Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / The Midterms and What Comes Next
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Engineering Influence Podcast from the American Council of Engineering
- 0:03Companies, coming to you from our 2026 fall conference in Phoenix, Arizona.
- 0:08At the time of this recording, we're going to be days away from the 2026 midterm
- 0:13elections. That's where the attention of the country and the world is right
- 0:17now, because we're looking at if the odds makers are correct,
- 0:21at least a divided government.
- 0:23Prevailing wisdom right now is that the House will flip. The question is going
- 0:27to be the margin with the Democrats most likely taking control and the Senate
- 0:31is still really a toss up.
- 0:34But no matter how we look at it, it's going to be pretty tight.
- 0:38And that's going to define what happens in the 120th Congress.
- 0:42And I'm very privileged to be joined by two people who know this in and out.
- 0:48The first ambassador, former Senator Jeff Flake from the great state of Arizona.
- 0:54Thanks for coming here to Arizona.
- 0:55Thank you for having us. It's been great. I think that, you know,
- 0:59everyone here has loved it. And it's just, it's great to be here this week.
- 1:04And Bruce Melman, he is the founder of Melman Consulting. He was also undersecretary
- 1:08of commerce for science and technology under President Bush.
- 1:14President W. Bush, George W. Bush.
- 1:17Two astute political observers and to talk about kind of what lies ahead and what could happen.
- 1:23Thank you very much for a great presentation this morning. I think you put some
- 1:26great perspective, Ambassador, on kind of just your approach to government.
- 1:32And Bruce, of course, you know, how you view the last two years of the Trump
- 1:37administration, what could happen.
- 1:39We are so close to the election. I mean, you know, you agree with where things
- 1:43are pretty much laying right now, where you've got a house aspired on a flip
- 1:48and the Senate is just, you know, a question mark?
- 1:53Yeah, I agree with the Convention of Wisdom. The House is certainly going to
- 1:57flip. Pendulums do swing. This one's swinging with a bit of a vengeance.
- 2:02I never would have thought until a few weeks ago that this map could produce
- 2:07a victory in the Senate, a majority in the Senate.
- 2:11But it truly is a toss-it. And that just speaks to how unpopular these policies
- 2:16right now are and how unpopular the president is.
- 2:20So it's something I thought I wouldn't see, but I wouldn't be surprised now
- 2:24if Democrats do take the Senate.
- 2:26I agree. When all the conventional metrics that you take a look at, whether it's.
- 2:32Polling or even the prediction markets or where they're deploying surrogates,
- 2:36where they're spending and not spending.
- 2:38It all really looks like 2006 when voters were unhappy about the Iraq war as opposed to the Iran war.
- 2:45The economy was a little bit stronger back then, but there was a similarly low
- 2:49presidential approval.
- 2:51The only thing I wonder about, and I'm interested in your take on this ambassador
- 2:54is it's 20 years since then.
- 2:56States have gotten even more calcified.
- 3:00And so all of the numbers tell you it's going to be 52 to 55 Democrats in the
- 3:06Senate, but there's that back of the brain that says South Carolina is not going to flip.
- 3:11Kansas is not going to flip. Nebraska is not going to flip. It's just at this
- 3:14point in the same way in 2018, Trump loses the House with negative 41 seats,
- 3:19and he goes plus two. Republicans go plus two in the Senate. Yeah.
- 3:24And I am interested in what is your read on that situation? I mean,
- 3:27do you feel the same way or?
- 3:29Yeah, well, that's been my initial approach to the Senate, just looking at the
- 3:33map. I think, how in the world? Obviously, Texas, that's been the white whale
- 3:36for Democrats for decades.
- 3:39Lloyd Benson, yeah. There you go.
- 3:42So that's just tough to see still, but I don't think anybody accounted for these
- 3:48type of candidates. Yeah.
- 3:50I mean, if you're thinking you might have a problem in Texas,
- 3:53certainly don't put up a Ken Paxton, someone that carries the kind of baggage that he carries. Yeah.
- 3:59And then the farm states are just hit with everything. First,
- 4:03it was the tariffs that, you know, limit their markets. And then you have diesel
- 4:08and fertilizer prices. That's just a double whammy.
- 4:12And then the president going around really not helping issues.
- 4:16It's kind of a vanity tour himself.
- 4:20But I don't know that he helps anybody when he says that, you know,
- 4:23These prices are people are getting rich, and we ought to be grateful that the
- 4:27oil companies are getting rich. So, yeah.
- 4:32I never would have thought we'd be here right now. Yeah, our chair kicked off
- 4:36the session talking about how a divided Congress could be seen as a situation
- 4:42for gridlock, and our industry should look at it as an opportunity because it,
- 4:46provides leverage on issues that generally are bipartisan.
- 4:49And normally infrastructure is bipartisan in principle.
- 4:53You get into technicalities when you start talking about formula,
- 4:56when you talk about the technicalities and spending.
- 5:02What comes next here? I look at this and say,
- 5:07are we going to find ourselves in the same kind of situation where if the majorities
- 5:10do switch, that there's going to be the opportunity to say, okay,
- 5:14let's actually put together a legislative agenda from the Democrat side of Speaker Jeffries.
- 5:19I would imagine whoever would be the Senate majority leader at the time.
- 5:22I'm not sure if that would be still Schumer. That would be an interesting question.
- 5:27But to put together an agenda that moves forward, or are they going to go back
- 5:32and say, okay, now it's a retribution tour. We're going to start investigating.
- 5:35We're going to start impeachment. We're going to go and play to the political edges.
- 5:42Do we see an opportunity for things happening or is it just going to become
- 5:45gridlock because it's going to be investigations galore?
- 5:48Bruce, start with you and Ambassador. I like to defer.
- 5:52I would have deferred given my respect for you, but the fact that you were knighted
- 5:56by the Swedish government, I always defer to Swedish knights or fish.
- 6:04Both things can be true. Yeah. There is 0% chance they're not going to be very
- 6:08aggressive in oversight. First of all, because that's a job of Congress. Yes. To do.
- 6:12There is, well, it's more target rich. Mm-hmm. There are more things meriting
- 6:17investigation, but they've seen less investigation. Yes. So even objectively,
- 6:21forgetting you're playing to the base, you're playing to the edge,
- 6:24you know, Article 1's converse. Yeah.
- 6:26They are supposed to have responsibility. They're supposed to take a look at what's happening.
- 6:32Whether those investigations can be remotely bipartisan, I don't know.
- 6:36The fact that the January 6th commission couldn't tells me we're,
- 6:40at least right now, at such a hyper-partisan environment, there is no such thing
- 6:45as the Watergate-era collective oversight, where people want to get to the truth
- 6:50wherever the chips fall.
- 6:52That said, they're going to have to get things done.
- 6:56You can't simply say, well, we just won't fund the government for two years.
- 7:00We'll ignore the debt ceiling.
- 7:02And that's going to force some compromise. But in a climate of nasty oversight,
- 7:07the ambassador talked about Trump, art of the deal guy.
- 7:10You can cut deals with him, but I think he'll cut a deal with anybody who will agree that he won.
- 7:15And I think for the Democrats, they can cut any deal except one that is perceived
- 7:19that Trump won. That's why I- That's where the conflict, that's the conflict.
- 7:22But interesting, it's not about the substance of the deal. It's about how the
- 7:25deal reads in the media. It's the framing and how, I think on both ends,
- 7:29it's what the deal is and how it's framed. And then also, how is the Article
- 7:34I responsibility framed?
- 7:35And that's the big open question. Ambassador, how do you feel?
- 7:39Yeah, I think it's less somebody think, well, if you have divided government,
- 7:42that just negates any possibility to pass legislation because one party can't pass them through.
- 7:48But if you look at what we've had, you know, the House majority for Republicans
- 7:53has been, you know, one or two seats, depending on which month we were in the
- 7:57past year, with some pretty extreme Republicans holding the keys there.
- 8:03And then in the Senate, obviously, you have filibuster, great filibuster still,
- 8:07that forces kind of compromise there.
- 8:10So it's not that the divided government that produces the gridlock so much as.
- 8:17What might happen with investigations and how the president responds to that
- 8:21and whether there's going to be people pushing for impeachment and that kind
- 8:26of environment can make it less likely.
- 8:27But divided government itself, we've seen a lot of important legislation happen
- 8:32with divided government.
- 8:33I particularly like it as a fiscal conservative because Republicans typically
- 8:38only act like fiscal conservative Republicans when there's somebody else wanting to spend the money. Yes.
- 8:44If we're in control of everything, then we'll spend it. Yeah,
- 8:47exactly. Interestingly, the Senate, by its very rules, is kind of permanent divided government.
- 8:52The filibuster more or less guarantees that. Right, yes. Yes.
- 8:56And also, I think that there's been a, I mean, this is my, I'll put on my own
- 9:00personal view, is that to an extent, and this is not something new,
- 9:04but it's been happening over time, is that Congress has kind of ceded its authority to the executive.
- 9:09Amen. And too much the executive shall or the secretary shall and not so much you will do this.
- 9:16And you think there's an opportunity for the chamber to stand back up and say
- 9:22that we are constitutionally enabled to do this and we will take that authority
- 9:26back. Is that something that's possible in this environment?
- 9:30Ambassador, is that something you would love? I would love nothing more.
- 9:32That's what's been frustrating. I mean, our system of government,
- 9:36if you have an executive presidency, a strong president, its power is going
- 9:40to drift toward the president, but away from Congress, just as a matter of course.
- 9:44What's been frustrating is to see Congress, in particular the Senate,
- 9:48which has always jealously guarded its prerogatives, just willingly cede that
- 9:53on issues like tariffs and issues like war powers.
- 9:57And that's what's been really frustrating. And I don't see that,
- 10:02that changing that much in the next two years at least, because you're still
- 10:07going to have, I mean, if it's divided government, you have Republicans,
- 10:10you're still going to have,
- 10:11not enough to override a presidential veto.
- 10:15So, yeah, and Congress has simply become used to not taking the blame on war powers, for example.
- 10:24Congress would rather simply pass off that authority to the president and then
- 10:29not have to be accountable if it blows up like it has in Iran now.
- 10:34And so that's part of not just willingly ceded authority, but it's laziness
- 10:40and Congress thinking, well, let's just escape the blame.
- 10:43I'll agree with all of that. Maybe three nuances on it. You know, first.
- 10:48The world's bigger and has more challenges and Congress is not,
- 10:52Congress was designed by smart guys in the late 1700s to not do too much.
- 10:59And so an interesting post-World War II environmental challenge is we need a
- 11:05lot more muscular chief executive than Hamilton and Madison perhaps thought
- 11:10was prudent in the day. That's one. Two. Yeah.
- 11:13A lot of the questions of has the executive exceeded his constitutional authority
- 11:18have been decided by the current Supreme Court in favor of a much more powerful unitary executive.
- 11:24So a lot of folks in Congress might say, we passed laws that say they can't do it.
- 11:30We passed a law that said we want a bipartisan federal trade commission.
- 11:34And this president, not any prior president, said, I'm going to fire the Democrats.
- 11:38And the Supreme Court said, okie doke.
- 11:40Like so they're going to have to figure out in this tougher environment how
- 11:45to change these sort of things and then finally i i do think just like you and
- 11:49i were talking about in our respective appearances and on the panel,
- 11:53we need some systemic reforms and how we do politics because the incentives
- 11:57are aligned in favor of people who are more performative and less productive
- 12:02yes and that's unhealthy but we similarly need
- 12:05probably some operational reforms so that for example, if something passes the
- 12:09House with 417 votes, like the taxpayer, the ratepayer protection.
- 12:14That the Senate can't just decide we're going to, you know, 53 people want this,
- 12:19but it's not even going to get to the floor because of the filibuster.
- 12:22There are probably reforms in how Congress operates that would make them less
- 12:27likely to punt because of their inability to do a lot.
- 12:30Let me just say on that last question, Congress's role, foreign affairs.
- 12:34One thing that is encouraging obviously is Congress's passage of the,
- 12:39you know, the Lindsey Graham Act with the Russia sanctions, 86 to 11.
- 12:44That to me, if there's a proxy for that old bipartisan consensus on foreign
- 12:49policy that we used to have, that's it.
- 12:53And I, like I said, I don't.
- 12:56There are limits to what they can do to challenge the president now,
- 12:58but it gives me hope that beyond this presidency, beyond this administration,
- 13:03that Congress will kind of reassert that role.
- 13:07Now, I tell my former colleagues, having served overseas, you have no idea how
- 13:13many heads of state listen to what you say as a senator, in particular the Senate,
- 13:17because they know you have a six-year term.
- 13:19They know you outlast any administration. You're usually there for a couple of terms.
- 13:23So you go way further. And so that matters to them. What you say about NATO
- 13:30alliance or trade rules or preferences, I mean, that matters to them.
- 13:35So the problem is we just haven't had many in the Senate.
- 13:39We've lost John McCain, now Lindsey Graham, Dick Lugar, and others who were
- 13:44really first in foreign policy.
- 13:46We just don't have that many now. But those who are there need to speak up more.
- 13:50And I was going to say, that's two things that you brought up in your presentations.
- 13:55Number one, and I think that as an aside...
- 14:00For a lot of people out there, the American experiment is the experiment.
- 14:05We're still in it. It hasn't been solved.
- 14:07So this back and forth testing of who has more power and how that works out
- 14:16is still being negotiated and how you vote always will impact that.
- 14:21And then the question becomes also the voices that are in the room and to your
- 14:27point, candidate selection, you know, exactly who are we actually putting up for office in.
- 14:33In, in kind of litigating all these questions, you know, who are in your minds,
- 14:38the voices that are probably going to be,
- 14:41the most listened to, not so much the loudest, but maybe the most listened to
- 14:46in the next Congress to help address some of these questions.
- 14:50Where a divided government forces some negotiation and forces someone to come
- 14:55out and try to broach the middle round.
- 14:58And who would that be in the 120th? Does anyone come to mind?
- 15:03I want to hear Bruce on this. You know, it's ironic. The people likeliest to
- 15:08look to operate in the middle, to forge bipartisan compromise,
- 15:13are usually people in the purplest districts. Yeah.
- 15:16And the people in the purplest districts are the most aggressively targeted by the other part.
- 15:22So the great irony is, for example, Democrats are spending a crazy amount of
- 15:26money to try to defeat Susan Collins in Maine.
- 15:28Susan Collins in Maine is the ultimate example of the Republican that every
- 15:34Democrat wishes the rest of the Republicans were like.
- 15:37That's the nature of the system that we've got. It's why we tend to talk about
- 15:41the need for systemic reforms.
- 15:43You know, on the point a moment ago that, you know, you were talking about as well,
- 15:47In the thing that I publish every week, a couple of months ago,
- 15:51I suggested that at least as I look at the tug of war, and it is forever.
- 15:59It is baked into the system to be permanent.
- 16:01The tug of war between Article I, Article II, Congress, and the executive branch,
- 16:05it's been a bit of a sine wave.
- 16:07There are times when you've seen Gulf of Tonkin, you've seen presidents exert
- 16:12more authority, and then Watergate Congress, you've seen some of that taken back.
- 16:17What's probably true, because I'm a visual thinker, is while it has gone up and down, it has done so,
- 16:25on a rising curve where each peak of presidential power is greater than the
- 16:30prior peaks before it, even though it will be, and I'm confident you will see,
- 16:36some of the power taken back by institutionalists.
- 16:39And there are institutionalists up there. That's who you were,
- 16:41and that's always your friends.
- 16:43There are. And I think in this new Congress, if Democrats do take the Senate,
- 16:48an area that I have an interest in foreign policy, Chris Coons will be chairman
- 16:53of the Foreign Relations Committee.
- 16:54And Chris is, he's probably the last one that ever, you know,
- 16:59the old Senate tradition of caring,
- 17:01where if some senator had to be necessarily absent for a funeral or whatever,
- 17:06somebody from the opposite party or the other side of an argument on a particular
- 17:09bill would vote as they would have so as not to upset the balance. Mm-hmm.
- 17:15The last time that happened is Chris Coons doing that for Johnny Isakson on
- 17:19the Mike Pompeo nomination, 2018, where somebody, an institutionalist,
- 17:25came out and said, you know, I know I may get,
- 17:28blasted by my constituents for this, but I'm going to vote as Johnny would have.
- 17:33And I still remember Bob Corker, the chairman of that committee,
- 17:36actually crying when he talked to the media, saying, I haven't seen that happen for years.
- 17:40But there are some institutions still there and some who will do it just because
- 17:44it's the right thing to do. Yeah. And they want the Senate to work. Yeah.
- 17:48I'm just hoping that we can get back. I mean, you know, I still remember when
- 17:52Chairman Schuster had his portrait unveiling, you know, one person and,
- 17:56you know, Bill Schuster was a conservative.
- 17:58You know, he was always rated in the 90s on all the surveys of all the groups of care.
- 18:05But the one person who made sure damn sure he was going to be there was Steny Hoyer. Right.
- 18:09Right. Because even though he was a conservative, he still knew how to work
- 18:13on the other side of the aisle and bridge and make compromise and understand
- 18:17that if you get, you know, 40 percent or 30 percent of what you wanted to get, that's a victory.
- 18:23And and and and I hope that we can have that in the next Congress.
- 18:26And it's not to your point that you made in your, in, in your presentation,
- 18:31the fact that, you know, the social media echo chamber, everybody's called in,
- 18:37and having that kind of wag the dog because, you know.
- 18:41Yeah, to your point, Bruce, when you said, you know, do you trust healthcare
- 18:45or do you trust your doctor?
- 18:46Do you trust, you know, the big media or my local paper? Everybody's going to
- 18:50say, I trust my local doctor, my paper, my member of Congress is great,
- 18:53but the bums in Congress got to go, you know. Can we get back to,
- 19:01that ability to just not be seen as evil for looking for compromise?
- 19:09Well, I think one, true leadership, somebody who will step out and just do it
- 19:14because it's the right thing to do and not see the other side as the enemy. Yeah. It's evil.
- 19:19And then two, some institutional reforms on how we nominate,
- 19:23you know, candidates for both parties.
- 19:27And those have to happen at the state level. And they're very difficult because,
- 19:31the parties don't want them.
- 19:33Yeah. The organizations, party structures don't want them. So,
- 19:36but those are two things that I think kind of have to happen. Yeah.
- 19:39Yeah. Agreeing and amplifying on that. It's, it's the political forms are necessary.
- 19:43I'm not sure totally sufficient.
- 19:46You also need economic reforms. You need social reforms. The good news is if
- 19:50you nerd on American history, we've been here.
- 19:53Yes. This is America in the Gilded Age, where back then we were operating with
- 19:57a 19th century operating system in a increasingly 20th century emerging world.
- 20:03There were economic reforms like.
- 20:05Progressive income taxation, professionalizing the government,
- 20:08banning corporate and union contributions. They couldn't set their own rules.
- 20:12Antitrust. Antitrust got invented. Yeah. And then you had, it's hard to pass a law.
- 20:18It's really hard to amend the Constitution. They did it for direct election
- 20:22senators for women's suffrage.
- 20:24And I know of great importance to the ACEC. Back then, students were done in eighth grade. Yeah.
- 20:30And they were getting prepared for the agrarian economy that was way in the rearview mirror.
- 20:35And the recognition that it started, just like Jeff was saying,
- 20:38it started locally in the Northeast and the Midwest was we need to keep them
- 20:41in school, 9th through 12th, paid for by taxpayers, learning skills for this
- 20:46new industrial era that's rising.
- 20:48At the time, it was decried as socialism.
- 20:53Now we call it high school. Yeah. Rather than killing American capitalism,
- 20:56it's why American capitalism defeated the fascists as the arsenal of democracy
- 21:01and out-competed the communists in the second half of the 20th century.
- 21:05We're at another one of those pivot moments where we've got 20th century rules
- 21:09and 21st century problems.
- 21:11It's going to take economic, social, political reforms.
- 21:15Can America do it? We always have before. Never been easy. When you read about
- 21:19it, it sucked if you threw it.
- 21:21But we now look back quite fondly. We got stronger. we got better,
- 21:25we got fairer, I think we will again.
- 21:28Basser, do you agree? No, I don't think I can end it. I know,
- 21:31that was pretty good to me.
- 21:34Well, let me ask the question that I always have to ask, because you said at
- 21:38the top of your presentation, the draft, Jeff Flake in 28.
- 21:42So is elected office in your future? Are you looking to get back in the game?
- 21:47Elected office, I have a hard time seeing that. I mean, I did 18 years in elected
- 21:52office. that's probably done. But,
- 21:56Public service, still in the future. Secretary of State doesn't have to be elected.
- 22:03Well, I thank you both for taking the time of a consequential election.
- 22:07Yeah, we've been here before. And then, you know, we'll make it through again.
- 22:12I think it just takes voices to calm the storm and forge some compromise and
- 22:18leadership. So we'll see what happens in a couple of days. Thank you very much,
- 22:24Ambassador Flake, Bruce Bellman.
- 22:26Thank you very much for joining us. And again, this has been Engineering Influence
- 22:29Podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies. We'll see you next time. Thanks, Jeff.