
- 3:41And lastly, when we hear an idea in person during brainstorming, our mind kind of
- 3:46sticks on that idea, and it's hard to come up with divergent thoughts from that.
- 3:51So basically, research shows that early stages of brainstorming, you
- 3:54get more and more novel ideas when you do it separately and virtually.
- 3:59But then later on when you're trying to decide an idea or tweak an idea,
- 4:03that's when you wanna meet as a group, because that's when you have
- 4:07that back and forth, that's when it's good to work off of each other.
- 4:10Matt Abrahams: So what I'm hearing you say is the biggest determinant
- 4:13of which channel you use is what you're trying to accomplish.
- 4:17If you're expecting some back and forth, or you really rely on somebody
- 4:21else's response, maybe the more interactive approaches are better.
- 4:26But if you're really trying to do things like ideate and brainstorm.
- 4:29It might make more sense to do that more isolated where you don't
- 4:33need that real time connection.
- 4:34Andrew Brodsky: Exactly.
- 4:35And those are some key examples of thinking about when one versus
- 4:38another might work better or worse.
- 4:40Matt Abrahams: Yeah, I think so many of us just want to get the message
- 4:42out that we don't really think about the channel and how that channel
- 4:45can impact what we're trying to do.
- 4:47So that's a really key bit of advice.
- 4:49Your new book has the subtitle, The Secrets of Successful
- 4:53Virtual Communication.
- 4:54So I gotta ask, what are some of these secrets?
- 4:57Let us in.
- 4:58Andrew Brodsky: When it comes to books on business or improvement, I really like
- 5:03when there's a framework to organize all this stuff 'cause it helps me remember it.
- 5:06So I think the best answer for this is to think about the framework that
- 5:09I introduced in the book, which is the Ping framework, which should be easy to
- 5:12remember, 'cause the book's titled Ping.
- 5:14The Ping framework stands for, P, perspective taken.
- 5:18And that's the idea that when you're interacting virtually you're
- 5:22often much more self-focused.
- 5:24So whether you're just looking at text on a screen, or even if you're
- 5:27doing video, there's just a little square of the person you're looking
- 5:30at, and it's not the same as when they're standing right in front of you.
- 5:33So we end up looking at things from our own perspective, and we tend to be much
- 5:37more overconfident than we should be about our communication because we're not
- 5:41taking the other person's perspective and realizing that it's different than us.
- 5:44They might read our emotions different.
- 5:46I is initiative, so it's thinking about what is missing from a given
- 5:52mode and how can I edit back in?
- 5:55One of the examples that I often talk about with my students and executives
- 6:00is about when it comes to small talk.
- 6:02So I know it's been a topic on your show previously, but the
- 6:05thing about small talk, many people hate it, for good reason.
- 6:09It takes up time.
- 6:10So it's a productivity waste.
- 6:12But on the other side of that, small talk is useful for building trust.
- 6:16We trust what we know, we trust who we know, and it creates warmth.
- 6:21Research has found that, for instance, in negotiation studies, when they had
- 6:26participants negotiate over text-based communication, there was much less small
- 6:30talk than when there was in person.
- 6:32So what they did is they had some of those participants who are engaging in
- 6:35a text-based negotiation have a quick phone call where they just schmoozed
- 6:40for a few minutes and then they went to text-based communication and negotiate.
- 6:44And those negotiators ended up doing a whole lot better than those who
- 6:47didn't engage in schmoozing beforehand.
- 6:49So taking that initiative just to have a short phone call before some intense
- 6:53interaction can be really useful.
- 6:56Then N, nonverbal, that's the idea that we send a lot of different
- 7:01nonverbal behavior over virtual communication than we do in person,
- 7:04and it's important to be aware of that.
- 7:06Typos can send emotion, time of day can send singles of power.
- 7:11There's a whole bunch of different things that happen virtually
- 7:13that just don't happen in person.
- 7:15And those are really key for making sure that our messages
- 7:18are interpreted as we intend.
- 7:21And then lastly is G, for goals.
- 7:23There's not one best mode.
- 7:25It depends on what your goal is in a situation, for example, cameras
- 7:29on versus cameras off calls.
- 7:31The idea here is people have strong preferences on it.
- 7:34But research shows that it depends what your goal is here.
- 7:37So if your goal is you wanna make a strong impression for someone you don't know,
- 7:41well, you wanna show you're engaged, video on is really good for that.
- 7:46But if you are trying to save energy, if you're trying to focus,
- 7:51video off is better because research has evidence showing Zoom fatigue
- 7:55or video conferencing fatigue.
- 7:57This idea that being on camera is really exhausting 'cause we're staring at
- 8:02ourselves, analyzing nonverbal behavior.
- 8:04And there are all these things that happen when we're not in person that
- 8:07can drain energy from interactions.
- 8:09So if it's a new interaction, maybe videos on or better.
- 8:13But if it is someone you know really well, strong impressions already built,
- 8:17they know you're gonna be engaged, then you might as well turn that video off
- 8:21because it'll help you to save energy.
- 8:23Bringing it all together, the Ping framework P, perspective taking, I,
- 8:27initiative, N, nonverbal, G, goals.
- 8:30Throughout my book, I tie each of the recommendations into
- 8:32that framework to help make it more memorable and more usable.
- 8:36Matt Abrahams: I love a good framework and I love one that I can
- 8:39remember, and Ping is very memorable.
- 8:41You spend in your book a lot of time talking about richness.
- 8:44What does richness mean in the context of communication and why
- 8:48should we be concerned about it?
- 8:50Andrew Brodsky: Richness is this idea about how similar is a mode
- 8:55to face-to-face interactions, and that's generally how it's defined.
- 9:00But you can't think about it as a single dimension.
- 9:03There are different components that make up richness.
- 9:06The two main ones are synchronicity, whether it's real
- 9:11time or not, and cue variety.
- 9:14How similar are the degree of cues or nonverbal behaviors
- 9:18to those that are in person?
- 9:20And just because two modes seem similar in one dimension, doesn't mean they aren't.
- 9:24For instance, email and instant message, both have a
- 9:29similar type of cues available.
- 9:31You can use emoticons, texts, but they different in terms of
- 9:34expected synchronicity, people tend to respond to instant messages
- 9:38quicker, hence instant messages.
- 9:40But the thing is, even small differences on richness have a huge impact on
- 9:46the outcomes of our interactions.
- 9:48Thinking about video calls and in-person interactions, fairly similar,
- 9:53except you can't see the bottom half of the person, which in many video
- 9:57meetings is probably a good thing.
- 9:59What also happens is with video calls, there's a very slight lag due to data
- 10:06transfer speeds over the internet.
- 10:08Whereas in person, there's no lag 'cause you're just talking to each other.
- 10:11Some studies have found that even that slight lag in video calls can make
- 10:16conversations run a little more awkwardly.
- 10:19There can be more silences, we can interrupt each other more because
- 10:23we're both waiting for the other person to finish, or we thought
- 10:25they finished but they didn't.
- 10:27Even these lags in the milliseconds can end up changing the conversational
- 10:31dynamics, and there's a variety of other ways that richness
- 10:35also plays into interactions.
- 10:37As an example, when we're interacting virtually, it can feel awkward to
- 10:42use richer modes of communication.
- 10:45So if you're reaching out to help someone or to reconnect with an old colleague,
- 10:49there's this idea that people would just rather do it via email, and the research
- 10:53shows email just feels less awkward.
- 10:55What authors who studied this found is that richer modes like telephone
- 11:00or video end up being more effective.
- 11:03It builds trust more 'cause it's richer, and then when participants
- 11:07rated it after the fact, they note that it's not actually any more awkward.
- 11:13So we think it's gonna be awkward before the fact to move from email to
- 11:16just calling someone or having a video meeting, but in reality, it works out
- 11:20better and it's not any less awkward.
- 11:22That said, especially in the work context, try and proceed a call
- 11:25with an instant message or email.
- 11:27That way you're not interrupting whatever the other person is doing,
- 11:31so you could still get the benefits of that mode without necessarily having
- 11:34the interruptive effect of forcing them to talk whenever you decide.
- 11:38Matt Abrahams: Thank you for defining richness and for giving some useful
- 11:42examples and insight into what it is and how we can consider using it.
- 11:47I wanna dive deeper into what you just said about alerting people
- 11:51in advance of reaching out.
- 11:53In your Ping model, the nonverbal piece, you've got a lot of ways
- 11:57of looking at nonverbal that I don't think many of us think of.
- 12:00You even use the example of the time of day you set a meeting can
- 12:04be a way of establishing power.
- 12:06Can you share your way of looking at nonverbal
- 12:10communication when we're virtual?
- 12:12Most of us who study nonverbal communication think about what you do
- 12:14with your body and your voice, but there's also the use of time, the use of space.
- 12:19Can you share some of your thoughts on that?
- 12:21Andrew Brodsky: For nonverbal communication, one of the most illustrated
- 12:25examples to think about this is one that Hayley Blunden from American
- 12:29University actually led a research project with me on, and its on email typos.
- 12:35In this set of studies, we've had three findings.
- 12:38First, email typos generally make you look less intelligent.
- 12:43The second finding was that email typos can relay emotion.
- 12:48It's like putting your fist up in the air, where your fist up in the air can make
- 12:52you seem happier or more proud or more excited, but it depends on the context.
- 12:56So in angry emails, typos made you seem angrier and happy emails,
- 13:01they made you seem happier.
- 13:02And then we had a third finding, which was in the context of emotional
- 13:07messages, there was a decreased penalty on intelligence for typos.
- 13:12So put simply, typos make us look less intelligent.
- 13:16But if there's another reason, such as emotion, the other person says,
- 13:20oh, it's because they're emotional.
- 13:22This matches other research.
- 13:23Studies show that having sent from my iPhone in your email signature
- 13:27decreases the penalty of typos 'cause they assume it's sent from your iPhone.
- 13:31Knowing someone's from a different culture reduces the penalty for intelligence
- 13:35for grammar errors because English might not be their first language.
- 13:40So the key kind of theory behind all of this is this idea that
- 13:45in virtual communication there's often missing information.
- 13:49As recipients of it we're searching for reasons for this missing information.
- 13:54Whatever is there, is what we attach it to.
- 13:57It's clear the person was emotional or rushed or whatever else, we
- 14:02use that information to fill in the gaps in our understanding
- 14:04and assume it's because of that.
- 14:06The problem becomes that the person on the recipient side who's making these
- 14:10guesses is often guessing incorrectly.
- 14:13So realizing how other people interpret our messages and making sure we add in
- 14:19extra information to make sure they don't have to fill in those gaps can be one
- 14:23of the most useful things that you did.
- 14:25Matt Abrahams: Wow.
- 14:26That's a lesson in attribution theory, but also in some practical things.
- 14:30You've just totally changed my perspective on something.
- 14:34One of the first things I do when I upgrade my phone is I remove the automatic
- 14:39signature that says, sent from iPhone.
- 14:41Because I felt like that was not useful information.
- 14:45But based on what you've just said, maybe what I should do is change it to say,
- 14:49sent from iPhone while likely rushing, so that everybody who gets one of my
- 14:54typos attributes it to that and not to the fact that I'm not as intelligent.
- 14:58Andrew Brodsky: It depends if your goal there is to typos or not, 'cause that
- 15:01also is sending other information as well.
- 15:04You didn't feel the need to sit down at your computer to email them.
- 15:07Maybe sometimes it's a good signal that you're sending it from the go.
- 15:10Maybe other times that's a bad signal, and that could be seen
- 15:13as a power play potentially.
- 15:14So you do have to be wary of what other information you're sending from that.
- 15:18But with typos, it helps.
- 15:21With other things, it may not.
- 15:22Matt Abrahams: And that's that nonverbal piece I was thinking about.
- 15:25So people are reading into, oh, he just sent me a text.
- 15:30She sent me an email about that.
- 15:33Maybe there's some meaning behind it.
- 15:35Maybe she was more thoughtful than, and so not only do we make choices
- 15:40for ourselves, but we have to think about the impact of the choice of
- 15:43channel, what message is that sending?
- 15:46Andrew, this has been a fantastic conversation.
- 15:49I, I am certainly considering changing a lot of my behaviors
- 15:52based on what we've said.
- 15:54Before we end, I like to ask all my guests three questions.
- 15:57One, I make up for you, and the other two are similar for everyone.
- 15:59Are you up for that?
- 16:00Andrew Brodsky: Yep, definitely.
- 16:01Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 16:02So not everybody has the benefit of actually seeing
- 16:05you as I do as we're speaking.
- 16:07What's your advice and guidance on what we do with what's behind us
- 16:11when we're virtually communicating?
- 16:13Are there some best practices we should follow?
- 16:16Andrew Brodsky: The evidence when it comes to video backgrounds or how you look
- 16:19on video does show that they do matter.
- 16:22Having good lighting, having a good camera, and in terms of what's
- 16:26behind you, so there's been some studies on the virtual backgrounds
- 16:30and they show that having virtual background over bookshelf or plants
- 16:35tend to be seen as most professional.
- 16:37Blurred is somewhere in the middle, and then the novelty ones, an example I
- 16:42used in the study was a walrus on ice, were seen as the least professional.
- 16:45So you wanna use some common sense if you're using a virtual background, but
- 16:49then there's another set of studies about what shows in your actual background.
- 16:54And what they've found is that when there are things that show
- 16:59who you are, so you wanna of course have the professional stuff.
- 17:02So bookshelf is always good.
- 17:04Maybe some plants.
- 17:05So in my case, a picture of my dogs and a couple other little
- 17:09tidbits about me can be useful for creating some social cohesion.
- 17:13An example in the study they had things that showed people were parents, number
- 17:17one dad mug, and they found that for other people who were parents, they
- 17:21felt they could trust that person more.
- 17:23So having those opportunities to potentially have conversations to show a
- 17:27window into who you are, while remaining professional, can be incredibly helpful.
- 17:33Matt Abrahams: So the fact that I have a Lego flower that I made behind me gives
- 17:38some insight into something about me.
- 17:40I'll take that as a positive.
- 17:42The one thing I want to advise people against, and I assume you would agree
- 17:44with this, is you need to be authentic.
- 17:47I can imagine somebody hearing what you just said and said, oh, I'm gonna
- 17:49manipulate by putting a number one dad mug and I don't have any kids.
- 17:53We need to be authentic because just like you mentioned around AI, that
- 17:57if the language you use influences how people see you, if somebody were
- 18:01to find out that you're not telling the truth, that would be a problem.
- 18:04Andrew Brodsky: Exactly.
- 18:05And I have some research to it in virtuality and authenticity, and
- 18:09it's a major factor that drives satisfaction of the other party.
- 18:12So it's not just being authentic what you say or do, but also being seen as
- 18:17choosing the right mode, making sure that you don't have unintentional
- 18:21nonverbal behavior leaking through.
- 18:24When video calls, for instance, people might see that we're trying to be
- 18:27happy for them, but we're actually not, because maybe something happened
- 18:30earlier in our day that's really bad.
- 18:32So authenticity is a topic that is not just relevant for in person, but
- 18:36is incredibly relevant to virtual interactions, especially because
- 18:40the person can't physically see you.
- 18:42So they're making a lot of assessments of authenticity to fill in those gaps.
- 18:47Matt Abrahams: Really, I wanna put an exclamation and point.
- 18:50Authenticity is so important in all communication, and what I'm
- 18:53hearing you say is, in virtual communication it's even more important.
- 18:57Let me ask question number two.
- 18:58I'll be curious to hear your answer.
- 18:59Who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 19:03Andrew Brodsky: I'm guessing there may have been a chance you would've gotten
- 19:05this answer before because he's many peoples, but for me it's Adam Grant.
- 19:10I took his first class that he taught at Wharton.
- 19:14It was just inspirational, the degree to which he motivated students.
- 19:18It was one of the driving factors that drove me to getting a PhD and, and
- 19:21coming into academia was just seeing the impact he had on students and how
- 19:25he was able to just draw everyone into a topic that many people came in thinking
- 19:30wasn't gonna be that interesting.
- 19:32Matt Abrahams: So this notion of your passion and connecting
- 19:36that and, and sharing that and making it relevant to others.
- 19:39Final question.
- 19:40What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 19:47Andrew Brodsky: For a successful communication, I recommend
- 19:50three things that start with pausing and taking a breath.
- 19:55We're overloaded by communication, especially virtual communication.
- 19:59We've got full inboxes.
- 20:01We've got a back-to-back video meetings, and it's so easy to just keep on
- 20:07going and not take a second to pause.
- 20:09And step two is consider if what you're doing is actually the best.
- 20:14We tend to follow this trap of the default bias, which is this idea that
- 20:19we just do whatever we've normally done or what's right in front of us.
- 20:22So if we always have a meeting for X, we continue to have a meeting for X.
- 20:26Or if we have an email for Y, we give an email for Y. Or if the conversation
- 20:30is already happening in email, we don't take the initiative to say, hey,
- 20:34let's switch this to a phone call.
- 20:35I think that'd be more productive.
- 20:37And so actually getting out of that default mindset can be incredibly
- 20:41helpful for improving productivity, your relationships, and your overall wellbeing.
- 20:46'Cause you may find that you decrease your communication load by
- 20:50being thoughtful about what's the most productive mode and when, as
- 20:54opposed to just going with the flow.
- 20:55And lastly, my third ingredient is keep learning.
- 20:59Especially when it comes to technology and communication technology,
- 21:02there's new advances every day.
- 21:04People are changing how they use things.
- 21:06So keeping up with the research, the science, and understanding what are the
- 21:11best strategies for what, how is that changing, can be one of the best things
- 21:14that you can do because communication technology is such a dynamic landscape.
- 21:21Matt Abrahams: I really like those three things.
- 21:22Uh, I'm gonna take them in reverse order, staying up to date, and really
- 21:27challenging yourself to explore and learn the new technology makes a big difference.
- 21:31There are things that, as you said, are getting better all the time.
- 21:34I think about when we all first went to virtual and where we are
- 21:38today, not just in our comfort level with it, but just what we can do.
- 21:42I like to talk about turning habits into choices.
- 21:45Many of us communicate in that default mode and taking the time to make a
- 21:49conscious choice rather than just do what you've always done might make the
- 21:53communication better and your life easier.
- 21:55And then finally, taking a pause.
- 21:58We are often rushing in all of our communication and taking that beat, taking
- 22:02that moment can really make a difference.
- 22:05And if we do it in the presence of others to show that we're listening or
- 22:08to show that we're being thoughtful, it can have an added benefit.
- 22:11Andrew, this has been a great conversation.
- 22:14You shared so many useful tips and helped me, and I hope everybody listening, think
- 22:20a little bit differently about how we show up when we communicate virtually and
- 22:25what tools and channels we choose to use.
- 22:27Thank you so much.
- 22:29Andrew Brodsky: Thanks for having me on.
- 22:29I appreciate it.
- 22:32Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for this episode of
- 22:35Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 22:37To learn more about virtual communication best practices, please
- 22:40listen to episode 53 with Jonathan Levav and episode 31 with me.
- 22:46This episode was produced by Ryan Campos and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 22:50Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 22:52With thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 22:55Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 22:58Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 23:00Also, follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram, and check out FasterSmarter.io for
- 23:05deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.
- 23:10Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 23:13Ask Matt Anythings and much more at FasterSmarter.io/premium.