Latest / Surrounded / 1 OF Model vs 20 Anti-S*x Work Advocates (ft Farha Khalidi) | Surrounded
Transcript
- 0:00The product is you.
- 0:01The product is not a cup of coffee.
- 0:03The product is your body.
- 0:05The product of NBA is also human beings.
- 0:08That doesn't make it degrading,
- 0:09right?
- 0:09What are,
- 0:10what is that,
- 0:11you know,
- 0:11if I'm making rated R horror movies and if you were to go,
- 0:14what about all the kids who sneak into your movie?
- 0:16I wouldn't go,
- 0:16I'm doing something wrong just because I have an age
- 0:18limit that some people are breaking is way different than,
- 0:20than OnlyFans.
- 0:21Why a lot of them have nudity.
- 0:22Have you seen the Terrifier?
- 0:23You are.
- 0:24Contributing to the loneliness,
- 0:25even if there is an epidemic or not,
- 0:27you're a dealer and you're selling a drug that people get addicted to.
- 0:31You know,
- 0:31you're deep in a goon sash and you're clicking and
- 0:34clicking and then things are there and then you,
- 0:36you,
- 0:36you're almost there,
- 0:37but then it's like,
- 0:37wait,
- 0:38599.
- 0:39It seems like OnlyFans actually helped you.
- 0:41It sobered you up a little bit.
- 0:43It made you think maybe I shouldn't be doing this,
- 0:44right?
- 0:45Are OnlyFans creators taking advantage of lonely men?
- 0:49I'm Paris Rose from Jubilee Media,
- 0:50and this is Surrounded,
- 0:52where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:55Today we're exploring if sex work degrades women,
- 0:58whether being an OnlyFans creator affects
- 1:00your ability to have healthy relationships,
- 1:02and if people are only against OnlyFans because it gives women control
- 1:06and power.
- 1:07I'm here with our featured guest,
- 1:08OnlyFans model
- 1:09Farha Khalidi.
- 1:11Hello,
- 1:11welcome in.
- 1:12How are you feeling?
- 1:12I'm feeling great.
- 1:13You ready to take everyone on?
- 1:14I'm definitely ready.
- 1:15All right,
- 1:16debaters,
- 1:16are you guys ready?
- 1:19Right,
- 1:19yeah,
- 1:20that's what I want to hear.
- 1:21Hi,
- 1:22I'm Farha Khalidi.
- 1:22I'm an OnlyFans creator,
- 1:24and today I'm surrounded by anti-sex work advocates.
- 1:31My first surrounded claim is that OnlyFans creators
- 1:33are not taking advantage of lonely men.
- 1:35If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:37get to the chair in 321.
- 1:43Nice to meet you.
- 1:43What was your name?
- 1:44Farha.
- 1:44Farha,
- 1:45nice to meet you.
- 1:45I'm Mato.
- 1:46Nice to meet you.
- 1:47So can you tell me a little bit about
- 1:48the chatting feature in OnlyFans for your subscribers?
- 1:52Um,
- 1:52the chatting feature is you can pay for dates,
- 1:55you can pay just to talk for the hour,
- 1:57you can pay just to buy content.
- 1:59OK,
- 1:59I see.
- 2:00So
- 2:01do you specifically talk to your viewers on your chat?
- 2:04Yeah.
- 2:04Do you know that's not the main practice that most OnlyFans creators do?
- 2:07I do.
- 2:08I still don't think that makes it taking advantage of lonely men,
- 2:11because I think when you're engaging with a sex worker,
- 2:13you know that you're willingly forfeiting
- 2:14a three-dimensional relationship with a woman.
- 2:16You're engaging in a fantasy,
- 2:17right?
- 2:17When I go to,
- 2:18if you go to a strip club as a guy,
- 2:19you know her name's not Crystal,
- 2:20you know,
- 2:21she doesn't actually want to be giving you a lap dance,
- 2:22right?
- 2:23When you go to Hooters,
- 2:23you know,
- 2:24the waitress doesn't actually find your joke funny,
- 2:25she just wants your tip,
- 2:26right?
- 2:26So I don't know why we play.
- 2:27Dumb and we're acting as if these men are being so,
- 2:29uh,
- 2:29viciously preyed on
- 2:31and that they're so naive when it when it suspend our disbelief about
- 2:34every other way that men engage with sex work on a daily basis.
- 2:37But why do you think they even
- 2:38use that chatting feature?
- 2:39What,
- 2:40what do you think?
- 2:40What do you think the purpose is for them chatting with you?
- 2:43Um,
- 2:43I think the chatting feature is they want to talk to a girl they find hot.
- 2:47And are they actually gaining that,
- 2:48or do they talk to a
- 2:50chatting person that's paid by the hour for that?
- 2:52Yeah,
- 2:52more often than not,
- 2:53if they're a big creator,
- 2:54they're talking to.
- 2:56Probably a chatter.
- 2:57I think that's common sense that if you're trying to talk to Amaranth,
- 2:59who has 10 million Twitch subscribers or whatever she has,
- 3:02she's probably not sitting around just talking to like some neck beard all day,
- 3:05right?
- 3:05Well,
- 3:05is that what she advertises though?
- 3:07Um,
- 3:07it might be,
- 3:08but whether a question of whether it's fraud is not the
- 3:10same thing of whether it's taking advantage of lonely men.
- 3:12So if you want to ask me whether it's fraudulent to use a typer,
- 3:14there's an argument for that.
- 3:16Do I think these men are so
- 3:17innocent and they're being so taken advantage of and I should feel so bad for them,
- 3:21my answer is an unequivocal no.
- 3:22I don't think these men.
- 3:23are lonely.
- 3:24First of all,
- 3:25a study found 89% of OnlyFans subscribers are married men,
- 3:28right?
- 3:28That doesn't mean married men can't be lonely,
- 3:30but usually when we use the term lonely men,
- 3:31we're using it as a proxy for incels or guys who are shut out of the dating market.
- 3:34But if you want to use the word lonely to qualify to any type
- 3:36of guy who'd be so desperate that they would talk to a sex worker,
- 3:39you're begging the question,
- 3:40right?
- 3:41So,
- 3:41again,
- 3:41just because it's fraudulent,
- 3:43a lot of the times does not make it
- 3:45taking advantage because I think there's an understanding,
- 3:47again,
- 3:47when you engage with a sex worker that you're engaging in a fantasy.
- 3:50So you would agree it's fraud though.
- 3:52Um,
- 3:52do you concede that?
- 3:53I think maybe on a,
- 3:54a legal basis,
- 3:55I'd have to look into whether
- 3:56technically,
- 3:57like,
- 3:57would an OnlyFans girl face any type of legal like problems if it,
- 4:01if she revealed that she was a typer.
- 4:03I have no idea,
- 4:04but if,
- 4:04if she would,
- 4:05then yeah,
- 4:05that would qualify as legal fraud,
- 4:06right?
- 4:07OK,
- 4:07uh,
- 4:08I think that that's good.
- 4:08I appreciate you for conceding that,
- 4:10um,
- 4:10but what can you repeat what you would say they're,
- 4:12they're not lonely.
- 4:13I said they're not lonely because 1,
- 4:1589% of OnlyFans subscribers are married men,
- 4:18and obviously,
- 4:18like I said,
- 4:19married men could be lonely in theory,
- 4:21but usually when people say the term lonely men,
- 4:24we're using it to refer to incels.
- 4:25When people talk about the male loneliness epidemic,
- 4:27they're not talking about some 40-year-old married guy with kids,
- 4:29right?
- 4:29They're talking about this idea of these,
- 4:30like,
- 4:31invisible men who are sitting around all day gaming.
- 4:33They have,
- 4:33like,
- 4:33no access to women,
- 4:34right?
- 4:35So that's why I would say,
- 4:36first of all,
- 4:36they're not lonely.
- 4:37I also am a bit misanderested on this point.
- 4:39I think that a lot of the male loneliness discourse is extremely
- 4:43I think it's creepy.
- 4:44I think it's very entitled
- 4:46because the loneliness crisis,
- 4:47I think it makes an absolute boys' club out
- 4:49of an existential dread that disaffects both genders,
- 4:51right?
- 4:51Like Generation Z is the loneliest generation alive,
- 4:54and a lot of people have just taken the term
- 4:55loneliness crisis and conflated it with involuntary sex recession.
- 4:58Not just sex recession,
- 4:59because that would apply to both women and men because
- 5:01both genders have been retreating from the sexual marketplace,
- 5:04but by narrowing the parameters to just mean involuntary sex.
- 5:06recession,
- 5:07you are automatically shutting the door out on women from being
- 5:09applied uh for qualifying for this existential problem that everyone's facing,
- 5:13while also demanding entitlement
- 5:15to their emotional labor.
- 5:16And it's basically to me,
- 5:17like the equivalent of guys who are like,
- 5:19oh,
- 5:19if you dump me,
- 5:19I'll kill myself.
- 5:20And it's basically going,
- 5:21oh,
- 5:21because these women aren't sleeping with me,
- 5:22we're suicidal,
- 5:23we're depressed,
- 5:23whatever.
- 5:24So I also find it just super.
- 5:25Well,
- 5:26what about all the kids that access OnlyFans,
- 5:27all the underage people that access Only?
- 5:29I would say that's wrong,
- 5:30but I would say that if I'm selling,
- 5:32you know,
- 5:32if I'm making rated R horror movies and if you were to go,
- 5:35what about all the kids who sneak into your movie,
- 5:36I wouldn't go,
- 5:37I'm doing something wrong just because I have
- 5:38an age limit that some people are breaking.
- 5:40It's way different than,
- 5:41than OnlyFans.
- 5:42Why?
- 5:42A lot of them have nudity.
- 5:43Have you seen the Terrifier?
- 5:44That's a lot more severe than anything I do
- 5:46on OnlyFans that nudity and horror movies are,
- 5:48are is equivalent to not just the nudity.
- 5:50They're like sawing naked women in half.
- 5:52Yeah,
- 5:53yeah,
- 5:53yeah,
- 5:53well,
- 5:53um,
- 5:54OnlyFans content stimulates the brain differently than horror movies do.
- 5:56Can we agree on that?
- 5:57I think that's a lot more graphic.
- 5:59Can we agree on that?
- 5:59Well,
- 6:00I would,
- 6:00I would agree with you that it's graphic,
- 6:01which is better for a kid to see my tits or a naked woman being sawed in
- 6:05half and I would not want any kid to see your tits or any horror movie.
- 6:11But,
- 6:11uh,
- 6:12yeah,
- 6:12what,
- 6:13what would you say to all the kids that are,
- 6:14that are accessing your OnlyFans content?
- 6:16I know they shouldn't be looking at me.
- 6:17Should I speak to the children right now?
- 6:19No,
- 6:19no.
- 6:19What,
- 6:19what do you?
- 6:20Would you advocate for more regulations against kids accessing OnlyFans content?
- 6:24Do you have any statistics to prove that
- 6:25there's a significant number of minors accessing OnlyFans?
- 6:28I have yet decided that.
- 6:29Well,
- 6:30the average age of exposure for pornography in general is 12 years old.
- 6:33That's for Pornhub,
- 6:35and I agree that that's,
- 6:36well,
- 6:36not only for Pornhub,
- 6:37for all porn,
- 6:37yeah,
- 6:38for most porn,
- 6:38not for OnlyFans.
- 6:39For OnlyFans,
- 6:39it requires the most amount of identification,
- 6:41not just for the,
- 6:42not just for the creator,
- 6:43in California,
- 6:44they don't require an ID,
- 6:45right?
- 6:45And you don't even OnlyFans,
- 6:46yeah,
- 6:47no.
- 6:48No,
- 6:48to create an account,
- 6:49you don't require anything.
- 6:50You require for you to say
- 6:51you're 18 years old or your account says you're 18 years old,
- 6:53and any kid can do that.
- 6:54All kids lie.
- 6:55Kids lie about that,
- 6:56and,
- 6:57uh,
- 6:57not,
- 6:57they don't even require a credit card.
- 6:59You can buy a prepaid gift card on Walmart.
- 7:02And so kids,
- 7:03kids are accessing the,
- 7:03these sites when they shouldn't be.
- 7:05What do you advocate for?
- 7:06I,
- 7:06I would definitely advocate.
- 7:07I,
- 7:08I'm not familiar with that.
- 7:09I would definitely advocate for stricter regulation.
- 7:10All I know is on the,
- 7:11on the,
- 7:12all I know is on the creator side is you need to have,
- 7:14uh,
- 7:15they have very stringent expectations
- 7:16on identification,
- 7:17which I think is good for like staving off things like trafficking and stuff.
- 7:20But again,
- 7:21even if kids are accessing it,
- 7:22I don't know what that has to do with the claim of like taking advantage of lonely men
- 7:26are lonely men.
- 7:28You've been voted out by the majority.
- 7:29Thank you.
- 7:34If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 7:35get to that chair in 321.
- 7:40Hi.
- 7:41Hi,
- 7:42I'm Amelia.
- 7:42Nice to meet you.
- 7:44I wanna start with asking you a question.
- 7:47Why do you not believe
- 7:48that men are facing a harder time in the dating realm right now
- 7:52and that the male loneliness epidemic does not exist?
- 7:56I didn't say it doesn't exist.
- 7:58I was more so saying it's a subset of a larger loneliness epidemic,
- 8:01and I think it exists as much as a female loneliness epidemic,
- 8:04but I think that oftentimes gets overlooked
- 8:05because our culture is very misogynistic,
- 8:07and they tend to code any sort of female shortcoming
- 8:10as being biological or hardwired.
- 8:12So,
- 8:13for instance,
- 8:13if a girl sits around all day on her phone,
- 8:14on TikTok or stuff,
- 8:16you know,
- 8:16the man is fear or people will say,
- 8:18oh,
- 8:18it's just because women have no hobbies,
- 8:19right?
- 8:20If a guy like,
- 8:21fritters a day,
- 8:21fritters the day away all day watching porn,
- 8:24People will go,
- 8:24this is because society's disordered.
- 8:26This man's being disenfranchised,
- 8:27he's disillusioned.
- 8:28He's been,
- 8:29he's been the victim,
- 8:30again,
- 8:30of a very Miss Sanders culture that tells him
- 8:31men are shit and toxic and all these things.
- 8:33And I'm like,
- 8:34that's so interesting because,
- 8:35for instance,
- 8:35when women,
- 8:36for instance,
- 8:36don't fulfill STEM positions or they fall behind in particular verticals,
- 8:40we say this is because women are just not interested in hard sciences.
- 8:43But if men,
- 8:43for instance,
- 8:43drop out of college and they're not doing it,
- 8:45we don't attribute it to laziness.
- 8:46We,
- 8:46again,
- 8:46attribute it to some sort of misandrus culture,
- 8:48which is disenfranchising men and that they're being.
- 8:51Again,
- 8:51so kicked back by loneliness and dating and stuff.
- 8:53So you're saying that there's like two different standards that
- 8:56the genders are expected to reach in society,
- 8:58and if they fall short,
- 8:59then
- 8:59they kind of fall into like a victim mindset.
- 9:02I'm saying that I don't think male loneliness is a unique category.
- 9:06I think it's a subset of loneliness which equally affects women.
- 9:09So,
- 9:10the statistic is actually that the men's suicide rate is 3.5 to 5% higher than women,
- 9:16and they make up for 80% of suicides in the.
- 9:18US alone per year,
- 9:20there is a men's mental health crisis.
- 9:23Where is
- 9:24the advocation for them?
- 9:26I want to ask
- 9:27first.
- 9:28Pride Month took over Men's Mental Health Month.
- 9:31We are setting aside that the suicide rates are higher,
- 9:34the loneliness is higher,
- 9:36the societal expectations loneliness is higher.
- 9:39What causes suicide?
- 9:40What's the feelings of worthlessness,
- 9:42as you know,
- 9:42women attempt suicide more than men,
- 9:44therefore,
- 9:44are women lonely.
- 9:45than men by your own definition.
- 9:47We're talking about death is the attempt itself
- 9:50not a good enough litmus for determining loneliness?
- 9:53If you try to take your man,
- 9:54but you just said we should bait,
- 9:56we should use whether someone's killing themselves as
- 9:59a basis for how lonely they feel.
- 10:01So if I put a gun to my head and try to kill myself,
- 10:03but for some reason I survived,
- 10:04would you go,
- 10:04well,
- 10:05therefore you're less lonely than the guy who actually got the job done?
- 10:07That seems kind of ridiculous.
- 10:09It feels kind of like a red herring conversation
- 10:11that you're starting right now because not at all.
- 10:12You just said suicide is a good litmus for determining loneliness,
- 10:16and women attempt suicide more than men.
- 10:18All right,
- 10:18let's loop back around to this.
- 10:21How does your job
- 10:23help those men if there is a problem,
- 10:25or if there's women,
- 10:26does it contribute to the positivity of their brains,
- 10:28or does it make them worse?
- 10:30Does it make society
- 10:31worse or better?
- 10:32What do you contribute?
- 10:33Because the brain
- 10:35during an orgasm
- 10:37releases as much dopamine
- 10:39as heroin.
- 10:40You are selling a drug,
- 10:42you are not helping
- 10:44the mental health
- 10:45of,
- 10:45I'm sure women buy your content as well,
- 10:47so let's just put it away from men.
- 10:49You are contributing to the loneliness even if there is an epidemic or not.
- 10:53You're a dealer and you're selling a drug that people get addicted to.
- 10:56Why are they lonely?
- 10:58Why are they lonely?
- 10:59Because society,
- 11:00I told you 89% of OnlyFans subscribers
- 11:03are married.
- 11:04OK,
- 11:05they're probably lonely.
- 11:05Maybe they're not being fulfilled by their wife.
- 11:07Maybe they're falling short of Christianity,
- 11:09so they have to cheat on their wife because she's not putting out enough.
- 11:12They don't have to do anything.
- 11:14OK.
- 11:14They don't have to do this is what I.
- 11:15I find really grating about these conversations is
- 11:17that these men are not victims of loneliness.
- 11:19More often than not,
- 11:20they're perpetrators of adultery,
- 11:21right?
- 11:22And yet again,
- 11:22we want to coddle them
- 11:24much and it's like,
- 11:24well,
- 11:24maybe they're in a dead bedroom,
- 11:26maybe their wife's not giving them enough attention.
- 11:27Maybe they're,
- 11:28again,
- 11:28victim of this misandra's culture,
- 11:29which drives men to suicide.
- 11:30It's like,
- 11:31none of that's really the case,
- 11:32right?
- 11:33These are men who are horny,
- 11:34they're entitled,
- 11:34they want to see some hot 18 year old in a Spider-Man suit,
- 11:37and they want to see them like,
- 11:38yeah,
- 11:38they want to get off to it.
- 11:39They want a JOI or something.
- 11:40Why do we have to pretend like they're so lonely?
- 11:42Before OnlyFans,
- 11:42no one used this language of loneliness for men.
- 11:45If you as a wife told your husband,
- 11:46he,
- 11:46I don't feel comfortable with you watching porn,
- 11:48which 70% of married men do,
- 11:50they said you're insecure,
- 11:51it's,
- 11:51uh,
- 11:51purely physical,
- 11:52it's meaningless,
- 11:53right?
- 11:53They were the most eager to adopt this language of levity to apply to their porn use.
- 11:57Only after women like me start turning a seven-figure profit
- 12:00do they now suddenly want to claim loneliness.
- 12:02And to me,
- 12:02it reminds me of,
- 12:02like,
- 12:03the caricature that men wield of women of like,
- 12:05oh,
- 12:05they cry
- 12:05after a guy gets rich and famous,
- 12:07right?
- 12:07So why is it that these men Only again,
- 12:09adopted this language of victimhood after women started
- 12:11wielding control over their own bodies in porn.
- 12:14Why were they not victims,
- 12:15for instance,
- 12:15when Pornhub was hosting sex trafficking content with porn stars were
- 12:18constantly getting abused on camera and getting ripped off constantly?
- 12:21Why were these men like completely silent?
- 12:24Why did the male loneliness epidemic only coincide again with
- 12:27women being able to make control and make strides?
- 12:29Why is it only now they're falling behind because women are
- 12:32advancing past them in college and stuff and in the workforce?
- 12:35Are they actually that lonely or are they just sore losers?
- 12:38I think it's the latter.
- 12:39Sore losers,
- 12:40oh my goodness.
- 12:41OK,
- 12:42well,
- 12:42I think that
- 12:43they are held to a different standard back around to your original claim.
- 12:46There's different standards,
- 12:48and when you're born under 6 ft.
- 12:50When you're born with a bad hairline,
- 12:52when you're born,
- 12:53men have a different standard,
- 12:54especially for looks
- 12:55that in and of itself is one standard that already stresses them the hell out.
- 12:59Women have it easier.
- 13:00Women have it easier.
- 13:02I have it easier than my brother or my boyfriend.
- 13:05I'll put it that way because men are being held,
- 13:07are you kidding me?
- 13:08The way that you look,
- 13:09it's so much easier to fix yourself as a woman
- 13:12it's harder for men in terms of just,
- 13:14just everything.
- 13:15sex appeal,
- 13:16your general attraction,
- 13:17how society views you,
- 13:18the standard that you reach to be accepted and just feel good in your own body,
- 13:22enough to hit those high standards.
- 13:24Men are held to a different standard,
- 13:25OK?
- 13:26Their job,
- 13:26their false appeal is the standard of advancement,
- 13:29then women on OnlyFans are doing a good thing because you just said
- 13:32life is easier for you and you're able to wield more sex appeal.
- 13:35No,
- 13:35I think if I'm gonna pause here,
- 13:36you've been voted out by the majority.
- 13:38Thank you.
- 13:39Thank you.
- 13:42If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 13:44please get to the chair in 321.
- 13:50Hey Farah,
- 13:52nice to meet you.
- 13:52Nice to meet you.
- 13:54Um,
- 13:55so
- 13:57I'm a lonely man.
- 14:00Um,
- 14:00and I've,
- 14:00I've been tempted
- 14:02by
- 14:03OnlyFans models on the internet sometimes.
- 14:06I've never quite gotten there,
- 14:07you know,
- 14:08cause you hit that credit card wall
- 14:10and you're like,
- 14:10no,
- 14:11you know,
- 14:12just don't do it.
- 14:13But if,
- 14:14if lonely guys
- 14:16aren't your target audience,
- 14:18then who is?
- 14:20Um,
- 14:22I would say,
- 14:22like I said before,
- 14:23the vast majority of OnlyFans subscribers
- 14:27are married,
- 14:28and usually,
- 14:28again,
- 14:29you can make an argument that those men
- 14:30are lonely because their wife isn't as hot anymore,
- 14:33she's not putting out as more,
- 14:34she's not sexually satisfied,
- 14:35but that's not even lonely,
- 14:36that's just sexually hedonistic.
- 14:38That's just.
- 14:38Greedy in the relationship potentially,
- 14:41potentially,
- 14:41but I don't even,
- 14:42I don't even think that's the case,
- 14:43right?
- 14:43Like 87% of young men watch porn.
- 14:45They,
- 14:45they,
- 14:46a lot of them still have girlfriends,
- 14:47right,
- 14:47but they're,
- 14:48they're watching porn out of sexual hedonism,
- 14:50not out of loneliness.
- 14:51So the fact that 89% of the people buying the stuff,
- 14:55uh,
- 14:55you know,
- 14:56the chick
- 14:57shaking her ass on the internet or
- 15:00whatever,
- 15:01you know,
- 15:02it's,
- 15:02it's gross,
- 15:04but like,
- 15:05who's your target audience?
- 15:06Like,
- 15:06do you have like,
- 15:08A demographic you're after.
- 15:10No,
- 15:11no,
- 15:12you just kind of
- 15:13put it out there and see what happens,
- 15:14see what sticks.
- 15:15Yeah,
- 15:16I post
- 15:17reels of me debating.
- 15:18I post thirst trap photos,
- 15:20and then people come and subscribe.
- 15:21I have a lot of lesbians on there too.
- 15:22I don't have like a,
- 15:24I'm not like preying on a particular demographic.
- 15:27OK.
- 15:28OK.
- 15:29But here,
- 15:29here's another thing,
- 15:30like,
- 15:30even if I were to grant,
- 15:31for instance,
- 15:32that
- 15:32all of the men coming onto OnlyFans are lonely,
- 15:35let's just grant that.
- 15:36I would still argue that OnlyFans is not,
- 15:39is definitively not taking advantage of lonely men,
- 15:42because
- 15:42advantage to me implies some sort of exploitation,
- 15:45implies maybe like price gouging.
- 15:46I'm thinking this is like an essential need or service.
- 15:49Porn is not a need.
- 15:50Men do not need porn.
- 15:52I would go even further and say men don't need sex,
- 15:54but if you don't want to take it there,
- 15:55men don't need porn.
- 15:56Further,
- 15:57if we were to grant that they are lonely and that they do need porn,
- 15:59it's still not taking advantage because there's this website called Pornhub
- 16:02where you could see billions of hours of free content.
- 16:04And while I have my own,
- 16:05like,
- 16:05moral objections to Pornhub,
- 16:06the majority of men do not.
- 16:08They watch it all the time.
- 16:09So it'd be weird to say I'm taking advantage by paywalling
- 16:12something when you can get it for free somewhere else,
- 16:14right?
- 16:14If I'm selling bottled water next to like an infinite reservoir of free water,
- 16:17it'd be weird to say you're taking advantage of these people.
- 16:19So even if we were to grant they're lonely and that porn is a need,
- 16:21neither of those things are true,
- 16:22it's still not taking advantage.
- 16:24Agreed.
- 16:24I don't think it's a need,
- 16:26and I don't think you're taking advantage of lonely men
- 16:29per se,
- 16:30because I think
- 16:31you're also a victim of the whole industry,
- 16:34which has been
- 16:35booming.
- 16:36The porn industry gets more clicks and more view time than Netflix.
- 16:41It's like really sad to see for everybody.
- 16:45So,
- 16:46I,
- 16:46I think it's,
- 16:47it's very grand.
- 16:47It doesn't make it sad,
- 16:50but it is sad.
- 16:51It is really sad.
- 16:52So you mentioned that you were a lonely man.
- 16:55What made you almost subscribe to OnlyFans and what made you stop?
- 16:58Well,
- 16:58it's kind of personal,
- 17:00um.
- 17:02You said it,
- 17:02not me.
- 17:03I know I did.
- 17:04I did,
- 17:05um,
- 17:06yeah,
- 17:06I mean.
- 17:08You know,
- 17:08you're deep in a goon sash and you're clicking and
- 17:11clicking and then things are there and then you,
- 17:13you,
- 17:13you're almost there,
- 17:14but then it's like,
- 17:15wait,
- 17:15599.
- 17:16It seems like OnlyFans actually helped you.
- 17:18It sobered you up a little bit.
- 17:20It made you think maybe I shouldn't be doing this,
- 17:22right?
- 17:23So maybe it's deterring lonely men.
- 17:24From watching porn,
- 17:25actually,
- 17:25maybe I think we should paywall all porn.
- 17:27I actually do think that,
- 17:28I think,
- 17:28one,
- 17:29because it's a better,
- 17:29I,
- 17:29mostly because it's a better standard for the porn stars,
- 17:31not because I care about
- 17:33these lonely men,
- 17:34but I think it should all be paywalled.
- 17:35Yeah.
- 17:36Kany,
- 17:36do you know any other lonely men that just subscribe to OnlyFans?
- 17:41Um,
- 17:43you know,
- 17:44I,
- 17:45I,
- 17:45I,
- 17:45I know some guys,
- 17:47I know some guys who probably do,
- 17:49um,
- 17:50but
- 17:51But I don't wanna oust those guys.
- 17:53Um,
- 17:54would you feel like they've been,
- 17:55sorry,
- 17:55would you feel like they've been taken advantage of?
- 17:58No.
- 17:58So I,
- 17:59I,
- 17:59I don't think they're really being taken advantage of by you.
- 18:02I do think they're being taken advantage of
- 18:05by the entire porn
- 18:07industry,
- 18:08um,
- 18:09because.
- 18:10You know,
- 18:10it's pushed out.
- 18:11It's,
- 18:12it's out there.
- 18:12It's easy to gain access to.
- 18:14It's like so easy and,
- 18:15and it's super addictive.
- 18:17And these guys,
- 18:18it's so sad,
- 18:19you see them kind of fall off and get worse and worse.
- 18:22And you hear stories about guys losing so much money.
- 18:25I,
- 18:26I don't really feel that.
- 18:26Bad for them.
- 18:27It's,
- 18:27it's their I don't either.
- 18:28We can agree on something.
- 18:30Yeah,
- 18:30I,
- 18:30I,
- 18:31I really don't feel bad because they made that decision.
- 18:33Well,
- 18:34so I,
- 18:34I don't actually believe it's an addiction,
- 18:35right?
- 18:36Yeah,
- 18:37the whole system is all right,
- 18:38we're gonna pause here.
- 18:39You've been voted out by the majority.
- 18:41Thank you so much.
- 18:42Good luck.
- 18:42Thank you.
- 18:45If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 18:46please get to the chair in 321.
- 18:53Hi there.
- 18:54How are you?
- 18:54I'm Austin.
- 18:55Nice to meet you.
- 18:56I don't know that I,
- 18:58I want to focus on taking advantage of,
- 19:00cause it doesn't seem like you have an intent to go take advantage of lonely men.
- 19:04Would you,
- 19:05and you,
- 19:05you've talked about it a little bit that you're acknowledging that men are lonely,
- 19:08at least some men are lonely,
- 19:10right?
- 19:11Yeah,
- 19:11I would say
- 19:12they're lonely as a subset of a general loneliness epidemic,
- 19:15which just affects women and men
- 19:17generally equally.
- 19:19OK,
- 19:19so
- 19:20why do you think that the men are coming to you or to an OnlyFans creator?
- 19:24Lust,
- 19:25lust,
- 19:25OK.
- 19:26And what are you selling to them?
- 19:27What are you offering to them,
- 19:28um.
- 19:30Sex,
- 19:31in other words,
- 19:31even though I'm not actually
- 19:33them or whatever,
- 19:34it's
- 19:34basically selling sex,
- 19:35yeah,
- 19:36OK.
- 19:37And you said something like OnlyFans is helping them,
- 19:41right?
- 19:41No,
- 19:41no,
- 19:41I didn't.
- 19:42Oh,
- 19:42I said kind of
- 19:43facetiously because he was saying that he was in the middle of a goon fest and that
- 19:47the paywall deterred him.
- 19:49So I was saying,
- 19:49oh,
- 19:49so then it's not taking advantage of these men,
- 19:51it's deterring the gooners.
- 19:52If,
- 19:53if you think porn is wrong,
- 19:54then it's,
- 19:54it's doing something good by creating a
- 19:56deterrent.
- 19:57OK,
- 19:57so you think it,
- 19:58if porn is wrong,
- 19:59do you think porn is wrong?
- 20:00No.
- 20:01OK,
- 20:02what good do you think it's doing?
- 20:03Um,
- 20:04the main good
- 20:05would be that I think it offers women sexual autonomy in the sense of,
- 20:08like I said in my
- 20:10earlier,
- 20:10I think we obviously all grant that there's nothing wrong,
- 20:13and there's actually something good oftentimes with women sexualizing
- 20:16themselves for a man at some point in time.
- 20:18We just grant,
- 20:19we just assume it's obvious that that sexualization is
- 20:21only OK when it's done for a husband,
- 20:23but I actually don't think that's the case.
- 20:24I can make lots of arguments to argue that,
- 20:26like,
- 20:26It could actually be more degrading oftentimes to sexualize yourself
- 20:29within a marriage than it could be for money,
- 20:30right?
- 20:31So,
- 20:31I think that if we're going to grant that sexualization
- 20:33for a woman is benign or oftentimes ethical or empowering,
- 20:36I don't understand why it couldn't also lend to then sexualization with it
- 20:40for money as being good for women or good for their autonomy.
- 20:43So I would say that's like the first and foremost reason why I think,
- 20:46uh,
- 20:47OnlyFans is good for women.
- 20:48Got it,
- 20:49OK.
- 20:51What do you think it does to relationships,
- 20:52like to these 89% of OnlyFans subscribers who are married men,
- 20:57how do you think that the,
- 20:58the relationship is being affected by somebody consuming OnlyFans content?
- 21:02I think that porn use is one in an infinite
- 21:06number of ways that men routinely cheat on their wives,
- 21:08and I think
- 21:09it's unfortunate,
- 21:10right?
- 21:10I think that,
- 21:11again,
- 21:12prior to OnlyFans,
- 21:13nobody was interested in having these conversations about male
- 21:16porn partner porn use being a form of infidelity.
- 21:19Than rad fans.
- 21:20I was someone who's been talking about this for a decade,
- 21:22even before OnlyFans.
- 21:23I've been saying that like,
- 21:24hey,
- 21:24did you know 50% of wives actually consider it cheating,
- 21:27and they,
- 21:28they report being uncomfortable with their husbands
- 21:30and boyfriends watching pornography and nobody cared.
- 21:33They said,
- 21:33this is natural,
- 21:34this is necessary.
- 21:35If you want to find a man who's who doesn't watch porn,
- 21:37you'll be hard pressed.
- 21:38You got to go be single or go be gay,
- 21:40right?
- 21:40So again,
- 21:40it wasn't until OnlyFans that people started probing,
- 21:43well,
- 21:43how does this affect the relationship,
- 21:44right?
- 21:45And I think
- 21:45the fact that most wives don't want Their husbands watching porn,
- 21:49to me speaks to the issue that porn is not the issue,
- 21:51ironically,
- 21:52it's an issue of fidelity and boundaries,
- 21:54because if the issue is that they don't even want them to be watching it,
- 21:57it'd be weird to go,
- 21:58oh,
- 21:58therefore,
- 21:58porn is a problem,
- 21:59it's ruining relationships.
- 22:01In the same way,
- 22:01I don't want my husband,
- 22:02for instance,
- 22:02to go other women,
- 22:04but if he did it while,
- 22:05you know,
- 22:05if he did it,
- 22:05if he set up a Bumble account to meet women while we're married secretly,
- 22:09it'd be weird for me to defer that blame onto Bumble and go,
- 22:12oh,
- 22:12well,
- 22:12therefore we should ban Bumble,
- 22:14right?
- 22:14So that's how I feel about porn.
- 22:15I think Like porn,
- 22:16Bumble,
- 22:17Bumble,
- 22:17Tinder,
- 22:18workplaces,
- 22:19bars,
- 22:20these are all mediums in which men use
- 22:22to cheat on their wives,
- 22:23but we shouldn't put the blame onto the medium.
- 22:25We should put the onus onto the men
- 22:27and hold them to a higher onus and say,
- 22:29hey,
- 22:29maybe you shouldn't be cheating on your partner,
- 22:31and you shouldn't be such a coward that you defer the blame onto the
- 22:34one in a dozen ways that you use to cheat on your wife.
- 22:37Got it.
- 22:37Did I blame the medium?
- 22:40Um,
- 22:41no,
- 22:41I guess when you ask,
- 22:42like,
- 22:42what do you think it does for these relationships,
- 22:44for these men.
- 22:44Be watching and if I'm saying most wives don't even want them to be watching,
- 22:47it feels in a way like you're implicitly deferring the blame to the medium.
- 22:50No.
- 22:51Well,
- 22:51what do you feel that OnlyFans does to marriages?
- 22:55Well,
- 22:55what I feel about it is different than what the data suggests,
- 22:57and the data overwhelmingly suggests that OnlyFans and
- 23:00pornography broadly is not good to relationships.
- 23:03I agree,
- 23:03and I would,
- 23:04I would agree pornography is not
- 23:06the problem.
- 23:07It is a very big problem,
- 23:08but there's usually an underlying lack of connectedness,
- 23:10we could call it loneliness,
- 23:11that people are actually seeking.
- 23:13One of the problems I think with OnlyFans is that it
- 23:16never actually satisfies what the person is going and trying to,
- 23:19to have happen there,
- 23:20which is an experience of connection.
- 23:22If it did,
- 23:23they wouldn't come back.
- 23:25So how would you respond to that?
- 23:26Like,
- 23:27if people are coming for some sort of connection,
- 23:29they're never getting it,
- 23:29and they keep coming back.
- 23:31What do you,
- 23:32what do you make of that?
- 23:33Can you reword it?
- 23:35Yeah,
- 23:35why do,
- 23:36if,
- 23:36if they're
- 23:38If there's an underlying connection that somebody's looking for,
- 23:40right,
- 23:41so let's say that it's not just because they want to see a certain body part,
- 23:44there,
- 23:44there's actually a deeper drive there that
- 23:46marriage dissatisfaction is happening.
- 23:47So I'm going to go try to get a need or a desire.
- 23:49It's not a need or desire.
- 23:50It's just entitlement.
- 23:52When I say need or desire,
- 23:53you're making an assumption of what I'm talking about,
- 23:55right?
- 23:55I'm not saying sex is a need.
- 23:56That's another conversation.
- 23:58Connection,
- 23:59I would say is
- 24:00something that people do need.
- 24:02OK,
- 24:02so
- 24:03do you,
- 24:03do you agree with that?
- 24:05That connection is something people need.
- 24:07OK,
- 24:07yeah,
- 24:07so,
- 24:07so then what are you actually selling?
- 24:10I would say it's selling.
- 24:12There,
- 24:12there's
- 24:13two different types of customers.
- 24:14There's people who come on just because they want like the sexual content to get off.
- 24:17They're not interested in the conversation,
- 24:19they just want to see like porn of you.
- 24:20And then there are people who come on,
- 24:21I would say that's the other half,
- 24:23where it's like they just want to be like talking to a girl or a girl all day.
- 24:28So you could argue that it's selling intimacy,
- 24:30but I wouldn't then say that they're being taken advantage of,
- 24:33same way,
- 24:34you know,
- 24:34a therapist is in a way selling a form of connection and intimacy
- 24:38that doesn't require,
- 24:38that doesn't then extend to then
- 24:40price gouging or exploitation or taking advantage or anything like that.
- 24:43Well,
- 24:44a good therapist should work themselves out of a job.
- 24:46They should
- 24:47begin an engagement with the customer
- 24:49so that there is an end because they're wanting to.
- 24:51To leave them nourished with some sort of feeling of connection or purpose
- 24:55that makes it so they don't need to come back to the therapist.
- 24:58I haven't seen an OnlyFans creator with the goal of
- 25:00saying there's a need or a service I'm providing,
- 25:02and I hope to leave these people better
- 25:05so that they don't have to come back to me.
- 25:07Yeah,
- 25:07I would say whether or not,
- 25:08you know,
- 25:09we're rehabilitating men,
- 25:11it doesn't,
- 25:11if even if we're not rehabilitating men,
- 25:13that doesn't mean we're taking advantage of them
- 25:15or that they're victims or anything like that,
- 25:17right?
- 25:17So it's not one or the other,
- 25:18and I think that's a
- 25:19false binary,
- 25:20right?
- 25:20I'm definitely not going to say that I'm offering
- 25:22necessarily a moral good
- 25:24to the men or something necessarily positive in their lives,
- 25:26and I think most of the time they are adulterous,
- 25:28right?
- 25:29But again,
- 25:29like I said,
- 25:29that doesn't mean I'm taking advantage of them.
- 25:31But also,
- 25:32again,
- 25:32someone returning to a service doesn't point
- 25:34to that service being Predatory or wrong,
- 25:36like,
- 25:36actually,
- 25:36a lot of people would say,
- 25:37even if you feel like your problems are gone with therapy,
- 25:39that you should keep going.
- 25:40That's actually most of the people I know who do therapy.
- 25:42That's what they say is you're supposed to keep going.
- 25:44It should be like an endless thing.
- 25:45But if you keep returning to a service,
- 25:47like,
- 25:48I,
- 25:48like,
- 25:48should someone,
- 25:49should a gym owner work themselves out of owning a gym,
- 25:51right?
- 25:51No,
- 25:52the idea is you're supposed to keep coming back.
- 25:53So I,
- 25:53I think that's a weird standard of
- 25:55if someone keeps coming back to that thing,
- 25:57that thing is therefore
- 25:58negative.
- 25:59We're gonna pause here.
- 26:00We're out of time for this claim.
- 26:02Nice to meet you.
- 26:03Thank you.
- 26:07My next surrounded claim is that people are
- 26:09only against OnlyFans because it gives women control.
- 26:11If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 26:13get to the chair in 321.
- 26:18Hey,
- 26:19see you again.
- 26:22OK,
- 26:22so I think it's a little hypocritical when you come up here and you say,
- 26:27uh,
- 26:27you know,
- 26:27my intentions are not to take advantage of lonely men,
- 26:31and then you come up here and claim that you
- 26:33know the motivations of all of us for opposing OnlyFans.
- 26:36Um,
- 26:37I think that's a little hypocritical.
- 26:38I think that's a little ridiculous,
- 26:40and I think
- 26:41a question I have for you
- 26:42is that,
- 26:43has anyone in this circle
- 26:45made
- 26:45any argument saying
- 26:47we should ban OnlyFans to take control away from women?
- 26:51Um,
- 26:51I haven't heard
- 26:53anyone pushing for a ban,
- 26:54but everyone here is
- 26:56obviously against OnlyFans,
- 26:58so I don't,
- 26:58they don't have to push for a ban.
- 27:00Your claim isn't that we're against OnlyFans because that's
- 27:03obviously the case.
- 27:04You guys are against OnlyFans because it gives women control,
- 27:07so we don't need to import this idea of a ban
- 27:09as qualifying for my claim.
- 27:12Sure,
- 27:12but,
- 27:13but no one has argued that we are
- 27:15against OnlyFans because we're against women having control.
- 27:19Sure,
- 27:19that's my claim.
- 27:21So right,
- 27:21so,
- 27:22so go,
- 27:23go ahead and prove it.
- 27:24No,
- 27:24no,
- 27:24no,
- 27:24you made the claim,
- 27:25so actually you have the burden of proof.
- 27:27Oh,
- 27:27I will.
- 27:28OK,
- 27:28go ahead.
- 27:29First of all,
- 27:29like I said before,
- 27:30this type of discourse only took,
- 27:32only coincided when women started doing OnlyFans.
- 27:34Before the advent of OnlyFans,
- 27:36men were very eager and society was very eager to claim that men have a prerogative.
- 27:39to the sexual commodification of women,
- 27:41and any woman who protested it because it was actually
- 27:43disproportionately women who were against sex work and porn,
- 27:46they were ruthlessly punished,
- 27:47right?
- 27:47So for instance,
- 27:48during the Playboy era,
- 27:49when feminists would protest porn,
- 27:51Hugh Hefner said in a leaked internal memo,
- 27:52we need to ruin feminists.
- 27:54They are a natural enemy,
- 27:55right?
- 27:55When Andrea Dorkin,
- 27:56who wrote on pornography,
- 27:57men oppressing women,
- 27:58protested Playboy and,
- 27:59uh,
- 28:00Penthouse,
- 28:01they turned out these really degrading cartoons of her having sex as
- 28:03well as her mother and called her a dyke and stuff.
- 28:06Sure,
- 28:06that's an anecdotal.
- 28:07That's an anecdotal.
- 28:08These are all examples to show that.
- 28:10What do you mean no,
- 28:10it's not.
- 28:11Everyone was.
- 28:11Wait,
- 28:12wait,
- 28:12wait,
- 28:12hold on.
- 28:12How is it not anecdotal?
- 28:13You gave one example.
- 28:15That is,
- 28:15that is the definition.
- 28:16I can give you 1000 more.
- 28:18OK,
- 28:18here's an anecdote.
- 28:19Before OnlyFans,
- 28:20men were much more likely to morally approve of pornography.
- 28:24Before OnlyFans,
- 28:2420% of,
- 28:25uh,
- 28:25men were buying sex from prostitutes.
- 28:28Before OnlyFans,
- 28:2970% of men were going to a stri club?
- 28:31OnlyFans,
- 28:3190% of men.
- 28:33Watching porn.
- 28:34It doesn't matter.
- 28:34OK,
- 28:35listen,
- 28:35I'll fully grant you moral disapproval of porn.
- 28:38Hold on,
- 28:38I'll I'll grant when women started turning a
- 28:41profit off of sex work and wielding control,
- 28:44then why were they not against things like Hooters?
- 28:46And when feminists protested Hooters,
- 28:47men made an absolute mockery of women.
- 28:50There's posters all over Chuckle buzz and male humor
- 28:52sites mocking feminists and saying if you're against Hooters,
- 28:54you're just too ugly to be a Hooters girl.
- 28:56They said that if you're not OK with pornography as a girlfriend,
- 28:58if you say,
- 28:59hey,
- 28:59I actually don't feel.
- 29:00OK with my partner jacking his shit to other
- 29:02naked women while we're supposedly in a monogamous relationship.
- 29:05They said you're insecure.
- 29:06It's purely physical.
- 29:06It's meaningless,
- 29:07right?
- 29:07So why isn't all these other instances of sex work,
- 29:09hey,
- 29:10I don't feel comfortable.
- 29:10Why was sex work a rite of passage for you and go to a bachelor party and have on it?
- 29:15let me go.
- 29:16Well,
- 29:16you asked me to give more than an anecdote,
- 29:18so I had to flush it out,
- 29:19right?
- 29:19Well,
- 29:19yeah,
- 29:20but you ended up giving a lot more anecdotes,
- 29:22anecdotes,
- 29:22but,
- 29:23and,
- 29:23and sure,
- 29:23and some statistics,
- 29:24and the latest statistics,
- 29:26right,
- 29:26there's a Gallup poll done.
- 29:27Um,
- 29:28actually,
- 29:28the majority of men actually disapprove of porn,
- 29:31so that's not true.
- 29:32Well,
- 29:32no,
- 29:32no,
- 29:33no,
- 29:33no,
- 29:33no,
- 29:33you gotta let me finish.
- 29:34You gotta,
- 29:35you gotta let me finish.
- 29:36You gotta let me finish.
- 29:37OK.
- 29:37Secondly,
- 29:38right,
- 29:39um.
- 29:40Your claim is only
- 29:42that we're only against it because it takes control of women.
- 29:46That is a huge universal claim about everyone.
- 29:49It's not the majority of people are against it because of it,
- 29:52it's every single person.
- 29:54I provide one example
- 29:56myself.
- 29:56I'm not against it because it takes control of women.
- 29:59Actually,
- 29:59I,
- 30:00I love women.
- 30:00I respect women.
- 30:02I want women
- 30:03to not degrade themselves,
- 30:05and my view is that only.
- 30:07Fans degrades women
- 30:08and so
- 30:09I want to oppose that because I care about the women.
- 30:12So
- 30:13I'm 25.
- 30:14OK,
- 30:15before the explosion of OnlyFans,
- 30:16is there anywhere on your digital footprint where
- 30:19I can find any vocal opposition to pornography,
- 30:22sex work?
- 30:22Did you say mention,
- 30:23go to strip clubs before they get married?
- 30:25Did you say mention watching porn
- 30:27online at that point?
- 30:28Did you say it to your friends?
- 30:29Was this something anyone was a vocal proponent of?
- 30:32I've always been,
- 30:32I've always.
- 30:33Been against porn.
- 30:34Was it something anyone was vocal about outside of radical feminists?
- 30:37Yes,
- 30:38what are you talking about?
- 30:40Christian morality has always been consistent throughout the years.
- 30:44What are you talking about?
- 30:45People have always been against it because it's not against the natural order.
- 30:49consume more pornography than secular states.
- 30:52That,
- 30:52OK,
- 30:53just because they consume more doesn't mean that they actually approve that.
- 30:56Yeah,
- 30:56sometimes,
- 30:56yeah,
- 30:57yeah,
- 30:58exactly.
- 30:58Christians are hypocrites and thank.
- 31:00God,
- 31:00they put their trust in Jesus Christ,
- 31:02and they redeem,
- 31:03Jesus Christ redeems them of their sins,
- 31:05but that doesn't mean
- 31:07just because they're,
- 31:07they're actively doing it,
- 31:09that they don't disapprove of the things that they do,
- 31:11right?
- 31:11And you actually see that in the Bible.
- 31:13Paul talks.
- 31:13I'm saying I didn't see all these like cohorts of
- 31:15tradcons coming to the mic talking about how they're so anti-porn
- 31:19until again talking about purity culture was a huge thing.
- 31:23Purity culture was a huge thing,
- 31:24and it was not based in taking control away.
- 31:26From women,
- 31:27it was based in a biblical sex ethic.
- 31:29Your claim has already been proven false
- 31:31agree that these Christian pundits became vocal
- 31:35once OnlyFans took off.
- 31:37No,
- 31:37they've been vocal for
- 31:39against porn
- 31:40ever since Christianity has started,
- 31:42they have been against
- 31:44anything outside of biblical sex ethic.
- 31:46I mean,
- 31:47you can even go back to Roman times
- 31:49where,
- 31:50uh,
- 31:50Romans,
- 31:51like slaves were just used for sex.
- 31:53And that was just a normal natural thing that the Romans did in their society.
- 31:58Christians opposed that and actually got that to be made illegal.
- 32:02They banned that.
- 32:03Christians have always been against it because
- 32:05it's always been against God's design,
- 32:07and you to say with OnlyFans,
- 32:09and I wanna bring the viewers are only debating people like
- 32:12me and they're not debating the average guy who watches porn.
- 32:16Why,
- 32:16why,
- 32:16why was all the moral onus always just directed at the OnlyFans creator because.
- 32:20Now we have control.
- 32:21Why not debate?
- 32:22Why,
- 32:22why aren't they debating the average dude?
- 32:2490% of dudes are watching porn.
- 32:25Where were the average dude going on jubilee and,
- 32:28and debating these prompts?
- 32:30No,
- 32:30you're doing it and I'm debating you.
- 32:32But that podcast,
- 32:33but,
- 32:33but listen,
- 32:34listen,
- 32:34that goes,
- 32:35that's still your claim is still false.
- 32:37What is your claim
- 32:38that this is the
- 32:39only
- 32:40reason that has been,
- 32:41that has been disproven.
- 32:43You have not addressed it because the Christian sexual
- 32:46ethic.
- 32:47You haven't disproven it.
- 32:48They did not speak that with their chest until women started doing is a lie.
- 32:52You didn't know that is a lie.
- 32:53You know that's not true.
- 32:55I brought up a Christian up a historical fact.
- 32:59I did not see a Christian in a single public space or public medium
- 33:02debating with a guy,
- 33:04debating with a girl about the ethics of porn.
- 33:06Therefore,
- 33:06because you didn't see it,
- 33:07it didn't happen.
- 33:08If can you point to where you saw it?
- 33:10It doesn't have to purity based off my.
- 33:12Do you,
- 33:12do you know about purity culture?
- 33:13I do.
- 33:13OK,
- 33:14yes,
- 33:14it is a huge thing.
- 33:15It was a huge.
- 33:16Huge movement,
- 33:16they spoke out against porn,
- 33:18they spoke about
- 33:19out against any sex outside of a covenant marriage.
- 33:22Can you give me a single prominent example of a Christian influencer or anyone
- 33:27taking up arms with the porn industry
- 33:29prior to the advent of OnlyFans in a significant way?
- 33:32Um,
- 33:33like a very specific example.
- 33:35I just pointed to a whole movement which is
- 33:37actually way more powerful than a very specific example,
- 33:40quiet,
- 33:40and it was a movement that still directed itself largely at women.
- 33:44A lot of purity culture still is disproportionately targeted at women.
- 33:48There were,
- 33:48there's some things about purity so many women across the world,
- 33:51barely,
- 33:52rarely any men.
- 33:53Where do you get that statistic?
- 33:55Purity culture,
- 33:56honor culture,
- 33:56you don't think.
- 33:57Honor culture,
- 33:57honor killings,
- 33:58the idea of killing a woman,
- 33:59killing a person because they transgress standards of purity.
- 34:02You don't think that disproportionately harms
- 34:03and kills and tortures women globally.
- 34:06You think purity culture was about killing women?
- 34:09Purity culture globally
- 34:11is a huge source of homicide against women.
- 34:13Yes,
- 34:13it's a huge source of femicide.
- 34:14When I,
- 34:15when I say purity culture,
- 34:16I'm talking about the movement that happened here in America
- 34:19and there was a specific.
- 34:21Movement in America,
- 34:22purity culture where you would sign a thing saying that,
- 34:25you know,
- 34:25you wouldn't have sex before marriage,
- 34:27and a youth pastor taught it,
- 34:28and there were some problems and flaws with it,
- 34:30sure,
- 34:30but what it goes to show is that your claim is false because it was not saying,
- 34:35hey,
- 34:36don't have sex outside of a biblical marriage,
- 34:39um,
- 34:40because we want to take control from women.
- 34:42No,
- 34:42it's saying this is God's design.
- 34:45And you can disagree.
- 34:46Like,
- 34:46the claim isn't even like,
- 34:48we're not even arguing like whether that's correct or not.
- 34:51You're arguing intentions.
- 34:52You're,
- 34:53you're claiming to know what's in my heart,
- 34:56which is ridiculous,
- 34:57and I would never,
- 34:58I would never say that you are trying to take advantage of lonely man.
- 35:02Like that
- 35:03that's would you say people like Candace Owens,
- 35:05for instance,
- 35:05are good symbols for like the Christian community in terms of like purity culture?
- 35:09No.
- 35:10I,
- 35:11I'm not a fan of Michael Knowles,
- 35:12these types of like popular trad cons,
- 35:15because my point is when I think of like loud Christians or
- 35:18people who are like symbols or the face of the Christian movement,
- 35:20I'm thinking people like Candace Owens who will
- 35:22go on things like the whatever podcast,
- 35:23Fresh and Fit,
- 35:24debate girls like me and tell us we're ruining society the culture ourselves,
- 35:27but then she's like also like always dick riding people
- 35:29like Andrew Tate and always defending them and saying like,
- 35:32oh,
- 35:32they're being unfairly targeted to be friends with people like Kanye West.
- 35:35So I'm saying that the loudest critics of things like.
- 35:38Sex Work and OnlyFans,
- 35:39they never put any of the blame on people
- 35:41who are actually male contributors of the industry.
- 35:43It's only to the girls.
- 35:45I'm gonna pause here,
- 35:46Farha.
- 35:47Well,
- 35:47how would you,
- 35:47you mentioned,
- 35:48uh,
- 35:48Hugh Hefner before.
- 35:49What would you respond to Michael when he said that there was a Christian movement
- 35:53that was really anti-H Hugh Hefner,
- 35:55anti-Playboy,
- 35:56anti-hustler?
- 35:57Were you aware of that movement?
- 35:59Um,
- 35:59I think,
- 36:00I think prior to OnlyFans,
- 36:01yeah,
- 36:02the,
- 36:02the groups that were against it were Rad Femmes and then Tradcons,
- 36:05people who were like.
- 36:05Traditionally conservative and stuff,
- 36:07I just think that their loudness coincided with women taking control.
- 36:10We see a lot more vitriol.
- 36:11We see a lot more just volume of opposition.
- 36:14Sometimes loudness is because something is
- 36:15becoming more prominent in the culture,
- 36:17right?
- 36:18So like,
- 36:18obviously like when it comes to prominent,
- 36:20when it comes to,
- 36:21when it comes to more control,
- 36:23no,
- 36:23well,
- 36:24because porn use was at 90% for male consumption,
- 36:27but that even if I granted you that,
- 36:29like,
- 36:30oh,
- 36:30it,
- 36:30it coincided with women taking control,
- 36:32that does.
- 36:33It doesn't mean their motivations were because of that.
- 36:36Their motivations was again,
- 36:38because it's going against the God's design for,
- 36:40for family and for marriage and for sex,
- 36:43and you have not proven your claim,
- 36:45not coincided with the fact that this was becoming more relevant culturally,
- 36:48it was becoming a bigger problem.
- 36:49But I said the only thing that changed in terms of
- 36:52the proliferation of sex work because it was practically ubiquitous,
- 36:5590% of men are watching it.
- 36:56Most men are going to the strip club for their bachelor party,
- 36:58or maybe not Christians,
- 36:59but I'm sure they are anyway.
- 37:00Because like I said,
- 37:01they consume more porn inordinately.
- 37:03Um,
- 37:04they could probably fact-check me on it,
- 37:05but I'm sure the same way,
- 37:07same way they're,
- 37:07you could fact-check me on whether Christian red states are watching more porn.
- 37:10Some would tell me that they're going to a lot of strip clubs and purchasing
- 37:12prostitutes as well at a pretty high rate comparable to the rest of the population.
- 37:16So I'm just saying,
- 37:17you're saying the loudness from Christians over the past
- 37:19few years coincided with it becoming a bigger problem.
- 37:21OnlyFans didn't make it a bigger problem.
- 37:24The only thing that shifted was it subverted
- 37:25the power dynamics and gave these women,
- 37:27the female sex workers.
- 37:30More control because why was the problem clearly made it more popular,
- 37:32right?
- 37:32It became,
- 37:32it became actually more accessible for women to do something like that,
- 37:36right?
- 37:36And so now you have an explosion of OnlyFan creators that are just
- 37:40on OnlyFans that have never even entered into like a Pornhub type situation,
- 37:45right?
- 37:45And so it definitely became more prominent and just like you see like with
- 37:49with the transgender
- 37:51meant to be consuming,
- 37:52we're gonna pause here.
- 37:53You've been voted out by the majority.
- 37:55Thank you.
- 37:59If you would like to be the next debater,
- 38:00please get to the chair in 321.
- 38:06Mm.
- 38:08Hi,
- 38:08I'm Guy Hooley,
- 38:09huge fan.
- 38:11Um,
- 38:12so first of all,
- 38:13just like,
- 38:14you know,
- 38:14as a non-rinary person,
- 38:16I do understand that like,
- 38:18you know,
- 38:19when you're
- 38:20non-rinary trinary,
- 38:21yeah,
- 38:22I haven't heard that before.
- 38:22Can you,
- 38:23I don't fit into like the trinary spectrum of like male,
- 38:25female,
- 38:26non-binary.
- 38:27So
- 38:28anyways,
- 38:28regardless,
- 38:29what control do you think
- 38:31that you are,
- 38:32um,
- 38:33like
- 38:33what control do you think that you have
- 38:35as,
- 38:36uh,
- 38:36an OnlyFans creator?
- 38:37Like what control is it that you're taking back?
- 38:40The control is that I,
- 38:42as an OnlyFans creator,
- 38:43can choose when I clock in,
- 38:44when I clock off.
- 38:45I don't have to meet any of these people.
- 38:46You're actually not even allowed to configure any
- 38:48type of meetup off the OnlyFans site,
- 38:50you'll get in trouble,
- 38:51right?
- 38:51So I'm not subjected to the same vulnerable conditions as a typical sex worker
- 38:55or a Hooters girl or,
- 38:56you know,
- 38:56a stripper or a prostitute,
- 38:57whatever it is.
- 38:58So I have control again over who I speak to,
- 39:00what I charge,
- 39:01what I make.
- 39:02I don't necessarily even have to make porn.
- 39:03I don't even necessarily have to do nude content if I want to.
- 39:05I don't have to even touch a man though,
- 39:07right?
- 39:08You don't,
- 39:08but the bob house,
- 39:10Sophie Rain,
- 39:10for instance,
- 39:10she's the highest creator in the world on OnlyFans.
- 39:12She's never done nudity.
- 39:14So that's one particular case,
- 39:15right?
- 39:15That's the highest earner.
- 39:17That's the highest earner.
- 39:18But at the same time we know what the purpose of OnlyFans is,
- 39:21right?
- 39:22And it's to commodify.
- 39:23Sexual gratification,
- 39:24is that not the case?
- 39:26So you're commodifying sexual gratification,
- 39:28and
- 39:28we're already,
- 39:29like you said,
- 39:2989% of the,
- 39:32uh,
- 39:32your consumers are
- 39:33married men.
- 39:34I'm assuming it's close to 100% of your consumers are men.
- 39:36I know you had some lesbian cases.
- 39:38But maybe like 60/40
- 39:41if the case is that men are still consuming your content,
- 39:44you do have economic control,
- 39:46I would say as an OnlyFans creator,
- 39:47but
- 39:48I don't think that economic control is equivalent to,
- 39:51uh,
- 39:51the control of your bodily autonomy.
- 39:53I still think that you are selling your body online
- 39:56and as you do that,
- 39:58why is that incompatible with control?
- 40:01Why is
- 40:01what specifically incompatible with control?
- 40:03If I'm selling painted canvases,
- 40:05that doesn't mean I don't control my art.
- 40:08So why is it if even if I'm selling my body,
- 40:10which I'm not disputing,
- 40:12I'm selling my body,
- 40:13why is that antithetical to me wielding control?
- 40:16Because when you're selling art versus selling your body,
- 40:18there's also a,
- 40:19uh,
- 40:19moral aspect to it.
- 40:20I'm not Christian,
- 40:21you know,
- 40:21I'm Jewish,
- 40:22Shabbat Shalom,
- 40:22you know what I mean?
- 40:23So like I'm not like gonna argue on like Christian standards,
- 40:26but I am saying that
- 40:28when you're selling your.
- 40:29Body essentially you are still like you're if we're talking about
- 40:33the influence that you have on other women who are unrelated,
- 40:35even
- 40:36women in your family or or like we talked about girls,
- 40:38children,
- 40:39you're uh promoting this ideology of misogyny essentially that your body is
- 40:45a transaction.
- 40:46Why is it not misogynistic promote misogyny.
- 40:49Because essentially when you're uh posting online your body,
- 40:53right,
- 40:53would you say that your body is a product at this point?
- 40:58Are you objectifying your body?
- 41:00Yes,
- 41:00but like I said earlier,
- 41:01objectification is not inherently,
- 41:03uh,
- 41:04malicious.
- 41:04A lot of objectification is benign.
- 41:06So for instance,
- 41:07like Martha Nussbaum,
- 41:08who's a philosopher who's talked a lot about objectification,
- 41:10she talks about how like when husbands and wives have sex,
- 41:12in theory,
- 41:12like you're technically objectifying in those people in those.
- 41:14Moments if you're having,
- 41:15if you're consumed by really horny thoughts,
- 41:17you're objectifying your partner in a sense when you use their torso as a pillow,
- 41:19right?
- 41:20But we don't consider this objectification usually because it's loaded
- 41:22with all this like normative concepts of being malicious or it
- 41:25means degrading the person or do you think that you
- 41:27are not taking advantage of these men when you are,
- 41:30wait,
- 41:30sorry,
- 41:30but to get back to your other point,
- 41:32you were saying that because I'm selling my body,
- 41:35I don't have control,
- 41:36and then I said if I sell art,
- 41:38I'm not forfeiting control.
- 41:39And then you said the difference there was the
- 41:41fact that you're imbuing what I'm doing as being
- 41:44immoral.
- 41:45And when I asked you why it's immoral,
- 41:46you said,
- 41:46because I'm objectifying myself,
- 41:48but like I said earlier,
- 41:49you're objectifying yourself in pretty
- 41:50much all marketplace transactions there just
- 41:52because I don't think that it's immoral because you're objectifying yourself.
- 41:55I think it's immoral because of the impact that you create as a result of this,
- 41:59because you do profit from this economically and you are,
- 42:02yeah,
- 42:02that's interesting.
- 42:02Why does it,
- 42:03um,
- 42:04can I,
- 42:04can I continue?
- 42:05It might answer what you're gonna ask me.
- 42:06So if you are,
- 42:08um,
- 42:08Dan Ayla,
- 42:09I got ADHD,
- 42:10you know what I mean?
- 42:10I can remind you,
- 42:11you were saying it promotes misogyny,
- 42:12and I'm actually really curious why you think
- 42:15if I were to post,
- 42:16you know,
- 42:16if OnlyFans girls are posting their naked body,
- 42:18why that promotes misogyny.
- 42:19Well,
- 42:19would you say there's a presumption that your body is now like a sexual,
- 42:24uh,
- 42:25you know,
- 42:25object when you post your body online,
- 42:28because that is the intention that you're going into it,
- 42:29is it not?
- 42:30I would,
- 42:31I wouldn't contend with the claim that it's sexual objectification.
- 42:34I would just contend with the claim that sexual objectification
- 42:37is inherently wrong or misogynistic.
- 42:41Because you are sexually objectifying.
- 42:42If I'm married and my husband on Victoria on Valentine's
- 42:45Day buys me like red lingerie because he thinks,
- 42:46oh,
- 42:47she's gonna look super hot in this,
- 42:48this is gonna fit her curves really well.
- 42:49I put it on,
- 42:50he's lusting after me.
- 42:51I feel sexy because he finds me sexy in it.
- 42:53Technically,
- 42:54that's still objectification,
- 42:55sexual objectification.
- 42:55We just don't classify it that way usually because we think objectification
- 42:58has to necessarily mean
- 43:00degraded.
- 43:01But that's actually not the case.
- 43:02By the definition
- 43:03of objectification,
- 43:04you are still objectifying yourself in that moment,
- 43:06but we just see that as benign,
- 43:07healthy,
- 43:08cute,
- 43:08intimate,
- 43:09and I'm saying why can't this is a healthy standard to
- 43:11like send off to society.
- 43:13Like,
- 43:13do you think that what you're doing is healthy,
- 43:14and how is that healthy to society?
- 43:16For the same reason,
- 43:16I don't think it's unhealthy if I
- 43:18my husband,
- 43:19and I don't think that's promoting misogyny.
- 43:21Am I?
- 43:21Am I promoting the idea that women are just sexual objects?
- 43:24If I sexualize myself or my husband,
- 43:26if I do like a engaging him and are engaging in a market that promotes this ideology.
- 43:32Like if,
- 43:32like,
- 43:32like,
- 43:33for example,
- 43:33let's say you're not taking specifically,
- 43:34you're not taking advantage specifically on lonely men,
- 43:36like men,
- 43:37like you're taking advantage of,
- 43:38or let's just not even use the word taking advantage.
- 43:39There are,
- 43:40the end user of your product is a man,
- 43:42correct?
- 43:43So
- 43:43the end,
- 43:44the end user of all my romantic relationships have also been men,
- 43:47so whether or not my entire
- 43:49clientele or the object of my sexualization is virtually entirely male
- 43:53does not speak to whether I'm degrading myself or by
- 43:55that logic you should promote that all women be lesbians.
- 43:59We're gonna pause here.
- 44:00You've been voted out.
- 44:01Thank you.
- 44:02Thank you.
- 44:03Pleasure.
- 44:06If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 44:08please get to the chair in 321.
- 44:15Hi,
- 44:16hi,
- 44:17nice to meet you nice to meet you.
- 44:18Um,
- 44:18so,
- 44:19um,
- 44:19thank you for pointing out that,
- 44:20that women have been,
- 44:21um,
- 44:22opposed to pornography for decades and have been pushing against it.
- 44:24I appreciate that.
- 44:26Um,
- 44:26so a lot of the reasons that women don't
- 44:28like pornography because it promotes violence against women.
- 44:31Um,
- 44:32you said that if you had a child,
- 44:33you would encourage them to wait until they're,
- 44:35I think you said 25,
- 44:3623,
- 44:3725,
- 44:38um,
- 44:38to engage in pornography.
- 44:40Yet on OnlyFans,
- 44:41um,
- 44:4224% of OnlyFans,
- 44:43um,
- 44:43creators are 18 or 19 years old,
- 44:45and 39% are between the ages of 20 and 24.
- 44:49I wonder how you feel about the fact that,
- 44:51um,
- 44:52almost 3/5 of the creators are
- 44:54younger than the age you would tell your daughter to do pornography.
- 44:58Hm.
- 44:58Like I was saying earlier,
- 44:59I think that
- 45:00for the same reason that I'm not against sex
- 45:03wholesale as a concept,
- 45:04even though a lot of the people engaging in sex probably shouldn't be
- 45:06because they aren't of an age where they have the wherewithal to really
- 45:09discern what they're doing,
- 45:10right?
- 45:10But I don't think that translates to needing to be
- 45:12anti-sex.
- 45:12So I guess I'm curious from your point of view,
- 45:14why is it then with sex work just because I would create a carve
- 45:16out and prescribe that most people under a certain age not engage with it,
- 45:19that
- 45:20that means I should be against the industry as a whole.
- 45:23Well,
- 45:23the industry as a whole does harm.
- 45:25So Reuters did a um seven piece article,
- 45:28um,
- 45:28really just,
- 45:29it was a huge investigative,
- 45:30um,
- 45:30article just sort of outlining all of the harms that,
- 45:33that come from OnlyFans.
- 45:34And so it,
- 45:35it outlined.
- 45:36A ton of child sexual abuse,
- 45:38nonconsensual sex,
- 45:40um,
- 45:40and then revenge porn,
- 45:42and then there are,
- 45:42of course,
- 45:43a ton of cases where people are coerced,
- 45:45and you mentioned earlier the lover boy method.
- 45:48Um,
- 45:48this is,
- 45:48it,
- 45:48it's very difficult to prosecute those cases and to
- 45:52because I work with childhood sexual abuse survivors,
- 45:55it's very difficult to have a point of entry.
- 45:58Um,
- 45:59when something is legal and it is encouraged,
- 46:02um,
- 46:03and glamorized,
- 46:04uh,
- 46:04it's very difficult to go in and support those people who are engaged in those,
- 46:09um,
- 46:09exploitive,
- 46:10uh,
- 46:10situations,
- 46:11uh,
- 46:12because it is very difficult to sort of prove that,
- 46:14you know,
- 46:15you're doing this because you are in love with this person.
- 46:17And not because you really want to.
- 46:19And so,
- 46:20the lover boy method is very popular way and,
- 46:22and then also just,
- 46:23just,
- 46:24um,
- 46:25just bribery.
- 46:26So like there's a,
- 46:26uh,
- 46:27there was a case where,
- 46:28um,
- 46:28a yoga,
- 46:29a global yoga studio was,
- 46:30was coercing women to come to a yoga retreat.
- 46:33They called it a yoga retreat,
- 46:34and it was supposed to be about female empowerment and
- 46:37Um,
- 46:37loving your body and all of this.
- 46:39And so one of the things you had to do was you had to submit a video of yourself,
- 46:42you know,
- 46:42with no clothes on just to show that you
- 46:44were ready for this like moment of empowerment.
- 46:46And then when women were getting there,
- 46:47they were being blackmailed and said,
- 46:49we're going to send this content into your family if you don't do OnlyFans.
- 46:53Now that person is still at large because it's a global,
- 46:55um,
- 46:56it's,
- 46:56it was a global scam.
- 46:58And there have been a ton of women who were negatively impacted.
- 47:01It was just a case in,
- 47:03uh,
- 47:03Bellevue,
- 47:04Washington,
- 47:04where they're calling it the OnlyFans mansion,
- 47:06where
- 47:07there were a ton of women who were going out for
- 47:10men who were the men were the ones who were controlling,
- 47:12um,
- 47:13this mansion.
- 47:14Girls were going out and recruiting young girls.
- 47:16They were recruiting girls specifically who were teenagers,
- 47:19and then they were starting the OnlyFans content when they,
- 47:21the day they turned 18.
- 47:22So it just creates so much danger.
- 47:24It creates,
- 47:25um,
- 47:26so much potential for exploitation.
- 47:28And I wonder
- 47:29what you think about that.
- 47:30I have a lot of thoughts on that.
- 47:31Um,
- 47:31I'm definitely not interested in sanitizing the sex
- 47:33trafficking industry in order to win a debate.
- 47:35I'm someone who's been
- 47:36pretty
- 47:37consistent about my stance about it.
- 47:38I don't think people should
- 47:39use Pornhub because it's oftentimes just been used to host
- 47:43really,
- 47:43really awful content,
- 47:44sex trafficking content,
- 47:45uh,
- 47:46child content.
- 47:47There's a reason that Pornhub scrubbed 80% of their content
- 47:50a few years back,
- 47:50right?
- 47:51They had asphyxiation content of women being suffocated with plastic bags.
- 47:54They had gay
- 47:55content,
- 47:55right?
- 47:56And I think,
- 47:56um,
- 47:56it's unfortunate that.
- 47:57It took so long
- 47:58for that to be overturned.
- 47:59I think OnlyFans
- 48:01so far is the best iteration of sex work we've ever seen.
- 48:04It has the least amount of trafficking content that we've ever seen.
- 48:07Granted,
- 48:07it's only been around for 11 years now,
- 48:10it's possible that we'll see higher numbers as it goes up,
- 48:12but for right now,
- 48:13it has really strict standards on identification and things like that.
- 48:16Um,
- 48:17but yeah,
- 48:17I'm definitely not interested in,
- 48:18again,
- 48:19glossing over sex trafficking.
- 48:20I think a lot of the sex work industry,
- 48:21like you pointed out,
- 48:23is trafficking,
- 48:23right?
- 48:23Like 9 over 90% of street walkers,
- 48:26like women who do street.
- 48:27Prostitution,
- 48:28all report that they would leave the industry if they could.
- 48:30A rate of California massage parlors,
- 48:32which sell sexual services,
- 48:33found that over 70% of the women there were being trafficked.
- 48:35A rate of Vancouver massage parlors found that 100% of the workers there,
- 48:39when asked if they'd like to speak to a victim's rescue unit,
- 48:42all when told,
- 48:43you'll be safe,
- 48:44you're not going to be punished,
- 48:45this isn't a trap,
- 48:46all said yes,
- 48:46right?
- 48:47So I'm not going to argue that,
- 48:48like,
- 48:49most of the people in sex work
- 48:50want to be doing it.
- 48:51I think it's,
- 48:52I think it's a travesty.
- 48:53I would just argue that
- 48:55a couple of things.
- 48:56One would be,
- 48:57when I'm asking if something is inherently degrading,
- 48:59I'm basically asking people to peel back all the unnecessary variables of it
- 49:03and ask,
- 49:03at its core,
- 49:04is the idea of sex for money inherently degrading?
- 49:07Because I would argue a lot of the industry,
- 49:08which frames it
- 49:09is degrading.
- 49:10But I think if you were to ask me,
- 49:11for instance,
- 49:12is marriage inherently degrading,
- 49:13and if I were to say yes,
- 49:15because 15 million women,
- 49:17uh,
- 49:1715 million women globally
- 49:19are being forced into marriage,
- 49:20and that includes child brides,
- 49:21you'd probably say that I'm glossing over the key word thereof inherently,
- 49:24and you would say I'm missing
- 49:25the key.
- 49:26Components,
- 49:27the necessary components of what qualifies
- 49:29as marriage.
- 49:30So for instance,
- 49:30some other industries I like to think about is fishing and chocolate.
- 49:33So for instance,
- 49:34if I'm a chocolatier and I harvest my own cacao beans
- 49:37here and I,
- 49:38uh,
- 49:38make chocolate bars or something,
- 49:40it'd be weird for someone to go,
- 49:42you're doing something unethical simply because 2 million
- 49:44kids are being trafficked on the Ivory Coast
- 49:46to
- 49:47farm chocolate,
- 49:47right?
- 49:47We would wait,
- 49:48can I respond to that?
- 49:49OK,
- 49:49so you are very,
- 49:50very well spoken.
- 49:52Um,
- 49:52you seem like a really bright person.
- 49:54And so I just wonder like why.
- 49:56So you understand that there's all this exploitation and and and across all
- 50:01fields like I think that the thing about it is is that women
- 50:04Um,
- 50:04over the course of history,
- 50:06have fought really hard to not be
- 50:08objectified without regard to our well-being,
- 50:11except I'm gonna add that last piece.
- 50:13So it's not just objectification,
- 50:14it's objectification
- 50:16without regard to our well-being.
- 50:18OK?
- 50:18So we're whole holistic people.
- 50:20So yes,
- 50:21in marriage,
- 50:21you can have sex and there's a moment where
- 50:23your husband might just see you as an object.
- 50:25Yes,
- 50:25but after you have sex in your
- 50:27Lying next to your husband,
- 50:28he's your husband.
- 50:29He has to think about you.
- 50:30He has to think about your needs.
- 50:32And men don't have to do that with,
- 50:34with an OnlyFans model,
- 50:36you know,
- 50:36they just log off and they don't have to care about you anymore.
- 50:38And well,
- 50:39go ahead.
- 50:39I have a lot to say,
- 50:40but go ahead.
- 50:41I don't think that particular interaction needs to be enshrined in romantic
- 50:45love for it to be in accordance with the woman's well-being,
- 50:47kind of like I was pointing out earlier,
- 50:48like when we think about
- 50:49jobs which are respected.
- 50:51We don't usually think that we need to have a compassionate relationship.
- 50:54So again,
- 50:54when I go and buy coffee from a barista,
- 50:56it's fine that technically I'm just getting coffee from them,
- 50:59but the thing that would be wrong is if I'm also mistreating them,
- 51:02if they're getting underpaid,
- 51:03overworked,
- 51:03like these are the things that we base degradation but there is a,
- 51:05there is a component when I was saying before about women
- 51:08have really worked really hard over the course of history,
- 51:10like we fought for the right to vote,
- 51:12uh,
- 51:12you know,
- 51:13child brides,
- 51:13you mentioned.
- 51:14There are a ton of women who are fighting against this female genital mutilation.
- 51:18Like there's just so much that we're trying to do to empower women and say to men,
- 51:21we are not sex toys.
- 51:23Like we are people,
- 51:24like,
- 51:24and you have to see us as whole people who can go be CEOs,
- 51:28be business owners,
- 51:29be the president,
- 51:29you know,
- 51:30we can do these things.
- 51:31And it,
- 51:31I just wonder if you think that,
- 51:33that,
- 51:33that sort of inviting men to say,
- 51:35no,
- 51:35you can use me as a sex toy.
- 51:37Uh,
- 51:38that,
- 51:38that doesn't sort of pull us back.
- 51:40Like,
- 51:40why not join the movement of people who were saying,
- 51:43like,
- 51:44like I said,
- 51:44you're really bright,
- 51:45and there are a lot of girls out there who are very vulnerable,
- 51:47like the,
- 51:48the
- 51:48Um,
- 51:49the,
- 51:50the number,
- 51:50the percentage of people in,
- 51:52in Las Vegas that,
- 51:53that,
- 51:53um,
- 51:54enter into sex work,
- 51:55there's 45% of them
- 51:57aged out of foster care,
- 51:5853% of them entered sex work,
- 52:02uh,
- 52:03while they were homeless,
- 52:04right?
- 52:04Like,
- 52:04we need people like you
- 52:06to join the movement to sort of
- 52:08advocate for those women and say,
- 52:09listen,
- 52:10you,
- 52:10we are not going to do this to women.
- 52:12We need to give women better opportunities.
- 52:13Opportunities we need to treat them with respect,
- 52:16and we need to create an environment where they don't have to do this,
- 52:19because a lot of them don't have a choice.
- 52:20It sounds like maybe you feel like you do have a choice,
- 52:23but a lot of people don't.
- 52:24I agree.
- 52:25That's kind of what I was getting at.
- 52:26I,
- 52:27one,
- 52:27I don't think sex work
- 52:28is antithetical to the idea of people seeing us as
- 52:31whole people.
- 52:32And I think that if a guy,
- 52:33if a,
- 52:33if a guy seeing a woman in latex is enough
- 52:36for him to justify seeing women as second class citizens,
- 52:38I don't think that.
- 52:39I was on track to be a feminist ally,
- 52:40right?
- 52:40Like,
- 52:41I think if a man can't reconcile the idea of a woman
- 52:44being sexual with also women being equal to us as a class,
- 52:47I would say he's suffering from a pretty intense Madonna whore complex,
- 52:49right?
- 52:50And that's not going to just end with sex work,
- 52:51that,
- 52:51like,
- 52:52if a guy already has misogynistic preconceptions,
- 52:54and they've done studies about this with porn,
- 52:55if a guy already has misogynistic preconceptions,
- 52:58yeah,
- 52:58watching sexual content of women is going to reinforce his beliefs.
- 53:01If he doesn't have that preconception,
- 53:02watching porn will not reinforce it.
- 53:04But if He already has that lens.
- 53:05It doesn't matter if the woman he's married to waited until marriage him,
- 53:08he's going to see that woman as a sex slave.
- 53:10It doesn't matter if the woman
- 53:11is not
- 53:12a prostitute,
- 53:13but she put out on the first date,
- 53:14he's going to see that woman as inherently being
- 53:16lesser than because she put out.
- 53:18So he's going to use whatever data points he can
- 53:20and color it with that lens.
- 53:21The idea is,
- 53:22I think we need to be eroding men's lens at that first step rather than
- 53:26just saying,
- 53:26like,
- 53:26we need to cater these data points around what's going to.
- 53:30Erode that lens because it doesn't work that way.
- 53:31And like I was saying before,
- 53:33I don't think OnlyFans is necessarily
- 53:35um
- 53:36antithetical to men seeing us as humans,
- 53:38and I also am very anti-trafficking,
- 53:40and I do see OnlyFans actually,
- 53:41like,
- 53:42ironically,
- 53:42as a way that could combat that.
- 53:44So for instance,
- 53:44the biggest driver of sex trafficking globally is economic collapse.
- 53:48Wait,
- 53:48I wanna hear that.
- 53:48I'm gonna,
- 53:49I wanna go back to it,
- 53:49but I want to respond to what you were saying a moment ago.
- 53:51So
- 53:52the um
- 53:53men.
- 53:55Yes,
- 53:55there are a lot of problems with men currently,
- 53:57but let's look at the cycle that we're creating.
- 53:58So the,
- 53:59as somebody said earlier that the average age of porn,
- 54:01uh,
- 54:01consumption was age 12,
- 54:03but I've,
- 54:03I've actually seen much lower numbers,
- 54:05and I work in the field,
- 54:06so I've seen a lot of the numbers.
- 54:07It's,
- 54:07I think,
- 54:08typically between the ages of 7 and 9.
- 54:10So let's just say like young boys are,
- 54:12are viewing this content,
- 54:14and they're,
- 54:14they're viewing women
- 54:15who are compliant.
- 54:16They're,
- 54:16they're viewing women who are doing whatever the person is saying.
- 54:19They're,
- 54:20they're,
- 54:20they're
- 54:21viewing women who are getting choked and.
- 54:22Bagged and just treated just terribly,
- 54:25gang banged and so forth.
- 54:27And if you are training a,
- 54:29a young boy from that young of an age,
- 54:31look what's happening in,
- 54:32in terms of his ability to have an intimate relationship with a woman.
- 54:35He's gonna go in and expect,
- 54:36as you said a minute ago,
- 54:37that,
- 54:37that other women are going to act like that.
- 54:39So,
- 54:39so
- 54:40you're creating this,
- 54:41this instance where,
- 54:42so let's look at women,
- 54:43OK?
- 54:43So young girls,
- 54:44right?
- 54:44So we,
- 54:46we have the bodies that,
- 54:47that force us to be organized,
- 54:49right?
- 54:49So we,
- 54:50menstruation is.
- 54:50Between the ages of 9 and 13.
- 54:52So when,
- 54:52when that happens to us,
- 54:53we have to think about,
- 54:54we have to plan for the future,
- 54:55we have to take care of our bodies.
- 54:57We have to be organized,
- 54:58we have to be responsible.
- 55:00Men typically become responsible because they have
- 55:02a sex drive and they approach women,
- 55:04and women set up those boundaries and say,
- 55:06hey,
- 55:06you cannot,
- 55:07I have to,
- 55:08to deal with the consequences if I get pregnant.
- 55:10OK,
- 55:11I,
- 55:11I have a,
- 55:12um,
- 55:12can I respond to a couple because I think you're pivoting points a little bit.
- 55:15Yeah,
- 55:15the first thing I wanted to say,
- 55:16you were saying men are seeing
- 55:18negative.
- 55:19Content online and then they're modeling it in the real world.
- 55:21I would agree with that.
- 55:23My antidote to that wouldn't be you need to completely,
- 55:26uh,
- 55:26trash the genre.
- 55:27It's you make alterations to the genre.
- 55:29So,
- 55:29for instance,
- 55:30before the 2010s,
- 55:32you'd be hard pressed to find a sitcom that wasn't littered in like homophobic,
- 55:35sexist,
- 55:36uh,
- 55:36racist tropes,
- 55:37whatever.
- 55:38Our solution to that isn't let's just get rid of TV as a genre.
- 55:40We think,
- 55:41how about we use this,
- 55:42uh,
- 55:42medium as a vehicle to promote the sorts of messaging we want to see in society.
- 55:45So if you're a Christian,
- 55:47Think,
- 55:47let's,
- 55:47let's imbue this genre with a bunch of family messaging.
- 55:50If you're a liberal,
- 55:51you'll think,
- 55:51let's fill it with gay love stories.
- 55:53Let's fill it with,
- 55:54uh,
- 55:54body positivity,
- 55:55etc.
- 55:55You know,
- 55:56minstrel shows,
- 55:56for instance,
- 55:57our antidote to that wasn't,
- 55:58let's just get rid of theater.
- 55:59It's,
- 55:59no,
- 55:59let's get rid of the content in which people learn that black people
- 56:02are second-class citizens because they're seeing minstrel shows.
- 56:05So it seems like porn is the one category where we're
- 56:06very eager to throw away the baby with the bathwater and go
- 56:09because it's often littered with content,
- 56:11which is unfair to women.
- 56:12We're going to pause here.
- 56:13We're out of time on this claim.
- 56:15Thank you.
- 56:19My next surrounded claim is that being on OnlyFans does
- 56:22not make you unfit for a healthy relationship or family.
- 56:25If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 56:26get to the chair in 321.
- 56:31Hello.
- 56:32Hi,
- 56:32I'm Sarafina.
- 56:34How are you doing today?
- 56:35Doing great.
- 56:35How are you?
- 56:36Deeply like,
- 56:36how,
- 56:36how,
- 56:37how are you feeling?
- 56:38I feel really good.
- 56:39I'm I love doing this.
- 56:40Yeah,
- 56:40I'm happy you're here.
- 56:41I've actually have never met like an OnlyFans model or anything like that,
- 56:44so I'm like in LA.
- 56:46I'm,
- 56:46I'm from San Diego,
- 56:47originally from Chicago,
- 56:48but I'm just,
- 56:49I'm not really well exposed.
- 56:50So if anything,
- 56:50I know we've been talking.
- 56:51This is a debate.
- 56:52It's a lot of facts.
- 56:52Yes,
- 56:53we can talk,
- 56:53talk
- 56:54facts,
- 56:54facts,
- 56:55statistics all day long,
- 56:56but I really want to get to like
- 56:58kind of why you're doing this.
- 56:59And I know that your claim is talking about how it's,
- 57:01doesn't make you not unfit
- 57:03for a healthy relationship or a family.
- 57:05I'm kind of curious on the family side.
- 57:07So,
- 57:08and I,
- 57:08I also just want to start off.
- 57:09I don't think so if someone's in this industry that you can't
- 57:11have a healthy relationship and that you can't have a family.
- 57:14I'm not saying that.
- 57:15I'm just confused on how it could be beneficial,
- 57:17and I just want to hear from your perspective.
- 57:18If you were to have a family one day,
- 57:20which is you,
- 57:21maybe your husband or someone,
- 57:22and you adopt children or you have children on your own,
- 57:25how is your content gonna affect them?
- 57:27Um,
- 57:28it could affect them in multiple ways.
- 57:30I would say,
- 57:31first of all,
- 57:31the reason I don't believe it disqualifies you from being
- 57:34a good parent is that the number one factor
- 57:35for child outcome is going to be socioeconomic status,
- 57:38right?
- 57:38So I've actually been able to make an absolute killing on OnlyFans in a way that
- 57:42my parents weren't so lucky to make as much money being immigrants and coming here.
- 57:46Like I said earlier,
- 57:47they were,
- 57:47uh,
- 57:48minimum wage workers my whole.
- 57:49Life,
- 57:49and I think that's going to have more adverse outcomes on the kids
- 57:52than whether or not the job I do is considered prestigious by other people,
- 57:55right?
- 57:56Um,
- 57:57what do you think the negative outcome would be
- 57:59for my future children of me doing OnlyFans?
- 58:02My two main points with that would be one,
- 58:05when you have a child,
- 58:06the first thing of love that they're going to know
- 58:08is the relationship between you and your partner.
- 58:11And when they get to grow up and be like,
- 58:13love is,
- 58:14I mean,
- 58:15everyone's gonna have a different definition of love,
- 58:16but part of that is intimacy.
- 58:18Intimacy is love.
- 58:19And when they realize the most sacred thing that you and your husband did
- 58:23to create the child
- 58:24was through sex,
- 58:25and you're commodifying that to so many people out there,
- 58:28they might realize,
- 58:29wait,
- 58:29is it really that special what they did
- 58:31to have me?
- 58:33Does that lessen the value of it because it's out there?
- 58:35And the other one too as well was like,
- 58:38if you,
- 58:38if you,
- 58:39you have your kid.
- 58:40have friends and then their friends find out that their mom
- 58:43and their dad are doing OnlyFans and get bullied for it.
- 58:45That's not something they necessarily signed up for.
- 58:47And I guess,
- 58:47you know,
- 58:48there's traumas that get passed down gender relationally,
- 58:50but
- 58:51I also think this is something that's in your choice.
- 58:52So I'm,
- 58:53it's not you.
- 58:53I'm just curious as to
- 58:55how that's like just beneficial for a child that,
- 58:57um,
- 58:58for your first point,
- 58:59the fact that it somehow degrades the sanctity of
- 59:01it to again make it available for a transaction.
- 59:03Like I was saying earlier,
- 59:04I don't think we apply this to other things,
- 59:06right?
- 59:06Like if I'm making food for my child,
- 59:08and then,
- 59:08Like I said,
- 59:09if I'm a personal chef or I open up a restaurant,
- 59:11I would think my child's an idiot if they're like,
- 59:12Oh,
- 59:13so you don't really love me
- 59:14because you make food for other people too.
- 59:15I would say,
- 59:16why don't you love.
- 59:17We talked about that earlier.
- 59:18Yeah,
- 59:18yeah.
- 59:19So I'll address your second point,
- 59:20the bullying thing.
- 59:21I don't think we should treat bullying as a moral litmus.
- 59:22So I was a financial aid kid at prep school my whole life.
- 59:24People poked fun at the fact that my parents were cashiers.
- 59:27I would never want my parents to,
- 59:28uh,
- 59:29discern from that that their job is degrading,
- 59:30that there's something wrong with that.
- 59:32I think the moral failure of bullying falls on the bully and
- 59:34the parents of the bully more than the parents of the bullied,
- 59:37right?
- 59:37So the two biggest factors for whether a child's going
- 59:39to get bullied in school is looks and race.
- 59:41So if they're like weird looking or if they're racial minority,
- 59:43right?
- 59:44So for instance,
- 59:44after Brown versus Board of Education when we saw desegregation in schools,
- 59:47we saw an uptick in bullying because now you have,
- 59:50uh,
- 59:50kids of color going to school with white kids,
- 59:51right?
- 59:52But we don't say,
- 59:52well,
- 59:53maybe we shouldn't do this in order to stave off bullying.
- 59:55We see bullying as a lesser goal in order to preserve some sort of higher,
- 59:58higher order goal
- 59:59such as liberation,
- 1:00:00right?
- 1:00:01So I don't think we should expect people,
- 1:00:02for instance,
- 1:00:02who are gay,
- 1:00:03to not enter gay relationships because their kids might be bullied for them.
- 1:00:06Guy,
- 1:00:06so I don't know why sex work would be the exception.
- 1:00:08We expect people to again,
- 1:00:10forfeit their autonomy,
- 1:00:10forfeit what they believe is morally neutral or morally benign in order to again
- 1:00:14stave off bullying when bullying is not a reflection of you doing something wrong.
- 1:00:18And I think it's actually
- 1:00:19very morally corrupt to see bullying as a gauge of whether you're
- 1:00:22doing something wrong because it's basically giving ethos to the bully.
- 1:00:25But don't you think it's Harris,
- 1:00:26pause for a moment,
- 1:00:27Farha.
- 1:00:28For people who don't know your content,
- 1:00:30how explicit is your OnlyFans content?
- 1:00:33Um,
- 1:00:33you just gotta subscribe.
- 1:00:34I'm not subscribing.
- 1:00:35I'm not subscribing.
- 1:00:37And another question,
- 1:00:38are all these transactions considered equal,
- 1:00:41you know,
- 1:00:42paying for food versus paying for OnlyFans
- 1:00:44paying or actually actually paying for sex?
- 1:00:45Is all that equal to you?
- 1:00:49It's equal generally in a moral sense,
- 1:00:51but like I said earlier,
- 1:00:52I think we should be more morally scrutinizing
- 1:00:55of sex
- 1:00:56as a transaction because I think,
- 1:00:57for instance,
- 1:00:58if someone is being forced to sell sex,
- 1:01:00I think that's a greater moral sin or a greater moral.
- 1:01:03Transgression than if someone's forced,
- 1:01:05for instance,
- 1:01:05into other types of labor.
- 1:01:07So they're not equal in that sense,
- 1:01:08no.
- 1:01:09But if,
- 1:01:09if it's consensual and voluntary and have their own volition,
- 1:01:12then yes,
- 1:01:12they're equal.
- 1:01:12I just also just have kind of like a curiosity question.
- 1:01:16Like,
- 1:01:16if
- 1:01:17do you want to have kids one day?
- 1:01:18Just wondering.
- 1:01:18I'm not sure yet.
- 1:01:19OK,
- 1:01:20so let's just say like maybe you do want to have a kid one day,
- 1:01:22and
- 1:01:22your
- 1:01:23daughter,
- 1:01:23let's say you have a daughter and she's like,
- 1:01:25you know,
- 1:01:25she's getting a little bit older,
- 1:01:26she's 1013,
- 1:01:27entering puberty,
- 1:01:28and she finds out the content that you're creating.
- 1:01:30Do you think you're setting a good example for her?
- 1:01:32Um,
- 1:01:33yeah,
- 1:01:34how so?
- 1:01:35Because
- 1:01:35I don't think I'm setting a bad example.
- 1:01:37If my daughter was 13 and said,
- 1:01:39I'm gonna
- 1:01:40try to sell sex,
- 1:01:41I would say no.
- 1:01:41I would advise my daughter to wait until she's like 23,
- 1:01:4425 to make any sort of sexual decision like that.
- 1:01:47Even when it comes to just having sex,
- 1:01:48I would say,
- 1:01:49I want you to wait till you're 23,
- 1:01:5025.
- 1:01:50I didn't even have sex for the first time until I was 26,
- 1:01:52right?
- 1:01:53So I would want people
- 1:01:54to wait until they're older because the rates of
- 1:01:55sexual regret tend to nosedive once you're 23,
- 1:01:58how you're
- 1:01:59putting your body out there.
- 1:02:00Would you want her at 13 years old to know that it's OK to
- 1:02:03flash myself out there?
- 1:02:05I would want her at 13 to know that there's no moral
- 1:02:08sin
- 1:02:09in showing your body
- 1:02:11for money at the age of,
- 1:02:12if she's 26,
- 1:02:13for selling that types of photos rather than reserving it for a husband.
- 1:02:16I don't believe,
- 1:02:17again,
- 1:02:17that she's necessarily empowering herself
- 1:02:19anymore by doing it with a husband,
- 1:02:20and I think when we say things like that,
- 1:02:22we offer
- 1:02:23too much moral ethos to relationships,
- 1:02:25and we assume that your husband's just someone who's
- 1:02:27going to respect you and all these things.
- 1:02:28And I think it glosses over a lot of interesting factors,
- 1:02:31which is that,
- 1:02:31like,
- 1:02:32a lot of women are being degraded within relationships.
- 1:02:34You're more likely,
- 1:02:34for instance,
- 1:02:35to be coerced into sex acts that you don't want
- 1:02:37by a romantic partner rather than a casual partner.
- 1:02:39A romantic partner has a lot more emotional leverage over you.
- 1:02:42This is why pimps,
- 1:02:42for instance,
- 1:02:43they often use like the lover boy method as a
- 1:02:45coercion tactic to goad women into really violent sex acts,
- 1:02:47right?
- 1:02:48So this assumption that,
- 1:02:49you know,
- 1:02:49she's ought to have sex with.
- 1:02:50Within a marriage,
- 1:02:51I actually think does a lot of disservice to sexual ethics and glosses
- 1:02:54over again a lot of the sexual coercion that we see within relationships
- 1:02:57and overestimates them within marketplace transactions.
- 1:03:01OK,
- 1:03:01but I'm still trying to we have to pause here.
- 1:03:02You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:03:04Thank you so much.
- 1:03:04I appreciate your time and I wish you well if you have kids in the future.
- 1:03:07Yeah,
- 1:03:08take care.
- 1:03:08If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:03:10please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:03:16Hi,
- 1:03:17hi,
- 1:03:17hi,
- 1:03:17it's nice to meet you.
- 1:03:18You too.
- 1:03:19Um,
- 1:03:19so really quickly,
- 1:03:20I wanted to ask you for your definition of like what would make
- 1:03:23a healthy relationship and what does that look like to you?
- 1:03:27Um,
- 1:03:27I think it'd be respecting your partner's
- 1:03:29boundaries.
- 1:03:30I would think it's not doing things behind their back,
- 1:03:32keeping secrets from them,
- 1:03:34um,
- 1:03:35not talking poorly about them,
- 1:03:36not humiliating them,
- 1:03:37things like that.
- 1:03:38And so when a child is included into that
- 1:03:42argument,
- 1:03:42does it really,
- 1:03:43like,
- 1:03:43where,
- 1:03:44where do they
- 1:03:45add to that,
- 1:03:46to the health of the relationship?
- 1:03:48Could you rephrase?
- 1:03:49So
- 1:03:50between two people,
- 1:03:51right,
- 1:03:51a healthy relationship is something that's open.
- 1:03:53You both know what each other are doing and you both consent to whatever it is
- 1:03:57you're,
- 1:03:57you know,
- 1:03:58like,
- 1:03:58OK,
- 1:03:58OK,
- 1:03:59so where
- 1:04:01is,
- 1:04:01OK,
- 1:04:02what more would you add on to that
- 1:04:04when a child is introduced into that situation?
- 1:04:06Similar extensions expecting your child's
- 1:04:09um.
- 1:04:11Helping your child's well-being,
- 1:04:12not
- 1:04:13hurting their well-being,
- 1:04:13things like that,
- 1:04:15and can you inherently hurt your child's well-being?
- 1:04:18Yeah,
- 1:04:19mhm.
- 1:04:20So
- 1:04:21say your child,
- 1:04:21like again,
- 1:04:2213 year old daughter,
- 1:04:23thirteen-year-old son goes and finds like
- 1:04:25your content online.
- 1:04:27Is how it wouldn't that be hurting their their well-being mentally because
- 1:04:31that is something that we try to separate from the conversation of
- 1:04:35OnlyFans having an effect
- 1:04:37on not just adults but also children too.
- 1:04:40We cannot,
- 1:04:41you can't,
- 1:04:41you can't constantly be with your child so you
- 1:04:43don't know the type of content they're consuming,
- 1:04:45but
- 1:04:46because there's to you there's nothing wrong with OnlyFans,
- 1:04:48there's nothing wrong with this,
- 1:04:49um.
- 1:04:50Type of work,
- 1:04:51would it be wrong for your child,
- 1:04:52like,
- 1:04:53for your child,
- 1:04:53even if they're 18,
- 1:04:54to watch your content?
- 1:04:55I would think it's strange.
- 1:04:56I,
- 1:04:57I would think it's
- 1:04:58less traumatizing,
- 1:04:59I guess,
- 1:05:00if they're over 18,
- 1:05:01because if you're comparing like whether an 8-year-old stumbles into it,
- 1:05:03I don't think they have the wherewithal to understand what they're watching,
- 1:05:05and I think
- 1:05:05that potentially be more scarring,
- 1:05:07the same way I wouldn't prescribe 8-year-olds have sex,
- 1:05:09right,
- 1:05:09even though
- 1:05:10there's nothing
- 1:05:11wrong inherently with sex,
- 1:05:12right?
- 1:05:12So,
- 1:05:13I would,
- 1:05:13I would say that the age changes it,
- 1:05:15but I would,
- 1:05:15I would still think it's weird,
- 1:05:16yeah,
- 1:05:16if like,
- 1:05:17I was 60 and my 30 year old kid,
- 1:05:19for instance,
- 1:05:19was looking up old sex tapes of me,
- 1:05:21yeah.
- 1:05:22And what if they just stumbled upon it,
- 1:05:23like they didn't have to search up all my mom's sex video from 20 years ago,
- 1:05:27like,
- 1:05:27what if they just stumbled upon it?
- 1:05:29Um,
- 1:05:29I would think that's unfortunate.
- 1:05:30I'd probably have a conversation with them of like what I do online.
- 1:05:34I,
- 1:05:34I don't know how they would just like stumble
- 1:05:35into it maybe if they're on Twitter or something,
- 1:05:37but I,
- 1:05:37I wouldn't say that that makes me
- 1:05:38a bad parent if they stumble into something
- 1:05:41unflattering.
- 1:05:42And would you rather they not stumble into that?
- 1:05:44Like,
- 1:05:44would you rather they not consume that type of content?
- 1:05:47Well,
- 1:05:47those are two different questions.
- 1:05:48Would I rather they not consume that type of content wholesale,
- 1:05:51like watch porn?
- 1:05:52I don't.
- 1:05:52Particularly care if they're of a certain age,
- 1:05:55such as,
- 1:05:55like I said,
- 1:05:56over 18 or something like that.
- 1:05:58Whether I want them to consume that content of me is different,
- 1:06:00right?
- 1:06:01Probably not.
- 1:06:02But
- 1:06:02even if they do,
- 1:06:03I,
- 1:06:03I don't think that makes me a shit parent.
- 1:06:05OK,
- 1:06:05and I think that's fair,
- 1:06:06but
- 1:06:07it's still,
- 1:06:08in my opinion,
- 1:06:09I don't think that's a healthy situation to put.
- 1:06:11Your children in or like the friends of your
- 1:06:14of your um partner or whoever you can say like within that relationship,
- 1:06:17oh it's it's still healthy,
- 1:06:19however,
- 1:06:19I think there the real consequences consequences that surround that
- 1:06:23choice,
- 1:06:24that decision
- 1:06:26is.
- 1:06:27Going to affect not just you and your partner,
- 1:06:30but the people around you,
- 1:06:31and you can,
- 1:06:32you can decide not to care about what happens to the people around you,
- 1:06:34but that's,
- 1:06:35yeah,
- 1:06:35I,
- 1:06:36I,
- 1:06:36I think it's just strange to me because like I said,
- 1:06:37the biggest factor of your child's outcome
- 1:06:39is going to be things like socioeconomics.
- 1:06:41So for me,
- 1:06:41if I can ensure
- 1:06:42a situation in which they're in a household which is financially healthy,
- 1:06:46in which they can have the sorts of things they need,
- 1:06:48to me that takes obvious precedence over,
- 1:06:50you know,
- 1:06:50maybe this like fringe.
- 1:06:51Thing where they accidentally stumble into a sex tape of me,
- 1:06:54which I don't even know how they would
- 1:06:55accidentally stumble into it again unless they're like
- 1:06:57searching me on Twitter or something like that,
- 1:06:59you know,
- 1:06:59so
- 1:06:59I,
- 1:07:00I think these are just such niche cases and even if they did stumble into that,
- 1:07:03I think that would pale so much in comparison to the to the beneficial
- 1:07:06outcomes they would receive from
- 1:07:08being with a parent who has a high socioeconomic status.
- 1:07:11But is that the only I'm gonna pause here?
- 1:07:12You've been voted out with the majority.
- 1:07:14Thank you.
- 1:07:19If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:07:20please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:07:28Hi Chris,
- 1:07:29nice to meet you,
- 1:07:30um.
- 1:07:32So,
- 1:07:33You mentioned that if you had a child,
- 1:07:35a daughter,
- 1:07:36you would encourage them to wait till they're 23 to 25 years old to have sex.
- 1:07:40Is that correct?
- 1:07:41Yeah,
- 1:07:42I wouldn't
- 1:07:43force it or anything like that or punish them if they didn't,
- 1:07:45but I'd probably just give that suggestion of you're gonna be less
- 1:07:48likely to regret it if you wait a bit till you're older.
- 1:07:50OK,
- 1:07:51um,
- 1:07:52so if that's what you think and that's what you believe,
- 1:07:54um,
- 1:07:55you're a part of a,
- 1:07:56a,
- 1:07:56a platform
- 1:07:57that I don't know if I,
- 1:07:58I would necessarily say that it's encouraging
- 1:08:01the sexual,
- 1:08:01the sexualization of children,
- 1:08:03but
- 1:08:05they have things like the bop house,
- 1:08:06you know,
- 1:08:06where the influencers all live together.
- 1:08:07The girls are,
- 1:08:08I think we can agree that they are young,
- 1:08:10youthful looking.
- 1:08:11And that's kind of their gimmick.
- 1:08:13And I think they're purposely marketing
- 1:08:15to
- 1:08:15younger females
- 1:08:17to groom them
- 1:08:18into thinking this could be you,
- 1:08:19you could have this money,
- 1:08:20you can have this lifestyle.
- 1:08:22All you got to do
- 1:08:23is,
- 1:08:24you know,
- 1:08:25maybe they're not so much saying it,
- 1:08:26but it's like,
- 1:08:27We all know what they're trying to say,
- 1:08:28like,
- 1:08:29they're trying to sexualize kids,
- 1:08:30and so you're part of a platform that is
- 1:08:33sort of an indirectly encouraging that kind of behavior,
- 1:08:35but then you're saying,
- 1:08:36but I don't think,
- 1:08:37you know,
- 1:08:37kids should be or people should be having sex until they're 23,
- 1:08:4025.
- 1:08:41So a lot of the members of the Bob House,
- 1:08:42for instance,
- 1:08:43Sophie Raine and Ari Kitsy is technically not part of the Bob House,
- 1:08:45but does a lot of work with them.
- 1:08:46They've all actually said they don't encourage
- 1:08:48girls to do the type of work they do.
- 1:08:50They actually say that,
- 1:08:51like,
- 1:08:51the odds of you make it,
- 1:08:52I say.
- 1:08:53Every podcast I do,
- 1:08:54I don't recommend that women go into it.
- 1:08:55I was already sitting on 2 million followers before I
- 1:08:57started any type of sex work or anything like that.
- 1:08:59So I knew I was going to be able to retire off of it.
- 1:09:01Like someone mentioned earlier,
- 1:09:02the medium take-home is going to be like $100 a month.
- 1:09:04I don't think it's necessarily worth,
- 1:09:05uh,
- 1:09:06eroding your digital footprint for it,
- 1:09:07not because I think it speaks to your moral worth or your capacity as a parent,
- 1:09:10but because
- 1:09:11it's going to ruin you economically,
- 1:09:13or it's,
- 1:09:13it will affect you economically because we do live in
- 1:09:15a society where people are going to discriminate against you
- 1:09:18if you have done sex work.
- 1:09:19I personally don't think that should be the case,
- 1:09:20which is why I don't think it speaks to morality,
- 1:09:22but I think that that is going to be the economic outcome.
- 1:09:24So I advise people not to do it.
- 1:09:26Many members of the Bob House
- 1:09:27advise women not to do it.
- 1:09:29OK,
- 1:09:29they're saying that you're saying they don't advise.
- 1:09:31Well,
- 1:09:32I don't think they can advise
- 1:09:33children to do this,
- 1:09:34but,
- 1:09:34but you said they were grooming,
- 1:09:36so I
- 1:09:36pushed you on,
- 1:09:37in what sense are they grooming?
- 1:09:38Um,
- 1:09:39well,
- 1:09:39they're showcasing these girls who are all very young looking.
- 1:09:42They are
- 1:09:43sort of in a way saying,
- 1:09:45This could be you.
- 1:09:46Like,
- 1:09:46how are they saying that
- 1:09:47they,
- 1:09:47they live in this mansion.
- 1:09:49They're all having fun all the time.
- 1:09:50They're all like doing these dances.
- 1:09:51It's,
- 1:09:51it's very sexualized in like in an indirect way.
- 1:09:54So it's kind of saying,
- 1:09:55you know,
- 1:09:55they're glamorizing it,
- 1:09:56yeah,
- 1:09:56right.
- 1:09:57So in a way they're kind of saying this could be you,
- 1:09:59and in a sense it's like it's they're making it OK
- 1:10:02for um this kind of behavior.
- 1:10:03And I think we can all agree that we would like to see that,
- 1:10:07um,
- 1:10:07that age where kids start viewing pornography,
- 1:10:09which we,
- 1:10:10I've read some studies where it's 11 now,
- 1:10:12and every year it keeps getting younger and younger.
- 1:10:14And
- 1:10:14the reason why,
- 1:10:15why do you,
- 1:10:15why do you think that is?
- 1:10:16Why do you think we want to um prevent kids or young people from looking at porn?
- 1:10:20Why,
- 1:10:21why do you think that is?
- 1:10:22I think because they don't have the wherewithal
- 1:10:24to really understand what they're looking at,
- 1:10:25and with porn especially,
- 1:10:27people model the sorts of behaviors that they see digitally in the real world.
- 1:10:30And if they don't have that frontal lobe fully developed,
- 1:10:32and let's say they're seeing
- 1:10:33a lot of negative,
- 1:10:34unfortunate content on the hub,
- 1:10:35which I believe there's a lot of,
- 1:10:37it's not good for them to then pitch,
- 1:10:38propose,
- 1:10:39and pressure their female partners into undertaking it with them,
- 1:10:41right?
- 1:10:41So I think that's an argument for excising a lot of the negative.
- 1:10:44Types of content on the hub rather than just getting rid of porn wholesale.
- 1:10:47And I think it's an argument for,
- 1:10:48again,
- 1:10:48pushing for a harder ID verification limit
- 1:10:52on these sites in the same way that I think,
- 1:10:53you know,
- 1:10:5413-year-olds shouldn't be having sex because it will lead to a lot of regret.
- 1:10:56Like,
- 1:10:5750% of women or 45% of women regret their first time,
- 1:11:00right?
- 1:11:01That doesn't mean sex is bad.
- 1:11:02You wouldn't say,
- 1:11:02therefore,
- 1:11:03husbands and wives shouldn't be having sex just
- 1:11:05because a lot of people regret the sex.
- 1:11:06They're having,
- 1:11:06it just means
- 1:11:07we should push for people to wait until they're a bit older,
- 1:11:09and I feel the same way about sex work.
- 1:11:10I don't think girls should be signing up for OF
- 1:11:12when they're 18 and stuff,
- 1:11:13but that doesn't mean it's wrong for me
- 1:11:14as a 27-year-old to do it.
- 1:11:16And I would just push for people to
- 1:11:18understand that analogously again with sex again,
- 1:11:19just because it's wrong for younger people to do it
- 1:11:21doesn't speak to the wholesale moral complexion of it.
- 1:11:24OK,
- 1:11:24but the porn are you gonna pause here?
- 1:11:26You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:11:28Thank you.
- 1:11:32If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:11:33get to that chair in 321.
- 1:11:38Thanks.
- 1:11:39Jason,
- 1:11:40nice to meet you.
- 1:11:40Nice to meet you.
- 1:11:41So I just had a quick question just to like pull from your personal experience
- 1:11:44because for me
- 1:11:45when I thought about doing OnlyFans myself
- 1:11:47that
- 1:11:48you know it's,
- 1:11:49it's money,
- 1:11:49you know,
- 1:11:49it's like I was in it for the money.
- 1:11:51I could,
- 1:11:51I think I'm a pretty good looking dude.
- 1:11:53I have a pretty nice body.
- 1:11:54I was like wow,
- 1:11:55I could,
- 1:11:56I could use that
- 1:11:57for,
- 1:11:57for income.
- 1:11:58So my question for you,
- 1:11:59for anyone that's aspiring to be an OnlyFans model,
- 1:12:02like what was the hardest like hill for you to get over?
- 1:12:05Like what was like the hardest obstacle
- 1:12:07for you to get over?
- 1:12:09Um,
- 1:12:10kind of like I was just saying earlier,
- 1:12:11the only time I've had difficulty with it mentally was
- 1:12:13just working with an agency that made me hate it.
- 1:12:16I had a period of time after that where I didn't want to
- 1:12:18wear any clothes that showed cleavage cause I felt really disgusted by it,
- 1:12:21and it made me for a while feel anti-sex work,
- 1:12:23but then I realized when I actually have control over the content,
- 1:12:25those feelings evaporate,
- 1:12:26right?
- 1:12:27So I think that was the only hill I had to surmount.
- 1:12:29I got you,
- 1:12:29but do you think that there's
- 1:12:31different hills that people that do have
- 1:12:33like a strong fam familial affiliation?
- 1:12:35Or like that connection with their family,
- 1:12:37do you think that there is a hill that they need to get
- 1:12:39over in order to pursue the career that you that you do now?
- 1:12:43I think people need to assess for themselves,
- 1:12:45yeah,
- 1:12:45whether or not their family is going to disapprove of
- 1:12:47it and whether that's the risk they want to take,
- 1:12:49but
- 1:12:49I wouldn't say that that speaks to whether it's degrading or wrong to do,
- 1:12:53you know,
- 1:12:53like my mom didn't speak to me for 3 months when I switched
- 1:12:55my major from computer science to English cause she's like a South.
- 1:12:58Asian mom who just like,
- 1:13:00hates the humanities,
- 1:13:01right,
- 1:13:01but I wouldn't say I did something wrong.
- 1:13:03So I think parental judgment is something that you should definitely factor in,
- 1:13:06but it's not something that you should base,
- 1:13:08uh,
- 1:13:08that we should base like morality or your human worth in.
- 1:13:11Understood.
- 1:13:11Do you still have a strong connection with your family?
- 1:13:14Um,
- 1:13:15I do.
- 1:13:16No,
- 1:13:16it's fine.
- 1:13:17Um,
- 1:13:17I do,
- 1:13:18yeah,
- 1:13:18I started on TikTok for several years before I did OnlyFans.
- 1:13:21I didn't do anything sexual,
- 1:13:22didn't show cleavage.
- 1:13:23I actually prided myself on
- 1:13:24being able to build a following,
- 1:13:26not doing anything remotely sexual.
- 1:13:27My mom,
- 1:13:28because she's very traditional,
- 1:13:29even just the idea of her daughter putting herself out there
- 1:13:31in that way was a big thing we had to,
- 1:13:33we had to struggle with,
- 1:13:34and we didn't speak for several months
- 1:13:36because of that.
- 1:13:36But I think enough time has passed,
- 1:13:37and we've made amends and everything's completely fine.
- 1:13:40Wow,
- 1:13:40that's real,
- 1:13:41yeah.
- 1:13:41I was just curious about that because
- 1:13:43I feel like there is like some pressure and there
- 1:13:45is a hill that people do need to get over
- 1:13:47and I feel like that's,
- 1:13:48you know,
- 1:13:48sometimes not recognized by,
- 1:13:50you know,
- 1:13:50creators.
- 1:13:51I feel like you,
- 1:13:51we all hear it from the other side like,
- 1:13:53like for me personally,
- 1:13:54like I don't think I could go back to my family and my family wouldn't accept me.
- 1:13:57Like that's just like a real hill that
- 1:13:59I feel like people need to to get over.
- 1:14:01So
- 1:14:02I guess with that being said,
- 1:14:04like,
- 1:14:04do you think that there is people in the industry that are
- 1:14:06that there are people in the industry that do deal with that?
- 1:14:09But the familial the familial.
- 1:14:11Definitely,
- 1:14:12what I've heard people saying this was actually similar to my experiences,
- 1:14:15once you make enough
- 1:14:16money,
- 1:14:16a lot of people's morals can be bought.
- 1:14:18So you'll hear,
- 1:14:19for instance,
- 1:14:19like I think Nala Ray was saying that like,
- 1:14:21her dad was on board with it because she made
- 1:14:22all this money and bought him a house or something,
- 1:14:24right?
- 1:14:25That doesn't again speak to moral complexion,
- 1:14:27but I think that a lot of families will turn around,
- 1:14:29because my mom's biggest fear was that I'm ruining my future.
- 1:14:32By doing TikTok and because employers are going to see it,
- 1:14:34but now that I've been doing social media full time for
- 1:14:366 years to a point where I don't need to go back
- 1:14:38financially,
- 1:14:39I think her biggest concern has essentially been excised.
- 1:14:42Understood.
- 1:14:43So,
- 1:14:43would you say that,
- 1:14:44you know,
- 1:14:45money making people turn on their morals
- 1:14:47is a healthy thing to exercise towards like your family,
- 1:14:49cause I feel like
- 1:14:51your family conformed towards like the,
- 1:14:54the financial gain.
- 1:14:55Like,
- 1:14:55do you feel like that would change people's moral morality,
- 1:14:57and do you feel like that's a good thing for the family?
- 1:14:59It depends what they're basing it on.
- 1:15:00I would,
- 1:15:01I would say the family's a bit cowardly.
- 1:15:02Yeah,
- 1:15:02if they pretend they're morally righteous in this way,
- 1:15:04and they could be bought.
- 1:15:05But like I said,
- 1:15:06I think my mom's concern was more so me ruining my own future opportunities.
- 1:15:09But this kind of brings me to another point,
- 1:15:11which is that
- 1:15:12even if your family isn't accepting of you doing this thing,
- 1:15:15I don't.
- 1:15:15I think that makes you unfit for a fam like a family life.
- 1:15:18I think even if people have a particular prejudice
- 1:15:20towards the things you do,
- 1:15:21doesn't make you unfit for a family,
- 1:15:22right?
- 1:15:22Like,
- 1:15:23I,
- 1:15:23I don't know your
- 1:15:25background,
- 1:15:25you look
- 1:15:25somewhat ethnic,
- 1:15:26but I think for a lot of ethnic families,
- 1:15:28for instance,
- 1:15:28a lot of them have a lot of,
- 1:15:29uh,
- 1:15:30racism when it comes to how their kids are going to date,
- 1:15:32right?
- 1:15:32So I've had friends who their parents wouldn't
- 1:15:34accept them if they came home with like,
- 1:15:35A black fiance or something,
- 1:15:37right?
- 1:15:37And I don't think because their parent would be unaccepting of it,
- 1:15:39that that means that they're unfit for a family,
- 1:15:42right.
- 1:15:42So I wouldn't base your suitability for family life based off people's prejudices,
- 1:15:46whether it be towards,
- 1:15:48uh,
- 1:15:48sex work or interracial marriage or anything like that.
- 1:15:53I feel like it does have to take we're out of time for this claim.
- 1:15:54Thank you so much.
- 1:15:58My final surrounded claim is that sex work is not inherently degrading to women.
- 1:16:03If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:16:04please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:16:11Hi.
- 1:16:12All right,
- 1:16:12so first,
- 1:16:14your claim is talking about inherently degrading.
- 1:16:17I think definitions are really important.
- 1:16:19And so when it comes to degrading,
- 1:16:21what does it mean to degrade someone?
- 1:16:23Um,
- 1:16:23I think degrading means to debase oneself,
- 1:16:26to humiliate oneself,
- 1:16:27to kind of surrender one's dignity.
- 1:16:28If you want,
- 1:16:29I can give you a basic premise for why I don't believe it's degrading,
- 1:16:31or you can start with yours.
- 1:16:33Yeah,
- 1:16:33yeah,
- 1:16:33sure,
- 1:16:34go ahead.
- 1:16:34So I believe that we all kind of grant the premise that it's not inherently
- 1:16:37degrading for a woman to sexualize herself for a man at some point in time,
- 1:16:40right?
- 1:16:40If this were the case,
- 1:16:41then even the most ardent sexual puritans or traditionalists would
- 1:16:44prescribe that a woman commit to a lifetime of celibacy.
- 1:16:46Obviously this isn't the case unless you're like a fringe radical feminist,
- 1:16:49lesbian.
- 1:16:50We all kind of grant that it's benign,
- 1:16:51healthy,
- 1:16:52and even congruent with a woman's self-actualization
- 1:16:54for her to sexualize herself for a man at some point in time.
- 1:16:56The disagreement we're probably gonna have is whether.
- 1:16:58That sexualization necessarily becomes degrading
- 1:17:00when it's performed not for a husband or romantic partner,
- 1:17:03but instead for a stranger,
- 1:17:04let alone a stranger within a marketplace transaction.
- 1:17:06My answer is an unequivocal no.
- 1:17:08There's no magic button that automatically takes sexualization that's done
- 1:17:11within a marketplace transaction and makes it morally bankrupt or degrading,
- 1:17:14and there's no magic button that makes sexualization done within
- 1:17:17a marriage or a relationship and automatically makes it morally righteous
- 1:17:20or ethical or empowering.
- 1:17:22I,
- 1:17:22I haven't heard.
- 1:17:23Is there,
- 1:17:23is there any sexual act that is inherently degrading?
- 1:17:27Um,
- 1:17:28I think one,
- 1:17:29yeah,
- 1:17:29I would say lack of consent.
- 1:17:30I would say ones that are being done
- 1:17:32because the woman is giving into sexual compliance.
- 1:17:33If she feels like,
- 1:17:34for instance,
- 1:17:34it's her sexual duty duty to have sex with her husband when she's not in the mood,
- 1:17:38if she's afraid he's gonna cheat on her,
- 1:17:40if she's doing it because she thinks like this is just
- 1:17:41what I need to do to be a good wife,
- 1:17:43something like incest that can contain
- 1:17:46consent is still inherently degrading.
- 1:17:49I would say it's inherently disordered.
- 1:17:51Degrading for me is a higher ethical benchmark,
- 1:17:53which is,
- 1:17:53is this at the cost of the person's well-being.
- 1:17:56Disordered uncomfortable.
- 1:17:58No,
- 1:17:58I would say disordered.
- 1:18:00So if someone were to tell me,
- 1:18:01I only like to eat foods that are blue,
- 1:18:03I wouldn't go so far as to say you need to be locked up.
- 1:18:05Obviously if we're talking about incest in the sense of like,
- 1:18:07this is a parent taking advantage of a child,
- 1:18:09that's a bit different.
- 1:18:09But if you're talking about like two people who were related,
- 1:18:11they didn't know each other,
- 1:18:12they somehow came about and found each other 20 years later and they hook up,
- 1:18:15yeah,
- 1:18:16I think it's fine to say that's disordered.
- 1:18:18That's not what we're ordered towards naturally,
- 1:18:20but I wouldn't say you should be locked up.
- 1:18:22I wouldn't say they're degrading.
- 1:18:23No one's talking about locking someone up.
- 1:18:25We're not talking but when I'm thinking unethical sexual acts,
- 1:18:28I'm thinking things that
- 1:18:29that should require some sort of,
- 1:18:31uh,
- 1:18:31social punishment.
- 1:18:32Yeah,
- 1:18:32well,
- 1:18:33OK,
- 1:18:33social punishment aside,
- 1:18:35like we're just like,
- 1:18:36I think,
- 1:18:36I think,
- 1:18:37I think strangulation during sex is degrading,
- 1:18:39and thus I think it should be excised from pornographic content.
- 1:18:42So when I'm talking about degrading,
- 1:18:43I am requiring a higher ethical benchmark which does
- 1:18:46like require some sort of punishment should be,
- 1:18:48should be banned or from porn.
- 1:18:50Yeah,
- 1:18:51I would say that's degrading to women even if they
- 1:18:53want to be doing it because I think it's.
- 1:18:54So there are,
- 1:18:55there are things that are inherently degrading that are sexual in nature.
- 1:19:00Yeah,
- 1:19:00lack of consent.
- 1:19:02It's sexual in nature.
- 1:19:03It's obviously degrading.
- 1:19:04Yeah.
- 1:19:05Well,
- 1:19:05just to be clear,
- 1:19:06you can still call something immoral without necessarily calling it degrading.
- 1:19:09So I understand that you personally think it's immoral,
- 1:19:11but you need to do more work to explain it,
- 1:19:13to bridge the gap between immoral and degrading.
- 1:19:15Well,
- 1:19:16degrading,
- 1:19:16right,
- 1:19:17especially in that act,
- 1:19:18you are degrading your body.
- 1:19:19You are doing,
- 1:19:20so it's immoral for me to go shoot up a bank.
- 1:19:22It'd be weird to go,
- 1:19:23oh,
- 1:19:23you just degrade.
- 1:19:24yourself,
- 1:19:24right?
- 1:19:24So you can't use the phrases interchangeably when you do,
- 1:19:27when you that's a stretch.
- 1:19:28When you take human life,
- 1:19:29you are degrading it,
- 1:19:31right?
- 1:19:31Did I degrade myself by doing something morally bankrupt
- 1:19:34by going to a bank and shooting them up?
- 1:19:35No,
- 1:19:36I degraded other people.
- 1:19:38So same way you might think that it's immoral,
- 1:19:40you might think it's immoral for people to engage in incest.
- 1:19:43That doesn't automatically make it that doesn't automatically make it degrading.
- 1:19:46So I want you to separate the words,
- 1:19:48OK,
- 1:19:48but in that act,
- 1:19:51you aren't using your body in which one.
- 1:19:53In the robbery one in the in the robbery one,
- 1:19:55right,
- 1:19:55um,
- 1:19:56clearly in the,
- 1:19:57the,
- 1:19:57the,
- 1:19:58the,
- 1:19:58you,
- 1:19:58you may be using your body to like shoot a gun,
- 1:20:00but that's,
- 1:20:01that's the instrument.
- 1:20:02Your body is the instrument,
- 1:20:03whereas
- 1:20:04in the other act,
- 1:20:05in the sexual act,
- 1:20:05your body is actually the ends,
- 1:20:08and so that you are degrading yourself when you're doing something like that,
- 1:20:12um,
- 1:20:13because your body is actually the ends.
- 1:20:15Does that make sense?
- 1:20:16It does.
- 1:20:17I would still want you to fill out why
- 1:20:18it's necessarily degrading to do something sexually disordered.
- 1:20:22I don't think someone's degrading themselves,
- 1:20:24for instance,
- 1:20:24if they jerk off while staring at a tree,
- 1:20:26or if they're starting to
- 1:20:27plant or they're stuffed animal.
- 1:20:29I think it's disordered,
- 1:20:30but you're gonna have to,
- 1:20:31again,
- 1:20:31bridge why is something disordered automatically degrading.
- 1:20:34OK,
- 1:20:35because when something is disordered,
- 1:20:36right,
- 1:20:37it's,
- 1:20:37it's not natural.
- 1:20:38And so if something's not natural,
- 1:20:40it,
- 1:20:40it is not something that necessarily we should be doing like that,
- 1:20:44that is degrading.
- 1:20:45You are,
- 1:20:45you are lowering human nature,
- 1:20:47you're lowering.
- 1:20:48Um,
- 1:20:48what it means,
- 1:20:49what sex actually means.
- 1:20:51I think actually the,
- 1:20:52the,
- 1:20:52the Christian sexual ethic
- 1:20:54actually raises sex to a higher level than other people because it's saying that,
- 1:21:00no,
- 1:21:00it's actually reserved for this special commitment.
- 1:21:03And so,
- 1:21:04uh,
- 1:21:05it,
- 1:21:05it actually,
- 1:21:06uh,
- 1:21:06elevates sex.
- 1:21:07Um,
- 1:21:08I,
- 1:21:08I think your view actually degrades sex into
- 1:21:10this thing that can just be a transaction.
- 1:21:12The sex is not just a transaction that is degrading to you.
- 1:21:16That is degrading to your.
- 1:21:17Why is it?
- 1:21:18Why is it automatically degrading to have sex for money as opposed for marriage?
- 1:21:22OK,
- 1:21:22because you are using
- 1:21:24someone as a means to an end,
- 1:21:26and you that doesn't automatically make it degrading.
- 1:21:28Yes,
- 1:21:28you shouldn't if I go and get a coffee and buy it off a barista,
- 1:21:30am I degrading?
- 1:21:31Simply because I'm using them as a means to an end
- 1:21:33and I'm not necessarily engaging in some sort of loving,
- 1:21:35compassionate relationship with them.
- 1:21:37We,
- 1:21:37we engage in transactions all day without them qualifying as degrading.
- 1:21:40So again,
- 1:21:40I'm gonna like I said,
- 1:21:41I'm gonna want you to delineate between transaction and degrading,
- 1:21:44right?
- 1:21:45The question is,
- 1:21:45what does the transaction actually contain,
- 1:21:48right?
- 1:21:48And the transaction is you.
- 1:21:50The product is you.
- 1:21:51The product is not a cup of coffee.
- 1:21:53The product is your body.
- 1:21:55The product of NBA is also human beings.
- 1:21:58That doesn't make a difference.
- 1:21:59Rating right of the NBA or of sports teams,
- 1:22:02the product is still a human being using their body.
- 1:22:05The product of an athlete is not their own body.
- 1:22:07What is that?
- 1:22:08No,
- 1:22:08absolutely.
- 1:22:08It is their skill.
- 1:22:09It's their skill.
- 1:22:10So I,
- 1:22:11I'm a big Pittsburgh Steelers fan,
- 1:22:12right?
- 1:22:13If it's Ben Roethlisberger or Aaron Rodgers throwing the football,
- 1:22:16the fact that they can throw the football,
- 1:22:18that's what I'm watching.
- 1:22:19It doesn't matter what their,
- 1:22:21their actual body is.
- 1:22:23I mean,
- 1:22:23Big Ben is a bigger guy.
- 1:22:25Aaron Rodgers skinnier than Bigger Ben.
- 1:22:26It doesn't matter.
- 1:22:27I mean,
- 1:22:28that's super disingenuous to say that athletes are not selling their body.
- 1:22:32It's not super disingenuous.
- 1:22:33It's because we,
- 1:22:34we watch them for their skill.
- 1:22:36We don't watch them to sexualize them,
- 1:22:39and that's exactly what you're doing.
- 1:22:40Yeah,
- 1:22:40if you're gonna say,
- 1:22:41if you're gonna say,
- 1:22:42because we don't sexualize them,
- 1:22:43they're not selling their body,
- 1:22:43you're begging the question,
- 1:22:44right?
- 1:22:44Selling your body doesn't have to imply sexualization.
- 1:22:47You're selling your body when you're part of the,
- 1:22:48when you're conscripted for the military.
- 1:22:50You're selling your body in pretty much any job you do.
- 1:22:53So you have to address my argument.
- 1:22:54Why is necessarily selling your body and using yourself as
- 1:22:56a means to an end within a transaction inherently degrading?
- 1:22:59is the product.
- 1:23:01Your body is the product in all these other instances as well.
- 1:23:04Yes,
- 1:23:04it is.
- 1:23:05It's the skill and then mine is the sexuality that it's not my body.
- 1:23:09So,
- 1:23:09we can make these leaps as much as we want.
- 1:23:11I could also make a bridge and say then it's not my body I'm selling,
- 1:23:14it's my sexuality.
- 1:23:16It's a sexual service.
- 1:23:17That's inherently All right pause.
- 1:23:19You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:23:21Thank you so much.
- 1:23:22Thank you.
- 1:23:23Bye.
- 1:23:26If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:23:28please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:23:33Hi,
- 1:23:34nice to meet you.
- 1:23:36OK,
- 1:23:36so
- 1:23:37he was talking about the order of sex,
- 1:23:38what it's ordered towards.
- 1:23:39It's ordered towards procreation.
- 1:23:41When he was mentioning the Christian
- 1:23:43virtue of sex,
- 1:23:44it raises it to a bond between a man and a woman,
- 1:23:46a husband and a wife,
- 1:23:47so it raises that order.
- 1:23:48It,
- 1:23:48uh,
- 1:23:49when you have sex outside of marriage,
- 1:23:51it goes from,
- 1:23:52uh,
- 1:23:52something that's ordered towards procreation into something less,
- 1:23:55or it goes to something.
- 1:23:56That is meant for
- 1:23:57lust,
- 1:23:57sexual gratification,
- 1:23:58something instant.
- 1:24:00That's why it degrades what sex is ordered
- 1:24:02towards into something that is lesser than.
- 1:24:04That's why it's degrading.
- 1:24:05It degrades women
- 1:24:07by turning them into sexual objects meant for sexual gratification.
- 1:24:10Well,
- 1:24:11OK,
- 1:24:11the second thing was a leap,
- 1:24:12even if it doesn't order it towards procreation and marital pair bonding,
- 1:24:15doesn't necessarily mean it's turning women into sexual objects,
- 1:24:17right?
- 1:24:17So simply because it's not pertaining to the Christian sexual ethic,
- 1:24:20again,
- 1:24:20doesn't mean it's degrading those women.
- 1:24:21You could say maybe it's degrading how sex is supposed to be used,
- 1:24:24but it's a leap even by your worldview to
- 1:24:25say that it somehow turns women into sexual instruments,
- 1:24:27right?
- 1:24:28Doing something in a disordered way doesn't
- 1:24:30necessarily turn someone into a sexual object.
- 1:24:33But I also would like to push back on the Christian sexual
- 1:24:35ethic because my understanding of it is that there's 3 necessary conditions,
- 1:24:38right?
- 1:24:38be consensual.
- 1:24:39It needs to be ordered towards procreation,
- 1:24:41as in it's wrong,
- 1:24:41for instance,
- 1:24:42to wear a condom or be on birth control,
- 1:24:44even if the woman is,
- 1:24:45uh,
- 1:24:46post,
- 1:24:46uh,
- 1:24:47menopause,
- 1:24:47that's still fine,
- 1:24:48but you can't be wearing a condom.
- 1:24:50And it also needs to involve that level of pair bonding.
- 1:24:52So for instance,
- 1:24:52something like
- 1:24:53IVF is wrong by the Christian sexual ethic
- 1:24:55because it's procreation without the pair bonding,
- 1:24:57sex with a condom is wrong because it's,
- 1:24:59uh,
- 1:24:59pair bonding without the procreation,
- 1:25:01right?
- 1:25:01Right.
- 1:25:01And also one more,
- 1:25:02it has to be between a husband and a wife,
- 1:25:04yeah,
- 1:25:04within the confine,
- 1:25:05within the parameters of marriage.
- 1:25:07I don't think most Christians and Catholics
- 1:25:09actually subscribe to the Christian sexual ethic.
- 1:25:11I think everyone is pretty much a secular when it comes to sexual ethics,
- 1:25:14and we all believe that the only necessary condition is
- 1:25:16for it to be consensual or ordered towards self-actualization,
- 1:25:18as in responding,
- 1:25:19respecting that woman's dignity,
- 1:25:20right?
- 1:25:21So if I were to give you two scenarios,
- 1:25:22if I were to ask you which is more ethical,
- 1:25:24for a woman to engage in casual sex with a male best friend who thinks the world of her,
- 1:25:27they're wearing a condom,
- 1:25:28so it's not ordered towards procreation,
- 1:25:30and they're not married,
- 1:25:30so it's not ordered towards marital pair bonding,
- 1:25:32or the sexual,
- 1:25:33uh,
- 1:25:33the second scenario is that she's having sex with her husband.
- 1:25:35He's not wearing a condom,
- 1:25:36but every time they hook up,
- 1:25:37he's telling her,
- 1:25:38You look hideous naked,
- 1:25:39you're disgusting,
- 1:25:39you're a fat pig,
- 1:25:40which is the more ethical scenario in your opinion?
- 1:25:43Because for me it's the first one.
- 1:25:44It's hard to compare,
- 1:25:45but they're both very unethical.
- 1:25:46They're both unethical,
- 1:25:47but as a Christian,
- 1:25:48as a Christian sexual ethicist,
- 1:25:49you should be opting for the second one
- 1:25:51is better because that fulfills more necessary conditions.
- 1:25:53It's ordered towards marriage.
- 1:25:54It's ordered towards procreation because they're not wearing a condom.
- 1:25:57The first one fails on more necessary conditions.
- 1:26:00There's a condom,
- 1:26:01they're not married,
- 1:26:02they're not going to get married.
- 1:26:04So in the first step,
- 1:26:05uh,
- 1:26:05in the first scenario,
- 1:26:06both,
- 1:26:07uh,
- 1:26:07parties are engaging in a sinful act.
- 1:26:09In the second scenario,
- 1:26:09it's the husband,
- 1:26:10while the wife isn't engaging in a sinful act.
- 1:26:12But I think you veered off the point a lot.
- 1:26:14I haven't.
- 1:26:14I'm just trying to prove the point that everyone
- 1:26:16like who claims to subscribe to Christian sexual ethics,
- 1:26:18actually don't,
- 1:26:19because when it comes down to it,
- 1:26:20if I'm listening,
- 1:26:21if these are all three necessary conditions for you,
- 1:26:23and in one scenario,
- 1:26:242 of them are being disrespected and transgressed,
- 1:26:26and in the second scenario,
- 1:26:27only 1 of them is being transgressed.
- 1:26:29Not even being transgressed because verbally abusing your
- 1:26:31wife tely isn't a necessary condition that's being transgressed
- 1:26:35within a sexual ethic.
- 1:26:36Sure,
- 1:26:36it's a sin.
- 1:26:38Sure,
- 1:26:38it is,
- 1:26:39but I'm saying if these are all necessary conditions,
- 1:26:41and they're equally necessary conditions,
- 1:26:43right,
- 1:26:43because within the Christian sexual ethic,
- 1:26:45it doesn't rank them
- 1:26:46necessarily,
- 1:26:47you should be opting for the one that commits less,
- 1:26:49right?
- 1:26:49So if I think murdering your child is wrong,
- 1:26:50and I ask you,
- 1:26:51OK,
- 1:26:51so which scenario is better,
- 1:26:53murdering one child or two children?
- 1:26:54You should
- 1:26:55obviously say murdering two children,
- 1:26:57right?
- 1:26:58Because they're all bad,
- 1:26:59but you don't actually think they're all bad
- 1:27:00because you're weighing self-actualization and within a sexual ethic
- 1:27:03as being much more important than whether it's with a condom or not with a condom,
- 1:27:06whether it's within marriage or not within marriage.
- 1:27:09Otherwise,
- 1:27:09why,
- 1:27:10why have this preference or even this like hesitation about
- 1:27:13your male best friend with a condom on is even
- 1:27:15comparable to doing it within marriage without the condom,
- 1:27:18right?
- 1:27:18It's because nobody.
- 1:27:19Actually believes in Christian sexual ethics.
- 1:27:21No,
- 1:27:21that's a very big leap to say that just because someone can't choose between
- 1:27:24the lesser of two evils means they don't believe in the Christian sexual ethic.
- 1:27:27Have you ever heard of the trolley problem?
- 1:27:29Right?
- 1:27:29You have to decide in that scenario between
- 1:27:31choosing one person to die or letting 5 people die outside of your choice.
- 1:27:34That is a problem that a lot of people have an issue deciding,
- 1:27:37but that doesn't mean that either choice is like not bad or anything like that.
- 1:27:41They're both immoral.
- 1:27:42They're both actions have an evil outcome.
- 1:27:44But you're jumping off the point a lot where I'm saying
- 1:27:46sex is ordered towards procreation.
- 1:27:48The Christian sex my question would be,
- 1:27:49why would it not,
- 1:27:50sorry,
- 1:27:51Christian,
- 1:27:52you,
- 1:27:52the question,
- 1:27:52or sorry,
- 1:27:53my point is
- 1:27:54sex is ordered towards procreation.
- 1:27:56The Christian sex sorry,
- 1:27:57sexual ethic raises that and
- 1:27:59raises it up.
- 1:28:00The
- 1:28:01normal sexual ethic that most people practice today where it's,
- 1:28:04there's a lot of,
- 1:28:05uh,
- 1:28:06prostitution,
- 1:28:07sex work,
- 1:28:08uh.
- 1:28:09Um,
- 1:28:09you
- 1:28:10procreate with people or have sex with people that aren't married,
- 1:28:12that degrades it from what it is ordered towards into something lesser,
- 1:28:15something that is less desirable.
- 1:28:17And my rebuttal to you is you don't actually believe that
- 1:28:20that degrades it because the only thing that you actually believe in
- 1:28:22like intuitively that degrades it is if it's not congruent with consent
- 1:28:26and self-actualization and that woman being respected by her male partner.
- 1:28:29Otherwise,
- 1:28:29again,
- 1:28:30if you believe,
- 1:28:31yeah,
- 1:28:31it's not the only thing,
- 1:28:32but if that's one of.
- 1:28:33Package deal of things and the other ones are
- 1:28:35being ordered towards procreation and marital pair bonding,
- 1:28:37then again,
- 1:28:38you should opt for the scenario in which
- 1:28:40more of those conditions are being fulfilled.
- 1:28:41The question is,
- 1:28:43uh,
- 1:28:43whether OnlyFans is degrading towards women.
- 1:28:45It's not whether I can choose between two
- 1:28:48different hypotheticals of which one's worse,
- 1:28:49which one has more evil.
- 1:28:50The question is,
- 1:28:51does OnlyFans degrade by your ethics,
- 1:28:53the second scenario has more evil,
- 1:28:55so you should opt for the thing or has less evils,
- 1:28:57you should opt for the.
- 1:28:58Thing that carries less evils.
- 1:29:00My point of this is just to point out
- 1:29:01that nobody actually intuitively subscribes to Catholic sexual ethics,
- 1:29:04and we all kind of believe what a secular atheist would believe,
- 1:29:07which is that the only necessary condition is whether that
- 1:29:09male partner is respecting her and treating her well.
- 1:29:11It doesn't matter if they're wearing a condom.
- 1:29:13It doesn't matter if they're not married.
- 1:29:14That's the thing that we all give preference and priority to.
- 1:29:17OK,
- 1:29:17consent matters.
- 1:29:18It matters.
- 1:29:18We're gonna pause here.
- 1:29:20Some flags are up.
- 1:29:20You can return to your seat.
- 1:29:22Thank you.
- 1:29:26If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:29:27please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:29:34Hi,
- 1:29:34I'm Mara.
- 1:29:35Nice to meet you.
- 1:29:35Nice to meet you.
- 1:29:36OK,
- 1:29:36so I want to ask because I know that the
- 1:29:38first two debaters were bringing up the aspect of Christian.
- 1:29:41So are you,
- 1:29:42do you identify as Christian or Catholic or anything religious based?
- 1:29:45Absolutely not.
- 1:29:46OK,
- 1:29:46so yes,
- 1:29:46I don't think that those claims would be even
- 1:29:48valid for this argument for you because if you don't
- 1:29:50have that standard of Christian,
- 1:29:52then of course you aren't going to be.
- 1:29:54Enticing those standards as well for your own work.
- 1:29:56So I would bring up this.
- 1:29:57I am a content creator as well as you are because you do OnlyFans.
- 1:30:00There is an aspect of burnout.
- 1:30:02So when you are messaging all these men and they're saying
- 1:30:04like nasty comments or they're making these degrading marks to you,
- 1:30:07you are constantly having to use your body to be able
- 1:30:09to respond to them and to come out with these messages,
- 1:30:12and you're also creating this aspect with them
- 1:30:14of a relationship
- 1:30:16and parasocial relationships are very dangerous and are.
- 1:30:18Society today,
- 1:30:19as there are a lot of people
- 1:30:21that are falling into this pit of them and believing that it is something real,
- 1:30:24then you would more say so.
- 1:30:26And when we brought up the relationship dynamic as well,
- 1:30:29so when you also have a partner and when you are
- 1:30:32engaging in this kind of sexual activity with strangers online,
- 1:30:35not only are you engaging in intimacy with your partner,
- 1:30:37but you're also engaging in intimacy with a lot of different people online as well.
- 1:30:41And I feel like in my mind.
- 1:30:43And I feel like from a lot of different perspectives that
- 1:30:45I've seen online and that I've heard OnlyFans creators say,
- 1:30:47it kind of can cause a strain on the relationship because
- 1:30:50you're not only sharing these emotions with your partner,
- 1:30:52but you're also sharing them with so many different people online,
- 1:30:55and those people also believe in this relationship with you as well,
- 1:30:58because they are
- 1:31:00utilizing all their time and effort into this relationship with you and
- 1:31:03paying for it and subscribing to it and falling into this loop.
- 1:31:05And it's kind of like an addiction,
- 1:31:07like gambling.
- 1:31:08I read online that OnlyFans can be stimulated as like gambling,
- 1:31:12it can be like kind of the same effect because you're getting that stimulation,
- 1:31:15you're getting that reward,
- 1:31:16and then you're falling back into this circle.
- 1:31:18OK,
- 1:31:19this feels like it pertains more to my other prompt about
- 1:31:21whether this is taking advantage of men or lonely men.
- 1:31:24Um,
- 1:31:24do you have something about,
- 1:31:25like,
- 1:31:25why you think it's degrading to women,
- 1:31:26or was your answer mostly about how it's like,
- 1:31:28burnout to the women?
- 1:31:29I think it's degrading to women,
- 1:31:31and I think it's degrading to yourself as well,
- 1:31:33because you're seeing your body as an aspect of money,
- 1:31:36you're seeing it as a product.
- 1:31:37And I know that you brought up the point that,
- 1:31:39you know,
- 1:31:39athletes are able to use their bodies because they are using it as a skill,
- 1:31:43but I would argue that you're using your body and your
- 1:31:45body is something that is sacred to you and it's personal.
- 1:31:47To you and you're sharing it with everyone online,
- 1:31:50and when you share it with everyone online,
- 1:31:52they feel that they have access to you that they
- 1:31:53actually do not have because this is an online relationship.
- 1:31:56So,
- 1:31:56you're giving people the expectation that
- 1:31:59they are buying more into you than you are actually giving them yourself.
- 1:32:03So that's why I think it's degrading to you because it's not necessarily that seems
- 1:32:06again more of an argument for why it's unfair or unethical towards the customers,
- 1:32:10but in terms of why it's degrading towards the women,
- 1:32:12I agree with you in the sense of like sex is sacred and
- 1:32:14that I think it's special and that it's deserving of a unique.
- 1:32:16moral status.
- 1:32:17I think we should be incredibly scrutinizing of
- 1:32:19all sexual scenarios to make sure they ensure,
- 1:32:21uh,
- 1:32:21meet some sort of ethical benchmark,
- 1:32:22right?
- 1:32:23But I don't think,
- 1:32:23I think it's a very
- 1:32:25crude delineation to go,
- 1:32:26OK,
- 1:32:26all sex done for love is automatically
- 1:32:28and magically ethical and empowering for women,
- 1:32:30and then all sex done within the confines of a marketplace transaction or
- 1:32:33done for a financial carrot is automatically unethical or degrading towards her,
- 1:32:37right?
- 1:32:37I think that's a leap that I haven't heard someone,
- 1:32:39like,
- 1:32:40justify yet.
- 1:32:41I haven't heard a single substantive,
- 1:32:42logical or compelling argument from
- 1:32:43pretty much anyone in my life ever.
- 1:32:45For why that delineation would take place.
- 1:32:48And in my opinion,
- 1:32:48it overlooks a lot of other incisive gauges that
- 1:32:51we should be using to grapple with sexual ethics,
- 1:32:53such as was this consensual?
- 1:32:54Was this due to sexual compliance?
- 1:32:55Was this due to sexual coercion?
- 1:32:57Was this due to,
- 1:32:58to a socially inculcated belief that this is just something she needs
- 1:33:00to do in order to satisfy her husband or her boyfriend,
- 1:33:02right?
- 1:33:03So if someone just goes,
- 1:33:04OK,
- 1:33:04you're degrading your body,
- 1:33:05again,
- 1:33:06you're just begging the question.
- 1:33:07I'm saying it's not degrading your body for all the reasons I've listed
- 1:33:09because simply objectifying yourself within a
- 1:33:11marketplaces transaction is not inherently degrading.
- 1:33:13Otherwise,
- 1:33:14a barista.
- 1:33:14It would be degrading themselves.
- 1:33:15A teacher would be degrading themselves.
- 1:33:17Like everyone's technically objectifying
- 1:33:18themselves within a marketplace transaction
- 1:33:20because we're using that person as a means,
- 1:33:21right?
- 1:33:21Objectification can oftentimes be benign.
- 1:33:24It doesn't have to be insidious or malicious.
- 1:33:26You're objectifying someone when you go to them for a particular aspect.
- 1:33:28So if I go to a teacher simply to learn things,
- 1:33:30technically that qualifies as objectification,
- 1:33:32right?
- 1:33:32Objectification is not just cash out
- 1:33:34and whether you're specifically using your body as an instrument.
- 1:33:36It could be any sort of skill.
- 1:33:37OK,
- 1:33:38sorry to cut you off,
- 1:33:38but then can I bring up a different argument?
- 1:33:40I'm going to pause here.
- 1:33:41You've been voted out with the majority.
- 1:33:42Thank you.
- 1:33:47If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:33:49please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:33:56OK.
- 1:33:58OK,
- 1:33:59so I wanted to see what your definition of commodification was.
- 1:34:03Um,
- 1:34:03commodification would be
- 1:34:05selling that particular thing,
- 1:34:06making it available
- 1:34:07for public consumption in a
- 1:34:09marketplace transaction.
- 1:34:10Absolutely.
- 1:34:11And then,
- 1:34:11so whenever it comes to commodification,
- 1:34:13would you say that monetary value dictates the actual value of the product?
- 1:34:18Not necessarily,
- 1:34:18right?
- 1:34:19Like you,
- 1:34:19you could give something off for a discount,
- 1:34:21you give something on a price scale,
- 1:34:23right?
- 1:34:24Like if I'm off,
- 1:34:24if I'm a therapist,
- 1:34:25but I do a sliding scale for poor people,
- 1:34:27it doesn't mean my time is worthless just because.
- 1:34:29Because I'm giving someone who really needs help,
- 1:34:31a free session.
- 1:34:31It doesn't mean like an hour's worth of my time listening to your grave problem
- 1:34:35is worthless,
- 1:34:36right?
- 1:34:36So no,
- 1:34:37I wouldn't say that.
- 1:34:38Absolutely.
- 1:34:38OK,
- 1:34:39well,
- 1:34:39I wanted to bring up an interesting statistic that I had found.
- 1:34:43So
- 1:34:44the mean,
- 1:34:45the median creator on OnlyFans makes,
- 1:34:47it takes home,
- 1:34:48yeah,
- 1:34:48takes home about 1000 bucks,
- 1:34:50while the top 1%
- 1:34:52are making 1/3 of the entire.
- 1:34:55Kind of.
- 1:34:56I,
- 1:34:57I,
- 1:34:57again,
- 1:34:57I don't know how that speaks to degradation because like I just said,
- 1:34:59I don't think that speaks to your wholesale value,
- 1:35:02what you're able to make.
- 1:35:03Like my parents my entire life were minimum wage cashiers.
- 1:35:05I don't think that means that they're only worth 8 bucks an hour,
- 1:35:08right?
- 1:35:09So I would push back on your claim that what
- 1:35:11you take home per hour speaks to your objective worth.
- 1:35:13Absolutely,
- 1:35:14but in this industry,
- 1:35:15we're talking about.
- 1:35:17The body is the product,
- 1:35:18right?
- 1:35:18The intimacy between
- 1:35:20the woman and the camera or the woman and the man,
- 1:35:23or whatever is the product that's being sold.
- 1:35:25So whenever you're placing that price tag on your body or
- 1:35:29a woman is placing placing that price tag on her body,
- 1:35:31and it's $180 a month,
- 1:35:33I think that is generally degrading.
- 1:35:35Why?
- 1:35:36Why is that degrading?
- 1:35:37Yeah,
- 1:35:38because I think what I find frustrating is that this seems like the only
- 1:35:41area or type of transaction where we're age.
- 1:35:44To say,
- 1:35:44because you're taking something that can often
- 1:35:45be done within a private domain setting,
- 1:35:47such as with your husband or boyfriend or whoever,
- 1:35:49and you're making available within a public domain,
- 1:35:51it automatically makes it degrading when we don't
- 1:35:53apply that standard to other types of employment.
- 1:35:55So,
- 1:35:55for instance,
- 1:35:55if I enjoy cooking for my family and friends,
- 1:35:57that's great.
- 1:35:58There's nothing wrong with that.
- 1:35:59But if I become a private chef or open up my own restaurant,
- 1:36:02become head chef,
- 1:36:02we wouldn't go,
- 1:36:03you're degrading yourself because you took something that's often done within
- 1:36:05the sanctity of your own home and you made it available.
- 1:36:07We'd actually say,
- 1:36:08no,
- 1:36:08you just self-actualize,
- 1:36:09you did something really great.
- 1:36:10Likewise,
- 1:36:11I enjoy making paintings for my friends for free.
- 1:36:13That's fine.
- 1:36:13That's really lovely,
- 1:36:14but it doesn't make it degrading that if I do paintings for commission for people,
- 1:36:17right?
- 1:36:17So why is this the one instance
- 1:36:18where we automatically assume that we're importing degradation
- 1:36:21simply because you took something private and
- 1:36:22we're making it available for public consumption?
- 1:36:24Quick question.
- 1:36:26So aside from the transactional gains,
- 1:36:29why do you feel like
- 1:36:30sex work is inherently degrading to women?
- 1:36:32So I feel like aside from the transactional side of things,
- 1:36:36I think that it's insanely degrading.
- 1:36:38To a woman,
- 1:36:39just because that is,
- 1:36:40so you compared it to other industries,
- 1:36:42and you compared it to other careers,
- 1:36:44and intimacy isn't the thing that's being sold.
- 1:36:47Like I'm,
- 1:36:48I'm saying that sex and industry and nudity
- 1:36:52is what's being sold with basketball players,
- 1:36:54like you mentioned earlier,
- 1:36:55with cooking,
- 1:36:56with all of those things.
- 1:36:57So why is the fact that sex is the thing being sold automatically make it degrading?
- 1:37:01Again,
- 1:37:01you're begging the question,
- 1:37:03what if I were to just say,
- 1:37:04well,
- 1:37:04the fact that,
- 1:37:05you know,
- 1:37:05you become a private chef,
- 1:37:06you're selling food,
- 1:37:07therefore it's degrading because of the other,
- 1:37:09these other instances,
- 1:37:09you're not selling food,
- 1:37:10you're selling your body.
- 1:37:12So therefore those things aren't degrading.
- 1:37:14So you need to bridge the gap for me.
- 1:37:15I'm sorry for cutting you off.
- 1:37:16Um,
- 1:37:17so I'm just saying because of the worth itself
- 1:37:20is inherently based off of your outward appearance,
- 1:37:23right?
- 1:37:23It's not based off of who you are as a person,
- 1:37:25how good you cook,
- 1:37:26you know,
- 1:37:26anything like that.
- 1:37:27Whenever it comes to sex work,
- 1:37:28we are literally grading women off of their appearance degrading.
- 1:37:32What do you mean?
- 1:37:34What do I mean?
- 1:37:35Is modeling degrading?
- 1:37:36You just said if it's based off the the external
- 1:37:40appearance,
- 1:37:40it's automatically degrading.
- 1:37:41Is modeling degrading?
- 1:37:43Honestly,
- 1:37:44in my opinion,
- 1:37:45I think that today's modeling and all that,
- 1:37:47but we're getting off no,
- 1:37:48because then you're gonna say,
- 1:37:49oh,
- 1:37:49because a lot of the modeling today is oversexualized.
- 1:37:52You said based off the external appearance,
- 1:37:54so remove sexualized modeling
- 1:37:56is me posting.
- 1:37:56For a Calvin Klein ad degrading.
- 1:37:59Well,
- 1:37:59I think that whenever it's based off external appearance,
- 1:38:03whenever you add in the nudity factor,
- 1:38:04but you said external appearance.
- 1:38:06You said it's judging,
- 1:38:07it's degrading because it's based off the external appearance.
- 1:38:10So then why did,
- 1:38:10why does it have to be sexualized?
- 1:38:12Well,
- 1:38:13because that's the entire nature of this industry.
- 1:38:15I'm saying that the sexualized nudity,
- 1:38:17your benchmark was that it is degrading.
- 1:38:19For me to do sex work because I'm being judged of my external appearance.
- 1:38:22Well,
- 1:38:22if I'm doing cooking or painting or being an athlete,
- 1:38:25I'm not being judged singularly on my appearance,
- 1:38:27and that's what separates it from being degrading to not degrading.
- 1:38:30So I gave you rebuttal and said,
- 1:38:31so is modeling degrading,
- 1:38:33and you said it's not degrading unless it's sexual.
- 1:38:35So you're not even subscribing to your own benchmark.
- 1:38:38OK,
- 1:38:38we have to pause here.
- 1:38:39We're out of time for this claim.
- 1:38:41Thank you so much for your time.
- 1:38:44All right,
- 1:38:45now it's time for our final debate.
- 1:38:47I feel like it's been a really informative and healthy conversation so far,
- 1:38:50so that's really good,
- 1:38:51guys,
- 1:38:52um,
- 1:38:52but now you have 10 minutes uninterrupted.
- 1:38:55So farha,
- 1:38:56look around the room
- 1:38:57and choose wisely someone you wanna continue the conversation with.
- 1:39:00Hm,
- 1:39:01I'll go with you.
- 1:39:04All right,
- 1:39:04Farha,
- 1:39:04why have you chosen Veronica?
- 1:39:06I thought we had a more productive conversation,
- 1:39:08and I share a lot of her passions against the trafficking industry,
- 1:39:11and to me that's the most compelling argument
- 1:39:14against OnlyFans rather than just this idea of
- 1:39:17Christian ethics or anything else.
- 1:39:18My surrounded claim is that love,
- 1:39:21not pornography,
- 1:39:22is the only empowering force for women.
- 1:39:25So the reason that I,
- 1:39:26I say this,
- 1:39:27what I mean by love is like,
- 1:39:29so let's think about for a moment,
- 1:39:31um,
- 1:39:32how our bodies are meant to be in terms of sexuality.
- 1:39:36So,
- 1:39:36um,
- 1:39:37like I was saying earlier,
- 1:39:38I think that women have really been the ones who create,
- 1:39:41created the boundaries in relationships with,
- 1:39:44with men and sort of forced them
- 1:39:46to,
- 1:39:46uh,
- 1:39:47consider women's needs by,
- 1:39:48we tell them,
- 1:39:49we say like,
- 1:39:49hey,
- 1:39:50I cannot,
- 1:39:51you know,
- 1:39:51make love today or have sex today because I have a
- 1:39:54I,
- 1:39:54I have my period or I have cramps,
- 1:39:56or like I'm just tired or,
- 1:39:57or whatever.
- 1:39:59So women have been typically the ones who like set up that boundary and,
- 1:40:03and then also,
- 1:40:04um,
- 1:40:05and that helps men to grow in character and to
- 1:40:07go out in the world and compete with other men.
- 1:40:09Um,
- 1:40:10but also there is a,
- 1:40:11a component actually of,
- 1:40:13of the,
- 1:40:14the lovemaking itself that is,
- 1:40:17this is empowering to women.
- 1:40:19So
- 1:40:20when you engage in a sexual relationship,
- 1:40:21right,
- 1:40:22there's this sort of exciting period leading up to it,
- 1:40:24right?
- 1:40:25Your,
- 1:40:25your body is,
- 1:40:26is,
- 1:40:27there's adrenaline,
- 1:40:28there's excitement,
- 1:40:28your heart's pumping and all of this sort of stuff,
- 1:40:30and then you have an orgasm.
- 1:40:32And then what happens when you have an orgasm is on the other side of that,
- 1:40:35your,
- 1:40:35your restoration part of your body kicks in.
- 1:40:38So,
- 1:40:38So that's the calming,
- 1:40:40relaxing,
- 1:40:40and healing part of your body kicks in.
- 1:40:42So,
- 1:40:43when you're lying there with your partner and
- 1:40:45skin to skin contact is really important too,
- 1:40:47we,
- 1:40:47we know that it's,
- 1:40:48it's a part of the,
- 1:40:49the human
- 1:40:50physiological need is to be close to somebody.
- 1:40:53So when you're lying there and you're in skin to skin contact with your partner,
- 1:40:57your body is healing itself,
- 1:40:58it's restoring,
- 1:40:59it's releasing oxytocin,
- 1:41:01which helps you to sleep better,
- 1:41:02it lowers the risk of cardiovascular disease.
- 1:41:05There are a lot of benefits that come along with that period.
- 1:41:08And,
- 1:41:08and pornography,
- 1:41:10it,
- 1:41:10it doesn't give women any of those benefits.
- 1:41:12And
- 1:41:13when you are in a romantic relationship and somebody is in love with you,
- 1:41:17they have to consider your needs,
- 1:41:18right?
- 1:41:19So,
- 1:41:20again,
- 1:41:20like
- 1:41:21when you are in an OnlyFans
- 1:41:23and that person has an orgasm,
- 1:41:25and then they're all done,
- 1:41:26then they don't have to care about you anymore.
- 1:41:28Whereas with your partner,
- 1:41:29you,
- 1:41:29you then have to,
- 1:41:30to wake up and you have to consider the person as a whole,
- 1:41:33right?
- 1:41:34You have to understand that she,
- 1:41:35she has things going on.
- 1:41:36Maybe she's a mother,
- 1:41:37she's got a problem,
- 1:41:38you're there for.
- 1:41:39What if she gets cancer?
- 1:41:40What if she gets a cold,
- 1:41:41right?
- 1:41:41You have to be there for her,
- 1:41:42you have to take care of her,
- 1:41:43and that's love,
- 1:41:44and that's what creates character
- 1:41:46in people,
- 1:41:46and that's what we want to encourage in our society as opposed to this sort of like,
- 1:41:50thank you for your service,
- 1:41:51bye-bye.
- 1:41:52It sounds good.
- 1:41:54It obviously sounds good to say,
- 1:41:55you know,
- 1:41:56sex is done better when it's by someone who
- 1:41:59thinks the world of you,
- 1:42:00who treats you better,
- 1:42:00who elevates you as a result.
- 1:42:02It doesn't cash out in the actual statistics that we see.
- 1:42:05Like,
- 1:42:05I could easily argue that it's more degrading,
- 1:42:07for instance,
- 1:42:08to have sex with a man you're married to than have sex for money,
- 1:42:11right?
- 1:42:11I could argue it's more degrading to have sex with a man.
- 1:42:13Can you argue that?
- 1:42:14Yeah,
- 1:42:15I could.
- 1:42:15I could argue it's more degrading to have sex with a man,
- 1:42:17for instance,
- 1:42:18who routinely leaves in a second shift for you to take up at home,
- 1:42:21even if you're the primary breadwinner.
- 1:42:22The average man does less housework in a relationship than he when he was single.
- 1:42:26So where's this idea of more respect?
- 1:42:28I could argue it's more degrading to have sex with a
- 1:42:29man who's 70% of the time when he's your husband.
- 1:42:32is watching pornography,
- 1:42:33even though 50% of the time wives consider it cheating.
- 1:42:35I could argue it's more degrading to have sex with a man who 98%
- 1:42:38of the time has sexually fantasized about another woman in the past two months,
- 1:42:41and oftentimes while he's fucking you,
- 1:42:42he's thinking of another woman.
- 1:42:43I could argue that's using you as a flashlight.
- 1:42:45I could argue it's more degrading to have sex
- 1:42:46with a man who you're statistically likely going to divorce
- 1:42:49because of either adultery,
- 1:42:50emotional abuse,
- 1:42:51or some sort of emotional neglect when you voice a problem,
- 1:42:53he's stonewalling you,
- 1:42:54he's leaving,
- 1:42:55he's storming off,
- 1:42:55he's doing all these things.
- 1:42:56I could argue it's more degrading.
- 1:42:58This is from the CDC to have sex with a man
- 1:42:59who 34% of the time is either gonna Physically abuse you,
- 1:43:02stalk you,
- 1:43:02or destroy something important to you,
- 1:43:04right?
- 1:43:04So,
- 1:43:04I think as much as we want to use these really fluffy,
- 1:43:06beautiful words about,
- 1:43:07you know,
- 1:43:07well,
- 1:43:07sex done within a relationship is automatically congruent with your well-being,
- 1:43:10the reality,
- 1:43:11the statistics show a completely different reality,
- 1:43:13right?
- 1:43:14And oftentimes,
- 1:43:14like,
- 1:43:14sex done for money
- 1:43:16is not necessarily trafficking either.
- 1:43:18So,
- 1:43:18it seems like you're only interested in pointing to
- 1:43:19these really positive outliers of relationships when the average relationship
- 1:43:23will end in divorce because because of her.
- 1:43:26She's going to be filing for divorce,
- 1:43:27right?
- 1:43:27It will,
- 1:43:282/3 of the time,
- 1:43:29involve him cuckold.
- 1:43:30Her with women he sees online.
- 1:43:32Why is it less degrading to be the cock than to be me,
- 1:43:35the whore,
- 1:43:36right?
- 1:43:36I have first of all,
- 1:43:37I would never call you a whore.
- 1:43:38That is,
- 1:43:39I would never speak to a woman that way as a pejorative.
- 1:43:42I just mean like a prostitute.
- 1:43:44OK,
- 1:43:44OK.
- 1:43:45So I think that,
- 1:43:45that,
- 1:43:46um,
- 1:43:46that's a really good point.
- 1:43:48But I think that the,
- 1:43:49the,
- 1:43:49there's this sort of underlying idea that people sort of are
- 1:43:52like these individual islands,
- 1:43:54and they make all of their decisions,
- 1:43:56um,
- 1:43:57through rational,
- 1:43:58you know,
- 1:43:59means and,
- 1:43:59and.
- 1:44:00That society has no responsibility.
- 1:44:02So we have a responsibility.
- 1:44:03So
- 1:44:04just like we were talking about before,
- 1:44:05like young boys who are watching pornography with a very,
- 1:44:08very young age,
- 1:44:09you know,
- 1:44:10don't we have a responsibility as a society,
- 1:44:13as a community to come together
- 1:44:14and to show people how to be?
- 1:44:17And,
- 1:44:17and so can I respond to that?
- 1:44:18We do have a responsibility,
- 1:44:19which is why I'm a proponent of banning
- 1:44:21strangulation content and banning any types of content,
- 1:44:23but you understand that you're part of a decently modeled,
- 1:44:26but don't again,
- 1:44:27I think we should get rid of movies that includes.
- 1:44:29Sexist tropes because people will emulate what they say on screen.
- 1:44:33Now the same thing's living in a utopian fluffy world?
- 1:44:35Like why is utopia to be pro-theater but anti-minstrel shows?
- 1:44:38Is it utopia to be pro sitcom but anti-homophobic tropes?
- 1:44:41Why is that a fantasy?
- 1:44:43Because the UK UK banned strangulation content this year as
- 1:44:46well as 10 other categories that they considered degrading.
- 1:44:48Why is that a fantasy?
- 1:44:49You work for a company that would never support that ban.
- 1:44:53OnlyFans,
- 1:44:54yes,
- 1:44:54OnlyFans,
- 1:44:55for instance,
- 1:44:55one went anti-sexual for like several months.
- 1:44:582.
- 1:44:58OnlyFans content is very,
- 1:45:00very strict.
- 1:45:00You can't have any knife content.
- 1:45:02You can't have most of the categories that would be allowed on the hub.
- 1:45:05You cannot import onto OnlyFans.
- 1:45:07So no,
- 1:45:07it's not a fantasy.
- 1:45:08Yes,
- 1:45:09it is a fan.
- 1:45:09Well,
- 1:45:10and Pornhub was extremely liable to outside pressure.
- 1:45:12That's why they scrubbed 80% of their content after petitioning
- 1:45:15and protesting and stuff like that.
- 1:45:17So kind of like someone brought up earlier,
- 1:45:19Pornhub gets more clicks than Netflix and TikTok combined,
- 1:45:21right?
- 1:45:22We have representation on basically
- 1:45:23every genre and content vertical.
- 1:45:25We have representation on what to do if someone's cyberbullied.
- 1:45:28Let me just finish one point.
- 1:45:29We have representation on what to do if you're being cyberbullied.
- 1:45:31We have representation on what to do if your partner does X,
- 1:45:33Y,
- 1:45:33and Z to you.
- 1:45:34Why is it with porn,
- 1:45:35the subject matter that deals with things like STDs,
- 1:45:38consent,
- 1:45:38marriage,
- 1:45:39infidelity,
- 1:45:40sexual coercion,
- 1:45:40all these things,
- 1:45:41why would we leave a void of representation on the subject matter that
- 1:45:44I think warrants it the most out of every other subject matter?
- 1:45:47And why not use the fact that men globally are
- 1:45:50watching this genre more than any other type of content,
- 1:45:52movies,
- 1:45:52Netflix,
- 1:45:53TikTok,
- 1:45:53whatever,
- 1:45:54and use it to remodel them to create the sort of sexual
- 1:45:56behavior that We want to see modeled in society rather than again,
- 1:45:59just getting rid of the baby with the bathwater,
- 1:46:02uh,
- 1:46:02because you can't,
- 1:46:03because there's not actual relationships on there.
- 1:46:05If you're going to model actual relationships,
- 1:46:07then you have to,
- 1:46:07it has to be an environment
- 1:46:09where actual relationships are taking place.
- 1:46:11And the two healthy sexual behavior without it needing
- 1:46:14to be within the parameters of a relationship.
- 1:46:17Relationships don't automatically default to healthy sexual behaviors.
- 1:46:20Like I said before,
- 1:46:21you are more likely as a woman to be pressured by
- 1:46:23a romantic partner than a casual partner into violent sex sex.
- 1:46:27Forced pregnancy,
- 1:46:27forced abortion.
- 1:46:28Like I said,
- 1:46:29a romantic partner has a lot more emotional leverage.
- 1:46:31So why is it that it has to be within a relationship for it to qualify as healthy?
- 1:46:36So,
- 1:46:36when I say that society has a responsibility to model this,
- 1:46:39what I'm saying is that there is this huge rise of,
- 1:46:42of OnlyFans,
- 1:46:43and what is actually happening is not that we're modeling healthy relationships.
- 1:46:47What's actually happening is the rise of the manosphere and people like
- 1:46:51Andrew Tate and Clavacular and Jonathan Dougherty and all of these men
- 1:46:54who are sort of saying like,
- 1:46:55I have I have this like whole harem of women.
- 1:46:58So in,
- 1:46:59in the West,
- 1:47:00where we have sort of said for a very long time that we don't do harems,
- 1:47:03that's not,
- 1:47:04we don't,
- 1:47:04that's not acceptable behavior in society.
- 1:47:07Now all of a sudden,
- 1:47:08like what these men are actually coming out in
- 1:47:11public with no shame whatsoever and being like,
- 1:47:13yeah,
- 1:47:13these 12 doesn't really track because a lot,
- 1:47:16most of the manosphere
- 1:47:18is anti-OlyFans like Myron Gaines,
- 1:47:20who's who encourages his male followers to keep a harem.
- 1:47:23He's anti-sex work,
- 1:47:24right?
- 1:47:24So if actually the people Who are the
- 1:47:25loudest voices against OnlyFans are actually pro harem.
- 1:47:29So Clavacular just came out and said like he has OnlyFans models,
- 1:47:33and so they do this really crazy thing where they make money off of OnlyFans models,
- 1:47:38not the manosphere,
- 1:47:39but yeah,
- 1:47:39but at the same they're making money off of OnlyFans as
- 1:47:42being like managers while at the same time they just critical.
- 1:47:45Yes,
- 1:47:45they treat them like crap.
- 1:47:47They say like,
- 1:47:47oh,
- 1:47:48you know,
- 1:47:48I would never actually marry or date you because you're a,
- 1:47:51you know,
- 1:47:51you do pornography.
- 1:47:52Their misogynistic norms do not result as a.
- 1:47:54Results of the sexual commodification of the female body.
- 1:47:57Andrew Tate's very pro
- 1:47:58marriage and family.
- 1:47:59He's very pro eight wives.
- 1:48:00Does that mean the institution of
- 1:48:01marriage is inherently misogynistic and degrading?
- 1:48:03No,
- 1:48:03but I'm just saying we have to decide on what's healthy.
- 1:48:05But why do you deduce misogyny as being the natural result from sex work,
- 1:48:09because that's what we're seeing from marriage when
- 1:48:11people like Andrew Tate are very pro-marriage,
- 1:48:13but he's not just pro-marriage in a very polygynous way.
- 1:48:16But he doesn't know what marriage,
- 1:48:17what marriage between a man and a woman,
- 1:48:19or I would say two people who are pro-sex trafficking,
- 1:48:21don't know what sex work is at its core,
- 1:48:23right?
- 1:48:23So.
- 1:48:24If you want to load something with just like the positive interpretation of it,
- 1:48:27then I could do the same for sex work.
- 1:48:29OK,
- 1:48:29so let's just forget marriage for a moment.
- 1:48:31I'm talking about like
- 1:48:33being in a,
- 1:48:34a sexual interaction with somebody,
- 1:48:36which can be ethical regardless of whether it's in a real,
- 1:48:38do you agree that you can have ethical sexual relations outside of a relationship,
- 1:48:42or do you think they are necessarily
- 1:48:44degrading and morally bankrupt if they're done outside of,
- 1:48:46well,
- 1:48:46it depends on what you mean by relationship.
- 1:48:48There has to be some sort of concern for the
- 1:48:50person that you are engaging in sexual activity with.
- 1:48:52I agree.
- 1:48:53I,
- 1:48:54that's why I think sex work is not incompatible.
- 1:48:55I think so long as the sex workers are being treated fairly,
- 1:48:58as long as they have control,
- 1:48:59like I can block any man who comes on and
- 1:49:01calls me any sort of pejorative,
- 1:49:02I can get rid of him.
- 1:49:03But I like to understand you're in a position,
- 1:49:05you're in a position of power because from what I understand,
- 1:49:07you're a very popular and you're a well paid creator.
- 1:49:10This is not the experience of 90% of OnlyFans creators.
- 1:49:13I actually know many personally.
- 1:49:15I just talked to somebody a couple of days ago.
- 1:49:16She was like,
- 1:49:17She was like,
- 1:49:18Veronica,
- 1:49:18like,
- 1:49:19I tried to do it and I was,
- 1:49:21I,
- 1:49:21I didn't make enough money to hold down my other job.
- 1:49:23And let me tell you,
- 1:49:24like,
- 1:49:24when men subscribe to your stuff,
- 1:49:26they feel very entitled.
- 1:49:27She was like,
- 1:49:27I was at work and I'd be like,
- 1:49:28hey,
- 1:49:28I'll talk to you later.
- 1:49:29And they'd be like,
- 1:49:30I'm paying you,
- 1:49:31you need to talk to me right now.
- 1:49:32Like,
- 1:49:32this is,
- 1:49:33it's not creating coercion is an issue
- 1:49:35that doesn't disappear in relationships.
- 1:49:37How many husbands are like,
- 1:49:38Oh,
- 1:49:38come on,
- 1:49:39stop saying you have a headache.
- 1:49:39It's the 3rd day in a row,
- 1:49:40right?
- 1:49:41Like that dynamic does not disappear in marriages.
- 1:49:42It's actually more promis.
- 1:49:43marriages.
- 1:49:44OK,
- 1:49:44but it is empowering to women,
- 1:49:46right?
- 1:49:46So we have a legal system where if you have,
- 1:49:48if you get divorced,
- 1:49:50you're entitled to half of the person's money.
- 1:49:52Like if a woman who is like on OnlyFans,
- 1:49:55you're not entitled to anything of his.
- 1:49:56Like,
- 1:49:56I am,
- 1:49:57for him to even message me,
- 1:49:58he has to pay like $50.
- 1:49:59OK,
- 1:50:00$50 is not,
- 1:50:01like,
- 1:50:01what if he has $10 million?
- 1:50:05$50 is more than enough.
- 1:50:06If he just says something rude and I could block him,
- 1:50:08I wouldn't go,
- 1:50:08damn,
- 1:50:08I got really like robbed blind.
- 1:50:10OK,
- 1:50:10so I will,
- 1:50:11I will grant you,
- 1:50:12OK,
- 1:50:12so I,
- 1:50:13I,
- 1:50:13I think that OnlyFans and pornography is an addiction,
- 1:50:15and it's addiction akin to like heroin.
- 1:50:17So I will grant you that there is a
- 1:50:20cartel boss who has a really great life and
- 1:50:22he feels very empowered and everything's going well.
- 1:50:24Now,
- 1:50:25that cartel boss who deals heroin to the globe
- 1:50:27also is just like,
- 1:50:29what do you,
- 1:50:29what do you say?
- 1:50:30Like,
- 1:50:30I don't care that other women are being my question is,
- 1:50:33why is that
- 1:50:34more of an addiction to doing a transaction?
- 1:50:36Setting than do it in a marital setting.
- 1:50:38It's not am I dealing heroin every time I
- 1:50:40do again like a striptease for my husband you,
- 1:50:42wait,
- 1:50:42are you suggesting that there is no difference
- 1:50:45between logging in and subscribing to somebody and getting
- 1:50:48sex,
- 1:50:48uh,
- 1:50:49just you having a conversation with that person
- 1:50:52for the purpose of orgasm
- 1:50:53versus being in a marriage?
- 1:50:55You,
- 1:50:56you think those are not different,
- 1:50:57having sex with your wife?
- 1:50:58They are different.
- 1:50:59I don't believe one is,
- 1:51:01I don't believe the marital.
- 1:51:02One
- 1:51:03is more morally better.
- 1:51:04I think what I look at to determine which is morally better is,
- 1:51:07which is the result of coercion,
- 1:51:09which was the result of sexual compliance.
- 1:51:10So,
- 1:51:10for instance,
- 1:51:11if the wife is putting out because she's scared her husband's going to
- 1:51:13cheat on her or thinking this is just what I owe my husband,
- 1:51:16then I would say that's the morally worst scenario than
- 1:51:17a woman who's paywalling a bikini photo for $100.
- 1:51:20OK,
- 1:51:21that's fair,
- 1:51:21but this is what I was talking about before,
- 1:51:22when I was saying,
- 1:51:23like,
- 1:51:23hey,
- 1:51:24join the other side.
- 1:51:25Like,
- 1:51:25there are women who are out there sort of saying,
- 1:51:27like,
- 1:51:28listen,
- 1:51:28We want women to be viewed holistically.
- 1:51:31We want to be people.
- 1:51:32We don't want to be we don't want to be objects,
- 1:51:34OK?
- 1:51:35But you're the object,
- 1:51:36but the degradation isn't implied by doing it transactionally is my point.
- 1:51:40I agree.
- 1:51:41I,
- 1:51:41I think there's an onus on men in society to see.
- 1:51:43Sex workers as people,
- 1:51:44and I think we do a disservice when we say by sexualizing yourself,
- 1:51:47you're making it,
- 1:51:48you're asking to be degraded,
- 1:51:50but I think that's a misogynistic outlook.
- 1:51:53We're gonna pause here.
- 1:51:54We're out of time.
- 1:51:55Thank you both.
- 1:51:57That was wonderful.
- 1:51:58Thank you so much.
- 1:52:02All right,
- 1:52:02that's all the time we have for today.
- 1:52:04That was an amazing debate,
- 1:52:05ladies,
- 1:52:06and of course the debaters,
- 1:52:07you guys did amazing,
- 1:52:08so give it up for yourselves.
- 1:52:13Kaha,
- 1:52:14thank you so much for joining us.
- 1:52:15Now,
- 1:52:15would you want to join us on our podcast to follow up this conversation?
- 1:52:18I would love to.
- 1:52:19Love it.
- 1:52:20Love to hear it.
- 1:52:21And thank you all for watching at home.
- 1:52:23Sound off in the comments.
- 1:52:24Let us know what you guys think.
- 1:52:26We'll see you next time.
- 1:52:27Bye.
- 1:52:32All the advocates today were really nice.
- 1:52:34I was a bit unimpressed with their debate performance,
- 1:52:37to be honest.
- 1:52:38I think Veronica impressed me the most with moral character.
- 1:52:41I could feel like her heart was in it more.
- 1:52:43I think she was definitely trying to justify her participation in an industry
- 1:52:47that does a lot of harm that she herself said she.
- 1:52:50I against.
- 1:52:51So I thought it was really interesting that she made the argument that
- 1:52:55the only reason that people are against OnlyFans
- 1:52:57is because it gives women control and then
- 1:53:00within the debate itself she gave many,
- 1:53:03many arguments against OnlyFans and reasons not to like it.
- 1:53:06For her to compare women to food,
- 1:53:09I mean,
- 1:53:09I,
- 1:53:10I,
- 1:53:10I don't think she's going to have great self-esteem
- 1:53:13and super high confidence typically if you're given.
- 1:53:16The most intimate part of yourself up
- 1:53:19so freely on the internet,
- 1:53:21you don't have high self-esteem.
- 1:53:23Unfortunately,
- 1:53:23I think a lot of people in the circle
- 1:53:26just let her kind of steamroll them with her points
- 1:53:29and she would bring up a bunch of different points
- 1:53:32and kind of a gish gallop,
- 1:53:34I would say.
- 1:53:34And so,
- 1:53:35um,
- 1:53:35I think rhetorically she was strong,
- 1:53:37but logically I don't think anything was there.
- 1:53:40Women have been trying really hard for a for all of.
- 1:53:42History really
- 1:53:44to get men to see them not as sexual objects but as whole people who are fully capable
- 1:53:50of doing almost anything that a man can do,
- 1:53:51at least professionally,
- 1:53:53and to be in healthy relationships that are characterized by
- 1:53:56being considerate and compassionate and loving.
- 1:53:59I think that pornography sets us back in all of our goals for trying to be healthy.
- 1:54:04I think sex work is politicized in the wrong ways.
- 1:54:06I would love to see people who are constantly pearl clutching
- 1:54:09about how OnlyFans is degrading women and making them sell their souls and
- 1:54:12taking advantage of lonely young men
- 1:54:14to focus some of that energy on sex trafficking,
- 1:54:16and I'd appreciate if they focused again their
- 1:54:18qualms with sex work on actual problems.