Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Journey for Margaret (1942): The Changing Perspective of Time
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting on opposite sides of a rather flat,
- 0:35gray, L -shaped couch in my hotel room suite.
- 0:40I apologize for the cramped quarters. Thank you
- 0:44for coming to visit me in such bizarre circumstances.
- 0:48Last week, an extreme, wild, Midwest windstorm
- 0:53blew over a pine tree in my backyard onto a power
- 0:57line, ripping it out of our wall. No one got
- 1:01hurt, but the repair is rather complicated and
- 1:04requires a lot of waiting, so all the bureaucratic
- 1:08details can line up correctly. As such, the insurance
- 1:12company has put us up in a hotel until we have
- 1:15power again. We're all feeling rather displaced,
- 1:19even as life goes on. My husband is working remotely
- 1:23from that hotel desk, I still have to do the
- 1:27laundry just at friends' houses instead of my
- 1:30own, and my kids still have to go to school and
- 1:33their activities every day. This is not a vacation.
- 1:38From our perspective as grown -ups, this is incredibly
- 1:41stressful. The amount of logistics and coordination,
- 1:45an area in which both of us struggle in ordinary
- 1:48times, is staggering. We miss sleeping in our
- 1:52own beds, living in our own house, getting to
- 1:56host you in my attic room. I wonder how my kids
- 2:00perceive this whole event. There is a lot more
- 2:04screen time these days, just to cope with it
- 2:06all. And we're pretty much exclusively eating
- 2:09out. Do they view this as an exciting adventure?
- 2:13Is this just a slight deviation from the norm?
- 2:17Is this a grand tragedy that they'll have to
- 2:20recover from? I don't know. I can't know. At
- 2:26this point, they're not even fully capable of
- 2:28describing their feelings to me. Even a ten -year
- 2:32-old struggles with nuanced descriptions of emotional
- 2:35and psychological reactions. And often, so much
- 2:40of it goes over their heads. I look at my own
- 2:44childhood with that kind of bizarre reimagining,
- 2:47seeing things as I did then and realizing, with
- 2:52adult eyes, how different the stakes were, the
- 2:56horrific tragedies I barely escaped. the genuine
- 2:59traumas I walked off, the minor inconveniences
- 3:03I experienced as great suffering. It's amazing
- 3:08how perspective changes experiences, and how
- 3:12time changes perspective. And this is a regular
- 3:16occurrence when it comes to movies. There's even
- 3:20a bit of an economy for this phenomenon. Does
- 3:23this movie hold up, being the premise for any
- 3:26number of podcasts, YouTube videos, behind -the
- 3:30-scenes TV shows? Hosts and creators will watch
- 3:34a movie from their childhood as an adult and
- 3:37comment on how it hits them differently these
- 3:39days. It's pretty common for the movies you watched
- 3:43on repeat to be absolute garbage. My aunt had
- 3:47recorded a Shirley Temple marathon off of Turner
- 3:50Classic movies spread out among several VHS tapes,
- 3:54and I particularly enjoyed Susanna of the Mounties.
- 3:58It struck my child brain as a thrilling adventure.
- 4:02It strikes adult me with horror at the sheer
- 4:05amount of racism involved. Sometimes you watch
- 4:10a film from your childhood and discover that
- 4:13it's actually a work of art. I had that experience
- 4:17re -watching 1993's The Secret Garden as an adult,
- 4:21and discovering that it was photographed by Roger
- 4:25Deakins, considered to be one of the greatest
- 4:28cinematographers of all time. More often than
- 4:32not, the films from your childhood sit in a liminal
- 4:36space of memory, half -forgotten fragments of
- 4:40bizarre scenes, images misremembered. All generations
- 4:45in which film existed have this experience, though
- 4:49the reasons for the misremembered differ based
- 4:51on technology. I'm sure that the greatest generation
- 4:56held unnamed silent films in their memory, lost
- 5:00because of sheer volume. The silent generation
- 5:03has a special place for film reels and shorts.
- 5:08Boomers and Gen Xers have fragments of TV movies
- 5:12or specials. For millennials, it's bizarrely
- 5:16acquired VHS tapes we watched on repeat, Gen
- 5:21Zers, straight -to -DVD films, and Gen Alpha
- 5:25will fight over a fever dream of streaming exclusive
- 5:28works or YouTube channels. As a kid with older
- 5:33siblings, I have a repository of clips from rented
- 5:37films. I'm sure some of them were acquired with
- 5:41the intent for me to watch them. Others I snuck
- 5:45into partway through or sat in the hallway listening
- 5:48to. As a film hobbyist, I've been able to place
- 5:52most of these works, though only enough to remember
- 5:56that I've seen them, not anything else. There
- 6:00was one film that I was unable to place for about
- 6:0415 years. I remembered an image of a hospital
- 6:08bed and a stuffed toy. and the feeling that something
- 6:12confusing and terribly sad had happened. I remembered
- 6:17a little girl who always carried around a bombshell.
- 6:22There was also a single very clear scene. There
- 6:26were two children, one a girl in a pointed hat,
- 6:30and the other a boy in a pea coat. And they were
- 6:34arguing. I'm the fattiest! No, I'm the fattiest!
- 6:40And for many years, this film remained an enigma.
- 6:45I was researching for a book, a speculative fiction
- 6:49piece heavily inspired by the rise of fascism
- 6:52in Europe, particularly the slow burn threat
- 6:55of war and the rise of resistance movements.
- 6:58I wanted to build a diet of World War II set
- 7:02media so I could put myself in this headspace.
- 7:06I listened to a lot of Glenn Miller, hunted down
- 7:10some Neville Shute novels, and watched films.
- 7:14I watched some well -regarded period pieces,
- 7:17but the best research was tracking down contemporary
- 7:21films. I re -watched Mrs. Miniver and Hitchcock's
- 7:26Foreign Correspondent, and as I was exploring
- 7:29my options, I found a bizarre little entry. Journey
- 7:34for Margaret There, on the poster, was a little
- 7:41girl in a pointed hat. Journey for Margaret is
- 7:46a 1942 film directed by W .S. Van Dyke, adapted
- 7:51from a 1941 memoir by journalist William Lindsay
- 7:56White, an account of how he and his wife adopted
- 7:59an orphan from London. The book was considered
- 8:03a bestseller, and it fit a particular industry
- 8:07mandate in Hollywood at the time. Stories with
- 8:10a propagandist streak, designed to convince American
- 8:14audiences of why joining the fight in Europe
- 8:17was essential. And in its time, Journey for Margaret
- 8:21did just that. It was a surprise hit. The biggest
- 8:26standout was the girl in the title role, Margaret
- 8:30O 'Brien, whose performance of a traumatized
- 8:33child orphaned by the Blitz made her a breakout
- 8:36star. The studio had suspected it might be so,
- 8:41and arranged for O 'Brien, whose given name was
- 8:44Maxine, to have her name changed to further connect
- 8:48her to the film. O 'Brien went on to become a
- 8:52notable child star for MGM. And I think it's
- 8:56her fame that initially gave this film a legacy.
- 9:00Yeah, it was a hit, but it was no Mrs. Miniver,
- 9:04which, if you haven't seen, by the way, wow,
- 9:08that's a watch. So it makes sense that this little
- 9:13piece would fall through the cracks. History
- 9:16sometimes remembers it as a melodrama. It could
- 9:20be labeled as old propaganda and filed away.
- 9:25Except, this film isn't viewed that way. It's
- 9:30hard to track down, but that's because its streaming
- 9:33rights are still valuable. It isn't available
- 9:37right now, but it's part of the Turner Classic
- 9:40Movies catalog, which means that it sometimes
- 9:43gets trotted out on cable and possibly put on
- 9:46HBO Max. It's also shown up on Mubi, which, if
- 9:52you aren't aware, is a streaming service for
- 9:54cinephiles whose boast is curation rather than
- 9:58an algorithm. I've never been interested because
- 10:02the kinds of things picked for it are often heavy
- 10:06or bleak. A lot of good high art films are. And
- 10:11I have to be careful about that kind of media
- 10:13diet. Heavy food can give you indigestion. Heavy
- 10:18movies can affect my mental health. But if Mubi
- 10:22picks a movie, a human who cares about film thought
- 10:26that this one was valuable. This little propagandist
- 10:31-streaked melodrama is an important contribution
- 10:34to the film canon. Why? Here's the thing. The
- 10:41movie might have been made to persuade Americans
- 10:44that supporting England on the European front
- 10:47mattered, but the film is also a piece of journalism,
- 10:51too. William Lindsay White was an American journalist.
- 10:56He was a wartime correspondent for CBS and other
- 11:00news organizations in 1939 and 1940. And in 1941,
- 11:06he reported from London for Reader's Digest.
- 11:09His job was, quite literally, to explain the
- 11:13Blitz to American readers. His book, about his
- 11:17search to adopt an English orphan, is about his
- 11:21meeting three -and -a -half -year -old Margaret,
- 11:23but it is also, very much, about the Blitz, about
- 11:27the situation in London. When the book was published
- 11:31in January 1941, it must be emphasized, the U
- 11:36.S. had not even entered the war. The reason
- 11:39the book made such a good candidate for a wartime
- 11:43film was because it was a piece of journalism
- 11:46about what was happening in London. And as propagandist
- 11:52as the intentions might have been, it was still
- 11:55made in 1942. The London Blitz wrapped up a mere
- 12:01four months after White's book was published.
- 12:04In mid -1942, when this movie was filmed, Things
- 12:09in Europe did not look great. While the Blitz
- 12:12was over, Germany had begun its Russian campaign
- 12:16and had yet to be routed. This film was released
- 12:20during the middle of Stalingrad, when it still
- 12:24looked like Germany might win. So this film is
- 12:29an oddity, a World War II film made when the
- 12:33people involved did not know that victory was
- 12:37certain. And boy, does it show. I want to talk
- 12:42to you about why, and so I'm going to have to
- 12:46run down the plot for you. If this movie does
- 12:49become available on streaming at some point,
- 12:52or if you can track it down through your library,
- 12:55it does have a DVD release, please do. The performances
- 13:00are definitely worth your time. Journey for Margaret
- 13:04is a fictionalized version of White's account,
- 13:07focused on a journalist named John Davis and
- 13:10his wife Nora. They flee France in 1940, heading
- 13:15for safer London as Nora is pregnant. John wants
- 13:20Nora to head back to Connecticut, but she's committed
- 13:23to staying with him, especially as he's lost
- 13:27something of his spark, and his writing shows
- 13:29it. He used to be angry about what was happening
- 13:33in Europe, but as he says, One night, John decides
- 13:44to go out during an air raid to be able to report
- 13:47on the Blitz firsthand, ducking into a doorway
- 13:50as a shell lands on a nearby building. An air
- 13:54warden recruits him to dig out the mother and
- 13:57son sheltering in the cellar. They find the four
- 14:00-year -old boy clutching his toy lamb, his face
- 14:03smeared with his mother's blood. John carries
- 14:07the boy to safety, tucking his lamb into his
- 14:10pocket in the process. He forgets to hand it
- 14:13back. When he returns to his hotel, he discovered
- 14:17that a bomb detonated nearby and his wife was
- 14:21injured. She lost their baby and had some kind
- 14:25of internal injury that required surgery. The
- 14:29Hays Code means the doctors aren't very specific,
- 14:32but it's clear her reproductive organs were involved,
- 14:36as she can no longer have children. They've killed
- 14:40our baby, she tells John while falling asleep
- 14:43from a sedative, an experience she says feels
- 14:47more like dying than sleeping. They've killed
- 14:50all our babies. Several months later, Nora leaves
- 14:56on a rare flight out, heading for the U .S.,
- 14:59drunk and laughing. She's been unable to face
- 15:02what happened to her. John hasn't either. He's
- 15:07completely apathetic to the whole situation.
- 15:10But he still has to be a journalist, and he is
- 15:14reluctantly assigned to write a story on a children's
- 15:17home for blitz orphans suffering from shock.
- 15:20run by child psychologist Trudy Strauss. There
- 15:25he encounters a familiar -looking little boy,
- 15:27bleary -eyed and dazed, hardly speaking. It's
- 15:32Peter, the four -year -old he pulled from the
- 15:35rubble, and John is able to return his stuffed
- 15:38lamb, an act which prompts the boy to become
- 15:41more connected to reality. John is also present
- 15:46when little Margaret is brought in by her foster
- 15:48mother. She's been in several homes, but isn't
- 15:52adjusting well. S -U -L -K -Y, as her foster
- 15:57mother reports. Margaret is steely -eyed and
- 16:01has a tick of rubbing away imaginary tears with
- 16:06the heel of her palm. Ms. Strauss realizes that
- 16:10she has been punished for crying and gives her
- 16:14permission to sob as loudly as she wants. Because
- 16:19of John's connection to both of these kids, he's
- 16:22persuaded to stay for the rest of the day, and
- 16:25both children fight over him, calling him My
- 16:28Mr. Davis. A few nights later, while out covering
- 16:34the air raids, John stumbles on a delirious mother
- 16:37still carrying her dead child, and something
- 16:41wakes up in him. He begins to pray, Oh God, let
- 16:46me stay mad. Give me the wisdom. Give me the
- 16:50strength to stay mad. He grows closer to the
- 16:54children, and when they are brought to potential
- 16:57foster parents, they cling to him instead. John
- 17:01decides to try and adopt them and writes to Nora.
- 17:05Initially, she has a nervous breakdown, but is
- 17:08finally able to face what happened to her and
- 17:11agrees to bring both children to the U .S. John
- 17:16has a rare ticket out of London on a flight,
- 17:18but the limited space means the children can
- 17:21only come if he forgoes his luggage and convinces
- 17:25another passenger to as well. Initially, only
- 17:29Margaret is able to come, to her great anger,
- 17:32but at the last minute, another passenger agrees
- 17:35to let Peter come in place of her luggage. They
- 17:40fly to Lisbon and then sail to the U .S. on a
- 17:42boat, arriving just a few days after Pearl Harbor.
- 17:47Nora joins them as they wait in the bay, and
- 17:50the new family comes together for the first time,
- 17:54just as the lights of New York City are turned
- 17:57off for the blackout. When we tell the story
- 18:03of the Blitz, we do so with assumptions. You
- 18:08know what an air raid siren sounds like. You
- 18:11have an idea of what an air raid shelter looks
- 18:14like. You've seen footage of bombed out cities.
- 18:18You know what war orphans look like. You also
- 18:22know that the Blitz ended. You know that England
- 18:25won. That Germany never crossed the English Channel.
- 18:30None of that is assumed in this film. Early on,
- 18:36John and Nora go down to the air raid shelter
- 18:38for the hotel, only to find that it's full. The
- 18:42camera pans to show guests sleeping in cots,
- 18:46and as the planes whine overhead, one guest covers
- 18:49her ears and begins sobbing. A child recites,
- 18:53Now I lay me down to sleep, and the line, If
- 18:57I should die before I wake, hits a lot harder.
- 19:02I'm convinced that some of the scenes of John
- 19:05out during the air raids used actual news footage.
- 19:09There's a clear cut and change of film quality,
- 19:13and there are real blazes and real ruined buildings
- 19:16in the footage. Some of the footage in the background
- 19:19was clearly a special effect, done on a soundstage,
- 19:23but not all of it. In this way, Journey for Margaret
- 19:28shows us what audiences did not know, what they
- 19:33did not take for granted. It gives us a snapshot
- 19:36of feelings at the time, which, yes, included
- 19:40the hope of children like Margaret having a future
- 19:43if people will fight for them, but also included
- 19:47the psychological realities of war. We have so
- 19:52many words today for what happens in this film.
- 19:56John, at the beginning, is clearly suffering
- 19:58from compassion fatigue. Nora disassociates after
- 20:02her miscarriage. Peter and Margaret have PTSD.
- 20:07One child at the children's home has a flashback,
- 20:10screaming at the top of her lungs as she sees
- 20:13John remembering the man who took her away from
- 20:17her dead mother. The people who made this film
- 20:20understood enough to depict it. But we know so
- 20:24much more now. What happens to minds. What happens
- 20:29to bodies. I picked up none of this as a child.
- 20:36I knew it was sad, but I didn't understand why,
- 20:39or what was happening, or that any of this was
- 20:43real. What I remembered was the little childhood
- 20:47details. Margaret always carries the shell of
- 20:51an incendiary bomb slung over her shoulder. She
- 20:55refuses to part with it. And she and Peter express
- 20:58delight over the bombed out buildings, always
- 21:01looking for a proper bomb. And these are the
- 21:05kind of morbid things that children of the time
- 21:08absolutely incorporated into their everyday lives.
- 21:12And they were vivid to me because they spoke
- 21:15to my childhood perspective. I watched World
- 21:19War II movies with a sense of adventure. The
- 21:23Blitz was the reason the Pevensies had to leave
- 21:25London for a magical house in the country. World
- 21:29War II was why the heroine of Number of the Stars
- 21:32had to do dangerous, exciting things to protect
- 21:35her Jewish best friend. It was the inciting incident
- 21:38in Snow Treasure for the Norwegian children to
- 21:42help smuggle gold bars out to help the war effort,
- 21:45hiding them under their bellies as they sled
- 21:49past Nazi soldiers, burying the gold under snowmen
- 21:54for the resistance to collect later. I read these
- 21:59and watched these with a child's perspective.
- 22:03Just as Margaret and Peter experienced them with
- 22:07a child perspective. I don't know how much of
- 22:12this trauma they carried with them into adulthood.
- 22:15Would Peter remember the bomb falling on his
- 22:19house? Would Margaret remember being abused for
- 22:22crying? Would these realities come out in their
- 22:26lives anyway as confused adolescents? Watching
- 22:31this film as an adult, It's remarkable how John
- 22:35Davis's prayer to stay mad feels relevant, that
- 22:40sorrowful rage can fuel action to care for children
- 22:43in all manner of terrible circumstances, in war,
- 22:48in systemic injustice, in domestic abuse. But
- 22:55it's also remarkable that while championing empathetic
- 22:59rage, It also does so from hope. From this film's
- 23:05perspective, victory was hardly a sure thing.
- 23:09Europe had remained under fascist control for
- 23:12years. Pearl Harbor had brought war to American
- 23:16shores. The lights of New York City had to be
- 23:20turned off. As Nora tells Margaret and Peter,
- 23:25All the lights in all the cities in all the world
- 23:28will have to go out until the war is over. But
- 23:33John, now filled with a reason to care, with
- 23:37two reasons to care very deeply, says that they
- 23:41will come back on again. And even as my life
- 23:46has changed, even as time marches on, these words
- 23:50aren't just a propagandist statement meant to
- 23:53support the war effort, but a reminder that one
- 23:57day the traumas and the sufferings will be behind
- 24:01us, and we will look on them with new understanding,
- 24:05new realities of the stories we have lived through.
- 24:10Do you promise? demands Margaret. Will I see?
- 24:16Yes, Margaret. You'll see. Thanks for coming.