Latest / Interfaiths / When a Hindu Scholar Translated the Quran: Bridges Between Sanskrit and Arabic Sacred Languages
Transcript
- 0:00welcome back to the deep dive we have a uh a
- 0:02really unique stack of documents today yeah this
- 0:05one's different usually we're looking at history
- 0:07or tech or you know the latest science today
- 0:10we're looking at a linguistic high wire act that's
- 0:13a good way to put it and frankly the more i read
- 0:15about this the more i felt like i was watching
- 0:17someone try to defuse a bomb While solving a
- 0:20Rubik's Cube. That is probably the best way to
- 0:23describe it. It's a massive undertaking. We're
- 0:26looking at a specific moment in 1945 where two
- 0:29massive ancient civilizations just collided in
- 0:33the mind of one man. We're talking about the
- 0:35translation of the Holy Quran, a text rooted
- 0:38in, you know, the deserts of Arabia, Semitic
- 0:41language, strict monotheism into Sanskrit, the
- 0:43lush liturgical language of Hinduism and Vedic
- 0:47philosophy. And just to set the stakes here,
- 0:49this is not like translating French into English.
- 0:52You aren't just swapping grammar. You are trying
- 0:55to bridge two completely different operating
- 0:57systems for reality. You've got the one god of
- 1:00the desert. Meaning, well, the pantheon of the
- 1:03subcontinent. Right. And our guide for this is
- 1:06a fascinating paper by Samuel Kutluturk titled
- 1:09The Translation of the Holy Quran into Sanskrit.
- 1:12We're going to focus specifically on one translator,
- 1:14a man named Gunderal Harker, and his translation
- 1:17of just the opening chapter, the Surah Al -Fatiha.
- 1:20Gunderal is the key here. He's our expert witness,
- 1:23so to speak. So the mission for this deep dive
- 1:25is to understand how you explain strict, absolute
- 1:29monotheism. Yeah. Using a vocabulary built for
- 1:33a pantheistic or, you know, a polytheistic worldview.
- 1:36Yeah. How do you rewrite the DNA of a religion
- 1:39using the words of another without, well, breaking
- 1:42both? Precisely. It is a masterclass in cultural
- 1:45mediation. It forces us to ask, are these religions
- 1:48as different as we think? Or is it, at some level,
- 1:51just a language barrier? Okay, so let's start
- 1:54with the context because the where and who here
- 1:56mattered just as much as the what. We're in the
- 1:58Hyderabad Nizamate. Right, pre -independence
- 2:00India. This is a crucial background. The Hyderabad
- 2:03Nizamate was a princely state, effectively its
- 2:05own country within British India. And it had
- 2:08this very specific dynamic. A Muslim ruler, the
- 2:11Nizam, governing a population that was overwhelmingly
- 2:14Hindu. Which, you know, historically speaking,
- 2:16sounds like a recipe for tension. It certainly
- 2:19could be, and often was. But it also created
- 2:21this... Weirdly fertile ground for intellectual
- 2:25exchange. The Nizam wanted his administration
- 2:27to work, and he wanted the culture of the ruling
- 2:30class to be understood by the populace. So into
- 2:33this mix steps Gunderao Harkar. And, I mean,
- 2:36on paper, this guy seems like a walking contradiction.
- 2:39He really does. Born in 1887. He's a Brahmin,
- 2:42so he's from the priestly caste in Hinduism,
- 2:44the guardians of the Vedas. Right. But he isn't
- 2:46sitting in a temple somewhere. He's a munsifa
- 2:49civil judge working for the Muslim king. Wow.
- 2:51So he's a Hindu Brahmin interpreting law for
- 2:54a Muslim administration. And get this, he wasn't
- 2:56just some bureaucrat. He was a bona fide polymath.
- 2:59The sources list his languages, Sanskrit, Telugu,
- 3:03Marathi, English, Persian, and Arabic. And he
- 3:05held the title Vakaspati, right, which is master
- 3:07of eloquence. And Vidyapushana, adorned with
- 3:11knowledge. I mean, this is someone deeply embedded
- 3:14in the Hindu intellectual tradition, deeply respected.
- 3:17Yet he decides to take on the Quran. Now, the
- 3:20source notes that Muslims had been in India since
- 3:22the 9th century. Surely there were translations
- 3:25before 1945. Oh, there were. But they were vernacular
- 3:28translations. You had translations into Persian,
- 3:30Urdu, Sindhi. The day -to -day languages. Exactly.
- 3:33In the 18th century, the scholar Shah Walilo
- 3:36really pushed for people to understand the text
- 3:38in their local language. But Sanskrit, Sanskrit
- 3:41was kind of the final frontier. Why? Was it just
- 3:44too difficult? It wasn't about difficulty. It
- 3:46was about sanctity. Sanskrit was... Sort of the
- 3:49VIP section of languages. It was the exclusive
- 3:52domain of the Hindu clergy, reserved for the
- 3:55Vedas and the Upanishads. Using Sanskrit for
- 3:59a mlechia, or a foreign text, was considered
- 4:01taboo by Orthodox pundits for a very long time.
- 4:04So Gundero isn't just translating, he's almost
- 4:06trespassing in a way, or breaking a seal. Or
- 4:09opening a gate. Okay, so let's get into the text
- 4:34itself. This is where it gets nerdy. and really
- 4:37fun he starts obviously with the bismillah in
- 4:40the name of allah yeah and right out of the gate
- 4:43he hits a wall how do you translate It's the
- 4:45ultimate problem. I mean, if you use a word like
- 4:47Ishvara or Bhagavan, you trigger these immediate
- 4:50associations with Hindu deities. Sure. You say
- 4:53Ishvara and a Hindu reader might picture Shiva.
- 4:56You say Bhagavan. They might think of Krishna
- 4:58or Vishnu beings with forms and myths and families
- 5:01and avatars. Which completely defeats the whole
- 5:04purpose of the Quran's strict formless monotheism.
- 5:07You can't have the reader picturing a blue -skinned
- 5:10god when you're trying to describe the unseen.
- 5:12Exactly. So Gundera bypasses all the popular
- 5:15guides and goes straight to the philosophical
- 5:18core. He chooses the word paramatman. Paramatman.
- 5:21Let's break that down. Okay, so para means supreme
- 5:24or ultimate. Okay. And atman translates to self,
- 5:28spirit, or soul. So you get the supreme self
- 5:32or the supreme spirit. That feels very... abstract.
- 5:36And that's the point. In Vedantic philosophy,
- 5:39Paramatman is the formless, absolute reality.
- 5:42It's the ground of all being. It doesn't have
- 5:44a face. It doesn't have a statue. It encompasses
- 5:47everything. So by choosing that word, he's stripping
- 5:49away all the anthropomorphic baggage. He is aligning
- 5:52the Islamic definition of God uncreated, formless,
- 5:55absolute, with the highest abstract concept in
- 5:58Hinduism. He's saying, look, the all of the Quran
- 6:01is the same reality as the paramatman of the
- 6:03Upanishads. That is a massive theological bridge
- 6:06to build with just one word. It's like he's saying,
- 6:08we aren't talking about your gods versus my God.
- 6:10We are talking about the source. Exactly. But
- 6:12then he immediately runs into the next phrase,
- 6:14Rab al -Alamin, Lord of the Worlds. And here,
- 6:17the source says he does something that made me
- 6:19do a double take. He translates worlds using
- 6:21the concept of Devas. He does. But wait a minute.
- 6:24I thought Deva meant God, like a deity. If he
- 6:27just got rid of the gods to use Paramet Man,
- 6:29why is he bringing Devas back in? In common parlance,
- 6:32yes, Deva means God. But Gunderao is playing
- 6:364D chess here. Okay. He translates Rab al -Alamin
- 6:40as the ruler of the world of humans, animals,
- 6:42and divas. But he clarifies in his commentary
- 6:45that he is not talking about independent gods.
- 6:47So what are they then? He goes back to the etymological
- 6:50root of diva, which is divan meaning to shine
- 6:53or to be luminous. He argues that in this context,
- 6:57divas refers to luminous beings. Luminous beings.
- 7:01That sounds a lot like angels. Exactly. He maps
- 7:04the Islamic concept of angels, beings of light
- 7:06who serve God onto the Sanskrit term diva. He
- 7:09effectively demotes the divas from gods to servants
- 7:12of the paramatman. That is incredibly bold. He's
- 7:15redefining his own religious vocabulary to fit
- 7:17the text. He's telling his readers, you know
- 7:19those beings you worship. In this system, they're
- 7:22the staff, not the boss. It is. He's telling
- 7:24his Hindi readers, in this worldview, the hierarchy
- 7:26is different. The divas exist, but they are created
- 7:29beings. It preserves the Islamic hierarchy, God
- 7:33is supreme, everything else is a creature, while
- 7:36using words that feel familiar. Okay, moving
- 7:38on. We have the famous attributes, ar -rahman
- 7:42and ar -rahim, usually translated as the most
- 7:46gracious, the most merciful. Now, I'll be honest,
- 7:49I've always found these hard to distinguish in
- 7:51English. They just sound like synonyms, you know,
- 7:53two ways of saying nice. They often do in English,
- 7:55yeah. But in Islamic theology, there's a very
- 7:58specific nuance. Rahman is usually understood
- 8:01as general mercy. It exists for everyone. It's
- 8:04the mercy of existence itself. Rahim is specific
- 8:07mercy, often interpreted as mercy for the believers
- 8:10or mercy that responds to an action. So how does
- 8:13Gunderao capture that distinction? Because if
- 8:15English struggles with it, surely Sanskrit has
- 8:17a million words for mercy. He brings in a heavy
- 8:20hitter from Hindu philosophy, the concept of
- 8:22dharma. Dharma. Okay, that's a huge word. Duty,
- 8:25cosmic law, righteousness, the right way of living.
- 8:28All of the above. It's the moral fabric of the
- 8:30universe. Now, for Ahriman, he uses the phrase
- 8:34Aparakaruna Paravara. Aparakaruna Paravara. I'm
- 8:38not going to try saying that five times fast.
- 8:39What does it mean? It translates to the ocean
- 8:42of boundless compassion. Para implies an ocean.
- 8:46a shoreless expanse. He explains in his commentary
- 8:49that this mercy is like the ocean or the rain.
- 8:52It falls on everyone, regardless of their dharma.
- 8:55Regardless of their duty, regardless of whether
- 8:57they're good. Right. It doesn't matter if you're
- 8:59a king, a thief, a believer, or an atheist. The
- 9:02sun shines on you. The rain falls on you. You
- 9:04get to breathe the air. That is Ramat. It is
- 9:07independent of your actions. It's unconditional.
- 9:09And Rahim. For Rahim, he uses Karunavat, which
- 9:13means possessing mercy. But here's the kicker.
- 9:15He distinguishes it by saying this mercy interacts
- 9:18with Dharma. It's the mercy that responds to
- 9:21those who follow the path of righteousness. Ah,
- 9:23I see. So Raman is the operating system of the
- 9:25universe. It just runs, no login required. That's
- 9:28a great way to put it. And Rahim is the user
- 9:30interface. It responds to your input. It does.
- 9:33And by anchoring it in Dharma, he makes it instantly
- 9:36clickable for a Hindu scholar. They understand
- 9:39that some things are cosmic constants and some
- 9:42things are karmic results. He's using their own
- 9:45ethical framework to explain Islamic theology.
- 9:48Speaking of karma, we have to talk about the
- 9:51timeline. Because this seems like the place where
- 9:53the two worldviews would just fundamentally crash
- 9:56and burn. The collision of time, yes. This is
- 9:59probably the hardest part. Because Hinduism is
- 10:02generally cyclical, right? You have Kalpa creation,
- 10:04destruction, rebirth. It's a wheel. You die,
- 10:07you come back. Right. And Islam is linear. Creation,
- 10:10history, judgment day, the end. You can't really
- 10:14merge those. You can't have a little bit of reincarnation
- 10:16in Islamic theology. You have to pick a lane.
- 10:18So what does Gunderao do with the phrase master
- 10:20of the day of judgment? Does he try to fudge
- 10:22it? No, he completely respects the source text.
- 10:25He steps out of the cyclical worldview entirely
- 10:27for this verse. He translates day of judgment
- 10:30as punaruthana divasa. Punaruthana divasa. It
- 10:33literally means the day of rising again, resurrection.
- 10:37And in his notes, he explicitly describes a cosmic
- 10:40dissolution. A singularity where the universe
- 10:43ends. He's very clear. This happens once. But
- 10:47here's where the deep dive aspect really kicks
- 10:49in. He uses a specific word to describe God on
- 10:52that day. Yes. Falaviaka. The giver of fruits.
- 10:56The giver of fruits. Which sounds kind of pleasant,
- 10:58like a guy handing out mangoes. But I suspect
- 11:01it means something else. It does. In Sanskrit
- 11:03philosophy, falafrut is the technical term for
- 11:06the result of an action. It's the output of karma.
- 11:09If you plant a seed, which is an action, it bears
- 11:12fruit. So God is the one who hands out the karmic
- 11:15results at the end. Exactly. He's taking the
- 11:17mechanics of Hindu ethics, cause and effect,
- 11:19karma and phala, and installing them into the
- 11:21Islamic linear timeline. He's saying, on that
- 11:24final day of dissolution, the paramatman becomes
- 11:27the phaladiaka. That is brilliant. He's using
- 11:30the logic of karma to explain the mechanism of
- 11:33judgment day. It removes the arbitrariness. For
- 11:36a Hindu reader, judgment might sound like a king
- 11:39just deciding who he likes, but giving the fruit,
- 11:42that implies justice. You get exactly what you
- 11:46grew. I love that image. It bridges the gap between
- 11:49judgment and consequence. It makes the concept
- 11:51of a final judgment feel less like a courtroom
- 11:54and more like a harvest. It appeals to the Hindu
- 11:57sense of cosmic justice perfectly, even though
- 12:00the timeline itself is completely different.
- 12:02So we've got the supreme self, the luminous beings.
- 12:05The ocean of mercy and the giver of fruits. Now
- 12:08we get to the people. The surah talks about the
- 12:10straight path, Surat al -Mustakim. Which he translates
- 12:13as, Supantha, the good path or beautiful path.
- 12:15And it describes the people on that path as,
- 12:18those upon whom you bestowed favors. And this
- 12:20is where the emotional texture changes. He translates
- 12:23that phrase, those upon whom you bestowed favors,
- 12:25as Priya. Meaning? Beloveds. That's surprisingly
- 12:29intimate. The path of the beloveds. It connects
- 12:32directly to the Bhakti tradition in Hinduism.
- 12:34You have to remember, Hinduism isn't just dry
- 12:37philosophy. You have the whole bhakti movement,
- 12:40the path of loving devotion. It's personal. It's
- 12:43emotional. By using priya, Gunderao is suggesting
- 12:47that the favor of the Quran isn't just guidance
- 12:50or wealth. The favor is being loved by God. It
- 12:53reframes the whole relationship. It's not just
- 12:55master and servant. It's lover and beloved. He
- 12:58calls them exclusive devotees of the supreme.
- 13:01It just adds this layer of warmth that a dry,
- 13:03literal translation might miss. But now, OK,
- 13:07hold on to your hats. We have to go to the dark
- 13:08side, the end of the surah, the path of those
- 13:11who earned wrath and those who went astray. Yes.
- 13:13And this is historically the most difficult part
- 13:16of the text to translate diplomatically. Yeah.
- 13:18Traditional Islamic exegesis often identifies
- 13:21those who earned wrath as the Jews and those
- 13:23who went astray as the Christians. Right. Does
- 13:25Gundero keep that interpretation or does he sort
- 13:28of? scrub it to be polite. He actually keeps
- 13:31it. He references it in his notes, Yehudi and
- 13:34Nasara. But, and this is the biggest aha moment
- 13:38of the entire paper for me, he explains why using
- 13:41formal Indian logic. Indian logic, you mean like
- 13:44a specific school of philosophy? Yes, specifically
- 13:47the Naya school. Naya deals with epistemology,
- 13:50how we know what we know and how we make errors.
- 13:53Gundral uses this toolkit to categorize the wrath
- 13:57and the astray. Okay, walk me through this. How
- 13:59does Indian logic explain wrath? Gundra defines
- 14:02the state of wrath using the term atyantapava.
- 14:05Atyantapava sounds heavy. It means absolute non
- 14:08-existence. In Aya logic, it refers to something
- 14:11that is fundamentally absent. So Gundra argues
- 14:13that this group implies an ontological absence
- 14:16of knowledge regarding the true path. So it's
- 14:19not just that they're bad people, it's that the
- 14:20connection to the truth is broken. Or blocked.
- 14:24Gone. He suggests that due to historical obstinacy
- 14:27or baggage, the capacity to receive the truth
- 14:29has faced a total blockage. It's an absolute
- 14:31absence. The signal isn't getting through at
- 14:33all. And the astray, the Christian. For them,
- 14:36he uses a different logical category. He describes
- 14:39a state where the capacity for knowledge exists,
- 14:42but it's deviated. They are engaging with non
- 14:45-truth. So the receiver works, but it's tuned
- 14:47to the wrong station. Essentially. He argues
- 14:50this is a willful deviation or a misunderstanding
- 14:52rather than the absolute non -existence of the
- 14:55first group. That is wildly sophisticated. He's
- 14:58taking theological condemnation and turning it
- 15:01into an epistemological diagnosis. He's categorizing
- 15:04error. He's saying here is a type one error,
- 15:07absence, and here's a type two error, deviation.
- 15:10It allows a Hindu logician to look at these groups
- 15:12and say, I understand the structural difference
- 15:15between them. rather than just seeing them as
- 15:18bad guys. It really drives home the mission we
- 15:20talked about at the top. He isn't trying to convert
- 15:22the reader to Islam, is he? No, and that is so
- 15:25important. The source emphasizes that Gunderao
- 15:28and other translators like Dr. Satya de Verma,
- 15:30who came later, treated the Quran with deep respect,
- 15:33but also with impartiality. They weren't engaging
- 15:36in polemics. They were looking for the one behind
- 15:38the many. Finding the signal in the noise. Exactly.
- 15:42Dr. Verma, for instance, would quote the Vedas
- 15:44side by side with the Quran in his commentaries.
- 15:46Not to say the Vedas are better or the Quran
- 15:48is better, but to say, look, they are talking
- 15:52about the same ultimate reality. It challenges
- 15:54the way we think about religious boundaries.
- 15:56We usually see them as walls. Gunderao saw them
- 16:00as what? Different dialects. Different dialects
- 16:03of the same spiritual language. He showed that
- 16:05you can express strict Islamic monotheism using
- 16:08the vocabulary of the Vedas without breaking
- 16:11either system. He proved the concepts are translatable,
- 16:14even if the histories are different. It brings
- 16:16me back to that first word he chose, paramatman.
- 16:19The supreme self. It makes you wonder about the
- 16:22sensory experience of religion. If you grew up
- 16:24praying to Paramatman, does that change the flavor
- 16:27of the divinity compared to praying to Allah
- 16:30or God? I think it has to. Words are containers
- 16:33for history and emotion. Paramatman sort of smells
- 16:36like sandalwood and sounds like temple bells.
- 16:39Allah carries the stark, beautiful silence of
- 16:41the desert and the call to prayer. So when you
- 16:43wrap the Quranic concept in the Sanskrit word,
- 16:46you create a fusion flavor, a new way to taste
- 16:49the divine. And maybe that's the ultimate value
- 16:51of translation. It forces you to see your own
- 16:54beliefs through a stranger's eyes. Gunderal Harker
- 16:58gave us a glimpse of what monotheism looks like
- 17:00when it wears the robes of the Vedas. A beautiful
- 17:03thought to end on. From the Hyderabad nizamit
- 17:06to the supreme self, this has been quite a journey.
- 17:09It certainly has. Thanks for diving deep with
- 17:11us. We'll see you on the next one. Stay curious.