Latest / Interfaiths / To Bigotry No Sanction: Pluralism and the American Covenant
Transcript
- 0:00I want you to picture just A morning of profound
- 0:03peace. Right. It's May 18th, 2026, the first
- 0:07day of Dulhija, which is, you know, a deeply
- 0:10sacred time in the Islamic calendar. Yeah, a
- 0:12really important time. Millions across the world
- 0:15are turning their thoughts to Mecca. And locally
- 0:18at the Islamic Center of San Diego, it's this
- 0:20quiet morning of devotion. Children are sitting
- 0:23in the Al -Rashid school classrooms, memorizing
- 0:27surahs. Elders are beginning these sacred 10
- 0:30days. Where, uh... Tradition says mercy descends
- 0:34like rain. Exactly. But then at 1140 a .m., that
- 0:38quiet piece is just completely shattered by the
- 0:40sound of gunfire at the front door. It's just
- 0:42it's devastating. And it highlights this terrifying
- 0:44modern reality. Yeah. Places designed specifically
- 0:47for sanctuary have become, well, ground zero
- 0:49for targeted violence. Yeah. And that's exactly
- 0:52why today we're taking a deep dive into an essay
- 0:54that attempts to map out the anatomy of that
- 0:57violence. Right. It's a really powerful piece.
- 0:59It is. It's titled To Bigotry, No Sanction. And
- 1:07before we get into it, I want to be super clear
- 1:10with you, our listener, right up front. This
- 1:12deep dive touches on some intensely politically
- 1:15charged themes. We're talking Christian nationalism,
- 1:18white supremacist ideology, recent right wing
- 1:21political rallies. Yeah, right. So our goal today
- 1:24is not to take a political side or endorse these
- 1:26movements left or right. We are just acting as
- 1:29like historical detectives. Exactly. Just unpacking
- 1:32the author's data and historical analysis. Right.
- 1:35To see how this modern tragedy in San Diego connects
- 1:37to the actual roots of the American founding.
- 1:40OK, let's unpack this. Let's do it. We need to
- 1:42start with the grim reality of the event itself.
- 1:45The details are just devastating. The perpetrators
- 1:48were two teenage shooters. Yeah, just 17 and
- 1:5018 years old. Right. And three people were killed,
- 1:53including two school staff who tried to shield
- 1:56the children and the security guard who stood
- 1:59his ground at the door. And then the shooters
- 2:01took their own lives blocks away. Leaving behind
- 2:03these notes obsessed with racial pride. While
- 2:06the local community was dealing with that horror,
- 2:09the author points out something happening concurrently
- 2:11on the exact other side of the country. Wait,
- 2:14on the exact same day? Literally the same hour.
- 2:16Over 400 Jewish Federation leaders were arriving
- 2:20in Washington, D .C. Wow. OK. Yeah, they were
- 2:24there lobbying Congress for a billion dollars
- 2:26in federal security funding to protect houses
- 2:28of worship. And the author notes they specifically.
- 2:32explicitly included mosques in that funding request.
- 2:35I mean, for a listener just catching up on the
- 2:37news, it might be easy to view an attack on a
- 2:39mosque and, say, an attack on a synagogue as
- 2:42two totally isolated tragedies. Right, affecting
- 2:45two totally different communities. But right
- 2:46away, Temple Israel of West Bloomfield, which
- 2:49had been attacked just two months prior, they
- 2:52issued a solidarity statement. They realized
- 2:54the threat was basically the same. And the data
- 2:56totally backs this up. The author brings in the
- 2:59FBI's 2023 hate crime statistics. Right. The
- 3:02nearly 12 ,000 incidents. Yeah, record highs.
- 3:06Anti -Jewish incidents hit historic highs and
- 3:09anti -Muslim incidents jumped 49%. Yeah. The
- 3:13author writes this haunting line. He says, the
- 3:15two graphs are the same curve. Same curve. Wow.
- 3:18What's fascinating here is how the author leans
- 3:20on extensive historical scholarship to explain
- 3:23the actual mechanics behind that curve. Like
- 3:26why a white supremacist in 2026 targets both
- 3:29groups. Right. Because historically, you wouldn't
- 3:31necessarily link them like that. Exactly. So
- 3:34he points to Scholar Gill in a jar. who traces
- 3:37this back to 19th century European thought. Okay.
- 3:40So before then, the word Semitic was basically
- 3:43just a linguistic term. It just categorized a
- 3:45family of languages that included Hebrew and
- 3:47Arabic. Just a language group, nothing biological.
- 3:50Right. But then 19th century European pseudoscience
- 3:52started aggressively categorizing humanity into
- 3:56rigid biological races. Oh, right. And they hijacked
- 3:59that linguistic term and basically invented a
- 4:02new racial category called the Semite. Wait,
- 4:04so if I'm understanding this, they basically...
- 4:06basically welded the Jew and the Arab into just
- 4:09a single combined racial block in the European
- 4:11imagination. Yes, that is the crucial mechanism.
- 4:15By creating this single category, 19th century
- 4:19thinkers basically ensure that whatever prejudice,
- 4:22xenophobic rhetoric they threw at one group could
- 4:25just seamlessly be applied to the other. Oh,
- 4:27wow. They were historically engineered to be
- 4:29dual targets of the exact same bigotry. That
- 4:32is wild. And then the author brings in Susanna
- 4:34Heschel's research to show how this evolved in
- 4:37the 20th century. She looks at theological projects
- 4:39in Nazi Germany that tried to de -Judaize Christianity.
- 4:45What does that even mean? Like trying to manufacture
- 4:47an Aryan Jesus. And the author argues that the
- 4:50exact ideological tools forged back then are
- 4:53simply being picked up, dusted off and repurposed
- 4:56by modern white nationalist movements today.
- 4:58OK, so that explains the historical link. The
- 5:01modern execution of this, that's what I'm trying
- 5:03to wrap my head around. Yeah, it's intense. The
- 5:04author mentions journalist Nathan Lane's work,
- 5:06right, showing how digital networks manufacture
- 5:09anti -Muslim hatred by recycling century -old
- 5:12anti -Semitic conspiracy theories. Literally
- 5:14almost word for word, like the protocols of the
- 5:16elders of Zion. Yeah, yes. So if you have these
- 5:19two communities that the general public often
- 5:22views as culturally distinct, maybe even at odds
- 5:25sometimes. How does the Internet manage to recycle
- 5:28the exact same conspiracy for both? Right. It's
- 5:31a paradox. It's like we're watching a single
- 5:33virus mutating to attack two totally different
- 5:36immune systems using the exact same mechanism.
- 5:39That's a really good way to put it. And the primary
- 5:41virus the author identifies today is the great
- 5:43replacement theory. Right. We hear about that
- 5:45a lot. It's the lethal tool driving that shared
- 5:48statistical curve. The premise is this bizarre,
- 5:51hateful fusion. It claims that a global Jewish
- 5:55conspiracy is actively engineering mass Muslim
- 5:59and non -white immigration. To replace the white
- 6:02Christian populations of the West, right? Exactly.
- 6:04Notice how it traps both groups in one overarching
- 6:07narrative. It frames one group as the architect
- 6:10and the other as the invading weapon. Which totally
- 6:12explains the tragic footprint the author maps
- 6:15out. I mean, he lists the Tree of Life Synagogue
- 6:17in Pittsburgh, the Christchurch mosques in New
- 6:20Zealand. The Poway Chabad. Right. And the El
- 6:22Paso Walmart targeting Hispanics and the Buffalo
- 6:25supermarket targeting black shoppers. To the
- 6:28ideology driving these attacks, those aren't
- 6:31separate targets. They are the exact same target
- 6:34drawn by the same imagination. And if this intertwined
- 6:37hatred is so adaptable today, it begs a massive
- 6:40question about the American experiment itself.
- 6:44What exactly was the original American immune
- 6:46system designed to do about this? Oh, that's
- 6:48a great question. The author argues that to understand
- 6:51what that security guard in San Diego actually
- 6:53died defending, we have to look past modern assumptions
- 6:56and look directly at the founder's original blueprints.
- 6:59OK, here's where it gets really interesting,
- 7:01because, I mean, you turn on the television today
- 7:03and there is a very vocal modern narrative insisting
- 7:07the U .S. was designed exclusively as a Christian
- 7:09nation. Right. You hear that everywhere. But
- 7:11the author goes straight to the primary texts,
- 7:13and they paint a wildly different picture. Take
- 7:16George Washington, for example. Yeah, his 1790
- 7:18letter. Exactly. In 1790, he wrote to the Touro
- 7:22Synagogue in Rhode Island, the oldest standing
- 7:24synagogue in North America. The congregation
- 7:27had praised a government that gives to bigotry
- 7:30no sanction, to persecution no assistance, and
- 7:33Washington took that exact phrase and wrote it
- 7:36back to them as official policy. We really need
- 7:39to pause on Washington's letter here because
- 7:41the author highlights a philosophical distinction
- 7:43that is vital for you, the listener, to understand.
- 7:47Okay, what's the distinction? Washington explicitly
- 7:49stated that the United States government was
- 7:51not built on the concept of toleration. Wait,
- 7:55isn't toleration a good thing? Well, back then,
- 7:58toleration was the language of a powerful, indulgent
- 8:01majority graciously allowing a minority to exist.
- 8:05It implies the power to revoke your safety stays
- 8:08with the ruling class. Oh, I see. So it's basically
- 8:11the difference between a landlord letting you
- 8:13stay in an apartment rent -free because they're
- 8:15feeling generous versus you actually owning the
- 8:18deed to the house yourself. Exactly. Because
- 8:20if it's just toleration, the landlord can change
- 8:22the locks tomorrow. That analogy hits the nail
- 8:24on the head. The founders were rejecting the
- 8:27landlord model. They were codifying natural rights.
- 8:30Right. They believed the government doesn't grant
- 8:32you the right to your conscience. You are born
- 8:34with it. And the government is legally forced
- 8:37to protect it. Wow. Furthermore, when Washington
- 8:40addressed the synagogue as the children of the
- 8:43sock of Abraham, the author notes he was using
- 8:46a broad theological vocabulary that inherently
- 8:49included the descendants of Ishmael, which means
- 8:52Muslims. And he didn't just use this language
- 8:55in like lofty public letters either. No, he used
- 8:57it in everyday life. Yeah. In 1784, he wrote
- 9:01a memo about hiring craftsmen to work at Mount
- 9:04Vernon. And he explicitly instructed his manager
- 9:07that he didn't care where the workers were from.
- 9:10Right. He literally wrote they could be Mohammedans,
- 9:12Jews or Christians of. any sect, or they may
- 9:15be atheists. Yeah. Mohammedans being the heiress
- 9:18term for Muslims. Exactly. This wasn't a big
- 9:20speech. It was a hiring memo. It was just how
- 9:23he practically operated. And Thomas Jefferson
- 9:25was fighting the exact same battle on a legislative
- 9:27level. The author brings up the 1786 Virginia
- 9:30statute for establishing religious freedom. This
- 9:33wasn't a smooth process. Right. There was a documented
- 9:35legislative fight. an amendment was proposed
- 9:38to insert the name of Jesus Christ into the preamble
- 9:41of the law. Which would have basically made it
- 9:43a uniquely Christian document. Right. But Jefferson
- 9:46recalled later in his autobiography that this
- 9:48amendment was rejected by a great majority. And
- 9:51he was very clear about why they rejected it,
- 9:53too. He wrote that the legislature intentionally
- 9:55meant to protect the Jew and the Gentile, the
- 9:59Christian and the Mohammedan, the Hindu and the
- 10:01infidel. Yeah. So you have founders explicitly,
- 10:05casually name -dropping Muslims and Hindus in
- 10:08state legislature debates in the 1780s just to
- 10:12ensure they were legally protected. It's amazing.
- 10:15And James Madison took it further in his 1785
- 10:18memorial and remonstrance. He warned against
- 10:20using tax dollars to support Christian teachers,
- 10:23calling any state establishment of religion the
- 10:25first experiment on our liberties. And Benjamin
- 10:28Franklin, famously, helped build a preaching
- 10:31hall in Philadelphia explicitly open to any faith.
- 10:35Franklin noted that if the Mufti of Constantinople
- 10:38wanted to send a missionary to preach Islam to
- 10:40them, the pulpit was his to use. OK, so we have
- 10:43personal letters, hiring memos, state laws. But
- 10:46the author points out that this all culminates
- 10:48in a legally binding federal document. Yes. One
- 10:51that firmly settles the historical debate about
- 10:54the nature of the U .S. government. The Treaty
- 10:56of Tripoli. Right. Negotiated in 1796 under Washington
- 11:00and signed by John Adams in 1797. Article 11
- 11:04is the crucial text here. Right. It states, and
- 11:07I quote, as the government of the United States
- 11:09of America is not in any sense founded on the
- 11:11Christian religion. It is a definitive legal
- 11:13declaration, not in any sense. I mean, that feels
- 11:16like a massive historical contradiction to the
- 11:19rhetoric we hear today. Completely. It's literally
- 11:21like finding a 250 -year -old receipt that completely
- 11:24settles a modern heated argument. But why does
- 11:27this decisive primary source get overlooked today?
- 11:30Did it cause some massive uproar back then? Well.
- 11:33If we connect this to the bigger picture, it
- 11:36often gets overlooked today because it complicates
- 11:38a much simpler, emotionally resonant political
- 11:41narrative. That makes sense. But back in 1797,
- 11:45there was virtually no public pushback. It wasn't
- 11:48some obscure document discovered centuries later.
- 11:51It was a public declaration to a Muslim sovereign
- 11:53printed in full in American newspapers. Wow.
- 11:57And most importantly, it was ratified unanimously
- 12:00by the United States Senate. The founders and
- 12:03the public didn't view a non -Christian government
- 12:05as controversial. They viewed it as the entire
- 12:08point of their constitutional project. The author
- 12:11also cites scholarship by Denise Spellberg, which
- 12:14adds even more context to that. Yeah, her work
- 12:16is great. She shows that Jefferson actually owned
- 12:18and read a copy of the Koran. And during the
- 12:21ratification debates for the Constitution, the
- 12:23possibility of a Muslim or Catholic president
- 12:25wasn't just some hypothetical thought experiment.
- 12:27Right. It was a live, active debate. They knew
- 12:29exactly the kind of pluralistic structure they
- 12:32were building, and they built it anyway. And
- 12:34this historical bedrock brings the author to
- 12:37the stark contrast we face today, exactly as
- 12:40the United States approaches its 250th anniversary
- 12:43in 2026. He outlines a confrontation between
- 12:46two very different visions for the country's
- 12:48future. Right. And the author details this political
- 12:51rally called Rededicate 250 that took place in
- 12:54Washington, D .C. on May 17th. Literally the
- 12:58day before the San Diego mosque shooting. Exactly.
- 13:01The essay points out the event featured a prerecorded
- 13:04video from President Trump reading scripture,
- 13:06a massive white cross on the stage, and a speaker
- 13:10lineup drawn almost entirely from one specific
- 13:13stream of American Christianity. Yeah, excluding
- 13:15almost everyone else. Muslims, mainline Protestants,
- 13:19historically black denominations, Hindus, seeks
- 13:22the author notes they were all excluded, save
- 13:24for one Orthodox rabbi. The author uses this
- 13:27rally to illustrate what he identifies as a Christian
- 13:29nationalist vision for America's 250th anniversary.
- 13:32It's basically an attempt to legally and culturally
- 13:34rededicate America to a sectarian founding that,
- 13:37based on the Toro letter, the Virginia statute,
- 13:39and the Treaty of Tripoli, it never actually
- 13:41had. But the author doesn't just critique this
- 13:44vision. He uses sociological data to explain
- 13:47how it functions. And this is where we get into
- 13:50the research of Andrew Whitehead and Samuel Perry.
- 13:52And their findings are incredibly counterintuitive.
- 13:55Deeply counterintuitive. So Whitehead and Perry
- 13:58conduct expansive sociological surveys to measure
- 14:01Christian nationalism. OK. They ask respondents
- 14:04questions like, should the federal government
- 14:07declare the U .S. a Christian nation? Or. Should
- 14:11the government advocate Christian values? And
- 14:13what did they find? What their data reveals is
- 14:16that Christian nationalism often acts as a substitute
- 14:19for ordinary religious practice. Wait, a substitute?
- 14:22What does that mean in practical terms? It means
- 14:25that the people who score highest on Christian
- 14:27nationalist scales are frequently not the people
- 14:29sitting in church every Sunday. Yeah. In fact,
- 14:33their data shows that as Americans become more
- 14:35genuinely religious through standard measures
- 14:37like frequent prayer and regular worship attendance,
- 14:40they actually move away from these nationalist
- 14:42views. That is fascinating. Right. Christian
- 14:45nationalism in this context isn't about theology
- 14:48or personal piety. It is an identity marker.
- 14:50It's about drawing a hard boundary around who
- 14:54belongs in the country and who doesn't. The author
- 14:56also cites Philip Gorski and Samuel Perry, right?
- 14:59They demonstrate that when you fuse the flag
- 15:02and the cross into a single political identity,
- 15:05you create a politics that inherently requires
- 15:08enemies to function. Exactly. Because if your
- 15:11national identity is defined by a specific religious
- 15:13dominance, you constantly need an external threat
- 15:17like refugees or minority faiths just to justify
- 15:20maintaining that dominance. Yep. It demands an
- 15:22enemy. So what does this all mean? If one vision
- 15:25requires enemies to sustain itself, it seems
- 15:27like the founder's vision is the exact inverse.
- 15:30Precisely. A republic that gives to bigotry no
- 15:33sanction doesn't need an enemy. It just needs
- 15:36active citizens committed to a shared legal framework.
- 15:39And the author highlights the tragic stakes of
- 15:41these competing visions. The first rededication,
- 15:44the exclusionary narrative, creates an environment
- 15:46of hostility that inevitably leaves a guard to
- 15:48die at a mosque door. Yeah. The second rededication
- 15:51to the actual... founding documents to natural
- 15:53rights and pluralism is the republic that the
- 15:57guard actually died descending. That is the core
- 15:59tension of the essay right there. But, you know,
- 16:01the author doesn't leave us in that heavy conflict.
- 16:03No, he doesn't. He transitions to something deeply
- 16:06personal. He offers a solution for how we maintain
- 16:09that shared civic space today. And surprisingly,
- 16:12he builds it on ancient theological traditions.
- 16:15Yeah, the author reveals his own background here.
- 16:17He's a Muslim preacher in Louisiana. And after
- 16:20the geopolitical trauma of October 7, 2023, he
- 16:24helped co -found an interfaith network in Miami.
- 16:27Wow. And this network wasn't built on ignoring
- 16:29differences. It was built painstakingly by Jews
- 16:32and Muslims sitting together in their shared
- 16:34grief. He makes this profound. observation about
- 16:37the process. What does he say? He writes that
- 16:39when ordinary American Jews and Muslims sit together
- 16:41in pain, they do not become each other. They
- 16:44become more themselves. That is beautiful. And
- 16:47to explain how this works structurally, he points
- 16:50to ancient linguistic and cultural concepts of
- 16:53covenant, right? In Hebrew, the word for this
- 16:55binding agreement is Brit. In Arabic, the parallel
- 16:58concept is mithak. He takes us all the way back
- 17:01to the year 622 CE when the Prophet Muhammad
- 17:04arrived in the city of Medina. He drafted what
- 17:07historians call the Constitution of Medina. This
- 17:10is a vital historical comparison. The Constitution
- 17:13of Medina was a document that bound together
- 17:15early Muslims, various Jewish tribes, and pagan
- 17:18clans into a single political community under
- 17:21a shared law. The genius of it was that it wasn't
- 17:24a melting pot, and it wasn't about forcing anyone
- 17:27to agree on theology. It was a civic... Mutual
- 17:30Defense Pact. Each community kept its faith.
- 17:32No one was forced to convert, but all were legally
- 17:35bound to mutually defend the city against outside
- 17:38threats. The author draws a direct line from
- 17:40622 CE to 1787. He argues that the U .S. founders,
- 17:45maybe without even realizing they were echoing
- 17:47an ancient Abrahamic concept, basically built
- 17:49a modern Mishak in Philadelphia. They built it
- 17:52using enlightenment language of natural rights.
- 17:54But the structural DNA is the exact same civic
- 17:58covenant. It is a legally binding agreement that
- 18:01we don't have to worship the same way, but we
- 18:03will mutually defend each other's right to exist
- 18:06safely. It's literally like finding out the blueprints
- 18:09for the house you live in were drafted centuries
- 18:11before the country even existed. This raises
- 18:14an important question, though, about how we view
- 18:16our own safety today. The author connects this
- 18:19ancient blueprint directly back to the tragedy
- 18:22in San Diego. Right. That security guard at the
- 18:25Islamic Center, the rabbi in West Bloomfield,
- 18:27the Sikh Grandi in Oak Creek, Wisconsin, they
- 18:30all rely on this exact same ancient shared civic
- 18:34covenant. It is the only mechanism that allows
- 18:37them to sit under their own vine and fig tree
- 18:39without fear. We've covered an immense amount
- 18:41of ground today. For you, the listener, trying
- 18:43to map this all out, we started with the heartbreaking
- 18:46loss at the Islamic Center of San Diego. Yeah.
- 18:48We explored the terrifying sociological data
- 18:51showing how anti -Jewish and anti -Muslim hate
- 18:53crimes are inextricably linked by modern white
- 18:56supremacist ideologies. The same curve. Right.
- 18:59We traveled back to read the unapologetic, crystal
- 19:02clear words of Washington, Jefferson, and the
- 19:05unanimous Treaty of Tripoli, proving the founders
- 19:08intentionally designed a pluralistic republic.
- 19:10Yes. And we ended on this ancient concept of
- 19:14a shared civic covenant, a methek, built on mutual
- 19:18defense. It serves as a powerful reminder that
- 19:21the tools to fix our current civic fractures,
- 19:24well, they aren't something we have to invent
- 19:26from scratch in 2026. The blueprint already exists.
- 19:29It is the very foundation the country was built
- 19:31upon. And this matters deeply to you listening
- 19:34right now. Whether you were commuting, prepping
- 19:36for a meeting, or just trying to navigate the
- 19:38anxiety of the daily news cycle, the freedom
- 19:41for you to safely be whoever you are, to worship
- 19:44how you want, or to not worship at all without
- 19:46fear of violence is entirely reliant. on us collectively
- 19:49remembering and enforcing this 250 -year -old
- 19:52covenant. It really is. It isn't just a history
- 19:55lesson. It is the active legal and cultural shield
- 19:57protecting your daily life. And the author focuses
- 20:00beautifully on how historical physical texts
- 20:03like the Constitution of Medina and the U .S.
- 20:07Constitution were designed to protect geographic
- 20:10physical communities. It was fundamentally about
- 20:13defending the city, defending the actual neighbors
- 20:15down the street from physical harm. Which leaves
- 20:18us with a lingering thought to chew on after
- 20:21this deep dive is over. In our increasingly secular
- 20:24digital age, our communities are so often online
- 20:27rather than physical. Yeah, that's so true. We
- 20:30exist in digital spaces where our neighbors are
- 20:32anonymous avatars instead of the people next
- 20:34door. So if the original Mabach and the U .S.
- 20:37Constitution were built to protect physical bodies
- 20:39in physical cities, how do we enforce a covenant
- 20:42of mutual protection in a digital world? Wow.
- 20:45How do we give to bigotry no sanction when the
- 20:47bigotry is algorithmic and the community is virtual?
- 20:50It might be the greatest structural challenge.
- 20:52us for public faces in its next 250 years. It
- 20:55just might be. But as we navigate that digital
- 20:58frontier, the author reminds us we must never
- 21:00forget the physical reality where this all begins
- 21:03and ends. We must return to the image of the
- 21:05first day of vushidja, the dust of the prayer
- 21:07rug, the children memorizing suras, and the profound
- 21:11enduring debt we owe to the guard at the door.