Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Kentucky's Constitutional Amendment on School Choice
Transcript
- 0:00♪
- 0:02[♪♪]
- 0:11Good evening. Welcome to
- 0:12Kentucky Tonight. I'm Renee
- 0:13Shaw. Thanks for joining us. Our
- 0:15topic tonight: school choice.
- 0:18It could be the most
- 0:20talked-about item on the ballot
- 0:22this November: amendment two,
- 0:23the so-called school choice
- 0:23amendment.
- 0:35(FULL SCREEN)
- 0:36IF PASSED, THE AMENDMENT WOULD
- 0:37ADD LANGUAGE TO THE KENTUCKY
- 0:38CONSTITUTION STATING, IN PART•.
- 0:39QUOTE•. “THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 0:39MAY PROVIDE FINANCIAL SUPPORT
- 0:40FOR THE EDUCATION OF STUDENTS
- 0:41OUTSIDE THE SYSTEM OF COMMON
- 0:41SCHOOLS.” UNQUOTE.
- 0:42THE PHRASE “COMMON SCHOOLS”
- 0:43REFERS TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 0:45SUPPORTERS SAY THE AMENDMENT, IF
- 0:47PASSED, WOULD MEAN MORE
- 0:47EDUCATION OPTIONS FOR PARENTS.
- 0:48CRITICS SAY IT WOULD DRAIN MONEY
- 0:50FROM ALREADY-UNDERFUNDED PUBLIC
- 0:52SCHOOLS. INSTEAD OF A BATTLE
- 0:53BETWEEN LEFT AND RIGHT, SOME SAY
- 0:54THIS IS SHAPING UP AS A BATTLE
- 0:56BETWEEN URBAN AND RURAL
- 0:59KENTUCKY.
- 1:00TO DISCUSS IT ALL, WE ARE
- 1:01JOINED, IN OUR LEXINGTON STUDIO,
- 1:04BY: JOEL WOLFORD, VICE PRESIDENT
- 1:05OF THE KENTUCKY EDUCATION
- 1:07ASSOCIATION;
- 1:07JIM WATERS, PRESIDENT OF
- 1:10BLUEGRASS INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC
- 1:11POLICY SOLUTIONS; CHAD MEREDITH,
- 1:13ATTORNEY AND FORMER KENTUCKY
- 1:15SOLICITOR GENERAL; AND JASON
- 1:16BAILEY, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
- 1:18THE KENTUCKY CENTER FOR ECONOMIC
- 1:18POLICY.
- 1:21WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU. YOU
- 1:23CAN SEND YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:24COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 1:27-- AT K-Y TONIGHT K-E-T. SEND AN
- 1:29EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT K-E-T
- 1:30DOT O-R-G. OR USE THE WEB FORM
- 1:33AT K-E-T DOT O-R-G SLASH K-Y
- 1:34TONIGHT. OR YOU CAN CALL
- 1:371-800-494-7605. WELCOME TO OUR
- 1:43GUESTS.
- 1:47>> I WANT TO BEGIN WITH YOU
- 1:49Mr. MEREDITH TO TALK ABOUT THE
- 1:51LANGUAGE OF THE AMENDMENT.
- 1:52THIS HAS BEEN A LONG CONTESTED
- 1:54BATTLE IN THE STATE HOUSE THIS
- 1:56PAST SESSION.
- 1:57OVER THIS BALLOT QUESTION.
- 1:58TELL US WHAT IT WILL EMPOWER THE
- 2:02GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO DO IF THE
- 2:03VOTERS DO RATIFY IT.
- 2:04>> SURE, THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME
- 2:07TODAY.
- 2:07JOEL, JIM, JASON THANK YOU FOR
- 2:09BEING HERE.
- 2:10THIS IS JUST OF SUCH 'IMPORTANT
- 2:13SHOW, THE J'S AND THE C'S.
- 2:15THIS IS A WONDERFUL SHOW IT'S
- 2:17VERY IMPORTANT FOR PUBLIC
- 2:18DISCOURSE IN KENTUCKY AND I'M
- 2:21GLAD WE CAN BE HERE TO DISCUSS
- 2:22SUCH AN IMPORTANT TOPIC.
- 2:24WHAT DOES THE AMENDMENT DO?
- 2:26IT DOES ONE SIMPLE AND IMPORTANT
- 2:28THINGS.
- 2:29AND THAT IS IT GIVES THE PEOPLE
- 2:32OF KENTUCKY THROUGH THEIR
- 2:33ELECTED LEGISLATORS THE RIGHT TO
- 2:36SET EDUCATION POLICY FOR THEM AS
- 2:39OPPOSED HAVING IT DETERMINED BY
- 2:41PEOPLE IN THE 1800'S.
- 2:42WHAT I MEAN IS THIS...
- 2:44THE EDUCATION PROVISIONS IN OUR
- 2:45CONSTITUTION WERE WRITTEN IN
- 2:471891.
- 2:48AND THEY ADDRESSED PARTICULAR
- 2:50CIRCUMSTANCES THAT EXISTED AT
- 2:51THAT TIME.
- 2:54AND THOSE THE CHOICES THEY MADE
- 2:56THEN MAY OR MAY NOT HAVE BEEN
- 2:57RIGHT FOR THEM AT THAT POINT BUT
- 2:59THEY STILL BIND US TODAY.
- 3:01AND THOSE CHOICES IN LARGE
- 3:03MEASURE PUT HANDCUFFS ON OUR
- 3:05LEGISLATURE AND THEY CONSTRICT
- 3:08THE POLICY DECISIONS THEY CAN
- 3:11MAKE PERTAINING TO EDUCATION.
- 3:12I DON'T THINK THOSE RESTRICTIONS
- 3:15MAKE SENSE TODAY.
- 3:17I TRUST OUR LEGISLATORS I'VE
- 3:19WORKED WITH A LOT OF THEM AND
- 3:23KENTUCKY'S LEGISLATORS ARE GOOD
- 3:24PEOPLE AND WORK HARD AND CARE
- 3:25DEEP WHETHER I ABOUT THE
- 3:26COMMONWEALTH.
- 3:27IT MAKES SENSE TO TAKE THE
- 3:30RESTRICTIONS OFF.
- 3:30LET THE PEOPLE OF KENTUCKY MAKE
- 3:33DECISIONS TODAY SELECT THE
- 3:34EDUCATION POLICY THEY WANT AS
- 3:36OPPOSED OF HAVING IT DETERMINED
- 3:37FOR THEM BY THE RESTRICTIONS PUT
- 3:40ON IN THE 1890s.
- 3:44>> Renee: AND THE QUESTION
- 3:45DOESN'T LAYOUT THE OPTIONS OR
- 3:48ANY PARTICULAR PATH, RIGHT?
- 3:50>> THIS DOESN'T SET POLICY IT
- 3:52TAKES THE HANDCUFFS OFF AND SAYS
- 3:54THE LEGISLATURE GETS TO MAKE
- 3:56THESE DECISIONS.
- 3:57IF THIS AMENDMENT PASSES ON DAY
- 3:59ONE, NOTHING CHANGES.
- 4:00ALL THAT IT MEANS IS THAT THE
- 4:03LEGISLATORS, THINGS CHANGE IN
- 4:05THE SENSE THE LEGISLATORS GET TO
- 4:08MAKE DECISIONS THAT IS UP FOR
- 4:10THE LEGISLATORS TO DECIDE.
- 4:13>> Renee: 183, 184, 186 THAT
- 4:15ADDRESS THE COMMON SCHOOLS WOULD
- 4:17HELP IF YOU DEFINE THAT, IS THAT
- 4:20ONLY APPLICABLE TO PUBLIC
- 4:21SCHOOLS?
- 4:22>> THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION,
- 4:24RENEE.
- 4:24COMMON SCHOOLS IS A TERM USED IN
- 4:26THE CONSTITUTION.
- 4:27AND THE MEANING OF THAT IS OFTEN
- 4:30HOTLY DEBATED.
- 4:31I THINK THAT SOME OF THE
- 4:35JURISPRUDENCE AS STRAYED FROM
- 4:37THE ORIGINAL UNDERSTANDING OF
- 4:39183, 184 AND 186.
- 4:41I THINK FOR INSTANCE THE CASE IN
- 4:43FRONT OF THE KENTUCKY SUPREME
- 4:44COURT, I THINK FOR INSTANCE, THE
- 4:47CHARTER SCHOOLS CAN WIN THAT
- 4:49CASE NO MATTER WHAT HAPPENS WITH
- 4:50THE AMENDMENT.
- 4:51THERE'S ENOUGH ROOM IN THE
- 4:52CONSTITUTION TO ALLOW THAT.
- 4:55SO BUT, WHAT THIS AMENDMENT DOES
- 4:58IT SAYS NO MATTER WHAT THE
- 5:00SECTIONS SAY OR MIGHT RESTRICT,
- 5:03WE'RE NOW GOING TO ALLOW THE
- 5:05LEGISLATORS TO SPEND PUBLIC
- 5:07MONEY ON WHATEVER SCHOOLS,
- 5:09COMMON SCHOOLS, PUBLIC KHAFRTER
- 5:12SCHOOLS WHATEVER EDUCATIONAL
- 5:12PROGRAMS THEY WANT AND IT BRINGS
- 5:14US INTO LINE WITH OTHER STATES
- 5:16WITH WIDE RANGING EDUCATIONAL
- 5:17FREEDOM OPPORTUNITIES.
- 5:19>> Renee: AND JIM YOU HAVE BEEN
- 5:20ON THE PROGRAM BEFORE Mr.
- 5:23WATERS, WE'VE TALKED A LOT ABOUT
- 5:24THIS ISSUE AND YOU'VE BEEN ON
- 5:26MANY OF THE DISCUSSIONS ABOUT
- 5:27THIS.
- 5:28IT DOESN'T AS THE AMENDMENT IS
- 5:30PRESENTED DOESN'T CREATE A
- 5:32POLICY.
- 5:33BUT THERE ARE OPTIONS THAT ARE
- 5:34OUT THERE THAT CERTAINLY PROVIDE
- 5:36A TEMPLATE FOR STATE LAWMAKERS
- 5:38WHEN THEY RETURN IN JANUARY.
- 5:39CAN YOU DEFINE MORE WHAT THOSE
- 5:43OPTIONS CAN LOOK LIKE?
- 5:44>> THAT IS A GREAT POINT.
- 5:46THESE ARE IN THE OTHER STATES
- 5:48AND WHAT WE CAN DO IS DO AN
- 5:50OUTSTANDING JOB WITH THE POLICY
- 5:52THE CREATION OF SCHOOL CHOICE
- 5:53POLICY BY LOOKING AT WHETHER
- 5:56WHAT IS WORKED AND WHAT HASN'T
- 5:57WORKED IN OTHER STATES.
- 5:58THAT IS A GOOD POINT.
- 6:00AND THERE'S ALL KINDS OF
- 6:01OPTIONS.
- 6:02WE'RE SEEING PUBLIC CHARTER
- 6:04SCHOOLS LIKE CHAD MENTIONED,
- 6:07EDUCATION OPPORTUNITY ACCOUNTEDS
- 6:08LIKE WE HAVE PASSED HERE.
- 6:10DURING COVID, RENEE, PARENTS GOT
- 6:13MORE CREATIVE AND CREATED THEIR
- 6:15OWN SCHOOLS MICRO SCHOOLS.
- 6:18AND KIND OF RETURNED TO THE
- 6:22ONE-HOUSE ONE ROOM SCHOOLHOUSE
- 6:22IN THE MODERN TIME.
- 6:24BECAUSE THEY WANTED TO GET THEIR
- 6:26KIDS EDUCATED AND THAT WAS MORE
- 6:28IMPORTANT THAN THE SYSTEM OR
- 6:30NECESSARILY THE VEHICLE BY WHICH
- 6:32THAT WAS ATTAINED.
- 6:33SO, YEAH, YOU ARE RIGHT.
- 6:36THIS WILL ALLOW A FULL DEBATE TO
- 6:39TAKE PLACE WITH LEGISLATORS
- 6:41KNOWING THAT WHATEVER THEY PASS
- 6:43IT'S NOT NECESSARILY GOING TO
- 6:45STOP THE COURT BECAUSE OF
- 6:47CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES.
- 6:48IT IS LIKE A BUSH HOG I WROTE
- 6:50THIS LIKE A BUSH HOG CLEARING
- 6:52THE WAY FOR THAT DEBATE TO TAKE
- 6:53PLACE.
- 6:54I THINK THOSE WHO OPPOSE THIS,
- 6:56ARE REALLY SAYING THAT THEY
- 7:00OPPOSE HAVING ANY DISCUSSION AT
- 7:01ALL ABOUT ANY CHANGE IN OUR
- 7:03EDUCATION THE WAY WE DELIVER
- 7:04EDUCATION.
- 7:04AND THAT OUGHT TO BE THE FOCUS.
- 7:06ARE WE DELIVERING EDUCATION IN A
- 7:08WAY THAT BENEFITS STUDENTS AND
- 7:10NOT JUST KEEPING A SYSTEM IN
- 7:12PLACE BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT WE'VE
- 7:14HAD SINCE 1890s.
- 7:16>> Renee: JASON BAILEY WITH THE
- 7:17CASE APP, KENTUCKY CENTER FOR
- 7:19ECONOMIC POLICY.
- 7:20GOOD TO SEE YOU.
- 7:22YOU'VE WRITTEN A RECENT OP-ED AT
- 7:24THE END OF MAY AND THERE'S NO
- 7:26GUESSING GAME WHAT STATE
- 7:27LAWMAKERS WILL DO IF THIS
- 7:29AMENDMENT PASSES STATES LIKE
- 7:30FLORIDA AND ARIZONA THAT STARTED
- 7:32WITH SMALL AND TARGETED PRIVATE
- 7:34SCHOOL VOUCHER PROGRAMS ARE
- 7:36GROWING THEM INTO EXPENSIVE
- 7:39GIVEAWAYS THAT ARE BUSTING STATE
- 7:41BUDGETS, GIVE US MORE ABOUT
- 7:42THAT.
- 7:43>> THIS AMENDMENT IF IT WERE TO
- 7:45PASS WOULD OPEN THE DOOR TO
- 7:47PRIVATE SCHOOL VOUCHERS FOR THE
- 7:48FIRST TIME IN KENTUCKY.
- 7:49AND JIM CALLED THE CONSTITUTION
- 7:51BUSH HOG, WE AGREE, I THINK THIS
- 7:54WOULD SHRED THE 133-YEAR-OLD
- 7:57CONSTITUTIONAL COMMITMENT TO
- 7:58PUBLIC EDUCATION AS A RIGHT TO
- 8:00ALL KENTUCKIANS AND THE STATE'S
- 8:02RESPONSIBILITY AND THE
- 8:03LEGISLATURE'S RESPONSIBILITY TO
- 8:04FUND THAT.
- 8:04AND IT WOULD JUST SAY TRUST US
- 8:06TO THE POLITICIANS AS TO WHAT
- 8:08THEY WILL DO.
- 8:10AND WE KNOW BASED ON A LAW THAT
- 8:13IS ON THE BOOKS THE ONE THAT WAS
- 8:15TOSSED OUT BY THE SUPREME COURT
- 8:16AND THE REASON THIS IS ON THE
- 8:18BALLOT WHAT THEY WILL DO.
- 8:19AND THAT'S TO PROVIDE PRIVATE
- 8:21SCHOOL VOUCHERS TO TAKE PUBLIC
- 8:23DOLLARS THAT GO TO PUBLIC
- 8:24SCHOOLS THAT ARE AVAILABLE AND
- 8:26OPEN TO ALL CHILDREN, AND
- 8:29REDIRECT THEM TO PRIVATE SCHOOL
- 8:31VOUCHERS AND THAT IS WHAT IS
- 8:32HAPPENING IN OTHER STATES.
- 8:33THEY START WITH SMALL PERHAPS
- 8:35AND THEY GROW LARGE AND BECOME
- 8:38UNIVERSAL AND THEY ARE BUSTING
- 8:39STATE BUDGETS.
- 8:41FLORIDA IS SPENDING $4 BILLION
- 8:43ON PRIVATE SCHOOL VOUCHERS.
- 8:451.1 BILLION IN OHIO.
- 8:471.1 BILLION IN ARIZONA.
- 8:48AND MOST OF THAT MONEY GOES TO
- 8:51KIDS IN FAMILIES ALREADY IN
- 8:53PRIVATE SCHOOL ABOUT 70% ON
- 8:56AVERAGE.
- 8:58SO WE ARE TAKING DOLLARS AWAY
- 9:00FROM THE PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM
- 9:01THAT SERVES EVERYBODY AND GIVING
- 9:03IT TO THOSE WHO ALREADY ARE
- 9:05BETTER OFF ON AVERAGE.
- 9:06WE CAN'T AFFORD THAT ESPECIALLY
- 9:08IF YOU LOOK IN RURAL KENTUCKY
- 9:11WHERE THE PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM
- 9:12IS HEAVILY FUNDED BY THE STATE
- 9:14BECAUSE THERE'S LOW PROPERTY
- 9:17WEALTH IF YOU SEND IT TO THE
- 9:18PLACES WITH PRIVATE SCHOOLS
- 9:20WHICH IS HALF OF THE PRIVATE
- 9:21SCHOOLS ARE IN THREE COUNTIES IN
- 9:24KENTUCKY IT WILL BE DEVASTATING
- 9:25TO RURAL AREAS THAT HAVE ALREADY
- 9:29LOST SO MUCH THEY ARE FACING A
- 9:30TEACHER SHORTAGE, A BUS DRIVER
- 9:32SHORTAGE AND PROBLEMS WITH
- 9:33FUNDING THEIR SYSTEMS FROM THE
- 9:35TYPES OF BUDGET CUTS WE'VE SEEN.
- 9:37>> Renee: LET'S DO A GLOSSARY OF
- 9:40TERMS.
- 9:40WE THROW AROUND TERMS.
- 9:42SCHOOL VOUCHERS VERSUS
- 9:44EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITY ACCOUNTS
- 9:45WHICH THE KENTUCKY SUPREME COURT
- 9:46STRUCK DOWN
- 11:06schools anymore.
- 11:07Another thing this if it
- 11:08passes, this could be the last
- 11:09referendum you see because it
- 11:10not not withstanding the
- 11:12section. We have to take these
- 11:14things. The people. So it's
- 11:18less Democratic
- 11:19we know what vouchers have done
- 11:20in other states. We know what
- 11:22they've done to their their
- 11:23budgets. Kentucky's public
- 11:24schools are doing their jobs
- 11:27there, the hubs of their
- 11:29communities there are a vital
- 11:30part of our rule, communities
- 11:36and are people know that.
- 11:36>> Mister Mayor. If I do want
- 11:37to go to that point, the missed
- 11:40just made about how there is
- 11:43a ballot question for
- 11:45statewide. But there is not
- 11:47another procedure, a process by
- 11:48which local communities could
- 11:50then buy ratify their
- 11:53participation in 2 a school
- 11:56voucher program as an example.
- 11:58>> Sure. Well, let me before I
- 12:00address that address something
- 12:01The Joel said they want to take
- 12:03a little issue with. He said
- 12:04this. If this amendment passes,
- 12:05there will not be an obligation
- 12:06of the Constitution to fund
- 12:07public schools. That's just
- 12:09not sure when it says that not
- 12:11withstand section one, 83, it
- 12:12doesn't mean that it's wiping
- 12:13one 83 off the books. What it's
- 12:17saying is that that the
- 12:17legislature who wants can use
- 12:21public funds on outside the
- 12:22common school system. That's
- 12:23that's it's taking away any
- 12:25restriction that section one 83
- 12:26might put on funding not come
- 12:26to school. So what it's saying
- 12:29is to the extent the section
- 12:32one, 83 would prohibit funding
- 12:34schools outside the common
- 12:36schools that restrictions taken
- 12:37away. It's not saying we're
- 12:40taking away the obligation to
- 12:41fund public schools. That
- 12:42obligation will remain one.
- 12:4583 will stay on the books.
- 12:46So there still will be a
- 12:46constitutional obligation to
- 12:48fund public school does not to
- 12:50the current level well know
- 12:51that they're there with there
- 12:52will be there absolutely will
- 12:54be
- 12:56and obligation under the
- 12:56Constitution to fund to fund
- 12:57common schools. Now, what's
- 13:00interesting is nearly all of
- 13:03the funding for common schools
- 13:06today comes from the general
- 13:07Fund. The Constitution says
- 13:08that the school fund has to
- 13:09be obligated for comma schools.
- 13:11But the reality is the school
- 13:14fund is is.
- 13:14Extraordinarily small compared
- 13:15to the general fund. Almost
- 13:18all of the money for schools
- 13:19comes from the general fund.
- 13:20The Constitution does not
- 13:22obligate that money to go to
- 13:23schools. And yet the General
- 13:24Assembly gives it to schools
- 13:26anyway. So I think you're going
- 13:26to see the same thing. If this
- 13:27passes. All this does is it
- 13:30takes restrictions off. We can
- 13:31trust our legislators. They're
- 13:32good people. They live in our
- 13:34communities. They want the best
- 13:35for our communities. They want
- 13:35the best for public schools.
- 13:39This is not the death sentence
- 13:39for public schools in Kentucky.
- 13:41All this does is it takes the
- 13:44shackles off of public policy
- 13:45for the Legislature. Just
- 13:46unveiling the rose decision
- 13:47that said that our school
- 13:47funding was unconstitutional in
- 13:511989.
- 13:51>> Specifically looked at both
- 13:53the adequacy and the equitable,
- 13:54equitable equity of of school
- 13:56funding and found it to be.
- 13:58>> To not meet the
- 13:59constitutional standard.
- 13:59What this change says is that
- 14:02notwithstanding the requirement
- 14:05that we do that we can provide
- 14:07money outside of that system.
- 14:09So the constitutional
- 14:10obligation could be met by just
- 14:11shifting dollars away from that
- 14:12comment school system to the
- 14:15to the non to the to the
- 14:16private schools. And that is
- 14:16the purpose of this. I mean,
- 14:18this is about taking dollars.
- 14:20They have been dedicated for
- 14:23many years to that system.
- 14:25Dollars that have been cut
- 14:26already from budget cuts over
- 14:27the last 15 years and diverting
- 14:28them to private schools.
- 14:29That's when it opens the door
- 14:30to him. Mister Meredith has
- 14:35said twice now I trust the
- 14:35Legislature. So that is what
- 14:37this is telling us. Trust us
- 14:40trust the legislature to as
- 14:41to what they're going to do and
- 14:44how they want to fund and what
- 14:46they want to fund and it's a
- 14:46blank check. It opens the door
- 14:49wide open to fund anything.
- 14:51And we know from other states
- 14:52what that means. It's
- 14:55unaccountable private school
- 14:56vouchers, private schools that
- 14:59that aren't aren't subject to
- 15:00that anti-discrimination laws
- 15:00that don't have to meet the
- 15:01same accountability
- 15:02requirements that don't accept
- 15:05all kids and you go on and on.
- 15:08And in many cases in many
- 15:08states, what we're seeing is
- 15:09schools that pop up and then
- 15:10close a couple years later
- 15:14creates a lot of turn and that
- 15:15sort of thing that that this
- 15:15opens the door to him that
- 15:16we're seeing in other states
- 15:18and given we only have so many
- 15:22resources in the budget.
- 15:22Diverting more dollars away
- 15:23from the system that it is open
- 15:26to all kids is a very dangerous
- 15:30path that that denies a
- 15:30students that need something
- 15:31different than what the public
- 15:33education system gives.
- 15:34>> My question would Mister
- 15:35Bailey admitted that these
- 15:36programs are growing in other
- 15:38states and I wonder if he
- 15:40stopped to consider why that
- 15:42Why is it that parents are
- 15:42wanting options? Why is that?
- 15:44The families are choosing some
- 15:45of these options that are
- 15:48available and his claim most
- 15:50of these scholarships are going
- 15:51to families that don't need
- 15:52them or can't use them is just
- 15:54not true. For example, in
- 15:55charter schools around the
- 15:58country, a majority of charter
- 15:59school students are low-income
- 16:00minority students in our
- 16:02nation. And that's we're
- 16:04talking about 3.7 million kids
- 16:04going charter schools, almost
- 16:09a million children in America
- 16:10in schools of choice through a
- 16:12scholarship that they normally
- 16:13would have been able to get
- 16:15before. So we've heard Mister
- 16:17Bailey talk about the system,
- 16:18the system, we've got to fund
- 16:19the system. But this really
- 16:19ought to be about what's best
- 16:21for our students, whether they
- 16:23need. And then I think we
- 16:24should do everything we can to
- 16:24make sure our students are
- 16:26going to have a successful
- 16:29future. And right now we have
- 16:31some problems with that
- 16:31considering just about one in 3
- 16:33of our kids are reading
- 16:35professionally in that number
- 16:36drops with low-income minority
- 16:38into the teens. So he's right
- 16:41about Kara. Kara, a promise
- 16:43that every child can learn at
- 16:44the highest level and it
- 16:44promised that those dollars
- 16:49would be used to close the
- 16:50gaps. But we've seen the fixing
- 16:50of the funding. And I think
- 16:51that's proper. I mean, I was
- 16:52out in Jackson County last
- 16:55week, beautiful place and, you
- 16:56know, they get a lot more of
- 16:57their funding from the state,
- 16:58then saying that Creek school
- 16:59district are some of the
- 17:01wealthier districts, too.
- 17:03But the fact is the fact is
- 17:04that we're not seeing the
- 17:06progress with academic
- 17:07performance. We've more than
- 17:08tripled are fending and many of
- 17:11our school districts. And and
- 17:12Jackson County, only 8% of
- 17:13their 8th graders can breed
- 17:17can after officially in only a
- 17:19in the teens can do can re
- 17:20professionally. So so at what
- 17:23point does this become about
- 17:25what those dollars are for and
- 17:27what they're producing, whether
- 17:28the end results of those and
- 17:29why are so many parents and
- 17:30other states warning to use
- 17:32these and why are those numbers
- 17:34growing? So we also talked to
- 17:36some educators. There's a group
- 17:37called protect our schools,
- 17:38Kentucky. That opposes
- 17:40amendment number 2.
- 17:41>> It's holding events around
- 17:43Kentuckyian in an event and
- 17:44Warren County last week
- 17:44included the superintendent and
- 17:45a teacher. Here's what they had
- 17:48to say.
- 17:49>> Here locally in the state
- 17:54of Kentucky. We are in
- 17:55opposition of amendment 2
- 17:58because we understand how
- 17:59critical the quality of our
- 17:59public schools are for the
- 18:00fabric of all of our
- 18:03communities.
- 18:05We know that in our current
- 18:07situation, the funding has not
- 18:08met the need for now more than
- 18:13a decade. In fact, we're still
- 18:14advocating for funding levels
- 18:16that would put us on par with
- 18:18where we were in 2008, more
- 18:21than 16 years ago.
- 18:22And although our legislature
- 18:25has provided additional funding
- 18:26here in the legislative
- 18:30session.
- 18:32Book of those funds really are
- 18:34going to sure up the pension
- 18:35system that's been woefully
- 18:36underfunded for again, more
- 18:38than a decade.
- 18:40>> Public education is the
- 18:40cornerstone of our community,
- 18:42its home base for those kids,
- 18:44its home base for those
- 18:45families, its home base for
- 18:47the community leaders because
- 18:48they're always pitching in and
- 18:50helping where they can. If this
- 18:53voucher amendment passes, I'm
- 18:53scared of what it's going to be
- 18:55for my students. I'm not just
- 18:55scared of what it's going to do
- 18:57for me. I'm scared of what it's
- 18:59going to do for those kids.
- 19:02All of our kids diverting money
- 19:04out of the system, draining
- 19:04resources, more resources away
- 19:07from schools. It weakens our
- 19:10schools and it hurts our
- 19:11students period. Vouchers
- 19:12divert critical resources away
- 19:14from public schools and it's
- 19:16instead to unaccountable
- 19:17private schools. Who do they
- 19:19answer to? They don't answer to
- 19:22the same people. We do. In
- 19:23every state that vouchers are
- 19:24present. These costs ballooned
- 19:26very quickly. Over time the
- 19:27strain placed on public schools
- 19:30by this voucher scheme becomes
- 19:31too much and it leads to
- 19:32radical disinvestment in the
- 19:34public schools. Vouchers would
- 19:36lead to cuts in services.
- 19:37We would be able to provide our
- 19:37students and families with
- 19:40otherwise.
- 19:41We provide so many things that
- 19:43the community doesn't even know
- 19:46about. I would love for you to
- 19:47take a walk in a teacher.
- 19:47She's one day just to see all
- 19:49of the things that we provide
- 19:50that people don't even
- 19:51register, that we give our
- 19:53students day in and day out
- 19:53and a lot of times because the
- 19:55money's not there. It comes
- 19:58out of our pockets. We're not
- 19:59complaining because that's what
- 20:00we do because we love the kids.
- 20:03But if you're taking more
- 20:05things away from public
- 20:06schools, your teachers are
- 20:06going to have to pony up even
- 20:08more. And lot of us are staying
- 20:10because we love it, but some of
- 20:14them can afford to stay.
- 20:16So much to offer. Want to go to
- 20:16you first to react to what you
- 20:17just heard that educators say.
- 20:22>> She's exactly
- 20:23Public schools are the
- 20:24cornerstone of our communities
- 20:26in during the flooding in
- 20:28eastern Kentucky. We made the
- 20:30trip after trip up there taking
- 20:30supplies. We didn't take him to
- 20:31the fire department. We didn't
- 20:33take in the city hall. We took
- 20:36them to a public school.
- 20:37And there to receive them and
- 20:38distribute them to their to
- 20:40their neighbors where public
- 20:43school teachers and classified
- 20:44employees, these public schools
- 20:45are vital to our rural
- 20:48communities. This is going to
- 20:51be a giveaway. To private
- 20:53schools in the don't try almost
- 20:54rule counties don't have
- 20:57private schools.
- 20:59So I think what this means it
- 21:00was saying is right on the
- 21:02money.
- 21:03Public schools are vital and
- 21:06they're especially vile in
- 21:07rural areas.
- 21:08>> So earlier this evening on
- 21:11our week night newscast,
- 21:12Kentucky Edition, we told you
- 21:13all the viewers about a recent
- 21:15kids count data book the
- 21:17results of which were released
- 21:19today and they have several
- 21:19metrics that, of course, kind
- 21:23of gauge the well-being of our
- 21:23come to Kentucky kids and Stack
- 21:27set up with kids across the
- 21:27nation and it's not just
- 21:28education, but for the purposes
- 21:29of tonight's or just go look at
- 21:32a few of these key What they
- 21:36found was is that 69% of 4th
- 21:36graders score below proficient
- 21:40in reading in 2020 to 79% of
- 21:418th graders score below
- 21:43proficient in math in 2022.
- 21:4510% of high school students
- 21:47don't graduate on time in 2021.
- 21:5022 2020 in 2021. and 20% or
- 21:51more than that. 25 1% of
- 21:55children are chronically absent
- 21:56the last academic school year.
- 21:56So want to go to the dentist
- 21:58role for Mister Bailey to say,
- 22:00you know, you look at those
- 22:01numbers that were just on the
- 22:02screen and it makes the case
- 22:05for some that traditional
- 22:06public school environments are
- 22:06just not cutting it. And
- 22:08they're just not making the
- 22:10great give us the defense of
- 22:10why those numbers are the way
- 22:11they are and why public schools
- 22:14need more support.
- 22:16>> Well, you know, they're
- 22:17definitely schools and
- 22:18classrooms that are struggling
- 22:20in its highly coordinate,
- 22:21coordinate correlated with
- 22:21communities that are struggling
- 22:23with individuals that are
- 22:23struggling. People, kids that
- 22:24are facing homelessness that
- 22:27are facing hunger that, you
- 22:30know, our our our alright
- 22:30households that don't have
- 22:32living wage jobs and we have to
- 22:35do more to invest in our
- 22:35schools and we have to do more
- 22:36to solve the problems. Entire
- 22:39communities face to, to make to
- 22:42to make all the entire
- 22:43situation. But if we can't put
- 22:44everything on our schools, but
- 22:45our schools can do more and
- 22:46they want to do more. But a lot
- 22:49of the the the interventions
- 22:52that we know work, particularly
- 22:53to deal with those kids that
- 22:56are more disconnected, do costs
- 22:58resources and it requires
- 23:00wrap-around extra extra
- 23:02tutoring, support. It requires
- 23:03that we have teachers in the
- 23:05classroom and we have a teacher
- 23:06shortage that is growing so
- 23:08that there's higher turnover
- 23:09and there's entire classes that
- 23:09are not being filled. We have
- 23:13bus drivers
- 23:13if that seats that are filled
- 23:14so kids can even get to school
- 23:17on time necessarily particular
- 23:19day. So so there there are
- 23:21solutions to these problems.
- 23:25They do require that we we we
- 23:25invest in a definite require
- 23:27that we don't dis invest in
- 23:29those public schools because,
- 23:30again, the places that are
- 23:30experiencing these biggest,
- 23:33the biggest problems in these
- 23:34areas are going to be the ones
- 23:36that lose public dollars if we
- 23:37shift to about this team
- 23:40because they don't have private
- 23:41schools and no vouchers going
- 23:41to stand up a private school in
- 23:43these rural communities.
- 23:44>> So to that point, kind of
- 23:47viewer from Owenton says,
- 23:47quote, Public schools will lose
- 23:50funding if students leave.
- 23:50Most rural counties won't see a
- 23:51change in enrollment so they
- 23:53won't see a loss of funds.
- 23:54We've got several questions
- 23:55coming in and we'll try to get
- 23:55the mostly statements and we'll
- 23:58try to integrate those into
- 23:59the conversation tonight.
- 23:59I do want to ask the side of
- 24:02the table, though. Do we know
- 24:06that private schools that
- 24:08accept whether it's public
- 24:09school dollars and used in
- 24:11whatever form that they
- 24:12actually serve students better
- 24:13at those students actually have
- 24:17better academic outcomes.
- 24:18>> Well, the students that need
- 24:19that opportunity, yeah, they
- 24:19serve them better. And that's
- 24:22the whole point here is that
- 24:23you hear again here talking
- 24:26investing in systems are in
- 24:28and in the schools. But this
- 24:29really ought to be about what
- 24:31students need them. We know
- 24:32if a special needs student, for
- 24:36example, needs need services
- 24:37or they need a different kind
- 24:40of than the traditional public
- 24:41school can provide. We even
- 24:43have public schools that are
- 24:44referring students to private
- 24:44schools in order to get what
- 24:47they need. So the other side
- 24:48table needs this to be about
- 24:50an either or situation. But the
- 24:55fact is we want to expand the
- 24:56opportunities, not not limit.
- 24:57Then we want to expand that
- 24:59and the dollars are for
- 25:00educating students. So that's
- 25:03that's why all the polling that
- 25:03we've seen shows tremendous
- 25:07support among Kentucky families
- 25:09in rural and urban areas.
- 25:09So there may be more score,
- 25:10but are the outcomes there to
- 25:12make the case?
- 25:13>> Well, when we the only thing
- 25:15around the country that's
- 25:17closing gaps, for example,
- 25:17between black and white
- 25:18students in key academic areas
- 25:20of public charter schools,
- 25:21which are public schools.
- 25:22But they're managed
- 25:23differently. Their run
- 25:24differently. And I hear the
- 25:26other side. The table wants no
- 25:28change. They want no
- 25:29consideration of how to deliver
- 25:30education differently. That's
- 25:31not realistic. And the time
- 25:32we're living, there's too many
- 25:36different needs. And I think
- 25:36they're great public schools
- 25:38doing a great job with
- 25:39students, but that doesn't mean
- 25:39they're going to be able to
- 25:40educate every student in the
- 25:42school. So there needs to be
- 25:46opportunities and options.
- 25:46And there was a comment made
- 25:47about these are all vouchers
- 25:50know the Supreme Court has
- 25:51recognized that an education
- 25:52opportunity accounts were a
- 25:54scholarship. For example,
- 25:55government never touches that
- 25:57many. That money is donated by
- 25:58individuals and businesses to a
- 26:013rd party nonprofit that hands
- 26:02out the scholarships, the
- 26:04qualifying students. That's not
- 26:05a voucher. They want to use
- 26:05that term because they think
- 26:08it's a negative turn. What's
- 26:10negative here is we're going to
- 26:12deny students that need
- 26:13something different. We're
- 26:14going to deny them because we
- 26:15want to KET the system and prop
- 26:18up this system that is
- 26:19educating that one in 3 of our
- 26:21kids professionally,
- 26:22insufficient. That alter
- 26:24results of the last decade have
- 26:25been.
- 26:25>> Pretty dismal. If you look
- 26:26at there's been studies in Ohio
- 26:30and Indiana in Louisiana and
- 26:31they show academic results that
- 26:34are behind the public schools.
- 26:36What happens when you pass
- 26:37about your program like this?
- 26:37A constitutional change would
- 26:41allow, is it primarily funds
- 26:43about 70% funds. Kids already
- 26:44in private school. So they're
- 26:45already there. Their families
- 26:48can already afford it.
- 26:49For those who you know that
- 26:51there's they're not able to
- 26:52afford those elite private
- 26:53schools, even with a voucher
- 26:54because their families don't
- 26:56have the resources to do so.
- 26:58>> So it ends up being sort
- 27:00of these pop-up schools.
- 27:02They just aren't able to
- 27:03provide the quality of
- 27:06education that kids need.
- 27:07And and that's why the results
- 27:08are poor. And that's why many
- 27:08of them end up closing the kids
- 27:12have to go back to the public
- 27:12school. It's it's hard to run a
- 27:13school like it is expensive
- 27:17to run a school and we have our
- 27:18hands full as a poor state
- 27:19running our system of public
- 27:19schools. Do we want to add a
- 27:21whole other system on that
- 27:23funding with school vouchers
- 27:24that if you look at these other
- 27:26states, the costs are
- 27:28tremendous. So this question
- 27:30from Honey, Goldman, all why is
- 27:31this amendment not to return to
- 27:32segregation? So there was some
- 27:36conversation about.
- 27:36>> Private don't have to abide
- 27:37by the same level of
- 27:39accountability as public
- 27:41schools that they can and
- 27:43essence cherry pick the types
- 27:44of students that they want.
- 27:45Only high-achieving from high
- 27:48source to resourced families
- 27:51and could they not KET race
- 27:54and the so that it still prices
- 27:54many out of the market who
- 27:55you're with alleged would
- 27:56benefit the most.
- 27:57>> What we're finding is that
- 28:01when there is a supply and the
- 28:02ability to create schools.
- 28:06We're seeing we're seeing
- 28:07private schools or nonpublic
- 28:08schools work with families in
- 28:09order to meet those educational
- 28:12needs it. There tuition is
- 28:13higher than than the than what
- 28:14the families able to pay.
- 28:15There's all kinds of options
- 28:17there that are being done.
- 28:18That's just that statement.
- 28:18Just ignores all of the great
- 28:22things happening in in these
- 28:22programs in other states.
- 28:24And that's one of them that
- 28:26if if you can't meet if you
- 28:27can't pay the full press, we're
- 28:29going to find a way to educate
- 28:30your children. And I would
- 28:31challenge the other side to
- 28:32find where that's not
- 28:35happening. And by the way, the
- 28:36reason is a private school or
- 28:38even a charter school would
- 28:40fail is if the parents are not
- 28:41satisfied with the education
- 28:43being delivered by that school,
- 28:46that's a far different thing
- 28:47than we see in the traditional
- 28:48public education system where
- 28:48if a school doesn't meet the
- 28:52needs of it, students, it never
- 28:54closes. We pour more money
- 28:56into. We put more resources
- 28:56there. We don't really give
- 28:57parents the option, which would
- 28:59be a great dynamic to cause
- 29:01public education to improve.
- 29:02And Renee in other states in
- 29:05Florida, for example, the more
- 29:06choices they have offered
- 29:07people there, the better their
- 29:08public education system has
- 29:12performed. And so we think that
- 29:12the answer to a better public
- 29:16education system is not more
- 29:16money because we've already
- 29:17increase spending dramatically.
- 29:20I mean, in Jackson County,
- 29:21$24,000, almost per pupil.
- 29:23We're spending there. So that's
- 29:24not getting the job done.
- 29:26So we need to ideas. I'd like
- 29:26to hear what they are. If it's
- 29:29not giving parents options and
- 29:31empowering parents giving them
- 29:32freedom, then is it going to be
- 29:33propping up the system at so it
- 29:36continues to fail.
- 29:37>> So Mister mayor of the
- 29:38question to you about all the
- 29:40legality of it all, because
- 29:41there there's been a lot of
- 29:43question about standards and
- 29:43would private schools have to
- 29:45adhere to the same type of
- 29:47standards? Could the General
- 29:48Assembly out if this was
- 29:52ratified by the voters, then an
- 29:54act law that also stipulated to
- 29:55private schools, what they
- 29:57should do in terms of accepting
- 29:59certain types of students.
- 30:00You know, enrollment types of
- 30:02measures, that kind of thing
- 30:03is that wise and has that done
- 30:06elsewhere?
- 30:07The so?
- 30:08>> Let me just say that the
- 30:08state legislature has what we
- 30:10call the police power. The
- 30:11federal government doesn't have
- 30:12that, but states do and what?
- 30:13And that's not literally
- 30:15pertaining to police but
- 30:17remains is the state
- 30:18legislature has a general
- 30:19regulatory authority over
- 30:19everything that goes on in the
- 30:21state with exceptions, of
- 30:23course. So, yeah, there's a lot
- 30:24that the Legislature can do
- 30:25just are generally regulate
- 30:28education in the state. They
- 30:28want to bring this back the
- 30:29amendment for a second point
- 30:30out that this is a great
- 30:32discussion we're having about
- 30:36policy right? But you know
- 30:37where this discussion should
- 30:39be taking place in the
- 30:41legislature, but it can't take
- 30:42place in the legislature by and
- 30:43large because of the
- 30:45restrictions placed on the
- 30:47legislature's authority.
- 30:47The constitution restrictions
- 30:48were put there in 18, 91.
- 30:50By the way. So all this
- 30:51amendment does is clear away.
- 30:54Those restrictions to get the
- 30:55legislature, the authority to
- 30:56go and make policy. This
- 30:57amendment doesn't make policy
- 30:59for anybody. Doesn't set any
- 30:59policy for anything. All it
- 31:02doesn't says people of
- 31:04Kentucky, you now have the
- 31:04authority to make whatever
- 31:08education policy you want.
- 31:09And with some exceptions, of
- 31:10course, you've still got to
- 31:10fund public schools minute,
- 31:13but that's a pretty important
- 31:15thing in the United States
- 31:15Supreme Court has referred to
- 31:16the state legislature's as
- 31:19laboratories of democracy.
- 31:19And what that means is the idea
- 31:20for each state is each take it
- 31:22to set its own policy for
- 31:23itself and states get to
- 31:24experiment with policies and
- 31:25figure out what works best and
- 31:27what doesn't work. And the idea
- 31:28is that over time, the best
- 31:30ideas rise to the top right?
- 31:31And so we've had school choice
- 31:32and charter schools in this
- 31:34country for decades. Now.
- 31:35And at this point in history.
- 31:38You have 45 states and the
- 31:39District of Columbia that have
- 31:41charter schools. If this were a
- 31:43really bad idea, it would not
- 31:46have spread that far. So I
- 31:47don't I don't really understand
- 31:50why we would want to.
- 31:53KET our legislature from having
- 31:54the full range of of options
- 31:54before it like other states.
- 31:57Do.
- 31:59This was going to destroy this
- 32:00in their school choice would
- 32:02destroy public education.
- 32:03>> I mean, we would have seen
- 32:04this happen in many other
- 32:07states. Well, we are seeing.
- 32:08>> The voucher programs explode
- 32:09just over the past few years
- 32:11ago in Florida, spending for
- 32:13billion dollars. So the the the
- 32:15the experiment, the laboratory
- 32:16is happening around the country
- 32:18and we're seeing the harmful
- 32:21where money is being diverted
- 32:24from from public schools to to
- 32:25an accountable private schools.
- 32:26I want to sail around the
- 32:28discriminatory point that, you
- 32:29know, when we have a a program
- 32:30on the books, a private school
- 32:34tax credit voucher there was an
- 32:36amendment on the floor to
- 32:37require that the that anybody
- 32:37receiving that school received
- 32:38that does not discriminate.
- 32:39And then amendment was voted
- 32:43down. So so we know that
- 32:43there's a bad track record here
- 32:47mean vouchers. A rose
- 32:47originally in response to
- 32:50school desegregation as a way
- 32:50to to maintain those those
- 32:54divides. And so that there's
- 32:55nothing in this amendment that
- 32:57would require the General
- 32:58Assembly to to to prevent those
- 32:59sort of things. There's nothing
- 33:00in this amendment to require
- 33:02the General Assembly put
- 33:03accountability measures in
- 33:04place. It is a blank check.
- 33:062 politicians to do whatever
- 33:08you want to do and the reason
- 33:10in 18 91, we put this in our
- 33:14Constitution is because we know
- 33:15that public education is so
- 33:16important to a strong
- 33:16democracy. We wanted to put
- 33:19protections in place.
- 33:21And this throws those out and
- 33:23for it it it not withstand 7
- 33:25sections of the Constitution
- 33:27and throws those out. And I
- 33:27think the voters of Kentucky
- 33:31should be very wary before
- 33:31tossing out a commitment to
- 33:34public education. When we see
- 33:35what's happening in other
- 33:36state. And we also see that
- 33:37they're very powerful
- 33:38interests, billionaires who are
- 33:40funding these efforts in other
- 33:42states that, you know, that
- 33:44their interests are not about
- 33:45education there about in
- 33:46challenging the fundamental
- 33:50the our fundamental rights and
- 33:50and our our system of
- 33:53democracy.
- 33:56public education is at the core
- 33:56that are in effect. And that's
- 33:57something that that Mister
- 33:58Bailey said are quickly.
- 34:01I think you said that.
- 34:02>> These these constitutional
- 34:02provisions were put in place in
- 34:0618. 91 to protect public
- 34:06education and for some of them,
- 34:08that's that's true for certain
- 34:10section. 23, the first couple
- 34:13clauses of section. 24. But a
- 34:14lot of the clauses that have
- 34:17been used to restrict school
- 34:18choice or not put there to
- 34:18protect public education.
- 34:19The report there as taxpayer
- 34:22protection measures, for
- 34:23instance, the last claw, the
- 34:24last couple clauses of Section.
- 34:2524 were talks about taxation
- 34:28yet in that require a
- 34:28referendum before you can have
- 34:32taxation for education that was
- 34:33put there in response to a
- 34:34Kentucky Court of Appeals
- 34:34decision from 18, 90 called he
- 34:38can be prayer a pretty before
- 34:39the current constitution.
- 34:41The 18 50 constitution said
- 34:43that any taxes raise for
- 34:43education had to go straight to
- 34:44the common school system can go
- 34:48anywhere else. The Legislature
- 34:49institute attacks specifically
- 34:50for the University of
- 34:51Kentuckyian all the money went
- 34:52to Kentucky. There's a lawsuit
- 34:53over that because the question
- 34:54was, this is education. This is
- 34:55money raised for education.
- 34:57Shouldn't go to the common
- 34:58schools and the Kentucky Court
- 34:59appeal says, well, we know
- 35:00that's what the Constitution
- 35:02said, but we're going to go to
- 35:02UK anyway. So the people in
- 35:04the constitutional convention,
- 35:06we're very concerned. This is
- 35:07going to open the floodgates
- 35:09to more taxes that would not go
- 35:11to the common schools. They
- 35:12thought the populace was
- 35:12already over taxing the didn't
- 35:15want more taxes. So this was
- 35:18this was really a taxpayer
- 35:18protection measure, not a high
- 35:21school protection measure.
- 35:22So it's very important to
- 35:24understand the history behind
- 35:25this. And so over time, some
- 35:26of that history, we've lost
- 35:27sight of some of that history
- 35:28and all this amendment does
- 35:31is clear out that thicket and
- 35:32say people of Kentucky, we
- 35:33trust you not to trust people
- 35:36to trust the legislators.
- 35:37And KET in mind, the
- 35:37legislators go to Frankfort
- 35:39and act. They're not acting for
- 35:40themselves. They're acting as
- 35:41proxies for the people. So if
- 35:43you trust the people of
- 35:45Kentucky, just given this
- 35:45opportunity just give them,
- 35:46give them, give them the
- 35:49opportunity to set policy for
- 35:49themselves.
- 35:50>> I want to go back to our
- 35:51original question. I think I
- 35:52asked you earlier, as you've
- 35:53said a few times that this does
- 35:55allows them to have more
- 35:56options right? That's right.
- 36:01Could they then say then pass
- 36:02it? This is ratified coming to
- 36:03a session. Maybe it's 25.
- 36:06Maybe it's 26 to say now we
- 36:06want to empower local
- 36:08communities to make that choice
- 36:09themselves. Just like a wet
- 36:12would work.
- 36:15>> I thought about that.
- 36:15I have to think about some
- 36:16more, but I think it may be
- 36:19conceivable. I'm not.
- 36:20>> Well, I just wanted from
- 36:21this perspective. If that would
- 36:23satisfy you more, if the voters
- 36:25speak in November, the first
- 36:27Tuesday in November and say
- 36:29we approve and we want the
- 36:30lawmakers to have a wider range
- 36:33of options and let them set
- 36:35policy. Would you support a
- 36:35policy that would allow the
- 36:36vote to actually be held in
- 36:41local communities? I would
- 36:42>> the public knows how good
- 36:45our schools are.
- 36:47They will talk about trusting
- 36:49people every morning people.
- 36:50The Commonwealth of Kentucky
- 36:51make the conscious decision
- 36:53to put their child on a school
- 36:55bus or drop them off at school
- 36:56and put them into the hands
- 36:59of public educators.
- 37:00They trust our teachers.
- 37:01They trust the staff at school
- 37:03school is a refuge for a lot
- 37:05of our children. Public schools
- 37:08do that.
- 37:09The province schools have no
- 37:10accountability academically.
- 37:11No accountability financially.
- 37:1680% of the students receiving
- 37:18vouchers in Arizona were
- 37:20already attending private
- 37:20schools. This is just a
- 37:24discount for their parents and
- 37:25talking about financial
- 37:25accountability. Some of the
- 37:26things that were spent. In
- 37:30Arizona. The voucher lodge
- 37:31about supplies, books, things
- 37:34of that nature.
- 37:35Paid for skiing equipment and
- 37:39troops. It paid for theme park
- 37:42tickets. Chicken Coops, Hawaii
- 37:44vacations, hunting lessons
- 37:46driving lessons in luxury cars
- 37:49and calf roping. That's what
- 37:52you've got in Arizona.
- 37:52>> Was that part of an
- 37:53education curriculum and
- 37:53someone?
- 37:57>> I don't know what.
- 37:57>> Let's say. They are met your
- 37:58passengers. We will talk about
- 37:59rest. Let's trust parents.
- 38:02I think parents know what's
- 38:02best for their children versus
- 38:05the bureaucrats. The
- 38:06superintendent's, the the
- 38:08system. They know what's best.
- 38:10And I when we talk about trust
- 38:11and by the way, the question
- 38:16about Natalie, to marry a
- 38:17Camry, know Lopez, she manages
- 38:18the research for the National
- 38:19Alliance for Public Charter
- 38:22Schools and she compared
- 38:23student demographics and
- 38:23charter schools versus those of
- 38:25traditional public school
- 38:26districts found that charter
- 38:28schools have a higher portion
- 38:30of students of color compared
- 38:32to district schools and have
- 38:33had for the past 17 years.
- 38:37Nearly 71% of public charter
- 38:38school students were minorities
- 38:40in the 2021. 22 school year.
- 38:41That doesn't mean it was a poor
- 38:43versus just as they were.
- 38:44Minorities doesn't mean that
- 38:44they come from was severed.
- 38:45>> I was answering the question
- 38:48about segregation, but it
- 38:50supposed to be more to help the
- 38:52neediest of Co. We also have to
- 38:53also of well resource, right.
- 38:54But we also know that there's
- 38:58about a million kids in using
- 38:59these programs that wouldn't be
- 39:00able to if they didn't have
- 39:02that opportunity. So I think
- 39:04the trust issue here is with
- 39:06parents and plus, look, I'm not
- 39:07saying this is a silver bullet
- 39:08that, you know, is going to
- 39:10solve our problems. We've seen
- 39:12a lot of financial malfeasance
- 39:15in the public system as well.
- 39:15We've got people in prison to
- 39:169 from here in Kentuckyian just
- 39:19recently been convicted of of
- 39:21practicing financial
- 39:22mismanagement. But what
- 39:22accountability is there for
- 39:25that system. And so if school
- 39:26closes because they're not
- 39:27doing well as as they've
- 39:29mentioned several times now,
- 39:31that's actually a good thing.
- 39:33We don't want bad schools open
- 39:37failing students. We want them
- 39:37to close and you see that in
- 39:39the public in in Florida time
- 39:40after time, children would get
- 39:43up.
- 39:44The go to school. The teachers
- 39:45would arrive there. This sign
- 39:46on the door of their private
- 39:47school. It said.
- 39:49>> School is closed. The
- 39:51students had nowhere to go.
- 39:55The teachers were not pie.
- 39:56That's anecdotal onto its also
- 39:57the truth. I'm talking about
- 39:58the day, though, that the tree
- 39:59was not that these kids were
- 40:00standing out there.
- 40:03>> Well, in Florida.
- 40:05Wanting to go to school and
- 40:06couldn't because their school
- 40:06had closed. There was no
- 40:09warning, no, nothing. What
- 40:09about the kids who can't read
- 40:13but they get a diploma
- 40:15in Kentucky and there was a key
- 40:17point on that. But I KET your
- 40:18The national economy is booming
- 40:21and 9% of the people who are
- 40:22driving the economy went to a
- 40:23public school or schools were
- 40:25and we need. And so that's
- 40:26fine. If they're working great,
- 40:29then why not? The parents will
- 40:29decide, right? We trust
- 40:31parents, they'll make the
- 40:33decision that will make the
- 40:33decision to send their children
- 40:36to the public school. And this
- 40:37amendment will change at this
- 40:40time and will Tanya will drain
- 40:42the state budget and will hurt
- 40:43Communities who don't have the
- 40:44option to go to a private
- 40:46school. Well, actually, by the
- 40:47way, on that point, the
- 40:47Heritage Foundation's done some
- 40:51interesting research about
- 40:51rural schools and 7 out of 10
- 40:53families in America live within
- 40:5710 miles of some kind of
- 40:58nonpublic school. There He's at
- 41:00the case in Kentucky. That's
- 41:01the case in Jackson County
- 41:03where there's a couple of small
- 41:04nonpublic Christian schools.
- 41:05They're they're operating so
- 41:07to say that those in and if we
- 41:10have the opportunity where kids
- 41:12could get financial help and
- 41:13families and lower-income area
- 41:14could get that. I think we
- 41:14would see more. We've heard
- 41:16that we would see.
- 41:18>> But we've also heard
- 41:19legislators, Republicans say
- 41:21that the traditional public
- 41:23school will be the prominent
- 41:24and prevailing method of
- 41:27education in Kentucky.
- 41:28>> It's not the first. It
- 41:29covers 90% of kids. Now it
- 41:31will. It will continue to have
- 41:32that many even after vouchers,
- 41:32because what vouchers are going
- 41:35to first is fun. The kids are
- 41:36already in private schools
- 41:36that's not spread throughout
- 41:39the state. Half of those
- 41:42schools are in 3 counties,
- 41:42existing Kentucky. So it's
- 41:44going to take money out of
- 41:45these rural areas where the
- 41:48the public school is the center
- 41:49of the community, where it is
- 41:51the only option and they're
- 41:52just won't be enough money in
- 41:55vouchers to is to stand up
- 41:55private schools, private
- 41:56schools that are operating in
- 41:59these areas. Now these are
- 42:01wealthier areas where people
- 42:01have more of their own
- 42:04resources. They're putting into
- 42:05that of voucher is not going to
- 42:07make a difference to make new
- 42:07schools pop-up. They're all
- 42:08throughout. Kentucky State is
- 42:11going to take money from the
- 42:13existing public schools that
- 42:14Artie serves folks in. That's
- 42:15already been half of missile
- 42:16for. We already have school
- 42:18choice in many ways. You have
- 42:19magnet schools. You have
- 42:20schools and districts of
- 42:23innovation. Remember that that
- 42:24concept.
- 42:24>> Many, many years ago.
- 42:25I mean, if if you're doing it
- 42:27well, as throughout the state
- 42:28now, well, that's right.
- 42:28So we're going to pose when we
- 42:32did it. So it seems as if
- 42:34perhaps that for some kids,
- 42:35they are deserving and in need
- 42:37of an alternative to help them
- 42:38reach higher levels of
- 42:39learning. What is wrong with
- 42:40that to give the parents the
- 42:42choice?
- 42:45>> If a child needs special
- 42:46care, honestly don't think
- 42:48they're going to get a private
- 42:48school. Most private schools
- 42:50are not equipped to help
- 42:51children with special needs.
- 42:52That's still on the public
- 42:54school to do that. Well, a lot
- 42:57of public schools are not set
- 42:58up to meet some of those
- 43:00special needs. We've, as I said
- 43:00earlier.
- 43:01>> Some of our public schools
- 43:03are referring children to other
- 43:05like the some of the county in
- 43:05Louisville, for example,
- 43:08they're referring kids with
- 43:09severe disabilities or some
- 43:11kids that need another option.
- 43:12They're they're referring to
- 43:14them to that. So and the far
- 43:15if our public schools are doing
- 43:17great, then that's their.
- 43:18Then parents are going to say,
- 43:20hey, this is great for my
- 43:22children. But if it's not
- 43:24working, then kids does or it
- 43:27should be about what each
- 43:28student needs and by allowing
- 43:29that we actually make our
- 43:30public system better, we make
- 43:32them perform better and we make
- 43:32it more efficient. We've seen
- 43:35this in other states. They've
- 43:38spent less than Kentucky in
- 43:39many cases and gotten a better
- 43:40result like Florida. So it's
- 43:43competition work. So why
- 43:44wouldn't work and the education
- 43:45space? Why would it help all
- 43:46boats rise if you have this
- 43:47competition from private
- 43:49schools, why would help
- 43:50publicists?
- 43:50>> Because it's going to take
- 43:51resources from the system that
- 43:52we have work. We don't have
- 43:56endless resources.
- 43:56>> To to sort of divide among
- 43:59both public and private
- 44:00systems.
- 44:00>> If we if we would provide
- 44:03vouchers to the 58,000 kids
- 44:04already in private school in
- 44:05Kentucky, which is exactly
- 44:06what's happening in other
- 44:08states. That would be hundreds
- 44:08of millions of dollars. Where
- 44:09is that going to come from?
- 44:10I haven't heard anybody talk
- 44:14about raising taxes or this
- 44:15magic pot of money it's going
- 44:16to come from. It's going to
- 44:18come out of those schools.
- 44:20And so it's going to be they're
- 44:21going to be less able to do the
- 44:24kind of things that that that
- 44:24we need them to do. And in
- 44:25public schools are required
- 44:28to accept all students. They
- 44:28required to do everything they
- 44:32can to serve them. When they
- 44:33win. Their resources are
- 44:33reduced which they already have
- 44:34been even before vouchers and
- 44:37will be even more. So after
- 44:38vouchers, if this amendment
- 44:40were to pass, it is going to
- 44:41be harder for them to serve
- 44:41every child to the to the
- 44:44degree that we need them to.
- 44:45>> So this that came in earlier
- 44:47this evening from Lexington
- 44:49viewer. If amendment 2 passes
- 44:50and parents can get vouchers
- 44:52for any private school. They
- 44:54want. Will that allow parents
- 44:55to use their public tax dollars
- 44:56to pay for schools that teach
- 44:59things like the Earth? It's
- 44:59flat. And we've gotten a few
- 45:03questions about ideologies and
- 45:05religiosity in their kids being
- 45:07exposed to that. And that being
- 45:10funded through public dollars
- 45:11again, I think parents should
- 45:11be able to send their children
- 45:14to school. That's not going to
- 45:15undermine their values,
- 45:16whatever those are.
- 45:19>> And that could be a whole
- 45:20list of things. Whether it's
- 45:21we're talking about religious
- 45:23values, cultural values, they
- 45:24should have that option.
- 45:25They should not be forced to
- 45:26do. We think really the parent
- 45:28should be forced to send their
- 45:30child to a school that doesn't
- 45:32support their values or their
- 45:36beliefs or doesn't properly a
- 45:38just so if a as a mater of
- 45:40Black Lives Matter, it should
- 45:42be funded. The is one that we
- 45:44do office. It was exactly
- 45:45because I remember the
- 45:45difference in the public and
- 45:47nonpublic school is the
- 45:48accountability factor in the
- 45:49greatest accountability is.
- 45:51>> Those are schools of choice.
- 45:52Parents choose to send their
- 45:55children to those schools.
- 45:56And if they choose not to the
- 45:58school doesn't exist. That's
- 45:59the greatest level of
- 46:00accountability I can think of.
- 46:04>> For an economic one I
- 46:05appreciate the bit. I think
- 46:06there's something very
- 46:07important to understand here.
- 46:09Mister Bailey keeps talking
- 46:09about vouchers, understand he's
- 46:11very passionate about that
- 46:12issue. But let's be very clear
- 46:14this this is not a voucher
- 46:15program. This amendment does
- 46:16not make any policy. This
- 46:17amendment does not institute
- 46:19vouchers. That does not choir
- 46:20vouchers. There will not
- 46:21magically the vouchers the day
- 46:24after this passes. All this
- 46:27does again is it puts the ball
- 46:27in the court of the Legislature
- 46:30to make policy if the
- 46:31Legislature decides to make
- 46:34to cry about yours, then we'll
- 46:35have a system like that.
- 46:37If they don't, we won't.
- 46:38This amendment has nothing to
- 46:41do with vouchers. All this
- 46:41amendment does is it sets the
- 46:42stage for the legislature to be
- 46:47able to make education policy
- 46:48unfettered of any restrictions
- 46:50were put on the 18 90's.
- 46:51If there's to be a voucher
- 46:51program. That's a policy
- 46:53question for the Legislature.
- 46:56This amendment does not address
- 46:57that. It does not make that
- 46:58decision. It may never come to
- 47:00pass that we have actors in
- 47:02Kentucky. So I understand
- 47:03Mister Bailey passion about it.
- 47:04But that's that's like that's
- 47:05comparing apples and oranges.
- 47:06We have about your program on
- 47:07the books. It was it was passed
- 47:11in 2021. It was this is a tax
- 47:12credit program. It was tossed
- 47:13out by the Supreme Court
- 47:14unanimously unanimously about
- 47:15for violating our commitment to
- 47:18>> a public education. And it's
- 47:19still in the General Assembly
- 47:20has not repealed it. So we know
- 47:21what they're going to. They've
- 47:23already put it into law.
- 47:25They wanted. It's a voucher
- 47:26program. It's not even if you
- 47:29look at other states that don't
- 47:30have the constitutional
- 47:31protections for public
- 47:32education that Kentucky has.
- 47:33They started with a small
- 47:34targeted program like that one.
- 47:35And they've expanded them over
- 47:38the last year. So so the idea
- 47:40that they want that this
- 47:44amendment would overturn 130
- 47:45year commitment to public
- 47:47education. And they're not
- 47:48going to create a new policy on
- 47:49them and they're not going to
- 47:50do anything with a dramatic
- 47:51change to the Constitution.
- 47:54I think it's hard to buy this
- 47:55is this is it. This is here for
- 47:56a reason for not doing
- 47:57anything. We cannot make any
- 47:58changes. The think there is not
- 47:59any room for discussion and
- 48:01debate. That's what
- 48:02>> this amendment will simply
- 48:02allow, that we can't even have
- 48:05that debate right now. So what
- 48:05what is the problem when are
- 48:08you afraid of that? We might
- 48:09have some changes to even if
- 48:11it's going to answer that.
- 48:12That might benefit students.
- 48:15You KET talking about
- 48:15unfettered. That would be
- 48:16unfettered the be unfettered by
- 48:18our Constitution.
- 48:20>> They would have unfettered
- 48:22unchecked power to do what they
- 48:24want with our public schools to
- 48:26make any policy want without.
- 48:27You're right. It's not. They
- 48:28haven't said it's about
- 48:28vouchers. We're going to give
- 48:30them the unfettered unchecked
- 48:36power. Something.
- 48:40But no, it was Meals would mean
- 48:41we know. Mister Bailey's point
- 48:43they did in 2021 past
- 48:43education. Opportunity
- 48:46accounts, right? Well, that
- 48:47>> they did. Yeah. And that
- 48:47was that was so why would they
- 48:50do? That's not a voucher
- 48:51program, though. They may very
- 48:52well do it. But my point is all
- 48:54this does is it gives the
- 48:56legislature the opportunity to
- 48:57make policy for itself versus
- 48:59having options taken away from
- 49:01it. And of course, there will
- 49:02still be other constitutional
- 49:04restrictions mean there are
- 49:05there things that the
- 49:06government cannot do just
- 49:08because, you know, you've got
- 49:08all the the bill of rights.
- 49:10You got all these restrictions
- 49:11that the government cannot
- 49:12transgress. So those are all
- 49:13still be there. You'll still
- 49:13have an obligation to fund
- 49:15public schools that will still
- 49:17be there. That will still
- 49:17happen. Section one. 83 is not
- 49:20going off. The books are a lot
- 49:20of laws on the books that are
- 49:23not withstood every year.
- 49:24The legislature.
- 49:25>> And that there's no right
- 49:26prevent them from
- 49:28notwithstanding that 6, the
- 49:28cause. That's right. And the
- 49:29Commonwealth does not fall to
- 49:30pieces because that happens.
- 49:32The Legislature has free free
- 49:34rein to set policy on most
- 49:35things. And it does a pretty
- 49:37good job. It has. It has free
- 49:38rein to set to set the criminal
- 49:41justice policy that works out.
- 49:44Fine has free rein to set tax
- 49:46policy had free rein also to
- 49:48make ensure that any private
- 49:49school that came in Kentucky
- 49:49will not discriminate on the
- 49:53basis of race, gender.
- 49:54Religion. Sorry. That's right.
- 49:57And they decided not to do
- 49:58that. I'm not. I'm not. And
- 49:59how well I'm saying that you
- 50:01say that Russell legislatures.
- 50:04I'm sure there are nice people
- 50:07collectively they voted to
- 50:09allow discrimination in private
- 50:10school. I'm not sure if you're
- 50:11talking about because it's it's
- 50:13illegal to discriminate on
- 50:15those bases. House Bill 570, 32
- 50:16years ago. But you can't you
- 50:18can't discriminate on the basis
- 50:20of race religion. You just you
- 50:22can't. Yeah. to shun. And there
- 50:23was an amendment to the bill
- 50:25that was voted on the floor.
- 50:26>> That would prohibit
- 50:28discrimination. It was voted
- 50:30down. Many of these programs in
- 50:33other states do not have a
- 50:34anti-discrimination provisions.
- 50:35About half of them don't have
- 50:38anything about race that
- 50:40they're They they require
- 50:41people to suspend their rights
- 50:42as far as disabilities. Concern
- 50:43to to take the voucher and go
- 50:46to the private school. There
- 50:47are all kinds of ways in which
- 50:48they they do not that the whole
- 50:50purpose of of wanting to change
- 50:52the Constitution to fund as
- 50:54fun schools outside of that
- 50:58common schools is to remove
- 50:59public a kind of, you know,
- 51:00when you say suspend their
- 51:01right. So when someone deals
- 51:02with disabilities, what do you
- 51:02mean by that? That they don't
- 51:05have to?
- 51:07>> Require certain require
- 51:08certain accommodations. There's
- 51:09federal law associated with
- 51:10that in these these are private
- 51:12institutions that they can do
- 51:14that and and they will be in.
- 51:14They can do that now. But the
- 51:16difference is if this was to
- 51:18pass.
- 51:18>> And the policies with a
- 51:19voucher policy would be put in
- 51:20place, which is what we should
- 51:20expect because it's already on
- 51:23the books. Is it they would be
- 51:24funded with public tax dollars
- 51:25and this should be just a
- 51:29different level of scrutiny in
- 51:30a kind of this last week was
- 51:31happening. And that's just
- 51:32against the constitution that
- 51:33says the so that's that's just
- 51:34that's just a scare tactic
- 51:36that's never going to come to
- 51:37for signs White. Why if I'm a
- 51:37parent with a special needs
- 51:39student in I need that and they
- 51:40need that. I'm not I'm not
- 51:40going to choose that school.
- 51:44>> Here's here's the point I
- 51:44want to make their is school
- 51:45choice of Mister Bailey is
- 51:48right. We do have school choice
- 51:49in Kentucky if you're wealthy.
- 51:50Yeah, school, you can. You can
- 51:52send your child to a private
- 51:53school and write the check for
- 51:55the tuition.
- 51:56>> Do you dispute the fact that
- 51:5980% of those would already go
- 52:02to private and those numbers
- 52:03from the other states were
- 52:04right. But I did when I I
- 52:04there. Yes, that's I don't.
- 52:06That's not right. We're seeing
- 52:09tremendous enters the bone
- 52:12middle and lower income
- 52:13families and kids hockey in in
- 52:13not well in other states.
- 52:14That was the court. That was
- 52:16the point about weather.
- 52:17People were in other states
- 52:19where wealthy people are using
- 52:21We're using the scholarships.
- 52:23But the other point not all
- 52:24school choices. The same.
- 52:27What about public charter
- 52:29Mister Bailey has has opposed
- 52:31even having that. That's just
- 52:32simply a different way of
- 52:34delivering public education.
- 52:35So that's not even involving a
- 52:37voucher or a scholarship.
- 52:39Why? Why such opposition that
- 52:40doing something different in
- 52:43trying new ideas? This question
- 52:45real quickly from would like to
- 52:47know if the members of the
- 52:47panel attended public or
- 52:48private secondary schools.
- 52:51>> Public school.
- 52:51>> Public school public school.
- 52:54And this isn't going to change
- 52:56that. This is this is giving
- 52:56this is expanding the options
- 53:00for parents. If you like your
- 53:01public school, this is not
- 53:02going to be, in fact as chance
- 53:04that this amendment is not
- 53:05going to set policy at all.
- 53:06It's going to simply allow us
- 53:08to have that discussion.
- 53:09And I don't know why there
- 53:10would be such fire with that.
- 53:12>> As you mentioned earlier,
- 53:14why stop there? Why didn't you
- 53:17wouldn't just give the
- 53:17allowance without doing
- 53:19something with the permission
- 53:21has been granted by what what
- 53:21is done is still to be decided.
- 53:23What is that now? We have a
- 53:25some of that. Would you agree
- 53:26that there's been some
- 53:28discussion to give path forward
- 53:30on the options available
- 53:31education opportunity accounts
- 53:32about issues? I think you'd be
- 53:35wrong not to with only 1, 3 of
- 53:36our kids reading professionally
- 53:37and they could be wrong not to
- 53:38talk about new ideas, but
- 53:39what's what that's going to be?
- 53:40I think we need to just have a
- 53:44debate about it. 45 states have
- 53:46public charter schools. 33
- 53:46states have nonpublic school
- 53:47choice options. The sky has
- 53:51fallen in. It's many of their
- 53:52public systems have done better
- 53:54and spent less. So as we round
- 53:54out here, it just got a couple
- 53:56of minutes remaining. We
- 53:57mentioned at the top of the
- 53:58show that this is one of the
- 53:59most interesting items on the
- 54:00Kentucky ballot this year.
- 54:01We expect to see a lot of money
- 54:03on both sides of the on this
- 54:05issue to to push it across.
- 54:07I do want to give you Mister
- 54:08offered. If you want to give a
- 54:11last pitch for, I'm making the
- 54:12case for why voters in November
- 54:14should reject amendment.
- 54:14What would you say? I love your
- 54:16speech.
- 54:18>> Voters should reject this
- 54:20amendment because it not
- 54:21withstand 7 sections of our
- 54:23Constitution. It gives our
- 54:25Legislature unfettered power
- 54:29to not fund our schools to not
- 54:29have referendums on school,
- 54:33financial issues.
- 54:35People in Kentucky trust their
- 54:36public schools that they trust
- 54:38public educators. I think
- 54:40that's going to show up in the
- 54:41event.
- 54:42>> we also think, as I
- 54:43mentioned in the intro that
- 54:45this is not going to be red
- 54:46versus blue Republican versus
- 54:47Democrat, but urban versus
- 54:47rule. Mister Meredith, you care
- 54:50to chime in on that.
- 54:52>> Yes, a good question.
- 54:53And I am I'm originally from a
- 54:55ruel part of the state and a
- 54:58proud graduate of Grayson
- 54:59County High School. if that may
- 55:00very well be the but I think
- 55:03people across
- 55:05the state recognize the value
- 55:07in having 19th century
- 55:09restrictions removed from
- 55:11educational policy and they
- 55:12recognize the value in allowing
- 55:13their legislators to act on
- 55:15their behalf and have their
- 55:16trust and their confidence
- 55:18allowing those people to make
- 55:19the decisions that they think
- 55:20will best benefit the
- 55:22Commonwealth.
- 55:27One got 20 seconds. Mister Bay,
- 55:28there's reasons you put things
- 55:30in the These are core The bill
- 55:31of Rights was mentioned
- 55:32earlier. We don't just throw
- 55:33that up to the Legislature to
- 55:34vote on.
- 55:35>> In the same way, public
- 55:36education has long been a
- 55:37communique. Me give you the
- 55:40final word. Mister Waters We
- 55:41need to focus on students
- 55:43rather than systems and this
- 55:46can be a both and this can be
- 55:49expanding ideas. New ideas for
- 55:49education. And we need that
- 55:52in Kentucky. According to our
- 55:53outcomes.
- 55:53>> All right. Good discussion,
- 55:55very robust conversation will
- 55:56probably have it again before
- 55:58the election November next week
- 55:59on Kentucky. Light will look
- 56:01at the state of the media.
- 56:02That's going to be a good one.
- 56:03Be sure to join us each week
- 56:04night as well at 6.30, Eastern
- 56:075.30, central for Kentucky
- 56:08Edition, we break down these
- 56:08types of issues in the
- 56:10activities going on around them
- 56:12and then join Bill Bryant and a
- 56:13team working journalist to
- 56:15discuss the News of the week on
- 56:16comment on Kentucky Friday at 8
- 56:18Eastern 7 central. Thank you so
- 56:19much for watching Kentucky
- 56:21tonight. I'm Renee Shaw and
- 56:21I'll see you tomorrow night for
- 56:22Kentucky. Addition, take good
- 56:24care.
- 56:24♪
- 56:29♪
- 56:33♪
- 56:39♪
- 56:44♪
- 56:49♪