Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 21)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:06where we left off with the Alex LaCosta interview with
- 0:09the OIG inspectors. Question. Let's just move to Exhibit forty six.
- 0:14This is an email from misredacted to you and redacted
- 0:18discussing how she has interviewed some victims that day. There
- 0:21is a mention that one of the victims said that
- 0:24you would rather not get any money and she'd have
- 0:26she would rather have Epstein spend a significant time in jail.
- 0:30Did that piece of information go into your character list
- 0:33at all about how the case should be resolved? Answer? So, again,
- 0:37not based on recollection, because this is maybe, if not
- 0:41twelve eleven years ago. Question. Okay, but at this point
- 0:44there had been an agreement, the agreement was signed, it
- 0:47was being reviewed. Based on this email, we're trying to
- 0:50get and expedite the Criminal Division because I see it
- 0:54says please reach to redacted to make her decision. And
- 0:58I think at this point, as I've said, if we
- 1:00knew earlier, if we knew that this was going to
- 1:02go this long and take all of this, I think
- 1:05we may have approached the case differently, but we were
- 1:08so far along on this there was a signed agreement.
- 1:11The United States can unwind an agreement just because it's
- 1:14frustrated or just because some victim indicates that they don't
- 1:17like it. That's not you know, if the agreement is
- 1:20not legally valid, if there are some other concerns. But
- 1:23I don't think that this in and of itself would
- 1:26have been grounds for unwinding an agreement. Question do you
- 1:29think it's misleading for the government to have been interviewing
- 1:32these witnesses and preparing them for a trial when there's
- 1:35already as signed NPA that resolves the issue? Answer? So
- 1:40that was part of the judgment, that there is a
- 1:43signed agreement, But based on the course of conduct, is
- 1:45that agreement really an agreement that will be honored? And
- 1:48so there was an ongoing investigation as well, because we
- 1:52didn't know if we'd go to trial, and I know
- 1:55that not. I know. My recollection is that the judgment
- 1:59was until we know that this agreement is really going
- 2:02to be performed fully, that to inform the victims of
- 2:06a possibility of civil recovery is problematic, And I can't
- 2:09say that judgment's incorrect. I think that's a valid judgment
- 2:13question fair enough. And then the last question on this
- 2:16email is at the bottom. Mispredacted invites you to attend
- 2:19an interview with four of the girls that would be
- 2:22coming the following day. Did you attend? Answer? I did not,
- 2:28and as a US attorney, I don't think I attend.
- 2:30That wasn't typical for the office. Question would or was
- 2:36that ever? Had you ever had that type of request
- 2:38come from a line assistant? Answer? Not to my recollection,
- 2:42but I also tended not to have communication from the
- 2:44line assistance in the first place. Question were you at
- 2:48all curious? Given you had discussed the issue with the
- 2:51witnesses in this case that potential impeachment you know that
- 2:56caused you two that went into the negotiation phase. Did
- 2:59you have any inn in seeing these people, even interacting
- 3:02with them personally so you can make your own assessment? Answer?
- 3:07So any interest? Is he gets cut off? Question would
- 3:10there be value in doing that? Answer? So we had
- 3:13very experienced prosecutors. It's not just interacting with the victim
- 3:17that were in a really hard position. How I would
- 3:20draw a distinction between a victim being interviewed by an
- 3:23agent and how a victim holds up in court in
- 3:25a public setting under cross examination, and in that I
- 3:29don't think anyone in the office was questioning the pain
- 3:32or the suffering of the victims. I think that the
- 3:35issues were how they would hold up in court, which
- 3:38are uniquely trial issues. Question. Okay, so let's move on
- 3:41to what was your understanding that the federal government was
- 3:46going to do as far as the notification about the
- 3:49resolution of the case. Answer? So, my understanding was that
- 3:53once we believed that the case was going, that the
- 3:56plea was going to go forward, that we would notify
- 3:59the victims of the resolution and of the agreement and
- 4:02basically how it played out. Question, Now, are you saying
- 4:06you had agreed to not notify. I mean, one would
- 4:10read your December twelfth, nineteenth letter as an agreement that
- 4:13the federal government is not going to notify the victims
- 4:16of the state plea and that will end the part
- 4:19of the case. Is that correct? Answer? So I would
- 4:22parse my letter differently. And this is twelve years after
- 4:25the fact, and so this isn't based on recollection, but
- 4:29on my reading and my understanding of the course of
- 4:31conduct in the case sitting here now, my understanding was
- 4:35that our office was notified, was it on a Friday afternoon,
- 4:39that he would be pleading on Monday, and that at
- 4:41that time Redacted made efforts to notify victims that he
- 4:44would be pleading and that he would terminate the federal
- 4:47resolution of this matter, and that the victims should attend
- 4:50the hearing, which wasn't the state resolution of the case,
- 4:53it was the federal resolution. And so you're saying that
- 4:56the state plea was also the federal resolution of the case. Answer,
- 5:01based on my understanding of what happened, that's how my recollection,
- 5:04based on having reviewed the record, that's how I believe
- 5:07it proceeded, although I think Redacted attempted to do so,
- 5:11couldn't reach some attorneys and exercise best efforts to let
- 5:14them know, but did not get a hold of all
- 5:16the victims over the weekend. Question. Before we get too
- 5:20deep into that, let's just take a quick look at
- 5:22Exhibit fifty one. So this is an email forwarded to
- 5:26you from Redacted from January June twenty fifth, two thousand
- 5:29and eight. So that's five days prior to the plea
- 5:32in the case, or the state court plea, and the
- 5:35attachment there you'll notice is a letter with a notification
- 5:38of identified victims, and the letter is written, Would you
- 5:41disagree it's written with on June thirtieth, Epstein pled guilty.
- 5:45Do you see that? Answer? Yes? Question so the inference
- 5:49it appears to be that this letter was to be
- 5:52sent after the plea answer. I see that also based
- 5:56on my review of the record where I think I'm
- 5:59recalling there a day at Affid David where she said
- 6:02that she made an attempt to notify the victim as
- 6:04soon as she was made aware that he would be pleading,
- 6:07that he would be pleading in state court. Question, Well,
- 6:11what it says in the Affid David I believe is
- 6:14that she made notification and the police department chief redacted,
- 6:18Police department made notifications. Is that correct? Does that ring
- 6:22a bell? Mister Todd? Do you have a copy of
- 6:25the Affid David. It's right here, one copy Acosta on
- 6:31the back. Acosta so relevant to this paragraph thirty four
- 6:35and then another paragraph. These and other attacks and efforts
- 6:39to avoid the NPA's terms led the FBI investigative team,
- 6:43the office and me to conclude that prosecution at trial
- 6:46remained a possibility and we should prepare as much. This
- 6:51meant that the victim notification letters had to cease because
- 6:54one we no longer knew whether Epstein would perform under
- 6:57the NPA, and hence we did not know whether providing
- 7:01information about the NPA would be accurate until we believe
- 7:04that Epstein, through his counsel, would attempt to use victim
- 7:07notification concerning the NPA to suggest that victims had been
- 7:11encouraged by the FBI or the office to overstate the
- 7:14victimization for a monetary compensation, and then fast forwarding because
- 7:19you can read it on your own. On Friday, June
- 7:21twenty seventh, at approximately four to fifteen, I received a
- 7:24copy of Epstein's pro post state plea agreement and learned
- 7:27that epstein State Court change a plea was scheduled for
- 7:30eight thirty am on Monday the Palm Beach Police Department,
- 7:33and I attempted to notify the victims about the hearing
- 7:36in the short time available to us. I specifically called
- 7:40the attorney Edwards to provide notice to his clients regarding
- 7:43the hearing. I believe it was during this I never
- 7:46told that state charges involved other victims, and neither the
- 7:49state court charging instrument nor the factual proffer limited the
- 7:53procurement of prostitution charges to a specific cell, So that
- 7:58was what I was referring to. Again, I'm basing this
- 8:01based on my review of the affid David and not
- 8:04on recollection of how this may or may not have
- 8:06proceeded twelve years ago. Question Okay, you know, would it
- 8:10surprise you to learn that misredacted only communicated with mister
- 8:14Edwards that day? That's because she was under direction from
- 8:17the manager to only contact Edwards regarding the potential plea
- 8:21for that Monday. Answer the AFID David said she attempted
- 8:25to notify the victims, So I can't speak to that question. Okay, answer,
- 8:29and I don't have an independent recollection of this going
- 8:32back twelve years question, were you aware that misredacted was
- 8:36directed to have no communication with the state Attorney's office
- 8:39and probably during the later period of the case in
- 8:42two thousand and eight? Answer not to my recollection question Okay,
- 8:46so did you have would you not recall hearing anyone
- 8:49directing her to not communicate with the State's Attorney's office?
- 8:53Answer I can't speak twelve years later, what role I
- 8:56may or may not have had I question, how if
- 8:59we need if there is an attempt to schedule a
- 9:02plea in all of that, how can there not be communication?
- 9:05But I can't say whether I did or did not.
- 9:08When I say I have no recollection, I mean that
- 9:11in the broadest sense of the word. Question. Okay, in
- 9:15your December nineteenth letter, you did agree that the State
- 9:18Attorney's Office would notify the state's victims. Right answer, yes.
- 9:22Question And do you have any idea how that was
- 9:25supposed to be accomplished? Answer? I can't speak to that.
- 9:28No question. And would you have any knowledge of who
- 9:31the state victims are? Answer? I would infer that our
- 9:35office would have sufficient communication with the State Attorney's Office
- 9:39to communicate who the victims were in the case because
- 9:42it was ongoing. It was an ongoing matter. But I
- 9:44don't know. Question do you want to go on misredacted? Okay?
- 9:51Are you? Are you done with your that portion at
- 9:53least for the moment redacted? Yes? Thank you. Question. I
- 9:59just want to clarify something you said a moment ago,
- 10:01mister Acosta. You said that you referenced or referred to
- 10:04the agreement the NPA as having been it was signed,
- 10:07and it was being reviewed. Were you talking about Washington?
- 10:11Answer right, question the Criminal Division? But we established earlier,
- 10:15did we not that the NPA was not the subject
- 10:18of the Criminal Division review? They expressly declined to review it. Answer,
- 10:22I stand corrected, question, Okay, I just wanted to be
- 10:26clear on the record. Thank you. So we've had a
- 10:28lot of conversation about the facts. We're fortunate in this
- 10:31case to have a plethora of documents upon which we
- 10:34can rely even after twelve years, and we've tried to
- 10:38plumb the depths of your memory as to the events.
- 10:41Are there any facts, any conversations, any incidents, anything based
- 10:45on the questions that you've heard here today that you recall,
- 10:48have recalled that you want to tell us about, want
- 10:51us to know? Answer, So give me a minute to
- 10:54just sort of think this through. I think we've covered
- 10:58most of the issues pretty clearly. I guess I would
- 11:00have two general comments. The first is whether folks agree
- 11:04or disagree with the initial two years, you know, registration
- 11:07and restitution. The office's focus was on having mister Epstein
- 11:11go to jail at the time, when from our perspective,
- 11:15these cases were at least presented with the facts federally
- 11:18at least unusual, and the most trafficking cases involved different
- 11:22sort of nexus. It involved bringing individuals into the country,
- 11:26or holding individuals against their will or doing something like that.
- 11:30And this will go to my second point, which is,
- 11:32you know, sitting here we now see several high profile
- 11:35individuals who abuse power and have now been prosecuted, who
- 11:39were known at the time to who abused drugs, like
- 11:41Bill Cosby. There were rumors at the time, and you know,
- 11:45so looking back, maybe it was the right call, maybe
- 11:48it wasn't the right call, but there is some degree
- 11:50I'm not sure what the right adjective is frustration that
- 11:55and certainly some of this goes to me, but I
- 11:57think a lot of this goes to redacted and the
- 11:59individual involved, that the attempt to put someone in jail
- 12:02as opposed to decline the case and say this is
- 12:05just a state case, that the federal issues are too tricky,
- 12:09that ultimately this is the sort of novel interpretation that
- 12:12the attempt to come up with an outcome has rebounded
- 12:15in the way that it has. And I'm not saying, look,
- 12:18that's life, and I understand that, but I do think
- 12:21it's important to look back on this and try to
- 12:23be in the shoes of the thought process in six
- 12:26and seven, when trafficking prosecutions were fairly new, when you know,
- 12:31more so than today, some jurors may have looked at
- 12:33this as prostitution, perhaps more so than today. Judge's tolerance
- 12:37for victim shaming may have both caused more hesitation on
- 12:40part of the victims, but also created more issues at trial.
- 12:44And so I think we've touched on that, and I
- 12:46think we've sort of wrapped up this portion of it,
- 12:48and it's important just to restate that question and the addition,
- 12:53are there any facts that you or the conversations or
- 12:55anything that we have talked about that elicited for you
- 13:00that you want us to know and to be clear,
- 13:02you'll have an opportunity to supplement all of this. Answer
- 13:06not at this time that I can think of. Question
- 13:08all right, how do you respond to public criticism that
- 13:12the defense attorneys, the Epstein defense team were getting extraordinary
- 13:15access to an influence on prosecutors from the line level
- 13:19all the way up through the department. Answer. So I
- 13:23would point out early in the case when I said
- 13:25early you push back, but from my perspective, early on
- 13:29in the case, not when it was first investigated, but
- 13:31when it was first bubbled up for a decision. Question
- 13:35and that would be mid two thousand and seven answer
- 13:37mid two thousand and seven juneish May to June two
- 13:40thousand and seven, May June July. We determined, here is
- 13:44what we need for resolution, and I think we address
- 13:47some of this in the letter because we were receiving
- 13:49criticism back then, and I think the letter has been
- 13:52misconstrued to some extent because it was not here influential
- 13:56people were backing off. It was early on set three
- 14:00criteria two years registration restitution. Despite all these attorneys, despite
- 14:06all these appeals, despite all these efforts, the Office did
- 14:09not budge with the caveat of the twenty four to
- 14:11eighteen months, which we've discussed. And from my perspective, despite
- 14:16all that, I backed the Office in sticking by that
- 14:19resolution in the various appeals in Washington, and so ultimately
- 14:23it was a year long process, but we ended up
- 14:26in a year later exactly where we started with the
- 14:29caveat of twenty four to eighteen And so to the
- 14:32extent that there was influence, there was no change in position. Question, Well,
- 14:37my question was access that this team of defense attorneys
- 14:40had extraordinary access, that they asked for meetings, they pressed
- 14:43for with communications, and that they had access. Did that
- 14:47seem extraordinary to you answer? So they asked for a
- 14:50meeting with me before the agreement was signed. I granted
- 14:53that that's not the first and only time that I
- 14:56granted a meeting to defense attorneys. I don't think it's
- 14:59a typical, particularly as a case coming to a resolution,
- 15:03for US attorney to sit down and meet with the
- 15:05opposing council. And I can think of several cases where
- 15:08that happened. There was certainly a lot of access in Washington.
- 15:12I would speak to you know, I think that's a
- 15:14question to direct to this building because the process here
- 15:19was lengthy and frustrating. But I think we successfully held
- 15:22firm in our position despite all the process in this building. Question,
- 15:26and again, my focus is not on your response, but
- 15:29on the access based on the prominence and the prominence
- 15:32of the defense attorneys. If these had been local, your
- 15:35sort of average criminal defense attorneys from you know name,
- 15:38where they hang out in Miami coming to you and
- 15:41pressing you for this you writ large the department, Do
- 15:44you believe you would have had the same or comparable
- 15:47level of access. Answer, Yes, so I guess i'd respond
- 15:51this way if an attorney after meeting with my management
- 15:54staff as for a meeting with me. I believe I
- 15:57did and would have granted it. And I think of
- 15:59several matters on which those types of meetings were granted,
- 16:03and so that was not unusual with respect to the
- 16:06back and forth after the agreement was signed, this was
- 16:08an unusual agreement, and to some extent, as a result,
- 16:12the back and forth quickly elevated, particularly because matters would elevate,
- 16:16in particular when they were being addressed at Main Justice.
- 16:20That would be a natural way for matters to elevate
- 16:22within the office, and so the fact that they were
- 16:24being addressed and reviewed and letters were coming here would
- 16:28naturally elevate the way the matter was treated. In Miami
- 16:32question in particular, Jay Lefkowitz had ready access to Of course,
- 16:37he was involved in the negotiations with redacted directly in
- 16:41creating the NPA, but after that it appears from the
- 16:44record that he was often contacting you and running or
- 16:47going above the people who work for you, and on
- 16:50numerous occasions you, again my characterization, reprimanded him or instructed
- 16:55him not to do that, and to do direct his
- 16:57communications to a line attorney or a supervise. Is that
- 17:01a fair characterization? Answer? Yes, I think on several occasions
- 17:05I said direct them, and again that was after the
- 17:08agreement was signed. But yes, question, but there were many
- 17:11issues still pending correct answer, yes, question okay. And then
- 17:16was his ability to reach out to you as a
- 17:18function of your personal association? Is that fair? Answer? So?
- 17:23I don't think that's a fair characterization. You could also
- 17:26say that it was the ability of a function of
- 17:29his his insistence is not doing what we asked and
- 17:32the fact that in a typical course a Miami attorney
- 17:35would not have done this because they would have to
- 17:38interact with the office on an ongoing basis. And so
- 17:41the repeat litigator behaves very differently than the one time
- 17:45raised Earth litigator question raised rzed answer correct question. Is
- 17:54it reasonable for us to understand that had you followed
- 17:57the media coverage of what happened in the Epstein case
- 17:59over the year? Answer yes, question in your view overall
- 18:04and in whatever specific respect you wish to address it,
- 18:07has it been accurate or not so? Answer? I think
- 18:10it's been accurate or inaccurate? I should say in several ways,
- 18:13and we can go through them cut off if you
- 18:16could just tick those off answer. So I think it's
- 18:19inaccurate in that it has been characterized as our approving
- 18:22a state plea, and the complexity of this case was
- 18:25a state plea, and we were deferring in favor of
- 18:28a state. Prosecution has been lost and it's something that
- 18:31I have attempted to correct, but it's been very difficult
- 18:34to sort of explain that in the media. You know,
- 18:36this is a bad analogy, and so I haven't used
- 18:38it in the media, but I thought about it, and
- 18:41so I'll share it. So after the juicy Smoley plea
- 18:45in Chicago, there were some discussion of whether the federal
- 18:48government should bring charges, and I remember the media saying that.
- 18:51And I haven't used this analogy because I don't want
- 18:54to compare, and I think it would be disrespectful to
- 18:56compare the facts of the case to what happened to
- 18:59these victims. And I still I don't want the comparison
- 19:02to be drawn, but there is a legal comparison. Right
- 19:05The US attorney in Chicago could have stepped in and
- 19:07said whether or not the state takes this plea, we
- 19:10may investigate this federally and sort of stop that plea
- 19:13from going forward, or at least put a wrench in
- 19:16those gears. Or the US Attorney could have pursued that
- 19:19under petite policy and did not. And so our stepping
- 19:23into this sort of reminded me of how many times
- 19:26cases that are viewed as a manifest injustice to occur,
- 19:29and yet the federal government does not step in, and
- 19:32the fact that we stepped in has been construed as
- 19:36this became a federal prosecution and sort of going sort
- 19:41of question earlier. The distinction between it was a manifest
- 19:44injustice versus this was the right outcome is something that
- 19:48I think has been lost on the coverage in this matter.
- 19:51I think a second issue that has been lost in
- 19:53the coverage of this matter is there is reference to
- 19:55Prince Andrew and Alan Dershowitz and Governor Richardson and Buil
- 20:00Clinton and the thing happening in London and the so
- 20:02called Lolita Express where things may have happened on airplanes,
- 20:06and so this is viewed from the public as this
- 20:08international matter where the victims were local. The actions to
- 20:12my recollection were local, and so the distinction between this
- 20:15Palm Beach incident and what the media likes to cover,
- 20:17which is, you know, did mister Epstein force a minor
- 20:21to have sexual relations with Prince Andrew is a very
- 20:24different fact pattern, both in terms of the public perception
- 20:27of forcing a minor to have sex with a third
- 20:29party that they you know, there is an outside solicitation
- 20:32in context, it's sort of traveling with these women and
- 20:37forcing them to have sex, versus the more local matter.
- 20:40I don't want to say solicitation because I think we've
- 20:42covered that, but some may view it as that, and
- 20:45I think those two are major elements that have been
- 20:47lost in coverage. Question. The case has been criticized as
- 20:52having involved in proper influence or favors or payments that
- 20:55affected decisions that were made within your office. Are you
- 20:58aware of all of those allegations as well in connection
- 21:01with this case, Were you yourself ever offered any payment
- 21:05or any favors or any promises of job assistance or
- 21:08anything like that in connection with the case? Answer no question.
- 21:13And to your knowledge, was there any offer to anyone
- 21:15associated with the case in your office? Answer not to
- 21:18my knowledge. Question. It's been asserted also that the handling
- 21:23of the case in the office was affected by Epstein's
- 21:25wealth and influence in the Palm Beach community. Do you
- 21:30what is your response to that criticism? Answer again, my
- 21:34response would be, you know, sometime in May or June,
- 21:37we came up with these three points and we stuck
- 21:39to them. And you know, I despite all of this,
- 21:42you know what, people make these assertions somewhere along the way,
- 21:46the fact that we stuck to those points is lost
- 21:49and not talked about. And so we did stick to
- 21:52those points, you know, and question whether the case would
- 21:55have come to us in the first place, and so,
- 21:57you know, I think that could go a long way
- 21:59the other way. I don't understand that. Answer that it's
- 22:04highly unusual for a case to be brought to the state,
- 22:07to the US Attorney's office after the state attorney declined,
- 22:10not declines, but question fails to fully prosecute. Answer right,
- 22:16And so one question that also doesn't get asked, you know,
- 22:19to what extent was this case brought to us in
- 22:21the first place because of this because of his profile? Question?
- 22:26In other words, are you suggesting that his wealth and
- 22:28influence in the community affected the state's authorities? Answer? I'm
- 22:31not suggesting that what I'm suggesting is that the case
- 22:35came in, the case proceeded, and someone can make the
- 22:38argument that the only reason the Chief redacted brought it
- 22:40to us was because it had such a high profile.
- 22:43Are there other matters that take place in Palm Beach
- 22:46that a state attorney declines in the first place, that
- 22:48isn't brought to the state attorney because it doesn't rise
- 22:52to the US attorney because it doesn't rise to the
- 22:54profile question. All right, Well, in fairness, he might have
- 22:59done it because the number of victims too. Right, answer,
- 23:02he may have. I don't know. What I'm suggesting is
- 23:05we tried to treat it fairly, not looking at hey,
- 23:08how wealthy is he, but also not saying we need
- 23:10to do this because he's so wealthy. All right, folks,
- 23:13we're gonna wrap up right here, and then the next
- 23:15episode dealing with the topic, we're gonna pick up where
- 23:17we left off. All of the information that goes with
- 23:20this episode can be found in the description box.